
Papa Johns Reviews
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.
Our editorial standards
- Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
- We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
- All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
About Papa Johns
This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.
Papa Johns has specialized in serving pizza, breadsticks and desserts since 1984. The company offers customizable pizza options, aiming to provide quality food through its "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." philosophy, serving customers in numerous locations worldwide.
Visit www.papajohns.com- High-quality food options
- Frequent order inaccuracies
Papa Johns Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (32)
- (3)
- (16)
- (82)
- (505)
Popular Mentions
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
Recent
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
Our review standards
- Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
- We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
- Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.

Reviewed Nov. 18, 2026
I’m typically happy with Papa Johns and please believe me when I tell you I’m far from a Karen! I placed an online order (Edgemere)and even though I received my pizza 50 minutes late, I still tipped the driver. Where I draw the line is, I opened the box and the pizza was ice cold and not what I ordered.. I was very disappointed, so I called to let them know about the mistake. They promptly let me know that they saw where the driver was delivering very late and they also saw that the order was incorrect and they offered to send out another pizza but advised me that it was going to take a while since they were very busy. At that point I just said I would prefer a refund. I don’t want to wait another hour. The manager Evelyn let me know that she would get the refund out to me and it would take about 3 days and to call back on the 3rd day.
I still have not received the refund and when I called, they let me know that there was a miscommunication somewhere. They didn’t see me in the “system” a different manager, Leo told me that he saw in the system where there was a free pizza supposed to be sent out, but then that was “canceled” so for that reason they were not allowed to offer me a refund. I was disappointed with that, but I still said well then I guess you can send me the correct pizza that I never got to begin with and he said “I’m sorry I won’t be able to do that either.. the system won’t allow me to”. Pretty much I just had to take the loss. I didn’t get the pizza that I ordered OR a refund! They are perfectly OK with that. I guess one customer doesn’t matter to them. We ordered pizza regularly and I was very shocked at the thanks I got for being a loyal Customer.
Reviewed Nov. 13, 2026
I called Papa John's on Saturday November 7th at 12:25 p.m. to order a delivery & asked if there were any specials. The girl who worked that shift advised me that "specials are only ordered through the App or online." I asked, "What if you're a senior citizen and don't have the App or know how to do that?", and without a word she put me on hold and left me there. For 3 minutes & 17 seconds. I hung up & called back immediately at 12:28 p.m. (I know she could see my phone number) and she just let the phone ring. For 4 minutes & 40 seconds until I hung up. I called back again immediately at 12:33 p.m. & she just took the phone off the hook & laid it on the counter. I could hear them working & the pizza oven timers going off. She left me there for 1 minute 27 seconds & I hung up.
I called back immediately at 12:34 p.m. & she did the same thing, took the phone off the hook & laid it down. This time for 1 minute 47 seconds when, again, I hung up. I called back immediately at 12:36 p.m. & she did the same, just took the phone off the hook & laid it down. This time I waited for 20 minutes & 18 seconds & she never came back to the phone except to hang me up after all that time. I've called Papa John's Corporate & am waiting on a return call which I was told would happen but no one had called me back. I'm calling them again today. I will NEVER EVER order from them again. And I'm going to spread this far & wide, what customer service, or lack thereof, they have. My family has ordered from them for about 25 years & my daughter used to work there, but NEVER AGAIN.
Thanks for subscribing.
You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

Reviewed Oct. 31, 2026
They are ruining a "game day bundle" deal. It claims you can but 2 large, 2 topping pizzas, for $9.99... however, they charge you for your servings tipping... be careful, they are dishonest and stealing from their customers!
Reviewed Oct. 29, 2026
I just purchased a pizza and a Philly sandwich. Pizza was great Philly was 95% bread with barely any product on it. Did not look like the picture at all. Sucks. And it's supposed to be new ? Better get someone new that knows how to make one. One and done with me.
Greg
Newburgh, In.

Reviewed Oct. 29, 2026
Atrocious as always. After last time I swore I'd never be back. Went in, got in line and when it was my turn associate looked right past me and helped the person behind me in line without even acknowledging my presence. This store is such a joke.
Reviewed Oct. 19, 2026
Ordered a pizza tonight and they didn’t even cut it and look like they took a bite out of both the peppers!!

Reviewed Oct. 16, 2026
When the pizza is done right it's great. However apparently Homosassa Papa Johns has no structure, no teaching and no understanding of how to properly bake a pizza so the dough isn't slimy in the middle and everything doesn't look raw. I'm sick of paying high dollar for a pizza that I have to cook once it arrives. That's the point in getting pizza - So you can come home after a long week and NOT HAVE to cook.
Reviewed Oct. 11, 2026
We just ordered from Papa Johns in Anaheim hills. 2 of the people who answered the phone could not speak English. My daughter used to work there at 16 yrs old when it was only americans that spoke English!! Sorry John, but we won't support any businesses that have workers that do not speak English or we can't understand!! How sad!!!!

Reviewed Oct. 4, 2026
Placed an online order for location 6559 W Hwy 90, Milton, FL 32570. Get to the location and it's not open. No further information listed at location. Now will have to file fraud charges in order to get money back.

Reviewed Oct. 1, 2026
This review is for the store located on Arapahoe Ave in Englewood, CO. I’m a DoorDash driver. I came in a few days ago at 2:39am to pick up DoorDash order. An ** teenager told me that he didn’t have the order, but no customers are allowed after 2:40am. However, they take orders until 2:55am. I’m a DoorDash driver, so I’m not a customer. But just out of curiosity, how are the orders picked up between 2:40am and 2:55am? Today was even better. I hope DoorDash drops them. I came in and the guy said they didn’t have the order. I reached out to DoorDash support. The agent came back on the line and told me that he called the store twice and no one answered.
I walked into the store and the guy behind the counter refused to get on the phone with DoorDash and walked away to the basement. The customer service agent called two more times and said that they were not answering. I asked for contact information of the store owner and was refused. I will contact the corporate office about this. They forgot that the reason for the orders is DoorDash sending customers.
Reviewed Sept. 29, 2026
I used to love Papa John’s and ordered it this weekend with my husband, and man has it changed! The crust was cheap and crappy and nothing like the delicious crust I remember getting. I’m not sure why they changed it but it was definitely not a good move in my opinion.
Reviewed Sept. 11, 2026
The local Papa Johns in s beloit. The food sucks. The store has issues as in the customer is not right, they are. The district manager does not contact you back.

Reviewed Aug. 29, 2026
Ordered a large stuffed crust pizza. They delivered the wrong one. We called to talk to the manager. He said he was sorry. He remembered that he made it wrong because he was the only one there. He also stated that he was the ONLY one on duty. He had no helpers at all. Told us he would put the correct pizza for free for us on our account. The NEXT day we called for that pizza and they said he refunded our money instead even though that isn't what we were told. NEVER ORDERING FROM THERE AGAIN.

Reviewed Aug. 28, 2026
Small addition on all products (sauce, cheese, pepperoni, sausage, bacon) to the pizza crust.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2026
Watch their website. It changes your order for no reason and you end up with an onion only pizza. Totally disgusting! Store wouldn't do anything at all, called corporate and some guy that sounded stoned out of his mind, in fact, I kept having to say hello until he woke up and responded. The outcome was someone would contact me within 48 hours. I guess we go hungry tonight. Ridiculous. Fix your website!
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2026
Good pizza, amazing, it’s delicious and the cheese

Reviewed Aug. 10, 2026
The food was as I expected. What I didn't expect was the driver telling me they didn't have the drink I ordered and they couldn't/wouldn't refund me the cost of the drink. I shouldn't have to pay in advance if they can't guarantee I'll get everything I order. They informed me I would have to contact Door dash, but provided zero information to do this. I called the store and they refused to help with any of it. They acted as if I ordered through door dash, but I'd ordered through Papa John's website... but they were terribly rude and very unhelpful. I still haven't received a refund. I was ordering about once per week until now... now I'm annoyed and looking for a different vegan option for pizza delivery.

Reviewed Aug. 9, 2026
This weekend I was forced to sit through the same Papa John's commercial while in a hotel in Jackson, MS. The commercial caused me to question the quality of their pizza and sanitation in general. The commercial showed pizzas being made with pepperoni and cheese being added to the pie. The thing that concerned me was the fact that whoever was slapping the ingredients on the pizza wasn't wearing gloves. He was barehanded. Gross!! Watch closely the next time one comes on TV. I would have commented directly to Papa John's but their website did not provide an option to do so.
Reviewed Aug. 6, 2026
Ordered online, only one person working front counter at location. I asked about my order. It was still in oven. I step back to wait. 5mins later, she started pulling orders out the oven. My order was set aside. She let me wait 3 to 5 more minutes before she just handed my order over. My pizza was cold when I home. I feel that was not good customer service. She didn't seem rushed or real busy.

Reviewed Aug. 5, 2026
Food really Hot and cooked correctly and tasty. Evening shift is the bomb! Love the quality at a low cost.

Reviewed Aug. 3, 2026
The Stuffed Pepperoni Deal tasted like cardboard. Like a Deadbeat Papa. Dry. No good. Taste like old ass cheese.

Reviewed July 15, 2026
Website and app said open until 12:30am. Placed a to go order around 9pm, it was accepted via app. Drove 15 min to the store and lights are off with door locked. They had already taken my money on the app so called customer service and spoke with multiple "managers", they all said they had to call the location which of course didn't answer but left the back ordering system/computer on. They said they are open even though they didn't answer, and we have pics of being closed. Said they couldn't refund us and someone would call in 48 hrs to discuss. NOT acceptable and will never patronize this business again, actually not any Papa John's due to the business practices or lack thereof.
Reviewed July 13, 2026
They have a poor website that does not work half the time. The last time (recently) I tried to place an order it would not recognize my account. When I went to the alternate way through my email, lo and behold, my name came up and I was able to place my order. I used my remaining credits and placed my order. The store is just next door. When I walked over there the guy said they had no order from me. I went back home and saw there was no confirmation email. What the **? When I checked my credit card statement it did not show a transaction. I tried going back to the site and still had the same issues. I did get to a point that it would not log me in, but it sure knew who I was and I saw my order, without my discount on it. What a ** up company. You cannot even do a review to the corporate office.
Reviewed July 10, 2026
Disappointed with how I was treated at this location. I came in to order food, and the lobby was completely empty. You have to ring a buzzer just to be let inside, yet the staff turned me away because I brought my bicycle into the large lobby with me. I explicitly explained that I did not have a lock and could not leave my bike outside to be stolen. The employee claimed that if they allowed me to bring my bike in, everyone would start doing it—which makes no sense given that they strictly control who enters via a buzzer. It felt like an arbitrary rule used to selectively target and turn away certain customers. Extremely unwelcoming and rigid service. I will not be returning.

Reviewed June 26, 2026
First pizza I've gotten there that the crust was like something you would get making it yourself, from a box of a Chef Boyardee pizza kit. Pitiful! I called the manager to let her know, and she got very ill tempered with me. Lost my temper then too. Ended up hanging up on her. Won't ever go back to that location, perhaps never Papa Johns period.
Reviewed June 15, 2026
Wait for 2 hours. I placed order online. I got there, pay for my order and get a seat online, said my order was ready for pick up. Went to the counter, ask for my order and the lady with shaking hands looking like drunk not even talk to me. I call the guy in the back. I believe his name is John and talk to her about my order. I get back to my table and 30 minutes later go back to the counter and finally she give my order. Half of my order was missing so I ask for a refund it and the guy yelling me was so mad. Well only way to get my money back I have to call the police. Never see anything like that crazy people, danger people working with the customer.

Reviewed June 5, 2026
Trash, whoever made that pizza should never cook again.

Reviewed May 12, 2026
I had boycotted Papa John's for 5 years. I on 5/8/26, I placed a delivery, ordered the pizza, was delivered as if the driver was in a NASCAR race. I called the store on Hamilton Ave and the manager was rude. I called corporate uncle to understand to rep. Who claim she unable to issue a refund but have a pizza remade. I don't have 25 to waste.

Reviewed May 3, 2026
I have over the years had really good experiences with Papa Johns but today not so much. I paid 10.00 for a bowl that wasn't even a quarter inch thick. The whole bottom of the bowl was not even covered with melted cheese. Will not be order that again. Don't waste your money on one from this location. Or that is exactly what you will be doing wasting money.

Reviewed May 2, 2026
Just went to Papa Johns. Love the pizza and price. Breona was very helpful and patient. Thank you so much!! Always come here when I'm in town. Never disappointed when Breona is working!!
Reviewed April 30, 2026
I ordered pizza for my office and was charged twice on my credit card and my co-worker was charged once after being told the card didn't go through. I first spoke with customer service and a manager and was told they didn't see the charges even though I showed proof of the transactions. Now they won't respond nor issue refunds for the charges. I will NEVER go back! Avoid this place unless you want to get Ripped off!

Reviewed April 26, 2026
You have no right to push for your customers to pay for your employees via tips. I'm referring to the message that is now shoved at everyone when they come to your company for food. You're going to lose customers over this because people are tired of being pushed around by arrogant companies and having tips demanded from them.

Reviewed April 15, 2026
If could give 0 stars would, always messes up order and never willing to replace and management is trash and does not handle business well at Mall Road Florence location
Reviewed April 15, 2026
When I ordered a pizza from Papa John's in Sumter SC, my pizza was overcooked, hard, and the pizza was cut into four big slices. It was a disappointment. I called the store to Papa John's back and was kept on hold for 30+ mins. I went back to the store the next day and the manager Steven, apologized and remade my pizza. I was happy that he was nice and professional. I don't like to spend money to be dissatisfied. I'm glad Steven got my order straight.
Reviewed April 12, 2026
Ordered some pizza tonight and it wasn't delivered until an hour later. 10:50- 11:01 was the delivery time and it came after closing, at 12:11 the pizza was ** cold, the wings were cold, one of my pizzas didn't even have cheese or toppings on it and it was ripped up on one side. This was the worse experience I've ever had with Papa Johns, the manager tried to say it was in a oven / hot box and that's a damn lie because ain't no way for a dasher to bring my food and it's completely cold. It's okay because I know now I won't order delivery anymore. The manager wasn't a help either, he said I could take the pizza back for a refund or they could remake it. What a total inconvenience. And annoying AF. I'll be taking the jacked up ** pizza back so they can refund me my money. I'd give less stars if possible.

Reviewed April 8, 2026
Blocked my number. They did not get last name right and the pizza is nasty and cold and called 9 times And had to call of a different phone because they blocked the number.
Reviewed March 22, 2026
No gloves used. Came right in from outside and prepared dough, no hand washing. That's gross. Hand washing is the key. Last time I order from them....
Reviewed March 19, 2026
I go to the Festus, Mo. Papa Johns weekly. After placing a pizza order and every time it is made perfectly the same, absolutely, delicious. All the staff are nice, helpful and always working hard. The Manager, is so kind, courteous to even help carry items to my car or hold the door open when I am struggling. Best Pizza place in Festus and perfect every time with friendly faces. Rhonda P.

Reviewed March 19, 2026
I haven't ordered from them since they got rid of the meatballs. I have quietly suffered through raw or burnt pizzas, rancid garlic sauce, popped sauce containers that were shoved in with pizzas; raw toppings or desserts, what tasted like frostbitten cheese and dumbass delivery fees. After all of that, I STILL ordered their food, but doing away with meatballs? Unforgivable offense. They may have been subpar but who tf eats six meatballs. It's un-American if you ask me. Preposterous.

Reviewed March 14, 2026
No gloves are used in their food preparation process. Employees say they’re NOT required to wear gloves, just wash their hands. I guess they can dig in their nose and scratch their hair and continue to fix people food. Food looks fine but it is what I cannot see is what worries me.
Papa Johns Company Information
- Company Name:
- Papa Johns
- Website:
- www.papajohns.com



