Our one-year test of the electrically powered Chevrolet Volt ended a few weeks ago but it's been so enjoyable -- and economical -- we're likely to keep the car for at least another year, even though our test pales in comparison to Erick Belmer of Ohio, who has piled up 200,000 miles on his 2012 Volt.
According to Clean Technica, Belmer drives so much that he routinely exhausts the battery and runs on the back-up gas engine. Even so, he has achieved an average of 60 miles per gallon over the last two years, all with no breakdowns, repairs or noticeable loss of capacity in the battery.
Belmer loves his car and so do many of the Volt owners we've run across in our year of driving electrically. Several have volunteered that it's the best car they've ever had.
I'm not certain I would go quite that far but I can't really think of any of the other 31 cars I've owned or leased that were any better, and certainly none that achieved anything like the average 84 MPG that I racked up in 2014. Perhaps a more meaningful figure is the average cost per mile, which came out to a whopping 4.24 cents, not counting electricity. This chart shows the total year's activity:
DATE | GALS | $ | MI |
12/31 | 9.00 | $0.00 | 0 |
1/8 | 8.20 | $32.44 | 592 |
5/23 | 5.00 | $21.00 | 1341 |
5/25 | 7.40 | $33.00 | 2174 |
5/31 | 8.00 | $34.32 | 2528 |
7/3 | 1.50 | $6.60 | 2761 |
7/19 | 2.00 | $8.81 | 3282 |
7/19 | 5.70 | $25.03 | 3405 |
8/21 | 5.40 | $21.71 | 3663 |
10/9 | 4.00 | $16.03 | 4182 |
10/13 | 4.00 | $15.14 | 4566 |
12/27 | 8.30 | $29.25 | 5727 |
| 68.50 | $243.33 | 5727 |
| | | |
MPG | | | 83.61 |
$/Mi | | | $0.04 |
If I had driven those 5727 miles in my 2013 Volkswagen Tiguan, which barely gets 21 miles per gallon, I would have burned through about 272 gallons of premium gas. At an average of $3.50 per gallon in my neighborhood, that would have cost me $952, or 16 cents a mile.
It's true I have not accounted for the cost of the electricity consumed by the Volt. That's mostly because our electricity bills have been much lower than the previous year, thanks largely to our converting to LED lights and replacing an aging heat pump, so the energy used by the Volt has simply been undetectable.
GM this week is unveiling the 2016 Volt, which is expected to have several improvements, including enhanced regenerative braking and other upgrades that will improve its efficiency even further.
Quibbles & pluses
So why doesn't everybody rush out and buy a Volt? Well, for one thing, it's a little on the small side when it comes to seating. The Volt seats only four people. The battery intrudes into the passenger compartment to such an extent that a large hump down the middle divides the seating areas rather decisively. GM has disguised the hump with cup holders and so forth but there's no question that seating is tight.
The car is designed to squeeze every last mile out of each speck of energy, which results in an aerodynamic design that includes a sharply raked windshield and a very low roof.
I'm just 6 feet tall, which is pretty average for an American male, and it's hard for me to get into the Volt without cracking my head on the roof. Once seated, two very large roof pillars intrude into the driver's field of vision; you really need to be careful turning corners lest pedestrians or bicyclists wind up in your lap.
Cargo space is tight but like most hatchbacks, the Volt will hold a lot more than you'd expect. On a recent trip to New York, we had much more luggage than usual thanks to a family member having endured a recent knee replacement. We tried to load bags, wheelchair, walker and other paraphernalia into the Tiguan -- which, after all, is supposed to be a mini-SUV. No dice.
We lugged everything over to the Volt and a few minutes later, glided off towards the Beltway.
The common wisdom is that the Volt is a good city car but not so great on the highway. This is not true, at least in my book. I find the Volt to be a fun car for road trips. It accelerates instantly and smoothly, handles well and is quite comfortable in a solid sort of way.
In the kind of gridlock that prevails in the D.C. area, the Volt is a godsend. This car loves to creep. There's none of the jerky, stop-and-go stuff you get with a spritely gas-powered car. The Volt brings a zen-like attitude to crawling along at 3 mph.
About those freebies
A final word of caution: If you're counting on the much-advertised $7,500 income tax credit that is supposed to entice you to go electric, be careful. I didn't get the credit for 2013 because my accountant had not handled the procedure before and did not file the proper forms. He thinks -- thinks, mind you! -- that he can file an amended return and maybe -- maybe! -- get the money but doesn't sound very confident.
I don't know about you but I consider $7,500 to be a little more than walking around money. So review everything and be sure you know exactly what you need to do to get the tax credit if you decide to Volt up. Here are a couple of places to start: IRS Form 8936 and a posting on an enthusiast's blog. Most improtant: talk to your account before you buy the car and make sure he has reviewed the process thoroughly and knows what needs to be done to pry the money loose from the government.
And finally, check around to see if there are local and state tax incentives. California and other western states tend to have reduced licensing fees for plug-ins and some also require utilities to provide discounted electrical rates. Some states allow hybrids in the carpool lanes on busy freeways.
None of this (except, sometimes, the carpool lane exemption) happens in Virginia, where my Volt lives. In fact, until last year, Virginia had a special hybrid tax of $60 or so. It was supposed to make up for the fact that hybrids don't use as much gas and therefore don't pay their share of highway maintenance.
Fairfax County, which sees itself as a suburban environmentalist's nirvana, hit me with a $1,000 personal property tax bill for the Volt, just to thank me for helping to clean up its ozone-filled atmosphere. And Dominion Resources, the local utility, does exactly zip to make life easier for plug-in owners. Discounted rates, cheaper overnight energy, separate meters? Forget it.
In other words, you might want to move to California before you buy a Volt. Hey, the weather's nicer anyway and there are more Trader Joe's stores.
Our one-year test of the electrically powered Chevrolet Volt ended a few weeks ago but it's been so enjoyable -- and economical -- we're likely to keep the...