
Cars.com Reviews
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.
Our editorial standards
- Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
- We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
- All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
About Cars.com
- User-friendly interface
- Wide selection of vehicles
- Comparison tools
- Poor customer service experiences
- Inaccurate or outdated listings
Review Summary
Reviews of Cars.com are strongly negative, from private sellers, dealers and shoppers alike. Common complaints are listings with wrong mileage or prices, instant offers slashed at the dealer, scam inquiries and hard-to-reach support. The exception is praise for dealers.
Reviews powering this summary
... not only was the car exactly as represented but the staff was very knowledgeable and gave great customer service.
Read full reviewPositive and professional salesman. Very helpful and knowledgeable.
Read full reviewFreehold Dodge & Ram is the best Dealership in the Tri-State Area.
Read full reviewThe staff are wonderful. I am very pleased with their expertise.
Read full reviewShe showed us the car and made the process really quick and easy. The best part was they were willing to negotiate the price.
Read full reviewThe sales team was excellent and trustworthy.
Read full reviewCan't even get logged back in after listing. No email response as well.
Read full reviewIt's been 3.5 weeks and they still haven't activated my listing to sell my car on their website.
Read full review... forces you to contact customer support. Oh, guess what? There is no customer support.
Read full reviewCars.com has very poor customer service and generates very few good leads.
Read full reviewThey give you a price to buy your car, then try to chisel it down to nothing when you get to the dealer.
Read full reviewThey sent me an offer for $3025, I go to the dealer and they offered $2000.
Read full review... they tried to reduce the trade-in value by $2,000 without any legitimate explanation.
Read full reviewI started working up a plan to sell my 2003 VW Passat Wagon. ... It sold in two days!
Read full reviewI found the car I wanted on here. ... I would recommend this site to other car shoppers out there.
Read full reviewI got one legitimate lead three days before the listing expired, and sold the car to that person at a reduced price.
Read full reviewTrying to sell car as a private party. Lots of inquiries, all of which have turned out to be bogus.
Read full reviewI probably experienced 3 scam attempts for every legitimate interest.
Read full reviewIt's all a scam, so be careful.
Read full reviewThis entire experience feels like one giant SCAM! Highly suspicious of them and their affiliate dealers and their practices.
Read full reviewA quick look through the Carfax showed that the odometer had been rolled back 100,000 miles!
Read full reviewI believe Cars.com is working a "bait-and-switch" move in conjunction with Simi Valley Chrysler Jeep.
Read full reviewCars.com misleads (lies to) customers by telling them that their "Autocheck" mileage is much greater than actual.
Read full reviewBuyer beware. Make sure you’re actually getting what you’re made to believe you are buying!
Read full reviewMost positive reviews focus on individual dealerships and salespeople rather than the Cars.com platform. Reviewers praise knowledgeable, patient staff, vehicles that matched their listings and quick, easy transactions.
Reviews about dealership experience
... not only was the car exactly as represented but the staff was very knowledgeable and gave great customer service.
Read full reviewPositive and professional salesman. Very helpful and knowledgeable.
Read full reviewFreehold Dodge & Ram is the best Dealership in the Tri-State Area.
Read full reviewThe staff are wonderful. I am very pleased with their expertise.
Read full reviewShe showed us the car and made the process really quick and easy. The best part was they were willing to negotiate the price.
Read full reviewThe sales team was excellent and trustworthy.
Read full reviewTechnical problems and poor support frustrate many users. Reviewers report listings that never go live, login problems and unanswered emails and calls. Several dealers say sold vehicles reappear in their inventory and can’t be removed.
Reviews about customer service and account support
Can't even get logged back in after listing. No email response as well.
Read full reviewIt's been 3.5 weeks and they still haven't activated my listing to sell my car on their website.
Read full review... forces you to contact customer support. Oh, guess what? There is no customer support.
Read full reviewCars.com has very poor customer service and generates very few good leads.
Read full reviewSellers who used the instant offer or trade-in tool are frustrated. The common pattern is a solid quote online that the partner dealer refuses to honor, cutting the value by hundreds or thousands once sellers bring in the car. Reviewers feel steered toward lowball dealer offers.
Reviews about instant offer and trade-in values
They give you a price to buy your car, then try to chisel it down to nothing when you get to the dealer.
Read full reviewThey sent me an offer for $3025, I go to the dealer and they offered $2000.
Read full review... they tried to reduce the trade-in value by $2,000 without any legitimate explanation.
Read full reviewSellers report mixed results on Cars.com. A few received multiple buyer inquiries or sold their cars quickly, while others got few legitimate leads or had listings that never went live. Several say they had better results with free options such as Facebook Marketplace.
Reviews about selling results
I started working up a plan to sell my 2003 VW Passat Wagon. ... It sold in two days!
Read full reviewI found the car I wanted on here. ... I would recommend this site to other car shoppers out there.
Read full reviewI got one legitimate lead three days before the listing expired, and sold the car to that person at a reduced price.
Read full reviewPrivate sellers repeatedly describe being targeted by scammers and fake buyers. Reviewers say most inquiries turn out to be bogus, with fake names and suspicious stories, and several call the site a scam. Some note the anti-scam team helped but bad leads wore them down.
Reviews about scams and fake inquiries
Trying to sell car as a private party. Lots of inquiries, all of which have turned out to be bogus.
Read full reviewI probably experienced 3 scam attempts for every legitimate interest.
Read full reviewIt's all a scam, so be careful.
Read full reviewThis entire experience feels like one giant SCAM! Highly suspicious of them and their affiliate dealers and their practices.
Read full reviewReviewers cite listings with incorrect mileage, suspected odometer rollbacks and prices that change at the dealership. Some describe differences between online prices and dealer offers as bait-and-switch tactics. Several private sellers also say Cars.com favors dealer listings.
Reviews about listing accuracy and pricing
A quick look through the Carfax showed that the odometer had been rolled back 100,000 miles!
Read full reviewI believe Cars.com is working a "bait-and-switch" move in conjunction with Simi Valley Chrysler Jeep.
Read full reviewCars.com misleads (lies to) customers by telling them that their "Autocheck" mileage is much greater than actual.
Read full reviewBuyer beware. Make sure you’re actually getting what you’re made to believe you are buying!
Read full reviewCars.com Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (24)
- (15)
- (7)
- (3)
- (35)
Popular Mentions
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
Cars.com Company Information
- Company Name:
- Cars.com
- Website:
- www.cars.com











