Friday's report by the U.S. Labor Department showing a sharp drop in the Consumer Price Index (CPI) is, at first glance, good news for consumers.
The December CPI fell 0.4%, largely on the steep drop in gasoline prices. That gave consumers who drive cars a nice end-of-the-year bonus.
But consumers who don't drive a car didn't fare nearly as well. And even motorists had to give back some of their fuel savings when they sat down at the dinner table.
Rising food prices
While the government's gasoline index plunged 9.4% – a massive one-month decline – the food index rose 0.3%, the largest jump since September. Drilling deeper into the food index we see that food consumed at home also rose 0.3%, as 5 of the 6 major grocery store food groups were more costly.
The cost of dairy and related products increased by the largest amount, rising 0.6% after declining slightly in November. Fruits and vegetables also cost more. The fresh vegetables index rose 2.4%, negating a 1.3% decline for fresh fruit.
Prices for meats, poultry, fish, and eggs all went up. The index for other food at home increased 0.3% while the cereals and bakery products index advanced 0.2%.
Give and take
In short, it cost less to drive to the grocery store but cost more to fill up the cart when you got there. And this is not just a one-off in December. The government statistics show the cost of food prepared and consumed at home has risen 3.7% over the last 12 months.
It also cost more to eat at restaurants. The index for food consumed away from home rose 0.3% in December on the heels of a 0.4% increase in November, and has risen 3.0% over the last year.
Other items, in addition to food, were more costly in December. Even though oil and gasoline prices were lower, people heating their homes with natural gas paid 1.5% moe last month. Homes using electricity – and that's about all of them – paid 0.8% more.
It cost more to put a roof over your head, with rents and owners' equivalent rent and lodging away from home all rising 0.2%.
It cost more to go to the doctor in December, with medical care rising 0.5%. The index for prescription drugs rose 0.9% and the hospital services index increased 0.5%.
Air travel and used cars cheaper
Was anything else besides gasoline cheaper? Sure. If you bought a used car or truck, took a trip on an airline, bought some clothing, selected a new sofa for the living room or restocked the liquor cabinet, you saved a little money.
But to say that inflation plunged in December, as the headlines proclaimed? Not really, at least not for most consumers.