How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

Papa Johns Reviews

1.8
683 reviewsRating Calculation
A company’s ratings are a time-based and verification-based weighted average numerical calculation of the ratings submitted by consumers in the most recent 24-month period.

Our editorial standards

  • Our editorial team reviews and fact-checks all content before it’s published.
  • We rely on expert input and trusted sources to verify our articles.
  • All articles published must meet our editorial standards and independence policy.

Our review standards

  • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
  • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
  • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.

About Papa Johns

This profile has not been claimed by the company. See reviews below to learn more or submit your own review.

Papa Johns has specialized in serving pizza, breadsticks and desserts since 1984. The company offers customizable pizza options, aiming to provide quality food through its "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza." philosophy, serving customers in numerous locations worldwide.

Visit www.papajohns.com
Pros
  • High-quality food options
Cons
  • Frequent order inaccuracies

Papa Johns Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (32)
  • (3)
  • (16)
  • (82)
  • (505)

Popular Mentions

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Recent
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    Our review standards

    • Our moderation team evaluates reviews to make sure they meet our guidelines.
    • We require contact information to verify reviews come from real customers.
    • Financial relationships do not influence whether we publish a consumer review.
    Page 2 Reviews 40 - 80
    Sales & Marketing

    Reviewed March 9, 2026

    Hello, this review is not about the product itself, it is not about the personnel or any one establishment. It is about the advertisement my wife and I just saw on NETFLIX, it is an ad that runs constantly on NETFLIX. The ad has a rap song that has very offensive, vulgar language in its lyrics. The advertisement team chose this song to promote its product? Out of all of the songs that are popular and could possibly entice someone to try their Papa Johns pizza, this is the song that made it through the rigorous challenge of finding the perfect jingle? Come on, have some higher level of decency and respect for your customers. The words M....F....er is not an attraction, it is a turn off and low on the respect shown to your customers. Do Better....

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceStaff

    Reviewed March 8, 2026

    Excellent customer service, love the energy coming from the crew, they make you feel at home, and the food is always amazing. I can definitely say they showed us some love. ❤️ Thank you for your hard work and dedication to the community.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Staff

    Reviewed Feb. 18, 2026

    Papa Johns on 3416 Clark Rd, Sarasota, FL is the best papa ever. They have the BEST EMPLOYEES AND INGREDIENTS. They take pride in the product they put out for public consumption EVER. Simply put the employees that work at this store are hardworking, caring people.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & SpeedMaintenanceResolution

    Reviewed Feb. 14, 2026

    Once again, I ordered pizza from the Papa John's on Wax Rd. in Central with the manager "Bryce" working and NOT PAPA JOHN'S, but Door Dash was supposed to deliver my pizza. I placed my order at 7:25pm, it is now 9:30pm. The pizza is not only over an hour and a half late, but door dash just sent me an automated message saying that their last order took all of their change. I called Papa John's, and the manager Bryce said that it is not his problem and there's nothing he can do about it, they are not required to carry change. If that were the issue, he should have called when I placed the order where it says very clearly on the order ticket that I will "need change". Good thing I was able to scrape together what I needed, but either way, at this point it's been two hours since I placed the order.

    After speaking to the Door Dash guy, he said someone else originally was supposed to get the order and Papa John's didn't have it ready so they threw my order back into the queue, he got the order an hour later he said. So my order sat there, likely intentionally because "Bryce" has gotten the order wrong every single time that he is "the manager" and has given us a very difficult time, and does not even fix the issue. Example: One order Bryce had the entirely wrong order delivered to us, we called and he said there was nothing he could do, it was too late. For a $100 order!?!?

    Also, I did not order this through Door Dash, I ordered on Papa John's and it's not Door Dash's fault regardless because Papa Johns had my pizza sitting there for over an hour and a half. BRYCE needs to do better with his time management, delegation and customer service skills, since as of the moment, her HAS YET to complete an order correctly any night that I have ordered and he was the lead.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer Service

    Reviewed Jan. 31, 2026

    Papa John's Y'all would have it going on if y'all sold chocolate ice cream with the brownies. Y'all definitely are the best in taste and value. Add ice-cream to your menu and y'all would conquer the pizza market.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    PriceRefunds & PayoutsStaff

    Reviewed Jan. 31, 2026

    I'm a senior and I ordered pizza for husband and I, at 6:62, the young lady who took the order couldn't decipher what I was saying. I said I wanted to order two pizzas with the Italian with the Neil crust. She kept saying one and as high as it was it was $26 and change that I paid for one pizza with onions, green peppers, cheese and pepperoni. It was a medium Pizza and it shouldn't have been that expensive. I thought $26 and change was for two pizzas I ordered but then I didn't get the pizza until almost 8:00 and the person that delivered it put the pizza on the steps and I was looking out for the driver to come because I wanted to tip him, never showed up. But then I happened to look down on the step and there was the box with the pizza in it frozen.

    It had been out there that long I guess because it was below zero temperature. Anyway I will never ever order Papa Johns again. I'll go to the store maybe that they will understand. I wished I'd taken photos of the pizza in the iced cold steps surrounded by ice and salt, what I'm saying but I will never ever order, delivery because those guys just don't get it plus the pizza gave me diarrhea. Not good

    Thanks for your vote!
    Price

    Reviewed Jan. 27, 2026

    I order a the works stuffed pizza. I received my pizza & there a hardly any veggies on the pizza. I spent $25.97 for sauce & meat. This is unacceptable. Y'all pizza is not cheap to be skipping on ingredients. I'm attaching a picture of a supposed to THE WORKS pizza. This is like the second time that I had issues with the Lancaster, Tx location. I'm done with this location.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Customer ServiceRefunds & PayoutsStaffFollow-Through

    Reviewed Jan. 27, 2026

    I want to share a positive customer service experience with Papa Johns. I had ordered pizza for my daughter in Nevada, and unfortunately it took about two hours for her to receive it. I filled out the survey explaining what happened, and within 12 hours I was contacted by the manager of Papa John’s Store #1970 on Valley Verde Dr. in Henderson, NV—**. ** emailed me personally to apologize for the delay and explained that the store uses DoorDash for deliveries, which caused the issue. She immediately offered to either refund my card or deliver a replacement pizza to make it right.

    I chose to have the pizza delivered the following Saturday night, as my daughter’s husband was out of town and she was home caring for sick children. ** made sure the pizza was delivered on time and personally followed through to ensure everything went smoothly. I truly appreciate **’s effort, kindness, and excellent customer service. She went above and beyond to turn a frustrating experience into a positive one, and it meant a lot to our family. Thank you, **, for your professionalism and care!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Refunds & PayoutsStaff

    Reviewed Jan. 23, 2026

    I ordered a small Hawaiian Barbecue Pizza with no onions and extra pineapple and that’s exactly what I got. I received the extra sauces that I paid for. Delivery driver was nice and delivered my food hot and fresh. Definitely will be ordering again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Sales & MarketingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed Dec. 30, 2025

    My wife and I have sophisticated palettes and are from the New York City area. We have found several pizza establishments here in Southwest Florida that have reasonably good pizza establishments turning out not New York delicious pies but acceptable good pies that satisfy one's taste buds. Papa John’s Pizza was tried for a first time in our 24 years of residency in Fort Myers. It’s Monday, the Christmas and New Year's holidays when our 1st and/or 2nd choice establishments are closed due to the holidays.

    Our leaning for a good pizza tonight prompted us to weigh trying new and since Papa John’s Pizza is seen in advertisements and looked reasonably good, we said, “What Hell, Let’s Try Them”. In a few words to spare all reading our review about our experience with the Papa John’s Pizza location on College Parkway next door to Publix, know that IT WAS THE WORST TASTING PIZZA WE EVER HAD IN OUR LIVES. Little kids, college kids, adults without educated palettes will not know GREAT PIZZA FROM VERY BAD PIZZA”.

    Our Pizza experience from this shop was terrible so much so after a few bites, we threw the Pizza out and ate cereal in its place. Imagine breakfast cereal taking the place of Pizza. Know that the cereal was great in the Pizza's place. Best advice is stay away, don’t waste your money on trash. The advertisements look great but the Pizza is the “PITS”.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Online & AppBilling

    Reviewed Dec. 29, 2025

    I have the worst time trying to have a pizza delivery to my niece. Website is hard for me to use, I try to make payment. It adds other items to my order. Very difficult to order pizza for a delivery. Should not be this hard. Finally I get disgusted and don't place my order.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.

    Reviewed Dec. 24, 2025

    I used to love the wings, but for the last few years, they're different. They seem steamed, not crispy anymore. Also, the buffalo sauce is glopped on rather than the wings being tossed in and well coated.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Price

    Reviewed Dec. 19, 2025

    Website states that if you order more than $40.00 you pay no delivery fee. Spent almost a 100.00 and they still charged me Delivery Fee $5.49 and to think I use to work for this place. Reminds me of Brandon that was in office a year ago.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Customer ServiceTransparency

    Reviewed Dec. 19, 2025

    Horrible! Management was rude and the delivery took 2 hours! Just horrible. I might as well go to Domino's. I am so confused not an update or anything then mad at me for calling to figure out what my food is and I know it’s going to be cold once I get the pizza!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Staff

    Reviewed Dec. 14, 2025

    Driver was smoking when she arrived. Dark crown Vic with dented side. Farmington Missouri Papa Johns. My food smelled like cigarettes. I really hope this isn't how you deliver all of your pizza, scared to order again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Customer ServiceStaff

    Reviewed Dec. 11, 2025

    What tf ordering pizza from the Philippines in America!! What kind of place is Papa John's!! Lame, definitely will not order again! 1 pissed customer! Thank goodness all the other pizza places actually answer phones at their location. I called to leave a request for delivery, at the actual store, girl was rude as hell, she should be fired, Orange City Florida location. Probably will never ever order pizza from this place again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Punctuality & SpeedStaff

    Reviewed Dec. 7, 2025

    I ordered a pizza online. Went to get it 20 mins later. When I got there, they said they didn't have my order. What great service? Right? I will never order from Papa Johns again. They are like the other fast food companies. All they care about is your money. Not you.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Staff

    Reviewed Dec. 1, 2025

    When my order was delivered half of the order was not there. The delivery driver said it was too far to go back to pick up the missing part. It's less than 2 miles from my place. The pizza was barely warm. I'm getting over a serious illness so I was unable to pick up the order in person. Not happy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServicePunctuality & SpeedStaff

    Reviewed Nov. 30, 2025

    Recent visit, I attempted to place an order for a pizza, but I encountered an unexpectedly rude and unprofessional response from the manager on duty. When I referenced a previous order that had been significantly delayed, the manager reacted negatively. Instead of addressing my concerns, she informed me that she would not allow me to place an order and threatened to cancel any attempts to do so, even if my husband tried to order under his name and phone number. True to her word, my husband’s order was promptly canceled. The manager‘s tone was very argumentative and rude. Using my address this manager now has blocked me from having pizza delivered to my home. This manager at Long St., Charlottesville, VA. Papa John’s is not a good representative for the company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.

    Reviewed Nov. 29, 2025

    I haven't ordered Papa John's for a long time. I bought two pizzas large pieces, they had four little bitty rabbit poop size sausage on each piece. I'll never order there again. They used to be pretty good in Valparaiso, Indiana.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    timothy increased rating by 3 stars.
    Customer ServiceStaffTimeliness
    After a positive interaction with Papa Johns, timothy increased their star rating.

    Reviewed Nov. 28, 2025

    Ordered pizza in Destin. Box was not sealed and got the wrong pizza and delivery had no response. Pizza was wrong crust and no one cares. I was told they were really busy at the store. I tossed pizza since it was half open when I got it. Never will order again!!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Staff

    Reviewed Nov. 28, 2025

    Papa John's Pizza App is super great! But, when picking up my pizzas recently at 1 pm, the crew working there completely messed up the order. On the pizza I ordered with extra toppings, it was made with regular amounts and the dough was not the New York Style I ordered. Another pizza they did not even make. This one was remake of the other pizza with the NY Style dough and overkill on the sauce with very little amount of toppings. These kinds of things happen fairly regularly, like 50% of the time. If Papa John's Pizza App offers all the adjustments to customers' orders then why can't they hire and train employees to make and produce the Pizzas that's expected of them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed Nov. 21, 2025

    Horrible customer service. I placed my order by phone and was told it would be ready in 15 minutes. I got there 25 minutes after placing my order and there was still 6 pizzas in front of mine. This is the 3rd time this has happened to me this month. I shouldn't have to wait an hour and a half to get a pizza. They only have 3 people working on a Friday afternoon! Insane!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Nov. 7, 2025

    On Oct 30th and Nov 2nd I ordered pizza for me and my girlfriend at the Domino's Pizza in Toms River, NJ. The bill was 90, when the food arrived the stuffed pizza was cold and had no flavor & the papadippa all the cheese on top was over cooked and burnt, it was a horrible experience. One of the flavor cups was ranch when it was supposed to be pizza cup, then on Nov 3rd they delivered pizza to wrong address where there's a lady who lets her dog go to the bathroom on my trash can.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Nov. 5, 2025

    I am a long loyal fan of Papa John’s, however I’m a little disappointed with what has happened to the quality. The individual that work in the Foley store needs to be retrained. The finished product is terrible. Please correct this!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceStaff

    Reviewed Nov. 4, 2025

    Just tried the newly opened chain store in Ellijay GA. My call into the place to order was taken by person who barely spoke a single word of English. I could not understand 1/2 the words she said. The pizza we ordered was a standard pepperoni and mushroom. Horrible, not cooked through, little sign of mushrooms and a sloppy mess. The staff at the store could not have been nicer. Do not waste your money with this pizza place.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Punctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed Nov. 3, 2025

    Yesterday at the Poinciana Papa John's newly opened I went and order a pizza with a special they had for $9.99 with free topping. I was hungry most of the day. Wanted to eat a nice pizza. I took it home and it tasted a little weird, but I was so hungry and I had like four slices of pizza. A couple hours later I started feeling like I had fever, nausea, dizziness. I felt like there was something in my stomach. I had a lot of pain. I thought I was going to die. The people that were here said that I look great, I went to the store today, November 2. 2025 in complaint to the manager, they refunded me my money for the pizza, but the dough was not properly cooked and I feel very sick. If I feel the same way tomorrow, I will go to the clinic. A shame it tasted good, but they didn't cook the dough correctly. Shame.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoveragePriceStaff

    Reviewed Oct. 27, 2025

    I placed an order through the Papa Johns app and waited nearly 40 minutes before noticing it was marked as delivered. Nothing was outside. I called the store and the manager immediately blamed DoorDash. While I appreciated the offer to remake the order, what arrived was one of the worst pizzas I have ever received from any location.

    The pizza was a complete mess. There were large pockets of air that burst during cooking, causing all the toppings to slide and pool in the center. The cheese coverage was terrible and over half the pizza looked like burnt scraps. I also paid extra for pepperoncini, which was not included. Instead, I received three ranch cups I did not ask for.

    When I called back to report the quality issue and the missing items, the manager argued with me, claimed it passed a quality check, then admitted he submitted the order incorrectly. How does a pizza pass quality check if it was made wrong to begin with? And then he hung up on me. Yes, the manager hung up on a paying customer over an issue caused by their own mistake. I used Papa Points that I earned from prior orders and still had to cook from my pantry because the pizza was not edible. Why spend money on takeout if I am going to cook anyway?

    I chose Papa Johns over the Pizza Hut located in the same shopping center. Like many others in this area, I used to be a loyal Papa Johns customer. Not anymore. The manager’s behavior was unprofessional, dismissive, and rude. Yelling at customers and hanging up in their face is unacceptable behavior for anyone, especially someone in charge of a store. This should not be the standard. It is completely unacceptable to waste my loyalty points, deliver a poor quality product, and then refuse to take accountability for it. If you cannot treat customers with respect, you should not be in charge of customer service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed Oct. 14, 2025

    Got a large thin crust pizza with Canadian bacon and pineapple at Farmington Utah - pick up order. There was NO canadian bacon and only about 2 - 3 small pieces of pineapple per slice. I could not believe it!!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServicePricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed Oct. 11, 2025

    Ordered my pizza, it was way late and cold, talked to the general manager, he said he called several times to let me know it might be late. My phone was charging, he did not call several times. He was also very rude.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServicePriceOnline & App

    Reviewed Sept. 30, 2025

    I had never tried Papa John's until Sunday night. Some friends told me they weren't bad so I tried them. Ordered a large NY Pizza and chicken parm bites. I opened the box and knew I was in trouble. The cheese was concealed on the pizza. No stringy mozzarella happening here. The pizza was cold. The dough was under cooked. The pizza was cold and the sauce was inedible. The chicken was pretty much the same. Cold, undercooked and tasteless. This wasn't pizza. This was somebody version of how can we make a cheap, easy to make pizza. Maybe it's cheap for them but those 2 items were $40.00. Why would anybody go back and order again. After leaving a review on their website the manager called and asked if I wanted them to remake it and send it. I said No Thanks. If they couldn't do it right the first time why should I believe it would be better now. Don't eat Papa John's pizza. You will regret it.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Sept. 29, 2025

    During my travels, I’ve visited many Papa John’s restaurants, but the one in Tunisia stands out as a true gem. The Papadias here are absolutely incredible. From the very first bite, the dough impressed me—light, fluffy, and perfectly baked to a delightful golden hue. The sauce was just the right amount of tangy, enhancing the flavors without overwhelming the palate. The cheese was beautifully melted, providing that satisfying stretch that every cheese lover craves.

    What really made this Papadias special was the quality of the meat. It was flavorful and cooked to perfection, adding to the overall deliciousness. The combination of these elements created a taste experience that I haven’t encountered anywhere else. If you’re a fan of Papa John’s or simply enjoy great food, you must try the Papadias at the Tunisian location. They’ve raised the bar for me, and I find myself wishing I could taste that perfect blend again. Don’t miss out on this culinary delight while you’re in town!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Sales & Marketing

    Reviewed Sept. 28, 2025

    We just ordered the Shaqaroni pizza expecting there to be a lot of pepperoni. NOPE. Very false advertisement. Just regular pepperoni pizza, NOTHING RONI ABOUT IT. Very disappointed. I could have just ordered a regular large pepperoni pizza CAUSE THAT'S JUST WHAT WE GOT. NEVER AGAIN...

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed Sept. 16, 2025

    I don't like Dominos or Little Caesars pizza so I tried Papa Johns. I wasted a trip and I WASTED 15.00. I ate maybe 3 pieces and threw the rest of it out in the yard for my cats to eat. I put Papa Johns BELOW both Dominos and Little Caesars and that is how I feel about Papa Johns.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed Sept. 7, 2025

    Order their $9.99 extra large New York style pizza special. Ask for light sauce, extra cheese and mushrooms. It was a big pile of dough with a quart of tomato sauce on it and fake cheese. I think they put five mushrooms on it. The sauce is terrible so the more they put on the worse the taste. They have no concept of what a New York style pizza is. The crust was about a quarter inch thick. Extra large my ass. The pizza was 14 in. I would call up the restaurant and ask for my money back but I just don't have the energy to deal with these Crooks. That's what America is now. Poor customer service and poor quality products. Everyone's got their hand out looking for money for terrible service Period. For God's sake Papa Johns have some pride in your Product Period.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceStaff

    Reviewed Sept. 7, 2025

    Such a horrible service at the east market location. I literally ordered 2 cheese sticks and 2 2 liters of pop and some sauces and the delivery driver completely forgot my sauces and pop and had to go back to store to get my pop and my mother had to go back out and get the sauces. Such a horrible store. When my mother was at the location she said they all looked like they were smoking.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Staff

    Reviewed Sept. 5, 2025

    Wow Dee at 17th Street Papa John's in Sarasota FL is the best. She's really nice and very helpful when it comes to ordering. I love that she is really good at her job. There's nothing better than a person that's patient and understanding how she is.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceOnline & AppMaintenanceStaff

    Reviewed Sept. 4, 2025

    Love Papa John's Pizza, however, if you want to order from their website, it’s very difficult and when you have to input your address, it says (the address is not in a delivered area) and then when you call, you get someone on the phone that you can’t understand and does not understand what you are wanting to order. Please address these issues and maybe look into fixing the website for ordering online.

    Thanks for your vote!
    PriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed Sept. 3, 2025

    I wanted to try their thin crust pizza. Apparently you can only order it in a large even that was more than I wanted. I did so anyways. I ordered sausage with extra mushroom. The crust was soggy, wet cardboard, texture and taste. It had about seven little pieces of sausage and maybe ten quarter pieces of mushroom. Sauce was thick and sweet like old tomato paste. I contacted the GM, they agreed to refund but then told me I paid cash through a DoorDash. I shared a screenshot with her of my bank charge. But she maintains I paid with cash through a DoorDash. Currently going through my bank for results.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceContract & TermsPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed Sept. 2, 2025

    My name is David**. I ordered a large pizza sept 1st 2025. Just pepperoni, extra cheese and a 2 liter Sherri plus 5 dollar tip. I waited an hour and half. They delivered it to next door neighbor to the right of the house where I was working. The next door neighbor brought me pizza and drink and the pizza was cold. I asked the neighbor if the pizza guy knocked on his door. He said no so I called Papa Johns to come get the pizza and drink. They said they would not come pick it up so the guy at papa Johns he was going to cancel my order and get my money back. That is not the worst of it. I was starving. Didn’t eat all day. I didn’t trust the pizza because it was left outside so I have it to the next door neighbor. I’m working at **. Papa John’s got my number and papa John’s store is 2.5 miles from where I was working. Will I buy from there again? No I will not. The pizza cost me about 30 dollars.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    Papa Johns Company Information

    Company Name:
    Papa Johns
    Website:
    www.papajohns.com