How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

Best Extended Car Warranty Companies of 2026

Compare plans on costs, coverage and what happens when you file a claim

    • Best overall
      Endurance Warranty
      4.5(19,477)
    • Older and high-mileage vehicles
      CarShield
      4.0(10,509)
    • Coverage variety
      CARCHEX
      4.3(4,430)
    +2 more
    Author picture
    Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin

    Best Extended Car Warranty Companies of 2026

    Extended warranties, also known as vehicle service contracts, help cover big repair bills after your factory warranty expires. But not all plans are worth the price. The best ones offer useful coverage and come through when you actually need it, so we compared plan details with verified customer experiences to find companies that actually deliver.

    Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
    • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
    • 4,957,058 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

    Our 6 picks for the best extended car warranty companies

    Price and coverage tell you what a warranty promises. Claims tell you whether it delivers. We looked at how each company performs before and after a breakdown to find the best options for different drivers.

    1. Best overall: Endurance Warranty
    2. Best for older and high-mileage vehicles: CarShield
    3. Best coverage variety: CARCHEX
    4. Best maintenance benefits: Omega Auto Care
    5. Best claims process: Zurich Vehicle Service Contract
    6. Best value: American Dream Auto Protect

    We compared extended warranty providers based on customer satisfaction, coverage, costs, vehicle eligibility and claims experience. We also collected quotes for different vehicles and analyzed verified ConsumerAffairs reviews to see what happens when customers actually use their coverage.

    Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us, but this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations. Read our full methodology for more details.

    California has different rules for vehicle service contracts. State regulations prevent any business other than a car dealership from selling extended car warranties, but you can purchase mechanical breakdown insurance from several of our top picks.

    Compare the best extended car warranty companies

    Learn More About Extended Car Warranties
    * Average cost across four sample vehicles: 2016 Toyota Camry (110,000 miles), 2015 BMW 3 Series (125,000 miles), 2014 Honda CR-V (135,000 miles) and 2013 Ford F-150 (150,000 miles).
    Endurance Warranty logo
    Levels of coverage
    3
    Eligibility
    Up to 500,000 miles or 20 years
    Waiting period
    30 to 60 days and 1,000 miles
    Deductible options
    $0 to $250
    Why we picked Endurance

    Endurance is our top pick overall based on customer satisfaction ratings and coverage value. It’s also a direct provider, which means Endurance handles its own contracts and claims instead of working through a third-party administrator.

    Plans also include 24/7 roadside assistance and one year of Elite Benefits, with perks like tire coverage and collision repair discounts.

    Best for: If your factory warranty is about to expire and you want comprehensive coverage from a company that handles claims directly.

    Pros
    • Direct provider
    • Broad coverage options
    • Choose your own mechanic
    • Transferable plans
    • 24/7 roadside assistance
    Cons
    • Higher prices than some competitors
    • Some claims denied
    • Some cancellation complaints
    4x Award Winner
    Endurance Warranty won four 2026 Buyer's Choice Awards from ConsumerAffairs for Best Coverage, Best Claims Handling, Best Experience with Staff, and Best Customer Service.

    Coverage details

    Endurance offers three main coverage levels, ranging from basic powertrain protection to near bumper-to-bumper coverage. Secure Plus, Superior and Supreme let you balance cost and protection, with additional options available by phone.

    Plan costs

    Endurance plans cost an estimated $1,200 to $1,920 per year. Our quotes for four vehicles averaged $1,913.84. Your price will depend on your vehicle and coverage, so compare quotes before committing.

    Anecdotally, Richard in Virginia paid $3,600 for four years of coverage. Some consumers report paying more.

    What reviewers say about filing a claim

    Reviewers often report successful claims with only their deductible left to pay. Others mention denied claims or unexpected exclusions, making it important to understand exactly what your contract covers before signing up.

    Best for older and high-mileage vehicles
    CarShield logo
    Levels of coverage
    7
    Eligibility
    Up to 300,000 miles or 25 years
    Waiting period
    30 days and 1,000 miles
    Deductible options
    $0 to $250
    Why we picked CarShield

    CarShield combines high mileage limits with flexible month-to-month coverage. Vehicles with up to 300,000 miles may qualify, and plans are available for everything from basic powertrain protection to EV-specific coverage. Most contracts also include 24/7 roadside assistance.

    Best for: If you own an older or high-mileage vehicle and want flexible monthly coverage you can cancel without a long-term commitment.

    Pros
    • Covers vehicles up to 300,000 miles
    • Month-to-month plans available
    • EV coverage available
    • Rental car reimbursement available
    Cons
    • No online quotes
    • Some claims denied
    • Some claim approval delays
    3x Award Winner
    CarShield won three 2026 Buyer's Choice Awards from ConsumerAffairs for Best Coverage, Best Claims Handling, and Best Customer Service.

    Coverage details

    CarShield offers several coverage levels for newer, older and high-mileage vehicles. It also has specialty plans for electric vehicles, motorcycles and ATVs.

    Plan costs

    Our quotes for four vehicles averaged $1,149. Many customers choose monthly payments, typically around $110 to $170.

    What reviewers say about filing a claim

    Reviewers often describe the claims process as straightforward and customer service as helpful. The most common frustrations involve coverage exclusions or disagreements over whether a repair qualifies.

    Best coverage variety
    CARCHEX logo
    Levels of coverage
    5
    Maximum mileage
    250,000
    Waiting period
    30 days
    Availability
    Nationwide
    Why we picked CARCHEX

    CARCHEX is a good fit if you want more choices instead of being pushed into one or two standard plans. Because it works with multiple warranty providers, you can choose anything from basic powertrain coverage to near bumper-to-bumper protection, including options for EVs.

    The tradeoff is that CARCHEX doesn’t administer every plan itself, so the claims experience can depend on the provider behind your contract.

    Best for: If you want more control over what your warranty covers and several plans to compare.

    Pros
    • Many plan options
    • $0 deductible available
    • Use any licensed repair shop
    • Transferable coverage
    • 30-day money-back guarantee
    Cons
    • Not a direct provider
    • Claims experience varies by plan
    • Plan options can be confusing

    Coverage details

    CARCHEX offers over 20 plans across five coverage levels, with options for EV coverage. Titanium plans provide the most comprehensive, exclusionary coverage, while lower tiers let you spend less for protection focused on major components.

    Plan costs

    A five-year CARCHEX plan costs about $1,500 on average, or roughly 2 cents per mile of coverage. Prices vary based on your vehicle, coverage level and deductible.

    Michael in Colorado paid $2,299 to cover his 2019 Ford F-350, and Judy in Florida said she pays about $1,000 per year.

    You may also be able to negotiate your price. Raymond in Rhode Island said CARCHEX agreed to his $99-per-month budget for its highest-level plan.

    » COMPARE: CarShield vs. CARCHEX

    What reviewers say about filing a claim
    Some reviewers report quick approvals and helpful claims representatives. Others describe confusion about waiting periods or what their contracts actually covered, so it’s worth reviewing those details carefully before buying.
    Best maintenance benefits
    Omega Auto Care logo
    Levels of coverage
    5
    Eligibility
    Up to 250,000 miles or 15 years
    Waiting period
    30 days
    Deductible options
    $100
    Why we picked Omega Auto Care

    Omega stands out because its plans include benefits that help with routine car care, not just breakdowns. Its maintenance program can provide up to $500 toward services such as oil changes, brake pads, wiper blades and cooling system maintenance.

    Best for: If you want repair coverage plus benefits that help offset the cost of routine maintenance.

    Pros
    • Up to $500 in maintenance benefits
    • Covers high-mileage vehicles
    • Deductible waived at some repair shops
    • 30-day money-back guarantee
    Cons
    • No online quotes
    • Some claims denied
    • Some claims and customer service delays
    1x Award Winner
    Omega Auto Care won one 2026 Buyer's Choice Award from ConsumerAffairs for Best Customer Service.

    Coverage details

    Omega offers five coverage levels, ranging from basic powertrain protection to near bumper-to-bumper coverage. Options are available for newer, older and high-mileage vehicles.

    Plan costs

    Omega Auto Care plans start at around $60 per month. On the higher end, Samuel in Florida told us his protection plan costs almost $130 per month. Omega will waive your deductible if you take your car to a RepairPal-certified mechanic.

    What reviewers say about filing a claim
    Reviewers often say dealerships or mechanics handle most of the claims process for them, making repairs relatively easy. Some customers, however, report delays or difficulty reaching claims representatives.
    Zurich Vehicle Service Contract logo
    Levels of coverage
    3
    Eligibility
    Up to 150,000 miles or 15 years
    Waiting period
    30 days and 1,000 miles
    Deductible options
    Varies
    Why we picked Zurich Vehicle Service Contract

    Zurich earned our claims-process pick because reviewers frequently describe easy approvals, quick repairs and dealerships handling the paperwork for them. That can make an already stressful repair much simpler.

    Best for: If you’re buying a luxury car, EV or newer vehicle through a dealership and want a smoother, dealership-managed claims process.

    Pros
    • Dealership can handle claims
    • $0 deductible options
    • Transferable plans
    • Roadside assistance
    • Motorcycle coverage available
    Cons
    • Primarily sold through dealerships
    • Pricing varies by dealer
    • Limited rental reimbursement
    3x Award Winner
    Zurich Vehicle Service Contract won three 2026 Buyer's Choice Awards from ConsumerAffairs for Best Coverage, Best Claims Handling, and Best Experience with Staff.

    Coverage details

    Zurich offers three coverage levels, from basic powertrain protection to comprehensive exclusionary coverage. Higher-tier plans add systems such as steering, suspension, air conditioning and electrical components.

    Plan costs

    Zurich warranty costs vary by dealership, vehicle and coverage level. On the lower end, Alexandra in New Jersey told us she pays $40 per month. John in New York said he spent $4,000 total on coverage.

    If you finance the warranty with your vehicle, remember that you’ll also pay interest on the cost of the plan.

    What reviewers say about filing a claim
    Many reviewers say their dealership handled the claim directly, with little work required on their end. Experiences can vary, though, and some customers have had to manage more of the process themselves.
    American Dream Auto Protect logo
    Levels of coverage
    3
    Maximum mileage
    200,000 miles
    Waiting period
    Not disclosed
    Availability
    49 states (not CA)
    Why we picked American Dream Auto Protect

    American Dream stands out for relatively affordable pricing, frequent discounts and customizable coverage. We also considered how customers rated the company’s prices and claims experience, along with extras such as towing.

    Best for: If keeping costs down is a priority and you want the flexibility to choose coverage without paying for extras you don’t need.

    Pros
    • Competitive pricing
    • Customizable coverage
    • Frequent discounts
    • Transferable contracts
    • Large repair network
    Cons
    • No online quotes
    • Some claims denied
    • Some customer service complaints
    1x Award Winner
    American Dream Auto Protect won one 2026 Buyer's Choice Award from ConsumerAffairs for Best Experience with Staff.

    Coverage details

    American Dream offers three coverage levels, from basic mechanical protection to more comprehensive plans covering systems such as steering, suspension, air conditioning and navigation.

    Plan costs

    Our quotes for four vehicles averaged $1,149. Many customers pay monthly, though your rate will vary based on your vehicle and coverage.

    On the lower end, Natalie in Pennsylvania said she pays $123 per month. Tom in Texas told us, “My policy through American Dream for the Cadillac was $187 and something and $153 and something for the Ram.”

    What reviewers say about filing a claim

    Experiences are mixed. Some reviewers report prompt approvals and helpful representatives, while others describe denied claims, long waits or difficulty getting clear answers.

    Extended Car Warranties Buyers Guide

    Jump into our guides and start learning

    Top Picks

    See who reviewers like

    Endurance Warranty logo
    CarShield logo
    CARCHEX logo
    See our top picks

    Simplify your search

    Compare plans tailored to your car & budget.

      Extended warranties cost around $1,000 to $2,500 per year and help pay to fix your car when a covered part breaks on its own. A good plan can pay for itself if it covers one major engine, transmission or electrical component repair. But not all providers are reliable, and a bad plan may leave you paying out of pocket when you need coverage most.

      This guide will help you understand everything you need to know about extended car warranties before deciding which provider is best for you.

      Key insights

      Most extended warranties cost about $1,000 per year. The exact price depends on your car and the company you choose.

      Jump to insight

      Extended warranties, also known as vehicle service contracts, pay to fix your car when a covered part breaks on its own.

      Jump to insight

      What’s covered depends on your contract. Full coverage (called bumper-to-bumper) is usually the best deal.

      Jump to insight

      You can buy an extended warranty anytime, but it’s usually smart to wait until your factory warranty ends.

      Jump to insight

      How do extended auto warranties work?

      An extended car warranty works like a service contract. The contract states the provider will pay for certain repairs if your car breaks down during the coverage period. The important part is that it only covers breakdowns when parts fail on their own without any outside influence. They do not cover damage caused by accidents or misuse.

      An extended car warranty typically lasts between two and seven years.

      A warranty is often listed like this: “three years/36,000 miles.” This means it expires after three years or 36,000 miles, whichever comes first. Some companies go as high as 250,000 miles. Most plans, though, last around five years or 50,000 miles.

      Don’t get confused: that doesn’t always mean it adds five years to your factory warranty. In reality, your “five-year warranty” may expire when your vehicle is just five years old. Then, you’re effectively buying two years of additional coverage on top of your three-year factory warranty.

      Who does the repairs?

      Your car warranty company may decide where you can take your vehicle for repairs. Usually, you can visit any ASE-certified mechanic.

      Warranties only protect you from parts that break because of a manufacturing issue — not outside damage.

      Be aware that you’ll likely need the repairs preauthorized by your warranty provider before the shop can begin working. Once your car is ready for you to pick up, you’ll pay your deductible to the shop and be on your way.

      Who’s eligible for an extended warranty?

      Most vehicles are eligible for an extended car warranty, but eligibility depends on a few key factors.

      • Age of the vehicle: Newer cars are the easiest to cover. Many providers offer the best plans for vehicles under 10 years old. Some companies have stricter limits, especially for manufacturer-backed warranties, which are often only available before the factory warranty expires.

      • Mileage: Mileage is one of the biggest factors. Many providers cap eligibility at around 100,000 to 150,000 miles for comprehensive plans. However, some third-party companies offer coverage up to 200,000 or even 300,000 miles, usually with more limited protection.

      • Condition of the car: Your vehicle generally needs to be in good working condition. Most providers won’t cover cars with preexisting issues. While inspections are not always required, providers may deny claims if they determine a problem existed before coverage began.

      • Vehicle type: Most standard cars, trucks and SUVs qualify for extended warranties. However, certain vehicles may be harder or more expensive to cover, including:

        • Luxury or high-performance vehicles

        • Modified vehicles

        • Commercial-use vehicles (like rideshare or delivery cars)

        • Salvage or rebuilt title vehicles

      How to file an extended warranty claim

      Most extended auto warranties require you to follow this process to file a claim:

      1. Take your vehicle to an authorized repair shop or dealership.

      2. Provide your warranty information to the shop. The repair shop or dealership will open a claim with your warranty provider.

      3. Wait for diagnosis, pre-authorization and repairs.

      4. Pay your deductible and pick up your vehicle.

      How to choose an extended car warranty

      Picking the right extended warranty is a lot like shopping for a phone plan. You want the best deal, but you also want to make sure it does what you need. Don’t just go with the first offer you get. Prices, benefits and coverage can vary between providers, so it pays to shop around.

      1. Find the right amount of coverage

      Some extended car warranties cover only a few parts, while others cover 5,000-plus parts. Exclusionary (bumper-to-bumper) plans offer the most comprehensive coverage and are typically best for newer vehicles or drivers seeking minimal repair risk.

      The type of provider you choose can also affect your coverage options. Manufacturer-backed warranties are designed specifically for the brand’s vehicles, while third-party warranties can offer more flexibility across different makes and models. Here’s how the two typically compare:

      2. Research the claims process

      A warranty is only as good as its claims process. Look for companies that make it simple to file and approve claims quickly.

      In most cases, filing a claim involves taking your car to a licensed repair shop, getting a diagnosis and having the shop contact the warranty provider for preauthorization. After approval, the provider typically pays the shop directly and you just cover your deductible.

      The claims process matters more than the price. A cheap warranty that denies claims is worth nothing.

      Before choosing a provider, check reviews for mentions of delays, denied claims or difficult approval processes. A smooth, transparent claims experience can make a big difference when you actually need repairs.

      3. Read reviews

      Focus on reviewers who talk about a company’s claims process, not just customer service at sign-up. Filter for keywords like “claims process” or “denied coverage” for more relevant insights. Reading reviews is the best way to learn what to expect from a car warranty company.

      4. Compare quotes

      We’ve seen quotes for exclusionary plans on the same vehicle differ by as much as $1,500 between companies. If you want to make sure you’re getting the best deal, get at least three apples-to-apples quotes (same deductible, coverage level and contract length).

      5. Look for transparent terms

      Know what’s covered, what’s not and when it starts. Most plans have a 30-day/1,000-mile wait before coverage. Some, like those from olive, start right away.

      6. Understand the cancellation policy

      Understanding the cancellation policy for an extended auto warranty can save you money and frustration if your circumstances change and you no longer need coverage. Thoroughly read the contract to learn when prorated refunds are given, if there are cancellation fees and what the timeline is for qualifying for a full refund.

      7. Look for extra perks

      Some warranties come with useful extras worth hundreds, even thousands, over the life of the contract. For instance, 24/7 roadside assistance can save on AAA or other memberships, and some companies will pay for rental car reimbursement while your car is in the shop.

      Certain plans cover lost or damaged key fobs, which can be expensive to replace. A few top providers include or offer add-on protection against road hazard damage.

      How to choose an extended car warranty, explained

      tips for choosing an auto warranty video

      What to know about warranty contracts

      The majority of extended auto warranty companies do not require an inspection. However, plans have a waiting period before coverage begins. This is to prevent claims on preexisting conditions. Before you sign anything, ask about:

      • Maintenance requirements: Failing to keep up with oil changes or inspections can void your warranty. Keep your receipts, or else your provider can deny a claim on the basis that you didn’t take care of your car.
      • Claim limits: Look for per-claim and lifetime payout caps, especially if your vehicle is older.
      • Transferability and cancellation: Some plans let you transfer them to new owners. Others give you some money back if you cancel.

      Pro tip

      Avoid plans that require a down payment before sharing contract details.

      » MORE: Tips to avoid the worst car warranty companies

      Extended car warranty cost

      Extended car warranties typically cost $1,000 to $2,500 for bumper-to-bumper coverage, or roughly $85 to $210 per month, depending on your vehicle and coverage level. On the high end, a reviewer in Nevada told us they spent $6,000 on a warranty for a 2015 BMW X5.

      Most companies let you spread payments over time. Most providers now offer month-to-month plans, which are easier to cancel if you change your mind.

      Compare annual extended car warranty costs

      *Nova Warranty quotes are based on a three-year contract

      Factors that affect extended warranty cost

      Factors that can drive up the cost of an extended warranty include high mileage, bumper-to-bumper coverage and owning a luxury vehicle. Car warranty companies consider multiple factors when calculating quotes. Here’s what can change the cost:

      • Type of car: Fancy or high-end cars cost more to fix. That means warranties for luxury cars, sports cars or cars known for having problems usually cost more.

      • Mileage: Warranty providers charge more for higher-mileage vehicles, which are more likely to need repairs.

      • How much is covered: Plans that cover almost everything (like bumper-to-bumper) cost more than basic plans (like powertrain-only). Also, longer plans cost more than shorter ones.

      • Deductible: This is the money you pay each time you use the warranty. A typical deductible for a repair or replacement is $100. A higher deductible usually means a lower plan cost, and a $0 deductible means a higher plan cost.

      • Driving habits: Drivers who commute 20,000 miles per year tend to have more part failures, but they also run out of warranty coverage faster. Commercial use, such as driving your vehicle for Lyft or hauling construction materials, can also raise the price.

      Typical auto repair costs

      Here are the average costs of typical auto repairs. Without an extended auto warranty you’d be responsible for covering the full amount.

      Manufacturer vs. third-party extended car warranty companies

      We should also mention that most manufacturers have their own extended warranty programs. However, these plans are usually limited to covering the car brand’s vehicles.

      Manufacturers such as Hyundai, Kia, Mitsubishi and certain luxury offshoots of these brands have been known to offer better new car warranties, like 10-year powertrain coverage, as part of their factory or extended warranty programs. This coverage typically applies to essential drivetrain components like the engine and transmission.

      Choose manufacturer-backed for newer cars and peace of mind, or third-party if you're budget-conscious and willing to do your homework.

      Manufacturer warrantyThird-party warranty
      Offered byVehicle manufacturer (Ford, Toyota, Honda, etc.)Independent warranty company
      Eligible vehiclesUsually newer vehicles, often before the factory warranty expiresNew and used vehicles, including many high-mileage models
      CostGenerally higherOften more affordable and easier to customize
      Where repairs are completedAuthorized dealership service centersUsually any ASE-certified repair facility (varies by provider)
      Claims experienceTypically streamlined through the dealershipVaries by provider and may require more claim approval steps

      How can I avoid car warranty scams?

      You may have heard a call like this: Hello, we’ve been trying to reach you about your car’s extended warranty. It’s probably a scam.

      Car warranty scams are common, but they’re also easily avoided. Here are the three takeaways from our reporting on how to avoid car warranty scams:

      1. Don’t talk to unknown callers. If someone calls about a warranty and you didn’t ask for it, hang up right away. Never buy anything or give out personal information over the phone.
      2. Only buy a car warranty from a trusted company. This helps you avoid scams, plus it can save you money. Middlemen who don’t work directly for a warranty provider often charge extra hidden fees.
      3. Report scams. If you get a scam call, report it to the Federal Communications Commission. Every valid consumer complaint goes toward reducing the number of scams and robocalls we all receive. You can file complaints directly with the FCC.

      » MORE: How to find reputable warranty companies

      What do extended car warranties cover?

      Car warranties only cover parts that fail entirely on their own during normal, everyday driving.

      Let’s say you’re driving down the road, and your infotainment system suddenly stops working for no discernible reason. A part failure like this would very likely be covered under warranty. But if you spill coffee on it first, that would not be covered under an extended warranty.

      Types of coverage

      Car warranties come in two main types: stated-component and exclusionary. For the most part, 95% of extended warranty plans are exclusionary, midtier or powertrain plans by other names.

      • Stated-component warranties list exactly which parts are covered.
      • Exclusionary warranties cover everything except the parts listed in the contract.

      Types of plans

      • Bumper-to-bumper warranties: Bumper-to-bumper warranties offer exclusionary coverage, meaning they cover nearly everything unless it’s listed as not covered. Companies often call these plans “Platinum,” “Diamond” or something similar. These comprehensive warranties are typically reserved for cars with under 100,000 miles.
      • Powertrain warranties: As the name implies, these extend your car’s factory powertrain warranty. Powertrain warranties cover the most important parts that make your car run, like the engine, transmission and drivetrain. They don’t cover as many parts as bumper-to-bumper plans.
      • Midtier stated-component warranties: These provide coverage somewhere between the powertrain and bumper-to-bumper tiers. They are often called “Gold” or “Silver” plans. What they cover can be different for each company, so always read the fine print.
      • Drivetrain warranties: A drivetrain warranty is similar to a powertrain warranty, but it does not cover your engine. These are not very common anymore.
      • Specialty warranties: This is an umbrella term used to describe warranties that only cover specific component groups, like electronics. Not all manufacturers offer specialty plans, and those that do may have very different offerings.
      • Wrap warranties: These plans are designed for cars that are still under a manufacturer’s powertrain warranty. Wrap warranties complement your existing coverage and get the rest of your vehicle back under warranty.

      What do car warranties not cover?

      A car warranty does not cover damage from preexisting conditions, owner negligence or accidents (that’s what car insurance is for). It also does not cover routine maintenance, cosmetic issues and regular wear items.

      ExclusionExamples
      Routine maintenanceOil changes, tire rotations, fluid changes, tuneups and inspections
      Cosmetic issuesPaint, upholstery, trim, dents, scratches and interior stains
      Regular wearBrake pads, tires, wiper blades, spark plugs, belts and hoses
      Preexisting conditionsProblems or symptoms that began before coverage started
      Accidental or environmental damageCollision damage, flooding, hail, fire, theft and vandalism
      Unauthorized modificationsFailures caused by aftermarket performance parts, lift kits, engine tuning or other modifications
      Owner negligenceDamage caused by missed maintenance, overheating, improper fluids or continued driving after a warning light appears

      Is an extended car warranty worth it?

      An extended car warranty can help you save money if your car needs big repairs. An extended car warranty is worth it if:

      • You drive a less reliable car.
      • You can’t afford a surprise repair bill.
      • The warranty costs less than the expected repairs.
      • You don’t mind paying for peace of mind.
      Your ideal coverage depends on your car’s age, reliability record and how long you plan to keep it.

      For example, Robert in Texas was happy to only pay a $100 deductible for a $775 repair on his Mercedes-Benz. “I paid $2,800 for the policy,” he told us. “So, I'm going to keep a running total to see whether it was worth it or not. I don't put that many miles on the car and I may have another repair or I may not. But at least I know if I have a major repair, it's going to be covered.”

      Questions to ask yourself

      To break things down a little further for you, if you answer "yes" to any of these questions, a warranty might be a good idea for you, both financially and emotionally. If not, paying out of pocket for repairs could cost less than investing in a warranty. Plus, you’ll have more control over where and how repairs are done.

      Is my car reliable?

      If your car breaks down a lot or is known for having problems, a warranty can help. If your vehicle only needs relatively affordable or infrequent repairs, it might not.

      Will the warranty cost less than future repairs?

      Try this: Look up how much your car usually costs to fix each year. Multiply that by how many years you’ll keep the car. Is that more than the cost of the warranty? If yes, a warranty might make mathematical sense, even if it doesn’t cover 100% of expected repairs (which it won’t).

      Would a big repair bill wreck my finances?

      Even a $1,000 unexpected repair would wreck most drivers' savings, and the most expensive car repairs cost a lot more than that. They’re also getting more expensive. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, maintenance and repair costs increased 48% between May 2020 and May 2026.

      Do I like peace of mind, even if I never file a claim?

      Some people sleep better knowing they're partially protected from surprise expenses. Just don’t make the common mistake of thinking your warranty will cover 100% of parts 100% of the time.

      Pros and cons of extended auto warranties

      It’s important to weigh the potential pros and cons of an extended warranty before committing to one.

      Pros

      • Peace of mind
      • Financial protection in case of unexpected breakdowns
      • Roadside assistance often included
      • Can be cheaper than paying for major repairs out of pocket
      • Can help maintain your vehicle's resale value

      Cons

      • May not be worth it for reliable vehicles
      • May not cover all parts or situations
      • May require using specific repair shops or parts
      • Mileage or time limits
      • May have deductible for each repair

      FAQ

      What is an extended car warranty?

      An extended auto warranty, also known as a vehicle service contract, is like an insurance policy that can safeguard you against repair bills. When your car breaks down, you pay a deductible and your warranty provider pays the repair bill. Coverage lasts for an agreed-upon period or until your car hits a given mileage.

      Different providers offer varying types and levels of coverage, and an extended warranty is not the same as car insurance, which you should have regardless.

      What voids a car warranty?

      A car warranty can be voided if you miss required maintenance and cannot show records, cause damage by improper use or make unauthorized vehicle modifications that lead to part failures. Keeping detailed receipts for oil changes, tuneups and other factory-recommended services helps maintain the validity of your coverage.

      Can I cancel my extended warranty?

      Yes, most extended warranty providers allow you to cancel your warranty. The process may involve a cancellation fee, and the amount you get refunded will depend on the length of time the warranty has been in place and whether you've made any claims.

      What is a manufacturer’s warranty?

      A manufacturer’s warranty is the coverage that comes with a new vehicle to repair or replace specific components that fail due to defects. 

      All new cars come with a manufacturer’s warranty or factory warranty that is backed by the car maker. The minimum new car warranty is three years/36,000 miles.

      Where can I buy an extended warranty for my car?

      You can buy an extended warranty for your car from your car’s manufacturer (often before the factory warranty expires) or from third-party providers at almost any time, as long as your vehicle meets mileage and age requirements. There is often a waiting period of 30 days and 1,000 miles before coverage kicks in. The price of coverage typically rises as your vehicle ages.

      Methodology: How we picked the best extended car warranties

      The ConsumerAffairs Research Team compared extended car warranty companies using verified customer reviews, coverage details, vehicle eligibility and overall value.

      We analyzed verified reviews submitted between Aug. 1, 2025, and July 31, 2026, focusing on satisfaction with:

      • Coverage
      • Customer service
      • Price

      We also compared:

      • Claims experiences
      • Number of coverage plans
      • Maintenance and other benefits
      • Vehicle age and mileage limits
      • Pricing and overall value

      Companies that covered older or higher-mileage vehicles scored better on eligibility.

      Each company received a score from zero to 10 for each factor. We then adjusted the weights based on the award. For example, “Best claims process” puts more weight on claims and customer service, while “Best for older vehicles” focuses more on age and mileage limits.

      The highest-scoring company in each category earned the corresponding “Our pick for” designation.

      Get expert advice on extended auto warranties

      How can consumers determine whether the cost of an auto warranty fits within their budget?
      Lori Lohman

      Lori Lohman

      Professor, marketing, Augsburg University

      The best way to determine if an extended warranty fits within your budget is to find out the cost of some of the most common repairs and determine whether you have the funds to cover them. It also depends on how much you like your vehicle and are willing to spend to keep it running. Some major repairs, such as engine or transmission failure, can easily run $4,000-$8,000, and you might not want to keep the car if it's older and has high mileage. Other repairs, such as air conditioning, are expensive but don't affect the drivability of the vehicle and can cost $1,000-$2,000.

      If you don't think you can afford such a repair, then you might want to consider an extended warranty, but make sure it doesn't overlap with any existing coverage offered by the auto manufacturer — and remember that it may end up costing you more in the long run if it's wrapped into your auto financing. Rather than buying a warranty, you could develop a dedicated savings account to handle anticipated future repairs because all cars, sooner or later, will need some repairs as well as basic maintenance (such as brakes) that isn't covered by a warranty. If you bought a vehicle that has had good reliability ratings, it's unlikely that you will experience the need for major repairs.

      Read their bio
      Michael Noel

      Michael Noel

      Professor, economics, Texas Tech University

      First, ask yourself if you need an extended warranty. New cars come with warranties, often three years, while used cars purchased from a dealership may or may not have a (shorter) warranty attached. Extended warranties can extend that time but not indefinitely. While repairs can be expensive, if you have the funds and can handle the risk of a big repair, it is cheaper over the long run to self-insure, i.e. pay for repairs yourself as you go … If an expensive repair would be outside your budget, however, then you should consider additional insurance. Paid by the month or annually, it provides a known expense that is easier to manage. It is then straightforward to see if such a number fits within one's budget. But be wary of what the insurance does and does not cover, so you don't find, surprisingly, you're paying twice. Check in particular about policies on hybrid-related parts. Note that emissions systems often come with an extended warranty for free under state law. For new cars, it is worth checking if there is a no-use refundable option as well, which some manufacturers have offered — with this, if you go through the extended warranty period without a claim, you are refunded the premium altogether. This protects not only against things going wrong but also against things going right. After three years of driving and learning about your car's reliability, you may well learn which is the greater risk after all.

      Read their bio
      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Assistant professor, economics, Lewis University

      To determine whether the cost of an auto warranty is affordable, consumers should consider the following:

      • Evaluating Disposable Income:
        • Disposable income, or net income after taxes, is essential for financial planning. So budgeting should prioritize necessary expenses such as housing, health care, food, transportation, utilities, and savings.
      • Auto Warranties as a 'Necessary' Expense:
        • Reliable transportation is crucial for daily life, making an auto warranty often a 'necessary' expense.
        • High repair costs for modern vehicles justify allocating funds to mitigate unexpected expenses.
      • Assessing Warranty Costs vs. Expected Repair Costs:
        • Evaluate the warranty cost relative to potential repair expenses based on the vehicle's make, year, age, and condition.
        • On the one hand, new vehicles with existing warranties and lower repair costs may not require additional coverage. On the other hand, older or used vehicles with higher repair risks are better candidates for extended warranties.
        • Hence, a mechanical inspection by an authorized dealer can help determine if an extended warranty is necessary.
      • Opportunity Cost of a Warranty:
        • Disposable income can be allocated to consumption (essential or nonessential) or savings, so funds not spent should ideally be saved then invested to preserve value against inflation.
        • Transportation expenses are essential, but a car warranty's necessity depends on the vehicle's condition stated above.
        • Thus, consumers should weigh the benefits of investing money versus spending it on a warranty — ensuring alignment with financial goals.

      Read their bio
      Tin-Chun Lin

      Tin-Chun Lin

      Professor, economics, Indiana University Northwest

      In my opinion, consumers need to figure out their vehicle’s age and mileage because older vehicles with higher mileage would have higher warranty costs. In addition, consumers need to estimate their future costs for repairing their vehicle and compare quotes from different providers to figure out the best value and benefit for their needs. Moreover, consumers need to study what components would be covered by the warranty and further compare them to the potential repair cost of these parts.

      Read their bio
      How can consumers effectively negotiate or shop around for the best prices and terms on extended warranties, and what leverage do they have in these transactions?
      Lori Lohman

      Lori Lohman

      Professor, marketing, Augsburg University

      Extended warranties are moneymakers for dealerships, but they could potentially be negotiated if you do your homework and check with other dealers/other plans, both those provided by manufacturers and by other third parties. Here is an instance in which using artificial intelligence tools may be useful to compare prices and coverage. That will give you some leverage, but remember that many dealerships are moving away from sales negotiations and may refuse to budge on the price tag; it's worth a try, however. If you want to get the best deal, do your homework.

      Read their bio
      Dina El-Mahdy

      Dina El-Mahdy

      Associate Professor, accounting, Morgan State University

      To secure the best prices and terms on extended warranties, consumers should shop for and obtain multiple quotes from various providers, including dealerships and third-party companies, for comparison. Competitor offers can provide leverage in negotiations. Recognizing that dealerships often increase warranty prices before negotiation can also give consumers an advantage and a margin to negotiate. Timing is another critical factor. Negotiating an extended warranty when purchasing a vehicle or during holiday sales events may result in better offers, as dealerships are often motivated to close sales. Consumers should carefully review contract terms and conditions, including cancellation policies, transferability, and claim procedures, to ensure the terms are flexible and fair.

      Read their bio
      D. Scott Emge

      D. Scott Emge

      Professor, finance, Loyola University Maryland

      1. Get quotes and compare pricing from multiple sources (make sure you understand the coverage details and you are comparing comparable plans), ask the company for specials and deals, and don't be afraid to negotiate the pricing. As a consumer, you can leverage multiple competitive offers — and always be prepared to walk away (you are under no obligation to buy).
      2. Consumers should assess the likelihood of repairs and associated costs and select a warranty that best meets the usage (this entails evaluating your vehicle's age, mileage, reliability, and driving habits). Consumers should also understand the specifics of a warranty plan to understand what is covered, exclusions, and limitations before making any decision.
      3. Consumers should also read reviews to help get a sense for how consumers with the warranty feel overall about the specific plan and the value provided.

      Read their bio
      Laura Gonzalez

      Laura Gonzalez

      Professor, finance, California State University - Long Beach

      Most households need more than one car. This is a powerful negotiation leverage when getting to know a new provider. Potential extended business helps negotiate the conditions of an extended warranty for just one car. It allows for better conditions and time to test, gather information, and plan effectively for the future and other cars, motorcycles, etc. No significant financial commitment or decision should be made in a rush or following a soon-expiring deal with some discount for a multi-item contract.

      Read their bio
      Under which circumstances does an auto warranty offer the most value?
      Dina El-Mahdy

      Dina El-Mahdy

      Associate Professor, accounting, Morgan State University

      Auto warranties are especially valuable for vehicles prone to frequent or costly repairs. They are also beneficial for owners of cars with unique features (e.g., body trim that is easily damaged and requires frequent repairs or an expensive electronic 'sunroof'), providing peace of mind and financial protection. Warranties that offer transferability to new owners (e.g., warranties linked to the vehicle's identification number (VIN) regardless of the owner) deliver the greatest value to consumers. For consumers with tight budgets, an auto warranty ensures predictable costs (e.g., fixed monthly fees) and reduces the risk of significant out-of-pocket expenses for unexpected repairs. Additionally, in areas where repair services are expensive (e.g., due to high labor costs or scarce materials), an auto warranty can be a cost-effective safeguard against steep repair bills.

      Read their bio
      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Assistant professor, economics, Lewis University

      An auto warranty provides the most value under these circumstances:

      • Older or High-Mileage Vehicles:
        • The condition of the vehicle is a key factor in deciding whether an extended warranty is necessary. While new vehicles often come with warranties lasting two to 10 years, used vehicles typically lack this coverage. Consumers should have the car inspected by an authorized dealer to assess its condition and determine if an extended warranty is needed. Extended warranties are frequently recommended for used vehicles to mitigate the high repair costs associated with potential mechanical breakdowns.
      • Luxury or Imported Vehicles:
        • The type of vehicle significantly influences the need for an extended warranty. For luxury or imported vehicles, parts may be more expensive and harder to source, often requiring importation, which increases both monetary and time costs. Additionally, these vehicles may demand more labor-intensive repairs, further raising overall expenses.
      • Financial Vulnerability:
        • Investing in an extended warranty can provide financial protection against costly mechanical failures. Consumers, particularly those with limited savings, should consider the potential savings and peace of mind an extended warranty can offer.

      Read their bio
      Hyeong-Tak Lee

      Hyeong-Tak Lee

      Assistant professor, marketing, University of Iowa

      An auto warranty can be particularly valuable when the vehicle’s brand is relatively new to the market and there isn’t enough data available for consumers to accurately estimate the likelihood or frequency of repairs. For example, an imported carmaker introducing a new brand to the U.S. market may use extended warranties to address potential quality concerns that consumers might have about the unfamiliar brand. In such cases, the warranty not only reassures consumers by providing additional protection but also helps the automaker build trust and confidence in their new brand.

      Read their bio
      Gyan Pradhan

      Gyan Pradhan

      Professor, economics, Christopher Newport University

      An auto warranty offers more value if one intends to own the car for longer durations; if the brand is unreliable; if the cost of the warranty compares favorably to the cost of potential repairs; if one does not tend to keep up with regular maintenance; or if one expects to drive a lot. Finally, it may also offer more value if peace of mind is important to the insurer. To put it differently, the more risk averse a person is, the more value the warranty provides.

      Read their bio
      Beyond price, what factors determine whether an auto warranty saves money in the long run?
      Dina El-Mahdy

      Dina El-Mahdy

      Associate Professor, accounting, Morgan State University

      When evaluating an auto warranty, consumers should look beyond the price and focus on the depth of coverage and expected quality of service after the sale. Comprehensive warranties that cover expensive components tend to offer better value over time. Checking for claim limits and understanding exclusions is essential to avoid unpleasant surprises. The reputation of the warranty provider is another critical consideration. Researching reviews and complaint histories can help assess their reliability and responsiveness. Vehicle history and usage also matter — warranties are often more beneficial for less reliable vehicles or those with higher expected use. Consumers should evaluate the claims process, including options for repair shops, payment methods, and customer service quality. High deductibles or service fees can diminish savings, so these costs should be factored into the decision. Finally, the terms and conditions of the warranty should align with how long the consumer plans to keep the vehicle. If consumers intend to sell their vehicles in the short term, investing in a long-term warranty may not be a viable decision and could result in wasted resources.

      Read their bio
      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Oguzhan Batmaz

      Assistant professor, economics, Lewis University

      To assess whether an auto warranty is cost-effective, consumers should evaluate the following:

      • Reliability Data:
        • Data is invaluable in decision-making. Consumers should research the vehicle's history and reliability to make informed decisions about purchasing an extended warranty.
      • Coverage Specifics:
        • Consumers must carefully review what the warranty covers and what it excludes, ensuring all details are clear to avoid misunderstandings. It's equally important to watch out for hidden fees that could impact the overall value of the warranty.
      • Claims Process:
        • Before purchasing an extended warranty, consumers should investigate the claims process of the provider or dealer. Understanding how claims are handled can offer clarity and confidence in the warranty’s practicality.
      • Transferability:
        • Since vehicles are often sold or traded, consumers should check if the warranty is transferable. A transferable warranty can add value to the vehicle and make it easier to sell in the future.

      Read their bio
      Tin-Chun Lin

      Tin-Chun Lin

      Professor, economics, Indiana University Northwest

      Beyond price, the key indicators I would suggest for consumers to consider may include the covered parts and repairs, the deductible amount, the warranty provider’s reputation, the length of coverage, the claims process, the reliability of the vehicle, and whether the warranty is transferable to a new owner. Certainly, consumers need to evaluate their vehicle’s age, mileage, reliability, and their own driving habits. The above-mentioned key indicators may be used to judge whether consumers’ auto warranty will truly save them money in the long run.

      Read their bio
      Wooyang Kim

      Wooyang Kim

      Professor, marketing, Minnesota State University Moorhead

      I would like to emphasize two primary considerations for this assessment: brand reputation for vehicle reliability and quality customer service in the functional dimension, and peace of mind against anxiety about uncertain future events in the psychological dimension. While several other factors should be evaluated before making a final decision in the cost-benefit analysis, these two considerations serve as critical baselines for estimating the potential cost savings offered by a vehicle warranty. Since purchasing an auto warranty is an investment in both the monetary and psychological assets of car owners, these two rationales can help ensure meaningful savings in their perceived value over the long term.

      Read their bio
      Guide sources

      ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work. Specific sources for this guide include:

      1. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, “What is an extended warranty or vehicle service contract?” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.
      2. Federal Trade Commission, “Auto Warranties and Auto Service Contracts.” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.
      3. Federal Trade Commission, “Extended Warranties and Service Contracts.” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.
      4. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, “Do You Want an Extended Warranty with That?” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.
      5. Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, “Consumer Price Index for All Urban Consumers: Motor Vehicle Maintenance and Repair in U.S. City Average.” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.
      6. California Department of Insurance, “Guide to Automobile Service Contracts, Extended Warranties and Other Repair Agreements.” Accessed Sept. 9, 2026.

      Not sure how to choose?

      Get buying tips about Extended Auto Warranties delivered to your inbox.

        By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

        Thanks for subscribing.

        You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

        Compare extended car warranty reviews

        Showing 10 of 79

        Want your company to be on this guide?

        Yes, Continue
        Comparing

        ×