Blue Nile

Blue Nile

 3.9/5 (105 reviews)

Our promise. We provide a buying advantage with verified reviews and unbiased editorial research.

Overall Rating3.9 out of 5
See all 105 reviews

About Blue Nile

Blue Nile Reviews

  • Recent
  • Oldest
  • Most helpful
  • Any
  • Rated with 5 stars
  • Rated with 4 stars
  • Rated with 3 stars
  • Rated with 2 stars
  • Rated with 1 star

A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Blue Nile?
  • 4,241,241 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Page 1 Reviews 0 - 10
Rated with 1 star
Verified Reviewer
Original review: March 25, 2023

Ordered ring size 9.5 (based on their plastic ring sizer) and received a ring sized 8. Then call customer service. Given that wedding day is in 3 weeks, I am recommended to order a new ring, and that I should not be worried given that, if new ring doesn't fit, Blue Nile can always send a new ring "overnight". Turns out "overnight" means it takes 7 days to build the new ring, so in reality it's ~ 2 weeks to deliver, which would mean I would not be able to get the new ring in time for the wedding. This is a very misleading statement by "Customer Relations Specialist" agent "Catherine **". The agent clearly understands the nature of my concern (I might not get ring for the wedding), and outright lies above the "overnight" shipping to make me walk away. When asked about a supervisor, said she is the only person I can talk to to file a complaint.

3 people found this review helpful
Rated with 1 star
Verified Reviewer
Original review: Jan. 12, 2023

Awful experience. I went to their showroom in Charlotte, NC to exchange a necklace for a bracelet. I was told in the store that my item would arrive the following Thursday. It did not. So I called the customer service (if you can call it that) and was told that it hadn't been mailed out yet. They said they would overnight the item. Again they didn't. Lie number 2. When I got the shipping information, showing it hadn't been overnighted I called again. I was told a supervisor would call me back to discuss. No one called me back. Lie number 3. I called again 4 days later and was told tough. They also accused me of lying about what I was told in the showroom. Avoid this company, they don't tell the truth and take no accountability when found out.

4 people found this review helpful

Not sure how to choose?

Get buying tips about Jewelry Stores delivered to your inbox.

    By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

    Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Aug. 26, 2022

    At first the purchase was great. Very nice staff at the King of Prussia store, very nice ring. I was worried that it was too large (my fiancee kept on going back & forth about what size she was) but I was assured that Blue Nile will resize once for free, even if past the 30-day return window. I proposed, she said yes, it was too large. We were told we could stop by the store to send it in for a free resize, which we did.

    I received an email stating my ring was not re-sizeable and I would have to purchase a new setting (they offered to give me $200 off of a $2,000 setting), because I was outside the 30-day return window. Not even close to what I was originally told in person and via email ("Downsizing/re-sizing for your ring is no problem and is free."). After many emails, calls, arguments proving my case, Blue Nile finally agreed to provide me with a new setting free of charge. It has now been > 6 weeks without our ring. They notoriously give you a ship date, then back up the ship date (they have done it 4x so far). Go elsewhere for your engagement ring.

    16 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: May 12, 2022

    I ordered a ring two months ago and was given a delivery date. The day of the delivery it was postponed a month due to quality assurance concerns. I let it pass. It's covid. Things happen. Two days before the delivery date I reached out to their support team and asked for a status update. They said everything was scheduled on time. Day of delivery - I reach out again and they said it should be there tomorrow. Tomorrow comes and I get an update that it will be moved out another month.

    Don't trust this company to do the right thing. Don't rely on them to ship things on time or tell you when it will actually be delivered. If you want a ring on time use one of their competitors or whomever they are sourcing the rings from to begin with and cut out the middle-person. The service people were very friendly during the process. You can tell that their bosses are making all of the money per usual and that their hands are tied. Go buy somewhere else so that they have more competition and can learn how to run a business.

    19 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Jan. 26, 2022

    Awaiting to see how Blue Nile will handle my latest return of my eternity band... Purchased in 2009 - replaced once - returned for lost stones at least every other year..... Stay tuned. Not a happy consumer..

    17 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Dec. 21, 2021

    They were good in the past. But now they are just another online scammer. Two incidents one after another. Paid for a product, next day they said, "Oh we are out of that diamond." Why would you let me add it to the cart and pay for it if it's out of stock? The answer they gave me was, "We source from different vendors." Okay, Blue Nile is a middleman now, that was news to me. After the first purchase went sideways after a few weeks I tried again. Delivery scheduled after 2 weeks. Multiple notifications in between, "We have the diamond, on its way, exciting news it's scheduled.." Then nothing till 10 days after the delivery date. "Sorry for the inconvenience." They held my money for almost a month. Middleman needs cash flow but why hold the customer as collateral?

    29 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Oct. 29, 2021

    I bought a beautiful diamond bracelet for my wife and on day one it showed up with a loose clasp. No big deal. It still worked and was fine. But recently one of the links broke. When I contacted customer service they approved the request but was very clear I'd be responsible to pay for certain damaged. A yellow flag already. This is a clear defect so no worries there. But they require the customer to pay to ship the item back. So the "lifetime" warranty has some catches. So I proceed to get the label and it says it costs $50 to ship back. That is pretty pricey. So I informed them I'd have a local jeweler look at it as I'd hate to pay $50 to ship the bracelet in for a $10 repair.

    They immediately told me if I did this it 100% voids the warranty. This is totally shady. Kay for example actually gave my wife's engagement ring their lifetime warranty because it was soldered to the wedding band I bought from Kay. A few diamonds fell out not long ago and Kay replaced them. No questions asked. The moral here is that if you want quality you can count on and want a true warranty DO NOT buy from Blue Nile. Stick to your local jeweler or the true national brands that actually care about their customers. All of this over a $50 shipping label. Again avoid.

    31 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    profile pic of the author
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: Aug. 31, 2021

    They could not repair a ring they sold me. They would not allow me to trade it in for another one. They would however “buy the materials back from me”. And then sell me the ring again. So they can sell two for the price of one? I’m done with Blue Nile.

    25 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 5 stars
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: July 30, 2021

    I've been a customer ever since I found these guys about 10 years ago. Their jewelry is excellent and a very good value. My wife loves everything I've ever ordered from them and I've spent thousands with them. Customer service is impeccable and I'm just now returning the first thing I've ever bought from them to get larger diamonds. I love these guys!

    9 people found this review helpful
    Rated with 1 star
    Verified Reviewer
    Original review: June 10, 2021

    "Buyer Beware." This is Comenity Capital Bank's repulsive act to nickel and dime good customers for others who cannot pay their bills on time during a world crisis. I purchased jewelry twice from Blue Nile over the past two years for a total of $7,020. Comenity Bank is the credit card company Blue Nile uses for credit purchases. Both purchases were paid off in full. However, every time I paid off the balance, the bank would charge me additional interest charges unbeknownst to me. A month or two would go by when I'm thinking the balance is paid and meanwhile, I have a interest balance for the amounts of $2, $4, etc that is accruing late fees of $27.00 monthly and more interest charges accruing on late fees.

    I've never been late with my payments. I have impeccable credit which has now been ruined by this bank for interest fees charged on $4.65 which totaled $127 in late fees as of June. Those late fees charged were reported to the Credit Bureaus. My credit score decreased 69 points due to this. This is a atrocity by a bank to charge these amount of fees on a $4.65 interest charge when the customer has paid off their balance in full twice. Not to mention, the balances were paid during a pandemic. During a time such as this it is hard to build and maintain credit. I have been responsible with paying my bills on time for years. To now be penalized 69 points on my credit for "Pennies" owed on this account.

    31 people found this review helpful
    Loading more reviews...

    Blue Nile author review by ConsumerAffairs Research Team

    Blue Nile is an online-only jewelry company that has been in business since 1999. The company is headquartered in Seattle, Washington and offers customers a huge selection of products containing diamonds; customers can search the company's inventory of diamond by carat weight, clarity, color, and more.

    • Certified diamonds: The diamonds that Blue Nile sells to customers are all certified so customers can be sure they are of high quality and from a legitimate source.

    • No commission sales: Blue Nile salespeople do not work on commission, so customers can expect unbiased service, and they will not be pressured to make a purchase they are uncertain about.

    • 30-day return policy: The company offers customers who order products a 30-day period to return any piece they are unhappy with.

    • Jewelry education: Blue Nile's website has an education section about jewelry and how to pick pieces to wear and give as gifts, so it's a helpful resource for customers looking for more information before they shop.

    • Free shipping: Customers who order jewelry from Blue Nile receive it through free, fast shipping.

    The ConsumerAffairs Research Team believes everyone deserves to make smart decisions. We aim to provide readers with the most up-to-date information available about today's consumer products and services.

    Blue Nile Company Information

    Company Name:
    Blue Nile
    Year Founded:
    United States