How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

Fidelity National Home Warranty Reviews

1.2
374 reviewsRating Calculation
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.

Our editorial standards

  • Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
  • We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
  • All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.

Our review standards

  • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
  • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
  • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
+2 more
Author picture
Fact-checked by: Becca Blanco

About Fidelity National Home Warranty

This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.

Fidelity National Home Warranty provides warranties that cover the major systems and appliances in a home. It offers annual plans for both single-family and multifamily homes. It will repair or replace home items for a set trade call fee. Fidelity National Home Warranty will evaluate if the item needs to be repaired or replaced, and labor on service is guaranteed for 30 days.

Visit www.homewarranty.com
Pros
  • Fast claim dispatch times
  • Service guarantee covers 30 days on labor and 90 days on parts
  • Available for single-family and multifamily homes
Cons
  • Renews automatically at potentially higher rates
  • Coverage restricted to 13 states

How Fidelity National Home Warranty works

Fidelity National Home Warranty covers most major systems in your home. If a covered item needs repair, you can file a claim, and the company will send out an authorized service provider.

The company will typically repair the item rather than replace it. If an item cannot be repaired, Fidelity National Home Warranty may reimburse you for the repair cost after you purchase a new item. For example, if a repair on your oven would cost $300, the company may approve a $300 cash buyout toward a replacement. The company may also choose to pay cash in lieu of replacement.

You can purchase an initial contract for one or two years, and it will automatically renew annually thereafter.

Fidelity National Home Warranty service area

Fidelity National Home Warranty is available in 13 states, including:

  • Alabama
  • Arizona
  • California 
  • Colorado
  • Florida
  • Georgia
  • Idaho
  • Nevada
  • New Mexico
  • Oregon
  • Texas 
  • Utah
  • Washington

Fidelity National Home Warranty coverage and plans

Fidelity National Home Warranty offers four plan levels: Standard, Comprehensive Plus, Enhanced and Enhanced Plus.

All plans cover the basic household systems such as heating, plumbing and electrical. A separate, non-refundable trade call service fee is charged for each service request. Your trade service fee is defined in your contract; for context, a sample contract we reviewed quoted $75 to $95 per request.

On the Standard and Comprehensive Plus plans, you can warranty a single-family home, condo, townhome, mobile home, duplex, triplex, fourplex and new construction. With the Enhanced Plus plan, you can cover a single-family home, condo, townhome and mobile homes.

Fidelity National Home Warranty will replace the item up to the coverage limits if repair isn’t possible.

Fidelity National Home Warranty cost

The pricing listed below is for a one-year plan for single-family homes. Warranties are billed annually, and you can purchase coverage for either one or two years.

Note: Costs are accurate at the time of publication and may vary by location.

Fidelity National Home Warranty optional add-on coverage

Most items covered in the Enhanced plans that aren’t covered in the lower-tier plans can be added on individually.

For example, roof leak repair isn’t covered under any plan, but it can be added for $100 per year.

Other annual prices for popular add-ons are:

  • Water softener: $75
  • Pool and spa equipment: $225
  • Septic tank system pumping: $75
  • Well pump: $100
  • Second refrigerator: $60

Fidelity National Home Warranty exclusions and limitations

There are coverage limits per term for most of the covered items. Your exact limits will vary by location. Some coverage limits can be increased by purchasing additional coverage.

Here are the coverage limits for the major components on the Standard plan for a home in California:

  • Plumbing: $1,000
  • Water heater: $1,500
  • Ductwork: $1,000
  • Heating and air conditioning: $1,500
  • Kitchen appliances: $5,000 per covered appliance

Note that washers and dryers aren’t covered by the Standard or Comprehensive Plus plan unless purchased as an add-on. Ceiling fans are also not covered, and there’s no option to add them.

Fidelity National Home Warranty recently added subterranean termite treatment coverage as an optional add-on in some areas. However, there is an increased trade call fee for this service.

Fidelity National Home Warranty claims

To file a claim, call 1-800-308-1420 or visit the Fidelity National Home Warranty website. Within three business hours, the company will contact an authorized service provider. The service provider then contacts you directly to schedule an appointment.

If you request emergency service for a nonemergency repair, you may incur additional fees. Also, if you contact a service provider directly, without making a claim through Fidelity National Home Warranty, you likely won’t be reimbursed.

Service work is warrantied for 30 days on labor and 90 days on parts. Fidelity National Home Warranty may also pay cash rather than replace the item outright.

FAQ

Does Fidelity National Home Warranty have a service fee?

Yes, Fidelity National Home Warranty charges a nonrefundable trade call fee per request. The fee is set in your contract and covers service calls for the same claim for 30 days.

Can you cancel Fidelity National Home Warranty?

Yes, you can cancel your Fidelity National Home Warranty plan. However, there may be a $50 cancellation fee.

Does Fidelity cover air conditioning?

Yes, Fidelity National Home Warranty covers the air conditioning system in all plans.

What states does Fidelity National Home Warranty serve?

Fidelity National Home Warranty serves Alabama, Arizona, California, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Texas, Utah and Washington.

Does Fidelity National Home Warranty offer any guarantees?

Yes, Fidelity National Home Warranty guarantees service work for 30 days after a repair.

How do I file a claim with Fidelity National Home Warranty?

To file a quick claim with Fidelity National Home Warranty, you can visit the homeowner website or call 1-800-308-1420.

Still have questions?

Is Fidelity National Home Warranty worth it?

Fidelity National Home Warranty is worth it if you want predictable repair costs or have an older home that may need repairs soon. It can also be a good fit if you’re a landlord with a multifamily property, since it simplifies handling repair requests while keeping expenses more predictable.

However, if you have a newer home or a substantial emergency fund that can cover unexpected repairs, you may find a home warranty of any kind unnecessary. Fidelity may also not be worth it if you want to choose your own service providers.

Shop with confidence

Compare with top companies

Fidelity National Home Warranty Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (6)
  • (1)
  • (1)
  • (7)
  • (355)

Popular Mentions

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Recent
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Page 1 Reviews 0 - 40
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceContract & TermsCoverageTechPriceRefunds & PayoutsStaffBillingResolutionTimelinessHonesty & Transparency

    Reviewed Nov. 3, 2026

    Fidelity National Home Warranty is a terrible company with terrible customer service and illegal cancellation practices. After escrow closed, I purchased a home warranty on my main house and another on my casita/"granny flat". The same day I received the paperwork from them (Nov 2nd, 2026), I contacted them to have the property re-keyed, which is something they offer included in their warranty. However, because the property is in such a rural area (licensed contractors are over an hour away), Fidelity nor I could locate a licensed locksmith willing to travel to the home to do the work. I realized I am going to have this issue with any and all types of contractors because of the location of the property and that Fidelity National Home Warranty would not be able to provide the services that I paid them for.

    I explained all of this to them and asked them to cancel both home warranties that I had just received THAT VERY SAME DAY - They proceeded to tell me that I would be charged a $50 Admin Fee for each warranty, as well as a proration of the amount paid for each as of Oct 22nd, because that is the day escrow closed and they "backdate" the home warranty to the close of escrow date regardless of payment or date on the contract (I paid for them on Oct 30th and received the supposed "contracts" that I never signed on Nov 2nd). This doesn't make any sense, as I am ONLY cancelling because THEY CANNOT provide the service I paid them for!!

    I shouldn't have to pay any fees to cancel when I am cancelling because of them, and I shouldn't have to pay any prorated amount when I couldn't have asked them to re-key the home prior to the date I received the information for the home warranty! I fought with their customer service, asked for managers, spoke to someone named Alex, who refused to give me any other information like a last name or ID #. He refused to transfer me to his superior, and repeated the same BS script over and over: "Our contract states there is an Admin Fee of $50 and I cannot waive that fee." "I do not have any available manager, the 'escalation' was assigned to me." I explained I didn't sign their supposed "contract", nor did I see a copy of it before paying for the home warranty and therefore it was not enforceable.

    He just kept repeating the same thing and refusing to help in any way. I also had to speak to customer service in order to receive an email with instructions on HOW to cancel the home warranties - which took the entire day to receive, so they can try to say I didn't cancel until the following day. And they are saying it will take 2 to 3 weeks for them to process the cancellation!!! The whole thing is completely insane, and I ended up disputing the cost with my credit card company. I am thankful I paid using credit card, because had I paid another way, I'd be stuck fighting with them. I still may have an issue, as I don't know what will happen when my credit card company speaks with Fidelity. Avoid this company at all costs. It's a corporate nightmare, absolutely no customer service, and honestly, fees charged and cancellations processed illegally.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTechSales & MarketingStaffBilling

    Reviewed Oct. 30, 2026

    Fidelity does not have a billing department or compartmentalized departments for customer service, billing, contracts, and sales. They only provide one department which apparently can assist with all concerns. The representatives are rude, short tempered and unable to process information properly. They refused to assist me on multiple occasions with various concerns. They are uneducated, and poorly trained representatives and they are not able to provide any guidance or assistance with contract related issues and renewals.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Not sure how to choose?

    Get buying tips about Home Warranties, Service Plans delivered to your inbox.

      By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Thanks for subscribing.

      You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

      CoverageSales & MarketingPunctuality & Speed

      Reviewed Oct. 28, 2026

      SCAM. SCAM! This company showed me one set of coverages but then denied me coverage later and refused to cover my refrigerator. THey did not honor their OWN paperwork. In looking more at their own fine print it is super scammy - they cap coverage on major appliances at ridiculously low levels and hide all sorts of exclusions.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Verified purchase
      CoverageTechStaff

      Reviewed Oct. 19, 2026

      Fidelity National Home Warranty closed my claim on a completely dead, 13-year-old water heater after a dispatched technician falsely reported that the unit was operational. I am currently left with zero hot water at my home in CA, despite having an active 2-Year plan that explicitly covers full water heater replacement, disposal, and permits. Hot water is an essential utility and habitability requirement. Refusing to re-dispatch a technician or authorize emergency replacement is a clear failure to uphold their contract. A formal complaint has already been submitted to the BBB, and I am demanding an immediate corporate resolution.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Oct. 19, 2026

      Took a month to get my dishwasher done. I had to call them back multiple times to get anything started. Do not purchase.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      TechPricePunctuality & SpeedStaffRatesTimelinessHonesty & Transparency

      Reviewed Oct. 15, 2026

      Since purchasing our home in November 2021, and signing up with Fidelity National Home Warranty, we have honestly had 99% OUTSTANDING service! Have there been some issues? Of course there have. A rep here or there who isn't as nice as everyone else, but that's with any business. I've never experienced automatic renewal at a higher price, and in fact when I received my renewal notice for this year, the price did not increase for the level I have, so I'm likely going to renew for the higher level.

      When I need service they do everything they can to get it there quickly, for instance recently I had an issue with my hot water heater and the service technician was there the next day and the problem was fixed and everything is working beautifully now. No company is 100% perfect, but as a homeowner, I am extremely happy with the service provided by FHW and the vendors they work with.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageStaff

      Reviewed Oct. 14, 2026

      Complete waste of your money. You buy a warranty so that way you don’t have to have extensive repairs in the first year of living in your home and our HVAC unit which was over 25 years old was leaking from the inside within the first year and they refused to cover it because they claimed that we stepped on it even though neither of us had ever been into the attic. They made a conclusion based off on an assumption that they had no evidence of. Also, anytime I made a claim we would deal with multiple people that would say different things in the customer service was terrible. When we would ask for clarification when they would contradict what the other agent would say they would get upset with us for questioning them even though their company is the one that set it in the first place.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.

      Reviewed Oct. 9, 2026

      Terrible Company. A waste of your time and money based on my own experience as a customer for over twenty years.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Punctuality & Speed

      Reviewed Sept. 14, 2026

      Nothing is ever resolved in a timely manner. 3 to 6 weeks is the average wait for repair. We had to throw out food in our freezer because of the lengthy back and forth with this lame company. And many other appliances with the same result.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      CoverageTechSales & MarketingRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceResolution

      Reviewed Sept. 10, 2026

      I have had Fidelity National Home Warranty for a long time and up until now they have been fine. So the AC just stopped working. I put in a work order, they sent a company to fix the problem. The guy applied pressure to an electrical connected and the unit came on just fine. Then he said he would not repair it until we paid for a "chemical clean" which is outside of the coverage, and is MANDATORY. Not related to the issue at all. So Fidelity are MAKING customers pay their subcontractors for unrelated work before they will fix the issue at hand. Never had that problem before, but it's obviously a SCAM, no question about it.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

      Reviewed Sept. 1, 2026

      We have had them for ten years. So, why one star? On some things they have done okay. For example, six months ago our garbage disposal failed. Replacement went okay except vendor put in a low power, cheap unit. Other times, like today... **. Water pressure regulator previously failed. They replaced it but with a big hassle to us and much arguing about coverage. Now, that new one has failed a month later. FNHW refuses to even send a plumber out. They say because the part is under manufacturer warrant. I told them that I don't KNOW that is the problem. I'm not a plumber. I asked to speak with a supervisor. The operator ("Luke") said he could not transfer me. He then hung up on me. Geeez. So, I called them back. The new operator ("Eric") said the supervisor would call back.

      Now, hours later, still no call. At next contract renewal, I will definitely look at other companies. I see the reviews cite a lot of complaints for denials of coverage for questionable reasons, and denials based on small contract print. THAT is really true of FNHW. In our case, some things go okay. Others, denials really seem based on their whim. Talk to a supervisor? Good luck with that....

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedStaffRates

      Reviewed Aug. 27, 2026

      Terrible. Had them come out to service a dishwasher and the company they sent out has a one star rating on Yelp, Google and Reddit. Why are we using subpar one star companies to service people‘s homes? Anyway the Company came out disassembled my dishwasher and left. Fidelity then called to tell me they would not cover what was wrong with the dishwasher. Ok fine but my dishwasher was in pieces and they would not send tech out ASAP to put it back together even though they wouldn’t fix it. My dishwasher sat for 3 1/2 weeks unassembled so I couldn’t even get someone else out to come and fix what they would not cover.

      Again the company they sent out was terrible, rude, condescending, unresponsive, and the tech became belligerent when I started to ask questions about things that were not put back together correctly, like the dishwasher, not being level and not being set evenly between the center of the cabinet. I felt unsafe with him in my home at that point, and he was scheduled to come out and replace a part on my washing machine. Called the home warranty company to explain to them the situation, and how I no longer felt safe with this man or this company being in my home. Fidelity did not care and would not switch it to a different company. Had zero sympathy or compassion even tho I explained I am a woman at home by myself and no longer felt safe with this man or company being in my home. Fidelity, you need to work on your company policies. This is unacceptable.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Verified purchase
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & PayoutsStaffTimeliness

      Reviewed Aug. 27, 2026

      I've had Fidelity for 4 years and never a problem. Claims got processed quickly, vendors next day if not same day depending on the issue. HOWEVER, this year, a totally different story. The vast majority of service reps I dealt with were short, rude and couldn't be bothered with explaining what wasn't going to be covered and why or an expected date of repair.

      I had a major leak, (it actually was spraying in a jet-stream) when the valve to a water line broke off, requiring me to turn off the water to the whole house. They did not have a provider that could come out for 3 days, and average temps at this time was 115*. They told me that I could hire someone, but the information they wanted the company to submit was insane, including they wanted to do a video conference, that submission of pictures would not suffice. When the plumber got here, unfortunately he did not have time to jump thru all their hoops, so I just paid out of pocket. The LAST STRAW was when my air conditioning went out during a heat wave of temperatures 118-122* for over 2 weeks in a row.

      The HVAC company submitted all the info to Fidelity on 8/7, Fidelity placed the order on 8/10 to the supplier, United Refrigeration, who filled the order on 8/12. Since Fidelity didn't specify whether it was to be shipped or picked up, the HVAC company didn't receive the compressor until 8/20...which only happened after making several calls to Fidelity. I again informed them this area of the country was under Extreme Heat Warnings and requested that Fidelity compensate with me for portable air conditioners while I wait, but they would not reimburse me, they refused to pay for a hotel and kept saying that they are not responsible for how long it takes the supplier to obtain the part.

      Despite the fact that the order was filled on 8/12, my air did not get fixed until 8/21, and Fidelity declined $245 saying there was a clause and I was responsible for "non-covered items", even after having to wait all this time. The last issue I have with Fidelity, they used to have several contractors in the area, only for me to find out this HVAC company was the ONLY one in the network for this area, and the same in regard to plumbing companies.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      TechPunctuality & SpeedMaintenanceStaffRatesHonesty & Transparency

      Reviewed Aug. 20, 2026

      I like others had the warranty added in with all the purchase figures on my home. The outdoor A/C unit needed repair and the first visit went ok. The technician didn't act like he wanted to be there much less working. I paid a second $95 dollars for a second visit on the inside unit which fan had quit blowing and was sporadic as best. A technician showed up in 2 days and diagnosed the fan motor needing replaced along with the thermostat. That's the last service I received and it's now 16 days later with nothing but lies and excuses from the contractor. Fidelity contracted with this company and has contacted them once with no results. I find it interesting that Fidelity claims to have no responsibility for delays, parts etc., when they are the ones who contract with such pathetic companies.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Aug. 19, 2026

      This company is sham. Their network is so small; they are not able to send service people to your home when you need them most.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedStaffWait Time

      Reviewed Aug. 8, 2026

      I purchased a home 6 months ago, the home warranty was purchased by the realtor included as a gift for us. I called them to come fix a leaking water heater and their response was, "Okay we have wait until we can get a bid from our companies (wait time unknown)," we are unable to wait because we needed to shower every day so we can't just turn off the water to the water heater without turning off our water. Absolutely useless, if we didn't get this warranty gifted to us, we will never have purchased this warranty from them, and I strongly recommend anytime to not as well, because they are here to take your money, but when it comes to helping you...they will do all they can to not be helpful and leave you stranded.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPricePunctuality & SpeedRatesCoverage Limits

      Reviewed Aug. 5, 2026

      FAIL!!!! This company used to be extremely more reliable across the spectrum of coverages, customer service and contractors. Those days are long gone!! The “service fee” does not go to the overall cost; you find your own vendor due to the lack of “contracted providers,” because the contractors don’t like their late reimbursements, and you have to pay the vendor at the time of service, not the case in the past, as the company would handle all of that after determining the “coverage.” A recent kitchen sink stop-up repair cost $525, and the company allowed coverage of $181. Not even close!!! Rates from the ‘90’s!! Customer service was horrid, inefficient, tedious, and ill-trained. I spent more time on solving the issue than they did. If there was a negative star rating, it would fill a galaxy. FAIL!!!!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceTechOnline & AppMaintenance

      Reviewed Aug. 1, 2026

      Poor service. My A/C stopped working. I started a work order and received confirmation that my work order was received and then I didn’t hear anything back. I received a text message that they weren’t able to reach me. Impossible and not true - I was sitting by my phone and there is no call history on my phone, indicating that no one did call me. I called the number (818 435-4442- Platinum Repair, try and see) several times and each time they put me on hold for 20 minutes and then disconnected the call at the end, before I was able to speak with anyone. Bottom line, I didn’t hear from Fidelity Home Warranty or their vendor. What is a home warranty good for if you don’t get service when you need it.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceContract & TermsCoverageTechSales & MarketingPriceMaintenanceStaff

      Reviewed July 28, 2026

      Horrible company to deal with. Representative assured me that the home warranty would cover my garage door opener broken belt. Paid the $100 trip fee. Technician assessed the situation upon arrival and called Fidelity National Home Warranty. They denied the work order. Cost me my time and money. They're a scam so be very careful.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageRefunds & PayoutsStaffBillingHonesty & Transparency

      Reviewed July 23, 2026

      Orange County and San Diego County, California - consumers and realtors beware of the manipulative and deceitful practices of this company, and in particular, the Assistant Vice Presidents Sharon Whaley and Debi Levenson from OC and SD, respectively. Sharon was emailing a colleague about a claim on my home warranty and accidentally sent it to the wrong person, and it ended up in my possession. In this email she openly discloses that her and Debi discussed telling lies to coerce us into renewing our policy.

      They claimed there was a "rule" from the Department of Insurance that they have no choice but to follow, which prohibits them from making any kind of payment to a client unless they have a current and active policy - even if the claim was from a covered period of time. THIS IS A LIE. They're own legal team and claims department confirmed this. After reporting them for their unethical behavior, they changed their mind and issued us a full refund - no renewal required. If they've lied to you or treated you unfairly, know that you can file a complaint with the Department of Insurance to hold them accountable.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedStaffRatesNetwork Quality

      Reviewed July 21, 2026

      We have had a homeowner warranty policy with Fidelity for 20 years. When we got it, it saved us a little bit of money. Their service was OK, but not that good. Some of their contractors were good and others didn’t know what they were doing. It saved us a little money so we continued until this year. In the past few years, their service has become horrible. For a clothes washer, a hot water heater, and recently our refrigerator. We had to wait about three weeks to have something done. It takes them a week to just approve a part. Their customer service people are nice, but they have no interest in helping their customers. The last few years were very frustrating. We did not renew our policy this year.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      CoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

      Reviewed July 10, 2026

      They are the worst home warranty company ever. They don't cover what the contract says. They said, "Sorry we changed it." But of course they don't tell you till you make a claim. They just don't want to cover it. They breached the contract. I will be going to BBB.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Claims HandlingRefunds & Payouts

      Reviewed July 1, 2026

      These home warranties don’t pay out and when you file a claim they make it impossible to get anything repaired and try to blame it on a pre existing condition! And it wasn’t even on the inspection report. Such a waste of money!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceTechRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceStaffTransparencyCommunicationResolutionWait Time

      Reviewed June 26, 2026

      I would give Fidelity Home Warranty zero stars if I could. My HVAC system has been broken for over a week during the summer. I submitted my claim on Friday of the previous week. The technician inspected the system and submitted the repair estimate to Fidelity last Friday. Since then, I’ve been told the estimate is “under review” by someone named William on the Expert Team. I have called Fidelity every single day, and every day I receive the exact same response: “It’s still under review.” No one can provide an update, a timeline, or an explanation. Even worse, there is no way to contact William or anyone on the Expert Team directly. Customer service simply repeats the same script over and over without offering any real assistance or escalation.

      What is the point of paying for a home warranty if, when you actually need it, your claim just sits in limbo while your home has no air conditioning? A home warranty should provide peace of mind, not endless frustration and uncertainty. If you’re considering Fidelity Home Warranty, I strongly recommend looking elsewhere. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this company. In fact, you may be better off setting aside $200 each month in your own emergency repair fund. Over time, you’ll have money available for repairs without having to deal with long delays, poor communication, and a company that seems unwilling to make timely decisions when it matters most.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceStaffTransparencyTimeliness

      Reviewed June 19, 2026

      This is my second year with this company and I will most likely not renew as my current experience has been extremely poor. Last year the experience was good but now, it has become very frustrating and disappointing! Our washing machine broke down 1.5 weeks ago on June 10 and after filing a claim the same day, the appliance tech came out on June 11, and assessed the problem in literally 10 min; I needed a new transmission. His report was sent in that day, but, when I called Fidelity 2 days later for an update, as I had not heard back, the agent stated they received no report!

      They called the appliance company, and Fidelity, lo and behold magically found the report and told me the primary agent will evaluate within 24 hours; I waited until the next day to await a decision. When I did not hear back, I called again to be told that an " expert" panel will decide whether to pay for a new transmission or write a check to replace the old one but it would take 2-3 business days to make that decision! Well it's business day # 3 and after another phone call; no decision has been made!

      The appliance company has been on the phone with Fidelity daily without any luck or reservation. They even expedited the transmission order to help me out as the washer will require hauling out to the repair shop but fidelity has not not made any decision despite the appliance company's proactivity. Fidelity is not for the people, they are a typical insurance company out for themselves! When I saw the 331 out of 346 reviews are 1 star, the red flag has been flown.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Contract & TermsCoverageTechPricePunctuality & SpeedMaintenanceStaff

      Reviewed June 11, 2026

      Do not waste your money with this company! I bought a two-year warranty as a new homeowner, thinking that it would help me if I needed a major repair. They offer an ”annual air-conditioning tuneup.” I had them come out two years in a row. This is my third year in the home, and I did not renew the warranty. My air conditioner died, and I had someone come look at it. The inside of it was absolutely disgusting. There was a moss growing, dust, dirt, etc growing on the inside, where the venting is. There was not any for the air to flow. My motor basically burned up. The technician told me that it had been at least five years since I had been cleaned.

      Prior to that. I had them come look at my water dispenser in my refrigerator that wasn’t working, and it was a frozen water line that was not covered by the warranty. They also looked at my furnace and told me that it was installed incorrectly, and it cost me about $1100 to fix it. I found out later that it was not actually installed incorrectly.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechSales & MarketingPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceStaffTimelinessCoverage Limits

      Reviewed May 19, 2026

      Fidelity National Home Warranty was the company that was contracted as my home warranty as part of my closing through the title company and realtor. I have nothing but denials every time I contacted them for a repair. I had to pay them the $90 claim fee each time to even file a claim. I find that onerous. First claim was last summer 2025. My air conditioning unit failed. I called them and paid my fee. A man, without any identification and dressed in street clothes, in unmarked car, not wearing a mechanic's uniform, came out and went on the roof of my condominium building. He returned within 1/2 hour. He said he would get back to Fidelity and I would hear the next day.

      The next day, Fidelity called and said that the man refused the job and they were sending another repairman from another appliance company out to look. A man came the next day with a uniform, name tag and marked truck. He went up to the roof and returned in one hour. Told me he would call Fidelity with his report and they’d get back to me. Well, 5 days later, Fidelity called me and said they do not cover “vandalism”. I questioned them and said, "How could only my unit, out of 24 other units on the roof, be vandalized. You even need an HOA code to enter the door to the roof."

      I called an independent air conditioning company. They came out, took pictures. Showed me the physical damage to my unit. I called Fidelity back, and the claim adjuster on the phone was not polite and refused to discuss the denied claim further. I had to pay $16,000 out of pocket to replace the unit. The new air conditioning company was very sure someone had vandalized my unit. So read between the lines about the chain of events leading to the denial. Who vandalized my unit….? Because the policy was part of closing on my condominium, the policy continued. Almost a year later, my refrigerator was leaking water. I called, paid my $90 to file a claim.

      An appliance man came out with his phone on FaceTime with someone from Fidelity. They opened my refrigerator doors. The man put the phone in the refrigerator and the person on the phone said it was a frozen line, and I had to defrost my refrigerator for 48 hours. Denied any claim to a replacement part needed.

      This would have meant throwing food out and eating out for 2 days. I called an independent repair company. They came out and examined my refrigerator and determined that my sensor unit for defrosting was broken. I had to pay $385 to replace it out of my pocket. Does this seem legitimate?? A Face Time diagnosis and a denied claim….. Fidelity National Warranty Company scams its policyholders and does not pay claims. Even border on doing whatever they can to make the situation worse. I would definitely stay clear of this company. At closing, recommend another company if this company is used by the seller. Stay clear of them.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPricePunctuality & SpeedTimeliness

      Reviewed May 18, 2026

      If you are ever looking for a warranty company, stay clear of this company. No response or follow-ups. We had a clothes dryer repair, and the vendor did not fix it correctly. When we called to come fix it, we were charged a trip fee of $100 again, but it is still not fixed. Now it is my fridge, waiting on a part for a month, and they say it is not covered after a month. So frustrating. But they get your money ahead of time.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedStaffRatesCoverage Limits

      Reviewed May 14, 2026

      Fidelity National Home Warranty was the company that was contracted as my home warranty as part of my closing through the title company and realtor. I've filed 3 claims with this company. The first one went well but the last two both in the last week have been a nightmare. The first for an electrical outlet was with a local contractor and went well. The representative from the warranty company was responsive, polite and responsive. They asked me the pertinent questions and got the visit set up. The last 2 on Tuesday and Thursday were not good. It seems like this warranty company has issues with and can be difficult and restrictive with the companies they contract. The plumber they assigned had to drive all the way from Forney Texas over a hundred miles to my home in Granbury. For a simple job. Why? Surely there are reputable plumbers in Granbury or at least with 50 miles they could contract for a simple plumbing job.

      The plumber for the job done on Tuesday arrived at 10:24, diagnosed the problem but said he needed to contact the warranty company in order to get approval for the parts. He left to go get the parts at 11:19 and didn't return until almost 2 pm. He worked for about an hour and said he was finished but not before saying that he found another leak. He said we'd need to call the warranty company for the new leak and left at about 2:50 pm. When we went to close the under sink cabinet all three were still leaking. We had to call him to come back so he could finish the job right. He fixed all three about 4 pm. We called Fidelity National Home Warranty about the new leak. (Don't know how it just seemed to magically occur?) Paid the 95$ service fee and the rep said that a different plumber had been assigned. When they texted me, I saw that they had changed the order to the same technician from Forney.

      When I called to verify, the rep said the first contractor declined the job! I wonder why? Could it be that Fidelity National Home Warranty doesn't let them do the work properly? Today, Fidelity National Home Warranty email me that the cheapest basic chrome faucet was all that was authorized and not a brown or bronze color that closely matches our other side sink. I wasn't aware that there was anything wrong with the faucet. The leak is coming from a quick connect hot/cold y flex hose that are available online and at most hardware stores. When I realized it was more of a hassle to wait hours for the technician and the sink wouldn't match, I called in to cancel the work order.

      The representative Gricelda, was very hard to understand and after asking her to repeat the details of the job cancellation, she seemed to get perturbed. It seemed that she didn't understand my response about the reason why I wanted to cancel the work order and said the contractor had already arrived and diagnosed the problem and was on the way to service the call. I had already spoken to the technician and he was still on a separate job in Arlington.

      Due to the strong accent and difficulty understanding the representative, I requested to speak to a manager. She said to stand by and put me on hold for 20+ minutes. She finally came back on the line and said no one was available but that "someone" would call me back. That was about 5 hours ago. I will definitely not renew my policy with them and would not recommend Fidelity National Home Warranty company to anyone. They have an extremely bad rating for a reason. Completely incompetent.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      CoverageSales & MarketingPunctuality & Speed

      Reviewed April 15, 2026

      Fidelity home warranty is basically a scam. They don’t cover anything and they make you wait even with an emergency.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceTechPriceRefunds & PayoutsNetwork QualityCoverage Limits

      Reviewed April 10, 2026

      Our dishwasher began failing due to its age and eventually stopped draining. After attempting a repair myself, I chose to use our Fidelity National Home Warranty (Enhanced Plus Plan) rather than invest more time and money. I contacted FNHW, explained the issue, and paid the required $100 service fee. FNHW claimed they were unable to find a contractor and instructed me to locate one myself and follow their reimbursement procedure. This was unacceptable, as multiple qualified contractors were readily available in my area.

      The contractor I hired charged a $110 service call fee, which FNHW stated would be reimbursed. The dishwasher was repaired successfully, and the total contractor invoice was $350. In total, I paid $460 to the contractor, plus the $100 paid directly to FNHW. Despite collecting the service fee and providing no contractor support, FNHW reimbursed only $176. The out‑of‑pocket cost was nearly equivalent to purchasing a replacement dishwasher, rendering the warranty effectively useless. This warranty provided little value and shifted the burden entirely to the homeowner while keeping the fees. I strongly discourage anyone from using Fidelity National Home Warranty.

      Thanks for your vote!
      CoveragePunctuality & Speed

      Reviewed March 27, 2026

      My gas water was leaking and I was a new home owner. Each day the leak got worse and worse. They wanted to say it was preexisting and not cover it. It took them 3 weeks to finally have the water heater replaced. Then my stove caught on fire. It took 3 days after someone whom they sent to check stove before getting purchasing to approve replacement. Still waiting on new stove.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPriceMaintenanceStaff

      Reviewed March 26, 2026

      Dear Sir or Madam, I am writing to formally file a complaint regarding my recent experience with National Fidelity Home Warranty and the handling of my HVAC service request. After submitting a claim for issues with my air conditioning system, two separate service providers within your authorized network were dispatched to diagnose the problem. Despite multiple visits, neither company was able to correctly identify or resolve the issue. This resulted in an extended period without a functioning air conditioning system and considerable inconvenience.

      Due to the lack of resolution and the urgency of the situation, I made the decision to hire an independent, licensed HVAC technician outside of your network. Within a very short time—approximately two minutes—the technician was able to accurately diagnose and repair the problem, restoring my system to proper working condition. Given that your authorized providers were unable to resolve the issue despite multiple attempts, I believe it is reasonable and justified to request reimbursement for the out-of-network repair. However, I have been informed that my reimbursement request has been denied, which I find both disappointing and unacceptable under the circumstances.

      This situation raises serious concerns about the effectiveness of your service network and the fairness of your claims process. As a customer, I relied on your company to provide competent and timely service, which was not delivered. I respectfully request that you review my case in full, including the failed service attempts by your authorized providers and the successful resolution by the independent technician. I ask that you reconsider your decision and provide appropriate reimbursement for the repair costs incurred. Please respond to this complaint within a reasonable timeframe, outlining the steps you will take to address this matter. If necessary, I am prepared to escalate this.

      Thanks for your vote!
      CoverageTechStaff

      Reviewed March 23, 2026

      I was denied coverage even though I followed instructions per their representative, and I was blamed for not having cross-referenced those instructions with the contract. Customers are not lawyers; they rely on what they’re told by staff.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechMaintenance

      Reviewed March 14, 2026

      We have been with Fidelity for about 5 years and have noticed in the past year or so that customer service has definitely gone down. About 2 months ago we had an actively leaking toilet. I could not get the water to turn off and contacted Fidelity immediately. It took more than a week (while toilet is still leaking) to get someone out to fix it. Right now we have a leak (yes, it’s an old house) under our kitchen sink. We called them Tuesday (4 days ago)… still leaking. We live in Yuba City, CA and they always send someone from Sacramento which is 40 minutes away. We will be ending our contract when it expires.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTechRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceBillingNetwork QualityCoverage Limits

      Reviewed Jan. 20, 2026

      I have been a Fidelity National Home Warranty customer for nearly 20 years. My recent claim has been mishandled from start to finish. Fidelity classified this claim in writing as a return visit under the 30 day warranty provision, meaning no second service fee should apply. Despite this, I was billed again and my coverage was impacted. Their contractor misdiagnosed the HVAC issue twice, failed to repair a non functioning furnace, and did not communicate with me. I ultimately paid out of pocket for an emergency controller replacement, which fixed the problem immediately. This was a covered repair that Fidelity’s vendor was unable to diagnose or resolve.

      On December 19 I was told reimbursement would be submitted for manager approval. On January 8 I was told the claim was under manager review. As of January 20, there is still no decision, no timeline, and no meaningful response. I pay Fidelity for a service. This repair was covered. Ignoring a customer who is seeking resolution for a documented covered claim is unacceptable and disrespectful. Fidelity should reimburse the covered repair and reverse the improper second service fee.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer ServiceCoverageTech

      Reviewed Jan. 9, 2026

      DO NOT GET FIDELITY HOME WARRANTY!!!. There have been significant and concerning changes to this company’s contracts and customer service over a relatively short period of time. We have used this company in our homes for many years and have historically been satisfied with their services. However, the most recent renewal notice states that the company may replace covered items with significantly lower-quality alternatives. In addition, they are now denying services that were previously included under a “lifetime warranty.” A clear example is Delta Faucets, the company now refuses to service or replace them. These items come with a warranty on the product but not the service of replacements. These changes represent a substantial departure from the terms and expectations under which we originally contracted. We have since left Fidelity and have home warranty with a company that still aligns with proper home warranty.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Jan. 6, 2026

      Terrible!! I just purchased a home with this warranty and am sooo disappointed. They will do anything to deny a claim. The reviewers work together to record calls and twist/dispute every word you say.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.
      TechPrice

      Reviewed Dec. 17, 2025

      I’ve been a customer for 8 years. Recently had the garbage disposal replaced and it was installed incorrectly, leading to a water leak under the sink. Because it had 2 days over the “warranty period”, they wouldn’t do anything to remedy the issue and wanted me to spend $100 to submit a new work order! No, thanks. Now canceling my contract and they’re charging a $50 “admin fee”. What a ridiculous company…

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedHonesty & Transparency

      Reviewed Dec. 8, 2025

      I purchased my home and, on the day of closing, both garage door openers were functioning properly. Three days later, they continued to operate without issue. However, the following day, one of the openers ceased to function. When I contacted the company to request a service call, my claim was rejected based on the way I allegedly answered their questions. I was told that I had stated the opener had never worked and that I had prior knowledge of its failure, which is entirely inaccurate and illogical. Such a claim makes no sense, and it is unreasonable to assume that any customer would make such a statement.

      From the outset, my interaction with this company has felt punitive, as though the intent was to identify any possible reason to deny service rather than to resolve the issue. My request fell well within the parameters of coverage, yet it was dismissed without remedy or resolution. I was promised a call back from a manager, which has not occurred, and the responses I have received have been generic, dismissive, and devoid of accountability.

      This experience has led me to conclude that the company prioritizes denial of claims over customer satisfaction. I no longer expect coverage for legitimate issues in the future and will adjust my expectations accordingly. I also intend to share my experience widely. A willingness to assist with this minor repair would have demonstrated goodwill and strengthened the company’s reputation. Instead, the company has revealed a misleading and dishonest agenda, focused solely on profit at the expense of its customers. Such practices are unacceptable, and I strongly condemn this approach.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Simplify your search

      Compare plans tailored to your home & budget.

        Loading more reviews...

        Fidelity National Home Warranty Company Information

        Company Name:
        Fidelity National Home Warranty
        Address:
        1200 Concord Ave., Ste. 400
        City:
        Concord
        State/Province:
        CA
        Postal Code:
        94520
        Website:
        www.homewarranty.com
        Do you have questions about Fidelity National Home Warranty?