American Home Shield Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+2 more
About American Home Shield
American Home Shield (AHS) is a home warranty provider based in Memphis, Tennessee. It offers three home warranty plans with varying levels of coverage, and you can choose either a $100 or $125 service fee. Its plans cover rust, insufficient maintenance, unknown preexisting conditions and faulty repairs, which are often excluded from this type of coverage. AHS is available in 48 U.S. states.
Visit www.ahs.com- Three plan options, plus add-on coverage
- Discounts and promotions available
- 30-day workmanship guarantee
- Covers rust, corrosion and sediment damage
- Coverage limits and exclusions
- Must generally use a contractor from its network
- Only available in 48 states
American Home Shield Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (67,381)
- (16,581)
- (8,804)
- (4,399)
- (13,840)
Popular Mentions
- 4,962,754 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,962,754 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
American Home Shield is saying on TV commercials that they'll have someone out to get to you the next day but that's a lie. I called to file a claim then I had to call two or three times before I could even get someone. Then the lady said she had put it through. She didn't know any more than I did with getting someone to come out. I told her what they advertised on TV like they'd gonna get somebody on a Saturday. She said that it would be Monday or Tuesday. I looked on Monday and nobody was there. Then at Tuesday, still nobody came. The contractor came out Wednesday morning. American Home Shield's customer service was poor. However, the contractor was really good. They got right on and fixed the problem. This was the first claim that I filed and I hope AHS will do a better job when I need the service again.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
When I had an issue with my freezer, broken ice maker, I was able to easily submit a claim with American Home Shield. I went online and just filled out the form. I typically do everything online as calling in at a call center takes forever to get through. I could be on hold for around 20 minutes. I got a text message before the AHS contractor came out and it had their ETA. They then came out and looked at the freezer but they weren’t able to fix it right away. They had to order the part and then come back in. It took two trips to get the freezer fixed but it wasn’t a major issue.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
My heater didn’t work and that was when it was really cold here for California. I filed a claim to American Home Shield online and it was fine. As soon as I knew the contractor's number, I called them right away and they were out within two days. Metropolitan Heating and Air was polite and on time. Also, they found the problem and fixed it. I was pleased.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I have a 30-year-old house. Once, I got hit by 10 grand bill for my 30-year-old heating and air conditioning unit that went out and I wasn't able to afford that. I got a home warranty from American Home Shield and it has been helpful as I have a really old house and stuff happens. Once, I filed a claim for my washer as its motherboard was having issues. I file my claims over the phone. There have been times where I have been put on eternal hold, but whenever that happens, I just hang up and call back a different time. I know that there are times where the call volume is higher than other times.
AH Appliance Repair then came out for the washer. What's good about them is that they do all my appliances in the house and so I already know who I'm dealing with. One time, I even asked the tech if I was gonna get them if anything in the kitchen or the washer and dryer goes and he said yes. Another thing that's cool is that on your phone, you get this little text that says where the tech is located on the map and it tells you when exactly he's gonna be at the house. That's really nice for me because I work a lot of hours at a place that's close to home, so if I know I can run home really quick, that makes it more helpful.
The AH Appliance Repair tech replaced my washer's motherboard and the unit is all good now. I've also filed a claim with AHS for my garage door. I knew it was gonna be a tricky claim because the motor died but the repair company came out and replaced one of the doors. In the year and a half that I've had American Home Shield, I've dealt with two different contractors and they've both been very good.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I had my AC unit repaired before through American Home Shield, and that was fine. I also had a couple of other plumbing jobs. I submitted a plumbing claim with them and the experience I had was not great at all. First, it took me a long time to get anybody on the phone. And then, the plumber that came by couldn’t do the job. They thought that I didn’t have an access hole. So, they had to come back and I had to show them the access hole. When they tried to do the job, they told me I was missing parts, which I wasn’t missing. Now, they said that in order for them to complete the job, they will have to charge me $400. I didn’t understand that. I feel like I wasted my money for that deductible. I should not even deal with them.
I had another one for my wife's rental property where they sent out a HVAC guy due to a problem with the ductwork. He claimed that he couldn’t do it because the ductwork is in a bad shape due to animals in the attic. There are no animals in the attic and the ductwork is just old. He bailed out on the job and we couldn’t get anything done. My dad had the same problem, too. The contractor went over there for plumbing but said that they couldn’t do the job. I called American Home Shield and was hoping that the guy could do it, so I didn’t waste my deductible. But that’s what it’s coming down to.
Good afternoon Mark,
Your concerns are understood regarding the heating and air conditioner service requests. I would be glad to speak with you and assist to reach a resolution.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I had submitted a claim to American Home Shield three weeks ago and it was with a toilet bowl. It was okay with the filing and then, the technician came and partially fixed the problem. We are expecting that they will change the toilet bowl. But they said that we can still use the same one and they sealed that bowl. But the sealing was not the best one. Still, my wife is complaining that the toilet bowl is not fixed fully.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
There are so many things that are not covered with American Home Shield and I’m considering dropping my account. When my garage door broke, there was no emergency garage door repair service. I had to pay over $600 to get it fixed so that I could get my car out and go to work the next day. That was almost a whole year's worth of my monthly payment with AHS. Then, when I submitted the claim to be considered for reimbursement, it was denied. They said emergency services were not part of garage door services and that it would have to wait until Monday. The company also had 24 to 48 business hours to schedule my appointment, and I couldn’t wait to get my car out of my garage. It irritated me after being a customer of them for almost 10 years.
American Home Shield is also awfully expensive. I feel there are things that I don’t even call for because they’re not gonna cover. And the garage door just tipped me over the edge. I had been debating and I am going to be canceling. I referred my parents to them and my parents have since stopped their account because they’ve run into the same problems.
Hello, Ashlee. I completely understand that you needed to get your car out of the garage and that it was an actual emergency for you and your family. I apologize that you did not get the service that you requested. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly to discuss your concerns.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I called and filed a claim with American Home Shield for our heat. They sent this guy out and he replaced an item on the unit. He told me to call him back if anything else was wrong with it or I could call my warranty company to call him. I told him that I would call him if anything happens. After the repair, the heat still did the same thing and a couple of days later it broke. I called the tech but he told me he was on vacation and that I had to call my warranty company. I told him, "You were here, I paid you, you fixed the unit, and now that it's broken again the next day you're telling me to call my warranty company?” But my husband said to not worry. The guy told me to take the filter out since the problem could have been the filter size and he told my husband to get a new one. So, my husband went to Home Depot, bought the filter, and cut it out. And the guy was actually right. The unit worked and the heat came back on.
However, the following day, the heat stopped working again. I texted the guy and he sent me 18 pictures of him in Aruba. He also told me to call my warranty company. I called AHS but nobody was answering, so I went online. But their website didn’t say recall anywhere, it just had heat and furnace. I was freezing and I just had back surgery, so I put furnace because that sounded like the next best thing to put in. I did put heat but it said, "You can't put in the same thing.”
I called AHS again the next morning and I was able to get through really early. The rep I talked to told me to wait until someone got here and she cancelled the claim I filed. Climate Control was then assigned to my claim and Tom was the tech who was supposed to get here in two days. But he called and cancelled. He said he couldn't come out for four days because he broke his rib and had a doctor's appointment. Finally, when he showed up, he was with his 14-year-old son. He took off the big duct by the top of my heater and said that the problem was the unit was not getting enough oxygen to the pilot. He then took the whole duct off, plugged in the duct that’s coming in from the outside, took out the filter, and put it back in. I didn’t know what he did but the unit lit back up again. He was here for 10 minutes then he left. But no sooner than a couple of hours later, there was no heat again.
I called American Home Shield and said that what was happening was ridiculous and that they were not sending me the right guy. I called Tom but he told me that he would be going to a family reunion on Friday and that he wouldn't be back unit Monday. That was three days and there was no way in hell I was gonna wait that long. I already waited for him for four days and the issue was going on for two weeks by then. I was done.
So, I called American Home Shield again and asked them to give me the opportunity to call somebody who was a real heating person. They gave me an outside authorization and I called a ma and pa heating company that was recommended to me by a friend. The guy came out and he told me that the unit's modulator and sensor were out and that it should be fixed because that was what burned everything. He said that if the previous techs fixed those right away, none of these things should have happened. He then fixed the unit and it has worked perfectly ever since. So my experience turned out to be good and now I am satisfied. I've been with American Home Shield for nine years now, on and off, and I love them. I know that the problem was the crazy people they sent out.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
Our heating unit quit working and we didn't know exactly what it was doing. It would either not come on at all no matter what we set it on or it would come on and just run and run. I submitted the claim with American Home Shield over the phone and the process was really simple. Within a few minutes, I started receiving a text saying that they've received my claim and that they were working on it. However, it was over the weekend, so we didn't get anyone over until later. They called me and the techs came out quickly. They were gonna put me a week out, but I told them that we couldn't go without heat that long, so they bumped it up for a couple of days.
The techs came out the first time but realized that our units are on top of our house, so they rescheduled for someone with a ladder truck to come out. He came out and he changed off the thermostat, but within a couple of days, it quit working again. So he came out and went up on the roof and said that it was the computer that was in the system. He ordered the part and he came out the next day and put it in, and it has been working fine. The contractors sent out by American Home Shield were great.
Thanks for sharing your warranty experience Robin. I am happy that we were able to resolve your HVAC issue. We look forward to handling your warranty needs.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
Our water heater wasn’t working and we needed it fixed. We've had someone come and look at it before. I filed a claim to American Home Shield and did it online which was super easy. Their response time was very fast and my interactions with the techs have been great. They’ve been super nice and efficient. Since then, the water heater has been great. So far, I'm very happy with AHS's service.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I called American Home Shield to submit a claim for a leaky bathroom faucet and the gentleman that they sent out was really nice. He ordered me a new faucet and told me it would take 7 to 10 days, but it came in about the sixth day, so it was good.
Reviewed March 12, 2019
I had a pool heater that didn't work. I submitted a claim online to American Home Shield and navigating through their website was easy. Getting someone on the phone is the hard part though. The tech from Aeon Blue Pool & Spa came out and diagnosed that the pool heater needed to be replaced. They did all the work of contacting American Home Shield for the authorization to replace it.
The tech has been out here before. He’s a habitual contractor that AHS use for the pool service. And I've had him three times through American Home Shield. He’s always done a great job. Since the repair, the pool heater works great and its repair helped tremendously. We’re getting ready for my son's 16th birthday party and it's hard to have a pool party without a heater in this weather. American Home Shield gives me peace of mind that I’m not gonna have a huge bill during this particular month for an outage of a system. That heater for the pool was a $1,100 repair, and I paid a $75 deductible for that. My experience with AHS has been excellent.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I had to have a water heater repaired, and it took 14 days to get it replaced. The company ordered the replacement too early, and then found out it would not fit. They then offered cash in lieu which was much less then it cost to actually replace the water heater. After speaking to multiple people at AHS, I finally got to a supervisor, who offered 2 different concession checks. These checks never showed up and then they denied that any offer was ever made for this. No apology, no refund, no resolution.
Hi, Adam. I regret to hear that you have experienced these issues with replacing your hot water heater. Our records show this issue is from this past Spring of 2018. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
Updated on 03/13/2019: This is an update on my previous review. I'm sorry to say things went from bad to worse. After over an HOUR on hold on 3/11/19, I spoke to a supervisor named June who told me that there was an authorization on file to replace all three faucets. I was pleasantly surprised, although not sure why no one called me to inform me. The following day, June called me back and left me a message stating that she "misunderstood" the authorization, and it is, in fact, to replace only one faucet. Are you kidding me? From not calling back, to the endless holds, to the negligent selection of contractors, and, now, to making a representation and essentially taking it back. This is the worst and most unprofessional company I have encountered.
Original Review: On 3/4/2019, the company that AHS sent to our home to repair a leaky sink arrived at our house. The technician was not only unable to fix the problem, but, in the process of unsuccessfully trying to remove the handles on the sink, the plumber damaged the handles to the point that they now need to be replaced. He caused damage without ever even working on the underlying problem. When he saw that the handles were not removing, it would have been both professional and standard conduct to discontinue what he was doing, call for assistance or let us know that, if he continues to try to remove the handle, he may damage it. He did none of the foregoing.
The company and AHS offered to replace the one handle with a builders grade handle. Replacing one faucet in a bathroom that has two sinks and a bathtub with matching handles is not an adequate or reasonable solution. Certainly, we cannot have different bathroom hardware in the same bathroom. Through the negligence of the plumbing company in their services, and AHS's negligence in selecting a sub-professional company with terrible reviews, we are in a worse position than we were before we called AHS and before the plumber came to our home.
The appropriate solution is for AHS to replace the bathroom hardware on both sinks and the bathtub so that it all matches. I have called AHS 3 times and was told that someone would call me back. No one has to date. The plumbing company is also not responding. I am currently on hold with AHS - it's been 31 minutes. This is by far the worst customer service I have ever experienced. I'm at the point where I'm preparing to file for arbitration.
Hello, Maria. I apologize that you have had these issues with your plumbing work order. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I have submitted TWO claims (and paid two deductibles) for the same leaking pipe under my house. On both occasions, the plumbing company did just enough to "fix" the issue for a short period of time. Once the issue popped up again, AHS said that they only guarantee work for 60 days and I would need to file another claim. THREE claims for the same issue is robbery. Oh, and when I called to discuss, the representative would not let me speak to his supervisor and told me "they shared the same opinion on the matter". If you are reading this, please take your business elsewhere, as this company does not care about its customers.
Hello, John. I definitely understand your concerns with a reoccurring issue. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly to discuss your concerns.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I can't even get through, lines are down. It's been over an hour. I finally get someone on the chat and Susan ** says she can't help because she is in sales: what kind of business does not even have their phone lines functioning. I was told to call after I told them I have been redialing for 1 hour. Get with this century. Horrible customer service. What a rip off.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I have had American Home Shield for 9 years. I pay monthly over the years anywhere from $85-95 a month. I am a single woman who purchased this to keep my house/appliances protected over the years and had them come out maybe 5-6 times over the years. This last incident set me over the edge because all I needed was for my pilot to be lit on my water heater. The water heater was replaced 8 years (by American Home Shield) ago and the nice service tech warned me that whoever installed it didn't do it to code and when it needs to be replaced American Home Shield won't cover it. When I called American Home Shield about it trying to make sure it would be covered it took six weeks of back and forth to get no answer.
This is the second time American Home Shield contracted out workers that did the cheapest fix, and again not to code. The first time was for my heater which then I got a fine for the local gas company. Last but not least cancelling my policy. I have cancelled my policy 4 weeks ago and was told it would be cancelled and an email/phone confirmation confirming it along with a prorated check for the month that was not used. I have called twice and have to constantly call and follow up. There are notes in my account but no one is putting the paperwork through, just pushing the paperwork in circles. This company used to be great years ago. As many people have told me, "You're better off saving your $1,000 a year for a just in case, than have to deal with the aggravation of this bogus warranty company."
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
Warranty came with the house when we bought it in Oct 2013, Jan 2014 furnace was running on Auto EMERGENCY HEAT (basically a giant electric heater inside the unit-causing a $500 monthly electric bill). Call AHS. They dispatch tech, the outside unit was low on Freon, cost $400 (service charge+Freon=$475). This same scenario has repeated every winter since costing a total of $2375 so far. Each time a different company and still none could find a leak. This year when the new technician diagnosed it, he said it was the inside unit which was leaking (never opened it up) and the unit was going to be condemned...then he said he forgot his paperwork and would send info to AHS.
3 days pass, call AHS Rep said they have no documentation that he was here. Husband explained that we are currently have no heat and it’s 35 degrees outside. AHS rep attempted to contact Technician. Being Sunday he didn’t answer. AHS claims Tech has 48 hrs to send paperwork and stuttered when ask to clarify the 48 hrs in which he had to do this (he was here Thursday morning). Today is Monday morning. Currently waiting for a response from AHS. I feel as though I am being taken advantage of, I cannot continue to receive $400+ electric bills NOR can I continue to fill this unit with $300 Freon that will leak from an unknown location.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
Our American Home Shield warranty was originally a one-year gift that the realtor presented to us when we bought the house. We liked it and we decided to keep it. However, their financial part is not good right now. This month, for some reason, we got billed and charged something extra after we had our call in for a service. We got charged for the $75 fee, which was fine, but we found another fee when we looked at our bank statement. It was 80 and some change, so I already notified the credit card company to contest it. I called American Home Shield and they had no record of it so something got mixed up there. Another issue I have is that, evidently, we had an increase in the first of the year. It would be nice to get a notification on an increase coming up for the new year since we’ve been a customer for quite a few years. Other than those issues, their service is good.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I made a claim on my appliances with American Home Shield. I read through the contract and it said that I could pay one deductible for all the appliances, so that was what I did. The main issue is with the washing machine. It had several problems. Number one, my daughter and I both thought that we smelled something burning as it was going through the cycle and also, it would not drain. So, it would go through the entire cycle and then I’d go to put it in a dryer and the water was still in the washer. Then the hot water didn’t come out of it as well. We also thought maybe it could be the dryer was smelling like it had a burning smell.
Then I had the microwave. It doesn’t cook like a normal microwave and it makes all these terrible noises. I didn’t think it was functioning properly which with microwave made me a little afraid about that. Then two of the four burners of my stove would just keep getting hot. There wasn’t a temperature regulation and that included the oven as well. Any time I put it over 400, it would just keep getting hot and everything burned. The first time I used it, I set off all the smoke alarms in my house. It was very scary.
The first time we called AHS, the technician was able to rule out that it wasn’t the dryer that had a burning smell and that it was a rubber piece in the washing machine. The tech then replaced the timer and he said that everything worked fine. Then the first load of laundry that I did, the water did not drain again. I immediately called back. The tech was able to fix the stove though or at least he replaced parts. I still don’t think it’s operating right. Also, he was not able to take care of the microwave because the only way he could access the parts was from the top and my house is older and there’s a façade up there that I have to remove so the tech can get to the top of it. I’m a little disappointed in that. I wish he would’ve said something when he first came out and I would’ve had that done.
I called back in January and it is now the middle of March and my washing machine still doesn’t work. I haven’t heard back from them from the second time they came out. They have told me that I need a new drain pump. I’m not 100% happy but they’re very nice though. Eric has been the same person that has come out and he was very polite. I’m just curious as to why it takes so long. They have to come out and assess the issue which I understand. Then he has to go back and order parts. But the first time, it was almost two weeks. They say they’re gonna be here between 8:00 and 2:00 but they come at 2:00. It has always been the latest time.
The coverage that I have with the home warranty is awesome. I do understand that they're trying to repair the item rather than replace it but I wish that it was more comprehensive. I am disappointed that I have to not only take days off to be at home just so that they can try to fix it, where if it was a replaced item or even if it was a used item if I called a repair place, they would come out and fix it that day. I feel like we’re having to jump through different hoops with AHS. I try to cut them a little bit of slack but I would like to have a functioning microwave and washing machine. My sister is very tired of me coming over to do my laundry there in her house.
Good afternoon Peggy,
Your concerns are understood regarding the appliance service request. I would be glad to speak with you and assist to reach a resolution.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I had a leak in front of the house, outside my mobile home. I thought it was a pipe leak because I have a septic tank and I thought that it might have been from that. When the plumber came out, he went underneath and he said there was no leak. It was good, but it took a $75 deductible just to find that out. He thought it might be the septic, a sprinkling system that goes out throughout the yard, but it was coming from underneath the home. If I used the shower or if I used the washing machine, when it drained, it came out to the front. It was not going through the pipe, but he felt it underneath and he said it was running through the pipe when I drained it.
I submitted the claim with American Home Shield over the phone and the interaction I had with the claims representative was great. They were telling me the contractor would be dispatched out between 4:00 and 8 o'clock p.m., but it changed and they sent me another message that it would be between 5:00 and 9 o'clock p.m. It was a late time for a plumber to come out. It was dark and I didn't know how he would figure out what to do. But the guy was good. He looked through everything and it didn't take a matter of time. He did not waste any time.
I also had electrical problems where my bathroom electrical lines were not working. I put my dryer and plugged it in, and it must have blown the fuse. I wasn't getting either bathroom to work and I wasn't aware that the circuit breaker was off. That was one problem with the electrician and it cost me $75 for him to tell me, "Well, your breaker was off." We had where our heater wasn't working and it turned out that when the electrician was doing something, he had to start something off outside with the gas tank, the propane. They shut it off outside but didn't turn it back on, so my heating unit was not working. It was another $75 wasted. The tech came out to find out that the propane guy turned the gas off outside and that was why we couldn't get any heat. I wasted $75 each time that it could've been something fixed.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
There was a blockage in the sewer and the water was not going through. I filed my claim to American Home Shield online and later over the phone because initially, they could not understand. Someone else had to come so I was communicating over the phone. Street Plumbing & Rooter had to come out a few times and they tried to get the sewer cleaned up. After a few days, we saw the same blockage again. The blockage did not flush out completely when they put the initial snake, which was a smaller one and was good for 2 to 3 inches. But the guy who came towards the last visit had a bigger snake which is good for the 4-inch pipe. He did a good job and now it's resolved.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I had an appliance claim with American Home Shield for my washing machine. The first man they sent out said that there were two parts that he needed. Then a different man came to install and he decided that it only needed one part. He only put one part in and from then on, I had trouble. They kept coming back to fix that same part after a month. I also kept having water sounds and all that kind of stuff. The company that was fixing it, couldn't fix it. Then AHS wound up calling Sears to come out and do it. It took a while for the washing machine to be fixed entirely and it wasn't a good experience. I wash every day since I have blankets. And if I couldn't wash, it was overall affecting the house with what was going on.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I had an emergency where there was a leak on the back of my toilet and the water was coming out quickly. It happened around 9:30 at night and I immediately called American Home Shield. However, they told me they don’t do emergency service and that I have to call in the morning. When I couldn’t find someone to come out, I called them back that night and asked if they could get me someone first thing and they said they could. So, I just had to deal with the problem, and it was horrible. American Home Shield sent someone out the next morning and the guy was here at 8 AM. He was extremely professional. He rang the doorbell, introduced himself, looked at the problem and then told me what he was gonna do. He had the issue resolved within an hour and a half. He was great.
Overall, I’ve been happy with American Home Shield. The people have been professional and they contract with great companies. I just feel that in some situations, it’s kind of game-ish. American Home Shield is always trying to find ways out of covering things and paying for our claims. I don’t like that at all because I am dedicated to paying my bill every month. They take it out of my account. They covered my last claim and it was great but I had a situation with my AC where they didn’t cover many things. In addition to the $125 service call and the monthly $40 I pay them, I had to pay an additional amount because they found ways not to cover things. It cost me $500 including their $125 fee. I’m a new homeowner and that to me is really crappy. Those are things that should be discussed upfront. I’m not an AC professional, so I don’t know all the components of an air conditioning and what’s covered and not. Some things that were not covered were very costly and unexpected, and I felt would’ve been covered with having a home warranty.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
The dryer was making a weird noise. I made the claim with American Home Shield on the phone and the wait time to speak to an actual agent was a headache. I need the customer service to be a little expedited. You could do it online, but for someone like me who is a little more traditional or old school, I just get the phone and call somebody, and it is hard to get a hold of a representative. It is usually anywhere from a 10 to a 45-minute wait.
The interactions I had with the representative was fine but the call went to another country because I was having difficulty understanding. I said that I needed my dryer fixed and I told them what was going on, and they finally were able to get somebody. They called me and they had a work order on my schedule. It took a couple of days for them to come out, but it was fine and they did it on my schedule. Apparently, the bearings in the dryer went out, so the techs fixed the bearings. However, the next time I used the dryer, it started making noise again but double the noise, so the repair performance was a poor. I called the company back again and they had to come back out and fix it. They were able to make the final repairs on the second time and it is working fine now.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
Our tenant submitted a claim for the replacement of the ice maker in our refrigerator. The contractor Major Appliance Repair Services finished the job and it was great. I’ve had American Home Shield for about 20 years and it’s a safety net. I’ve always been satisfied with them.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
We have two heating units. One was heating and one was not. The fan was just blowing but no heat was coming out. I filed a claim with AHS online and the contractor did very well. He was very fast and took care of it. We've been using AHS for a few years and we really like their service. They've been really helpful.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
There was a problem with my washing machine. I called American Home Shield and submitted a claim through the automated system over the phone. It was fairly easy doing that and it works for me. Also, the interactions I had with the techs were good. They were always professional. Definitely having a warranty with American Home Shield has been useful since I’ve had it. I will recommend them to others.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I’m satisfied with American Home Shield. Their warranty is extremely valuable if everything keeps breaking down on you. I have a claim on our microwave and I submitted the claim over the phone. The contractor they sent out were from United Appliances Services. They worked with us on our time frame and they were on-time. They were very friendly and got right to work. Also, they were very conscientious of our belongings in the house and they explained what they did very well. They’re ordering a part and should be out this week.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I went online and submitted a claim to American Home Shield for our water heater. The website was user-friendly and I was able to find what I needed. It had a button that said, "Issue Claim," and I did it that way. It was easy and I was able to do it late at night. The website stated that I could expect to hear something within 24 hours. However, it was after a day and a half when I've heard back that the company Emergency Plumbing and Rooter would be coming out. Still, that was fine and was expected because it was late at night when I submitted the claim.
We had problems with our water heater where it was making loud sounds like explosions so the contractor company checked it. The guy was great and very professional. My husband was home, so he was able to talk to him, and he explained what he was going to be doing and how long it would take. He confirmed that we needed to have the water heaters changed out 'cause it was a possible issue that it could explode. So, both units were changed out and have been great since. I was very pleased with the service and that was a very positive experience. In fact, I've shared with several people my experience and how it's benefited us having American Home Shield.
When I signed with American Home Shield, I wasn't thinking about my water heaters. But it so happened that they covered it. If I wouldn't have had it, we would have had to pay for the full replacement of both. We had to pay for the plumbing portion as well, which was expensive. And if we had to pay for everything, it would have been triple that amount. So, having a warranty is very valuable. We've had American Home Shield for about a year and a half now and I plan to keep it. I highly recommend them too.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
They have an inability to discuss and resolve any issues regarding warranty service and repair. It takes numerous phone calls to handle any claim, no follow-up, and the have charged me for several service calls, which they said was covered, but turned around and charged me for the very calls, they initially approved. I had to cancel this company's services, due to non-payment of verified warranty claims.
Good afternoon B Jeanz,
Your concerns are understood regarding the service fee charges per each claim that was placed and the cancellation of your contract with American Home Shield.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
Submitting a claim to American Home Shield was very easy. But a year and a half ago, it was very difficult. I'd be put on hold for a good hour and a half, and it was like an endurance test to see if I could actually get it through. This time, I just got through and did not take that long at all. Speaking with their reps was good. They just ask me what the problem then tells me that they are gonna get such and such contractor to call me. Then the contractor calls and we set up a time.
The person that came out most recently from Service Giant was great. I had a problem with my garbage disposal. Then I also had a problem with my sump pump in the crawl space. It had been replaced a long time ago, when I first started with AHS, and it stopped. It broke and didn’t work anymore. There was a little bit of leak in addition to that. He was very professional and wanted to get my problems fixed. I've been with American Home Shield closer to three years now and they're doing well. I will tell everybody that they should have this home warranty because it's good to have.
Reviewed March 11, 2019
I've used American Home Shield two or three times and it has been working out well. When my garbage disposal was not working, I called in and placed a request for service then AHS put me in touch with someone the next day. The guy came out within three or four days, on my day off, and tried to repair the disposal. It didn't look repairable so he replaced it. He was very professional.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
Even though our oven is gas, all its functionality is lost if the power goes out because of its electrical system. But my experience with the oven claim with American Home Shield was perfect. The technician they sent out was very nice and well-presented. He determined really quick what the issue was and ordered the part. A week later, he came back with the part and fixed the oven in a couple of minutes. He was really good.
I’ve been with AHS for almost 15 years and I always call in to submit a claim because sometimes, when you do it online, things can go left and the system interprets it incorrectly. That happened to me once, so I’d rather talk to somebody in person. Other than that, I would recommend American Home Shield. I could be stressed out because something broke but the minute I give them a call, the stress goes away. I know that they’re gonna send qualified people over to address the issue.
Good morning Michael,
Your patronage is greatly appreciated for the past 12 years. I am pleased to hear about the technicians that serviced your home. It is our goal to provide you with a great experience.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
Water heater still leaking with no response from AHS - I contacted American Home Shield in mid February to report a leak in my water heater. They were quick in sending out a plumber to diagnose them the damage and the needed repairs. The plumber came out the following week and I was contacted by American Home Shield the next day. The voicemail I received from American Home Shield indicated that none of the repairs were covered. I immediately contacted American Home Shield and asked for another review of the plumber's recommendation. After the review I was told by the representative that she was able to get some of my repairs covered. American Home Shield covered a little over $400, my responsibility was over $1000. How is it that customers pay hundreds of dollars a year in monthly dues but when they need services American Home Shield pays little or nothing at all?
When the plumber visited my home, the first question I asked was does my water heater need to be replaced. The water heater is over 20 years old and I had already mentally prepared my mind that the answer was going to be yes and that I would incur out-of-pocket cost. To my surprise, the technician said that yes the heater was old but that it was in good working order and did not need to be replaced. He said that if I completed the recommended repairs that he suggested I would be in good shape with the heater. Therefore, I agreed to have the recommended services performed. The plumber returned on Thursday completed the repairs but indicated that the water needed to be turned off for 24 hours while the system was flushed. A different technician returned on Friday, turned my water back on and let me know that all of the repairs were completed and that the leaking issue resolved.
This turned out not to be the case. I returned home from traveling on Monday to be confronted by my neighbor alerting me that they were still experiencing issues at their home as a result of the leak from my water heater. I contacted the plumber immediately and received a visit at my home around 8:30 PM that evening. The technician found the source of the leak and indicated that the valve was corroded and should be replaced. However, later that evening around 915 I received a call from that same technician to inform me that per her manager, the resolution was to place a cap over the valve. She said that someone would be at my home the next day to place the cap.
After thinking about it through the night, I was very concerned that with the fact that the valve was corroded, placing the cap would only serve as a temporary solution and I would likely have to contact AHS in a few short months, incur another service fee, only to be told that the valve needs to be replaced. I contacted the plumber the very next morning and voiced my concern but I heard nothing back. I contacted American Home Shield that same day and voiced that same concern and indicated that I preferred a permanent fix even if I had to pay for it myself.
The American Home Shield representative said that he understood my concern, placed me on hold, and contacted the plumber. When he returned to the line, he indicated that the master plumber and the technician would be contacting me that day to make an appointment to come back to my home to take a look at the leak. The other interesting thing that happened while on the call is that the representative read the plumber's notes to me which indicated that my water heater would need to be replaced.
This was In total contradiction to the response I received when questioning the plumber about the need to replace the unit. I was never contacted as I was told by the plumber nor did American Home Shield follow up to ensure that I received a visit. It was not until Thursday evening that I received a visit from a plumber. The plumber was instructed not to bother me and that he was simply to place them on the valve without interrupting me. He indicated that since he saw my car in the driveway he decided to knock to let me know what he was doing. I asked if he was aware of the concerns that I’ve voiced regarding the and that I preferred a permanent fix. He was not aware. He placed them and left.
The cap did not resolve the leak and so on Sunday I contacted American Home Shield again. I explained the entire situation to the representative who documented my complaint said that she would out reach to the plumber and even provided me with a reference number. It is now a week later on Sunday, still no reply from the plumber, still no follow up from American Home Shield, and yes, the water heater is still leaking. I’ve reverted to placing down towels and a bowl to catch the leaking water.
I am more than disappointed in American Home Shield and the plumber. I am convinced that American Home Shield only contracts with vendors who they know will do patch up work and band aid repairs. They are very happy to take their customers money but do very little to ensure customers are taken care of especially in situations where customers complain of subpar, incomplete and unsatisfactory work on the part of their contracted vendors. At this point, I feel as though my only recourse is to find and hire a plumber outside of my home warranty. I will never refer anyone to American Home Shield. In fact I will warn everyone I can away from this company and I will not renew my contract when it expires in September.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
We purchased a home in Florida in October 2019 and it came with warranty from American Home Shield (AHS). We just had our first claim and it was a TERRIBLE experience. Our air conditioner stopped working on Feb 23 and it was not fixed until March 7... 13 days!!! Totally unacceptable! AHS had to get the technician's report saying we needed a new compressor, then get the compressor purchase authorized. Then AHS ordered the compressor themselves instead of just letting the air conditioning company get it, that in and of itself added another 5 days just waiting for it to be delivered.
There was no sense of urgency from anyone at AHS. The customer service reps just told us what we wanted to hear, whether it was factual or not. We even asked for a call from a supervisor - was told "no supervisors on duty" - that a supervisor would call us within 24-48 hours. Did we ever get a call? NO. I would NOT, under any circumstances, recommend buying a home warranty from this company.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Original Review: March 10, 2019
You can't talk about American Home Shield without the word "Fraud" coming up. In my latest go around with them, my torsion spring broke on my garage door. I have additional coverage for garage door openers. Thinking that since the spring was required for the garage door opener to operate that it would be covered, I called them to schedule a repair. They contacted a service technicians and within 2 days they came out. The service tech called for authorization and was denied because the spring was part of the "door" and not the opener.
Now being stuck with a non operational door, I had to get it serviced. The technician told me how much the repair would be, and I paid the full amount. I later receive a charge for my trade service call from AHS, even though they denied coverage. When calling them to complain, they said that since I used them to contact a technician, I still owed them the fee. So this company will charge you even though they deny claims. FRAUD. FRAUD. FRAUD!
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I purchased this home warranty when I purchased my home three years ago. My 20 year old home has had a few issues with appliances and AHS has done a wonderful job in taking care of things for me. I also had an AC unit malfunction on a very hot day and they got a technician here on a Sunday! Very impressed with this company.
Colleen,
Your feedback regarding your recent experiences with AHS is greatly appreciated. Our main objective is to provide exceptional service and a quick resolution to all of your home warranty needs. We look forward to servicing you in the future as needed. Enjoy your day.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
Having a warranty on my property is very valuable. But with American Home Shield, there’s always an issue and I need to have somebody come out twice or they can’t seem to fix the problem. For example, the garage guy came out here and he had to change my garage door. He gave me a remote. I have two cars and it has to be standard to give me two remotes. But he said that I have to pay extra if I wanted it. Another time was when I was out without a stove for a month. The first guy who came out was really nice. He said he was gonna order some pieces, but I heard nothing. I called back and I was told that it was closed because he couldn’t fix it. I was having a dinner party then and I was stressing out about it. Then I got ahold of a local rep and he was excellent. He was Johnny-on-the-spot.
The last contractor who went here didn’t speak English very well so it was very difficult talking to him. When I asked him to look at my dishwasher, he came in, looked at it, cleaned the filter and then brushed off the top of the dishwasher. Then he said he cleaned the calcium off. I said that I've done that and I needed him to at least run the dishwasher. He said that there was nothing wrong with my dishwasher and left. He wanted me to sign the paperwork but I said that I won't sign it because he didn’t do anything. I called AHS and I complained, and got the reply that the contractor said it was a calcium buildup and that he cleaned it up, but I still have the same problem. Lastly, submitting a claim with American Home Shield on the phone is ridiculous. It takes no less than three hours on a usual call. I haven’t talked to somebody, and they put me on hold. There are other companies that do what AHS does and I would go to them.
Hello, Debra. I apologize that you had some issues with getting some of your service requests resolved. We definitely care about you and your feedback. A member of our Social Media team will contact you to discuss your concerns.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I've had AHS for a long time. We've owned this house for nine years and we've had it even before we've had this house. It's the one I started with so I stayed with them. So far, I've only had one claim, the one for my garbage disposal, and I submitted it over the phone. The experience was perfect. Their reps were courteous and as helpful as they could be. They had very quick response. Their contractor came out and checked the problem, and then they came out and replaced the garbage disposal. The plumber that they sent out was very personal, explained to me what was going on and told me what I needed to do, and everything worked out fine.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
Something broke under my faucet. It started off as the hot water popped off. After that, I had to get everything replaced at the bottom. The contractor that AHS sent out said that the part that they looked at had been broken off so they didn't cover it. My house was 20-something years old. My ex-husband tried to fix it and it broke off when he was trying to turn it. So, of course, they were saying that it was broken off so they wouldn't cover it. Nevertheless, the guy that came out was good. He fixed it but I ended up having to pay $225 out of pocket, plus the $100 that I had to pay American Home Shield. So far, the people that AHS have used were slow and some were terrible. In fact, when my refrigerator needed a compressor back during the early part of fall, I was without a refrigerator for three weeks.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
The motor on the ceiling fan in the master bedroom was out and I filed a claim to American Home Shield. I did it online which I prefer because I don't have to look at the clock and make sure I'm calling between certain hours. The technician they've sent out have always been fantastic. But this time, I'm disappointed that I'm left to get my own fan. The ceiling fan is still not working and the company that came out said that the warranty company would cash it out and send me a check, which would cover the installation for them to come out and install a new one. But still, I have to contact Hunter to get a new fan.
I’ve been with AHS since 2009 and this was an isolated incident. Every time I've called before, they've always been awesome in taking care of things. The only other problem I had was I had a company that I paid to come out twice a year to do checks on the AC and the heater, and there was a problem with the AC. The company I use is not part of AHS and when AHS sent somebody out, they said it wasn't a problem. So, their technician had a difference of opinion than what mine did. This last one left a bad taste in my mouth but AHS has always been good and never had any problems.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
We had a pipe in the basement that was like a sewage drainage type that had backed up. I submitted a claim to American Home and I did it online. Their website was very easy to navigate and within 24 hours, we had someone out. AHS was so good. They've always sent out Niebuhr Plumbing for plumbing issues and they were always on top of things. They were so good. Since then, our pipe has been perfect. However, it seems to be very hard to reach anybody if you make a call to get a service. AHS need to improve on that, if possible.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
My wiring in the kitchen was not working as the light wasn't coming on. I called and talked with the American Home Shield representative to let them know that I needed someone to come out. I was informed via text and email to expect the contractor. Then within 24 to 48 hours, the contractor called and let me know when they would be out. When the guy arrived, he was very professional and fantastic. He completed the job and also let me know what the issue was and where it was. I wasn't able to see really well without the lighting and so everything changed when that was fixed it.
I'm happy that I have American Home Shield because if something breaks down, I'm comfortable and happy to know that I have them available for me to get the repairs done. My home is about 14 years old, so things are gonna start wearing down. Knowing that I have American Home Shield is awesome because they get it done. It's very valuable and I tell my neighbors that they should get it.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
The thermostat on my water heater went out and I didn’t have hot water in the middle of winter. I submitted a claim with AHS online and it was fairly simple and convenient to do. Then the guys from Blue Ridge Mountain Plumbing showed up and they were very nice. They came a little bit early, did the job and got it all completed on the same day. It was urgent that they came and they got there as soon as they could, and I was thankful to have hot water after that. I’ve had AHS for seven years and I haven’t had any issues except when my AC unit went out last year, which caused me to stop doing business with them for a couple of months.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
We were having a problem with our washing machine and my wife went online and filed a claim with American Home Shield. It was a simple process. A repair company then came out and we really liked them. We would request them all the time if we had the option to.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I call American Home Shield to submit claims and the reps usually explain things well. Then, I usually wait for a few hours for a contractor to come out and if they don't call me, I call them. They're always on time, they're very efficient, and they fix everything. They’re polite and clean as well. I had Air Star Services for a heating issue and their services were excellent. The heater is now working fine.
Sharon,
We are happy to hear that we were able to resolve your heating issue. We appreciate you taking the time to share your warranty experience. Have an amazing week.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I did a claim with American Home Shield for the air conditioning, and the guys who came out were very professional. They came in and they did what they had to do. The tech told me what the problem was, diagnosed it and took care of it. And so far, everything is still working good. It was a great experience. It’s well-worth the money.
Good morning Courtney,
Your feedback is greatly appreciated regarding your most recent service experience. We are pleased to hear about the technician that repaired your air conditioner unit.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I am involved with several properties and I've used my parents' service persons, but they are all going to the wayside, so I have to rely on home warranties. American Home Shield has been very good. My heater wasn't working and the process of submitting the claim with American Home Shield was easy. They called and got the information, then they contacted Crispy Air & Heating in an instant. Crispy Air & Heating sent me a text when they were gonna be coming out and they gave me a window. They were on time and were courteous. I live in a remote area, but they were able to find the house and service the unit and get it going, although there was some difficulty and they had to get parts.
However, I'd like to see American Home Shield be more consistent with the same guy. That was the only issue because even though they took great notes, they were reading from what the other guy did. I wanna stay with the same person. There are two that are good and they seem to know the unit well, so those are the two that I like being out there if they are gonna work on it. I would recommend the service, nevertheless. If you have any difficulties, the key thing is communication and as long as there is communication going, I don't have a problem.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I was having a problem with the toilet. I saw water on the floor so I thought I had a leaky toilet. I filed a claim to American Home Shield over the phone and got the automated system. Then, someone called me back and I explained what I saw, that I thought it was a leak, and they said they would get back to me and let me know who was coming out. They followed-up and Dave & Sons Plumbing called and introduced themselves. The good thing about it was, when they sent me a notice that it was their company, they sent a picture of the actual service person, so I knew who was at my door. I thought that was the best thing in the world, so you know who you’re dealing with.
It was excellent, very pleasant, and very professional. The guy came in and checked the toilet. He couldn’t figure out what was going on at first and then we kept hearing this funny noise and he thought as well that it was a leak in the toilet because he said it makes that kind of noise. But when he fixed the toilet, we kept hearing it. He couldn’t find it. We thought maybe it would have been behind the wall or something like that. He checked everything, without tearing down the walls. We even checked the security alarm system. He took the batteries out of the smoke alarm but it wasn't that. He was very, very thorough even though he was there trying to figure out what was going on. He reported it back to American Home Shield and they said they don’t come out for noises.
We finally figured out the noise but it wasn’t what normally we thought it would have been. I would recommend American Home Shield to a friend. My only thought was as a home owner, I don’t know what noises are. I don’t know where they come from. We just know that there was a consistent noise. I would think that they would have sent someone to try to locate the source of the noise, to find out if it’s something that they do handle or not because I have no clue. But I was not dissatisfied with the experience.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
I was having some toilet problems in my son’s bathroom so he had to use another bathroom. My claim submission experience with American Home Shield was easy and quick. The contractor, Loftin Mechanical Inc, came out quickly. I was given an expectation when a contractor will be out and it was a couple of hours on that day. The experience with them was friendly. Since the repair, the toilet is performing well.
I would have had to pay out a lot more money if not for AHS as I use it for my rental property as well. I've had some issues with them. Last time, the claim was for my rental property. I had a Realtor that managed that property so there was a lot of confusion - the timeframe of being put on hold, then one operator telling us one thing about the whole payment issue and another one telling us something different. I wasn’t supposed to be charged for one time that their contractor came out because it was a mix-up. But I just went ahead and paid it. The other issue was I did not like Walston Mechanical before because of the issues that we had at my rental property, and I let them know when they came out that I wasn’t too happy about that. Other than that, they were good when they came out to my house.
Reviewed March 10, 2019
APC Plumbing, the company that American Home Shield contracted for my plumbing claim, handled the service poorly. The technician they sent out was not knowledgeable at all. They told us the water supply line was bad and needed to be replaced. I called out an independent plumber and it was just a quarter-turn valve that was bad. It’s a $4 valve versus a $5,000 job. The people that AHS sends out to do these home service calls are apprentice people. They’re not licensed, masters-of-their-trades people. I got a 24-year-old that showed up to my house and he was supposed to be a licensed plumber but he’s an apprentice. I looked at him and there was no way in hell that this kid knows what the hell he was doing.
I didn’t bring it to American Home Shield's attention though because, in the past, when we bring it to their attention, they have nothing to say except they go by what the contractor said. Also, when I ask for a different plumber, there are only two plumbers, so it’s the lesser of the two evils. This entire thing is not the first time that it has happened and it’s a continuing saga. Whatever home warranty company I go with next when this one expires, I go through the same saga with them. It seems like it’s a thing with all home warranty companies these days.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I would like to say that American Home Shield is a damn joke! For a gushing leak they can’t get anyone out till MONDAY!! Home buyers and owners beware. This company is worthless. Just 3 weeks ago I got someone out on a Sunday at 8:00 pm for a leak but I placed a request at 10 am this morning and it won’t get a response till Monday! So we get to go 48 plus hours without water. What am I paying for?!?
Good morning McCall,
Your concerns are understood regarding the delay in 24 hour service to have the leak repaired. I wold be glad to speak with you and assist with a resolution.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
American Home Shield is a fraudulent insurance company that collects high premiums and denies claims as a matter of practice. Once a client has a few claims, they increase premiums and deny all claims in an effort to get you to cancel your contract since they are not allowed to drop you. Our sump pump failed 2-3 years ago. We put in claim with American Home Shield (AHS), their contractor came out and replaced it and they covered it. Recently, the sump pump magnetic float failed so it was running constantly. We put in a claim with AHS, they sent out a contractor who said it needed to be replaced. He called it in to AHS, and this time, they denied the claim stating it was not covered because it was supposed to be ground water only and there was condensation from the heater/AC going into it.
When I followed up with AHS, they claimed the contractor told them it failed prematurely failed due to the water PH being highly acidic from the heater condensation. She stated the contractor had actually tested the PH. I spoke to the contractor and he told me he never tested the PH of the water and only told AHS the float had failed and never claimed to know why it failed. So - they basically lied and tried to lay blame on the contractor and alter "his" report.
Regardless of why the float failed, the true issue is that AHS put the sump pump in themselves and now they are saying they will not cover it. I elevated the claim with them based on the fact if there was an issue with the sump pump their approved contractor installed, it is on AHS and not me. They then said they were going to send out the original contractor who installed the sump pump to get a second opinion. I asked how a second opinion would make any difference and she stated they would then put the blame on the contractor. I am paying AHS and they are putting the customer in the middle - I am paying AHS and they are responsible for their contractor's work and educating them on what is and isn't covered.
Next, the original contractor came out. He explained to me that he has been replacing sump pumps for AHS for many years and only in the last couple years did they suddenly start denying them based on the "ground water" claim. He stated the set up for our sump pump is standard and how most sump pumps he sees are set up. He stated that the amount of water coming from the heater/AC unit was minimal and would not affect the overall PH of the ground water and that even if it did, the sump pump/magnet was plastic based which would not be affected by the PH anyway. AHS was also claiming there was condensation coming from our tankless hot water heater which he said was not true - there is an emergency release valve coming off the hot water heater but nothing comes out of it unless there is an emergency. This "ground water" clause is just another way for AHS to deny a claim.
I spoke to AHS today and they told me they are denying the claim due to the "ground water" claim. They completely changed their tune that high ph/water caused the pump to prematurely fail and are now say that it failed from "old age!?" The sump pump was installed less than 3 years ago. They take no responsibility for the fact that they installed the sump pump. How can they not cover something they installed themselves??
This is a reoccurring theme. They state they cover appliances in the garage but when we put in a claim for our refrigerator in the garage, they denied the claim based on it failed not from normal wear and tear but because of conditions to it being in the garage. That make no sense - if they are going to cover appliances in the garage, it is going be in the conditions of a garage! They ordered the wrong part for our dishwasher and wouldn't reorder the correct part claiming they do not guarantee color matching so my dishwasher was going to be 2 different colors.
We have been customers with AHS for approximately 8 years and during this time, the monthly premiums have increased while the coverage has decreased. We should have canceled years ago. I feel like I am in the movie The Rainmaker where I am dealing with a fraudulent insurance company who charges high premiums but denies the claims as a matter of practice and forces customers to fight for the coverage we have already paid for.
Good morning Julie,
As a customer for more than 8 years, your frustration is greatly understood. I understand your concerns regarding the claim denials and overall most recent experience. I would be glad to speak with you and get the issues resolved.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
We normally file claims with American Home Shield online and it is an easy process. And then we get a response in regards to when a contractor will be out to do the service within 24 hours.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I had a re-key scheduled through American Home Shield (AHS). The technician, Michael from Realty Rekey LLC showed up on 3/3/2019 and did not have all of his tools. He said he would be back tomorrow. We then texted back and forth up to 3/8/2019 each time the technician cancelling or phoning me past business hours. His excuses ranged from "something coming up" to it being a "hectic week". This is not my problem. I hope I can show the text messages as it just shows how horrible and poor the customer service was. When I spoke with an AHS representative asking to cancel him and send someone new after he bailed on me the second time, I was told that couldn't be done.
I was told since this was the first time I made them aware of the situation, I had to wait again. Wait again until he cancelled again, which he ultimately did four times in total. I told the representative I can send them the text messages showing how unprofessional the technician was but they said it was not necessary, just give him another chance. When I called AHS to demand a new technician that day they said their dispatch was very busy and it might not happen today, 3/8/2019. Thank you American Home Shield for not standing by your customers.
Good morning Mauro,
I understand your concerns regarding the delay in service that you experienced to have the re key repaired. I would be glad to speak with you and get the issue resolved.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
We called AHS to report a leaking water valve on 3/5/2019. The first thing they said is they would charge us for service. As of today, 3/8/2019, we have not had anyone fix the problem. The 1st plumber said they couldn't come out because of rain-it wasn't raining! So, we called AHS and they wouldn't deal with our concern, telling us to work with the assigned plumber. In the meantime, waters is pouring out! AHS call center is not equipped to help resolve these problems either.
Good morning Le,
I understand your frustration and concerns regarding your most recent experience to have to valve repaired. I would beg;ad to speak with you and assist with a resolution to the issues.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
We have had to deal with AHS for 2 issues: 1. Washer. 2. Garage door. Let me start by saying that their support is one of the worst ever! They never ever pick up the call and chat is as slow as one can imagine. Horrible experience to start with. 1. Washer - When we called in to complain about our washer, it took us 7 calls to reach a specialist. When we explained them our issue, they assigned MAJOR HOME APPLIANCE to perform the repair. The specialist came to our home, and was very rude. When we asked him what the issue was, he said, "Let me do my job and you won't even understand, so don't bother asking." He mentioned a part needs replacement and ordered it. Next time he came, he replaced it and left, without even explaining us the issue.
After 2 days, the washer stopped working again so we had to deal with AHS again! Called them multiple times but nothing helped. Finally, we got ahold of someone from chat option and after arguing with them for more than 10 hours, they assigned another company - NANA SERVICES. These guys are awesome as they came home within a day and were kind enough to explain us the issue. Not to forget, they mentioned the 1st company replaced the wrong part! They also offered to talk to AHS and tell them that repairing would be most costlier than the new machine. They agreed AHS only thinks of replacement of parts and nothing in regards to customer satisfaction.
2. Garage door - Unfortunately, our garage door stopped working after a few days of washer issue. We tried to chat a few times and finally got hold of a specialist. They assigned ACE's GARAGE DOOR REPAIR AND INSTALLATION. The person came to check out our garage door and mentioned that he would need to change the whole assembly of garage (drums, spring, bearings, etc.). He told us he would charge $1500. To his surprise, we had already called in 3 other companies and got a quote on the issue.
All 3 companies mentioned issue was with drums and spring bearing only, and it would cost around $175! When we told this to the person from ACES, he said, "Okay I will repair for $300." We were like, "Why did you even lie in 1st place." He gave crap reason that I thought issue is with motor and the assembly. We then told him, "We don't want you to work on this" so he left and told his company that we agreed to order bearings and a few other parts, which we never ever did! When we called them to complain, they apologized and would make sure that our garage door gets repaired without unnecessary charges. The person was supposed to come again at 8 am but came at 3 pm! When he came, he mentioned he will only repair the spring bearings which need dis-assembly of many things. When we told him we know the issue and there is no need for dis-assemble, he said, "I don't want to work for you" and left.
We then contacted AHS again and they didn't even agree to re-assign to another company. All they do is assign the issue to a crap company and then the problem is all ours. I would highly recommend going against these guys as it's a huge hassle and waste of time as well as money! I genuinely hope people ready my review so that you don't have to go through the same ** as we did.
Good morning Kunal,
I understand your concerns and frustration regarding both experiences to have your washer and garage repaired through American Home Shield. I would be glad to speak with you and get the issues resolved.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
There was a leak in the plumbing underneath our sink. We filed a claim with American Home Shield over the phone. There’s always a long wait time, like at least 30 minutes. But once I got through the process was pretty simple and easy. The first guy was very professional. The second guy that actually put the part in, was very quiet, but he did excellent work. Everything’s working okay.
AHS usually has someone come out and fix things right away. With the air conditioner guys that I had last year, I like one company more than the other. They were good to resolve any issues. I had an issue with the first company. The guy had said, “Okay, we’ll call you back in one or two days.” But they never called back and I didn’t like that. Right there over the phone, this girl called them and resolved everything beautifully.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I booked a claim online and arranged a visit on the American Home Shield website. I’ve had claims before and I was able to check off the right boxes. Everything went smoothly. My furnace wasn't getting hot and it was intermittent, and I restarted it and it worked for a little while but then it didn’t. Stellar Heating & Cooling called and made an appointment. The tech was able to come the same day and he was able to fix it. He also called back to make sure the furnace is working. Both times, the tech that came out was very nice and he was able to come in a very reasonable amount of time. I was satisfied with the service.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I’ve had very good experience with American Home Shield. I’m very satisfied. My most recent claim was for a washer and dryer that we have in a condominium that we just purchased. I submitted it online and their website was very user-friendly. They said I would receive a phone call within 24 hours and I did. The workman was very nice and professional. The dryer is running okay now, but there’s still a problem with the washer. He said it was working, and we checked it. We tried it a little later, and it still wasn’t working. I notified them immediately and I’m still waiting for a callback.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
American Home Shield has been great. Every time we call, they answer our questions and get us through our issues. We recently filed a claim after waking up with a flooded basement. The boiler was pressurized and dumped a bunch of water all over my floor for hours on end while we were sleeping. AHS got someone out in about 24 hours, and the guy was great. He definitely knew what he was doing. He was very experienced and knowledgeable. He got everything fixed as fast as he could and got us back up and running. He also pointed out a couple of things maintenance-wise for us. I didn't have an inline oil filter, so he said I gotta change the screen and do all the efficiency testing. I had him back out last Friday on my own dime to do the whole PM on the boiler. I was very happy with him.
Thanks for sharing your warranty experience Davin. I am happy that we were able to resolved your boiler claim. We look forward to handling your future warranty needs.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
If the service person they send is good; then service is great. Some of their people just aren’t good; and, I’ve learned that I can ask for another. Also, ask for your own repairman instead of theirs. Telephone wait time is getting better; best to do online.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
The user-friendliness of the American Home Shield's website is fine overall and I had an easy experience submitting a claim online. However, I didn't have any expectation on when a contractor would be out until I spoke with Joe's Mechanical. I have a very old heat pump unit and there was a series of things. The first thing that we had Joe's Mechanical come out and do under American Home Shield's behalf was placing a hard start kit. The dual run capacitor wasn't enough to actually keep the compressor running. They came out and took care of that. They were great and I had a very good experience with them. Then we later found out that there was Freon leak that was what really pushed it over the edge. They said it was a big enough issue that an upgrade is warranted. Once I got linked up with the upgrade department, everything was very smooth. Overall performance of the heat pump is now outstanding.
American Home Shield has been generous and we got a lot of value out of the warranty. The fact that we now have a brand new, efficient unit that's heating and cooling our home is just priceless, especially considering the price that we paid for it. So if you're buying a new home, I couldn't recommend going through American Home Shield enough.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
My dishwasher wasn't working and so I filed a claim online to American Home Shield. The process was easy and I got a response quicker than I expected. The contractor came really quickly and got the job done the same day he came. He was professional and explained what my issue was.
Good afternoon Karoline,
I am pleased to hear about the dishwasher repairs that were completed and the ease of the process to get the repairs completed. I hope you continue to enjoy!
Reviewed March 9, 2019
The pipe where my washing machine goes into for the drainage was clogged and I couldn't do my laundry. I called American Home Shield to file a claim and NW Sundance Services came. The guy was great. He put a snake in there then we ran the washing machine and everything was drained. He was here less than half an hour.
I bought a new home and the seller included a one-year warranty with American Home Shield. I got it through my Realtor and she said that they always have this. She likes to add a warranty, which is great. But as a buyer, you're not told what that entails, that you have to pay a $75 service charge with it every time you use it. I think it needs to be explained every time when signing up. To me, having a warranty is not having to pay for anything.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
We own a couple of homes and we have American Home Shield warranties. When our rental house in California had an electrical problem, they sent Unified Contractors and the timing was very slow. Half of the house was without electricity and there is a pregnant lady in that house. I don’t know how uncomfortable that made her life but they waited a week or so for the contractor to get there. That took too long in my opinion. It seemed that American Home Shield could not find a local technician. Meanwhile, I know that there’s an HVAC school one town away, so I can’t understand why they couldn’t find a contractor. It was an electrical issue and I was assuming that HVAC system is related to electrical work.
Then, I got a text and I was told at first that the contractors would be there within 48 hours. The next thing I received is a text message saying that they would be out. I assumed they were gonna be out there within the next day so I told my tenants that. That was Friday but it was the following week that they got there. So, it was poor communication or miscommunication and they were very slow to react.
There are pros and cons on both processes of submitting claims to American Home Shield, and I like doing it over the phone more. There's a paper trail when it's done online. But customer service wise, it might be better talking to somebody on the phone and at least taking generic answers. The representatives have been great but the service providers are the ones that are in question. For example, I’ve had at least 10 issues come out to repair my refrigerator and every time somebody shuts my refrigerator, I’ve had spare parts. So, I literally started collecting my parts from my refrigerator. I’ve also had American Home Shield send someone out for my stove once.
For the most, it seems like I ended up with spare parts and not like, “Oh, we took a part out. We replaced it with a new part.” Hence, I have the spare part and that are more like extra parts. It's the kind of deal which is “You don’t need this anymore.” One guy communicated that it’s just unnecessary but a couple of times, I just found pieces when they left. And worst, I’m paying for the services to come out and they’re not even depiction for one of the problems that I’m having, which is vacuum seal. So, I’m not a very happy customer. Overall, while I would rate the technicians low, the concept of American Home Shield is great. It’s awesome to have that comfort.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
We filed a claim to American Home Shield for our dishwasher and for our stove. We did it over the phone and they got a contractor out quickly. The technician repaired the stove in a timely manner but American Home Shield said that they weren't gonna cover the dishwasher because it was normal wear and tear. I would have to purchase a dishwasher on my own.
Good afternoon Sandra,
I understand your concerns regarding the claim denials and the AHS coverage. I would be glad to speak wit you and address the issues that were experienced.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I had to have my air conditioner repaired so I went online and submitted a claim with American Home Shield. They did very well on responding to the claim and in about 24 hours, a contractor was out to my home. He was very good. It was the second time we opened a claim for this issue over the last couple of weeks. The unit's performance has been very good since the last repair. I really like American Home Shield and the service they give me. I'm happy with it. I would recommend them to almost anybody.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I had a leak in the house. I submitted a claim to American Home Shield. I called over the phone and the process was good. The tech went out the next day. I showed him the leak. He went to the truck, came back and fixed the leak. After the repair, everything has been good. Having a warranty is very valuable. They have a good price. I will recommend American Home Shield to others.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
The water heater wasn't getting hot. After one or two people took a shower, the water would be cold. It would take at least two hours to warm back up. I called the automatic number and put in a claim with AHS. The interaction with the rep was good. The tech came out the next day. He came right in and started fixing the heater. He flushed it out, and he had to fix some part on it. After the repair, everything has been good. In some instances, having a warranty is okay, but sometimes, it's not because it seems that a lot of stuff isn't covered. Even so, American Home Shield is good for beginning home buyers.
Reviewed March 9, 2019
I had a bathroom faucet that wouldn’t quit leaking. The actual faucet was original to the house. The plumbers came in and replaced it for me and they were great. Everything has been working perfectly since the repair. I used the phone to submit my claim with American Home Shield last time, but I’m not sure I will do that again because the person I spoke to didn’t speak English and was very hard to understand. It was terrible. I just wish that their call center people would be more fluent in English.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
Have been paying AHS for more than 2 years. 6 Months ago the Dishwasher broke and the company came and ordered parts took 2 weeks to get parts and 1 week to schedule and install. Ended up doing dishes with hand for a month. This happened twice. Whenever dishwasher breaks it's more than 2 weeks to order parts and fix.
In peak winter furnace stopped working Jan 26, it took 3 different contractors and 6 weeks to figure out the problem by contractors. Last 6 weeks we suffered through hell at home without heat, with 3 and 8 year old kids at home. At last the last contractor figured that furnace needs to replaced and it's bad. When called the contractor to fix... I was asked to pay more than 2k to fix the furnace while other contractors were ok to install it for me next day for the same price... Instead of waiting another week as the contractor would not schedule until AHS orders and the furnace arrives at their place. I choose to install the furnace with 3rd party contractor. It sucks to say but please don't cheat customers saying AHS can save paycheck. When time comes... Drain their pockets. Everything I said above is my experience. Chicago is 15 degrees. Have 3 year old and 8 year old kids suffered through peak winter.
Good morning Jagan,
I understand your concerns regarding your most recent service experience and the delay to have both the dishwasher repaired and your furnace system. I would be glad to speak with you and get the issues resolved.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
My hot water tank leaked unknowingly soaking 2 bedroom walls & carpet. I called AHS about 7 pm that Wed. night. They gave me the name of the company that was to respond within 48 hrs. I was called a day later, tech came the following day to look at it only, said we would be up and running by Tuesday (7 days later). I found this unacceptable so I called AHS back and was told the tech has not completed his notes to them yet. A day later I called AHS again only to find out the tech said there were modifications that needed to be done and AHS wanted me to pay and ADDITIONAL $395. I have now been without hot water for 4 days. I requested a cash out option. I was not happy with the tech that came out so I hired my own plumbers to do the work.
3 weeks later I still have not heard back from AHS so I called today only to find out my request for my cash out option was not filed, and had to refiled my request a second time. I finally received a phone call from them telling me my options, I could pay the additional $395 or submit my bill to them to receive a $361 check for a $900 water heater. I was told they do not pay retail, only wholesale. I explained to her that I was without hot water for 4 days and they were not in any hurry to speed this along, never mind covering the damage the water leakage caused to my home. HORRIBLE Plumbers they sent me, and HORRIBLE Customer service from AHS, and HORRIBLE pay out for their screw up. I was considering renewing my contract but after this experience I will never do business with them again. They have gotten their last dollar from me.
Hello, Barb. I apologize that you had to endure that amount of time without hot water. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
One day, my wife had pressed the garage door and it went halfway up to stop. I came out to take a look at it and the chain was loose and hanging down. We found the sprocket on the floor and apparently, the shaft of the drive sprocket on the garage door opener itself had worn down and snapped off. I submitted my claim to American Home Shield over the phone and my experience with their rep has been nothing but pleasant. Their contractor, Edelen Door & Windows, came out and replaced the shaft of the drive sprocket, put it back in and everything worked fine. They did it quickly and professionally. They were excellent. I'm very happy with their performance. It's been a good experience. I've had The Appliance Guys for a refrigerator and they've been excellent as well. They were professional, courteous and very knowledgeable.
We have American Home Shield for a couple of years now. I've had two other home warranty that I've been unhappy with. I have top line appliances. For instance, my refrigerator is $8,000. They would only give me $500 if it went out on me and couldn't be repaired. I changed to American Home Shield because they understand and they know that I have topnotch appliances. They may not cover the entire cost, but they cover a lot more than any other home warranty that I've talked to.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
I had an issue with my garage door. The door would go up and it would stop. And then, it would start to slide down again. I submitted a claim to American Home Shield and the tech was out the next day. He came in and set up his ladder. He was looking for the control or switch up in the unit itself that prevents the garage door from sliding back down. He readjusted some stuff and had me hit the button to try and open and close it, and it was fixed.
However, I’m a little upset with AHS right now. It has to do with the pool heater. A specific policy was purchased by the sellers of our home before we bought it. Part of why we bought this home was because they were gonna add the AHS warranty to cover the pool heater. It is not working now. AHS sent out their repairman to diagnose it and to fix it or have it replaced. That gentleman said it needs to be replaced.
AHS has now come back and said they don’t cover this type of pool heater. We bought this house and spent $600,000 in part because AHS was to cover the heater. AHS has misread the contract having to do with heat pump pool heaters and they have incorrectly applied the provisions of the policy. I have asked them now since they’ve denied the claim, to provide me with a write-up because I’m gonna sue them or I’m gonna arbitrate against them, having to do with this. They blew the policy and didn’t interpret it correctly. The garage repair person was fine but I am very dissatisfied with the product that AHS offers and their ability to do their job. They need to be reported to the state insurance commissioner. Their business practices are deceptive and fraudulent.
Hello, David. I regret to learn that you have had an issue occur and that you are now taking legal procedures. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
American Home Shield has been excellent for me. Once, I went online and filed a claim with them for my AC. Navigating their website was easy and I received a text message right away. It was unbelievable and I was very surprised. A guy from Efficient Air called me while I was at work and told me he was on his way to our house. After about half an hour, he showed up there. He went inside, turned the AC on, walked upstairs, and fixed the unit. Then he came down, called me, and told me that everything was done before he left. The guy performed the service excellently and the unit has been working well since then. I appreciate that.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
My faucets were old and leaky, so we got them replaced. I called American Home Shield to file a claim and the reps I spoke with were fine. Contreras Plumbing was sent out and I was happy with them. They’re very professional and the work that they have done is very good. Everything has been fine ever since.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
My water heater was leaking. I submitted a claim online to American Home Shield and their claims process was smooth. The plumber from their contractor, Hers & His Plumbing, Florida, was very professional. He came on time and finished his job. He replaced the water heater for me because the old one couldn't be fixed. We also had some additional issues apart from changing the water heater. There were some valves that were broken, so he fixed them as well. He did a great job.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
We're having problems with our cooktop oven. Submitting a claim with American Home Shield over the phone was very easy. Their response was very timely and the contractor they sent out was very professional, but he wasn’t able to fix it. The unit has to be replaced and that process has been horrible. They said they would replace it and they would give me prices on other appliances and I sent the model numbers. I’ve got an email and phone calls to them and I’ve got nothing back. We’re still sitting with a broken stove. You just can’t get AHS to call you back.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
My husband has handled submitting the claims with American Home Shield every time and he seems to think it has been pretty easy. We've never had a problem getting something set up or scheduled. One day, the AC just stopped blowing cool air. It was a super easy fix and the guy who came was great. We also filed a claim about another AC unit inside. We had several people come out and look, but I don't know that the issue was ever totally resolved. We're curious to see how it pans out this summer, whether it's gonna be good or not.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
Our garage door wouldn’t come down. It would come partway down and go back up. Sometimes, it would come a little further down and then go back up. Sometimes, if I held the button, it might stay down. It was a real nuisance. I called in to submit a claim to American Home Shield. The gentleman that came out from Superior Garage Doors had done some work for us before and we were very pleased with him. He's very personable and professional. He knew exactly what the problem was. My husband said that he replaced the garage door's eyes and worked on some wiring that may have come loose or partially broken.
Sometimes getting ahold of anyone from AHS to speak and ask a question is very hard. Also, I get frustrated once in a while because things that we are under the impression were covered are not and that’s a little disturbing. But when I had an issue with one of their contractors who caused more problems than what he fixed, I called and told AHS not to ever let him in my house again and they never did. American Home Shield's customer service is fine most of the time.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
I had two recent claims with American Home Shield. One was for a wine refrigerator. It just had an error message. I submitted my claim online and it took about a week to dispatch the contractor out. The contractor was from Arizona Value Appliance and Repair and they were professional. However, they didn't fix it. It was a Sub-Zero appliance, and I don't think that they were qualified to work on Sub-Zero appliances. The other claim is I have a HVAC unit that's been out since August. I've had three different companies out and probably eight to 10 different service appointments, and it still hasn't been fixed. I don't know if the subcontractors AHS were hiring are incompetent or if it's just an issue with the machine.
Hello, Albert. I regret to hear that you have some unresolved issues. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly to assist with a resolution.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
I previously had AHS with another house that I owned in the past then I added it on the newly built that I bought. Recently, our compressor kept coming on and going off. I Googled it and it said that wasn't normal so I contacted AHS and it was my first time having them to come out and fix anything. They sent Air Smith Pro out and the technician told me it was some valve that had gone wrong on the unit. He had to order it in for it to be replaced but he was able to put my heat on emergency heating so I could continue to be warm in here.
When the technician came back to fix it a week later, he said that he was sorry that the company quoted me a price for another house. They told me it would cost $1,500 and that was what they provided American Home Shield. The company said that I needed a certain refrigerant and the tech said that the one in my unit is the updated one. They also said I needed some kind of locking cap that was gonna cost me $150 and that's code in our area. Come to find out, I already have the locking cap on my system. It turned out that it only cost me $800 and that was a tremendous difference to be getting wrong. He was very professional and I appreciated all his help in telling me that they quoted me the wrong price. Overall, I'll recommend AHS.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
I normally submit my claims with American Home Shield by phone, however, the hold times are long. And when I try to do it online, it keeps telling me to call. It takes me through the steps, but I have not been able to use it to submit anything. The website could be a little more user-friendly. I submitted a claim for my washer. Every time it gets through a spin cycle, I would have to go out and stop the cycle and then turn the machine off and shift it over to a spin and rinse cycle for it to drain the water out of the clothes. AHS sent Sears out about two months before because the washer was doing that, but they couldn't find the issue. The issue wouldn't repeat when the guy was there. But after a couple of months, whatever was wrong became evident and it showed up when the technician was there.
I've had two contractors come out. They called me as I was promised before they came. They were considerate, timely and they communicated with me what they were doing. The one who couldn't find the issue stayed a while and ran a couple of cycles and when he couldn't get the washer to duplicate itself, he reminded me that the coverage was good for that particular service call for 60 days and if I had the problem to repeat, I could contact them again, which I did. We missed the second technician the first time. He had called us and he waited a bit if we would get home timely, but my husband didn't make it and we had to reschedule it. The reschedule went fine and he was able to find the issue with the washer. The machine is being replaced and I've already purchased it. I just need to fax or email AHS the receipt.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
I filed a claim to American Home Shield for a microwave that wasn’t working. Their claims process was really good. They sent out someone to check and let me know that the microwave needed to be replaced because it was a combo machine, and the people that came and installed it were excellent. So far, everything has been working good.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
American Home Shield sent a contractor out here before because I replaced the water heater. Then, it started leaking but it wasn’t the heater itself. It was at the top, some sort of connection that was overflowing and they fixed that. I’ve been with American Home Shield for around a year now and so far it has been worth the money. The people that they've been sending have been very professional, personable and efficient. They called, came and responded. They checked and they answered all of my questions.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
There was a loud humming noise coming from my heat pump and I wasn't sure what it was. When I went out and looked, the fan wasn't moving. I went online and filed a claim to American Home Shield. The claims process was very simple. I could do it anywhere because I have a cellphone. The contractor that came out from JG Mechanical was polite and very knowledgeable. He gave me a call the night before and told me he'd come out in the morning if that was okay and I agreed. He came out at 8:30. He went around back, took a look at it and evaluated the situation, and told me he needed to replace the fan motor.
He was trying to get back that day, but we had a snowstorm. He contacted me within four hours and told me he'd have to come out the next day because of the storm. He came out the following morning around 11:00 and took care of my heat pump in two and a half hours. He was a nice guy and I was very happy. I just filed another claim and I had a GE technician came out today to fix the dryer. He couldn't have been nicer, and also very knowledgeable. I have been having good experiences with the coverage and the people that AHS has been sending out. I would definitely recommend American Home Shield to other people.
Reviewed March 8, 2019
So far, I've been pleased with my experience with American Home Shield. Among their contractors, Choice Electric is one that I've dealt with a couple of different times and their technician has been very good. When the compressor of our heat pump went out, he had to replace it. But it was down for about a month and a half because when the compressor was sent, not all of the right parts were sent so we ended up reordering some other parts for it. But other than having to wait for parts to come in, he did a fine job. Besides, the delivery of the parts wasn’t his issue.
Thanks for sharing your warranty experience Albert. We look forward to handling your future warranty needs. Have an amazing weekend.
Updated review: April 6, 2019
A social media rep from AHS contacted me offering a cashout of $900. I hired a technician, completed the AC changeout and emailed her the receipt. Total cost was just over $4k dollars. I was hoping they would cover at least half.
Took about 10 days to receive payment; impressed. The media rep was excellent.
I could not go any higher than 3 Stars because it took 7 months and a negative online post to energize them.
Original Review: March 7, 2019
The technician came by, inspected and left. AHS has been giving me the runaround ever since. In the contract it list that you must attempt arbitration before taking them to court; another $200 just to file it. I will post again if they improve.
Hello, Joseph. I regret to hear that your issue has not been resolved after all of this time. A member of our Social Media team will be contacting you to assist with a resolution.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Updated on 03/12/2019: I wrote a negative yet very true review on 3/7. I received a prompt response saying that someone from the social media dept would be in touch. Well that has not happened yet. Just more proof of the poor customer service offered by this company!
Original review: Several years ago we had only great service from this company for a property in CA. But the past few years have been terrible. The few times we have called for service, we have had someone come out and after paying our $75 they tell us the repair itself is not covered for whatever reason. So we paid the deductible and then bought a new appliance! Now they raised our monthly fee without any notice. I found this out by looking at my credit card statement.
To make matters even worse, when I called and got nowhere with the customer service agent and asked to speak to a manager I was out on hold forever and gave up after 1 hour. I did this twice so this is standard practice for them. They tell you they will get a manager and then put the phone on hold until you give up and hang up. The customer service agents are like robots who clearly read the set answers they have been given. Save your money and put it towards your new appliance or repair rather than paying for both of them and this ridiculous insurance!
Hello, Nancy. I apologize that you have had issues with your service. A member of our Social Media team will contact you to discuss your concerns.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
This is absurd! This has been going on for almost a year. Faulty contractors will not fix my heat and have it rigged on constantly but will not fix it. My electric bill is $250 and AHS won't get back to me! The first company broke my heater. $200 later with two claims a new contractor comes to “fix” it. And says the motherboard fried again because they did not turn off the rigged heat the first time. Our electric bill is $250 a month and we have a baby on the way! AHS is fraudulent and will not get back to my hundreds of calls and emails. The 2nd contractor is also trying to charge us $500 plus permits with a new system when all they said what was needed was a new part the second time and now all of a sudden it’s a $500 fix!!! I need answers and compensation for my time and money!!! The customer service department refuses to call me.
Hello, Nicole. I regret to hear that you have been dealing with issues with your heat for this amount of time. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Our water heater was not giving us a lot of hot water that we barely make it through a full shower before we started getting cold water. It wasn’t working efficiently. It was possible that there might have been a slight leak on the top of it, too. But I didn’t wanna mess with that because there is very severe corrosion on the top pipes where that connection is on top of the water heater, so I called it in with American Home Shield. I did it on a Saturday and I heard something back that Monday. AHS sent Simply Water Heaters who was very informative. They walked me and my wife through things that we needed to do as far as taking care of the new heater and they were prompt as far as getting the old one out and getting the new one in. In about five hours, the service was completed. The whole family makes it through showers with no hiccups now.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I submitted a claim to American Home Shield for issues with my toilet. The contractor came out here and I was fine with them. However, I have a problem with American Home Shield's new policy change wherein I have to pay $75 before they come out there. For the 14 years I've been with them, I've always paid. They said other people didn’t pay before so now, the people that did pay were responsible for paying upfront, which I do not like because when I call and it’s already paid, I gotta wait two days for them to come out there.
I don’t like the fact that right now, I’ve had issues with five other things in my house. I’m paying $75 a month but for each of those five things, they’re not covered. I have refrigerator, stove, the ice maker. Some stuff are together, some stuff are separate. So, if I have an issue with the toilet, I have to call them out and pay them $75 for that. If I have an issue with the refrigerator, that same $75 is not gonna cover the plumber. It covers differently. I don’t like how they do things now. I’m still paying a monthly fee and I also have to pay each individual differently.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
We keep using American Home Shield. This is my third house with them. I have two houses with them right now, and we’ve had our other house with them. The contractors they've sent were really knowledgeable, really quick, and very nice. They were really good contractors that they sent out. We had a leak underneath our kitchen sink, and it was flooding down through the basement ceiling. It was a mess. I called AHS and they asked me for my deductible, and they sent someone out. They asked me to turn the water off to that area, so the damage won’t get any worse, which is only smart to do, and then the tech came right out and fixed it. He had to replace all of the underneath valves. He changed them from the old style to the new style, so it wouldn’t happen again right away. He cleaned it all up and made sure it was working perfectly before he left, and we haven’t had a problem since.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Something was wrong with the outlets in about four rooms. The one in the kitchen was blowing out everything that I plugged in. Then I had one that kept resetting my phone. I also had a couple of them that didn’t work. Over the past few months, it had seemed like there was something wrong in each room. It was funny when Clay called me and I was telling him about the complaints. I think he owns the contracting company and he told me I may need holy water because I had so many different things going on in so many different rooms. He was so charming on the phone and was very nice. Then he came out and the response couldn't have been any faster. He and the guy with him were very personable and nice too. I felt comfortable having them in my home. They went right to work and took care of my problems. Everything has been great since then.
The experience has always been that way whenever I've called American Home Shield. They’ve always been easy to reach by phone. It was extremely easy to get this claim started and the person that I talked to was very attentive. The representative took down all the information, assured me that they would get it looked at and find out what was going on, and they did. I also like the contractors that American Home Shield has. I feel comfortable that they’ve already pre-screened them so I’ve been pleased with everyone that they’ve sent out for the different problems that I’ve had. But I really liked this last contractor. They were a hoot. I enjoyed them.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
When I was starting to work with AHS, I specified to the salesman the items that I want to be covered. He told me it was no problem. I also paid extra for my pool system which includes the heater, the pump and the filter. Then my heater wasn't working. I thought it was not a big deal because I knew I have insurance and I was covered.
I called American Home Shield and they sent a technician. But the tech cannot come on Friday. We waited until Monday. The gentleman came over and he acted like a doctor. He was just visual. He took the cover out and said it was leaking all over. He said it was beyond repair. He said he had to talk with the insurance and that they would have to decide what have to be done. I asked why it was leaking. He said that it was normal for the units to leak. They overheat at one point and because of the time, the gasket gets out. He said that it's too expensive to be replaced and it's too much money on repairs so they would usually just change it. The unit is about $2,000 for someone to try and change it.
Then, somebody called me around 5 o'clock and told me that I was not covered. Also, they couldn't change the unit because it's what the report says. That is the most bogus thing I have heard in my lifetime. I asked the rep to explain to me but she said, "Well, I don't know how to explain, I'm not the technician, but the report says your water in the pool, the chemical in your water pool was unbalanced." I asked to speak with a supervisor. Twenty minutes later, I was told that the supervisor couldn't take my call and that he would call me later on. Yesterday until now, nobody has called me.
Also, I have a professional company who cleans my pool. So it's totally bogus to tell me the chemical are unbalanced and that the heater broke because of that. I've been in the swimming pool for the past years and if these things happen the way they say, it has to be tremendous. If I get into the water and the chemical is unbalanced to that percentage, my skin has to be burned by now. I pay for my insurance and I want to be responsible. I want to be covered for what I pay, not to pay for something they don't cover. On top of that, I have to pay again to get a second opinion. At this point, it's unspeakable the way how American Home Shield handles business and gives false information to the people.
Good morning Vali,
Your concerns are understood regarding the swimming pool service claim that needs to be resolved. I understand per the diagnosis a second opinion is being requested. I would be glad to speak with you and get the issues resolved.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My wife put in a claim when the dryer wouldn't operate. I’ve had All-Tech out here several times, and they’re wonderful. The tech who came for the dryer was very polite. He was very efficient and he really knew what he was doing. He's been out here several times on other issues and he's been excellent. I was very pleased with American Home Shield.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My room downstairs had an electrical outage on one of the outlets and a full room upstairs had no electrical power. American Home Shield sent out Bill Richards Electric. Their guy was in our area when I filed the claim and he was notified somehow. He was at my house within an hour of when I filed the claim. He did a great job troubleshooting the issue and he fixed it within an hour. It was just a loose wire but it wasn’t very obvious. Everything else went smoothly.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Our furnace wasn’t working and we didn’t know why. I went to American Home Shield's website and submitted a claim for it. The site was easy to use because the option that we wanted was on there. The technician came out right away and showed up on time. He was polite. He walked me through what happened and then also helped provide maintenance tips to avoid things happening in the future that would make it not work. Everything’s been working well, so far. Our furnace turned back on when it was 50-something degrees in our house, so the repair is definitely beneficial.
One other time, I tried to submit a claim for our gas fireplace. But then I realized that it must not be covered under the policy that we had. It wasn’t an option on the website. An "other" option might be something that they would wanna consider provided what you’re calling for doesn’t fit the template that’s on there. Other than that, at least for my particular case, they listed the company and the address and their phone number. And it said, “We will call you within 24 hours" and to call American Home Shield if they don’t call us within 24 hours. The warranty has been worth it. I’d tell others to look into American Home Shield.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I submitted a claim to American Home Shield for a leaking drain pipe on my washing machine and their contractor responded very quickly. They were great. We have a hole in the sheetrock and I'm not getting much help from AHS repairing that. I've been trying to communicate with them to have someone come back and patch the sheetrock, and we finally got the ball rolling. Yesterday, I had somebody call me. It sounded like some offshore or some answering service and I can barely understand the person, but he's with AHS. I finally got it through to him that I don't need another plumbing repair, I just need the sheetrock repaired. I'd just like to get the job finished.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My dryer was making a loud grinding noise that I couldn’t even turn the dryer on because it was so intense. American Home Shield sent a cool guy but the first thing that he told me was that the warranty doesn’t cover noise. It didn’t make sense. It was a hum and there was something that was causing that noise. So, he took a part out and he sprayed WD-40 on it. I asked him if he would vacuum the dust and he told me that he wouldn’t. No sooner than he left, the same intense noise started, so I called back and he came. He told me that it was the dryer’s pulley and he replaced it and so far, so good. I asked him though why he didn’t just do it in the first place and he told me that they had to do what was left first. That sounded cheap and wasting my time but other than that, he fixed the dryer.
I had another claim, which was for my icemaker, and I asked the repair place if their team comes out equipped to fix or replace anything. They said that they would come out and diagnose the issue first and then if it’s not broken, then they won’t come back. I don’t like that because I could guarantee that the ice machine doesn’t work and then I would have to call back again and waste more hours. Then they would come out and replace the ice machine mechanism. Their subcontractors do the least that they can and then they’ll come back and that’s way too time-consuming. Now, I’m just waiting for Monday for the technician to come out and look at the icemaker. But, other than that, American Home Shield has got their thing going on. When I called to place a service order, a very thorough and friendly guy got it.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My claim with American Home Shield for when my water heater was leaking was a great experience. It was the TP valve. Normally, I call to file a claim but I tried it online this time and I was actually really surprised I got service the same day. Heros Plumbing came out and was professional. They also had the correct parts on the vehicle. They took care of the problem and were in and out. Since then, I don't notice any more leaks.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
The garage door broke, it rolled off the railing. I forgot that I have a home insurance so I called some guys and they fixed the problem. They put it back on the rail and replaced the springs and ripped me off. I spent $1,000. A week later, I had another problem. The garage door wasn't going down. I called those guys back and they said that it was not the work that they did, and that it was something else. And then, it dawned on me, I have insurance. I called American Home Shield and their contractor came over and readjusted the lasers where you walk in front of the thing and it stopped the garage door from opening. Then the problem was resolved.
Submitting a claim to AHS has been great. I prefer it online where I could just go on the internet, tell them what the problem is and they'll call me to set up someone to come by. And the contractor would come by to fix the problem. The contractors that they've sent out were great. They were just trying to fix the problem and not trying to rip me off. My experience with AHS has been easy. They just need to get the parts quicker, but that's not really in their control.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
AHS had the best reviews in terms of what was offered between the different providers and the last thing I wanted to do is to fight my way through repairs if something came up. I got their warranty and so far, everything had been really good. Recently, I had a fan failure on a heat pump and sounded like an engine with a bad connecting rod bearing. It was knocking, thumping and banging, and then it froze up.
I put in the request for service and AHS scheduled it right away. I got the emails and then I was able to touch base with the provider. That happened on a Saturday so nothing was gonna have till Monday morning. I called the provider immediately Monday morning and they were able to hook me in and get somebody out there within the next couple hours. Then the repair was made right away. The contractors were knowledgeable and they were willing to give me some insight on how I would upgrade it so it was good. Based on my experience so far, I would be willing to recommend AHS.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My washing machine wasn’t draining the water and it wasn’t washing the clothes. I called in the claim and American Home Shield sent out AT Appliances. The tech was very nice and he was on time. He said he would be there between 12:00 and 5:00, and he called before he came in to announce where he was on my house. My washing machine is doing fine now.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Having American Home Shield's warranty has been very valuable for us. Most recently, both United Contractors and AHS went above and beyond to help us. We had two separate claims and they were both great. Navigating their website was perfect too. AHS has saved us a lot of money in the long run.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Our HVAC unit was not heating and it was only cooling. So, when we increase the thermostat temperature, the hot air was not coming out, it was always the cold air that seemed to be blowing. I originally called the actual equipment manufacturer and somebody came over and said that they could fix it in 10 minutes but they were charging $150 for the labor and then another $150 for the part. I realized I have some warranty so I called American Home Shield. Their claims process was pretty good and seamless. They said it would cost me $75 as opposed to the $300. The only thing was it took 24 to 48 hours for them to get back to us. It was really cold in Dallas at that point and I wanted some heating to happen, but we had to stay without heat for two days before somebody responded back.
I told American Home Shield exactly what the problem was because we’ve already got it looked at. I told them that they needed to get the circuit breaker to fix it. They listened to the whole thing, but when the tech came, he did not have the circuit breaker. When he came back, he had to place an order, and then get it back. And it took another day. I thought that was weird because I already told them the problem. They should have brought the item with them. But the tech was pretty good. My wife said he was very patient and he did the work well.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
American Home Shield is very convenient and worthwhile. They offer more for a good price. When we bought the house eight years ago, we got a warranty and stuck with them a couple years, but they didn't cover the HVAC. And so, we switched to American Home Shield, which covered it, and the price was not that much different. Recently, they sent A-US Air Conditioning of Texas for their spring tune-up offer on the HVAC system. I usually do my claims online and then they call, or I get a text, and they're right on the ball. And, usually, the next day, the actual provider will call or text and then let us know they're on their way. All have been great with the service providers.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My microwave's handle had broken off and the vent was open. The door was falling apart too. It was just glued on. After we used it a couple of weeks, it broke and fell off. I called AHS's, got a claim number and paid my $75. Their reps contacted the appliance people and they looked at both appliances. They did great and were very professional. For the oven door that would not close, the contractor replaced the hinge on it which alleviated the problem. While the stove was fixed, the microwave is gonna be replaced. Still, AHS was very prompt in getting us a replacement website and all the value for that. Overall, I had a very good experience with them.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I called American Home Shield and filed a claim for a spring on a faucet and check valves. This was my first experience with AHS and submitting the claim was pretty simple. It booked the appointment, and then a guy from STL Plumbing came out. He walked me through the whole process of what the issue was, what I could expect moving forward, and how easy it was if I needed to take care of something.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Our experience with American Home Shield has been good. My wife puts in the claims and the only problem she's had was when we first scheduled for the washer to be looked at. The receptionist wasn't that good at customer service and gave us a bit of trouble with scheduling. The rep caught an attitude with my wife. Other than that, everything was handled professionally. The techs came out and took care of the washer.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I recently submitted a claim with American Home Shield for the air conditioner that wasn’t coming on. They sent out Advanced Heating & Air Conditioning and the technicians that came out were professional. They were A-plus, although they are still working on the problem now. It has been going on for about a week now, but it is getting taken care of.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
We used American Home Shield recently for our furnace, and the response was quick. The gentleman that came out initially to look at the problem was very professional. I told him the problem, and he looked at the furnace and said something that would take care of the problem. And true enough, they took care of our problem. He said that they would be out within the next week, and they were out within two days with the part and replaced it. So, I'm very happy with that. We also used them about two years ago when our washer and dryer went out. I have nothing to complain about or else we would no longer have them or we'll not be paying them money anymore. We bought this home about three years ago and the party that was selling it had bought the policy and it worked fine for us. And I would recommend AHS to other people.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I called in to American Home Shield when our tank wasn’t getting any hot water at all. The reps were good and really nice, and the technician they sent did really good. He was from Centurion Plumbing Services LLC and he really helped me. The thermostat had something wrong but he put a new part in and fixed my hot water in less than an hour. He was really nice too.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
When our hot water tank went out, the whole claims process with American Home Shield online was so easy. The contractor came in, introduced themselves, who they were with, and looked at everything. They explained everything very clearly to me and what’s needed to be done. So, it was good. They had to go get the new hot water tank across town, and once they got everything hooked up, they made sure it filled up and got hot.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I'm pretty happy with American Home Shield. Overall they seem to be professional and pretty organized. Everything ran smoothly. If I reported an issue, they have it addressed in a timely manner. I usually call them to file a claim and it has been a pretty straightforward process. I might be on hold for a couple of minutes. Sometimes I get a person and they file the claim.
When American Home Shield sent out High Priority Plumbing, the plumber forgot several things. There's a cover for the sewage ejection pump, and that cover has a little hole in it where the wire come out, and there's also a cover for the little hole. So we have the big cover and then a cover for the little hole. But the plumber did not put the big cover on securely. The big cover has like 10 screws but he only put the two of them in there, and he didn't really screw them all the way. It was really loose. And then the little hole in the big cover, he didn't put that back. We noticed it because there was an odor coming up from the tank. So, the plumber fell short there.
I called American Home Shield and explained to the rep that the plumber didn't put the thing on right, but he made it seem like they would have to issue a totally new claim. That was the only person that I spoke at American Home Shield who was kinda difficult. But then I called back, spoke to someone else, and she took care of everything. The service has been great overall.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Since I've been with American Home Shield, which is about 12 years now, they've done excellent work and I've been satisfied. I called when I had an issue with my thermostat and told their rep that I didn't have heat. My thermostat wasn't working right. The rep did the job and the technicians came right by the time they said they're gonna come. They had put a new thermostat again. But I complained that it wasn't working right. It would say one thing but when I took the temperature around the house, it would say another thing. I had to turn it up really high before the heat even started even to work. I never had that problem before.
My son was there when the technicians came and he told them what the problem was for me. The thermostat seems like it's a little better but I still have to turn it up a bit. I got a thermostat that is supposed to do the whole house. This thermostat they gave me, when I put it on 75, the whole house still has a chill in it. Now, I have to turn it up way up on 78 or 77 before I feel the warmness start coming out and hold there. It goes from heat to cool really quickly. You say 75 degrees when it comes on 75. It seems like it comes on a few seconds then it goes back off. Other than that, American Home Shield should keep up the excellent work. I'm gonna tell friends that they need to jump on board with them really quickly.
Your patronage is greatly appreciated for the past 12 years. I am pleased to hear about the technicians that serviced your home. It is our goal to provide you with a great experience.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I submitted a claim online to AHS because the stove exhaust wasn't working. It took the contractors a week to come out and now, it's been a week since they've been out and I've not heard back from them. I assumed they would need some parts so they ordered the parts. I'm still waiting to hear back from them. They should send the customer a status to let them know what's going on. No communication is not good. But overall, the claim process was very good.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I signed up my home and rental properties with American Home Shield after my property manager recommended them. Once, one of my five Nest thermostats at home wasn't getting power from the outlet and the whole area got cold. I put in a space heater there, but it blew up the whole circuit. I filed a claim with American Home Shield for the AC and the contractor called me the next day to schedule an appointment. Four days after that, the tech came. He went to our utility room and he figured out that the power line to the thermostat was loose. However, it took him a while to see exactly where it was loose, which ended up being in the basement. He then fixed the issue within 30 minutes. He was very careful, professional, and it was an overall good experience.
This was my first claim with American Home Shield and I was very happy about it. I've been with multiple home warranty companies before and my major complaint about them is that they don't keep an eye on the performance of their contractor network. American Home Shield is doing the right thing by keeping the top-performing contractors in their network. AHS also followed up, sent me text messages informing me of the filing the claim, contact information of the assigned contractor, and appointment reminder. It was really good.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I used to be with Old Republic and I just kinda fell out of liking American Home Shield and their service so I thought I'd give them a try. Recently, I called in to file a claim because the website was not clear as to what I wanted done. It was very generic. But the customer service I got was very good. AAA Brands Appliance came out and the service was handled fine. The guy didn’t find anything wrong. He checked out the inside and the outside, and he didn’t know why the appliance was not cooling like it was supposed to so he checked everything over and then it was working.
If only AHS could fix their website, I won’t have to call in. If it was plumbing, it should have at least toilet or shower in it, but it just said plumbing, ‘cause contractors could come out here and find out it's something that they don’t cover. I've had that happen before and I ended up paying $75 more for them not getting what needed to be done. But the technicians that AHS sends have been very professional. They all seem to find the problem in their diagnosis and get it fixed right away.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I try to go online when I submit my claims to American Home Shield, but it doesn't work a lot of times. When I don't have my contract number, I should be able to put in my address, but it doesn't, and I don't know why. So I have to wind up calling them. Once I get through and talk to a representative, they are always really nice. And if I have an issue, it gets worked on. Everybody there was really helpful and understanding of the situation that I'm going through. Even though I had to wait for the process, they apologized to me and they really tried to make me feel comfortable with the situation that I was going through.
The lock on my oven wasn't working properly. It would show that it was on on the stove, but it really wasn't on. But when the tech came out, he said it was a whole bunch of other stuff going on, which I didn't even know. He said he ordered the parts, and once the parts came in, he would be able to fix the parts. When he came out this last time, he said he got the parts and he tried to put the parts in but it was not repairable. This was because mice got into the oven, and that's not covered under my contract, so it's not gonna get fixed. Even though the stove wasn't covered under the warranty, the tech at least fixed the stove so I could still utilize it until I'm at a place where I can get it replaced. Overall, I would recommend American Home Shield. They are the best. There's the copay but it is more than worth it because it is so expensive to get appliances repaired.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Reliable is amazing and I love them. I had a leak from the pressure relief valve on my hot water heater. It was full of water that was getting dumped out onto the side of the house. I logged into American Home Shield's portal, it asked what the category of the repair was, then they did everything automatically. It generated a text messaging service once I submitted the claim that says, “Okay, your claim has been submitted, and we are contracting it out.” Then, AHS sent me another claim with the information of who they contracted with the name of the company and the contact information.
Reliable called me back right away and the woman that I spoke with was extremely helpful in working with my work schedule. She made the appointment for a time that was convenient for me and gave me a window. I got regular text message update from American Home Shield giving me the status of the order and the appointments. The plumber called when he was about 15 minutes away to give me a heads-up and came towards the beginning half of the window. He did a quick little assessment, listened to all of my concerns and fixed everything the same day. He serviced my hot water heater and had all the parts needed in the truck. The plumber did a beautiful job.
All of the reviews that I read about American Home Shield echoed the same sentiment that I had, which is that the claims process was really wonderful. They handled everything really great and kept me informed. I was really thrilled with the outcome.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I call American Home Shield to file my claims and they always follow through. The people are thorough and always polite, and they always try to get our problems solved. They schedule the tech to come out and they also schedule deliveries. But I have to do a lot of calling and following up, and the wait time, every time I called was 50 minutes. The wait time is terrible. So, they could have more people answering the phone.
Other than that, I would recommend American Home Shield. I had a great experience, and their customer service rectified our problem. I filed a claim for my washer that was totally blasted. The drum had broken loose. The tech told AHS what the problem was, and they said they were gonna get me a new one. And they gave me seven choices to pick out from the washers that were available that they would supply. They also told me that if I wanted to, I could go and get one at a Lowe's or Home Depot and they could give me a certain amount of cash. So, I could've got an even better washer if I had the money.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I've had American Home Shield for a long time and I usually got a good response from them when I needed to use them. When my heater was not working, I called late one evening, and the following day they sent somebody from A & R Complete. He was here in good time and went right to work after I explained that the heater would try to kick in but the blower never did put out. He diagnosed it, replaced the main circuit board, and he was done in no time.
There was one time where I had to replace my own water heater. It was an emergency and I never got reimbursed with it because I never got it inspected after the installation, even though I had a licensed plumber install it. The plumber is my neighbor, so he just came over, took the old one out, put the new one in, and everything's up to code. But American Home Shield never wanted to honor that. They said it has to be a legit company. Since I'm not gonna go around their back and get fake papers signed, I let it go.
Other than that, the coverage AHS provides is adequate. They cover all the major things like the refrigerator, the stove, the air conditioner, and the heater. They charge extra to cover a pool, but for the basic things in the household, they do well. Lowering the rates though could be an improvement. And while I've heard stories from friends that American Home Shield sends out unqualified people, everybody that I've ever had has done well.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
The guy from Performance Heating & Cooling showed up quickly and got our problem fixed. He did it quickly, and we're really happy with it. The unit wasn't heating. So, he had to change out something on it. Prior to the guy coming out, my wife called American Home Shield and reported the issue. We've been with AHS for several years, and they're the one I've heard the most about and had the most experience with other people telling their experiences with them. You should get AHS, too.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My wife submitted a claim to American Home Shield for an air conditioning unit issue. The unit was hanging. It was frozen and would not turn off. A technician from Controlled Comfort came and he was great. Since the unit was repaired, I was able to save on my electric bill. I have been with American Home Shield for 16 years. It's a good company and I trust them.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I submitted a claim with American Home Shield over the phone recently and getting that claim process started was simple. AHS was able to get somebody out here the next day. They sent the contractor, Westbrook Plumbing. The plumbers that came out were great, professional and courteous. They were on time and they answered any questions that I had. They assessed the issue and said that I needed a new water heater, and it didn’t take long for them to order, receive and install it. Since the old water heater was replaced, the performance of the new one has been good so far. At this point, we're happy with AHS' service.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I like the whole American Home Shield, but it's very often hard to get somebody to come over and at the times that are convenient for the customer. If you work, you're really in trouble because none of these guys work on the weekend. The second thing is that I always seem to need an upgrade, and they say it's not supposed to cost me anything. I pay $70 a month, and then, my issue with the heating still costs me $2,700 out of pocket. So, I'm not happy about that. I had an air handler replaced in September, and that cost me $3,000. It's not complete coverage.
Sometimes the contractor don't call me back right away. They're supposed to call you in a 24-hour period, and I've had this experience where they called me randomly, and if I missed them, I couldn't get them afterwards. It was like I was chasing them. It's not conducive to get somebody to come and it's painful. But overall, I would recommend American Home Shield. Everybody should have them, especially if you have an older home.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
I've been waiting since December to get my heating taken care of but until this day, it still has not been resolved. The heat isn't being evenly distributed. There is no heat coming in to my room at all then there's very little heat coming in to my son’s room. So when I filed the claim in, I wasn’t sure if it was the furnace or the ductwork. I just clicked furnace and duct, and American Home Shield sent somebody out. The guy was great and I thought that he was being open and honest with me. He said I needed a new furnace and he repaired the furnace. He also told me that I needed the ductwork done and that he was gonna put it in his notes that the ductwork is mandatory. But I was charged and I had paid $825. Why did I have to pay the $825 if the problem is still not resolved?
American Home Shield said they were gonna have somebody out for the duct thing. And finally, on the fourth appointment, somebody came out. But American Home Shield denied the claim. I think they said it was because it was improperly installed. I just bought the house back in November and the reason I bought the warranty was in case there is something wrong that I didn’t see when I bought the house. Plus I'm anemic and asthmatic. So during the polar vortex, I couldn’t sleep in my room because it was freezing cold. Now, I'm gonna have to start passing the hospital bill to American Home Shield as well because they told they were gonna take care of this issue but they didn’t.
With the exception of the contractor that just came, the ductwork people were all unprofessional. American Home Shield was sending out mom-and-pop shop type of people. It was not anything where it was like a business. I had one company that called initially and was upset. He told me I probably needed a new furnace and when I told him I just had a new furnace put in, he said, "Well, if you had a new furnace put in, what's the use of me coming out?” I told him he was coming out because he was a ductwork specialist. He said he would be on it but that I should have gotten a furnace through him. That was not even my call. That was American Home Shield's call. Still, the contractor called and set up an appointment. He also called me the day before and on the day of the appointment. But he never showed up.
The second company was a lot more understandable. It was still a family-owned company but the dad had a heart attack. It was the same day that my appointment was supposed to be and the daughter knew that I already had a hard time with the first company that was supposed to come out. She thought he let me down and she was crying when she called me. But I told her to calm down and that it was okay. I told her to just give me a call when her dad was okay.
But American Home Shield ended up reassigning my case to a third duct vendor. That vendor came out, stayed in my house for five minutes then walked through and out of my house. He said he would send in something to American Home Shield but two days later, I still had not heard anything. I called in to American Home Shield and they told me that he still hadn’t sent anything in. So they contacted him to find out what was going on. He sent in the paperwork and then American Home Shield called me back the next day and said that they denied the claim. I asked about it and they said they would send out a person for a second opinion but they were gonna charge me another co-pay. So I've paid three deductibles for the same thing and still, my ductwork is not fixed.
Hello, Jasmine. I apologize that you have had issues with getting your heating issue resolved. There is a lot of information regarding the diagnosis of the duct work. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
My husband submitted a claim to AHS because our shower head broke off from the pipe. The contractor who came out was a really nice guy and he seemed to very much know what he was doing, got it all fixed and it’s working great.
Reviewed March 7, 2019
Our ice machine stopped working so, I went online and filed a claim with American Home Shield. That was really easy to do. Then, Major Home Appliance Service then came out and they were pretty solid. They were nice and professional. They checked out what exactly was wrong with the unit and once the part got ordered and shipped, they came right back. I left them to do what they needed to do but at the times that we were there, they would explain to us what they were doing. They didn't have to do that, but it was nice to understand what you own a bit more. Everything worked out and now, we have ice. I'm very satisfied with American Home Shield.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
Sears Appliance Service was due to repair my oven on 3-6-2019, we have been waiting on the repair since 2-19, at the time the technician requested an assistant to help with the oven removal. At 12.04 pm I received a voice mail confirming the appointment for 8 am to 5 pm on 3-6-19. Then at 3:30 pm I received a text canceling the appointment and to reschedule. I called Sears and the excuse was that they have to reschedule because they did not have a helper available. NOW I was out of town and change my schedule to be at home ALL DAY. Again at the visit on 2-19 the technician requested an assistant/helper. This really bad business. NOW I have burn another whole day waiting for something that may or may not happen. I sure everyone is very sorry, this is inexcusable, And reflects very poorly on Sears and American Home Shield. Thanks for nothing and apology not accepted.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I have a home repair insurance contract with AHS. Their mode of operation is to deny, deny and deny any claim. It takes forever to get someone on the phone. And then I was sent to multiple people and had to say the same thing over and over again. Despite what the plain language of the contract says, they still are denying payment and are rude about it.
I will now have to go to court to get my claim paid. I also intend to file a complaint with the insurance commissioner for the State of CT and with the Consumer Protection Department. I would not recommend this company and its so-called insurance product to anyone and I feel that the real estate agents who are pushing it are most likely getting commissions to sell their product on top of it all.
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
AHS sent a contractor to fix the AC during the summer. They didn't come nor call for 6 days. I called AHS. They said that contractor was not on my area. They sent a second one who came 3 days later. After 5 visits during the summer they said I have to pay $1350 for freon before they can replace the compressor. They however said, "If you pay and in a month or 10 days the compressor broke again because something else is bad with the machine" they will have to charge me another $1350 for new freon. So I said, "Well please check what could be causing the unit to break the compressor." They said they can't as it was impossible to find out.
I called 2 companies and one 3rd expert who told me, "Replacing the compressor is a patch, the unit under the house is rotted and the fan is sticky (bearings) and the dehumidifier in the unit stopped working hence your new compressor will work 24/7 to try and maintain temperature." AHS never diagnosed this, they simply want to replace the compressor and for me to pay $1350 yet they won't warranty the job, story short AHS has not responded and the unit won't cool nor heat as it is an electric heat pump. What can I do?
I certainly hate to hear that you have received less than satisfactory service. I will follow up with you as soon as possible in an effort to assist with unresolved issues. Thanks for your patience.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
This is most awful company I had ever dealt with. They keep you on hold forever and never keep their promises. I never got a copy of my contract after requesting a copy three times. The vendors then send to your house are not reputable. Make sure to check all reviews from all websites about this company. BUYER BEWARE!!!
Hello, Steve. I apologize that your policy was never received. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
They will continue to repair a 20 year old Heat pump and not pay you ANYTHING towards replacement if you decide to upgrade to a new unit. Total scam. I saved them the 600.00 of replacing the compressor on my outside unit by replacing the entire system at my cost and they wouldn't pay me a single cent of the 600.00 I saved them. I should have just continued to let them repair a very old unit at my cost of 125.00 each service visit.
Hello, Anzor. I apologize for the issues that you are having with the hot water heater replacement. A member of our Social Media team will contact you directly.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I had a water heater that was leaking all over. The heater was 19 years old and so, it had started to rust and the pan where it sat in had cracked. I made a phone call to American Home Shield to submit a claim and the process was very smooth and seamless. The tech from Peter Klein Plumbing came out the same day. He went ahead to submit the information he needed to do on his part. And my phone rang within 30 seconds, and they let me know that the tech received the information on how to proceed. It was very prompt. The tech first came out on a Sunday and by Tuesday morning, he replaced the heater. The tech was very courteous and professional. He's definitely somebody I would hire.
Good morning Leslie,
Thank you for sharing your American Home Shield experience to have the water heater replaced. It is our goal to provide you with the best experience.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
One of the smartest things a homeowner can do is to get American Home Shield. Last week, our icemaker wouldn’t let water out through the ice machine. It was making ice but we weren’t getting water in the glass. I filed a claim to American Home Shield and their contractor came and did whatever he needed to do. He got a hairdryer out and he blew the hairdryer onto the icemaker until it thawed out. It worked great and he left. The guy who came out was very friendly, customer-caring and very intelligent. He knew what he was doing and he did a great job. He explained what he was doing and said that typically, that was the problem with the refrigerators nowadays. Apparently, the icemaker froze because of lack of use. My wife drinks a lot of water and I don’t. So, when she was out of town, it wasn’t being utilized and, therefore, it froze up.
Since then, water was running really quickly and everything was doing great. And then, as my wife was going to bed last night, she realized that the carpet was wet in the bedroom and it was cold water. I told her that I might have spilled something and that we’ll check it in the morning. We went to bed, got up this morning and came out, and the carpet was soaking wet. I went in to the kitchen and stepped on the floor, and the water was coming up through our wooden floor. I pulled the refrigerator out and there was a leak behind the refrigerator, in the waterline that goes into the refrigerator. I can’t drive and my wife is blind so we can't go and replace the waterline. I called American Home Shield and filed a claim. They are supposed to call me and they have not called yet so I shut the waterline off.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I’m very satisfied with American Home Shield. I had an issue where the furnace was not shutting off and the blower would keep on running. Then when it did shut off, as soon as it shut off, the heat would come back on again. Because it had run so long, it had cooled the house. I submitted the claim over the phone. But I also had a problem earlier that I had called on, for the same thing, and they told me they would be getting ahold of me after the weekend was over. But I couldn't wait. I had this fellow and he went ahead and helped me. It would work but then it would quit working.
So finally, I called American Home Shield again. I let them go ahead, set up the appointment and come over here. I already knew what the problem was and the only way I was gonna get the control box replaced was to get a heating person in here to do it. Altogether, the repair took about an hour and a half. It’s working perfectly now and the technicians were very nice and helpful.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
We have a two-year-old refrigerator that suddenly would not keep anything cold. So we called American Home Shield and reported a claim. They dispatched this BRM outfit and it took them about two weeks to get it fixed because they don't carry parts with them. I'm accustomed to service people coming to your house and having parts with them or they can quickly get one and fix the problem on the same day. This was the first time that I was not sure if the guy was equipped to do the job.
My impression was that he was a little mom-and-pop guy. He wasn't a vendor that carried any sort of inventory although that's unrealistic these days, given the variety of refrigerators and brands then the models within the brand, that he would have every single part in his inventory. I was just disappointed that it took so long to wait for parts and get it fixed. It was a little bit more than annoying to have a refrigerator that didn't work for two weeks. He was a lovely gentleman and a nice man. But I didn't have a level of trust with him. My husband even said that we should have just bitten the bullet and called Sears. They would have had all the parts and the problem would have gotten solved, presumably, on the same day in one visit.
At first, the contractor came and fixed one part that he thought he needed. But then he discovered, while he was replacing that part, that he needed another one. So we had a few more days to wait for him to order that other part. But then the refrigerator stopped working totally. We thought he was all done though, and we went and did our grocery shopping. We spent a few hundred bucks on groceries with the family but when we woke up, everything in the refrigerator was ruined because it had thawed over the night.
That happened on a Saturday morning and he came back out on Monday. But during the weekend, he asked us to unplug, wait for a few minutes then plug the refrigerator back in to reset everything. We did that and that seemed to jumpstart it. Everything was working fine. When he got here, he started looking at the electrical plug. He said that it wasn't grounded and that the white and the black cables weren't reversed. He surmised that there was some issue with the electricity and that we should have an electrician take a look at it. American Home Shield then dispatched State Electric. They came out, did their testing and said there was absolutely nothing wrong with the electricity.
Since we had plugged the refrigerator in on the last weekend, it's been fine. But we are reluctant to go do a big grocery shopping and put something in there. We just don't trust it. But it's holding out on its own and hopefully it continues to do so. As time goes by, my trust will be okay. It's just sad because the damn refrigerator is two years old. It is $3,000 worth of an appliance and it aggravates me to no end that we're replacing parts in it already. It's not a heavy traffic refrigerator either. Overall, I'm satisfied. American Home Shield was very responsive. And maybe it was just this situation. American Home Shield did a furnace for me last year and I couldn't have been more pleased with the folks they sent out for that. They were wonderful.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I had a problem with our dryer and American Home Shield's rep was great when I called them. I called Friday evening, and the contractor was over Monday morning or the next business day. Everything was excellent - both the callback person and the person that they sent out for the repair. The dryer was also fixed in one day and I've had no problems since.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
Sears was sent by American Home Shield when our washer went out of service. We interacted well with them when they came. The parts needed to fix the washer was way much more than replacing it, so I got it replaced. American Home Shield gave me a link to check out online and I picked the washer that they recommended as a good one. They had a trucking company who brought it in and installed it.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I submitted a claim online to American Home Shield for the icemaker and the refrigerator. Online is where everything is. You go to the site, put in all the information, then they tell you to pay the money and let you know who’s gonna come. AHS sent out RC Appliance. They had to get some parts from somewhere. I just had a total knee replacement and I needed the ice for my knee because I have to keep it iced to keep the swelling down so not having the icemaker working was a real problem. But RC Appliance got the icemaker fixed in a relatively timely manner. Overall, I've been happy with AHS.
Good morning Thelma,
I am pleased to hear about your experience with American Home Shield and the contractor that serviced you within a timely manner. It is our goal to ease the stress of home repairs.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
We had American Home Shield when we moved into our first home 10 years ago and it has always been very good. We were pleasantly surprised when we purchased this new home and saw that the same warranty company was gonna handle it because they were very helpful the first time we used them. When I submitted claims with AHS, I discovered how easy it was to do it on the web. So, I’ve been doing it on the website where I go and click what the problem is. I usually go and triple check that the problem is covered by our warranty. Once I verify it is, I can go ahead and I can do the submission that way.
When we couldn't get hot water out of our shower, the contractors who came out were super nice. They showed me what the problem was and how they fixed it, and it was an easy fix. They replaced a piece and they had another piece on their car, so I didn't have to go out and buy another one. They were able to repair fairly quickly. They even mentioned that my hot water was a little hot. So, before they left, they took a quick look and made sure they adjusted it. I told them that I have young children and I don't wanna burn them. The contractors were nice enough to take a minute, looked it over, and showed me how to adjust my hot water heater.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
There was a leak in our upstairs bathroom. The spigot kept dripping and I couldn't get it to stop no matter how much I tightened it down. It was also happening on the outdoor spigot on the back patio. And so, I put in a request on the American Home Shield portal online for both of those to get fixed. Filing the claim was very easy and self-explanatory. Blue Star Plumbing called the same day and set up the appointment for the next day, and everything was fixed the next day. I had to have my mother meet the technician over there. But they did call me ahead of time and let me know that they'd be here in 25 minutes. So I was able to let my mother know and she was able to go across town and meet him. She said he fixed the leak really quickly and gave a 60-day warranty on the work. They took care of the problem, and everything went really smoothly and I was happy with the result.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
We filed a claim with American Home Shield for our heating and air conditioning unit as we were having a problem with it. The house is older and so the unit has been refitted. The repair company AHS sent came out thrice and put a new board in. However, the unit eventually fried it in a week. The company then came out and said that the unit needed to be replaced. American Home Shield ordered a unit that met the government's current rules and regulations. The installation people picked up the unit and they were prompt. They kept me well-informed of where they were, what was going on, and when they expected the unit in. Then, as soon as it came in, they came out and installed it. They put a new base on the air conditioner, which was just sitting on blocks before, and had me up and going within a week.
The courtesy of American Home Shield's contact person was always super, as well as their willingness to help me with a problem. We were having a very cold month and we're both disabled here at the house. They knew that we really need some heat and so they got on it and got it turned around quicker than I thought we would. They have also always been very helpful and kept me informed. When the claim had to be sent to another department to get approval, they let me know what was going on and when I should hear back. So I've been very pleased. Also, thank goodness, we had taken American Home Shield's policy out because if not, I would’ve been stuck spending $6,000 and $7,000. I've had the policy for a year now and I've renewed my contract with only a $2 increase. I have recommended American Home Shield to a couple of people who have older homes and have to remodel them.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
I've been with American Home Shield for a few years and I've never had a problem whenever I made a claim. Within 24 hours someone has contacted me and within 24 hours of that phone call, they are at my home. Recently, my heater stopped working and started to blow cold air. I called AHS and the contractor who came was someone I've used before. He is always on time, very professional, and friendly.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
We had a water heater that went bad. We submitted the claim with American Home Shield and the online process was very easy. The initial response was very quick and it took about four hours before we got an actual response. However, it took us a week to get the water heater repaired. The service provider that they had locally didn't have an opening for two or three days. We reported on a Friday, but they couldn't even come out to look at it until Tuesday. When they looked at it, they said the heater was gonna have to be replaced, so it took them another three days to get the heater and get back on their schedule to get it out here and get replaced.
The contractors were very professional and very proficient. When they first showed up on the initial visit, they were very quick to diagnose what the problem was. They said the water heater was 20 years old and the heating element had failed and that it needed to be replaced. They got a hold of American Home Shield and got approval for the replacements and to make sure that everything was gonna be covered. And while they were here, the work they did was excellent. The water heater has been working fine since then.
Reviewed March 6, 2019
The icemaker wasn’t working and there was visible rust in the freezer and refrigerator compartment. Submitting the claim for it online with American Home Shield was fairly easy. Before this, there was a first claim and I had two appliances. We had a power outage and I had a problem submitting for the second appliance. It wasn’t clear to me how to do that, so I called and the person on the phone was very helpful. The icemaker was in a second home and I wasn’t there and when I talked to the tech on the phone, he told me that he did what he said he was gonna do. He didn’t call me to tell me he’d actually done the job though. There had been a snowstorm and he called to tell me that he would do the job at another time but he never called me back to tell me the job was complete. I had to call them in a few days to ask what the status was.
Also, for the rust issue, I had to reach out back to AHS to ask what they came up with? The tech never reported back to me about that issue and I’ve never heard from American Home Shield to tell me about that part of the claim, which I assumed the tech submitted but he kinda gave me his own opinion that it wasn’t something that American Home Shield would cover. There was a gray area there as if the rust would be covered or was covered or non-covered. The follow-through on both the service company, Ken’s Repair Service, and American Home Shield has not been that great. But other than that, we’re happy to have the coverage.
Media


