American Home Shield Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+1 more
About American Home Shield
American Home Shield is a home warranty provider that offers service plans throughout the contiguous United States. It offers three home warranty plan options, priced from $29.99 to $89.99 per month, with either a $100 or $125 service fee. In addition to normal wear and tear, plans cover breakdowns from rust, insufficient maintenance and faulty repairs, which are often excluded from home warranty coverage.
- Three plan options
- High coverage limits
- 30-day workmanship guarantee
- Covers rust, corrosion and sediment damage
- Relatively high service fees
- Not available in all states
American Home Shield Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (66,965)
- (16,388)
- (8,662)
- (4,311)
- (13,496)
Popular Mentions
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My refrigerator was leaking and not producing water and I contacted American Home Shield. I spoke to a live claims agent who provided good customer service and informed me that a contractor, Right Refrigeration LLC, would be in touch. However, I had to reach out to them as they did not contact me as promised, which was disappointing.
The contractor arrived about a week later and was professional and knowledgeable. They identified that I needed to change the filter and addressed an issue at the back of the refrigerator. They also instructed me to run a gallon of water through the sprout before using it, which was helpful.
I've been with American Home Shield for about 2 or 3 years. I chose their service for the reassurance that if an appliance couldn't be repaired, it would be replaced for free. While my recent experience was a 5, in other instances, I encountered issues, such as with a leaking showerhead. The company required me to resolve issues behind the wall before they returned to fix it, which I found frustrating and felt they should track ongoing issues better to avoid additional charges for repeat visits.
Overall, I rate my experience with this claim as a 5 as well as the price. Customer service and coverage both get a 4. Despite some frustrations, I believe American Home Shield is worth purchasing for the peace of mind it offers in appliance repair and replacement.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
The microwave kept tripping the breaker for that side of the house and eventually, it completely went out. The technician from Atari Services Appliance Inc. identified a faulty switch as the problem, which was promptly fixed.
I submitted my claim via the app, which was straightforward. However, getting someone to my house was another story. The technician was supposed to arrive within a certain window but showed up about an hour and a half late. I did receive a message at 3:50 PM stating they'd arrive between 4 and 6, and then another at 6:03 PM from the technician saying he'd be there in 40 minutes, arriving around 7 PM. Despite the delay, the technician was efficient and did an excellent job.
Unfortunately, I'm dealing with another claim related to electrical issues. I only have one company available through American Home Shield for electrical work, and scheduling has been a challenge since their hours don't align with my work schedule. I found their customer service generally helpful, but when I requested an alternative technician due to issues with the current provider's reviews and past performance, they couldn't accommodate this request.
I chose American Home Shield based on a neighbor's recommendation, as I moved into an older house. Overall, my interactions with American Home Shield's representatives have been positive, but the limited service provider options in my area have been frustrating.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
Sears handled an issue with my refrigerator and I'm frustrated because their service has been appalling throughout this process. It started on February 4th, and I still don't have a working refrigerator.
On their first visit, the Sears technician claimed the coils just needed cleaning but didn't perform any cleaning himself. When I cleaned them, the issue wasn't resolved. Sears then canceled multiple appointments, and when they did show up, they’d drive off without even checking the appliance properly. Their technician eventually replaced the main board and relay for the compressor, which didn't solve the problem. It was a constant cycle of canceled and rescheduled appointments, leading to significant inconvenience as I couldn't operate my mobile food truck or store food, resulting in about $3,000 in lost revenue and additional daily expenses for eating out.
American Home Shield eventually refunded my original service fee due to the numerous issues. They arranged for Economy Heating and Air to step in. Unlike Sears, Economy Heating was professional and quickly identified the problem—a thermostat issue—which explains why the compressor was overheating and the refrigerator wasn't functioning correctly. We're now waiting for the repair approval.
Due to my poor experience with Sears, I've considered canceling my policy with American Home Shield. They need to reconsider using Sears for service calls as it could tarnish their reputation. I've rated my experience as a 3 out of 5.
Hi Peter, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a leak in the sewer pipe and in a copper pipe. I called it in on a Thursday, but the repair was not completed until the following Friday. The delay was inconvenient, as I had to deal with water leaking into the basement through a crack in the wall. However, once HM Plumbing came out, they did a great job fixing the issues. I've been with American Home Shield for around 3-4 years. They've been helpful, having worked on my air conditioner before, but I'm not fond of the continuous price increases. I'm considering discontinuing their service because of this. Overall, I'd rate them around a 3 out of 5.
Dear Dale,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed March 7, 2025
Attempted to get service for my refrigerator that stopped working. Was sent to vendors who could not come out to even look at refrigerator for several days. In the meantime I had to worry about food spoilage. Disappointed that there did not appear to be many vendors available to service the appliance in this situation. Could not wait and incurred cost to replace old fridge. My past experience with them on another issue took weeks to resolve. In urgent situations, would be great if they had technicians that could at least diagnose enough to determine if appliance is repairable or needs to be replaced. I could not risk waiting days for someone to come out and possibly additional days on top of that to order parts. Fridge is almost 10 or more years old. Considering changing to another company.
Hi Melody, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
When Comfort Pros came out for a repair, the experience was fantastic, largely due to the tech named Dean. He was professional and provided useful tips about my furnace and overall boiler maintenance.
If someone is considering a warranty, it's worth it for the peace of mind and savings on potential repair costs. The annual fee and service charges are manageable and the coverage is comprehensive, including appliances, plumbing, and electrical systems. There are no restrictions on calling for service as long as the issue persists.
Overall, I couldn’t be happier with the ease and effectiveness of the service.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I recently had a new dishwasher installed under my warranty with American Home Shield. Initially, they sent a contractor to fix the existing dishwasher by replacing the gaskets, but it wasn’t successful. As a result, they ordered a new dishwasher for me, which was installed today. The interaction with the contractor was smooth and without issues. The process so far has been satisfactory.
I would rate my overall experience with American Home Shield as a 4.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience.
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I've had the HVAC technicians working on my heating unit with American Home Shield. The process of submitting my claim was simple. The contractors were fine when they came to address the issue. However, I'm on the seventh visit, so I'm not sure if it's completely repaired yet, as it's a complex issue. I would rate American Home Shield a 4 out of 5.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield and the service we provide!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
For my recent claim with AHS, my air conditioner stopped responding to the thermostat and during the coldest part of the season, when it was 17 degrees here in Texas. Submitting the claim was effortless; the process was straightforward and easy on the site. The contractor interaction was great; he arrived on time, was professional, explained the problem clearly, and fixed it efficiently. It was a 5-star experience overall. My heater has been working fine ever since.
The only downside is the cost, which has increased significantly over the years. I started paying around $35 a month when I first joined 18 years ago, and now it's $109 monthly with a $100 service copay. This makes it a considerable expense at $1200 a year, not including service calls. If the cost continues to rise, I might consider other companies like Sears due to my long-standing experience with them. Overall, I'd rate the price a 3 due to the expense. However, the online tools are excellent, deserving a 5.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My furnace was unable to maintain the set temperature, and it was getting too cold for comfort. I contacted AHS and I was able to speak with a live agent. The interaction with the agent was smooth, and they arranged for East Ohio Furnace to come out quickly.
The contractor who came was excellent. They diagnosed the issue efficiently and explained it to me in simple terms since I'm not familiar with how furnaces work. Ultimately, the problem was resolved, and my furnace is now working perfectly. I feel secure knowing I won't have to worry about this in the future, especially during winter.
Overall, I am very happy with American Home Shield's service. There was one instance during my first year with them when a plumber wasn't available to come for almost a week, which was frustrating. I prefer quick responses, and a week was not acceptable at the time. However, aside from that, my experiences have been positive.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a stint with AHS for about two years. During that period, I faced a few appliance issues which led me to interact with their service. Firstly, my ice maker stopped working, but they replaced and fixed it. Then, my dishwasher was running too long, which they also addressed. However, the seal was still leaking after the initial fix, so a tech had to return to install a new seal. Unfortunately, during this process, the tech ran a screw through the front of the dishwasher, which added to the hassle.
This entire experience became very tedious; it involved around 20 phone calls back and forth between AHS and their contracted service provider. It became too cumbersome, so I decided to cancel my policy with them. While I've had the coverage for a couple of years, I felt it was more straightforward to directly hire someone to take care of any issues rather than navigating the claim process with AHS.
Thankfully, everything is fixed and working well now. However, due to the extensive back and forth required to get to this point, I wouldn't want to go through the same process again.
Dear Josh,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My tub was clogged. The process of submitting the claim with AHS for it was fine, and the contractor they sent was very nice and respectful. Since the repair, I haven't had any further issues with my tub.
As for the pricing, it's standard with the market, although I noticed that the claim fee has increased, which seems to be a trend across the board.
I have used the online tool and visited their website, and I am quite satisfied with it. Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been positive.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I submitted a claim online with AHS recently for my heating system. The thermostat and heating system weren't syncing, where the thermostat showed one temperature, but the interior was different.
The initial contractor couldn't solve the issue, and it took three different contractors over approximately six weeks to identify and fix the problem. The last contractor was knowledgeable and quickly replaced the necessary part, resolving the issue. Due to the duration, I would rate the experience as a 3, even though the system has been working well since.
I've been with American Home Shield because a relative recommended it, expressing their satisfaction. I've had no problems with them and find them to be reliable. The pricing is reasonable, and the claim process is simple since they honor their claims. My only suggestion for improvement would be to ensure they screen their contractors.
Dear Charlene,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I was very pleased with my recent experience with AHS. The techs were wonderful, exceeding my expectations. Before their visit, they called ahead, which I found very courteous. Upon arrival, they were polite and took the time to explain how my refrigerator works. They also showed me how to properly run the water to clear out any charcoal in the lines, set up the temperatures, and even demonstrated how to install the filter, which seemed easier than my previous one.
Overall, the service felt like they went the extra mile, making the entire process smooth and informative. I would definitely give them a high rating, a perfect 5 out of 5 stars.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
Legacy Appliances came out and repaired my stove. I contacted AHS online, hoping for a quick resolution, but unfortunately, it took two weeks to fix the issue. They couldn't provide an estimated timeline, and the delay was mainly due to waiting on parts. It would have been more convenient to replace the stove, but they opted for repairs.
I've been with AHS for nearly three years, and this is the first significant issue I've faced. If asked by a friend or neighbor, I would describe American Home Shield as a good company overall. This incident was the only hiccup in my otherwise positive experience.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a service experience with AHS when my ice machine stopped working and my refrigerator wasn't cooling properly. The contractor was professional and resolved the issue by installing a new motor for the ice machine and later ordering and fitting a vent.
The process of getting the quote and the repairs went smoothly. There was a slight delay waiting for parts, but overall, it took about two weeks for the issue to be fully resolved. I'm pleased with the professionalism of the contractors and the service coverage, and I've only had to pay the deductible. Overall, my experience with their service has been positive.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My washing machine stopped draining and wouldn't complete the wash cycle. I contacted AHS through their app to submit a claim. The process was straightforward and very easy to navigate. The contractor from Sears who came out to fix it was extremely knowledgeable and polite. He quickly diagnosed that the drain pipe needed replacement. Once the part was ordered and arrived, he came back to install it, and now my machine works perfectly.
I've been using AHS since I bought my first house; my sister recommended their service to me. What I appreciate most is how easy it is to use—they have an app that minimizes the need for phone calls, which I prefer as I often get overwhelmed with too many calls. I have found their customer service to be excellent and their coverage quite comprehensive, although the price recently increased. It used to be 89.99. Then it jumped up to 125. Despite this, I understand it's due to the current economic situation, and the coverage remains valuable.
I would rate my overall experience with the service as a 4 out of 5, particularly for its ease of use and effectiveness. I have also recommended it to my family and friends because it's been a reliable support for my home needs.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I encountered problems with my furnace. The motor was running, but the power light wouldn't come on, causing it to blow cold air. The thermostat also wasn't working correctly. Harvey Home Service came to repair it, and the tech was friendly, knowledgeable, and helpful. He did a great job, and the furnace has worked well since the repair.
This was not my first claim with American Home Shield, and my experiences with them have always been positive. However, I experienced a delay in getting a part approved and processed, which took longer than expected. Improving the speed of claim processing would be beneficial.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a service visit from American Home Shield for issues with my dryer and dishwasher. The technician who came over was a very respectful young man who was also training someone. It went well. They were supportive, pleasant and they both did their work. The team ordered the necessary parts and are scheduled to return and complete the repairs soon.
I appreciated their communication, especially how they informed me about their arrival with a call 20 minutes beforehand. This aspect of their service was quite nice. Overall, I am very satisfied with my experience with American Home Shield and would rate them 5 stars.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
AHS dispatched US Air Conditioning of Texas for a yearly checkup as part of their preventative maintenance screening. I discovered this service while I was making a claim for my hot water heater on their website. I find their claims process fairly easy, though it would be great if more characters were allowed in the description field when detailing what's happening.
Once a claim is made, they promptly send me a text assigning a contractor and indicating when I can expect contact to schedule the appointment. The contractors I've encountered have been professional, helpful, and polite. The last claim I made was for a slow leak in one of the drain pipes of my hot water heater. The contractor replaced the leaking component effectively, and everything has been functioning perfectly since then.
I appreciate the convenience of their service. Navigating their website is straightforward; it involves a simple checklist to specify the issue step-by-step. I'd rate my overall experience with American Home Shield as 4.5 out of 5 stars. The service is very handy to have when needed, so it's best to have it available rather than waiting until it's too late.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
Recently, I had a claim regarding the motor on our furnace, which had stopped working. We contacted American Home Shield, and they sent out Detroit Heating and Cooling to handle the repair.
Initially, when they arrived, they informed us that they couldn't fix it for about two weeks due to a supposed unavailability of parts. However, we had confirmation from another heating and cooling contact that the parts were available and that they should be able to do it immediately. After some time, the Detroit Heating and Cooling technician agreed to return within an hour to fix the motor.
When he completed the repair, something was off, as the heat wouldn't shut off—it was a thermostat issue due to an incorrectly connected wire. We called a couple times and left messages to get them to come back out. After the first visit, the same technician came out four days later, ‘cause there was a weekend in between, and resolved the issue, acknowledging his initial oversight. Now, everything works perfectly fine.
The claim submission process was easy to follow, but due to the timing, it's inconvenient sometimes because there's no work over the weekend or a delay to get someone. While I wasn't personally present for the technician's visit, they resolved the issues eventually.
I've been using American Home Shield for a few years now, approximately three. Overall, I'd rate my experience with the company as a 3 out of 5.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I reached out to AHS because there was a rattling noise in my walls every time the furnace turned on. Although it wasn't the furnace causing the noise, the tech from East Ohio Furnace was able to identify the issue. Surprisingly, after his visit, the noise stopped, which was a relief. I've had them service my furnace before and I've always been pleased with their work.
I'm very satisfied with the customer service from American Home Shield. If a friend or family member asked for my opinion about getting a warranty with them, I would certainly recommend it.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I recently had to deal with a plumbing issue at my home, which American Home Shield addressed by sending out Warhold Mechanicals. While I was away in Florida, a hose pipe burst, causing water to flood my basement. Warhold Mechanicals responded by cutting the pipe, soldering it, and sealing the hole in the brick of my house. Everything has been working fine since the repair.
I've had American Home Shield for two years at this house, and I was familiar with them from a previous property. My experience this time with Warhold was remarkably better than a previous encounter—I had a very poor experience with them at my old house, which was so problematic I had to escalate the issue to the Better Business Bureau. Thankfully, this recent service was a vast improvement; the technician was thorough and explained everything clearly.
The only drawback was the response time. Due to the urgent nature of the issue, I had to shut off all water to the house and no one could come out immediately. I had no water for two days, which was inconvenient, but otherwise, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield a solid 5.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I needed my refrigerator repaired and arranged the service through American Home Shield's online platform, which was convenient. However, I was not satisfied with the turnaround time for the repair. The technician needed to order parts, and it took about 5 to 7 weeks for them to arrive, which was much longer than expected.
While waiting for the part was frustrating, I understand that the delay was beyond their control since they were just ordering the parts.
If a friend or family member asked me about American Home Shield, there isn't a lot of great companies, so it's the best they could do. Despite my frustrations, I would rate my overall experience as a 4 out of 5, considering the customer service and quality of work.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I've used American Home Shield for a few home repair claims. Our most recent claim was for the garbage disposal, which was handled while I was away. My husband was present during the repair, and the technician replaced the disposal efficiently, leaving us without any further issues.
Before that, I experienced a claim for our air conditioning unit, which I was present for, and the technician was excellent. He was very friendly and treated me well, calling 20 minutes before his arrival to ensure I was prepared. His demeanor and work ethic left a great impression on me—he was truly amazing.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been highly positive. I don't have any suggestions for improvement at this moment. From my experiences so far, I would confidently rate them a 5 out of 5. The price, including both the monthly subscription and service fees, is fair. The customer service is exceptional, and the online claim submission process is intuitive. Additionally, the level of coverage provided has met all my expectations.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My dryer wasn't staying hot and the technician identified a faulty part that appeared melted, ordered a new one, and fixed the issue. During that time, he also checked my washer, addressing all the problems efficiently. The repair process was quick, and the technician was very professional and knowledgeable.
Despite some delays due to weather conditions, once everything was clear, service resumed promptly. I've been satisfied with both the technician's work and American Home Shield's service overall. I would rate my experience as a 5 out of 5. I'm confident in recommending American Home Shield based on this experience.
Thank you for sharing your feedback regarding your AHS customer experience. We are glad to provide you with prompt and professional service!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had two appliances that needed servicing, and American Home Shield initially connected me with two vendors who weren’t adequately informed about my needs. For instance, they didn’t know my dryer was a stacked unit instead of a side-by-side, which is essential information that should have been provided by American Home Shield. As a result, the vendors couldn't address my issue because they lacked the necessary equipment.
After several calls to American Home Shield, I finally got Sears involved. However, the situation didn't improve much. The first technician from Sears ordered parts based on his assessment, but when the second technician arrived, he disagreed with the first assessment and decided not to install the parts. This confusion left my issues unresolved, and my refrigerator is still making noises, which was one of the problems I needed fixed.
Overall, my experience was disappointing, and I wouldn't rate American Home Shield positively. I'd give them a 1 out of 5. I generally contact them by phone rather than through their website. Their customer service wasn't particularly helpful, hovering around a 3 out of 5, and given the unsatisfactory service, I feel overcharged for what I received and would rate the value at a 2 out of 5.
Hi Ms. Singh, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
When the Samsung technician arrived, they provided a diagnosis that contradicted what American Home Shield's technician had initially mentioned. The issue, covered under Samsung's 10-year warranty, wasn't covered anymore, creating confusion. I reached out to American Home Shield for another technician, hoping they could provide a cohesive resolution with the Samsung diagnosis I received.
While American Home Shield has consistently delivered excellent service in the past, this particular incident left me dissatisfied due to the lack of follow-up and clarity about what was covered. Despite this hiccup, I still hold them in high regard for their overall service, rating it a 5 out of 5 for past experiences.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I've been with American Home Shield four months and my experience has been extremely frustrating and disappointing. They didn't repair anything. I purchased my house four months ago with the understanding that it had a finished basement—a significant selling point for me. Unfortunately, I discovered that the basement is not stormproof. The basement is walls up and painted, but there's nothing stopping floodwater or stormwater from getting in. I paid Roto-Rooter three grand to extract water out and bring fans. Two days later, it rained as well as flooded again. I spent hundreds of dollars on wet vac and also paid $1,200 to get the gutters fixed to see if that would do it. All of these didn't work. My basement still flooded again. I'm $7,000 in the hole and my warranty doesn't help me do anything. My biggest problem with it is while money comes and goes, for me to give out seven grand on a house I just moved in to is ridiculous.
Throughout this ordeal, my interactions with American Home Shield have been less than satisfactory. They were reachable and they picked the phone up, but it was nearly impossible to get the necessary support or proper guidance from them. Whenever I reached out, communications seemed to fall through the cracks. I found myself constantly transferred between representatives, many of whom I struggled to understand due to language barriers. That's a problem on its own, and then I was also having orders canceled from different plumbing companies and I was getting email confirmations. I was lost with all of that. I expect somebody to give me guidelines and lay out for me what needs to take place.
I feel misled and unsupported, especially as a first-time homebuyer who invested significantly in this property. I give my home warranty company money every month, and they don't help. Based on my experience of confusion, canceled services, and lack of effective communication, I would rate American Home Shield at a one out of five stars, indicating my deep dissatisfaction. I wouldn't want anyone else to go through the same ordeal.
Hi Ramone, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a plumbing issue and submitting the claim to American Home Shield was straightforward. The contractor they sent did an excellent job fixing the plumbing. However, there was some disappointment because a broken fixture couldn't be replaced under the warranty. American Home Shield classified it as a modification rather than a repair, requiring out-of-pocket payment.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been positive. The plumbing works fine now, and the contractor was great. The cost of the warranty seems fair to me, and I'd give that aspect a rating of 3 out of 5, as it's reasonably priced.
I have used their online tools and website, which were easy to navigate. It did take some effort to locate specific policy details regarding the fixture issue, but the website generally functions well enough, warranting a 3 out of 5 rating.
In sum, I'm overall satisfied with American Home Shield's services, despite the minor hiccup with the warranty coverage.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I recently purchased a home and American Home Shield was suggested during the buying process. We were provided with a warranty, which was a nice addition. We've been covered by AHS for about four months now.
I had to submit a claim when our HVAC unit failed on a Sunday. The process was easy and quick as I just went online and filled out the form. A contractor arrived the very next day and resolved the issue promptly—a loose wire in our unit was the problem. The interaction with the contractor was straightforward and pleasant.
The overall experience with American Home Shield has been positive. I appreciate the simplicity and efficiency of their service. If I were to rate them, I would give them the highest possible mark. I genuinely feel it's a great benefit, especially for new homeowners who might not be aware of any underlying issues in their homes.
We’re thrilled to hear that you were satisfied with our services. Your feedback is appreciated, and we look forward to helping you again.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a faucet that needed repair, and when I called for service, the contractor American Home Shield sent out was excellent—he fixed the problem, and we've had no issues since.
I really appreciate having American Home Shield because it acts like insurance for minor things, allowing us to avoid dipping into our savings when something goes wrong.
I probably first heard about American Home Shield on the internet, and now, we've been good customers for over 12 years. We appreciate what they do.
We’re thrilled to hear that you were satisfied with our services. Your feedback is appreciated, and we look forward to helping you again.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
There's a gear on top of the garage that rotates the belt back and forth, and from wear and tear, the belt fell off. It was on the floor of the garage when I had to go through the house. Then, I noticed that one of the springs on the right side was completely snapped. The bolt held it from snapping and exploding in the garage, but it was cut in half almost, and I didn't even know that happened until everything. I used the app to file a claim to American Home Shield and it was easy to use. We received a phone number of who would be contacting us in 48 hours. Then, I received a text message with the date that the contractor would be there. I could have called to change the date. I dealt with AHS before on an AC unit and the company was more of a professional one. They called first to confirm an appointment. Holiday Home Repair on the other hand is not a full-fledged business with multiple fleets.
The contractor showed up and I explained that something was broken. They said they would order parts and it took almost 14 days before they came back so our claim was open for a long time. I had to send an email to AHS and the contractor showed up 17 days after. The only communication I heard after the original time that they showed up was that other time. But customer service-wise, they were helpful. My car was stuck inside the garage and the garage door would not open without having a ladder hold it in place. They helped open the garage and pushed the car out when I put it in neutral. They were very friendly and down-to-earth.
I’ve had good experiences as far as coverage. I’ve never been blindsided where I file a claim, the contractor shows up and says it’s not covered because a small little pin is missing, and you’re stuck with the bill. I've recommended AHS. It’s better to have coverage than to find out that you need coverage after the fact. We just use AHS as a secondary insurance because homeowners insurance won't cover a down appliance. It’s a little bit of a side investment because if the fridge goes, it removes a little bit of a headache. You don't have to find a technician. So, I'd rather be overinsured than underinsured.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield and the service we provide!
Reviewed March 7, 2025
My toilets couldn't flush and water was backing up into my showers so I submitted a claim with American Home Shield online. The website was easy to use, just a few clicks to send the request. However, I wish they had more descriptive options for reporting issues. For instance, there wasn't an option to specify if water wasn't draining or if the toilet was bubbling, which could help in identifying specific problems.
The contractor from Emergency Plumbing LLC who came out was excellent. I actually initiated contact with them because I was anxious waiting for feedback. The contractor provided valuable information over the phone, helping me to determine whether the problem was inside or outside the house. This allowed us to temporarily manage the situation until he could arrive and fix everything.
I would rate my experience with American Home Shield a 4 out of 5. They're generally a good company, employing professionals who do a commendable job. Unlike some other home warranty companies I've dealt with, American Home Shield employs technicians you'd willingly hire on your own.
The peace of mind this service provides is priceless. I can submit a claim anytime using my phone, which is comforting. In the past, with another company, I faced a similar situation but couldn't get emergency help immediately, resulting in extra costs. However, with American Home Shield, I was able to reach someone quickly, even though the technician couldn't come until the next day. He provided guidance over the phone which allowed us to use the bathrooms temporarily.
American Home Shield is a great company, and I strongly recommend its protection for your home.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
The technician American Home Shield assigned for my air conditioner claim came to my home and informed me that two of the three are outdated and essentially non-functional. Although they could be repaired, they were very old and it would have been too costly considering the need for freon and other components. I knew this was coming, so I decided to move forward with replacing them. I obtained an estimate and plan to proceed, so I will have three quiet and efficient air conditioners. It’s not cheap, but time’s come.
The technician was commendable. On a scale from 1 to 5, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield and their home warranty service as a 4.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
American Home Shield sent Extreme Heating to work on my AC, and the technician was very good. As a matter of fact, while he was here, I called his headquarters and let them know that I was thanking them for the professionalism and how attentive he was to taking care of my needs. The technician explained to me what was going on, answered all my questions and even took his shoes off when entering my house. I've found Extreme to be the best company that American Home Shield has sent to address my needs.
I've been with American Home Shield for over nine years and currently have coverage for four houses with them. Generally, I reach out over the phone, and my customer service experience has been pretty good as of late, with no significant issues. If there's ever a service delay, it's minimal, and they are quick to address any problems.
I often recommend American Home Shield to friends, advising them to get some coverage for peace of mind in case things break down. However, I do find the cost of their service to be on the higher side.
While I'm aware that they have a website and app for setting up requests, I personally prefer to talk to a live person. Overall, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield as excellent.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
We had a garage door issue where the remote wouldn't connect properly—it required holding down the button to open or close the door. Fortunately, Winston Doors' technician fixed it without any problems, and he was able to resolve it on the same day. My husband handled most of the interaction with the technician, who was very professional and friendly.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been excellent, and I'd confidently rate them 5 out of 5 stars.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
The roof was leaking and when I submitted a claim with American Home Shield, the process was straightforward and quick, taking less than 10 minutes on the phone. The contractors they sent were really good and efficient—there were no issues at all. Since the repair, my roof has been leak-free and working perfectly fine. I'd rate my overall experience with American Home Shield a 5, meaning I would recommend them to a friend.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
When my pool heater wasn't staying on and was giving error messages, American Home Shield assigned J&J Pools Inc. to come out. They checked the problem and explained that sometimes after a pool heater has been unused, gas collects in the lines causing it to need several attempts to start. They tested everything and eventually got it working again, and now it's functioning normally.
However, I would rate American Home Shield a 2 out of 5. Over the years, I've encountered several issues with them. Specifically, their warranty coverage has been disappointing. For instance, I had to pay for my air conditioner replacement out of pocket because they only offered $3,200, citing wear and tear was not covered. What is the warranty for though?
Parts break, and I have tried to use American Home Shield for that as well. When my compressor broke, I had to wait three weeks to get them to send somebody out, then I had to wait for them to agree to pay for it. I had to pay partial on my own too. The warranty coverage does not meet expectations, as they don’t fully cover necessary parts. Recently, I had to spend $1,000 on a new air conditioner due to inadequate coverage.
While the scheduling and service attempts are appreciated, the fulfillment of the warranty terms overall falls short of what was promised.
Hi Kristy, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I reached out to American Home Shield online for a plumbing issue and the customer service was very professional. The plumber arrived promptly at 7 a.m. the next day, quickly resolving the problem in about two hours. I've been with American Home Shield for nine years and find it worth the money, so I would recommend them to friends and family.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had a claim with American Home Shield for two of our fans and the process to submit it was straightforward. I just had to call them, and they replaced the fan that wasn't working at all. However, they refused to replace the fan that is still making a lot of noise because it's not completely broken yet, even though the technician who checked it stated that the motor would fail soon. The contractor sent by American Home Shield was knowledgeable and post-repair, the fan that they fixed is working perfectly fine.
We are committed to providing the best possible service and your feedback is instrumental in helping us achieve that goal. Thank you once again for sharing your experience with us. We look forward to serving you in the future and continuing to build a strong relationship.
Warm regards,
Marc
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I've had quite a prolonged ordeal with American Home Shield regarding my air conditioning unit. It's been an issue for about 8 months now. Initially, the problem was with the condenser, but later it moved to the evaporator coil. Unfortunately, both components of my older model unit seemed to be failing. I had to pay for Freon three times and ended up spending around $1500 out-of-pocket because it wasn't covered under the American Home Shield warranty.
Submitting the claim was straightforward, although there was confusion due to having two AC units at the back of my house. One AC went out, then the other one went out about a month later. They were confusing the ACs and what work had been done to both ACs at the same time. The mix-up left us without air conditioning for about three months during the summer, which was quite unpleasant.
The last contractor we dealt with was good. However, over the past several months, I've had to interact with 3 or 4 different contractors due to the need for multiple second opinions. That's what caused the confusion between the issues of both ACs. This time, the guy from Higginbotham Air Conditioning knew exactly what to look for, because he had been out there the last time as well. His familiarity with our situation was a relief.
If I had to rate my experience overall with American Home Shield, it would probably be a 3 out of 5. Their customer service, on the other hand, would get a 1. The price of the warranty seems average compared to other policies, so I'd give it a 3 or 4. As for their online tools, the initial online submission process was easy to use. We first started off with putting it online, then they made the phone call to us to set up appointments.
I hope this helps others consider what to expect with American Home Shield.
Hi Steven, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I had some issues with several of my appliances, including a dishwasher that didn't work for about three weeks. The technician who came to my house said it needed to be replaced. My microwave was also making an extremely loud noise when I turned it on. As for my refrigerator, the back line was frozen and it rusted the entire back, making it irreparable.
I contacted American Home Shield, and they've been proactive in getting replacements for the appliances. I've been extremely happy with their customer service throughout this process. My experience with American Home Shield has been absolutely positive, and I would recommend them without hesitation.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I did a claim with American Home Shield involving my furnace, which had developed an issue with a switch. Initially, there was a delay of a couple of days due to a snowstorm, but once the technician arrived, they fixed the problem promptly, and the furnace has been working well since. Although there was a wait, I understood the circumstances and appreciated the swift repair once service was available.
Previously, I faced a more challenging situation. American Home Shield struggled to find a technician in my area, Hampton Roads, Virginia, which I found surprising given the high population density. I ended up hiring someone myself and was reimbursed later. While this process was a bit inconvenient, the reimbursement was appreciated.
Overall, despite some hiccups, my experience with American Home Shield has been positive, and I would rate them 4 stars.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
When my garage door wasn't opening, American Home Shield had a nice technician come by and quickly resolve the issue by adjusting the pressure on the door. In addition to solving the initial problem, he also performed some necessary maintenance on the garage door, which wasn't covered under my plan, but I decided to pay for it separately. Now, everything is working well and all maintained.
Overall, I've been satisfied with American Home Shield and would recommend their service to others.
Joanna, thanks so much for taking the time to reach out and share your experience! I'm pleased to see that our team was able to get your garage door repaired so quickly.
We look forward to the next opportunity that we'll have to assist you.
-Ken
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I submitted a repair request to American Home Shield because the glass part on my oven door broke, and they sent someone out to take care of it. The technician was friendly and informative, answering all my questions and even providing advice for future use of the oven. He confirmed that they would order the replacement for the oven door, and they returned to install it once it arrived. The entire process took about two weeks. Everything is working perfectly now. I'm very satisfied with the service and the vendor they used.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
Recently, I called American Home Shield about water running down because there were some spots in my ceiling where the water leaked from the pipes. They addressed that through their service provider, clubs home remodeling and plumbing services, and the service guy fixed that. However, water's still leaking down my bathroom wall and we've been wondering why. Last night, my grandson noticed that the seal around the shower head is loose, causing water to leak down the bathroom wall.
I have been with American Home Shield for a very long time, primarily because whenever I call them, they address and take care of any issues. Overall, while the response is generally reliable and satisfactory, I still need to contact them to address the recent problem with the shower head seal. Despite this, I would highly recommend their services.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I truly appreciate the peace of mind American Home Shield provides. I have been a customer for almost 24 years, and over the years, I've used my warranty for various issues. Recently, our refrigerator's ice maker stopped working due to a freon leak, and they replaced the entire refrigerator in less than a week. The technicians have always been top-notch, especially the latest ones. Throughout the years, American Home Shield has replaced our hot water heater, furnace, central vacuum, and even the components of our hot tub at our last house. Their service has been terrific, and I highly recommend them.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 7, 2025
I did a claim for a garbage disposal in a rental property I own and the process of submitting it online was fine. However, the experience with the contractors was less than ideal. The garbage disposal was clearly beyond repair, yet it took two visits to resolve the issue. This was inconvenient for my full-time working tenant. After the replacement, the new disposal has been working well.
As a realtor, I frequently use their online tools, but I found it odd that garbage disposal wasn't an option during the claim process. Overall, I'd rate American Home Shield a 4 out of 5. The customer service and price for the coverage get a 4 as well. However, my rating on the functionality of the online tool dropped in this scenario, offering room for improvement.
We hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield and the coverage we provide!
Reviewed March 5, 2025
I ordered a service on the furnace. American Home Shield sent a company out of my area, but closer to me who went out there and did not tell us exactly what needed to be done. But American Home Shield denied the claim. Nobody called to communicate. So I called American Home Shield and they kept telling me I needed to call the people. I couldn’t get the original people. They sent Guaranteed out here to service. They couldn't service. Then you went back and hired this company closer to my house who took the money, never could get in touch with them to come and do the work. They then stood in front of my sister’s face and did not tell us about the fence, because the fence was not a problem. But American Home Shield just automatically denied the claim.
I had to fight, cuss, call, and cuss to get somebody to get me somebody out there to fix that furnace. Then when Guaranteed finally got back out there, the house was filling up with the poison that came from the gas. My sister has medical issues and she was in a cold house. American Home Shield kept putting me through and telling me somebody was gonna call me, but they got my money. I had to tell them that I was gonna sue them for every penny I paid them so I could get my furnace fixed.
Guaranteed Services came to my rescue when American Home Shield finally agreed and took care of the furnace. We got a brand-new furnace. But American Home Shield's customer service people were lousy. They didn't hear my needs, but they took my money. Matter of fact, they kept calling me trying to tell me I ain’t paying my bill and you were drafting my account.
American Home Shield needs to be a little bit more compassionate, especially during the wintertime. Their system needs to have an elevation when it's an emergency. With my sister having an illness, they should have taken consideration and not waited another three weeks, and I had to keep calling back. Somebody should have been reaching out. Somebody should have said, “You know what? We see this needs to be elevated, not the normal elevation.” But they didn't do that. They made me wait trying to reach somebody who they couldn't even reach themselves, and kept telling me, “Well, you want to try to reach out.” I told them, “For what? I didn't hire them. Why you didn't send the people you sent the first time?”
American Home Shield sent Guaranteed Service to service the furnace, but then they got this man to fix it, and that was the problem. Then Guaranteed Service had to come back. But they were so nice. They tried to work over their time to get my sister some heat once they came back, and they’re the ones who deserve all the praise. They tried to flip it and rush American Home Shield to get that furnace for them so they could get it done for my sister. I got two houses I got under American Home Shield. So they need to hear from me because they're getting my money. They’re getting over $100 a month.
Hi Gloria, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 5, 2025
I was without hot water during one of the coldest winters in years for almost 2 weeks due to my hot water heater failure and American Home Shield failure to reassign my project to another contractor who could have repaired the hot water heater faster. On Sunday, February 9th, my hot water heater stopped working. I contacted American Home Shield to file a claim. The project was assigned to a contractor.
The tech arrived on Wednesday, February 12th, to diagnose the problem. The tech determined that a replacement part was needed and the part was ordered on the 12th. I was informed that delivery of the part could take up to 7 days. And it did. When AHS was informed of the time frame to receive the part, it should have reassigned the project. My family and I ended up renting a hotel room for 2 days. The part was finally delivered on February 20th and the repair was made on the same day. Very unhappy. Searching for my next Home Warranty plan.
Hi Lou, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 3, 2025
American Home Shield scheduled the appointment with Winston Doors and when they came out, the tech asked if I could unlock my third car garage. I told him it had a lock on it and we had a bunch of baseboards that were sitting in front of it so it'd be easier if we go through my house. I took him in there and he walked into the garage and said I had a one-spring garage door system and it was out of code. I said that was how it was when we bought our home and it passed inspections then. He said that wasn't gonna work.
They were supposed to be here between 11:00 and 4:00 and I had an appointment that day. I told him we had somewhere to go. I asked if he'd be able to fix the garage door and he said he didn't know and that we were gonna have to see what they say. He talked to my husband for a minute and he was going on and on about how our garage door was out of code. He said it was supposed to be a new spring system.
We didn't hear anything and I tried calling Winston Doors to see when the spring would be in and if they'd be able to fix it. But they couldn't tell me anything and I had to call like 500 times just to get someone to answer the phone. I called AHS and they said they had not gotten the paperwork to see what needed to be done. Mysteriously, in the next hour, I saw on my online account with American Home Shield that the authorization had been approved and next thing I knew, I received a text message that I had an appointment on a certain day from 11:00 to 4:00.
My husband was at home and was waiting all day but 4:00 rolled around and nobody had shown up. I looked on American Home Shield and pulled up the text message. My appointment had been changed to 12:00 to 6:00. No one called me to change the appointment. I was just supposed to miraculously know this without being notified. We waited and no one came. I called Winston Doors and asked when the tech would be here and the rep said they didn't have me on their schedule. My husband called AHS and they said no one ever confirmed the appointment. But the text message didn't say I needed to text them to confirm.
No one from American Home Shield ever contacted Winston Doors, from what I was told, that I had an appointment. Then, they told me they couldn't make an appointment for a week and a half. I told them I had already been waiting. I waited a week for my original appointment and a week and a half for them to supposedly order the spring. I was not waiting another week and a half because they couldn't communicate and come to my home to fix my garage door. They said someone could be here the next day from 9:00 to 3:00 but I said I was not gonna wait at home for six hours again. After a long time waiting on hold -- and we were on the phone for over an hour and a half -- they said that they would come at 3:00.
My husband and kids were home and the tech showed up at 5:00. I took him to the garage and he asked if I could open another door. I again told this guy that it was locked. There were boards and I preferred not to unlock it. I told him I thought they were coming at 3:00 and he said they don't give specific times. I was trying to tell him what had happened but he just kept cutting me off and told me he was in a hurry. Then, he said he didn't think he could fix my garage door because it's a one-spring system. I told him he should have that on his truck. He was here to fix it. He said he didn't know if it got loaded. I told him I had already been dealing with this for more than two weeks and he was being rude. I told him he could talk with my husband. My husband came out there and he told him that he was in a hurry because he had to get to his next appointment before it got dark. That doesn't mean to be rude to me because you're late and it gets dark in 30 minutes. But he had the spring and he put it on.
But he didn't make my door, so it closed all the way and I had a gap in my garage door. We had to call Winston Doors again like 10 times to get them to answer the phone. They finally answered and the rep said they can't get back out here for a week and a half. I told them they fixed my door improperly and they agreed to come out within two days and the tech adjusted the door.
My husband called American Home Shield and told them it was poor customer service. That was the second time. The last time we had someone come fix our stove, we also had a similar situation. American Home Shield is using companies that are really rude. They don't have good customer service, it takes forever for them to come out here, and they don't submit the paperwork to AHS in a timely manner. We're just waiting forever and that's crazy. My husband spent I don't know how long getting transferred from person to person to person to get someone to hear our complaints about the situation and we're supposed to be getting back the fee that we paid to get the garage door repaired.
Hi Kristie, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 2, 2025
The customer service with American Home Shield has been extremely frustrating, primarily due to communication barriers. Initially, I struggled to understand representatives with heavy accents, which made resolving issues quite difficult. Recently, I had multiple issues with my dishwasher that required me to call service multiple times without any permanent resolution. Despite multiple service attempts, the dishwasher remains non-functional. Furthermore, I'm dissatisfied with their practice of replacing high-end fixtures with lower-grade alternatives. For example, they proposed substituting a builder-grade faucet for a much more expensive one under warranty, which is not acceptable in a home appraised at $1.3 million. This approach diminishes the value of my home.
In terms of customer interaction, I found the representatives to be often rude and unhelpful, seemingly uninterested in truly resolving the problems. Over my many years with American Home Shield, I have unfortunately seen a decline in their service quality. Despite having been a customer for 14 years and once being highly satisfied with their offerings, recent experiences have drastically shifted my perspective. While their sales and marketing efforts have been impressive in the past and I have insured two homes with them, the service received of late does not reflect their promotional promises.
The price of the warranty has also increased substantially while the value has decreased, now offering less suitable replacements and services for my needs. It used to be $75 a month and $50 for my service fee. Now, it's $180 something dollars a month and $100 for service fee. Despite the easy functionality of their online tools, the dissatisfaction with their core services and coverage deeply overshadows any benefits. I would currently not recommend American Home Shield to others given my recent experiences.
Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed March 2, 2025
My freezer stopped working properly, and even though I had initially called another service, the issue wasn't fully resolved. When I reached out to American Home Shield, they sent out multiple technicians to address the problem. It took some time—about three weeks—but they eventually diagnosed that it needed freon, and since then, it's been working perfectly. The delay was a bit frustrating, but it wasn't due to a lack of effort on their part.
I also want to mention the technicians who visited. The first one was very nice and professional, but the second technician wasn't as communicative and did criticize those who came before him, which I didn't appreciate. However, apart from that, everyone was courteous and respectful.
As for the customer service, I would rate it highly. The process of purchasing my home warranty through them was smooth, and the representative offered me a discount, which was unexpected but very welcome. I've had to deal with several appliance breakdowns recently, and having this coverage has been a relief, especially as I've lost my husband and everything seemed to start failing at once.
All in all, I'm very satisfied with American Home Shield. They lived up to their promises regarding the services they provide, and I appreciate the peace of mind that comes with their coverage. I'm happy to recommend them based on my experiences.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed March 1, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield to fix an issue with my oven door, which was locked. Initially, the first vendor couldn't fix the problem, and there was a delay in getting the next vendor, who also couldn't resolve the issue. It took three weeks, during which I had to wait for a third vendor, PJ Appliances, who finally fixed it efficiently. The technicians were professional, especially the one from PJ Appliances, who quickly identified and addressed the problem, completing the job within 15 minutes and returning promptly with the needed part.
While the initial claim process with American Home Shield was smooth, I was dissatisfied with the delays and communication regarding scheduling the subsequent vendors. This aspect could be improved to ensure quicker service, especially when the initial vendor can't handle the problem. Since the repair, the oven has been working well without any issues.
We appreciate your feedback and hope you continue to enjoy American Home Shield!
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2025
American Home Shield sent Plumbing Buddy to fix my toilet, which wasn't flushing correctly. The technician managed to fix the issue, and I've only encountered the problem once since then, so I haven't felt the need to call them again yet. I have been using American Home Shield for nearly two years and the claims process has generally been good, although I am not happy with the price increase from $100 to $125. One significant issue I have is with the warranty period for repairs. My washer had a spinning problem that was addressed three months ago, and now the same issue has occurred. I believe the warranty should last longer than three months because having to pay $125 again for the same problem feels unfair. Originally, when you purchase an appliance, the expectation is for the warranty to cover a longer period.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2025
I have been using American Home Shield for about 11 years now as part of my home warranty service. Recently, I had a plumbing issue that needed fixing—a leak in the garbage disposal and faucet. Unfortunately, I had to pay an additional service fee to Pronto Plumbing, a company sent by American Home Shield, even though it was to correct a mistake made by the first company they used.
Most of the time, my needs have been addressed by American Home Shield, but I have had some issues. I wasn't happy with the garbage disposal and also had a dishwasher repair in the past. The technicians provided weren't great, and the replacement garbage disposal and faucet weren't as good as the original models. While I appreciate the security of having a home warranty, the quality of these replacements has been disappointing, considering it is a service I use only about once a year.
Overall, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield as a 3 out of 5. While I'm generally satisfied with them, I'm not particularly thrilled with the quality of the products or the usefulness considering the cost. The customer service, however, deserves a 5 as they've been polite and effective. The pricing and the online service experience are decent for the most part.
Dear Andrea,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2025
Submitting the claim for my dishwasher that broke was smoother than in past experiences. I had some issues before and I was in the verge of canceling the policy because it took a while for them to respond. But this time, American Home Shield responded quickly, and within three weeks, they had someone come to fix the dishwasher. The contractor who came was courteous and efficiently completed the repair. When I mentioned a related issue upstairs, he took care of that as well without any hassle.
However, I encountered a significant issue when it came to replacing my boiler. The compensation value American Home Shield offered was much lower than the actual cost. They provided only $1,000 for a boiler replacement, whereas purchasing a new one cost around $5,000. This meant I had to pay an additional $6,000 out of pocket. It seems the values they assign to certain items are much lower than their market cost, leading to increased expenses for consumers like me.
While I would still recommend them for certain repairs, the experience highlighted that sometimes their financial support falls short of actual replacements. Overall, I would give American Home Shield a rating of 2 out of 5. Their customer service often seemed unsupportive when help was needed, which affects the overall experience.
The marketing and pricing seemed reasonable—I'd rate them a 4 each for the pushy but effective sales approach and the fairness of the product's price. The online tool was effective, so I'd give it a 4. I once attempted to disconnect my service due to these issues, but the process was cumbersome, leading me to continue despite my reservations.
Dear Eusebio,
I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2025
I have been using American Home Shield for a number of years, ever since I purchased my home. Initially, I found their service quite beneficial. I've had a variety of appliances serviced, like my air conditioner, washer, and refrigerator, with only a minimal service call fee, which used to be $75 but has recently increased to $100. I've had some dealings with them that were awesome. But there were others where I still had to pay a portion. When I got my water heater replaced, I still had to pay out-of-pocket.
I typically make service requests online, which is straightforward. However, the interaction is predominantly impersonal, making it feel more transactional. One downside I’ve experienced is the lack of transparency regarding coverage. For instance, I was surprised to find out that my upright freezer wasn’t covered because it wasn't a refrigerator/freezer combo. This information emerged only after the technician’s visit, resulting in some unnecessary charges and inconvenience.
My dealings with their customer service have been mixed. Some representatives seem uninformed on coverage details and often need to consult supervisors for simple queries, which can be frustrating. The overall customer service experience would rate a 2 out of 5 due to these issues.
Despite these occurrences, I still find the service to be reasonably priced for what’s covered. The website itself is easy to navigate, mainly focusing on service requests, which is quite user-friendly and would also rate a 4 out of 5.
Overall, American Home Shield has provided a decent service, although the quality seems to have fluctuated over the years. I'd give my overall experience a 3 out of 5 as their initial service was excellent, but recent interactions have been less satisfactory.
Dear William,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2025
I had a claim with American Home Shield regarding a pool heater that was not working correctly. When the contractors came to inspect it, they denied my claim. They said it was a commercial heater, which puzzled me since this heater has been a part of my pool since I bought the house in 2009. Consequently, I've been left to handle the repair out of pocket since the company refuses to cover it.
I've been with American Home Shield for about ten years. My previous experiences were satisfactory. They've replaced several items in my house, like an oven, washing machine, and a tankless water heater without any issue. The technician they sent for the heater seemed knowledgeable, identifying the problem as a possible issue with a relay and commenting on the age of the unit. However, they never followed up after informing me that they wouldn't cover the repair.
I am disappointed with the lack of direct contact with their customer service. It's frustrating not being able to speak to someone directly or having a proper channel to dispute the claim. Despite my past satisfaction, this experience has left me very dissatisfied with American Home Shield.
Dear Glenn,
I'd like to thank you for bringing this to our attention. I apologize for the difficulties you've been experiencing and would like to discuss this more. Feel free to contact me at consumeraffairs@ahs.com.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I've had American Home Shield for about 9 to 10 years, ever since I moved into my house. My experience with them has been mostly positive. Recently, they sent someone out for plumbing issues with my sink, garbage disposal, and sprayer. The contractor was excellent and did all that was expected of him. Typically, the claim process takes only a few days, though at times, I've had to wait for parts.
There was a negative experience last year when communication was poor. My hot water tank was leaking during the summer, and I had to go to the gym for showers. The company frequently changed their appointment times, which was incredibly frustrating as I had to take time off work. They once tried to schedule a repair late at night, which I declined because I live alone with my daughter. It would have been easier if they just informed me about delays.
Apart from that incident, the vendors they usually send out are good. I prefer to use those who are familiar with my home, like those who originally installed my systems. Even though I've had some pricing disputes with American Home Shield in the past, I believe they are one of the best companies, which is why I continue to use them. Overall, I would rate my experience as a 4 out of 5.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
May Heating & Air came out for my furnace that wasn't heating properly, leaving my house quite chilly. I found the claims submission process much easier this time than in the past.
The technician from May Heating seemed more knowledgeable than previous ones. I’ve had issues with technicians not being able to fit into tight spaces like under the house or in the attic, but this guy was more competent. However, there was an issue with the unit's power supply, which led to a frustrating back-and-forth between the HVAC and electrical guys. They wouldn't address the electrical issue, which left me stuck. Eventually, they just added some freon, claiming it would fix the heating, though I remembered being told before that repeatedly adding freon signified a leak.
Rating American Home Shield, I'd say a 3 or 4 out of 5. They've improved over time, but they're still not as exceptional as my experience with Old Republic. What I appreciate about American Home Shield is the ease of making claims online. However, sometimes there are language barriers when calling customer service, which can be challenging.
If I were to recommend American Home Shield to friends or family, I'd say they're not bad. They offer competitive deals and are one of the companies I'd suggest, alongside Old Republic.
Overall, while the renewal rate increased, which they explained was due to rising costs, I decided to give them another chance. Though I hope costs stabilize, I'm optimistic about the service standard improving.
Dear Karen,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
American Home Shield handled a plumbing issue for me. Initially, the process had its ups and downs, especially in terms of the contractor lineup. It felt like they don't always choose the top-rated contractors, but instead, those who are more familiar with the fine print, which can lead to initial job rejections.
The first contractor they sent claimed that parts were missing and couldn't complete the job, which I found inaccurate. Fortunately, after I refused to pay more, they sent a second contractor who managed to fix everything that the first one couldn't. That resolved the issue, and the appliance has been working fine since the repair.
While I appreciate having this kind of insurance because it's tough finding reliable contractors across the US, there were pricing concerns. Even though they advertise plans in the range of $45-$50, my plan has unexpectedly increased to over $80. I might have to cancel and re-sign to get a better rate. While it involves a 30-day waiting period, I can wait 30 days to get the lower price.
Overall, I'd say the service is decent and cost-effective compared to other limited options, and I would recommend it. However, their approach to pricing and contractor selection could use some improvement.
Hello Muhammad, and thank you for the review. I apologize for the issues you encountered with the first contractor who was assigned. I'm glad that our next vendor was able to resolve the situation.
I do understand your concerns regarding pricing; in this current inflationary period, cost-efficiency is on most of our minds. AHS is working to maintain the lowest possible cost to our homeowners for even the most expensive repairs. We appreciate your business, and this is one of the ways that we show that.
I hope that you will continue to make use of our warranty in the future.
Best wishes,Ken
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I had an unsatisfactory experience with American Home Shield. After remodeling my kitchen a few years ago, I encountered a leak under the sink, which caused damage to my floor and cabinets. Despite having a policy with American Home Shield, the service process was frustrating and inadequate.
When I submitted a claim online, it cost me $125, with the expectation that a plumber would address the issues. However, scheduling the appointment took almost three weeks due to rescheduling, and communication with the plumber was lacking. Once the plumber finally visited, the service cost unexpectedly amounted to nearly $500 for issues that American Home Shield wouldn't cover, citing improper installation during my initial remodel.
Despite requesting email communication about a possible payout, as of yet, I haven't received any follow-up. While their online tools and customer service were satisfactory, I am disappointed with the coverage provided and ultimately plan to cancel my policy. Overall, I found the coverage to be unsatisfactory, even though I had initially signed up based on positive recommendations from friends.
Dear Tracy,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I had a clogged sink stopper that needed fixing. Whenever I've tried using American Home Shield's online system, it fails and directs me through unnecessarily complicated steps. So, I've had to resort to calling their customer service. Though I would prefer not to, the representatives I've interacted with are usually pretty good. They note down the issue and within the stated timeframe, I can expect a call to schedule an appointment. A1 Plumbing came out as planned, and I have had no issues since. However, I am expecting another service visit soon for a different appliance - my dishwasher.
I'd rate my experience with A1 Plumbing and American Home Shield as a 4 out of 5. Their customer service is courteous and gets the job done. For the costs associated with their service, I'd also give them a 4 out of 5. My biggest gripe is with their website - it doesn't function for me. Even after inputting my contract number and following all required steps, it still doesn't allow me to book service. Due to this ongoing issue, I would rate their online platform a 2 out of 5.
Dear Robert,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I needed to make a claim with American Home Shield for my hot water heater. The control valve was not working, and after a few days, a contractor was sent. He mentioned needing to order a part but since then, I haven't received any updates on the status of this order. This lack of communication has been a bit frustrating.
My past experiences with American Home Shield have been mixed. The first time I needed service was for my refrigerator, which took about three weeks to repair. Unfortunately, it only lasted a month before I had to contact them again and pay once more. The second repair was faster, taking about 10 days, and the refrigerator is now functioning properly.
When it comes to their customer service, it typically starts well but lacks follow-through, primarily due to the vendors. If I were to rate my customer service experience, I'd give it a 4 out of 5. As for the overall coverage and product, I would give it a 5. The website is user-friendly and navigable, and I rate it a 5 as well.
My decision to go with American Home Shield was influenced by my realtor during the purchase of my new home. As for the price, I feel it's fair. Overall, while American Home Shield is a fine company, they could benefit from ensuring their vendors are efficient and reliable.
Dear Richard,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I recently had an experience where American Home Shield arranged for Twin City Appliance to check out our fridge, which wasn't cooling properly. The technician initially thought it might need a Freon reload, but since Twin City didn't handle that, they transferred us to another company. This new company discovered that no Freon was needed. the issue was just a buildup of dust and dirt inside the refrigerator. Once cleared, our fridge started cooling immediately, and we haven't had any issues since.
I generally set up requests through American Home Shield online. They responded quickly Even though it was on a weekend. Twin City called me on a Sunday and asked if it was OK to come out Monday morning.
I've been with American Home Shield for about a year and have been very satisfied with their service. I would definitely recommend them to friends or family considering a warranty and tell them it's a good idea. Their pricing is reasonable. Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been excellent.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield has been a mixed bag. Recently, we had a leak in our washing machine, and they were able to send a contractor in a timely fashion to replace a pump and a hose. We live in a rural area, so finding a contractor quickly was a pleasant surprise, and they did a very good job once they arrived.
However, the process of submitting a claim is frustrating. The customer service representatives are difficult to understand, possibly due to reading from scripts and being from another country, which happens every time I call. It often takes too long to find a contractor as well. Despite these challenges, my past interactions with the technicians have been positive – they are competent and perform the necessary repairs.
While the coverage provided by American Home Shield is satisfactory, at times it feels overpriced for the service level. The online tools have not impressed me either. Overall, the technicians are reliable once they are assigned, but the initial steps to get service leave much to be desired. We plan to terminate our contract within a month as we are preparing to move.
Hi Kenneth, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2025
I've been with American Home Shield for nearly two years, and my experience has been positive overall. Recently, I had a claim involving hers and his plumbing services because my toilet was unsteady. The technicians resolved it efficiently, stabilizing the toilet, and I was very pleased with their service. So far, all the technicians dispatched by ahs have been excellent.
Having this coverage has been especially important because my husband used to handle all our repairs, but due to his illness, he's unable to do so now. Ahs has been a great help, offering peace of mind and eliminating concerns about unexpected repair costs. It’s truly been a blessing, and I plan to continue using their services.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had Elite Electric Solutions come out through American Home Shield because there was an issue with the electrical system; a line was off. They resolved it quickly within five minutes, and since then, everything has been working fine. I initially set up the service online with American Home Shield. I found the process efficient, as they were prompt with the service. However, I had questions about potential charges if I needed service for different issues at the same time, like kitchen versus electrical problems, but it seems they charge once per claim, which I found satisfactory.
My overall experience with American Home Shield has been positive, though the first time I needed them for an air conditioning issue, it was rather challenging. It took three attempts from the mechanic to fix it, leaving the air conditioning system off for 2 days, which was inconvenient. Because of this, I'd rate the air conditioning service as three stars. On the other hand, the electrical issue was resolved promptly, and I'd give it five stars for that. In general, I'm satisfied with the service, especially since they handle things on time, and I would recommend them to a friend.
Dear Keramat,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I have been a customer of American Home Shield for roughly three to four years. Recently, I placed a claim due to a slight leak beneath my bathroom faucet's valve, which required attention. The service technician sent out by American Home Shield only managed to replace the valve and handle to address the leak but did not change the faucet as needed. The technician cited water pressure from the street as a reason, which I found confusing, since other faucets in my home do not have this issue. I've used the existing faucet for months by manually turning the hot water valve on and off, likely leading to this leak.
Disappointingly, they refused to replace the faucet despite it being covered in the contract. My dissatisfaction extended to the technician leaving a bag of trash in my driveway, which was unrelated to my job, and there was no follow-up after I reported his rude behavior. Though I requested a different contractor to address the incomplete job, no one else was sent. On one occasion, they had to send another technician to finish the plumbing work previously attempted by someone else. Given these experiences, if improvements aren't made soon, I may consider another company. The cost of the service, which is about $1,200 a year plus $100 per call, warrants reliable service and attentive follow-ups.
Dear Kelly,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My recent experience with American Home Shield has been frustrating and unsatisfactory. I filed a claim for a double oven replacement, and despite following the necessary procedures, I'm currently in a disagreement with the company over the reimbursement amount. I found their customer service lacking, as they hung up on me multiple times when I expressed my dissatisfaction with the compensation offered, which is not enough to replace the appliance.
Submitting the claim wasn't straightforward. They initially sent a contractor to assess the situation, but I had to request a second opinion, as I frequently do, due to their initial reluctance to cover replacement costs. This incurs an additional $125 for each assessment. Although the contractors acted professionally, the final resolution wasn't favorable to me. The company deducted $703 to cover the service calls, making it impossible for me to replace the appliance with the cash received. American Home Shield's customer service needs significant improvement. Hanging up on customers who challenge their decisions is unprofessional. I'm paying them monthly for reliability in times of need, yet they seem to evade their responsibilities.
Hi Timothy, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
American Home Shield sent American Comfort for the furnace. They're very good. I've had them before, and when they say they're gonna be there, they're gonna be there. As far as the repair, so far, so good. I've had American Home Shield for a long time and I have no intention of changing. I'm satisfied with my plan. It covers a lot of stuff. I'm happy with the service.
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I have been a customer of American Home Shield on and off for nearly 20 years. My experiences have varied over the years. Recently, I had an issue with Chesapeake Appliance and Repair. They were supposed to order parts for my microwave and didn't follow through. When they came back, they only installed a light bulb and the issue persisted with noise from the fan. They then asked for another claim for a separate issue, and I was unhappy with the continued deductible charges.
Despite these frustrations, I appreciate the coverage American Home Shield offers. They cover appliances and systems, offering peace of mind with the payment of a deductible. However, the reliability of the contractors they send out is sometimes inconsistent, and the rising monthly fees, which started at $55 and are now over $100 for some policies, are concerning.
The service does offer good coverage when claims are approved, and they often help offset costs for larger replacements, like my heating system. However, there have been occasions where claims are denied over small technicalities, which is frustrating. The customer service is decent, and overall, I would rate American Home Shield a 3 out of 5 for coverage and customer service. The increase in pricing is significant, and I would rate it 2 out of 5.
Dear Miguel,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield has been quite positive. We had an issue with our dishwasher where water was leaking at the bottom. When the technician came, he discovered that the dishwasher was not installed correctly initially, although it was someone else's installation, not by American Home Shield. The dishwasher was unlevel, causing the leak. The technician fixed this during his first visit and also identified that the wrong brackets were used. Though the correct brackets were eventually found, they couldn't be installed as intended. The technician worked diligently to secure the dishwasher with the existing brackets in a way that met our needs. We were very happy with his efforts, although the time it took to get the parts was long enough that he forgot the reason for his return call. Despite this, everything was resolved, and the dishwasher works perfectly now.
Additionally, my husband had a mishap involving the dishwasher, and thankfully, it held up well. We've had to utilize American Home Shield's services for other issues, such as our furnace, which we felt might have shortcuts due to the way our townhouse was built. Each time, they've responded promptly, which has been reassuring. Overall, we're satisfied with American Home Shield as they've helped us rectify various issues. Although we are new to using such a service since moving from rural Iowa, the fees seem reasonable because we only had to pay once for an issue like the dishwasher, even if the technician returned. We've filed claims both by calling and online, and both methods have worked well for us.
We're happy with American Home Shield and would feel comfortable rating them positively based on our experiences.
Dear Jolene,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had an issue with my washing machine and contacted American Home Shield for assistance. I usually file my service requests over the phone through an automated system. After I filed the request, it took a couple of days for a contractor to be sent to my home. The contractor was very helpful and knowledgeable and took about half an hour to diagnose the issue. Unfortunately, they couldn't fix it on the first visit, and we had to get the machine replaced.
American Home Shield provided us with a list of replacement options, and we could choose the one we wanted. Depending on our choice, we could contribute additional money towards the new machine. The replacement was supposed to arrive on a Wednesday but eventually came on a Friday, so it took about a week in total. The new washing machine has been perfect since it arrived, and I've had no more issues with it. While they were helpful, I find the service expensive. I prefer to remain anonymous in sharing this review.
Dear Roxanne,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield and my experience was quite positive. The issue was with a leaking expansion tank related to my furnace heating system. I submitted the claim online, and the process was straightforward and user-friendly. American Home Shield responded promptly with an email stating that WarHold Mechanicals LLC would be in touch, and they did contact me directly.
When WarHold Mechanicals LLC arrived, they assessed the situation, explained the issue, and began working. They determined the necessary parts needed to be ordered, which took about 3-4 days to arrive. Once the parts were in, they returned and completed the repair. Currently, everything is operating smoothly, although I'm in need of a new thermostat, which is unrelated to the initial issue.
I've been with American Home Shield for over two years, thanks to recommendations from my brother and real estate agent. I'm very satisfied with the service. The process is simple; if I have an issue, I can email or call, and if it is covered, I just pay the deductible and they send someone to resolve it. It's really hassle-free, and they don't bombard you with unnecessary questions.
Overall, I'd rate my experience with American Home Shield as excellent, as it provides a straightforward solution for home warranty needs.
Dear William,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
The furnace unit was malfunctioning; it would work intermittently. When the technician from AirMax first came out, they ran some tests, and it seemed to be working fine, so they couldn't find anything wrong. But the problem persisted after a few days, so a different technician came back. This time, they identified an issue with air intake related to a plate or sensor.
The technician could not repair it on the first visit because they needed to order parts. I initially waited about four days and ended up calling Air Max myself to follow up on the part order. It turned out there had been a delay because American Home Shield needed to approve the order, which hadn't been done. Once I gave the go-ahead, the parts arrived in a couple of days. As for the technicians who were sent out, they were very professional and polite. However, I did have a previous issue with a different technician when dealing with an AC unit, and I requested not to have that person come out again.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I had a claim for my washing machine. The issue was that the tub wasn't spinning during the spin cycle. I submitted the claim through their website, which was straightforward and easy to navigate. After submitting, I was contacted the next day by the dispatcher to schedule the appointment.
The contractor from Assist Services TNINC arrived on time and was very professional. Although he didn't explain the repair process in detail, he identified that the clutch needed replacement. The part had to be ordered, but he returned within a couple of days, as promised, to complete the repair. Now, even though my washer is an older model, it's working fine.
I would rate my experience with American Home Shield as highly satisfactory. This was my second claim with them, and both experiences were smooth, with prompt and professional service. For the first claim, involving a dishwasher, the process was similarly efficient, with the repairs completed in a timely manner.
Overall, I would recommend American Home Shield to friends and family for their reliable service.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a frustrating experience with American Home Shield and their contractor, Patio Pools. The ongoing issue began when there was a problem with the pool filter. Patio Pools came out and diagnosed the issue, but after supposedly making repairs, a leak appeared. Despite my concerns, they insisted it was a coincidence.
The situation worsened when we had freezing temperatures, and Patio Pools neglected to secure the leak, risking damage to underground pipes. This oversight was alarming, especially since I'm located in a high desert area that can get quite cold.
Throughout this ordeal, American Home Shield has been supportive by ensuring I only pay the deductible. However, Patio Pools sent me invoices totaling around $2,900, which I was not responsible for due to the coverage. It’s concerning because I believe there might be others who have wrongly paid these invoices, suggesting a potential pattern of deceptive billing practices.
Patio Pools’ service quality has been lacking. There was still debris entering my pool even after they said the filter was fixed. They took pictures at my request to document the situation, which revealed plastic inside the filter, something my pool maintenance person confirmed should not be there. This raised doubts about Patio Pools’ competence, especially since they are the ones who originally built the pool.
American Home Shield handled my inquiries efficiently and reassured me that they have taken note of the billing issue. They promised to flag Patio Pools in their system, preventing future assignments of this vendor to my property.
This experience has been drawn out since November, characterized by numerous delays and unprofessional behavior from Patio Pools, including missed appointments and a lack of transparency. I was informed that American Home Shield may not use Patio Pools again, and I was advised to recommend a preferred contractor should future issues arise.
Overall, American Home Shield’s support has been commendable, but the challenge lies with Patio Pools’ poor service and potential fraudulent billing practices. I hope American Home Shield investigates this further for the benefit of all their customers.
Dear Jodi,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had to use American Home Shield for a broken dishwasher, and I was impressed by their service. They dispatched a technician within 2 to 3 days, which was quite prompt. The technician was very nice and efficient, managing to fix the appliance on the same day. The dishwasher is now working perfectly fine.
I've been sharing my positive experience with friends as I genuinely like the service from American Home Shield. Overall, I've had a great experience with their service, price, and coverage.
Dear Michelle,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I've been with American Home Shield for over 10 years, ever since we bought our house. One of the things I appreciate about American Home Shield is how promptly they handle payments and dispatch service technicians. For instance, during a recent freeze when our heater stopped working, they sent someone immediately. The experience with Blue Sky Heating, who handled our heating, was positive. Additionally, another company dealt with our air conditioning issue quickly as well.
The technicians were professional and respectful. After some issues were initially identified by an inspector, such as exposed wires that should have been covered, they returned promptly to rectify these problems. Now everything is working perfectly.
Overall, I've never had a problem with American Home Shield. Although the cost tends to rise, the security and peace of mind it offers during emergencies are invaluable. I'd never consider getting rid of it.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield involving a claim for a furnace cleaning. During the process, the contractor discovered a gas leak, which was caused by a loose screw. The claim submission went smoothly; the repair technician contacted American Home Shield, explained the issue, took a photo, and mentioned the claim deduction of $125. The repair was quickly taken care of, and I appreciated the courteous service from the contractor. My units functioned well afterward, except for a thermostat issue due to an unclosed furnace door, which was resolved.
This is my first year with American Home Shield, and my overall experience has been great. The customer service is friendly and there's been some confusion due to having two units with similar coverage, but it was handled well. I've also dealt with a refrigerator claim previously, which also went smoothly.
In terms of customer service, coverage, and the sales process, I would rate everything a 5. Although I felt slightly overwhelmed by the marketing, the service I received was excellent. Additionally, the pricing was fair, offering comparable options to what I had for my refrigerator, and I had the freedom to choose where to make the purchase. As for the online tools, while I haven’t used them recently, my previous experience would rate them as a 5 too. Overall, I have been very pleased with my experience with American Home Shield.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I sent in a claim experience with American Home Shield concerning my non-working dryer. Initially, the process went smoothly as they responded within a few days. They sent two contractors, and the second one was particularly knowledgeable and took the time to explain everything clearly, which I appreciated.
Eventually, they replaced my dryer, and I was delighted with the replacement process. The new machine is functioning fantastically and is of excellent quality. I expected a cheaper model, but they offered several choices, making me very impressed with the quality I received.
I also had a separate issue with plumbing, where they sent three people to address the problem. Although there was some uncertainty because it was underground, they managed to resolve it satisfactorily.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been positive, and I would definitely recommend their services.
Dear Samuel,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I've been a customer of American Home Shield since 1984, and my overall experience has been quite positive. Recently, I had a claim where they sent someone promptly, and the person was both personable and professional. They were able to address and complete the repairs the same day, which was very convenient.
Though I usually set up calls through their automated service, the turnaround for the service was quick—usually within a day or two. I value this efficiency, and as a result, I often recommend American Home Shield to others.
However, there was one instance around two years ago regarding my water heater where the situation was quite urgent. The experience was less than satisfactory mainly due to a challenging communication process, possibly because the support center was located overseas.
Despite this, I would still rate my overall experience with American Home Shield highly, giving them a solid 5 stars because I have frequently recommended them. However, my only concern is the increased pricing and copays, which have noticeably risen over time, affecting my rating of their pricing to about 4 stars. Overall, I appreciate their service and efficiency.
Dear DeAn,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a positive experience with American Home Shield. I filed a claim to fix my broken dishwasher. Submitting the claim was straightforward, though it took over two weeks for the contractor to arrive. Once they did, they performed well, and my dishwasher has been working very well since the repair. I would rate American Home Shield a 4 out of 5 for their service. Their customer service and overall warranty product are both excellent, earning a 5 out of 5. The sales and marketing process, as well as the pricing, were also top-notch. The website functionality was good, deserving a 4 out of 5 rating. Overall, I'm satisfied with my experience.
Dear Hamdi,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield regarding my washing machine. The process was smooth, and they efficiently arranged for it to be fixed. The contractor sent by American Home Shield was friendly, efficient, and thorough, leaving me with no complaints. Since the repair, my washer has been working fine. Overall, I've found American Home Shield useful for the standard maintenance that comes with owning a home. It has saved me money compared to independently finding a repair person.
Dear Matthew,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield which left me with mixed feelings. A plumber from Honest Plumber INC, sent by American Home Shield, was quite unprofessional and alarmed my tenant with exaggerated claims about the plumbing and the need for a complete rework. When I expressed my dissatisfaction and requested not to have that technician return, I was told by the company that they might discontinue services at my property, which was quite frustrating.
Despite this, previous claims have generally been handled well. The process of calling in a claim is straightforward, but the response time can be a problem. For instance, when our only bathroom was out of service, they took too long to address the issue, which is quite inconvenient when there's no alternative.
Though I've mostly had good experiences otherwise, this particular incident stands out. I would rate American Home Shield a 3 out of 5 due to the slow emergency response and the issue with the plumber.
Overall, I have recommended American Home Shield to family members, and some have taken up the service. I appreciate having a service that can quickly connect me with contractors since I'm not familiar with local plumbers or handymen myself. However, I also had a case where I had to pay $5,000 out of pocket for a new air conditioning system, while a friend of mine, a fellow recommender, had a similar installation for less, raising questions about pricing.
In terms of customer service, I would rate it a 3 out of 5 because communication can sometimes be difficult. For the price and coverage, I feel it's a mixed bag, warranting a 4 for price. This reflects the fluctuation in cost-sharing based on the service provider they connect with.
Dear Mary Ann,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My most recent experience with American Home Shield involved a claim for a hot water tank issue. The claim submission process went smoothly, and the contractors performed well. However, I was charged extra for things I believed should have been covered in the installation. In the past, I have often encountered additional charges above the standard $125 deductible, which usually end up doubling that cost. This recurring issue is unsatisfactory, and I am contemplating canceling my service with them.
Hi Ronnie, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
As a homeowner with a warranty through American Home Shield, I recently contacted them to address a non-functioning spigot and a toilet issue in my home. Unfortunately, my experience was far from satisfactory. From the start, customer service was poor, and despite the initial claim being made nearly a month ago, the spigot is still not repaired, and the toilet was fixed incorrectly.
The first plumber they sent was unprofessional; he installed an incorrect water supply line and, when I pointed out the mistake based on my experience in real estate, he responded rudely and left abruptly. This kind of service is simply unacceptable. To make matters worse, this same plumber had issues two years prior with a similar repair, which resulted in the rejection of the claim back then as well.
While the representatives from American Home Shield are polite and apologetic, their apologies come with no resolution. The entire situation has been incredibly frustrating, especially when I consider the cost of $700 annually for their services and the increased service fees. After this experience, I am seriously considering canceling my policy once the current issues are hopefully resolved in another week.
I felt it necessary to share my experience because the frustration and lack of service from both American Home Shield and their assigned plumbing company have caused unnecessary stress and inconvenience. This experience has also affected my ability to recommend American Home Shield to my real estate clients, as both my clients and I have faced similar negative experiences.
Hi Jim, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I had a plumbing issue with my home, which caused a leak in the ceiling. When I contacted American Home Shield, they sent a technician to diagnose the problem. The technician identified the issue as a leaking toilet and promptly replaced the necessary part. The repair was completed the same day, and I haven't experienced any further leaks since then.
Overall, my experiences with American Home Shield have been generally positive, although it varies. While sometimes the technicians fix issues on the first visit, there are occasions when they need to come back because parts need to be ordered. They usually resolve issues in a timely and efficient manner.
Dear Jimmy,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently submitted a claim with American Home Shield because my hot water heater was leaking. I used their online system, which was fairly easy to navigate. Before Gateway Plumbing LLC came out, I received a text to schedule the appointment, and that was the extent of the information provided.
When Gateway Plumbing arrived, I found the technicians to be nice, but unfortunately, the hot water heater is still not fixed. I haven't been informed yet whether it will be repaired or replaced.
I've been with American Home Shield on and off since about 1999, often due to our moving as part of military life. While generally we've had good experiences in the various homes we've insured, there have been issues, such as when I couldn't get service for my stove and dishwasher three years ago, leading me to just buy new ones. Despite this, I generally find the service beneficial, particularly for people who can't afford to replace items outright. It's been useful when things break, though there have been many years we've paid without needing to use the service.
Overall, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield as excellent and would recommend them to friends, especially for new homeowners. However, I'd advise potential customers to consider that while the service fee may be more manageable than replacing appliances, service availability can vary based on location.
Dear Charlene,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I initially had a roofing issue, specifically a leak. I submitted a claim to American Home Shield by calling them directly, and I found it quite easy to reach a representative. The interaction with the agent was straightforward. When Elite Roofing LLC came out to address the problem, the experience was great, very intuitive, and straightforward. They managed to correct the issue temporarily and provided me with options for either replacing the entire roof or just fixing it. I believe they handled it well.
I've been with American Home Shield for about two to three years for peace of mind. What I like most about the service is how fast and reliable it is. However, I think it would be better if there was more clarity on what is included and what is not before signing up for any service. I would tell friends and family that American Home Shield is worth it.
Dear Charif,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently filed a claim with American Home Shield for my central heater, which had gone out during a particularly cold period. The initial technician thought the issue was fixed after adjusting the thermostat, but it wasn’t. However, they promptly sent another technician named Michael, who was great. He quickly diagnosed the problem and ordered the necessary parts, which were installed within two to three days. This efficiency was impressive, especially since my previous service provider took two weeks to respond to similar issues.
Submitting the claim was straightforward. I prefer calling them directly, and they were quick to process my information and provide follow-up details via email. The contractor they sent was excellent, offering additional maintenance suggestions that proved helpful.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been positive. They responded swiftly and accurately, which is why I trust their services. In the 20 years I’ve lived in my home, I never realized my heater needed significant repairs until now – the improvement was remarkable.
I highly recommend American Home Shield for their prompt service and excellent contractor connections. My overall satisfaction and their coverage of my warranty have been excellent. The only small downside was the $125 service fee, but it’s worth it considering the quality of service received. I've been very pleased with their performance, especially their ability to quickly get the right people out for service and repairs.
Dear Cotessa,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I had a service experience with American Home Shield and Sears regarding my stove. Unfortunately, the technician from Sears wasn't very professional, and the quality of the work was not what I expected. Prior to their visit, they asked me to provide detailed information about my stove, such as the model number but since it came with the house and I had no paperwork. They said this information was necessary to ensure they had the right parts when the technician arrived so I had to look for the model number. However, when the technician came, he asked me to move the stove myself and after inspecting it, he mentioned that a part had to be ordered and left without much communication.
The board they ordered arrived at my house, contrary to my expectations of it being sent to their service center. This miscommunication delayed the repair by another week. Eventually, they came back when scheduled, installed the part, and left without much interaction. Although the stove was working after that, the service experience was less than satisfactory.
Hi Zsatari, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I had a mixed experience with American Home Shield. I initially contacted them for a plumbing issue involving a clogged pipe. The first contractor they sent, FAHR Home Solutions, didn't have the necessary equipment to fix the problem completely, as their router was only 25 feet long. American Home Shield then identified a second contractor, Showers Plumbing, who had the appropriate tools and expertise to resolve the issue. While the second contractor was excellent, the delay in finding them was frustrating, taking about 2.5 weeks overall. The technicians themselves were professional and courteous. My main concern was the time it took for American Home Shield to locate a suitable contractor. During the delay, I was inconvenienced as the clogged pipe affected my laundry room, kitchen, and bathroom, preventing me from using them.
On a positive note, I previously experienced a very efficient service from American Home Shield when dealing with an air conditioning issue. The swift response and effective resolution made that situation much easier to handle. The contrast between these two experiences highlighted the variability in service response depending on the type of issue. Overall, I understand the nature of home warranties, but the time taken to resolve the plumbing issue was lengthy and frustrating. Despite this, I acknowledge the satisfactory resolution once the right contractor was found.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a mixed experience with American Home Shield. I had a claim for my furnace, and the contractor they sent was knowledgeable and courteous. They had to come out twice as the initial diagnosis wasn’t correct, but eventually, the problem was fixed, and the furnace has been working fine since then.
However, my first experience with American Home Shield was less satisfactory. I had issues with some valves, and the plumber they sent was unprofessional, both in appearance and service. He opted to spray WD-40 on the valves instead of replacing them, which didn’t resolve the issue.
Despite the initial hiccup, subsequent experiences improved. A different contractor successfully addressed problems with my refrigerator, and the furnace repair team was persistent in resolving the issue.
One aspect that stood out as challenging was the dual-company structure American Home Shield operates under. It was confusing to deal with two different entities, making the process complicated and unclear at times. Additionally, I found their online tools difficult to use and preferred speaking to someone directly.
Overall, while my experiences with the contractors were varied, the warranty coverage itself was satisfactory, though the pricing might be a bit high for what you get.
Dear Philip,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield where Fast Response Heating and Cooling came out to replace parts under my house because I didn't have heat for two weeks. They were excellent — in and out quickly, and I'm grateful for that. It happened back in January and they responded very fast. The claim process was smooth; they had to order parts, which took about two days, but once the parts arrived, they replaced them, and I had heat back on.
This was my first experience with American Home Shield and I was very pleased with the company they contracted. The overall service cost is worth it, though I was confused about the $3,000 replacement fee for a new unit, as I thought it would be a total replacement. Nevertheless, I'm doing fine for now and thankful for their help. At 66, I still work and need reliable service without getting taken advantage of. Repairmen have let me down before, but Fast Response was fantastic.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had my washing machine replaced through a claim with American Home Shield. My fiancé was at home when the technician visited, and he mentioned that the technician was nice and thorough. The process was quite quick. After the technician assessed the situation, they determined that the machine was too old and needed replacement. American Home Shield swiftly followed up, sending me the paperwork to choose a new machine. Within about two weeks, I received the replacement, and it has been working perfectly so far.
Dear Haleigh,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had my washer repaired by Alert Appliances through my home warranty company, American Home Shield. I reached them by phone, and I would describe the customer service as average. The turnaround time for them to get a repair technician out was a little over 24 hours, nearly 48 hours. The technician had to order parts and return to complete the repair, but since then, my washer has been working fine with no further issues. If a friend asked about my experience, I would tell them it was average regarding the efficiency and quality of service.
Dear Ron,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently dealt with American Home Shield for a hot water heater issue, and I'm satisfied with the outcome. When I submitted the claim, the process went smoothly, which was a pleasant surprise as I was considering switching companies a couple of years ago due to frustration. However, they've significantly improved. The contractors were kind, knowledgeable, and efficient, getting the job done quickly. Since the repair, everything has worked perfectly. While I have no complaints about the service, I do wish my monthly payments could be lower.
Dear Michele,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a plumbing issue and submitted a claim with American Home Shield. The process was very simple and easy. The contractor they sent out was fantastic—very courteous and thoroughly answered all of my questions. The repair was done flawlessly, and I've had no problems since.
Dear Michael,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I have been using American Home Shield for about a year and a half now. Recently, I had an issue with my oven. It wasn't functioning correctly, so American Home Shield sent Sears out to take a look. They tried to repair it, but ultimately they couldn't fix it and ended up giving me money to purchase a new one because the part required wasn't working. This process took about two months, but I didn't mind since they attempted a quick temporary fix initially.
Overall, I've filed four claims with them, and three of those went smoothly. However, there was one instance where the vendor came out and claimed everything was fine, even though it clearly wasn't. In the end, I explained the situation to American Home Shield, and they refunded me the charge, which was good customer service.
One area for improvement is their customer service response time, especially when trying to reach someone in a leadership or managerial role—it can take quite a while.
As for their vendors, it's hit or miss—some are great, while others are just average. Generally, I'd rate my experience with American Home Shield as a solid four out of five.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I had a frustrating experience with American Home Shield. My hot water heater went out, and I needed both my toilet and shower handle fixed due to a broken cartridge. Initially, when I reached out, it was difficult to get someone from American Home Shield to listen to my issues. And the plumbing company they sent was quick to inform me that nothing was covered under my contract.
The plumber quoted around $275 for the hot water heater replacement, insisting that it wasn't covered. However, after some back-and-forth and a lot of phone calls, it turned out that the valves were covered. The main issue was a miscommunication which seemed to stem both from the language barrier with the plumber and the assumptions made by the plumbing company. Eventually, a three-way call with American Home Shield and the plumbing company sorted it out.
While the plumber sent was hard to understand, he did help by leaving the old parts with me, proving no modifications were made. The parts were just replaced, which contradicted what had initially been recorded.
While my online claim experience was smooth, as the platform is straightforward to use, the customer service over the phone was lacking. I needed to make about 12 calls in a short period to get through to a helpful representative. In terms of repair quality, everything has been working fine since the adjustments.
When it comes to costs, I faced an issue with the pricing of a shower handle that wasn't covered. The company's quotation wildly exceeded what I could find on my own from retailers, which was quite frustrating.
Overall, while the American Home Shield's website is user-friendly, the persistent issues with customer service and pricing discrepancies made my experience less than satisfactory.
Dear Susan,
I'd like to thank you for bringing this to our attention. I apologize for the difficulties you've been experiencing and would like to discuss this more. Feel free to contact me at consumeraffairs@ahs.com.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
Recently, I requested service for the lights in my bathroom, but American Home Shield informed me that this wasn't covered under their plan, and I ended up fixing it myself. In the past, I had an issue with my dishwasher, and they came to fix it without any problems, which was a positive experience.
Generally, their customer service is good. They have a dispatch center that helps in scheduling appointments and arranging maintenance, which I find convenient. However, I do think there’s room for improvement, hence why I would rate my overall experience with American Home Shield a 3 out of 5. Their customer service experience gets a 4, indicating I’m quite satisfied with it.
As for the pricing, I feel it’s average. I use their website frequently to log in and request services, and it's quite user-friendly.
Dear
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My recent experience with American Home Shield has been quite disappointing. We had an issue with our water heater, which needed to be replaced. The new one provided by the company didn’t match the capacity or efficiency of our previous one. The one we had was a 66-gallon and it was energy-efficient and it would go from hybrid to electric once we wanted it to go electric if we needed more warm water, but this one isn't. It's not even near to what we had. Our home requires a larger unit due to its size, but we received a smaller, less efficient model. The contractor, Free Water Plumbing LLC, was professional and did the best with what was approved, but it wasn’t what we needed.
The process of getting the replacement took longer than expected. Despite stressing the urgency due to water leakage in our garage during freezing weather, it took a while for the situation to be resolved. Initially, the contractor made temporary repairs, but the problem persisted until the entire unit was eventually replaced.
In the past, I've had positive experiences with American Home Shield, especially with an older home where they provided excellent service. However, with this incident, I feel very dissatisfied. If I were to rate them, I'd give a 2.5 out of 5 stars currently. The customer service at the beginning was great. But what I encountered during this last experience was disappointing as they didn't address my concerns adequately. The customer service rep didn't understand where I was coming from, with the unit that I replaced. She said it was what was approved and that's what they could provide for me. While their website and coverage have been solid, the service during this case didn't meet my expectations. I would caution others to ensure they communicate their needs clearly when dealing with them.
Hi Martha, We understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield for a broken pipe and submitted my request for service online. The online process was standard, as I didn't interact directly with a representative, which made it neither a bad nor a good experience. When the contractors arrived, the experience was fine, and the pipes have been working well since the repair.
Although I haven't engaged with American Home Shield's customer service in recent years, I remember it being much easier to deal with early on. It feels like there's more red tape now, perhaps due to an increased customer base.
I'm satisfied with the coverage provided by my warranty; I'd rate this past service as a 5. However, I find the product price to be less favorable, rating it a 2. As for their online tools and website, my experience has been positive. Overall, making a claim was a smooth process, and the service itself was satisfactory.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My downstairs heating stopped working and I submitted the claim through the online portal, which was quite straightforward. I simply had to select the issue, confirm my address, and pay the deductible. Soon after, All Tech Air Conditioning contacted us for the service. Although I wasn't home at the time, my wife mentioned that everything went smoothly during their visit.
After the repairs, the heating is functioning perfectly, as it should. While I would rate the claim process a 4 out of 5, due to some past challenges I faced with communication over the phone, I prefer to use the portal for its simplicity. Previously, with a different company, I could speak directly with a representative, but with American Home Shield, phone calls sometimes lead to misunderstandings. I recommend improving the communication aspect, especially for consumers already frustrated with broken appliances. Despite this, the service is reliable and cost-friendly, which I'd highlight when recommending American Home Shield to friends or family.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My refrigerator went out due to a power surge. I contacted AHS for service. I was told they did not have anyone in my area who serviced refrigerator and they would need time to find someone. They never did. I had to jump through hoops to cancel the policy. I got it cancelled on Dec. 21, 2024. I checked credit card statement on February 26, 2025 and saw charges from AHS. I contacted AHS and was told that I had a duplicate contract that was initiated on Jan. 17, 2025. I did not initiate it. I was told it would be cancelled and I would receive a refund in 14 to 21 days after lengthy conversations with representatives. They did not have a supervisor that I could speak to. I do not believe them and I believe AHS is a predatory company.
Hi Nancy, I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience. Sincerely, Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
Jones Family Appliance is undoubtedly the best repair service I've ever dealt with. They were incredibly responsive and delivered exactly what they promised, resolving issues efficiently. Unfortunately, my other experiences with American Home Shield weren't as impressive. I had repeated issues with my refrigerator that previous technicians failed to repair properly, often due to communication barriers and shortcuts taken during repairs. This led to further problems, making the process frustrating.
Also, on my last attempt to schedule a repair was through American Home Shield's automated phone system, it incorrectly stated that my appliance wasn't covered. I had to speak with a live representative to correct the error, and although they resolved it, this added unnecessary hassle. I've been with American Home Shield since around 1998, but their customer service and quality of service have not met my expectations recently, leading me to rate my overall experience a 2 out of 5. The ease of using their website has been satisfactory in the past and although I haven’t used it recently, I would suggest improvements for a more intuitive and user-friendly web interface.
Dear Patrick,
I'm so sorry for the problems you've been experiencing. Please reach out to us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can discuss this further.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
We had some plumbing issues with our toilets and the contractors dispatched by American Home Shield were very professional. They arrived on time, completed the repairs effectively, and the performance since the repair has been satisfactory. The process of submitting a claim with American Home Shield was straightforward, as I usually do it online. The website is user-friendly, and I seldom need to speak to someone directly. However, I've noticed that their prices have become increasingly expensive, reaching about $112 a month. While the service maintains its quality, the continuous price hikes concern me, as they don't accompany any improvements or additional services. Because of this, I would consider looking for a more cost-effective provider.
Dear Charlene,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had my toilet repaired with the help of American Home Shield, and I must say that the service was excellent. The technician who handled the repair was extremely professional and competent. Since then, I haven't encountered any issues with the toilet. This was actually the first and only claim I've had to file with American Home Shield, and the entire process was seamless. I reached out for assistance, and within just a few days, a technician was sent to my home. Overall, I had a very positive experience. The technician was knowledgeable, and I was very satisfied with the service provided.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield has been mixed. Back in January, I submitted a claim, and although the process was pleasant and the contractors were friendly, the service was quite delayed. It took almost a month for them to address the problem, and during this time, I had to go to the laundromat to wash and dry clothes, which was a significant hassle, especially with my work schedule. While I understand they have a high volume of business, the delay was frustrating. I also got a claim out here now for the same problem that I had back in January. The same maintenance people called today to schedule an appointment for some time this week.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield regarding a claim on my heater. They came out and put in new heat strips, which went smoothly. However, I'm still facing ongoing issues with the freezer in the garage and the ice maker in the refrigerator inside the house. While the ice maker was fixed initially, it only functioned for about three to four weeks before it stopped producing ice again.
The technician who visited was polite, which I appreciated, but it's frustrating to have a recurring problem. I haven't reported the ice maker issue to them again yet, as it seemed resolved initially. Overall, I'd rate my experience with American Home Shield as a 4 out of 5, mainly because of these unresolved issues with my appliances.
Dear William,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield when I needed someone to repair my dryer. I simply called them to report the issue. The contractor who came to fix it was pleasant and professional, though there was a slight language barrier due to his heavy accent when he was trying to explain something. He did manage to repair the steam function, but I feel the dryer doesn't heat or dry clothes as efficiently as before.
Overall, I'm quite satisfied with American Home Shield's services, including their customer service and warranty coverage, which I’d rate around a 4 out of 5. They were also very helpful in transferring the policy into my name after my husband's passing. He was the one who purchased the policy and there were a couple of things that my husband had repaired in the past that he was happy with. While I haven't used their online tools much, their pricing seems reasonable. My experience with American Home Shield has been pretty good.
Dear Susie,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
The service provided by the techs was satisfactory. The appliances have been functioning well since the repair. The outcome was positive.
Dear Mrs. Abbas,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim

Reviewed Feb. 26, 2025
I have been a customer for over 3 years. I wish I could give zero stars. If you don’t believe me, go to the BBB website for HONEST reviews. Their contractors are questionable. I had one write up an absolute lie about a problem in my Home so AHS denied the claim. I called and told them what the contractor wrote in the report was an absolute lie and their response was basically there is nothing they can do since the contractor submitted what they submitted. There is always something that is not covered leaving an out-of-pocket expense that’s insane.
I just paid $1800 to have my water heater replaced with their coverage. I then had a friend that used Home Depot for the same job and a better system was installed and she paid less than what I paid without using a home warranty company. I have tried to cancel several times and keep getting the runaround. No one returns calls or sends email confirmations like they say they will. Please, please do not use this company or at least do your research first. Again look at the BBB website.
Good day, K. Thanks for your feedback.
I am sorry to see that the warranty plan is not working out for you the way that you had hoped. Our warranty plans are designed to reduce costs, but no warranty plan can eliminate costs completely. The expenses you paid for the water heater replacement were expenses that are explicitly not covered in the contract. With an authorized parts replacement, AHS will always cover the cost of the tech's labor to install and the cost of the replacement equipment. The cost of modifying that equipment to go into one's home and the cost of options that must be added due to federal, state, or municipal building codes are costs that fall to the homeowner.
The overall cost of the repair is still generally lower than the cost would be to have the repair done outside of the warranty plan; if that were not true, then AHS could not have grown to be the market leader in home warranty service over a 6 decade period. In cases where homeowners do think that they can find a better deal for a repair or replacement outside of our vendor network, you always have the option to request a cash-in-lieu reimbursement. This allows you to take the money that AHS would have spent on the repair or replacement and instead select your own vendor to resolve the situation.
You stated that you've tried to cancel several times. I've tried to locate your AHS account using the email you have listed on the Consumer Affairs site, but it does not pull up an account. If you still need help, please send us an email to consumeraffairs@ahs.com. As the subject line, put "Attention: Ken, Review # 13697881 for K. Andrews. "
Sincerely,Ken
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
The people that American Home Shield uses are not qualified to come out and give me any kind of quotes or fix the problem. They come out and do as little as possible. They just try to sell me their unit from them and not AHS. All they try to do is make money for themselves. We had Fast Response. They didn't fix anything. They never do. They came, got their $100, and said that our blower is not compatible with our unit. But it has been compatible for four years. They wouldn't do anything. They just left. The tech told me, “Just run it on emergency heat” which costs a lot more in the blower because it doesn't go through the blower. It goes to the outside unit.
Fast Response was supposed to give me even prices. I've requested that I don't want them at my house, but they are always the ones that come out. I let them come in and I'm very unhappy with it. It's not the first time that happened to me. I always have to get a second opinion. I am still happy with American Home Shield. They are not the problem.
Dear Sandra,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
American Home Shield was unable to fix an issue with my heating system, and I eventually had to hire another company to resolve it. I even took it upon myself to fix part of the problem when they failed to deliver. When I made a claim with them, their service was subpar. I had to call them three times over three days, with no resolution until I sought help from another service.
The invoice from the other company mentioned various repairs like flushing the system and reconnecting the electric for the pump, which was evidently beyond the scope of American Home Shield's initial service. The customer service from American Home Shield was unsatisfactory, as they couldn't address the issue effectively, forcing me to seek alternative solutions. If they can't send anybody else actually helpful, they should not bother.
Dear Nancy,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
I’m not satisfied. I called American Home Shield in for a microwave replacement. They were able to send a technician on time. But they said I'm not covered. I'm disappointed. I was not able to get my microwave fixed. Last time, I had this in my situation with my heater. I ended up paying for the service. I was able to get the warranty, but I paid for the service. That was not covered. Why am I paying AHS? They do not cover anything. It looks like I'm going to replace the microwave myself and pay them for the service.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield regarding a claim for a garage door opener. The process was straightforward as I submitted the claim online. It was hassle-free, and everything was resolved efficiently, even though we needed to call in an electrician. Overall, we were satisfied with how the issue was handled.
However, I've noticed that the deductibles seem to keep increasing, which is a bit concerning. In a previous situation, we attempted to have our pool heater covered, but they declined. I was worried they might do the same with the garage door opener, but thankfully that experience was seamless.
Although I didn't interact much with sales or support representatives, as I managed everything online, I found their platform easy to use. Overall, I’d give American Home Shield a solid 4-star rating based on my experiences.
Dear Louis,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
My recent experience with American Home Shield was positive. We had some plumbing work done, and the process of submitting the claim online was straightforward and easy. Although my husband interacted with the contractor, he reported that everything went smoothly without any issues. The repair itself has been functioning well; the only ongoing problem is related to the plumbing line outside our house, which is the city's responsibility.
Dear Julie,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
My furnace had gone out and the contractor that American Home Shield sent out was good. I did the claim online and it was easy.
Dear Teresa,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
Our previous home warranty company said that they were no longer gonna cover our area, so I started making phone calls. American Home Shield had the best price for the quality that they offered, the things that they covered, and the trade call fees, so I went with them. Recently, I did a claim for my dishwasher that wasn't working at all, and the submission process was real easy. The contractor was very knowledgeable and did a good job diagnosing.
The only complaint I have is they still haven't been out to install the part. I tried calling for two weeks to get them but couldn't. Come to find out the part had been delivered 18 days prior. They just had not called to schedule an appointment to come install the part. I ended up having to call American Home Shield back to call the contractor and get them to call me so that I could get it fixed. American Home Shield's customer service has been great ‘cause they got the contractor on the phone and did a three-way call that day, a few minutes later. It's been over almost a month now since I put the claim in, but the contractor is finally coming tomorrow.
Dear Dakota,
I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
When I had an issue with my gas fireplace ignition. I initially thought it would be covered as an appliance issue, but it wasn't, which was a bit confusing. Although their claim submission process was straightforward and they called me back to explain what was or wasn't covered.
The contractor they sent was helpful. The first time, he only relit the pilot without checking the cause. I had to call him back because the pilot went out again. Upon returning, the contractor identified a part as the issue, which was a safety mechanism. He was thorough in explaining this to me, and the performance has been good since the repair. He did advise me not to keep it on for long periods due to the system's age and the replacement part's longevity.
Overall, I've had a positive experience with American Home Shield. The customer service was responsive, and their online tools are user-friendly. However, I found the initial cost for a service visit to be somewhat high compared to the monthly fee. In summary, they seem to be one of the leading warranty companies.
Dear Judy,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
When my garbage disposal seemed faulty, it turned out the issue was with the drain itself. A plumber came and efficiently resolved the problem by snaking the drain about 30 feet. The turnaround time was quick; I submitted my claim one evening, and the plumber contacted me the next day.
The contractor was professional and offered to assist with any further issues. Since the repair, everything has been running smoothly without any problems. This was my second repair experience with American Home Shield, and both times the response was prompt, and the contractors were courteous.
One of the contract features I appreciated is that if they can't fix something, they will replace it at their cost. Though I haven't needed a replacement yet, I expect them to honor this as they appear to be a reputable company.
Overall, I would recommend American Home Shield to others based on my positive experiences. I rate their service highly and find their website easy to navigate. However, I have noticed that the price of the warranty has increased over time, which is a concern for the future.
Dear Terry,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
American Home Shield is a good company. They're very professional. Once I call the people who are gonna fix my issue, they call in less than 30 minutes. When I had my garage door fixed, the company who came out did a really good job. However, the people who I called Friday about fixing my washing machine haven't called me yet. Also, when submitting a claim, you don't talk to anybody live anymore. It's still smooth but sometimes you need to be able to talk to somebody live. Another thing is when I first started with American Home Shield five years ago, the cost was was $75. Now, it's gone up to $100.
Dear Blake,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
American Home Shield has always responded quickly and I'm satisfied. I've had a good experience the last three years that I've had them. If they couldn't repair what's broken, they've always been fair in offering some kind of cash settlement. Recently, my washer went out and it was unrepairable. In lieu of trying to repair it, we're in the process of them sending me cash. When I signed up, they went over everything, offered me different variables, more coverage and what coverage they had. My plan covers mostly everything and the price is more reasonable than some other home warranty companies. I'm gonna renew again when it comes in June.
Dear Norman,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
I have been a loyal customer of American Home Shield for over 30 years, ever since I bought my house. The previous owners included a year-long policy with the home sale due to the high cost of potential repairs like HVAC, so I decided to maintain the coverage. My most recent experience was when I had to file a claim to repair my heating system, and the process was straightforward. A quick call was all it took to get a contractor out to my place, who handled the repair efficiently.
I'm satisfied with the performance; my heater is working fine now. Over the years, I've found their customer service to be very responsive. While I think the prices have increased, I rate the price of the coverage as a 4. As for the online tools and website, they deserve a 5. Renewing my coverage is a breeze, usually through a text or email notification. Overall, American Home Shield has been reliable, and they are there when I need them.
Dear Jane,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield was disappointing. I signed up based on a family friend's recommendation, thinking it was a great warranty service. However, they were not transparent about the limitations of their service. After a technician came out and checked the situation, they sent me documents outlining restrictions that were never communicated before. This lack of transparency made the warranty pointless for me as I could have just paid out of pocket.
When the contractor came, he quickly took some pictures and left for another appointment without thoroughly walking me through the issues. I ended up using a utility company's service for repairs because American Home Shield's contractor presented a $5,000 bill, which was contrary to my expectations of the warranty covering such costs.
Although my friend had a good experience and would rate them highly, I can only give American Home Shield a 2. They failed to provide the necessary contract limitations upfront, which influenced my decision negatively. I also had a poor customer service experience since calls were outsourced, making effective communication challenging. When I needed further explanation, it felt more like I was given standard assurances rather than actual solutions. I would rate their customer service a 2 as well.
The app provides some information, but it lacks detailed limitations that could help in making more informed decisions. Overall, the warranty products deserve a 3, given they clarify what is covered and what isn't. The sales and marketing aspects were not appealing either since I only heard about them from my cousin rather than any direct marketing efforts. In terms of the online tool, improvements can be made to include comprehensive details about the limitations within the app.
Based on my experience, I would not recommend them without cautioning potential consumers to thoroughly review their contract details.
Dear Mian,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
I appreciated how smoothly everything went when I filed my claim with American Home Shield. Despite a minor delay from the contractor, things worked out since the person waiting wasn't ready anyway. The contractor sent by American Home Shield was great, and the repair has been holding up well, so I'm satisfied with the outcome. I would recommend American Home Shield to others looking for a reliable insurance policy. I even learned that there's a referral incentive for recommending their services, which is a nice bonus. However, the price increased without prior notification, which was a bit surprising.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
I have been satisfied with my experience with American Home Shield. It's almost time for me to renew my contract, and I'm planning to do so. I switched from Sears to American Home Shield and prefer the latter. I've had two claims so far and the most recent claim was during a snowstorm when my central heating went out. Despite the city being closed due to the storm, American Home Shield scheduled a repair for Friday, and the contractor arrived as soon as the roads were clear on Saturday. It turned out to be just a breaker box issue, and the young, courteous contractor handled it efficiently. He was attentive, checked everything thoroughly, and kept me informed throughout the process. I've been pleased with the performance of the unit since then and to ensure I'm prepared next time, I even bought extra electric heaters as a precaution.
The first issue I had was with my toilet that kept running. The service technician, a tall gentleman, addressed the issue professionally and quickly. Everything has been working so far and overall, I am impressed with American Home Shield's service. The customer service has been excellent and the pricing is reasonable for a senior on a fixed income like myself.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2025
Have been paying for more than 10 years, haven’t used as much and now that I need it for an electric problem, they denied the service, because it doesn’t cover it, so they can change an outlet but when the wire is not good anymore they said that it is not covered. Save your money yourself. They are not good for sure.
Dear Angel,
I'm so sorry for the problems you've been experiencing. Please reach out to us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can discuss this further.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 24, 2025
My kitchen sink was clogged. I submitted the claim through American Home Shield’s website. Then they assigned it to Ace Plumbing and I've worked with them before. So, I talked to some of the people there in the past on the phone. I did end up calling them the next morning, feeling kind of not very cool about doing it. I tried to get a handle on when I was going to have someone at my house to get my sink fixed for me again. They got someone out here incredibly fast. It was great. The guy was very professional and helpful.
Sincerely,
Mariah
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2025
American Home Shield (AHS) has been negligent with utilizing the company Air Plus for years. We contacted AHS when our furnace stopped working on January 31st. AHS responded by sending out Air Plus based in Sumter, SC. Air Plus arrived on Feb 5 and diagnosed the problem as the wrong voltage transformer; they installed a new one causing the control board to burn out. Air Plus technician stated they would contact AHS to cover the replacement parts. Air Plus, in the AHS notes fabricated they found a burned-out control board and transformer caused by a power surge when they arrived. I explained to AHS that Air Plus misrepresented what happened at my residence.
After researching Air Plus, we realized this company has a history of poor ratings by customers along with years of various negative complaints. AHS has known about these complaints but has continued sending out an incompetent company such as Air Plus and its technicians to customers in need of quality service providers. AHS has failed their customers and their contractual obligations. Air Plus clearly has a history of damaging property/equipment, poor customer service and leaving problems unresolved. We spent 2 weeks without heat and did not hear from AHS or Air Plus, to the point where we had to go out of pocket with a new company for over $1,000 to repair what Air Plus broke.
The new company we contacted could see that it was a simple sensor issue and not the control board nor the transformer. It is unprofessional for Air plus to fabricate or misrepresent the facts that they misdiagnosed a minor problem and created a major problem. Air Plus never reached out to see if they could help rectify the situation nor did they return my calls. After considering the facts and lack of response the only solution is to end the contract with American Home Shield immediately for failure to cover cost and creating a financial burden that I had to resolve.
Hello LaToya. Thank you for reaching out to us about your service concern. We apologize for the difficulties you've encountered. We were unable to locate your service account with the information in your post. Please email your account information to us directly using this email: consumeraffairs@ahs.com. Once we've received your information and can locate the work order, we will contact you to see what we can do to assist. Thanks.
Best Wishes,Ken
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2025
I recently had an interaction with American Home Shield (AHS) regarding a claim for my garage door. Initially, the door wasn't responding to the button press, but strangely enough, when the technician arrived, it was functioning perfectly. My husband dealt with the contractor, and everything seemed to work when the technician was there.
I've been with AHS off and on for many years since I first purchased my home. It's common practice for homes to come with some sort of home protection plan, though it's different now than it used to be. The service back in the day was better and cheaper, but having a home warranty is still essential for homeowners, particularly for women managing a household.
Regarding the service provided by AHS, I think of it like comparing different cereals. They all serve the same basic purpose; some are just more expensive than others. I feel like the cost has gone up significantly over the years. We used to pay around $50 for services, and now it's up to $150 for a visit.
The contractors, whether through AHS or any other service, have generally been professional. They come in, finish the job, and leave. One challenge I encountered was with the quality of replacements. For instance, when my pricey kitchen faucet needed replacement, they only provided a basic model, citing that they only offer "builder grade" replacements per the policy's fine print.
Additionally, AHS has these persistent follow-up calls that remind me of an overzealous date you can't get rid of. While I appreciate the due diligence, sometimes their outreach is excessive.
Overall, I would say my experience with American Home Shield is mixed. It's important to have a home warranty, but it's essential to be aware of what you're getting—especially the limitations of replacements as they only provide builder-grade solutions. Despite some drawbacks, having that safety net can be useful for unexpected home repair issues.
Dear Evangeline,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield when Frank's Appliances came to fix our refrigerator. Initially, we faced issues with the water dispenser on the freezer door, which only produced a trickle of water, while the ice maker was producing small and hollow ice cubes. When the repair technician came, they ordered a new filter, a water valve, and a few other parts. After a wait, they installed these parts, and both the water and ice seemed to work at first.
However, we started noticing that the water was leaking into the ice tray, creating small blocks of ice alongside the cubes. We had to call American Home Shield again, and they promptly set up another visit from Frank's Appliances. During this second visit, the technician determined there was no hole in our ice tray and decided the valve needed replacing again. Despite this inconvenience, they were proactive and set up another appointment to install the needed parts.
The initial process of setting up the claim through American Home Shield was straightforward. I filled out the request form on their website, paid the initial service fee, and didn't have to pay anything beyond that. Although our location is 75 miles west of Oklahoma City and lacks local service partners, the technicians from Oklahoma City and sometimes from further west have provided excellent service.
Overall, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield as 5 stars. Despite some initial challenges, they have consistently provided good service for various issues, including significant past claims with our air conditioner and oven. While there aren't local partners, the service quality and professionalism have outweighed this inconvenience.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2025
I recently had a mixed experience with American Home Shield regarding a furnace issue. Fast Response Heating and Cooling came out quickly but didn't have the necessary part for a week, leaving me without heat during that period. I felt misled by a technician who promised a temporary fix and coaxed me into giving a good review but never returned as promised.
The process of submitting claims is straightforward, often involving speaking with a live representative, which is easy. However, there's a significant delay in getting the actual service from contractors.
I discovered that American Home Shield sources some parts from overseas, which potentially lengthens wait times, emphasizing the need for better local warehousing solutions. Their contractors sometimes come from quite far, which can delay urgent repairs.
In the past, I've also had issues with a water heater that required multiple visits and eventually resulted in a significant water bill due to a leak. Despite this, they have provided satisfactory service occasionally, even paying for emergency services from a local contractor when their timeline was too long.
It's hit or miss with American Home Shield. Sometimes it's good. They need to have people that work 24 hours like some of these companies and people on-call instead of waiting for you to call in, and then somebody calls you within 48 hours. They need somebody who can get out here in the middle of the night. Overall, while American Home Shield can be adequate at times, they need to improve their response times and ensure more timely assistance, especially in emergencies. Given my recent experience, I'd rate them around a 3 out of 5.
Dear Michael,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2025
The Communication was normal but the effort by the technician was inadequate and did not address and complete the problem. The AHS policy covers up to 100 feet of distance but I watched on video camera as this technician did not use the full length of the tool yet he wrote up that he used the tool up to 125 feet which was nonsense. He never used anything close to 100 feet. He also used it at the farthest point away from the property line which he claim the tool could not reach. I measured it from the home's clear-out point and property line and it is only 33 feet to the property line yet the technician claimed they ran the tool 125 feet yet he could not clear the blockage.
I have video proving this guy only used part of the tool to try and clear out the blockage. With the distance only being 33 feet the 100 feet policy would easily clear the blockage to the property line yet he wrote up that it need a longer device and reported that to American Home Shield yet the tech wrote up that customer have main line stoppage. Tech snake the line up to 125ft but was not able to clear stoppage. Tech recommend to have a vendor that has bigger snake and camera the line.
This was extremely poor customer service and misleading to say you did something you didn't do then charge a service fee then make it where I would have pay for so-called noncovered cost associated with this service to this same vendor which was Waldorf Plumbing. Be aware of this company which was hired by American Home Shield. Poor service, did not complete the job and closed out the service request as complete. Took the money and did a poor job.
Good day William. Thank you for reaching out to us regarding this service issue. We were able to locate your account request using the information in your profile.
In situations where a vendor's diagnosis results in a denial, the customer has the option of requesting a second opinion from a different vendor. When AHS dispatches the second opinion vendor, we do not tell them the reason for the denial in order to help ensure independent assessment. I see from your account notes that a 2nd Opinion vendor has already been dispatched. If you still have questions or concerns after their diagnostic visit, please reach out to us via consumeraffairs@ahs.com. Thanks.
Sincerely,Ken
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
We were with another company and saw an ad from American Home Shield. The rates were better and there are things that they covered that our company didn't. So, we gave AHS a try. In the beginning, when we started using them, the people who were taking over the phones go off the script and that was the most frustrating part. Our experience with AHS has gotten better. I wish they were same day services but people are busy and other companies get there. The techs from American Home Shield are good though the guy who answered the phone from Ukon Appliance wasn't very friendly. But he was friendly the second time on our second job that we’re gonna have done with them. He did our refrigerator and we have another claim coming up.
Dear Claudine,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I have been a faithful customer of American Home Shield for four years. I finally made a claim on a microwave that had stopped heating. They sent out a technician (Feb 14, 2025) who left a report that said the following: it was not heating due to the magnetron going bad, needing to be replaced. The hinges were loosening on the door, recommended replacement. This is all covered in the AHS contract.
However, AHS lied and said that the technician didn't report these items, so they denied my claim. They said the technician didn't say anything about the magnetron being bad. However, the work order itself clearly says that it is bad and needs to be replaced, and the AHS contract clearly says it's covered. So -- I called to dispute on February 17, and after talking to six different people at a call center in the Philippines, I finally said I wanted to cancel the account. Once he understood I was serious, the customer service person said he would send someone out to fix it, with no additional charge and apologized, said it was their mistake. So, he opened another work order and said it would be fixed, if only I would not cancel.
Then, despite a text saying someone would come within 24 hours, 4 days later on February 21 I called the repair company (which is fake - just another AHS person in their Philippines call center pretending to be a separate company) to ask why no one had come. She said it was a mistake, that she would figure it out and call me back. Instead, she canceled the work order that same day. So, I called back again, and they said they didn’t know why the work order was canceled, but that I could pay the fee again to submit another request. So on Feb 22 I called again to cancel. After many tries to cancel and talking to many people, they finally canceled my account, but they still charged me after I canceled!!!
I now have to pay to get my microwave repaired ($450), even though it was supposedly covered by AHS, and a fraudulent charge ($96) that was posted to my credit card. This is an outrageous scam company. They took my money for years, denied an obvious claim with all kinds of lies and manipulation, and then charged me more after I cancelled. Please save yourself the pain and frustration of even thinking about signing up with these liars and cheats.
Hello Peggy. Thank you for your feedback.
I understand that you are frustrated, but we've been unable to locate any information at all regarding your service request. The email address associated with your Consumer Affairs account is not pulling up an AHS service request, and your name also did not pull up a request. Also, your statement that AHS is impersonating a repair agency is incorrect. AHS clearly states in the contract that we are NOT a repair company, and we dispatch our service calls to US-based repair vendors.
If you still need assistance and can provide concrete details confirming the account and service request, I will be happy to take another look at the request. Please email your contract address and the work order dispatch number, as well as the name of the account holder, to us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com. Thank you.
Best wishes,Ken
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I have been a customer of American Home Shield for nearly 10 months and more recently, Home Choice came out for a plumbing issue. A clogged toilet and sink needed attention. The technician arrived promptly with the necessary tools and efficiently resolved the problem using a snake. The process was quick and the technician displayed professionalism.
While my overall experience with American Home Shield has been positive, the quality of technicians can vary. Some are thorough and effective, while others might lack attention to detail in addressing issues. Despite this inconsistency, I still found their service satisfactory.
Given these experiences, I would rate them a 3 out of 5.
Dear Amit,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
When one of my home appliances needed servicing, American Home Shield sent out Gary Appliance and I found them to be quite efficient. They were responsive and communicated well, keeping me informed about the arrival of parts, which impressed me. However, this hasn't always been my experience with American Home Shield. In the past, I had issues where it took three different companies to fix a problem with my washing machine. This was incredibly inconvenient and left us without the appliance for an extended period. So while I appreciate the promptness of their service visits, there is certainly room for improvement concerning the expertise of the personnel they send out. Overall, I would rate American Home Shield around a 2.8 out of 5 because although I haven't canceled their service yet, there have been several instances where I considered doing so due to my dissatisfaction.
Dear Kenny,
I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I recently had my water heater repaired by Gaithersburg Plumbing through AHS. They did a great job, and I was pleased with their efficiency. I've been using AHS for several years, and the technicians they send have always been very good. Overall, I would highly recommend their services.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I recently had a great experience with AHS. My washing machine started spilling water all over my laundry room during the spin cycle. I submitted a claim through their app, which I found very convenient since I didn't have to speak to anyone in person. The entire process was smooth—I paid my deductible through the app, received text notifications about which company would handle the repairs, and then Frank's Appliance and Repair reached out to coordinate the visit. The contractors were professional, polite, and kind.
The replacement process was quick. They emailed us a confirmation, and we chose to pick up the new washer from Lowe's ourselves. Within just a few days, Lowe's delivered and installed it. Everything is working perfectly now.
I've been with AHS for about five months since I transitioned from renting to buying a home. Having this service eases the financial burden of unexpected repairs. What I appreciate most is their app, which allows easy claim submissions without having to spend time on the phone. Overall, I'm very satisfied and I highly recommend American Home Shield.
Dear Shantel,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I have been a customer of American Home Shield for 15 years and my experience has consistently been great. I've never had any complaints. Recently, I thought my furnace wasn't functioning properly, so I placed a claim. The technician from Air Express checked everything thoroughly, provided some suggestions, and his advice certainly helped lower my bill. The technicians American Home Shield sends out are wonderful, always friendly and professional. My only complaint, which seems to be common these days, is that the service call fee has increased to $125, which stings a bit, but that's become par for the course with many services.
Dear Vicki,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
We had a toilet leaking and it was a really good experience to submit the claim online with AHS. The techs were good but more work needed to be done, so we were told to contact American Home Shield and they have the worst call center situation. Then, the techs came back, but the toilet leak didn't show. We shut off the water because it flooded our bathroom, so there was no visible leaks anymore. We turned on the water that morning of the appointment but it didn't want to leak. Then they closed it and said that if it leaked, we should call them.
The thing is, the problem happens overnight when we're asleep or when we're not home. So it was a hit or miss with the leak, but American Home Shield's service at the time seemed good because they communicated with the contractor. At other times, when I would contact American Home Shield for other services in our other home and the techs have to come back again, it would get hard. Or when they tell us that American Home Shield will give us a call because their services don't cover the work needed, no one ever calls us for weeks. Then I have to call the call center. So, AHS needs to do better following up with every customer.
I had an AC issue last year and it was months of the follow-up that I had to work harder than American Home Shield did, because I was the one calling things in, calling them, calling the contractor, and calling them again. Those two were pointing fingers at each other when I asked how much the repair would cost. The contractor told me that I had to get the quote from American Home Shield. But AHS said I had to get the quote from the company. There were many points where I had to call them on three-way. Eventually, the AC situation got fixed and I had to pay.
All in all, AHS is good to have and we've had them for many years. But I wouldn't recommend them because of the constant back and forth and the lack of follow-up. There are other companies now that are available. I'm enduring the experience only because I have three properties with them, but then I am paying three different prices, and I don't have to be. I should call them about that.
Dear Ms. Patao,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield has been positive over the five years I've been with them. Recently, I had a claim with their contractor, Clearing Pool and Spa Service, to fix a recurring issue with my Jacuzzi. The heater, pump, and temperature sensor were replaced after the system kept tripping the breaker. The technician initially seemed unsure, but they eventually resolved the issue, and everything ran well for about three weeks.
However, the problem resurfaced, prompting me to call an electrician who ruled out any breaker issues. I've had to bypass the warranty and contact Jacuzzi directly. It seems like my Jacuzzi is a lemon, given the numerous parts replaced over five years—four heaters, two circuit boards, and many sensors and pumps. Despite this, American Home Shield has consistently done what they promised and resolved issues with my equipment, so I would rate them a 5 out of 5.
Dear Donald,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I appreciate that with just a phone call, American Home Shield takes care of everything swiftly and their claims process is easy. I had a plumbing issue and Heroes Plumbing Services LLC, the contractor they dispatched, provided excellent service. Since their visit, everything has been functioning perfectly. I would rate American Home Shield a 5 because I am extremely satisfied with their service. They could lower the premium, but for anyone purchasing a house, having a home warranty like this is essential.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
We've had a really good experience with American Home Shield, especially the plumbing guy. He's been great. We've had him fix other plumbing issues through American Home Shield in the past, and he was very responsive. The other people who repaired things for us have been fine as well. We had somebody for the dryer one time, and someone for the refrigerator twice. All in all, it's been very helpful having American Home Shield's service. The issue is solved on the first time.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I had a service call with American Home Shield for an issue with my dishwasher. The technician identified and fixed a computer-related problem quickly, demonstrating his expertise. He was a very personable, nice young man and it all went very well. I've had three service calls with American Home Shield overall, and each time the technicians were knowledgeable, polite, and presentable, resolving the issues efficiently. My only suggestion for improvement would be a faster response time for service calls, though I understand they currently operate as quickly as possible. They do a good job and given my experiences, I would rate American Home Shield a five out of five.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2025
I recently encountered an issue with my heating system, and American Home Shield was able to assist in getting it fixed. The system had stopped producing heat, necessitating the replacement of a part. Although I had to wait about three days for the part due to it being a weekend, the contractor, from a company called Hollywood Air, was great throughout the process. This was my first claim with American Home Shield in a long time, and the experience was quite positive despite my initial apprehension from reading bad reviews. Based on this experience alone, I would rate American Home Shield a 4 out of 5.
Dear Tiffany,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I had a frustrating experience with American Home Shield regarding my refrigerator, which was not cooling. The initial claim dates back to August when Sears was supposed to come out for the repair. After several no-shows from Sears, the service was transferred to another company. Unfortunately, even after multiple visits and component replacements by various servicemen, the refrigerator's issue remained unresolved. By November, one technician suggested it might need replacing, though Home Shield insisted there were no mechanical problems.
Despite numerous attempts to rectify this over several months, including paying additional service fees, my refrigerator still doesn't cool properly. The most troubling visit was from an arrogant young technician from Sears who claimed a refrigerator running at 40 to 50 degrees was normal, which is unacceptable for food storage.
After a series of ineffective service attempts and unsatisfactory support from American Home Shield, I've decided to cancel my service with them. I've been a customer for 8 years, but their failure to resolve this issue and their lack of accountability compelled me to make this decision. My sons, who also were customers, have canceled their services due to similar dissatisfaction.
Dear Debbie,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had my first experience with American Home Shield when I needed a repair for my garage door. The spring and cables had broken, and the technician assessed the situation quickly. Although he didn't have the exact spring needed right away, he went to get it and promised to return by the end of the day after completing another job. True to his word, he came back and successfully fixed the door. Overall, I was impressed with the service and would rate it highly.
Dear Brenda,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I encountered an issue with my garbage disposal and contacted American Home Shield. They promptly connected me with Delmar Plumbing and Construction Inc., who arranged an appointment swiftly. The technician who came was punctual, courteous, and very knowledgeable, advising on a better model of disposal. My husband was present during the visit and noted how efficient and tidy the technician was.
However, there was one negative experience when another vendor completely disregarded my input and communicated only with my husband, despite me being the primary contact. This incident slightly marred my otherwise satisfactory interactions with American Home Shield.
Overall, I appreciate how efficiently American Home Shield assigns vendors and manages claims, making the process smooth, except when dealing with high-demand items like air conditioners in summer.
Dear Rosalyn,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently experienced a situation with American Home Shield regarding my refrigerator. Unfortunately, it was beyond repair, and replacing it was more cost-effective. JayBee's Appliance, who came to assess it, was fantastic. The technician who visited was polite and efficient. I don't have any suggestions for improvements, as I am satisfied with their service. If someone asked me about American Home Shield, I'd definitely say it's a great idea to sign up.
Dear Bonnie,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield concerning my refrigerator, which had both an air and water leak. They acted promptly by fixing the water leak on the first day and returned later to address the air leak, which required a new gasket. However, the process was delayed, which was a bit frustrating. My experiences with American Home Shield have varied; some have been excellent, while others were less satisfactory. It seems to depend largely on the technician dispatched. My recent technician was quite effective, even though the repair took longer. Overall, I would rate American Home Shield a 4 out of 5, noting that the quality of technicians could be an area of improvement.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield when our sink was completely stopped. Although we had to wait for two days due to an intense cold snap in Alabama, their response was understandable given the circumstances. Submitting the claim online was straightforward—simply paying the $100 deductible and having someone call us for service. The contractors arrived promptly and fixed the issue efficiently, and everything has been working smoothly since.
Throughout multiple incidents over the years, American Home Shield has consistently been responsive and helpful. It's reassuring to know you can speak directly to a human representative when needed. The convenience and peace of mind offered by their service justify the cost, particularly as I approach retirement and appreciate having predictable expenses for repairs instead of unexpected large costs.
While the monthly fee of $80 sometimes makes me consider self-funding repairs, the ease of service and budgeting make it worthwhile. The online tools are user-friendly, and overall, the security and reliability of having American Home Shield are invaluable, especially for someone planning their finances for the future.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I've had a negative experience with American Home Shield. My latest issue was with a plumbing problem involving a rusted-out water heater, which was not resolved promptly. In California, it's illegal to be without hot water, and my HOA alerted me to the issue due to a leak. Unfortunately, American Home Shield only seemed to have one plumber on rotation—Honest Plumbing—and they couldn't respond for days. I had to fix it myself, which was quite frustrating.
In the past, American Home Shield has offered discounts and paid trade service call fees to keep me as a customer, but not for the sake of saying good things about them. However, their service has consistently been lacking. They need to expand their network of contractors since relying on one vendor is inefficient, especially when that vendor has a poor reputation. They should allow homeowners to choose a licensed and insured vendor independently, matching integrity and turnaround times. To anyone considering them, I'd advise caution. My experience has been consistently disappointing, and I wouldn't recommend them.
Dear Gizel,
I'd like to thank you for bringing this to our attention. I apologize for the difficulties you've been experiencing and would like to discuss this more. Feel free to contact me at consumeraffairs@ahs.com.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had a positive experience with American Home Shield concerning a claim on my microwave, which stopped working. The technician arrived quickly, checked both the appliance and my fuse box, and got it working again. Over the past six or seven months, I've had two service calls, and both technicians were excellent. I appreciate how promptly American Home Shield responds—usually within a day or two after my call. I've been a customer since my time in Memphis years ago and remain satisfied with their services.
Dear Danny,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I've been with American Home Shield since my husband passed away because I knew I wouldn't be able to afford costly repairs or replacements on one income. My washing machine was knocking, and the service from National Factory Services resolved it; they said something about loose springs. The contractor was really nice and fixed both my washer and stove. What I appreciate most about American Home Shield is their prompt communication. They respond quickly whenever I reach out, and they let me know when parts arrive, which was particularly helpful when getting a part for my stove. Initially, it was surprising to learn about the upfront service charge of $125 to $150, which I wasn't expecting. However, I've recommended American Home Shield to others because it can potentially save a lot of money on repairs. I've told friends that it's a smart choice to avoid hefty repair costs.
Dear Ora,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
We're getting ready to cancel our contract with American Home Shield. I had them years ago when we first bought the house. We had them for five years and they were much better then. I had a stove issue and that one only took two days. I was surprised. But this time, it took me over four days to get somebody out to see our house because AHS couldn't find anybody. It was 116 degrees and it was 95 degrees in my house. It's a hot spring. We ended up finding the contractor and had to argue with them to get things approved and paid for. We paid the company and AHS reimbursed us.
Dear Edna,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I've been a long-time customer of American Home Shield, both as a realtor and a homeowner. Recently, I filed a claim for a dishwasher repair. Submitting the claim was straightforward through the website, which is easy to navigate. After filling out the necessary information and paying the fee, I quickly received a notification that a technician had been assigned. They reached out promptly, sometimes even the same day. The contractor who visited my home was courteous and professional, and I was already familiar with him from a previous claim. He respected my home and ensured everything was in order. The repair he conducted was successful, and the dishwasher is now working perfectly.
Having had an American Home Shield warranty since I bought my first home back in the early 2000s, I've always been impressed with their service. They consistently fulfill their contract obligations. As a realtor, I often recommend them to clients, advocating for an American Home Shield warranty specifically. Overall, I am immensely satisfied with American Home Shield, and from my extensive experience, I consider them one of the best in the business.
Dear Kevin,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield due to an issue with the inducer on my furnace. It was making a loud squeaking noise, so I reached out for their assistance. Initially, the process was frustrating as I had to call them to submit a ticket, but it took a long time to create, causing delays. This experience highlighted the need for a faster, simpler process, especially during winter when prompt service is crucial.
During the first visit from the contractor, they identified the failing inducer but mentioned American Home Shield's policy prevented them from replacing it until it completely stopped working. This policy was incredibly frustrating since the screeching noise was unbearable, and I had a newborn at home. Although the furnace was still operational, it was clear the part was failing, which made the situation stressful.
While I appreciate the service American Home Shield offers, especially since having coverage is better than none, improvements could be made. For instance, having the option to select only HVAC coverage rather than bundled HVAC and plumbing packages would be preferable. This would provide more tailored and cost-effective options for consumers.
For potential customers, I'd suggest considering American Home Shield's services but being aware of the policies that could affect urgent repairs. My overall rating would be a 3 out of 5 due to these inconveniences. Though the customer service team was helpful, the delays in ticket processing and lack of coverage customization were areas that could be improved.
Dear Cassandra,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had a plumbing issue in my home and American Home Shield contracted Water Solutions INC to address the problem. The issue was with my shower, where the water was constantly running, and also with the toilet, which took a long time to fill after flushing. The contractor replaced the seals in the shower faucet and adjusted the toilet, resolving both problems perfectly.
Submitting the claim was initially difficult due to a wrong button press, but the customer service team was very helpful and guided me in the right direction. I received timely updates via text from both American Home Shield and the contractor when he was on his way. The contractor was punctual, professional, and communicated clearly about the repairs he was making.
I'm very happy with the outcome and would rate American Home Shield highly. I recommend them as they are dependable, though I feel the service could be improved by reverting to a lower deductible, as it was $50 before and now it's $100. Despite this, I still find their service valuable and would suggest them to friends and family. The customer service was excellent, and I would give it a 5. But the price gets a 4 due to the recent increase. Overall, everything was resolved to my satisfaction.
Dear Cynthia,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I put a claim in on my double oven, my dishwasher and my microwave. The double oven is 27 years old and instead of replacing it because the thermostats are no longer available, American Home Shield offered to rebuild the thermostat. I have no idea though if it’s gonna be an Underwriters Laboratories-certified rebuild. It was a 12-week delay and they paid me 340 some odd dollars in lieu of a new thermostat, which leaves me with a dead oven that I had to replace for a total of $2,700. So, I'm not happy about that.
I was under the understanding that if AHS couldn't repair an appliance, they could replace it. But I'm not looking for a rebuilt thermostat. That involves safety to my home. And trying to revive a 27-year-old oven with no factory replacement parts or legitimate aftermarket parts is not acceptable to me. AHS claimed it was a pre-existing condition on the dishwasher and they weren't gonna cover it. The microwave had a cracked door and they replaced the door. Out of the three issues that I had, I had one of them satisfactorily taken care of.
Dear Stephen,
Thanks for bringing this issue to our attention. Please know that I'd like to look into this further. Send your contact info to consumeraffairs@ahs.com and I'll be back in touch with you soon.
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I had a recent experience with American Home Shield regarding an issue with my furnace. Unfortunately, American Home Shield's policy is not to fix anything until it is completely broken, despite being informed by Omni Home Comfort that something is wrong and will eventually fail. This approach is quite frustrating as it feels like waiting for my furnace to break down completely before getting any help.
Omni Home Comfort, the company sent by American Home Shield, was exceptional in their service. Their customer service was great, informative, and very helpful. They reported the issue to American Home Shield, but no action was taken because the furnace was not technically "broken."
This wasn't the first time I faced communication issues with American Home Shield. Although they send surveys, they have never directly contacted me to discuss my experiences or concerns. The lack of direct communication is disappointing.
If I could share one suggestion with American Home Shield, it would be to address potential problems proactively rather than waiting for a complete failure. When a technician or service provider identifies an impending issue, they should act on this information.
Overall, based on their approach and lack of communication, I would rate my experience with American Home Shield at 2 stars. I've been satisfied with the service providers they send, but the company's overall service and communication could use improvement.
The service fee and monthly price have been reasonable and the coverage is adequate, though I believe more detail could be provided about what exactly is covered. Submitting claims online is straightforward and efficient, deserving a 5-star rating.
I hope American Home Shield considers this feedback to improve their service and address issues like the one I faced with my furnace proactively.
Dear Dane,
I'd like to thank you for bringing this to our attention. I apologize for the difficulties you've been experiencing and would like to discuss this more. Feel free to contact me at consumeraffairs@ahs.com.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield that I would describe as overall positive. I initially faced an issue with the freezer portion of my refrigerator, which basically malfunctioned. To handle this, I submitted a claim through a phone call, and I must highlight that I actually spoke to a representative, not an automated system, which was a relief given the unusual circumstances.
The interaction with the claims representative was quite satisfactory. They seemed to genuinely understand the problem and were responsive, which eased my concerns regarding the replacement process. Ladd's Appliance, the contractor sent out by American Home Shield, arrived promptly. They were friendly, efficient, and quickly assessed the situation by taking necessary photographs to document the damage.
American Home Shield offered me a replacement option through their website, where the process of selecting a new appliance was clear-cut. They provided options detailing any additional costs, covering delivery, installation, and removal of the old appliance. I found the online tool to be very helpful.
Regarding customer service, I’d give it a 4 as they were fast and focused, though I’m usually reluctant to give a perfect score. The coverage could use some improvement and similarly, the fees seem a bit high, so both get a 3. The aspect of pricing during appliance selection could be improved by incorporating feedback systems similar to Amazon's, which would aid in comparison shopping. This is important to me as a keen shopper who values getting the best deal. A more competitive and up-to-date pricing model on their site could benefit consumers who do not have the time or inclination to shop around.
In summary, American Home Shield addressed my issue swiftly and efficiently, resolving a significant problem where my refrigerator was no longer functional. While there's room for improvement, particularly in pricing and coverage, my experience was substantially positive and I'd likely recommend their services in similar situations.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had a plumbing issue at home involving a burst pipe in the wall. We had to shut off all the water, which was quite inconvenient. I contacted AHS and their quick response was impressive. They sent a tech that same day who promptly fixed the problem. I couldn't have been happier with their service.
The tech was knowledgeable and kind, ensuring we received all the assistance we needed swiftly. Moreover, the drywall tech they sent later was also excellent. We were very pleased with both professionals.
Currently, everything is working great. Overall, my experience with American Home Shield was surprisingly positive.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
Clear Flow Water Solutions came out twice to address a plumbing issue. Initially, they couldn't resolve the problem because my pipes were frozen. However, on their second visit, they successfully fixed the issue. I managed to submit my claim online, and while the first technician was handled by my wife, the second tech provided excellent service.
Overall, my experience with American Home Shield has been satisfactory.
Dear Glen,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I've been using AHS for seven years, and generally, I've been quite content with their service. However, I recently faced a frustrating situation when I had an issue involving a leaking exhaust fan housing in my master bathroom. The electrical, plumbing, and roofing services couldn't initially figure out the problem. They each recommended some fixes, but the issue persisted until it was finally addressed by replacing the housing.
Despite this, I've had a positive overall experience with AHS as they usually manage claims effectively. I initially chose their service when buying my home, as my loan officer suggested and arranged for the home warranty as part of my purchase. Despite the recent hiccup, I would still rate AHS highly as their service typically meets my expectations.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I recently had a service experience with American Home Shield regarding an issue with my washing machine. It started making a lot of noise, so I filed a claim, and the technician from McKinney Appliance was quite prompt, arriving within a day or two. I was pleased with this speedy service, as the technician, who is always quite busy, managed to address the issue efficiently.
I've been with AHS for a couple of years now, and while the service in McKinney has been good, overall I'm not very satisfied with the company. I find the warranty expensive and it doesn't cover as much as I'd like.
Overall, I'd rate my experience with American Home Shield a 3 out of 5.
Dear Dwight,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2025
I had an experience with American Home Shield regarding the repair of our furnace. Although the furnace was repaired, it continues to exhibit intermittent issues. We are in contact with the company that previously fixed it and they've provided us with some suggestions to try and address the problem.
Overall, my experiences with American Home Shield have been positive. We've consistently had good service from them, and this current situation seems to be an exception rather than the rule. The technicians we've dealt with have always been polite and professional, and we've considered ourselves quite fortunate in that aspect.
We have been satisfied long-time customers of AHS. If I had to rate their service, I would certainly give them a high rating.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I learned about American Home Shield from my neighbor after my water heater malfunctioned. At first, I didn't have it because my house was relatively new. However, my neighbor strongly recommended it, so I decided to get the coverage for peace of mind, knowing that potential repair costs could be significantly minimized.
I've been with American Home Shield for nearly two years now. The service gives me a sense of security should anything go wrong, like when my air conditioner needed repair. Although I paid $125 as a service fee, the repair cost did not include all necessary parts, resulting in additional expenses. The technician explained that without the service, my total outlay would have been much higher, so I appreciated the savings.
I've also experienced ongoing issues with a faulty ice maker in my refrigerator since last August. While American Home Shield was efficient in processing a refund when repeated repairs were unsuccessful, the unit still required multiple visits without resolution. Eventually, it was determined that the entire refrigerator door needed replacement. American Home Shield agreed to cover this $600 cost, showcasing their commitment to fulfilling their coverage promise.
Overall, I find American Home Shield to be reliable, though some situations showed limitations in coverage details. I'd rate the service a solid 4.5, given my experiences of both favorable cost-saving outcomes and extended repair processes.
Dear Roxanne,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I had an issue with the ice maker not producing any ice, and I submitted a claim with American Home Shield, which I chose to do online. The process was quite user-friendly, and I appreciate being able to handle it digitally. Before the contractor from Alpha Appliance LLC arrived, I received text notifications about the visit. The contractor was efficient, and the overall service was good. I'm pleased with how quickly the problem was resolved, and I’d definitely recommend American Home Shield to others, as they were prompt in addressing and fixing the issue.
Dear Doris,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I had a plumbing issue where both my toilet and garbage disposal were backing up whenever the washing machine drained. I contacted American Home Shield, and Northgate Plumbing was sent out within a day or two. The plumber managed to clear the blockages successfully. I've held a policy with them for several years, covering two different homes. Generally, the cost and the quality of service have been agreeable. However, I did have a frustrating experience with a hot water heater replacement. It took a whole month from the time I reported the issue to when someone was assigned to handle it. That delay was quite a nightmare. Despite this, the plumbers and the technician, Tony, who eventually replaced my hot water heater, were very friendly and helpful.
Dear Darlene,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I submitted a claim with American Home Shield for our faulty furnace. McCormick Mechanical came out to handle the issue, and our experience was excellent. They replaced the pump efficiently, and our furnace has been working flawlessly since. Submitting the claim online through the American Home Shield website was straightforward and user-friendly.
We've been with American Home Shield since 2009, initially signing up upon purchasing our house based on my dad's recommendation. He suggested it as a cost-effective backup for any potential issues, and he was right. It's far cheaper to pay the service fee than to replace everything on our own. The only downside has been the price increases, but their responsiveness and the peace of mind they provide make it worthwhile.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I reached out to American Home Shield for a leaking outside spigot issue. Their contractor, F6 Plumbing, came by but only informed me of what they couldn't do without making any fixes. Over the years, I've had coverage with American Home Shield, which is soon ending, as their service hasn't lived up to my expectations. There have been multiple situations where I've been given conflicting information from different representatives. For example, I was told my toilets would be replaced once they fell below a certain level, but then another representative contradicted this. This inconsistency causes a lot of frustration.
I've had several repairs handled poorly over the years, like constant toilet and sink blockages and issues with the garbage disposal that resurface regularly. Their contractors' quality of work seems inadequate. Considering the services provided, their pricing seems overrated. I'm charged about $100 per service call, which feels excessive given the outcomes. Overall, based on my ongoing experience, I would suggest trying a different company for home protection services.
Dear Lorenzo,
I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've been using American Home Shield since October, having switched from another company due to their unfavorable cancellation terms. My experience with American Home Shield has been mostly positive, but there are areas for improvement. I had an issue where the outlet outside my house was malfunctioning, causing my Christmas lights to flicker off. I submitted my claim online, and I found the process of submitting a claim to be easy. However, I was not fond of how the payment process was structured online, as it required providing banking or credit card information without any visible secure alternative options like Google Pay or PayPal.
When the assigned contractor, Whitney T Holdings, came to resolve the issue, they initially had to reschedule the appointment on the day of, which was inconvenient. Fortunately, I was not working, but such a change could have been problematic if I had to take a day off from work. Upon their return, I insisted they check the circuit breaker and replace it, despite the contractor mentioning that the issue was common this year. I was keen on understanding why it was happening and not just hearing about its prevalence. Once the repair was done, my lights worked correctly. I believe American Home Shield provided excellent service during this whole process. However, I think they could improve by providing paper copies of their policy documents for easy reference, especially for those who prefer hard copies over digital ones.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've been a customer of American Home Shield for over four years and have always been satisfied with their service. They consistently uphold their advertised promises. Years ago, we made the mistake of switching to Choice, which was a frustrating experience with constant issues and excuses about coverage. In contrast, American Home Shield promptly replaced our water heater and repaired our furnace without any hassles.
I typically set up service requests online, and the turnaround time is reasonable. They arrange for competent contractors efficiently, unlike Choice, which struggled to find reliable technicians. For example, when J&M came to work on our plumbing, they did their best despite the challenges posed by our older home.
I've recommended American Home Shield to friends and family, including my sister, who were considering similar services. I've had no issues in my years with them, and I’m confident in their reliability. If I had to rate them, I’d give them five stars for overall experience and customer service. Although I haven't had to contact their customer service often, my limited interactions have been positive.
As for pricing, while I wish it were cheaper, it's still manageable within our budget, especially considering the rising costs of everything. I'd rate the cost around a two.
Overall, I genuinely appreciate their service and would recommend it to others seeking a home protection plan.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield was quite mixed. When I filed a claim, it took over two weeks to resolve, which was a bit of a drawback. The process involved several issues; for example, when fixing one component, another would stop working. However, the service specialists did their best under the circumstances, but I felt they could have been more thorough in checking their repairs before leaving.
The customer service aspect was satisfactory. They were attentive, calling to inquire if I had any other concerns, which I appreciated. Overall, I'd rate the service a 4 out of 5 because, despite the delays and minor issues, they eventually resolved the problems. I'd recommend American Home Shield for home needs, as they do offer helpful support, and there’s a good chance they can assist effectively.
Dear Gurpreet,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently filed a claim with American Home Shield due to a crack in my glass stovetop. I used my laptop to submit the request online. Initially, they assigned a contractor who didn't perform well, so I filed a dispute. They then sent Frank's Appliance, which did an excellent job meeting our needs and repairing the stovetop. The entire process, including the transition from the first contractor to the second and the ordering of parts, took about 4 to 6 weeks, which seemed longer than necessary.
Since the repair, I haven't experienced any further issues with the appliance. I would recommend having a home warranty if you own a house. American Home Shield has been beneficial to us, covering costly repairs with just a $100 service fee. We've been with them for about 4 to 5 years, and overall, I'm quite satisfied.
If a friend asked about my experience, I'd tell them American Home Shield is a pretty good company to have for home warranties. I'd rate them 5 stars for recommending them to others, 4 stars for customer service, and 4 stars for the cost of service. Their website is user-friendly and easy to navigate, deserving 5 stars in my opinion.
Dear Betsy,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I had an icemaker that went out on my refrigerator and that's when the trouble started. American Home Shield sent out about five different plumbing people to come out and do it. The first company had me defrost everything out of my refrigerator. So, I lost all that food. And then he came back and he brought parts and then he supposedly fixed it. Then we said, "It wasn't fixed." So, then he said, "Well, you have to defrost again." He went back in. He totally rebuilt the icemaker and it was supposed to have been fixed and it wasn't.
Another company came out and they did parts and it's still wasn't fixed. One company said, "It was completely rebuilt, the icemaker, but it still is not working." And the last report that I did to them was this year, I called and I told them, "Look, this is not fixed yet." And they said, "Well, we'll contact another company." And I've never heard anything else from American Home Shield about a new person coming out. But the last person in April of last year was supposed to replace the panel on the front of my refrigerator where the icemaker's at, but they never came back and did it. I'm still without an icemaker. The bottom line is that refrigerator needs to be replaced.
According to the contracts that American Home Shield have, if it's not replaced after trying to have it fixed three times at least, there's either a payout or a replacement. Now, I've had my washer done once and I had a heater done once and that's what happened. They replaced it. But this icemaker in my refrigerator has never been taken care of.
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've had a long-term relationship with American Home Shield (AHS) and recently made a claim through their partner, Quality Appliance, for a clothes dryer issue. The technician was prompt, knowledgeable, and polite. He quickly diagnosed the issue, ordered the necessary parts, and returned within a week to complete the repair to my satisfaction. This experience was quite positive compared to some previous encounters with AHS service provider.
However, I faced significant challenges with a plumbing issue. After multiple poor experiences with a particular plumbing company AHS sent, I requested an alternative, to no avail. The company’s limitations in offering alternative service providers led to a delay in resolving my issue. Frustrated with the recurring incompetence, I had to resort to handling the plumbing repair independently. AHS did reimburse me, albeit after a prolonged wait of nearly a month, which was inconvenient.
While the company has its drawbacks, such as limited choices for contractors and delayed payments, I still recommend AHS to others. The costs are often more manageable than sourcing technicians independently, especially for seniors like myself.
Dear Donna,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently had an experience with American Home Shield as I needed help with a recurring issue with my refrigerator. The service from Bayer Appliance Services, the vendor, has been prompt and responsive, and I appreciated their efforts. My concern, however, is with American Home Shield's online service. Initially, I reached out by phone, which worked seamlessly, but when I tried to report an unresolved issue online, my requests seemed to go unnoticed. I submitted the problem multiple times online, but there was no acknowledgment from American Home Shield, which was frustrating. I prefer resolving issues online rather than calling, so this was quite disappointing.
When I reached customer support by phone, my experience was much better, and the service was satisfactory, but their online system needs improvement. Based on my overall experience, I would rate American Home Shield with a 4 out of 5, considering the helpfulness of the vendor but deducting points for the ineffective online service.
We appreciate your business and value your feedback. If there is anything else we can do for you, please let us know.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently had a mixed experience with American Home Shield. My most recent claim involved multiple electrical issues, including three ceiling fans and a couple of light fixtures that weren't working. I processed the claim through the American Home Shield site, which was straightforward this time, unlike a previous plumbing issue that took six months to resolve.
When the contractor from R&R Electrical All Stars arrived, he effectively addressed and repaired the issues, explaining what was wrong with each fan and providing advice on resetting them if issues arose again. Everything's been working well since his visit.
While this recent experience was positive and worth a 5-star rating, my overall impression of American Home Shield is more nuanced due to past difficulties, leading me to rate them a 3 overall. The quality of service largely depends on the contractor's proficiency. I chose American Home Shield based on a positive recommendation from my neighbor, and because I needed a reliable way for my son, who lives at my home, to handle repairs without hassle.
Dear Laura,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield was generally satisfactory. I initially encountered an issue with my dryer, which wasn't spinning or drying correctly. When I submitted the claim, I found the process of calling in to be straightforward with no significant difficulties. My husband was at home when the contractors came to make the repairs, and he said they were adequate. Although I wasn't personally briefed on the specifics of the repair, he mentioned that they replaced a part in the dryer.
Since the repair, the dryer is working better, though I did expect a full replacement as suggested by American Home Shield if the problem couldn't be fixed. Despite that, they managed to resolve the issue with a part replacement.
When reflecting on my overall experience with American Home Shield, I would rate them a 3 out of 5. They were neither superb nor disappointing, sitting comfortably in the middle ground, similar to my experiences with other home warranty services I've tried.
I appreciate that they seem to have a good number of servicemen available, which is a plus. However, I find their deductible to be quite high. Paying $125 upfront over the phone, before service begins, is a new process to me, and it feels like a significant change from before when payment was only made after the service. This upfront payment on a credit or debit card before any work is done is a new approach that perhaps all companies are adopting, possibly due to past issues.
Overall, I think of American Home Shield as on par with other warranty services I've used.
Dear Sharyn,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I have been with American Home Shield for about three years, and I have to say that they have provided excellent service and coverage, especially living out in the country where we rely on a well pump. They are one of the few warranty companies that offer coverage for this, which was a big factor in our decision to go with them. Initially, we faced an issue with our fridge; it was making odd clicking noises and the temperature didn't seem right even though the digital display showed it was. The Sears contractor suggested it could be the main chip, as no error codes were appearing. While waiting for parts, I've been impressed with how efficiently American Home Shield has handled everything, especially considering there was a holiday.
I've found that their customer service is a world apart from our previous warranty provider, where call center interactions were scripted and often frustrating. With American Home Shield, I've experienced quick, effective communication where my issues are heard and addressed without the need for endless repetition. Their choice of service providers has also been convenient, preventing unnecessary long commutes for technicians which previously led to taking entire days off work.
I would rate American Home Shield a 5 out of 5 since they have been a great investment, offering reliable coverage and superior customer service. I've spoken with their representatives both online and over the phone, and I've found the process to be straightforward and reassuring. I would wholeheartedly recommend American Home Shield to family and friends looking for a dependable home warranty service.
Dear Maria,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
The last contractor that came for my air conditioner told me that the person before him removed a piece of the air conditioner that's supposed to have been replaced and put back. But that person just removed it and threw it on my roof. So the last guy couldn't do anything because the piece had to be replaced. Every time I called American Home Shield to see what was going on, everybody kept telling me, "Oh, we don't know what you're talking about." I said, "What do you mean you don't know? I have a claim thing in a jiggy." Then the next would say, "Okay. I'll put everything in the notes. And then I promise I'll call you right back.” But now it's been three weeks since she did it and no one's called me back. So, nothing has been done, and the stuff was never repaired. I still have the broken piece of plastic sitting on my patio.
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've been a customer of American Home Shield for over 25 years. When I faced an issue with my washer not dispensing water properly, I submitted a claim online, which I found very easy to use. The experience with Blue Collar Appliance Repair, whom they sent out, was excellent. The technician was professional, communicated well, and wore protective booties inside my home. After they resolved the issue, my washer has been working perfectly without any problems.
Initially, I switched away from American Home Shield due to price concerns and experimented with Choice Warranty after hearing mixed reviews, but the service was poor. The contractors were delayed, and my friend experienced similar issues with his own claims. Because of this, we returned to American Home Shield. We’ve found their contracted service providers to be reliable and efficient.
One improvement I’d suggest for American Home Shield is better consistency in customer service, particularly when re-signing with them. It was challenging to connect with the same salesperson to address questions. Despite this, I appreciate the service overall, and I understand their price increases due to market trends.
In terms of ratings, I would give them a 5 across the board for customer service, price, the website's ease of use, and the quality of service and coverage. I’ve even recommended their service to friends who have since become customers as well.
Dear Andrea,
It's because of members like you that we continue to improve as a business. Please feel free to call us again when you need us.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield wasn't particularly smooth. Our heater stopped working, so we contacted them and they sent Chesapeake Comfort Systems to diagnose the issue. Initially, they identified the problem as the control board needing replacement. It took a week before they returned with the part, and although it worked briefly, it stopped again soon after. When they came back, a different technician said it was still the control board, but without any prior notes. This back-and-forth left us without clear communication, relying on space heaters and increasing our electric bill. After seeking a second and third opinion, it turned out the actual issue was with the pressure switch, which we had replaced for significantly less money.
When rating American Home Shield’s contractor quality, I’d give them a 3 out of 5. The response time was poor, and we often had to initiate follow-ups. Even their customer service feels lacking. You're only greeted with automated prompts, which isn’t ideal when you need human assistance. Despite these challenges, I've rated their customer service and price around 4 or 4.5 out of 5 because of past experiences, though recent events have made me feel more neutral.
Overall, while the initial technician was friendly, the process was frustrating, with a lack of feedback and delayed responses, especially during a time when we needed our heater the most.
Dear Thomatta,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've been a customer of American Home Shield for a total of 24 years, having them at my current home for 8 years and my previous home for 16 years. Overall, my experience with them has been positive. Recently, I had a claim where Intertech Maintenance came out to work on my dishwasher. They replaced the heating element, but the issue wasn't fully resolved as it still doesn't heat properly. I believe the thermostat might need attention, so I plan to call it back in under their 90-day recall policy, which I've used before.
One thing I like about American Home Shield is the efficiency and ease of processing claims. They have always been responsive whenever I reported an issue. I appreciate the cash-out option if we choose not to proceed with a repair, and getting a replacement item has been hassle-free. For instance, when my cooktop couldn't be repaired, they quickly sent a new one directly to my house, and a technician installed it within a couple of days. Their technicians and vendors have always been reliable and I've had no issues with them.
Dear William,
Wow! Thank you so much for the feedback. We appreciate your business.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I had a positive experience with American Home Shield when I needed service for my oven and refrigerator. I scheduled the service using their app, and I found it quite easy to use. When the technicians from Amtec came to fix my appliances, they were efficient and timely. After initially repairing my refrigerator, it stopped cooling again due to a power outage caused by a snowstorm. I contacted American Home Shield, and they promptly sent someone out the next day to address the issue. The technician quickly identified the problem and resolved it, and I've had no issues since.
If a friend or family member were to ask about my experience, I would recommend American Home Shield as a good investment due to their reliable service and the overall positive experience I've had.
Dear Larice,
We are so happy that you enjoyed your experience with us! We appreciate the great review and look forward to working with you again soon.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I've been a customer of American Home Shield for about 24 years, mainly due to the repairs they provide. I find the vendors they send out for repairs to be pretty good. Although my husband handles most of the claims, we've been happy with the service received from them. The overall cost and quality of service with American Home Shield are satisfactory. The service personnel I've interacted with have been very polite and professional.
Dear Lisa,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
My experience with American Home Shield regarding a furnace issue went quite smoothly. Although it took about 3 to 4 days for Pro Source Heating to come out after my request, they were professional and efficient. They needed to order a part, which extended the total claim process to about 10 days, but ultimately, everything was repaired correctly and has been working perfectly since. Overall, I am very satisfied with their service and would highly recommend American Home Shield for their excellent handling of the situation.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently had a repair done on my garage door through American Home Shield. The spring had broken, and I arranged the service request online through their platform. The process was efficient, as they managed to have the repair completed within 24 to 48 hours of my request. The technician from Flash Garage Door fixed it on the same day they came, and I haven't had any issues since.
I've been with American Home Shield for about 10 years, and they've consistently provided great service. If a friend asked, I would certainly recommend them due to my positive experiences. Although their service price increased this year, I still feel satisfied with the overall value they provide, earning them a 4 out of 5 in that aspect.
Overall, I'm very pleased with American Home Shield and would rate them a full 5 stars for the quality of customer service and service received.
Dear Amy,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I have been AHS customer for 3 year. Really bad experience. They only want to collect monthly premium and that's it. No service. All customer service is being outsourced to Philippines who are really very difficult to understand and deal with. They hang up the call and cut the chat.
Dear Ashutosh,
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Your feedback is important to us, it will help us ensure a better experience next time.
Many Thanks,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently used American Home Shield for a claim involving our heat pump. While the initial diagnosis was carried out about three weeks ago, it took several calls to get the claim processed and approved. They just ordered the parts today. My experience with the technicians has been mixed; some were good and others not as much. Overall, I would say the cost and quality of service are okay.
Dear Donna,
We greatly appreciate your loyalty to us and thank you again for sharing your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I have been an American Home Shield customer, holding one of their higher-tier contracts at $115 a month. My experience with them began with an issue in my upstairs shower, where the floor and wall grout were not properly installed. When Home Choice Services INC came out to address it, the technician said it required re-grouting and tiling, but they informed me that such work wasn't covered under my contract, nor do they provide tiling services. This was particularly frustrating because AHS didn't suggest alternative solutions that could have resolved the leaking issue without tiling.
Each time I called for service, it cost me an additional $125 just to have a technician visit and assess the problem, and AHS required this payment upfront. They also did not offer a second opinion unless I agreed to pay again. This has happened several times, making it financially draining without any resolution.
While AHS has promptly addressed other issues in the past, the lack of support and suggestions regarding my shower has been disappointing. Furthermore, the language barrier with customer service was an additional challenge. I did share my feedback fully expecting it would be reviewed, but frankly, the overall experience has confounded my expectations. I've had both good and frustrating experiences. As for advice to others considering AHS, I’d suggest gathering all the facts about coverage and costs before committing.
Dear Marc,
I understand your frustration and appreciate your feedback. Please feel free to contact us at consumeraffairs@ahs.com so we can talk more about your experience.
Sincerely,
Kim
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2025
I recently had a claim with American Home Shield and had Reliable Garage Door LLC come out to address the issue. My garage door wouldn't go up, and when I reported the claim, I clarified it wasn't the door itself but the motor. The technician who came out was great; he was professional and honest, explaining that he could fix the motor but that I needed to pay separately for the wheels, as American Home Shield couldn't cover that part.
The repair involved the gear and chain within the motor section of the garage door opener. Now, the garage is functioning well. I'm very satisfied with the service I received, and I'd rate the experience highly, as the technician was prompt and efficient.
I've been with American Home Shield for about four years. Initially, my sister recommended the service. Although I had to pause my membership at one point, I'm pleased to be with them again. What I appreciate most is their responsiveness; they've addressed my calls consistently well.
However, I used to pay almost $100 a month in addition to $100 for service calls, which I found expensive. Now, I've switched to a less costly plan, with a $25 service call fee, which suits me better. While the cost was a downside, the overall experience with American Home Shield has been positive, and I have no significant complaints.
We appreciate the fantastic review and are glad we could be of service. If you have any further needs or questions, please reach out to us again.
Sincerely,
Kim
Media


