FOLLOW US

OurTime.com
OurTime.com
Overall Satisfaction Rating
1.28/5
  • 5 stars
    2
  • 4 stars
    3
  • 3 stars
    8
  • 2 stars
    11
  • 1 stars
    131
Based on 155 ratings submitted in the last yearSHOW RATING DISTRIBUTION

OurTime

ConsumerAffairs Unaccredited Brand

This company is not yet accredited. To learn more, see reviews below or submit your own. Want to know more about ConsumerAffairs accredited brands? Check out ConsumerAffairs for Brands.

Be in the know

Get trending consumer news and recalls

Thanks

Keep an eye on your inbox, the lastest consumer news is on it's way!

250 OurTime.com Consumer Reviews and Complaints

Filter by: Any
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 17, 2018

From the moment I became a subscriber I realized that I had made a mistake. I was contacted by phony profiles who were only interested in obtaining personal information on me. Take heed. Be warned, this site is a scam infested social media nightmare.

3 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 13, 2018

The site appears to be a scam... based in fake profiles and no regard to personal preferences. Most every message received is from out of state, with the same M. O., almost the same details like being written from a script. They disappear quick once you let them know. I specified local contacts, daily I would get profiles from all over the east coast. Save your time and money, steer clear of OurTime.com!

12 people found this review helpful
Get expert advice delivered right to your inbox

We try to avoid the fluff and deliver tips and guides that really matter

Thank you, you have successfully subscribed to our newsletter!Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
Unsubscribe easily whenever you want
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 13, 2018

I signed up yesterday with ourtime.com for a free account. I filled out everything and uploaded some pictures. I immediately was bombarded with "Likes", "Somebody favorite you" and "Messages". Of course, with a free account you are not able to see who it was. One has to subscribe in order to see this info. This was going on throughout most of the night. This morning I logged back in and discovered in the "Notification" field (on the bottom of the main site) that somebody had sent a answer to my message.

This was rather confusing to me since as unpaid member I was not able to send any messages. This clearly means that somebody sent out a message in my name without my consent. I found this highly disturbing and immediately deleted my account. In general, Ourtime.com is doing everything possible to trick you into becoming a paid member and I find this behavior highly questionable and unethical.

View more
13 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 13, 2018

When I tentatively joined to have a look, I got stalled according to their estimation, at 18% complete, so I gave up and went to bed. Then began a steady stream of notifications, asking for money, showing me my matches, flirts, propositions etc. Although I unsubscribed (successfully, by their reply) numerous times, the spam just kept coming, 24 hours a day. Women from as far away from Edmonton as Des Moines Iowa were apparently desperate to meet a guy with no picture and an 18% profile. I have (successfully, according to their warped command of the English language) unsubscribed a bunch more times, but the spam just keeps coming. Avoid these charlatans the way you would a steaming mound of Ebola vomit.

14 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 12, 2018

Where do I begin? This site is full of scammers and catfish! I have connected online with three people and they all turned out to be scammers. The latest forgot to mention on his profile that he has a child. Also represented his self on profile as being in the science/engineering field and is supposedly doing automotive bodywork (how is that scientific?). He sent a phone number for texting, which belonged to a woman (probably the wife?). When I declined his offer to meet for lunch, he sent a tirade about things I will not write here, but suffice it to say that he would have made me a 65 year old sex slave if he had his way! Incredible. Also my matches rarely had anything to do with what I wanted as far as level of education, even got some from women... STAY AWAY FROM THIS BUSINESS. You have been forewarned.

17 people found this review helpful
How do I know I can trust these reviews about OurTime.com?
  • 1,168,455 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

For more information about reviews on ConsumerAffairs.com please visit our FAQ.

Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 11, 2018

If you make any indication in your profile that you cannot IMMEDIATELY respond to messages for any reason, your profile essay will get declined. The terms of service say that you cannot say that you are not paying member. Which means they want everybody to appear as if they can respond to you immediately, whether they can or not. But what OurTime does not tell you is that you cannot not state that you are unable to immediately respond to messages FOR ANY REASON. For example, you cannot say the following... "I won't be logging on for a few weeks, because I have some personal issues that I need to take of, but I promise to get back with you." If you say something like that (or anything remotely similar), your essay will get declined.

This is policy is extremely shady and deceptive. After I reworded my essay it got declined for the second time, I took my pictures down and moved on. It's no skin off my back to go to Match.com. The same people are probably on there and then some. Why waste money on a third-rate website that goes out of their way to block people who are trying to be open and honest?

View more
18 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 3, 2018

Just signed up for OurTime after having a free account for a couple of months that I did not use. It seemed like a safe site and connected to Match.com which I think has a fairly good reputation overall. Decided to add photos to my profile on the free account but when I did, the photos were tagged as pending for 2 days in a row. On 3rd day when I tried to log in, my account was not accessible so I called the customer service number given on the message displayed. The CS rep was pleasant and tried to retrieve my account but after searching several ways, she could not find any evidence of an account being set up. She suggested I start over with new account. I did and decided to give it a shot and try the paid subscription. Immediately I began getting "flirts", photo likes and some weird messages... many from out of state.

I then discovered the site had sent out a whole bunch of photo "likes" and posed questions from my account to other members without my consent. Of course, I was horrified! The site sent multiple communications to some members making me look like a stalker! I've now read here that other members have experienced the same. I also read about the automatic renewal issue and have gone in and disabled this feature and will watch my credit card. It's been 2 days and the site seems pretty scary. I've definitely seen strange profiles that seem to be fake with exactly the same "in a nutshell" wording but with different photos and cities. After reading some of the reviews here, I am considering just deleting my profile.

I joined Match.com years ago. I was only on that site for about a week before beginning a long term relationship with someone I met on the site. Match experience was a bit overwhelming but seemed more reputable than this offshoot. I guess I'll give it a week and see what happens. I'm sure there must be some normal people on the site - or maybe they all get quickly disgusted with it and get off? I'm very hesitant to communicate with anyone on the site after reading about some of the scams and fake profiles others have experienced. I guess best advice to other women joining the site is "beware and be safe".

View more
33 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 3, 2018

This website is an absolute joke and a fraud besides. They show you a photo of a person and when you try to pursue it, it often turns out to be a different person in a different city. DO NOT join this site. Customer service is non-existent. They connect you to someone in the Philippines and then that person refuses to allow a supervisor to come on because they are told just to repeat the same lines over and over. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY.

37 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: July 1, 2018

I wanted to take a look at this website and provided little more than my email address. After a few minutes I tried to deactivate the "account". The website advertises that you can cancel at any time and your information will be deleted. Upon checking my "account status" I receive the message that account information is unavailable. I sent them email asking that they delete my account and information and they reply that the account, which existed for all of a few hours, was under review by their security folks and they can't delete it. It's the roach motel folks, you can get in but you can't get out. Luckily I didn't sign up or provide and personal information. They do this probably to artificially inflate their "membership" numbers. What a scam. Stay away.

35 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 29, 2018

This online dating site automatically debit my checking for 7 months at 30 bucks a pop. No email. No notification. Nothing. I obviously don't check my account with a fine tooth comb - had a major medical issue but now I need to add it to the list - Scam. I need to let bank know and I've went on the site to cancel. I don't see a phone number to call.

23 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 22, 2018

Especially for seniors this site leads you right into fraud and worse. It's a very spammy site with many phony profiles whose sole interest is to secure personal information. I've been on other dating sites and like Match.com this site is VERY SPAMMY and many people aren't who they see. Here are guidelines that I live by on dating sites:

1. Don't reply to any profile without a picture. 2. Don't give out your email/phone etc unless you've had a few exchanges with the person. 3. Unless you're considering a long distance relationship, block or ignore those who contact you beyond your city/state. Chances are, the people aren't real. 4. Ask questions and if they don't get you answers that satisfy you break off contact/block the person from contacting you again. 5. In the text of profile look for inconsistencies and evidence of broken English. 6. Prefer to be lonely/disappointed rather than to be lonely/disappointed/broke/identity compromised. 7. Use this site as ONLY one part of your social program and include meetup groups, volunteer work, time with family friends.

View more
52 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 22, 2018

I've read many of the reviews, and from my own experience, I think this site engages in some questionable/unethical practices. While it is important to remember, like offline dating, this requires effort, good judgment and a sense of humor, at times, there are some real problems OT introduces into the brave world of dating over 50:

Fake messages ARE generated from your account and sent to other members who you did not screen/select. This serves to flatter you and retain members because you are getting messages, photo "likes" and "flirts" from these members in return. Often, you have nothing in common. You will recognize these by the subject line which will read "ECHO:" And most of them will come from states well outside of your "radius."

Fake profiles are rampant. These are easy to spot because the photo looks like a professionally taken portrait in many cases and the profile will be sparse and generic. These are for appearance to encourage users and likely many set up by non-members - who knows why. Scammers do fish in these waters. This is just common sense... Do NOT provide your email, address or phone number right off the bat. If you do provide an email early in the getting acquainted process - create a separate email account for this purpose that does not include your first/last name. Scammers will use words like "destiny," and "soulmate", often claim to be widowed, will use poor grammar/typos, and will always eventually ask for money.

Infidelity is not the site's issue - but is a fact of online dating. Statistics say 50%+ of actual members are either married or in a relationship and looking for something on the side or something better. Often these individuals will not post photos and use fake zip codes/cities to remain anonymous. Data is drama filled enough without throwing that into the equation. If they don't send a photo at some point, quickly cut your losses. I made a mistake of spending 2 months corresponding with a man who seemed wonderful, genuine, educated...but was "private" about his appearance because he said I was out of his league.

I've never judged people based on appearance (in fact the best looking men can be arrogant), so I let it continue. DON'T do that. He was married. OT will keep your expired account/profile live - and people will message you, but you won't/can't respond. Just be aware of that. Best of luck. But I vote for getting "out there" in the real world doing things you love...as the best way to meet quality/like-minded individuals.

View more
32 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 18, 2018

I joined OURTIME about 2 weeks ago. The first person that I began talking to said that his subscription was about out and asked if we could talk on Google hangout. This is the first dating site I have been on and didn't think anything of it when he asked to talk on Google hangout. After talking for a few times, I realized that English did not seem to be his primary language. He told me that he had a post graduate degree in Business Admin. and that he was educated here in the US. I finally caught on and told him never to contact me again. Then began to receive some really nasty emails from people I didn't recognize.

I didn't open them fearing he may be trying to install malware on my computer possibly trying to get my financial information. Today, 6/17, I met someone that at first glance appeared to be a really nice guy. He asked if we could email each other. Should have learned my lesson. Just after two exchanges, this person began saying exactly the same thing the other person did. It was the same person, just different photos and had a different state that he supposedly lived in. I am appalled that this company, as much money as they take in, and with the ability to vet people, just allow this garbage to happen.

View more
45 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 10, 2018

From October 2017 to January 2018 my profile was hacked two times. Pictures and geographic location was changed. The company did little except to reset my password so I could get back in and fix my profile. When I let my membership lapse they were quick to offer a 50% discount subscription and suddenly I was getting messages and likes! However, I would have to pay to find out who. After each renewal the profiles that had liked me were withdrawn or no longer available. Yet they appeared on SeniorPeopleMeet another site owned by the same company. When I finally stopped my subscriptions I started to get spam mails to my regular email from OurTime which tried to get my credit card info by claiming I was due a refund. This site is a spam! Their concern for your information security is a joke, and the people who do respond are likely employees who are trying to get you to renew. Avoid this site.

51 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 8, 2018

This site seems to cater to Scammers. Every guy claims want to get to know you, "Oh but I live in Gaza, France, always out of the States, but I will be back in a few months. Give me your phone number so we can get to know each other till I get back to the States". Check the profile and almost all of the guys who want your money say they make over $100000 - that is your first clue. They are good looking and look younger than the profile says they are- 2nd clue.

Most say they lost their wife or have been single for many years 3rd clue. And then they say they are out of the States but due back in a few months - 4 clue and then they want your phone number so you can get to know each other 5 clue. It is true you can report these "guys." However you pay for a month of service and it takes less the 24 hours to see MOST of the Guys are scammers and OurTime says cannot refund your money because you messaged someone. Seems like OurTime is actually the scammers. DO WASTE YOUR MONEY!!!

View more
44 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 6, 2018

Navigating this site is horrible. Don't waste your money. Constant pop ups annoy to no end and they have all these additional charges for stupid things like when the last time someone was online. And be careful to close your account after a month because it will charge your card automatically. I just tried to discontinue my account when my month is up and I still haven't found the link to my account info. They hide it --- at the time of this review I still haven't found it. Oh, and when you set your preferences, they keep injecting matches that you don't want and have to keep resetting... Save your money.

36 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 4, 2018

I only joined OurTime.com a few days ago, I have not been proactive, rather waiting to see what contacts I would get. I have had several flirts, and actually have been talking to one match almost exclusively. Very happy with the site, so far. The site is very easy to use, and I am quite impressed by the quality of the matches, and it has been fun reading and responding to the flirts and it is nice to know there are other who are also looking. However, there was a huge amount of emails the first day, a bit overwhelming but nothing to complain about. And the couple of obviously fake responses.

12 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 4, 2018

Ladies, be very careful, just because someone is handsome and knows all the right things to say, does NOT mean they are worthy of you. I just had 78 thousand taken from me. Charmed me until I really got worried about mind control. I was doing whatever he asked of me. Check them out thoroughly. And don't assume they are giving the right name, or showing their true picture. CAUTION!!! We feel because the site is for older people, that we are safe. NOT TRUE AT ALL! Be very careful!!!

47 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 2, 2018

I was very disappointed with the photos and profiles I was matched with. I did not find most of them to be a good match. Most of the people I was matched with were out of my preferred date range and photos were not up to date. The profiles of some members were not entirely honest. For example, when I said I was only interested in casual dating, I was matched with the same. However, some members were really interested in more than that. So I wasted my time in a lot of cases. I cancelled my one year membership 4 months early, forfeiting the money I had already paid, and never tried OurTime again. In fact, I was so mentally or emotionally exhausted after using the site for 8 months I never used a dating site again. I do not recommend people in my age group rely solely on a dating website.

I hope they screen people better, if possible and verify if someone is really who they say they are if there is a way. No dating site is foolproof, but it behooves the dating site to try to accept on!y truly vetted candidates. Perhaps there could be an over the phone interview to help filter out those people who seem deceptive or not really serious about finding the right person.

View more
38 people found this review helpful
profile pic of the author
Verified Reviewer
Original review: June 1, 2018

I have only been on Our Time for a couple of weeks. ALL of the men that reached out to me have fake profiles & live in Nigeria. There is absolutely no vetting on these sites. It is a catalog for phishers & worse.

45 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 31, 2018

In general my experience was okay. It was very easy to use and to make a profile. The quality of the matches is sometimes hard to meet nice people but if you meet quite a few people eventually you do meet some nice people also. I liked that the people seemed a little more down-to-earth. When I used OurTime as opposed to just plain Plenty of Fish the people seemed a little more mature on that site and like they were genuinely interested in meeting someone.

11 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 30, 2018

The website itself is very good, the matches though do not represent themselves like they truly are though but that it not the website's fault. It is an easy to use site and app and I will stick with it. I do like that it is geared more to a specific age range of people, it is better than a site that has a broad range and makes it more limiting to find someone age appropriate. Overall it is a decent site. Just haven't had much luck finding a good match on there.

7 people found this review helpful
profile pic of the author
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 28, 2018

This site is NOT in real time. I found they would keep your profile even after you canceled your membership unless you requested specifically so. No wonder I did not get any response from the men I contacted. I was able to see (in one of pages) that they were last logged in a month ago, two months ago, 6 months ago. Also many different icons and pre-fixed messages are just so redundant and impersonal. Then one day, "flirt" was sent to all without me doing so. I think most messages you get when you first join are the scammers, asking phone numbers and e-mail addresses. Anyways don't waste your energy on here!

36 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 26, 2018

I wish zero stars was an option, this is supposed to be a dating site for over age 50 individuals. The free membership does not allow you to do anything, so the only option presented by the website is a 6-month membership fee (which will cost you about $120). I spent over an hour answering all these questions and uploading profile photos and a few photos of landscapes I had taken (since photography is one of my hobbies). Every few days all my photos would disappear, no reason given by the website. There is no support on the website to ask why my profile keeps getting changed and deleted. Everyday they will email you with "so-called" matches, every person I was matched with looked like local gang-members or men in prison. I make a six-figure salary (and am highly educated) and I am being matched with men who have completed some high-school and appear to be unemployed.

This was a complete waste of time. I cancelled my subscription within about a week, but never received a refund from OurTime.com. This is a SCAM, they get all your money upfront and NEVER REFUND your MONEY. I was shocked by how disgusting my OurTime.com matches were. You are able to put in certain criteria you are looking for, the OurTime.com website COMPLETELY IGNORES all your CRITERIA and sends you a local criminal or gang-member as a "special match for you."

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY on this SCAM, most members on the site have left. Even when you leave the site, OurTime.com will keep your dating profile up so it appears they have much more membership than they actually do. This is another part of their SCAM. Also, if the men do not look like gang members, they appear to be in their 70s or 80s, I am 43 and am looking for someone who is not older than my father. Also, OurTime.com will auto-renew your membership for $168 if you do not dig through the site and disable this feature. My advice, DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY or TIME with this USELESS OurTime.com WEBSITE.

View more
49 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 25, 2018

I signed up for this website a three days ago, completed ALL the questions, set my criteria for height and age range. Received a few emails, responded and asked questions. Never heard back from them. The matches that were selected for me, didn't meet any of my criteria, age, fitness, height. I called to cancel my 6 month subscription 3 days later and was told NOT POSSIBLE. Spoke to a Jeremy and was told supervisor would tell me NO also. NOT PLEASED. STAY AWAY, they also run Match.com.

42 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 25, 2018

There are some real people on this site. But, there are also a LOT of fake accounts. Guys who fall instantly in love and eventually ask for money... they get easy to spot after the first few. The worst part of the whole experience was finding out that the site was sending out messages on my behalf. I noticed in my mailbox a lot of replies and when I clicked to open there were messages sent to guys that I hadn't done! I would imagine to keep guys interested or to stop someone from deleting their profile (and I imagine I got a few bogus messages too). When I messaged these guys to tell them, "Sorry but I didn't send those messages," the site deleted me. LOL... I guess as punishment? Haha so I relogged on and needed a new password. Rode out the rest of my one month membership, and exchanged emails with a few men I thought sounded genuine... we'll see...

34 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 24, 2018

OurTime.com is made for older people like me who are over 50 so I am not wasting my time with people who are too young because that is a waste of my time and their time. I enjoyed the experience just sometimes too many matches. It's overwhelming. Sometimes I like to be able to respond to all who contact me. With so many matches it's hard to do that. Sometimes I don't have enough time to answer everyone.

6 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer Verified Buyer
Original review: May 21, 2018

The pros, is that their app is easy to navigate. Had no problem with that. The desktop is a little more complicated but not hard. The cons is that there are quite a bit of scammers, but they seem to follow the same pattern. First they exchange a couple of emails with you, then they either ask for your email address or cell (don't fall for this) or they send this long email of how much they love you and age and distance should keep lovers apart or some such nonsense.

Other problem is that my profile got highjacked several times. Getting help is limited, and although they said they cancelled my account and deleted my profile, I just got a notice that I have 89 messages waiting for me. Oh yeah, I've also been a 45 year old Latina, a 71 year man, a 30 year old gamer and I don't know what my profile looks like now since I can't even get into it. With this type of security I worry that the hackers will really get into their database and steal my data. They really need white hackers to test their site, because it's horrible. I would give them an F- in IT security.

View more
24 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 21, 2018

I agree with the majority of the folks who have given this site low reviews. The site is actually kind of hard to get through, with different filters for different things; and they are BURIED in the site itself, in places you would never think to look. I'm pretty savvy, and am on several other sites and none of them (even Match.com, this site's owners) is as bad. I get "matches" from women, although I have clearly specified that I am looking for a man; the age range is off, the geographical range is off, the number of actual paying clients is very, very low -- and since you can only send "flirts" and can't answer if you don't have a paying membership, the number of flirts is outrageous, and the number of actual contacts is underwhelming. They have an aggressive message if you don't respond to all those idiotic "flirts" that says you're a "poor responder". Give me a break. Why on this great earth would I spend my time responding to shadows?

On other sites, they have different mechanisms, like buying the possibility to allow someone who is not a paying member to respond, or responding with a pre-fab message (that is pretty bad, but...) which gets the recipient's attention and if s/he is interested, s/he can let the genie out of the bottle so to speak and allow the person who sent the initial pre-fab essay to write in his/her own voice. And you can't access your account if you are overseas. Which I am on a regular basis. So, my suggestion is pile your money up on the corner, light it on fire and flirt with the first person who comes to help you put out the fire. It will likely be more effective.

View more
36 people found this review helpful
Verified Reviewer
Original review: May 18, 2018

They send you matches and you can click yes or no. You never hear from a single person. The people that do contact you live at least a thousand miles away and supposedly want to meet you. You never get a date.

36 people found this review helpful

OurTime.com expert review by Mark Brooks

OurTime is the largest dating site created specifically for the baby boomer market.

  • 50+: Unlike most dating sites which are aimed at the 18-35 year old market, OurTime puts 100% of its focus on the 50+ baby boomer market of singles, many of whom are re-entering the dating world after a divorce or the loss of a spouse.

  • Simplified dating experience: In contrast to many other dating sites which offer a plethora of unnecessary options, OurTime keeps their interface and searches simple so that they can be used efficiently and with little to no hassle.

  • Paid self promotion: For a small fee, OurTime allows you to bump your profile up so it appears near the top of the search rankings. This helps make your profile more visible to prospective matches.

  • Best for: Singles over 50 years of age who are seeking friendship, short-term or long-term relationships.

Profile picture of Mark Brooks
Mark Brooks

Online Dating & Matchmaking Contributing Editor

View Profile

Harvard Business School graduate, Mark Brooks, has been an expert in the Internet dating business since 1998. He is currently the CEO of Courtland Brooks, a consultancy agency for the Internet dating industry, and runs OnlinePersonalsWatch.com. He prides himself on being a New Media Futurist and can be reached at LinkedIn.

OurTime.com Company Information

Company Name:
OurTime.com
Year Founded:
2004
City:
Dallas
State/Province:
TX
Country:
United States
Website:
ourtime.com

ConsumerAffairs Solutions for Business

Let's talk

Follow us

ConsumerAffairs ranks 562 on Inc. 5000 for 2017

At ConsumerAffairs we love to hear from both consumers and brands; please never hesitate to Contact Us.

At ConsumerAffairs we take privacy seriously, please refer to our Privacy Policy to learn more about how we keep you protected.

You’re responsible for yourself and please remember that your use of this site constitutes acceptance of our Terms of Use.

Advertisements on this site are placed and controlled by outside advertising networks. ConsumerAffairs.com does not evaluate or endorse the products and services advertised. See the FAQ for more information.

The information on our website is general in nature and is not intended as a substitute for competent legal advice. ConsumerAffairs.com makes no representation as to the accuracy of the information herein provided and assumes no liability for any damages or loss arising from the use thereof.

Copyright © 2018 Consumers Unified LLC. All Rights Reserved. The contents of this site may not be republished, reprinted, rewritten or recirculated without written permission.