Compare Cochlear Implant Reviews
Since the 1970s, thousands of people who are severely hard of hearing or deaf have received the gift of hearing from cochlear implants or other hearing implants. “Cochlear implants are very different from hearing aids,” Dr. Selena Briggs told ConsumerAffairs. Dr. Briggs is a neurotologist-skull base surgeon in the Department of Otolaryngology at the MedStar Washington Hospital Center. “Hearing aids only amplify noise. Cochlear implants channel sound to bypass damaged parts of the cochlea.”
“There are only three cochlear implants that are FDA-approved,” Dr. Briggs says, “but, ultimately, the choice is up to the patient.” In addition to cochlear implants, other types of hearing implants may be a good choice for you depending on the type of hearing loss you have. Most hearing implants cost about $40,000 before insurance, but each brand has different features to keep in mind before choosing the best one for you.
Top 5 Best Rated Cochlear Implants and Hearing Implants
|Cochlear||Read 6 Reviews|
Founded in 1981, Cochlear Limited is a leading manufacturer of Nucleus® cochlear implants and other hearing solutions, including the Nucleus® Hybrid Implant System and the Baha® bone conduction system.
|MED-EL||Read Expert Review||Be the first one to rate this company|
MED-EL is an Austrian hearing technology manufacturer founded in 1977. It offers cochlear implants, bone-anchored hearing systems and middle ear implants for people with sensorineural, conductive or mixed hearing loss.
|Advanced Bionics||Read Expert Review||Be the first one to rate this company|
Advanced Bionics is a California-based manufacturer of cochlear implants. Founded in 1993, it offers three processors, including two behind-the-ear models, the Naída CI Q10 and the Harmony, and a body-worn processor, the Neptune.
|Oticon Medical||Read Expert Review||Be the first one to rate this company|
Oticon Medical is a leading manufacturer of hearing assistance devices. It offers hearing aids along with implantable hearing solutions, including the Ponto bone-anchored hearing system and the Neuro cochlear implant system.
|Sophono||Read Expert Review||Be the first one to rate this company|
Sophono is a hearing solutions division of Medtronic, an Ireland-based medical device company. It offers a magnetic bone-anchored hearing system called SOPHONO™ for adults and children with conductive or mixed hearing loss.
ConsumerAffairs Research Team
Rosemary Avance, Ph.D., uses her social science research background as a member of the ConsumerAffairs research team to help people make smart choices. She researches products, businesses and industries thoroughly, then passes on the most relevant and essential information for consumers looking to make important purchasing decisions.
Important questions when considering hearing or cochlear implants
What are the components of a hearing implant?
Cochlear implants and other hearing implants might look complicated, but they are relatively simple machines. Nearly all available devices feature the same basic components, though they process sound differently.
- Microphone: The microphone is located on the part of the device that sits above the ear or is worn on the head.
- Processor: The processor is also external and converts sounds picked up by the microphone to digital information (in cochlear implants) or to sound waves (in BAHAs and middle ear implants).
- Receiver: The receiver is implanted under the skin behind the ear. In cochlear implants, digital information is passed from the processor to the receiver, where it is converted into electronic impulses. In acoustic implants such as BAHAs and middle ear implants, the receiver is fused to the bone or cochlea to receive sound waves.
- Electrode array: Cochlear implants and auditory brain stem implants use a small wire called an electrode array to transmit electronic impulses and stimulate the auditory nerve or brain stem.
What does the process involve?
Understanding how the procedure is done can help you feel more confident in making a decision for you or your loved one. The various types of hearing implants involve a similar process.
- Surgery: “The surgical process takes about one to two hours,” Dr. Briggs says. An incision is made behind the ear to insert the receiver. Some people are able to undergo the procedure and return home that day, while others need a few days in the hospital to recover.
- Recovery: The surgery recovery period is usually several weeks, during which time scar tissue forms over the incision. During this time, you will not be able to hear because the external part of the device, the processor, is not yet connected to the receiver. “Some patients also experience vertigo for about 48 hours after surgery,” Dr. Briggs says. “This is caused by fluctuation in inner ear fluid, and it resolves on its own.”
- Activation: About a month after surgery, you will have an appointment to activate your implant and hear sound through it for the first time. The sound processor will be adjusted to the correct level of stimulation.
- Post-operative care: You should plan for many follow-up visits to your hearing specialist to monitor your progress and continue to adjust the processor settings. You will also need rehabilitative care, usually including speech therapy, as your brain learns to process sounds. Even people who recently became deaf require rehabilitative care because the brain needs help to adjust to the device.
- Possible complications: According to Dr. Briggs, “Fewer than 0.1 percent of patients have problems with cochlear implants. These implants rarely fail, and if they do, they must be reimplanted.”
What style of processor do you prefer?
Cochlear implants and other hearing implants come in a variety of styles.
- Behind-the-ear: Behind-the-ear sound processors look similar to hearing aids. The microphone sits on top of the ear and connects with a wire to the processor, which attaches with a magnet or abutment to the internal receiver in the skull.
- Off-the-ear: Off-the-ear devices look like the processor of a behind-the-ear implant without the earpiece and connecting wire. The processor is round and about the size of a quarter. These usually come in neutral colors that can be hidden with hair, making this the most discreet option.
- Body-worn processor: Some implants feature processors that can be clipped to the wearer’s shirt, belt or pants. Some manufacturers make waterproof covers for these processors so they can be worn while swimming.
- Single or double implants: Most specialists recommend a cochlear implant for each ear for people who have bilateral hearing loss, since sound processing works best when receiving information from both sides. However, some people opt to try only one first to see if they can tolerate the process or because one is more affordable. Many people, especially children, wait a year or more before receiving a second implant.
What rehabilitative services are needed?
Recipients of hearing implants derive the most benefit when they receive ongoing services to help them adjust to the implants. “It takes a lot of patience and learning to get it programmed correctly,” says Dr. Briggs. “You can expect to work with an audiologist for up to six months to get your programming right.”
- Implanted babies and children: Most experts agree that young children who receive implants have the best chance for success because the young brain can adapt and quickly relearn how to process information. Still, families must be able to commit to regular speech therapy and appointments with hearing specialists for many years in order to help children make the most of their hearing.
- Congenitally deaf adults: People who have been deaf since birth and opt for implants as adults may need the most rehabilitative support services to help familiarize their brains with sound processing.
- Adult onset hearing loss: Adults who experience hearing loss and opt to receive implants will need support from hearing professionals but may have less difficulty adjusting to sound processing than others.
What other options are there?
If a cochlear implant or different hearing implant is not right for you, there are several other options that might improve your hearing.
- Hearing aids: If hearing aids provide enough support for you to be able to hear and understand speech, most hearing specialists recommend that you simply wear them. Because implants are much more expensive and invasive, they are meant for people who do not receive enough support from hearing aids alone.
- Hybrid cochlear implants: People with some hearing in one or both ears might opt for a hybrid cochlear implant. The microphone connects to a processor and receiver as in a typical cochlear implant, but the device also amplifies sound and uses an earpiece to deliver the sound to the inner ear.
- One implant and one hearing aid: If you have some hearing in one ear, you may opt to receive an implant in your less functional ear. After a month or two of adjusting to the implant, you can use your hearing aid in the other ear. This can provide additional sound cues to help you interpret and respond to sounds.
What types of hearing implants are there?
Cochlear implants are primarily used for patients who have bilateral (both ears affected) sensorineural hearing loss that is considered moderate to profound. Unlike hearing aids, cochlear implants do not amplify sound but instead conduct electricity to stimulate the auditory nerve.
Bone-anchored hearing aids (BAHAs)
BAHAs are surgically-implanted devices that amplify sound waves for people with conductive or mixed hearing loss. They are generally used as an alternative to hearing aids for people who have problems with their ears that make wearing hearing aids difficult, like allergies or ear malformations. The receiver is titanium and is implanted on and fuses to the bone behind the ear. Some BAHAs are transcutaneous, meaning they process sound through intact skin, while others use an abutment system that is placed through the skin to physically connect the processor and receiver.
Auditory brainstem implants (ABIs)
These are an alternative to cochlear implants for people with profound sensorineural hearing loss, particularly those who are completely deaf. ABIs bypass the cochlea and implant directly into the brain stem, so they are considered more invasive than cochlear implants.
Middle ear implants
Middle ear implants are the newest on the market. These are alternatives to conventional hearing aids for people who have allergies to hearing aid earmolds, chronic ear infections, malformed outer or middle ears or other problems that make wearing traditional hearing aids difficult or impossible. The structure and function of a middle ear implant are similar to a cochlear implant but work by amplifying sounds instead of conducting electricity.
Who is eligible for a cochlear implant?
Candidacy criteria can vary
Each of the companies that have FDA approval to market their hearing implants in the United States suggest slightly different criteria for implant candidacy. Additionally, insurance providers as well as Medicare and Medicaid each write their own criteria to determine who is a candidate to receive implants. “If you’re on Medicaid or Medicare,” Dr. Briggs says, “you’ll have to show at least 40 percent hearing loss before you’re covered.”
Moderate to profound hearing loss
Adults ages 18 and up with moderate to profound hearing loss may be candidates for implants. The requirements are different for children; kids ages 2 to 18 with severe to profound loss (70 decibels or greater) are often candidates, while toddlers ages 12 to 24 months may be candidates if their loss is profound. The FDA does not approve implants for infants under 12 months, but many have been implanted off-protocol and in other countries.
Bilateral hearing loss
Most people who have unilateral hearing loss, which means hearing loss in one ear, are able to adjust well without implants. People with loss in both ears, called bilateral hearing loss, may be candidates for one or two implants, even if only one of the affected ears has severe or profound loss.
Type of hearing loss
There are two main types of hearing loss: Conductive hearing loss results from damage to the outer or middle ear that prevents sound waves from entering properly, and sensorineural hearing loss results from damage to the inner ear or auditory nerve. People with conductive hearing loss may benefit from middle ear implants or BAHA devices, but don’t benefit from cochlear implants. People with sensorineural loss or mixed loss (both conductive and sensorineural) may benefit from cochlear implants, but not the other types.
Limited speech intelligibility
Most adults are given a speech intelligibility test to see if they are candidates for implants. If a person can already understand sufficient speech, they may not need cochlear implants. However, if a person struggles to hear others or understand speech or cannot use a telephone, they may be a candidate for implants.
Limited benefit from hearing aids
Candidates for implants are not sufficiently supported by hearing aids alone in one or both ears. Some tests require a person to have 50 percent or less speech intelligibility with a hearing aid in the ear to be implanted. People who cannot wear hearing aids because of ear malformations or skin allergies may also be candidates for implants.
Most people say that sounds heard through cochlear implants or other hearing implants are different from natural sounds. For some people, the adjustment to this new type of sound can be difficult, and some people find they do not prefer to use their cochlear implants because of it. Still, patients can expect a larger increase in clarity with implants than with hearing aids. “Hearing aids can help people regain about 50 percent of their hearing,” Dr. Briggs explains. “Patients with cochlear implants often regain 75-100 percent hearing.”
Cochlear and hearing implant expert reviews
Founded in Australia in 1981, Cochlear Limited is a leading cochlear implant manufacturer. It was the first company to receive FDA approval for implantation in adults and children the United States. In 1984, Cochlear introduced the first multichannel system to transmit multiple sound frequencies. More than 450,000 people have been implanted with Cochlear brand implants. The current model is known as the Cochlear™ Nucleus® System. Cochlear also offers a combined hearing aid and cochlear implant system called the Nucleus® Hybrid Implant System and a bone conduction system called the Baha® System.
Founded in Austria in 1977, Medical Electronics Corporation, now called MED-EL, was the first cochlear implant company. It offers cochlear implants, bone-anchored hearing aids and middle ear implants for those with sensorineural or conductive hearing loss.
- Sonnet cochlear implant: The Sonnet behind-the-ear cochlear implant processor is water-resistant and lightweight. It has safety features and color customization options that make it a great cochlear implant choice for children.
- RONDO single-unit cochlear implant: MED-EL’s RONDO cochlear implant is a single-unit implant that is worn off the ear. It is discreet and lightweight and can be customized with a waterproof accessory for use while swimming.
- Bonebridge BAHA system: MED-EL created the world’s first active bone conduction hearing aid system, called Bonebridge. It is recommended for people with conductive or mixed hearing loss that is not improved by hearing aids, or for people with such hearing loss who are unable to wear hearing aids because of medical reasons.
- Options for children: MED-EL’s cochlear implant and BAHA systems are available and FDA-approved for implantation in children.
- Vibrant Soundbridge middle ear implant: MED-EL offers the Vibrant Soundbridge middle ear implant system for people who have conductive or mixed hearing loss but can’t wear hearing aids. It offers excellent sound perception and is the only middle ear implant with a single-point attachment.
- Best for: adults and children with sensorineural hearing loss or those who have conductive loss but cannot wear hearing aids.
Advanced Bionics Corporation has more than 20 years of experience in the hearing implant industry. It offers three models of cochlear implants: the Naída CI Q series and the Harmony models, which both use an over-the-ear processor, and the Neptune, which features a body-worn processor.
- Naída CI Q series: Advanced Bionics’ Naída CI Q series offers the most advanced sound processors available for cochlear implants. It comes in three models, the Q30, the Q70 and the Q90, which offer increasing features and options.
- Only waterproof processor: Advanced Bionics offers the only waterproof processor on the market, the Neptune, which does not need any accessories or adjustments to be fully submersible in water. The Neptune is a body-worn processor that clips to the wearer’s clothing. It uses the AquaMic™ headpiece, which is the only waterproof microphone.
- Harmony™ processor: Advanced Bionics’ Harmony processor is a behind-the-ear model that uses T-Mic™ Microphone, which is located at the opening of the ear. This helps transmit more natural sound to the device’s receiver. Unlike most cochlear implants that tend to come in neutral colors, the Harmony is available in several colors including turquoise, pink and lime green.
- HearingJourney™ online community: Advanced Bionics offers the largest online community for hearing implant recipients, called the HearingJourney™ forum. You can meet others with implants, browse topics, ask questions and more.
- BEA Mentor program: Advanced Bionics also offers the Bionic Ear Association (BEA) Mentor program to connect implant recipients and their families with others who have valuable experience to share. You can also attend community events for implant recipients.
- Best for: adults and children with sensorineural hearing loss that is not improved with hearing aids.
Oticon Medical is a leading manufacturer of hearing technology, owned by the William Demant Group. It is one of the top six hearing aid manufacturers in the world. It offers the Ponto bone-anchored hearing aid and has recently introduced its first cochlear implant, Neuro. While Neuro is not yet approved by the FDA for implantation in the United States, it is available in many countries.
- Ponto Plus sound system: Oticon’s Ponto Plus BAHA system is a direct sound transmission device, meaning it connects through the skin to transmit sound from the microphone and processor to the implanted receiver.
- Ponto 3: Oticon’s new Ponto 3 system is the most powerful abutment processor on the market, offering the greatest volume range (up to 65 decibels) while reducing distortion.
- Neuro Zti cochlear implant system: Oticon’s Neuro Zti implant has the most compact receiver on the market. It lays flat beneath the skin to be discreet and comfortable.
- MRI compatible: The Neuro Zti is one of the only cochlear implants that is adaptable for high Tesla scanning, so it is safe to use in an MRI machine.
- Futureproof technology: Oticon Medical designs its hearing implants with specialized computer chips to ensure that they are future-proof, meaning that any future advances in hearing technology will be compatible with the existing implant. As a result, you may be able to update your hearing technology without undergoing further surgeries.
- Best for: adults and children with conductive or mixed hearing loss or those in other countries with sensorineural loss.
Sophono is a hearing solutions division of Medtronic, a medical device company based in Dublin, Ireland. Sophono manufactures the SOPHONO™ magnetic bone-anchored hearing system, which is designed for use in adults and children with moderate to severe conductive hearing loss.
- First transcutaneous BAHA: The SOPHONO™ was the first transcutaneous BAHA system, meaning it was the first to transmit sound through unbroken skin instead of requiring an abutment that penetrates the skin. The sound processor attaches with a magnet, and when it is removed the device is invisible under the skin.
- Smallest implant: The SOPHONO™ magnetic bone anchored hearing system is the smallest hearing implant available. It has a flat profile and can be implanted flush against the skull so that it is not visible when covered by your hair. This also makes it safer in case of accidental trauma to the head.
- Optimal sound amplification: The SOPHONO™ system offers the most sound amplification of any implantable hearing system on the market.
- MRI safe: The SOPHONO™ hearing system does not have to be removed for use in an MRI. In fact, it is safe for up to three hours and causes only a five-centimeter shadow on the MRI.
- Programmable: SOPHONO™ has eight channels and four programs. It also features a direct audio input that can be used with personal music players, cellular phones and FM radio.
- Best for: those with conductive or mixed hearing loss.
Information in this guide is general in nature and is intended for informational purposes only; it is not legal, health, investment or tax advice. ConsumerAffairs.com makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from its use.