You look a little different than you did 10 years ago, right? We all do. And, if you’re a Facebook user, it’s probably a safe bet your Facebook page has photos from various stages throughout your life.
Now comes a report that Facebook may be using facial recognition in tandem with a notion called the “10-Year Challenge” to surreptitiously mine sensitive information for its 2.7 billion users.
The challenge is simple enough -- people post one photograph from 10 years ago alongside a more recent photograph. While it sounds innocent, skeptics are throwing up flares left and right. The trend is claimed to be a "ploy devised by Facebook to help train facial recognition algorithms on age progression,” said Rebecca Jennings of Vox Media.
“The challenge provides Facebook with “a perfect storm for machine learning. It presented Facebook with a terrified opportunity to learn, to train their systems to better recognize small changes" in users' appearances,” Amy Webb, a professor at NYU Stern School of Business, told CBS News
Critics think that some folks may have even gotten suckered into adding context to their then-and-now photos.
“Through the Facebook meme, most people have been helpfully adding that context back in (“me in 2008 and me in 2018”) as well as further info, in many cases, about where and how the pic was taken (“2008 at University of Whatever, taken by Joe; 2018 visiting New City for this year’s such-and-such event”),” wrote Wired’s Kate O’Neill.
“In other words, thanks to this meme, there’s now a very large dataset of carefully curated photos of people from roughly 10 years ago and now.”
Not Facebook’s first facial recognition run-in
In the middle of all the faux pas Facebook made in 2018, the company had already encountered a run-in with its use of facial recognition.
In April 2018, ConsumerAffairs reported that Facebook was sued, with plaintiffs alleging that the company’s Tag Suggestions feature violated users’ privacy by storing biometric info without their explicit consent. The backbone of that suit was the Illinois Biometric Information Privacy Act (BIPA), which requires consent before companies can collect biometric data.
A federal judge in San Francisco went as far as dismissing Facebook’s argument that the law didn’t apply to it because its servers aren’t located in the state.
One ConsumerAffairs reviewer also raised their hand about the platform’s use of facial recognition. “They are holding the site hostage to get more private info off of me… want(ing) a passport style photo so they can scan a biometrics ID of my face. Then they held me out of the site for two days until they could verify,” they said.
A second chance?
You may have guessed that Facebook refutes having any hand in the #10YearChallenge. "This is a user-generated meme that went viral on its own," a Facebook spokesperson said responding to O’Neill’s story.
"Facebook did not start this trend, and the meme uses photos that already exist on Facebook. Facebook gains nothing from this meme (besides reminding us of the questionable fashion trends of 2009). As a reminder, Facebook users can choose to turn facial recognition on or off at any time.”
While Facebook’s data privacy past is riddled with holes, it’s highly possible the company is really trying to do the right thing regarding facial recognition, after all. In 2017, Facebook vowed that its users control whether Facebook can recognize them in photos and videos.
“Soon, you will begin to see a simple on/off switch instead of settings for individual features that use face recognition technology,” wrote Joaquin Quiñonero Candela, Facebook’s Director of Applied Machine Learning. “We designed this as an on/off switch because people gave us feedback that they prefer a simpler control than having to decide for every single feature using face recognition technology. To learn more about all of these features, visit the Help Center or your account settings.”
If you’re part of the better-safe-than-sorry crowd on the facial recognition issue, Mashable has put together a step-by-step guide on how to turn that feature off on Facebook.