1. Shopping
  2. Best Jewelry Stores

Best Jewelry Stores

Author picture
Author picture
Written by

Choosing jewelry is a personal decision, and people often have different needs and taste. Read our guide to research the best jewelry store for you. Some jewelers make pieces by hand, while others stock their inventories with products from other manufacturers. Some jewelry stores also offer services such as jewelry repair.

Why trust ConsumerAffairs?
  • Our recommendations are based on what reviewers say.
  • 4,307,388 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

Compare Reviews for Top Jewelry Stores

  • Best Rated
  • Most Reviewed
  • Highest Rated

What features to look for in a jewelry store

Products offered

Jewelers sell a wide range of products made from a variety of materials.

  • Watches: Some jewelers sell watches and other timepieces in addition to traditional jewelry. The watches sold by jewelers differ from those sold in traditional stores; they are usually made of precious metals like silver, gold and white gold. The watches often contain stones like diamonds to make them pieces of beauty and high value.
  • Diamond companies: Some jewelers focus on selling jewelry that features diamonds, and they often specialize in selling engagement rings to couples planning marriage. Buyers looking for a diamond engagement ring should choose a diamond company, since they often have a large variety of stones in different sizes and colors to suit different tastes.
  • Ceramic or beaded jewelry: There are some jewelry companies that do not sell metallic or stone based jewelry, but instead, offer ceramic and beaded pieces that are often crafted by hand. These pieces can often have more intricate look, but a more casual aesthetic than finer jewelry.

Services offered

Jewelers can offer customers a range of extra services in addition to selling pieces of jewelry or doing simple repairs.

  • Appraisal: Some jewelers stores have the ability to analyze a piece of jewelry a customer already has, then tell them the worth of that piece; many of these companies will purchase jewelry from customers or accept it as a trade-in for a new purchase.
  • Jewelry refurbishment: Jewelers that specialize in jewelry refurbishment specialize in refurbish old, antique, and vintage pieces of jewelry; beyond simply fixing jewelry that is broken, these companies can take pieces that have been weathered over many years and restore them to as if they were new. This refurbishment often takes a very skilled craftsman.
  • Customization services: Jewelers may offer consumers customization services. To customize jewelry, customers can do a range of things like getting the jewelry engraved with a monogram, designing a unique combination of stone and metals or resizing a piece so it becomes a much larger or smaller piece than it once was. For example, making a necklace that is too small for a customer into a new and unique bracelet.

Warranties and protection

Jewelry companies often offer customers warranties to protect the goods they purchase. There are many types of warranties that cover products for certain periods of time. They also offer policies to help customers protect their investment.

  • Lifetime warranties: Jewelry companies that offer lifetime warranties will guarantee the jewelry for its life. This means that if it breaks, tarnishes or becomes damaged, the company will replace or repair it at no cost to the customer.
  • Jewelry insurance: Some companies offer customers insurance policies along with the jewelry; thus, if something happens to the piece they purchase, the policy will reimburse them for some of the cost.
  • Limited time guarantees: Most jewelers offer a guarantee of some kind for new pieces of jewelry, which means that customers have a certain amount of time during which a jeweler will replace or restore broken or tarnished jewelry. Sellers of used jewelry rarely offer warranties.

Company staff

Jewelry companies often have a variety of staff onboard, and the companies do not just consist of people who sell jewelry.

  • Artisans and engravers: The artisans and engravers at a jewelry company are the skilled workers who can alter a piece of jewelry; these people add monograms, make repairs, and customize products for customers.
  • Gem experts: Many companies have skilled gemologists onboard who have studied the history and science of gems, and these experts can tell customers about the worth of pieces, their makeup, as well as a how to maintain and care for them so they last through the years.
  • Customer service team: Jewelry is a large investment; so many jewelry companies have a dedicated customer service team on staff. This team helps manage payments and transactions for customers, and they can also field questions and concerns they have; these dedicated staff are also skilled at fielding inquiries from unsatisfied customers, as well as those who want to use their warranty or return a piece.


Jewelers can hold a number of certifications that prove their level of skill, dependability and service.

  • Bench professional certification: Bench professional certifications declare that a professional is qualified to both sell and repair jewelry, and there are several levels of bench professional certification that indicate the level of skill a jeweler has. Customers can often bring jewelry purchased somewhere else to a bench jeweler, who will repair the jewelry for a fee.
  • GIA certification: The Gemological Institute of America, or GIA, certifies the diamonds that jewelers sell, and they are considered to have the strictest of grading standards when it comes to certifying the quality of diamonds and diamond jewelry.
  • Jewelry degrees: There are many academic degrees that jewelers can obtain, including a B.A. in jewelry design, an associate degree in jewelry design and a certificate in jewelry.

Jewelry source

Jewelry stores can get the products they sell from a range of different sources.

  • Artisan jewelers: Artisan jewelers hand-make each piece of jewelry individually and sell only the jewelry they make in their stores. This means that each piece that is sold is unique and one of a kind. Artisan jewelers often also make jewelry out of unique materials, like beads, non-precious metals, freshwater pearls, seashells and more.
  • Estate jewelers: Some jewelers collect jewelry from estate sales and resell the jewelry to customers. In some cases, families of people who have deceased will call in jewelers to appraise and purchase jewelry from the estate, and the jeweler will then take the jewelry he has purchased and resell it for profit, often after restoring and cleaning it, at a jewelry store.
  • Popular jewelry designers: There are many large, popular makers of jewelry throughout the world, and some jewelers sell a curated collection of jewelry pieces from other designers and manufacturers, like Stuller, Inc., David Yurman, or I. Reiss.

What are different types of jewelry stores?

Handmade jewelry artisans

Handmade jewelry artisans specialize in creating unique pieces of jewelry by hand. These artisans sell jewelry that is not available in any retail store or online shop but their own. For one-of-a-kind jewelry that buyers won't see worn by anyone else, choose to shop at an artisan jeweler.

Large jewelry store chains

Some jewelers work at large chains of jewelry stores. These large jewelry chains have retail outposts in many locations across the country.

Specialized jewelers

Specialized jewelers focus on one product or material, such as diamonds, gold or engagement rings. This means that they offer a greater selection of one type of jewelry, and they often have specialized knowledge about how to maintain, clean, care for and customize that one type.

Bench jewelers

Bench jewelers are jewelers who specialize both in selling pieces of jewelry, as well as working to restore and repair tarnished or broken jewelry.

Who are jewelry stores for?

Couples getting engaged

Couples getting engaged may turn to a jewelry store for an engagement ring. They often shop for gold rings for a wedding or diamond rings to celebrate an engagement.

People looking to restore antique jewelry

People who want to restore antique jewelry may turn to a jeweler to make an old piece look like new. Jewelers who do repair and restoration can help return an antique piece of jewelry close to its original state.

Customers looking to buy a luxury gift

Jewelry is a popular gift for a special occasion, particularly romantic occasions like anniversaries or Valentine's Day, and momentous events like graduation. Jewelers can help provide luxury gift items that are valuable and high-quality enough to mark a very special occurrence.

Religious consumers celebrating milestones

Many people who are religious use jewelry as a gift or memento to mark a religious occasion like a Christening, Baptism, Bat Mitzvah or Confirmation.

Jewelry stores FAQ

How much can you negotiate on jewelry?
Jewelers have a high markup, so you can expect to save anywhere from 10% to 50%, depending on your skills as a negotiator. For the best results, be sure to:
  • Price shop
  • Bring cash
  • Be prepared to walk away
Do jewelers buy rings?
Yes, jewelers buy used rings, but you shouldn’t expect to get anywhere near what you paid for it. Research local jewelry buyers in your area to find a shop offering the best price on your ring.
What is the average cost of an engagement ring?
The average cost for an engagement ring is around $6,000; this figure continues to increase each year.
Can a jeweler cut off a ring?
A jeweler is the best option for having a ring cut off, as they can remove it with minimal damage to the ring itself. They can then resize the ring for a small fee, usually ranging from $20 to $200.
What is the difference between fine jewelry and costume jewelry?
  • Artisans craft fine jewelry with real gemstones, pearls and noble metals like silver and gold.
  • Jewelers make costume jewelry from base metals like copper or brass and usually use fake stones.
Is rose gold more expensive than platinum?
Rose gold isn’t as durable as platinum, so jewelry made from this blush-colored material is often more affordable. Rose gold jewelry is usually priced similarly to white and yellow gold.
What is the highest quality diamond?
The highest quality diamonds are rated flawless (FL) on the clarity scale. These diamonds have no visible inclusions or blemishes under 10 times magnification. Under 1% of diamonds in the world have this classification.
How do you store fine jewelry?
Fine jewelry should be stored in a clean, soft box away from extreme temperatures and humidity. Jewelry that’s prone to scratching or tarnishing may need to be stored separately in jewelry bags or boxes. It’s also best to choose a well-hidden location in case of a break-in. You may want to invest in jewelry insurance for added protection.
How much does it cost to get a ring resized?
It usually costs between $20 to $200 to have a ring resized. It may be more expensive if the resizing is particularly complicated or time-consuming.
Why do jewelers wear gloves?
Jewelers wear gloves for a variety of reasons, including:
  • To protect their hands from jagged edges and chemicals
  • To reduce smudges and oils on jewelry
  • To make it easier to grip small items

Not sure how to choose?

Get buying tips about Jewelry Stores delivered to your inbox.

    By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Thanks for subscribing.

    You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

    Author reviews for jewelry stores

    Stauer Jewelry

    Stauer Jewelry is a company that sells a range of accessories and luxury items to customers online, and they are known for selling jewelry and accessories at affordable prices. The company is headquartered in Burnsville, Minnesota, and it offers a range of products, including traditional jewelry and watches for women, as well as a slew of accessories geared toward men.

    • Watch selection: In addition to selling traditional jewelry pieces, Stauer Jewelry has a large selection of watches for customers to choose from.
    • Value options: The company offers upscale jewelry, but it also has a selection of fine jewelry pieces under 100 dollars for both men and women, making it a good choice for customers on a budget.
    • Unique items: Stauer Jewelry stands out because it not only has jewelry in traditional gems and metals, like silver and gold, but it also features unique jewelry options, such as pieces made of Murano glass.
    • No questions asked: Every product purchased from Stauer Jewelry comes with a 30-day, money-back guarantee so customers can return products without any questions asked.
    • Platinum membership plan: Stauer offers customers a platinum membership plan. For an annual membership fee, they get 10 percent off every order and 100 dollars in discounts.
    Read 1130 Reviews
    Kay Jewelers

    Kay is a jewelry company owned by Signet Jewelers that was founded in 1916, and the company is headquartered in Fairlawn, Ohio. It is one of America's biggest jewelry store chains with retail stores located in large shopping malls, and it also offers customers online shopping for a range of jewelry products.

    Read more about Kay Jewelers

    Founded in 1924 in Wichita Falls, Texas, Zales is a jewelry company that sells its products in more than 750 stores across the United States and Puerto Rico. Customers can shop for jewelry from Zales at retail outlets and online.

    Read more about Zales
    Blue Nile

    Blue Nile is an online-only jewelry company that has been in business since 1999. The company is headquartered in Seattle, Washington and offers customers a huge selection of products containing diamonds; customers can search the company's inventory of diamond by carat weight, clarity, color, and more.

    Read more about Blue Nile
    Jared The Galleria Of Jewelry

    Jared The Galleria of Fine Jewelry is a jewelry company founded in 1993 that is now also owned by Signet Jewelers. Headquartered in Akron, Ohio, the company has retail jewelry stores across the nation. They are considered to be Signet's "off-mall" store, which means that Jared the Galleria of Jewelry stores are located in smaller shopping malls and shopping centers.

    Read more about Jared The Galleria Of Jewelry
    Fred Meyer Jewelers

    Fred Meyer Jewelers is a jewelry company founded in 1973 by jeweler Fred G. Meyer as a jewelry catalog-showroom company. The company, which operates retail locations in malls and larger department stores in California, the Midwest, and much of the Northeastern U.S., offers a wide range of jewelry products. The company operates under both of the names Fred Meyer Jewelers and Littman Jewelers.

    Read more about Fred Meyer Jewelers
    Tiffany & Co.

    Headquartered in New York, Tiffany & Co. is a company that sells luxury jewelry, fragrances, accessories, watches and leather goods. While known for outstanding products, Tiffany is particularly well-known for offering stunning and high-quality diamond jewelry.

    Read more about Tiffany & Co.

    Swarovski is an upscale jewelry brand that was founded in 1895 in Austria. The company is known for offering customers high-quality crystal products, including crystal jewelry, chandeliers and their world-famous figurines. They use crystal which has been created to allow light to refract in a rainbow spectrum.

    Read more about Swarovski

    Often considered one of the most luxurious jewelry brands in the world, Cartier Jewelers is headquartered in Paris, France. The company is known for a wide range of jewelry products, but it is especially renowned for its selection of watches.

    Read more about Cartier

    Compare Reviews for Top Jewelry Stores

    Want your company to be on this guide?

    Yes, continue