Compare Matchmaking Services Reviews
Matchmaking companies are devoted to finding suitable romantic partners for their customers. They interview and then use personal information about their clients in order to pair appropriately matched people. They’re very different from Internet dating services in four respects.
- A professional matchmaker guides clients
- They generally meet all of their clients and interview them
- They provide pre-date guidance and post-date feedback
- They cost a lot more
Top 10 Best Rated Matchmaking Services
|Read 11 Reviews|
Master Matchmaker is a full-service matchmaker that guarantees introductions and offers coaching to help you succeed on dates. Joann and Steve Ward operate the service, which serves clients in all 50 states. Find out more
|Read 5081 Reviews|
Since its founding in 1991, It's Just Lunch has arranged over 2 million first dates around the world. Clients have an interview with the company, and then It's Just Lunch's matchmakers arrange the details of the date.
|Read 853 Reviews|
Events and Adventures is a dating site geared toward introducing singles at group social events. It schedules events and outings that its members can sign up for and meet other people in the process.
|Read 12 Reviews|
Based in New England, Successful Singles is a dating site that has been in operation since 1984. It works with attractive, well-educated residents who are interested in meeting other singles looking for a long-term relationship.
|Read 97 Reviews|
California Singles is a dating site targeted at singles all over California. Its staff meets with all clients in person to screen them. Then members are assigned a personal matchmaker to find the right match.
|Read 307 Reviews|
Lifemates is Canada's largest personalized dating and matchmaking service. It is focused on bringing together single men and women who are looking for lasting relationships and has been in the field for over 20 years.
|Read 15 Reviews|
Selective Search uses Fortune 500 recruitment techniques to match members to other compatible members. The company has an 87 percent success rate with its clients, thanks to the use of its Meet Your Future process.
|Read 5 Reviews|
Elite Matchmaking has been offering matchmaking services in some of the nation's largest cities for over 22 years. Agents meet personally with members and coach them after every date to help ensure dating success.
|Read 20 Reviews|
Located in Pennsylvania, All About Singles PA is a dating service that has been operating since 1988. It offers a personalized approach to finding partners for singles by screening and qualifying all members in person.
|Read 370 Reviews|
Great Expectations is a dating site that was founded in 1976 as a small family business and is now a national dating service. It offers background checks on all members and allows members to search and choose people to contact.
Online Dating & Matchmaking Contributing Editor
Harvard Business School graduate, Mark Brooks, has been an expert in the Internet dating business since 1998. He is currently the CEO of Courtland Brooks, a consultancy agency for the Internet dating industry, and runs OnlinePersonalsWatch.com. He prides himself on being a New Media Futurist and can be reached at LinkedIn.
What features matter most?
Matchmaking companies are a lot more expensive than Internet dating companies, although occasionally it’s possible to get their services for free.
- Paid services: The vast majority of the time matchmaking services are paid. Prices generally range from $5,000 to $50,000 a year for a set number of match/introductions. This may include an element of coaching. It generally includes pre-date guidance and post-date feedback, which is a key service difference between Internet dating and matchmaking services.
- Free services: People who are in a highly desirable demographic, i.e. age range and location, and are especially successful and good-looking, may be able to get the benefit of matchmaking services for free. They will be matched with paying clients. The under-represented demographics are women in the their twenties and early thirties and fit and successful men over age fifty-five.
Not all matchmakers will work with any prospective client. In fact, many of the services require customers to qualify for their services in a myriad of ways before they work to match them with a partner.
- Relationship status qualification: There are many matchmakers that require clients to prove that they are single before they begin the matchmaking process, and they will not work with customers who are in any way already committed to another person.
- Background checks: Many matchmaking companies will run background checks on their customers, which helps ensure that they have not been in trouble with the law or government previously.
- No screening process: It’s a rarity to find matchmaking services that don’t do at least an interview along with a relationship status check and/or a background check.
Matchmaking companies offer a variety of services, including matching clients with a wide variety of people or a smaller, more specific pool of people.
- General matches: Some Matchmakers have a wide, varied pool of matches that they can pair up. The larger national matchmakers generally take this approach.
- More specific niche-matchmakers: There are matchmaking companies that focus on clients who have a particular sexual preference, religious affiliation or cultural heritage. These are few and far between, but they do exist.
There are a variety of platforms and media by which customers can access a company's services, which offer different levels of convenience depending on customers' preferences.
- PC-based: Many matchmaking companies have created websites accessed via the Internet on a PC, so users must be at a laptop or desktop to access their latest matches.
- Mobile-based: Some matchmakers offer their services via mobile apps or responsive sites that are easy to use on a phone or mobile device.
- Over the phone: Some traditional matchmakers who offer more personalized services require customers to call in via a telephone in order to work with matchmakers.
The specific aim of the matchmaking company is an important factor for clients to consider when choosing a matchmaker.
- Relationship-focused: Most matchmaking companies operate to match potential partners for a long-term serious relationship.
- Casual: Matchmakers generally don’t work with people who are looking for a casual short-term relationship or fling. Casual relationships are more the domain of Internet dating sites and apps, like Tinder or Pure.
In order to match clients with potential matches, matchmakers require customers to submit a range of relevant personal information. This is normally done during a face-to-face interview and allows matchmakers to get to know their clients and to create a profile of each customer to match them with other good potential matches from their client base or beyond.
- In-depth information: Most quality matchmaking businesses require a lot of personal information about a customer in order to get an in-depth knowledge of their personality and desires.
- Minimal personal information: Matchmaking services will usually initially require basic information like name, age, location and a photo submitted online to assess if they can properly match a potential client.
What are different types of matchmakers?
Full-service in-person matchmaking companies
Most matchmaking companies use professional matchmakers who work closely with clients in-person to get a good sense of their personalities and with whom they would pair well.
Hybrid ‘customer-driven’ matchmaking companies
A few matchmaking companies do the in-person interviews and then are more customer-driven after the initial interview. They offer an Internet-based platform on which customers can browse through potential matches and make contact themselves.
Compatibility algorithm companies
Matchmaking companies are moving toward using computer-based algorithms to match potential partners. They gather information about clients from their initial online screening and interview and match them based on personality (stated and inferred) and preferences, and then use a pre-programmed system to match up the best potential pairs.
Who is searching for matchmakers?
Single people looking for a relationship
Single people who are looking for a relationship can turn to a matchmaker to find a good pairing. Many matchmakers have a reasonable selection of customers interested in a committed partnership. Ask the matchmaker to show you how many people they have in their database in your desired age range, and look at testimonials.
Divorcees or widows looking for new love
Adults who have ended one relationship and are looking for a new partnership, but have been out of the dating pool for many years, are good candidates for matchmakers. Matchmakers can pair them with the right pool of singles looking for partners in their age range, and they can benefit greatly from the pre-date guidance and post-date feedback.
People who are new in town
A particularly good use of matchmakers is with people who are new in town. The benefit is greater to them than to locals because even if they don’t make a great long term match on a date, they’ve expanded their social world. People who are new to a geographic area who want to meet more people like them can use a matchmaking firm for this purpose and hopefully find a longer term match as well.
It's Just Lunch! is a matchmaking service that caters to professionals who would like to meet over lunch or drinks. This service has over 23 years of matchmaking experience.
- Uses professional matchmakers: Rather than leaving meetings up to chance, matchmakers meet with users for a confidential interview. They then match users based on the information discussed during this meeting.
- All matches take place at partner restaurants: It's Just Lunch! sets up dates at local restaurants they are partnered with, taking the stress out of deciding where to have the first date.
- Focus on privacy: Prior to the first meeting, users are only given their date's first name, description and reason why the matchmaker thinks the date will work out.
- Users can give feedback on every date: Whether a date works out or it is a dud, matchmakers want to hear what happened and follow up after every date to fine tune the dating process based on the user's experience.
- Matchmakers can be found worldwide: No matter where users are in the world, they can make a date through It's Just Lunch!
- Best for: People seeking a long-term relationship, people with hectic schedules and people new to the area.
Events & Adventures offers a unique take on the traditional concept of matchmaking. By adding in the element of adventure, this dating company works to take the nerves out of any first date.
- Group meetings: Events & Adventures makes a first date experience more like a social club. Everyone involved meets up for a fun activity and gets to know each other under easygoing circumstances.
- Vetting process: Meeting someone for the first time is filled with uncertainty. With Events & Adventures, participants know that the person they meet is who they say they are. A complete vetting prior to any adventure helps ensure a safe and fun time.
- Dating for introverts: In most dating situations, the extroverts get all the attention, but this unique dating service works just as well for the introverts out there. It allows a group of people to meet and interact naturally, removing the stress of the dating atmosphere.
- Activity variety: Put the dinner and a movie model out of your mind when you sign up with Events & Adventures. They offer 30-50 great event choices each month.
- International adventures: Where most dating services feel they've done their job after the first date, Events & Adventures works to keep the fun going all around the world. Participants can enjoy local activities and international travel, all with a group of like-minded adults.
- Best for: People seeking long-term relationships, people seeking fun activities and those looking to meet new friends.
Master Matchmaker is operated by Joann and Steve Ward. The mother-son duo hosted and produced Tough Love on VH1 and cowrote Crash Course in Love. Master Matchmaker offers dating coaching and matchmaking services to help singles find dating happiness. The full-service matchmaking service is available in all 50 states.
- Free consultation: Master Matchmaker offers a free consultation to all interested clients. They’ll help you figure out if the service is right for you, and, if so, which services you need. The consultant can discuss pricing with you during the consultation.
- Background checks: To be accepted as a Master Matchmaker client, you have to pass a criminal background check. You’ll know everyone they set you up on a date with has undergone the same screening, so you can feel comfortable and safe on your dates.
- Guaranteed dates: Master Matchmaker guarantees you’ll be introduced to eligible partners when you sign up for their dating service. You’ll see pictures and profiles of potential dates before you’re introduced.
- Nationwide service: Master Matchmaker has dating coaches and clients all across the United States. Visit the website and complete a short interest form to have someone contact you with details about the dating coach nearest you.
- Dating coaching: Master Matching offers dating coaching services to help ensure success in your dating life. You will have regular coaching sessions, and your coach will be available to help you with questions and concerns between sessions.
- Best for: people seeking long-term relationships, people who are new in town and people looking for a dating coach.
Lifemates is a dating service for people in Canada and has helped Canadians get together for over 20 years.
California Singles helps people in California find dates and long-term partners. This site matches people in almost all major California cities, using a professional matchmaker.
Kelleher is a matchmaking company that has been in business for nearly 30 years and is headquartered in the Boston area. The company has been making matches since 1986 and have an impressive clientele list that includes accomplished actors and athletes.
eLove is a dating service that is headquartered in Newton, Massachusetts. The company was developed by the former CEO of LoveAccess.com.
Selective Search is a matchmaking company that was founded in 2000. The company is considered to be the largest luxury dating service In North America.
Elite Matchmaking is a matchmaking service that has been in business for 22 years. The company operates in Beverly Hills, Houston, San Diego, San Francisco, Boston, Orange County, Fort Lauderdale, D.C. and New York.
Information in this guide is general in nature and is intended for informational purposes only; it is not legal, health, investment or tax advice. ConsumerAffairs.com makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from its use.