First American Home Warranty Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+3 more
About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 35 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.
- HVAC tuneup
- No age limit on appliances
- Can pick your service call fee
- Not available in all states
First American Home Warranty Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (4,626)
- (1,076)
- (490)
- (322)
- (2,417)
Popular Mentions
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2019
I have used First American twice. Once for a leaky toilet and once for a garbage disposal. They were extremely prompt in arranging repairs and their contractors were timely and provided excellent service. I highly recommend their services. Their customer service representative was polite and informative.
Hi John, thank you for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2019
Technician (from Sears) was on time on date assigned. He did a thorough inspection (refrigerator) and concluded that parts were needed. He then called FAHMB, ordered the parts, and scheduled an appoint to return. The earliest was 30 days later. Parts arrived within a week or two. Showed up on the scheduled appoint day, and fixed it. He meticulously took his time and cleaned the area after done. Nice, courteous and very professional man. This is the second time a person from Sears comes to my home. I’m very happy.
Hi Rose, we appreciate your review and thank you for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2019
First American took care of my issue (water heater leak) quickly on a holiday. I spoke to a representative who assigned a company while we were on the phone. The company contacted me immediately and were there the next morning. The problem was resolved. The company they assigned was excellent and the service tech answered all of my questions.
Thank you Jeri for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2019
Updated on 02/07/2019: Still having issues getting my problem resolved, in the meantime they are still sending us false billing!! No use to call because the “supervisors” never are actually in the loop and none of the customer service reps note your account.
Original Review: I wish I could give 0 stars. Let me start off as I AM A LICENSED REAL ESTATE AGENT AND I WILL NEVER RECOMMEND FIRST AMERICAN TO ANY CLIENTS. Please do not waste time or money on them. I live in Arizona where it gets incredibly hot, our air conditioning went out in mid summer time. Extremely dangerous especially since I have a baby at home. They refused to send someone out right away or even that week!!!
Anyways they eventually sent someone out and the guy went off on how he ** hated First American and took off without fixing. At this point I’m very upset, the lady on the phone said she would get someone else out and waive the fee. Months later get a letter threatening that we owe them. I called and the supervisor conveniently couldn’t find our call even though when you call they say it’s been recorded. DO NOT ATTACH YOUR NAME TO THIS COMPANY.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2019
I got a First American home warranty plan and everything about it looks good. I liked their re-key service and a lot of their coverage stuff is reasonably priced. Submitting claims with them has been good so far. I called them once and I learned that one can file claims electronically and not have to call anybody. I then got their app, went online, and set up a profile. I've also had excellent interactions with the techs that have come to my home. They talk you through what's wrong and what should be done. They also have good tips for you for future maintenance.
Thank you Aaron for your feedback. We look forward to servicing you in the future!
Updated review: Jan. 31, 2019
The company has reached out to me after posting the review and indicated that their previous decision to deny my claim has been reversed. Cash compensation or replacement were offered and I chose cash compensation as I have already purchased a replacement online.
Original Review: Jan. 30, 2019
I bought this warranty when I purchased my house June 2018 thinking that it was a reputable company, However I was quickly proven wrong. This company works with contractors who know that if they approve too many claims, they will be replaced with others that will be more willing to assign the blame to the customer to save the company money and so they play ball to keep their business.
When we first moved in I noticed that the upstairs AC cannot cool the upstairs; the temperature doesn't go below 76 and therefore the AC stays constantly on if I set it to 73 making my bill almost $400. I filed a claim and the contractor came out, all they did look at it and say everything looks good but nothing changed. No repairs were made. Called them again after the problem persisted and another technician from the same company came out, they then discovered that the previous technician didn't service the unit properly and that he caused it to leak Freon so they replaced that and said it should now be ok. The unit did not improve, they won't replace it and I ended up paying out of pocket to replace the AC.
Now move to 2019, our microwave won't heat anymore, so I placed a claim and the technician came out and I paid him my $75.00 deductible, he told me that the "switches misfired" causing the main board and other parts to be damaged and that he will send his report to the company. I called First American 2 days later only to be told that the claim was denied because the microwave was damaged due to grease. I asked to speak to a supervisor who said that grease got inside the unit and I explained to him that it is an over the range microwave, I have no control if greasy smoke from what we cook on the stove seeped in it from the underside and that we use the vent feature.
It was late and the contractor was gone so he couldn't get more clarification from him. Called the next day and they talked to the contractor, now the story has changed to "grease got into the heating unit from food you cooked inside the microwave". We always use a splatter guard on our food and we mainly use the microwave to heat coffee. I explained that to him and that I only owned the house for 7 months, I couldn't be responsible for how the previous owners used their appliance. If I am responsible you can easily claim that anything that goes wrong was due to fault of the previous owners and having a warranty is absolutely useless.
Oh your water heater went out/the previous owners didn't maintain it, your AC went out/there wasn't yearly maintenance done on it. Sorry. This is a scam and people should stay away from it, you still pay $75.00 for them to come out and they will whatever they can to deny your claim and it is not cheap either at $600/year.
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2019
Our hot water heater stopped working. Service technician came out and said we needed replacement of our 65 gallon unit. He also said FAHW won't like that b/c 65s aren't made anymore and we would need an 80 gallon. FAHW stated they would only provide us with a 50 gallon tank. When asked why we are being down-graded to 50 gallons over what we have of 65, we were told they would put in a mixing valve to make it more comparable to what we have; we were also told it would be 7-10 business days before the work was done...so no hot water for over a week in the winter.
After calling several plumbers, we were advised not to use the mixing valve because it requires setting the temperature on the unit to a much higher temperature therefore increasing the temperature of the water that comes out which was advised not to do with young children in the home (which we have). When I stated this concern to FAHW, they stated there was nothing they could do but they could provide me with a cash out option of $470 for total replacement, installation and removal and permit. The county permit cost alone is $170 which is required.
They stated their total cost was $300 for removal of the old unit, the new unit itself and installation. When I stated I felt they were taking advantage and trying to force us to take a ridiculous buyout offer rather than having to wait for over a week for hot water, I was told that was a fair price. That price doesn't even cover the cost of the unit let alone any installation and permit. When I re-stated my concern over the mixing valve and the safety of my young children, I was told they understand my concern and there was nothing they could do because I was being provided an option...they were sorry I didn't like the mixing valve option.
Hello Amanda,
Our records indicate you accepted a cash payment of $457.77 in lieu of the water heater replacement on January 31, 2019. Upon further review, we revised the cash payment to include the permit and mixing valve. Please be advised, you will receive your check in seven to ten days. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2019
My claim with First American started on 01/04/2019 with a Fridge that did not work. The first technician that came out to fix it actually broke it further and voided my manufacturer warranty. Now 25+ days I still have a broken. I have gone through 6 technicians and they keep scheduling them to come out and try and fix it. The last two technicians cancelled prior to even coming out stating they would not work on my fridge due to the type of gas involved. I have a family of 6 in my house and not living with a fridge is unacceptable living conditions. First American still refuses to purchase a new fridge for me as the technician that they sent out the first time did not fix it, actually made it worse and voided my warranty. Worst Experience ever!
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2019
We were having problems with our air conditioner and I had to fix it myself and pay for it. It was $500 for a $17 part. My best friend has had First American for years and he has been telling me to get a home warranty so, I got them. I could call First American to submit a claim but I usually file the claim online. Then, somebody would call me. First American would always check back to make sure the contractor got with me if it was done and if it was still in the works. They stayed on top of it.
We had a vent fan in the bathroom that went out and it caught fire. When I called in for the warranty, they said they would send somebody. I tossed the parts and didn't have them so, they couldn't do anything about it. If they told me to hold on to the parts because they were gonna need them, that would have helped. That was my fault but it would have been better if it was clearer. Nevertheless, the technicians were all fantastic. We had them come out at 8 o’clock at night before. Sears was the guy that came out late when our range went down the day before thanksgiving which was nice. He couldn't fix it but he still came out just to see if he could and it was cool. I’ve had several people sign up with First American.
Hi Brenon for your review, we appreciate it.
Updated review: April 11, 2019
After my review, First American Home Warranty did reach out to me and helped resolve the issue. Although I appreciate the final resolution, it should not have taken this long and such significant effort to get the attention and resolution for my concern.
Original Review: Jan. 29, 2019
I have been trying to resolve an issue with my dishwasher since September 2018. The top rack in my dishwasher does not move in and out of the dishwasher properly. I called First American twice to ensure this was covered under my warranty. I was told it was and had an appointment scheduled. The first appointment that was scheduled, no one showed up. I had to call and reschedule. When the technician did show up, he looked at my dishwasher and told me there was nothing he could do to resolve the issue with the dish rack. I have been calling First American for months trying to get this resolved, but I never get a straight answer. I have spoken to representatives that say my service fee will be waived (since nothing was fixed) and to call back in 24-48 hours to confirm. When I call back, I am told there is no record of the previous conversation. Then I am very rudely told I must pay the service fee even though the issue will not be resolved.
I have no problem paying the fee if I get the service I was promised and the issue is fixed. However, this does not seem to be the goal of First American. They just want me to pay the fee and then figure out some other way to fix my dishwasher. I have yet to be able to speak with someone who can actually help me. When I ask to speak to a supervisor or a manager, I am told one is not available and that I will receive a callback. I never get a call back and just continue the cycle of calling and trying to explain the situation to a new person. The customer representatives are not helpful and are very rude. I don't think this company cares about actually doing the work but rather just making money off the service fee. The entire experience has been very unprofessional and I will not be renewing our warranty with this company.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2019
Updated on 03/02/2019: 1st American initially put their stated position on this blog ("that we are not required to comply with HOA guidelines") in Jan 2019. When I pointed it out to them that they were publishing a legally flawed position on-line they removed that comment on-line and marked this complaint as "resolution in process." Thankfully I previously requested and also have a written letter from their H.O. for use in Court/suit once my medical situation improves (written by Alexandria ** in their claim evaluation department, 11/18). If others have been wronged in this same manner get in-touch for possible class action.
Original Review: We submitted a claim for a failed AC in 2017. 1st AM sent out teams of repair techs in 2017-2018, all failed to correct the problem. After over 1 year (in AZ temps) they acknowledged that it couldn't be fixed and replaced the unit. The unit they installed is not the correct size physically (too high) and it is nonconformant to our HOA CC&Rs (too high above roofline). 1st AM refuses to correct the issue and says that they are not responsible to conform to HOA rules and denies responsibility to correct this issue (their position is flawed).
We have been advised that HOA legal proceedings will commence against us shortly unless we install a correctly sized unit. We are going to have to purchase and install the correct unit at our expense. The Arizona Department of Insurance has advised us to proceed with legal action against them as their stated policy is against public policy. Do not ever purchase a warranty from this Company, they are not on your side and don't even understand what their own policy language covers. We will have to sue them even though it is the last thing we want to do.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2019
When we submitted a claim to First American, we did it over the phone and everything was okay. Everyone was very helpful with every claim that we made and I was sent technicians who were friendly and who got the job done. We had to pay a little more than expected as the springs were not covered in the warranty and it had to be purchased. We also had the contractors come out three times and after replacing the springs, the garage is still acting weird but it is beyond anyone’s control. I am satisfied with First American and I have recommended them to some of my coworkers.
Thank you Jessica for your review, we appreciate it.
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2019
My Experience with First American Home Warranty could not have possibly been any worse of an experience from start to finish. I am typically not an individual to write reviews, but my experience has been so horrific I want to save others from having to deal with the same lack of professionalism and disrespect. Please read my experience below. My installer did not show up on first scheduled visit (canceled after service window). Claim has been open since July of 2018 (current date 1/28/19). I have had to take off work over 5 times to meet installer to try and troubleshoot issue with refrigerator with no resolution. The wrong part was order several times with a month of waiting time in - between each visit only to ultimately be told that my whole unit would need to be replaced.
I was reported to collections without warning due to an outstanding $75 service fee related to the repair that was not yet completed (still not completed). After waiting months for resolution of either my refrigerator being fixed or replaced, I was told they were unable to fix the unit and it would need to be replaced. The replacement refrigerator that First American is offering me is not a suitable replacement. Not only is their recommended product a much lower caliber unit with not all the same features, but the refrigerator has the wrong dimensions and simply will not fit in my kitchen (the recommended unit is 5 inches deeper than my opening, causing it to stick out and block the walkway).
I contacted GE (manufacturer of my refrigerator) to inquire what a suitable replacement would be for my unit. After receiving email confirmation from the GE customer service representative of the correct make and model for replacement, I forwarded this correspondence to First American in hopes they would simply order the correct unit that would fit my kitchen. I was told by First American that the refrigerator they offered was the only unit they were willing to provide me and if I was unhappy with the offer that I should take a cash payout for the amount of $1100 (1/3 the value of my unit before installation fees). I explained that I would prefer if they could simply order a unit that fit my opening, as I cannot purchase a suitable replacement for that price.
The policy says that they will cover up to $2,500 for a refrigerator, but when I asked why I was not entitled to this amount to go toward the purchase of a new unit, since they cannot provide a suitable replacement with the correct dimensions, I was told because that was not the predetermined "claim value amount". I ask how this claim value amount was derived since I need a total refrigerator replacement, and the unit itself is more than the $2,500 limit that is in the contact. The First American claims resolutions specialist could not definitively explain the discrepancy in value and continued to explain that this was not going to change and I only had two options: 1) take the unit they offered that simply does not fit. 2) take the payout amount of $1,100 that will not even cover 1/3 the value of a new unit.
Overall, I cannot express enough how much I recommend to go with another insurance company that treats you fair and with respect. I am in disbelief that I have waited for over 7 months for a resolution of this claim and that I am ultimately left with paying thousands of dollars out of pocket because First American could not provide a replacement that would actually fit the opening in my kitchen. Good luck to anyone that decides to choose First American!
Hello Austin,
Our records indicate you accepted the cash payment in lieu of the replacement to your kitchen refrigerator. Please be advised, you will receive the cash payment in seven to ten days. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you
Original Review: Jan. 28, 2019
The garage door would not open due to a broken belt on the opener. The company repairing it was quick to respond after submitting the issue to FAHW on-line. FAHW was quick to contact the repairing company. I was happy with the results.
Hi Robert. We are happy to hear that your garage door opener was repaired. Thank you for your review and we look forward to servicing you in the future.
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2019
I had water dripping from the AC pipe and that created a lot of water accumulation in my backyard. I submitted a claim and they contacted me almost immediately! The technician arrived on time the following day and took care of the repair. He was very professional and provided me with valuable advice on what caused the leak and how to take care of it if it happened again. Paid $75 fee but I knew I would have paid more if I had had no home warranty. I submitted another claim just a week ago when the garbage disposal failed to turn on and I had the exact same experience. It’s time to renew and I’m definitely going to renew the policy... I would recommend this company and I would say it’s worth the $$$.
Hi Abdelghani, thank you for your review. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2019
Submitting a claim to First American has been pretty seamless and easy. I can go online and do it. I've submitted a couple of claims, and they've been pretty quick and easy. Whoever they hire to fix the thing usually calls, comes out within a couple of days, and fixes it, and it's done. Although, one contractor came and he looked at something. He said he would call back but he never called me back. I don't know if he ever let First American know what he had found. Other than that, everything's been really good.
Thank you Joshua for your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2019
I got impressed with First American due to word of mouth. Others had a good experience with them so I got the warranty for my rental property. Their reps are good and there is no complaint from the tenant. The first time a water heater broke and the guy worked really good about it. And then the second one was the ice maker on the refrigerator and my tenant got in touch with them. First American is reliable.
Thank you Carla for your feedback and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 27, 2019
Last Summer 2018, I wrote a review on this site complaining about First American Home Warranty. They had delay after delay, and no sense of urgency, which led to my waiting over a month for an air conditioner repair, in July. This time, I contacted them on a Wednesday about my water heater not heating water. They contacted the repair person who contacted me immediately and came to my home by Thursday afternoon. After assessing the problem, he determined the need for a replacement. First American approved it IMMEDIATELY and permitted the plumber to install it immediately with a unit he brought, instead of their making him and me wait until they could ship him the new unit. Amazing improvement in quality customer service! I am very pleased!
Hi Suzanne. We are glad the water heater we replaced. We look forward to servicing you in the future!
Reviewed Jan. 27, 2019
I submit claims to First American both online and over the phone. They make it convenient both ways but it's simpler online because the response is quick. The staff has been good and helpful. When I’m concerned about something, I usually give them a call and they answer my questions right away. I tell all my friends and family about it.
When I had a plumbing emergency, they bent over backwards trying to find a plumber that will come out to the area. They didn’t stop until they found one and they kept me in the loop on what they were doing. The technicians who came to the house were pleasant and professional. They explained to me what they did step by step. I worked with the contractor who replaced the AC system and I saw what they were doing. They were very knowledgeable. I’ve been with First American for at least 15 years and the quality of their work has been good. They've been open, honest, helpful and all the things that the consumer looks for in the company.
Thank you Byron for taking the time to provide us with your feedback. We look forward to servicing you in the future.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
I been six months and counting for them to replace or fix my garage door opener. They sent all these people out to see my door. All of them crooks. Trying to get paid on the side for some things I don't need. They sent out 4 different techs with 4 different diagnostic. Now they are saying they not going to cover. Would give them zero stars if possible.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
We put in a service order for a built in microwave in October. It is now the end of January. We have had four service calls for the same problem. It is still not repaired. The last person came on Thursday and was here for over three hours and left at almost 10:00pm. When he left, not only was our microwave not working, but we are now without an oven (they are a built-in unit)!! We have been patient, but this is ridiculous!! We just spoke with a service representative and were told that they have to wait until Monday to talk with the service technician to see what he did on Thursday night. I am absolutely dissatisfied with this company and their inability to live up to their claim to provide quality service when we need it the most. Now I want to know who is going to cover the cost of a family of 5 eating out for the next who knows how long until this gets resolved!!
Hello Lori. We will have a representative be in contact with the contractor holder regarding the microwave claim. Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
Service call for leaking water heater, service was requested on Sunday evening, tech was dispatched on the following Monday afternoon. Water heater needed to be replaced. Replacement was completed on Wednesday of the same week. Service was fast, well done and very professional.
Thank you Lucille for your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
I had a problem with my Electric Double Oven. The display was not working. The technician came and he said one of the module is not working and needs to be replaced. After some search the technician said that the part is not available and hence whole double oven needs to be replaced. That took some time to find the replacement that will fit in the wall opening. The oven was replaced and the technician did a wonderful job in fitting the oven.
Thank you for your review Indru and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
Refrigerator wasn’t cooling properly unit was replaced due to techican coming out to replace a bad part but the part ordered was bad. Customer service asked were we satisfied. No was the answer so the refrigerator was condemned... So we were asked to purchase one online or go buy one. So we bought a new refrigerator and a replacement check was mailed out.
Thank you Michael for taking the time for provide a review. We appreciate it.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
First American Home Warranty has always responded very promptly and professionally. I have never had any complaints and they make sure to follow up on service. I know if something fails and I am not sure if it is covered they can check it for me. I recommend this to everyone.
Thank you Diane for your feedback and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
American Home warranty resolved my issue within timeframe and replaced the same when warranted. The top management is very efficient. I recommend to others based on my experience. There were initial issues but resolved. Thanks the team of this company.
Hi Ishwar, thank you for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
We could not be more pleased with the level of service, communication and follow up we received. We had previously been with an American competitor who said they would Shield our Home and the service was terrible. We had a claim with First American and I was pleased with their service. From filing the claim through to checking our satisfaction they were timely, professional, courteous and easy to work with. If you are looking for a Home Warranty look no further - First American should be your first and last stop!
Thank you Jeff for your review.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
The Indoor Blower Motor quit working on my AC/Heater unit, thus I had no heat in the middle of the winter. Called up First American Home Warranty and they got right on it. The company sent was fast, courteous and appeared to know what they were doing.
Thank you Jody for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
My garage door sounded like an explosion, and it was my spring that broke in half. I called in the morning, and by 1:00pm the garage door person was there and took 30 minutes to fix. The door wouldn't open and he was great, polite, and a lifesaver, It feels great to know that I could pick up the phone and get something done right away.
We appreciate your feedback, Patricia.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2019
I've been very happy with the support and service that I have received from First American Home Warranty. Whenever I call in and submit a claim, they have been very responsive and they have solved the problem every time. I've also had very positive and wonderful interactions with the technicians they've sent out.
Hi Keith, thank you for your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2019
This garage door had a mind of its own. First it locked me out while I was gardening, then began to open of its own accord at 2 a.m. I called First American Warranty first thing in the morning, and they set me up with a service person two days in the future. In the meantime, I kept the electricity off in the garage to keep the door from opening. It only took the service person from Sears a few minutes to fix. He told me what I could do in the future to make the door quieter, and suggested several things I could do. I'm so grateful for this warranty!
Hi Helene. Thank you for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2019
Repair leak from garbage disposal - Company was great with the technician that performed the work. They introduced themselves and explained what was the issue and what they were going to do. The company guaranteed that everything was going to work great and that if anything goes wrong to call them and they will fix it.
We appreciate your review William. Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2019
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2019
We had a plumbing issue and when we submitted a claim with First American, things went perfectly. It was very easy to contact them, to follow up, and to get somebody out here. In fact, the contractor came out almost within a few hours. Initially, we weren’t sure if we had a clog in our septic line and that was what it turned out to be. At the time, the toilet wouldn’t flush and the bathtub was backing back up when I did the laundry. So, when the tech came in, he cleaned out the line and everything’s perfect now. He fixed the problem immediately and was out of here in no time flat. It was great and so far, our experience with First American has been terrific.
Thank you Barbara for taking the time to provide us with a review. We appreciate it and look forward to servicing you in the near future.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2019
I originally called my claim (that I was without heat) in on December 12, 2018. I had to call First American about four times and each time had to explain the situation to the new staff member I was talking to - action item: keep better notes on your claims files when your customers have to call in and go through it every single time like it’s new, it’s frustrating and comes across as unprofessional. The first HVAC company (Accent Comfort Services) that First American sent out was extremely unprofessional and uninformed - the technician tried to tell me I needed to have a plumbing pipe moved before any work could be done to fix the heating unit.
At my expense and sacrifice of time I had a plumber come out and say it wasn’t necessary. The licensed plumber spoke to First American on my behalf and was told, that since their vendor said it needed to be done they had to go by that. When I called First American about the anticipated cost out of my pocket - they quoted that it would be an estimated $1200 dollars out of my pocket to fix the unit (uncovered by the warranty). Once again at my time and expense (I had to take a day off work and get two more contractors to come out - another plumber and another HVAC company), I was told that the pipe (which would have cost $700-1400 to move) did not need to be moved. My second plumber sent pictures and a synopsis to my First American, and got on the phone with me to talk to First American.
The CSR we talked to was once again not familiar with the claim (even though I had call several times at this point) and finally said that since two licensed plumbers agreed the pipe didn’t need to be moved, that they would send out a second opinion HVAC company (Total Air Care). When the second HVAC technician - (who was great) came out he said the first technician had ordered an $800 motor that wasn’t necessary, and that the unit could absolutely be fixed and he put in the order for the parts - this was on December 15th, so I’d been without heat for four days. He said the part should come in in a few days. I followed up every day the next week with Total Air Care’s Parts department, and each day they said the part (an evap coil) was two to three days out, I don’t understand in this day and age when everything can be tracked, how it took so long.
They finally got the part in and I was scheduled to have the technician come out 12/22 - so another week without heat. Dakota came back out, and said he was so sorry but the wrong part had been ordered. The HVAC company and First American both said the other had messed up and ordered the wrong heat, but once again I was without heat for another week. They got the correct part in, and scheduled me to have a technician (Technician "O" not first technician, because I wasn’t going to wait another weekend to get on Dakotas schedule). Technician "O" got there, was super unhelpful, had only been there for about twenty minutes and said that the part wouldn’t fit and they’d have to get it ordered again - another week without heat.
At this point I was extremely frustrated with First American and the HVAC company. My First American Claims representative, L.I., was not helpful at all, she was reactive rather than proactive. I ended up doing her job and calling and following up with the HVAC company because I didn’t trust her to prioritize my claim and give it the urgency it deserved, because at this point I was without heat for 3 weeks. I even called to talk to her supervisor to discuss what First American should do for me since every point of this process had been so mishandled, and I’d had to take one full day and about 12 hours on different days off work to meet the contractors and technicians and it still wasn’t fixed.
I was told the most they could do was refund the original $75.00 service fee I paid to the first company. Nothing else. They were super unhelpful and I was extremely irritated with their lack of service and options, especially considering the length of time that had gone on with my heat still being out. Total Air Care finally got the correct evap coil in, and schedule Dakota to come out and fix it. When he came out they discovered the drain pan didn’t fit and that they would need to order one this was 1/9/19, he promised me I’d be on the schedule for Friday and this would be the last time. I called the HVAC company to get on the schedule and they said they couldn’t schedule me until the part was in, and when the part finally came in they tried to push me to the next week.
I followed up with several staff members and supervisors until they put me on the schedule for Friday. During this back and forth I had tried to reach out to my claims representative, L.I., but she never responded and her out of office was out of date. When I finally heard from her she said that she had been in the hospital, and apparently no one at First American was keeping up with her messages or files. Technician "D" finally came back out on 1/11/19 and fixed the unit. Lisa called and said she had been following up with the HVAC company through the process, which I didn’t believe and didn’t make any difference to me because I’d been advocating for weeks for myself because of the lack of responsiveness and service continually shown for First American employees at every level.
Ways your company could improved: When customers call reclaims, your CSRs should keep detailed notes so they don’t have to repeat themselves on each and every call. Get better vendors to do the work, one vendor was a crook for all internet’s and purposes and the other seemed to be incompetent with scheduling/parts management. Train your management and claims representatives on responsiveness. Give management avenues to compensate/affirm when customers have been seriously underserved. Buy the quality parts the first time, don’t nickel and dime your vendors because that contributed to the wrong part being ordered multiple times.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2019
This company doesn't honor their contract with the homeowner. They breach their contract with the homeowner. They won't replace or repair a broken appliance and their reason is nowhere in the contract as being a valid reason to deny a claim. In fact, our contract stipulates that the appliance be repaired or replaced based on the part that is broken, however they will not abide by the contract. They have terrible customer service and terrible business practices.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2019
We bought our house a month ago and the seller purchased the upgraded warranty package for us. A couple weeks after moving into the house the dishwasher stopped working. We put in a claim for the repair. A technician came out two days later to work on the dishwasher. My husband was home with me and the technician refuse to talk to me and kept telling my husband how awful wives and women are (right in front of me). He then proceeded to tell us he couldn’t replicate the problem with the dishwasher and left.
The next day the dishwasher still was not working so we called and asked that the technician be sent back out. The same technician arrived and this time was able to find the problem and ordered parts to repair the dishwasher. He scheduled an appointment for a week later to come put the parts in that he had ordered. The day he was supposed to show up I took off work and sat home all day. He never called or texted to say he was on his way. At the end of the day there was a note on my door saying that he had come and I hadn’t been home.
We had specifically told him to call or text because we do not have a doorbell and cannot hear if someone knocks unless we are in the very front room of the house and I certainly could not be expected to sit in the very front room of the house all day waiting for him. When we called the home warranty company they told us that he claimed he did not have our number even though he had called us on the two previous occasions that he had come out. When I mentioned that to her she said she had called me and I had not answered the phone.
I asked her to please send the tech back out and she told me she would and that she would call me back with a time. She never called me back. When my husband came home he called and complained and told them to send a new repairman. Two days later a new repairman came and spent the whole time complaining that they had sent him to do a job that required replacing parts all while talking on the phone to his friends. When he left, he left a big pile of trash in the middle of my kitchen floor and in that pile of trash was one of the brand new parts that was supposed to be replaced, still in the box.
When we called the home warranty company. They said that the repairman said that he had replaced it. When we told them that we had the part and the box both with matching serial numbers she said that he could not actually replace it (even though she had just said he had replaced it) because he had found damage from roaches from the previous owner and that voided our warranty. He lied and told her that it was the dishwasher was full of roaches and it was absolutely not. She then told us she was denying the claim.
We absolutely do not have a pest problem and there is nothing in the warranty that would state that roaches would void a claim. This company is shady, lies, and does everything they can to avoid honoring your claim. I am incredibly disappointed in the customer service and in the technicians that have been sent to do the work, and I still don’t have a working dishwasher.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2019
We moved into an older home which needed work on several different appliances. First American arranged for servicemen who were prompt and capable. The service didn't cover everything we thought or would have liked but it was still a good value.
Hi Dennis. Thank you for the review. We appreciate you taking time from your day to let us know how we are doing. We look forward to servicing your next claim.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2019
I've been with First American Home Warranty for five years now and they have provided me with great service, reasonable cost, and quick responses. Submitting a claim with them has been extremely easy. I do it online and I usually get a response within 24 hours. Most of the time, the techs that have come out have also been very responsive and informative. We’ve only had one issue before but other than that, everything else has been very good.
HI John. Thank you for the review. We appreciate you taking time from your day to let us know how we are doing. Have a great day.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
This is the worst warranty service EVER. Long wait times for a claim and right now I have RUNNING WATER COMING FROM A TUB FAUCET and they can't get any plumber to come within 5 days??? I could have a plumber here today to repair it but they can’t get service for 5 days?!? UNACCEPTABLE.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
As many of the reviews I have just read indicate that it can take anywhere from 2 weeks to 2 months to get an issue resolved. Well I am still waiting and am at just shy of 8 weeks since submitting my claim. Have had 2 technicians tell me the exact same thing is wrong but NOBODY can seem to get the part to fix it! It is cold in my house because I don't have heat due to this issue and yet still no fix in sight! 2nd contractor is "hoping" that the part shows up by Friday so that it can be fixed this week... Needless to say not holding my breath!
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
My water heater is leaking and now almost flooding my house. I called FAHW and they sent out a company with awful reviews. The contractor came, said my water heater was leaking and needed to be replaced. Then after numerous phone calls and tracking FAWHW down, they told me the tech said my water heater was fine and to contact the water heater company if I had problems. The tech said my water heater was NOT leaking. He also checked my pressure regulator and said it needed to be fixed. FAHW verified that they would get that information from him. He again lied and said he doesn't evaluate pressure regulators. I asked FAHW what to do since he was obviously lying and they told me "sorry there is nothing we can do." I refused to pay the $75 service fee for the lying crook they sent out. They said I do too and again nothing they can do. Awful service. Now I have to tend to my flooding house. FAHW is useless.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
Toilet was leaking at base, contractor came in, quickly assessed the issue, showed me and explained the problem and quickly fixed the problem, and presented the invoice to me then left. He tested to make sure no leak and left, job completed. Very polite and professional.
Hi Frances. Thank you for taking the time to leave a review on your recent claim experience. We are happy to hear that your repairs we completed professionally and efficiently. We look forward to servicing your next claim.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
I bought a house and the previous owner had that insurance policy with First American. I went ahead and continued with it. Everything was good. I have no regrets. First American did what they said they were gonna do, and I’m very well-satisfied with it. I took a cash payoff instead of getting replaced. The item has been replaced. I went ahead and bought a dishwasher, and I had it installed. And I’ve got the receipts. I’m fixing to email it back, so they can put that dishwasher back on the warranty. Also, I have already told others about First American. I told them that it is a good company. I also told them that First American backs up what they say they’re gonna do. There’s no argument as far as prices and they’re very reasonable.
Thank you Luis for your review, we appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
My heat pump went out. It was 10 degrees. I needed to have it fixed quickly. I contacted the company who installed it. They have been in business for 50+ years and have an excellent reputation. But because they aren't affiliated with FAHW, they would not cover the repair. Instead they wanted me to use a company that had terrible reviews online. This warranty is a joke. Just because they use someone who is licensed does not make them reputable. I would suggest that if you want things done correctly, don't bother buying this warranty. It is a waste of money.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
I have been without heat for two months. It is 4 degrees outside. I have had three contractors state I need a new heat pump. CS is rude, unhelpful. Their out of pocket costs are ridiculous. A true nightmare! Don’t be fooled by what they say they cover. I had a rep tell me she didn’t care that I had no heat, as she lived in the Dominican Republic. My electric bill for one month was over $500 from running space heaters. I have NEVER dealt with a worse company.
Hello Diane,
Our records indicate your heat pump and air handler were installed on February 15, 2019. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2019
On my recent purchase, a toilet in our hallway bathroom would have a loud whistling noise, would auto flush and rock. Looking for a solution, I turned to First American as I saw symptoms that would cover a replacement. Once submitted and reviewed, my claim was authorized for repair. A week goes by and I jump online to check status on my ticket. Upon review I see the case was closed and a service fee due. I explain to the representative that I would not pay until the original repair that was authorized was remediated. They tell me paperwork received differs and that the authorization was by accident. The following day my toilet failed to flush. I've asked for First American to waive the service fee as I had to take the liberty of hiring elsewhere to replace the faulty toilet. They refuse and to this day, I refuse to deal with First American.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2019
Updated on 04/22/2019: Continue from previous: it is unfortunate that I have to write a follow up to my previous review. I felt it necessary to inform others. Shortly after I wrote my previous review, I was contacted immediately by First American (to their credit) in an effort to resolve my claim. They asked me for the information which I gladly provided. However, weeks went by with no response. I decided to send a follow up email to the person who initially contacted me and no reply.
A week or so later, I received a denial of my claim. Ok, so from a consumer point of view two things took place: 1) their lack of follow up and professionalism was proven the lack thereof of my claim and 2) was told the same thing as before. In retrospect, why pretend to address someone’s concerns when you will give him or her the same response as before? Perhaps a facade of the customer service they never intended to provide? You be the judge. P.S. I am not renewing my First American Home Warranty.
Original Review: I have been with First American for over 6 months thus far. Three months in I need an emergency repair. However, did not know I have emergency services since I never received a contract due to now physical mailbox. I submitted a claim and was denied based on "First American does not reimburse for work done without prior approval, this policy is available to review under the Important Section of your contract."
Please note I never received of a contract whereby I could have review the "Important Section" referenced, did not have a physical mailbox where I could have received it, No follow-up despite numerous calls and voice messages, and was hung up on by an agent when trying to express my concerns. Taken together, my claim was denied without consideration of the facts. NO follow up. No documentation when asked for prove of "administrative review." NO notices of decisions. NO willingness to consider the facts and discrepancies. In the end--BAD for your home. BAD for customers. BAD business. You choose.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2019
Beware of this company...had my heating and air conditioner on the roof replaced by one of their contractors. The installation was done improperly. The unit was not sealed to the roof and I now have a roof leak. I had a roofing contractor come to my house and he told me that my roof leak was caused by the heating and air conditioning installation. I called the contractor that First American hired to install it. They are out of business. I called First American to let them know their contractor went out of business and to see if they could get a current contractor out here. They told me it WASN’T their problem that their contractor went out of business. That I needed to hire someone to have the repairs done. They would not send a current contractor out.
Beware that they don’t stand behind the work that their contractors do if a contractor goes out of business. The 4th man I spoke to was incredibly rude, not sure how he’s a manager. His name is Julio and when I asked him for his last name he refused to give it to me and gave me his extension. It is beyond me why I should have to pay to have the unit sealed to my roof like it initially should of been. Beware.
Hello Carol,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your air conditioning claim. Our records indicate Coaches HVAC ExtraordianAir sealed the package unit which corrected the leak. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2019
The claims submission has been easy with First American. We just call and their reps are super helpful and always willing to help if there are any other needs. Then the problem we have usually gets fixed fast. The contractors come and work fast. Plus, they are very helpful. We really like First American.
Thank you Geovany. We appreciate your review!
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2019
I have First American on a home that I bought last August. Their pricing is reasonable and the service has been very good so far. They're very quick and responsive, and everything is on time. Submitting claims is also an easy process, which I do through their very user-friendly website. The technicians they've sent out have been very good and on time as well. I would definitely recommend First American.
Hi Gerard. Thank you for your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 21, 2019
I have been with FAHW for about 6 years now and have filed probably a dozen claims with no major issues. I have had my washing machine repaired twice and now am having another issue with it and call to file a new claim on it and suddenly it isn’t part of my standard “basic” plan?!? When I look at their website it clearly states that it IS covered under the basic plan!!! Buyer beware false advertisement!!!
Hello Brandy,
Our records indicate you have had a home warranty contract since November 2, 2012. Please be advised, the clothes washer and dryer coverage has always been an optional coverage which includes an additional payment. Our records indicate you never elected to have the clothes washer and dryer coverage. In addition, a clothes washer and dryer claim has never been placed under your covered property address.
First American considers this claim closed.
Reviewed Jan. 21, 2019
We had American Home Shield originally but they did a few bad things to me, so I started searching around online and I found First American. I submit claims to First American online. Basically, I deal with the reps to schedule my initial appointment. Then I receive a confirmation that the service request was received and within 24 hours, I receive the email back with the name of the company that will be servicing my appliance at home. After that, I receive a call directly from the contractor.
I talked to the reps only when the first contractor screwed up the job. They were here in the house twice or thrice but they never finished the job. But First American was involved with that issue and they found another company pretty fast. The second company that was scheduled to do the job came over, and they resolved the issue within an hour or so. I absolutely will recommend First American. They are going to be the first one on my mind before American Home Shield or any other company.
Hello Edward. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how we are doing. We appreciate and value your time.
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2019
You can't always guarantee a work order will go the way you want and your home warranty company is dependent in many ways on the quality of service providers in your area. But its great to know that your warranty company will go to bat for you when things go wrong, follow-up on issues, and communicate effectively with you so that you can make informed decisions. Even though my issue wasn't covered by the warranty this time, they still covered full price of diagnostics (the service provider tried to charge me for this when the claim was rejected).
First American called them for me and even walked them through how to submit reimbursement. I only paid the required service fee. I've used First American for 2 homes and my parents have as well on their home. Never had a claim denied - this time is made sense and turned out the seller I bought my home from ended up covering it. I highly recommend Frist American because of their transparency and follow-through when calling customer service.
Thank you Stephanie for taking the time to provide us with your feedback. We appreciate it.
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2019
I purchased a property and the sellers provided the First American Home Warranty policy for me. I've submitted claims both online and over the phone, although I feel a little more comfortable with doing it on the phone because their online response time isn’t that great. If I call and I talk with somebody, I know I've got it, while it might take a day or two to hear from them if I do it all online. I've had great service from the claims representatives.
They have people that they go to and they assign the claim to a contractor who has up to two days to get back to me, although for the most part, they’ve been faster than that and I've always been satisfied with the people that they sent out. My tenant turned up with a problem with her refrigerator on December 22nd, but the techs couldn’t get out there until January 2nd, which was a long time, and she had foods that were defrosting. First American Home Warranty had to connect with Sears. My experience with First American Home Warranty has been good.
Thank you Sandra for your feedback, we appreciate it.
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2019
We were not happy with our previous company, American Home Shield, so I looked around for other companies on the internet and it showed First American Home Warranty. Their coverage was more comprehensive than AHS. Submitting claims with First American has been great and their contractors have been okay. We had an issue with the contractor that’s supposed to fix our microwave though. They would try to fix it and then the part wouldn’t work and then it was the wrong thing. They were out here for about three times and during that period, five weeks, we were totally without a microwave oven.
Then finally, I dealt with a representative at First American and just had the whole thing replaced. But so far, everything else has been good. The air conditioning company was fine. We bought the house three years ago and it seems as though everything is going at once but we’re really happy to have First American at our back. I have recommended them to other people who talked to us about home warranty insurance and we’ve said that this company is top-notch.
Thank you Judith for your review!
Updated review: Feb. 7, 2019
FAHW reviewed the documentation that I provided and reconsidered the claim. They processed a refund to me for the repair that I paid for. I believe this could have been handled without any issues if the service provider had been accurate and truthful with the information that he provided the company! Perhaps FAHW should look into the service provider's credentials and performance.
Original Review: Jan. 19, 2019
I have had this contract for 6+ years at $760+ each year. I have called them about 5 times, each time it has taken at least two service "technician" visits to complete the repair. The last two service persons did not have "logo" on arrival car, nor on uniform. Broken latch on 14 year old dishwasher, FAHW refused claim saying not due to normal wear! Had to call another appliance repair who confirmed latch was broken due to age and normal wear! FAHW is a scam, they only want to collect their annual contract amount and send "repair" persons who only want their service fee, not to repair anything!
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2019
I recently signed up for an First American Home Warranty plan. Moved into the new home. Microwave worked briefly then broke. Invoked the policy. FAHW said they could not find a repair person and elected to pay $500 of the new purchase price of $1,500. When I questioned this the claims person stated that they have the option of paying whatever they want... "Pay towards a new microwave" was what the agent stated. So I stated..."So you will not replace the microwave; rather you will only pay less than one third of the replacement cost." The claims person read off to me the policy paragraph number where they can do this. I said I would let others know this...which I am doing now. Run Forest Run when dealing with First American Home Warranty.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2019
Manager Rodrigo just confirmed via phone that contractors only need to show up at a residence for the Warranty Holder to have to pay them. They do not need to perform any diagnostics or services. The 7th and final time I utilized the First American HVAC repair service, the contractor reviewed the issue for 10 minutes & determined that the system was simply dirty. 2 independent contractors later both confirmed that one duct had come unhooked from a vent & another duct had a hole. Very obvious to them... One of which fixed the issues on the spot (not two weeks later, see timeline below).
The First American contractors - yes, multiple, since none of them fixed the real issue - all told me that they were not allowed to make any repairs, even simple ones because they must first submit a report & schedule a second and possibly third visit to the home. Timeline: Day 1: A/C stops working. Submit request to First American. Day 2: First American responds. Day 3: Contractor calls to schedule appointment within one week. Day 10: Contractor finally "arrives at home" to force service fee from Warranty Holder. Day 11: Contractor submits report to First American. Day 12: First American approves services. Contractor calls to FINALLY schedule repairs.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2019
This is the worst experience I have ever had with a warranty company. I just finished my waiting period to begin coverage today and when I tried submitting my first claim for service for my heat it went on a hold and I was told they could not give me service based upon the ASSUMPTION this was a pre existing condition because I placed in on the first day of coverage. They would not even send a technician out to investigate if it was preexisting. They simply said they would not cover me. SO WHAT AM I PAYING FOR? Then when I try to cancel my service there is NO ONE to speak to on the phone. You have to submit by email with no response deadline so basically this company took my money and is providing no service! I have gone to BBB and now ConsumerAffairs. STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY. THEY ARE CROOKS!
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2019
Buyer beware! First American failed me in every way. It’s been 2 months since I first filed a claim to repair a heat pump. 2 months! Three contractors have been assigned to remedy the issue; still no heat. Claims advocacy service is deplorable. No call backs; communication is non-existent. First American has left a family with a newborn baby without heat in the coldest winter months and still to this day, has failed to take action. What makes it so frustrating and offensive is that I’ve been a paying customer in good standing for over 8 years, but First American has NOT reciprocated that same level of loyalty. I wish I would have chosen another home warranty company. I feel so betrayed by First American and will be researching legal channels to get compensated for my trouble and for breach of contract.
Hi Terry. We sincerely apologize for any delays or inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. We are working diligently to get your matter resolved. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2019
Sometimes First American is a little bit slow processing things. Like with the plumbing, one of the contractors that the home warranty used was Sears and we had to call them a couple of times. They would set up something, but when we called the contractor they knew nothing about it at first. Communication is the biggest thing between home warranty and the contractors. Sometimes, it's very, very slow. We had to redo the claim again and it was another day or two before we heard from Sears. But that issue has been taken care of.
The claims have also been often very good than not. We called the home warranty last week and we were able to get a plumber out to work on the issue today. The plumber wound up shooting an estimate of the work that needs to be done and now he has to contact home warranty. By the time this is done, I would say, it will take a little over a week. My wife also usually puts the claim on the computer and within 24 hours they are able to reach out to us.
Hi Ron. Thank you for the feedback regarding your recent claims. We appreciate your honesty and are always looking for ways to improve our service. We appreciate you and your business, and look forward to servicing your next claim.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2019
I received a letter advising to call to cancel in October. I called prior to my contractual year end date of 11/16/18 and asked to cancel. I was advised to cancel the auto billing which I requested on that call. I asked for a closure confirmation email or letter. Neither were available per the rep, just simply requesting the auto-bill canceling would end it. I went to their site a couple of days after my final payment and removed my credit card information. I was billed on the renewal date, 12/16/18 for a new policy/contract, which I did not authorize, my account should have been noted previously. I disputed the charge on my credit card, it was removed. I called to cancel once again 12/17/18. Was told that the account would be closed, no future payments due, and this unauthorized payment would be reversed.
I went back to the web site, logged in on 12/28/18 and the account still showed open online and next payment due on 1/16/19. Filed BBB complaint on that date. Received response that payment was reversed, nothing about a permanent closure. Again on 1/16/19 I see a charge authorization for $40 to First American on my credit card. I sign onto their website on 1/17/19. The account is now showing past due for Dec 2018 and still appears open. I replied to the existing BBB complaint. I followed the instruction of their October 2018 renewal letter to cancel the account, but they will not cancel, and now I am afraid it will impact my credit score if a delinquency on an account that I did not approve is reported. Next step is going to be small claims court, or to go to a local news agency friend to see if she can research any others having this issue in the area, and if it can be escalated in the media.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2019
Waited weeks in the hottest months of summer for the company to send out a technician. The HVAC company went to the wrong address and waived my $75 copay to make up for it. I got an invoice from the HVAC co for $0 as proof that the copay was settled. Yet First American now is claiming I need to pay the $75 to First American. 7 months later, my account has been sent to collections. I cancelled my 1 yr service with First American warranty because they are not professional and they are a waste of time. The HVAC company would be reaching out to them to clarify the misunderstanding. I don't even have an account with the home warranty, so speaking or communicating with them is useless. If they're not making money off of you, they don't want to provide the services their warranty promises.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2019
Everybody had suggested that getting a warranty is a good idea, and I wanted to make sure that the seller was selling something that they will guarantee. First American was given to us at the closing via real estate, and having it has definitely been worth it. Submitting a claim online has been excellent. It takes a day for a contractor to come out and they've been very pleasant. They explain what they're doing and what causes the problem, and they answer any questions that I have. I had issues with the top of my glass stove, and they came and replaced the whole thing for nothing.
Hi Marie. Thanks for the awesome review. We look forward to servicing your next claim.
Original Review: Jan. 16, 2019
Very bad service and do not call you back when they say they will. Attorney in my office same thing happened to him and with the seller of our home. Do not use them. Find another warranty company. Run. Don't walk.
Hello Twyla,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. Our records indicate your drain pipe was replaced on or around January 22, 2019. We consider your claim closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2019
Had a problem with my heater so a company came out to repair and ultimately replaced it but it was not done correctly. Now I have to pay a second service fee to get another company to fix the first one's mess up. Why am I being charged twice? Reporting here because there is literally nowhere to report to on their website.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2019
I called First American Home Warranty regarding a problem with my toilet on January 7, 2019. The contractor didn't call until January 10th and showed up January 12th only to let me know he couldn't fix the problem so had to order a part. The contractor called on the 15th to let me know the part wouldn't be in until the 21st so I am still without the use of a toilet. Toilets run about $99.00 at Home Depot which is pennies compared to what I pay for this policy monthly. This company is a ripoff and doesn't care about its consumers. My experience with them is horrible!!!
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2019
When I bought my house, First American was the company that the seller bought a warranty with for me. I'm in the first year and I purchased one of their policies for a rental property I own. Submitting claims has been really easy. I do it over the phone and the reps have always been great. But I had a company sent out for a tankless water heater issue and they really didn't understand the product or anything. So, First American sent me a different company that was completely familiar and knew what to do.
Then, I had an issue with the second tankless water heater. I called and they wanted to send the first people. I said they didn't seem at their expertise even in this area and asked if we could get the other company. And they would not do it. I asked for a manager and he would not do it either. Also, there was one technician from the Sears Appliance company that was extremely rude, but I told them about it and they sent someone else. Other than those, every other experience I've had with them has been above and beyond fabulous.
Thank you, Sandra! We appreciate you taking the time to leave an awesome review. We appreciate you and your business
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2019
After over 2.5 hours on the phone, terrible customer service, and wondering why I ever signed up with this company we are still without a refrigerator and it has been 17+ days and counting. They sent two companies and 3 trips to say it cannot be fixed. Both companies were late or didn't call and didn't send the report until I called them several times. Never once did a First American agent apologize for the situation, poor service, etc. I WOULD NOT RECOMMEND First American for a Home Warranty!
Hello Bryan,
Our records indicate you accepted a cash payment in lieu of the replacement to your kitchen refrigerator. Please be advised, the check was mailed out on January 19, 2019. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2019
I purchased a home late December. I had a license inspector report that did not show any issues with the hot water heater not working. After a couple weeks, it stopped working. I contacted First American and they sent out plumbing company. He pushed the reset button, and changed the element. He did not report any other issues with the water heater.
After a few days, it quit working again. I resubmitted the claim, and they sent out a different company. He took things apart and replaced the switch, and trying to figure out what was wrong. He contacted the warranty company and was on speaker. He advise that he could not determine inside the unit but the water heater needed to be replaced I heard the representative asked him how long he thought the problem existed, and he told her "HE DID NOT KNOW". He said he would be guessing. So the representative decided to put what she wanted to without knowing if it was correct. Because of this denying my claim saying it was like that before I purchased the home. If that was the case, the inspector, and the first plumber would have documented. The company is trying to get out of covering an item on made up information.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2019
We have been with First American for over a year and don't see us changing. Their customer service is friendly and helpful. They work really fast to get you taken care of and refers the best companies with the best service workers. I would recommend them to any homeowner.
Hi Laura. We appreciate your feedback and look forward to servicing you in the future!
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2019
First American was part of the purchase agreement for the house that we bought in Knoxville. We've made claims online but we have done it on the phone as well. For the most part, the contractors have been very good. They usually come in and tell us what they're doing. We love First American and we definitely recommend it to people all the time. It saves a lot of money and you don't have to worry about a big expense coming all at once.
Hi Mary. Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. We appreciate you and your business. We look forward to servicing your next claim.
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2019
First American has been a reliable company and they’ve done well by us. I usually submit claims to them by phone and have great interactions with their claims reps. They have very pertinent questions and they’re quick to explain what’s covered and what’s not and to dispatch somebody appropriate. Their technicians have all been very helpful and covered exactly what they say that they will. They will also clarify if I ask them to do something they can’t, and they’re very patient about that. They are very good about getting the job done. I would recommend First American.
Hi Christina. Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2019
We recently had an unacceptable experience with your company. On Christmas day 2018 we discovered (due to the smell) that an outlet was literally so red hot the drywall was already scorching. My husband immediately turned off the breaker. The fire department came and stated within the hour the wall would have burst into flame and the house would have gone up so we were most fortunate. We then contacted "First American" for repair work. The electrician only replaced the plastic outlet not the badly burned box encasing it. We were obliged to pay the $75.00 service fee but would not sign the work was completed to our satisfaction. We contacted "First American" again to give them the opportunity to have the work done properly. This request was refused.
Here is the report explaining the issue from a most knowledgeable source: The following comments reflect my personal observations after having inspected the resultants damage from the recent fire at your home. The source of this fire was the 120VAC electrical outlet in the utility room. This outlet is fed from the main breaker box located on the outside eastern wall of your home. There are additional downstream loads (lighting and receptacles) that are supplied via "daisy chain" from the subject receptacle. There are 4 areas of damage that should be properly corrected. 1. Electrical Outlet. 2. Electrical Outlet Box. 3. Electrical Conductor (feeding the outlet). 4. Sheet Rock (Damaged by/during the fire).
Electrical Outlet - Heating has warped and melted the outlet, damaging the insulation and making it non-utilable for any further use. It should be replaced in whole. Electrical Outlet Box - The existing box is made from a synthetic insulating material. The side of the box has been melted and is partially gone, directly. exposing the electrical connections to the wall studs and covering. The remaining box has extensive carbon build-up (from electrical arcing and the fire) which is strongly conductive. This can facilitate electrical discharge to the studs and wall, posing a serious safety and liability issue. This box is non-utilable for further use and should be replaced in whole. It is worth noting that neither items 1 or 2 will meet local or state electrical codes and inspection in their damaged condition.
Electrical Conductors - Heat from the fire has melted and destroyed the insulating material on the conductors immediately adjacent to electrical outlet. It may be possible to cut the damaged ends of the wires back to the point of non-damaged insulation, pull up excess wire (slack) in the wire run and properly reconnect the wires to the receptacle. If there is no slack wire, the conductor should be replaced in whole.
Sheet Rock - In addition to the obvious aesthetic issue, there is a safety issue here. You do not want the electrical conductors and box, normally sealed behind the wall, exposed to yourselves or the public. The sheet rock should be cut back to eliminate all areas damaged by the fire, patched and finished to close the opening. This was a safety issue to say the least.
Hello Rose,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2019
I was a First American Home Warranty for over a ten years and it always take at least 2 weeks to get the problem solved. The reason why I canceled my house warranty is because they refuse to cover my dishwasher repair even before the technician show up.
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2019
I was looking to replace my home warranty. I saw First American on the internet, did some comparing, and chose them for their price and rating. I typically submit my claims to them online and the techs they've sent out have been fine. They did what they were supposed to do on a timely basis. I've spoken to their reps, too, and they took care of my concern. I would recommend First American.
Thank you David for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2019
The seal under the toilets had to be replaced and I filed a claim for it with American Home Shield. The first time I called, I got somebody who seemed like I was bothering him. Luckily, we got disconnected and I called back and got somebody decent who was able to send a tech who was professional and nice.
Hi Craig. We appreciate you choosing First American Home Warranty as your home warranty service provider. We look forward to assisting with your next claim.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2019
Getting a home warranty seemed to be sensible. My friend, Bob, was raving about what great service First American was and so I went with them. I submitted a claim for my disposal which all of a sudden, dropped dead and wasn’t working. They sent the plumbing company out. The guy had the disposal right on his truck and the whole thing was a half hour. He first determined that mine couldn’t be fixed by trying to manipulate it somehow. And then, he went to the truck and got a new one and stuck it in. It was perfect.
I had a second claim for my heat system downstairs. It was heating fine, but it was making these horrible noises like a train rumbling through the house. So they sent somebody out, and he was very polite. He spent time under the house looking at it and he said that he thought that the motor on the heat system was bad, and that was what was causing the noise. So he said he would submit a note about the motor. I got a notification that First American approved the motor. It's been definitely since before Christmas and I haven’t heard a word back. Other than that, I’d recommend them because they were polite. The people called me really quickly. They came out in a good and timely manner.
Hi Nadine, thank you for your providing us with your review, we appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2019
My wife and I just purchased our first home and despite having a thorough inspection done before purchasing, drain problems have arisen within the first few weeks of living here. We called First American to send a plumber on December 27th 2018 because none of the shower or bathtubs were draining properly. The first plumber First American sent out (several days later) could not clear the blockage without having to open up a wall. He said he would need to contact First American for authorization to fix the problem and then call us. We never heard back from this plumber. So after waiting for several days we called First American again. They told us they would send out another plumber.
Finally on January 11th 2019 two men who did not identify themselves other than as “the plumbers” (providing no company name or other identification) showed up without calling us ahead of time. Only one of the men barely spoke English and the other spoke no English. Despite my misgivings I allowed them to take a look. Once they examined the bathtub they told us that they would need to remove a toilet to fix the bathtub drains, but first they would need preauthorization from First American and then would contact us.
Again we heard nothing for several hours so I called First American to see if they had heard from these so called plumbers. They had not and then informed me that until they heard back from these definitely shady plumbers, they would not be able to help us. I asked if were possible for me to select a different plumber from a list of plumbers that have been authorized by First American. I was informed that this would be impossible. So essentially my wife need to decide if we should keep waiting to hear back from First American once they get a report from these so called plumbers or just bite the bullet and pay for our own plumber out of pocket. Meantime every time we need to take a shower for the past few weeks we’ve had to go over to our relatives.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2019
I have had First American Home Warranty for almost a year. They have always exceeded my expectations. Everything I have contacted them about, any problem, any appliance and air condition system. They have always repaired or replaced the items. This is a great company that takes care of their client.
Thank you Williams for your feedback, we appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2019
Good service on the oven. The repair person quick fixed a problem but then couldn't replace other parts because of age of machine. FAHM approved a replacement, and I'm very happy with it and the fact that FAHM was willing to do this. Only negative is that sometimes it takes a while for the companies to call to let you know status, and so you wonder what's happening. That happened with the delivery in this case. Closing the communication loop sooner would be an improvement.
Hi Denise. Thank you for your feedback. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2019
Toilet clog - A plumber was sent out immediately. Very nice and professional. The problem was more involved, so he got permission from First American to come back with bigger equipment. He was unable to solve the problem. First American sent out a plumber from a different company and he was able to solve the problem, however it involved him getting on the roof which is not covered by First American, so I paid him $190. Problem solved. I am happy.
Thank you Mary for taking the time to provide us with your feedback. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2019
I like everything about FAHW and would highly recommend to anyone. The price is the main reason we are cancelling the home warranty. I have used two other HW companies and feel this is the best in comparison.
We appreciate your review, Larry and thank you for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2019
I'm a little unhappy right now with First American so I might be switching. They covered something electrical on my house that I needed to be repaired. The technician wanted to drill a hole through my wall and I was like, "No, I'm not gonna drill a holes to my wall." I ended up paying extra and out of pocket for the repair. I haven't received any call saying what was covered for what I paid. The technician was actually very cool. He pretty much told me that the insurance company wasn’t gonna cover it because it was a little bit more than what needs to be done.
First of all, it took three weeks for them to even do the work. So I was without electricity for three weeks. I tried to explain that to the claim adjuster by saying, "Hey, think about it if that was your house. Would you wanna be without lights for three weeks, during Christmas time?" The claim adjuster said, “Well, it’s not us, it’s the company that we're in contract with." But I said as a claims adjuster they should be on the contractor's **."
If I would have gotten my own private electrician to come over, it would have taken two days or a day. So in a way, at the end I ended up paying extra for the service and it took three weeks. And with the turnaround time, if I called to make a claim, it shouldn't take a whole week and a half. With my washer and dryer it was the same thing. I called them and it took a couple of days for the contractors to come.
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2019
We've been new with First American, but everything has been all right for us in getting service done. We had one claim which we filed over the phone and they took it over quickly. The technician who came explained everything that was going on, the time it would take to get it completed, and he told us what was wrong and fixed it. The quality of his work was really good.
We appreciate your feedback, Ron! Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
I want to say thank you for the service and concern for my repairs. Thank you Frankee customer service to help me. I appreciate it the call and go all the way to get a new cooktop. Thanks for your help.
Thank you Tito for your feedback. We look forward to servicing you in the future!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
I have been nothing but pleased when I have had to contact First American Home Warranty. They are always right on top of things and I have never waited more than a day for service. I was on the fence about continuing coverage after I bought the house but I went ahead and did it and am so happy I did!!
Thank you Kellie for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
It did take close to a week to get Sears Repairs here, however technician was polite, courteous, and knowledgeable. Best of all replacement parts was in his truck. Very efficient! Was a good experience overall. Would recommend to someone wanting a Home Warranty.
Hi Susan, we appreciate your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
Outstanding customer service. Very satisfied with the repairs to the freezer ice maker. Technician was timely, professional, and extremely knowledgeable. The problem was identified, parts were ordered, and repairs were completed expeditiously upon receipt of the parts. Purchasing First American Home Warranty was one of the best decisions I have ever made.
We appreciate you taking the time to provide a feedback Wilfred. We look forward to servicing you in the future.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
Had outlets not working on outside of my house. KNIGHT'S MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR LLC came and found issue was caused by only one tripped GFCI that cut off all power to all my outlets around the house. Repair was quick. I also had a flood light on outside of house.
Hi Ashton, we appreciate your review and thank you for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
All good - GE was knowledgeable - ordered parts and can immediately when they arrived. I would definitely recommend them for all GE appliances - especially for me. Work was done in professional but friendly manner. Washing machine sounds a lot quieter now. Sears had tried once before and no success.
Thank you Darlyne for your feedback. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
First American Home Warranty has always provided top-notch service for the last 20 years I have been a customer. They have a very simplistic and easy to use system that focuses on providing quality customer services while providing top notch service.
Thank you Juan for your feedback and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
In weeks I will expose their fraud in court. My range died, repairs exceeding value. The company offers me a $1200 cash out offer. I explain, the feature model similar will cost $2000 and that is what I want per contract terms. The claims rep was infuriated by my request, and while their offer is in writing she proceeds to retract it and offer zero, daring me to sue them. I was not surprised, we live in an age of iron and rust. I even e-mailed their president and they are hiding behind their paper walls, standing by their representative. They can all stand together in court and be exposed. Beware!
We understand that you were replacing the unit and although we did not provide authorization to do so, we still offered a cash payment in the interest of customer service. We have reviewed the offer and are aware that the cash payment offered to you reflects a unit similar to what you had. If you do decide to accept then please advise. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2019
Our home warranty from First American was part of the purchase when we bought our house. I submit my claims to them online and First American has taken care of everything we’ve had issues with and in a timely manner. We weren’t forced to wait to get repairs taken care of. The techs who have come out have been good. They'd say they’re coming and they've been on time. They also have always been informative, letting me know what was wrong and what they were fixing. The quality of their work has always been good too.
Hi Angela, thank you for your review and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2019
I've had an excellent experience with First American. I've had them since I bought my home in 2008. Thus far, I've probably had five claims with them and all were very easy to submit. I called them and told them what the problem was. The next day, I got a call from the contractor. The techs who have come out have all been very knowledgeable and polite. I've had one fellow come out a couple of times because he worked on the dishwasher and the dryer. He's an older fellow and obviously, he has worked on a lot of these pieces of equipment. When he worked on the dryer, he told me all kinds of information about who manufactured what dryer and what washer because there has been so much consolidation in that particular industry. So, it was very interesting.
I've had two claims in the last year. One was for our house heater, and the other was for a stove. Both of those claims were very good. The heater took a little while. It was an older heater and they had some difficulty finding the parts, but they fixed it to my satisfaction. The heater was a bit of a problem because we were in the middle of winter. First American tried and responded accordingly. There was a young lady and she called me several times to see how things were doing. She called a contractor a couple of times to get updates from them and I know she checks on parts for me. She put out a lot of effort and she's a real asset. Fortunately, it wasn't really cold that week, so it wasn't a big issue. I had a couple of electric space heaters that I put on in the living room and it was okay. Had it been a really cold winter, it might have been a different story. I’ve already recommended First American to several people.
Hi Victor. We appreciate your review and thank you for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2019
Both of our places are getting old, as is all of our appliances and infrastructure, and it made sense to me to have home warranties. I've used First American for a few years on both of our homes and I've had nothing but good luck with them whenever I submit claims. I've used both online or over the phone claim submission methods and the claims process is very easy. Sometimes, the time it takes to get the service out there can be a little longer than one would like but it's tolerable. My experience has also been good with the contractors and they do good quality of work.
Thank you Jim for your review and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2019
16 day without hot water so far... PLEASE AVOID THIS COMPANY!!! If you have minor repairs, they may be OK, but if you ever find yourself needing an appliance replaced, beware!!! We are currently on day 17 of having no hot water in our house in the middle of winter with two small diapered children living in our house!!! This company has told us several lies during this whole process. We were told over 10 days ago that they were ordering a replacement tank for us. It was supposed to have arrived in our area yesterday and be installed yesterday or today, but today we were told by the current technician that no tank was ordered.
Every time you call this company, you talk with a different representative. They always say they'll take care of it and then you find out later they've lied to you. A claim specialist was assigned to our account over 2 weeks ago and I don't believe we've actually talked to her in person yet. She never answers when we call her and we always have to leave a voice message. DO NOT BELIEVE ANYTHING THIS COMPANY TELLS YOU!!!
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2019
Submitting a claim with First American was easy, and they've been very accommodating. I called to submit the claims, and the claims representative has always been very helpful. The technicians have always been helpful, too. They explained everything that they were doing and the quality of their work was very good. I've recommended First American and had other people sign up with their policies as well. I've been very happy with them.
Hi Sheryl, thank you for your review!
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2019
This company and their warranty is horrible. We had our dishwasher break within the first year of owning a home that the seller purchased an upgraded warranty on. They hired a contractor that was located over an hour and a half away from us when we have an appliance repair company less than a mile away from our house. The contractor never submitted the report saying the dishwasher needed to be replaced and it has been a month and we just keep getting told to wait. This is ridiculous. Oh and we had to pay $95 for the contractor to come out. The previous owner paid thousands for this home warranty. We still have no dishwasher and we are out the $95. If you really care about your home, don't purchase a warranty from these people.
Hello Brandy,
Our records indicate you accepted the cash payment in lieu of the replacement to the dishwasher. You will receive your check in seven to ten days. This claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2019
I woke up to my shower leaking on Dec. 14th and here it is Jan 7th and still nothing. I have had to call First American over a dozen times. Contractors don't show up when they are scheduled, I have missed work and my water bill has gone up because of this issue. They DO NOT care about their customers! And now after calling me again they are telling me that no one will fix it and I should could call a plumber myself and have them fix it, out of pocket. Then IF I get approved I MIGHT be able to be refunded for paying out of pocket first. I have missed several days of work, spent countless hours on the phone, still have to research and get my own plumber and pay out of pocket. Why am I paying First American? Yes, they have low service fees but do yourself a favor in the long run and find another warranty company.
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2019
FAHW is terrible. Customer service is terrible, they replaced our nice thermostat with a very cheap one. We'd been better off just replacing it ourselves instead of paying them $75 for a cheap one. I would never recommend anyone use them. I had to leave work two days in a row, waiting for their contractor to get to our house. They take no responsibility for their contractors. Because I called and requested and ETA on our technician (because I was already waiting over an hour after receiving a text saying that they were on their way, and I needed to get back to work) they escalated our case to a supervisor- no one else would talk to me. I called our elected supervisor 5 times, and never received a message or call back. Yes, our heat is working and we're thankful, but to get to that point was nothing short of a headache. Missed 4 hours of work, got a super cheap thermostat in replace of our $200.00, and paid them $75. Worst home warranty ever.
Hello Aprille,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. On April 10, 2019, you confirmed your air handler, condenser and thermostat were replaced and working properly. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2019
First American was offered when I closed with my purchase of the home and I've been with them for four years now. I submit claims to them by calling and I've had good interactions with their claims reps. However, before, the turnaround time took longer than usual. It is way quicker now, so my experience with filing claims has gotten better.
The first couple of times the techs came out were bad experiences. They were taking apart stuff but not putting things back because they assumed they were gonna get the job. So every time I have to call in, I gotta let them know not to touch my stuff or an adult needs to be there when they’re present. My most recent experience was the only one that was pretty great and it doesn’t cover the rest of the years of bad experiences, so I wouldn’t recommend First American yet.
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2019
We got First American as part of the purchase of the house and we’ve extended it. I usually file my claims online and it’s very easy. Whenever I talk to their reps through the landline, they’re helpful. It doesn’t take very long and it’s issue-free. Also, the contractors that were sent out have all done well. I’ve had good results for what I needed. Overall, First American does a good job. They do what I need when I need it.
Hi Alan. Thank you for the positive review. We appreciate you and your business.
Reviewed Jan. 5, 2019
I had a home warranty but I wasn't happy with the service, so I changed to First American. I like their service program. We've had one claim and it was experienced as advertised. I was very pleased. I submitted the claim online and I was able to navigate their site and get all the information there. I was promised a call within 24 hours from the contractor, and it happened. The contractor was a great guy. He knew exactly what he was doing, and things went well. He had to order a part, so we had to wait for the part to come in but we're happy with the result. I was very happy with the quality of work, too. I would and I have recommended First American. I'm very pleased with what they do.
Hi Nathan, thank you for taking the time to provide us with your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 4, 2019
We’ve had First American forever. When we bought the house 50 years ago, somebody recommended them and we’ve been with them since. However, our experience with them about the problem that we have with the washing machine was not good. About a month and a half ago, our washing machine broke down. They sent a technician who supposedly would fix it, but it didn't work. So, we put in another work order and it took another two weeks before the technician went out. Then, he told me that the machine needs more part and that it was related to the same problem. They were gonna send the technician the following week, but for whatever reason, there was no technician around the area, so it was bumped up for another week.
Finally, the technician went out and ordered the parts which came in yesterday. I then tried to get ahold of the technician as he was kind enough to give me his phone number. I guess he felt sorry for us and he wanted us to get our washing machine as soon as possible. I left him a message and that is where we are right now. I’m not blaming the technician nor First American, but I’m blaming the system that First American has. Nevertheless, I like First American. They have been there for us. When our ACs broke down in the summertime, they sent a technician right away and I was happy. I will recommend them.
Thank you Martin for your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2019
KC Appliance Repair Services Was fantastic. Within minutes of completing my request for service, Sony with KC Appliance had contacted me. We made an appointment for the same day. Sony was kind, efficient and taught me the signs of what to avoid in the future. Next time I need service on an appliance, I’m calling Sony with KC Appliance.
Thank you Kathleen for your review! We appreciate it.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2019
Updated on 01/28/2019: So, I receive no help to a refrigeration issue until I write A negative review I Bought a ConsumerAffairs. Then, I receive Prompt service on one unit and an offer to refund my $75 service fee on the other. Literally the minute I accepted The refund, the service rep. marked my issue as resolved on this website. However, on January 18th I was Told I would Have a check in 7-10 days. It is January 28th. I have No check. Today I called. Today I am Told it will be here in 7-10 days. So, up to Feb. 7th. Which will mean it could take a total days IF the person today is right. This is EXACTLY how it happens EVERY TIME I DEAL with First American. Empty Promises and two to three times as long as it should take. NOT ok.
Original Review: I have the extra refrigeration package. I called To have my kitchen fridge and outdoor ice maker repaired. After 2 missed days at work, they said they had no one to do the ice maker and cancelled the appointment with NO call to me. I waited all day and heard nothing! Then they gave me an authorization to find my own repairman. As I did that, the man came to fix the kitchen fridge AGAIN. He STILL COULDN'T do that (3rd time) but also looked at ice maker. Couldn’t fix that either. But now, the warranty company suddenly says the ice maker isn’t covered. It was covered on the first 2 visits but not visit 3?!? Bait and switch and I STILL HAVE TO TAKE 2 more days off work for the kitchen fridge. Incompetent contractors. Incompetent warranty company. Beware.
Hello Jenna,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your kitchen refrigerator claim. Our records indicate the unit was repaired and working properly as of January 9, 2019. As for the ice maker, the unit is not within the main foundation of the home. Please be advised, items must be located within the foundation of the primary living quarters. You may refer to your home warranty contract under Important. In the interest of customer service, First American reimbursed the $75.00 service call fee. You will receive your check in seven to ten days.
This claim is considered closed.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2019
Six weeks ago (11/23), we made a service request for our built-in refrigerator that stopped working and was covered in the plan I purchased. My journey since then, in case it helps anyone reading this: 5 or 6 independent visits from the same appliance repair company, who I actually felt did their best to fix it. Each visit they took the unit almost completely apart, replaced the part they thought would fix it, then notified me that yet another part was needed, with usually a 7-10 business day wait every time, including the most recent (last week). It's still not fixed, so I have been 6 weeks without a refrigerator - and counting.
I called First American several times during this process, and the various reps I spoke to told me that despite the 5-6 separate repair trips, the repair "budget" had not yet been reached. The FAHW phone reps had zero concern for the fact that I had been without a working refrigerator for 6+ weeks - one even told me that owner downtime doesn't even factor into their decision to replace it. I even called the direct extension of the person at FAHW assigned to my work order three different times and none of my voicemails were returned. Truly remarkable. Like most large service companies these days, it is almost impossible to identify the person who will take actual ownership of a problem and resolve it ASAP. To echo others on this website - I will never use this company again. Ever. After this issue is resolved one way or the other, adios amigos.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2019
We had a water heater failure. I went online and clicked a few buttons to submit a claim to First American. They called thereafter and got the appointment set up. Wonderful gentlemen came and fixed the problem. Getting this warranty is definitely worth it for financial wellbeing and peace of mind.
Hi Timothy, we value your feedback. Thank you!
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2019
I contacted First American about 2 months ago in regards to a pinhole leak in a pipe in our kid’s bathroom. When the contractor they sent Fix It All Plumbing, came to our house they said there was no leak. After asking them several times to check more closely, they finally found the source of the leak. I was then informed that it required 3 Modifications (I have this in writing) on the pipes and it would cost me $200 additional, since modifications were not covered by First American. I asked at the time to further clarify what "modifications meant" and the answer I got was that they needed to make new the pipes fit the existing pipes. Since I went from not having a leak to having to pay out of pocket I contacted Fix It All Plumbing and asked for further clarification, prior to them fixing the issue. I was then informed that they needed to change the flow of the pipes and, hence the Modifications.
Still not convinced by the two completely different answers, so I call First American and asked them to verify within my policy what would constitute a Modification and how I would know if what they were doing was indeed correct and due such large sum. Their agent instructed me that work could continue and at the time they received the claim they would review it and let me know. After 1.5 weeks waiting with a hole in my wall, Fix It all Plumbing finally came and did the work. It took them all of 35 min and the only thing they did was cut the existing copper pipes and replace them with plastic pipes (I have photos before and after). Their receipt now showed 2 modified pipes, not 3 as originally stated, so I once again asked for clarification how that constituted a "modification" and was told that they needed to make the pipes fit, in order to prevent a leak.
I may not be a plumber, but my understanding was that it was the job that they had been hired to do in the first place. I called Fix It All Plumbing once again, and asked for clarification on the service. I was told that they needed to "reroute" the pipes. I then informed them that I had pictures that proved that no rerouting had taken place and asked to speak to a manager to further clarify the additional charges. At this point, I was informed they had no manager available and that since I was "refusing" payment, my bill would be sent to their "billing" department. I contacted First American a total of 10 times, asking for help clarifying the service detail, and each time received different answers or was told that it was being sent to "claims review". Throughout this entire process, I was never contacted by First American with clarification or even update on the issue. I have emails sent to them requesting their help.
I never denied the service was provided, simply wanted to make sure that I was not being taken for a fool, since it did not seem to warrant such a high price for simple service, their paperwork did not match what they claimed to have done, and their refusal to explain further the scope of the work. After many calls and back and forth, I was unfortunate to speak to a person named Mitzy who told me that this was not First American problem, since modifications were not covered by my insurance, and I needed to deal directly with them. I then asked to have a service evaluation, and she said that such thing did not exist and it could only be done if I had been randomly selected.
I've now have been served with a bill from Fix It All Plumbing threatening further "legal" action if I continue to refuse payment, which I never did. They never tried to explain or even clarify the order. Their paperwork states first 3 modified lines, then 2 and I consistently got different answers for the same question. First American had no interest in making sure that contractors being brought into my house by them, are indeed doing the work they claim to do. After all this a back and forth, and almost 7 hours on waiting on the phone and multiple emails, I've concluded that First American has no interest in customer satisfaction, if their claims are being properly settled or if their contractors are behaving an a professional manner while make sure that the scope of their work is clear and properly explained.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2019
As with many other customers who wrote here, I waited and waited to have a HVAC repaired or replaced. Months later, I paid out of pocket to have a working heater and air conditioner. FAHW said the unit was fixed, even though I have a recording of the contractor telling me he was waiting for parts. I also have a recording of the contractor's employee telling me FAHW told them to say the problem was preexisting. Even after hearing the recordings, FAHW did not offer to reimburse me and I need to sue them.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2019
Years ago, I used to be a customer of First American Home Warranty then I changed to another company. However, the company I was using sucked and I liked First American's service better, so I signed back with them. There was a time when I though I had a leak in a bathtub so I had a guy come in and check it out. He ran the tub for about a half hour and there was no leak. He thought that it might have been some prodding on the tub. I haven't had any problem since so that worked out well. Overall, First American did a good job the last time I used their service.
Thank you Glenn, we appreciate your feedback!
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2019
I’m a property manager and I have warranties on many of our managed property. And we sell so many because home warranty has become standard in the marketplace. First American Home Warranty was the first one in the marketplace and I had a fine experience with them. Submitting claims to them has gotten better but it is by no means perfect. They take way too long to answer phone calls and give any kind of report or set up service. They don’t know what an emergency is.
As for the reps, as long as they are in the United States, I don’t have any problem. When they’re out of the country, they have difficulty understanding things because they are not used to how we live. If you’ve never seen a dishwasher, you don’t know what one is. So, it’s hard to explain to somebody that has never even seen one. Some other time, I report their contractors for their attitude, ability to perform, lack of good service, having to call them back to finish the job and for not answering the phone. But most of the time, my interactions with them were good.
Thank you B.J. for your feedback, we appreciate it!
Reviewed Jan. 1, 2019
I called FAHW when I had just moved into our new house. The grout around my tiled shower remained wet after stopping showering for several days. We didn't want to apply tile sealant if the grout wasn't drying completely. We thought maybe the shower pan liner was installed incorrectly and moisture under the tile couldn't drain out completely. I wanted to see if this issue was something covered with the home warranty offered with FAHW. I explained this issue to FAHW to see if that was something they could cover and the agent assured me it was something that they do cover. For a $75 service fee she could send out someone that would resolve my issue.
The agent was difficult to understand and English was poor but I tried my best to explain the issue. She mistakenly set up a service call with a general plumber instead of someone that deals with tile. When the general plumber came couple days later I asked him first if he does work on tile and tiled showers and he said no. He came to my door with a snake and plunger and when I explained my problem he said that they were told this was a plumbing stoppage issue. So he didn't do any work or assessment just came in and we talked about the shower area about how there must have been a mix up with setting up the claim. I called customer service to explain that the wrong company was sent out to my house and the agent that I talked to told me he was very sorry that this had happened. When I explained how this seemed to be an error on FAHW and not my fault he seems confused.
I asked to speak to a supervisor. The supervisor understood right away and said that this issue I am having isn't something that FAHW is capable of handling and that they shouldn't of sent someone out in the first place. I agreed and requested that I not be charged the service fee of $75 because of the error on FAHW. The agent assured me I would not be charged. He also noted that the agent that set up the claim would be notified of her mistake so she could get the feedback on what FAHW covers and how to properly assign the correct contractors. I was impressed at this point with the customer service taking care of their mistake.
6 weeks later I get the full $75 bill and when I call customer service about it the agent says there is no documentation about the conversation I had with this agent. They said I called in and spoke to two different people and each documented that I requested a plumber for plumbing stoppage. They have no documentation regarding my explanation of the wet tile issue just that I needed a plumber for plumbing stoppage.
The supervisor told me she sees that I requested to have the service fee removed but that each agent had told me I would need to pay the fee since I had explained the problem as a clogged drain and needed a plumber for plumbing stoppage. I explained to the supervisor that I completely disagree with how they documented my explanation and I tried to thoroughly explain my issue to the supervisor and she said that since I explained the issue incorrectly in the first place I would be responsible for the fee.
I tried to explain to her that I did my best in explaining the issue I was having and that I should not be responsible for FAHW sending out not only the wrong person for the job but and not even knowing that the problem I was having isn't something that the company even covers. I was so frustrated and wanted a better resolution than just being told I am lying and changing my story. The agent offered to bill me for half of the service fee. I feel like I shouldn't be charged anything for a mistake like this.
I asked who I contact to make an appeal and she said the information is on the website. I asked where on the website? She just kept repeating the information is on the website. I told her that I am just trying to get more contact information to make an appeal or speak to corporate about this issue and all she can tell me is look on the website. I still don't see any information on the web about how to start this process and definitely nothing on the website. I really don't feel like I was treated fairly on this issue. I feel like the agents are using the documentation they have to their own advantage. Conveniently, the only information in the documentation supports their conclusion that I am lying and changing my story. None of the documentation from the helpful agent exists.
So nowhere can they see the documentation of the guy assured me I wouldn't be charged and that the initial agent made a mistake setting up the claim. Very frustrating experience. Very weird too because why would I lie about it? What incentive do I have to lie and change my story? All I want is the get my problem fixed so it is in the best interest of me to explain it the best I can. I have no misleading intention and no incentive to be misleading. Why would I want to explain something incorrectly and get the wrong person to come to my door and risk getting billed for it? FAHW somehow believes that I am lying still. Agent said no audio record of calls are available. I wish I would have recorded the conversation with the helpful agent myself. I want for someone to contact me for a fair resolution.
Hello Scott,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your plumbing claim. Upon review, First American waived the $75.00 service call fee.
Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 1, 2019
I opened a claim because my sewer cap was broken as well as my bathroom sink was leaking. I was assigned a rude plumbing company. To sum it up my sewer cap was not covered and the sink had a missing part which was also not covered. I have had the sink for years and it never leaked. Now all of a sudden the part was missing. I was charged 75$ to do nothing. Why wasn’t I told from the beginning the cap was not covered. I would not have had anyone come out. It’s been weeks and I’m still waiting for a supervisor to call me. I have had several bad experiences with First American. I just had it. It’s time to terminate services and go somewhere else. They are horrible but take my payment every month.
Reviewed Jan. 1, 2019
I had two people telling me that First American was good warranty provider. I chose to get one from them when I bought my house. One time, sparks were shooting out of my fan in my bedroom at 2 o'clock in the morning. I called the warranty place and they sent someone out within a couple of days. Luis, the tech who came, said he would replace the fan and we made another appointment. Still, he taped up the wall socket so that nobody would turn it on. He came out again, put the fan in and it's been fine ever since. I'm was very happy with Luis as he was knowledgeable and friendly. He was here when he said he would get here.
Thank you Carol for your feedback!
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2018
Our dishwasher was not working properly and the dishes were not cleaned. Service tech came out and diagnosed that the control panel was damaged and the motor assembly (motor, impeller and seals) needed replacement. FAHW decided they should review to see if it would be better to replace the entire dishwasher. This took a week, when they decided not to replace it, but order parts. We were told the parts would arrive in another week, but they would schedule the repair tech for the day after the scheduled arrival date. Of course they did not do that. When the parts arrived, I again called FAHW and they said no appointment had been scheduled even though the record showed they had promised to do this.
So we waited another week for the repair tech to finally arrive. When he opened the box's of parts that were ordered, there was no impeller and no seal kit for the motor. How do you order an electric motor for a dishwasher with no seals? So here we are still waiting after 6 weeks for a dishwasher repair. I am currently still waiting to talk to a supervisor 45 minutes into this phone call, of which there have probably been at least 10 for this simple issue..
Hi Stephen. We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. Our records indicate that you matter has been resolved. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2018
The only problem with First American Home Warranty company is that they look to good to be true. For over 5 years they have protected us from having to pay large sums to cover unexpected charges. We've tried to convince family & friends to sign up but they refuse to listen. My uncle was smart enough to look into home warranties. He discovered that FAHW was the only warranty company that actually replaced/repaired appliances. The others replaced appliances on a depreciated value unlike FAHW who replaced appliances over 20 years old with brand new Kenmore appliances. My mom had to have 3 different electricians come out & was out over $700. If she would have had listen to us. She would have only had paid for the first electrician. It would have been $75 regardless of how long, how many electricians or companies it took to take care of the problem. They also would have come out a lot quicker.
After FAHW replaced our air conditioner saving us over $3000. I thought for sure we would be cancelled but that was 5 years ago. We bought a old house that had the original appliances still being used. They have all been replaced except for a 15 year old refrigerator. I know it will go out anytime now, but I know that for $75 it will be replaced. I know this because the parts for this fridge are no longer available. The manufacturer went out of business over 5 years ago.
Recently the freezer my wife & her ex bought at a garage sale before we married went out after we had used it for 20 years. After purchasing a ceiling fan a wire broke inside the fan. FAHW prevented us from having to pay another $100 by repairing it for $75. It would have easily cost over $75 just to have an electrician come out to look at the problem. Then they would have charged us even more to fix the problem or they would have told us that buying another would be cheaper than having them repair it. If FAHW wouldn't have been able to repair the fan they would have bought us a new one.
After our neighbor called Hudgins Plumbing come out to clear out a clog. FAHW sent the same company out to repair our garbage disposal and a clogged drain. They had to replace the disposal and removed the clog. We still paid a fraction of what our neighbor paid. If I were to give you all the reasons you should sign up with FAHW I would have to write a book. Simple put if you want peace of mind you need to sign up. Take my word for it. It's for real. I heard the way FAHW is able to do what they do. It's because they make their money from new homeowners. It's a lot like an insurance company.
Jay, Thank you for taking the time to share your detailed feedback here. It is always great to hear when our customers have a fantastic experience with our team. We know how many choices you have when deciding on a home warranty company, and we are glad you chose us!
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2018
My sister-in-law in Little Rock, Arkansas told me about her experiences with First American Home Warranty. She had bought a house and the home warranty came with the house. She kept it as she had a need for it and she said that they were very responsive. I might need a home warranty at some point too since I'm retired and I didn’t want any big expenditure. So, I got one and I went with First American for their price and for what they cover. The claim submission process was very easy. A contractor was a little slow on one of the claims but on the first couple of claims, it went very, very smoothly. When I filed a claim online, I got a phone call almost immediately and the rep over the phone was great.
The first contractor for the garbage disposal was very, very easy to work with and very quick. I called them one day and they came the same day. So, that was good. The experience with Sears on my dishwasher claim was very good as well. However, I'm having confusion with the microwave. The gentleman that came from GE said that the parts that I needed were not available any longer, that they were gonna need to replace the whole microwave and somebody would be calling me in three days. Nobody called me from the contractor's end nor First American. I called the contractor and they said I should be getting a call from First American. I called them and they said that they were following up on whether they can find parts for it. And they hadn’t done it. They hadn’t started yet. But they were gonna conduct their review and then decide if it really was necessary to replace it, and they would call me.
The gentleman that I talked with on First American was really nice. He said, “I’ll make sure that we take care of it and that we’ll look into it right now.” That same day, I got an email that said, “Would you accept this model for your replacement?” I sent my response right back and I got a call a couple of days ago from Christina, who’s my representative at First American, and she said she would call me tomorrow to let me know the status of when it would be coming.
Hi Patricia, thank you for your review!
Reviewed Dec. 30, 2018
This warranty company tries to find loopholes to get out of fixing your problem. They’ve made me spend money on 3 separate “covered” occasions. Recently I’ve had a plumbing issue, and they stated it’s not normal wear and tear. So a lady by the name of Tiera ** called back and sent a plumber out for a second opinion. The second plumber said “This should be covered” and also he wrote a complete different description of the problem. I asked for my copy for records. I’m now getting an attorney involved. I had to replace my own garage motor as well even though it’s covered on the warranty. She asked for my receipts so she could reimburse me.
My lawyer told me not to let them reimburse me anything nor send any receipts. ??? I haven’t heard a word back from them after the second plumber came out, so I canceled my contract. Guys save your time and money!!! Note - they only respond to the people who give good reviews! Beware!!! I will write a review to the BBB and other sites as well.
Reviewed Dec. 30, 2018
** was in contact with me very shortly after logging my online service request, HE came out the following day, on time. Mr. ** was professional, neat and thorough. He explained everything as he did the service. This was a very convenient way of scheduling a service appointment.
Hi Kathleen. We are happy to hear about your positive claim experience. We hope you have a great 2019!
Reviewed Dec. 30, 2018
I filed a claim with First American Home Warranty for my microwave. I submit my claims online and it's normally seamless and straightforward. I get contacted 24 hours later with the date when somebody's gonna come to take a look at whatever issue I was having. However, my last claim took a bit of time. First American called me and told me that because of the problems we've had with our microwave, they needed to replace the unit. That took a bit of time to work out - I had to negotiate with them and figure things out because they had to send me some samples and I had to make sure I was all okay with it. Still, I'm satisfied with First American.
Thank you Peter for your feedback. We look forward to servicing you in the future!
Reviewed Dec. 30, 2018
I moved into an older home and it had some appliances that we inherited. Who knows if we’re gonna encounter trouble with those, so a home warranty seemed like a good kind of safe fall back. I got First American Home Warranty which was recommended by a neighbor. She was very satisfied and spoke very highly of her experience. It's very easy to submit a claim and we have had nothing but good experiences with them, except with what's going on right now, which involves a washing machine repair. We've now been without a washer for three months since November 8. We've had two different service contractors out to diagnose it and they diagnosed it wrong.
Although the customer service rep has been helpful and responsive, the machine should have been condemned about 2 months ago. First, the washer was diagnosed by some Sears repair guys and we were waiting for five parts. It took forever for them to come. First American sent out another technician to take a look at it and he came up with a totally different diagnosis. Then, we had to wait for more parts. When the parts finally arrived, he installed them and it was the same problem. He wasn't able to fix it at all and so he is coming out again tomorrow to see. It's been really awful, especially going through the holidays, not only Thanksgiving and Christmas.
I had nothing but a good experience and a very high opinion of First American then it just plummeted with this last experience which is really the only bad experience we've had with them. In several occasions, I've thought about canceling it because it's been so disheartening to be strung along. But I'm giving them the benefit of the doubt that this is just a kind of what worn off. I’ve also recommended them to other people. We haven't used them all that many times and we've been with them for about eight years now.
Hi Sheila. We appreciate your feedback and value your concerns. We will have a representative be in contact with you regarding your clothes washer claim. Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
My water heater went out 12/20/18. Today is 12/29 and I’m still without hot water. I paid 95 for a tech to come out. Then called first American over 10x to get someone to come out and replace the heater. Then they tell me I have to pay an additional 400 out of pocket to update codes, modify the line and pull permits. I called another company out who came out for free and none of these extra charges were needed. These people are con artist and rip offs who are just looking to scam people out their money. They don’t care about the customer or have a sense of urgency when it comes to repairs. RUN!!!
Hello Val,
Scout Plumbing Incorporated reported your water heater needed to be replaced because it was leaking. As a result of the replacement, there were non-covered charges for modifications and haul away which are not covered under your home warranty contract per Limits of Liability, Number Six. Please be advised, our records indicate you agreed to the non-covered charges and your water heater was replaced on or around December 10, 2018. As such, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
I am a client of First American Home Warranty and have been for two years. I recently had issues with my dishwasher and First American was responsive to my needs. Anytime I had issues with the contractor, I could call First American and they dealt with it immediately. The contractors assigned were fine and generally responsive.
Hi Andrew. Thank you for taking the time to leave us a review. We are happy we have met your service needs. We hope you have a happy and healthy 2019
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
FA took care of our problems right away with no hassle. This was super great because the leak started right before Thanksgiving with lots of family coming over for the Christmas. Our holidays were saved! Thanks First American Home Warranty!
Thank you Victor for the positive review. We are happy to hear that your Christmas was saved. Happy New Year
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
I recently had my hot water heater not working. I called First American, they assigned me a contractor. I called the contractor to schedule the repair. The contractor originally wanted to schedule the repair for 5 days later because they are not open on weekends. I explained that I can't wait that long because it is the winter season and hot water is needed. The contractor then scheduled for next day between 9am -12pm. The technician came out at around 10:30am and determined that a new hot water heater is need but he has to order the heater so he can't do the repair until 4 days later. On top of that there was a $480 modification fee that I would be responsible for.
I asked the technician why the 4 days wait even though hot water heaters are sold and available at Home Depot. I called First American back and advised them of this. I was back and forth with them the whole day. The end result was that First American did purchased a hot water heater within minutes from an Home Depot which was about a mile away from my property but the technician was not available to do the repair after the diagnostic even though approval was granted and the material was ready. First American, then wanted me to wait the 4 days without hot water during winter or take a cashout which did not cover the cost of a new hot water heater much less installation. They refused to assign me another contractor and even refused to have me find a contract that is available to do the repair and reimburse me later.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
We bought a new house in September 2018 and I called the cancel policy on my former home. I sent in a letter per their instructions and I’m still trying to cancel this policy. I have a policy with them on my new property but they will not help me with this. I don’t know what to do. It should not be so difficult to cancel a policy. I’ve been with this company for 5 years now. Beware when you get a policy because if you ever need to cancel it you will not be able to.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2018
My realtor had a warranty with First American Home Warranty when I bought the home originally and I extended it. I've been in my home for two and half years and I'm not sure I would own a home without the warranty with First American. Submitting a claim is simple. I do it all online and within hours, I get an email immediately saying, "Your claim has been received," then, I get a phone call. It has been a seamless, very good process. Overall, the site is easy. There have been no issues and it has worked so well.
I have had two technicians come to our home for repair and both have been exceptional. One shared a cup of tea with me, which was fantastic, because we were waiting for the washer to get onto the cycle if it makes a bit of noise, so we got a nice chance to connect. The other fellow, the electrician, was absolutely fantastic. He got the job done and asked if there was anything else he could help us with, and left a nice business card. He provided really great service.
The electrical work was done very quickly and very efficiently, and it works perfectly. Unfortunately, we had to order a part for my washer, but the tech tightened up the washer, so I could use it in the interim. They are coming on Saturday to finish the job. They did great work. My experience as a customer with First American has been absolutely great from the corporate side to the vendor side. The quality of work from the vendors that they send has been terrific, so the vendors obviously value being a part of the organization.
Hi Rick! Thank you for your feedback and we are glad the repairs were completed to your washer and electrical! We look forward to servicing you in the future!
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2018
Although First American may provide decent customer service, the contractors providing repairs for First American are subpar. I will not be renewing my policy - time spent trying to resolve poor contractor work is not worth my time. You may want to look elsewhere for better contractor service.
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2018
For years, FAHW warranty provided peace of mind -- I’d file a claim and resolution was achieved less the service call fee. (Over these past few years, a disposal & a small dryer part was replaced/fixed.) Fast forward one week to today: WATER HEATER: I’ve read so many reviews that are identical to mine. Unfortunately, the story is the same, only the name of the customers and contractors change. The customer files a claim, the contractor comes out, insists ‘modifications’ are necessary for which the contractor upcharges a ridiculous fee. Then after multiple calls/multiple hours, FAHW states your only option is to pay the ‘modification charges’ or accept a payout (in my case, $361).
Now, mind you the contractor, while he is in your home, states that it costs a minimum of $1800 to replace a water heater. I have placed multiple calls, have 15+ names of people/extension I have spoken to and/or been disconnected from... And the last ‘manager’ I spoke with told me she doesn’t have any record of this…so they must have erased all my calls. Essentially what FAHW is making you do is pay for your own water heater and service call.
In reviewing other complaints regarding this: My upcharges/modifications are almost twice what other peoples are, coming in at $620+…hmmmm because I’m a single woman? There are no modifications needed to bring my home to code. I’ve had two licensed contractors over the years install with no modifications necessary. I don’t know how many of you are reading FAHW reviews, specifically related to water heaters, but I will be contacting FAHW corporate, the BBB etc to achieve resolution.
Additionally, I will post my experience in as many forums - Nextdoor, Google, Yelp, consumer reports - as possible to share with people my experience. I believe FAHW not only know their contractors are unfairly assessing these charges but are actually endorsing it as part of their business model, especially since the last ‘manager’ tried to insist I take the payout. There are over 20+ (almost identical) water heater related cases on this review board alone. Should there be resolution achieved, I will let you know.
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2018
Motor quit - technician arrived on time and completed repairs promptly. He was polite and advised my wife of the nature and scope of the repair. He did not try to create an aura of mystery around his work. Complete transparency.
Hi Ted, thank you for your review! Happy Holidays
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2018
You have to go through the normal menu to get stuff done with First American. Maybe it could be easier to get through the automated stuff at first. The plumber claimed to fix something and it actually wasn’t fixed. The problem was still there. But I’m not mad at him about that. He was still timely and polite. It’s good quality and I’m happy once it’s done right. First American is also wonderful and they provide good service. Their follow-up is nice. They wanna know how things went and that’s important. The reps were very helpful in connecting me with a different plumber who fixed it. And I like the companies that have signed up with First American.
Thank you Michael for your feedback, we appreciate it. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2018
My most recent experience wasn't good. I bumped the spigot in my tub and it broke off. It was a gentle bump. The contractor (they were great) told me the problem was due to bad/faulty pipes that were used. FAHW refused to cover this as they said it was not normal wear and tear??? My contract is high level and is supposed to cover "code" issues. I spend several days and several hours on the phone with them to no avail. It is hit or miss with the contractors that come out. Most look for a quick easy way to fix or rig the issue. There is one contractor who does great work and takes pride in doing a good job.
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2018
Imagine waking up at 5:30 AM in December with no heat. And the saga begins. At 5:37 a call was made to First American Home Warranty (FAHW) and actually speaking with someone who begins the claim process, stating "you'll receive an email with info on the company who will look into the heating issue. They are available from 6 AM-6 PM." It was suggested I contact them regarding my issue. The email arrived as promised.
Called Accent Comfort Services at 6:15 AM, recording states office open at 8:30 AM. Called at 8:45 AM, Accent didn't have claim. They directed me to FAHW. FAHW responded they would refax the claim but expressed confusion as to why it didn't go through earlier. Called Accent at 9:25 AM. Still no claim but told it would take 30-40 minutes to receive the claim (apparently 25 minutes was too soon) and they would call me when they received it.
No call so at approx 11 AM, I emailed FAHW expressing upset in the lack of follow up on this claim. It's December, I have no heat and no appointment. 11:45 AM Accent calls to set up my appointment between 3-4 PM tomorrow. I asked if there was any other alternative. It's December and with no heat for 48 hours, I'm concerned that the HVAC system won't be my only problem if my pipes burst. Their polite response was "we're all booked up until then but perhaps the FAHW could find another service who would be available. I did make the appointment for tomorrow but called FAHW. After a short wait, I was informed that all the other companies were "booked for today". To me, response in 48 hours is ok for a dishwasher or washer, but heat is another issue in the winter. If FAHW doesn't have enough HVAC service providers to provide services in a timely manner, perhaps they aren't the company for you or me.
Hello Gwen,
Accent Comfort Services reported your furnace was working properly on December 28, 2018. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2018
Everything went well. Much appreciated. I would recommend First American Home Warranty to friends and family. Courtesy of the representative was a pleasant experience. The promptness of getting the problem solved was quick and efficient. Thank you for being a reputable and dependable company.
Thank you Carolyn for your feedback and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2018
FA phone technician was easy to reach, and then polite and professional in soliciting information about the problem; verifying it was covered; assigning a vendor; and confirming all information via email. Vendor technician was prompt, polite and professional in diagnosing the problem and making the electrical repairs.
Thank you Keith for your review, we appreciate it. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2018
I was having issues with my sink and I submitted a claim with First American online. It was easy. I just did the work and they went ahead and assigned a plumber. The plumber came out, found the issue, did the work and everything was great. They were very professional. Unfortunately, I don’t think it was fixed the first time. It was the way that the plumbing was installed, but I called them back a few hours after they left and they came right back and fixed it. They changed out some pieces. As a new homeowner, there’s already enough expenses so having a warranty really does help.
Thank you Shan for taking the time to provide us with a review. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
The technician was efficient and completed the Air conditioning unit repair in one visit. We are happy with the insurance and find it to be good value in most cases. We actually had two claims in one day and both were completed in a timely manner.
Thank you Anne for your review! We appreciate it! Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
I’m extremely disappointed with First American. I purchased insurance with them because, 1) it’s good to have coverage when something goes wrong, and 2) I don’t live in the area and wanted a service that would contact the right contractors to fix whatever’s needed. When my furnace broke, neither of these two things happened. I had to pay over $3,000 out of my own pocket, only receiving $294 from insurance, and I had to find my own contractor to fix the issue from out of state. This is ridiculous. I would not recommend this company, and plan to look for new insurance.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
The customer service received from First American was excellent and I will be recommending them to all my friends. They sent a service person to the property within 24 hours of the time I called and the issue was resolved within 48 hours. Excellent service.
Thank you Nancy, we appreciate your feedback! Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
The technician got the door to open for about 2 days. Then problems happened again. He claimed we needed to have new rollers. He seemed to be in a hurry. We called another company when problems comtinued. Paid almost $300
Hello Linda,
Our records indicate Sameday Overhead Services Incorporated (Sameday Overhead) reset your overhead chain drive and reprogrammed your garage door opener on December 3, 2018. In addition, Sameday Overhead reported that your door needed new rollers and an adjustment. Please be advised, these items are not covered under your home warranty contract as listed under Garage Door Openers, Not Covered. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
As previously commented I performed related duties for the U.S. Government prior to retirement. First American Home Warranty is by far the best I have ever purchased. The most critical service in my opinion is the follow-up on the contractors and their performance. Previous home warranty services for me refused to even discuss follow-up when I inquired. There will be some contractors better than others but with no follow-up could mean big trouble for customers.
Thank you Garland for your feedback. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
They have been super helpful; prompt responses and no delays. This is a great program. I would recommend it for any home buyer. We purchased a 15 year old home with all the original appliances and we have had to use the policy twice already. They have been great.
Thank you Emily for your feedback, we look forward to servicing you in the future. Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
The electrician called me within 48 hours of submitting my service order. He was able to schedule my service without a delay. He arrived at my home on time. He explained the issue to me in a manner that I could understand. He was very friendly.
Hi Leila. Thank you for taking the time to provide a feedback. We are glad to hear that your electrical has been repaired. Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
Dishwasher would not end cycle. It was the board and Williams ordered it and put it in and all is working as it should now. Took a little time for the part but Williams did a fine job. I am very satisfied with my first claim and the service was great.
We are happy to hear your dishwasher was repaired. Thank you for review and for choosing First American!
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
Water heater would not heat, the plumber replaced the gas control valve, the heater worked but shut off in the middle of the night. Being the holiday with 20 people in my house I looked on the internet for help. I was able the clear the fault codes on the gas valve, it continues to work fine.
Thank you for your review Ralph. We are glad your water heater is working. We look forward to servicing your next claim!
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
Marilyn is amazing!!! Very helpful with all requests - fast responses, good at getting results for me and my family. She is experienced and always available to help. The company is well organized and very accessible. I would recommend them for all Home warranties and related needs.
Thank you Doug for taking the time to provide us with your review. We appreciate it!
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
We have a plumbing leak and AHW has now assigned our order to TWO terrible plumbers. We have no confidence in either company for this repair which is crucial and at risk for causing major water damage to our quality home.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
The technician came out and very quickly changed the code and the fan works fine. I would recommend the service to anyone. Originally the fan would turn on and off at odd times. By changing the code it fixed the problem.
Thank you for Paul for your review! Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2018
We spent $630 on a home warranty from First American Home Warranty. This covers blockages in the mainline. 2 weeks after the purchase of the home warranty I had a complete blockage of the mainline which caused a sewer spill under the crawl space of our home. I put a service request in on December 23rd. Meanwhile, my family and I had to manage without using wastewater over Christmas. I hadn't heard from anyone by December 26th, so I logged onto the online system and found that First American Home Warranty COMPLETED the service request. Their system also indicated that I owed them $75 for the service request (that never happened).
I called them and they admitted that someone completed it but their systems couldn't tell me who completed it (yeah sure). They tried to get me to directly contact their contracted plumbing service, All Express Plumbing (who by the way has over 50% 1 star reviews on Yelp). I told them that I don't have an agreement with All Express Plumbing, First American Home Warranty does. I informed First American Home Warranty that our agreement states that they will use their contracted companies to respond to claims covered in our warranty. The customer service representative was clearly annoyed with me and put me on hold twice for over 10 minutes in total.
Reviewed Dec. 25, 2018
Our water heater was spraying water all over the walls and floor. We called for a plumber and they came out. We called First American Home Warranty and was told by Ms. ** that our claim would be approved due to the fact that we had a plumber at our house and they couldn’t get a plumber there until Wednesday. She stated we would need to send in the invoice that we paid and we would be reimbursed. Yesterday we received a letter stating they were denying our claim after calling and speaking with Mario and Daniel. They are stating the same sorry but you will not be reimbursed. How can a supervisor approve a claim and tell you to email everything in and the claim is still denied. We will never use or recommend this company to anyone and will be contacting our realtor about this company and how they do not stand behind their contracts.
Reviewed Dec. 24, 2018
I've been with First American for two or three years. I've submitted claims over the phone and their reps have been awesome. Also, their techs have been good.
Hi Edgar. We appreciate your feedback and we thank you for your loyalty. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 23, 2018
I have a couple of properties and my property manager is in Virginia. She was having issues with First American Home Warranty in sending a technician out to fix one of the refrigerators on the property. Then, they sent somebody out there and the person said that they don't work on those refrigerators. Two or three weeks went by and First American sent another technician out. When this person showed up, he didn't have the right equipment and hadn't been seen ever since.
So my tenants have been without a working refrigerator for 66 days now and I know that my property manager filed a grievance against First American because she's frustrated with the whole process. This stuff wasn't brought to my attention until about a week ago. One of First American's reps, Rachel, spoke to me last week and said that they'd see if they could get me a mini fridge for my tenants and that they'd give me a $75 credit for that. But you can't even buy a miniature refrigerator for $75. I'm not gonna pay $152 on a fridge that I don't even need. I have a home warranty which I'm already paying $100 to First American and they should come fix the refrigerator that I have. Rachel called me again today and said that she was gonna see what they could do about getting a refrigerator.
My property manager was supposed to be taking care of this stuff for me. Also, I have a home warranty for that reason and as a consumer, home warranties are a valuable thing for me. But right now, it's a lot of kick in the can down the road with someone else that First American would assign to the claim. I'd reach out to this person then I'd get back to First American. It's not consistent and as the property owner, it's frustrating for me because they really need to be talking with my property manager. I'm on the West Coast and she's on the East Coast, so there's that delay of consult.
All in all, First American does a lot of things right but it's that one thing that they do wrong that people will always remember. In fact, this is the first major issue that I've ever had with them. I also have their home warranty on my property out here in California. I've used it once and it wasn't an issue for me. But I don't know what's going on with the technicians in Virginia or the lack of communication there. They're not very professional or responsive. Still, I understand that business is a business and First American have these contractors who are ultimately responsible for their unprofessionalism. That was the case with this scenario. It was just a bad contractor. The stars didn't align the right way and the problems were just compiling. But to take over 66 days to resolve something like this, especially with the refrigerator, is unacceptable.

Reviewed Dec. 23, 2018
I got the warranty and boy was I happy when a month later my bathroom sinks clogged up. Until it took 4 days to get somebody out then they were not unable to unclog the drain and said I needed a cleanout installed. First American warranty said "we don't cover that." So I bought a $25 snake and unclogged the drain myself. Just took a little intelligence, not a cleanout. So I paid $75 for a service call that was really an upsell on something that I didn't need. American home warranty is really like a pimp for crappy contractors to come into your house then upsell you.
I also had an issue with my air ducts. The plastic that covers the ducts was eroding off. They said they don't replace the insulation inside of the plastic. WHAAA...the plastic is falling off of the outside of the duct I don't need the insulation replaced I need the duct replaced. Bottom line yep they don't warranty that. I asked, "What do you mean by your warranty covers ducts." They said they replace faulty ducts. I said my ducts are faulty. They said the insulation is showing...Whatever I will do this myself too.
Reviewed Dec. 22, 2018
I sell real estate and I've been using First American Home Warranty for 33 years now. I use them on the professional end, so I just call my rep when I have a claim. I've been through a lot of interactions with their reps and they were fine. But I'm not crazy about the technicians that they send out. Most of them don't speak in English and I haven't had great experiences with a lot of them. Despite that, I'd recommend First American to others. I probably sold 800 of their policies and I'd use them.
Hello Steven. Thank you so much for your loyalty and continued service. We are doing our best to provide the best technicians for our homeowner's. We appreciate your feedback. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2018
Contact Wendy ** for your Home Warranty needs! You won't be let down by her customer service. You will receive both fast & friendly service. I will continue to recommend First American Home Warranty to my family, friends & clients.
Hi Ginger. Thank you so much for your feedback! We are happy to have you as a customer. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2018
First American Home Warranty is a sham. There is nothing "American" about it except perhaps the executive staff. When you call, you reach call centers in various countries around the world, the latest call center I communicated with was in El Salvador. Their employees speak broken English at best. When I called, FAHW assigned a contractor to provide service. However, the contractor that FAHW assigned could not provide service for two weeks. I then called FAHW again to state that a two week wait was unacceptable. Again, I attempted to communicate with another individual who confirmed that he too was in Central America (maybe that's what they mean by "American"). This individual attempted to fix the problem and said that he had found a contractor who could provide service today. He asked me if I was willing to wait on a brief hold while he worked out the details. I said yes. He then hung up on me.
So, I called FAHW a third time. Same song, different verse. Another Central American who confirmed the contractor and the arrival time later in the day. I took off work, waited, the time came and went, contractor was a no show. Tried calling the contractor, but wouldn't answer my call. So, called FAHW a fourth time. Growing very frustrated by this point. Again talked with someone in Central America. They contacted the contractor who said that circumstances came up and they could not keep their appointment. They said that maybe they could come tomorrow but no guarantees. When I said this was unacceptable, FAHW hung up on me again! Unbelievable and unprofessional. I have yet to have my claim on the so called warranty adequately addressed and fixed, but FAHW has already received the $75 payment from me for services that have yet to be rendered.
As of right now, I'm still waiting to have my problem fixed. Frankly, I'm tired of calling over and over again to no avail. When I asked to speak with a supervisor the FAHW employee informed me that he was the highest level. He said there was no one else to whom I could talk. Contacting the Better Business Bureau now, and calling an attorney friend to see what my options are. Bottom line, I would avoid this home warranty company at all cost!
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2018
I submitted a claim with First American Home Warranty for my garage door opener online and the repair company that came out was knowledgeable. They confirmed what I thought was wrong and fixed the problem right there on the spot. It was an easy fix.
Hello Alfred. We are happy to know that you had a satisfying experience. Thank you for your feedback and Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 20, 2018
1 star is very kind for this horrible company. They deserved none, I have First American Home Warranty, I called them on December 13, 2018 to request work for my leaking kitchen faucet. They referred me to "On the Spot Plumbing" with work order number. I called the Plumber right away, told him what would be earliest time he can come to fix the leak issue, he said earliest would be Tuesday Dec 18, 9 am through noon. On following Tuesday I sat in the house with my daughter who was sick that day. Waited till 11.30 am. I have not received any text or call notifying more precise time which normally most workers do. I called him, his respond was "I don't have you on my notebook" and "I have not scheduled any work for you". "I have inspection. I am busy."
When I questioned how that can be, he said, "Because you called last week"? I didn't know what he meant. He said I could be his second job if I can wait another hour, I waited till 2.30 pm. Nobody showed up I called FAHW right away. Explained the situation, the agent told me they need 4 hour to find another plumber and I should get a notification call same afternoon. Never received a single call.
Following morning I called back again. The agent told me he doesn't know any of these details (by then that was my fourth call for the same issue explaining what happened that day over and over and my only choice would be arranging with the same plumber who is willing to come in the afternoon noon till 4 pm. By no choice I agreed as I had limited usage of kitchen water. Again I was at home waiting for this plumber, once again he was no show till 4 pm, I called FHA again, they called the plumber and he said he is with dealing with traffic. Will be at my place soon, finally he showed up at 5.10 pm.
What a journey! He comes in very rudely, goes into kitchen and looks at faucet briefly and leaves and when I asked whether he will fix it, his response is, he can't fix it, it may take a day or two weeks to get parts and leaves. I called FAW once again, told them what happened. The agent said "I am sorry, we will close the work, FAW doesn't cover commercial faucet and it is been forced", this is what plumber told them. I asked immediately to talk to Supervisor, I told him I have a simple generic home faucet has leak in plastic inner layer, it is simple wear and tear, this is home not a restaurant, what does commercial faucet means. He said doesn't know and will look at the report and pictures. Next morning I will get a call.
Today is next day, 3 pm. Here I am writing this horrifying extremely stressful experience both with a plumber and FAW put me through, with still broken faucet, the precious time and energy away from my children wasted this terrible insurance company. I have used other company for many years. Never been treated as I have with First American Home Warranty over a simple faucet leak! Save your time, energy, and your money. Stay away from this company.
Reviewed Dec. 20, 2018
Placed my service request on First American's website on Thursday evening. Received a call Friday morning from the contractor and scheduled an appointment for Saturday afternoon. The service tech arrived in the time frame promised. He was courteous and neat. He remedied the problem quickly and effectively. Couldn't ask for better overall service.
Thank you Joe for your review. We appreciate you taking the time to provide us with one. Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 20, 2018
I try to submit claims to First American online. I have a mix-up with accounts so I usually call them. It only takes about five minutes and I’m done. The reps know what they’re talking about, give me the right answers and get me to where I need to be. Plus, the technicians have been excellent. They have walked me through the process of what they were gonna do and rescheduled a time to come back out to get the repair done once the part was there. I had a problem with my refrigerator though. It had a recall on it and they had to come out a few times because it kept having the same problem. Still, the other stuff that I’ve had were done. Overall, First American has been very good and I plan on keeping them for as long as I possibly can.
Hello Evan. We greatly appreciate your feedback and your loyalty with us. Thank you and Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2018
Do not buy First American Home Warranty. Contractors sent to your home will try to get out of fixing your appliance. The contractor was not able to fix my stove top range. After paying the service fee I was told by First American Home Warranty that they are not going to do anything else to try and fix the stove. I had to spend two hours on hold for customer support to tell me this.
Hello Vincent. We apologize for any inconvenience. We will be reviewing your claim to provide further assistance. Thanks, Shanee.

Reviewed Dec. 19, 2018
My water heater burst on a Saturday. I had to contact the assigned plumber on Sunday and scheduled for a visit on Monday even though agent promised to have someone call within 24 hours. On Monday, plumber came and confirmed I needed a new water heater but it would cost me extra $450. At that point I just wanted the water heater ASAP and I spoke with the agent on Monday and agreed for extra charge. Tuesday another agent calls to confirm if extra charges are ok and I explained I already said extra charges are fine and I just need the water heater ASAP. I called on Wednesday to see if water heater was shipped and an agent said she would have to check. Called back on later and an agent told me that "because of your call we have sent out the water heater."
I have pleaded that it is freezing in PA and I need the water heater ASAP. Every agent assured me that this will get handled ASAP. But if I hadn't called today they would've never shipped it out. This company could care less about your situation. It's all empty words. Also I don't understand why the order wasn't process yesterday since plumber already informed the company 2 days ago that I need the water heater replaced. Also I asked if I can cash out so I can just get it replaced and they offered $400 to replace water heater. This company is a joke.
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2018
On November 20th 2018 I contacted First American Home Warranty to request service for a non functioning dishwasher. I filled the request online and while I was printing out my service request my phone rang, it was the contractor (Ukon Appliance) who scheduled an appointment with me for the next day to diagnose the problem (now that's Service). The technician arrived on time, was knowledgeable, friendly and stated that he would order the part needed and that it could take up to a week to get the part. Three days the tech called said he had the part and could finish the job that very day. I can't say enough good things about this experience.
Thank you Ave for your feedback, we appreciate it. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2018
My mother bought a new house and First American Home Warranty came with it. Whenever she has problems, she would tell me about it and I'd call First American, and their claims process was very easy. One time, she had her locks changed and the person who answered was very helpful. She was contacted immediately by the tech and was able to schedule the service to fit her schedule. The technician that came out was very positive and my mother appreciated it.
Hello Denise. We do our best to be accommodating and are very happy that you and your mother are satisfied with the service provided. Thank you for your feedback. Happy Holidays!
Original Review: Dec. 18, 2018
I had a leaking hot water heater 9/4/18. They assigned someone who came out, took my $$ and said they would be back to replace the water heater. No has ever returned. More than 12 calls to C/S & Nothing.
Hello Brent. We apologize for the inconvenience. We are currently reviewing your claim and will have a representative in touch with you. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Dec. 18, 2018
Please stay away from First American Home Warranty. They have very poor customer support. They provide contractors who are 50-60 miles away instead of local contractors. As a result, these contractors do not service the areas regularly. Maybe once or twice in a week and if you are outside of that schedule, sorry, you have to wait. Even requesting customer support to provide a contractor closer to your residence address or zip code is not entertained and they are very rude about it. Very unprofessional service. I regret switching out of my original company. Very sorry. :)
Reviewed Dec. 18, 2018
I had an issue yesterday. Not aware that you were not receiving your monthly payments from my bank account. I hadn't received any written or electronic correspondence until yesterday. I called today regarding the issue to find out that my contract was terminated. The customer service member said they had been attempting to call me. He concluded that the only way I could have my service reinstated was if I was to pay $750 today or they could break it up into 2 payments.
I have been a loyal customer for over 14 consecutive years and this is how I was treated. To add injury to insult, your customer service agent proceed to tell me about a $500 bill they covered for me in June. I almost flipped on the phone. $500??? For a mess up from one of your contractors that you had to send another contractor out to fix...I've paid you all more than $500 this year alone. Needless to say I refuse to patronize any company that is disloyal to long-time customers. This company has become incompetent over the last couple of years with poor customer service agents and dishonest contractors. I'm sure your letter was a blessing. Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 18, 2018
I have been with them for 3 years straight never used their services till I had a busted water heater. It happened on a Tuesday, I called First American home Warranty the next day Wednesday, on Friday they send a contractor. He looked and assessed the damage and left. Then I didn’t get the repair till the next Wednesday after so many calls begging for a rush service.
A month later I called to get my septic tank pumped. They told me I need to locate a contractor myself and they said they would reimburse me only 1/3 of the cost because they couldn’t find any contractor that serves my area. Well back and forth with the service department I decided to cancel my contract. They are crooks. Please don’t use them. They just want your money. Service is 0 to 10.
Reviewed Dec. 18, 2018
First American Home Warranty was selected for me by my realtor. My hot water heater was not working on a Friday night. I was told the vendor would contact me within 3 hours. This did not occur. I contacted First American the next day and was routed to a call center in Central America where I was hung up on and told the only way to resolve the issue was taking a cash out. I simply wanted a new vendor as the one sent to my home was not honest and had a poor rating on Yelp and wanted to upcharge me 500. I waited until Monday and spoke to the area manager who once again passed the problem to claims. They flat out refused to send a new vendor or resolve the problem without cash out even though the amount offered would not cover the costs of another person to install and dispose of the water heater.
I finally accepted that I would not get a new vendor and took the cash out which means a check won’t even be issued for 5 to 7 business days. The end result is I will be without hot water for almost 2 weeks. The company would not even overnight the check!!! American Home Warranty uses bad vendors then refuses to change the vendor and places the blame on the consumer. I would not recommend using this home warranty company. Please chose another one.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2018
I recently bought a home and purchased this home warranty. I even bought the extra premier package to ensure everything was covered. A week into the house I noticed water under my water heater. This was included in my warranty, so I called First American. They were very responsive and sent a contractor out right away. I knew my heater was cracked but the insurance company requires a technician to verify (which is understandable). I paid my $75 fee thinking that would be my only cost. The technician spent a total of 1 minute in my house looking at the water heater confirming it was cracked. The next day I received a phone call from First American telling me that there would be an additional fee of $285. I immediately responded with disbelief and questioned the charges.
They explained that my policy did include additional costs to bring the equipment to code, but this did not fall into that category. The fees the contractor was charging are $110 to replace the water lines and $110 to replace the pressure and temperature lines. They also wanted to charge me $65 to add a drain pan under my tank. First American told me that I had to speak to the contractor if I needed more information. I call the contractor and asked them why there were additional charges. They told me that it was their policy that they can't install a new tank without these items. Even though there was no evidence of damage I had to pay for the additional charges out of pocket.
I contacted First American about this and they told me that I only had two choices. One, pay the extra money to the contractor to make repairs, or two, take a buy out and deal with it myself. The buyout was only $370. Barely enough to pay for a cheap tank. I asked First American if I could at least get my $75 service fee back, they told me that since a technician arrived at my house, I could not get that back. I paid $75 to get my water heater fixed but now I must pay another $285 for recommended parts or else I lose my $75. This is the definition of extortion. First American should stand by their customers and not their contractors. If a contractor is requiring parts to be changed then the insurance should cover this. If you say $75 is the fee to get it fixed, then it should be it. I am now going to have to watch YouTube videos and figure out how to install this myself.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2018
I currently have 3 claims with this company. None resolved. I'll just highlight the main issue. The thermostat on my oven went out, and I paid the service tech the $75 when he came and looked at it. They couldn't locate the part because the oven is old. First American Home Warranty tells me they escalated the situation and are looking for the part, and that if they can't find it in 24 hours they'll get me a new oven. Next day comes and they tell me they need 48 hours. Next businesses day I ask to speak with a supervisor. This guy tells me they have an indefinite amount of time to find the part. They have no problem giving you the runaround, because they aren't obligated to help you. Don't use this company if you expect decent service and helpful people. These people's goal is to do nothing and take your money. Only gave 1 star because it wouldn't let me give 0.
Hello John,
First American has been unable to reach you to discuss your appliance and plumbing claim. Please contact First American at your earliest convenience to discuss your claims.
Thank you.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2018
So we bought our house Nov 2017 and our first electric bill was over 400$. Called to get the heat fixed through the warranty and had them come out about a total of 4 times, they replaced a gauge which we were told cost 1800$ so I thought we were getting our money's worth. Well it’s still broken over a year later so I renewed my warranty coverage through First American because I was afraid of this. They sent out a NEW contractor instead of the old company and it’s been 2 weeks in December without heat now. We’re being told now that the part has just now been ordered and should take 3-4 days. The contractor does not work weekend so now we will be out of heat on Christmas as well. I’m very dissatisfied. I will not be renewing and encouraging everyone I know to steer clear of this company.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2018
I had to cancel my warranty due to awful service and customer support. This warranty company is a scam and doesnt actually help with any repairs. First issue I had was the air conditioning in my house was blowing hot air, I paid a service fee approximately four or five times for you guys to send out a technician that only checked the servicing and said the servicing is good, it should be working but it wasn't and they would leave. After the 5th time I had to hire my own HVAC company and pay for them to fix the wiring and eventually replace my HVAC unit.
The second issue that I had was a leaking toilet after the first service call the technician replaced a valve but had to be called back because it was still leaking. When he came back he said he replaced a gasket but what do ya know it still leaked. I then went and bought a toilet tank gasket kit and replaced all the seals myself and now it doesnt leak.
The third issue my garage door wouldn't open, which I was told my garage door was covered when I signed up for my second year of coverage. The technician came out and told me the spring was broken and surprise wasn't covered under my warranty. So I'm now saving up money to replace my spring and door.The last and final claim I placed was a heater vent in one of my bedrooms had no flow coming out. I placed the claim last week and never got a callback or an appointment scheduled for someone to come look at it. I called back today and was told vents aren't covered. What is the point in paying for a service and a $75 service fee for each visit, if literally every issue I have placed a claim for I have had to fix myself or pay someone else to fix it. Thanks for stealing my money and not holding up your end of the bargain.
Reviewed Dec. 16, 2018
With First American, sometimes I feel like my problem isn't specifically listed on their website. The categories that are in the drop box menu does not match the problem that I'm having. Still, things have always worked out fine. Almost every time I found my own technician because they don't really have technicians in the area, except for Sears, which is the only one that's ever been sent by First American. Other than that, I haven't had any issues with my home warranty and I'm satisfied with them.
Hi Erika, thank you for the feedback!! Happy Holidays
Reviewed Dec. 16, 2018
First American. Not in the league of good companies for customer service. Our real estate salesperson purchased a policy from this company for us. I normally would not purchase a home warranty. A waste of money. Well, our pool heater was found to be malfunctioning. First American found fine print in their policy to avoid repairing the unit. Even though the policy was supposed to cover the pool and its components, First American would not cover it. I even contacted the CEO and one of their VPs. Other companies I have dealt with when I had warranty issues provided stellar support. HP, Costco, Sam's Club, Safelite, and Whirlpool. These companies do very well in taking care of the customer. First American Home Warranty is not in their league. I strongly recommend you avoid them.
Hello Joseph,
Our records indicate you have a heat pump pool heater which is not covered under your home warranty contract. You may refer to your contract under Pool/Spa Equipment, Not Covered: Heat pumps. Please be advised, in the interest of customer service, your $75.00 service call fee was waived.
This claim is considered closed.
Reviewed Dec. 16, 2018
We've been with First American for 13 years now and our experience has been very good. We submit claims to First American over the phone and our interactions with their reps have been very good. The quality of work of the technicians that have been sent was fine. They were very prompt and courteous, and everything was done quite professionally. We've highly recommended First American to a friend of ours.
We had a situation taken care of earlier this year regarding a faulty garage door. There were times that when we pressed the remote, the door would not go up and down properly. The techs came over within a day after we called in the claim. The problem was the adjustment of the motor, but now it's working fine. One time, there was a problem with regard to a fan above our dryer. It was a odd-shaped fan, and the tech went out of his way to get the parts for us. Another issue that we had was with a knob on our electric stove, and again, it was one of those odd-ball type knobs. We had a little trouble with that though because the first two techs couldn't find the part. It was also around Christmas time, so they were backed up and there was no way they could come over right away. But the third one worked out fine, and he was very good. It was a very odd part, and he found it.
Thank you Theodore for your feedback, we appreciate it. Happy Holidays.
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
The water leak was repaired in a timely manner and to my complete satisfaction. Each time I have had a problem First American Home Warranty has responded quickly when notified and each repair has been performed satisfactorily.
Hi Ted. We are happy to hear about your positive claim experience. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how we are doing. We appreciate you and your business. Happy Holidays!!
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
I am so thankful I have the warranty policy. It has been a lifesaver to be able to have unexpected expenses as the home appliances breakdown. Michelle in San Antonio is very personable and knowledgeable. She contacts the repairman and my repairs are made in short time.
Hi Carol. Thank you for the review! We are happy to hear that you have found the value in your home warranty. Happy Holidays!!
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
Repair went smoothly but getting parts took longer than expected, over three weeks. Not sure if excess deposit has been refunded yet. Repairman was courteous and efficient. Cleaned up workspace and made certain repairs were complete. Friendly and very professional.
Hi Eilieen. Thank you for the review. We are so happy to hear about your positive claim experience. We appreciate you taking the time to let us know how we are doing. Happy Holidays!!
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
I have been aligned with FAHW for 5 years and have had numerous claims. I have been completely satisfied with every claim. Each claim has not been without problems, but it has not been with them but with the contractors.
Hi Doylene. Thank you for letting us know how we are doing. We are so happy to hear that you have found the value of your home warranty! We look forward to providing you with another positive claim experience. Happy Holidays
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
Very disappointed. I waited more the 20 day to get my heater fix. I cancel my Thanksgiving dinner because my heater was broken. Also the company Coaches HVAC ExtraordianAir was very unprofessional. I call more the 10 time and most the time never get good answer.
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
I have no complaints with any of the plumbers sent out to my house anytime. I always received quality work in a timely manner. The workers/companies sent out were always very professional and friendly. I am so glad we are with First American Home Warranty.
Hi Connie. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how we are doing. We appreciate you and your business. Happy Holidays from our family to yours!!
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
First American's website is really good, but their phone service is terrible. It's great that you can request for a service, but they simply just kick it to a contractor, and then you're gonna have to hope, wait and see that a contractor picks it up. In my particular case, it happened on a Friday night. They gave me a contractor that doesn’t work Saturday or Sunday, so I have to wait until some time on Monday to talk to them, and they couldn’t get it scheduled until Tuesday or Wednesday. It's really hard to go without plumbing in your house for five days. And if you call them and you tell them it's an emergency, it still isn’t a guarantee that you're gonna get somebody that can help you in a timely fashion. Also lately, when I talked to anybody on the phone, it's very hard to understand them and they don’t really seem to understand what's going on.
I've had good techs and I've had some that were absolutely terrible. I've had some that I'd called back and reported to them that they should not be the people that they ever use or consider using. I never heard anything back or didn’t receive any follow-up and for all I know, they're still out working and other unsuspecting people are using them. First American needs to have a better feedback process for their contractors that they're using and not using, and they also need to hold them accountable for service response time. They are good about matching you with somebody within 24 hours, and it happens within minutes, but that doesn’t guarantee you will have service within 24 hours. Depending on the day and the problem, it could still be, like in my case, almost a week. And depending on what it is, that’s not doable.
It is unfortunate that I could just go around them and just hire somebody myself and have somebody the same day or next day and pay out-of-pocket. Their biggest issue is vendor management. But I've renewed with First American three or four times. They still have a great price and I still get what I need from a home warranty, overall.
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2018
First American is a great company and they do a good job. They give very good and prompt service. Plus, they follow up with the customer. If you have a complaint about the company that they hired to do your work, call them and they would fix the problem. You don't have to worry about being involved with it and so, they have good customer relations and satisfactory service. Most of their technicians will volunteer without being prompted to tell you that they're one of the better home warranty companies.
Hi Dan, thank you for taking the time to leave this review! We appreciate you and hope you have a wonderful holiday season.
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2018
When we purchased our home, the contract passed along a home warranty through First American Home Warranty. After 3 technicians coming out, the second which had no idea why he came out our house, the warranty company could not agree (claim specialist said one thing, customer service said another. Make sure they email you in writing for your records) on how to resolve the issue, nor could they return phone calls and communicate the direction that was being taken. This has now gone on for over a month, and still I am having to call daily to get answers. Terribly frustrating. Just communicate accurately and regularly.
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2018
I've been with First American for six months and so far, it's been good with them. Their website is easy to use to file claims. My wife has interacted with their reps and she's been happy. Also, the techs they've sent out have been professional and have done high-quality work. I would recommend First American.
Thank you Lance for taking the time to let us know how we are doing. We are happy to hear that you have had such positive experiences and we look forward to providing you another positive experience with your next claim. Happy Holidays!!
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2018
I'd been with several different providers and their plans didn’t cover a lot of things that needed to be covered and First American did. Even though it was a little bit pricier at the time, it was of better value for me because I'm 68 years old and I don't have anyone to replace the garbage disposal and fix anything at home. I felt like I gotta get a plan with them and their service was great. My interactions with their claims reps were always good and I never had a problem. Their technicians were better qualified to do what they were supposed to do than the other companies I've been with. However, I sold my house and I don't have First American anymore. I had them them for four years and I would recommend anyone that's looking for a home warranty to go with them because I had been with three different ones that I was not happy with.
Hi Brenda. We are very happy to hear that you are happy with your home warranty provided by us. We thank you for the feedback and wish you a very Happy Holiday season.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2018
Had 3 claims with this company and none was resolved. They just patched the issue rather than a fix and problem kept showing up every 3-4 months and they would patch up again and charge service fee again and again.
Hello AG. We apologize for any inconvenience. We have tried reaching you to discuss. Please feel free to contact us back to discuss further. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2018
Bought a house with the warranty. Second day in house November 28 and still waiting. First plumber said they couldn’t fix it and they said they would send second plumber out. I am still waiting. Water heater broke and the company said they ordered the piece and it would come in the mail, I am still waiting for that also. This company is a scam because they charge $75.00 to send someone and they fiddle around the house for one hour and then call American Home Warranty and say they can’t fix the issue. American Home said they would send someone else and I am still waiting. Please save your money because this company does not solve your issues and you waste time calling them.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2018
I've had to use my warranty coverage several times. First American Home Warranty did/performed EXACTLY as they said they would. The amount of money I pay for this Outstanding Service Pails by comparison to not having this coverage. I've already recommended this insurance to several home buying friends!
Thank you David for your review!
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2018
I've had First American for my home warranty for years. For the most part, it's been fine with them. Their website works fine when I submit a claim and their customer service team has gotten things done. The techs they've sent were okay too. However, the first one who came in for my last repair could have done more than he did, but he didn't. Then, the second one who came in place of him tried to sell me a new furnace and although it wasn't a bad idea, it just wasn't what I was looking for from a technician. I also have an unresolved issue at the moment on my last service. Still, First American has been good. They do what they say they're gonna do and that's the important thing. If I have a problem, they get it fixed. Also, the value for what I get is good.
Hi Geoffrey. Thank you for taking the time to let us know how we are doing. Please contact us regarding your unresolved issue as we are happy to help. Happy Holidays!
Reviewed Dec. 12, 2018
This pertains to the Pensacola/Gulf Breeze area. Upon filing a claim for our newly purchased house - the plumbing crew erroneously diagnosed the problem and First American denied our claim. Upon bringing out 3 separate licensed contractors, they all correctly diagnosed the problem, but First American stuck with their incorrect conclusion. Most corrupt warranty company.
Hello Ken,
Upon review, we have sustained the denial of your plumbing claim. Please be advised, your contractors indicated the shower and tiling need to be replaced which is not covered by your home warranty contract. At this time, your claim is considered closed.
Reviewed Dec. 12, 2018
First American is very valuable and we'll probably continue with the warranty. We don’t wanna be hit with some big repair bill so we figured it's best to have the warranty. I usually go on the computer and submit claims. It's easy and user-friendly. So far, I've had two things. I've had a plumber and an air conditioner person come out and they've both been good.
Hi Bob. Thank you for the review. We are happy to hear that you have found the value of your home warranty. We look forward to servicing your next claim. Happy Holidays!!
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2018
My water heater rusted out. I contacted FAHW and met the technician at my home to review the repair needed. He concluded the water heater needed replaced. The next day FAHW contacted me to tell me they would order the water heater but that the plumbing contractor was requesting an additional $680 from me to do the install as there were major modifications required. I'm in the home building business so I know what needs to be done and there are no minor modifications let alone major ones. The only extra is to replace the gas line as required for a new installation (at a cost of less than $40).
When I complained to FAHW they offered me a "cash out" which came to less than the discounted cost of the water heater, thereby leaving no money for the delivery and installation of the replacement water heater. I contacted the contractor and he said it didn't matter that there were no modifications, he wouldn't do the job for any less than $570 because he bid the job with FAHW too low to make any money without charging the customer extra. I contacted FAHW and they said I had no recourse but to pay the contractor his fraudulent fee or take the cash out. Needless to say I won't renew my contract with FAHW.
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2018
I placed a claim 6 months ago for a broken fridge. I have had countless repair companies/contractors come to "fix" the fridge - all of whom say it is unfixable. And yet First American continues to send out another service company only to say it's the same unfixable problem. And yet First American refuses to issue any compensation to replace the fridge. I have spoken to multiple Supervisors and when I ask to speak w/ their supervisor, they claim they are unable to speak w/ customers. Arguably the worst service company I have ever encountered. #NeverAgain
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2018
I called First American on 11/29/18 for service to fix our furnace which is not heating our house. It's now 12/11/19 and we have never heard or seen a repair person. I have been on the phone with First American seven times and all they keep saying is that they are trying to locate a contractor. Really?? I see repair vans driving by my house several times a day! Meanwhile it's 17 degrees outside and 40 degrees inside our house. We have been using space heaters for two weeks now!! STAY AWAY FROM THIS WARRANTY COMPANY!
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2018
It was the first year and only one claim but I must say I have dealing with others, this is lowest. The plumber they sent wanted to make deal but I did not accept. The second company changed the expensive end of the tub faucet with the cheapest on the market $15.00. He refused to touch the clogged tub and walked away. This process took over month and I was lucky to leave this miserable warranty as my year expired. Their staff are dedicated for saying no or giving excuses.
Hello Ismail,
We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. Our records indicate Cal Home Construction Incorporated replaced the tub diverter as it had failed. Please be advised, in the interest of customer service, We reimbursed your $75.00 service call fee. Your claim is considered closed.
Thank you.
First American Home Warranty Company Information
- Company Name:
- First American Home Warranty
- Year Founded:
- 1984
- City:
- Santa Rosa
- State/Province:
- CA
- Website:
- homewarranty.firstam.com
Media



