American Guardian Warranty Services Inc.

American Guardian Warranty Services Inc.

 1.1/5 (78 ratings)
  • 5 stars
  • 4 stars
  • 3 stars
  • 2 stars
  • 1 stars

Our Buyers Guide Top Picks:

Protect My Car

Protect My Car

View Pricing
Endurance Auto Warranty

Endurance Warranty

View Pricing
Author picture
Written by
Edited by

About American Guardian Warranty Services Inc.

American Guardian is an extended auto warranty company that offers warranties for cars, recreational vehicles, powersport vehicles, marine vehicles, and medium- and heavy-duty trucks and buses. All warranties from American Guardian are potentially transferable, and the company provides a 100% part replacement guarantee.

Find Extended Auto Warranties near you

    Overall Satisfaction Rating

    • 5 stars
    • 4 stars
    • 3 stars
    • 2 stars
    • 1 stars


    • Variety of plans
    • RV and powersport vehicle plans
    • Specialty coverages available


    • Low customer ratings
    • Doesn’t sell directly to consumers

    Bottom Line

    American Guardian offers a wide range of coverage options for a variety of vehicles. However, it only sells through dealerships, so it’s hard to get a quote and make a smart purchase.

    What is American Guardian?

    American Guardian is a company that offers extended warranties for cars and other vehicles, including recreational vehicles, powersport vehicles, boats, trucks and buses. It offers its products through dealerships, so most of its product information is directed towards industry professionals.

    American Guardian plans

    American Guardian has multiple vehicle service plans available at the time of publishing:

    • Compass Protection Plan contracts include coverage for mechanical repairs and parts and labor on eligible vehicles up to 20 years old or with up to 200,000 miles. Three coverage tiers are available under this plan.
    • Compass Platinum Plus provides exclusionary coverage (including wear-and-tear items) with no deductible.
    • Compass Basic gives you coverage for mechanical repairs, parts and labor on vehicles up to 20 years old or with up to 200,000 miles.
    • Compass Advantage is a loyalty program offering separate engine and powertrain coverage for up to the lifetime of the vehicle.
    • Your Plan is either a basic stated component plan or an exclusionary plan. Appearance protection products are also available.
    • GAP Protection covers you if your car is totaled while you’re upside-down on your loan.
    • Compass Limited Warranty offers coverage for repairs, parts and labor for up to six months or 6,000 miles.
    • Key Replacement protects you from paying for a new key after loss, theft or destruction.
    • Extended Lease Wear & Tear Limited Waiver Addendum covers wear-and-tear fees on leased vehicles.
    • Tire & Wheel only covers your car’s wheels, tires and rims from road hazards.
    • Paintless Dent Repair covers the cost of repairing dents and dings on your vehicle.
    • Theft Protection covers you against total loss.
    • Dealer Branded Pre-Paid Maintenance plans offer discounts on maintenance for 24, 36 or 48 months.
    • Driver’s Armor Ancillary packages offer protection for cosmetic repairs, tires and wheels.
    • Driver’s Armor Certified protects certified pre-owned vehicles with a limited engine warranty.
    • Complete Coverage is an a-la-carte plan that lets you choose your coverage.
    • Compass Tech + offers three levels of coverage for your car’s interior electrical components.

    Many of these plans offer similar coverages, so individual dealers likely won’t offer all of them. Contact your local dealer to see which they offer.

    American Guardian benefits

    Plans from American Guardian can come with benefits such as:

    • Roadside assistance
    • Rental car reimbursement
    • Towing
    • Trip interruption insurance

    Benefit details vary from plan to plan, so check with your dealership to see what benefits are included in their offerings.

    American Guardian cost

    American Guardian doesn’t list any prices on its website, so you’ll have to contact a partnered dealership for a quote. Not having pricing online is fairly normal for the extended auto warranty industry, but many companies offer a quote tool rather than making you deal with a third party for purchase.

    American Guardian’s published deductibles range from $0 to $500.

    American Guardian FAQ

    Does American Guardian have coverage for motor homes?
    Yes, American Guardian has warranties for motor homes and RVs.
    Can I get a refund on my car warranty from American Guardian?
    You can cancel your contract with the dealership that sold you your contract, and the dealer may offer you a refund.
    Can I transfer my American Guardian car warranty?
    Yes, car warranties from American Guardian are transferable, but you have to submit a request with the company.
    How can I get a quote from American Guardian?
    You can’t. American Guardian suggests that you contact a dealership for pricing information.
    Where are American Guardian warranties accepted?
    American Guardian recommends you take your vehicle to the dealership where you purchased it. If that’s not possible, you can take your vehicle to your choice of repair shop as long as it is a licensed business and can confirm the appropriate business insurance.

    American Guardian also has National Fleet Accounts with companies such as Firestone, Pep Boys, AAMCO, Interstate Transmissions, Multistate and Mr. Transition, meaning you can take your vehicle to any of these locations.

    Is American Guardian worth it?

    While it’s good that American Guardian covers diverse vehicles and has transferable warranties, consumer reviews are overwhelmingly negative at the time of publishing. Reviewers cite high-pressure sales tactics and frustrating experiences with customer service. If you are considering coverage from American Guardian, try getting quotes from several other companies to verify that you’re making a smart decision. This should help set expectations for pricing and customer service so you can make an informed decision.

    American Guardian Warranty Services Inc. Reviews

    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful
    • Any
    • Rated with 5 stars
    • Rated with 4 stars
    • Rated with 3 stars
    • Rated with 2 stars
    • Rated with 1 star

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about American Guardian Warranty Services, Inc?
    • 4,188,850 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

    For more information about reviews on please visit our FAQ.

    Page 1 Reviews 0 - 10
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: June 17, 2022

    We have an extended warranty for my 2013 dodge journey. This company will not approve our transmission replace because we can not find 2 missing receipts for oil changes. This is absolutely stupid for that fact that a oil change has absolutely nothing to do with the transmission going out. It has been 2 plus month with very little communication from them I have set multiple email and have called multiple times. They don't respond and I call and get the run around. I will be contacting a attorney. I advise everyone who is think of using this company to do research. This company is a scam and a rip off

    Be the first one to find this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: April 29, 2022

    Submitted warranty claim for transmission issue. Provided American Guardian with service records for transmission services that had been done on the vehicle which had been done based on the timeframe stipulated in the contract. They then requested all service records with regards to oil changes, which have absolutely nothing to do with the transmission. Claim was denied because a few of the oil changes were not done in the time frame stated in the contract. Customer service then said that the oil change time frames/mileage are based on the vehicle maintenance schedule from the manufacturer for that vehicle, which is different from what is in the contract. It basically comes down to this company has no morals with regards to doing what is right for the consumer.

    Be the first one to find this review helpful

    Not sure how to choose?

    Get buying tips about Extended Auto Warranties delivered to your inbox.

      By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Nov. 10, 2021

      The transmission line on my motorhome broke, sheering the metal line and dumping the fluid on the ground. The vehicle was never driven beyond the point that the line exploded. I reviewed the warranty and followed the instructions to authorize the repairs so that the shop could diagnose the problem. I contacted the warranty company and got the information so that the service center could begin to initiate the claim. Once the claim was initiated the assessor went to the shop. He asked why they had to replace the line and the technician explained that the line had to be repaired to determine if the issue was with the transmission. He was told that it was a failure within the transmission.

      I called every other week trying to get status updates to the claim. No one ever contacted me, not even the assessor. No one asked me what had happened or if there were any prior issues. I asked for the name and contact information several times and was told they wouldn't provide me with that information. They told me three times that they would email him for a status update. The company who pulled the transmission apart said that the pressure switch or pump had gone bad within the transmission and that it had to create an excessive amount of pressure to blow that line. Four weeks after the assessor had inspected the vehicle neither myself or the shop had heard back from the warranty company.

      I called and asked if I could get an update and they told me that the claim was denied. They never told myself or the service center why or informed either of us that the claim was denied. I see from other complaints that this is common with this company. I encourage others to DM me on Twitter at ** to explore legal recourse. Leave reviews with dealerships selling their warranties to warn their customers that they are selling a deceptive and fraudulent product. Contact your state Attorney General. This company should not be allowed to continue this scam.

      6 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: March 23, 2021

      Do not buy this warranty. I had a claim a couple months back on my RZR. They required service records and said they was good and paid the 900 dollar repair bill. Then a month ago it had another transmission problem. They required my machine maintenance records. I used the same records I had from before. This time they denied my claim because the invoice numbers on the receipts wasn't correct. 2 of them matched.

      Granted I have the same records of maintenance used last claim then they said because I told the repair shop to fix it cause it had been being drug out and wasn't going to have be paid for by my pocket or American Guardian because it had been taking so long for them to approve the repair or my maintenance records. I told the repair place to fix it before I had to start paying storage on the machine. American guardian then denied doing any more to resolve my claim and stuck me paying 3600 dollars for the repairs. This absolutely the sorriest company I have ever dealt with.

      7 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Feb. 12, 2021

      Do NOT use this company. They will rip you off. Take your money and when you need them they will do everything in their power to deny a legitimate claim verified by a reputable and well-known dealership. Save that money for your children, instead of giving them a dime. They will not look out for you...

      7 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Jan. 12, 2021

      PLEASE PEOPLE STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY SCAM! If I could rate less I would. We bought this insurance in 2018 when we bought our 2015 Tiffin. We have had to use it 2 times. 1st on a air condition fan blade and motor being repaired. This company would only pay for a little over 200 dollars of a 550.00 dollars invoice. The last time we broke down in the middle of the country, motor home (43 ft) had to be towed. This company only paid 300 of a 900 dollar tow bill. The problem that happened was 3 freeze plugs came out of the head. American Guardian will only pay for 2134.40 of a 3525.42 bill. By the way the work was done at a certified Cummins dealer! Part of the problem they say they don't pay for reprogramming the ECM although the ECM is what told the motor to shut down. So I don't have to get in details. PLEASE PEOPLE STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY. SCAM.

      15 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Dec. 14, 2020

      If you are buying a vehicle and they offer you GAP coverages from American Guardian Warranty Services RUN FOR YOUR LIFE!!!! Hands down the WORST company I've ever dealt with. When my new car needed a repair, they DENIED my claim and then when I got into an accident and the car was paid off by my insurance company, they stated that Progressive did not give them enough money and denied to cover the rest. I paid $900 for this GAP coverage only to get denied twice and have them NOT pay for the "GAP". The customer service reps are rude as hell, and they use this INACCURATE pricing website called ** to OVERVALUE my car so that they have a reason not to pay the remaining $1700.00 on my vehicle.

      They told me it "wasn't their problem" and that I would need to call Progressive to give them more money. Then I requested they email me a letter.... It took 4 calls and a month to get a denial letter. Before I purchased their GAP coverage, I read the reviews and they were HORRIBLE and I still purchased their plans. Biggest mistake ever! I am warning you to NOT make my same mistake and use this company. I've learned that most online reviews are pretty accurate and I am sure you have read a lot of unsatisfied reviews in addition to mine.

      Save your money and pay out of pocket or find another GAP company. This company is just SHADY as hell. You probably have scrolled down and seen a bunch of 1 star reviews. I bet you the 5 star reviews are all FAKE. Take my word for it and PLEASE DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY. Before you go to a car dealership, ask them what company they use for an extended warranty and GAP coverage. If they state it is American Guardian Warranty Services, then ask them if they have another company and if not, FIND ANOTHER CAR DEALERSHIP. Trust me, the reviews you see are ACCURATE.

      7 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      profile pic of the author
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Aug. 13, 2020

      This company does not pay diagnostic fees, though you the customer are required to have the diagnosis done to diagnose the problem(s) needing repair. This company denies coverage for manufacturer defects when non-related maintenance [like an oil change at the suggested number of hours] isn't done - though no proof exists that the manufacturer defect can be directly related to routine maintenance. The bottom line is that this company provides policies that apparently they do not fully honor, and we found out too late it's a waste of money and they are NOT consumer-friendly. It is not recommended to purchase a policy with this company for any reason.

      11 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      profile pic of the author
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Aug. 7, 2020

      Do not go here. Why:

      •NO NEW PARTS OFFERED IN REPLACEMENT. Only want to replace transmission with a junkyard part. LITERALLY.

      •Somehow justified not paying ANY LABOR COSTS. Also, their limit is a pathetic $100 per hour and you'll be hard pressed to find a legitimate shop that had that low a rate. YOU WILL PAY FOR LABOR ONE WAY OR ANOTHER.

      •They send out an inspector and take their sweet time so YOU WILL BE CAR-LESS FOR DAYS. WEEKS FOR ME PERSONALLY.

      Scam scam scam. Don't end up like me, go somewhere else.

      10 people found this review helpful
      Rated with 1 star
      Verified Reviewer
      Original review: Feb. 25, 2020

      The engine in my Hyundai Tucson needed replaced. After 4 WEEKS of them arguing with a Hyundai service garage, they finally approved the repair. ...But, they would only approve the repair based on aftermarket prices, knowing that a Hyundai repair shop is not going to order aftermarket parts when the entire engine needs replaced. In the end, I was forced to pay ALMOST $2,000 out of pocket (and my plan had no deductible). Stay away from this garbage.

      12 people found this review helpful

      Quick and easy. Get matched with an Auto Warranty partner.

        Loading more reviews...

        American Guardian Warranty Services Inc. Company Information

        Company Name:
        American Guardian Warranty Services, Inc

        Check out our buyers guide top picks

        Our Buyers Guide Top Picks:

        Endurance Auto Warranty

        Endurance Warranty

        View Pricing