Complain about a product or service

Sony Reaches Tentative Settlement in Spyware Cases

By Martin H. Bosworth
ConsumerAffairs.com

January 3, 2006

Sony • Sony: Dust Voids PlayStation 3 Warranty • Sony BMG Settles FTC "Rootkit" Charges • Sony BMG Settles Root-Kit Suits for $4.25 Million •: Sony BMG Settles California Case • PlayStation 3 Takes the Field • PlayStation 3 Brings Big Bucks on eBay • Court Approves Sony BMG CD Settlement • Sony Reaches Tentative Settlement in Spyware Cases • New Charges Against Sony's Use of Stealth Software • New York Joins Sony CD Investigation • Recalled Sony CDs Still On Sale • Consumer Group Sues Sony BMG • Texas Sues Sony for Violating Spyware Law • Sony Withdraws CDs With Copy-Protection Software • Sony Slammed for Hidden CD Software • Sony Loses Playstation Suit • Digital Camera Buyers Give Kodak, Sony High Marks • Sony Agrees to Stop Payola Payments to Radio Stations • Sony Playstation 2 Defective, Class Action Charges --- Complaints • Playstation 2 • Playstation 1 • Cameras, Camcorders • Computers • Computer Monitors • Computer Rebates • Home Electronics Rebates • TVs • WebTV

Sony BMG has offered $7.50 or a free album to victims of the illicit copy-protection software its CDs clandestinely installed on customers' computers.

The class action suit settlement provides:

• A recall of all CDs containing First 4's XCP copy-protection software, and an injunction against manufacturing any CD's containing SunnComm's MediaMax software until at least late 2007 or early 2008. Both MediaMax and XCP have been heavily criticized for their crippling effects on users' computers, the lack of clear terms of consent to install them, and in XCP's case, its own infringement on the copyright of another software license. ()

• A cash offer of $7.50 or the option to download a free album from Sony's catalog in any format, including Apple's popular iTunes software.

• Limitations on Sony's ability to collect identifying data using XCP, MediaMax, and any future content protection software without the user's explicit consent or permission.

• The continuing recalls and exchanges of the copy-protected CDs with "clean" CDs that can be "ripped" to a computer's hard drive or copied onto blank CD's.

• Offering improved uninstaller applications for the MediaMax and XCP software. The previous uninstallers were criticized for not actually removing the software, and for causing new problems and vulnerabilities on users' machines. (/news04/2005/sony.html)

The settlement must still be approved by the U.S. Southern District Court of New York, where the lawsuit was initially filed. It does not affect other lawsuits against Sony, including those filed in Texas by state Attorney General Greg Abbott and the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

News of the settlement elicited a predictably wide response. Mark Russinovich, the Windows security analyst who first discovered the XCP "rootkit" software on one of his own computers was listed as an expert witness in the class-action suit. Posting on his blog, he said that "this specific circumstance has had a best-case outcome for those affected."

Russinovich's statement did not say whether he had been compensated for his expert-witness status.

Russinovich said that "users need to have enough plain-English information presented to them during a software installation, DRM-protected or otherwise, that helps them make an informed decision when they consider accepting a vendor's terms and the software's impact on their system."

Others criticized the settlement for merely formalizing what Sony was doing anyway -- recalling the copy-protected CD's -- and the relatively small cash offer.

CD's can range in price from $12 to $18 at music stores. And Sony's ability to collect personal information from its copy-protection software isn't actually removed by the settlement, merely limited by requiring the user's consent.

InfoWorld's Ed Foster stated that the settlement also doesn't prevent Sony from taking the same actions in the future. "[N]ext time it just has to disclose what it's doing a little more clearly and completely in its EULA. And come 2008, Sony is free to revert to the old EULA or, for that matter, to go find a new rootkit to use on its CDs."

Report Your Experience
If you've had a bad experience -- or a good one -- with a consumer product or service, we'd like to hear about it. All complaints are reviewed by class action attorneys and are considered for publication on our site. Knowledge is power! Help spread the word. File your consumer report now.

Back to the top |