Evanger's Pet Foods Reviews

4,893,584reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.

About Evanger's Pet Foods

Pros
  • High-quality ingredients
  • Positive health improvements
  • Variety of flavors available
Cons
  • Quality control issues reported
  • Some pets may have allergies
  • Customer service can be lacking

Shop with confidence

Compare with top companies

Evanger's Pet Foods Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (48)
  • (1)
  • (6)
  • (27)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about Evegner's Pet Supply?
    • 4,893,584 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Recent
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about Evegner's Pet Supply?
    • 4,893,584 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 1 Reviews 0 - 40
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 14, 2026

    I called about a question to Evanger's about my dogs' health and the guy on the phone had a lot of good feedback. I felt confident ordering the correct product for the health and longevity for my pet. I chose the Lamb and Rice and my dogs' itching and scratching and diarrhea went away. I feel good about feeding my dogs good products now!

    Thanks for your vote!

    Reviewed May 12, 2026

    My dog loves the chicken legs in a can! In fact he likes all of Evanger’s dog food.

    Thanks for your vote!

    Not sure how to choose?

    Get buying tips about Dog Food delivered to your inbox.

      By entering your email, you agree to sign up for consumer news, tips and giveaways from ConsumerAffairs. Unsubscribe at any time.

      Thanks for subscribing.

      You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.

      Profile pic of the author.
      Verified purchase
      Staff

      Reviewed Feb. 12, 2026

      My blonde, 13-year-old Wirehaired Chihuahua has suffered with black skin and itching for 5 years. The vet visits did not help. I started making her food with salmon and vegetables a few months ago. She got a little better. Her vet said no chicken or potatoes. Upon going in my local Ingles Grocery, something pulled me into the dog food aisle. It was there I saw this brand and picked up the cans and read them. No chicken or potatoes in what I picked up even though they do offer a chicken product. It is Evanger's "Limited Ingredient Diet".

      Gypsy has been eating this for 2 weeks today and that yeasty smell is gone, not itching, not chewing her body or paws, the little bumps going away and the Pink is coming back in her skin. No gastric problems and she is sleeping soundly (the Wheezy sound she had in her nose is almost undetectable now) and she is more active outside like a rabbit! Yes I said she is 13 years old! No problems that I can detect from feeding Evanger's to my old girl. That front right leg in the picture used to be solid black. Her hip area is still healing and has bumps and black spotted skin but it's not solid black. I'd like to graciously thank Evanger's!!!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Sept. 23, 2025

      I have been feeding my toy poodle Evanders for over a year and she used to like it. Recently, past 4-5 months things have changed. She won't eat it and one time when she did eat a little she threw up. I noticed in the recent cans that they look different. The cans used to have nice lean beef and now they are about 80-90% FAT. (Paying almost $5 a can for FAT is ridicious!) The juice used to be like a liquid gravy and now it is thick gel. I wrote to the Company and sent them pictures but they did not respond. I will not be purchasing from this Company anymore because of the quality control on their products and lack of customer service.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Punctuality & Speed

      Reviewed May 20, 2025

      My chihuahua, who has a great appetite, seemed to enjoy Evanger's when I bought some a year or two ago, so I recently loaded up on cans of their "Super Premium Chicken Dinner," "Cooked Chicken Wet Dog Food," "Classic Chicken and Rice Wet Dog Food," and "Senior Dinner and Weight Management Dinner Wet Dog Food." She rejects every can as if it were poison. I went back to familiar brands like Blue Buffalo and Purina, and she eats those without issue. Every time I try to slip an Evanger's can back into the mix, she rejects it. I think her sense of smell & taste is telling me something. Too late, I did some research and read about Evanger's "spotty" record (to say the least), including numerous recalls, evidence of horse meat, and lethal doses of ** in their wet food - even if those were years ago and they've apparently cleaned up their act. I'll never trust this brand.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.

      Reviewed Feb. 14, 2024

      36 out of the 48 cans I received were seriously dented...especially the ones in the middle of the cases which tells anyone who has picked orders... It's like the rejected cans from recoup were all wrapped up and sent to me.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Profile pic of the author.

      Reviewed Jan. 9, 2024

      You all know the expression, "I wouldn't give that to my dog" in regard to bad food. Well that's about it...Gave it to my wonderful senior dog and he started throwing up almost immediately...How does the FDA allow this garbage product to be consumed by any living thing?.. With all the good dog food available, why would anyone buy this? Definitely not a quality product....

      Thanks for your vote!
      PriceBilling

      Reviewed Sept. 15, 2023

      Both of my dogs have been sick all year with bloody diarrhea. One keeps foaming from the mouth. I have been taking them both to the vet. It’s been heartbreaking, never mind expensive! I stopped feeding them the can dog food for about 6-8 weeks because money got tight with the vet bills. Their bloody diarrhea went away and no more foaming from the mouth. 1 day after starting it back up everything returns again! I was not aware the history with this company! I’m very upset! I will be taking action!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Punctuality & SpeedTimeliness

      Reviewed Sept. 7, 2023

      Purchased two cans of Evangers beef meatloaf style food, both made all my dogs that ate it, sick. The first can I fed to one dog (35lbs older husky puppy) mixed half with dry per usual, and she had very smelly, soupy diarrhea that night and into the next day. I hasn’t realized it was the can yet, thought she might have eaten something in the yard that upset her tummy.

      The next day I fed most of the second can, and the remainder of the first, to 7 of my 8 dogs, not realizing what was about to happen, or what the culprit was. All that day, and night, everyone who ate the evangers had the same soupy, rancid and awful smelling diarrhea, and they acted like they had to poop urgently. Several of the puddles contained blood. I was able to narrow it down to the evangers as the only dog that wasn’t affected was the one who didn’t eat any of it. Also, I went back and smelled very closely the remnants of the second can, and it was a distinct off-color and smelled bad.

      At this point, out of curiosity, I offered a spoonful of just the evangers to a couple of my dogs, and they refused it! They wouldn’t eat it unless it was mixed with something else. The diarrhea continued into the next day, with more blood, and then everyone went back to solid poos. 100% certain this evangers food made my dogs (all northern breeds from 32-130lbs) sick, and I encourage people to not buy their product. Also, I found a detailed list of evangers past problems, issues, and a recall after dogs died, listed on PoisonedPets website and it’s a long list of complaints and problems! If my mind wasn’t already made up to neverfeed evangers again, it would be now after reading their “troubled history”.

      Thanks for your vote!
      PriceRates

      Reviewed Jan. 23, 2022

      Evanger's canned dog food is carried in a local small business store as one of their mid-range priced but high quality canned dog foods. I especially like the grain free. My dogs love it and the ingredients seem safer than some other brands.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Customer ServiceSales & MarketingPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

      Reviewed March 7, 2020

      I normally don't feed my English Setters Evanger's brand food, but Chewy.com had a promotion and I bought two cases of the Super Premium Lamb and Rice Dinner can dog food to try out. My 2 yr old loves Lamb, so I fed it to her. The other Setter is a pup and she has her own puppy diet. When opening the first can, I noticed the food was coarse and extremely dry. I contacted Chewy.Com with my concerns and was told the food has a 78% moisture content, a loaf style and was fine, so I decided it was ok to give it to her. She seemed to like it, but drank a lot of water afterwards.

      A couple days later, while sleeping off a meal, she abruptly jumped up and then fell down on her side having had a brain seizure that lasted about a minute. Afterwards, she was fine. Two days later she had another seizure, but this one lasted about 2 minutes. My Vet couldn't diagnose the problem. So, not knowing the cause, I decided to immediately stop feeding her the food and since then she hasn't had another seizure. Coincidence, I don't know? Chewy.Com was notified about both events and I was reimbursed the cost of the remaining cans of food. I also reached out to Evanger's about my experience, as well as my concerns and their customer service has "never responded." I had included the stamped markings on the cans, so they would know what batch the food came from. A report has been filed with the FDA.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed May 19, 2019

      I feel this company is above and beyond any other. I have done a lot of my own research on various brands and I always come back to them. I have been using their canned food now for a few years and just started buying their dry food. They are a smaller company who care about our pets and what we feed them.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed March 25, 2019

      Recently the Evanger's Meat Lovers Medley dry food appears darker in color and has a slightly different odor. I feel there has been a change in formula though Chewy says they have asked Evanger's and they say there is no change. I am concerned.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer ServiceStaff

      Reviewed March 14, 2019

      My dog suddenly refused to eat her regular Evanger's Senior Weight Control chicken & rice canned dog food. My friend and I noticed it looked strange - much darker than in the past and had a different odor. I called Evanger's and spoke with their Quality Control lady who told me that the ingredients are the same, even though lot numbers on the bottom of the cans are different. She told me that both lot numbers show they were manufactured in the same plant. My dog will not eat the darker version with lot numbers beginning with 2118; however, she still will eat the original version, which looks like chicken, and contains lot numbers beginning with 1918. I now have to order it from Chewy by phone in order to make sure they ship the cans with lot number 1918; otherwise, I end up tossing it out and cooking a meal for my dog.

      I have seen many other pet owners who have the same issue with this darker version, which obviously contains different ingredients than in the past, even though the company is denying this. I think the FDA need to take a look at this. A rep from Chewy told me that she found reviews showing that over 90 cats also refused to eat the darker version of this food. Sad, but I'm going to have to start looking for an alternate food for my dog. Disappointed in Evanger's after many years of using their food. (I owned a boarding kennel for 13 years, so have been loyal to them for a long time until now.)

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed Sept. 22, 2018

      My friends and I have been feeding our Fur Babies Evanger's Wet Dog Food for years. In the past few months their recipes have changed. They must have changed packers. Supposedly hand packed cans are now horrible. I have to pick through and remove 20% of garbage from these cans. We have found lumps of FAT (20% or more per can), Veins & Arteries in the cans. Also, in the meat and Rice cans, the Rice is no longer pulverized. The long grains are not digestible. I should not have to use a food processor to do what Evanger's should already be doing. My friends and I used to buy 250 cans per month or 3000 per year. We are done. Emails have gone unanswered.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Jeanette increased rating by 4 stars.
      After a positive interaction with Evanger's Pet Foods, Jeanette increased their star rating on Nov. 28, 2018.

      Updated review: Nov. 28, 2018

      I emailed the company, and someone responded after 7-10 days, but my reply received something on the order of, "You aren't allowed to correspond with this person." (What?) So I called the company. I talked to a very knowledgeable person who assured me that there was nothing wrong with the batch, but something could've happened in the processing. (I read "cooking" from of that because the inside of the can lids were darkened like they had been exposed to too much heat.) He sent me a case of their "Chicken Lickin' Dinner", to make up for the case I took to the shelter. My cats like it a lot, and no longer drool over the original Evanger's I was feeding them, which is just as well because it's not a complete balanced diet for cats. I was most pleased with Evanger's response, and I'm glad to have this opportunity to clear up my negative first impression. I've tried several other kinds of Evanger cat foods, and so far my cats like them all.

      Original Review: Sept. 1, 2018

      When one of my preferred cat foods went out of business, I started searching for a replacement. We sampled 6-7 different companies' products, and settled on Evanger's grain-free chicken for dogs and cats. They loved it, so I fed a can a week for 5-6 weeks, and then ordered a case. I don't know what happened, but they won't touch this stuff. I thought it could be a bad can, so I tried a second can, same thing. Now I'm out $40, and have a case of cat food to give to the shelter. I have not contacted Evanger's yet, but I'm going there now.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Staff

      Reviewed May 7, 2018

      My dog loves Evanger's Vegetarian. I have feed this to her for the three years since she rescued me and have been very pleased with the results. And it doesn't have the usual gross dog food smell!

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed April 29, 2018

      Evanger's is only available at pet specialty shops because it is a high end product and my Akita's have maintained good health and great appearance so much so that my vet asked me what I feed them. They like it and it does not contain any crap - it's American made.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed March 11, 2017

      My dog loved this food (Evanger's pheasant dog/cat food) and so did I until: I fed my dog half a can one day. The next day I gave her the other half only to find a penny sized rusted steel slug on the bottom of the can! I know it was steel because I rinsed it off and could pick it up with a magnet! I am sure there were other bits and flakes of steel in that food when I looked at it and picked it apart! DO NOT feed your pet any of this food! I promptly emailed the company and of course got NO response at all. Then I filed a complaint with the FDA about this company and this incident. I would NOT recommend ANY type of food from this company at all... ever!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Punctuality & SpeedStaff

      Reviewed Feb. 18, 2017

      I have a 10 year old Shih Tzu. She has been a wonderful part of the family, She will actually be 10 March 26, 2017. As she ages, I have noticed it's been tough to find a quality, healthy food she likes. So, yesterday (2-17-17) I went to my local pet store and told the sales associate my problem. She was excited to give me a sample of Evanger's meat lovers medley for dry food and the chicken and rice canned pate' for the wet food. I always serve her breakfast, snack and dinner at the same time every day. So, yesterday at 5:30 P.M. I gave her a serving of the wet food. She is a pretty slow eater. Anyway, she seemed to enjoy the food as she finished it all. This morning, we got up as usual, I let her out to potty and she went pee and she pooped a little, but I noticed it was a little soft. So I made her breakfast, but she wouldn't eat it. About an hour later I noticed she began to shiver.

      So I thought it was a little cold in the house so I turned the heat up. It's now up to 72 degrees in the house and she is trembling uncontrollably. So I Sat and held her wrapped in her blanket for an hour as she trembles. Now she is just laying around on my lap, not playing. While I was in the kitchen making the humans breakfast, she just laid on the kitchen floor by my feet trembling. 10 minutes later I looked down and poop was running out of her uncontrollably! 23 hours later she is right now laying on me and trembling about half as bad as she did earlier. She still hasn't eaten anything since last night and continues to feel weak, sad and probably hungry by now. I have read other comments stating their pet had the same symptoms from consuming the same food. Please help and let me know what I should do with the exception of discontinuing this line of food.

      Thanks for your vote!
      PriceStaff

      Reviewed Aug. 20, 2016

      My daughter recommended this dog food to me when I asked her about a good grain-free food for our English Setters after one of them became ill with cancer. I started with the wet grain-free rabbit and quail food and all three love it. Our female setter that is 11 years old is acting 2 years old again and our 8 year old male with cancer is full of energy too. It's a little more expensive but all three eat every drop and their allergies have disappeared as well. I'd recommend this brand to anyone. Great job Evanger's!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Customer Service

      Reviewed April 12, 2016

      I have had to deal directly with Evanger's a few times, and have been ecstatic with their customer service! I have even had the pleasure of dealing directly with the owners! I am a raw feeder, but I use their freeze dried treats. My dogs love them! It is hard to find "clean" treats with simple ingredients (like 100% meat) and minimal processing.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase

      Reviewed April 12, 2016

      I have two very picky Yorkies. I have never been able to feed them the same food consistently, until I found Evanger's. They make such a large variety so my dogs are never bored! Llove this food!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Staff

      Reviewed April 12, 2016

      My dog loves Evanger's dog food. The can food is great. I haven't tried the dry food yet. My dog really enjoys the classic line as well as the hunk of beef. I love Evanger's dog food because it's natural and fortified with vitamins and nutrients. He's a healthy dog with a beautiful coat thanks to Evanger's.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase

      Reviewed April 11, 2016

      My animals have never looked this good or been this healthy. I have a cat and a dog and they won't eat anything else.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed April 7, 2016

      I have a dog and a cat, and after searching and comparing- we found Evangers. Being from Deerfield, Il we were loved it was locally sourced out of Wheeling and family-owned. We use the Meat Lover's Melody dry cat food and the Chicken and Brown Rice dry dog food. We also feed them BOTH the game meat lines (ie: 100% buffalo, salmon, pheasant etc). Our dog goes INSANE for the Chicken Drummetts from the Hand-Packed line. They are basically just chicken wings, and there are even videos of people trying it on their facebook! So happy to have finally found our forever food brand!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Staff

      Reviewed April 6, 2016

      My dog loves Evanger's Chicken and Brown Rice dry food. I recently had to mix in another brand of chicken and brown rice dry food because I was running low and in a pinch. My dog actually picked out the individual pieces of the other brand because he preferred the Evanger's brand. He also loves Evanger's wet food. Sometimes for special occasions I give him wet mixed with dry food and he scarfs it down.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Staff

      Reviewed April 6, 2016

      I have a 13-year-old Weimaraner, that is allergic to grain, chicken and lamb. I was feeding him kibble that didn't contain these ingredients and he would get bored & stop eating & I'd often have to find him something new. I even cooked ground beef & potatoes & other meals for him, just to get him to eat. One day, I stumbled across a person doing a demo in a pet store for Evanger's. They had a can called "Hunk of Beef" open & it looked like a roast I would have made at home! The ingredients read, "Beef & Beef Juice". I bought some & brought them home to my dog & he DEVOURED them!

      I found out that they had many other varieties that did not contain grain, lamb or chicken, that he could eat. He loves them all, even the pates! The Braised Beef Chunks have veggies mixed in & provides him with a well-balanced meal! Thank you Evanger's for providing my baby with a variety of food that is as awesome as anything I'd make him at home (and probably even better for him)!

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed April 6, 2016

      I have a 10 yr old black lab with pica. We had to change up his protein that he gets. He NOW eat Evanger's Wild Salmon and is mixed with Evanger's Sweet Potato. Even though all 7 of my dogs are on Evanger's dry food, Meat lovers, and thriving. You always have that one. It's wonderful they have SO MANY single proteins to choose from. It is saving my dogs life. I wanted other people to know there is a safe, healthy and tasty food for your pets with health issue.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase

      Reviewed April 5, 2016

      My rescue dog had pathetic fur when I adopted him. Now that he has been on an Evanger's diet, he gets compliments on his beautiful coat. Also, my mother's dog, who has problems digesting protein, depends on Evanger's Vegetarian. And all 4 cats love all the flavors -- no longer finicky when I serve Evanger's.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed April 4, 2016

      My dog has never been food-motivated and often needed to be coaxed into eating. That is, until Evanger's came along. He loves Chicken Drummettes and Hunk o' Beef so much that he's started begging for breakfast and dinner! We no longer worry that he won't eat when he is left alone with a dog sitter. I would recommend Evanger's to anyone with a furry friend.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase
      Staff

      Reviewed April 4, 2016

      My bulldog, Bud, was overweight. His vet recommended I change his food from Beneful to Evanger's. I switched to the Evanger's Whitefish and Sweet Potato and low calorie jerky treats. Bud lost 13 pounds over 6 months and looks like a puppy again, even though he's almost 9 years old. He gets compliments every time we're out for a walk about how good of shape he is in!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase

      Reviewed March 24, 2016

      My dog LOVES Evanger's, especially the beef chunks and chicken drumettes. The ingredient list makes me feel confident that I am feeding her a wholesome product without harmful additives. The edible bones provide additional nutritional value as well. The only negative I can say, is that it has turned her into somewhat of a monster! She tries to eat the bowl.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed March 14, 2016

      My older dog Hudson has experienced horrible environmental allergies, along with signs of aging. After feeding him Evangers White Fish and Sweet Potato Diet for the last year, he has improved by 300 percent, and is now spry and happy!

      Thanks for your vote!
      Verified purchase

      Reviewed March 4, 2016

      Evangers Nothing but Natural Grain Free Jerky Treats Oven Baked - I have two dachshunds that have very picky and have sensitive stomachs and this is the only treat that they enjoy having that does not upset their stomach. It is also low fat and grain free and healthy for them. It's been a great experience to have something now that finally works.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Feb. 18, 2016

      I run with my dog, Eddy, every day, but I noticed even though he exercises daily, he was getting fatty spots on his tummy. I took him to the vet and he had a clean bill of health, but they recommend I change his diet to see if that helps with the fat spots. They gave me a couple of cans of Evangers to try out, and Eddy loved it, so I bought a few more cases of different flavors, and have been feeding it for about 3 months now. The fatty spots have gone down a lot, and I noticed Eddy's coat is more shiny and soft. I am very happy with this brand, and I would definitely recommend it. And didn't even know that changing his food would help so much, so I am glad my Vet told me about Evangers.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Staff

      Reviewed Feb. 3, 2016

      My name is David **, and I graciously want to thank Evanger's for make such a fine wet/dry food. My little Shih Tzu name Willow, had not eaten for 7 days.

      After numerous trips to the vet and blood work I decided to try can dog food from my local pet supplies plus. The assistant manager heard me telling the store manager. She proceeded to interrupt, and begun to tell me all the research she had done on different dog foods, and when she heard my dog hadn't eaten, she highly recommended Evanger's vegetarian, and the Duck wet food. Keep in mind before I started Evanger's dog food my dog was way underweight. Now she has been on Evanger's for the past 4 weeks and then back to the vet and is put on weight her bloodwork come back positive and got good results from the vet from Evanger's dog food. Evanger's dog food company has earned my loyalty my respect in a long life Customer. Thank you Holly and Brett for a job well done.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Jan. 24, 2016

      Evanger's grain free cat food was recommended to us by our vet after we lost our last cat to kidney disease. There was another brand also recommended, but the price was beyond our means. We have now been using Evanger's cat food for over 3 years, and it suits the needs of our overweight cat, our tummy sensitive cat, and the health needs of both. I honestly cannot say anything negative about this product. Our cats are eating well and are healthy. Their coats have improved, litter box usage has diminished, and the odor from the litter box is a HUGE improvement. More of the nutrients from this product go into our cats rather than ending up in the litter box.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Staff

      Reviewed Jan. 19, 2016

      The best vegetarian dog food ever. My little Yorkipoo is sensitive to protein and cannot have meat. He is now 12 years old and he is one happy and healthy little dog. My thanks to the Evangers for having this wonderful product.

      Thanks for your vote!

      Reviewed Jan. 7, 2016

      This food is amazing. My dog loved the hand-packed Chicken Drummettes and Hunk of Beef. The food is very obviously human-grade, and the fact that it is cooked in the can means that all the nutrients are locked in. The Hunk of Beef is like a little pot roast in a can. My dog has done extremely well on this food, and it has cleared up a number of smaller skin and coat issues she had.

      Thanks for your vote!
      Loading more reviews...

      Evanger's Pet Foods Company Information

      Company Name:
      Evegner's Pet Supply
      Website:
      evangersdogfood.com