How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

Laminate vs. Tile

Laminate is more affordable, but tile is better for water resistance and durability

Get matched with a flooring partner near you.

Join over 8,000 people who received a free, no obligation quote in the last 30 days.
    Enter details in under 3 minutes
    +2 more
    Author picture
    Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin
    Tiled floor on a modern kitchen featuring various stainless steel appliances

    Most homeowners choose between laminate and tile floors based on water resistance, but there are other considerations, including comfort underfoot, upfront cost and ease of cleaning. Understanding how these products compare across these metrics is a good way to make sure you’re getting the best value for your money.

    Why trust ConsumerAffairs?

    Our editors, fact-checkers and moderators work to uphold standards for accuracy, transparency and trust.

    Our editorial standards

    • Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
    • We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
    • All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.

    Key insights

    Laminate is cheaper and easier to install for a DIYer, but tile is much more resilient to physical wear, more water-resistant and offers better long-term value.

    Jump to insight

    Tile is a much better option for kitchens because it will resist damage from plumbing and appliance leaks, and it will stand up better to the heavy foot traffic kitchens often see.

    Jump to insight

    Laminate is better for most living rooms because it’s warmer and more comfortable to walk on, and it helps reduce noise a bit better than tile.

    Jump to insight

    Key differences between laminate and tile

    Laminate flooring has a medium- or high-density fiberboard (MDF or HDF) core with a wear layer on top and, in some cases, a pre-attached underlayment underneath. Tile floors consist of ceramic or porcelain tile, which a pro will attach to your subfloor using thinset mortar. Your installer will also fill the gaps between tiles with grout for a finished look.

    Laminate flooring costs less than tile, and DIY installation is possible, so it’s a more budget-friendly material overall. It’s also easier to repair and replace, and it can resemble other materials, such as hardwood. Tile flooring is more expensive, demands professional installation and is less comfortable and colder underfoot, but it lasts up to seven times as long and offers better long-term value.

    Most homeowners choose tile for its water resistance and physical wear resistance, making it one of the best types of flooring for kitchens and bathrooms. Laminate is a better option for bedrooms and living spaces where homeowners want the look of hardwood at a more reasonable upfront price.

    Laminate and tile flooring compared

    You can use the table below to get a quick overview of how these types of floors compare and decide which might be best for your space based on its overall performance.

    Laminate vs. tile for kitchens

    Tile is a far better flooring option for kitchens overall because it has much better water and wear resistance. Laminate is a possible option for budget-friendly kitchens. However, most homeowners choose vinyl over laminate if they’re looking to save money on their kitchen floors but still want good long-term value.

    Spills and moisture resistance

    Water-resistant means the material can only slow down water penetration (laminate), whereas waterproof means the flooring won’t be damaged by standing water (tile).

    Laminate offers slightly better performance when it comes to spills because the top layer is impervious, so your flooring won’t stain immediately if you spill food or beverages. However, spills that you don’t get to right away can seep through the seams around your laminate planks and damage and stain the core layer, which readily absorbs liquids.

    Spills won’t stain the tile itself, but things like tomato sauce, red wine and coffee can easily stain the grout lines between your tiles, even if you clean up the mess quickly.

    When it comes to general moisture resistance, however, tile is a better flooring choice. Tile flooring is completely waterproof. Although water can soak down to your subfloor through grout lines or around the edges of the floor, the risk is low. The seams around laminate planks will more quickly allow water to seep through, damaging the core of your flooring and the subfloor below.

    Scratch and dent resistance

    Tile is a much more resilient floor when it comes to physical damage, too. It can stand up to constant foot traffic without getting worn down and won’t scratch from pet nails. Although the tiles might crack if you drop a pot or a pan, they won’t dent.

    Laminate has a wear layer on top that is resistant to scratches and physical wear, but the material as a whole is much less resistant to damage. Pet nails and foot traffic will more quickly damage laminate, and the material is more prone to denting from impact.

    Cleaning and long-term maintenance

    Kitchens are key areas to keep clean, so you should consider how easy your desired kitchen flooring material is to clean. Tile is simple, as you can vacuum, wet mop and scrub without worrying about damage. Laminate is more likely to get scratched from debris under a vacuum or heavy scrubbing, and it’s susceptible to water damage from wet mopping.

    Keeping the grout lines between kitchen floor tiles clean will require some extra work, but overall, tile is an easier floor to maintain in a kitchen than laminate.

    Comfort

    One area where tile kitchen floors fall short is comfort. Tile is cold and hard underfoot, so it’s one of the most uncomfortable flooring materials to walk on. Laminate either has an attached underlayment or a separate underlayment that adds a bit of padding, and the material itself is less rigid and more comfortable.

    Laminate vs. tile for living rooms

    Living rooms have fewer considerations to make when choosing a flooring material because they rarely see leaks and moisture, and spills are far less common than they are in kitchens. Laminate is usually a better option for living rooms, but there are a few factors to consider.

    Warmth and underfoot feel

    Most homeowners want some semblance of comfort in their living rooms, and on that front, laminate is a much better option.

    Laminate doesn’t feel as cold as tile, and it typically has an underlayment that adds some cushioning under the floor. Tile goes down on thinset and adheres directly to your underfloor, which makes it very rigid and hard, and there’s no other underlayment option.

    Laminate also resembles hardwood flooring, so homeowners looking for the natural appearance of solid wood floors on a budget typically go with laminate.

    » READ MORE: Vinyl vs. laminate vs. wood flooring

    Noise reduction

    Tile floors will cause sound to bounce off them, which can create a hollow or empty feeling. Most homeowners gather with family and friends in their living rooms and find that the slightly better noise dampening they get from laminate flooring creates a more inviting experience.

    Kids, pets and heavy foot traffic

    Living rooms tend to see heavy traffic, including activity from children and pets. For those who want the most resilient floor possible, tile is a much better option than laminate, as it will last up to seven times as long.

    However, most homeowners will sooner choose a high-end laminate floor with a thick wear layer that can resist scratching, scuffing and physical wear. This strikes a good balance between upfront cost, underfoot feel, appearance and durability.

    Matching adjacent flooring

    Homeowners also tend to like to match flooring across rooms for a more cohesive feel in their living spaces. Tile is common in kitchens and bathrooms, but for areas that living rooms typically flow into, like dining rooms, hallways and dens, laminate is a more common option. This means that laminate is more likely to create that design flow than tile is.

    Cost and installation

    On average, you’ll pay between $3 and $12 per square foot to install laminate flooring, whereas tile flooring costs between $7 and $25 per square foot for materials and installation. Tile is a more expensive material, and the installation is much more time-consuming and labor-intensive, which leads to the higher overall cost.

    Laminate flooring installation is very simple and straightforward thanks to the click-lock system that many laminate floors use. Pros charge less for the easy labor, and handy DIYers can even tackle the work themselves to save more. Tile requires making sure the subfloor is perfectly level, laying down thinset and spacing tiles, which demands more skill and time.

    There are a few additional factors that also contribute to higher installation costs for tile:

    • Subfloor repairs: You might need subfloor repairs if a pro finds hidden damage when removing your old floor, and that can add $2 to $10 per square foot to your installation costs. Damage issues are more likely under old tile floors, which are more common in areas where water and moisture are a bigger issue.
    • Subfloor leveling: Tile also demands a perfectly flat subfloor to reduce the risk of the material cracking, so you may need to pay extra to level your subfloor. This service costs between $2 and $8 per square foot and is less commonly required under old laminate flooring in dry living spaces.
    • Old floor removal and disposal: Tile is hard to remove and heavy, so you’ll pay more for tile flooring removal and disposal than you would for most other materials. Since many homeowners replace tile with tile, you’re likely to see higher costs for flooring removal and disposal when installing a new tile floor.
    • DIY vs. professional installation: Laminate flooring installation is a DIY-friendly project, whereas tile almost always demands help from a professional. On average, laminate flooring costs less to install because some subset of homeowners can and will opt to install laminate flooring themselves to save on labor fees.

    » COMPARE: The best flooring companies

    Long-term ownership costs

    While laminate typically has a lower flooring installation cost, you should also consider the long-term value each material offers. Since tile costs about twice as much as laminate, on average, but lasts for up to seven times as long, tile is a better investment and is more likely to save you money in the long run.

    Get matched with a flooring partner near you.

      FAQ

      Do high-end homes use laminate flooring?

      It’s rare for high-end homes to use laminate flooring. Laminate flooring is a budget-friendly option, and while some top-of-the-line products can resemble natural materials like hardwood, luxury homes far more often opt for the real thing or go with vinyl flooring that resembles wood instead. Hardwood provides better value over time and maximum visual appeal, while vinyl is a more water-resistant and wear-resistant option than laminate while still providing a high-end look and feel.

      What is the downside to laminate flooring?

      The primary downside to laminate flooring is that it can swell and deteriorate with prolonged exposure to water and moisture. The core of laminate flooring is made of MDF or HDF, which will absorb water that seeps through the seams between flooring planks or tiles. As a result, it’s not a good fit for most bathrooms, kitchens or basements.

      What is the downside to tile flooring?

      There are a few downsides to tile flooring, including the cost, comfort and safety. Tile flooring costs between $7 and $25 per square foot, making it one of the most expensive flooring materials. It’s also hard and cold, so it’s not terribly comfortable to walk on, and it can get slippery if it’s wet or moist, creating the potential for slipping and falling in the rooms it’s best suited for.

      Is laminate flooring waterproof?

      Laminate flooring is water-resistant but not waterproof. It relies on a top protective layer to keep spills, leaks and moisture from getting to the core layer, but water can still seep through seams or around the edges of the flooring and get underneath. Once moisture reaches the MDF core layer, it will almost certainly sustain permanent damage and require total replacement.


      Article sources

      ConsumerAffairs writers primarily rely on government data, industry experts and original research from other reputable publications to inform their work. Specific sources for this guide include:

      1. International Association of Certified Home Inspectors, "InterNACHI's Standard Estimated Life Expectancy Chart for Homes." Accessed Oct. 25, 2026.
      Did you find this article helpful? |
      Share this article