Best Online Car Buying Sites

  • DriveTime
    4.4(9,795)
  • Carvana
    3.4(4,641)
  • CarGurus
    3.9(734)

Best Online Car Buying Sites

Our top 3 picks for online car buying sites

  1. DriveTime
  2. Carvana
  3. CarGurus
While our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us, this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations.
DriveTime
Warranty
30-day/1,500-mile
Return policy
5 days
Price
Fixed
Financing
Yes

DriveTime is an online platform with dealerships across the United States. It's a great route for people with different credit histories because it lets you see financing terms after you complete an application with no impact to your credit score. DriveTime employees don’t work on commission, so shopping with them will be a no-pressure process.

The used vehicles on DriveTime’s site include a free AutoCheck history report and come with a five-day return policy and a 30-day/1,500-mile limited warranty. DriveTime’s site also has an Advice Center with resources on credit scores, auto financing and personal savings goals to help educate you.

Pros

  • Quick application process
  • Five-day return guarantee
  • Options for all credit backgrounds

Cons

  • Interest rates on the higher end
Carvana
Warranty
100-day/4,189-mile
Return policy
7 days
Price
Fixed
Financing
Yes

Carvana performs a 150-point inspection to make sure each vehicle is fit for purchase. The company has a policy against selling cars that have been in an accident, and it runs a CARFAX report on each vehicle to confirm this. Buyers don’t get a traditional test-drive but do get seven days to return the car for any reason.

The prices on Carvana are fixed, so there’s no haggling. Listings have 360-degree photos to simulate the experience of seeing the car in person. Cars are sourced from auctions, trade-ins, dealerships and private sellers.

Buyers who are near a Carvana vending machine can pick up their car for free. Alternatively, shipping is available, though it isn’t free for every vehicle. Shipping and delivery typically take less than 48 hours.

Pros

  • Seven-day money-back guarantee
  • Convenient online process
  • Wide selection

Cons

  • No delivery to Alaska or Hawaii
  • No price negotiation
CarGurus
Warranty
Varies by seller
Return policy
Varies by seller
Price
Negotiable
Financing
Yes

CarGurus is an online platform that works to simplify the buying process by providing transparent pricing information for new and used vehicles and helps facilitate transactions between buyers and sellers. It acts as an online marketplace that connects interested buyers with dealerships or private sellers.

To help buyers, the CarGurus site includes deal ratings, price analysis, financing options and vehicle history reports. Positive CarGurus reviews point out how attentive the customer service team is, and customers mention that they appreciate CarGurus facilitating contact with the dealership.

Pros

  • Nationwide
  • Financing available
  • Extensive vehicle selection

Cons

  • No warranty
  • Changing inventory
  • Dependent on seller integrity

Online Car Buying Sites Buyers Guide

Jump into our guides and start learning

Top Picks

See who reviewers like

DriveTime logo
Carvana logo
CarGurus logo
See our top picks

Online car buying sites: a guide

Feel like you’re spinning your wheels trying to research and purchase a car? More people are turning to online car shopping to help them narrow and compare their options before purchasing their vehicles (as opposed to visiting a dealership in person).

Before you get too far along in your search, consider the pros and cons of online car shopping versus the in-person dealership experience. Then, when the time comes, you can feel confident in your new ride.

Key insights

Shopping for a car online can streamline the entire car buying journey. You can use a dealer-specific site or an aggregate of dealers and private sellers.

Jump to insight

While buying a car online is convenient, it may not always guarantee the lowest price due to limited negotiation opportunities.

Jump to insight

Vet online car buying sites by checking customer reviews, accreditations, return policies and financing options.

Jump to insight

How online car buying works

Online car buying sites either show inventory from a single dealer (e.g., DriveTime, Carvana) or they serve as a marketplace that shows cars for sale from multiple dealers and private-party sellers (e.g., CarGurus). Buyers can research vehicles, view actual inventory, apply for financing and complete the entire vehicle purchase through the website (or app).

Online car buying costs

In many cases, visiting a dealership in person allows for some room to haggle for a lower price — so while you may save time and energy shopping for a car online, you might not save money. Many online car buying sites won’t let you negotiate car prices, unfortunately. Sites that connect you with a private seller typically allow for more negotiation room than those that are associated with dealerships.

Make sure to research the site’s rules and policies as well as the fair market value of the car you're looking to buy (based on its age, condition, etc.) before assuming you can or need to negotiate the price.

Many online sellers charge shipping and delivery fees separately from the price of the vehicle — make sure to ask about any additional fees so you can see the full financial picture.

How to choose a car buying site

It’s always important to exercise caution when shopping online. As with any online purchase, avoid online car scams by looking for appropriate accreditations or certifications. Check out customer reviews online, and read through any return policies. The right online car dealer for you has ideal financing options and policies regarding auto warranties.

To find the perfect car at a great price, consider the following:

  • Inventory: How many cars does the site have listed? Does it specialize in certain types of vehicles (e.g., new, used, certified pre-owned, classic)?
  • Pricing: Does the company offer competitive prices and tools to help you assess the car's value? Look for sites with price comparisons, history reports and market value estimations.
  • Financing options: Does the site offer financing or connect you with outside lenders?
  • User experience: Is the site easy to navigate? Are the search filters helpful?
  • Customer reviews: What do customers say about their experiences?
  • Additional features: Are there any available extras, like vehicle history reports, warranty options or home delivery?

Tips for using online car buying sites

  1. Compare prices, features and reviews across multiple sites.
  2. Determine how much you can afford before you start shopping.
  3. Knowing your credit score will help you get preapproved for financing and secure the best rates.
  4. Pay attention to fees, warranty terms and return policies.
  5. Be cautious of deals that seem too good to be true, and always verify the seller's identity.

Pros and cons of buying a car online

Buying a car online can be much more convenient than shopping at a traditional dealership, and you can research and compare vehicles without pressure from a sales associate. Make sure you keep an eye out for added fees or additional costs, though, so you get the right car for the right price.

Pros

  • Shop from home
  • Easy to compare different vehicles
  • More buying options
  • No pressure from sales associates

Cons

  • Can’t see, feel or test-drive car in person
  • Not as much room for negotiation
  • Hidden fees (shipping charges, taxes, etc.)

Questions to ask when buying a car online

Whether you’re shopping for a new car or a used one, knowing the right questions to ask can help eliminate any concerns you have about the vehicle you plan to purchase. If you can’t find specific information about a car online, it’s always a good idea to first ask the dealership or individual seller, especially if the car you want to buy is used.

Used cars

When buying a used car, always ask the buyer questions about the service history, previous owners and past repairs. Having this information upfront gives you a better idea of how the car has been maintained and the likelihood of future problems.

Why are you selling the car?

This is a good question to ask if you’re dealing with an individual seller rather than a dealership. This is one of many questions that will help you get a better understanding of the car’s overall health.

Has this car been in an accident?

The best car buying websites run a vehicle history check to prevent vehicles that have been in accidents from being sold on the site. If a vehicle has been in an accident, it’s a major red flag.

Aside from visible damage to the car, you can learn more about a vehicle’s accident history by reviewing the CARFAX report. You’ll need the car’s vehicle identification number (VIN) to learn more about its service and accident history.

Is the car under warranty?

It's helpful to know if a car is still under warranty because it can help cover costs if your vehicle breaks down. Depending on its age and mileage, a used car may have passed out of its coverage period. If this is important to you, consider purchasing an extended car warranty from a third-party company.

Do service records prove that the maintenance is up to date?

Most good online car buying sites can provide the ownership history of the vehicle. This gives you a better idea of the condition of the car. If service records are available, that’s a good sign. Make sure to review them carefully. If they aren’t readily available, that might mean the car hasn’t received proper service in the past.

Some online car purchasing sites will provide an oil change and a car wash for a used car. Even so, it’s good to also check whether other important maintenance is up to date. A history of several owners on a relatively new vehicle might imply something is wrong with the car.

Would anything stop me from taking the car on a long road trip?

This is another question that tells you more about the car’s condition and lets you know what might need to be fixed — which gives you a better idea of the true cost of the car. Features like the heater, air conditioner, turn signals, lights and audio system should all be working.

Asking if any features aren’t functional helps you fish out any details about how the car’s condition may be less than optimal. It’s vital you have a transparent history of a used car before buying.

Can I take the car to a mechanic for inspection during the test-drive?

If you’re about ready to buy, this is a good question to ask. The assumption here is that you’ll buy the car if the mechanic gives you the go-ahead. If a dealer is reluctant to let you do this, consider it a red flag.

However, not all car buying transactions provide an opportunity for a physical test-drive. In this case, the seller usually offers a grace period for free returns. It’s a good idea to take the car to a mechanic for an inspection during the trial window.

What is the Kelley Blue Book value of the car?

Kelley Blue Book lists the value of used vehicles as well as new cars. Estimates are based on private party value, trade-in value and certified pre-owned (CPO) value, among other factors. It’s a good idea to ask what the KBB estimated value is, even if you already know.

New cars

New cars don’t have an extensive history that you need to know about; however, there are still a few questions you should be asking. It’s easy to get caught up in the excitement of buying a new car online or in person and forget to ask the right questions. Make sure you know how to best take care of your car and that it fits your current needs.

Consider it a red flag if the seller can’t or won’t provide answers about any new cars on the lot.

Are there any additional fees?

Nothing’s more annoying than hidden fees popping up at the last minute. Many online sellers charge shipping and delivery fees separately from the price of the vehicle. Make sure to ask about additional fees so you can see the full financial picture.

What do repairs typically look like for this make and model?

Sometimes it can be hard to get an answer on this one, so it might help to look at other user reviews online for answers. Look for patterns in repairs and factor these into your budget.

What’s the gas mileage?

It’s important to know what kind of gas mileage a car gets as you’re budgeting for monthly payments. Many of the better sites provide this information before you have to ask for it. Refer to original manufacturer information to get mileage figures.

Does this vehicle have four-wheel drive?

All-wheel drive (AWD) and four-wheel drive (4WD) help with traction and acceleration when driving on slippery surfaces or in inclement weather. They typically cost more and require more maintenance than two-wheel-drive (2WD) vehicles. If this is important to you, make sure to ask about it. You don’t want to need it and not have it.

What does the warranty on this car cover?

If something goes wrong with your new car through no fault of your own, it’s always comforting to know you can repair it at a low price. But warranties don’t cover everything, so it’s important to know what yours does cover.

Is it possible to hold the vehicle?

Some car dealers will put a hold on the vehicle for you while you decide if you really want to buy. Holds can range from 24 hours up to a week. It’s better to take time and think over a big decision like buying a car than rushing into it.

FAQ

Can you negotiate the price of a car online?

Some online car buying sites let you negotiate the price of the car you’re looking to buy, but some won’t. For example, Carvana and CarMax have fixed-price vehicles, while Autotrader allows for negotiating.

Are online car buying sites trustworthy?

Yes, online car buying sites are generally trustworthy. Before giving any site your personal information, check out customer reviews, look for appropriate accreditation or certificates, and read through any return policies and information on warranties. If something seems way too good to be true, chances are it is and could be a scam.

Is it cheaper to buy a car online or at a dealership?

Much like online car buying sites, some dealerships allow for negotiation and some don’t. The price you get your vehicle for depends on several factors, including the demand for the specific car you’re looking at, the condition of the vehicle and the time of year you’re looking to buy. The best plan of action is to narrow your list to the vehicle you want, then shop around to see where you can get the best price.

Not sure how to choose?

Get buying tips about Online Car Buying Sites delivered to your inbox.

    By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Thanks for subscribing.

    You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

    Read online car buying site reviews

    Showing 10 of 22

    Want your company to be on this guide?

    Yes, continue
    Comparing

    ×