Travelers Auto Insurance Reviews

4,881,224reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.

About Travelers Auto Insurance

Travelers Insurance sells car, boat and property protection policies, as well as other coverages. It offers liability, collision, comprehensive, personal injury protection, medical payments and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. It has add-on coverage options for rental cars, roadside assistance, accident forgiveness and ride-sharing.

Pros
  • Insurance bundles available
  • Several discount opportunities
  • Multiple coverage options
Cons
  • Extra charge for roadside assistance
  • Add-on coverage can be pricey

Travelers Auto Insurance Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (91)
  • (48)
  • (31)
  • (21)
  • (184)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about Travelers Auto Insurance?
    • 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Recent
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about Travelers Auto Insurance?
    • 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 2 Reviews 10 - 40
    Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & PayoutsBilling

    Reviewed April 17, 2025

    I found out we had been driving without auto insurance for six weeks after River Valley Insurance had not forwarded paperwork to Travelers. I am being billed for those six weeks, I will not pay for something I did not have. I now have a bill for $144.00 and do not intend to pay even after being threatened by River Valley Ins. that I may be turned into the state for no insurance. Never in my life have I had a late payment on any account. This River Valley (Robbie), doing business for Travelers is a bad faith group. Every attempt to contact Travelers send all calls back to these people. When finding I had no auto insurance I was promptly reinstated but then demanded to pay for the six weeks without coverage, I cancelled the policy immediately.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageSales & MarketingPriceRefunds & PayoutsStaffBillingTransparency

    Reviewed April 11, 2025

    We all hear how wonderful multiple driver discount are. That discount is good until one of the drivers comes off the policy. They do not refund that portion of payment for that particular vehicle. They do not refund period. They consider the individual cars and drivers as one on the policy. There is one payment that is discussed in the quote process. But we are not told how it actually works. Whatever amount left that is owed on the policy after the policy is adjusted when a vehicle is removed, that amount is what they care about and the refund you think you should get back actually goes to the updated policy. Hope that makes sense.

    I am out 180$. It is a loophole they use to screw the person coming off the policy. Same if there is an accident, violations... They report the vehicles as one... THE POLICY to Lexus Nexus. I had 2 quotes from other ins companies and my premiums were almost doubled because Lexus Nexus showed me reported with the accident... I am currently disputing with Lexis Nexis which they said takes up to 30 days. I finally got the right department at Travelers to dispute. They all say the drivers/vehicles are reported together as a policy to Lexus Nexus. And who runs insurance quotes with other company's should see driving records.

    I called travelers policy services to get a loss run report. They did have me listed as having the accident. The rep said it was a mistake in the automatic inputting system or something like that. I don't know. It has been a headache with getting new insurance and learning how multiple drivers' policies work with travelers. I do not know if all companies work this way. The loophole is that the POLICY is all people and vehicles as one. Each individual coverage is one. Just realize this is what happens. I did not realize what could happen and how things are reported.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoveragePricePunctuality & SpeedStaffRatesTransparency

    Reviewed Feb. 1, 2025

    Travelers is NOT an insurance company I would recommend. We’ve had them for 14 years, and only have filed one claim for a very small fender bender. As a result, they punished us by increasing our monthly rate by an additional $517 per month. The agent could not provide any satisfactory explanations as to why the huge hike per month. This prompted us to look for other insurance companies, and learned that there are much better price options with much better customer reviews.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & PayoutsMaintenanceStaffBilling

    Reviewed Sept. 26, 2024

    I have been insured with Travelers on two different vehicles. I have used road service in the past with very good and prompt service. This time was different. I am very unhappy with both their procedure and service. I live in Phoenix Arizona, this is Sunday morning on September 15th around 9am. My dog and purse are locked in my air conditioned vehicle. I am seriously considering dropping my insurance because of this incident. My dog, my purse and my keys were locked in my car. It is around 9am. The air is running. I am in the shade it is still warm at this hour. I was hopeful to get fast and helpful response time on a sunday am. I had only been a few minuets before discovering that the one door left open, had locked up AND the hidden emergency key had apparently dislodged.

    It took nearly 30 minuets to get someone live because everything is automated and digital...HOW DOES THIS HELP IN EMERGENCY. I was fearful to hang up and try something that could be quicker. Fortunately I had two other people come by and offer help using their tow service and called in to see if someone would come. When I did get a live person they told me that my policy was cancelled. I begged them to dispatch someone and that I had a card verifying that I was insured. I was told they could do this but I would need to pay the service and then could be reimburse.

    Anxious to get someone on route I said that was fine. However, she was demanding payment to dispatch. At that time I was agitated and down right angered, knowing full well I was indeed insured I actually had to state that Travelers would not be very happy if they denied service to an insured client that was stranded with their dog in the vehicle in the hot Arizona sun. Within a few minuets they found my current right standing account and dispatched immediately. It have been more than 30 minuets by this time. I now had a 50 minuet dispatch call. I begged to get it moved up if possible.

    In the process the police also were called, but the quickest responder without questions was a lock smith who arrived in 15 minuets and had my dog out in less than 5 minuets. When I knew the lock smith was arriving I tried to call and cancel Travelers. I was again digitally put on hold and then told to call my agent directly. I never received any notifications that a driver was on the way. After I had my dog out of the car, Triple A showed up and then finally Travelers.

    In conclusion: I did not get fast service. I actually got the runaround and it was at least an hour and a half before I had Travelers arrived. It is shocking to me that someone< especially the elderly is made to text digital information and go through multiple menus trying to get assistance. When you are stranded it is challenging enough to think clearly. Often the digital system is either not working correctly or is less familiar to someone they may panic in the process of trying to get help. For future road service I am very skeptical that I would receive the needed help from Travelers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Customer ServiceCoveragePricePunctuality & SpeedStaffBillingValue

    Reviewed May 14, 2024

    Travelers Insurance is the worst! I accidentally tapped a large Chevy Silverado 2021 truck's rear right bumper with my compact Volkswagen Tiguan while backing up a narrow driveway during a snowfall. The truck was partially parked, blocking the driveway exit, and there was nobody in it. My car didn't even get a scratch on it and or no damage. Unfortunately, a supposed family member filed a claim against me five days later and ended up getting a whole new bumper, tow hitch, and paint job. The truck never even had a tow hitch before I tapped it. It took the insurance company eight full days just to inspect the truck. Initially, they told us the damage was very minor and that it was the smallest claim ever. Nonetheless, it took from March 25th until May 10th, 2024 (when the claim finally closed). It took from April 29 until May 10 for the owner to get their truck back.

    I was then informed that the claim was over $1700, and the truck had been in the shop for two whole weeks! I was not provided with an itemized bill of the charges from the insurance, and the body shop refused to help me. I was advised to contact a lawyer to obtain the necessary information for an itemized bill. The representative, Pedro **, offered the worst customer service I have ever experienced with car insurance. He did not respond to my inquiries for many days and seemed not to care. I do not recommend this insurance at all. I canceled my policy and am returning to Progressive. I do not care if travelers was cheaper. It is not worth it!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechStaffBillingHonesty & Transparency

    Reviewed Feb. 3, 2024

    One reason that I will not renew with Travelers Insurance - "Leanna P. **". She was unprofessional, rude, noncommunicative, dishonest, authoritative and attempted to withhold care on all fronts, even though the insurance of the responsible party was willing to, and did pay. Now that the claim has been settled, I am signing with the competitor insurance (the insurance of the person at fault in this MVA). They were much more professional and did NOT block my ability to obtain necessary (not unnecessary or superfluous) care.

    Just one example of the atrocious demeanor of Leanna: I had just seen a doctor as a result of the rear end accident. Leanna called and yelled at me, accusing me of “insurance fraud” in attempting to obtain care that was unnecessary and told me that PRIOR to ANY doctor visit, or for ANYTHING related to the MVA, that I must submit and be approved to see any care provider. She also informed me that she is the sole authority in my obtaining care for the accident.

    NOTE: I was the victim of a simple rear end accident. I was not seriously hurt but was minimally hurt. I was not looking to sue. I was honest about these things with Leanna. I only wanted some basic care. I was NOT the person responsible, in fact the person at fault was cited as being 100% at fault. So Travelers was not responsible for any bills. But Leanna had to the nucleus of dictatorship. She is a loud-speaking, harsh, controlling person; one that should not be dealing with those who have been involved in accidents. We have enough stress and pain to deal with. We don’t need someone like her to make things absolutely unbearable. Every call with her was this way, so I stopped responding to her assaults and dealt with the “at fault” insurance.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed Oct. 13, 2023

    The claims are pathetic. They will not cover all the car damage cost and deductible is just for name sake. I had a vandalism claim, for which they only covered a part and asked me to submit another claim for other parts. This only increase deductible for each claim, which is generally around $500. Also, nobody there will answer the call and nobody will response on the email as well. This is my first time and I will move away soon. Claim Number: **

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePricePunctuality & SpeedStaffRates

    Reviewed Sept. 19, 2023

    I know that they have to look out for their shareholders first and then their workers. Also, it's a business that needs to make money. There have been several claims recently, lawsuits, etc. according to reports. On the other hand, it seems that when these big companies cough, the small guys get sick. I received an initial quote over the telephone after 5 minutes trying to find a contact number online while talking to a machine (AI). Every time I called back to make a small change/purchase, the price it changed. It looks like each agent wants to create a new one. I was even told why my rates went up in 24–48 hours; when I asked, even though I have an excellent driving and credit records.

    Whatever else, they used to screw you over was on display even when there are no issues for a reasonable price. The agent told me that I had a claim three years ago. I had to have the car towed to the shop to get it fixed because I couldn't drive it from my house from an earlier repair. No lapse in insurance (checked). No moving violations (checked). No claims filed (checked). I guess you must be the only who reaps the benefits of these companies. You are naughty if you file.

    I have been with another company for over 25 years, and only looking around. I'll move on, and stay put, but check your policy because that is going up fast, extremely high. Plus, they will look for any reason to drop you, and or increase your premium. Your experience maybe different, but this is mine! Thank you for reading.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 8, 2023

    Travelers increased my premiums to over $2,000 for 6 months. Slowly over 5 years they did this. I changed to Progressive on 4/7/23 for the same coverage but $600 for 6 months. Then Travelers took the premium out of my bank account, even though I canceled in person. I know I will be refunded the $200 Travelers stole, but DAMN they are ruthless. Travelers will steal your money then make you fight to get it back. DO NOT CONTRACT WITH TRAVELERS INSURANCE.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoveragePunctuality & SpeedBillingTransparencyHonesty & Transparency

    Reviewed Feb. 1, 2023

    Updated on 02/27/2023: It's been 52 days (1/5/23) and I still don't have my car back. Parts on national backorder. There needs to be another option other than just wait. Perhaps a buy-out option is needed or the insurance/collision shop should of been honest upfront. I would be in a better place if I was given the check and just sold my wrecked car as-is.

    Updated on 02/09/2023: Wrote a negative review and they will not comment. My car has been in shop for 5 weeks, waiting for parts. No other options than just to wait. This is not right. There needs to be a better option.

    Original Review: My vehicle has been in a collision shop since 1/5/2023. There are 4 Honda parts on national backorder and no ETA has been provided. If my car can not be fixed because the parts are not available, then there needs to be a buy-out option. I didn't have rental coverage on my policy due to an oversight when we sold our extra car 2 yrs ago. My rental coverage would of expired by now anyways. My claim was filed on 12/23/2022 and it took 2 weeks for an adjuster to look at my car to start the process. Thank you, Bill.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePriceStaff

    Reviewed Oct. 16, 2022

    Pay over 1K/mo for multiple drivers on half dozen vehicles. Recently had a vehicle totaled, other drivers fault 100%. Almost been a month with no resolution. Terrible communication from adjuster, to appraiser, to total loss adjuster, to supervisors of supervisors. Bottom line, THEY DON’T CARE! Zero customer care or concern about you, your totaled car or the actual value. All insurance companies are lacking for one reason or another, and I understand it’s a dirty business, but Travelers, in my over 40 years of paying and using insurance is the absolute worse. Hands down, not even close. BUYER BEWARE! LOOK ELSEWHERE and save yourself from the trouble I’VE experienced.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Refunds & PayoutsBilling

    Reviewed July 9, 2022

    Travelers provided me two account numbers. I sent the annual auto payment $1,500. They sent it to my mortgage co. I owed nothing there so they sent it back. Fiasco started 6/16/22. 7/8/22 zero refund.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageCommunication

    Reviewed April 18, 2022

    After months of them failing to notify me of arbitrary forms, they cancelled me without warning and caused a massive amount of lapsed insurance fees from the DMV, and to top it off they refused to reinstate my policy when the mistake was discovered entirely on my end.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageStaff

    Reviewed June 28, 2021

    On 6/23/21 a 18 wheel Truck hit my car in the rear while on 75 north in Jonesboro, Ga. I called Travelers Auto Insurance whom I have coverage with. I got assigned a claim Manager Velma **. She provided very brief info, considering the fact that I have never been involved in a car accident. In this case I would have needed some guidance. Anyways whenever advised me to not use my insurance since I was not at fault. She explained that she is very busy and if I need to call her and she don’t pick up, select 0 and get her coworker to assist. Needless to say that every time you call no one from her Team pick up. So as a result you needed up leaving texts, voicemails and emails. The time I did get a rep, she was very informative and rude and. Pasha.

    After having a poor customer service experience I reached out to Velma Supervisor named Kerri ** and she said emailed me saying she was in a meeting and wrote a entire email about the situation she knew nothing about. Instead of putting her Customer Service and Supervisory skills to work she just avoided me all together. Her meeting was 4 days ago and she still have not reached out to me via telephone as I requested. I finally was able to reach Ms. Velma Friday 6/25/2021 and advised her that I spoke to My Lawyer J Sanders and Associates and was informed that when I am not responsible for the wreck, then I would go through the other party responsible for any damages to my car and etc. I also requested that the Claim be canceled effective immediately.

    Today is Monday 6/28/2021 I checked my online Travelers insurance and the Claim is still showing open and active. I called and was advised by Shameka that Ms. Velma is the only person able to cancel my claim. I called Ms. Velma and she does not pick up the phone. It’s weird that only 1 person in the entire Company can only cancel my claim. Travelers is by far the worst Insurance Company I have ever had a negative experience with. I would never recommend this Company to anyone.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoveragePricePunctuality & SpeedBillingRates

    Reviewed June 1, 2021

    I was just informed that Travelers Auto Insurance charges "processing fees" no matter how you pay unless you "pay the policy in full" or "trick the system by paying the monthly fee twenty-two days early". These fees are based on "interest of the policy per year at 18% divided by 365". I shouldn't have to "trick the system" or pay thousands of dollars for a full policy payment in order to avoid predatory fees. This is fraud at it's finest. Don't do business with Travelers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServicePrice

    Reviewed April 29, 2021

    My claims adjuster carefully considered all possible causes for a small dent in my new car door and ruled "comprehensive" with lower deductible instead of "collision" cause, which he could have done. Further, he carefully walked me through the process, arranged for a rental car, and was constantly available by phone and email. I felt like I had a sympathetic partner during the claims process, which was new to me. I would strongly recommend Travelers based on this experience.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed Dec. 29, 2020

    This is a warning to all not to buy this insurance. It's not worth. They left my husband stranded all night in the cold. He called at 9:30pm 12/26/2020. Dispatch called him back at 2:33pm 12/27/2020 to tell him they are on the way. The phone operator said they were going to be 90 minutes. I've never been so frustrated in my life.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageSales & MarketingStaff

    Reviewed Nov. 25, 2020

    My claim got declined and I was told that reason is not covered however I asked specifically to the sales agent at the time of signing up and was confirmed that yes it is indeed covered. Now as expected they are playing the typical dirty tactics and have declined my claim. I want to warn everyone to take caution when signing up with this type of company. They always find a reason to turn down your claims. THIS COMPANY IS NOT RECOMMENDED. THEY ARE HERE TO JUST TAKE MONEY AND KEEP DECLINING YOUR CLAIMS. Absolute disappointment.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageStaff

    Reviewed Nov. 20, 2020

    It seems that the Travelers insurance seems to work for help people find the right auto insurance for people and people have helped with their insurance questions and they help them and some people do have their questions to be answered.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageStaff

    Reviewed Aug. 3, 2020

    We moved to PA a little more than a year ago and had to find our new auto coverage. We stopped in at a local agency and the representative found us the most extensive coverage for far less than we paid in NY.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoverageStaff

    Reviewed Aug. 2, 2020

    Have been insured with Travelers for 5 years. They have taken very good care of us. Both my wife and I have had accidents. They did an excellent job on handling our claims. That is why you buy Insurance. Plus in this uncertain times I know they are an A+ company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedMaintenanceStaff

    Reviewed July 27, 2020

    The only times I really had to use my Travelers insurance was to continuously have my poor car towed after being broken down. They have such a quick and amazing process. You call, go through the automated service, then they text you a link so you can check the progress of the tow truck coming to your location. My previous insurance company definitely didn't offer that!

    Thanks for your vote!
    PriceBillingRates

    Reviewed July 26, 2020

    Just switched to them from USAA. Although USAA was great they were a little pricey and we needed to save money. Went through a broker who found this great rate. Haven't needed to file any claims yet. They give options for payment.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageRates

    Reviewed July 25, 2020

    Consistently the best rates I've been given out of all others. And never any problems with customer service, which is not something I can say about Progressive (worst customer service experience and they tried to add coverage I did not need nor want!). Been with Travelers now for three years. Very happy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Coverage

    Reviewed July 23, 2020

    I think that my issues are likely more related to my insurance broker than with Travelers directly. Travelers has always come through and paid when we have had incidents. We have all of our insurance bundled with Travelers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    CoveragePunctuality & SpeedMaintenanceStaffBilling

    Reviewed July 13, 2020

    I was in A car accident involving A red light runner who hit me A week ago. My car is still not in A shop and not drivable as I have no headlight on one side and turn signals do not work (additionally the driver assist sensors were damaged and do not work). And today I received A notice of cancellation in the mail. My vehicle is not repaired nor have I received A check to cover damages.

    I had 2 cars and homeowners with them, never missed (or even late) on payments, never had A ticket, never had A claim, This accident was not my fault either, but they decide to cancel me.... What!? Absolutely the worst insurance company. Stay clear of them! [As A side note it appears that my states revised statutes are clear on how and why and insurance company can cancel A customer Travelers is in violation of this law - will be filing A complaint with the insurance board in the morning and consulting an attorney.]

    Thanks for your vote!
    Billing

    Reviewed July 2, 2020

    On 6/1/20 their member struck me from behind and instead of paying me they (KERRY) absolutely positively suggested I go rack up more BILLS because apparently the claim was too low. Glad I'm not a member. I've NEVER heard of that.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePunctuality & SpeedStaff

    Reviewed June 27, 2020

    Called for roadside assistance for flat tire at 11 am. The towing company was suppose to text or call with an ETA, waited almost and hour nothing. It was in the 80's in the sun in a parking lot. I called the only number I have for travelers. I had to start all over jump thru hoops to get to roadside again was told tow driver would be there in 20 minutes 45 minutes I called again. Oh goody the truck broke. I'm at Over 2 hours now in Walmart parking lot in Columbia MO. Now they will try another company another hour and someone MIGHT show up. I bought the insurance and yet my name isn't on the policy. Never an apology never any sense of urgency just wait for hours that's the best Travelers can do. I bought the policy and I am getting a new company. One that's not run by neanderthals and my name will be on the policy. I would suggest calling any roadside assistance especially Travelers every 10 minutes. Shameful.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageRefunds & PayoutsStaff

    Reviewed April 22, 2020

    Worst insurance company I ever had to deal with. Make a long story short, they were the insurance company of a company I filed a claim against. The company refunded my money and asked me to get estimates. I got 5! for the damages caused by their product. The claims rep. refused to pay the claim, even though the company admitted liability. I asked to speak to the claims rep's boss. He never even extended the courtesy of investigating and calling me back. Terrible customer service!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    PricePunctuality & SpeedBilling

    Reviewed March 7, 2020

    My Credit Score with Transunion is 765. After an online quote the site gave me an amount that is $200 more a year than who I have now, Geico. The reasoning for the amount was they did not place me in their best category based on my credit check. I am using my credit at 20%, no late payments. What is this?

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    Travelers Auto Insurance Company Information

    Company Name:
    Travelers Auto Insurance
    Website:
    www.travelers.com