First American Home Warranty Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+2 more
About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 40 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.
Visit homewarranty.firstam.com- HVAC tuneup coverage available
- No age limit on appliances
- Discounts on related products and services
- Not available in all states
- Does not publish detailed pricing
First American Home Warranty Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (4,701)
- (1,120)
- (504)
- (326)
- (2,452)
Popular Mentions
- 4,977,043 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,977,043 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed April 1, 2017
Someone that had First American home warranty told me about it and how they saved a lot of money on repairs. And I thought it might be a good idea to have one. Submitting a claim has been a good experience. I call them and they tell me who's going to fix it. The contractor then calls me and set up an appointment. The reps have been very nice and the service techs have been very helpful. They told me what was wrong and fixed it. They also told me what to do when it happens again. However, I had a rep who didn't speak English very well and I couldn't understand him. I asked him to get somebody that spoke English and he hung up on me. Then recently, my water heater went out. I live in Fresco, California and they've got a company at Modesto, California so I had to wait until they came to Fresno which I thought was weird. But all in all, it's been a very good experience and I'm very happy with First American.
Reviewed March 31, 2017
I've had a couple of claims with First American so far. They have been prompt in getting a contractor assigned. Sometimes the appointments are a little far out, but they schedule it quickly. All the technicians that have come out here were really good. I’ve had one replacement and one repair.
Reviewed March 31, 2017
I had them come out and fix an oven which they did an excellent job on. But about four weeks ago, the person they sent to fix the shower broke it and I still haven’t got any response back from them. I called First American to let them know what happened through the automated system which is easy to use. I keep calling them and they say, “the person you need to talk to will call you when she has it resolved.”
The contractor who came out didn’t really understand the problem even though he called to ask and I explained it to him. He said, “Well, I need to see all the original parts for this to be able to know what’s wrong.” This house was built in 1994. I'm not so sure where, if there's any original. I told him, “You can tell it stripped.” He went and bought a part and came back and put it on so tight that it broke. You can turn it on only on super-hot and you can't turn it any other way. I have to either use the bathtub in this bathroom or go to my other bathroom and luckily, I have another shower.
Reviewed March 30, 2017
First American was provided for me when I bought my house. I called them when my air conditioner went out and they have someone come and look at it the next day and fixed them in 30 minutes. When dealing with the claims rep, we're supposed to be going in quick, answered the questions and things I supposed to know, but it took them step-by-step. Then the technician who came was great. He explained to my wife what he was gonna do and then explained back to her what was wrong after he looked at it. The quality of the work was great, though there were some people who came in and took their time to fix it or we got to wait the next day to get parts and fix it. But overall, they're great ingenious people to work with.
Reviewed March 30, 2017
WORST COMPANY AND SERVICE EVER. I was told at time of renewal the only thing that was not going to be covered would be Washer & Dryer. Fridge broke down and they do not want to cover it. After talking to about 10 people in over 2 hours yesterday, I was told a supervisor would call me back before end of day... It has been over 30 hours and nobody called so I called back. Talked to 2 more people and the supervisor straight said 'it was a mistake but we can't fix it, we can sell you coverage for $90 extra but it won't cover this existing issue'.
I was lied to at time of renewal and yesterday when supposedly someone would call me back. The manager agreed they talk and read all that stuff during the renewal call because it is a contract... yet they don't want to go by the contract. They are not willing to pull up the call and verify I was lied to. I don't know if they work by commission or not but lying seems to be the company culture. I am very upset that I was not even given an apology. GOING SOMEWHERE ELSE!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed March 30, 2017
I switched to First American after we purchased a new house because they had a more competitive pricing as far as how much we were gonna have to spend to get the same coverage. I don’t like to do stuff online too much, so I just call their 800 number and give them the appliance or whatever it is that’s broken when I submit a claim. And then they give me my claim number and who I need to speak with, or the company calls me about a day later to set up an appointment. Their claims reps have been fine but the only negative that I have is it’s a little bit cumbersome to reach them. I have to go through multiple automated steps that most of the time don’t even recognize what I'm saying. So, that part is a little frustrating. But after that, once I get to speak with the rep, they’re great.
It's also been pleasant with their technicians. Usually, they're very knowledgeable and fix the problem within a reasonable amount of time. I have had to call one person back for a microwave claim, but it wasn’t the technician’s fault. It was the microwave acting up. However, I have had two issues that were not covered. One was on the pool and the other was a plumbing issue.
Reviewed March 30, 2017
I asked a few people and they have First American and said they were okay. Also, their prices were less expensive than the other one that I had. I submit my claims on the phone. The process is sometimes good and sometimes not so easy and it's difficult to get to people. But their claim reps are okay and most of the technicians have been good. One thing I really hate about First American is I have to take up whoever comes up on the board. They send whoever comes up on the computer. I think it's unfortunate that I have to have somebody different and I can't have back somebody that I thought did a really good job.
But a few of their technicians have not been great and I will not let them back in my house which I tell First American. Even if something's on the verge of not working, if they can give it a band-aid fix, that's what they are required to do. There have been a few times that something broke again six weeks after and they give you 30 days. Two weeks after that, it broke again and I have to pay another $60 or $70 and the $65 service call. That really makes me mad. Then, I've also had an experience with a repairman for one of my toilets where he fixed the inside tank mechanism with something that was not metal. It was plastic and six weeks after, it broke. There's nothing that they did to stand behind that.
I told First American to not send the people that fixed it the first time. Another company came out and they were great. Their guy is the one that told me that that's what they do and he replaced it with what it should have been replaced with, which was metal and it lasted. That's another thing I really do not like about this company. All their people are allowed to buy whatever they feel will fix it and they can buy the cheap stuff, which I'm sure most of them do. My contract is coming up for renewal and I have been considering changing. I'm not totally satisfied but that doesn't mean that all of the other companies now are all the same. They're sometimes fine and sometimes, I get a really good technician.
Reviewed March 29, 2017
My husband and I had First American Home Buyer's home warranty - we would NOT recommend this company to anyone! They send out who they want to repair your issues - it's a small selected group of low rated nonprofessionals like Advanced Appliance Service of Winston Salem NC - they installed two outdoor faucets and within months they both leaked around the knobs! The cost of the faucets and labor was over $600 with us paying the $65 fee and when we called about them leaking we were told they only give a 30 day warranty! SO before letting any low rated unprofessional companies repair your issues make sure you're aware of their warranty policy! Most companies First American Home Buyer's home warranty company use only give a 30 DAY WARRANTY ON PARTS AND SERVICE!
We ask several times after being transferred countless times to so-called customer service reps if we could select a better company than Advanced Appliance Service of Winston Salem NC and was told no! But then offered by a so called customer service manager they could send a man whom we found out had been removed from the BBB for not having a LICENSE! The issues with this company goes on and on!
Reviewed March 29, 2017
I was having some issues with budgeting and a friend explained to me that a home warranty was the easiest way to be able to prepare budgets and that you could stay within its boundaries. I felt like that was good advice and got First American. I always call my claims in. The only issue that I have is sometimes I get put on hold for too long. But this last time, the hold time was just fine. Also, their reps are always very polite. I've had this service for at least five years and a few years ago, there was a period of time when I was feeling dissatisfied because of my interaction with their claims representatives. But for the past two to three years, they're very polite and professional.
I recently submitted a claim for our refrigerator freezer drawer that would not close properly. It was an easy process and it was a good experience. The refrigerator is still not really working properly. But I don't think it has anything to do with what the technician came out for that day. Their technicians don't always get everything fixed but when it's not fixed, they come right back. I get results when I need something fixed and that's what I'm after and I've always been satisfied with the result.
Reviewed March 29, 2017
I don't have a brand-new home and you get concerned about some of the things that could be expensive and having a home warranty makes things work out much better. I had a different company but they had increased their deductible. So, I was looking around for a comparable company and found First American. A little bit of internet research showed me they were a big company so I chose them.
In general, they're pretty good. I’ve had two claims where I didn’t have any trouble with. But this last time, they had picked somebody out of state though instead of locally here to fix my washing machine. It was completely a bad experience. After two weeks of waiting for them and not being able to get in touch with the company First American wanted me to use, I called back and said, "Look, all these phone number that you gave me are not valid anymore. They're not workable numbers. I'm concerned about that if I have a hard time finding them now, how am I going to find them if I'm not happy with them?" So, they said, "Well, you got to give them a chance." I said, "Well, can't you find somebody locally?" "Well, we can't now."
I understand all that. But it was not somebody I would have hired to come in and do the work. After three weeks of not having a clothes washer, I ended up pulling it apart, damaging the machine, putting it back together and it works and say, "Okay, they work so we don't have to fix it." And there you have it. So First American did what they're supposed to do but just a little concerning when a client tells them that they don't have a quality company. They tend to adhere to the rules and that's okay. Most cases might work out, but this particular case, it did not. That's not First American’s fault, that's the vendor's fault. But that's something that they should really pay attention to and not be using again.
First American is a first-class and professional company and they try hard to do what they can to satisfy the consumer and solve their problems. The only thing that I would do if I were them is to have listings of vendors in some of the smaller cities that might have local vendors instead of sourcing from a larger city that's far away.
Reviewed March 28, 2017
I have tried a different home warranty company at one point but was not too keen on them. I signed up with First American and I have always had good results with them. Submitting a claim has been pretty good, too. However, I used to be able to get them to come out the next day, but now they have a 48-hour timeline and sometimes, that's not very good. I had a water damage in a rental property and they waited 48 hours while in the meantime, I could be getting mold or anything. I didn't like that. I should have made it more urgent to them and maybe they would have taken it. But the technicians who they send have been pretty good, though I had one who didn't find anything wrong and told me that I wasn't gonna be charged. However, I found out that First American charges me whether or not he does anything. But even when I have problems with First American, I'd still I recommend them because I know I can always get my problems resolved.
Reviewed March 28, 2017
I've always been happy with First American. I've had my house since 2012 and it was offered to me as a home warranty. We get our money's worth every year. Any reasonably-priced home warranty on an older house is always going to be worth its money. If you don't have a home warranty, you're throwing money away. Because any minor repairs that you require in the course of the year are always going to be more than $60.
When submitting a claim, I find the online option faster and more user-friendly in terms of the speed and efficiency of the process. It's extremely straightforward. I go online and submit a claim. Usually, I've got somebody out to take care of it in 24 to 48 hours. And then, they bill me through First American or I write them a check at the time. I find the phone system to be a little dated. It even takes probably twice as long to place a claim that way. Quality-wise, short of replacing the systems that were in question, they've done everything they could. I've been very satisfied with both the level and breadth of service they provide. It's been a great experience and one that I can recommend.
Reviewed March 28, 2017
I was living by myself and being on a fixed income, a home warranty comes in handy. I heard about First American from a co-worker when I did construction. He had the service and told me when his microwave was broken, First American came out to fix it. First American was the first home warranty provider that I’ve checked out and I signed up with them. Their claims reps are fine and it's pretty much easy to submit a claim. The first claim that I did was for my garage door. One of my springs got broken and I had to cover that myself. They came out and then the garage door worked for a couple of days. Then the other spring had to be fixed. I went for months and months without calling back because I thought I had to pay. And then somebody told me that if it doesn’t work, they’ll come back out so I decided to call back. They worked on the garage door opener and said it couldn’t be fixed, it had to be replaced.
Then I put in a claim for my dryer and the technician came out. The guy was so polite and really intelligent. He worked on my dryer and explained everything. I couldn’t have asked for a better person to come to my house and take care of something. I was really pleased with that. And when the technician came out for the furnace, that was good, too. I had to go out without heat for that whole weekend because it was zero degree, but I managed. And I was glad to get that fixed. First American has been good.
Reviewed March 27, 2017
First American home warranty company is a company that does not care about their clients. Simply put they care about the first check that you sent to them to cover your appliances furnace and air conditioning after that they will not support their clients. What they will do is constantly send out technicians to attempt to repair your broken items. First technician will come out and repair the item. When you call First American back to tell them the item is not working they send out that same technician. When the same technician comes out for his second visit he called First American and says you can't find anything wrong with the item. First American then sends out a new technician and the new technician find something wrong replaces the part and when you find that part is still not working.
First American then calls another new technician. The new technician they send out find a new problem and he replaces a part. When the technician leaves that part is not working... First American then send out another technician. That technician finds another problem and either has to order a new part then comes back to replace the part, leaves and you find that the part is still not working!!! In the meantime you have lost well over 500.00 and food cost.
First American does not care. As a matter of fact one of the technician said there's nothing wrong with the refrigerator. So at this particular time we went out and we bought food the meat unknown to us froze then it defrosted then it re-froze. We took the meat out cooked it and became violently ill as a result. We noticed that the freezer portion of the refrigerator was not working again because our ice maker was dripping water...
Do not use this company. We do not want our refrigerator replaced. We simply want it repaired correctly and it has not been over at least seven attempts to fix it at least. The First American home warranty representatives are rude. They failed to support the client. They go only based on what the technicians tell them and each technician gets angry with the client when they have to return a second time. This company is a scam. You will not get any support nor will you get the help you need. I am not renewing my contract with this company and I'm going to alert all real estate agent that push this company when people buy new homes to not push them any longer. This is a horrible company. They are insensitive and they do not care about their clients.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed March 27, 2017
To begin, I filed my claim on 1/28/17 for my HVAC condenser unit on the roof to be repaired. Today is 3/26/17 and remains unresolved due to inaction, non-correspondence, and failure to uphold the terms of purchased warranty by First American. The first repair service sent out, Platinum Repair, diagnosed the issue as a blown fuse. They simply replaced it and charged me the $65 service fee. (This is not the first time the fuse has been replaced). Within an hour, the heating went out and I contacted First American to service again with concerns Platinum Repair misdiagnosed. Platinum Repair was sent out for the 2nd time, again I expressed my concern that replacing the fuse was not the underlying problem. They added additional refrigerant and replaced the fuse. Within 15 mins the heat stopped working yet again.
After expressing my frustration to First American and the month that had passed, they sent out a second contractor. No Sweat Heating and Air reviewed the unit for about 2 hours without fixing it. They determined that it had been incorrectly serviced and damaged beyond repair. (The unit is possibly 10 years old). After NSHA filed a report with their findings with First American, I was informed a new condensing unit had been ordered under warranty. I set up an appointment to install for the following Monday. The Saturday before, I received a mailed letter from First American stating that there was work not covered by the warranty. No call, no email, no message on the online center, but a letter that takes days to be delivered. I was one day away from installing a unit that I believed to be under warranty only to be told by a letter that it wasn't.
Was I going to be left responsible for the bill after the contractor installed it? At no point did First American notify me that I would be responsible for these costs. For the past 2 weeks I have been trying to contact ANYONE to understand what is under warranty and what I am responsible for. I have called (3) claim resolution specialists a day, asked to be connected to supervisors only to be dropped into voicemail boxes, never had any calls returned, and barely any response every couple days from the claim specialist assigned to my claim by email.
When you ask anyone for a contact to customer service or where to file a complaint, they can only provide a PO Box. I have managed to get one email out of speaking to 20 employees to send any complaints or resolution to. No one is held accountable and they truly do not care about the "customer". I have seen more responses from First American on this website than my own claim on their website. I truly believe this company is a scam and it is laughable to suggest that this could be recommended to anyone.
Reviewed March 27, 2017
First American Home Warranty gives me pretty good and dependable service. We have a couple of rentals that we have it on plus we have it on our home. Submitting claims is basically simple. When I call up there, most of the time I get the machine and it asks me questions. I tell them what's going on. It’s easier to call in than go online. They send it to one of their people that work for them then somebody calls me back within 24 hours and within the next day they'll set up an appointment. Some of the times it takes 48 hours for someone to call me back and then another day for them to come out.
The only thing that I didn't like was when I had real good air conditioner guy come out that I really liked. This one guy called me back the same day and came out the same day. So it was a day shorter than usual and he was really fast. Then I had another issue in another house with issues with the air. I tried to request that same person, but for a new issue, and they wouldn't let me do that.
However, I've spoken to a few of their representatives and they're polite. They tell you how everything works and the little cost that you have to pay. They confirm things with you if you had an issue. Most of the technicians are professional. They’re prompt and would usually call me 30 minutes before they head out. This is to give me a little bit of a window if I'm doing something else and I can get ready to meet them. I had one guy out, I guess he hadn't worked with the home warranties before. He was the only technician that didn’t give me a call. He was clueless and he had to keep calling back to his office. Other than that, most of them know what they're doing. All the work done was good. I would recommend them if somebody asked me. I’m a satisfied customer.
Reviewed March 27, 2017
First American always comes when I have a complaint or problem. They're reliable and I like them so I have continued to renew with them. Submitting claims with them is always easy and quick. Someone gets back with me in a reasonable amount of time. I haven't had a bad experience with them. Their representatives were courteous and real nice and the service technicians do good work and I’m satisfied with it. They just come in, I tell them the problem, then they do their job. First American is a good company to have.
Reviewed March 26, 2017
Our realtor told us that First American Home Buyers Protection was a good company to go with. It's what our home builders picked when we purchased our home. We have submitted claims by calling them in and also through the website and both ways have been straightforward processes. The claims reps were helpful. Sometimes they couldn’t help us because they had to go to their supervisors but they always had a solution or would’ve worked to find a solution in a timely manner. Some of the technicians are better than others, but I haven't had any bad experience with them at all. Everyone has been courteous, on time, and helped out.
Reviewed March 26, 2017
Our garage door opener went out. I called First American up and they had somebody out within a week to fix it, and it's perfect. The tech showed up, diagnosed the door, and realized that it's too old to fix. He called First American to let them know what was going on. They said okay to a new garage door opener, and he put it in. The work done was great. The process was super easy and they did what they said they were going to do. They got right on getting it fixed and there was no delay. Overall, it was excellent. They have friendly customer service and overall, it was an excellent experience.
Reviewed March 26, 2017
When I submitted a claim over the phone with First American it worked real well. The claims representative was very helpful and I was very pleasantly surprised. We called it in and a couple of days later we got a call from the AC tech and they made an appointment. The technician was very professional. He came in and told us what he was going to do, and that it was going to be two days before he could get the part. Everything was done very timely. He came back with the part two days later. And he even called us before he came out here and told us he's on his way. He installed the part, the AC was fixed and they're done. It was great. My sister and a friend of ours are buying a house and we've already told them that they need to go ahead and get that insurance through First American.
Reviewed March 25, 2017
The real estate agent had the one year home warranty built into the home sale and I am still within that one year mark. I am in my first claim with what we thought was an air conditioner drain line leak, it runs through the ceiling and behind the wall. So, we had to cut an access point to see what was going on. It turns out it was the toilet from the second floor that was leaking. So, we fixed that. However, I still got a hole in the ceiling which, apparently, another company was supposed to come by and patch up the dry wall. But still I haven't heard anything from them yet.
The claims process is easy. Just picking up the phone and making it happen that way. But in terms of promptness and follow through, they are a little lacking. It’s easy enough to get a hold of them. Sometimes, a little difficult to understand the individuals on the other end of the line. The claims representatives were polite and professional. We had two service techs come out for the issue that I had most recently. Where an air conditioner guy, and then a plumber come out. But overall, no real issues either way.
Reviewed March 25, 2017
We bought the house and since we were elderly it might be nice to have a little protection that wouldn't cost us an arm and a leg. We saw First American on TV and gave them a call and I liked what I heard and signed up with them. We just had our dryer fixed and they got our washer fixed. They got right to us, got a serious repairman and it got done. Everything went well. The technician was very nice and explained things to us, asking to check the hose as while he was in there because we've had the washer in a while. He said they all look good. We had a real nice experience with him. I haven't had any problems with it since he fixed it. We were pleased that they handled our claims as fast as they did. They were polite and courteous with us and didn't make us feel pressured. We’re very happy and satisfied with the work and with our dealings with them.
Reviewed March 25, 2017
When we bought this house, it came with a 1-year warranty from First American. We've been with them for nine years now. When I submit a claim, I call and tell them what it is and whoever's coming to fix it would call the next day and tell me when they're coming. Also, their prices went down and they got a little more coverage which doesn't happen often. I've already been telling people that don't have a home warranty about First American.
Thank you for being a loyal customer of 9 years Maury!
Reviewed March 24, 2017
Our ice maker broke and they sent out American Repair company contractor who came out 6 times with a different diagnosis each time. The last time they not only didn't fix the ice maker, they broke the line to the refrigerator so we have no cooling at all. They are not allowed in my home again.
Reviewed March 24, 2017
We have First American Home Warranty, our furnace wasn't working and they would not fix or replace it. They claimed that because it wasn't broken completely and that it will rain, it wasn't their problem. I explained to them that they basically don't care if it doesn't do its job but it turns on that's means it's good. They said yes. I called PG&E and they condemned the furnace and the warranty place still argued that it's not their problem after it was leaking CO2 into our home. The warranty only could offer a small payout that only covers 1/10th of the price to fix the furnace. Because they couldn't fix it according to them. Nor did they want to replace it.
I felt scammed. I had to fight with them for 3 months and had to call 4-5 times a week. Not worth the stress. They never kept record of my previous phone calls or records from the heating and air people they sent out. They had 3 different companies come to our house. All 3 said the unit needed to be replaced and wished me luck with this company. Very sad to see this company take advantage of people. The customer service isn't even in America, you get transferred to some other country. Highly disappointed. Don't waste your money.
Hello Juliet,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed March 24, 2017
I submit my claims over the phone most of the time and it's been a fine experience dealing with First American. I'll recommend it to a friend.
Reviewed March 24, 2017
Submitting a claim to First American is not always as smooth as I'd like. It would be great to speak to someone right away as opposed to going through different prompts that ask me my account number which changes ever so often.
Reviewed March 23, 2017
There are multiple things that can go bad in a home as part of the cost of ownership. Being able to have some assistance in correcting those issues makes good business sense, and the amount of money paid for premiums can sometimes be offset by the ability to have an issue addressed. We've had First American for years and the claims process with them was easy. People would get back to me and the people who are going to address the issue would contact me and then I would arrange my time. We had a leak that I could not find in our shower that was going into our brand new kitchen. First American sent a plumber who found out that it was the valve stem behind the tile that needed to be repacked and addressed, which eliminated the problem. The quality of the repair is fantastic. Having them is absolutely the best homeownership decision that we've made.
Reviewed March 23, 2017
I was told about the benefits of having a home warranty and I liked it so I decided that I should get one that would fix stuff for me. I just had one with First American so I try to keep it. If I have a problem, I call them, say what the problem is and they send somebody the next day soonest most of the time. One time, my sink shutter wasn't working and the tech came, replaced it and did a good job. All in all, it's been an awesome experience and I'm happy with it. I'll recommend them.
Reviewed March 22, 2017
I called in to open a request to find out why my Fridge Ice maker and dispensing is not working and why the build in Electric Wall Microwave/Oven is not working. The request is open, they sent the repair person, the repair person did such a horrible job on the Fridge Ice maker, attached see the pictures of all the back marks which was left, so unclean, don't even want to use the Fridge Ice maker now, since it's in such a bad state, he put his dirty hands in the ice maker while fixing, yuck. See the handles of the fridge as well the way it was left. First American Home Warranty is saying dispensing is not covered this is not covered all the fine prints. I am saying to them first see the how the job is done. It is made worse than what was before.
On the Microwave/Oven, the repair person came twice and he cannot repair it, wasted almost more than 2-3weeks, still not working. First American Home Warranty says, "We will replace." Ok. Thank you. Though I requested, "Can you please have Steel as oppose to Black, since the price on the replacement one is same for both the models." They say, "No, we cannot do." Even if there was price difference for 50-100$ I could have paid the difference though they say, "No we will just give you black color, that's it." So rude. I don't believe. I will be recommending this in future to any of any friends to get insurance from First American Home Warranty.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed March 22, 2017
First American Home Warranty for one year was purchased for us by previous homeowners. The glass top to the electric stove cracked under normal cooking circumstances, put in a claim, First American scheduled a contractor to view the damage 8 days later, contractor took pictures and confirmed problem, First American called later that day to communicate claim was denied because they say it was an impact damage. I have confirmed with the contractor this was not in their report, First American has just decided on their own that this was an impact damage and not covered.
I've tried communicating with "customer service" people who just insist the contractor said it was an impact crack, which is just not true. I was able to send in my own pictures of the damage just after it occurred, heard nothing from First American until I called later, and they just said the claim was denied. They are scamming me out of what was contracted, and their customer service is horrible.
Reviewed March 22, 2017
First American was excellent and I'd recommend them. Anytime I had to speak with a claims rep, everybody was available.
Reviewed March 22, 2017
I like First American Home Warranty very well. However it's hard to get a hold of the one plumber that they used. I always have to call back First American and let them call him. They will answer the phone for them but not for me. Otherwise, I haven't had any problem. I just had a claim with First American and they're very good about it. The only thing is they said they'd buy me a new sink and then they decided they wouldn't because they said that it's old. I told them it's in bad shape and I can't even find stoppers for it. And they said, "Just because it's an old sink, doesn't mean we have to buy a new one." But it's one of the old sinks that has one little tiny side and then a great big side and it's just not a very good sink.
Reviewed March 21, 2017
I've got an older home, so I thought it would be a good idea to get a home warranty as a preventive measure. I liked First American's rating so I chose them, and my experience with them has been all good. They're great. They're there when I needed them. It's also easy to submit a claim because I can do it online or over the phone. I recently submitted one for my refrigerator and the technician just came and diagnosed it. The fan is not working and it got heated by an obstruction. He removed the obstruction and then the fridge started working again. He did a great job.
Reviewed March 21, 2017
First American is a very good company. We've had them for years and years on two homes, and it's always been a very good experience with them. They're prompt and reliable. The people they send out are also reliable and do a good job. My most recent claim with them was for a plumbing problem. The contractor came out the next day and fixed the issue.
Reviewed March 20, 2017
I think that getting the home warranty was the best thing that I could have done. This warranty has bailed me out a few times and with a small deductible. I am really happy with my warranty. If this was offered for renewal at a reasonable rates I would like to renew my policy.
Thank you for your comments Tanisha!
Reviewed March 20, 2017
We decided to end our contract with First American Home Warranty after the first year, and stated that when they called for the renewal period. They said they would cancel the contract, but no written verification was ever received. We continued to get monthly billings, and disputed the billings through First American and the credit card company. Finally 6 months after the verbal cancellation we got an emailed confirmation of the cancellation stating that further payments were canceled as of that date and a $36.00 credit had been applied.
But 3 months later another bill appeared on our credit card statement showing a "rebill" for $36.00. Reaching a person by phone for this type of issue is difficult through their phone system, but a person named "Anthony" finally agreed that the billing was an "error" and we should wait 3-4 days for a credit to appear on our credit card. The lessons from this for us were: (1) Always insist on written confirmation immediately on ending a contract; (2) NEVER agree to automatic billing from a main credit card or bank account from companies like this. If such billing is required, always use a temporary credit card for that company's bills and cancel the credit card when the contract is over.
Reviewed March 20, 2017
The home that we purchased came with First American and we just kept extending it. They always seemed like a good value to us and their service has always been very good. They've always been responsive and taken good care of us. I never had any problems with them. Our most recent experience was with our furnace. I called it in, and their claims rep took my information and gave me the information for the repair person. And within a day or so, the repairman was out to our house and fixed the problem within 30 to 45 minutes. He was friendly and courteous, and I feel good about his work. We haven't had any issues since so he did a good job. The whole process was pretty painless. First American has always been very helpful and the service that they arranged and promised us has always come through.
Reviewed March 20, 2017
My realtor signed us up with First American when we first bought the house and we'd been with them since. They've been there whenever we needed them. They responded quickly. We always take their word for what's wrong, and they've helped us take care of our situation within one or two days of us calling for help. There were times we called them on a weekend and we got to wait until Monday when they get back to work, to take our claim information. But, everything's been really good with them. They give us an appointment date when we call them and they come out within the timeframe they say they will be.
We are 100% happy with the quality of their work. They point out what we need to do and I take care of whatever needs to be done. And we're very satisfied with the people when they come out to take care of our home. They have always been professional, polite, and courteous - the way I expect somebody to be when they come to the house. My wife feels really comfortable with them and she's never afraid to let one of them in even though she's all by herself. We hope they stay the same as they are in the past when they come to us for any kind of claim. And that they maintain their promptness and their courteousness. And, if they do, we'll stay as customers.
Reviewed March 19, 2017
I bought my home seven years ago. The seller's realtor had thrown it in with the deal, that First American was included for a year of home warranty with our house that we bought. I continued it on. In the first year alone we used it for the furnace and the air conditioner and it saved us thousands of dollars. I decided to go ahead and keep First American with the home being almost 40 years old, and I've used it several times over the years.
The most recent claim was with my dishwasher. It stopped working, and the guy came and saw that it could not be fixed. I made a claim, and they paid for me to get a new dishwasher. It's a very easy process because I can just go online. Then a technician called the next day and set up an appointment. It only takes a few minutes and there's no follow up I have to do after making the claim. The electrician told me he was gonna replace it but didn't call back for a few weeks. I got hold of a claims rep and she called the electrician who came the very next day.
The technicians that came are always very polite and courteous. They know the warranty program very well, so they can tell me what's warranted and what's not. Their quality of work has been perfect. It's one of the better warranty programs just from the ease of access and the things that are covered, and the deductible is well worth having if one owns an older home. I'm very satisfied and I'd definitely gonna keep the warranty on the 25-year-old home that I'm buying this summer.
Reviewed March 19, 2017
Recently, I had a stove range that was not working. I initially called First American Home Warranty and the claims rep was good. They said the soonest they can get someone out was within two weeks. I was looking for my own repair guy then they called back and said that they could get someone out in the next day. Then someone from Sears came to the house. He was friendly and helpful. He identified the problem, but did not have the part on hand. He told me what needed to be fixed, but did not actually fix anything and still charged the fee. So, I was a little upset about that.
He said he was on vacation so he would not be able to come back out for another week so I did the work. I was already without the stove for a couple of days and we did not want to go another week. I went in and bought parts that totaled to be almost as much as the fee. But I was never dissatisfied with First American's service since I've had them in 2011. When we had a pipe break, they were quick and easy to work with.
Reviewed March 18, 2017
Had an air-conditioning unit go out only to tell me it's not covered because they believe the damage is months old. Really I, it's been 100 for over two weeks. It's been on every day... told me I should have had a home inspection report prior to me purchasing their extravagant bloated fake coverage. Try another company.
Reviewed March 18, 2017
Had First American Home Warranty and my microwave broke in December 2016. They sent an engineer and then he had to write a report. They then said the board needed to be replaced. They could not find the board anymore and said the board would need to be refurbished. The engineer strongly advised against this as it said it will break again after a few weeks/months. The First Home warranty agent didn't care. They should have replaced the microwave. It ended up taking 3 months for the board to be replaced and put back in the microwave. I have 3 small children and First home warranty did not care that I had to wait this long for the repair. The renewal came through. I refused due to the fact they did not meet their obligations. 1. did not replace the microwave, 2. took 3 months to fix, 3. no compensation.
And lo behold 1 month later the microwave has broken and I no longer have coverage. Complete waste of time dealing with this company. Horrible customer service and even the engineer said he has stopped working for the firm because of the way they behave and they were paying less fees. Save your money and don't bother with this company.
Reviewed March 18, 2017
I've been in my house for a few years and I thought a home warranty was a good idea to help cut the cost in having to replace or repair things. We looked at 3 or 4 home warranty providers and First American had the best coverage for the price. I signed up with them and there wasn't any problem when I submitted a claim for my furnace. Their claims reps were very helpful. I just called and it was easy as 1-2-3. They had the company that worked with them contact me. They scheduled the appointment and came right out.
The technician was very courteous and seemed to be knowledgeable. He knew what he was doing although I had never heard of the company he was with. That was my main concern - who the company that they would be sending out was because we used to have a maintenance agreement with a pretty large furnace and air conditioning company. So I checked up on them on the internet to see any complaints and I was a little nervous because there was a couple of not positive things in there about them. But they took care of the problem and I'm quite satisfied with the quality of their work. And they did not try to upsell me on things. Overall, First American is good. I have recommended them and my daughter and her husband signed up with them.
Reviewed March 18, 2017
I have been using First American for 10 years and it's hit or miss with them. The customer service people, generally, are hard to understand and they speak too fast. And our most recent claim is not good. It's still ongoing.
The appliance company that First American sent out did not call me back for weeks. And the first time I called First American about it, nobody did anything. The first rep who I spoke to did not do what he was supposed to do. Then they assigned it to another lady who was supposed to take it from there. When I left her messages, she never called me. They just said she was out of the office the week before. So then, I called back because nothing had happened. And I got another person who took care of it. He put me through a claims rep named Joseph and Joseph handled the claim. I'm two weeks out from that phone call and the contractor is finally coming tomorrow to fix my stove. But it's been nearly two months since the claim started. And two months is entirely too long to have a broken stove. It's so frustrating to spend the money for a warranty and then have to argue with them for 2 months to get my stove fixed. First American is not trying to deny the claim, it's just them trying to get somebody here to fix it.
The contractor's service rep said they were having trouble getting the parts. They called me yesterday and I told them that I needed to speak to First American, because I wasn't sure if they were supposed to come or not. Because as far as I knew, the parts were coming to my house. And the contractor's service rep called me back today and said that she talked to First American, and they were supposed to come and install them. This is the second time that I've had a major issue with one of the contractors that First American is using. I can't even find this contractor on the internet. There's no listing of him anywhere. So, I don't know how First American even found him. The first one was when my dryer was out of service. It took nearly three months trying to get it fixed because of the contractor failing to call back whenever they received parts. I told First American not to send them to my house ever again.
Reviewed March 17, 2017
I'm a single parent. I've always had a home warranty and I learned about First American from a friend. I've had another home warranty wherein if you have two plumbing issues, they have to come out two different times. With First American, you can have up to fix or six claims per time. I always submit claims over the phone because I like to talk to somebody. The claims process is easy and automated. The claims reps are all real receptive and I can understand most of them. Occasionally, I get one who is hard to understand, but most of the time, they're great and apologetic for the problem. They also ask if I have other problems and say that I can have up to six claims for one tech on one call for one fee. Then they're insistent that the companies get back out and they take care of that. First American is dependable and reliable.
The service technicians are usually okay. I had claims for a swimming pool and kitchen sink plumbing. First American contacted service companies and let me know who they were on the same day. However, both of the service companies had to come back out a second time. The pool company is lacking in service techs and there are not that many pool companies in Midland, Texas. They're real short-handed and didn't get the job done at first. They used an apprentice and he didn't get the pipes totally sealed so the owner had to come back out and finish them. The quality of work was adequate, though.
For the plumbing part, the tech was probably in a hurry and he replaced the part of the pipe that went from under the sink, out towards the wall. So when it was still leaking the next day, he had to come back because he had missed that curve in the pipe and he had to replace where the P-trap is. The plumbing is always excellent because I always use Waters Edge and they're the best plumbers in my experience with the company. It's always the same guys over and over so I don't feel uncomfortable with them.
Reviewed March 17, 2017
First American came with the home when we purchased it. One time the stove went out so my wife called and they sent Sears out. The tech came out but they didn’t have the part. He said there was one in the truck but it had been bouncing around and he didn’t feel comfortable getting that one so he ordered another one. It was fast. Within a week they had the part and came right back over and fixed the stove so it was a good experience. We will be extending the home warranty when it goes up.
Reviewed March 16, 2017
A breaker panel in my laundry room caught on fire a little bit. I went to First American's website to submit a claim and it was super easy doing it. I simply filled up the information online on my cellphone, they sent me emails and everything went through. The company the technician came from was very personable to deal with. They worked around my schedule, came on time and fixed everything in a timely manner. They were also very informative of what I needed to do later on in case something happens. First American's home warranty is a great deal to have and once this contract goes out, I'll renew it. I've recommended them to about five people.
Reviewed March 16, 2017
My friend said I need to get home insurance with First American when my water heater broke and that ended up as a claim with them. I went online and submitted it and it was super easy. They texted me the next day but it took a week and a half for someone to call me. But the technician was great, pleasant and professional. He came back two or three days later and replaced it. It worked and it was done.
Updated review: April 21, 2017
First American has taken care of all of my needs in a timely manner, I am very satisfied with their attention to detail and the way they treat their customers.
Original Review: March 15, 2017
Well, I called First American as soon as I got home to let them know my furnace wasn't working so I need someone to come look at it. It is the middle of March but is extremely cold in Ohio right now, 20 degrees, feels like 4. They said someone would contact me within 24 to 48 hours. I explained that it is too cold in the house and we need heat sooner than that. The representative told me it is not considered an emergency. I explained to him how cold it is and after about 20 minutes of bickering they, First American, decided they would dispatch a company that would contact me within 8 hours. It has now been 13 hours, still do not have heat. I was able to put space heaters in one room and get the temperature up to 57. Thankfully my wife and son are now at school where it is warm. I am working from home with gloves that I have cut the finger tips off so I can type.
I could call someone else for service on my own but of course, they won't pay unless they select the service provider. Maybe today I'll get a call from someone. I would never buy a warranty through First American Home Warranty. A home warranty should at minimum keep people safe, a house without heat in these temperatures is not safe. Sure, I can call someone else and pay for it on my own but then the insurance company wins. That is how they make money, they collect premiums but don't pay out on claims. It's worse than a Ponzi scheme, at least the first investors get some money back in a Ponzi scheme!
Reviewed March 15, 2017
I'm happy with the results given by First American. But while some of their contractors are good, some aren't that good. The temperature of my refrigerator was going nuts, the reset button was always on red, and the icemaker was no longer freezing. I called First American and they sent a vendor who told me that there's a very strong possibility that the control board is going haywire. The guy's English was terrible that I can hardly understand him. It was difficult communicating and I had to pry the information out of him. He was speaking in whispers and he didn't do anything. He came in, told me what could be wrong with it, and left. He didn't even charge me.
First American is unable to get a hold of the vendors. It would be like winning a lottery, if I get a hold of them. They're not answering the phone and still, it's not fixed. But the other two issues I had with my icemaker and garage furnace were taken care of immediately, with no problems at all. Those were just very simple, and smooth transactions. The people at First American are courteous professionals and overall good people.
Reviewed March 15, 2017
The house came with a one-year warranty provided by First American when I bought it and I never had any issues. I know other homeowners who had issues with their warranty companies who are not covering claims or they'll find a loophole but I never have to worry about that with First American so I decided to stay. Submitting claims is very simple and easy, either online or by calling them, and interactions with their reps are always smooth. If the contractor they hired doesn't service my area, they usually get someone else on very quickly. The technicians are also very pleasant. They come, do the job, restore whatever is broken and they leave. They don't take too much time and their work is good. They're a great company with easy transactions and I highly recommend them.
We appreciate your business Jaris!
Reviewed March 14, 2017
We bought a house in 2012 and took a policy with First American. A few months later our hot water heater broke. The customer service was awful and the contractors (we had to have 2 different ones come out) were incompetent and could care less about providing service. Because of their terrible service we went 7 DAYS without hot water. This is completely unacceptable.
We have since purchased a new home last year. Our sellers purchased another policy with First American. I wouldn't have gone with this company, however, the sellers chose it for us. Fast forward to yesterday when our hot water heater in our new home. AGAIN we are having issues with customer service. We asked to be flagged as an emergency service with a callback within 8 hours... this was not done. After we contacted the vendor they referred us to told us they couldn't come out for 2 days. It amazes me how uncaring and rude everyone has been through the past experience and now the current. Our policy is up next month and we will be exploring other companies.
Reviewed March 14, 2017
The gentleman who came to the house was professional and knowledgeable, along with being very nice. The work was completed in a quick amount of time. Time was also taken to explain why the issue had happened. The technician was on time, and person who scheduled the appointment was also very nice.
Reviewed March 14, 2017
This is my second time with First American and both have been very disappointing. Previously, I owned an 1920's craftsman style home so when the warranty was fairly useless (tech would come out and either claim something was not covered or stare at me with blank eyes because he didn't have a proper snake to unclog a pipe) I wrote it off on the age of the property. Second try turned out even worse. This time, I purchased a newer property and the warranty was part of the negotiation, so why not. The first time I filed a claim, it was denied due to some improper wiring. I paid $65 for the tech visit, which provided me with a ONE SENTENCE explanation for the denial, no suggestions, no nothing. Expensive, yes, but fine, things happen.
Remembering my previous experience though, I decided I will be probably better off not paying $65 for questionable service I received going forward and decided to cancel the policy. That took a little time and effort but I finally received my refund in the mail. Since it was less than expected, I contacted customer service and it turns out that I was charged a $140 claim cost related to the above mentioned claim. So basically, I ended up paying $205 for a half hour visit by a tech which provided me zero service. I reached out to customer service to try to understand how this pricing is anywhere near realistic and they just keep telling me that it's based on their negotiated price with the service provider. I will keep talking to them but I doubt I am getting any more of my money back. Beware.
Reviewed March 14, 2017
The previous owners of the house I bought had First American. I wanted protection and First American had a good price for what it would cover. The claim process was easy although I had one that was a little difficult ‘cause the person on the phone was hard to understand. It was when my refrigerator went out and he told me he couldn’t get anyone out there for three weeks. But someone else called me back and she got the technicians out a couple days later so it turned out fine. Anytime I had technicians come, they were good. Overall, my experience with First American has been good.
Reviewed March 13, 2017
On Feb 13, 2017, my Compressor fan was not working when I tried to switch on cooling. It took me a torturous 1 month, where I had to make several unsuccessful calls to First AM. They kept denying blindly the claim, and always found a false reason. Even after leaving several messages the claims Manager did not even bother call. Here is my painful experience: Both contractors said completely different things. 1'st Contractor North Star was inexperienced and said improper installation of fan motor was the cause of short. Which I challenged and submitted a report proving it wrong. 2nd Contractor was vague and said that the switch to join wires missing -> Which was not missing but broken by fan motor due to "Wear & Tear", again claim denied falsely.
At the end I got completely frustrated and go it fixed using an outside contractor. As suspected L1 Terminal shorted out on the compressor, and compressor Fan needs to be replaced. When I reported this back to First AM, they started a new theory that since I got this fixed from outside they will not cover it, while they were OK to keep denying this for 1 month. Guys please dont waste your money, this will be a torture.
Reviewed March 13, 2017
I put my claim through over the phone and they remember. They saw in the system where I've been a part of them. I told them what I was wanting as far as my claim. They went ahead and put me in the system. They treated me fine, even the guy that came out and serviced my call then. The quality of work was pretty good. So it’s the same steps that I had years ago and I've never had any problems out of it.
Reviewed March 13, 2017
At first, I thought that First American doesn't need to use Sears as one of their contacts. We had somebody to come out two weeks ago and look at our washer. He had to order parts, which was fine. Then, they came in a couple of days ago. When we called, they said that they're already here. But they gave a 9-hour window between 8:00 am to 5:00 pm and that's not good because everybody's busy. And if I don't know what time, I don't know if they're gonna show up then. We can take two to four hours but not from 8:00 am until 5:00 pm. Another problem is they didn't call that they were coming until 5:30. By then, I had already called First American to send somebody else. But the other people that they have assigned are doing very well and it's Sears. Other than that, First American is all doing a good job by finding people. I would recommend them.
Reviewed March 12, 2017
First American's coverage was the best and their price was right. I submitted one claim on a dishwasher and the technician who came out was very good. Everything is working like it should since the repair.
Reviewed March 12, 2017
There was an incident where the electricity didn't work in half of my house. I had a friend that used to own an electric company and so he came over and tried to find the problem. In doing that, he undid some plugs and switches. He couldn't find the problem. He went to leave and he asked me if he should put it back the way it was. I said no because it'll make it easier for the people that come from the home warranty company. So I called First American then and they sent someone. The technician came in and saw the plug and the switches hanging out. He was very rude and he said, "We can't fix those. You've taken them apart." I explained to him that I had a friend come over who couldn't find the problem, and he continued to be rude. All he did was walk around and take pictures of each plug and switch. So I asked him to leave and he did.
Then I called First Warranty and every time I called them, I got somebody that was very hard to understand because of their language. I couldn't get any satisfaction. When I finally got a hold of First American, they told me to put everything back the way it was, take pictures that things were back and send the pictures to them and they would send somebody back again. So I did that and then they were gonna send the same company back. I told them not to send the same technician so they didn't, and it was very helpful. My heater went out at the same time so they sent somebody and that was fixed. I would recommend them to a friend.
Reviewed March 12, 2017
We had them come out and fix our garage, and they were prompt. My husband gave them a call, and they set up a time. But then something came up so we had to postpone it, and they were very polite about it. Our garage is working now but I need to call them out again because it’s making a grinding, metal-on-metal sound. It was working fine when the tech left, but the next day, it started making this funny noise. But other than that, things are fine. They completed the work quickly and were very professional. And I’m sure as soon as I call them, they’ll come out. I would recommend First American.
Reviewed March 11, 2017
I submit my claims with First American online if it's a simple problem that I know what’s wrong. The technicians have been absolutely wonderful. Everybody they've sent so far has been very informative, very easy to talk to, and they were not curt. Once they’ve really fixed an issue, then they're gone.
In our previous call two years ago, we had an issue with the air conditioner. Something wasn’t working right. We called them and they sent a gentleman out to work on the air conditioner. He ran through it and then told us that he'd check something else. He went over to the breaker box, and he looked at it and said it's not an air conditioner issue. It's our electrical in the box. So he said, "I can't fix it. I'll have to advise them. They’ll send out an electrician." He also said, "The next guy that comes, he's gonna charge you." They didn’t charge me for the service call. Somebody sent out an electrician and he replaced the breaker and it's all peachy. And we paid one service call, which was very awesome. We are very satisfied with that. It was very nice of them to only charge us one service call for totally two different companies. I was very appreciative of that.
I also had a water heater, which wasn’t doing something. They had to replace the water heater, but it turned out we had a leak. It was in the concrete, so that ended up costing a fortune for us. The guy who came out was very nice. They had to cut a little hole in the wall underneath the sink unit but they didn't close it up. When he was trying to drill it into the bathroom section, he must have drilled a hole into the wall. The hole is up at the ceiling line so it's not noticeable but it's still a hole. But other than that, they did a great job. They fixed the water leak and everything is peachy keen.
The only concern is that they did comment that the line going through the ceiling is lying in the trusses over the insulation. And my husband expressed the concern, "Are those lines exposed or they could possibly freeze in the ceiling?" The tech said, “Well, we checked them where we could.” It didn't freeze and pop yet but not that it couldn’t happen in the future. I am not in the position myself to climb up in our ceiling and cover it all. It might be worthwhile to get somebody getting up there and do it to prevent the freezing. Other than that, it's very good.
Reviewed March 11, 2017
There are two different ways to submit a claim with First American. I can do it online where I can write out a little story if I need to, or I can do it over the phone and try to keep it short. There are a lot of prompts to go through but I get through it and sometimes I can get a live person. The ease depends on the type of emergency I have. If it’s something that needs quick attention, I’d prefer to do it on a phone call because the response on the e-mail or online could take a while and somebody might not see it. It’s a big company. I’d rather talk to a live person to get the ball rolling much quicker.
Most of the time, the claims representatives are courteous and able to answer all my questions. When we run into a problem, it usually is for scheduling and follow-up. We schedule and then the availability on the contractor would be another two to three days. There was one time where it took five days and I ended up fixing the problem myself, which I'm still going to maybe put some receipt in for possible reimbursement. The guy I talked to after was very thoughtful and nice with that regard. But as far as emergencies, they usually can have a contractor out within a 12 to 24-hour period. A non-emergency can take a little while. The work performed by the technicians has been really good.
First American's service is good. That’s why I've been with them for five years. I’ve had five years of contracts consecutively with them and not just the basic. They have the standard equal upgrade, first class upgrade, and it definitely helped me in my first year. It worked out when my air conditioning and furnace went out. And every other subsequent time except for a couple of little hiccups on the scheduling, emergencies were taken care of.
I travel and it’s worked for me. If a family member calls me when something breaks, I’ll make a phone call to First American and we’ll go from there and then I let my family know. For the most recent case, the hot water line that was above the water tank busted and it started spilling water into the garage. Luckily, my mother-in-law at that time happened to be doing laundry and she walked into the garage and looked up. I was miles away and my 70-year-old mother-in-law was helping me watch the house and she doesn’t know how to turn off the water when there’s a water leak, so I needed somebody to help. We had a neighbor help us but I needed somebody else to do the work because there’s no way I could be there to do it myself.
The people from First American were able to come within 18 hours, which was at 7:30 the next morning. They got it all fixed up, and everybody in the house was ready to roll again. They’re really responsive especially in emergencies. For the stuff that may not be emergencies, they may take a little bit of time so there’s a little trade-off there. Nonetheless, the people that do the work are doing a decent job. Within the last three months, I made five calls to the home warranty because some things started to pop off in the older house and each one was handled.
Reviewed March 11, 2017
I'm a first-time home buyer and some of my friends advised me to get a home warranty. I was looking on the internet for a couple warranties and insurances and I decided to get First American. So far, everything's okay and there's no problem. I already made a couple of claims and the services were done on time. They did a good and professional job and I don't have any complaints on the technicians. I'm satisfied with their services. I don't regret getting this warranty and insurance and I will keep going with this service in the future.
Reviewed March 10, 2017
I had good luck with FAHW in a previous repair to the ice maker part of the fridge but this time the fridge was not cooling, food and milk were spoiling and tenants were irate. Filed the claim as required. They contacted their contractor and sent him out. So far so good. He shows up with no tools, no documents, no uniform, i.d. and had his own car not company truck. He took a few pictures, said it might be the door sealers (which they replaced a year ago), took down some numbers and left and said he'd be in touch. Neither I nor my property manager ever heard from him again. I sent emails to FAHW every day and said food was spoiling and he wasn't getting back to us. Each time the same answer: "We don't have his report yet so we can't do anything"!
After 3 days of spoiling food, we couldn't wait any longer and had it repaired by an outside contractor who came right away (with tools), deduced the fan needed replacement and fixed it. So I contacted their claims dept and said I wanted a waiver of the fee and a reimbursement of the repairs because I followed their procedures and they didn't deliver. She then read the contractor's report. The entire report was a series of lies. He said there was nothing wrong with the refrigerator! He said he got back to us (lie). He said he went by and we told him it was fixed and we refused service! Lie. So today the lady called me and balked at the reimbursement because "we don't pay for outside contractors". I replied I went through them and their contractor as required and they didn't deliver and lied about it. The jury is still out as she is asking her supervisor about the reimbursement. I gave her my prop mgr number so she could verify with him.
Reviewed March 10, 2017
My sister had First American. We talked about it and I liked the idea, so we went ahead and bought. We had a difficulty with one claim that we had. Our ice maker went out, and there was nobody in our area to fix it. And to me, they totally dropped the ball because they didn't look outside the box. We're 30 miles from one big city and then everything else around us is about our size. But going North a little ways, 60 miles or so, there are other air conditioning people that do things, and we were able to find somebody ourselves about less than 100 miles from here. It took forever to get it settled because we'd gone out and found our own, but we didn't have a choice and we were told to. But that was the only problem I've had with First American.
The techs that were sent to our home have all been pretty good. The last one that I had was when I had a leak in one of my bathroom faucets. The tech came ready and was very professional. He had with him, everything needed to fix the faucet. He didn't have to leave and come back the next day, and I've had experiences like that outside of this company. He handled the job very well and I was very proud of him. First American seems to honor all of what's in our contract.
Reviewed March 10, 2017
My daughter who is in the plumbing business recommended First American to us. When submitting a claim, I call them by phone and the last experience with them was very good. A plumber from P & R Plumbing came and he worked on the sink and several places in the house. He was very good and the best we've had out. There have been some technicians who have come out and they haven't been that happy to work with. There was one claim where the technician tried to sell us a new heating unit instead of fixing the problem. But overall, I'm very satisfied with First American.
Reviewed March 9, 2017
I have had 2 experiences with FAHW this year. Both were very bad. First in January my heater broke, and I called. It took them 7 days for them to get a contractor out there to fix it. I explained it was the middle of winter and there was a newborn baby in the house, and we needed heat. They did not care and would not escalate the service. Second was in early February. The faucet in the master bath broke. The handle fell off. You would think not a big problem. Well it was for the incompetent contractors they use. After the 3rd contractor came out to fix the faucet and 3 weeks later, they still had not fixed the problem. I sent out a real plumber, the same day I called him, and 30 minutes later the problem was fixed. This company has very long wait times on the phones, unreasonable amount of days to wait for a contractor.
Reviewed March 9, 2017
I was into real estate for 20 some years and I refer First American to all my clients. So when I bought this home almost 13 years ago, of course, I wanted First American. I've had several claims over the 13 years in this house and I always call in. They've always been very helpful and it's been really great up until this last time we had a plumbing problem. They sent out a gentleman named Jim. It took a while to get him out here. He showed up in an old and beat-up pickup and came in with no tools. He had a wrench and a handful of Allen wrenches and he looked over everything and said he got to get permission to do the work and that it will take a couple of days. I already knew everyone that I ever used before went out to their truck and they would go ahead and call First American, tell them the problem and get authorization. Then, they'd come in and do the work.
But this man wasn't feeling good. I could tell he had a cold. He said he'd been sick and that he'd get back to me within a couple of days. But five days later, I still haven't heard from him. So I called him and I told him I've been waiting to hear from him. He's letting someone hang in the air for five days. I've got a leaky kitchen faucet and I've got to climb under my sink to turn the water on and off. He said he's doing the best he can but if it's not good enough then, I ought to get someone else. So, I called the home warranty company and they sent out a new technician. They came, went through everything and they were very polite and knowledgeable. They didn't have everything on the truck that they need so they went back in two days. They came back a second time, two of them, and they worked for almost three and a half hours. They got everything done and it's working perfectly.
I was really shocked over Jim cause First American has always sent out somebody that's been in the business. The second guy showed up with a plumbing truck and he's got all kinds of parts on his truck. But Jim in this old, rickety pickup with a handful of wrenches. I really was surprised that it was First American sending out this man. He was unprofessional and I did not get a feeling of confidence from him. But I was able to live with it. But if it had been in the middle of the winter and my heat was out, that would have never worked. I don't know how First American lined up the people that they go under contract with but Jim was one of the biggest losers I've ever seen. But everyone else through the years has been great. I forgive you for this one very bad mistake. I hate to complain and I've never had to before. I've always been very satisfied and they've always come back and checked in with me to see if everything went well.
Reviewed March 9, 2017
My real estate agent suggested First American when I bought the house. I kept the home warranty because I was afraid that my old air conditioner was going to die and the home warranty was cheaper than replacing it. I usually submit my claims online, they've got an online tool to do it and it's easy. But I've had to do one over the phone just because it was a little bit complicated and I couldn't get the tool to quite work. The quality of work has been a hit or miss, depending on which company they decide to contract out to. The ones they sent for my broken dishwasher and water heater were good, but the ones who came for my central air system have been terrible. I have a request out to get my air conditioner working again from the guy who had fixed my heater. Something got wired up wrong and now my air conditioner doesn't work. The heater is fine, but the air conditioner doesn't work now.
Reviewed March 8, 2017
First time buying a house and got this warranty included as part of my contract. I order two services and when they came to my house they weren't able to fix anything and advised me that I don't have to pay anything because they did not do any work. Later I get a letter from the company stating that I have to pay $65 + $65 for each service. I call the company and they told me that I have to pay the fee because they went to my house. However when the guys went to my house they said that I don't have to pay anything and as well that they did not collect the money.
I called so many times to get this resolved and all supervisors are RUDE! Not able to help and hang up on you. I spoke with Thomas extension ** not helpful at all. Did not want to let me speak with his manager and said that he does not care that I'm reporting him because there is nothing he can do to waive the fee. Guys please do not get this warranty! STAY AWAY FROM IT!! It's a scam and every time they go to your house they never fix anything, they just force you to pay the service fee $65. Even though it's free I don't want anything to do with this terrible company! Disgusted.
Reviewed March 8, 2017
I submit my claims with First American over the phone and the claims process is good. It's all automated. There's always the same person for the problems that we get, and they've been really good.
Reviewed March 8, 2017
So, when one goes to 'Google reviews' and FAHW is rate 1* and one looks at this site and only sees 5*, it should raise questions!!! I have had a horrible experience with fahw. 4 visits - problem still unresolved. Trying to hire an outside contractor who knows the product (a Sub-zero) and get reimbursed. Have been on the phone for 35 minutes. Refrigerator is sitting in the middle of my kitchen waiting to get a call-back! Anyone that does business with this company is out of their mind.
Reviewed March 8, 2017
The claim experience with First American has been good. However, the last episode wasn't that good as far as the job. I filed for a leaking faucet in my bathroom and it took them four tries to get out here to fix it. They sent three different plumbers and put holes in my holes. One of the plumbers dropped an antique glass ashtray off the window sill and he broke the toilet. It was a mess. So, I talked to the insurance agent and she said to make a note in my account so that if I ever have another plumbing issue, they won't send those people out. I told her that if they do, I'll send the people away and cancel my policy.
I understand their position where they couldn't send out somebody new after the guy already started because the plumbing company split it up. But I have no problem with First American. I continue to pay our copay and it hasn't gone up as bad as I had anticipated it would, so it's still within reason. I plan on keeping the home and the policy.
Reviewed March 7, 2017
We recently signed with First American Home Warranty and all seem to be good until we had a problem with our home AC unit. We placed a call to First American Home Warranty and they set up it with the contractor NorthStar Mechanical (Dallas Texas) to come out. They told me "it was going to be a few hours and the tech would call you." Was more like 9 hours and the tech showed up at 8:30pm which was very strange? So the tech looks at the AC unit and tells me the blower motor is out. He then goes to his pickup (just a plain white truck?), grabs what looks like a used motor. All beat up looking and missing some paint. I questioned him about the motor and he tells me, "it looks this way because it was rolling around in the truck." Mmmm Ok that's good to know. NOT. So that problem got fixed, but wait there is more.
About a month later I'm having problems again with the AC unit. We placed another call to First American Home Warranty and ask that a different contractor be sent out, but nope they sent NorthStar Mechanical again. He checks the AC unit and tells me the entire upper unit will need to be replaced. Writes it up and leaves. Now I'm responsible for any upgrades and code requirements. So I call NorthStar Mechanical and talk to them about the upgrades and codes. Some of which I don't need because I'm not in the CITY but in the COUNTY which doesn't have the same code requirements. So we go back and forth talking trying to get it straightened out for 4 WEEKS. That's if you can get them on the phone (meaning I had no AC or Heat for 4 weeks). I even called the city inspector to verify this and gave NorthStar Mechanical his direct number and still got nowhere with this company.
It doesn't matter how you look at. The bottom line is poor customer service on both sides, because First American Home Warranty would not provide me with a different contractor even when we told them the problem is still not resolved after 4 weeks and all we did was complain about the company lack of customer service with the contractor. NorthStar Mechanical would not call me back to set forth on getting the problem resolved even after I provide them with the information. Also when calling NorthStar Mechanical their voice prompt tells you they are open 8am-5pm in my time zone but you can't get anyone on the phone after 4pm. Trust me we have tried for several days when they told us they would calls us back but never did.
If I treated my customers this way, well I wouldn't have any customers. Zero stars for both companies. We thought First American Home Warranty was the right way to go. Please review and do your homework better than me because you don't want to have to deal with this type of crap. So much for American made Companies around here.
Reviewed March 7, 2017
First American came with the house that I purchased in November. Submitting a claim was pretty easy to do. I called and told them about the problem and within minutes, they emailed me about the repair company that would come out to take a look at it and do the work. Then I called the repair company to find out what the repair schedule was and when they'd be able to make it out, and they were quick in coming out and doing the work. It was an air conditioning issue and the technician showed up, took off the cover for the air conditioner and looked through it, and he was able to find the issue and repair it on-site. The work that he did was good and he got the problem fixed. He was very knowledgeable with the scope of his work and explained how the air conditioner works.
Reviewed March 7, 2017
I was with American Home Shield and they were horrible. First American had good ratings and I got them for my home warranty. They're a good company and I'm very satisfied with the experience. Submitting a claim is very easy and the reps are very, very courteous. I submitted a claim then one company called and they did it the next day. I had an air conditioning and something in the plumbing company and they both are very good companies. The quality of the work was very good as well. I'm very satisfied.
Reviewed March 6, 2017
First American came as part of the sale of my house. The technicians do a good job once they get out of here and I'm pleased with them. However, when I submitted a claim for my ice making machine, I had some problems trying to get people understand what I was talking about because it's a commercial type of ice machine. Ice machines on ice boxes and refrigerators are a lot different than that. It took me a while to finally get through to the people at First American what I needed because they sent a couple of different stuff. Repair people would call me, I would tell them what I wanted, and they would say they can't work on my claim. I finally asked the lady to go back and look on the records and find the people that fixed the thing a couple years ago. They found their name and called them, and they came out and got it fixed.
Also, I'm getting concerned about the fees because when I started, it was around $49 per house call and now it's close to a $100. It's getting higher and higher every year. It's almost getting to the point where it may not be worthwhile having the insurance. Nevertheless, the service is good and I've had really good luck with them.
Reviewed March 6, 2017
Everything has been good with First American Home Warranty. We were with them for so long and they are the only home warranty we know about. There was no problem submitting a claim with them.
Reviewed March 5, 2017
First American Home Warranty makes policy cancellation so difficult that it seems that they increase revenue by strong-arming clients into continuing policies they no longer want. They have now failed to cancel my policy after requests have been made both in writing and by phone. I have requested policy cancellation via phone at least five times over several years and have been told each time by rude call center personnel that cancellation must be in writing. I was told during the first call that cancellation could be made via e-mail. Each representative told me that they did not have that e-mail address and would not go look it up. The e-mail address is not listed anywhere on their website. The last representative finally gave me the e-mail address.
I then made a formal request to cancel my policy. I received a computer generated confirmation that the request was received, but the policy has not been cancelled and I have received no further communication from First American. I made a second request in writing and have also not received a response from First American. They have been billing my credit card for several years during this debacle and threaten to send you to collections if you don't pay for the policy that they are refusing to cancel while justifying it by claiming that your request was somehow not made in an acceptable manner (no acceptable manner seems to exist). To me, this borders on fraud.
Additionally, First American sent a letter SIX MONTHS after a service call was placed, claiming that I had not paid the $65 co-payment. I confirmed via phone twice with the contractor that they have been paid. First American continued to claim that I did not pay the $65 and threatened to report me to the credit bureaus.
Being a VERY busy professional person, it was not worth my time to further dispute the issue, so I double paid. The $65 call now cost me $130. This also seems like a company that is gaining revenue in a crooked manner by capitalizing on the knowledge that consumers only have so much time to fight with them. This issue started as an honest mistake by the contractor, however First American is so bureaucratic and has such awful customer service that they will make no real attempt to correct a problem once it occurs. I would highly recommend using a different company for your home warranty needs-- one that actually has empowered customer service agents with whom you can communicate.
Reviewed March 5, 2017
A friend of mine at work had First American for a while, he had a couple of things happen and he was happy with how it all worked out. I decided to get one because I wanted insurance on the appliances. It's hard to work on stuff by yourself nowadays. I call when I submit claims but they also have the online option. I was on hold for a while but that's understandable and whoever I talked to, they were courteous and professional. One claim was during Christmas day, my wife was cooking, had the oven going and the house was a little warm but it wasn't too bad. I turned my air conditioner on and it wasn't working. I called them but the contractor they had never called me back and they weren't aware of it. Luckily, it wasn't in the middle of summer with 100 degrees outside.
So I ended up calling back and they sent somebody else. The guy that came out here that time was great. He arrived on the same day, looked it over to diagnose the problem and he had the part and got it working the next day. It was a good experience and it was convenient because he lives a few miles down the road from me. So it all turned out good. Except for that one little glitch, it was no problem and I'm very pleased. I'd recommend them to anybody and I'd stay with them.
Reviewed March 5, 2017
I submit claims to First American both online and over the phone. So far, I've been pleased with the service when I speak with their rep over the phone. Interactions with their technicians as well as the work they performed have been very good too.
Reviewed March 5, 2017
The biggest problem that I have with First American is the type of people that they hire to do the work. They’re sometimes not very dependable. The first one that I got, I had to have my furnace replaced. They worked on it off and on for two weeks and still had to finally get somebody else to finish it up. They were respectable but they weren’t knowledgeable about what they were doing or they were too busy. My apartment has not been fixed and it's taking two weeks to do it, which is not very good. Then when you call the technicians to tell them that they need to get back out here, they'll say “We’ll be there at a certain time,” and they may show up the next day.
Everything else has been fine, other than not having competent people that you can depend on to do what they’re supposed to do. I would recommend First American to anybody, but they need to critique their workers. Also, they tend to listen to you, but it’s awfully hard to get a hold of them sometimes. It takes a long time sitting on the phone to get a hold of somebody to talk to.
Reviewed March 4, 2017
We didn't want to buy a house and then have something big tear up on it. People have bad deals and we couldn't afford it. When we bought our house a couple of years ago, the seller offered a First American home warranty to us at closing and so we went with them. Since then, submitting a claim has been good and they've been nice to us. The technician who comes to our home introduces himself and the work he's performed has been pretty good.
Reviewed March 4, 2017
My husband and I used to sell real estate many years ago. We knew that First American was a very good company. It was really easy when we filed our first claim. We had a leak in the toilet and it had some kind of a special low-flow bladder in it. We got it with the house. The technicians who came were from Habit Plumbing. They were very nice and it was quick. They fixed the problem but they had to wait for a part so we had to pay twice for the service. Otherwise, we're very happy.
Reviewed March 3, 2017
When I bought my house, First American was part of the deal. Submitting a claim with them was very easy. Their claims representatives were courteous and able to answer all of our questions. And the work that their technician performed was up to snuff. Our experience went very smoothly.
Reviewed March 3, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American is pretty easy. I usually talk to a machine but talking with their claims representatives has been positive. I just go with it on the phone and they give their reply after you've told them what the problem is. Then they would address the claim to the appropriate contractor. Then that person calls you and then they come out and hopefully fix it. The last claim that we put in was from a month ago and it was a bad experience. The faucet in the laundry room wasn’t working. The guy that came over claimed to be a plumber. I didn’t believe him. When the fellow doesn't have the right wrench and I have to go look for my toolbox to find it, you begin wondering. He said that the faucet is no good and we have to get a new one. We wanted a faucet that swivels and at a certain height so that we could put a bowl underneath and wash it in our laundry sink.
A week later, he called me back and said that the company would only pay for the lowest grade, builder’s grade faucet for a laundry room. I offered to buy the faucet myself and let him install it and he agreed. Then First American called and they won’t pay for the upgrade. Although I can't imagine it being that much more expensive even though I was willing to pay the difference of what they allow on the faucet and what I was willing to pay for. I said to them, "Now, you have someone come out and to do it." They said, "No, we don't pay that one. We'll just give you a thousand and we're done with that claim.” So, I got another technician to install it at my expense.
Most of the claims come through and with a little pressure, they’re able to get the job done. Generally, we don’t have that many things that are much of an upgrade. This one happened to be a little above upgrade. I've had them for 12 years now and extend it each time it was time to renew. However, I'm going to be very careful about renewing next time.
Reviewed March 3, 2017
Our realtor booked our First American home warranty when we bought our house three years ago. Submitting a claim has been nothing short of great. I submitted claims twice over the phone and their representatives are a 10 out of 10. That's why I've renewed for two years in a row.
Reviewed March 2, 2017
Our First American home warranty came with the house we bought in Abilene, Texas and we had a lot of success with it. We were very dissatisfied with another home warranty company which came with our house here in Liberty Hill. We researched on what our copay is and what the home warranty will cover, especially on air conditioning. First American covers freon whereas a lot of other home warranty providers do not. So, we switched to First American this year. We've only had to do one claim and that was for garbage disposal. The technician company that came to my home was called Country Boys Plumbing. The guy showed up with a new unit and I paid him the $65 and everything was good. Since the repair, we've had no problem. I would recommend First American.
Reviewed March 2, 2017
We bought the house and my daughter, who's a realtor, insisted we buy homeowners warranty and we did that. We're very pleased with the first year we had with First American so, I renewed it again this year. I hope I'll keep on renewing it because it's much easier than me trying to fix things myself. Usually, for any problem I have, I submit claims by phone. The only problem I've had is when we had a clogged up line with our built-in vacuum system. The first people they've recommended to come out does electrical repair for motors. So when I called these guys, they said they're not the ones who should be coming out and they don't do things like that. And, First American didn't have anyone.
Then, I did some calling and found someone locally and I got a hold of them. I called back First American and told them about it and they said to have the service company come out. It was all taken care of and they did a great job of taking care of the problem. I've been very pleased. Sometimes you have to wait a week to get someone to come out but the people that do the work are sometimes pretty busy, too. You can't expect them to be out the next day. But they did as well as they can and those that they've set out, they're very professional.
Reviewed March 1, 2017
The seller bought the warranty when I paid for the home. I had good luck the first time I called the company and had quick resolution. The problem is the 30 year old Whirlpool tub I called about in Dec 2016. The timer doesn't work and there is a leak. I have had a plumber come out and he contacted the manufacturer. The parts to repair this tub are no longer made. The manufacturer and the plumber have said that it would be unsafe to try to retrofit the tub with new plumbing and mechanics as suggested by the warranty company. I have explained this to the 3rd representative and she closed my service request because they won't replace the tub. I understand that replacing the tub is not their cost but they should at least pay a portion of the cost for parts and labor.
I opened a new service request saying that this was not completed to my satisfaction or even an attempt at working this out. This is the last email I received. "Good afternoon, Unfortunately we will not cover a portion or the entire replacement of the tub. We will not continue with the claim at this point since it has been determine the entire tub needs to be replace. We will only reimburse for the tech's diagnose. You can submit that invoice for reimbursement. Thank you."
Reviewed March 1, 2017
We worked with Old Republic and weren’t really happy with their service. So we talked to a First American rep and decided to give them a try. Their reps are friendly and are able to answer questions the best they can. Submitting a claim online is very easy, simply select what's needed to be done and roughly what the problem is. After the appointment is set up, I hear from the technicians within 12 hours so that's pretty quick and they are very courteous.
The most recent claim we had was for our washing machine. I had told the technicians that I noticed a rattling sound in the high spin of the washing machine. They came and they tried to recreate that and were unable to get the machine to give enough high spin so they ordered a new motor control board and then we waited for a couple of weeks. We had to leave work to meet another technician to install that board. Still unable to get it into high-speed spin so they ordered the main control board. The same process was repeated but it still didn’t fix the problem.
Then they sent another tech out but he could not find any problem at all so they switched companies and sent them out. They were on call number four now. The tech said the cause could be the wire harness and they were going to replace it. The same process of waiting for the part to be delivered then setting up a fifth appointment and we’re about two months into this. They came out and said they couldn't get it to go into high spin. So they were just about to order a new motor when I talked to the claims rep, Irene and asked how much we are going to spend and we haven’t even gotten to the main problem I called in about because we can’t recreate it.
At that point in time, they‘d spent over $1,000 on parts. There were some issues with the fact that they’d switched vendors and they hadn’t combined the totals. So one vendor had ordered the motor control board and the main control board. The other group ordered the wiring harness. I told them they are well more than what the machine’s value is. We ended up purchasing another machine ourselves then eventually have them cover the check to reimburse us. It took a lot of time away from work for multiple services and at some point in time, they should have cut bait really well before the fifth service call. That is the first frustrating experience we’ve had with First American. But we’ve been very happy with the service. They’ve always been very responsive, easy to work with and they've been efficient so we’ll continue to use them.
Reviewed March 1, 2017
My wife wanted to get a home warranty to add security, so we had American Home Shield before and then we decided to try First American out. They started out really well, and I'm satisfied. I prefer calling them and placing a claim. The claim process is very easy, and they get in touch with me within 24-hours. Then they come and work depending on their schedule. Their representatives are friendly but they probably need to be more knowledgeable. They will tell me what is not covered, but if I ask them a little more in detail, then they don't know. The technicians do good work, and on my air conditioning system claim, I had a really good experience.
The only thing I have not been happy about is when the garage door technician came, he told me in a funny language that I need to pay a certain amount of money to add the hardware. And later on, I realized that the problem is that the people at First American need to be knowledgeable enough to tell me in detail why they are charging that. They just told me that it is a transfer fee, but then I figured out what it was. What happened was my garage door has two springs. One spring on the left side and another on the right side, and the technician who came converted it to one spring. So, they charged me $160 for conversion. If they told me upfront that he'd be doing a spring conversion, then I would have told them to find a technician who will give me the two-spring solution so I don't have to pay for the conversion. Other than that, everything is fine.
Reviewed March 1, 2017
The part (the pumper) that the tech put in doesn't seem to be that good of a model. The horsepower on it is the same as with what we had, but it makes a lot of noise. He got the job done, but we feel like a better product would do the job, as well as make less noise. Other than that, my experience with First American was pretty good, easy and simple. I still recommend them.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2017
My claim was initiated on February 21st, and I am still trying to get an electrician assigned to my claim that will actually call me back and schedule an appointment. You know that part on their website where First American says you will be contacted by the assigned contractor in 48 hours? Not in my case. After repeated calls and email from me to the contractor without any reply, I reached out again to First American. They continually ask me to "wait four more hours and we will contact you" each time I call them, to try to get this resolved. They have never returned my call or sent me the email as promised.
Each day I call back in on their customer service line, today it has been twice, and still they have not figured out how to resolve this problem. It appears they only have one electrician under contract in my city of 80,000+ people. When I asked if I could use my own electrician, they said yes, but the dollar amount limit for diagnosis was extremely low. I don't know of a single electrician who would come out for that amount. So, in theory, these home warranty policies might look good. In reality, the home sellers paid for a service that I am not able to use. Sounds a little like theft to me to collect money for something they can't deliver.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2017
I'm a home loaner and home warranty has always been requested or referred to us. I then acquired one and went with First American. It was easy submitting a claim with them and I always do it over the phone. I answer a couple of questions from the agent then they create the claim and things are emailed on who will be helping. Everything is smooth. The only thing is that sometimes we're talking about products that I know nothing about and I'll go ask questions and it's a little bit over my head. Other than that, the quality of work that's been performed by the technicians has been great.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2017
I got First American for a rental house I had because a friend had them and recommended them. I've been with them for about 15 years and I'm satisfied with their service. I call in to submit a claim and I'm usually contacted within 24 hours. Their claims representative listens to me and takes care of my claim. The last technician who came out was excellent and I gave him an outstanding rating. He diagnosed the problem, told me he had to order the part, and that he'd be back within 48 hours. He returned in 24 hours and fixed the problem. He also discovered something wrong with the door that I hadn't even noticed and so he did some preventive work for me by doing the repair. Generally, the work done with First American has always been satisfactory, and I haven't had to call them back out to redo it, so they're not wasting my time. That's important to me.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2017
I have had an issue with my heater since December 2016. As of today 2/27/2017 I still have had no reply instead I get the runaround and Natasha AVOIDING my calls and all she does is give me excuses. She's really good at sending you to her voicemail. This is one of the WORSE home warranty. DO NOT GET THIS home warranty. All they do is steal your money. If I could rate how bad they are I would. They don't even deserve a 1 star but I had no choice.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2017
I've been familiar with First American for a long time because I work for a title company. I knew the value of their warranty so I decided to go ahead and get one. My last claim was for my heater and everybody's been fabulous. The claim process was easy and the technician called me the next day. The customer service center was great, too. I would definitely recommend them.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2017
The reps at First American were courteous. However, a couple of years ago, a technician gave me a wrong diagnosis on an appliance and I never wanted them to come back. I told First American about it then someone else came and fixed it. Everything is going pretty good so far. As a matter of fact, I have a claim now and I'm waiting for them to bring me a new toilet.
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2017
I've been a customer of First American for 10 years or so. Service was always satisfactory, so I had no reason to change. My last claim was for a plumbing leak. I submitted over the phone and everything was fine with the rep. It was over the Christmas holiday and it was a pretty busy time but they got out right after the holiday and took care of it. The technicians were great and did a fantastic job. I didn't have any problems at all and the quality of the work performed was great.
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2017
I don't have a home warranty then and I needed one so I got First American. I'm really glad I did because a couple of months later, my refrigerator went out. It was really easy to submit a claim to them. I just called them and they set up everything. Their technician told me what the problem was and his work was nice and quick. It was excellent. They replaced it and gave me a new refrigerator.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2017
Our company uses First American so I know the rep. I also have access to the Republic and Fidelity. I went from owning and had First American to renting and then, I owned again so I have First American now for my home. I had Fidelity on a rental as it was what the landlord had and they're terrible as they sent me the biggest clowns. First American, I've always been happy.
Reviewed Feb. 24, 2017
I've had First American for many years. I bought this condo, and me being a female, it's hard for me to fix things so I thought it was a good idea to get a home warranty. I'm working on a claim right now for toilet stoppage and they were supposed to be there between 12:00 and 2:00 today, and they're not. I called the guy at 2:15. He said he'd call me back because he was on the line with the plumber. This one is not so good. This contractor seems like a little fly-by-nighty to me. But otherwise, I've had a great experience with First American. I've done two other claims and they had been good.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2017
When we purchased the house, First American was offered to us as part of the closing deal. So, we bought the package at that time. We had very good responses when we submitted our claims. In fact, most of our claims have been promptly handled. Some of them were a little bit longer than I would want but that had nothing to do with First American. So, it was all good and they came through for us. There was one time when a glass had blown out of our oven. It exploded and shut out the bottom of the oven and across the floor, and it took a while to get someone to come, get the replacement part, and replace it, but then once the technician came, then all was good. The quality of the work was good, and I like it. Overall, we've had good experiences with First American.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2017
I know how much appliances cost, so I decided to get a home warranty from First American. I called them to submit my claims and I didn’t have problems. The process was easy. When the technicians came out to do what they had to do, they did it right. For the first claim I had, First American sent someone out to turn my gas off. The guy who came out was nice. He did what he had to do and I was satisfied. Then, my heating unit wasn’t heating right, so they also sent somebody out. The quality of their work was good.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2017
I opened up 2 claims with First American and both of them took 3 business days for a first american claim specialist to contact me. This means I should live with the problem for 3 days just to get someone ready to help me? The claim specialist told me it will require minimum 2 business days to send someone. Claim # ** - This Claim they can arrange someone to schedule in 2 business days (5 business days since the inception of the problem and since the problem happened over the weekend - a total of 7 days).
Claim # ** - Their response was (regarding the septic system) - they don't have anyone in my area - so please go ahead and schedule someone and to my surprise - for this big of an issue - they will only reimburse me 65 dollars??? This was a blow under the belt. Why am I paying first american for 2 of my properties. Simply Ridiculous... This is a fraud company tricking Americans to buy policies with no real value.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2017
I bought a new house and purchased home warranty from First American. At first they would call me everyday to get their policy until I signed up, then I had an electrical problem in my house that they denied to cover. Their contractor showed up almost after 8 days after I placed the claim, so I cancelled them after they told that they won't cover. I had their top of the line policy that covered more than anyone would need. Their customer care people will also tell one thing one time and the other time you call.
Even after putting my cancellation, they charged my credit card and continued service till the end of next month. When I called in for refund, I was told that there will be no refund, as the end date on contract is showing to be the end of additional month they charged me. The supervisor I talked couldn't handle the questions I asked about cancellation and he went on mute and didn't even disconnect. Based in the experience I had I can clearly say this company is a sham. I would never recommend this company to anyone. If anyone ever needs a home warranty, buy anything other than First American. When buying warranty I noticed this company had little lower rating than the competitors. After being their customer, I would tell every future buyer, that this company doesn't even deserve a single star. The supervisor who went on mute was named Anthony. Now they completely wiped out my account details from their website as well.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2017
My daughter has First American insurance and I like the service she has so I went with them as well. My most recent claim was for our heater. I just called, made the appointment, and then they came. The interaction with the rep was good and fast. Now, the heater's working. I would recommend First American.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2017
I've had three claims with First American and it's been wonderful. When it came to renewal time, there was no doubt about whether or not we wanted to renew it. I called to submit a claim and expected the hoops and the BS but no, it's pretty easy and the rep was very helpful. I was asked what my problem was and my location as well to confirm that the provider would be nearby. In one case, the claims rep was having trouble finding someone to service a particular appliance. So she went out of her way to find someone. They had to come from Portland, so she coordinated that.
So, they got back to me and found someone to service my appliance quickly and I was very pleased. The technicians have been great, especially the guy that came to replace my water heater. He came out, diagnosed the problem, called to see if he could get the part. He left then came right back. He was done in a matter of hours. I expected it would be delayed or he'd have to reschedule but he took care of it the same day.
In another instance, the technicians were having a hard time figuring out exactly what the problem was with my stove. They made a repair and the stove was working, but then the problem reoccurred. They came out and sorted it out really quickly. They had the part shipped here, came in and out in no time.
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2017
When we were buying a house, the realtor suggested acquiring a home warranty. We looked around a little bit but several of her customers were very happy with the experience they had with First American so we went with them and have been their customer for more than 25 years. About three years ago, I needed someone to fix my dishwasher door. There’s a fee that I paid first upfront but the guy never came back and I did not pursue it. I’m still a little bit messed over that. But, at that time, I had a lot going on and I just couldn’t go with it. So, it was really my problem because I didn’t follow-up. The latest interaction I had with them was when a part on my pool pump went out. They came out and repaired it the same day. I’m very happy and I would recommend them.
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2017
We moved from Maryland and we had to find a new home warranty company. My husband called a bunch of companies trying to find out what they offered and their prices. First American offered more and their prices were better than everybody else. To submit a claim, I normally do it over the phone and the claims reps were very helpful. Then the contractor calls me, sets up an appointment, and they come out. The quality of work performed depends on the contractor but we've been having good luck so far. The last claim was for the garbage disposal and it's an easy process. The technician who came put everything in and told me how to maintain the garbage disposal and I had good interaction with them. I would recommend First American.
Reviewed Feb. 19, 2017
I had an issue with another home warranty company and was skeptical in trying FAHW. I tried them and in the summer my pool pump went down. I contacted them for repair and they couldn't find a contractor and said for me to find one. I was not reimbursed with my previous company when doing this so FAHW said they would find a company to direct bill them, and did.
On Jan 3, I contacted FAHW that my heater was going out and I needed a repair. They, AGAIN, couldn't find a repair person and told me to find one, but it had to fit a list of criteria they sent. I informed them that I was not comfortable with that and of the repair person required all their criteria, they should find them. Here we are over and month and a half later and the still don't have hot water. They seem no more willing to help me than they did in Jan. I have contacted them at least 10 times to get them to resolve the issue, but it seems no end is in sight. When I speak to them, I tell them over and over, all I want is simply the service from them I pay for, nothing more. At this time, I would NOT recommend this company to anyone. I have searched on the web for the corporate office to call, but is seems to be hidden pretty well. If they are such a great and reputable company, why is their corporate office number so difficult to find?
Reviewed Feb. 19, 2017
I've had First American for 6 years on my home. It came with the house and I stayed with them because of their good service. They even rendered perfect service in the most recent claim I had. Submitting a claim, both online and over the phone, is a pretty easy process. The claims rep was polite and the techs were very good. They were all professional. I'm very happy with the quality of the work they performed.
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2017
I was looking around to get insurance for my house. My cousin who has insurance with First American called me and said, “I have this company you can go with.” I said okay then I bought it for my house. I submitted a claim when there was a water leakage with the water heater. They came in so quick and looked into the house and then told me everything is okay. I asked, "So then, what's this leaking from?" The tech said, "Sometimes, the water heater shuts down, and sometimes, when you turn it on, some water spills down the water heater so that's no problem." The technician that came to my home is a good guy and he's okay. This is the first time I called First American and they did a good job. The water heater is working right now and it’s good.
Reviewed Feb. 17, 2017
I am VERY dissatisfied with this company. When my electric range stopped working, First American sent an electrician out to take a look. The electrician was unable to fix the problem without ordering a part. Because LG no longer makes my range and the parts are no longer available from the manufacturer, First American is bullying me into ordering a part for my range off of EBAY!!!! I personally looked the part up on EBAY, and it does not appear to be in good condition. This part could be from a junk yard, a pawn shop, or perhaps some high schooler's technical school project, and they want to install it in my home??? This puts me and my family at RISK.
I asked First American if they would help to cover this cost when my house catches on fire, and they responded that they are only responsible for parts covered by the contract. They clearly do not care about the safety of me or my family and only wish to take the cheapest route for themselves. I have been working my way up the chain of supervisors and have yet to receive a resolution. I refuse to allow First American to place potentially faulty and dangerous equipment in my home. I, and my family, will not be using this company in the future.
Hello Emily. We appreciate your feedback. Furthermore, we are aware that this matter has been resolved. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Feb. 17, 2017
Acquiring home warranty is very convenient and beneficial to maintain our old appliances and I decided to stay with First American because their website is convenient and their arrival time is not bad. I recently filed a claim for plumbing and it was easy. They responded quite quick and I had an appointment the next day after I raised the claim. Then, the technician arrived and he explained all the details and made sure to help if I have any difficulty in understanding the procedure. I had a good experience.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2017
When we bought our home, our agent signed us up with First American and our friend said it's a good service. I call them when I file claims and they usually let me know who's coming then they give us a call in 24 hours. Sometimes they are very accurate and they come on time. But sometimes it takes a couple of days for people to call us and it's a little bit late. But the technicians are good.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2017
Don't go with this home warranty. My water pipe to the fridge broke (lots of water damage in my kitchen). They send out a contractor who told me that they couldn't use the appropriate materials (rubber instead of copper) because the current one is copper. After 30 days another contractor came to refinish my floors and had to remove the fridge. However, he couldn't close the water completely (he told me because they used the incorrect materials). I called First American to see if they can fix the problem. They told me, because it is after 30 days they can't fix the problem... The issue is that it was never properly fixed because they didn't want to use the correct materials. Very bad service. I don't use them anymore as service is for me #1.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2017
We were told about First American by a friend of ours who works for another company doing the same thing. He told us that First American was a very good company to go with. Everything so far has been fine and we had two claims with them. One was for our refrigerator freezer and the other one was for the electrical problem we had. The claims process was very easy and their reps were all courteous and did a great job. The repairs have been good too. I couldn't expect more.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2017
We needed to get First American for our rental property so it'd be a bit less stressful for me while he was in Iraq. He called them, spoke with somebody and whatever they discussed made him go ahead and purchase the warranty. It's pretty simple to submit a claim with them. However, it's a little difficult sometimes to understand their reps when I'm talking to them because they're not from here. But everybody's pretty helpful and usually they're quick on dealing with the situation and helping out. The claims process is easy and First American is really on top of it. I've had a great experience so far and I haven't had an issue on everything that's been fixed on the home. I've recommended them many times to people and I talk very highly about them. In fact, my sister-in-law is looking into getting them for her house.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2017
GO FIND ANOTHER COMPANY. On their web site I tried to review them and give 1 star. However they will not post any bad review... so read below. I had a pipe break in my basement. I called and since it was a weekend, FA did not want to pay an overtime call for a plumber on a weekend. Therefore, it took 3 days before they found someone to come out. All local plumbers will not deal with this company. They had to call someone from out of town.
In the meantime I had 2 inches of water in my basement. There was carpet and paneling down there that was going to be damaged with the water just sitting there. I was able to contact a local company to pump the water out of the basement to minimize the damage. Now First American says they will not pay for the water remediation. That I should of left it for 3 days and then MAYBE their plumber would of taken care of it. If your policy do not specifically state what is covered, then it is excluded. I never got a copy of my policy. So beware.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2017
Little things do happen in the house and sometimes I don't have a whole lot of money to get them fixed, so I got a home warranty with First American. I submitted a claim and their customer service was great, very professional, and not ballsy or too demanding. The technicians were professional too and the quality of their work was great. They always called ahead of time to make sure someone was home. They had ID's and they always announced who they were when they came to the door.
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2017
My wife does most of the interaction with First American because I don't have a lot of patience to wait on hold. Whenever we have to make a second call they'd have no good communication about an earlier call, so we end up where there was confusion on which person or department on the other end at First American was involved in the claim. My wife finds their hold time to be a bit aggravating and their menu system to go through the automated call direction to be confusing and not have very appropriate options. But other than that, we have no problem when we finally get to talk to a real person and we have no problems with First American.
A technician from Appliance Guru came out for our microwave and he seemed competent. He concluded that a printed circuit board was bad, and he told his boss to put the circuit board on order. However, an appreciable period of time went by but we haven't heard from anybody. We told First American what was going on and they said they had no record that Appliance Guru has asked them to order that circuit board or that they have ordered the circuit board themselves; therefore, we wasted time. Either the boss at Appliance Guru dropped the ball completely or the technician never told him. I have no idea what caused the delay.
So we got a circuit board out to Appliance Guru and they scheduled an appointment, they came out and replaced the circuit board. The technician put it in then he turned the microwave on but it wouldn't work. It made a pop and then not even the clock would work. It seemed that whatever was originally wrong caused the first circuit board to go bad. But whenever they replaced the circuit board that didn't fix what was wrong. The technician went back and he said, "I'll report all this to the boss and we'll take care of it. We'll decide what the next best thing to do is."
First American then called me and said, "We've talked to Appliance Guru and we want to confirm that your problem was taken care of." I said, "If they told you the problem was taken care of, they lied to you because it still wasn't. More things are now wrong with the microwave than we started with the claim." I told First American that the technicians from Appliance Guru are incompetent and I never want them to be scheduled for our work again. I told them that one guy said, "We may have to replace the whole unit," but he was just the technician. Then First American told me that they'll send my complaint to First American's purchasing department and let them make the decision. They will replace my microwave next week.
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2017
We’ve been with First American Home Warranty for four years when we bought our house and it's 90-something years old. It was easy submitting a claim and it worked out well. We made a claim for our hot tub and the furnace. The reps we worked with were very pleasant, very knowledgeable. It usually takes 24 hours to get a call back from whoever First American send the claims out to. This last one that did the furnace, we heard back within three hours and they came out the same day. The quality of their work was very well done. I've recommended First American and I plan on keeping them.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American Home was very easy and smooth. Jimmy the contractor is fabulous. Every bit of interaction with him has been A+. He came when he said he was going to come. He contacted me by text message which was excellent for me and I responded. He’s always pleasant and he did exactly what he said he was going to do, and also did it expeditiously. I’ve never had anything but an excellent experience. The quality of work is one hundred percent great. I’ve recommended this company to everybody that I can think of. I mention it all the time and tell everybody they need to get one of these.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2017
Our First American warranty was given to us at closing when we purchased our home at no cost for a full year. We have submitted four claims and everything was good except for the last one which was in December. Our water heater went out so we had no hot water and when I called, the company they referred us to told us it would be five days before someone would come out. We couldn't do without hot water for that long so we cancelled the claim and just did it on our own. I understand when there are things that aren't emergencies that we have to wait but for something like heating, air conditioning or hot water, First American should have companies that are available 24/7. So that was a little disconcerting. But other than that, the technicians who came for our other claims have done excellent work for us. We've had great experience with them and the First American representatives. And we will renew even though we had that one bad experience.
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2017
When I called First American, they explained everything and it sounded like a good opportunity. However, when I submitted a claim for the pool equipment, I spent a lot of time on the phone waiting. But the technicians that came were nice. It took a lot to get the job done but they did it.
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2017
We were living in our other house and there was an issue that happened. And we couldn’t find that same insurance company that we had. Then a friend said that she really like First American so we went with them. Things are always very smooth with them. The people that I've spoken with are professional and they try to get back to me in a timely manner. They’re usually quite informative and detailed as to what the process is step by step, and it always lines up exactly as they said. They always send people who are clearly qualified for what they’re doing in the area.
We’ve always been very pleased with the technicians that come out and they’ve been friendly. We like the quality of work and I’m always very impressed with what we get. They know what they’re talking about and there's no need to send somebody else to follow up for them to do something. It's money well spent and we don’t feel like money’s being wasted.
The company that I used last time for the plumbing claim I had did not come out as soon as First American had said. But it was over the holidays, so I understand some things get backed up at times. When they came out, they were a very professional company as well. Everything went smoothly. It’s always been a wonderful experience and we usually tell our family and friends when they have issues to get homeowners insurance to go with First American because we always have luck with them.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2017
They will never call you back when they say they will. The earliest they can schedule contractors for you is 4 days after you call, even if you have an emergency. I managed to find my own contractor to come within 2 hours of calling. Not sure why FAHW wasn't able to do the same after 48 hours of back and forth with them. First American is incompetent, dishonest, and inexperienced. Don't waste your time or money on these ** amateurs.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2017
I filed a claim with First American and it was very easy. They came out and checked on an air conditioning unit. It was handled completely to my satisfaction and very quickly, too. The technicians were friendly, nice and prompt, as well.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2017
Our electrical outlet wasn’t working properly in the house. I submitted a claim to First American and it has been a good experience. I called and they sent out a certified repair service. The technician that came out was very satisfactory.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2017
From what I saw on the internet First American is a trustworthy company so I chose them. I go online and follow the prompt to submit a claim and that's an easy process. The claims rep I spoke with was very professional. But when I first called, they assigned it to Sears and they were two weeks out when I called and they can't expect someone to wait two weeks to get a washing machine fixed. When I said that's too long, they assigned me to another contractor who was horrible. I called and told First American they should never use them again. The guy stood me up after my wife waited all day long for him, then he texted us about 5:00 that evening and said he had car problems and couldn't get an internet or phone connection to give us a call, and said that he would be out the next day. I said okay but I told him he had to come before a specific time and I never heard from him again. I'm more upset that he didn't call to say, "I won't be there. I can't be there."
So, we went about a month without getting the service work done and that's not acceptable. I'm not happy at all with that process. When the technician that was representing Sears came out, the first guy, he tried to fix it and he thought he had fixed it, but he didn't. And then the next guy that came out replaced a part and it's been working fine. Overall, First American is fine and I've used them several times.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2017
I've been a homeowner for so long and I've been with First American for quite some time. And when I file a claim with them, it gets submitted. However, I’ve been having some concerns because of issues with my dishwasher. When it wasn't working and there was an error sign, I called First American and it was fixed. However, the error sign happened again and I called two months later and the guy came back again. Now it's broken again and the technician will be coming on Monday 'cause that's when I'm working from home. I will talk to the technician myself.
Another concern I have is when I was trying to speak to the gentleman that took my call, he couldn't really understand what I was trying to say to him. I understand though that sometimes they have a protocol to follow and there's a script that they need to do. He couldn't give me a straight answer and told me they were going to get a technician. I asked him what the next step was if the technician couldn't fix it but he couldn't give me an answer. This issue with my dishwasher happened four times and I'm frustrated. I can't use my dishwasher and I pay 60 bucks a month for the warranty. When I have to do it continually, then they could at least demonstrate to me that they're sorry and that they're a bit concerned. They could tell me that they would get to the bottom of it and speak with the technician to see what the problem is. And when the technician comes, I have to pay for that as well.
When the call dropped and I wasn't contacted, I called again and tried to speak with a representative. The lady who took my call was really rude. She says, "Look, how many times have we been here? This person just called me and told me that they've already been to your house seven times." I told her that I was only trying to get this resolved. But she started asking me like she was interrogating me about when the person was there and what they did. I told her that I was the customer and was only trying to see if I could get someone to come and fix the dishwasher. If they can't fix it then they should let me know what else we can do to resolve this matter. We're paying a service and something has to get done. The last tech who said he fixed the dishwasher told us to use it continually like three times a week. We did that but the same issue happened. Hopefully, they could fix this by Monday when the technician comes.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2017
Maintenance and repair costs led us to look into getting a home warranty. My son did some comparative shopping and First American had the best rates and program as far as what they would cover. On the whole, they've been professional and excellent. When submitting a claim, we call in and they assign a contractor or a service to us. Those people call, arrange for a visit, and come out. And if the situation couldn't be repaired, then since they have to order a part, they inform us of what that part is and when it is going to be here. As soon as it's here, they come back out and replace it. The claims representatives are very polite and businesslike, to the point, and they try very hard to please. We've never had any problem with them. The technicians are good people, real friendly, professional, very polite, and very careful about what they do as far as rearranging something or having to get something out of the way.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2017
Submitting a claim to First American is very easy and their reps are very courteous and very helpful. I've been with the company for many years and I have yet to deal with a technician that's not first class. They've replaced or repaired just about everything in my house and I've never had a problem. They're a first class company.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2017
I was with American Home Shield and I got disgusted with them. So, I went through the internet and looked for a home program for protection. Then I decided to try First American. Around December 31st at 6:00 at night, the water was coming out of the water heater. There was a pipe broken and we had to turn the water off through the whole house. I called them up fo file a claim. I asked the representative if he could recommend a plumber as it was an emergency. He called three plumbers then he gave me names of plumbers that I could call. But they couldn't come out that night because it was a holiday weekend. So we had to call another plumber and he did the job. I called them back to see if I could get reimbursed and they said no because they didn't authorize me. I wasn't too happy with the $300 charge but that's part of life. It was okay and we had hot water that same evening so there was no problem.
Then I called them the second time for another problem with the heater and they took care of it right away with no problems. The person that answered the phone knew what he was doing. I'm satisfied so far with them. It's a very good feeling to know that they have competent people to do the work that you request and that's the most important.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2017
In the last eight years, there were a couple of times that I thought about switching, but I don't think there's anything better than First American so I couldn't really do any switch. In the beginning it's been a struggle finding the right service person. They would put me to some people that wouldn't even return my calls and make appointments. Also, their process was a little slow but it seems easier now to do things with them. They've established some people to take care of the client so it’s been better. I'm happy now and I might have several people signing up for it really soon.
I've got three properties before with First American. Now, I have two properties under them. I have one house in North Carolina which is getting older and getting more service done, and one here in South Carolina. I'm quite pleased with the people that they send in. The technician from Sears service center has been really good and I'm glad that he came the second time because I had problems with my dryer and he fixed it at the same day. He's the same person that checked my washer and I was pleased to see him because he would put towels on top of my counter and small things like that. He's been very courteous and professional, as well as the people that they called to do my air-conditioning. They would put shoe cover and things like we never really pay attention to, but it's quite nice to see those kind of people going to my house.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2017
We bought a condo almost three years ago and First American Home Warranty was included in the paperwork. We've had about four claims and had no problems with any of the technicians that came. One of the claims was for a new dishwasher that was in the condo when we got it. It wouldn't run. So we got a guy come out here and he had to come out at least six different times to fix the problem. They had to order the part but got the wrong one. It didn't bother me but it would have been cheaper to put a new dishwasher in here than to have the expense of all the repairs that was done on it. But other than that, I haven't had any problems with anything.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2017
I’ve been with First American for years now and they do a great job in most instances. I call them on the phone to file a claim and the process is fairly easy. You go through all the information first and once you’re through with that, then you describe what your initial problem is and they’ll tell you they’ll get back to you with a contractor. That could be on the same working day or the next day. Typically, it’s on the same day. Their technicians have been fine and have been pretty competent.
Sometimes, though, they encounter something they weren’t counting on and that changes the complexity of the job. Recently, they had to come back. Also, someone from First American called me yesterday and asked me when we wanted to schedule to get our garbage disposal fixed. But I put that claim on the website two weeks ago and I took care of it myself so I don't know what happened. Otherwise, my experience with First American has been great that’s why I keep renewing them.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2017
We've committed three claims and everything has been taken cared of ASAP. The technicians that First American sent out have been fine, especially the guy who came with the pool. The other guy who put a fuse in my drier wasn't here that long but he took care of the problem. They're very professional. We're happy with our experience and would recommend First American Home Warranty.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2017
First American Home Buyers Protections' claims process was real good. I've called their customer service before and they've been great with me. Their technicians were wonderful too. I'd recommend them to a friend.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2017
We purchased a new house and had to have a home warranty, and the mortgage company we purchased our house from suggested that we go with First American. The claims process was easy. I called by phone and the claims representative was courteous and professional. The technicians came out really quick the next day, assessed the problem, and made a suggestion. They did the plumbing that they needed to do and the work was done very well. First American paid the claim out really quick. We've had a good experience so we're not changing our home warranty insurance, we'll be keeping it.
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2017
I renewed my warranty with First American so in case I have any problems and if something breaks down, I can call them to come out and fix it. Whenever I submit a claim, they have somebody call me and give me a definite time when the tech is going to come out. So far, the fixes that have been done were good. I haven't had any problems about it. It's a good experience as long as they get the work done in a timely fashion.
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2017
We got First American through the escrow closing purchase of the house. Filing a claim to them was excellent. My house started smelling like gas and I thought there was going to be an explosion and we had to call the fire department. When we turned everything off and the gas smell went away, I went online and submitted a claim at one o'clock in the morning on the day of the big storm for the heating and air conditioning unit 'cause it was 39 degrees. It was Christmas Eve, so I didn't hear from anybody 'til Monday.
I got a phone call to make an appointment and they said they weren't going to be able to come up for another two weeks. But somehow, within half an hour they called me back and they said they had an opening. The guy came out and said my air-conditioning and heating unit was cracked in half and it was filled with water on top of the roof. He submitted the claim to First American, and four days later on Thursday morning, I had the truck and the crane, and a brand new air conditioning and heating unit was installed. It was incredible.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2017
It was easy to submit a claim to them and their reps were very helpful. Their technicians have all been good too, and when we had a bad experience with a person assigned to us, their customer service reps assigned us to someone else. All in all, it's been a great experience.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2017
I’ve been using First American for over five years and I have two policies with them. I have submitted claims on my dishwasher, air conditioner, and most recently for an electrical problem and my hot water heater. I've never had a problem with them other than a little issue with the scheduling of the company they used for the electrical problem as opposed to the issue getting fixed and it angered me.
First American used R&R Electric. The first time they called, I said that I'd really like to make an appointment on a time when my husband was gonna be home. They said they’d come on a Saturday morning and I said that would be great because my husband would be here at home. They said they’d give me a call first. So, their guy came and dealt with my husband.
However, on the second time when I had to do the recall, I called First American to set it up. R&R called me at 6:30 in the evening and said they’d be here the following day between 8:00 and 12:00. I said, "Tomorrow's not good for me because I work that evening." I only work three evenings a week, so there are days when it's easier for me to get up early. I asked if I can schedule it another day or a day the following week since the issue was not critical. It was a hallway upper light that just flicks on and off by itself, but we have other lights so we can still see. The rep said, "No. I can call you the day before we have our next opening in your area." I said, "You mean I can't say two weeks from now? I can't say in the future ‘will you come on this day?’" She said, “No.”
First off, if you work Monday through Friday and need to have a workman come to your house, you know you're gonna have to take off work. However, most people's jobs, unless you lie and call in sick, you would pre-schedule something like that. Like me, I was a nursing supervisor. With the job I do right now, I work weird hours. I also work from home and I can be at home in the morning, but I don't necessarily wanna get up at 8:00 AM because that's the middle of my night. So, I'm not gonna schedule the visit of the technician on the day when I know I have my every two weeks team meeting. I'll live without whatever the issue is so that I can be home. You should be able to schedule your own appointment within reason to be convenient for your schedule.
So, I called First American and talked to a guy and he bumped me up to a supervisor right away 'cause I said, "Is this what First American does? Honestly, I've never had this problem. If this is a reflection of the companies that you're using now, I'm gonna have to go look someplace else because at this day and age, people work and you have to give the customer some flexibility in scheduling. If I don't take the appointment your 8:00 to 12:00 appointment tomorrow, I have no idea. You're gonna call me another evening at 6:30 when the guy is in my area and you're gonna tell me that I have to stay home at 8:00 AM."
Anyhow, I took the appointment because I didn't have a choice. I asked the rep if the electrician’s gonna call because they have to call to wake me up because I may not hear the doorbell in the bedroom. The rep said no problem but then she goes, "Well, it won't be 8:00 anyhow." A second ago, she was telling me 8:00 to 12:00. Now, it won't be that early anyhow? So, why didn’t she tell me 9:00 or 10:00 to 12:00? And then I'd set my alarm and get up at 9:30.
It just was a luck-out that I happen to wake up and had gone to the bathroom around 9:30. Normally, I would go back to bed. I had just fallen back to sleep from going to the bathroom but my doorbell rang. I had on a pair of underpants and a t-shirt and had to grab a pair of pants. I told the technician that he was supposed to call first but he looked at me and kept walking in the house. He was about as pleasant as nothing when he walked in the door.
First American said that if I ever have an electrical problem again, they're putting it in my file that they're taking it to a different electric company. I said that FirstAm should use a different electric company for everyone. They should either renegotiate their contract with R&R. If that's their attitude, FirstAm should be done with them. I said, "I live in the Miami, Fort Lauderdale area. You can drive from West Palm Beach down to the Keys and it's like 60, 70 miles of non-stop city. I'm gonna guess there is another electric company somewhere in that 60 miles you could use in the area other than this Orlando-based company."
But at the same time I had this electrical problem, at my other house apparently, my three-year-old hot water heater had a crack in the bottom. Unlike R&R, The company who came for it gave me some windows and some flexibility in scheduling when they could come back 'cause I had to work around my son's school schedule. He cannot skip going to school but he doesn’t have school on Fridays. The company was able to schedule the visit on a Friday and gave me an afternoon appointment. R&R’s rep and company policy suck, but I’ve told people about First American.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2017
I've had First American on and off for a long time. We have a place in the valley and another one up in the mountain where no other warranty company covers so First American was our choice. When I first started, they didn’t use local vendors. We had one contractor that came up here. We're on granite and it was a plumbing issue. If a vendor does not know the area, they wouldn’t know how water would react. They sent somebody up from the valley and he could not find the leak. He was going to charge us $5,000 to bring some equipment here and another $5,000 an hour to use the equipment.
Luckily, we were having some work done on the roof and the guy happened to be a plumber. He said, “Tell him to leave. I will find it.” It just cost me $50 to get it fixed. That’s why I'm so happy now that we have local contractors. They're very nice but because of where we're located, if something goes out, it might take a couple of days to get the part, but that’s okay.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2017
My husband and I filed a claim last weekend when our heater went out. We called First American's preferred contractor and they didn't have any appointments for 4 days, and they were located close to two hours from our home. We expressed our concern to First American, especially since the overnight temperature had been in the 30s and we have an infant in the house. We asked if we could use our HVAC contact because we had had a similar situation. They told us they would get back to us. We never heard back and we went ahead with our own repairs, and now they won't pay for the claim. Every time we've needed to call them we've gotten the run around and it's been more of a headache than any peace of mind that was promised during the purchase of our home. There's got to be a better company out there because First American should be called Last Resort Warranty Company.
First American Home Warranty Company Information
- Company Name:
- First American Home Warranty
- Year Founded:
- 1984
- City:
- Santa Rosa
- State/Province:
- CA
- Website:
- homewarranty.firstam.com
Media


