Best Home Warranties in Virginia

We compared 21 companies and chose the top home warranty providers

    • Cinch Home Services
      4.0(11,581)
    • Old Republic Home Protection
      4.0(1,606)
    • First American Home Warranty
      4.2(8,625)

    Best Home Warranties in Virginia

    If you’ve been thinking about getting home warranty coverage in Virginia but aren’t sure where to start, we can help. We’ve selected the top home warranty companies in the Old Dominion by analyzing customer reviews and ratings and comparing brands on availability, price, coverage and other factors.

    Read our full methodology below for all the details. Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us — this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations but may impact the order in which companies appear.

    Our editor’s top picks

    1. Value: American Home Shield
    2. Quick service: Choice Home Warranty
    3. Roof coverage: Select Home Warranty
    Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
    • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
    • 4,604,607 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

    Our top 5 Virginia home warranty picks

    Home warranties can help cover the costs of unexpected breakdowns of your major systems and appliances. Our research team has analyzed 26 different home warranty companies to find the best coverage for you. By comparing customer ratings and reviews, coverage limits, prices and available plans, our team chose four companies that offer the best plans for your money.

    2024 Buyers Choice Award Winner
    American Home Shield
    Number of plans
    3
    Service fees
    $100 or $125
    Starting costs
    $29.99

    American Home Shield’s home service contracts cover up to 24 appliances and systems, and you can personalize your policy with your choice of add-ons and service fee. You can file claims by phone or through the website. Repairs are backed by a 30-day workmanship guarantee.

    We’ve compared this company’s plans based on select coverage items below.

    Many reviewers in Virginia mention an easy claims process and quality technicians.

    Eugene from Woodbridge said about his experience, “They sent out techs for a couple of things and seemed to fix it right away. We paid a certain amount a month, and paid $90 every time we called and a contractor would come out. No big deal.”

    Corey from Chesapeake said he’d recommend American Home Shield: “They're legit. The user interface for their website is straightforward. The turnaround time is 48 to 72 hours. It depends on when the request goes in because weekends are a thing. Recently, Performance Mechanical came out to address our shower. It wasn't draining properly. The plumber looked at it, went to his truck to grab a thing and it was fine.”

    Some American Home Shield reviewers from Virginia mention delayed or ineffective repairs and a lack of communication from technicians.

    Eugene from Woodbridge (quoted above) was happy overall with the company, but he was unhappy when AHS raised his price: “[A] few years ago, the monthly price went up by $30 and the every time a contractor came out went up. A year later, both prices went up. So, we called another company, got a price and it was better. I don't know if they do as good a job or not, but I get offended when AHS raised my rate every year.”

    5x Award Winner
    Selected for having one of the highest satisfaction rates for Best Claims Handling, Best Coverage Options, Best Customer Service, Best Technicians and Best Value for Price
    Buyers Choice Award Finalist
    Choice Home Warranty
    Number of plans
    2
    Service fees
    $100
    Starting costs
    $46.83

    Choice Home Warranty has more than 15,000 trained contractors, and if a repair fails within 30 days, you don’t have to pay another service fee to have it corrected. The company also frequently offers discounts and promotions.

    We’ve compared this company’s home warranty plans based on select coverage items below.

    Many reviewers in Virginia mention being happy with the price and with the prompt and effective service from technicians.

    Kim from Fairfax said about her experience, “I requested to repair our air conditioner which wasn't working. The Choice Warranty Co had the Beltway Air Comfort HVAC Company to checked and the Choice company replaced the condenser. I really happy about what they have done. Very prompt, professional services. I highly recommend the Choice Home Warranty company.”

    Rosanne from Fredericksburg said, “The technician came at a convenient time. I really did appreciate that he took the time to communicate with me a schedule that fits me most. He did his job diligently as well as took the initiative to even clean out the mess within the unit. Despite a not so pleasant entrance way to the unit he didn't complain. He worked quick and professionally.”

    Some reviewers in Virginia mention delays in receiving reimbursements, difficulty in getting claims approved and poor customer service.

    Monica from Hampton said about her experience, “I filed a claim and was told nothing covered..Upon purchasing this warranty I was told everything is covered with air conditioning so I have appt with case manager tomorrow..So right now I'm very upset. I hope we can resolve this issue. I would like to tell my friends and relatives about your company. So hopefully I will get some clarity with the case manager.”

    Select Home Warranty
    Number of plans
    3
    Service fees
    $60 or $75
    Starting costs
    $60.42

    Select Home Warranty sells home service plans for a variety of home types, including single-family homes, manufactured homes, mobile homes, rental properties and multiunit buildings. Select doesn’t limit the number of covered repairs you can get as long as the appliances are properly maintained. If you stay on for multiple years of coverage, you may qualify for a discount.

    We’ve compared this company’s plans based on select coverage items below.

    Virginians are fond of Select Home Warranty’s service, and multiple reviews specifically mention satisfaction with the company’s long-term coverage.

    Kamna from Manassas wrote, “It was very helpful to work with Jeff ** and getting a very warranty for 5 years. He did assist us with the understanding of the monthly vs yearly warranty and the discounts received. We have been having issues with our current Home warranty company so hoping to have a much better warranty with Select Home Warranty.”

    Alexis from Newport News shared similar sentiments about the long-term coverage: "Great service! I was able to communicate what type of coverage I was looking for and the Select was able to get me a awesome rate. Went with the coverage for 5 years and love that it's transferable to next house!"

    Some Select Home Warranty customers in Virginia have cited issues with claims being denied or delayed, and some mention frustration with having to pay out of pocket for repairs. Keep in mind that, with any home warranty, it’s crucial to have a solid understanding of your coverage (and any fine print).

    Hossein from Haymarket said, “Select Home Warranty is great until you put your first claim and then you find out their sevice is a joke, actually there is no service, you almost have to pay for all the repair cost on top of a flat claim fee. I found this out after paying them for 18 months with not even one service claim and when after 18 months, I put my first claim (and it was for a very simple and cheap repair) they told me they just pay for parts (that was less than $10 and I have to pay for labor cost $175).”

    2024 Buyers Choice Award Winner
    Cinch Home Services
    Number of plans
    3
    Service fees
    $100, $125 or $150
    Starting costs
    $38.99

    Cinch Home Services offers three home warranty plans, but what sets the company apart is its coverage for items not normally included in home warranties, like unknown preexisting conditions, rust and corrosion. Since its founding, Cinch has serviced more than 1 million claims nationwide, and all repairs are guaranteed for 180 days.

    We’ve compared this company’s plans based on select coverage items below.

    Reviews for Cinch Home Services are generally positive. Reviewers in Virginia mention their happiness with the company and the technicians it sends to fix their issues.

    Michael from Midlothian wrote, “We got some service recently with Cinch and it was very smooth. They got connected to the local people fairly promptly and the service was done well. The techs were very good. … Cinch is good quality for the money. Things will break down and people might as well be ready for it.”

    Frank from Virginia Beach was similarly pleased: “We've had Cinch Home for a long time and we've never had a bad experience with anybody they sent. They've all seemed very good.

    Some Cinch reviewers in Virginia have had issues with long wait times, difficulty reaching customer service and delays in getting repairs done.

    D from Henrico said about his experience, “I call every year for the same problem and they put a bandaid on it and keep charging a deductible. If they don’t fix it this time, I am canceling!”

    4x Award Winner
    Selected for having one of the highest satisfaction rates for Best Claims Handling, Best Coverage Options, Best Technicians and Best Value for Price
    Buyers Choice Award Finalist
    HomeServe
    Number of plans
    17
    Service fees
    $0
    Starting costs
    $3.99

    HomeServe offers coverage for a variety of home systems and appliances, including multiple plans with smaller coverage lists in case you want to protect only certain parts of your home. Plans do not require proof of home inspection, and there are no age-based restrictions on covered items.

    HomeServe has also partnered with Dominion Energy Inc. to offer eligible customers a variety of home service plans not otherwise available in certain areas.

    With HomeServe, you gain access to a network of over 12,000 licensed technicians and contractors. HomeServe also has its own app for plan and claim management. All repairs are guaranteed for an entire year.

    We’ve compared some of this company’s plans based on select coverage items below, but it’s worth noting that this is only a sample of HomeServe’s offerings.

    Reviewers from Virginia like HomeServe, and its specialty plans may be a great solution if you’re only worried about a specific part of your home breaking down.

    Agaither from Chesapeake wrote, “The experience has been fine submitting a claim with HomeServe. The process is easy. Whenever we have a problem at the house, I just call them. If it’s covered, they send someone out. So far, the quality of the contractors has been good. I never had an issue with anyone. I also didn't have to call them back behind something they didn't do.”

    “Plumbing came out very fast because Home Serve mark my appointment was urgent,” reported Steve from Hampton. “I wish I known about home serve years ago. You could save tons of cash getting expensive things repair in emergencies situation.”

    Vera from Richmond wasn’t happy with the company: “I have had a 'Contract' with this company more than ten (10) years, requiring very little service. When I needed them most they had an excuse ' Unfortunately' and then the 'Bull' started!!! Home serve is a partner of 'Dominion Power' who encourage 'Seniors to enroll in this 'program' and pay a dear price, only to find 'Excuses' when there is a 'Request for Service'. I am going to continue to address this matter until there is a 'FAIR RESOLVE'...Dominion Power will get 'feedback' also.”

    Compare top Virginia home warranty companies

    Sort
    • Best Rated
    • Most Reviewed
    • Highest Rated

    Simplify your search

    Compare plans tailored to your home & budget.

      Home Warranties in Virginia Buyers guide

      Jump into our guides and start learning

      Top Picks

      See who reviewers like

      Cinch Home Services logo
      Old Republic Home Protection logo
      First American Home Warranty logo
      See our top picks

      Simplify your search

      Compare plans tailored to your home & budget.

        richmond virginia skyline

        How to find the best home warranty in Virginia

        In Virginia, most home warranties include a list of coverage items, but some also allow for more customization. You can save a lot of time and money down the road by choosing a less expensive plan that only covers the things that are absolutely crucial to you and your home. However, this kind of limited coverage may be less than helpful over the long term. It’s hard to predict what will go wrong in your home, and a home warranty with the wrong coverage isn’t of much use.

        Pool coverage is almost always an add-on option if it’s available.

        Some home warranty companies in Virginia also cap how much they’re willing to pay for a claim, which can be an issue if repairs add up quickly. For example, if you live in an expensive city like Great Falls or McLean, you might want to find a plan that offers higher coverage limits.

        Virginia also has all types of weather, ranging from hot and humid summers to cool and dry winters. As such, your home needs to be able to withstand the changing seasons. Environmental systems, like heating and air conditioning, can break down when overworked, so it’s a good idea to make sure those systems are covered.

        Many Virginians also deal with water problems in their home, especially in coastal cities like Norfolk and Hampton. While a home warranty won’t keep you from paying to fix flood or storm damage (that’s what insurance is for), you may want warranty coverage for your sump pump or roof if you expect recurring issues with water intrusion.

        Home warranty regulations in Virginia

        In Virginia, home warranty companies are regulated by the Office of Charitable and Regulatory Programs (OCRP), which is part of the Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (VDACS). Many other states put their respective departments of insurance in charge of these regulations.

        Here are two regulations to keep in mind regarding home warranties in Virginia:

        • All home warranty companies in Virginia must be registered prior to offering service, and for added support and oversight, these companies are required to re-register every year by July 1.
        • Home warranty companies in Virginia are also required to hold aside a certain amount of money in a corporate surety to help demonstrate financial responsibility.

        If you end up having an issue with your home warranty provider that you can’t resolve, consider filling out a report with the OCRP for help.

        » MORE: Does a home warranty cover pest control?

        FAQ

        How much does a home warranty cost in Virginia?

        The average cost of a home warranty from one of our top picks in Virginia is about $30 to $90 per month.

        Your cost depends on the company, coverage and add-ons you choose. Some companies also let you choose a different service fee to adjust your monthly rate. That means you can sometimes choose a higher service fee in exchange for a lower monthly or annual cost. Depending on your situation, this may make sense, but if you expect to call for a lot of service, you may want to keep your service fee lower.

        Is a home warranty worth it in Virginia?

        The true value of a home warranty depends on how you end up using it, and that can be hard to predict when you’re shopping for a plan. In some cases, you might end up spending more on the plan itself than you save on repairs. In other cases, you might make up the cost of your warranty with one service visit. It’s also hard to put a number to the peace of mind and stability warranty coverage provides even when you’re not actively making claims.

        To get more value out of your home warranty, shop around to make sure you’re getting a good deal on your plan, and choose the right coverage for your needs.

        What is not covered by a home warranty?

        It depends on the plan you choose.

        Many home warranties don’t cover items that aren’t properly maintained, and some don’t include full coverage for high-cost items, like your HVAC system. Secondary damage, like that from flooding caused by a broken dishwasher, often won’t be covered even if the dishwasher is. Generally speaking, home warranties don’t cover the same situations as homeowners insurance, either.

        It’s critical that you read your contract (especially the exclusions and limitations sections) to understand what your home warranty covers and to what extent.

        What’s the difference between a home warranty and homeowners insurance?

        Home warranties and home insurance policies are two distinct forms of protection. Homeowners insurance is required by mortgage lenders and covers damage to your home and belongings due to events like fires, storms or theft.

        A home warranty, on the other hand, is optional and covers repairs or replacements for appliances and systems that break down due to normal wear and tear.

        » COMPARE:Home warranty vs. home insurance

        Methodology

        ConsumerAffairs carefully collects in-depth, verified reviews to tell each customer’s experience with a company. We believe customer experiences are a crucial indicator when evaluating companies, so these reviews are a significant factor when we make our top picks.

        To choose the top home warranty companies in Virginia, we started with the 26 popular providers listed in our main home warranty guide. First, we narrowed it down to the ones available in Virginia. We then weighted several key features to get our final rankings:

        • Coverage options: We broke down each company’s home warranty plans to ensure they offer multiple coverage options to fit a variety of needs.
        • Plan flexibility: Customizing a plan can tailor it to your needs and help you save money so you don’t pay for coverage you don’t need. We checked to see what customization options each company offers, including the ability to select a service fee and the number and cost of add-on coverages.
        • Cost: Costs for home warranty plans vary based on the size of the home and the type of coverage, but we confirmed our top picks’ prices are competitive in the home warranty industry.
        • Service call fee: We looked at the service fee each company charged to send a technician to your house to ensure our top picks are in line with industry standards.

        Bottom line

        Virginia has some quirks when it comes to buying a home warranty, but overall, the process in the Old Dominion is much like it is anywhere else. To learn more about home warranty companies, check out our home warranty buyers guide or our article on home warranty coverage.


        Guide sources
        ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work.

        Not sure how to choose?

        Get buying tips about Home Warranties in Virginia delivered to your inbox.

          By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

          Thanks for subscribing.

          You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

          Compare top Virginia home warranty companies