For Businesses
Write a Review
  3. Homeowners
  4. Home Warranties
  5. Best Home Warranties

Best Home Warranty Companies in Idaho

We compared 35 companies and chose the top home warranty providers

    • Best overall
      American Home Shield
      3.7(110,341)
    • Quick service
      Choice Home Warranty
      4.0(74,700)
    • Roof coverage
      Select Home Warranty
      3.6(16,168)
    Author picture
    By: Alina Bradford
    +2 more
    Author picture
    Edited by: Matt Zane
    Author picture
    Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin

    Best Home Warranty Companies in Idaho

    American Home Shield is the top home warranty company in Idaho, thanks to strong coverage for major systems that run hard year-round. Idaho's winters can be brutal, and summers can be hot, so when a furnace quits during a cold snap or an AC fails in July, a home warranty can help soften the financial hit.

    Many plans also include protection for everyday appliances like washers, dryers and water heaters. In Idaho, home warranty plans typically cost between $24.99 and $91.66 per month, depending on coverage level and service fee.

    Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
    • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
    • 4,858,738 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Key insights

    American Home Shield stands out in Idaho for robust heating and cooling coverage that fits the state's wide seasonal swings.

    Jump to insight

    The average cost of a home warranty in Idaho is $60.15 per month, with most plans falling between $300 and $1,100 annually.

    Jump to insight

    Because Idaho swings from freezing winters to warm summers, look for plans that treat HVAC coverage as a priority, not an add-on.

    Jump to insight

    Our 3 home warranty company picks in Idaho

    1. Best overall: American Home Shield
    2. Best for quick service: Choice Home Warranty
    3. Best for roof coverage: Select Home Warranty

    Our research team vetted home warranty companies that are rated by hundreds of customers in Idaho. Read our guide to choose the best home warranty in Idaho for you by comparing plans, contract lengths and service fees.

    Read our full methodology below for all the details. Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us, but this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations.

    Compare home warranty companies

    Our 3 Idaho home warranty company picks

    Learn more about our top picks for the best home warranty companies, based on real, recent reviews from customers in Idaho on ConsumerAffairs.

    Best overall

    American Home Shield

    American Home Shield
    3.7
    110,341 reviews
    Plans available
    ShieldSilver, ShieldGold and ShieldPlatinum
    Monthly premium range
    $29.99 to $89.99
    Service fees
    $100 or $125
    Labor guarantee
    30 days
    Get a Quote Read Reviews

    American Home Shield earns our top home warranty in Idaho pick largely because of scale. With a massive contractor network (over 17,000 contractors nationwide), it's better positioned than smaller competitors to serve homeowners outside major metro areas — including Idaho's rural and hard-to-reach communities.

    That reach matters in places where some providers simply can't get a technician to. The trade-off is that AHS tends to be strict about using its network. Even if the nearest in-network tech is far away, you may be required to wait rather than hiring a local out-of-network pro.

    Base plans from AHS start at $29.99 a month in Idaho. You can choose a {service_fee:398} deductible, but be aware that this affects your monthly cost. All plans have a total limit of $50,000 per agreement term.

    • {name:plan:0:398} ($29.99 or $39.99): Covers 14 major systems, including heating, cooling, electrical and plumbing. This plan has a $5,000 limit per covered HVAC system.
    • {name:plan:1:398} ($49.99 or $59.99): Covers 24 appliances and systems, including kitchen and laundry equipment. It also has a $5,000 limit per covered HVAC system and limits each covered appliance to $2,000.
    • {name:plan:2:398} ($79.99 or $89.99): The most comprehensive plan. It has the same HVAC system limit but raises the annual per-appliance limit to $4,000 and includes roof leak coverage up to $1,000.

    The premiums above are based on quotes we received for a three-bedroom, two-bathroom home in Boise. The lower cost plan comes with a higher service fee.

    Add-ons and discounts

    • Optional add-ons
      • Septic pump: {septic_pump_addon_monthly_cost:398}
      • Roof leak repair: {roof_leak_repair_addon_monthly_cost:398}
      • Well pump: {well_pump_addon_monthly_cost:398}
      • Guest unit: {guest_unit_addon_monthly_cost:398}
      • Electronics protection: {electronics_protection_addon_monthly_cost:398}
      • Pool and spa: {pool_and_spa_addon_monthly_cost:398}
    • Discounts: AARP and military service; $50 discount for covering multiple properties
    Pros
    • Massive contractor network helps cover remote and rural areas
    • Covers preexisting conditions, rust and corrosion
    • High HVAC and system limits
    Cons
    • Strict in-network policy can cause long wait times in rural zones
    • Relatively high service fees

    To understand how American Home Shield performs for Idaho homeowners, we looked closely at customer reviews. Punctuality and speed, technicians and customer service received the most positive feedback from local reviewers.

    American Home Shield review breakdown by category

    Idaho homeowners describe AHS as efficient when it comes to getting a technician scheduled and completing repairs, especially for common appliance and system issues. A recurring complaint, though, is that service fees have climbed over time.

    “I've had two claims with American Home Shield— the first was made over the phone and the second was submitted online. The customer service during both was excellent. The technicians that came to my home were super and exceeded my expectations.”
    Bradley Twin Falls, ID
    “I initiated the service call online and found the response time satisfactory and the process straightforward. Their team informed me promptly via email after receiving my request. … My experience with their website was also positive, deserving of a 5 out of 5 for ease of use and response time.”
    Debra Parma, ID
    “Before the service visit, I was informed that someone would contact me within 24 hours, which was reassuring. Heros Plumbing, who attended to the issue, was phenomenal—they were quick, efficient, and resolved the problem by replacing a pipe.”
    Cyndy Rathdrum, ID
    3x Award Winner
    Selected for having one of the highest satisfaction rates for Best Customer Service, Best Overall Value and Best Overall Process
    Best for quick service

    Choice Home Warranty

    Choice Home Warranty
    4.0
    74,700 reviews
    Plans available
    Basic and Total
    Monthly premium range
    $46.83 to $54.75
    Service fees
    $100
    Labor guarantee
    60 days
    Get a Quote Read Reviews

    Choice earns this spot because its size gives it leverage with its contractor network — especially in high-demand markets where homeowners can wait weeks for an appointment. In many cases, that volume helps Choice push for faster scheduling than homeowners might get when booking a technician directly.

    The main catch is flexibility: like several home warranty competitors, Choice generally requires you to use its assigned vendors rather than letting you pick your own technician if the network is backed up. These restrictions can sometimes lead to delays in service.

    • {name:plan:0:2135} plans start at {starting_price:2135} per month, and {name:plan:1:2135} plans start at {monthly_cost_1:plan:1:2135} per month. Both have a flat {service_fee:2135} service fee. Contracts last one year — expect to pay a $50 cancellation fee if you cancel early. However, you can transfer the contract with no penalty.
    • {name:plan:0:2135}: Covers 14 systems and appliances, including heating, electrical and plumbing.
    • {name:plan:1:2135}: Includes everything in the basic plan and covers your washer and dryer, refrigerator and air conditioning system.

    The annual cost of plans ranges from {annual_premium_cost:2135}.

    Add-ons and discounts

    • Optional add-ons
      • Ice maker: {ice_maker_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Second refrigerator: {second_refrigerator_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Stand-alone freezer: {standalone_freezer_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Sump pump: {sump_pump_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Central vacuum: {central_vacuum_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Septic tank pumping: {septic_tank_pumping_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Roof leak repair: {roof_leak_repair_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Well pump: {well_pump_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Sprinkler system: {sprinkler_system_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Septic system: {septic_system_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Pool and spa: {pool_and_spa_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
      • Additional spa: {additional_spa_addon_monthly_cost:2135}
    • Discounts: Annual price is for 13 months. 5% discount promotion available.
    Pros
    • Flat labor rates protect against local inflation
    • 90-day parts guarantee
    • 24/7 customer service
    Cons
    • Strict network rules limit rural contractor choice
    • Excludes AC from base plan

    To understand how Choice Home Warranty performs for Idaho homeowners, we looked closely at customer reviews. Technicians, punctuality and speed, and customer service received the most positive feedback from local reviewers.

    Choice Home Warranty review breakdown by category

    Many Idaho reviewers highlight fast scheduling and quick turnaround once a claim is submitted, and say the company uses competent technicians who complete repairs within a few days. The most common frustration was when reimbursement limits didn't fully match the real-world cost of replacing more expensive appliances.
    “I have received good service from them so far. Currently hold 3 warranties with them for 3 of my homes. Have asked for service for washer, dryer, garbage disposal, and refrigerator at different times and paid my contribution only to get them fixed.”
    S Boise, ID
    “From the moment of submitting a claim, to CHW setting up appointment with a networked technician (day 1) Who reviewed the issue and reported back (day 2), to repair/replacement (day 3).”
    Debra Meridian, ID
    “Roman was incredibly professional, punctual, meticulous, courteous, easy to talk with & explained every step he was engaged with & part as he was working on my dryer. I give him my highest endorsement & will be recommending him to my family & friends!!!”
    Heather Eagle, ID
    Best for roof coverage

    Select Home Warranty

    Select Home Warranty
    3.6
    16,168 reviews
    Plans available
    Bronze Care, Gold Care and Platinum Care
    Monthly premium range
    $60.42 to $63.75
    Service fees
    $75 to $100
    Labor guarantee
    180 days
    Get a Quote Read Reviews

    Roof work can be expensive — and it's often hard to get a roofer to show up for a small repair without a hefty minimum charge. Select stands out because its roof coverage can make those smaller fixes feel more manageable by turning a roof service visit into a standard claim with a predictable service fee.

    That said, the coverage cap may not pay for major repairs, but the real value for many homeowners is simply getting a professional dispatched without paying full out-of-pocket trip fees.

    Select Home Warranty offers three plans with monthly prices ranging from {monthly_premium_cost:16367} and a service call fee of {service_fee:16367}. You can reduce your premiums by paying annually instead of monthly.

    Add-ons and discounts

    • Optional add-ons
      • Sump pump: {sump_pump_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
      • Well pump: {well_pump_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
      • Stand-alone freezer: {standalone_freezer_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
      • Central vacuum: {central_vacuum_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
      • Septic system: {septic_system_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
      • Sprinkler system: {sprinkler_system_addon_monthly_cost:16367}
    • Discounts: Two months free if paid annually
    Pros
    • Absorbs service call cost for roof patches
    • Frequent discounts
    • Claims service available 24/7
    Cons
    • Must use approved technicians only
    • Low appliance coverage caps

    Idaho reviewers mention Select’s simple sign-up process and competitive pricing. On the other hand, some customers were frustrated with claim denials and slow reimbursement timelines around time-sensitive repairs.

    “We have been with Select Home Warranty since 2017. They are easy to work with. The people we deal with every time we call are very knowledgeable and competent. Very quick in taking care of our issues.”
    Amy Caldwell, ID
    “Signing up for this service was very easy and affordable. Jerry was easy to work with and had a few purchasing options to save me even more money than I originally thought. I just signed up so it gives me peace of mind knowing my home has good coverage!”
    Cherie Nampa, ID
    1x Award Winner
    Selected for having one of the highest satisfaction rates for Best Overall Value

    Home Warranties in Idaho Buyers Guide

    Jump into our guides and start learning

    In this guide

    Top Picks

    See who reviewers like

    American Home Shield logo
    Choice Home Warranty logo
    Select Home Warranty logo
    See our top picks

    Simplify your search

    Compare plans tailored to your home & budget.

      Idaho's cold winters and mix of older rural homes and newer suburban construction create varied repair challenges. Mountain regions and rural properties face particular strain from freeze-thaw cycles and isolation. We'll help you find coverage suited to your area.

      Key insights

      Idaho homeowners should prioritize heating and plumbing coverage.

      Jump to insight

      On average, a home warranty in Idaho costs $60.15 per month. Expect to pay between $300 and $1,100 annually. Most plans include a service fee of $75 to $150.

      Jump to insight

      Because of the distinct seasonal shifts, homeowners should prioritize plans that offer equally strong coverage for both heating units and air conditioning systems.

      Jump to insight

      How to choose a home warranty in Idaho

      To select a home warranty in Idaho, start by identifying the types of coverage you need, then compare what each provider offers in terms of plan flexibility, pricing, sample contracts and verified customer reviews. Here's how to make the best choice for your home:

      1. Decide on coverage level

      Figure out if you want to cover appliances, systems or both. If your HVAC, plumbing and electrical systems are relatively new but your washer or fridge is older, an appliance-focused plan could be best. On the other hand, if your appliances are still covered by the manufacturer but you're worried about a furnace or AC breakdown, a systems-only plan makes sense.

      Combo plans offer the benefits of both and are a popular option for homeowners who want broad protection and higher limits. If your home was built before 1985 or is in a mountain region, prioritize systems coverage. Rural and remote properties need strong well and septic options, while newer suburban homes may focus more on appliances.

      2. Compare costs

      Don't just look at the monthly premium — check the overall value. Service fees (typically $75 to $150 per visit) can add up if you file multiple claims. Coverage caps matter too, since some companies only pay a set amount for each repair or replacement. Be sure to check the cost of extras like roof leak coverage or a second fridge, as these can change your yearly total.

      Keep in mind that Idaho home warranty costs can vary by region. Rural and mountain areas typically cost more due to limited technician networks while suburban areas near Boise have more competitive pricing.

      3. Review sample contracts

      Most home warranty companies post sample contracts online. These outline exactly what's covered and what's excluded. Read through these to spot details like waiting periods, steps for cancelling, filing claims and parts and labor limits.

      When reviewing contracts, check freeze damage coverage carefully — frozen pipes and ice dams are common in Idaho. Verify that well and septic systems are available as add-ons. If you're in a mountain region, ensure roof leak coverage and confirm technician access in your area.

      Fine print details can come back to bite you when you file a claim. For example, Jack from Idaho Falls was disappointed to learn that his well pump wouldn't be covered. "There was something in the fine print which gave CHW an out."

      4. Read customer reviews

      Customer feedback is invaluable for understanding what to expect after you sign up. Watch for patterns on claim approvals, contractor punctuality and any surprise fees. Reviews from Idaho customers in your local area are especially useful — people in rural or mountain regions often have different experiences than those in Boise.

      Pay attention to whether technicians were readily available and how quickly they were able to respond during winter. Dax from Coolin ran into this exact problem: "Company spent a week 'contacting providers in their network', only to reply that none were available."

      » MORE: 10 questions for your home warranty company

      How much does a home warranty cost in Idaho?

      A home warranty in Idaho costs $60.15 per month on average. Home warranty annual costs generally range from $300 to $1,100, depending on the plan. The average cost of a home warranty in Idaho is 11.1% lower than the national average.

      Cost range by home warranty provider

      We received quotes for each of our top picks in Idaho for a three-bed, two-bath home in Boise.

      ProviderMonthly premium range*Service call fee
      american home shield logo$29.99 to $89.99$100 or $125
      choice home warranty logo$46.83 to $54.75$100
      select home warranty logo$60.42 to $63.75$75 to $100

      *Data updated January 2026

      Most home warranty providers in Idaho allow you to pay month-to-month or yearly. Monthly payments spread out your expenses, while annual payments can bring discounts. Your final cost will depend on the company, plan type and any add-ons you select.

      Service call fees

      Each time you request a repair, you'll pay a service call fee — like a per-visit deductible. Expect to pay between $75 and $150 for each visit, depending on your plan and where you live.

      Add-on coverage

      Many home warranty companies let you add extra coverage for things like pools or sump pumps. Add-ons usually cost an additional $2 to $25 per month per item.

      Other home warranty cost factors

      Home warranty prices vary widely depending on a few factors:

      • Home size and type: Larger homes generally cost more to cover, while condos or smaller properties are less expensive.
      • Level of coverage: Cheaper home warranty plans usually cover fewer items. More comprehensive plans that bundle systems and appliances will have higher premiums.
      • Location: Idaho's geography and climate variation may affect warranty costs. Mountain and rural areas typically pay more than suburban regions near Boise.
      • Discounts: Companies often run specials or reward you for paying for multiple years up front.

      Example: total annual home warranty costs

      • Systems and appliances combo ($50 per month): $600 per year
      • Add-on for roof leak repair and sump pump ($13 per month): $156 per year
      • Three claims ($95 service fee): $285
      • Total: $1,041 per year

      What does an Idaho home warranty cover?

      Home warranty plans in Idaho fall into three types: appliance plans, systems plans and combination (combo) plans.

      • Appliance plans usually include coverage for refrigerators, dishwashers, ovens, built-in microwaves, washers and dryers.
      • Systems plans focus on critical home systems like heating, plumbing, electrical, water heaters and ductwork — especially important in Idaho's cold climate where reliable heating and plumbing really matter.
      • Combo plans offer protection for both appliances and systems, providing the widest safety net.

      Most companies let you add extra coverage for things not included in standard plans. In Idaho, consider add-ons for well pump protection, septic system coverage, roof leak repair and sump pump coverage in mountainous or flood-prone areas.

      » LEARN: Home warranty misconceptions

      Reviewers' experience filing home warranty claims in Idaho

      • Evelen in Caldwell didn’t want a random repair bill when her freezer began leaking. She shared, "Filing the claim online with AHS was quite user-friendly." The assigned contractor showed up, diagnosed a blocked tube and stopped the leak. For her, the website made the whole claim feel straightforward.

        Key takeaway: User-friendly online claims make sudden repairs feel manageable

      • When her AC acted up late Friday, Lisa in Nampa still kicked off the claims process online. She noted, "Within hours I received an email confirmation of the claim." The appointment landed quickly, the tech used her video to pinpoint the issue, and after the part was replaced, she said she has had no problems since.

        Key takeaway: Quick confirmation, a fast appointment and a lasting repair make coverage feel worthwhile

      • Reza in Eagle expected a warranty claim to be simple and covered, not a battle. Instead, he warns, "They do not pay for warranty claims even if it is covered." After sharing the paperwork, he says they still denied it. For him, the monthly cost wasn’t worth it if approval felt unpredictable.

        Key takeaway: A warranty isn’t worth it if covered claims still get denied

      How much can you save with an Idaho home warranty?

      Your actual savings depend on which systems or appliances break down and whether you need a repair or full replacement. Even one covered major failure can more than offset the yearly cost of a plan.

      The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau recommends budgeting 1% to 3% of your home's value each year for upkeep and repairs. Most people spend much less on a home warranty, especially if they only pay $700 to $1,200 per year, including a few service call fees. Avoiding a single big-ticket repair could save you thousands.

      Average repair/replacement costs for covered items

      Idaho's cold winters, mountain terrain and rural isolation create diverse repair challenges. Furnace failures, frozen pipes and roof damage from heavy snow are common claims. Limited technician availability in remote areas adds urgency. Here's what repairs typically cost in Idaho.

      FAQ

      How does a home warranty work?

      A home warranty is a service contract designed to help with repairs or replacements on your home’s systems and appliances. You pay a set monthly or annual fee and a service charge when you request service.

      When something breaks, you file a claim, and the warranty company sends a contractor to diagnose and fix the problem. If repair isn’t possible, the company pays for a replacement — up to your coverage limits, which vary by plan.

      Is a home warranty worth it in Idaho?

      A home warranty can offer real peace of mind for Idaho homeowners who want to avoid large, unexpected bills for repairs or replacements. With the high cost of fixing or replacing a furnace or plumbing in winter, a warranty can be a smart investment — especially for older homes in rural or mountain areas, where a single emergency can cost over $2,500.

      What does a home warranty not cover?

      Most home warranty plans exclude things like preexisting issues, cosmetic damage, improper installation and repairs already covered by a manufacturer’s warranty. There are coverage caps for each repair or replacement, so very expensive fixes may not be fully paid for. Maintenance, landscaping and structural items like windows or walls are not included.

      Many plans exclude freeze damage, even though it’s common in Idaho. Standard plans usually don’t cover wells or septic systems, and mountain homes may have gaps in coverage for snow or ice damage. Always read your contract for full details.

      What’s the difference between a home warranty and homeowners insurance?

      Unlike homeowners insurance, a home warranty isn’t a requirement for taking out a mortgage. Home warranties cover various home appliances and systems in the event they break down due to regular use; homeowners insurance, on the other hand, covers your property and belongings if they’re destroyed in an accident (like a fire or bad weather).

      What’s a red flag for a home warranty?

      There are several red flags to look out for when choosing a home warranty company. A vague service contract is a major red flag — if you can’t easily see what’s covered, what’s excluded or how to file a claim, steer clear. Also, beware of aggressive sales tactics, hard-to-reach or unhelpful customer service and hidden fees.

      Methodology

      The ConsumerAffairs Research Team used a data-backed process informed by expert editorial judgment and verified customer reviews. We started with home warranty companies available in Idaho, then evaluated which performed best for local residents.

      Here's how we scored each company:

      • Contractor availability and choice (40%): In Idaho, vast distances and high demand often make sticking to a preferred network impractical. We scored companies that allow policyholders to hire their own licensed technicians immediately higher than those with strict in-network requirements, which can result in weeks of downtime while waiting for an assigned vendor.
      • Local satisfaction rate (35%): Reviews from real customers in Idaho are worth more than a company's nationwide reputation. If a company has a poor technician network locally or frequently denies Idaho homeowners' most frequent complaints, we capture that in our review analysis.
      • Cost (10%): To compare apples to apples, we looked at the lowest-priced comprehensive plan each company offers in Idaho. We also considered the lowest service fees each company offers.
      • National satisfaction rate (10%): To get a broader picture of how each company performs in specific aspects, we looked at national reviews. In this way, we could see who, overall, has the highest ratings for these seven satisfaction drivers:
        • Technician quality
        • Customer service
        • Claims handling
        • Punctuality and speed
        • Coverage
        • Value
        • Refunds and payouts
      • Additional benefits (5%): We rounded out our analysis by considering how many plans and service fee options each company offers (flexibility), labor guarantees and the availability of extra benefits like roof leak repair coverage and HVAC tuneups.

      Note: Each superlative emphasizes certain factors more than others. For example, the "Best value" superlative weights cost at 20%, while "Best claims handling" gives more weight to reviews that mention the claims process and customer service.

      Guide sources

      ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work. Specific sources for this guide include:

      1. Idaho.gov, “Office of the Attorney General.” Accessed Jan. 29, 2026.

      Not sure how to choose?

      Get buying tips about Home Warranties in Idaho delivered to your inbox.

        By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

        Thanks for subscribing.

        You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

        Compare top Idaho home warranty companies

        Showing 10 of 35

        Want your company to be on this guide?

        Yes, continue
        Comparing

        ×