American Home Shield

- Plans available
- ShieldSilver, ShieldGold and ShieldPlatinum
- Monthly premium range
- $29.99 to $89.99
- Service fees
- $100 or $125
- Labor guarantee
- 30 days



American Home Shield is our recommendation for the best home warranty company in Ohio, thanks to strong coverage for major home systems and positive local reviews. When a furnace or boiler fails at the wrong time (like during a January cold snap), a home warranty can help you avoid a steep repair bill and get service scheduled quickly.
Home warranties can also help with everyday breakdowns for items like water heaters, garage door openers and ovens. In Ohio, plans typically run from $19.99 to $99.99 per month.
American Home Shield is our top choice in Ohio because its heating coverage is built for cold-weather wear and tear.
Jump to insightOhio homeowners pay an average of $61.69 per month for a home warranty, with quotes ranging from $240 to $1,200 annually, depending on the plan and provider.
Jump to insightGiven how punishing Ohio winters can be, it's smart to prioritize a home warranty with high furnace and boiler limits — not just the lowest monthly premium.
Jump to insightOur research team vetted home warranty companies that are rated by hundreds of customers in Ohio. Read our guide to choose the best home warranty in Ohio for you by comparing plans, contract lengths and service fees.
Read our full methodology below for all the details. Our picks may be Authorized Partners that compensate us, but this does not affect our recommendations or evaluations.
| Company | Customer rating | Our pick for | Monthly starting cost | Service fee(s) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
![]() American Home Shield | Get a Quote | 3.7
110,003 reviews
110,003 reviews
| Best overall | $29.99 | $100 or $125 |
![]() First American Home Warranty | Get a Quote | 4.0
8,915 reviews
8,915 reviews
| Furnace coverage | $42 | $100 or $125 |
![]() Choice Home Warranty | Get a Quote | 4.0
74,118 reviews
74,118 reviews
| Claims handling | $46.83 | $100 |
![]() Cinch Home Services | Learn More | 4.1
12,301 reviews
12,301 reviews
| Value | $38.99 | $100, $125 or $150 |
Learn more about our top picks for the best home warranty companies, based on real, recent reviews from customers in Ohio on ConsumerAffairs.




Jump into our guides and start learning
Homeowners in Ohio often face furnace breakdowns in winter, AC issues in summer and plumbing or electrical failures in aging homes. A home warranty can lower repair costs and provide added security against expensive fixes.
In Ohio, focus on heating, cooling and plumbing coverage to handle seasonal extremes and older housing.
Jump to insightIn Ohio, the average home warranty costs $61.69 per month. Depending on your plan, annual premiums range from $240 to $1,200. Service fees are usually $75–$150 per visit.
Jump to insightHome warranty companies in Ohio are regulated by the attorney general’s office.
Jump to insightWhen choosing a home warranty in Ohio, look for coverage that balances protection across multiple systems. Here's a step-by-step process for picking the best home warranty plan:
However, you might not always get a full reimbursement, as Roberta from Cleveland found out: "The reimbursement didn't cover the cost of a new refrigerator that would fit under my cabinets. The one that fit cost almost double what I received, which was disappointing."
"I contacted them online, which is my usual method. Within just five minutes, they called back with an appointment. Impressively, a technician from Foxcroft arrived about two hours later to address the issue."
"They covered very little of my furnace. They only covered $3,000 of the furnace. I had to finance $10,000."
A home warranty in Ohio costs $61.69 per month on average. Home warranty premiums generally range from $19.99 to $99.99 per month, depending on the plan. The average cost of a home warranty in Ohio is 8.8% lower than the national average.
We received quotes for each of our top picks in Ohio for a three-bed, two-bath home in Columbus.
| Provider | Monthly premium range* | Service call fee |
![]() | $39.99 to $99.99 | $100 or $125 |
![]() | $51.69 to $91.69 | $100 or $125 |
![]() | $46.83 to $54.75 | $100 |
![]() | $19.99 to $79.99 | $100, $125 or $150 |
![]() | $39.99 to $99.99 | $100 or $125 |
![]() | $37 to $72 | $100 or $125 |
![]() | $46.83 to $54.75 | $100 |
![]() | $19.99 to $79.99 | $100, $125 or $150 |
*Data updated January 2026
Most companies give you the choice to pay monthly or annually. Spreading payments out month by month helps with budgeting, while paying annually could net you a discount.
A service call fee is charged every time you make a claim and a technician is sent to your home. Fees generally range from $50 to $150 for each visit, depending on your selected plan and location.
Customizing your plan with optional add-ons is common and can range from $2 to $25 per month per item. This is especially helpful if you have a pool, sump pump or other unique systems.
Several factors go into your final price:
Example: total annual home warranty costs
- Comprehensive coverage ($60 per month): $720 per year
- Add-on for roof leak repair ($10 per month): $120 per year
- Three claims ($100 service fee): $300
- Total: $1,140 per year
Ohio home warranty providers usually offer three kinds of coverage: appliance plans, systems plans and combination plans. Appliance plans typically protect your kitchen and laundry machines, while systems plans focus on things like heating, plumbing and electrical. Combo plans bundle both for maximum peace of mind.
You can often add extra protection for pools, electronics, roof leaks and more, depending on the provider.
Pat in Lewis Center was only five months into coverage when two everyday breakdowns hit back-to-back. “So far I’ve filed 2 simple claims; my dishwasher wasn’t draining and my disposal had stopped working.” With the repairs handled fast and service fees predictable, the monthly cost felt like money well spent.
Key takeaway: Simple claims and predictable monthly fees are far better than surprise repair bills
Sheila in Columbus had a smooth start when her microwave failed. She notes, "It was relatively easy to submit a claim and get the appointment set." The frustration came after approval, when replacement meant waiting: "I have to wait up to 30 days to receive the gift card," delaying the real solution.
Key takeaway: Claims are often easy, but replacement payout can take a while
Brian in Parma just needed his fridge running again, fast. “There was a lack of clear communication regarding what to expect, and I found myself without a working refrigerator for three weeks.” He praises the technician’s great work but says the claims timeline and uncertainty made an essential repair feel like a grind.
Key takeaway: Great techs cannot fix a slow, unclear claims process
The Ohio attorney general's office governs home warranty companies in Ohio. Though there are laws that determine what a home warranty is in the state, there are no specific regulations.
If you think something isn't quite right with a home warranty company, reach out to the Ohio attorney general's office at 800-282-0515 or visit the attorney general's website. The office also has some helpful information for purchasing a service contract in Ohio.
A home warranty can give you peace of mind, especially if the cost of unexpected repairs or replacements of major appliances and systems would strain your budget. The decision to purchase this type of coverage depends on factors like your financial situation, the age and condition of your home's appliances and systems and your personal risk tolerance.
» MORE: Is a home warranty worth it?
Home warranties and home insurance policies are two distinct forms of protection. Homeowners insurance is required by mortgage lenders and covers damage to your home and belongings due to events like fires, storms or theft.
A home warranty, on the other hand, is optional and covers repairs or replacements for appliances and systems that break down due to normal wear and tear.
» COMPARE: Home warranty vs. home insurance
The ConsumerAffairs Research Team used a data-backed process informed by expert editorial judgment and verified customer reviews. We started with home warranty companies available in Ohio, then evaluated which performed best for local residents.
Here's how we scored each company:
Note: Each superlative emphasizes certain factors more than others. For example, the "Best value" superlative weights cost at 20%, while "Best claims handling" gives more weight to reviews that mention the claims process and customer service.
ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work. Specific sources for this guide include:
Thanks for subscribing.
You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
| Company | Customer rating | About | Learn More |
|---|---|---|---|
American Home Shield
| 3.7
110,003 reviews
| Three home warranty plans in 48 states. Unavailable in Alaska or Hawaii. Plans start at $29.99/month with a $125 service fee. No coverage limits on systems; up to $6,000 on appliances. | Get a Quote |
First American Home Warranty
| 4.0
8,915 reviews
| Offers three appliance and system combination plans. Monthly costs range from $42 per month to $82 per month, with a deductible of $85. Add-on coverage is available. | Get a Quote |
Choice Home Warranty
| 4.0
74,118 reviews
| Offers two plans with basic or comprehensive coverage. Plans start at $46.67 per month with an $85 service call fee. Optional coverage for limited roof leaks, pools and spas available. Make a claim online 24/7. | Get a Quote |
Cinch Home Services
| 4.1
12,301 reviews
| Offers system, appliance and combination home warranty plans. Service fees start at $100. Monthly fees range from $34.99 to $61.99. All work backed by a 180-day guarantee. Not available in all states. | Read reviews |
Prestige Home Guard
| 5.0
6 reviews
| Home warranty plans starting at $29.99/month with $100 service fee. Available throughout the U.S. Fast claims processing. Contractor network to complete repairs. $5,000 coverage limit on most items. | Read reviews |
Liberty Home Guard
| 4.4
1,508 reviews
| Coverage starts at $1 a day. Customizable plans. Extensive technician network. Additional property discounts. Set per-claim fees. 60-day workmanship guarantee. Offers month-to-month coverage and longer-term plans. | Get a Quote |
HomeSafe
| 4.3
515 reviews
| Customizes home warranty plans in most states. Plans start 20 days after signing. Offers ability to choose own licensed service technician. Can submit claims via phone or online. Does not cover roof leaks. | Get a Quote |
ARW Home
| 4.4
2,815 reviews
| Flexible and affordable plans for home systems and appliances. Add-on coverage for water/sewer and electronics. 15,000+ local licensed technicians serve nationwide. File a claim and request service 24/7/365 online or by phone. | Get a Quote |
Old Republic Home Protection
| 3.9
2,138 reviews
| Offers home warranties designed for real estate professionals in the home selling process. Costs vary by state but expect to pay around $600 to $700 per year for Platinum coverage. Deductible averages $75. | Read reviews |
Regency Total Warranty
| 3.9
1,068 reviews
| Multiple home warranty plans. Coverage for home systems and appliances. Optional add-on coverage. Online and phone claim filing. Pricing starts at $39.99 per month. Discounted rate for annual payment. Available nationwide. | Read reviews |
Select Home Warranty
| 3.5
16,021 reviews
| Appliance, system and combination plans available. Plans start at around $60 a month. Roof coverage included for some plans. Special promotions include free extra months on your contract and annual pay discounts. | Get a Quote |
Achosa Home Warranty
| 2.1
7 reviews
| Established in 2018. Serves 26 states. Coverage includes plumbing, electrical, roof leaks and major appliances. Each claim has a $100 service fee. Allows customers to choose their own licensed contractor. | Read reviews |
First Premier Home Warranty
| 1.9
635 reviews
| Provides appliance and systems warranty coverage. Available throughout the U.S. Customizable plans. Submit claims online or by phone anytime. Technicians arrive in 24 to 48 hours. Portable warranty plans. | Get a Quote |
HomeServe
| 1.6
2,071 reviews
| A la carte options for customized coverage. Local, licensed technicians complete repairs. Guarantees repairs for one year. 24/7 claims hotline. Appliance coverage is available. Plans start at $7.99 a month. | Read reviews |
GE Service Contracts
| 1.3
340 reviews
| Offers in-home service for repairs of qualifying appliances. The Service Protection Advantage plan, which provides extended warranties for any GE appliances, is provided through Assurant, Inc. | Read reviews |
ServicePlus Home Warranty
| 1.4
1,949 reviews
| Offers two plans covering select systems and appliances. Costs start at $87.42, with a standard service call fee of $75. Coverage options vary by location. Add-on coverage is also available. | Read reviews |
America's Preferred Home Warranty
| 1.4
12 reviews
| Serves all of the United States except California. Offers 24/7 365 access to customer service. Service calls have a $50 or $100 deductible. Options to choose a local contractor or technician. | Read reviews |
Sears Home Services
| 1.1
392 reviews
| Technicians have an average of 10 years of experience. Available in all 50 states. 25% discount on noncovered appliances and HVAC repairs. Covers systems and appliances regardless of age, make or model. 30-day wait for repairs. | Read reviews |
2-10 Home Buyers Warranty
| 1.2
6,723 reviews
| Offers simple home warranty plans. Pricing is about average. Plan choice is straightforward. Optional add-ons allow for plan customization. Plan agreements are easy to understand. Claims are handled by an online portal. | Read reviews |
Elite Home Warranty
| 1.1
110 reviews
| Three base home warranty plans for appliances and systems. 12-month contract term. Licensed and insured technicians. 30-day waiting period before coverage starts. Older appliances covered. 90-day workmanship warranty. | Read reviews |
Home Warranty of America
| 1.1
4,028 reviews
| Offers two combination plans that cover more than 20 systems and appliances. Pricing starts at $48.33 with deductibles of $75 and $100. Drywall, doorbell and burglar and fire alarms are included in coverage. | Read reviews |
HSA Home Warranty
| 1.1
316 reviews
| Basic coverage includes systems and appliances with monthly costs averaging about $40 per month. Select 7-Star Upgrade coverage or optional add-ons to customize your coverage. Deductibles range between $75 and $100. | Read reviews |
Super
| 1.0
430 reviews
| Offers coverage for both repairs and maintenance. Three levels of service range in cost from $47 per month to $107 per month. Covers major appliances, systems and maintenance for lawn, cleaning, pest control and more. | Read reviews |
The Home Service Club
| 1.0
817 reviews
| Choose from two plans to cover systems and appliances. Available add-ons include roof coverage. Premiums vary by state, but expect to pay about $50 per month for standard coverage, with deductibles from $65 to $125. | Read reviews |
Frontdoor
| 1.2
25 reviews
| Free app offers one live chat session with experts. Free how-to maintenance articles available. Frontdoor Basic, Prime and Premium membership plans. App available nationwide. Frontdoor Premium plan available in select locations. | Read reviews |
AFC Home Warranty
| 1.0
2,278 reviews
| Available in 47 states and Washington, D.C. Guarantees repairs for duration of contract. Covers up to 18 systems and appliances, including electronics like smartphones. Low coverage caps on some systems and appliances. | Read reviews |
American Home Protect
| 1.0
136 reviews
| Offers one base plan with coverage for appliances and systems. Additional coverage options available. Three-year contract. Typical $36 to $65 service fee. Unlimited claims for covered repairs. No online claim portal. | Read reviews |
Home Warranty Inc
| 1.0
17 reviews
| Serves all of the United States except California, Oregon, Washington, Arizona and New York. $100 deductible on most plans. In-house or local technician options. 24/7 live claim support and four-hour response times. | Read reviews |
Global Home USA
| 1.0
View profile
| Home warranty company based in Addison, Texas. Offers three home warranty plans that real estate agents can purchase for their clients. Provides coverage for all states except Alaska, California, Washington and Wyoming. | Read reviews |
Global Home Protection
| 1.0
View profile
| Home warranty company offering three warranty plan options. Additional coverage options available at an additional cost. 24/7 customer service and claim support. Free service transfer available. | Read reviews |
Armadillo Home Warranties
| No reviews | Offers a variety of home warranty plans for homeowners and landlords. Plans start at $39.99 per month. Network of service providers in most ZIP codes. Offers add-on coverage items. Available in 50 states. | |
Complete Protection Home Warranty
| No reviews | Customizable home warranty plans. Four warranty plans. Pricing ranges from $49 to $79 per month. Covers appliances and home systems. 24/7 customer support. Online customer portal with claim filing. No deductible. | |
Everything Breaks Home Warranties
| No reviews | Monthly and annual home system, appliance and electronics plans. Five tiers of home warranty coverage. Option for individual appliance coverage. 31-day waiting period before coverage starts. |