Travelers Auto Insurance Reviews
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.
Our editorial standards
- Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
- We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
- All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
About Travelers Auto Insurance
Travelers Insurance sells car, boat and property protection policies, as well as other coverages. It offers liability, collision, comprehensive, personal injury protection, medical payments and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. It has add-on coverage options for rental cars, roadside assistance, accident forgiveness and ride-sharing.
Visit www.travelers.com/car-insurance- Insurance bundles available
- Several discount opportunities
- Multiple coverage options
- Extra charge for roadside assistance
- Add-on coverage can be pricey
Travelers Auto Insurance Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (91)
- (48)
- (31)
- (21)
- (193)
Popular Mentions
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
Recent
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
Reviewed Jan. 5, 2012
I have been with the company for many years and have always paid my premiums in full and never lapsed over 20 years, never a claim. Then I was in a huge accident on February 21 2011 and I was in the middle of all these cars crashing into each other and it was scary. I lost all control because of black ice and even the police officer did not issue any tickets.
I did try to avoid hitting her but I had no control and hit the bumper of her car. The company did resolve the claim and gave me a rental and it seemed like they really cared about me. Then I got my insurance rates and they are charging me with the accident which was no fault even though they said it was all my fault. I am getting surcharged for 39 months and this is a hefty charge. I tried to argue with them but they just keep saying I was at fault and the weather is not taken into consideration.
I really feel this company is not fair and now they have accident forgiveness for the first accident but I don't apply for this being it was approved in June for New York state. Now I am a nervous wreck driving because I am afraid of another no fault accident. I am nervous sick to my stomach and it has caused emotional distress I want to let others know about this incident. With all the years I paid them my premiums, they got more money out of my pocket than they put out for this claim.
Reviewed Dec. 20, 2011
Daughter blew a tire in 2001 Olds Silhouette van. Travelers used CCC ONE to value van at total loss. I was shocked and protested it was not a total loss. After visiting web sites seeing lots of complaints and class action suits vs. CCC ONE, I attempted to submit my own "comp car" valuations showing how grossly my car was undervalued. I found that the "comp" cars listed by CCC ONE were: not available, had prior accident records, had been sold several times at auctions and were not the same model as mine (mine was an Olds Silhouette Premier model with even more options over the Standard Premiere model, theirs were the much cheaper $6,000 new models). Car Fax reports on them showed dents, dirt, etc. Their comps were in some cases out of area and there are other discrepancies to be discussed later.
When I tried to send this info to Travelers they called and said not to bother sending my own comps; they were not going to look at them and their total loss figure stood based on CCC ONE values. All these issues have been in online complaints for periods extending to at least 2006 and subsequent with alarming regularity.
When I noticed the CC ONE valuation included a deduction for hail damage that I never knew I had, I took my car to a body shop for a hail damage appraisal by a firm actually doing most insurance company hail damage appraisals. CCC ONE had placed $200 (approximate) deduction for the hail damage, which I traced back to July 27, 2011 storm. Since I was going to buy the car back at salvage value if I lost my argument with Travelers over total loss, I submitted the hail damage claim. The comprehensive loss claim department quickly approved payment of the $2,050 less $100 deductible and told me the check was going out that day. When it never showed, after near a week I checked back and no one would reply to phone messages. Finally I got a call from the total loss department saying they held the check and tried to get me to agree that the comprehensive hail claim amount would be deducted from any future pay out on the collision loss.
I would not accept that because, as I pointed out, their CCC ONE estimate would have been the same whether or not I had collected on the hail claim in July and not fixed the car yet or for that matter just decided to pocket the money in July. They know that if I had accepted their check I was going to repurchase the car under the required Salvage purchase option and still had the hail loss to fix. They are using the CCC ONE valuation as a one-sided, concrete, immovable valuation not adjustable by the proof of "lowballing" the Travelers refuses to accept, but a lopsided inaccurate valuation subject to their discretion only (not contestable by me only by them); when it comes to saying the CCC ONE formula for hail damage should have resulted in a $2,050 mACV value deduction on my van not the $250 they tried to use initially against me. Amazingly, they sent the offer in writing which in effect transfers the comp loss for the hail into a collision loss with the both comp $100 deductible and the $500 collision deductible netted out of any prospective ultimate collision payout. They already took the $100 deductible out when sending the hail check this week. But they want to double dip on it on the collision loss.
Also, I had another vehicle, a Ford Taurus that I sold concurrent with buying a reconstructed Buick to replace it. This was in the past 2 weeks. Travelers refused to write the Buick. I believe it was retaliatory because my policy language says any replacement vehicle will be covered with the same coverage as the vehicle it replaced. Travelers’ policy does not state that they will not cover reconstructed replacement vehicles. However, this brought up an interesting issue. Is Travelers using total loss valuations as a vehicle to by pass Pennsylvania strict law on refusals to write or non renew? Declare a car a total and when you accept their money and buy it back from them as a reconstructed vehicle they refuse to write it. So they want to total my car, take $1,100 for it rather than the $3,100 offered originally (deducting the hail claim). They want to have me get the car back after paying them $500 for salvage and incurring all the title transfer and special inspection issues/costs inherent in repurchasing a salvage title car. They refuse to write coverage on it (I never would have known had I not bought the Buick-Travelers hid that fact), force me to get insurance elsewhere on the van at a greatly increased premium because Travelers had discounts for homeowners and auto placed with them, and lose additional money at van trade in time in the future because of a reconstructed title that was not necessary.
I want to add that Travelers refused to explain to me how the CCC ONE mileage deduction was computed. I checked and Car Fax says 15,000 miles per year is considered average for my van. After CC ONE gets a market value (based on take price not actual selling price offered to the public), they then use a mysterious other deduction on value from those take prices to come up with my comp value in a second column. One would presume the difference between the two columns would be a depreciation factor and mileage, etc., not condition or prior wrecks because the dealer price already has that in the cars on the lots. The used car dealers offer Car Fax reports and surely they have made their own deductions because when a customer comes sees the dents, etc. in the cars plus sees the prior accidents on the car, the prospective purchaser will only pay the "diminished value price". In any event, after using the lower of the 2 columns to get a CCC ONE price they double up the deduction on value by again taking off for the hail damage, condition, high mileage, etc. in a single line deduction that has absolutely no tie in to the difference between column one and column two of their report.
Travelers refused to discuss how this is reconcilable. They refused to respond to any of my questions about the CCC ONE valuation. They said they could not give me a premium effect of the accident on renewal; they remarkably at one point said the car was unsafe, but when I told them I wanted to move it to my home for free storage they said it's ok to drive it the 2 hours home from the town of Clearfield PA, where it was parked but had to be moved. So suddenly it was safe to drive 2 hours when they could save storage fees. Also, Travelers said I could drop the collision claim entirely and Travelers would remove the classification of the van as a total loss. Suddenly the tag on the widow that they placed as a total loss requiring a special Pa inspection means nothing when Travelers is off the hook. The car miraculously changes under their unsafe standard to a new Travelers stance that is now safe to drive as long as it saves them money.
I worked for Pa. Insurance Department for 35 years, received a special plaque from the Director of the FBI for assistance in teaching their agents how to investigate white collar crime, especially reinsurance fraud and in addition to conducting financial examinations conducted Market Conduct Examinations. I can say without doubt that there are many violations of Pa. Appraisal Act as well as Unfair Insurance Practices Act regarding my case at hand. I think a class action suit is warranted. I checked and legal fees can be added on as though compensatory when determining the limitations on punitive damages imposed by the Supreme Court on bad faith claims. I also believe that because my health condition included high blood pressure and it is obvious by my e-mails (reflecting loss of sleep in all night research to correct the wrongs), that mental duress can be put on the table as an additional compensatory damage to be put into the Supreme Court 9-1 ratio of punitive to compensatory damage calculation. A simple typing of CCC ONE into your browser will show all the complaints and class action suits. I want to sue Travelers and CCC ONE for conspiracy to defraud, bad faith, mental duress, fraud, etc.
Reviewed Sept. 29, 2011
After repeated attempts to inquire about my claim, I received a letter stating he could not reach me. That is a lie because we had already spoke several times prior to his letter. He kept telling me that he was not sure if his client had insurance. When I told him I was on my way to report his client for driving without insurance, he suddenly had a check for me!.
Reviewed Sept. 26, 2011
My car was rear-ended almost 2 months ago by a Travelers' client, and they have been the absolute worst company I have ever dealt with.
After months of fighting with them and another company, as there was more than 2 vehicles involved, the company still refuses to accept any liability. The Insurance company for the third vehicle was the only one that scheduled me for a courtesy estimate at a body shop, even though the damage to the front of their insured vehicle was only cosmetic as was the damage to the rear of the vehicle that hit me.
After all this time, I have photographic evidence of the extensive damage to the back of my vehicle and the front of the vehicle that hit me, both vehicles sustaining frame damage. The only answer I received from Travelers was, "I have a recorded statement from the driver of the third vehicle stating that that vehicle hit the second vehicle and might have pushed it into mine."
When asked how to justify minor cosmetic damage only for that impact compared to the major damage with my impact, the agent could give no plausible explanation, only kept referring to the recorded statement. When asked when a person's statement was taken as proof over factual evidence (photos, body shop estimates, and the extensive repairs already completed on the second vehicle), I was told the facts are being taken into account, but "we have a recorded statement".
This is the most useless company and is clearly intent on ignoring their financial obligations as an insurance company. Not only would I never recommend contacting them for your own personal insurance, I pray that no other vehicle accident victim has to experience this complete lack of customer service and professionalism. After reading some of the other reviews, it is apparent that this lack of professionalism is demonstrated to their own customers as well, which is truly sad. Again, stay as far away from this company, or any of their insured drivers, as you possibly can unless you want to experience the same feeling of violation.
I will have to either go to small claims court to get the repairs accomplished on my vehicle, or pay the deductible and hope that the insurance companies can fight it out and I get reimbursed
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2011
Recently she was in an auto accident. The claims person named in this complaint along with a Maria *****, I feel took advantage of my aging parents and didn't fullfill their duties as her insurance representatives. No one came to the house to see the vehicle and speak to her only Maria ***** by phone, nor did they asked her where she wanted the repairs done.
Ed ***** sent a tow truck to pick her vehicle up and took it to a repair shop where he has his office. My parents were made to understand that was where it had to go. When my parents were called to pick up the car across town they only repaired damages they assumed were done while leaving others they claimed had nothing to do with the accident.
My mothers car was like new with no dings, scratches, or other damages prior to the accident, and when I explained that to them both Ed ***** and Maria ***** told me that the repair shop would asess the situation and determine if those repairs would be done.
I asked Ed since when does the repair shop make those calls? Ed was rude and a smart a**. I said my parents wanted to take the vehicle to Bill Currie Ford to complete the repairs, where they would have gone had they been asked.
He said he would call back when arrangements were made and never did. I called several times and left messages and none were returned.
So here I am trying to help my parents out...they live on a retirement income and paid a $500 deductible only to have their car returned half repaired that was like new prior to the accident and Traverlers ignoring to help them, instead siding with their chosen repair shop.
Reviewed July 26, 2010
I was in a hit-and-run accident a few months ago that left my car and me in the middle of the street with damages. The person was never found and my insurance company has refused to help me from the beginning. They claimed my car as a total lost, even though it is in driving condition (only with damage to the back right side of the car). They refused to pay for any damages and they also refused to pay my medical expenses (chiropractor).
The company is also trying to possess my car and force a cash buyout. The car works fine and I have someone who can fix the damaged area. They still insist on taking my car and trashing it. I want my car. Is it against the law that I keep the car I paid for and paid insurance for? Does the law support insurance companies taking people's cars and not paying for damages like this? Can I get help solving this situation?
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2009
Reviewed Sept. 11, 2009
Reviewed Jan. 21, 2009
Reviewed March 25, 2008
I would like to report the "criminal act" committed by 3 attorneys of Travelers Insurance Co. To be brief, I was involved in an accident where a person ran a red light and struck me on the passenger side of my vehicle. I was wrongfully ticketed at the accident scene. I was struck with such force that it fractured my nose and required facial stitching. I also had a severe multicolored bruise on my hip from the seat belt. I was taken by ambulance to the hospital because I had severe abdominal and back pains. I did not even know I was bleeding or injured on my face. We went to court and the man who ran the red light admitted to the judge that he ran the red light. The judge asked him, "Sir, did you run the red light?" The man replied, "Yes, I did."
Travelers tried suing me and I believe my attorney countersued. The case was referred to mediation where the crimes were committed. The mediation process started with a white female attorney (Travelers), my attorney, the mediator and my father. The white female attorney was having trouble and called in 2 other attorneys - a black male and a white male attorney (I do not know their names). Both the white female and black male attorneys of Travelers were adamant that the case was not over who was at fault, but my ability to prove my injuries came from the accident. The white female attorney said, "We are not contesting this over who is at fault; we already know our client was at fault. We are contesting this over your ability to prove your injuries came from this accident." The black male attorney became upset about something and interjected, "Look. We know our client was at fault, your injuries came from another accident." The white female attorney also said, "If this goes to trial, we are not going to pay you one penny."
I was coerced into signing a release and settling for $11,500. After the attorney (mine) was paid and after paying pennies on the dollar to my medical practitioners, there was $2,800. left. My personal injury had a deductible of $2,000 which left $800. That did not even cover the expenses of going to and from the medical practitioners. I am charging that the 3 attorneys of Travelers Insurance used fraudulent deception in obtaining my release. They led me to believe if it went to court, that they did not have to pay! I was in fact coerced through fraudulent deception into signing this release. I was objecting the whole time but was led to believe I would receive nothing. I believe there is a law that says if 3 people of a company conspire an illegal fraudulent act, this is referred to as racketeering.
The insurance company (Travelers) was required by law to pay my full immediate losses - my medical bills, lost wages, support (my parents supported me while I could not work), my automobile (was 10 days old). Because Travelers was required by law to pay these losses, yet racketeered the act, they in turn profiteered from the act of racketeering. Travelers is also responsible for theft of my vehicle. They assumed liability for their client and were liable for the replacement cost. So the criminal acts I am charging that Travelers Insurance Co. committed: Fraudulent deception (fraud), that they conspired and racketeered the act, that they profiteered from the act and that they are responsible for the theft of my vehicle.
Just so you know, I was able to prove through forensic evidence that was in Travelers' hands at that time that my injuries were from this accident. I contacted Travelers and they said, "You should not have signed the release," that they won't pay because statutes of limitations. But these crimes were committed by Travelers. I have all the forensic evidence as well as document, medical, etc., and government data that supports the forensic evidence. These support all the forensic evidence and show the injuries that one may expect to have. I was driving my vehicle and was struck at approximately 35mph directly where the seat belt was. That is why I had such a severe bruise from the seat belt. My car was struck with such force that it bent the roof above my head on the driver's side of the vehicle.
Travelers Insurance know they are guilty of these crimes, yet they have no remorse, they feel no guilt, they are dishonest, unethical, immoral and down right criminals. I would like to give you the evidences and proof that Travelers are criminals and that they are protected by a blanket of law. Travelers Insurance Co are criminals who commit fraud, racketeer, profiteer, steal and destroy the lives of innocent accident victims. I also believe there is a possibility that they might also commit the act of witness tampering and possible deny innocent victim's workman's compensation insurance, causing further loss and injury by preventing these victims from obtaining meaningful employment. I believe that if they commit the crimes that they did, then there is a possibility that they might commit the tampering and workman's comp denials.
Travelers have been criminals - I can prove this! I believe that they probably still are criminals. And this is the most sophisticated form of racketeering, profiteering, fraud and conspiracy by abusing the process of mediation. This process must be fair. In order for the process to have been a fair process, the immediate losses had to be on the table from the beginning. They are allowed to negotiate future loss, pain and suffering, etc. But they, by law, have to pay the immediate losses as described earlier in this letter. So they may not compensate for the loss to myself and my family, but I will let people know the truth - that Travelers are criminals.
My car cost $3,400. I had to get a replacement car (approximately the same). My parents supported me and paid for expenses as well for travel to and from the medical professionals, my rent, my food, my fuel and a reasonable amount for entertainment to keep me from becoming inactive. The amount is approximately $50,000 at the least. I have other details about the domino effect it had on me and my family's finances, as well as the loss of a dream business where the person who purchased it became a billionaire, as well as the resentment from my siblings for the loss to my parents and the financial strain and loss of opportunity for a business that would have provided employment, income and a great future put that extra strain on my father's heart. He died of a heart attack!
Travelers, in turn, are partially responsible for the strain on my father's heart and are in part responsible for his death! These are the crimes that Travelers Insurance's attorneys are guilty of. Thank you very much, sincerely, for exposing the true crimes committed by Travelers Insurance. Have a great day!
** The statutes of limitations do not apply. Travelers used this contract that was obtained under fraud that makes the crime an active and ongoing crime. Once they used the fraudulently obtained contract to stop an internal investigation into the crime, the use of the contract activated the crime to present day.
Reviewed Dec. 4, 2007
Eric Flemming is the agent from Travelers that I've been dealing with. He's trying to make me take less than my car is worth. The Kelly Blue Book value was $2,985 and the NADA value was $3,150. Travelers Insurance is offering me $2,300.
Reviewed Nov. 20, 2007
I would like to file a formal complaint against Travelers Insurance and its claim representative, Mr. **. Mr. ** and I spoke on Thursday, November 15, 2007, regarding an auto accident that his client, Ms. Semone **, and I were involved in on Monday, November 5, 2007. The accident resulted in his client colliding with my vehicle, causing extensive damage. When discussing the offer of the claim, he proceeded to blame me for the accident and said that he was only going to offer 0% - 10% to cover the damages to my vehicle. Upon disputing the offer, he then said, "Now, were not going to give you anything.” I expressed to Mr. ** that I felt threatened because I did not agree with the offer. Mr. ** then said he did not care. He further stated that everyone will blame me for the accident because I was making a left turn and everybody knows that the person turning left is always at fault.
As a result of the accident and not having an offer presented to me that will result in repairing my vehicle, it has left me and my family without transportation to and from school, my spouse is arriving at work late because now he has to take our two children to school, as well as leaving me physically limited. The accident re-injured a preexisting spinal condition, which took three spinal surgeries to repair in 2006. I filed an amended accident report on Monday, November 12, with the Albany Records Bureau, and I'm awaiting a response. In the interim, Mr. ** has not responded to any of our phone calls. Mr. **’s unprofessional behavior and egregious means of handling the dispute is reprehensible. I hope that Consumer Affairs will help me with the issue, and I look forward to hearing from you soon. Thank you.
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2002
I lived in NY up until July 2001. I have a 2000 Honda Civic that was insured by Travelers. The car was in NY until July 13, 2001. It was shipped to Florida. I continued to pay insurance on this car until Sept. 2001. I had gotten insurance with GEICO, so I was paying two insurance companies at the same time. I sent Travelers copies of the Florida certificate of title and registration, which was issued to me on 9/18/01. I also sent them an original insurance card from GEICO. They said that I still had to pay them even though I had everything here in Florida. I was told that they wanted the FS-6T from NYS Motor Vehicles. I asked if they could give the address, they said to call the broker.
I wrote the broker, and they said they didn't have an address for Motor Vehicles and if I had a friend or family that I could give the plates to. They said I had to pay. I don't understand how I have to pay insurance to a state where the car is not in. And in between all that we also had the horrible day of Sept. 11th. They are now telling me that if I don't pay Oct. and Nov. that they are sending me to collection. I await your reply. I have suffered very severe migraines. I have a constant pain in the base of my neck. The doctor says that this is caused by nervous tension. I am a school teacher and this is making me very tense and not a nice person to be with. It is affecting my personality and even my memory. I do not want to lose my job.
Travelers Auto Insurance Company Information
- Company Name:
- Travelers Auto Insurance
- Website:
- www.travelers.com
