First American Home Warranty Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+3 more
About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 35 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.
- HVAC tuneup
- No age limit on appliances
- Can pick your service call fee
- Not available in all states
First American Home Warranty Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (4,626)
- (1,076)
- (490)
- (322)
- (2,416)
Popular Mentions
- 4,880,395 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,880,395 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2015
My wife had a protection plan through First American before I married her. I have a rental property and I've dealt with home warranties before, and they're kind of helpful. I've always been taken care of. I've had a good experience every time I've dealt with them.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2015
The home warranty company that we had before went bankrupt and our daughter told us about First American. The only problem when I submitted a claim was it was at Christmastime and the parts didn't arrive quickly. But it was taken care of and the service was great. They took care of things, made the phone calls and made arrangements.
We appreciate your feedback, Fred.
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2015
When we purchased the house, it was under warranty with First American. Their customer service is always friendly and willing to help in any way I need them. Great service and keep up the great work.
We will, Jenna!
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2015
First American has been in the family for a while now. I'm a realtor and their vendor handles our real estate office and that's how I found about it. I recently filed a claim for plumbing of our pool motor. The company immediately called afterwards and came over, made an appointment and checked it out. They got the part within a week or so and fixed it. The company was very good and courteous. They presented themselves and let me know when they left. It was a very, very good experience.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, John.
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2015
I chose First American because of their reputation for covering things that a lot of others refuse to, even though they advertise that they cover it. I've submitted two claims with them. The first one was horrific and the second a breeze. The first one took about five weeks to resolve. Everyone wanted to argue and dispute everything. I ended up having to contact the hotline to the office of the president, left a message, and a young lady called me back shortly after I left my message and walked me through the process and got it all taken care of. On this one, it was just combative but once she got on the phone, it was just days later that the process moved forward and was just a matter of waiting on the parts to come in and it was done. My second claim happened in the winter. It was our hot water heater that literally busted so we had no water at all. The next day, they had someone out and had it repaired. It was awesome. I went from awful to awesome.
Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback, Robert.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2015
Our home insurance broker bought First American for our home. I've renewed my warranty since I've had a favorable experience with them.
Thanks, Linda!
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2015
It was recommended by our realtor when we were buying our home. First American has always been good. The representatives are always friendly and helpful. Whenever we have something broken, it gets fixed quickly.
Great to hear, Stephanie.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2015
We called and they were very attentive to everything that we needed. Their claims representatives were very professional. Within 10 or 20 minutes, they were able to set us up and get somebody on their way out to fix our air conditioning.
Thank you for your feedback, Shane.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2015
When I bought my house, First American was included and overall, I had a good experience with them. I've never had any issues and every time that I call, they tell me that somebody's going to call within 24 hours and they always do get somebody scheduled. It's hard for me to actually schedule their work because I work 7:00 AM to 5:00 PM. But whoever they send out always works around it one way or another. It was great and everybody had just been real friendly and easy to deal with. I'll recommend them.
Thank you for recommending us, Jeffry.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2015
Our initial contact with First American for service was on 12/30, after our furnace shutdown in the middle of a cold night. The furnace will restart after turning off the power and then turning it back on. I was provided with the name of the contractor by First American, who after a call responded quickly. The technician arrived unkempt, dirty, and with wet shoes walked across our light-colored floors and carpet to get to the furnace in the garage while carrying his tools in a cutoff plastic milk carton. This was a big clue on what was to subsequently happen. After spending considerable time reading our furnace manual, he spent about two hours troubleshooting the problem.
After several trial runs and tests, he determined that the furnace controller had a bad circuit board. He installed a jumper wire to defeat the separate temperature control for the second floor of our house. He then added that we should not use the temperature setback feature of the control. Both of these actions will increase our energy costs. The technician then wrote his report concerning the controller board and left. At this time the furnace continues to shutdown intermittently about twice a week.
I contacted the contractor several days later to check on the report status to see when the repair would be done. They had submitted the information twice to First American and were waiting for approval. Subsequent telephone contact with both the contractor and First American did not indicate any report at First American until 1/27.
On 1/27 First American notified me ON THE WEB (!!!) that the repair request had been denied and closed! If I had not been checking the web daily I would not have known of the rejection. They said the rejection was because of the furnace zone control is not covered in the contract. The control system was installed when the house was built to minimize energy costs. I called First American later that day, after talking to two other people I was routed to MIKE who "curtly" stated that under the contract limits of liability, paragraph #5, the zone controls are not covered and the issue was closed. I pointed out to him that my contract paragraph #5 states and covers solar systems and their controls. The warranty sections on Gas Heating and Air Conditioning make absolutely no mention concerning zone controls.
I pointed out to him the house was built with and for these controls. Mike rather rudely stated that paragraph #5 does include the furnace, and even if it does not mention the furnace it still applies. Astoundingly he then said First American can interpret or change the paragraph to fit their needs. This concerns me because it indicates to me that their contracts are not worth the paper they are written on!
My conclusion first to all of this is that First American uses the cheapest contractor, with questionable technical ability and they will go to no end to keep from paying large repair expenses. I will relate to my realtor friend how my experience unfolded, question their use of First American if they want to avoid complaints from their customers. This is by far the worst warranty company I have ever dealt with, including cars, tires, appliances, consumer electronics and home improvements.
Currently I am left with no option, if the troubleshooter was right, but to incur the repair cost myself as the furnace continues to shutdown! NOTE: We paid for the warranty at the closing of the home purchase on 8/26, but did not receive a copy of my warranty until mid-January and then only after calling or messaging First American three times.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2015
I filed a claim with First American on New Year’s Day and thought it would be a little bit more of a hassle but it turned out to be fairly easy. They’re open 24/7 and after I got off the phone, a technician gave me a call within an hour. The timely manner was the best thing and that’s as good as it could get. The claims representative was great and she was able to answer everything that I asked about my home warranty. In the end, very satisfied!
We appreciate your business, Jesse.
Reviewed Feb. 10, 2015
We've had First American coverage for almost 10 years now. I've been with them since I bought the house and I don't think there was anybody else in our area we could've chosen at that time. Submitting a claim to them has been excellent. We haven't had any problems. We called them. They called out whatever contractor we needed and it was always fixed in a reasonable amount of time.
Our experience with this company has always been good. I think the only problem we had was in the first couple of years was they didn’t have coverage in our area anymore so we had to go through another agency or insurance company. Then they offered it back again a couple of years later and then I signed back with them again.
Thank you for being a loyal customer, Fredrick.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2015
I heard about First American from my son and daughter-in-law five years ago when I moved to Memphis and I've been with them ever since. They told me it was very good since they had it themselves and they were happy with it. I've had a wonderful experience with them ever since. I've had a number of claims, and not in the same year. But this year I've had two claims and I've had an excellent experience. Once in a while I have a claims representative that doesn't speak English really well but other than that, I don't have any complaints. I really don't have a complaint about that but I have to ask them to repeat. It's kind of embarrassing to me. They help me and I have no bad experiences with them.
Glad to hear it, Amy.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2015
My realtor suggested I acquire a home warranty and recommended First American. When I submit a claim, they send somebody out. I pay the $60.00. They look at the problem, they call, fix it and it's all fixed. They've been good to me. Everything has been a good, positive experience. I'd recommend them to anybody.
Thanks for recommending us, Barry.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2015
It was five or six years ago when I heard about First American Home Buyers Protection. I chose them because the lady that I've talked to when I first joined up was really knowledgeable and helped me out what I wanted so that's why I went with it. There's only been one time that I've been displeased with them. That was this last time. I needed an emergency thing because there's no heat in the house and it took them five days to get somebody out there to even look at it. But it wasn't their fault. Two claim representatives came. The first one wasn't very helpful or courteous, but the second one was. The second one was able to answer all of my questions. That was the only bad experience I've ever had with them. I always tell everybody to go with First American.
Thank you for your loyal business, Michael.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2015
I learned about home warranties from my brother who worked for a home warranty company. I decided to get one but I didn't want to go with that company because of what I knew about them from the inside. I did my homework and it came down to two but I decided to go with First American. I've been pretty happy with them. I can submit my claim online but I mostly just call. I got it on speed dial. It has been pretty good although I have had a couple issues where people came and temporarily fixed the problem but not 100 percent fixed it. That’s with the shower but other than that whoever they sent have all been really good and they've spoken well about First American which I can't say about other companies. My experience with them has been overwhelmingly positive.
Thank you for taking the time to leave your comments, Mark.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2015
I was using another company that I wasn't happy with and First American was recommended so that's what I have today. Submitting a claim to them wasn't bad. Initially it took a while to get it resolved but everything eventually did. There's no problem with the claims reps at all. There was a time we had a problem with our well over a weekend and it took a while to get the contractor out here. It could have been done a little bit quicker but I was happy with the end result.
Thank you for your feedback, Steven.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2015
Don't want to ever do business with these fools again! This is a BS service. DO NOT BUY this. It's a utter waste of your money. Every time they charge $65 for a visit even if they do not touch your electrical. Their replacement electrical parts is of very inferior quality as well. I just hate them and I was so annoyed that I wasted my money on them.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2015
The real estate agent introduced me to First American and their reputation got me sold. The home I had in D.C. had another home warranty company and I couldn't use my old provider anymore because the house I bought wasn't brand new. I figured it was okay to try First American because I haven't heard anything bad about them. It's a good experience to submit a claim. I just make a phone call, somebody comes, they fix it and we're done. Talking to the claims representative was very easy too. They asked questions and knew exactly what the issue was, which made it easy for them to make the contact to someone.
Thanks, Ronald.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2015
I first heard about First American from my family in Florida. Submitting a claim to them was very easy. The experience was good. I like to call a live person. I'd recommend them.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, Nadia.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2015
A real estate person mentioned First American to me and since getting them, they've been great for us. Everybody was very courteous and prompt. They send out good people to take care of our problem. I can't complain.
Thank you for your business, Betty.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2015
It was 2007 when I first heard about First American. The first time I used them, our AC went out. And they came and they had a whale of a time at finding the parts for the compressor outside. It took about two months to have it fixed. I called them up, and they gave me permission to go buy a window unit AC worth $200 so I could stay cool in the middle of the summer until they could get it fixed, and they got it fixed. And that was fine. It took them time to find the unit, find the compressor.
Another time I called them is when my wife's kitchen stove went out, and they came in. It was Sears. They subletted it to Sears because it was a Frigidaire. He came in and fixed it. Then, about four or five months later, it did it again. My biggest peeve was they only carry a 30-day warranty on the work. So I was out to $65 or whatever it is that I had to pay and to consider calling them again. I said, "No, I'm not going to call them again and do it again." So I took the stove apart and fixed it. I have the know-how, I just didn't have the time. But I fixed the stove and it stayed fixed.
And then, my furnace went out for the third time, no heat this winter. And it gets pretty darn cold in the house when it goes out. So I put in a claim, and the people came out and had to work on it, had to order a part. They did good work. I was pleased. They made the system work to the point where I could have some heat, and then I turned it off. And they came back and they fixed it all up. And then, it all worked properly. I was pleased with that service.
Now, I got an automatic dishwasher that is hung on rinse. It's electronic, it's digital. You pushed the buttons. And I've been a little slow to call that in because its going to cost me $65 or whatever. And I really don't have the time to study it, but if I have to, or I'll replace the whole dishwasher. I may have to go in my shelves and work the electronic touch button controls. So that's my history.
With our experience with them, other than the 30-day warranty, it's frustrating if it reoccurs. Now, these situations with with the AC unit and with the heater, that's a fixed thing. On the other hand, the furnace has two situations. And when I tried to use the heat after they fixed it one time and some time had elapsed because I had been in Roda, Spain. And when I got back, I tried to turn the heater of the furnace on for heat and it wouldn't come on. So then, I had to call back the second time. Now, that's a double dose of $65, 30-day warranty. Well, the people did their job. I can't say they didn't. It's just the circumstances.
We appreciate your continued business, Paul.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2015
Emergency Plumbing & Rooter was the contractor selected by First American Home Buyers Protection Corporation to address my claim about a problem with the water heater. A repairman showed up the same day (approx. 6 hours after they were notified) and the repairman determined that a new part needed to be ordered. I spoke with their office and I was told the part was ordered to be delivered next day. The parts didn't show up, so I called the contractor's office to request a tracking number. I was not called back.
The part arrived two days after the part was claimed to have been ordered. I called to schedule a same day install due to the fact that the house was now without hot running water for four days. The person I spoke to at the office stated they were too busy and couldn't have a tech available until the following morning, which was a Saturday. I requested same day due to the nature of the emergency and she stated this wasn't considered an emergency. I then contacted First American to request that the claim be reassigned so I could get hot running water as soon as possible since the replacement part was in my possession and was told no, and the representative I spoke with also confirmed the "guaranteed" time with no other options for expedited resolution.
The tech did not arrive as "guaranteed" for the Saturday repair. I called First American and addressed this with a representative and she contacted the contractor. After 15 minutes of trying to reach them, she finally heard from them and their only reply was that the tech was running late, and no attempts were made to notify me of this by the contractor or their tech. First American would not seek any other means of resolution since "the contractor already inspected the unit and ordered the part, so they need to complete the service".
Hi Robert. Thank you for your feedback. Per our phone conversation on Thursday, your claim has been resolved. Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2015
My wife was the one that got First American. Submitting claims to them was relatively easy. I called and put in a claim, and it said a provider will call me within the next hour or so, and they called me to schedule an appointment. The person on the line was friendly and she answered all my questions. It was a pretty fast service.
Thanks, Bora.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2015
I heard about First American when I bought my home in Florida in 2009 and I immediately bought a policy. I had that policy. I sold it. I sold my house in 2013 and moved to California and I bought another house in California in 2014 and I said, "Hey, I need this." So I bought another policy with First American and I enjoy it.
They give excellent service. I am very thrilled with the response time. In Florida, I made one claim against the insurance on my dryer. They immediately came out, repaired my dryer. Everybody was happy, cleaned up the mess, and away they went. Then here in California, I had an attic vent fan that went out and I had an electrical problem. Some of my switches weren't working. The technician showed up at his schedule, right on time. He spent an hour and I went up the attic. I came back down and he said that he couldn't repair. He had to replace it so they went back to shop, got another unit, came in for the brand new unit. I'm just tickled but I was so happy with it.
I told my son about it. He has since bought a policy. He told his neighbors about it. Both neighbors are in his city and bought the First American Home. So everybody is happy.
We're happy that you're happy, Richard.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2015
I got First American through my real estate agent. I hated the other one that she wanted and I said no. It was a very nice experience submitting claims. I had submitted two claims before. One, it was my fault cause I left the ice and there was water in my garage. I thought I had a leak in the wall and submitted that claim. Then I saw the bag of ice and called them up and said, “There’s nothing wrong with the house and you can cancel that one.” The other one, we had a clogged toilet. I had to call a plumber and they took care of it. They were very professional and very timely. I called them the night before and the next day, the guy was here to fix the problem. I enjoyed the whole thing and they did a great job.
Thank you for your feedback, Robert.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2015
I looked up First American online. I was just going over the comments and what other people rated, and when I purchased it submitting a claim was fast and convenient. During my first call the person that I spoke to was very nice and patient on explaining everything to me.
We appreciate your business, Miriam.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2015
It seemed like I got better coverage for the dollars I would spend. I get on their website and submit a claim online. They email me back and tell me that they have received it and give us the name of the contractor that they used. And they have 24-48 hours in order to get back to me.
Thank you for your comments, Frank.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2015
We've had nothing but excellent experience with the times that we've had to make claims with First American. The most recent experience we had was when we had the problem with our gas stove. It was an older unit and they sent a repair person out to evaluate it. Basically, they did the search to see if they could find the parts, but the actual product is no longer being manufactured. There were no parts to fix it and there was absolutely zero question about replacing the unit. There was no push-back on that. It was a seamless thing. I was very, very pleased with how quickly and how easy it was to get that resolved.
Glad to hear it, Albert.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2015
We bought our house and knew that we needed a home warranty right then. Our mortgage lender told us that First American was very reliable. Submitting a claim was very easy and if I have to talk to someone personally, they're very nice and get things done. They've also been able to answer anything I asked.
Glad to hear it, James.
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2015
We made a claim with First American under our home warranty insurance for the repair of our heating furnace. When they assigned us a contractor, I researched them online and found terrible reviews on Yelp. I raised my concerns with First American, but was assured they only used reputable contractors who are vetted carefully.
The contractor came to inspect the furnace and diagnosed a faulty motor. I called the contractor the next day and was advised the part had been ordered and would take 3 to 5 business days to arrive. They told me they would ring me the day the part arrived to arrange fitting for the next day. After 3 business days and no phone call, I chased up the contractor and was told they couldn't give me any estimate on the part's arrival - they had no tracking, no drop date, no information. I called on the 4th, 5th and 6th business days and was told the same. On the 5th day, I rang First American to express our frustration with the contractor. First American made enquiries with the contractor who advised them the part would arrive 'any day.'
Eventually on the afternoon of the 6th day, the contractor called to say that the part would arrive and be fitted the following Monday. The contractor did arrive on the Monday with a sealed package containing the new motor. When he opened the package we saw on the delivery note that the part wasn't ordered when they told us it had been - it was ordered 5 days later. Worse still, when the contractor removed the motor, it wasn't faulty - a dead bird was inside the motor preventing it from working. By this point we'd been without heat for 13 days during a particularly cold period, waiting for a part we never even needed.
During the 13 days we were without heating, we were freezing. In addition, we were incredibly frustrated with the way the contractor and First American dealt with our claim. The only information we were given about the part's delivery date was untrue - it was such a stressful experience. At the end of this process we are left with a huge energy bill - more than $200 above average because we had to use space heaters for an extended period.
I have complained to First American and asked for compensation for our energy costs which arose because of their contractor's negligence. I have been advised that they don't compensate customers in that manner - they are not responsible for any loss resulting from their own or their contractor's actions. We were gifted our home warranty insurance by our realtors. It goes without saying - we will not be renewing it!
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2015
I was with another home warranty company before but I didn't like the people I had. Their coverage had gone down over the years. When I had an event where they wouldn't repair something, I just thought, what the heck, I don't need that. I found First American in the internet, and it's been great. We've had two claims already and they've been first class service. I like both of the repair people. They were a pleasure to work with and I would recommend First American.
Thanks for recommending us, Raymond.
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2015
First American came with the house. My ex-husband bought the house for my daughter and we live here. He lives in Germany, so we knew we would need it... I had a problem with our furnace. They were very prompt and solved my problem. Submitting the claim was easy and fast and the claims rep was good.
Thank you for your comments, Debbie.
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2015
We were dissatisfied because it took over a month to resolve the issues with the Washing Machine. Often in the process we did not know what was happening and this with the time compounded the situation for us. We had had previous experiences with 1st American and they had been good. We have been a customer for 7-7 years.
Hi J Michael. We appreciate your feedback and we are glad to have brought a resolution to your claim. Thank you.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
Great service. First American was part of the warranty when I purchased the home. I previously had another company, but they offered more coverage. There's no hassle in submitting claims. Their customer service person is pretty helpful. It was a good experience, good company. I haven't had any issues or concerns over the last few times they had to come out.
Thanks, Nakia.

Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
Our claim of loss was in 01/12/2015 due to a water leak which had damaged our laminate flooring. We contacted First American on Friday 01/16/15. An adjuster K.M., who was assigned to us, contacted us and sent a plumbing contractor the next day and a field adjuster on Monday 01/19/15. He assessed the damaged area and found signs of mold. He relayed the message to our claim adjuster and also advise us to follow up with our claim adjuster to escalate the issue and expedite being that we have two children, a five-year old and a 2-week old baby. The mold abatement and remediation commenced on Thursday. The remediation contractor company started demolition and assessment on Friday 01/23/15. They had found potential presence of asbestos and sent a material for lab testing. This then changed their scope of work and submitted a revised estimate to our claim adjuster.
Our claim adjuster was not very prompt in answering our phone calls even after leaving voice messages indicating that they were urgent especially that we wanted to get the work authorization approved. We had to call First American to follow up since KM's voice message indicated she was out of the office on Monday. We had to be reassigned a temporary adjuster, TC to follow-up on the work authorization for the remediation company. The remediation company was able to get the authorization on Tuesday and continue the work. They completed the work on Thursday 01/29/15. We then called John, the field adjuster to follow up on his work estimate and sent him photos of the affected areas which need repair. John told us that he had sent the work estimate to KM on Thursday for approval.
We had called KM again and left a voice message to ask when we can get the approval and the next steps for us. We did not hear back from her on Friday so we called again on Monday to follow-up. Again, we had gotten her voice message. Therefore, we called customer service to get assistance. After that, we were able to speak with KM. That's when she told us that the work estimate was approved on Thursday, check issued out and mailed out Friday 01/30/15. So we waited for the check and three days had passed and still no check. We called KM and she was not able to give us any other info. So today is the 4th day from when the check was allegedly mailed and still no check in the mail. We had called her again to follow up and had gotten her voice message. So we called customer service and we were able to speak with KM.
We had a heated conversation because she seemed very unhelpful. We had told her that it has been 4 days and if the mail was being sent within California, that it shouldn't take 4 days. So we were requesting if she can assist us in tracing if the check was really mailed out and perhaps had gotten lost in the mail. She was unwilling to listen to us and go further in tracing out if the check was sent out. Due to the stress we were in, we had raised our voices and she demanded that we talk to her supervisor. We left a voice message to her supervisor to give us a call. 5-10 mins after, we received a call from KM and she indicated that the check wasn't mailed out after all because the work estimate was needed to be reviewed further. So she told us that she would overnight the check once approved. Due to the delays in responding to us, we cannot start any construction repair work and continue to live uncomfortably in our house.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
We spent $1200 on a one-year appliance insurance protection policy for a house we purchased. We've been working with First American for over 2 months now on a malfunctioning range vent hood. They parse words and told me at the beginning that they cover appliances that are "not functioning as intended", which this definitely was not. In fact it's vibrating so much it’s not usable. However, once they discovered it was the motor that was vibrating (at a cost of $900) to replace, their reasoning turned to the vent hood actually had to have a "mechanical failure". So beware of sending your money to them. I'm going to tell my realtor to stop recommending them to new homeowners.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
On Nov. 20 I called to report a problem with my washing machine, oven and dishwasher. I was assigned a contractor but they did not come until Dec. 3. The washing machine and oven were both determined to need parts. I was informed the stove may be difficult to get parts for so expect it may be a week before I hear back.
To date - I have called contractor many, many times! (Only get a recording, they have never returned my call). I have called First American at least 6 times. Every time, it is the same. They try to reach contractor, and escalate it, but absolutely nothing happens. I have even suggested we start over with a new contractor, and they said we can't because the contractor shows parts on order. I have paid the contractor and continued my payments to First American. I am due two working appliances, my premiums refunded for time I have been provided NO service, and my copay to a contractor who has yet to fulfill his responsibilities.
Hi Sheri. Thank you for your feedback. Your claim has been resolved. Best Regards, Natalie.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
When I bought the house, the realty agent was the one who said, "I suggest you get First American so you can be protected for a year," and he asked the house owner, the seller, to pay for it. That was 15 years ago. When I submit a claim, they're fast to answer and the people that have been coming to my house acted promptly too. I have had just two bad experiences in 15 years and First American resolved it very fast -- as soon as I called, they changed providers. I'm glad I have First American protection because my house is an old house so if it was not for them, it was going to be a money pit. But because ofthem, I've saved a lot of money.
Thank you for being a loyal customer, Wilma.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
|The claims process of First American was good. Every time I call for service or something going on with the air conditioner, they give me a good service.
Thank you, Jose.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2015
When I first enrolled I request full benefits for EVERYTHING on both my warranties. I ask for full coverage to cover every thing that can be covered. I will NOT renew again for the reasons mentioned above. Poor service and you don't get what you pay for. My fees are 41.00 for my first home and 48.00 for my second home and things are what they seem to be. I will also ask the other customer contact the BBB.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2015
I was looking for home insurance and First American sounded more legit than others so I went with them. My experience was great when submitting claims. They are quick and get everything done plus I like the low cost. I would definitely recommend. They are fast, courteous and on time.
Thanks for recommending us, Sandra.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2015
I have a client whose daughter sells First American. We were with another home warranty provider, but we chose to go with First American because she sold it, so I wanted to switch over. It's very easy to submit a claim with them, I just go online and do it. The First American team is very good, though I really haven't interacted with them that much since I do things online. We've always had things fixed.
Thank you for your feedback, Patricia.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2015
My daughter switched home warranties because she wasn’t happy with the company she was with. She handles my financial affairs and she put me in with First American. Overall, I had a very good experience with them. The only exemption was when the repairman came out to fix my dryer. He came out a couple of times because it wouldn't dry. Things got loose in the dryer while I was running it. I called First American and they switched me over to another contractor.
Thank you for your feedback, Elma.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2015
My experience with First American was good. The service tech fixed it on the first call. He didn't have to leave and get parts. Just boom. And they had terrible reviews? The people that they sent out? But they were great! I'll give them a sounding review. I liked them.
Thank you very much, Christopher.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2015
I bought a house in September of 2014 and chose First American for my one year of home warranty service that was included by the sellers. After a couple of months, our sewer lateral backed up with excess sewage flowing into our back yard. I called First American right away and received a work order and appointment with a First American approved plumber within 48 hours. Needless to say, I was pleased with the service. That was where my approval of First American's handling of the situation ended. The first plumber came out, took one look at the backup and said that he couldn't help us and left immediately. We called First American back and requested that a new plumber be assigned to our case since this one clearly had no interest in fixing our problem.
A second plumber was assigned and came out 3 days after the first one. He was 3 hours late, took one look at our problem, and said he would need a second person to take care of it. We asked him when that second person could come out and he said "that's not how we work", and left. We followed up with the plumber the following 2 days and received no reply. So, we contact First American again to request a third plumber be assigned to our case. At this point our sewer lateral had been overflowing into our backyard for over a week.
We explained to First American exactly what the problem was and they said we would need someone with a "hydrojet" to clear out the lateral and that a camera would be needed to investigate why it was being backed up. I spent over 2 hours with them on the phone as they searched for a plumber that had this equipment. They put me on hold, would call someone, then would come back and say they hadn't found anyone yet.
After 2 hours I gave up and asked them to call me when they found someone. 48 hours went by with no contact, so I finally gave up and took to finding someone myself. The first plumber I called had a camera and hydrojet and came out the same day to fix the problem. They cleared out the lateral, took a video of the problem, and that problem has since been corrected. All at my cost.
I followed up with First American to let them know that the problem had been fixed at my expense and requested a reimbursement per the previous conversations I had had with customer support that was an available option. They said they would review our case. 2 weeks later I received a letter denying my request saying that I was unauthorized to use an outside plumber. They even refused to refund my service fee, even though they never even got a plumber out there to try and fix the problem.
The contractors First American hires for their jobs are the absolute cheapest they can find. Do a quick search on Yelp of anyone they send out and you will consistently find 1-2 star ratings. DO NOT purchase a First American Home warranty. Their service is slow. Their contractors are sub par, and your problems will not be resolved.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2015
Submitting the claim to First American was easy and quick. The rep was fantastic and the tech was certainly competent. They were responsive, on time, got the job done in a hurry.
Great to hear, Tyler.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2015
First American came with the house I bought. A couple of years ago I filed a claim for the air conditioning when I found out that it was under warranty. I also had an experience with the fan. They put up the ceiling fans for me.
We appreciate your business, John.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2015
We've been with First American since 2001. It was cheaper at the time but now, it’s not. We’re considering relocating our services. But their service is very satisfying. They are great and take care of their business whenever they say they are. The last plumber who came in was real nice and did his job. There was nothing in between and then he left. I recommended them a lot.
We appreciate your continued business, Misty.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2015
First American was recommended by my realtor. I have a good experience whenever submitting a claim. I've been happy with them or I wouldn't have been with them for ten years.
Thank you for your loyal business, Celia.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2015
A friend told me about First American. I did some comparison and liked the product they offered. Submitting claims was easy. The employees were good. They handled what I needed.
Thanks, Mike.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2015
Garage door repair - My service request from initially reporting a claim to the assigned company contacting me was within 24 hours. The company also confirmed my appointment the day before. A plus and minus, the repairman came 30 minutes early. A plus because we didn't have to wait and a minus because we thought we had 30 minutes and we were within our family morning routine. It all worked out because the company had called us that morning and informed us the repair person was on his way. In the end, it all worked out and I'm back parking in my garage. Yeah!
We appreciate your business, Gwen.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2015
I got First American with the 30-year-old house I purchased in 2007. The seller of the home included it in the sale. I thought that it would be a prudent decision to have a home warranty because of the older heating and air systems. The last two claims have been very good. They had a problem with one of the contractors back in 2007 but since then, I really haven't had issues. They've always been very responsive in all interactions with them.
Glad to hear it, Kenneth.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2015
Everything has been perfect. The claims representatives are wonderful. Matter of fact, I have another one for my other house but it's through another company but when that expires someday, I'm going to renew my other home with First American.
We appreciate your business, Brian.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2015
My First American experience has been positive. They did what they said they were gonna do. It's easier to do it online than it is to call in a claim. If you set up the appointment online, it's very easy. They do very good follow-up, and every one of the contractors that they sent over were very professional and were able to do the job.
Glad to hear it, Kim.
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2015
When we bought the house eons ago, it was under the coverage of First American. They have been pretty good whenever we submit a claim. Sometimes it's a little bit of a wait to get in line but not all the time, but sometimes it has happened.. Also the process was easy and the claims representatives were very professional. The experience is very good and we're very pleased.
We appreciate your continued business, Elton.
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2015
It's been like years and years, and I was just looking for a home warranty plan. I did have one before. My air conditioning went out when we had real hot weather, like 100 degrees outside. It took them three to four weeks to finally get somebody out here to fix it. They turned around and charged me. Altogether they paid for the air conditioning unit, and I have a heat console, so the heat and the air conditioning had to go together. By the time it was all done, they had charged me about $800, because they said they had to modify the pipes . When they left, I looked and they didn't modify anything but they charged me $600-$700. So I let them go, and went online and searched and found out about First American. Submitting claims to them was good. When I give them a call, they get it done in a timely manner. I've had to use them a couple of times and each time, had somebody come out and get the job done to where I didn't have to wait three to four weeks.
Thanks for your business, Shelly.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2015
My overall experience with First American Home Buyers Protection is okay. One technician never even called and we ended up hiring our own people. We never received a phone call and the number that was given to me, there was no answer. The second technician wasn't able to fix the problem. The claims representatives were fine, however. They explained the policy to me. We had one outstanding experience and then found out that some of their vendors or some of their contractors are not as good as others. Thirdly, the policy really lacks some protection for home buyers when I thought that my home was actually protected and I wasn't.
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2015
I purchased a home and chose First American because of affordability. We filed a claim online. They called to make sure that I knew that it was scheduled after it was scheduled. They had a little bit of internal confusion where they weren't sure if it was scheduled or not. Somebody else called a couple of times but I'd rather be notified more than once than not at all. Everybody was fine. The service that was provided was standard. I prefer to have home warranties on my homes anyway and they use the same standard people that anybody else uses. Based on the one experience it was great.
Thanks for your comments, Michelle.
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2015
I had a home warranty that I wasn't satisfied with and heard about First American. Submitting a claim was pretty easy. Most of the claims representatives are okay but I've met several that have been rude and act like I'm getting the service for nothing. There's one woman in particular I talked to that was pretty short and snippy and rude, and treated me like I was a welfare recipient rather than somebody who was paying a premium every month for the service. She kept calling me and telling me she was managing my claim, and the claim extended out for about three weeks or more. One time, I said, "You're not really doing anything for me," and she got mad. But on the whole, they've been pretty good. They’ve done some things that needed to be done but sometimes they’ve been pretty slow to do it.
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2015
My daughter was satisfied with the service from First American so she introduced me to them. I now have them and I would recommend them to others too.
Thanks, Lillie.
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2015
I was very satisfied with any service I've had with First American Home Buyers Protection. I have no complaints.
Glad to hear it, Phyllis.
Reviewed Jan. 27, 2015
I called First American which I have been with for 10 years.This was not the first time I was treated like this: My bathtub was clogged and the faucet to the tub was leaking. When the plumber came he unclogged the tub and started leaving. I asked about the faucet. He said it was not on order. Sure enough First American did not include it in the order. So here we go placing another order, waiting for plumber again to show up and he said he could not fix it. They sent a second plumber, he took it apart, left it leaking. I had to call First American again, to send a third plumber! It is three weeks since they left. I called First American at least twenty times. The faucet is leaking so much that we cannot sleep from the noise.
All this happened because the insurance company, First American, failed to report the claim the correct way. After this is fixed hopefully today, if the plumber shows up, I will be cancelling my contract with First American Home Buyers Protection. I had enough of them! Unorganized, with tellers out of the states. Tired of hearing their pre-written texts that they read for me every time I call and I am angry. It is not worth it. I much rather pay a plumber to come and fix the problem get paid and go. My time is worth more than the aggravations they have given me every time I place a claim with them.
Reviewed Jan. 27, 2015
We were buying our house and the people that were selling the house offered First American so we took it. And then when it came to re-up, we thought "Let's just re-up it." We've had two claims so far: one was with the air conditioner and one was with the heater. We called and the claims rep took our information and said somebody would be getting in touch with us soon. Each repairman for the two appliances came out and fixed it. Our experience has been great. My son and daughter-in-law and my daughter are looking to purchase a home and then we told them it would be a good idea if unexpected bills or something unexpected might happen. They might want to look into having a home warranty with their home and so they're planning to do that.
Thank you for your comments, Lorrie.
Reviewed Jan. 27, 2015
First American is excellent and very timely. My realtor suggested it when I bought my house in 2013, and it's been fabulous. I submit my claims over the phone, they give me a claim number and then I hear from the vendor. They get someone out right away and fix the problems quickly. If there's any follow-up, they're very prompt and very good. The most recent claim was in December -- it was my furnace. It faltered again and a vendor actually came out on a Sunday afternoon and fixed it. I thought that was really nice.
We appreciate your business, Leann.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2015
First American came with our new home. We wanted to make sure that everything was covered in case we weren't there. Submitting a claim was fast and easy. The claims reps were good. They're very helpful, friendly, and knowledgeable.
Thanks, Pamela.
Reviewed Jan. 26, 2015
Submitting a claim to First American was good and quick. We've had good interactions with their claims representatives so I would recommend them to other families.
We appreciate your business, Dawn.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2015
My other home warranty had expired. A friend who is a realtor told me about First American then I chose them because of the lower prices. I've only had to submit a claim and it was wonderful. It was easy and fast service. The sales rep was good and knowledgeable.
We appreciate you, Lonna.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2015
Every claim has taken soooo long to finish. We had a broken washing machine (clothes washer) that took 6 weeks to complete. 6 weeks without a washing machine with 2 kids is awful! They don't have enough contractors and they just can't get things done. We switched to American Home Shield and they have a 48-hour guarantee. We have had AHS for another home we own (a rental property) for 10+ years & never had problems with AHS. Every claim with FAHW was a mess.
Hi Dusty. Our records indicate your issue has since been resolved. Thank you, Audrey.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2015
My real estate agent told me about First American. Acquiring a home warranty just seemed like the right thing to do, in case something went wrong or you needed that insurance policy. First American has met all my requirements -- speedy response, and they've just been great. It was a good experience. I had no problem when submitting a claim. I once had an issue with the furnace. The heating element went out so we called. They were prompt and got right on it, and service was great and I have no complaints. I had no problems too with their claims representatives. I would recommend First American to my friends and family members. They were very prompt, very courteous, and very professional.
Happy to be of service, Richard.
Reviewed Jan. 25, 2015
First American kept me well abreast of everything that was going on, and informed me of the local companies that were to do the job, and so I was very well informed. It was an excellent experience overall!
Thanks, Patricia.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2015
My son bought a house before we did and bought the protection. His house had had a couple of things that First American took care of so he was so happy with First American and highly recommended it to us when we moved here. First American provides excellent service. Submitting a claim was pretty easy. People were nice and handled it for us. The claims representative was very good. I would highly recommend other people to get involved and get them.
Glad to hear it, Suzanne.
Reviewed Jan. 24, 2015
When I purchased my house back in October of last year, my realtor said that the sellers are going to pay for a full year of home warranty for the appliances and what not. I got to pick between three different home warranty companies and ended up going with First American because it sounded like the best out of the three. Not only to suit my needs, but also just financially sound as far as the other options were concerned because the sellers were only going to pay so much. This one covers everything that I wanted it to cover at the time and was within that range.
I've only submitted a claim once. That was back in November and it was a good experience. Everything was handled professionally and within a timely manner. I was very impressed with the service and the amount of time that it took for everything to be completed. As long as they keep doing what they're doing, then I'll stick with them for as long as I own my house. And if I end up buying another one, then I'll probably go with them again on the home warranty.
Thank you for your comments, Nathan.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2015
I placed a service request a few months ago due to some problems I was having with electrical wiring for my lighting in the home. I wasn't for sure if the warranty covered it, so at my wife behest, I called to tell them about the request and make sure. The lady I talked to stated that we had the "upgraded" warranty or whatever they called it, and that it should be fine so I kept the request on order.
About a week later the technician shows up. He flips a light switch here and there, continues to check the power outlets even after I told him that all that was in order b/c I checked already, then proceeds to tell me that everything looks to be working fine and that my warranty doesn't cover what I requested. I "specifically" wrote what the desired work was. If you knew it wasn't covered, then why did they tell me it was, and why did the technician come out in the first place?? The guy was barely in the house 5 minutes.
Fast forward to a few months later. I get a bill for a $60 service fee. No way I'm paying that... for what? Nothing was done and I was fed misinformation by the company trying to charge me! I called today and explained what happened. The customer representative (they're really not there to represent us...) while not too rude, was not very helpful. Instead he tried to drill me like it was CSI and made me feel like he thought I was lying to him or something. Then he told me "I can't waive your fee because I don't see any record of you calling us..." Are you freaking kidding me? Did I have a conversation with myself on the phone or what?? "It's our policy to document calls..". Well you didn't, and now you're telling me it's my fault.
Nevertheless, I asked for supervisor because now someone needed to know that someone in their company is not following their own rules. The guy told me "2 minutes and I'll connect you." Well, 20 minutes later it goes through and I get Sherryl. This woman (from their California office) was the reason why they got 3 stars instead of 1 or 2. She was very courteous and understanding and told me that the fee would be waived. She is solid testament to the power of having someone with good people skills and the use of some common sense working for you. While I will not be using this home warranty service again, I do appreciate her listening and efforts.
Be warned though. She did tell me that the company's policy is that you as the client get charged regardless of the outcome whenever a technician comes to your home. If you don't like that rule, I highly recommend that you should not use this company. I'm going to search for a better one with better policies. If I can't find one, maybe I'll just start one of my own...
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2015
I heard about First American from my realtor. I haven't had any problems when submitting my claim. However, the first guy who came out didn't really do anything but the second guy got it fixed. The service seems to work pretty well though.
Thank you for your feedback, Brian.
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2015
I first heard about First American through my real estate agent when I bought my house about 10 years ago. There's no problem submitting a claim but sometimes there's a little bit of a delay in getting somebody there. But generally speaking, it's been fine. The claim process is pretty easy. I would recommend them.
Thanks for your continued business, Henry.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2015
Called the company on 12/2 for heater not working & was told the heater is doing good and re-called them back on 12/9 for same issue & they ordered the parts. Very disappointed in the service & no rectification of the situations but got bill for $60 service charge. Still no parts and not fixed yet.
Hi Kash. We appreciate your patience and we are glad to have brought resolution to your claim. Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2015
Everything went well. It was just hard connecting on the phone when I called. It took me about three times to get it to work.
Thank you for your feedback, Rebecca.
Reviewed Jan. 22, 2015
I've been with First American for about six or seven years. I was looking and comparing then for a home warranty provider and I saw that they have good reviews, so I went with them. So far, I've never had any issues with them. Everybody has always been helpful and friendly and I've got nothing bad to say. They are always there when needed. They're also always nice on the phone, quick to help me, and always checked back to see if everything is okay and make sure that the service that I needed at the time has been completed, or if the contractor or subcontractor has contacted me to schedule to get it done. They're always right on the spot. Because of this, I always recommend them to anyone I speak to.
Thank you for your loyal business, Silvia.
Reviewed Jan. 21, 2015
Quick and easy. The technician they sent out was knowledgeable and helpful and got the job done quickly.
Thank you for your comments, Damon.
Reviewed Jan. 21, 2015
We got First American when we bought our house. The seller paid for us to have it for a year. We are now renting the house out and so we wanted the protection for our tenants. We’ve submitted a claim once and it was good and easy. Everything went well.
Thank you for your feedback, Noel
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2015
I'd recommend First American to people. I filed a claim and my issue got resolved on the first visit!
Thanks, Justin.
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2015
The policy was bought on the house I just purchased. First American gave out good service and I have no complaints about it. I simply called the number, they sent somebody out and took care of the job. I was well satisfied.
Thank you for your feedback, Tim.
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2015
I chose First American because of the price and the protection. Submitting a claim has been quick and easy and the claims representative was okay. The one problem I ever had was with Sears - it takes forever for them to come out to fix the item, even longer to order a part and even longer to come back and make another appointment to fix it. It’s still not fixed and they’re coming back on the 19th. But I would recommend First American.
We appreciate your comments, Henry.
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2015
My experience with First American Home Buyers Protection has been excellent so far. Their reaction time is really fast. It has been great for getting a vendor out to take care of the problem I might have. When I have a problem, I call and it seems like they always get right on top of it.
We appreciate it, Clarence.
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2015
When we bought our house, the previous owners paid for the first year with First American. After that, we kept it. They're very good and I've referred people to join too. They're awesome and their rates are a lot better compared to other home warranty companies. My thing is the service. I've had no issues and stuff. We've been very pleased.
Thank you for your feedback, Kim.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2015
We've had First American for over 10 years through our realtor. Filing a claim is easy and their claims representatives are very good. We have mentioned the company to other people that we know and told them how pleased we are with it for a number of years and that if they ever thought about getting one, First American would be the one that we would go with.
We appreciate your loyal business, Ray.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2015
First American is great! They’re wonderful. I’ve saved so much on my home warranty, it’s unbelievable. I have two homes - two rentals and a house I live in - and the house that I live in is a newer house, but I wouldn't be caught without a home warranty with my two rentals because they're older property and I've gained 150% of how much I've put into the company. But I've had both my policies a long time so I'm sure I've paid out a lot, but I've gained back a lot too. I have recommended them to 15 friends or probably 20.
Thank you for your comments, Ann.
Reviewed Jan. 18, 2015
First American was the home warranty provider that my mortgage company gave out. Claim submission was very easy and the representative have been very helpful and very nice. The experience was very easy and prompt.
We appreciate your business, Se'nee.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2015
I knew First American Home Buyers Protection since I was an employee of theirs back in 2000. One of the things that I really like is the little magnet that they send me each year with the phone number on it. I have one at work and I have one at home and it just makes it quick and easy to remember the website or the phone number to place a claim. Placing a claim is really quick and easy and their staff is professional and nice. I would recommend them.
Thank you for your loyal business, Annette.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2015
My claim is pending for about 3 months now. The claim no is **, it regards with dishwasher and cooktop. The contractor came and promised to get new parts. We kept on hearing for 2 months that parts are ordered but they never arrived, instead the claim got resolved automatically while we were waiting for the parts and hoping to be repaired soon. After about 3 months they have assigned the claim to new contractor. Last time they put me on hold for an hour and again I called. They again put me on hold for 30 minutes. It’s like going in circle. Pathetic service. My last home warranty company was lot better.
Hi Pankaj. We appreciate your feedback. We are glad to know a resolution has been brought to your claim. Thank you.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2015
I heard about First American through our realtor. Whenever I need to place a claim, it's been real good and their claims representatives are good. They jump on it right away and get it taken care of. I'd recommend them.
Thank you for recommending us, Chris.
Reviewed Jan. 17, 2015
First American came as the home warranty with my house that I purchased in 2011. We just renewed it at the end of the year. Submitting a claim has been pretty much hassle-free and they've been very helpful.
Thank you for your continued business, Mike.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2015
Filing a claim with First American has been simple and easy and usually they contact us as soon as possible. They are always helpful whenever I had to talk to somebody on the phone and very fast and very professional.
Thank you for your feedback, Myranda.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2015
While our home was under warranty our sewer line began backing up, leaving raw sewage in the front yard. We went through First American and they sent out a great plumber to help. After snaking the sewer and evaluating the situation, the plumber determined that the sewer line needed to be replaced. He said it may not be covered, but that we should be contacted by First American within the week.
A week came and went (with raw sewage still right next to our front doorstep), and we hadn't heard anything. After another week with no response, we called and sent an email to the plumber, who was apparently on vacation, and heard nothing for another two weeks. When the plumber got back to us, the plumber said First American told them that First American had called us within a week of the plumber's visit, had presented our options, and that we had said we would take time to think about it. First American claimed that we had then called them back and said that it was too expensive and that we were going to go with someone else. Obviously, none of this was true.
At this point we knew it was not covered, however, the extremely slow response kept the work from being done, causing additional sewage buildup next to our front door. We felt that since this was caused by First American's dishonesty that they should pay for the cleanup, which had been quoted to us at $350.
The plumber gave us the extension of the contact at First American that had told them that and my wife attempted to call every day for a week, with no response (and voicemail made no indication of the individual being on vacation). The next week, my wife contacted the main number, and relayed our story. They said that their notes matched the plumber's account, and when we informed them that it wasn't true, they said they'd look into it and call us back in 24 hours. They didn't call us back, so my wife called them back two days later, and was referred to a conflict resolution employee at First American, where she then (surprise!) had to leave a voicemail.
For the first time in our entire dealings with First American, someone actually called us when they said they would, and I received a call from the conflict resolution employee, who repeatedly told me that though they were sorry that there had been a "miscommunication" there was nothing they could do for us. After she repeated that line to a few different objections on my part, I reminded her that the actions of First American employees caused us to live with raw sewage for a month. She said that it wasn't really their fault because their call notes said that I had been contacted. When I asked her why they didn't think they were responsible for the actions of their own employee, she said that she was sorry that there was a miscommunication but that there was nothing she could do for us. When pressed further, she told me that if I'd like to escalate I could write a letter to the corporate office, and that there was nothing further she could help me with.
My wife and I are definitely planning to continue having a home warranty, but I guess we need to find a new company to get our warranty through now. Preferably one that is above lying directly to their clients.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2015
My experience with First American was great.
Thanks, Nicole.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2015
I wanted a home warranty just so if something goes wrong, there's a little insurance there. I got First American because my son has them. Submitting a claim is very easy. I just call and let them know what's going on and they set something up very quickly. The claims representatives have always been helpful and I'm completely satisfied with them. I've had to use them a few times and they've always come right through.
Thank you for your feedback, Carol.
Reviewed Jan. 16, 2015
We've had First American for 14 years and so far it's been good. When my daughter bought the house that we're in right now, they were the company that started the one year and we just kept on going with it after that. We never even thought of going with a different company. 95% of the time submitting a claim was fast and within 2 or 3 days, there's a company out here whether it would be plumbing or appliance.
Thank you for your continued business, Katherine.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2015
We got First American Home Buyers Protection plan with the purchase of a condo. Soon we found out that the attic was infested with rodents. We called FAH and they sent a contractor over. The contractor, who didn't have a ladder, didn't even look at the attic and said that the attic was infested with rats and FAH only covers mice and left. Next thing I know, I'm billed $60 as a service fee. I called them and complained to one of FAH managers what had happened. He said that he waived the fee. But I received a bill again later. I called again. The operator said that there was no notes of the fee having being waived and why should it. I had to recount the whole story again to him, and finally asked to be transferred to a manager again. After a very long wait the call got disconnected. This is a very poorly managed company and only makes money by charging service fees for jobs that don't get done.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2015
I have had 1st American since 2005. My first experience was with my hot tub shortly after I moved in, and I had never used it. The tech came in, stated bugs ate through the wires, and collected his service fee. In conclusion, 1st didn't cover it. The other times they have covered it, and have always done the minimal work. For example, this passed summer, we had issues with the toilet on my rental property. They did minimal work, and then it flooded. And of course 1st American wouldn't cover it. So again, paid the tech to have no work done, plus the flood costs, clean up costs, toilet replacements, etc, etc. More wasted money.
Recently, my HVAC went out. They determined it was due to missing coils and lint and because they considered that to be missing parts, they would not cover the costs to replace the unit. Despite my years with them and paying for premier upgrades, lately they cover nothing. Service call fees wasted, monthly fees wasted. I am very disappointed with their services because they do minimal work, while I sit here and pay over $700 a year to them, with no real protection through the year for my home. It is very frustrating and extremely draining emotionally, not to mention the pockets.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2015
We bought it along with the house. So far it's been real good. Sometimes they take forever to get here but the people do. Otherwise I've been pretty happy.
Reviewed Jan. 15, 2015
Overall experience with First American was excellent. The person was very professional and completed the job in a very timely fashion.
Thanks, Diane.
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2015
We needed to get our garage door fixed because it had gotten off track. I called First American and they had someone come out within the next few days. Once the contractor was there he said that we would have to pay him additional to get it fixed. He was the only person that was nice during my whole experience. I called First American and they said the coverage that we had (which was just under $500) does not cover adjustments or doors but it does cover assembly. Really? My door is not broken, a roller was off the track and needed to be reassembled. No springs are broken. No new parts.
I am angry. I don't understand how they can cover putting the track together but not to adjust it? Don't you adjust it when you assemble it? They transferred me to two different people where I had to explain the situation to both. Ended up having to pay to get the door fixed. Our contract ends in April and I'm finding that it really is not worth staying with them. This is our first claim with them EVER. Go to someone else. Will never use them again.
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2015
Got this insurance when purchased a house, tried to use it. You never reach them on the phone, they never reply you back at their website fahw.com. Their contractors arrive at your house, take your co-payment and vanish into thin air. You never reach them as well on their phone numbers. If you are lucky and have some patience, you will probably get the problem resolved within a month or two. Not sure if you can wait that long when water does not stop leaking.
Btw, as soon as they saw this review on Yelp they immediately contacted me. Unfortunately, Yelp filtered out my review, because I am a new user there, so they disappeared again. I don't think this is a coincidence. This is their MO.
Hi Alexander. Thank you for your feedback. Per the contractor, repairs were completed as of January 15, 2015. Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2015
Our house is 10 years old so I figured we might start having problems so I should be getting covered. My sister who is a realtor referred me to First American. We’ve submitted two complaints since last summer and they both have been attended to immediately and the service has been good. Claims rep was good. When we make a claim, they get the service people to call us within 24-48 hours. They do and they take care of the problem and that's it. It's very easy.
Glad to hear it, Barbara.
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2015
I heard about First American from co-workers. I heard from others that the experience they had was good so I chose to go with that. It's been a great experience, it is prompt and the response was good. I rate it five.
Thank you for your comments, Serkalmaz.
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2015
When we first got our home, 8 years in May, the realtor who showed us around signed me up for First American and she paid for the first year. It's been several times that I've had to use them for claims and I've been more than satisfied.
Thank you for your continued business, Devonna.
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2015
First American was just one of the things that I got after I bought a house as it sounded like a good thing. Submitting a claim was always good. They’re very responsive and get it done quickly and under the terms that were agreed upon. We had it great. I'm happy. End of story.
Thank you for your feedback, Alan.
Reviewed Jan. 13, 2015
We are very satisfied and "comfortable" with the way we have been related to, and with the practical service we have received from First American. They are definitely trustworthy. We have been with First American for 14 years, and will continue to be so as long as we are able to "rattle around" in this house!
Thank you for your feedback, George and Gay.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2015
At first, I was quite pleased with this company. When we had an issue with our hot water heater, we put in a service request on Friday morning and a contracted plumber was out that morning, assessed the situation and ordered the new water heater, and advised us that the tank should be disconnected from the breaker because it was unsafe to use the water to due the leak in our tank. We gladly consented to the inconvenience if it meant keeping our family safe. That's where my good opinion of the contractor and the home warranty company ends. First, some pertinent background on the type of professionals with whom First American Home Buyers works.
The contracted plumber stated that the new water heater would be in for pick up on Monday and we should expect them that day. Fast forward through: "can't make it Monday, we'll be there tomorrow," to "our other truck is in the shop we can't come out Tuesday night," to speaking with the owner "What do you need done? Oh, we can't do that today." Finally, we consented to wait til Saturday for service (8 days later), if they could definitely install the water heater that day. So that Saturday 2 different gentleman from the same plumbing company did, in fact, show up at our house.
They proceeded to our basement, started to drain the tank and stated "this is draining too slow, we can't do this today." We asked how they planned to resolve the situation and were told they had to speak to their manager, who may be able to come by and hook up our hot water later on today (EVEN THOUGH WE WERE PREVIOUSLY TOLD BY THE SAME COMPANY THAT THIS WOULD BE DANGEROUS TO DO). They also stated that we would just need a new element, and made no mention of the leak that the previous person noticed (there was definitely a leak as the insulation was water logged and black). So the home warranty company had paid for the new hot water heater which was supposedly on their truck that afternoon, but now that they had ordered it, we suddenly didn't need it, we only needed a new heating element. I was obviously finished with the "professionals" who were either bait and switch scam artists or so grossly incompetent that they put my family in danger of an electrical fire. We called these folks after they left and told them we were finding another plumber and were no longer in need of their service.
Immediately afterward, I got on the phone with First American Home Buyers Protection to request immediate service from another plumber. I was on hold for just over one hour. Yes, you read correctly, one hour. When my call was taken, I spent the next half hour or so explaining the situation to the customer service rep and waiting on hold while she looked for someone that could do take the job today. Of course, they only had someone that could come out Monday morning, today, 11 days after our original call. After expressing my concern with their overall service, their lack of initiative in intervening on our behalf due to the length of the open service request, and my serious concern with their choice of bottom feeder contractors, we consented to wait another two days to have someone finally complete this job.
I was cautiously hopeful when the rep at First American Home Buyers Protection told me that the new plumber would be out between 7 am-9 am that morning. I called the plumber at 8:30 that morning since we had not seen or heard from him and was happy that he picked up the phone. He informed me that he had not received information from First American Home Buyers Protection as to what specific model and capacity water heater we needed, so he was not able to order it yet. While I left for work, my husband gave him the necessary information and learned that the new plumber would be out to the house by 1 pm. We called at 2:15 pm and he did not pick up, his phone went to voicemail. Since their office closed at 3 pm, we are now heading into day 12 with no hot water. I would like First American to redeem themselves and get a COMPETENT plumber out to our house tonight to install our water heater. I know there are plumbers that will make emergency calls. Please redeem yourself and I'll be happy to give you some positive press. I have listed all 3 work order numbers, as they are for the same ongoing request: **.
Hi Brynne. Thank you for your feeback, your claim has been resolved. Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2015
When I bought the house, First American was the warranty provider purchased by the seller and we continued the coverage. I have submitted several claims and they have been handled very well. The last one I had a little problem but it was resolved and my appliance is working beautifully now. The claims representative was very good.
Thank you for your feedback, Elizabeth.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2015
My realtor introduced me to First American. Overall, I've had a positive experience with them. I’m just in the process of renewing my claim. The representatives I worked with were positive and helpful, but as of right now, I’m not covered.
Thanks for your comments, Walton.
Reviewed Jan. 12, 2015
On November 30, 2014 (around 8am), I called First American Home Buyers because one of my water heaters didn't produce hot water. First American had one plumbing company come out and they deemed that the water heater needed replacing. First American then called two separate electricians who also deemed the problem was with the water heater not the electricity. First American told me that they had finally located a water heater to be installed and had the plumbing company scheduled to come around the middle of December.
In the meantime, on 12/18/2014, I had a problem with a flap in my toilet and called First American to have the toilet fixed. The company that came out to fix the toilet flap told me that the water pressure in my house was too high (needed to replaced my regulator). This plumbing company called First American to get approval for the toilet and regulator and told First American that they could fix the water heater. First American had the company fix the flap, replace the regulator (and charged me an extra $120), and attempt to fix my water heater. First American cancelled the water heater on order. This plumbing company tried to jury-rig the water heater but was not successful.
In addition to not fixing the broken water heater, the plumbing company did not properly install the regulator - so my water creeps out of my faucets. Due to the creeping water, the second water heater is somehow not working properly. Since November 18, 2014, we have not been able to take baths/wash hair without running slow water and boiling it, unable to wash clothes in the washing machine, and unable to wash dishes in the dishwasher. It is now January 11, 2015 and First American has not purchased a water heater to replace the one that needs to be replaced and they have not had a plumbing company fix the regulator. I wrote First American's complaint department, and then the BBB. First American told the BBB that they had scheduled an installation of the new water heater for last Wednesday - that wasn't true. My next step is to hire a lawyer.
Hi Muthrine. We are happy to have resolved your concerns. Our records indicate that your water heater has been replaced and is working properly. Thank you, Shanee
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2015
First American has been good up to this point. I've had some problems with the last one, but the technician returned with no problem at all. Finally did get everything to work properly, so service was great.
Glad to hear it, Jack.
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2015
The people that we bought the home from bought First American for us. It's been fine dealing with their representatives.
Thanks, Jami.
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2015
I am a current and highly disappointed customer of First American Home Warranty. I originally purchased my home warranty contract with First American in 2011 after learning about the company through Pentagon Federal (PenFed) Credit Union. I am a 21 year active duty Navy Sailor and probably would have never considered a home warranty with First American if not for the company being featured/endorsed on PenFed website at the time. Thus, like the military and its affiliates - I truly believed First American was a customer focused company that prided itself on integrity-based service and a commitment to excellence. I've been paying $59.00 a month for First Americans Premier Plan with the First Class Upgrade. Well, there is nothing first class, excellent or loyal about the way First American treated me as a customer when I recently filed a claim on 12/10/2014 for a water emergency/leak between the interior wall in my master bedroom and the exterior brick adjacent to the exterior water hydrant/hose bib.
First American contacted Draingo Plumbing Millington, TN to complete the service repair. Draingo arrived on 12/11/2014, assessed the water leak and stated the repair would have to be accomplished from inside the master bathroom. Draingo stated it would require me (the customer) to either remove or have removed the bathroom cabinet, stone sink top, and mirror/glass. I specifically asked Draingo to try to access the leak externally by removing the hose bib; however, the rep informed me that he did not think that would allow him to get to the leak to complete the repair. Draingo departed without actually attempting to accomplish repairs to stop the leak. I was left to try and figure out how to deal with the water emergency on my own while trying to limit/mitigate water damage to my home as much as possible.
After doing some research, I was fortunate to find a company WAGCO Home Services which properly diagnosed the problem and determined the issue was a leak from the water hydrant/hose bib area and should be accessed from the exterior of the home by removal and reinstall of the brick. I contacted First American service representatives and requested authorization to have the contractor WAGCO complete the repairs as indicated but was told that I would have to remove the bathroom cabinet as noted by Draingo and allow then schedule to have Draingo return to complete the repairs. At this point (12/12/2014), I had been dealing with this water emergency with no resolve for over 48 hours and First American did not support me as customer in a positive manner at all. Moreover, they were willing to share guidance to assist me in requesting cancellation of my policy rather than offering guidance/support to help derive the most timely and efficient solution to my emergent issue.
Thus, I had to proceed on my own by paying out of pocket to have WAGCO complete the repairs. The WAGCO technicians removed the appropriate brick, gained access to the hose bib pipe behind the wall and remove/replaced the corroded/fractured hose bib pipe. The new hose bib and pipe was installed and the brick was professionally reinstalled. I filed a Cash Out Reimbursement claim for $700.00 with First American and received a letter stated that my claim would not be honored because the repair action had not been pre-authorized. Note: I had requested authorization verbally with service rep but was denied. Additionally, First American also had the audacity to send a separate bill with denial letter stating that I owed them $65.00 for the repair service fee unbelievable! I am very disappointed in First American and myself for having paid a $59.00 monthly contract fee and then when my emergency struck First American left me high and dry to figure out how to resolve the issue at no cost to them.
I hate to agree with what I've heard many others say about home warranties but unfortunately I must agree that I would have been much better off setting aside the $59.00 per month in an emergency maintenance type savings account. Not only would it have saved me a significant amount of money, it would have also saved me a tremendous amount of stress. This experience has been a real eye opener for this 21-year Navy veteran and I plan to share this story with all who will listen in hopes that I can help them make more informed decisions regarding home warranties. I am also investigating potential legal recourse relative to fiduciary obligation and breach of contract. Any advice and assistance to help share this unfortunate experience with others (individuals/media) is greatly appreciated.
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2015
First American was given to me by my realtor when I bought the home. It has gone just fine but I have nothing to compare them with.
Thanks, Joan.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2015
The contractors First American has hired to service our home repairs have consistently been of poor quality. For example, a refrigerator which was not cooling properly took 8 visits by the repair company to get it working properly. Rarely were they on time. We are now without a working furnace in our primary living area. Not only did the contractor not show up (or even call) on two days when they committed, once they did show up and diagnose the issue, it took 6 days to actually order the parts (not sure if this was a contractor or First American issue, but regardless, it is my issue). Estimated completion repair is a week from now. It doesn't help that temperatures have been as low at 27 degrees. Customer service is very tough to get a hold of.
After being on hold for 20 minutes, I've hung up. When I do get through, I get contradictory information. The only reason I did not rate them with one star is that eventually, they have gotten the job done. In addition, we've had more than our fair share of needed repairs (unfortunate for us) and First American hasn't stopped servicing our home. The contract has saved us a significant amount of money, but the added frustration and hassle of working through the First American system will not make us a return customer. If you are looking for a home warranty company, I'd recommend looking elsewhere.
UPDATED ON 07/29/2016: First American Home Buyer Protection (FAHBP) did refund the cost of my service fee and the repair bill from an independent licensed A/C company. I’m still unsatisfied with their service and here’s why. FAHBP sent a technician out who, if they were qualified, could have fixed the problem on the first service call. The service technician actually seemed qualified and knowledgeable. His first instinct was that our A/C was low of refrigerant. His meter told him it wasn’t low. Next he checked the attic. He found some small slits in the outbound A/C venting which he taped up. He thought that would solve the problem. It didn’t and he came back a second time. The call was scheduled for between 4 and 7 PM on a Friday night.
Long story short, he showed up at 9:00 and stayed until 10:15 PM. He said he had been working since 8:30 AM non-stop. His diagnosis, as reported to me by FAHBP, was a bad plenum due to water damage. I was with him the entire time in the attic. I saw the inside of the unit. There were no oil spots, visible rust, or water drops inside the condensing unit; it looked brand new. There is no way to actually see the inside of the plenum without special equipment such as a flexible camera or by taking the unit apart. The technician never mentioned this water damage to me. Upon hearing this from FAHBP, I didn’t believe it.
FAHBP has a procedure where you can call in a certified technician of your choosing at your cost for a second opinion. I called a company who was highly rated on Angie’s List and Yelp. They said, based on my description, a new plenum would be $450 to $600. I scheduled a service call. They came out and inspected the unit. 10 days had passed between the initial visit by the FAHBP technician and this technician. They said the plenum was in good working condition. The issue was that the unit was low on refrigerant; he added two pounds. That was about 10 days ago and the unit is working perfectly and running about 8 hours a day versus over 20 hours a day.
I haven’t asked FAHBP to reimburse me for the electricity wasted, which, based on an Internet search looks to be $100. I haven’t asked them to reimburse me for my wasted time. What really gets me is that FAHBP said that as a courtesy and in the spirit of good customer relations, they would refund the initial $60 service call fee. First they waste my time with choosing a company who can’t make a good diagnosis and fix the problem in a timely manner, then they act as if they are doing me a favor. I don’t see it that way.
If this were an isolated case, I would not be writing about it on the Consumer Affairs review site. I’m coming to the end of my contract. Last winter (or the winter before) when it was in the teens in south Texas it took 4 months and 13 service calls to fix a furnace (basically, a sensor had gone bad). The year before, it took 8 service calls to fix a refrigerator. Then there was the time a technician couldn’t properly replace a broken thermostat. I have other stories of ineptitude, but won’t go into them. In general, the contractors hired by FAHBP to come into your home have the lowest ratings when looking at Internet reviews on Angie’s List and Yelp. I like the idea of what FAHBP offers, but the execution is terrible.
To be fair to FAHBP, they have saved us money over the 3 years we have been with them. Plus, once a “real” supervisor gets involved, you have a fair chance at resolving the problem, but it will take time and persistence. The aggravation, hassle, and anxiety that their contractors have brought into our home is no longer worth the cost savings. We will choose our own contractors and know that it will cost more per service call, but we save on the $800 plus annual premium. Unless they gave us a free year of service we will not be renewing our contract.
I don’t understand why FAHBP doesn’t offer a customer service call satisfaction survey after each call. It would take a few hours to put up on Survey Monkey. They could then more quickly weed out the bad contractors and have real customer input on how they are doing. My suspicion is they already know and don’t want to quantify it for others to see.
Hi Ed. Per your recent correspondence, the repairs have been completed. Thank you, Audrey.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2015
We got First American through our real estate agent when we purchased our last house. It was very easy submitting a claim. The person was very nice and came when they said they were going to come and did what they said they were going to do. It was great.
Glad to hear it, Helen.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2015
The heater in the lower level of our house went out on 11/26/14. We placed claim. A few days later, the contractor came out. He said he needed to order a part. We didn't hear from him again for a week or two. We placed a recall claim online. The contractor came out and installed a new thermostat. He said it would take a while to feel the heat. A few hours later, we could feel no heat. We contacted First Am online. By then it was 12/16. I said maybe we needed a different contractor who was more competent. But on 12/17, they said since it was within 30 days, the original contractor would contact us. He never did.
On 1/7/15, I logged in to see the claim had marked ‘Completed’ without anyone ever contacting us. I called First Am. Waited on hold for 39 minutes till I got to speak to lovely agent Courtney. She put me on hold while she contacted the contractor, who Courtney said she had spoken to, and was supposed to call me back, but never did. I called the contractor directly and was told they had never been contacted by First Am. Contractor finally came out and fixed it. Problem was a bad switch, so the new thermostat never would have done the trick.
Our previous claim was in the summer for A/C. Similar lack of communication and slow response. While we waited for contractor who initially came to contact us or reappear, we watched our newly finished wood floors warp for days in the Arkansas humidity. They did finally come and fix the problem, only after the website failed to yield a response and I had to call and be extremely assertive with the agent who acted as I was unreasonable to ask for what day the contractor would return. We would have been better off without the policy and just calling a contractor ourselves. I was slightly encouraged when my online complaint form resulted in a company rep calling me to follow up.
I cannot recommend First Am, at least in the Little Rock area, where the contractors they have sent us are those whom I am unable to find listed on the state's website for licensed contractors. The company seems to have no check and balance system for when communication with the contractor goes awry. And who wants or has 45 minutes to spend on the phone every time something breaks (plus extra time to take off work when the incompetent contractors require extra visits)?
Hi Stacey. We Thank you for your feedback and are aware that your heater has been repaired.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2015
My sister recommended First American to me when I bought my house. Their claims process was pretty easy to do. They generally got me someone assigned (my claim had to get re-assigned) and they got out here, contacted me to make sure I was home. Any time I've had a claim, it's been taken care of really quick. I paid for the service charge out of my own pocket, though. Nevertheless, I'd definitely recommend them.
Thank you for your comments, Kenton.
Reviewed Jan. 10, 2015
I've had very good experience with First American.
Thanks, Frank.
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2015
FirstAm replaced my pool salt chlorination system under warranty when it broke. The replacement system, selected by First Am and their contractor installed a part that broke after 4 months. The manufacturer will not replace the part (it has been 5 months since it broke) and since it is "under manufacturer warranty" First Am will not replace the part OR help me pressure the manufacturer to replace the part. First Am has significantly more buying power than I do and selected this manufacturer's (Compupool Products) product, not me. I am supposedly covered by two warranties and yet after 5 months I still have an inoperable system. First Am really the buyer of this broken part, so they should be the one pursuing the manufacturer. By the way, this manufacturer is still selling this salt system to others, therefore they have replacement parts available and could replace the part with the right incentive (ie, a big buyer of parts)!
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2015
Our real estate agent told us about First American when we were buying a home. The claims we have submitted online or through the phone have been resolved. We're happy and so we've renewed our contracts.
Thank you for your feedback, Catherine.
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2015
I had a very good experience with First American.
Thanks, Becky.
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2015
I've had First American Home Buyers Protection before - they were the only one in this particular area. When submitting claims via phone, it's frustrating because it does not allow you to bypass the prompts. It's easy when you're speaking to a claim representative for a particular claim - they take the service call and they route it to the appropriate person. But when you have to call back in, its not user friendly. It's easier done online.
When there are troubles with a particular contractor, First American basically releases their liability and places it on the customer to resolve issues. I am in a battle with First American and a plumber that they sent to my property. I spoke to the claims resolution person and their supervisor, and they referred me to a website to submit a letter. So they basically said that the problem belonged to me. I needed to resolve it to the vendor that you all recommended.
First American lacks professionalism. Your call-in procedure is not customer-oriented; a person should never ever have to wait 45 minutes on a call.
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2015
I had to give a rating so I gave one star, but I wanted to give zero! My dishwasher claim began 6 months ago and is still not resolved. Some of my initial complaints were residue left on my dishes and that my dishes and the inside of the dishwasher were soaking wet upon completion of the cycle. The repairman from the first contractor "cleaned out" the filter and told me to run white vinegar through the unit...I did, no change. And, he never addressed the wet dishes problem. The same contracting company made at least 4 different service calls with fixes ranging from the vinegar to replacing the control panel. Still no resolution.
I had been in constant contact with whomever I could reach at First American's customer service (was even hung up on by a very rude representative after being on hold for 20 min.) to let them know that the contractors they were sending didn't know what they were doing, that my unit still wasn't repaired and I wanted a new dishwasher. I was lucky enough to get a very nice representative who agreed that what I was enduring was crazy and that I should have a new dishwasher. My claim was sent to the Purch. Dept. who agreed to replace the dishwasher. They even went so far as to have me choose which dishwasher I wanted. Then, they changed their mind and said they would repair it.
After more phone calls, they changed their mind again and decided on replacement, only to change it once again deciding on repair instead. The second contractor they sent out said the heating element was broken (up to that point no one had even moved the unit away from the wall). He ordered a new part. But, because of the back and forth about replace or repair, it has taken over two months to get the new part installed. That was done yesterday. And, you guessed it, still wet and dirty dishes.
So, another call to First American today and 15 min. on the phone with a "supervisor" who informed me that procedurally they have to go with whatever their contractor says and this contractor says he can "fix" the machine. Now you tell me, after 6 months and as many or more service calls, do you think they can fix it? First American is one of the worst run companies with the poorest of customer service emanating from people outside of the U.S. with accents you can barely understand. My next step, complaint with the Insurance Commissioner!
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2015
This company has the worst warranty service I've ever dealt with. First, customer service is a joke. It’s an act of congress to speak to a person. I've been on hold 30 minutes and when someone finally answers he places me on hold another 15 minutes and then disconnects. My mistake was not getting his extension, however I did get his name. There is no email address that you can contact anyone. The first claim I filed took over 30 days for repairs. Now I have filed another claim and I can't even get an appropriate time on repairs. Looking at the contractors invoice, I can see if it is not the shaft then I’ll have to wait for a motor. They send someone out to diagnose the problem and then you have to just wait. It’s always waiting on a part. My appliances are Whirlpools made by Sears and a Sears is in my city. I would not recommend this company to anyone.
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2015
My first initial call was to them on the 26th of Dec. I have explained to them that the pump went out on our pool and that the temperatures were going to get below freezing and our pool automatically turns on at 32 degrees. Well we all know what the weather has been like. Then the next thing I know they are trying to tell me that I have to pay $200+ for pvc piping because my pool isn't up to code. It's only 4 1/2 years old. I explained to them that there was no way and basically... I wasn't paying it. Then they tried to say the company that they sent out here that I paid $65.00 for that didn't even look at the motor...just went on what I said, didn't use a screw driver, nothing, said, "Yeah the motor is grounded and you need a new one." I had to pay $65.00 for someone to come out here and me tell him what is wrong and he gets that for 10 mins. Would love to have his job.
Well this goes on and on. Well here we are and I frantically call and explain again the weather is getting colder and I can't turn on my pool to keep the water circulating and they are just well we have to wait for this. Now it's in the purchasing dept. Well I woke up this morning and there is at least an inch of ice (yes I have pictures) on my pool. Hockey anyone??? I told them that any more damages happen to my pool then they will be held responsible for. They informed me that they aren't responsible for secondary damages. I say they are if their negligence caused the secondary damages.
I also had to use them for hot water heater and an electric door opener. My garage door consists of 3 different manufactures. One for my car is from another company, my husband's is from another company. The garage door opener is from a completely different door company and so is the one in the house to open it from the house. So don't let them mislead you in the fact that they will be replacing it with exactly what you had or the quality of the merchandise that they replace it with. As soon as my contract is over, I will not and will also tell everyone that I know not to even bother with these people. It's not a lie... I am not a disgruntled person. But considering I have been paying them $78.00 and my pump is like a little over $200. I've already paid for it!!!
Hi Carol. Our records indicate that the repairs were completed. Thank you, Audrey.
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2015
I've been with First American for more than two or three years and have three properties listed with them. They're very good when submitting a claim. They listen to your service request promptly and there's no problem.
Thank you for your continued business, Waseem.
Reviewed Jan. 8, 2015
We purchased our new home in October and it came with First American for one year, and it was highly recommended. We've already had to do two claims and they were absolutely phenomenal experiences. It was really fast and efficient service. We didn't have to worry about anything. They always sent us the email followup. Both times that we had claims, we could have fixed it ourselves but we didn't mind paying for the convenience because it helps. It was a quick turnaround.
Thanks for your business, Anthrechelle.
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2015
After not being happy with my first home warranty company (Buyer's Protection Group), I went with First American because my family has used them for 20+ years. I just canceled my policy (it is up for expiration) and will be going with a different company. My original work order consisted of: Leak in master bath, faucet handles, leak under kitchen sink, leaking washing machine valve, burning rubber smell when washing machine is on spin cycle.
The contractor they sent out to fix my washing machine did the job in the end, but the repairman knew almost no English. He said he came from Germany 7 months ago and had to translate into his phone. This did not assure me that he was understanding my complaint, though he was kind and seemed knowledgeable. He found a loose part and tightened it, and it seems to have done the job but I don't understand why they would send a repairman who needs to translate into a phone app.
The master bath sink was fixed right away as well, but the plumber said he would need to order a new part for my garbage disposal underneath my kitchen sink, as that was causing (or would be a part of) the leak. He then instructed me to re-calk in the meantime, and that "they don't do that." I initially submitted my claim in early November, and the part (which I was told did not get shipped to the right place by the plumbing co.) was not replaced until December 29. In between that time, I had reported that the sink was still leaking despite having re-calked and that my claim hadn't been handled yet. It was difficult to get the customer service reps I spoke to on the same page as the plumber and I had to do all of the calling. The plumber even said they'd get the part in soon and would call me soon, and that fell through (over 1 week). I had had enough, called customer service and requested that the plumber fix the issue as soon as possible. I soon received a letter from FA, stating that 3/4 of my problems were not fixed, which was not the case. 2/4 were not fixed. I felt very frustrated from having communicated VERY clearly, and still not feeling heard.
The plumber finally received the garbage disposal part and installed it and told me I'd need to calk again to prevent more leaking. Fine, but I would have appreciated it if he'd step in at that point and do it as a courtesy but he said "We used to calk for customers but don't any longer because they don't follow instructions and ruin it." Not very professional to say. Additionally, he made several comments about how cheap my sink is, and how poorly installed it was (I moved in with it like this).
The last piece to this is my washing machine valve leak. Originally, the plumber stated that the valves were "not that old" and asked if I was "messing with the knobs." I said no (why would I do that? ) and that I was concerned about the leak becoming worse, as I've had several leaking issues in my condo and want to catch them as early as possible. I pay top dollar with FA and feel that I should get a valve replaced if water is being collected in a paper towel. He stated the replacement was not necessary. I called FA and requested that they be replaced, as they are leaking, whether it's "bad enough" for the plumber or not. I thought she understood me, but when the plumber came back, he still did not replace the parts and said he wasn't told to. This angered me to no end and I have just given up. He tightened the valve again and literally told me that First American is the worst company, they pay their contractors nothing and that's why he doesn't take many service calls from them. Either way, I got ** service and I didn't appreciate him complaining about business (and essentially one of his bosses) while in my home.
At this point, I don't know if he decided not to replace the valves because it wasn't financially worth it for HIM, or if FA didn't approve it. To boot, when I just canceled my contract upon expiration, customer service asked me why I'm canceling and I said I didn't like the service I received....he said NOTHING about it, didn't apologize or ask how they can improve/convince me to stay, so THAT was telling as well! Moving on!
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2015
We bought an older house and it needed a few things. First American Home Buyers has saved us a lot of money on things that we didn't know were gonna happen.
Thanks for your comments, Jim.
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2015
In the beginning, it was really good. Then afterwards, it wasn't so great. I had a difficult time with a couple of work orders that I had. And then the last one, it was better.
Thanks for your comments, Carlos.
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2015
This home warranty company refuses to repair/replace my a/c unit that is documented to need significant repairs. In the summer in Las Vegas to keep the power bills less than $400 a month I have to keep my 912 Sq foot condo at 83 and I am disabled with a significant heart problem. I provided documentation that the coils cannot distribute air due to age and dirt and that the bearings are loose and a supervisor said I would have to clean the irreparable coils (25 yrs old) before they would consider a repair/replacement.
My next bill is estimated to be $106 due to a one week cold spree in Vegas. My mom lives in the same complex with a condo 100 Sq feet bigger and she pays that amt in summer keeping her house at 73. I initiated a claim based on inefficacy last January with the documentation of the bearings and coil problems and the tech they sent turned it on hot and cold and said it works and refused to look at the mechanics of the unit. I refused to pay the $65 fee as I had told them it worked but very inefficiently when I made the claim. They did me a "favor" and waived the fee in September (8 months later) after I posted a complaint on Yelp.
Now, a year later they claim the documentation I have doesn't prove system failure even though the repair tech specifically states that the unit needs to be repaired/replaced. They are waiting for this to completely die but I can't go another summer at 83. My heart cannot take it. They take my money but do not live up to their obligation! As soon as I come up with the money to replace it I am switching warranty companies. First American is worthless!
Reviewed Jan. 6, 2015
It’s very easy to submit a claim. And they’re very good about doing things. When I had an issue, I called them. They sent people out that took care of the problem. Their reps are very pleasant and even the contractor gets back very quickly. The only thing that I have concerns with is the price. So I debated as to whether or not to continue with them. The service itself is very good, but the price keeps going up in terms of your co-pay.
Thanks for the feedback, Karen.
Reviewed Jan. 5, 2015
It was an excellent experience with First American. The contractor told me what he was doing, what need to be done in the future with the water heater and how to maintain it.
Glad to hear it, Clayborn.
Reviewed Jan. 5, 2015
I've had First American for 6 or 7 years now when I bought my house and I just stayed with them. Everything's been great with it, otherwise I wouldn't keep them.
Thanks for your review, Juta.
Reviewed Jan. 4, 2015
My experience with First American Home Buyers Protection was excellent. The companies that they use and the technicians were good.
Thanks, Jeffrey.
Reviewed Jan. 4, 2015
Submitting a claim is easy. I go online and submit the claim. That’s the easy part. The hard part is when the company that goes out and fixes the claim and let’s say for instance they can’t do it in one job the hard part is getting them to come back out again. The contractor will say "you have to call First American to reschedule your appointment" and then when I reschedule the appointment with First American the appointment may never get rescheduled. So you got to stay on both parties to make sure that it gets rescheduled properly...
At the end of the day, the job gets done. First American keep their word on the warranty and I just got to pay that monthly fee or a yearly annual fee. It’s just that I got to do my part to make sure it gets done.
We appreciate your comments, Adrian.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2015
On or about December 11, 2014, I put in a service request as there was no heat in my house. The first contractor dispatched did not bother to return any of my calls. I will assume they did not want to service the area I live in. I then called First American back on December 12, 2014 advised them of the issue and the customer service representative was kind and proceeded to try to find someone to come out to service the problem. I voiced my concern, as I am on the east coast and it is winter. The customer service representative dispatched Always Affordable. I was advised that I would receive a call to set up a time to come out and service the heater. I did not receive a call, so I called the contractor directly, of course leaving detailed messages and contact information. I did not get a call so I again called First American. I was advised that the contractor did try to contact me but I did not respond. This should have been my first sign that I was dealing with a company and a contractor that was not reputable, because if a customer calls you expressing their need for service and giving you all contact information, why wouldn't the company call to assure that indeed I was not reachable.
Finally the contractor shows up on December 14, 2014, diagnoses the problem advising that the thermostat needed to be replaced. We then said well if that was the case then why is there only a partial flame showing in the burner as that is why we placed the order. He disregarded that, and told us to call if it goes out completely. The contractor replaced the digital programmable thermostat with a manual one. I was perturbed but at least we had heat. Since that thermostat was manual it did not shut the heat off so I purchased a digital programmable one and all was working fine until 12/29/14 when the heat went out again. This time there was no flame at all.
I immediately called the contractor and put in another request with First American. I was advised since the repair was within 30 days then a recall would have to be issued and the same contractor would have to come back. The contractor shows up immediately noticing that the thermostat was replaced. He looked at the heater and after about 20 minutes or more he advised that we would need a draft damp motor, never heard of such, but he rigged the heater so we would have heat. He advised that he would order the part and call when it comes in.
We had heat for three days. On January 2, 2015 the heat went out again. I was on the phone with First American for approximately 80 minutes explaining the chain of events to two customer service reps. Customer service Brooke advised me that for one the thermostat issue was handled improperly because it should have been replaced with the same type of thermostat. She backed the contractor up as far as him not being preventive and addressing the partial flame issue on the first call as per their policy they don't handle preventative issues and to further complicate the issue the draft damp motor is not covered.
Now as I sit in the cold I ask so if there is a part that makes the heater work goes out and if it's not covered then I go without heat. Brooke got her supervisor and proceeded to call the contractor as she needed further confirmation that was the actual issue. There was no resolution so they advised that a second opinion would be needed and an emergency call would be placed to another contractor. I called the contractor myself leaving a detailed message. Well today is another day. My family and I are still in the cold, as no one from the second opinion contractor they dispatched nor First American has called.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2015
First American is very good. The contractors are always on time. They're professional and will fix everything and solve the problem.
We appreciate your business, Inessa.
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2015
Brent Walker Plumbing (ORIGINAL CONTRACTOR) ...came to the house, looked at the job, and quoted an outlandish price estimate, which I refused, causing me unnecessary expense for NOTHING!!!
Reviewed Jan. 3, 2015
Our real estate agent had recommended First American and included it in the deal. My experience in filing a claim is good. It was an easy process. The claims representative was excellent. I use First American as my evaluator for getting things done. When things are broken that are covered in the policy, it's nice just to call them and I don't have to worry. I'm a happy customer. I'd recommend them without any qualifications.
Thank you for your feedback, Michael.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2015
My experience with First American was excellent. The woman that helped me was excellent.
Glad to hear it, Karen.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2015
When I tried to use the automated service I couldn't get a date for a repair. When I called in the consumer rep. was very helpful and was able to answer all of my questions. I had a repairperson the same day.
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2015
Submitting a claim with First American has always been easy and smooth process. We hit a bump in the road on the garage door opener, but they worked that out and I was satisfied with it. They have been very good to work with and contact you within 24 hours. Normally everything is completed within a week of you initially reporting a problem.
We appreciate your business, Brooks.
Reviewed Jan. 1, 2015
I've had First American for 6 or 7 years. I've had no problems with them when submitting a claim. They've been very efficient, with everything happening and moving right along and so I have nothing but good things to say.
Thank you for your continued business, Marilyn.
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2014
We have lived in our home for 1.5 years. The door of the top unit of our oven won't stay completely closed so the oven cuts off. Two contractors have been here and said they can't find the part number. First American said it was "excessive wear and tear" - neither of the two contractors stated this. So I had to fax - yes, FAX, the service invoice from the second contractor to FA. I never heard back. Checked online two weeks later and the service request has been closed. After speaking to a customer service rep who gave me the run around, a "supervisor" told me that an email had been sent to me stating the fax was unclear. I received NO email. I have checked junk files, etc. I asked her to forward that email to me and she said she didn't have the ability to do that. So basically, because it may take a little more effort to find the part number, I'm being told that it's excessive wear and tear. And there was zero communication with me prior to them closing this service request.
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2014
Submitting the claim with First American was an easy process. Claims representative was pretty good.
Glad to hear it, Omar.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2014
This review doesn't even deserve a one star. I have been a member of First American Home Buyers for a little over a year now. My water heater began leaking on Saturday night and damaged my ceiling (note since then I have been without hot water and the leak continues). I filed a claim that night and told that due to secondary damage someone would contact me in 8 hours and be at my home in 24 hours since it was stated as an emergent claim. Fast forward to Sunday afternoon.. I have yet to be contacted so I called First American Home Buyers for an update. They tell me that someone will be at my home at noon on Monday and that I need to call that morning and confirm.
At this point I have called the company 5 times and the contractor more times than I can count (and I have yet to speak to him). I was told by the company that he would be there after lunch (which didn't happen), that he would call me "in 5 minutes" after they were able to speak to him but my calls have gone unanswered. After multiple phone calls I was connected to a supervisor that told me that contractor was too busy (like my time waiting for him all day didn't matter) to speak to me that I would just have to continue to wait and that he never said he would be to my home today. Everyone I have spoke to at First American Home Buyers were completely rude and gave me a different answer with no real solution. At this time I am doubtful I will hear from the contractor tonight and am ready to cancel my membership for multiple reasons. I am so disappointed in the service I have received the past couple of days.
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2014
My experience so far has been wonderful. The people that came down here to fix my heater were just precious! They were over in Little Rock and it was late, but they came and they were really nice. Can't say anything good enough about it. My experience with the claims representatives has also been very good. They're very nice, helpful and responsive.
We're happy that you're happy, Alice.
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2014
I first heard about First American several years ago. My experience with them has been excellent. I had no problems submitting a claim. I received good response plus the claims representative I spoke to was very nice. So far I have everything worked right. They've been very good. Fortunately, I haven't had too many experiences using them--and I don't plan on it.
Thank you for your loyal business, Joan.
Reviewed Dec. 25, 2014
It's been excellent so far and I've had no problems with it. We've had First American Home Buyers Protection for a while now. We chose them because they have good coverage and they covered more. Their representatives do everything like they're supposed to and they give me a call back... they're concerned with the problem. The people they sent out were also very concerned and told me other things that need to be done... And they call in, get the okay from me and take care of it right then and there. They really get things done immediately.
Thank you for your continued business, Clem.
Reviewed Dec. 23, 2014
I currently have a home warranty through First American Home Buyers and I did attempt to use it last January 2014. I want to cancel my warranty with them but have hung onto it, just in case, although they completely failed me when I did need them. My garage door opener malfunctioned, causing the whole door to get stuck halfway up. I contacted this company and was told they do not have a service person in my area and was told that I needed to find someone and was given a long list of what would qualify this person under my warranty. Needless to say, with my home freezing from the north wind blowing under the garage door, not to mention a half open garage door that just invites a burglar, I found someone and just paid for it out of pocket as I needed the door fixed pronto and I couldn't take time away from work to search for a repairman that fit the warranty company's specific specifications. Today I just balanced my checkbook and noticed the monthly fee taken out by the warranty company and am frustrated with myself for not terminating services with this company as soon as they failed me, and I believe that this company is not worth the $49.00 taken out every month, so I will be correcting my oversight shortly by taking my business elsewhere.
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2014
First American was recommended to me by a friend. So far I've been very satisfied whenever I have had to use them. The representatives have been very helpful and prompt.
Thank you for your feedback, Carolyn.
Reviewed Dec. 18, 2014
When we bought our home, First American came with the purchase. Everything's been excellent. I renewed it because they did an excellent job a year ago.
Glad to hear it, Bob.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2014
Submitting a claim with First American is very easy. The representatives are very good, knowledgeable and helpful. I've been with them for 12 years and I'm very satisfied all the time. They take care of things in a very timely manner.
Thank you for your comments, Monica.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2014
I hardly ever write reviews but I feel that it is necessary to disclose how completely FRUSTRATED and DISAPPOINTED I am with First American Home Warranty. Our oven stopped working shortly after we bought our house, the electrical panel was not turning on. After sending out a vendor to our home, we were told that panel has to get sent out to be rebuilt. After receiving notices that the claim might be delayed for 30 days, we patiently waited. We love to cook and bake in our family so not having an oven was a big deal.
Fast forward to 10 weeks later, the part was still not fixed and vendor cannot provide an ETA on the part. After numerous calls and follow ups, I was told it would be resolved by a certain date. That date has come and gone, the oven part was not fixed and again, no ETA can be provided. Another 2 weeks later, I was advised that the oven part could not be rebuilt and they will replace my oven. Great news, I thought. WRONG! Home warranty offered a comparable oven with same specs except that the dimensions was off. The new oven was too deep to fit in the current location, it is built-in a cabinet space.
After speaking to the supplier of the oven, they alerted home warranty of that fact. Home warranty said that we did not supply the model or serial number of the oven and they requested measurements and pictures. They did not EVER ask us for that information. Regardless of that fact, when I spoke to home warranty, they said that they do not match dimensions anyway, they just match the specs and functionality. Which translates to giving you the cheapest oven on the market. Which would not be a big deal if the oven FITS in the actual spot.
So my options are to take the oven, upgrade it with supplier or take the cash out. NONE of these options work for me since A) the oven doesn't fit, we will have to break down our cabinets and wall to make it fit which will be an additional cost, B) upgrading it to one that fits will be an additional cost and C) taking the cash out to buy our oven will be an additional cost because the amount they gave us does not even cover the oven they offered us at retail. So either way, we are out of pocket for at least a few hundred dollars.
I am not sure how First American runs their business but it is just not ACCEPTABLE especially when the supplier have the same brand of oven that we currently have but won't offer to us. We have missed cooking and baking for my son's first birthday, we have missed Thanksgiving and now it looks like we may miss Christmas. You would think after making us wait 3 months to fix our oven, they would be a little lenient in giving us an oven that actually fits in our current space. That would be the most simple thing to do. Instead now, they save money, we have to pay either to fix our cabinets or pay for an upgrade.
Now we are at 14 weeks and this claim has not been resolved and the only way to resolve it is for us to come out of pocket. We do not have that kind of money to just throw around since we are new homeowners and this was not an expense we had anticipated. No one would find this acceptable, no one. After speaking to the claim management specialist and his supervisor, it seems they don't really care or try to make an effort to rectify this situation after we have waited so patiently for them to make this repair. It is just a shame. This is just ridiculous for someone to go through just to get an appliance repaired or replaced.
Hi Kelly. Thank you for your feedback. Your claim has been resolved. Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2014
When we bought the house, First American was transferred over to the house. My experience in submitting a claim has been good. The contractor called us back within 24 hours at least so it's been great.
We appreciate your feedback, Connie.
Reviewed Dec. 17, 2014
I've been paying $46/month for a home warranty for 2.5 years. Tues, 12/9: Washer broke, I submitted a claim. Wed, 12/10: I got a call asking if I wanted Sears out on Friday or Monday. I picked Monday 10-2. Mon, 12/15: Nobody came so I called and was told my appointment was Monday, 12/22. I explained it was booked for 12/15, and was told, "Sorry, 12/22 is the soonest available appointment." After saying this was unacceptable and asking what they could do, Mari told me she would submit a ticket to see if there was a cancellation to squeeze me in, and it would take 24-48 hours to get a reply. She also said I couldn't talk to a manager as they couldn't do anything for me, so I called 1st American and after being on hold for 20 min, I gave up and sent a message attached to the claim through the site. It took 24 hours for them to respond, including this tidbit: "Given the time of year, to re-dispatch this claim could cause further delays in having someone out to the home to diagnose what the failure is."
Really, it would take longer to get out here if they tried to help? I understand mistakes are made, but when they are, you might try and help the customer. I'd like to add that I reviewed the contract and there is no service-level agreement with regard to how long it can take for a contractor to come out or how long it can take for the repair to be made. If you read the other 1-star reviews on here, you can see some customers have been waiting for months and months and no progress is being made to fix the item - they just continue sending different contractors out to try and diagnose the issue, which per the contract, they can do forever while meeting their contractual requirements.
Hi Jennifer. We appreciate your feedback. We are glad to know your claim was resolved. Thank you, Stephanie.
Reviewed Dec. 16, 2014
Submitting a claim to First American has been good so far. They are very helpful and concerned.
Thank you, Alberto.
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2014
I’ve had nothing but exemplary service with First American, both in the settling of the claims, people calling up to get the repair done and having somebody out the same day usually to have the repair made - very good experience.
Thanks, John.
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2014
My experience with First American has been wonderful. Everyone’s been so nice whenever I called. I never get a condescending tone in their voice. They say, “Here is what’s close to you. Here’s what you can call. If they haven’t called you within 24 hours, give us a call.” I never had to do that because everyone that’s been out has been very trustworthy. I know that if something comes up that’s not under the warranty that I need, I will call them especially these last electricians that came out. They were great.
Glad to hear it, Cynthia.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2014
It was a very easy process submitting a claim. We’re very satisfied with First American and plan to carry on the policy throughout the year. They were extremely professional. One thing we really appreciated was constant feedback and information, which we usually don’t get (you have to pry people to get information on status, etc.) and they were forthcoming that way and very proactive, which we very much appreciated. So even though there were moments that might have been a little frustrating, the frustration was alleviated by this forthcoming information.
Thank you for leaving your feedback, Adelaide.
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2014
It's been very good. We've used them more than once and they've sent reliable people to fix the job the first time and I'm very happy with it. I've only ever had one problem and that was with the plumber they provided. He did not know what he was doing. He did not come prepared with any tools and he never did fix the problem. So when we were having some plumbing issues (I tried doing my drain with the heavy duty liquid plumber stuff) and when I talked to them about my last claim about the refrigerator I asked who they have for a plumber because I definitely didn't want him back in my house again because he didn't know what he was doing and they said, "Well, if you don't like who we send to you, if you have a problem, we'll just send somebody else." And I don't think they do so that wouldn't have been an issue.
Thanks, Susan.
Reviewed Dec. 12, 2014
The person that we purchased our house from signed up for the year warranty with First American and we just continued it. It was definitely very easy submitting a claim. They were very professional, very quick and it kept our mind at ease from the issue that we had. Our entire experience with First American has been great.
Thank you for sharing, Julie.
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2014
I didn't really have any problems with First American. I was real pleased. There was some miscommunication with the plumber. The first one didn't call back which is not First American's fault. There was a little bit of delay there but all things worked out beautifully. Interacting with their claims rep has been very good. The young lady that helped me at the end was Michelle and she was excellent. She checked back on every little detail and kept communication lines open. She was wonderful.
Thanks for the feedback, Debra.
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2014
I found about First American online and I compared it with other home warranty providers. I thought First American was what I needed more. I've only submitted one claim and it was easy. Overall, a very good experience.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, John.
Reviewed Dec. 10, 2014
I was so dissatisfied with the warranty people that I had and I had read some good reviews about First American. Submitting a claim to them was an excellent experience. The repairman was here within 48 hours to fix the problem and I was very satisfied with the results.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, Shirley.
Reviewed Dec. 9, 2014
Out is dishwasher from over 2 months now. They have sent over 6 different contractor to look into that. All of them said that it cannot be repaired, but they are still sending more contractor to check the machines. Every time we call them, it takes over 45 mins on hold and after that either agents hang up the phone or is not supportive. At this time I am so irritated and want to sue them.
Hi Sumeet. Thank you for your feedback. Your claim has been resolved.Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Dec. 9, 2014
I wouldn't even give them even one star as they are extremely bad with their services. My dishwasher stopped working back in October. It's Dec now and already 5-6 contractors have visited with no results. Every time I call them it takes at least 40 minutes to get to an agent who keeps on assigning new contractors. Even the supervisor had no answers. He said it shouldn't be a problem washing a couple of dishes at home!!! It's really annoying because they cannot fix a basic thing as dishwasher in 3 months!!!
Reviewed Dec. 9, 2014
We heard about First American from our realtor. Submitting a claim to them has been excellent. The first time we had to deal with their claims rep was not good but the second and third time were good. The first time I would have probably cancelled but the second and third were excellent. They probably got it because I complained so much. It was really bad but it's good now. First American and the people they use are quick - that's why I like them. Within 10 minutes, I get a call back. My phone will ring before I even get it shut down. They usually tell you between four and five people will call and I've only had two people call but as quick as they are, that's what I want because they're going to be prompt since they're prompt calling me. The turnaround is phenomenal.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, Arlene.
Reviewed Dec. 8, 2014
Our entire plumbing in our home become clogged on a Saturday. I spent hours on the phone calling First American Home Buyers Protection, only to be put on hold for 15-30 minutes at a time. After hours of not getting anywhere I called back, was told they weren't able to provide a plumber. I was told they would give me the opportunity to find a plumber myself and they would then cover cost. Well here it is two days later while still having no water (and elderly, children and disabled), I've been on the phone mind you having to either be placed on hold for 20-30 minutes at a time, hung up on, etc. And am still on the phone 3 way mind you with the plumber and First American now for 35 minutes just trying to get First American to give authorization. I've paid this company (First American) $960.00 a year to be treated this way. Unbelievable!!!! Now I'm told they're not going to cover my plumbing!!
Reviewed Dec. 8, 2014
My experience with American Home Buyers was great! However, the price of the contract is more than I can envision expending for repair services on my appliances in a year. Therefore, it is not something I would consider renewing.
Thank you for your comments, Ethel.
Reviewed Dec. 8, 2014
I heard about First American through the mortgage company. It is easy to submit a claim and the claims representatives have been great.
Glad to hear it, Matthew.
Reviewed Dec. 8, 2014
If I could give this company ZERO star I would. It has been 3 weeks that they said they will come and fix my washer, in Florida. I own a condo in Florida and live in New York, but the condo is rented. The tenant has been out of a washer for THREE weeks now. As I have read other bad reviews about them, YES it is true you have to wait 20 minutes or longer for someone from the claims resolution to answer the phone. It is disgusting.
I started to take names, who I speak with and what department they are in. And I also asked for the OWNER or CEO of the company. I told everyone that I spoke with that he needs to know what kind of company he is running by hiring incompetent idiots! I advise you who have problem, to ask for the name of the owner and address and send him a complaint. REMEMBER, THE PEN IS MIGHTIER THAN THE SWORD! Once they fix my problem, I AM SO DONE WITH THEM!!!!
Reviewed Dec. 7, 2014
Overall experience with First American is good. They've pretty much taken care of what I want to do so it's a viable product. Any time we ever have anything wrong, we call them and there's usually somebody out there. The most trouble I ever have was with contractors and the area we live in is so big they don't always get to you as quick as you'd like. But First American does what they say. They are always good about approving your work.
Thank you for your feedback, Bryan.
Reviewed Dec. 6, 2014
First American contacted me and I liked what they were offering as well as the price. With them, it is not difficult to submit a claim. I had no problem and the claims representatives were all good. I would recommend First American. I’ve had a good experience with them and I’m glad that I got the service because it has been beneficial.
Thank you for recommending us, Lucy.
Updated review: Feb. 24, 2015
Over two months since writing the review, I can say the issue is finally resolved. It was not without serious pain. In short, after writing this review:
2) New equipment was ordered - which had the wrong dimensions to fit physically
3) The one-man band contractor went AWOL.
4) New one-man band contractor assigned
5) New heat pump system ordered - a correct match finally.
6) One-man band contractor took 4 days to complete about 25% of the work, worked in a dangerous manner, and sprayed the side of my house with refrigerant oil by disconnecting pressurized pipes incorrectly.
7) I refused to let one-man band return and also refused to pay anything out of pocket.
8) First American finally assigned a half-way decent contractor in their network - one that actually has an office, multiple employees, a scheduler, official company trucks, etc.
9) The new contractor had to send a team of 2 guys that worked 12 hours to correct previous mistakes and get the new system running.
In the end, I do finally have a working heat pump system, installed by a quality contractor. The effort required to get to this point was much too great, and I was only able to do it because I have a flex schedule and can work from home. I also have a dual-fuel system, so I was able to run on cheap natural gas furnace this entire time instead of electric backup heat. Somebody with a rigid schedule would have been screwed and would have had to accept a lesser repair and moved on or took the ridiculously low cash-out.
No coincidence, I just got a letter from First American informing me they will not be offering a renewal on my one-year contract (paid for by seller of home). I could see that one coming from a mile away. Ha!
Original Review: Dec. 5, 2014
On 10/17/2014, I opened a service request with First American regarding the heat pump system failing to operate. The contractor that First American assigned attempted repair unsuccessfully. The contractor condemned the heat pump condenser (aka outdoor unit). First American approved replacing compressor part inside the old condenser, even though that was against the contractor's professional opinion of replacing entire condenser. I escalated and First American agreed to replace the entire outdoor condenser with a R22 Model, to avoid having to change from R22 refrigerant to R410.
I asked First American to replace the indoor evaporative coil as well, as this is a covered component in the contract and the contract states when First American is replacing the condenser of Heat Pump split system, the Company will replace covered components as necessary to maintain compatibility and operating efficiency as required by the manufacturer of the replacement unit. The contract also states that when First American is replacing the unit, they will replace the unit with one that meets current federal efficiency standards. The current federal efficiency standard is 13 SEER/7.7 HSPF for Heat Pumps. The original indoor evaporative coil is approximately 25 years old and was rated for 9 SEER with the old condenser. It is impossible for a new 13 SEER condenser to operate at 13 SEER when it is paired with an old indoor evaporative coil, hence it needs to be replaced per the contract.
First American agreed and ordered CX34-36C-6F Evaporative coil and 13HPX-036-230 Condenser from Lennox. The installation manual for the 13HPX says the indoor evaporator coil used with the system must be specified in the Lennox Engineering Handbook. The CX34-36C-6F does not appear in the handbook and is not properly matched. This risks premature system failure, breaches the contract we have in place, and voids warranty of equipment!
I have provided multiple copies of official Lennox documentation to First American and they continue to deny the obvious facts that are clearly stated in the documentation. They say they "checked with Lennox" and "confirmed it is compatible", but they have not sent me one single shred of documentation. I would gladly drop the matter and be a satisfied consumer once again if they simply sent me the official documentation that refutes and supersedes the official documentation I provided. Instead, they are giving me no choice but to go to the Attorney General in my state, the BBB, Consumeraffairs.com, and lastly resolution thru the legal system. I cannot let them install a system in my house that is meant to last 10+ years that is not properly matched by the manufacturer, does not have an efficiency rating that meets the federal minimum as the contract states, and could have premature compressor failure and no warranty coverage because it is not properly matched.
Reviewed Dec. 5, 2014
We’ve had First American for 10 years ever since we bought the house. They’re fairly responsive. The claims representatives have been positive. We’re happy with them as they come in handy when we need them.
Thank you for your continued business, Lauran.
Reviewed Dec. 4, 2014
I moved to Oregon from California. I learned about First American from the real estate agent when I was buying the home here. I haven’t been here long enough yet but so far I’m very happy. It was very easy submitting a claim. They were very helpful and I was very satisfied with the claims representatives.
Happy to hear it, Jaroslav.
Reviewed Dec. 3, 2014
Our realtor gifted us First American for the first year. Submitting a claim has been fairly easy and most of the claims I submitted have been online. We're pleased with the coverage so far and would recommend them to friends.
Thank you for recommending us, Tracie
Reviewed Dec. 2, 2014
We were in another service company. We decided to go with First American because the rates were good. We’ve had a few occasions where First American had chosen the company to come to the home and they’re not adequately qualified to do the job but they’ve solved those issues and we’ve moved on.
Thanks for the feedback, Patricia.
Reviewed Dec. 1, 2014
I heard about First American Home Buyers when I purchased my house. It’s easy to file a claim with them. The claims representatives has been satisfactory and we haven’t had a problem. Everything has been well and I can’t complain. I already recommended it to one of my friends.
Thank you for recommending us, Rebecca.
Reviewed Nov. 30, 2014
I experienced a good experience. It’s all good.
Thanks, George!
Reviewed Nov. 29, 2014
We had a different home warranty provider. I hadn't had the best service and success rate with them. So I was looking around and my father gave me First American’s information, and that was the first and last call I made. The experience so far was pretty smooth. Had a claim and called it in. I had a little trouble with the phone system to try to understand what you're trying to submit. But then I got to a live person and we talked through it. Once we got that, the claim was made, someone reached out in 24 hours and got the job taken care of pretty quickly.
Glad to hear it, Steve.
Reviewed Nov. 27, 2014
I've had First American Home Buyers Protection for about three years now. I first came upon them on the Internet when I was doing a search. We used to live in Louisiana and the home we purchased over there had one, and we decided to continue with it. Not long after we moved in, I had the occasion to have to use it. And ever since then, whenever I purchased a home or had one, I've always carried a home warranty with it. Submitting a claim has been very pleasant and very timely. The people on the phone have been pleasant. They got in touch with the contractor and they got in contact with me fairly promptly - the same afternoon or the next morning. And they were able to get the work done and the contractors that I've so far had to use with them seemed competent. They've been very professional and courteous and they met my needs. I've been real pleased and have no complaints.
We appreciate your feedback, David.
Reviewed Nov. 26, 2014
Furnace went out in early winter. Call and wait at least 20 minutes each time you call, but get nothing but the runaround and lies. Been over 25 days without heat and still no furnace. Every day I call and wait 20-30 minutes on hold so they can tell me the same lies about how they can't get the supplier to give them a tracking number??? Waste of money and extremely frustrating. I would not recommend this company to anyone. It's a shame they use American in their name because they are not about customer service.
Hi Josh. Thank you for your feedback. Your claim has been resolved. Thank you. Natalie.
Reviewed Nov. 25, 2014
I had a home warranty before but since I traveled a lot I discontinued it. Now that I'm home, I just got another one and chose First American Home Buyers Protection. Submitting a claim with them was fine,. There were no problems and the process was easy. The gentleman who came out to fix it was fine as well. I'd recommend First American.
Thank you for recommending us, Alberta.
Reviewed Nov. 25, 2014
When we bought the house we got the seller give us the home warranty with it. And we’ve been with First American for about less than 10 years now. A year or two will go by without any problems, and then some problems may come up so it’s always good to have insurance. Some of the home repairs took a little longer time to schedule and get it done but that’s part of the process. But 75% of the time, they were pretty done within the expected time. Interaction with the claims representative was very brief, very short and prompt. They were able to answer all of my questions and they were friendly.
Thank you for your loyal business!
Reviewed Nov. 25, 2014
My dishwasher broke, it was not draining. Call First American to set up a repair. They send SoCal appliance, the technician shows up 5 minutes and tells me he needs to order a part, walks out. No receipt, no reschedule time frame was given by the tech. I had to go outside and look for the SoCal tech. He had left without giving a receipt or return date. A week later I call the house warranty and ask them what's going on with the service. They tell that they are going to return on 11/20/14 11 to 3 pm, so take a day off work to wait for them. They call me at 2:30 pm telling that the tech can't make it, that they could be here on Sunday the 23. So I waited again and nothing. I call the house warranty and they tell me that they will be here Sunday Nov 30. Now it's been 3 weeks and my dishwasher still has not been fix. I call the house warranty and they tell me all they can do is give $11.00 dollars for all my troubles and basically go screw myself. She hung up on me. Beware of this company, they are a scam. All they want is your money. When it comes to customer service or satisfaction they don't give a ** about you. Now I with no dishwasher and have to buy one out my pocket. Never again will I make business with this company.
Reviewed Nov. 24, 2014
When we bought our house, First American was offered to us. The sellers bought the first year for us. We found out that we could renew it ourselves, so we did. And I’m thrilled to death with it. We submitted a claim on some electric and they took care of it, and everything happened very quickly and people did exactly what they said they were going to do and it worked just fine. And then he did it on the dishwasher. The warranty has been wonderful. Claims representatives were wonderful. They were very polite, extremely helpful and they followed through. We got a call within 48 hours, or 24 whatever it was. We’ve been really happy with what we’ve experienced with them. I recommended them to our son who’s now doing it. And any chance I get to tell anybody how wonderful it is, I do.
Thanks for your comments, Michael.
Reviewed Nov. 24, 2014
I heard about First American through our realtor. She has an account with them personally and she trusts them so we chose it as our home warranty provider. Submitting a claim is pretty easy, I never had any problems with it. Either I do it live or online, everything has been followed through and I never had an issue. The claims representative was very helpful, professional, and work really hard to get everything set up as quick as possible. I've been happy with the service I've received through the vendors that they contracted with. They're professional and did what they needed to do. I've never had to argue about anything. I've never had issues like the stuff I hear about other warranty companies, so we'll continue to use them. I know several people that have started a policy through First American because of my experience.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, Ryan.
Reviewed Nov. 24, 2014
We chose First American as home warranty for our house. It’s very reasonably priced. Submitting a claim was excellent and claims process was very easy. The service has always been done correctly. They come out here, troubleshoot the problem, and if they can’t fix it that day, they give me an estimated time of return date and they come back and fix the problem. My experience with them has been very good and I’m very satisfied. It’s very reasonably priced.
Thank you for sharing about your experience, Leopoldo.
Reviewed Nov. 23, 2014
First American was part of my closing when I got my house and I've had them since then. I've always gotten excellent service and response to my needs. And other people recommend a different company but I rather stay with who I’ve been with. When submitting a claim, they're very prompt to respond. The representatives are very friendly and very helpful. And they make sure that if I’m having issues with the contractor, that they resolve it as soon as they can.
Glad to hear about your experience, Rosa.
Reviewed Nov. 23, 2014
I acquired a home warranty through First American because my daughter had it. She recommended it and it made sense. The first time I submitted a claim of something minor, that was taken care of though there was a little bit of a mix-up. They never sent me a bill and I got a letter saying they were going to drop me if I didn't pay the bill. So I paid the bill, it was $50 something. Then I called them recently and had to wait two weeks to have my stove repaired and that was a little inconvenient. The sales representative referred me to their outsourcing. They took all the information and the people that they had subcontracted out made me wait so long and I didn't like that. Other than that they did a great job and I'm very satisfied and would recommend them.
Thank you for recommending us, Domingo.
Reviewed Nov. 22, 2014
I've had First American for a long time and I like it. I haven't had any troubles. I always get something in the mail saying if I wanted to change or anything, but I don't. The claims representatives are fine and the contractors are always on time and do good work.
We appreciate your business, Beverly.
Reviewed Nov. 22, 2014
Submitting a claim through First American has been fine, simple and easy.
Fantastic, John!
Reviewed Nov. 21, 2014
First American has been very good. A few of the contractors that they have are really knowledgeable and very helpful. I've dealt with a few and they seem honest.
Thanks for your feedback, Armando.
First American Home Warranty Company Information
- Company Name:
- First American Home Warranty
- Year Founded:
- 1984
- City:
- Santa Rosa
- State/Province:
- CA
- Website:
- homewarranty.firstam.com
Media


