A recent study found that 40% of American households could get by just fine with an electric car, although electric cars currently make up only 1% of the nation's fleet.
I read this study with interest. It basically found that most people drive only 30 to 40 miles per day -- well within the range of today's electric cars. The study reminded me of a story about a Northern Virginia man who calculated he was getting 203 miles per gallon in his Chevrolet Volt, a plug-in hybrid.
I really should get my hands on one of these things and put it through the wringer, I thought to myself. And so it was that a few weeks ago, I hustled over to the nearest Chevrolet dealer and drove home in a Volt.
I considered several options before picking the Volt. The Toyota Prius is an obvious choice and by far the most popular hybrid. I have driven Priuses, however, and just don't like them. There's no farfigneugan, the elusive joy of driving that Volkswagen was touting a few years back. Ditto the Ford C-Max.
Range anxiety
Then there's the Nissan Leaf. It's a fine little car but, like many consumers, I am prone to range anxiety. My schedule is not consistent and sometimes I have to jump in the car and head for some event or other that wasn't on my radar until that very moment. A pure battery-powered car isn't up to that challenge.
The Tesla is out of my price range and besides, it's also battery-only, making it essentially a very expensive variant of the Leaf.
This brought me back to the Volt. It has a range of about 35 miles on the battery and another 300 or so on the gas tank, which powers a back-up engine that basically acts as a generator, providing the juice to run the electric motor when the battery is drained.
A key difference
This is a key difference. Most hybrids run on the electric motor when the battery is charged, then switch to the gas motor when the battery has given up the ghost. Some cars use both motors at times. Only the Volt, as I understand it, runs on the electric motor all the time.
So far, I haven't had much experience with the gas-powered engine, mainly because the battery has been adequate for most of my trips, just as that study predicted. I plug the car in at night and in the morning, it's charged up and ready to go. I used no gasoline in the first 10 days or so that I had the car, running my usual daily errands in 35 miles or less.
Compared to the $60 or so per week it has been costing me for gas to run daily errands in my old Porsche, that's not bad.
Do the math
Whether the Volt works out financially for you depends on your personal situation. Overnight charging is estimated to cost about $1.50 per day in most areas -- roughly $10 a week. Contrast that to $50 or $60 a week in gas consumption.
There is a whopping $7,500 federal tax credit -- a credit, not just a deduction -- which helps to absorb some of the pain of the purchase price, currently around $35,000 for a well-equipped model.
Some states also offer tax incentives. Others, like Virginia, where the Volt and I reside, actually penalize hybrids. The birthplace of Thomas Jefferson and other libertarians and free-thinkers imposed a $64-per-year fee on hybrids last year. Why? Well, they don't use as much gas and, therefore, don't pay as much gas tax.
I must say that this is the first time I recall being taxed for not buying something. Sort of a sales tax in reverse. But typical of the inside-out thinking that so often typifies Virginia.
Nasty weather
As luck would have it, it was snowing, raining, sleeting and otherwise being disagreeable for the first week or so I had the car, giving the Volt a chance to show what it can do in bad weather. It did just fine. Weighing in at about 3,500 pounds, with quite a bit of that weight over the powered front wheels, the thing hunkers down and powers through slush and snow quite nicely.
When the weather finally cleared momentarily, we zapped out to a small winery in Delaplane, Va., a distance of about 40 miles, finally getting a chance to fire up the gas-powered engine. The transition occurs smoothly, the only sign being the added sound of the gas engine. When running on the battery, the car is eerily quiet, with nothing but the sound of the tires on the pavement to indicate movement.
Our route took us into mountainous stretches of Interstate 66 but the electric motor provided plenty of acceleration, enabling us not only to keep up with the fast-moving traffic but to pass and maneuver with ease. Acceleration is excellent, especially if you switch to "Sport" mode, which tightens everything up a notch or two and makes the virtual throttle much more responsive.
Among its retinue of safety gadgets, the Volt warns you if you are closing too fast on the car in front of you -- a good thing to have in a car with this much torque.
On New Year's Day, I had a little more spare time and took the Volt to Charlottesville, Va., and back -- a little over 200 miles. The battery ran out of juice somewhere around Sumerduck and we made the rest of the trip with the assistance of the gas engine, achieving a back-of-the-envelope 42 miles per gallon. Not bad for a trip that included 75 mph spurts and more than a few steep hills.
Shiftless
Speaking of mountains, if you're accustomed to downshifting, upshifting and so forth, the Volt and other electric cars will take a little getting used to. The transmission is "continuously variable" -- meaning no gears and, therefore, no shifting. This quickly gets to feel normal. In fact, all the shifting and engine noises in our family Volkswagen now seem odd and slightly antiquated.
A few other observations about the car: Although it is about the same size as the Prius, the Leaf and the Ford C-Max, it feels bigger, though it handles well thanks to the low center of gravity created by the huge battery lurking down below. Also, the electronic steering, which I had expected to hate, is very precise and not mushy as I had feared it might be.
Unlike the Prius and the Leaf, the Volt looks pretty much like a regular mid-sized car. It is quite roomy inside, although legroom is somewhat lacking in the back.
One other thing to note: The Volt is a four-passenger car -- not five. There are two bucket seats in the back and a large tunnel running between them, sort of like a transmission hump in a traditional, rear-wheel-drive car. In the Volt, it's where the large T-shaped battery sits.
No question, there are some trade-offs. The Volt is not quite as nimble around town as some of the tinier specimens but makes up for it by being a comfortable and competent highway cruiser. We'll give it a real acid test with a trip to NYC one of these weekends and let you know how it holds up.