1. Homeowners
  2. Best Mattress Brands

Best Mattress Brands

Suggested offers from our partners.

Our favorite mattress companies of 2023

Shop Now
Author pictureAuthor pictureAuthor picture
Author picture
Written by
Author picture
Edited by
Author picture
Reviewed by

Our research team vetted 47 brands rated by more than 38,000 verified customers. Read our guide to choose the best mattress company for you by comparing mattress types, firmness levels and costs. See which mattress is right for you and the way you sleep.

Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
  • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
  • 4,313,342 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

Compare Top Mattress Reviews

  • Featured
  • Best Rated
  • Most Reviewed
  • Highest Rated

Our picks for top mattresses

You spend roughly one-third of your life in bed, so it's important to find a quality mattress that fits your needs and lets you get good rest. However, with dozens of mattress brands on the market, it can be hard to determine which product is right for your sleep style (and budget).

Many mattress brands run frequent promotions that can save you hundreds of dollars.

Take a few minutes to compare a few mattress brands before making a purchase. We’ve gathered info on costs, trial periods, warranties and reviews below.

Compare our mattress picks

Below, compare our favorite options from some of our top-rated mattress brands.

Starting costs*Trial periodWarranty
Saatva$1,580180 nights15 years
Luma Sleep$1,195100 nights10 years
Leesa$1,099100 nights10 years
Tuft & Needle$895100 nights10 years
Helix$1,099100 nights10 to 15 years
CraftmaticVary30 nights25 years
Nest Bedding$799100 nightsLifetime
Sealy$549100 nights10 years
Zenhaven$2,460180 nights20 years
Cocoon by Sealy$769100 nights10 years

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Top-rated overall Saatva Mattress
  • Costs: $1,580 and up*
  • Trial period: 180 nights
  • Warranty: 15 years
Shop Now
saatva classic mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

As of publishing, Saatva is the top-rated mattress company on our site. It offers hybrid, memory foam and specialty mattresses. It’s “a slice of heaven,” according to a reviewer in New York. “I never dreamed I could sleep so much better,” another reviewer in Georgia said. “It's cool, it's comfortable, it makes me want to go to bed!”

On the downside, some recent reviews refer to shipping delays (likely caused by COVID-19 supply chain issues). For more info, compare Saatva vs. Casper.

Our picks for stomach sleepers

Sleeping on your stomach can put extra strain on your body, so look for a firm, supportive mattress to ensure proper alignment and pressure relief.

Latex hybrid option Luma Sleep
  • Costs: $1,195 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Learn More
Luma Sleep mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Luma Sleep offers hybrid latex mattresses at varying firmness levels. Layers consist of foam, latex and coils, but the number of layers and their proportions differ by model. A reviewer in Arizona got one because they wanted an organic mattress, saying, “It's lovely and it doesn't smell bad. There's no off gap thing and it's very soft. I love it.”

Memory foam option Leesa
  • Costs: $1,099 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Learn More
Leesa memory foam mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Leesa offers memory foam and hybrid mattresses, all of which are medium-firm designs. While some stomach sleepers may want a firmer mattress, others might find a medium-firm mattress more comfortable for them or their partners.

Happy Leesa reviewers say their mattresses are comfortable and affordable. However, Leesa doesn’t offer as many cooling features as some other memory foam models do.

Still not sure? Check out four more mattresses for stomach sleepers.

Our picks for side sleepers

If you’re a side sleeper, look for a softer mattress that allows your hip and shoulder to sink in for proper spinal alignment. Memory foam mattresses can be good for this, but medium-soft or medium innerspring mattresses can also work well for side sleepers.

Softer mattresses aren’t recommended for most people because they don’t provide enough support for other sleeping positions, though.

Gel foam option Tuft & Needle
  • Costs: $895 and up
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Shop Now
tuft & needle mint mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Tuft & Needle offers three models, but its Mint Mattress is its best option for side sleepers because it’s the softest in the company’s lineup. The Mint Mattress is an all-foam design with cooling gel to help people that tend to sleep hot. However, this model is more expensive than Tuft & Needle’s other options, coming in at $1,195 for a queen-size model before any discounts.

Hybrid option Helix Mattress
  • Costs: $1,099 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 to 15 years
Learn More
helix sunset luxe mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Helix offers a wide range of mattress models, and each Helix mattress features individually pocketed coils to cradle your shoulders, spine and hips. Upgrades in its Helix Luxe line include zoned lumbar support, a breathable Tencel cover and additional comfort layers. Luxe models start at $1,949, and the Sunset Luxe model is the brand’s recommendation for side sleepers.

“Unboxing was straightforward, you slide it out of the box, align it with your base and cut open the plastic. It pops open and comes to life as soon as you cut the plastic,” according to a reviewer in New Jersey. Other mattress reviews say Helix is a great value for the money. However, a few reviews mention that its customer service could improve.

Still aren’t sure? Check out more of our mattress picks for side sleepers.

Our pick for back pain

If you have chronic back pain, finding the right mattress is critical. Firm mattresses provide good support for those with back problems. However, sometimes a mattress that is too firm can irritate joint pain. Depending on your sleeping position, you might consider medium-firm support, too.

Adjustable option Craftmatic Adjustable Beds
  • Costs: Vary
  • Trial period: 30 nights
  • Warranty: 25 years
Learn More
craftmatic luxury firm mattress

Craftmatic primarily makes adjustable beds. Mattresses for its Model I and Legacy models come in four firmness levels, but Luxury Firm may be the right option for people with back pain.

One reviewer in Florida said it’s “especially good if you or your significant other have any health issues. For back sufferers or breathing issues, this bed is perfect.” However, there are a few reviews that mention delivery delays.

Still not sure? Check out our other picks for the top mattresses for back pain.

Our picks for couples

If you sleep with a partner, consider a mattress that reduces motion transfer. This means the mattress won’t move as much if your partner gets up or moves during the night.

Memory foam mattresses are often a good choice for couples because of their superior motion isolation. If you’re set on an innerspring mattress, look for one with motion-reducing coils, though.

Memory foam option Nest Bedding
  • Costs: $799 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: Lifetime
Shop Now
nest bedding love and sleep mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Nest Bedding offers a variety of mattresses with different constructions, but its Love & Sleep mattress is our recommendation for couples. Designed with a SmartFlow Air Flow layer of foam for cooling, it’s a good option for both hot sleepers and side sleepers. It’s also made in the United States, and it comes with a lifetime warranty.

Overall, most reviewers seem pleased with Nest Bedding. However, a few reviews mention that the mattresses are not true to size by an inch or two.

Innerspring option Sealy Mattress
  • Costs: $549 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Learn More
sealy posturepedic plus spring iii mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

Sealy has several mattresses with varying features, but its top-of-the-line Posturepedic Plus Spring III is an innerspring mattress with motion-absorbing coils. This makes it a good option for couples who want to minimize motion but don’t like memory foam. However, this product line is expensive, with queen-size Posturepedic Plus mattresses starting at $1,099.

Reviewers are often enthusiastic about Sealy. “My wife and I are ‘old folks’ and really enjoy a good night's sleep (it's one of a few pleasures left). We need to rest and quiet all the aches and pains,” a reviewer in California said. “Nobody could go wrong buying this mattress, you'll never regret it.”

Our pick for hypoallergenic mattresses

Latex is naturally allergen-free and resistant to dust mites and mold, which makes latex mattresses a good choice for those struggling with indoor allergies.

Latex option Zenhaven
  • Costs: $2,460*
  • Trial period: 180 nights
  • Warranty: 20 years
Learn More
zanhaven mattress

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

The Zenhaven mattress from Saatva is made from natural, eco-friendly materials. These materials also mean it’s hypoallergenic. Another nice feature is that it's flippable, giving you two distinct comfort options.

However, it’s relatively expensive, and a reviewer in California said the mattress is too heavy, which makes it difficult for them to replace the bed skirt.

Our picks for people who overheat

If you find yourself kicking off the covers in the middle of the night, look for a mattress that doesn’t retain heat.

Innerspring mattresses tend to be temperature neutral, so they can be a good choice when paired with a cooling pillow or a ceiling fan. Also, gel foam mattresses have cooling properties that make them a good alternative to traditional memory foam mattresses, which are known to sleep hot.

Memory foam option Cocoon by Sealy
  • Costs: $769 and up*
  • Trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years
Learn More
cocoon by sealy

*For a queen-size mattress, as of publishing date.

We’ve already covered another option from Sealy, but its Cocoon Chill Memory Foam Mattress is a good choice for hot sleepers who like a medium firmness. Although it doesn’t actually have a gel layer, it includes a cover with a proprietary “Phase Change Material” that absorbs and dissipates heat.

Still not sure? Read our guide on cooling mattresses for hot sleepers.

Types of mattresses explained

Mattresses come in a variety of different sizes, styles and materials, and each has its own pros and cons.

Innerspring mattresses, also known as spring mattresses, are likely what you think of when you imagine a traditional mattress. For years, the innerspring design was the main mattress style on the market, and it remains one of the most popular options available today.

Construction: Innerspring mattresses use metal coils to provide support. Different coil styles offer varying levels of support and carry different price tags.

Pros: Innerspring mattresses are widely available, and there are many affordable options.

Cons: Metal coils can irritate pressure points and weaken over time, which means you may need to replace an innerspring mattress sooner than a mattress of another type.

Good for: Innerspring mattresses support a variety of sleep positions.

Memory foam mattresses provide consistent support and pressure relief. They conform to your body and provide cushioning where you exert the most pressure while maintaining proper support for the rest of your spine.

Construction: Memory foam mattresses are commonly made out of polyurethane, but open-cell and gel-infused memory foam variations are also popular.

  • Open-cell foam is a more breathable type of foam that lets air escape and circulate. As a result, you sleep cooler while still getting the same pressure relief you would from traditional memory foam.
  • Gel-infused memory foam is another cooling option. Foam mattresses that are gel-infused or contain a layer of gel help you regulate your temperature through the night.

Pros: Limited motion transfer makes memory foam mattresses ideal for those who sleep with a partner, and the extra support can help sleepers who suffer from back and joint pain.

Cons: You sink into the mattress, which some people find uncomfortable. Traditional memory foam mattresses are also known for retaining heat.

Good for: Memory foam mattresses are a great choice for side sleepers because they let your shoulder and hips sink into the mattress, which then cradles and supports them in a way spring mattresses can’t.

Latex mattresses are manufactured with natural latex made from rubber tree sap instead of synthetic materials. Latex mattresses are generally on the firmer side.

Construction: A latex mattress must have at least one layer of latex, but many contain multiple other materials in different layers.

Support: An extra foam layer is generally added to complete the core support of a latex mattress, but some companies manufacture latex-coil hybrid mattresses.

Pros: Latex mattresses are durable, and the firmness is good for relieving pressure points.

Cons: Latex mattresses tend to be more expensive than innerspring and memory foam mattresses.

Good for: Latex mattresses are a smart option for anyone concerned with allergens or looking for a durable, eco-friendly mattress.

Hybrid mattresses are a combination of two or more mattress types. The most common variation is a spring-foam hybrid, which uses traditional coils but surrounds them with layers of memory foam.

Pros: Hybrid mattresses combine the qualities of multiple other types of mattresses. They often are also a little cheaper than memory foam mattresses.

Cons: Hybrid mattresses are heavy, which can make them difficult to move.

Good for: Hybrid mattresses are a useful option for a variety of people (depending on their composition), especially couples needing different features out of their mattresses.

If you’re looking into a hybrid mattress, you may also want to consider a pillow-top mattress, which is an innerspring mattress with a top layer of padding made of foam, latex, cotton, wool or other fibers.

Mattress firmness comparison

Mattresses are frequently described in terms of their firmness (often on a scale of one to 10), so understanding what this means and how it impacts your sleep helps you narrow down which mattress is right for you.

  • Soft mattresses: A soft mattress ranks between one and two on the 10-point mattress firmness scale, which means sleepers often feel as though they’re sinking into the bed. Soft mattresses are often recommended for side sleepers because they allow people’s hips and shoulders to align with the rest of their bodies. However, soft mattresses can trigger back pain in some individuals, including stomach sleepers and heavier people. A medium-soft mattress (three to four on the firmness scale) may be a better option for these kinds of sleepers.
  • Medium mattresses: Sometimes referred to as universal comfort mattresses, medium mattresses (including medium-soft and medium-firm models) rank between three and seven on the firmness scale. These are a popular choice for all types of sleepers because they combine plush comfort with decent support. A medium-firm mattress is a great choice for couples.
  • Firm mattresses: Ranging from six to ten on the firmness scale, firm mattresses allow sleepers to rest on top of their mattresses with little to no sinking in. Firm mattresses are recommended for stomach sleepers and heavier individuals.

To find your ideal mattress firmness, consider your preferred sleeping position, body weight, physical condition and whether you share the bed with a partner.

For instance, while a firmer mattress is often recommended for people who suffer from back pain, those who suffer from arthritis, inflammation or other joint issues may find that firm mattresses create too much pressure and actually make their pain worse. However, a mattress that is too soft can cause improper spinal alignment.

Ideally, people suffering from joint issues should find a mattress somewhere in the middle that strikes a balance between comfort and support.

How much is a mattress?

The average cost of a mattress is around $1,000 (for a queen-size model). Keep in mind that prices vary significantly depending on the mattress’s brand, size and type, so a queen mattress can cost anywhere from less than $500 to more than $5,000. No matter what size mattress you’re buying, there are ways to make the mattress-buying process more affordable, though.

Average prices by mattress size

SizeAverage cost
Twin mattress$600
Full mattress$800
Queen mattress$1,050
King mattress$1,200

Based on innerspring designs

Average price by mattress type

Innerspring mattress$1,050
Memory foam mattress$1,050
Hybrid mattress$2,000
Latex mattress$2,050

Based on queen mattresses

How to buy a mattress

Once you have an idea of what type of mattress you want, it’s time to go shopping. Here are some tips to make sure your purchase ends up being the right one.

  1. Test it out: The only way to know if you like a mattress is to lie on it. Don’t just lie down and jump back up, either. Be sure to test the mattress in the position you typically sleep in, particularly if you are a side sleeper, and stay in the position for a few minutes. If you have a partner, be sure to bring them along to get an idea of how the mattress handles motion transfer.
  2. Look for a generous trial period: It can take several weeks to fully adjust to a mattress. That’s why many companies offer extended trial periods. Some brands, particularly those who sell their mattresses exclusively online, offer 90- to 100-night sleep trials. A longer trial period takes some of the fear out of buying a mattress because you can change your mind and try something else if needed. Just make sure you know the trial rules for each brand.
  3. Try more than one: Compare and contrast different styles and levels of firmness if you have the chance. However, trying too many mattresses can be confusing and ultimately muddle your experience. Try two to three models in the type you’re leaning toward, and add in one more you might not have considered just for context.
  4. Negotiate the price: Salespeople know you have nearly endless options when buying a mattress. Like when buying a car, this means they may be willing to offer a discount or rebate, and they may even upgrade you to a nicer mattress for the same price as a less expensive model. Don’t push too hard, though; not all brands are willing to negotiate.
  5. Ask about the warranty: Like any major purchase, mattresses often come with a warranty. Some warranties even extend well beyond the typical lifespan of a mattress. It’s worth finding out what might void the warranty, though.
  6. Check the thickness and layers: Most mattresses range between 8 to 12 inches thick and usually include two to five layers. The top layers deliver the comfort and cooling properties, while the bottom layers provide the foundation and compression support. In good mattresses, the foundation should be at least half of the mattress’s thickness. Each layer should be at least 2 inches thick. Increased padding often indicates a higher-quality bed; plus, the thicker the mattress, the longer it typically lasts.
A longer trial period takes some of the fear out of buying a mattress because you can change your mind and try something else if needed.”

Tips for buying a mattress online

There are pros and cons to buying a mattress in-store versus buying online. You may be able to get a better deal online, but you can only test a mattress before you buy it by visiting a store or showroom in person. However, most online mattress brands offer a decent in-home trial period to help give customers confidence in their purchase.

Buying a mattress online is a fairly simple process. You just need to know the style of mattress you want in advance. Here’s how to go about it:

  1. Determine the type of mattress you want
  2. Set a budget
  3. Read customer reviews
  4. Look for brands that offer generous in-home trial periods
  5. Select a mattress that offers a minimum 10-year warranty

Mattress FAQ

How long does a mattress last?

The Better Sleep Council recommends disposing of your mattress and replacing it every seven years. However, the effective life span of your mattress really depends on how you use it, your body type and the environment you live in. Higher-quality mattresses may last longer due to their superior materials and construction, but even expensive mattresses have an expiration date.

How do you know it’s time to replace your mattress?

Signs that it’s time to replace your mattress include:

  • Waking up with neck or back pain, stiff limbs or a tired feeling even after a full night’s sleep
  • Frequently tossing and turning or waking up throughout the night
  • Low spots or visible sagging in your mattress
  • Your mattress suddenly starting to creak
  • Your allergies growing worse, especially when it isn’t your typical allergy season
  • Finding a mattress you like more
How do I choose a mattress?

There are a few things to consider when choosing a new mattress, such as your:

  • Budget
  • Sleeping position
  • Weight
  • Personal preferences

Your sleeping position and weight are crucial factors to consider when purchasing a new mattress because they determine the level of firmness you need.

Which is the most comfortable mattress?

No mattress is the most comfortable for all people. How well you like a given mattress depends on the details of your sleeping position, weight and other preferences. Still, it’s hard to find the right mattress if you’re researching exclusively online. The surest way to determine if a mattress is comfortable for you is to try it out and see for yourself.

What is the best time to buy a mattress?

New mattress models typically are rolled out in June each year, making May the best time to find clearance offers. However, it's not always ideal to put off buying a mattress to wait for a sale, especially if your current mattress is causing pain or sleepless nights. Many mattress sellers offer affordable financing programs that can get you into a better mattress soon.

Not sure how to choose?

Get buying tips about Mattresses delivered to your inbox.

    By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Thanks for subscribing.

    You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

    Compare Top Mattress Reviews

    Want your company to be on this guide?

    Yes, continue