The fight over "swipe fees" charged to merchants who accept Visa and MasterCard is going into extra rounds. Nineteen large companies have opted out of a proposed settlement that would have ended a long-running class-action case.
Retailers say they pay the highest fees in the world to credit card companies and banks to swipe their cards because of unfair price-fixing within the industry.
Walmart, Costco, Starbucks and Gap are among the large retailers rejecting the settlement, saying it would not stop swipe fees from rising but would block them from challenging future increase.
"If this settlement is approved, it would allow credit-card companies and big banks to perpetuate an unfair and broken system that costs all consumers, including those who don't even have a credit or debit card," Mike Cook, senior vice president of finance and assistant treasurer for Wal-Mart, said.
The National Retail Federation is also expected to opt out of the settlement this week while the retailers say they are considering "additional legal action to recover damages from Visa and MasterCard under U.S. antitrust laws."
Europeans crack down
Another retailers' group charged that Visa has offered to reduce its credit card swipe fees on certain transactions in Europe while it "continues to stiff U.S. merchants with soaring fees that have tripled during the past decade."
"Here at home, U.S. merchants and consumers are struggling under the weight of swipe fees up to ten times higher than what Visa Europe is proposing for European transactions," the Merchants Payments Coalition said. "Credit card swipe fees in the U.S. are up to 4 percent of the transaction value, while the new Visa rate in the EU will be 0.3 percent."
“European regulators are holding Visa’s feet to the fire for their outrageous swipe fees – even though the fees in Europe are a tiny fraction of what they are in the United States,” said Doug Kantor, counsel of the Merchants Payments Coalition. “There is no reason for rates to be as high as they are. This should be a wake-up call that credit card swipe fee reform is long overdue here.”
Judge John Gleeson of U.S. District Court in Brooklyn granted preliminary approval to the class-action settlement last November and there is a deadline this week for parties wanting to opt out of the settlement. A hearing on final approval is scheduled for Sept. 12.
MasterCard says it's confident the judge will approve the settlement, the Wall Street Journal reported. Visa did not comment.
A spokesman for the Electronic Payments Coalition, which represents the credit card companies and large banks, said the retailers did not raise any new arguments in their opt-out announcement.