How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

Buyer's choice awards

Extended Car Warranties

How did we pick our winners?

The Buyer's Choice Awards, driven by consumer feedback, incorporate thousands of verified reviews from ConsumerAffairs users across the United States. These awards are based on sentiments important to consumers in various categories, identified through web research, and include assessments of whether consumers had positive, negative or neutral experiences with companies.

Best Coverage Winners

Direct administrator and obligor for most types of plans. Covers vehicles up to 20 years old for unlimited miles. Waiting period is 30 days and 1,000 miles. Offers 30-day refund guarantee. MBI products available in California.

  • Six customizable plans
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Free year of Elite Benefits
  • Choose any certified mechanic or repair shop

Provides coverage for cars, trucks, motorcycles and powersport vehicles. Perks include 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car coverage and trip interruption reimbursement.

  • Covers multiple vehicle types, including motorcycles
  • Offers comprehensive coverage options
  • Plans are transferable to a new owner
  • Includes roadside assistance benefits

Sells extended warranties for cars, motorcycles and EVs backed by American Auto Shield. Seven plans available. Contracts are transferable. Can cancel for a full refund within one month. Available in all states except California.

  • More plans than many competitors offer
  • Plans start at $99 per month
  • Month-to-month and price-locked plans available
  • Covers cars for up to 325,000 miles

Finalists

Offers exclusionary, used stated and powertrain protection for cars with up to 250,000 miles and 15 years old. Waives deductible if you go to a RepairPal-certified shop. Member of the Vehicle Protection Association.

  • Wide-ranging plan options
  • Covers older cars
  • Small down payments
  • Maintenance plan for life of policy

Best Claims Handling Winners

Direct administrator and obligor for most types of plans. Covers vehicles up to 20 years old for unlimited miles. Waiting period is 30 days and 1,000 miles. Offers 30-day refund guarantee. MBI products available in California.

  • Six customizable plans
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Free year of Elite Benefits
  • Choose any certified mechanic or repair shop

Provides coverage for cars, trucks, motorcycles and powersport vehicles. Perks include 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car coverage and trip interruption reimbursement.

  • Covers multiple vehicle types, including motorcycles
  • Offers comprehensive coverage options
  • Plans are transferable to a new owner
  • Includes roadside assistance benefits

Sells extended warranties for cars, motorcycles and EVs backed by American Auto Shield. Seven plans available. Contracts are transferable. Can cancel for a full refund within one month. Available in all states except California.

  • More plans than many competitors offer
  • Plans start at $99 per month
  • Month-to-month and price-locked plans available
  • Covers cars for up to 325,000 miles

Finalists

Offers exclusionary, used stated and powertrain protection for cars with up to 250,000 miles and 15 years old. Waives deductible if you go to a RepairPal-certified shop. Member of the Vehicle Protection Association.

  • Wide-ranging plan options
  • Covers older cars
  • Small down payments
  • Maintenance plan for life of policy

Best Experience with Staff Winners

Direct administrator and obligor for most types of plans. Covers vehicles up to 20 years old for unlimited miles. Waiting period is 30 days and 1,000 miles. Offers 30-day refund guarantee. MBI products available in California.

  • Six customizable plans
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Free year of Elite Benefits
  • Choose any certified mechanic or repair shop

Offers auto warranties for new and used vehicles. Has three plans available, plus custom options. Accepted at ASE-certified mechanics. Most plans are transferable. No published pricing or sample contracts.

  • Covers new and preowned vehicles
  • Three plan options
  • Choose your own ASE-certified mechanic
  • 20-year age limit on vehicles

Provides coverage for cars, trucks, motorcycles and powersport vehicles. Perks include 24/7 roadside assistance, rental car coverage and trip interruption reimbursement.

  • Covers multiple vehicle types, including motorcycles
  • Offers comprehensive coverage options
  • Plans are transferable to a new owner
  • Includes roadside assistance benefits

Finalists

Offers vehicle service contracts with 30-day money-back guarantee. Includes 24-hour roadside assistance. Choose your own repair shop. 10% back for referrals. Preferred pricing for members of some organizations.

  • 24/7 support
  • Direct payment to repair shop
  • Rental car coverage

Best Customer Service Winners

Direct administrator and obligor for most types of plans. Covers vehicles up to 20 years old for unlimited miles. Waiting period is 30 days and 1,000 miles. Offers 30-day refund guarantee. MBI products available in California.

  • Six customizable plans
  • 24/7 roadside assistance
  • Free year of Elite Benefits
  • Choose any certified mechanic or repair shop

Sells extended warranties for cars, motorcycles and EVs backed by American Auto Shield. Seven plans available. Contracts are transferable. Can cancel for a full refund within one month. Available in all states except California.

  • More plans than many competitors offer
  • Plans start at $99 per month
  • Month-to-month and price-locked plans available
  • Covers cars for up to 325,000 miles

Offers exclusionary, used stated and powertrain protection for cars with up to 250,000 miles and 15 years old. Waives deductible if you go to a RepairPal-certified shop. Member of the Vehicle Protection Association.

  • Wide-ranging plan options
  • Covers older cars
  • Small down payments
  • Maintenance plan for life of policy

Finalists

Offers vehicle service contracts with 30-day money-back guarantee. Includes 24-hour roadside assistance. Choose your own repair shop. 10% back for referrals. Preferred pricing for members of some organizations.

  • 24/7 support
  • Direct payment to repair shop
  • Rental car coverage

Past Winners: 2025