American Van Lines

- Deposit
- 50%
- Local moves
- Limited
- Long-distance moves
- Yes
- USDOT #
- 614506



Based on verified reviews from local customers, American Van Lines is the best moving company in Columbus. PODS is a good choice if you want a lower-cost, do-it-yourself option with flexible timing. Agility Van Lines is a strong fit if responsive communication matters most to you.
To help you find the best options, we compared moving companies available in Columbus. Then we analyzed ratings and reviews on ConsumerAffairs from Columbus customers.
To make our picks, we also considered pricing, the quote and deposit processes and the availability of packing services and storage options. Read our full methodology below for all the details. Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us — this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations.
| Company | Customer rating | Our pick for | Carrier vs. broker | Local moves | Long-distance moves | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() American Van Lines | Get a Quote | 4.2
2,726 reviews
2,726 reviews
| Best overall | Carrier | ||
![]() PODS | Learn More | 4.6
5,347 reviews
5,347 reviews
| Value | Container company | ||
![]() Agility Van Lines | Learn More | 5.0
137 reviews
137 reviews
| Customer service | Carrier | ||
![]() Colonial Van Lines | Get a Quote | 4.4
2,976 reviews
2,976 reviews
| Quote accuracy | Carrier |
Learn more about our top picks for the best moving companies, based on verified reviews from Columbus area customers and broader Ohio feedback on ConsumerAffairs.




» MORE: Top moving companies in Ohio
Jump into our guides and start learning
As Columbus expands, navigating the mix of historic districts like German Village and sprawling outerbelts requires careful planning. Brick streets in older neighborhoods can rattle items in the truck, so professional packing is essential. We'll help you find a mover equipped to deal with these unique road conditions.
Movers operating within Ohio borders must be registered with the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO). You can verify their certificate status on the PUCO website.
Jump to insightOhio allows for binding estimates, which is a huge advantage. Try to lock in a flat price to avoid paying extra if the truck gets stuck in stadium game-day traffic.
Jump to insightIf you’re moving into a historic district, check for tree clearance. Low-hanging branches in Victorian Village often prevent large box trucks from parking directly in front of homes.
Jump to insightChoosing a mover in Columbus starts with getting specific about your needs, then checking that each company is properly licensed for the type of move you’re booking. From there, compare at least three written estimates and read independent feedback so you can spot patterns like surprise charges, frequent delays or damage claims.
Hiring the right moving company can be one of the biggest line items in your relocation budget, so it pays to slow down and vet options carefully. Use these steps to compare movers in a way that protects both your schedule and your wallet:
Start by clarifying what kind of move you’re planning. Is it a local move within Columbus, a move to another Ohio city or a long-distance relocation out of state? Decide whether you want a full-service team to pack and handle everything or if you only need transport.
This decision changes which companies make sense and how pricing is calculated. Full-service movers cost more, but it can be worth it if you have fragile items, limited time or tricky access like narrow streets and tight staircases. Self-service and labor-only options reduce the bill, but you take on more work and more coordination.
Begin with referrals from people you trust, then validate those recommendations with third-party sources and online reviews from customers in Columbus. The most common complaints about moving companies we see on ConsumerAffairs include:
Jordan in Columbus was frustrated with the inconsistent pricing information they received, saying, “I was informed a 75 dollar fee at pick up then it turned into 300 at drop off.” To make matters worse, the delivery was then delayed over two weeks: “I was informed the drop off would be 2/3/25. The drop off ended up being 2/21/25.”
You can also browse reviews from ConsumerAffairs customers to compare moving companies side by side and get a clearer sense of how each one handles issues when something goes wrong.
Get estimates from at least three movers and insist on written documentation that lists what’s included. In-home surveys are often the most accurate since the estimator can see the true volume of belongings and assess access issues like elevators, long carries or limited street parking. Virtual surveys can also be effective if you walk through them thoroughly.
When you compare quotes, look beyond the price. Check whether packing materials are included, how labor is billed and what triggers extra fees. If one bid is dramatically lower than the rest, treat it as a warning sign that something is missing or that the estimate is designed to change later.
Secure a parking permit if moving to German Village or Short North.
Many moves in Columbus need add-ons that change the total price. Ask for clear pricing on packing and unpacking, specialty items like pianos or antiques, temporary storage and fees tied to challenging access. Historic districts and dense areas can require shuttles or smaller trucks, which should be disclosed upfront.
If you’re moving during peak leasing turnover in Short North, ask about guaranteed arrival windows. Getting these details in advance helps you build a budget for your move and reduces the chance of last-minute decisions under pressure.
Any mover you hire should be insured and properly licensed for the move you’re booking. For interstate moves, confirm it has a valid USDOT number through the FMCSA database.
For in-state moves in Ohio, verify registration and understand the valuation coverage included in your contract. Also ask how claims are filed, what documentation is required and how quickly the company resolves damage issues.
Moving prices can run from a few hundred dollars for a small local move to several thousand for a long-distance relocation, depending on the distance, volume and how much labor you outsource.
Key pricing drivers include:
Local crews typically charge $110 to $150 per hour. Most companies also charge a fuel surcharge or a one-hour travel fee. If you’re moving during the academic year, availability drops due to the massive student population.
Tipping is optional, but it’s common when the crew is careful, efficient and professional. For local moves, a decent moving tip is about $20 to $50 per mover. For long-distance moves, you can tip more or base it on a small percentage of the total if the service was excellent.
If you prefer not to tip cash, offering water, sports drinks and quick snacks can still go a long way on a physically demanding day.
» COMPARE: Top-rated movers in the US
Avoid moving on OSU home game days to dodge gridlock.
Any legitimate mover should be licensed and insured. If your move crosses state lines, the mover must be registered with the U.S. Department of Transportation and have an active USDOT number (verify through the FMCSA database).
The PUCO sets the rules for intrastate moves, and movers must offer you a booklet on your rights and responsibilities. Damage claims must be filed in writing within 60 days of delivery, which is shorter than in some other states.
Moving within or to Ohio?
We’ve got some resources for you:
Yes. Compare multiple bids, then ask about off-peak dates, weekday pricing and discounts for groups like seniors or military members. Bundling services like packing plus storage can also reduce the total.
Avoid any company that refuses written estimates, can’t prove licensing and insurance, frequently changes contacts or pressures you to pay quickly without answering questions.
Winter is usually the least expensive time to move in Columbus, though the weather can slow things down. Mid-month is often cheaper than the first or last weekend when student moves and lease turnover surges.
Basic coverage is included, but since it is often limited to just $0.60 per pound, a broken 50-pound TV would only result in a $30 payout regardless of its actual value. To protect high-value belongings against this weight-based valuation, ask your moving company about purchasing full-value replacement insurance.
To select our top moving companies, we start with reputable movers available in Columbus, then rank them based on how they actually perform in your area.
We score each company by combining:
This way, companies with strong national reputations are judged on their actual local performance.
We gather customer feedback in layers to make sure we have enough information to rank companies fairly:
The more reviews we have, the more confident we are in the ranking. If lots of companies have reviews in a city, we prioritize them over companies that lack local reviews.
We make sure our top picks are actually active in your area. Companies with solid local reviews rank higher than those relying only on national reputation, even if they perform well nationally.
We analyze customer reviews for:
We also research what pricing and services each company offers, including:
ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work. Specific sources for this guide include:
Thanks for subscribing.
You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
| Company | Customer rating | About | Learn More |
|---|---|---|---|
American Van Lines
| 4.2
2,726 reviews
| Offers long-distance, military, commercial and corporate moving services. No extra charges for last-minute moves. Requires a significant deposit to reserve a move. Cross-country moves typically cost from $2,000 to $5,000. | Get a Quote |
PODS
| 4.6
5,347 reviews
| Provides residential and commercial moving and storage solutions. Offers various container sizes. Local moves tend to cost about $500. Most long-distance moves cost between $1,000 and $3,000. Month-to-month pod rental. | Read reviews |
Agility Van Lines
| 5.0
137 reviews
| Full-service moving company. Does not partner with third parties. Does not use warehouses unless customer wants storage. Offers moving service in 18 states in Midwest and on East Coast. | Read reviews |
Colonial Van Lines
| 4.4
2,976 reviews
| Tailored moving services. Professional, experienced movers. Commitment to customer satisfaction, transparent pricing and a track record of reliable service. Moves out of state. Backed by years of expertise. | Get a Quote |
International Van Lines
| 4.8
1,429 reviews
| Licensed moving company that offers local, long-distance and international moves. Services available by van, freight, air and ocean. Works in the entire U.S. and more than 180 countries. Free moving quotes available. | Get a Quote |
U-Pack
| 4.9
31 reviews
| Provides movable storage boxes you pack and unload yourself. Handles moves of at least 100 miles. Offers free quotes and flexible storage options. Does not offer services for local moves. Typical moves cost from $500 to $2,500. | Read reviews |
AmeriSafe Van Lines
| 4.5
1,203 reviews
| Carrier moving services. Offers long-distance moves nationwide, including Alaska and Hawaii. Works with residential and commercial customers. Offers packing services as well as long and short-term storage. Provides free quotes. | Get a Quote |
Interstate Moving & Relocation Group
| 4.7
505 reviews
| Licensed moving broker. Offers long-distance and military moves, auto transport and packing services. Free quotes. Works with authorized carriers. Available across the U.S. Online payments. | Get a Quote |
Perennial Van Lines
| 4.7
112 reviews
| A brokerage company that arranges transportation for your move. Offers auto transport, packing and storage services. Not available in all states. Serves some states only partially. Free quote online or by phone. | Read reviews |
America First Moving
| 4.5
292 reviews
| Long-distance, long-haul moving services. Licensed and insured moving broker. 24/7 customer support. Partner network of carriers across U.S. Online quotes. Quoted price is 100% binding. Packing and unpacking services. | Get a Quote |
iMoving.com
| 4.4
145 reviews
| Offers local, long-distance, international and commercial moving services. Local moves cost $150 to $900. Most interstate moves cost $1,000 to $4,000. Storage services, auto transport and specialty packing services available. | Get a Quote |
New Start Relocation
| 3.9
1,121 reviews
| Offers storage and local, long-distance and office moving services from its location in Boynton Beach, Florida. Hires carriers for moves and provides a team of moving professionals. | Read reviews |
Moving APT
| 3.4
259 reviews
| Broker that specializes in interstate moves for residential and commercial customers. Handles moves of all sizes. Packing services available. Free quotes include tolls, taxes, fuel and all other fees. | Read reviews |
Allied Van Lines
| 3.0
844 reviews
| Over 95 years in service. Cross-country and long-distance moves. Offers a variety of packing, moving and storage services. Vehicle shipping. Covers all 50 states and international moves. | Read reviews |
Safebound Moving & Storage
| 3.1
287 reviews
| Specializes in long-distance moves. Charges around $2,500 for a cross-country move. Full packing and unpacking services. Short- and long-term storage options available. Provides a dedicated moving coordinator. Military discounts. | Read reviews |
United Regions Van Lines
| 3.0
824 reviews
| Offers long-distance moving and corporate relocation services. Packing services and storage available. Serves the continental U.S. Charges between $2,500 and $5,000 for a two-bedroom move from Philadelphia to Kansas City. | Read reviews |
North American Van Lines
| 2.8
521 reviews
| Over 90 years in service. Cross-country and long-distance moves. Offers a variety of packing, moving and storage services. Vehicle shipping. Covers all 50 states and international moves. | Read reviews |
24/7 Logistic Services
| 2.3
289 reviews
| Specializes in moves for corporations, military personnel and seniors. Charges from $2,000 to $5,000 for long-distance moves. Provides door-to-door relocation options. Offers furniture assembly and protection. | Read reviews |
Van Lines Inc.
| 2.3
194 reviews
| National mover licensed in all 50 states. Provides a single point of contact for support on all moves. Offers multiple services, including white-glove delivery, antique moving and motorcycle moving. Rents storage units. | Read reviews |
Alltrust Moving & Storage
| 2.3
139 reviews
| Miami moving and storage company. Local, long-distance and corporate moving services available. Optional storage services at its secure storage facility. Prices start at $435 for a three-hour local move. | Read reviews |
JK Moving Services
| 2.1
58 reviews
| Transports locally, long-distance and internationally. Offers residential and commercial moving. Also offers storage and archive services. Uses sustainable practices. Offers 24-hour customer support and mobile app. | Read reviews |
Penske Truck Rental
| 1.9
348 reviews
| Rents 12- to 26-feet-long moving trucks. Sells packing materials. Free unlimited mileage on one-way trips. Discounts for AAA members and other programs. Minimum rental periods apply. A move from Houston to Dallas costs about $202. | Read reviews |
Mayzlin Relocation
| 1.9
220 reviews
| Moving company based in North Carolina. Offers local, long-distance, commercial and military moving services. Packing and storage options are available. Provides a free quote with no hidden costs. Available 24/7. | Read reviews |
Mayflower
| 1.9
239 reviews
| Provides moving services for all types of households. Performs local, long-distance and international moves as well as military and government relocations. Add-on packages start at $195. | Get a Quote |
Bellhop
| 1.5
290 reviews
| Matches clients with moving service providers. Local and long-distance moving in 28 states. Provides tailored packages. Offers hourly labor for loading and unloading. Sells packing supply kits. Offers a tracking app. | Read reviews |
U-Haul
| 1.3
1,335 reviews
| Offers container shipping, storage, moving tools, packing supplies and hitches. Rental options include pickups and 26-foot trucks. Serves the U.S. and Canada. Hourly and per-mile fees. Local moves cost as little as $19.95 a day. | Read reviews |
Budget Truck Rental
| 1.1
953 reviews
| Rents out moving trucks and accessories for residential and commercial moves. Offers packing, loading and unloading assistance. Sells packing supplies. Available nationwide. Provides discounts for students, vets and older adults. | Read reviews |