SimpliSafe vs. Xfinity

Author picture
Written by Amanda Futrell
Edited by Justin Martino

Quick and easy. Get matched with a Home Security partner.

    How are SimpliSafe and Xfinity different?

    Xfinity and SimpliSafe provide customizable options for home security systems. Both have preselected equipment packages to choose from — SimpliSafe offers five packages and Xfinity offers three, but both make it easy to purchase additional equipment.

    Installation and cost

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Installation typeDIYProfessional
    Installation feeFree$100
    Upfront costBuild-your-own systems start at $129 with interactive monitoringEquipment cost of $360 to $600+; financing available
    Trial period60-day return window30-day money-back guarantee
    Contract termsNo-contract options availableTwo years
    simplisafe logoDIYFreeBuild-your-own systems start at $129 with interactive monitoring60-day return windowNo-contract options available
    xfinity logoProfessional$100Equipment cost of $360 to $600+; financing available30-day money-back guaranteeTwo years

    Monitoring plans and pricing

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Monitoring price range$15 to $25$30+
    Monitoring optionsProfessional or self-monitoredProfessional and self-monitored
    Self-monitoringFreeSelf protection feature available (live recorded video) for $10/month
    Upgraded self-monitoringNot offered
    24/7 professional monitoring$15/month$30+
    Upgraded professional monitoring$25/month$40+
    simplisafe logo$15 to $25Professional or self-monitoredFreeNot offered$15/month$25/month
    xfinity logo$30+Professional and self-monitoredSelf protection feature available (live recorded video) for $10/month$30+$40+

    Security equipment

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Wired or wireless?WirelessWireless
    Camera optionsIndoor and outdoor camerasIndoor and outdoor cameras
    Video doorbell
    Control panel
    Motion sensor
    Entry sensor
    Glass break sensor
    Keychain remote
    SirenNot specified
    Panic buttonVia touch-screen control panel
    Yard sign
    simplisafe logoWirelessIndoor and outdoor cameras
    xfinity logoWirelessIndoor and outdoor camerasNot specifiedVia touch-screen control panel

    Smart-home features

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Smart locksCompatible with August, Kwikset and Yale
    Smart lightsCompatible with GE (Jasco), Leviton, LIFX, Lutron Castéta, Phillips Hue, Sengled
    Smart thermostatCompatible with Carrier Cor, ecobee, Zen
    Garage door controlCompatible with Chamberlain LiftMaster
    Temperature sensor
    Water sensor
    Smoke detector
    CO2 detector
    simplisafe logo
    xfinity logoCompatible with August, Kwikset and YaleCompatible with GE (Jasco), Leviton, LIFX, Lutron Castéta, Phillips Hue, SengledCompatible with Carrier Cor, ecobee, ZenCompatible with Chamberlain LiftMaster

    Technology

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Mobile app
    Mobile app monitoring
    iOS rating4.84.4
    Android rating4.34.5
    Notification/alert optionsPush, text and emailText, email, push and TV
    Home automation capabilities
    Voice integration
    Amazon Alexa
    Google HomeNot specified
    Other integrationsApple Watch, August LocksNot specified
    simplisafe logo4.84.3Push, text and emailApple Watch, August Locks
    xfinity logo4.44.5Text, email, push and TVNot specifiedNot specified

    Reputation on ConsumerAffairs

    simplisafe logoxfinity logo
    Overall star rating3.73.8
    Verified customer reviewsSimpliSafe reviewsXfinity reviews
    simplisafe logo3.7SimpliSafe reviews
    xfinity logo3.8Xfinity Home reviews

    All information accurate as of publishing date.

    Quick and easy. Get matched with a Home Security partner.

      SimpliSafe highlights

      SimpliSafe is known for easily integrating with home automation equipment and smart devices, including Alexa and Google Home. It also provides five equipment package options to meet a variety of budget needs.

      Much of SimpliSafe’s equipment can be self-installed, but you can choose to have it professionally installed for $79 if you prefer. As of the time of publication, you receive a 25% discount on equipment if you opt in to 24/7 interactive monitoring.

      SimpliSafe plans

      • The Foundation ($229): The Foundation includes a base station, one entry sensor, a keypad and one motion sensor.
      • The Essentials ($259): The Essentials is SimpliSafe’s most popular package. It includes the base station, one motion sensor, three entry sensors and a keypad.
      • The Hearth ($374): The Hearth includes one base station, a keypad, one motion sensor, a siren, a key fob, three entry sensors and a smoke detector.
      • The Knox ($449): The Knox includes a base station, six entry sensors, two motion sensors, a keypad, a key fob, a siren and a smoke detector.
      • The Haven ($489): The Haven has the most equipment of SimpliSafe’s packages — it includes the base station, a key fob, a siren, a panic button, four entry sensors, a keypad, a smoke detector, two motion sensors, a temperature sensor and a water sensor.
      • Build Your Own System ($184+): The Build Your Own System starts with a keypad and base station. More equipment can be added for an extra cost.

      What SimpliSafe customers say

      Many SimpliSafe customers mention the ease of setup and installation in reviews left on ConsumerAffairs. Users enjoy monitoring their system remotely through the app and mention positive experiences with the SimpliSafe customer service team. Some customers did experience issues, with a few mentioning equipment not functioning properly and needing to be fixed.

      I’ve had them for many years. The system is easy to install yourself, the people are wonderful, very helpful and they work with you to figure out any problems you may have. Customer service is alive and well with Simpli Safe!

      Terry of Philadelphia, PA

      Xfinity highlights

      Xfinity provides home security systems with two monitoring options. You don’t need to sign a contract for monitoring, and you can self-monitor through the phone app. There are three equipment packages to choose from, and you can easily add on equipment. Xfinity partners with several companies to provide smart-home integration.

      Xfinity plans

      • Base Home System: The Base Home System includes a touch-screen controller, three door/window sensors, one pet-friendly motion sensor and a battery/cellular system backup. Pricing is $15 a month for 24 months or an upfront payment of $360.
      • Complete Home System: The Complete Home System is $20 a month for 24 months or $480 upfront. This system includes the touch-screen controller, five door/window sensors, a wireless keypad, a pet-friendly motion sensor, one HD indoor/outdoor camera and a battery/cellular system backup.
      • Ultimate Home System: The Xfinity Ultimate Home System has the most equipment included for $25 a month for 24 months or an upfront cost of $600. This package includes the touch-screen controller, 10 door/window sensors, a pet-friendly motion sensor, two HD indoor/outdoor cameras and a battery/cellular backup.

      What Xfinity customers say

      Xfinity Home has mixed feedback on ConsumerAffairs. Customers who enjoy the system like the HD cameras, mobile app and quality and price of the service. Customers who left negative feedback recount difficulty getting issues resolved via customer service.

      I am pleased with the way my home is monitored and I haven't had any issues with false alarms like many people experience. [The] system is fully operational. I experienced NO glitches or service interruptions so far, and I couldn't be happier."

      Karen of Philadelphia, PA

      Bottom Line: SimpliSafe or Xfinity?

      SimpliSafe and Xfinity are both great options for customers who are looking for equipment packages with the option to add on devices. Both provide multiple options for different budget types and have equipment that can be installed by the customer or by a professional for an additional fee.

      • SimpliSafe is best for customers who want more equipment package options with the ability to add more equipment.
      • Xfinity is best for customers who need the home security system to integrate with other smart devices.
      Did you find this article helpful? |
      Share this article