How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

First American Home Warranty Reviews

4,977,043reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+2 more
Author picture
Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin

About First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 40 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.

Visit homewarranty.firstam.com
Pros
  • HVAC tuneup coverage available
  • No age limit on appliances
  • Discounts on related products and services
Cons
  • Not available in all states
  • Does not publish detailed pricing

First American Home Warranty Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (4,701)
  • (1,120)
  • (504)
  • (326)
  • (2,452)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about First American Home Warranty?
    • 4,977,043 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Top reviews
    • Top reviews
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    2 featured reviews
    How do I know I can trust these reviews about First American Home Warranty?
    • 4,977,043 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 42 Reviews 5925 - 6075
    Tech

    Reviewed May 19, 2017

    Caution!! If you are buying a home or thinking about a home warranty, beware of 1st American Home Warranty. I have had 2 dealings with them. Both times were a complete mess. Hold times literally over 30 min, (unless you get smart and select "new purchase" option). The contractors do not like working with them because it's so difficult to get things done in a timely manner because of 1st American's process and it takes forever to get paid. Just FYI. I didn't give a bad review the first time, but now it hardly seems like a coincidence.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 19, 2017

    When I bought the house at Fortworth, it has been an antique for over a year. It was prudent to look into acquiring home warranty and the real estate agent recommended First American Home Warranty. Submitting a claim is straightforward, easy and painless although when my washing machine and dryer went out, my particular brand of dryer wasn’t in the list so I included it in the body of the note. Fortunately, the service person read it. Otherwise, he would’ve brought the wrong heating element. It’s frustrating though because I had a high-end Samsung washing machine and they replaced it with a refurbished one. However, since my recent claim, the repair has worked perfectly. Plus, the contractor was prompt, got the job done, and cleaned up after himself. I'm very happy with First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed May 19, 2017

    We have had 4 or 5 claims, and every single one of them has required babysitting these people to get responses or to get our issue resolved. We have had to resolve the issue ourselves on most of these occasions, and customer service and responsiveness is absolute garbage. I will never work with this company again, which is unfortunate because I am likely to sign up for another home warranty program.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Eric,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 19, 2017

    I will just list my cancellation letter. I can not believe how much time they will spend trying to sign you up and how little effort they will give in keeping you as a customer. There were two customer service reps that were incredibly helpful. The only problem is by the time you call back you have to start all over again. I would like to cancel my policy due to the fact I was told my house would be covered even if it was an older home built in the late 50’s.

    I placed a work order in November because my power in half my house kept going off and on intermittently. The breakers weren’t popping off but the power was going in and out. The contractor that you sent out which is Woo Brother’s Electronics said my panel was old and would need to be replaced. They told me my panel was overloaded. My panel had been working fine on the same load up until that time. Your claims department said they would not cover the replacement of the box because my home was old. I look into hiring a second opinion or for someone who could do it cheaper. I was advised to call SMUD. SMUD is the utility company I purchase my electricity through. They came out and said it was due to the power lines coming to my home and they replaced the attachment where the power line was coming to my home.

    Today they replaced and updated the lines coming to my home. There was no charge because the lines were covered under SMUD since it was due to the lines coming to my home. Since November 17, 2016 my home has not had a power outage or surge of any sort. I have not had to do any work on my electrical panel. I have not updated my panel and it seems to work with no problems. I called and spoke to a woman in April 2017 about how my panel seemed to have no problems since SMUD fixed their problem. I asked if I could have my money back for the service call since the diagnosis was wrong and misleading. She said after talking to her supervisor that I just needed to get a letter from SMUD stating that they did work on my home around that time. There is no work order or invoice or SMUD does not charge for the work they did.

    I got the letter and emailed it today to Irvin **. I had a hard time sending the attachment but I finally got it sent. When I called back to talk to Irvin ** I was connected to a new person and then her supervisor. They told me that my letter from SMUD was not detailed enough. I have spent multiple hours dealing with this problem. I am frustrated and disappointed and feel ripped off.

    First of all when I purchased this warranty I was not told my electrical panel was exempt from the warranty due to age. That was misleading. Secondly the wait for an electrician to come out was long and the diagnosis was false and misleading almost causing me to spend thousands of dollars that didn’t need to be spent at that time. I have spent hours on the phone trying to explain the situation and getting the proper documentation to no avail. I also have a letter that states the insurance policy is already going up in price.

    I am so frustrated and would just like to cancel my policy since my panel is not covered due to age and who knows what else will conveniently be determined to be too old if it breaks down. That is not what the sales person told me when he sold me the policy. I would like my money back on the service call to Woo Brothers Electrical. I expected to be told the real problem with my electrical problem. I would like reimbursement for the policy since I was sold a policy that was supposed to cover my home regardless of age. I would like my policy cancelled so I don’t receive any more charges.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 19, 2017

    We bought a condo and my realtor gave us a one-year home warranty under First American as a gift. I've renewed it a couple of times already. However, they didn’t do too good with their last choice of plumbers. But other than that, they’ve been very good. I had a pipe break underneath my kitchen sink. The claims rep was very polite and nice. She filed the claim for me and said that the people would be in contact with me in a day and they were, but they just sent out somebody inexperienced. The plumber didn’t fix it totally and so it leaked all night long and caused more damage than what it originally did. I was not too happy with that and I had to have them out twice.

    Also, I had a problem with my dryer and the tech fixed it the one time. Then, two months later, something else came up and they immediately told us that we needed a new part. They didn’t even bother to open it. My son opened it up when the tech left and found out that there was a pair of nylons twisted all the way around the motor, stopping it. I don’t wear nylons. Nobody else in my house wears nylons. They’ve had it open prior to that from the first time we called them a few months earlier regarding a different problem and should’ve been able to see that there was a pair of nylon sitting there. It just seemed awful fishy that it was going to be a $300 repair. I wasn’t too happy with that.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 18, 2017

    We called the home warranty company because our kitchen sink faucet would not pivot and would not turn off properly. We received a visit from a gentlemen, from a company selected by First American Home Warranty. We took a day off work to meet with the plumber, who came in with a clipboard in hand. He proceeded to look at the issue and said "Yes you need a new faucet", he then proceeded to let us know how much money he makes, cracked a couple jokes, and let us know he would have his "girls" call to schedule for the plumber to come out. If anyone has seen the commercial about the "Security monitor" at the bank, that just lets people know when the bank is being robbed... that was this guy, a "Plumbing Monitor".

    We schedule with the plumber, take another day off work. Plumber comes and changes out the faucet. He changed the faucet (definitely not the same quality of what was taken out) and leaves. A couple hours later we turn the dishwasher on, which floods our kitchen, damaging the cabinets. We try to call the plumber, who does not answer, so we call First American Home Warranty to end up talking to a person who spoke broken English, obviously outsourced customer service representatives in another country - difficult to understand. He was unable to help and said he would have the plumber come out the next day to take care of the issue. I asked to speak to a supervisor, so he connected me to another gentleman with broken English in another department that handles such issues.

    The new gentleman tells me First American Home Warranty will issue a claim if we send them pictures of the damage, but they cannot get our issue fixed that night, but assured me it would be fixed in the morning. We forward the pictures to the email he gave us that night. After not receiving any communication the next morning, we called First American Home Warranty back to be told that a work order was never initiated and they are not responsible for what their plumber may have done and they do not know why we were told to send pictures. They then initiated a work order for the plumber to return and said the plumber would be contacting us. We finally received a call from a young lady with the plumbing company, who told us she could give us another 4 hour window for a visit on Monday of next week.

    We told her that their plumber made the mistake and it needed to be taken care of immediately. She told us that their plumber was never sent. When we told her the plumber's name, she then said "How do you know he made the mistake to cause the damage?" And still rudely insisted that the only available time slot to get the plumbing issue fixed was next Monday, take it or leave it, they are really busy. And the new appointment would be with the first guy whom I call the "Plumbing Monitor". We still do not have use of our kitchen sink and are awaiting the plumbing monitor.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Charlie,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 18, 2017

    When I bought my place, First American was what I had for the home protection and I kept it because they’ve given me good service. In the last six months, I've had several claims including when my freezer went out and I had to have a whole new air conditioner unit on top of my roof. That worked out wonderful. Then, I had a leak in my faucet in my bathroom that was leaking into the storage room below my condo which took a little while but it eventually got fixed. I also had a shower faucet fixed and everything was done.

    Also, the contractors were all very good especially ENA, the one for the air conditioning one. The plumbing people that came to fix the faucets and the shower faucet were good, too. I’m very pleased and I will stick with them. I’ve been in my 13 and a half years and I quit them for a little while but then I thought something’s going to go wrong. So, I started up again and when things started to go wrong, I was very happy and little by little, everything worked out for me. So I was very pleased.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 18, 2017

    We had a little bit of a glitch in my last claim for the ice maker. The vendor they chose first was not going to be able to come out for two weeks and yet, they’re only 20 miles down the road. I called back and then one of the claim reps reassigned it. This guy was there in three hours and the problem was fixed. He should have been their first assignment as opposed to those other people. We’ve had people out for the ice maker three times before to the point that it had to be replaced and First American also took care of that very nicely. So far, I’m very happy with their response and the program.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed May 17, 2017

    From Feb 28th to current (17 MAY 2017) I have been dealing with a dripping sound between my floors from the master bathroom toilet. There is also an odor that is very strong that I now sleep in another room. I have had the wax ring replaced and told the jets in the toilet are messed up and the toilet needs replacing. The tech also stated that the smell of sewage was present. Because of this comment alone my claim has been denied. Not because of the other reasons but solely on the smell alone.

    I called in to get a second opinion, I was told the company assigned would call me in 24-72 hours. So I waited a full week. (Maybe they meant 72 business hours which equals 9 working days). Nevertheless I find I have a person assigned to my claim. I asked if I could speak with them and was advised they would be calling me. NOT ONCE have I received a call from the first time the contractors came out nor the SECOND time. I had to call in and find out each time what was going on with my claim. This is not a way to run customer service. I'm looking at American Home Shield for coverage. Although 10.00 more expensive it covers my pool and EVERYTHING in my house. If you ever want to email First American's claim service here's the email: claimreview@firstam.com. Just so you know, THEY DO NOT REPLY.

    Thanks for your vote!
    TechPrice

    Reviewed May 17, 2017

    Placed a service request to repair my air conditioner. After inspecting, the repair contractor stated he will have to return to complete repairs. Paid service request fee for inspection. Contractor called and stated to total service cost will be $1500 to complete repair. My FHW premier plan includes air conditioner option. Contacted FHW and rep couldn't explain why total service cost is $1,500. Repair contractor returns at 9 am PST (this day) to complete repair. Feeling pressured and no resolution forthcoming soon.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Donnie,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 17, 2017

    I’ve been a customer of First American Home Warranty for 13 years now. Submitting a claim to them was okay. However, I hate their automated system. Their machine does not recognize my keyword. Also, I have very bad experience with them. The claim I filed was really a pain. They messed up and it took forever for them to settle that because they did not file it on time and did not send anybody for several months so I had to get supervisors. It has been a very, very stressful experience. Nevertheless, they were able to fix it but it was three months of yelling and screaming but they've been okay lately. Overall, they’re very good and they know what they’re doing.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 17, 2017

    I got First American when I bought the house. I had no problems the first year. When I was thinking of renewing, I called them and talked to one of their representatives. They explained how everything would work and I thought that it was a good thing to keep, so I elected to have it for my house. When the fan on the convection oven of my dual purpose stove was making noise, their claim reps were very helpful and got the repair people out who were really knowledgeable. The first guy came out and figured out what was wrong and what he would have to do. Then they ordered the part. When the part came in, a different repair guy came and repaired it. I'm quite happy with everything that has been done.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 16, 2017

    My First American Home Warranty came with my home when I bought it three months ago. They had more options on their policy than the warranty I had with my previous home. Also, I've spoken to their customer service representatives to ask about pool coverage because I'm going to add things like that to the warranty. I'm very pleased with First American so far.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed May 15, 2017

    I've been a First American Home Warranty member for 10 years. Recently, I submitted a claim for my ice maker. I called First American and they put everything up for me. However, I didn't realize that my ice maker was not covered by the warranty until the contractor they sent told me. But First American has been great and I choose to stay with them because they're cheaper.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechOnline & App

    Reviewed May 15, 2017

    My realtor has First American and told me about it. He said that having a home warranty would be great because the owner who sold the house to me didn't really want to replace anything, and that if something breaks, at least I'm covered and won't have to spend as much money on replacing or fixing things. I've already done three claims with First American. The first one was for the washing machine. The pump broke on it and a tech came out and fixed it. It was a wham-bam-thank-you-ma’am kind of deal. It was great and I had no issues there. It was the same thing with the plumbing, where a guy came out, fixed the problem, and went about his way.

    However, my last experience wasn't so great. It was for the AC unit and there was nothing really done with it. It's still broken and right now, it's probably running on its last breath. The AC unit is kind of working, but I haven’t set it to a lower level for it to freeze up. It’s 13 years old so it is bound to fail soon. When I put in the claim for it, I called that day remembering that on the website, there used to be an emergency module, and I thought an AC being broken in Florida would be an emergency situation. And then, they sent out a company called Comfort Tech and the tech who came out said that it's not failing, but I think it is because it still keeps freezing up. When I called back First American, the rep said that if the technician says that it's not failing, then there's nothing they can do about it. I asked if it would be possible to send a different company or different person the next time that it does not work properly but he didn't say anything. I feel that it’s the same person who I’ve talked to twice and he was kind of not very helpful. But other than that, my experience with First American has been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 14, 2017

    The first time that I used First American, the experience was pretty good. The technician was fine. This would be my second time using First American. I had called yesterday and the people said they had set me up with a plumber. But they cancelled because I'm not in the area. I didn't know they weren't coming until I had called. They never called to say that thing has been cancelled. So, I had to call back today and they got me set up for Thursday with somebody else.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed May 14, 2017

    I put a claim 3 weeks ago and they still haven't resolved it. They told me I need to look for a company myself to get an estimate. I called back with the estimate I receive from the company (the company I looked for) and all they've done is transfer me from one department to another. The department haven't been able to help me. Overall, the Service is terrible and I am disappointed with the company after I've had them for 9 years.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 14, 2017

    I had a great experience with First American and I’m happy with it. It did not take the representatives very long to process my claim. For the general part of the process, they got on-site the same day. They went up a little bit, though. I used to pay $65. Now, it’s $75. But I like First American. It is a good company, so it's good keeping.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed May 14, 2017

    Submitting a claim with First American was really easy and pretty straightforward because I do it over the phone. The reps were helpful and knowledgeable. The technicians were knowledgeable, too. I try to look up the stuff after I talk to them and they know what they're talking about. But I had a guy come out initially on the water heater, flushed it, and said that was the only issue. Then a month later, I was seeing a lot of rust in the line. Another guy came out and replaced the heater. So the first time was not as good because the first guy said it'll clear up after I run it a while. But the second guy came out and recognized the issue right away and it got taken care of. It's nice to have the warranty. I don't want to have to use it, but if I need it, it's there. It's like insurance. I don't want to buy insurance, but if I need it, I'm glad I have it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 13, 2017

    When we purchased our previous house, it came with a year of First American Home Warranty. We continued it after that. Then when we bought our new house, it came with a different warranty company so after the year was up, we switched to First American. It was much better than the other company. The level of service and the features covered the benefits provided. What’s most difficult is to submit a claim by phone instead of online because you have to wait to talk to someone for ten minutes max but it’s not nearly as bad as the other company where I’d wait over half an hour. I called today and got someone on the phone within two minutes. It was an easy and smooth process. I've never had an issue with that aspect of it. Plus, the claims representatives are right to the point. If I called with a question, they always answered or get it handled and contact me back. It’s usually quick and not much wasted time.

    I put a claim in for my air conditioning. When the first technician came out, they noticed that it was low on Freon and he said that it’s typical to need a couple of pounds of Freon every year. Within a few days, it had already leaked out several more pounds of Freon. The owner of the company came out and looked at it and basically apologized for the misinformation of this other employee. He made it all right, did all the inspections and found the leak. We are now in the process of getting the part ordered and shipped in. When the replacement part comes in, the owner himself has assured me of the quality that it will be in and he guarantees his work even outside of the warranty company of First American so I feel confident that it will get taken care of. Nobody is perfect. A mistake did happen but at least up until this point, they are doing everything they can to correct the problem quickly and appropriately. I'm satisfied with First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed May 13, 2017

    When we purchased our home, First American Home Buyers Warranty was already on it for a year. It's comfortable. They follow-through right away and we've had no issues with them. So we just renewed it. Filing claims has been easy. We just call it in and it's not been an issue at all. A lot of times, it's because of air conditioner issues. Occasionally they'll have to research and call me back but usually they have it already assigned to someone before we get off the phone. And the technicians have done very well. They're Johnny-on-the-spot. They always know exactly what to do to fix it and fix it in a very timely manner.

    And if we've had to call First American again, it's gonna be a different issue maybe with the same unit. It's not like they do a sorry job so we need another person to come out. The only thing is just that the cost has gone up. It started out at $500 the first year. And now, we're almost to $700. That's just unfortunate. But I've recommended them to our children that are married and just starting out.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed May 13, 2017

    Our realtor bought First American as a closing gift for me and my wife then we renewed it. Submitting a claim was smooth and easy. My wife called in and she got a good experience talking to their representatives. We got a couple of things that we had to use it on like a water heater and a plumbing issue and it worked fine. Their technicians were great as well. I felt the price is reasonable and it’s a great warranty company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechSales & MarketingPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 12, 2017

    Based upon my own experience, I cannot believe this company is still licensed to do business in California. I have had to police every step of this relationship and have nothing still to show for it. I had a full plumbing failure due to pinhole leaks in the pipes and a leak under my slab, found after taking the outer wall of our house off (ourselves). We turned off our water as First American advises to minimize damage from further leaks.

    First Am's contractor was 2 hours away from our residence and didn't even bother to call to say he wasn't coming. We had to find our own contractor and have him call First Am for authorization (tough enough to get a plumber to come out, much less jump through red tape while we are without water). Took 3 weeks after claim was made to get water back on thanks to my efforts, not their claims of saving us hours of finding a contractor. He had to repipe the house and circumvented the slab so we wouldn't have this issue come up again.

    They did a great job, but I had to pay directly for the job as required under selecting your own provider option nearly $5,000.00, but considerably less than going through the slab. I submitted proof of payment in a cleared check, paid invoice, and even my bank statement showing it was cleared. Then nothing. Calls and e-mails finally got me a promise of a payment of $500.00 since it was under the slab, and as limited within the contract. I've read the contract, and there was a slab leak, but fixing this would not have fixed the problem. Ambiguity in the contract is on them!! I could even argue that no work was done under the slab so they're responsible without this limitation.

    Didn't really matter as nothing came, I had to call many times just to find out it was rejected for payment. Other e-mails said we needed an itemized invoice, and one that I needed to submit proof of payment (uploaded on their site 3 weeks prior — their ticket system is highly ineffective). Things happen, but when is it just obvious that they're going through some sort of checklist of excuses not to pay? I had a specific case manager assigned who would not return calls. First American, this means your first-line customer service folks are getting the brunt of frustration when the specially trained contact won't respond.

    So now, supposedly I am again being issued the minimum check amount. (Oh, but they tried to deduct the $65 co-payment from my $500 instead of the thousands already out of pocket. Really??) If this check shows up, I'm writing to this company for their handling of this process and requesting they pay an additional sum towards the rest of my out-of-pocket. I consider this incident an example of unfair, deceptive, and just inappropriate consumer retail business practices. If they do not respond and offer to rectify this in some manner, I will consider my next options. As a banking compliance professional, I would expect regulatory action from this unacceptable lack of caution and amount of effort. Mistakes happen and can be fixed, but this has been compounded and nothing would have happened if I hadn't stayed on it. PS: I have the premium coverage too.

    UPDATED ON 05/19/2017: It took my initial post here to get someone at First Am to speak with me beyond the front line. Marciela took the time to contact me and my contractor, whom I had to pay out of pocket since First Am couldn't send anyone that would show up and gave me this option (they treat this as some sort of privilege, but means you find them and pay out of pocket and like me, try for 8 weeks to get a dime back). Our contractor didn't remember anything beyond a slab leak - but we turned the water on for just a minute for his assessment. We had pin holes in other pipes outside of the slab, one was pretty big in that we lost water pressure - no wonder he couldn't see them when we turned on the water. His honest response cost me any further reimbursement, and I accept this from his end without question...

    My opinion remains that their practices are not as advertised and they hide behind a contract they do not even know (I showed Marciela the provision and she agreed that my interpretation was obvious as to a specific point First Am was hiding behind). I am in an impossible bind that precludes my getting any additional reimbursement mostly thanks to the way they handled it - would have been easily identified if the contractor they initially assigned actually showed up... during the two weeks it took me to find someone (while without water but for quick instances in which my husband would turn on then off) maybe the leaks above ground would have been easy to see and the larger one that made us lose all pressure and escalate First A to action would not have happened. I didn't ask for anything unreasonable except to protect my resources as anticipated by buying this policy.

    As to not burden my own hired contractor, I will pursue other venues to share this experience to dissuade purchasers. I am responsible for fair and accurate advertising and disclosure for my financial institution, and looks like First Am could use a little work of what we call UDAAP. Someday in some way, I'll be able to show them that the pipes have pinholes that would have required replacement if we had gone to the additional expense of re-piping under the slab instead of going around it. Maybe I'll send in the darned pipes themselves - they're still in place just no water goes through them. Even if too far off to gain additional reimbursement, enough to maybe change their thinking on how badly things can go wrong when they set my situation up to FAIL. Find my initial complaint for more information on my specific situation. Shame on First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPrice

    Reviewed May 12, 2017

    We have lived in our home for 3 years. We acquired the home warranty when we purchased the house in 2014. Two months after moving in, the A/C unit for the upstairs stopped working. We actually completely forgot about the home warranty until after I posted on Facebook that the initial A/C company quoted that the system needed to be replaced which was roughly $7500. Our realtor, seeing the post, quickly reminded me that we had the home warranty. We called them and they sent out another technician where they ended up replacing the compressor and one of the valves. We paid for the call out fee which was $95.

    In 2015 we had a cracked cooling coil in our air handler and it flooded our part of our attic space along with a bad capacitor and again it was recommended to them that our system get replaced. Again we paid for the service call. In Aug 2016 the compressor and valve from 2014 was again replaced (see a pattern here yet??). Now in March 2017, we called again due to the fan running non-stop and no cool air. The first technician they sent out stated that there was no electricity running to the unit. So the electrician comes out 2 weeks later, repairs that piece. We still don't have any A/C and the original A/C repair company, Home Reliance, does not know how to return phone calls after leaving 3 voicemails over a 5 day period. So I call First American to complain and get a new company assigned to us. At first this was denied, but after they couldn't get a hold of them they finally relented.

    Finally we get the next A/C company, Belair Heating and Cooling (5th different A/C company at this point in a 3 year time span) who states we need a new system because just replacing the compressor isn't going to fix this repeated issue. But oh by the way, First American does NOT disclose to us that now we are not only responsible for paying just the service call we are also paying for the removal/disposal of the compressor (that was put in 9 months ago) and the charging of the new one which is going to cost us $455. The A/C company tells us this. The A/C company has told First American that they can not ensure that this repair will hold. Their "representatives" Nicole **, Calvin @ ext ** or Louis @ ** can't return phone calls or when told to move my call to their supervisor want to argue with me that they are the 'sole' decision makers on these issues.

    I have my elderly mother with medical issues living with us and my special needs son who now both have window A/C units in their rooms. I don't have $7500 lying around to replace an A/C unit nor do I have the time to keep going through this every summer. One would think at some point that after reviewing the past 3 year history of this one and only issue that we have repeatedly called upon them for repairs, someone would realize the amount of waste occurring here. But I guess that's the minimal input from First American. So here is me reaching out yet again 6 weeks into the A/C unit still not working and paying for a service that doesn't provide their promised service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Erica,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 12, 2017

    When I got the house, the lady that helped me with it advised that I get a home warranty because I am alone. She recommended First American. At first when I had to submit a claim, I just started panicking. And then I'd call the number, and they usually have a technician call me back. So far, the claim process has been easy. Sometimes I don't even talk to a person because it's automated. The technicians who have come in have all been very nice, as well. They always explain what they're doing to fix the problem. I feel good about their quality of work and the payments have been fair, too. First American is a very helpful service especially if you're not living in a brand new house, you're an older person and living on one single income.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed May 12, 2017

    With First American, I can either file a claim online or call in and they pick up quickly. Their price is a bit higher than Fidelity and we're in the second year so the co-pay goes up from $50 to $75. But I've rehired some of the contractors that they have sent over. These contractors are good people. I love the plumber. He’s been back here twice doing some installations for me which were a separate item like when we took out the Corian and put in granite.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed May 12, 2017

    We have renewed with First American every year. Other places were just as expensive and it seemed easier to stay with First American. The claims reps are okay, but getting a claim over the phone is obnoxious and the website's even worse to try and navigate. But once we get a contractor here, everything seems to go okay. We feel pretty good about the repairs and we're satisfied.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 11, 2017

    My air conditioner went out then the vendor came and just collected his money. He said, "We've got let it fall out before I can do anything. I'll be back in a few days," and he never came back. I called First American and told them about that. They apparently called the vendor and the vendor said that it was not true and that's not what happened. First American took the word of the vendor over mine and threatened to send me to collection. I got really irritated and angry. I told them that I did not want that vendor to be sent to my house ever again.

    I've only had one bad experience with a vendor. Overall, I am pleased with them. I felt that their $65 deductible is pretty reasonable. My pool pump died and I couldn't fix it. They replaced it which is like $800. Then I kept having problems with the central heating air. It finally reached the point at 37 years old that it could not be repaired and they replaced it as well. All I had to do was to pay $300 for a cord outside to put it on. I was out of air conditioning in Pensacola, Florida in September for two weeks and that's understandable because they had to get it authorized. Then recently, they replaced my pool filter and all I had to pay was $70 for the fan in addition to the $65. So, they're acting in good faith.

    I have been told by other companies that First American is the most fair home warranty company that one could go with. And recently I mentioned that I'm planning to most likely move when I retire to another area and I mentioned it to a Realtor. The Realtor said that they had never heard of that home warranty and I'm thinking that I don't want another hassle about it. I've certainly got my money's worth with First American and they are quick to get somebody on it. They mean what they say and they say what they mean.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechPrice

    Reviewed May 11, 2017

    I like the price and the things that First American Home Warranty offers. I just call them when I submit my claims or I do it online. The techs that have come have been good except for one that was supposed to return but never did. However, First American was able to resolve it. I would recommend them all the time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 11, 2017

    First American is a reliable company. However, the contract states that their reps work 24 hours a day, seven days a week, but when I call them during the weekends, they are not there. And if I call them after 5:00 PM, nobody picks up the phone. So whenever I have a problem, I have to wait to get services. If they cannot perform during the weekends and if they are open only between 8:00 to 5:00, they should not put on that contract that they are available 24 hours a day and seven days a week. They should be specific and they should not put a clause that they cannot support. I've called and asked them about that and they have no reliable answer. I'd rather remove the clause.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 10, 2017

    I had a horrible experience with one of the contractors First American sent out. They had to come 3 different times to fix what should have been a very simple problem. The contractor said they'd be back at a certain time, then never showed up several times. Each visit was "We'll come sometime on a particular day" so we had to sit around waiting for these jokers every time they failed to fix the problem.

    I just found out while tromping around up in my attic, they broke the drain line to for the AC. Now I have thousands of dollars of water damage to flooring and walls due to the small leak that occurred over a few months time, but of course the contractor won't own up to it even though they were the only ones in the attic. Managers at the contractor wouldn't return calls and basically ignored the horrible service and multiple mistakes.

    But this review is about First American. You know what their response was? Basically nothing. Would they intervene while I was having this problem on my behalf? No. Would they contact their contractor? No. The only thing they'd do is file away my complaint. They have a problem contractor who provides sloppy, substandard repairs and they basically ignore it. First American doesn't care about its customers - evidence is they will do nothing to deal with problem contractors. BTW, First American's customer service takes on average about a week to respond to any complaint - wow!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 10, 2017

    Submitting a claim to First American Home Warranty was easy. I called and told them what was going on, they asked questions, sent the claim and then the contractor contacted me. We set a date, he came out and fixed it and it was done. It was simple.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 10, 2017

    I've used First American once and it went fine. I felt a little foolish because our disposal wouldn’t work. And then, the guy came in and within five minutes, he had it fixed.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 10, 2017

    First American was the one we had when we got our house. When we had a problem, somebody came out and fixed it, and we were happy with that so we renewed with them. I talked to the gentleman who came out to my house and he was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful, and courteous. He changed a whole switch out. He knew what he was doing and didn’t take a long time to get everything up and going. Overall, I'm completely satisfied with their workmanship.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed May 9, 2017

    I purchased a house with an upgraded premium home warranty. Firstly, you can't select your contractor (I don't use the ones they contract with). The electrical box to the pool shorted out and they would not repair it even though the system was connected to the main electrical box. Then I had a leak under the sink. It took days before the contractor could come over to take a look. It was determined that it was the garbage disposal and they replaced it with a new one. However, the plumber said they could not replace the rubber piece in the sink because it would be too complicated. It's only been in for a couple months and it now sounds like an airplane engine ready for takeoff.

    Then my dishwasher was leaking. That appliance repairman could not find out where it was leaking and though perhaps there was a small kink in the hose that could have caused the problem. After he left, the trim piece around the dishwasher fell off after he reinstalled it and now the dishwasher is noisy. I called to have the drain stoppers checked because they were stuck and inoperable... not covered. Knocking in the pipes... not covered. Stove was shorting out and I called the manufacturer, but then someone told me if the stove needed to be replaced that First American would not necessarily replace with the same type of high-end stove.

    When I got the renewal notice, the service calls went from $65 the first year to $75 for the current year, as well as the warranty purchase price increasing by approximately $100 a year. I got a phone call from First American asking why I didn't renew, so gave them the info. My real estate friends told me that home warranties are not a wise investment... kind of like the warranties that you purchase for your vehicles.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageTech

    Reviewed May 9, 2017

    I used my warranty several times over the course of a year. The contractors they sent were sketchy to say the least and each time they "fixed" the problem - more like put a band aid on it. Several things I had to have re-done by a reputable contractor. Specifically my AC - they sent two different contractors out because the first one didn't fix my issue. Each one basically just added freon and called it good.

    However, now that my warranty has lapsed, I'm having the same exact issue as I had last summer and the tech I had inspect it this year explained my system has a freon leak in the evaporator coil - which basically means my unit needs to be replaced. I asked both contractors last year to check for leaks. So even though they didn't fix the problem when I had coverage, now that my policy has lapsed First American will not do anything. Even if I renew my contract, they will not cover the AC because "it is not in working order" - GREAT. Their contractors failed to do their job. Why in hell would I renew with them? I asked to speak to their underwriting dept and was put on hold and then disconnected. What a surprise!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPrice

    Reviewed May 9, 2017

    I was with AHS but they were a little bit overpriced. Since First American was a little less expensive and was offering the same service, I swapped. Filing a claim was easy. I called them, they passed all my need to some recommended providers and I was immediately called back. The deductible was a little bit high, though. Other than that, First American was helpful when I needed them and I would recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 9, 2017

    I was with a different provider before and had some problems. Then I found First American and went with them. Most of the time we do claim submission online because I have an accent and it's hard for me to talk with the computer. I have to talk with the customer service and many times I cannot catch them, but if I do then it's okay. A year ago, I had a problem with the plumbing and air conditioner company. I waited three weeks in the winter to fix the air conditioner and after three weeks they made a mistake and all the units broke in 24 hours. I requested them to send me another company and they did. And half an hour, everything was okay. Most of the time, I don't have a problem and the experience is fine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 9, 2017

    First American was the home warranty that we had when we purchased the house. Once it was up, we had the option to renew it. And we decided to renew it and we've renewed it ever since. They are reliable. When something needs to be fixed, it's pretty easy to get through and they send out people who are decent. We've had a couple of ones who were not agreeable. So, we had requested to not send them back for reasons as not fixing the problem and not having a really good attitude about it. And First American took care of it. We are happy with them and I've already recommended them. My brother has First American now because I told him about them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 8, 2017

    Submitting a claim to First American is easy, you just call. The claims representatives are prompt in getting somebody to take care of the problem if it's covered. The interaction with the technicians is fine. It’s not a gigantic metropolis so we're working people that we're familiar with. They have a good reputation.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 8, 2017

    I call First American. They give it a claim number. They contact the contractor. The contractor contacts me. They come out and do whatever needs to be done. It goes really smooth. I’m really pleased. I typically pay $65 copay for claims. An example was my gas water heater went out and I paid $65. That’s a $1,700 unit so I'm happy with $65.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed May 8, 2017

    We have an older home so getting a warranty was most important. The first home warranty service I had didn't work and I didn't like it. The warranty offered by First American was a little cheaper compared to other warranty providers. The service of First American is also okay and it's easy submitting a claim over the phone. They get topnotch technicians who come out to our home and fix whatever problems we have. The technicians ask what the problem is and fix it. I'll recommend First American. They're good people and having them is beneficial. They're fixing up stuff in my house and make them operate the way they were.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed May 7, 2017

    I had First American Home Buyers Protection with my old home. I've researched and most companies don't cover a lot of stuff. But I liked the appliances that First American covered. Submitting a claim was super easy and the customer service is good. They play step by step during the process. The technicians were friendly and their work was good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 7, 2017

    First American sounded reasonable and so we got their warranty. We never had any difficulty filing a claim and they came to the house and fixed whatever we needed. The technicians have been very nice, polite and good. The last claim was for the air conditioning. It's working well once they figured out what was actually wrong with it. First American is one of those things you don't wanna have to call but we're so glad that we can. In fact, I have recommended them to a friend.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 7, 2017

    We have insurance with First American for years and I referred them to a lot of customers because I'm pleased with their service. We live in Westlake Village, which is 150 miles from our property, so to accommodate the tenants and provide good service, the best thing is to have somebody close by. Also, we know that First American deals with licensed and experienced contractors and stand behind their work. I can call them anytime and everything that we have any questions on was done. Their claims reps are also polite, patient, and work with their people. Not everything can be done on the same day but I have no problem. I pay my co-payment and I know the issue is gonna be taken care of. The tenants never complained about any of the technicians. And usually, if the people who work for First American cannot attend to an issue, then another one can step in. So, you cannot ask for a better deal. First American gives me a peace of mind.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 6, 2017

    My daughter and her family have First American and we also have them as our home warranty provider. Submitting a claim is mostly easy and I contact their representative on the phone. Their customer service is good and the technicians have been really nice and always been real good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed May 6, 2017

    I'm on my own and sometimes, you can’t get people to come out and you don’t know who to call to fix. I have furnace people because I have my oil company but no one when it comes to plumbing stuff. I looked into home warranties and my neighbor who lived down the street told me I should get First American. Submitting a claim hasn’t been too bad here but I'm very disappointed this last time. I had my faucets replaced in my kitchen and bathroom and I called back again because when you turn the hot water on in my bathroom, the faucet screeches all the time. They sent another guy out and the guy said there’s not much they could do for it because they’re not very good quality faucets.

    I called them back and they said that’s all that they pay for and if I wanna upgrade them, I have to pay the difference. I said that it’s all and good but if they're gonna give me a low grade, they should still work right. They asked if they were leaking and I told them they weren't but I asked if they would want to hear screeching every time you go to the bathroom and turn the faucets on. I called back again and asked for a supervisor but they never called me. I understand if that’s what I have to accept but if they’re gonna put a lower grade in there, shouldn’t the lower grade be working right? Why should something be put in there that screeches every time you turn the faucet on? I'm 75 years old, I never had a faucet to do that in my life! It’s annoying and I'm very dissatisfied. I am gonna look into someone else now because I’ve seen things advertised on television.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Helen,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed May 6, 2017

    My husband passed away and I'm at home by myself. I'm also handicapped and I needed help. And so, I decided to look into acquiring a home warranty. My neighbor recommended First American so I went with them. While it's nice to submit a claim to them, their phone service is a little slow. They take too long to answer the phone. I had to wait for two minutes before. Nevertheless, their claims representatives helped me and the quality of their service was wonderful. First American is an excellent company. I love them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 5, 2017

    A-1 Plumbing - I was quite happy with the plumber that AHB provided for me. Even though I had to call them to arrange, and they seemed overloaded with repair jobs, they still came by the same day, fix the problem, and got my family water to house again. I am quite pleased.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 5, 2017

    First American did a good work for me before. I'm a senior citizen and it was easier for me to just continue with them. I call them if I have a claim to submit and they take my name and the problem. Within 24 hours somebody calls me back. Their representatives were very friendly. The technician that comes to service and overall quality of work were very good. They had to go out and come back because apparently the house had an asbestos mold issue that had to be addressed before they could finish. It was an easy experience although it was traumatic because they had to have the kitchen cabinets knocked out and they weren't even a year old. They replaced it with the same cabinets and then I just called the contractor who remodeled for me. They were lucky enough to be able to prop up the granite.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 5, 2017

    We thought that a home warranty was a good service to have. We signed up with First American and so far, we've submitted one claim which was for the air conditioning unit that was leaking. We kept calling the company that we've given the information about. Eventually, a lady answered and told us she had just received the email from First American. It wasn't sent at the time that we were given the information. When we did the claim that night, the email should have went out but it didn't. Therefore, they had no knowledge of the claim that had been filed until we kept calling and calling. Other than that, the service is great. The technicians eventually came in and did what they had to do. The problem was resolved and I would recommend them to come back. Talking with First American on the phone was great, but because they didn't email the company and notify them that there was a claim, it wasn't a great experience. But I renewed and we're gonna keep the business.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 5, 2017

    My husband chose First American to be our home warranty provider. Submitting a claim is an easy process and it's easiest for me to call over the phone but my husband does online. Their claims representatives are professional. We've had good experiences with the technicians and a few bad experiences, so it's been positive overall. If the technician hasn't been good, we tell First American that we don't want them. We had some issues with one company and they sent another company. They are very accommodating when we complain. Our things have been repaired pretty good and we are satisfied overall.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Cheryl increased rating by 2 stars.
    Tech
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, Cheryl increased their star rating on June 11, 2017.

    Updated review: June 11, 2017

    Issue finally resolved.

    Original Review: May 4, 2017

    I am waiting on a part that the home warranty company is supposed to "locate" air con part to no avail. It is 90 degrees in Vegas and 80 at night. We are suffering every night for 3 weeks now. The first technician they sent didn't even look at unit. Then second company looked and stated we need a part which we've been waiting for over a week now! Our ordeal is total of 20 days now! WTF? I do not recommend you use First American Home Warranty company!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 4, 2017

    Last summer I placed a claim for a leaking faucet. When the serviceman came out to fix, he dismantled my faucet completely, and said he had to order a part. I then received notification that faucets were not covered? When I called and asked why someone was sent to do this when it wasn't covered, I was told I would have to upgrade to include faucets, but could not do so until the new year contract. So I waited and did so. I called to schedule, and they said I had to wait 30 days, which I did. Finally, I was so excited to get my faucet back in my guest bathroom. The serviceman came in, said they don't cover preexisting conditions, but would not charge me, since he felt so bad about the whole story.

    After wasting a day off work fighting this with First American, a supervisor asked for me to email him a copy of the original claim where it was dismantled. I did so, and no response. Emailed again, no response. A couple of weeks later I saw a letter in the mail rejecting my claim. Now, I receive a bill for the $65 service fee. I call to dispute, and she puts me on hold to call the plumber, and comes back and says they are going to charge me (which the plumber said he would not). I am calling the plumber service as soon as I hang up with her, and their billing service department is unreachable at this time? Ask for a supervisor, am put on hold for twenty minutes and disconnected. No words. I have been a customer for years, and no major claims, and they don't care about me one bit.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 4, 2017

    I heard about First American through FHA when I bought the home. The first time I submitted a claim was a great experience. They repaired and everything was good. I've got a dishwasher and something else fixed by them. But the last time that they sent somebody out, they did not fix the garage door which the spring had come off. It's closing on one side. I paid $65 to have that did but it still ain't fixed and the springs were laying on the floor.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 4, 2017

    We've always submitted claims to First American online and we call them to ask questions afterward. Their representatives were great. They were very nice and informative. The process has been super easy. We recently had problems with our hot water heater. The plumbing company that came out, Island Mann Plumbing, was fantastic. They actually got a permit from the city and did everything correct. They did a good job. We're confident with the quality of their work.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 4, 2017

    If you had an appliance that was bad and you paid the fees, First American would even go all the way up and replace it if needed. It was easy to submit a claim with them. I have no problems. It was a recording and First American would ask you different questions and you’d tell them what you want. And finally, they’d get down to the place where you need to discuss the particular problem, they would pinpoint the problem, and then they’d tell you who is going to come out and work on it.

    Their reps were very pleasant and receptive. When they gave me a worker that came out previously and I didn’t like what they did or they did shoddy work, I would call and talk to a live person, tell them the problem, and they would look it up on their file and say, “That’s true. We won’t send that person anymore.” All of the contractors they sent have been good, except for two. Also, the quality of the contractors’ work were 90% good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 3, 2017

    When we bought our current house, the previous homeowners had the First American plan in place, and we chose to continue it. It seemed like a good idea to do so and it has been a good experience for us. Submitting a claim was pretty smooth. During the daytime, from 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM, I can call and talk to a person to file a claim, but otherwise I have to do it online, like if it's in the middle of the night when nobody's working. Usually, when submitting a claim, I just called and talked to the reps, and they've been pleasant. I like the personal experience, and I prefer calling and talking to somebody better than doing it online. In fact, I've only used the website one time, and I try to avoid websites if I can.

    I recently filed a claim for an air conditioning problem, and the service contractor that came out to do the work was fine. He was knowledgeable, knew what he was doing, and he fixed the problem. Although the work he performed wasn't the best for me, my AC unit is working, so it was good. Overall, First American has been easy to use, helpful, and I've been glad that they were there.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 3, 2017

    I've always had a home warranty but I wasn't happy with my last company so I switched to First American. Their representatives were very knowledgeable, courteous and respectful. Moreover, submitting a claim with them was quick and easy. Also, the quality of the work was good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 3, 2017

    I wasn't aware that I could put three claims on one until the guy sent out by First American told me. I had a dishwasher that had some bad parts on it, a refrigerator and washing machine leaking and making noise. So, I said, "Well, I need to get my washing machine fixed. I'll call you in a couple of days because my dishwasher is messing up, too." He said, "Hold up. That can be put on the same claim." I said, "Really?" One $75 payment. Then I said, “Well, check this out. I got a refrigerator that's leaking water." He said, "Yeah, we can definitely put that on the same claim." So, in a week and a half, they had everything fixed. The technicians have been great and the last one was wonderful.

    The only problem I had was when I submitted a claim last year. I was having trouble with my air conditioning and First American couldn't get a contractor that had a ladder, they said I can call an outside contractor and they would reimburse me. But evidently, something happened. I didn't get my $60 back. It doesn’t matter at this point. But I called somebody else. And then when the guys that fixed it got here, he said, "Well, does First American know that you called somebody else in here?" I said, "Yeah, they told me to. They would reimburse me up to $200." And one of the guys says, "Well, that's $200 just to go to the roof." Long story short, the only thing that was wrong with the air conditioning was the fan blade had come off the motor. And they went up and they put a whole new motor fan blade on for me. It cost me $120 in co-pays. Other than that, the rest of the claims have been fine. I have already recommended them to other people.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 2, 2017

    We were offered this company when we bought our house. Never, ever use them! They nickle-and-dime everything. Most of their repair companies are below average. We signed up for the first class service and additional refrigeration coverage. I have been dealing with repair/replacement of our wine fridge for over 9 months now. They initially did not have anyone to repair it. We eventually had a company we found repair it but still did not work. Despite over 5 hours on the phone with them, they were unwilling to pay for it to be replaced and offered me $150. You will spend hours on hold waiting to speak to a supervisor and have to repeat the events of the repair over and over as they apparently don't document previous conversations. In my mind, they will do everything they can not to replace, and do not provide a warranty. BEWARE!

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Jeffrey,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 2, 2017

    Disgusted and enraged are the only words that come to mind when I think of FAHW. I've had contractors in my home 6 times in 3 weeks and still no resolution. I originally contacted them on 4/11/17 regarding my freezer not defrosting. They sent a contractor out. He diagnosed what the problem was and set an appt. He came out and did the work but while doing so, something else died. Had to order more parts. Visit 3. Came back out to replace the next part Visit 4. Now every time the freezer goes into a defrost cycle EVERYTHING THAWS. Water is leaking all over my freezer, all the food is freezer burnt and ruined. Visit 5 he came to "look at the issue". I tried explaining that it only thaws when it goes into defrost. Since it was frozen while he was there he said nothing's wrong. Even though you can clearly see ice crystals and dripping water. I told him I had video and photos which he has no interest in seeing.

    Fast forward to today when the "second opinion" company comes out. First I had to contact them to set the appt because no one ever called me. The guys looked around and then handed me a clipboard. I had to ask, "So what's wrong?" He said, "Uh maybe this and maybe something else but I don't want to talk about it until I talk to someone else." "Excuse me? You don't want to talk to ME about what's wrong with MY appliance?" I asked when I should hear something He told me to call them in 3 days. WHY should I call you? Why am I the one setting the appts and doing all the leg work.

    Both contractors that they sent to my home have 1 star reviews on Yelp. One has over 60 NEGATIVE reviews. What am I paying your company for yearly First American? I could have taken that yearly premium and applied to the cost of a replacement refrigerator. Why am I now at 3 weeks with no properly working freezer with children in my home? Has anyone in your company ever been without a freezer for 3 weeks? Would your CEO go 3 weeks without one? Why is this okay? Why is this not a priority? I contacted your company today, spoke with a "manager" who then transferred me to his manager. Which was just a random voicemail service that you needed to know the voicemail box. Once again no resolution, no assistance. I can assure you I will not be renewing my policy next year and I will make sure all my friends currently purchasing homes know not to use your company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPrice

    Reviewed May 2, 2017

    First American compares really well against the company I had before so far. The one I had before, I didn't care for their services. When filing a claim, I call First American and they give me a number for me to call while the previous one did the arrangement themselves. But it's expensive because I'm living off a pension and when I call, it's a recording that starts talking to me, saying, "If this is what you're calling for, press this," and 90% of the time, it's not what I'm calling for. So, I have to wait until the end when it says, “Otherwise, wait or press 0.” But it's not just First American. It’s all the companies now. Also, when it says, "Go at a computer. Do this and do that", it irritates me because I'm not computer savvy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 2, 2017

    Getting a home warranty was a requirement and my realtor told me about First American when I purchased my home. Submitting claims has been fine which I can do either online or over the phone but I typically do over the phone. They have a good customer service and our interactions were fine. The process is easy and the technicians that I have had come to my home were very courteous. They explained some of the processes of what they were doing as they were doing it and their quality of work was fine. It's been a very good experience.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed May 2, 2017

    I was a first-time homebuyer and knew I could not afford any big pieces such as furnace and water heaters enough that I would need to have someone in order to help me do these things. The lady I bought the home from paid for a home warranty for me for a year but it got expensive, so I had to let them go. And at the times that I thought I needed them the most, they didn’t cover what I needed. My air conditioner went out and when I felt that they were to help me, they didn’t. So I was really in need of a home warranty then I heard about First American Home Warranty on the TV so I called them and asked a few questions.

    First, I filed a claim for the oven coil in my range that went out and I was satisfied. And then, my dryer stopped working this March. The starter/stop switch went out and I called them. The technician who they sent was polite and funny. He looked it over, ordered the piece, and put it in. So far, I'm satisfied with First American. Their claims process was easy. However, they had Sears for everything and they took so long. It took two weeks for the man to come back and fix the parts for my stove. But the one who fixed the dryer only took one week. He was right back like he said and took care of the issue. I would recommend First American and already have.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Coverage

    Reviewed May 1, 2017

    I called a week ago about my air conditioner. I had a problem with it last year as well, and they "fixed" it. The tech actually disconnected some safety wires. This year a different company came. He said there had been an electrical fire! Probs due to the lack of safety turn-off wiring? The new tech wanted to do the right thing and replace the ac unit. It is 24 years old and well past its life expectancy. They told him they want a second opinion. It has been a week... still no AC. Wondering why we pay for this insurance. It seems they want the cheapest way out and not concerned about doing it right. I am a doctor and I would not do that to my patients.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 1, 2017

    I’ve been a realtor for many years, and always used First American for the properties that I have listed. All of the representatives have been very helpful. The technicians are great too. First American has a good technician base, although we have some companies that we’ve blackballed from working with our company and when I’ve asked First American to reassign, they do it right away. And if there’s any recalls, the techs go back out. So everything is good. First American has been professional and easy to work with.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed May 1, 2017

    When we first bought our house, First American came with it and it was prepaid for a year. We didn’t want to renew the contract afterward but we had a lot of problems with the house during that year so I called them to get a new contract. I researched a couple of other home buyer protection warranties and they all seemed to be within the same price range. But we decided to go with First American because we have five sump pumps on our property that flood quite a bit and First American had the option of covering them which was pretty important.

    Filing a claim with them goes really well mainly because it’s online. We’re able to list our problem relatively easily and they’re able to understand what the issue is. However, on the first year that we had the contract, we had an electrician come and look an outlet that wasn't working in our bedroom and he said that he can’t fix it because it was in the walls. I hadn’t researched the contract well enough to know what was and wasn’t covered. It was annoying in that sense.

    In the washroom where you’ve got the drain that leads to the main sewer line, we found out that the previous owners drilled holes into that pipe so the outside groundwater got into that pipe and drained out to the city main, which was stupid because when it rained a lot, it backed up into our house. We filed a claim for that and the plumber said that it was underneath the concrete so he can’t fix it. That was another thing that wasn’t in the contract. You have to read the fine print and not assume that it will automatically be fixed. I also know that some people have had issues with the contractors that First American sent them. But other than those, I've had good overall experiences with First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoveragePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 1, 2017

    The claims process of First American was really easy other than writing the checks. I called the number on the contract that we had and they brought to my attention that I can create an account. They sent me an email with the link so I got that setup. It makes it a lot easier to communicate that way. The responses are very prompt and dealing with their people has been fine. They are very cordial and very understanding.

    I got the warranty policy from closing upon purchase of the new house from the previous owner and the problem I have with the claim is the person who purchased the warranty because it didn't cover what I wanted it to cover. If I did it myself, I would have spent the money and got a better warranty than the basic. I should have checked but I didn't. So I have to outlay a lot of money to repair our air conditioner right now. It's a little disappointing. And it's taking a little while to work some of the things out on this air conditioner claim that we have going. They came out twice for the diagnostics and found different issues both times. As it turns out, they were both related. The air handler had to be replaced but they didn't know that the first time. But First American has been great all along. I also get prompt follow-up calls from them. Even the air conditioning company that they have associated with have reps who are really responsive and nice.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 30, 2017

    When I purchased my house about ten years ago, there was a First American warranty on the property. I then just renewed it and after 11 years, I'm still with them. It's very easy filing a claim. I make the call and they schedule a contractor to come out to the house. That contractor calls me, schedules the time, and come out to do the repairs. It's pretty much cut and dried and that's why I'm still with them. The deductible is very reasonable although it went up by $5. I was paying $60 when I first started and now, it's $65. Otherwise, the work of their contractors have been very good and I've never had a problem with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 30, 2017

    I had a compressor that I had to put on the air conditioning about a month ago. The first guy sent by First American didn't do what he was supposed to do. Two days later, the air compressor went out on my a/c. They sent the supervisor over and confirmed it. They came back and fixed everything. I prefer them doing the work correctly once they send somebody that had a little bit more knowledge. But I'm not throwing the first guy they sent out there under the bus. I'm an old gentleman and I understand him. He was just trying not to mess up but he needed more experience. Other than that, from a scale of 1 to 10, I'm extremely satisfied. I filed about four claims since our home is an older model. They come in and I pay my deductibles then they do what they need to do. I'd recommend them to others.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2017

    I was up in my age and live by myself. I couldn't afford stuff and thought First American was a good insurance. I have submitted about three claims and one of them was with my furnace. They send someone at least four days after I call. One of the contractors was nice and let me know when he's coming out. And as long as someone comes, I'm okay. First American is good and their service is worth it. But if something’s wrong, they don't come out right away. And they don't even call. They should have somebody ready to come out in a case of emergency.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2017

    I have had to spend hours upon hours on the phone with this company to have 3 issues repaired. I have yet to have our final issue resolved and have contacted the Dept of Insurance for help. This company does everything it can, including verbally mislead, in order to avoid having to pay for repairs. Their contractors are terrible because they get paid so little by FA. Please avoid this company at all costs!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2017

    We have an app on the phone and we just choose what the problem is, type in what’s wrong, hit send and submit a claim then First American would have a contractor go out to our home. Their quality of work isn’t like the American Home Shield. One of them was great and the other was one not so much. Our air conditioner was not working so the contractor came out and said that it was probably the thermostat.

    The contractor had a used thermostat in the truck so he put it then the air conditioner came on, which meant it was the thermostat. He said he usually carries thermostats with him but he just leaves the old one there and it would fix it. I was like, “No. It’s supposed to replace what’s on the wall.” So he took the old thermostat with him and he said he’d order me a new one. And then when he did that, he replaced it with a cheaper and basic thermostat that goes up and down. Whatever we set it, that’s what the air is. I had a seven-day programmable where we could program it different times a day and he didn’t replace it with that. It didn’t make me happy but he was ugly and so that’s what we got. I would never use that contractor. But overall, First American's good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 29, 2017

    We had a house and I figured that getting a home warranty would be the best thing to do. I did some research online and found out First American was one of the best ones to go with. I also heard about them from my mother-in-law. Submitting a claim with them online was very easy because everything was self-explanatory on how to do everything. Also, everyone was pleasant and nice. The people shopping around to find a home warranty are wasting their time on shopping around. They just need to go with First American. They're awesome.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 28, 2017

    I was allowed to choose the home warranty company when I purchased my home July 2016. My realtor recommended First American so chose them. This was the worst decision I could have made. Not only did they initially take 1 month to process the payment for the warranty, they gave me the run around about it. The title agency sent them the check, not me, and the title agency could tell they had cashed the check.

    The first claim with them was regarding the a/c about a month after we moved in. The assigned contractor never called so I called over the course of several days trying to reach them. No response. First American finally changed the contractor 8 days after the initial service request. They could not reach the first contractor either. The second contractor fixed the a/c no problem. We had no further claims until April 2017 when the drain tiles needed cleaned out. I filed a claim and tried for two weeks to reach the assigned plumber. Finally I could no longer wait so I cancelled the claim and First American said, "We will note that your oven was fixed" in their reply. This goes to show how horrible their customer service really is. The claim was under the "plumbing" category.

    End of April now and the a/c is not working again, so I filed a claim. I was assigned the original a/c contractor who never responded. I demanded that First American change the contractor because I do not want to wait another week until there is no response. They refused saying he is the preferred contractor. WHAT A JOKE! Steer clear of this company. They are designed to keep you renewing your warranty for years and years, they don't hire reputable contractors, they hire random guys that will do the work for the cheapest price. Flaky contractors that cannot even call on an assigned job. Customer service with these people is horrible too. Choose another company. I have colleagues at work that have had no issues with their home warranty company, of course they do not have First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 28, 2017

    I've had First American for a number of years. They have a good company that quickly fixes our air conditioning. But I have a current claim which is for a dishwasher repair and it's been going on for about two months. We're waiting for the parts to arrive for about a month each and there are two parts. We're living without a dishwasher for two months which is horrible. I called First American and they said the contractor has to wait for the part until it comes in. I told them I can go across the street and get the part for them if they want me to. The parts are readily available but they told me we have to wait. It's the worst experience I've ever had. They don't know how to talk to people. They are very bad. And they’re very short with me. They say, “This is the way we do it. You take this deal or you don’t, you tell me. I offer you Thursday. That's it." It's like they are doing me a favor or they work for free.

    I don't want to argue too much because I need my dishwasher to be fixed. Today, the technician came out and he found a new problem. I asked if it's going to be another two months for the part and he said, "No. I don't know how they do it in the office. But they get parts twice a week. I don't know how long it's gonna be." I should ask them to give me a payout for the dishwasher and go buy a new one.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 27, 2017

    This is so frustrating. Why would someone pay a premium and buy a home warranty when there is no responsibility and urgency from the service provider. I am waiting on a refrigerator repair service for last 2 days. I didn't get any call from the service provider or the assigned contractor till now. I would rather call some independent contractor with good rating on Yelp and they can come over same day in few hours. Here I am paying a premium plus service fee for each visit. I can just pay one time service fee to those independent contractor and get things done quicker. FAHW also increased the premium and each service fee drastically for the 2nd year. I am not going to renew for 2nd year.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 27, 2017

    When we purchased our home, the previous homeowner had the service. When he sold us the house, he bought us one year. He took care of all the appointments and everything. After the year was up, I received the letter from First American Home Warranty and we renewed it from there. It was a good price and we added in appliances too that fit into our budget. We already purchased appliance insurance like the dryer all that other stuff and we added up all of those. It would have cost more than what we were gonna pay for everything, including what they would cover with the plumbing and the electrical. It was a way better value than individually having one for your washing machine, dryer and refrigerator.

    The first time I submitted a claim, I called. But I also had gone online at the same time to see which one would go faster. I tracked the whole process and they were helpful about getting somebody out in time and getting it fixed. They had somebody out the next day. It was for our washing machine. My insurance on that washer was only for one year. It came in handy and perfect, and played out good. There was a copay, but so as my other insurance too. The contractor assessed the problem when he came. He had to order an actual part for that and he came back in a couple of days and fixed it. The washing machine is working fine.

    Recently, our hot water tank blew up. I did the claim online and then I called them. They have somebody out the very next morning. We are trying to get them out that night, but it was already six or seven o'clock at night by the time I got home. They got here and had it replaced the next day. It was the original heater with the house. It was old but they didn't question the age of the water heater, which was like, "Okay, cool." I didn't have to pay for repairs. My son helped out because he was there, but we had to put a piece of wood down. It was in my garage and it was sitting on a drywall. So, the water was everywhere. They don't cover that, but I was able to fix all that myself. I got a water pan and drip system going out if it ever happens again. I am happy that I bought the insurance, because I saved money in the long run. It's a very excellent job. So far, so good.. My supervisor actually signed up with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 26, 2017

    I purchased the one year home warranty through First American Home Warranty Company, but that was the worst choice ever. The water heater in my home broke down and I contacted them. It was a Saturday so they gave me the contact information of another scammer "contractor" that is J and S Mechanical. I called the contractor and they never responded. I sent them email, and called them and left multiple voicemails. No one ever called me back.

    On Monday, I received a call from the contractor saying that they were going to come to fix the issue, but the soonest they could come was on Tuesday. I told them that I had two small children and I was already out of water for a few days. They were like, "We are too busy, so you either tell me yes now or goodbye." I was like, "Wow!!! Really???"

    On Tuesday, the contractor showed up with no call in advance (although I called both the contractor, and the warranty company three times to give me an ETA), and told my wife that they needed to replace the water heater, but they had to "send a report to the warranty company before they can do that." That means they did nothing but just left a $75 invoice that I needed to pay.

    Tuesday passed and no one called from the warranty company or the contractor. I called the home warranty company, but I was told that I had to come up $725 out of pocket in addition to the $75 for the contractor trip charge in order for them to replace my water heater. I had to either pay $800 or accept their cash offer. The call dropped multiple times after putting me on hold and I had to call again and again and go through their stinking "verification process." It is Wednesday and I am still having no hot water to at least give shower to my two years old and five years old children.

    Finally, I called the home warranty company again and they offered me $420.77 cash for the issue so I can fix it myself. Please note the following ridiculous numbers: First American Home Warranty offered reimbursing me $135 for the Installation Cost when in fact their contractor asked me to pay $725 out of pocket for installing the unit plus the $75 trip charge. And by the way, $800 was only my cost, and that they may bill the home warranty company too.

    Also, they offered $345.7 for the water heater. I think that they meant to give me the price of a used or maybe broken water heater. I looked online and I couldn't find any gas water heater of similar model for less than $400. In sum, this company will try to rip customers off in one way or another. It's been almost a week I am out of hot water, and I still stand right in the same place that I was without a warranty, much less to say that I lost hours being on hold on the phone.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 26, 2017

    I purchased First American Home Warranty before the start of summer (February) and the salesman for company made me buy extra coverage at premium level to cover for any pre-existing issues. At the beginning of summer (April), I started having HVAC issues. The contractor discovered issues with the HVAC coils that need to be replaced. The company refused to service and denied any claims despite having paid for the extra coverage. I believe this company exists to swindle customers and any claims greater than a minor repair, which are not profitable for the company after the $75 deductible, are denied based on pre-existing conditions. This is a fraud.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 26, 2017

    Submitting a claim with First American has usually been easy. They're on top of it and are efficient. The technician who came out to my home was respectful and he explained everything thoroughly. However, we were expecting First American to pay the whole bill, but they only paid half. Also, the last time we used them, they only paid $1000, but the bill was $4000, so I had to take out a loan.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 26, 2017

    A friend of mine had First American for a very long time. They’ve done good service with him. He’s only had a couple of instances that he had a problem where he had to wait too long for something to get fixed so I figured I would try First American first. Submitting a claim has been easy, but the people that they choose to use sometimes are not the most efficient.

    The last technician that came out to do my air conditioning unit was very thorough. He knew what he was doing, but it took them longer than expected to get here, and also in fixing the problem. He’s supposed to be here today to fix my washer. I called them three days ago, and he told me he had to order the part. I decided to go upon myself and called the guy I used to use all the time. He said he can get it for me today and he can be here this morning.

    So the difference between services is slightly ridiculous but that bothers me. The cost difference doesn’t bother me too much because it costs me $65 for First American but then I pay $50 a month for it, and if I’m only gonna spend $190 anyway, which is what it would cost me to fix my washer today with my guy, I wouldn’t even have to have a home warranty. I could have had it done that day instead of now it’s three days later and my guy would hopefully be here before 5:00. My guy can give me a time to be there and that seems to be my biggest problem with First American because I can’t take off work and give them a four-hour block of time that I can be at home.

    They’ve been very nice speaking to me and professional. But the people that First American have chosen to be their contractors to get the job done have been slow. If they would allow the customers to find the vendors, it would probably be even better or at least for me. I have a bunch of people I used to use for all these things. Just like with the air conditioning company, I called to see how long it would take for them to get out here and they could have taken care of it in two days and it took a week and a half for First American's contractor to do it completely. They had to come back out and charge the system on a different day because they didn’t have the right stuff, and the same thing happened with the washing machine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Scott,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 25, 2017

    When I've had to file a claim to First American, I called them, put in payment, and told them what's wrong. Most of the techs they've sent were nice. But the bug people never showed up and we ended up having to switch companies. Other than that, everything else has been fine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 25, 2017

    I've always been satisfied with First American. I call in when submitting a claim, then they call somebody and then they contact me. Usually, somebody comes over within four days. Also, my interactions with their reps have been great and I have recommended First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2017

    When we bought our home, we were told to get a home warranty and First American was recommended. We’ve once filed a claim over the phone and it was trouble-free. Everything was handled professionally and courteously. The claims representative was fantastic. She directed me as to what to do and it was handled exactly the way she said it would be. Everything worked out fine for us. The technician was exceptional. He came out twice - once to diagnose and once to repair. He was very knowledgeable and willing to speak on the issues, so I couldn't have asked for more. Topnotch quality as well so I'm very happy with the service and I would be quick to recommend it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    TechPrice

    Reviewed April 23, 2017

    I live in Houston Texas and this is the worst company I have ever dealt with. They send unlicensed locksmith to my home. They charge a 65 co-pay but don't do the work. The contractors just leave. I'm going to sue First American Home Warranty for breach of contract. The plumber found a tiny leak, which he would not repair and said it was responsible for a 13,000 gallon water in one day. Turns out the water meter transmitter was bad. The appliance repairer would not fix the shaky washing machine suspension. The locksmith they sent to my home was not licensed. FAHW has been a disaster from day one.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 23, 2017

    Their contractors are rude. And then use excuses to get insurance out of having to do work. Their plumber says I had mold and could not work. I asked for 2nd opinion plumber, they refused. So got 2 other plumbers out of network. How funny that they say not a problem. Willing to fix leak. Not enough mold if any to be a problem. Both are 5* plumbing companies, say this. This insurance makes no sense. Not to fix leak first. Then if mold really found to take care of it. Sounds more sensible to me.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Conception,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 23, 2017

    I've been with First American for four years. The first year was an auto renewal thing. And then, I've used them and for the most part, I'm satisfied. I submit claims online. And then, I wait for the contractor to contact me. If not, I'll reach out and see if I can get in touch with them and get things moving. The contractors have been very responsive. The people at First American are very accommodating when I call. They've sent out two guys for the most part. Because they are all warranty company and I call in a lot of contractors in my profession. However, I had a couple of problems where I've had issues getting reimbursed. But in the end, they worked it out. It just took a little effort to get to that point. I have recommended them to my father-in-law.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed April 22, 2017

    I had my home warranty with First American. In the beginning because there were no issues with my home everything was good. Once I had to file a claim it all went downhill from there. My heat pump system fan went out. They sent a contractor out to fix it. It took 3 visits due to misdiagnosis to get it back working. I call FAH to ask can they just send another contractor out because clearly these guys are guessing at the problem. No even though they had multiple complaints on this company.

    Fast forward a month... the same issue. The fan is not moving on the heat pump. Instead of them sending another contractor which they call a re-call they wanted me to pay another fee. It's the same issue. I can see if it was another part on the heating/cooling system but it was the same issue. I just feel like that is ridiculous. Then they hit me with this horrible example. "Well if we send a contractor out because you said your refrigerator wasn't cooling then call back and say your refrigerator was leaking, it's the same thing. We would have to charge you again." Well Ma'am that's understandable because that's 2 different issues. This is the same one. It's like they're reading a script and all she kept saying was, "Yes Ma'am. I'm sorry to hear that. We'll do something about it." I just could not wrap my brain around why I have to pay another service fee when it's the same issue. I dropped them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns with you.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed April 22, 2017

    It was easy submitting a claim with First American and I had a very good interaction with the claims rep. When our AC unit went out the day after I bought the house, First American sent out a company that said that the AC unit needed a part and the repair would take two weeks. First American ended up firing that company and getting another one out right away to be able to fix our AC unit. The only issue I had so far was that they covered guaranteed work for 30 days and my AC went out again 35 days after, so that was 5 days beyond the coverage period. But the report that the company sent in to them actually shortened it by another day. The company had to go back out to my house to correct the problem, and they reported it as being fixed the day before. So, I had to pay another deductible, and it was after their stated 30-day time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2017

    My daughter and son-in-law have First American. They had a couple of experiences and were positive on their plumbing. You never know what's gonna happen so I decided to get it, too. I submit claims over the phone and it's been good. Their claims representatives have all been good. One time, I didn't route the pre-recorded thing when I wanted to change plumbers. I hit zero which gave me an operator and that guy was receptive to what I wanted. He listened to me and followed up with it.

    But submitting claims has been a little time-consuming. I've had two claims - one for air-conditioning and one for the lines going into my hot water heater. The first time on my air-conditioning, the guy came out back in September. It needed freon in my upstairs unit. The guy was a fast talker and all he wanted to do was sell me a whole new unit. He didn't want to add freon or try to repair anything so I paid him $65 for absolutely nothing. The next time, I waited a few months and had a different company that came out called All-Star Heat & Air. They fixed it and they didn't talk me into it, but I knew I needed service for my unit yearly so I signed up for a yearly service and they gave me a pretty good deal on that. I really like these people and I'm glad I ran into them. I'm sure I'll use them in the future.

    With my hot water heater most recently, I had a pinhole in some lines going to the valve going through the heater. The people First American first tried to send out never called me. Also, I've not heard anything good about them in the community. I finally called them and it took about three days to ever get a response. It was a little too time-consuming to get that ball rolling. Then Above & Beyond Plumbing came out. The guy, Tim, called up and his guys came out when they said they would. That's all been positive. Everything's been good and the technicians have been wonderful for both my claims. It's been a worthwhile experience and I would do it again and I'll renew it this year. I would recommend the warranty to anybody because it's the peace of mind, if not anything else, and it's been a good value.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2017

    When we bought a house, my wife looked through a few pamphlets that we had and then we went with First American for our home warranty. Everything went well when we had set up a claim. Also, the technician that we had was very professional.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechSales & MarketingPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 20, 2017

    Bought Home Warranty with purchase of home. Contract# **. Tried to use the warranty 3 separate times. First time, called for repair of pool gear, the cost to have someone come look at it was same to have it repaired by existing pool guy. Canceled that request. The second claim was for some electrical work, they assigned a contractor who never called. I called them 2 other times and still no one ever called me. I called back and they said, "Oh we're so sorry this claim was canceled," so after 3 weeks and no contact they cancelled my claim because they said it was not covered but no one called to inform me. Had to pay out of pocket.

    Third claim, our hot water heater went out on the weekend, called and they said, "We will have a contractor call you by Monday or Tuesday." For my family's sake I called contractor they assigned myself on Monday and he came out Monday afternoon, said, "Oh I'll have this fixed no prob." After collecting the $65 service fee and spending most of his time on his cell, he said he could not fix and would have to call the manufacturer for warranty info the next day (There was no way anything was under warranty. It was old). The next day nothing. I call him, he says he got a part and this would fix it. Came over, cut the drain pan under the water heater ($20 at Home Depot) to be able to get the old part out destroying the pan. The part did not work.

    Then he informed me he may need to add a drip leg which is about $5 in pipe pieces from Home Depot. He would have to charge me $270 to install and it would not be covered under the warranty. Said he needed to call the manufacturer again but they were closed for the day so he would call the next day. Next day returns late in the day with another part still not working. Left promising to come back next day. I said OK. After 5 days with no hot water, I went outside the warranty and within 3 hours had it fixed and an hour later HOT WATER!

    I called customer service although these processes who were not helpful at all and came to the realization that I needed to cancel the contract. After weeks of waiting and calling. They agreed to refund me $344.20. I had originally paid $535 and then another $65 to the UN-service guy. So total paid $600. They said even though they never provided me ANY services they could only refund me when I called to cancel no back any further. Even asked to just refund from the time I first tried to get service. They said no. And then said they had to also charge an additional $50 admin fee for cancelling. THIS COMPANY IS A SCAM AND HORRIBLE TO DO BUSINESS WITH. I am going to let all the realtors in my network know as well as escrow offices. Do not use. It is a scam.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 20, 2017

    I just closed on a condo last week, and lo and behold, the water heater is acting up. Called FAHW and submitted a claim. The rep assigned a plumber to the job. Two days pass. Plumber did not contact me at all. Called FAHW again; after 40 minutes on hold - first with Service, and then with Claims ("Disputes," I think it was), I was told that plumber was "inactive." Great. Only been two days. Then after holding for another half hour, total, was told that they couldn't find another plumber. I cancelled the whole request and have just called a REPUTABLE plumbing company to do the work. I'll have to pay out of pocket. This is "coverage"?

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Coverage

    Reviewed April 20, 2017

    I called for pest control, due to bees. Flying insects are not covered. I called for a backyard drain problem. Outside the house is not covered. I called for a kitchen and bathroom drain problems. Two separate visits and two separate $75 fees. I am not seeing the value of a warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Buck,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 20, 2017

    I have First American Home Warranty for a house I'm renting out. I chose them for the price. I submit the claims and the claims rep was helpful. Then the contractors contact the renter to make the appointment. Overall, the experience is okay.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 19, 2017

    I have been a policyholder for several years, having paid premiums of $696 for 2016 and $708 for 2016. I recently made a claim for a broken temperature control switch on my washer. The claim was processed under my 2016 policy, as it occurred before the expiration date. When the assigned appliance contractor finally arrived, I paid his service fee of $65. I heard nothing for nearly two weeks. When I called, I was informed First American had concluded broken switch must have been caused by someone forcing it and, thus, not "normal wear and tear." Thus they said it is not covered. I believe every Real Estate Broker in the country should be aware how these people conduct business before they recommend this so-called "warranty" to anyone. I doubt whether this review will be posted, because it exposes what this coverage really is.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 19, 2017

    I've had a few home warranties through a competitor of theirs and received this through the purchase of my new home. I filed a claim for a leaking hot water heater, was given a contractor to replace it and scheduled a time to assess the problem very quickly. My contractor arrived and informed me of several other fees that were not covered under my warranty to modify my existing plumbing to use the water heater that they had to install. Those fees were more than a new water heater even cost. After calling First American to question the charges they stood by the contractor and also claimed it would be my responsibility to pay to have my own plumbing modified to use a water heater that I am not choosing.

    I've filed this exact claim with other home warranty providers in the past and happily paid my service call fee but was not charged any additional fees myself. My fault is not with the contractor for having those fees, because I am a business owner myself and understand the cost of doing business, but if I charged any fee whatsoever for warranty work I would be put out of business. Get your checkbook out of you use First American. I will never use their service again, will immediate be returning to my old home warranty, and will not only never refer this home warranty to anyone but will strongly discourage everyone from using their service as well as inform my realtor who suggested this provider to me to use one of their competitors.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 19, 2017

    My brother's a broker and he's worked with a few warranty companies. He then told me a couple of ones that seem to have a better setup and he told us to get First American Home Warranty. Submitting a claim to them is easy. I do it online and then I'd receive a call from the contractor the same day or the very next day, and it was quick. Their techs were very professional. They quickly knew what the issue was and got the work done. The quality of their repairs is as good as I can get. Lucky for me that the contractor worked really well with my schedule because I had to cancel twice for the work. The whole process has been super easy and fast. Everything is positive with First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 18, 2017

    I have had no problems the first 2 years. However, my 3rd contract has proven they have changes their service. My stove went out Jan 30. It is now April and it is not fixed. The customer service said they can take as long as they need to and can come out when they want to. I have had 6 technician visits, 6 missed days from work, and still no repair, and it keeps getting worse. This is a 3 year old stove! Time for a new company. I think I have done my due diligence as a customer, by waiting through 5 hour appointment times for a technician that is always late. The customer service is rude, and not helpful. They appear to be interested in the bottom dollar and not their customers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 18, 2017

    We had them send someone to fix our air conditioner. It was low on Freon. They filled it up. It still would not cool below 80 degrees. They came back, put more Freon in and said it was normal that it was that warm. I came to find out that leaking Freon is a problem and I was lied to and taken advantage of. I feel as if they need better contractors.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Brittny,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed April 18, 2017

    I have experienced the WORST customer service from the First American Home Warranty Company. I was lied to by multiple supervisors in the company, I was never once contacted back by any Manager even after leaving more than 5 voicemails (which is the only way to contact them apparently). I was given the runaround by every person that I spoke to and because of an error on the part of the company themselves I followed their instructions and then after I did they denied my claim based on the instructions that they gave me. I am now being forced to pay for a 1500 dollar repair on something that is covered under my warranty but was voided because of the action that I took based on what 2 different supervisors in the company informed me to do.

    I never once received a callback from any staff member including my specific Claim review specialist who was assigned to my case. I spent over 25 hours on the phone never being able to get a hold of any of the people who were supposed to help me. I would not only never recommend this company to anyone but I would highly advise anyone who was thinking of using this warranty company to run in the opposite direction. I am disgusted by how I have been treated and the amount of disrespect I have received.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 18, 2017

    The garage door wouldn't go and stay up. Something was going on with the sensor or the sensor itself. I reached out to First American and the claim representative was very good and polite. A technician called me, which I told them to give me an advance notice because I was at work, and they met me. They were very prompt and did the job that I needed done. I was pleased with it. The people were very pleasant and informative of their work and what needs to be done. If I ever decide to move to a different location, I would go back and get First American again versus the other ones I hear about. I would recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 17, 2017

    When attempting to use First American home warranty to troubleshoot and repair an air conditioning leak that was ruining a bedroom ceiling the claim was denied because of faulty installation. On review it was determined that I had indeed purchased the upgrade to the premier coverage that covers installation problems. So now most of if not all of the cost of the work was denied for "modifications". The technician was very good and I hope the problem is indeed fixed... but meanwhile I paid a $65 service call and a $764 bill for work done. The first attempt to use American Home warranty was for a water leak... The plumber told us all they will allow to be done is put a clamp on it and then due to the old condition of the pipes they more than likely will leak somewhere else. We had the whole house re-piped... $9000 plus a $65 service fee. So far not very happy with results.

    UPDATED ON 04/24/2017: First American Home Warranty responded to my original review with simply a message "All is well." Yes the unit was repaired at a cost of $800 to repair not replace the drip lines. Not to mention that they changed their original improperly installed verbiage which would have been covered to "modified" which is not covered (I think because it is a made up phrase that could actually mean the equipment is not exactly in the same spot or condition that the unit was turned on). Look at the multiple reviews on here and make up your own mind.

    Also they did not add to their response that they sent a letter saying the upper air conditioning is no longer covered until it is properly fixed and proof of which is presented to them. Retaliation for posting on here? They state that the unit was properly fixed even on here. Why no letter stating your upper air conditioning system is once again covered. Does anyone know if they are governed by the same state insurance board as say homeowners insurance??? Or are they governed by the Consumer Affairs type branch of state watchdogs or does it vary by state to state?

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 17, 2017

    We've had a couple of claims with First American for some small things and they have handled it very well. The first claim that we had was for our range. A couple of the burners quit working. I've tried submitting claims online and it's a little bit limited with the choices. We've got a slide-in stove and oven and they only had a free-standing and a built-in in their options. It would be nice if they give you a dropdown menu to pick from and work your way through them. So, I called it in and calling seems to work a little easier. Then, it takes three or four days for someone to come out.

    We also had a relay that went bad on our heating and air conditioning. It took seven days so it was kind of inconvenient especially when everything in the house is getting really humid and it took a week for it to dry out again. They call somebody off of your list of approved repair people, finally get it scheduled then it takes a few days. It also takes a couple of days for them to order the part. So, a couple of days here and there and you're up to a week. But it's gonna be the same no matter where you go and it's been not too bad.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 16, 2017

    I've been with First American for the last four years and have never complained about the home warranty. I didn't want to try something else. I've tried submitting a claim through phone and online. But my most preferred option is online. Though they're very responsive when I called them. The time that the technicians come out depends on the severity of the issue. If it is something which I cannot live without, I would prefer that somebody comes within 24 hours or as soon as possible. The last time when I had issues I could live without headache, so 48 hours was okay. And the claims rep that I talked to was good. But the service fee of $75 is too high.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 15, 2017

    We have submitted a couple of claims to First American and it's all been easy. They've got a website that's easy to use for submitting claims. However, the first person that they sent out wired the air conditioner with the thermostat wrong. So when summer came, it wouldn't do air conditioning. Other than that, everything else has been fine. Two other techs have also come out here for two different things. Although there was a language barrier with the first one and he stayed on the phone with somebody that was trying to walk him through it. But he's very friendly and professional. The other two that came out seemed to be a bit more knowledgeable about what they were doing and were very pleasant. They were very good and they just sent me a check back for the deductible and they were very easy to deal with. Overall, the process was very easy and the people were professional.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 14, 2017

    I put in a request for my air conditioning to be fixed. I was told that I would be contacted by their contractor. My dissatisfaction with their contractor aside, I called FAHW to ask what the next steps were for getting someone out to my property. The agent that I spoke with told me that she called the contractor. Was told that they would have to reschedule me. I found that unacceptable and asked her what the procedure is if I wanted a different contractor. She (without asking me) canceled the original service request and put another in. I then asked to speak to a supervisor. The agent advised that she could not transfer me and I would have to call back. When I questioned her, she became upset and told me that's all she could do for me.

    I called back and asked for a supervisor. This agent was surprisingly able to transfer me. The supervisor stated that the other agent I spoke with wrote in the notes that she was able to get ahold of anyone at the company and left them a message. That is completely different from what she told me. Unfortunately, I am still waiting for my A/C to be fixed, and I've lost faith in my home warranty company. Do not get a policy from this company. Go with any other company than this one.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Veronica,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs

    Reviewed April 14, 2017

    When attempting to repair a water line in our kitchen, instead of replacing the outdated galvanized pipe, the plumber simply put a pipe patch in place. Water leaked from different places and kept placing patches that didn't work. End result is black mold in the kitchen area. Now that mold has settled they finally replaced the line.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 14, 2017

    The First American warranty came with the house when we bought it. We kept it up and also upgraded this year. I call in if we have a claim, they'll ask what's wrong and we'll describe it. They will pull up a couple of places, get in contact with them and we'd go from there. A majority of the time, the technicians come out within two days. One time, the tech didn't call back but as soon as we called and let First American know, they instantly called someone else and got them out right away. Overall, they're good. We haven't met a person that we haven't been satisfied with.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Haniffa increased rating by 2 stars.
    Tech
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, Haniffa increased their star rating on May 18, 2017.

    Updated review: May 18, 2017

    Dishwasher was not working, technicians came several times, they could not fix.
    Last person recommended replacement but the company was telling me that we do not have a stop valve, water pressure was high and all sorts of things not to replace.
    I bought a new Dishwasher from Sears and replaced and the problem was solved.

    I complained to BBB and the company refunded me the entire cost of replacing the dishwasher.

    Original Review: April 13, 2017

    I have been with this company for over ten years. They repair small problems but when it came to replacing the dishwasher which their technician recommended they did not do it. They told me to install a stop valve. It already has a stop valve. Then they were asking me to get a report from an independent plumber that the water pressure is correct. This has been going on for over a week. Don't know what they will say after I get the report. I got fed up, bought a dishwasher from Sears and cancelled the warranty. They don't want to spend for replacement.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 13, 2017

    First American was in my house when I purchased it. The old owner gave me the option. I have called and filed claims online and both ways are easy. I had a service with the old contract for my pool and they did a good job. The quality of work done by the technicians was very thorough.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 12, 2017

    First American Home Warranty was already in the house that I bought and I like their service so I stayed with them. I've submitted a claim with them and I did it over the phone. The claims representative was quick and easy to deal with, and the contractors who were sent finished the work in the time they said. It was fine with them and I'm happy with First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 12, 2017

    Submitting a claim with First American was sometimes easy. But, it seems like whenever I call for air conditioning, it was always difficult. I've had First American for four years and one time they sent out a technician, who has always pushed the limit to call back and he'd say he'll come out but then he's not always on time. And he's like a smart aleck when he gets here. So I called and told the First American rep not to send him anymore. However, they said that I had to file a written claim and it somewhat upsets me. Another issue I had is that the costs keep going up. It started out at $50 then this year it became $75. I also didn't like all of the technology that you have to go through to speak to a live person. I'm old and I don't do well with these recorded things. Other than these circumstances, most of my experience with First American has been good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed April 11, 2017

    My first experience with this place was quite awful. I called them on Sunday April 9th and spoke with a customer service rep that was extremely hard to understand. When I called I explained that my sump pump line running out to the ditch in the front yard was leaking water and creating a sink hole in front of my house. The guy I spoke with said it was covered under the home warranty but the sink hole would not be covered and of course I said that's not an issue at all. So they call a company and we set up for them to come out on Tuesday. Guy shows up and I hand him a check for $65 dollars because that's what is required per my home warranty. He goes out and digs up more dirt around where the sink hole is and confirms that it is leaking. He calls First American Home Warranty and is told that because the line is outside my house that is not covered.

    So by this point I've now called off work to have this guy come out which cost me over $300 dollars on top of the $65 I just paid him all to be told its not covered. Now even though I was quite upset that 2 days prior I very clearly explained the situation and was told one thing and now being told another I decided to call to hopefully get whatever confusion cleared up. The first lady I spoke with was named Lilly and while she was not able to help much she did tell me that they would have another person come out for a second opinion and that I'd receive a phone call within 30 minutes or so and of course no one ever called. Later that afternoon I call back and spoke with a male this time. He was not professional whatsoever. He told me that I should of read my home warranty more closely and that there is nothing he can do to help me.

    So I then spoke with a supervisor who's name was Manni. I asked him if his employee told me it's covered why are they not honoring that and he just kept telling me that he don't know why I was ever told that but there is nothing they can do. After several minutes of going back and forth he says they will return the $65 dollars which I still don't believe that is enough. All because an employee of First American Home Warranty does not know his job well enough and gave me wrong information. It's now costing me over $300 dollars from missing work on top of now I have to pay this company another $350. I don't ever write reviews on places or badmouth a company because most of the time it is out of their hands but my issue is that they should at least honor what they told me and fix the line but instead told me sorry about your luck. Think twice before going with this company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 11, 2017

    I spoke with 4 different people after they sent thieves to my house to fix my air (they took all my parts and haven't returned) and now if I want someone else to come we don't have parts to know what to order. The warranty company didn't care. Everyone I spoke with made up a new lie. My poor children and I are roasting and I have a baby! They don't care. It's been a week so far and I'm still waiting to hear from someone. Do not use this company! I've never experienced such horrible service and they sent out the bottom feeders to repair your broken appliances or in my case air.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 11, 2017

    I will not be renewing my contract with FAHW in June. I have been sent to the claims department to no avail. Dealt with a very rude rep who would call Fridays at 4:00 Arizona time. Most of the reps barely speak English and have no idea what is going on with a service issue. I waited 2 months for a simple refrigerator issue to be fixed, an entire month for a panel on my dishwasher to be fixed, air conditioning fixes that were just a band aids. I have chosen to deal directly with the contractors and have come to find out FAHW holds up repair approval for weeks. Even the contractors are frustrated. Time to shop for new warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 10, 2017

    In November 2016 I attempted to contact a vendor to return to my site to finish the job he started. He refused. I contacted FAHW and they in turn contacted the vendor and he refused their request. I was told FAHW would try and find another vendor and I would be contacted. After 3 months I contacted FAHW once again. I then was contacted by a person named Melinda from Contractor Relations who informed me that since I did not contact the vendor within 30 days, I would have to open a new claim and pay a new service visit. I then called and spoke with a front line supervisor who said he understood and could see the notes in the file where I had followed their rules back in November. He would escalate my request to upper mgmt.

    One week later after not hearing from him or FAHW I called back and was told by a Customer Relations Supervisor he could not see any notes in my record that I called one week ago. Nor could he see any record of my calls back in November. I am up for renewal of my home warranty – you can count on the fact it won't be FAHW. They do not seem to keep good records of when customers call in and what is said. They only seem interested in getting that first check and do not follow through on any customer issues.

    My recommendations on anyone considering FAHW is to save your money and seek out a more reputable home warranty company. FAHW is one of the more cheaper companies, but as they say, "You get what you pay for". As for the vendors they have contracted for service, do it for the business because the higher grade companies do not need to.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechSales & Marketing

    Reviewed April 10, 2017

    First American Home Warranty is such a scam. They are truly a scam company. My husband and I do not recommend anyone to have this service. We have it and they did not service us the way they should. We call them regarding to our water heater issue. They sent out some unprofessional plumber guy who worked for Reilly plumbing Company to our house. The plumber called us and told us that he will be arrive from 10:00AM - 2PM however, he didn't show up to our house until 10:00PM (we had wasted our whole day waiting for this guy and frustrated of calling multiple time to the 1st American Home customer service). Not only that by the time he arrived, after diagnostic he told us that we needed to replace thermocouple and the funny thing was he didn't have any thermocouple part left in his car. He ran out of part and told us nothing he could do at the moment and left.

    Before he left he told us that he did not work on Sunday but will contact his company to see if they can sent someone to our house on the next day to replace the part for us. However we didn't hear anything back from him as well as the First American Home. We had to end up calling other private plumber to fixed for us and paid them $250 for urgent service since we have a newborn baby at home (need hot water badly). Not only that, now we received an invoice bill from 1st American Home for a charge of $65. I understand that we still have to pay $65/service if they found no problem occur however there was something wrong with my water heater and they didn't have part to fix it. I don't want to pay $65 for unfinishing job. That's a scam!!!

    First American Home Warranty is extremely scam and provide a extremely bad customer service. I don't think they even care what their customer review or talk about them!!! Again do not recommend to anyone and next time when I help my customer buy or sell the home. I myself would not recommend them to buy 1st American Home Warranty!

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being to address your concerns directly with you.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 10, 2017

    I went with First American after one of my friends told me to look into them. I've had some good and a couple of bad experiences with my claims. For the good ones, the people called me back right when they were supposed to and they came and solved the problem. The bad ones were when the technicians didn't fix the problem. First, one tech came out, didn't do anything but turn a little knob even though I told him the issue, and that didn’t sit well with me. The second one, somebody was sent for my water heater and then it took them three or four days to find somebody who could work on it. They sent a guy out who didn’t fully know about the brand of water heaters and the water heater is still not fixed. First American is easy to get ahold of but I don't like some of the people they send to me. Still, my interactions with them are usually good and I'm satisfied.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 10, 2017

    I submitted a claim with First American on a Thursday and I thought they were going to call back by Friday. But nobody called. I had to call them back on Monday because maybe they just don't work on the weekends. But the actual work was done, and it was really good. The guy showed up on time, and he was very nice. I was very happy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 10, 2017

    The service tech from First American came here to fix the dryer four times. The first time, the guy said he had to get a fuse for it. Then the second time he came back, put a fuse in and it was working fine. My aide went down and took the clothes that she had washed in the dryer. Then she said the dryer was not working right and the clothes were not dried. And then for the third time, the guy said that he brought another fuse with him. So he came out, looked at it and said I needed another kind of fuse 'cause something keeps blowing that fuse out. He came back out and put another fuse in. And then my aide put the clothes in the dryer and it's still not drying. We turned up the heat and put it on radiator and dried the clothes that way.

    The fourth time they sent out this guy, he took the bottom part loose and said he found what it was. So my aide rewashed the clothes she had in the dryer from before and put them in the dryer again. And then she said the man doesn't know what he's doing. I called the troubleshooter and he said he'll call back in about 10 minutes. When he did, the aide answered the phone and said they're getting us a new dryer.

    They have good service but it was hard to pinpoint what's wrong with the dryer and I'm getting tired waiting for it. It's been over a month now trying to fix the dryer and our clothes are not washed up. And then I heard some place that they give a voucher and I can go buy a dryer myself or they bring something else to my house. But I don't know about First American bringing it to my house. I don't want to receive refurbished because I'll have more problems than I had. I had a brand new refrigerator and something broke down in it after 10 years. So they came out here and gave me another refrigerator, but then I was having problems with it and have had to fix one time. There was no warranty on it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 9, 2017

    I bought several homes and on an older home, it makes sense to buy a home warranty. I had a problem with my hot water heater and I called in on a Friday night, filed the claim, and the contractors came out Monday morning and took care of the problem. They were very good and easy to work with. So far, the quality was so good and the repair worked. Plus, it was very easy to call and make the claim. All I needed was my account number and the response was very quick especially for a weekend and non-business hours for the contractor. I'm sure had the claim been an emergency, First American would have addressed it even faster.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 9, 2017

    Our air conditioner stopped working December 24, 2016. First American recommended a company that came out in January, 2017 & replaced our compressor. Air conditioner still didn't work & the repair company couldn't figure out why & never showed up again. First American sent another company out... Expert AC Repair came out & replaced our thermostat. Air still didn't work, so they said we need a new coil. This is after countless days of taken off from work to meet them at our house... they never showed up when they said they would.

    Expert AC has an F rating on BBB (First American is well aware of their rating, but continues to send them to clients' homes). When they do show up, they say it's too late in the day to start such a big job. First American offers no resolution. They say "we cannot switch repair companies, because Expert AC has our parts & they won't pay another company for additional parts." Well, here we are in April in Mississippi in 85+ heat with no air conditioning. April 8th, 2017... still no air & Expert AC's voicemail is full which makes it impossible for us to get in touch with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 9, 2017

    It was a good idea to get a home warranty because it fills a spot of protection for consumers and sales people alike. I appreciated Chase, First American's representative. He was quick with answering the phone. I'm sure that everybody there is as good, but I feel a relationship with Chase. I don't see a point in making any changes unless there's something horrible that happens and the client doesn't get their satisfaction. Because it's my personal policy, I have a better feeling of being able to recommend him to my clients.

    My recent claim was on the electricity. I had some electrical outlets throughout the house that was not working and I was having some flickering in my lights. It's an old home. It's a 1927 little bungalow and I'm not sure that all the wiring has been replaced. And of an overabundance of caution, to make sure that it is okay, so I didn't worry about an electrical fire. The people that were sent out were the people that we have used just like for home inspections when we're getting properties ready to sell. He was prompt, courteous and took care of the situation quickly. He explained what he’s doing for me. Everything has been done quickly and handled courteously and satisfactorily. We recommend them

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 9, 2017

    I like the $65 co-pay in First American. I've used the service recently when I had a break in my water pipe in the ceiling and my garbage disposal which is the original, 26-year old, it rotted. I had to get a new one. The first guy that came to try to find the leak in the ceiling was very young. He was a short-term. And then the next guys that came to do the patching of the dry wall and the ceiling, did not bring any work equipment, drop cloth and a broom to seep up my floor. Luckily, I don't have a carpet and they made up a make-shift drop cloth out of cardboard that I had here. They didn't have all the equipment and the tools to clean. That also cost me two service calls.

    I'm a senior citizen and there are some things I can't be doing. They said, "We'll just pack it." I said, "Aren't you going to move the couch?" because I have an all-olive couch. And I said, "Aren't you going to either cover that up or move it?" They said, "Well, it's heavy." And I said, "Well, I'll help you. Well drag it here into the kitchen." I helped them move that, swinging around to the kitchen.

    I didn't know the warranties on these things. When I had the break in the water pipe which I've never had before because I'm the first owner of this house,they fixed the break. But what they don't tell customers is that they don't do any cosmetics, repairs afterwards. They are not responsible for mending the hole in the ceiling and painting the dry wall because I had acoustical ceilings. If you had a leak behind your toilet, they'll fix the leak but they're not responsible for any of the repairs to the wall. I understand that they're not responsible for second-hand damage. And I see and understand that now.

    I have the premier, top-of-the-line policy and I've got a lot of things covered in my two-storey house. I had to include a crane for anything that would be done on the roof in case I ever have air conditioner problems. I'm glad I have it because I'm a senior. I am a professional girl but I don't know how to do these plumbing and electrical repairs. So I'd have to have somebody come. I keep a very neat house which looks like a model home every day. I have no children, no husband, just me and my two cats. I take great pride in my home, I have to live here and I need to have things right.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 8, 2017

    We've been with First American for five years. It was recommended by my wife’s friend. The most recent claim we did was for our microwave. The process took a week which was reasonable. My wife would usually call the claims reps and she never had a problem getting a hold of them. Also, when technicians came to work on the A/C or deal with the problem with the water heater, they seemed competent and were professional. On the whole, it’s a good deal. First American has done everything we’ve asked them to do and would resolve the situation for us. We get our money’s worth out of it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & SpeedOnline & App

    Reviewed April 8, 2017

    First American Home was part of the deal with my realtor for the first year when I purchased my home. A month ago, I submitted a claim for my refrigerator online. Their website was pretty easy to navigate. Then it took a week and a half after I filed a claim before the technician came because my schedule wasn’t very good. They were ready to come out two days later, but I worked the next two days. Their technician was nice, friendly and professional. He showed what was wrong or what he felt was wrong and fixed it. The refrigerator has been working properly since. I haven’t noticed the same problem and I keep checking every time I think about it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPrice

    Reviewed April 8, 2017

    When I bought the house that I am currently living in, the sellers offered First American to me as part of the purchase negotiation. When submitting claims, I just typically call them and tell them what the issue is. Then they assign me a technician and give the name and phone number. Sometimes, they would send a little picture of what the person’s gonna look like, and then they will say that the person will call within one to two days. If it’s an emergency, they usually call right away.

    When we had a little leak in our bathroom sink, the plumber called us within a day and then came out. He wasn’t even there 30 minutes and fixed it. He was great. When my oven broke, I was fine with them replacing a part, but they couldn’t find the part for that particular model so they ended up giving me a new one. So, that’s pretty nice having something like that happen to you. And the work of every technician who's come to the house has been perfect. In fact, I even hired one of them to do work that was something else I wanted to have done. And he hardly charged me anything. It was really wonderful.

    The communication with First American is excellent. I’m really picky about things and I have never ever had a problem with this company or the quality of the people that they send out. I wish they would offer more services like an Angie’s List type of thing though. Angie’s List is there, but I gotta sign up and I still don’t know all these people. I wish First American would have a separate business that we could tap into where they vetted the technicians that they hire and have a list of people who are available to them under specific types of things. As a woman who owns a home, there are certain things that I can fix. But I get a little leery having men come out to my home. I'm not comfortable and I gotta be careful. But if it was a recommendation, I wouldn’t hesitate at all. It would be worth it for me because I would have a sense of security and safety. And also, I know that they would do a good job at a low cost as well.

    I have lived in a lot of places in the United States and Texas has got to be the worst place I've ever lived in in terms of the workmanship, the service, and the scams that go on here, especially in homeowners' shows. And so, it’s just a plethora of very bad things that go on. Now fortunately, it has not touched me. And I think a lot of it is because I do have this warranty. But my coworkers or friends that I have made since living here, the experiences that they’ve had in hiring subcontractors or third party to come in to work in their home has just been disastrous. It’s been plain fraud and horrid. So, that’s another reason why I really rely on the company to help me. I’m a big fan of First American and I’ve already recommended them a hundred times. They've been wonderful and I’m always gonna have them on any home I will have.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed April 7, 2017

    We had an expensive AC repair and we thought it would be wise if we have some coverage. First American was recommended by a co-worker. When we purchased our other house, it had a different home warranty company and we were not happy with them at all. First American is much better. Submitting a claim has been very easy for me. I don't do it online. I just call in, give them the identifying information they need for the home, explain what type of issue it is. And then, they automatically generate a claim and tell me who the contact will be and they just follow up with me. The Interactions have also been good. I don't have any complaints about it. Quality-wise, I’ve been satisfied. They have good coverage.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2017

    First American was provided the first year that we bought our house and we've had all over 3 years now. Submitting a claim was really easy and the people that I talked to were real informative and helpful. The technician who came out was very courteous. People at First American can get the job done and done right and are very dedicated.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed April 7, 2017

    First American was recommended to us when we got our mortgage and we've been with them for two years. We stayed with them because of their service and the price. When I submit a claim I just call the 800-number and the representatives are great. But when we've had the air-conditioner guy out, which we all have a contract with, he was horrible. He came twice and first time, just put some Freon in it, told us there was a leak but that First American won't let him do anything that he had to try to just fill it up. And then, he could come back if I called him again.

    So, a month later, I called him again and he came out and said that there was a leak and he was gonna order a part and fix it. Then he said his truck has broken down so he couldn't come. Then, his grandmother was sick and he couldn't come. And then, it was four different times he said he couldn't come and we never heard from him again.

    Then we had the exterminator and they were amazing and wonderful. He came out within 24 hours so that was great. And then, our air-conditioner just recently went out again. So, I called First American and told him that I didn't want to deal with that guy that came out last summer that did nothing and they let me do an outside contractor with no issues and paid in full.

    It was an easy process but it took a little bit of time, which, I understand there are some steps that has to be done for them to get that approved. But it would have been nice if they could've been faster because we were without air-conditioner for almost a week. If it was my stove, I could eat out every day and not be bothered. But trying to sleep in there when it's hot is not comfortable. But they've been great, so far. We haven't had any issues other than one and they took care of it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 6, 2017

    I had a warranty that I bought that previously been rated well. But, evidently, they did a considerable amount of change in everything they did and they charged me more money. They got a lot of basic things that I would expect to have done. And so, I had no use for a company that was doing shenanigans such as that. So I went online, did a comparison on different home warranty companies and got First American.

    I had to file a claim with a particular issue. I tried doing it on the phone because I wanted to verify coverage that wasn't explicit in the contract. But I could never get a hold of anybody so I went online. It was relatively easy to do it online and the guy that fixed my garage door was straightforward. He took a look at the product that just came apart and he was able to fix it. It couldn't be done in one stop because they don't have everything on the truck but that's the way it goes sometimes. It also took 36 hours for somebody to come out after I submitted the claim. But the quality of their work was excellent.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 6, 2017

    I was a new home buyer and thought it would be important to have a backup for when things went bad. I was referred to First American back then and I've been with them ever since. They came out in a timely manner and worked on the problem in a timely way as well. They replaced my refrigerator before Christmas. Before that, they came out and worked on my air conditioning, but it’s gone kaplunk again. However, this is the first time that I've had a problem with them so I’m totally flabbergasted.

    On the 28th of February, I made a claim for my stove. The young man came out, did a few things, and then abruptly left. And I asked him did I need to pay him right then. He said no. He had to order a part and he would bring it back the following Monday. This past Monday has been the fifth Monday that has passed. I've called the vendor over and over and left messages and messages because I've never been able to talk to anybody. And nobody has called me back.

    The only somebody that’s called me back has been a representative from First American and that’s been about three times. The first time, they couldn’t get in touch with the vendor. The second time, they said that the vendor said that he would be getting the part and would come out. That hasn’t happened. And again, I've talked to somebody and they said that they were waiting on a part. It’s been over a month. I need to cook. I’m disabled, myself and my brother. And I rely mainly on the oven to cook because I can't really stand and cook at the stovetop. I don’t understand why nobody is calling me back from the vendor, and why it’s taking them so long to get the part. And so, I don’t know what to do at this point. I still have not gotten my stove fixed or an offer to replace it. When I mentioned to the young man from First American why didn’t they just go on and give me another stove, he just rambled around and didn’t address it specifically.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2017

    The realtor recommended First American Home Warranty and we went with it. I have a couple of electrical problems and a dishwasher problem and they’ve been quick and great. They went out of their way to explain what was going on and why it was happening. They’ve done a fantastic job.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 5, 2017

    When I submitted a claim, I called and said my oven and electric outlets were not working. They said they’ll have someone call me and come out. They then came out and everything was great! They were knowledgeable and got both issues fixed. I paid the $60 and everybody’s happy. It went quick, easy, and fast. Everything works. They did their duty and it was a very good experience.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 5, 2017

    My realtor referred me to First American and my experience is good with them. I had really good interactions with the representatives. I've submitted a few claims and the process is very easy. The technicians who came out were real clean.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 5, 2017

    I've had First American for five years. The contract they use is much better than the other company I had before. There is no problem at all in submitting a claim, it’s very smooth, easy to work and efficient. The service contractors were great and quality-wise, they’re excellent. It was a superb experience.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed April 4, 2017

    Submitting a claim with First American is easy enough but sometimes, it takes too long. I don't want to wait 24 to 48 hours for someone to get me so I usually get the contractor's name and call them directly. The last time, I had come home from the hospital and I had a small grandchild and my daughter. I told them that I could have no heat with a small child and they were very good about getting out the next day. It was Friday mid-day and they had someone here Saturday morning.

    Then I had to replace a stove top which First American was willing to replace but what they sent me was sub-standard and I didn't like it. So I took the money and bought what I wanted. They gave me $400 and it cost me $1,000 to replace the stove top. Also, their price keeps going up every year and in eight years now, it's gone up $150. Other than that, they gave me a good service and I was happy with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 4, 2017

    I'm having an issue with the claim for my washing machine that I placed five weeks ago. It's still not fixed. The original people that First American assigned the claim to were coming and I called them back to say I'm not there at that day and time. Then they never called me back. So I called First American again and they assigned me to someone else. They came out on a Sunday, charged me an extra $50, but I thought I'm okay with that if it gets my washing machine fixed. However, they said they needed to order a motherboard. I had to call First American and First American called them. Then I called First American again and wait on hold while they call the vendor. It was back and forth to get them to turn in my form. Finally they turned in the right form.

    By next Wednesday, First American had placed the part, and according to them, it had been delivered to the vendor. But according to the vendor, they hadn’t seen it. On Thursday, the vendor still didn’t know where the part was at. First American gave them a tracking number but the vendor said they couldn’t find it. Friday came and they still couldn’t find it. The next week on Tuesday, I called again. The vendor said they still didn't have the part and I'm still going back and forth with First American and the vendor to follow up.

    Two days later the vendor still didn’t have the part and my washing machine was still not fixed. I called First American again. So it took four weeks, two weeks of the vendor saying they can't find the part, for First American to order the part again. So all last week, I'm waiting for the part again to be done. It's still not. I still haven’t gotten it. I called yesterday. I was on hold for 30 minutes and finally my phone went click because after 30 minutes of being on hold my phone goes "you're done."

    Two weeks ago, I was assigned a claims representative. I have yet to speak person to person to this person. She’s called and left a message twice and according to her voicemail she’s there until 5:00 o’clock Pacific time. So I'm calling at 2:30 in the afternoon Central Time and she’s not answering for two weeks. I'm going back and forth and this is ridiculous. And she was the second claims representative who was given to me because I never heard from the first person.

    This is the fifth week since I called First American. For a good three weeks before that, I didn’t have the $65 to pay for someone to come out and pay my part of the warranty. So for me, this is the second month now with no washing machine. I've been going to the Washateria and to neighbors' and relatives’ houses to wash my clothes. And I have two girls in my house. They are still being potty trained and still wetting the bed. I'm washing sheets in the bathtub in the middle of the night because I don’t have a washing machine.

    And this is the frustrating part. The vendor lost the part that First American ordered and First American was quick about it once, but I still don’t understand why I had to be the one to call back and forth to get the right form turned in and why I had to be the one to call and see if the part had been delivered. And if I had not called, First American would have never known that the vendor didn’t have the part or they lost it. First American never followed up with the vendor to see if they got the part. Nobody at First American is staying on top of the issue so I had to. So I'm the one having to do this back and forth over and over again and I'm wondering why am I paying First American a monthly fee when I'm doing all the work. It's ridiculous. For the amount of money just this year that I paid First American for the monthly fee plus the hundred dollars that I paid for them already, I could have bought a new washing machine.

    For the past 10 years, First American has been been absolutely wonderful. I've called at 2:00 o’clock in the morning on a Saturday. If I had a problem with the automated response, I'm able to get a hold of somebody and they assign the issue to somebody. And one time I had an issue with the diagnosis of somebody they sent out, they sent somebody else. This is the first time I've had an issue. When somebody says "we're gonna assign you a claims representative," I expect the claims representative to do something. Nevertheless, I would recommend First American to a friend. I always have recommended them to people. They’ve gotten First American and they said it's great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 4, 2017

    First American Home Warranty has better pricing so I chose them primarily for their cost. So far, I've only done one claim. Last month I had a question about my AC. It was just a simple phone call and they followed up with either a phone call or email. The claims reps were very knowledgeable and very professional. Then, the provider contacted me and scheduled an appointment. So, the tech went and flipped the switch on my breaker box and it worked. I've never had to use my breaker box for an AC. It’s normally them with electrical stuff. I just panicked when I turned on the AC and hours later it was still the same temperature in there. Everything was very smooth. The techs finished their job within their timeframe that they gave me

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 3, 2017

    Submitting a claim to First American is easy because I can just go online and type in what's the problem and then they just send us a claim. I like how they text me before they come. They also put the profile picture of the technician so I don't feel like other people are pretending to be them. The reps have been very helpful since they explained the policy and explained who is gonna come. The technician was also very good. He is knowledgeable, he knows what’s going on right away and he was able to fix the problem.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 3, 2017

    When I first got in my house, the lady that sold me the house kept First American going for another year. After that I took over. I have full coverage on all things in my house. Last month, I submitted a claim for my garage door. I called and they told me who would be coming and they'd be here but they couldn't put up a new door. They put some screws and it works good but he had me kind of skeptical when he said that he didn't know how long it would last. I know when something is wrong with one of my appliance and they couldn't fix it they'll just give me a new one and I need a new door for my garage. I was under the impression that it was covered.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 3, 2017

    The home warranty came with the house when we purchased it. I had good service from them and we’ve renewed four times. I've had very good interactions with the reps on the phone. They're helpful most of the time. The claims process is not difficult at all but First American has no real computer support, and so, we run into a problem with computer access. We can't get an update, we can't get it fixed and there's no web access any longer. They don't really care about it. I'd prefer to do the claims online, but I'll have to adjust.

    We had a problem with our switch sewage pump and they had to replace it. And at the same time, the washing machine was leaking. It still does but it hasn't been severe. They sent a couple of contractors that were displeased with their work, but they rectified it. Most of the service techs have told me "this will be covered by other insurances, but not by First American."

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 2, 2017

    American Home Shield kept going up with their rates every year, so it was time to switch out. And since First American offered the same thing as American Home Shield, I signed up with them. Whenever I submit a claim, I would just call First American, tell them the issue, and they will call somebody working in our area. And then, that contractor would call me, come out and I pay them the deductible and then it's fixed.

    Last time I submitted a claim for plumbing because my shower was leaking. But the people that they called out were unprofessional. My appointment was between 8:00 and 12:00, but they didn't come until 9:00 at night because they were so busy and backed up. The guy basically rushed in at the job because they had to go and do something else at McDonalds. So, my thing for my shower for the hot and cold was backwards and I had to fix it myself. I'm a retired military so common courtesy goes a long way. So, if I can't make it right now, then I'll call you and let you know, "Sir, I'm backed up on an emergency job." But they never kept in contact with me. I had to call them three or four times.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Gustavo,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 2, 2017

    I was with First American years ago when I had four houses then I quit with them. I went with Choice Home Warranty and they were horrible so I went back to First American Home Buyers because they did the job before. I normally do my claim online. I just plug into my computer and I submit my claim. But the claims that I had recently on this new contract, I did it over the phone. The claims representatives and technicians were friendly and professional but I called two times to get the diagnostics and the receipts sent to me regarding the washer/dryer in my house in Liberty Hill. They didn’t send me the receipts because I paid them over the phone and I called twice to get the diagnostic or what's the issue with the dryer sent as an email. But they went to the place on time and did take care of it, from this time, they were good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 2, 2017

    One of my best friends had First American and he was telling me about it. So I got it when I bought my house. I also had one for my son’s house. My last claim with them was about three weeks ago. It was about my air conditioning. The first guy they had sent was the same guy that they sent last year when I had a similar problem. He really wanted to replace the unit but I didn’t think it needed to. First American told him they needed a second opinion, so they sent out this other company which was excellent. Their guy fixed it. He replaced a couple of parts and put a new thermostat, and everything seems to be fine.

    Everything I’ve asked from First American, though it hasn’t been much, has always been handled well - fast and efficient. The only thing is I’d like some more English-speaking people. People who I don’t have to tell everything to twice. They’re very sweet people, but a lot of times they’re reading everything from script and I have to tell them two or three times why I'm calling. But outside of that, everything is fine. I have recommended three or four people who already had gotten through them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 1, 2017

    I've had First American Home Warranty for so many years and submitting a claim has been fine. I had an issue a couple of years ago and First American weren't able to help me. But on the most part, the technicians that came were respectful. I'm happy with my experience with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 1, 2017

    When I bought my house, I asked that the sellers buy a home warranty for me. My Realtor showed me different plans and told me this was the best one in his estimation. I took his advice. My contract originated when I bought the house in 2010. And I have renewed the contract every year and upgraded it. I've had new things on it that I wanted to cover. And for the most part, my experience with this company has been good. I've recommended them to a lot of people. My brother has been a Realtor for 25 years and has a lot of clients that recommended this company to him. Submitting a claim is an easy process as long as I can get it submitted over the phone. Sometimes, it's a little bit harder to get to the end of it. If they ever decided to strictly use a computer, I wouldn't be able to do it anymore, because I can't use a computer.

    I've had lots of claims. Generally, they are quick to respond. But I'm starting to have a little bit of trouble with getting things taken care of in a timely manner. I have a claim in right now and I'm having some problems. I have a second refrigerator that is covered. It is in my garage in South Texas and it's very hot down here. I called them a couple of weeks ago. I discovered that the refrigerator was not working. They sent someone out and he determined that. But he was unable to fix it and they would have to get someone who was more qualified with the problem. I had to wait for them to assign to someone else. In the beginning, I had better luck being able to request a certain contractor. But now, whoever is in line next, it's the one they call. They assigned it to Sears who always does a terrible job. I've never liked Sears. So, I'm unhappy about that.

    When they told me that Sears was going to come out to fix the problem that the first contractor couldn't fix, I said, "No, I don't want Sears." And then, they supposedly tried to find someone else but couldn't, which I don't believe. Sears came on Monday and as usual, the man was not very friendly and was not very good at answering my questions. Kind of just threw it back at my lap. It was like, "I think it's a problem with your electrical outlets. So, you will have to call the company." I called them back, told them what he had told me. They said they had not gotten a report back from the Sears technician yet. And so, here I sit. They have not called me. I have not heard from the electrician asking to schedule a time. The longer I go, the more mold there's going to be in that refrigerator. And I shouldn't have to be chasing them like this. But I'm going to keep calling. I'm really frustrated with them right now.

    I still will recommend them at this point. There had been hiccups here and there. But for the most part, they've been a good company. Some of the warranty companies are not very good at all, I hear people tell horror stories about what they've been through with the different companies. First American is a pretty good one. But it's getting harder to get the kind of service that I got when I started with them six years ago.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    First American Home Warranty Company Information

    Company Name:
    First American Home Warranty
    Year Founded:
    1984
    City:
    Santa Rosa
    State/Province:
    CA
    Website:
    homewarranty.firstam.com

    Media

    VIDEOS & IMAGES 
    Do you have questions about First American Home Warranty?