CarShield Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
About CarShield
CarShield offers customizable vehicle service contracts that cover new and used cars against malfunctions and breakdowns. Along with these extended warranties, CarShield also provides 24/7 roadside assistance, towing services, rental vehicle assistance and mobile app access. Month-to-month coverage plans include flexible monthly payment options.
- More plans than many competitors offer
- Plans start at $99 per month
- Free access to 24-hour assistance and repair facility map
- Month-to-month, price-locked plans available
- Covers cars with up to 300,000 miles
- Rental reimbursement isn’t standard
- Quote only available over the phone
CarShield Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (7,425)
- (680)
- (426)
- (253)
- (1,351)
Popular Mentions
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,881,224 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed March 28, 2021
Can't find anyone to fix my car that's cover by Car Shield in my area and the ones I did say that I'm still going to have to come outta pocket a couple thousand dollars for work to get done because y'all only cover so much.
Reviewed March 28, 2021
I have been with CarShield for over a year now. I have never had any problems with them. I feel bad that I had to cancel my coverage but my SUV was a lemon. I will be contacting them again when I get my new car without any hesitation.
Reviewed March 27, 2021
The man I spoke with was very knowledgeable in what was covered and what wasn't.. He also gave me a price then lowered it due to senior discount. I have a 2996 with just over 100,000 miles and still qualified for the Gold Package. With the year of the car and mileage, I expected less that cost more. If you have an older model car, and can't afford car payments, this is the way to go. BTW, everything he said was covered was the same on the contract. This man knows his job!
Reviewed March 27, 2021
I was happy to have this coverage, however, this car has been wrecked and was totaled so I no longer need this coverage. We will definitely use your service in the future when and if the need presents itself. Thank you.
Reviewed March 27, 2021
Car Shield stands by it word and service 100%. I am very satisfied and pleased. I highly recommend Car shield to be there when needed. My claim was handled in a fast no problem and a fast end to car issue.
Reviewed March 27, 2021
My 2011 Dodge Ram 1500 went into shop, shop called. Was given claim # and told Adjuster would call. So I call to status and was told no Adjuster would not call unless he had estimate. Repair shop was not given fax #, so I gave him # I was given and he faxed on 24th. No response as of 3/26. This all started in 3/22.
Reviewed March 26, 2021
Carshield is able to cover my car repair without any hassle. Repair shop dealer reported it took some time to process the claim which was a hassle for me to figure out what I needed to do as far as temporary transportation but after claim went through repair shop was able to get it fixed right away.
Reviewed March 26, 2021
Very informative. This is all I have to say about the experience, thank you. To writing more is just taking up my time, especially if I don't want to. The agent I spoke to was very surprised to find out that American Auto Shield's BBB rating was NR.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
I called CarShield for my issue but I ended up not using it because my insurance covered more of the cost. I do have to admit that the staff that helped me were very good and patient with what they explained.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
Brand new customer and I had several questions so I could better understand how to use this product correctly. Jessica was fantastic. So lucky she answered my call and CarShield is lucky to have her on the team. Thanks for listening.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
Rental car wasn't available because the job was expected to 1-2 hrs instead of 4hrs! I was carless for 4 days needing to get rides for things scheduled before the breakdown. I thought that was inconsiderate of Carshield to have that as a stipulation. Most car repair shops can't always get to your car the same day!
Reviewed March 25, 2021
Expensive coverage for my Honda but I hope if I need you down the road you will be there for me. My Honda has low mileage for its age and I hope everything holds up. But you never know what the future holds. So it is best to get insurance to avoid big bills.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
Was given very good and informative advice regarding my coverage that was very helpful. The representative was not only cordial but informative. He was able to explain things in my coverage that was unknown to me. In addition, he forwarded me a copy of my contract which made things easier to understand.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
A rental car and fixed my car and all I had to pay was $100 deductible if it's the blower on my air conditioner and fix something else. I can't remember what it was I had to get permission from to three different. It took about a week and a half but I had a rental so that was okay.
Reviewed March 25, 2021
I am so grateful to that commercial with Ice-T about CarShield. The response time for a tow was quick, the tow person was courteous and he took my car directly to my mechanic. The repair was done and payment for the repair was just as quick. The only thing left is reimbursement for my car rental, but I will be taking care of that on my day off. This is an awesome company and I would recommend it to everyone.
Reviewed March 24, 2021
I was hesitant about getting this coverage for my car. But after having some issues it has proven to be a necessity, the people are very concerned about my situation and ready to help get the issues resolved. The CarShield group overall is a amazing company caring, help with the dealership and pay to get my car fixed with no issues. One of the best decisions I have ever made is to get this coverage, if you don't have a factory warranty you need this coverage to keep your ride on the road.
Reviewed March 24, 2021
The lady that helped me was very polite and kind and polite. Couldn't get anyone better. Thank you very much. You was very helpful. The only thing I see that would be helpful is for them to fill out forms instead of calling another number or they call the shop directly
Reviewed March 24, 2021
Representatives that I spoke with were kind, helpful and informative. My vehicle had to be towed and the tow service was same day and the driver worked with me on the pick up time due to my being at work. The total job was done in a very timely manner. Thanks
Reviewed March 24, 2021
Car Shield was there when I needed help and I appreciate all the help I got from them. I totally recommend this to some of my friends. You're very reason boom payment was awesome for me. It work out for me. Just perfect for me. They took care of me. I took care of them by paying my bill. Thank you car Shield ????
Reviewed March 24, 2021
The they also sent a service tech to inspect which made sure that the dealership wasn’t overcharge us. Thank You CarShield; awesome job; I would recommend Car Shield to my whole family and friends, Very satisfy with Car Shield and the job. Thank you??? Much Love for Car Shield.
Reviewed March 23, 2021
My transmission was replaced, rental for 9 days and car moves very well. Customer services was reliable and helpful. Access to reach customer service was accessible and helpful. Also waiting for reimbursement for rental cost. Carshield is really true to their words and will recommend a friend.
Reviewed March 23, 2021
It would be more helpful and much better convenient to everybody, myself as your customer and to your company, to follow up any phone conversation with a confirmed email message with the subject(s) which was discussed. In my case it was the motor and/or the actuator of the Right side sliding door of my van. Also, the motor and/or the actuator of the third row Right window which opens outwardly. Both, door and Window, won't open immediately upon starting the engine and most of the time it takes more than an hour for the sliding Right door to open.
Please bear in mind that I am a handicapped senior citizen bound to wheelchair whereby my Chrysler 2014 Town and Country is fitted with automatic foldable Ramp that deploys automatically once the right sliding door is fully opened. But this month I suffered due to the sliding door won't open and the ramp wouldn't be deployed and I was not able to enter my van till 45 minures and when the door opens by itself after I started the engine of my Van! Very weird. My mechanic told me that it is for sure the motor or the actuator of the door is malfunctioned.
Reviewed March 23, 2021
I have not had an experience with your services as of yet, but you are pushing it! I talked with someone who answered the telephone today, earlier, and they told me to go on line for any information I may need, but it seems like I am going to have to find another way!
Reviewed March 23, 2021
I sent copies of a repair bill to you following your representative's instructions. I am still waiting for reply. Hope you can reimburse me for the covered repair even though I paid for it. Please accommodate me. Please! Please, please, please! Thanks, thanks, thanks, thanks.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
When I first got Car Shield I was told there would be no problem with repair to a vehicle I just brought from a mom and pop dealership. This car passed all requirements and no issues. The last week it started blowing blue smoke out the tailpipe and I brought to a shop which saying it was gas and oil mixture which causes harmful smells in to cabin of car and my adviser says he not covering repair. That not right.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
I love my Car Shield contract. It gives me the insurance I need while driving my 06 VW back and forth to work and other places. This is my first time with CarShield and I'm just relieved that if something goes wrong with my car the deductible is only $100 dollars. Thanks CarShield!
Reviewed March 22, 2021
Took my F250 to the shop to get repair but CarShield said the oil cooler wasn't under my warranty. But when I join I ask would it cover all of those thing. Now that I need you all it don't cover my claim. I'm really upset.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
You didn’t really do anything but the customer service was great. I just took my jeep to a shop you recommended and I had to paid for so minor things, like filters and they put air in my tires. That’s all.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
Thoughtful, to the point, great value, knowledgeable, easy to get in contact with, good coverage, great customer service. I feel a lot better and secure knowing our car is under warranty again. Thanks CarShield!. Car dealer was too expensive. Give them a call, find out for yourself.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
As I have not had any trouble with my car at this point and have not had to call on CarShield yet, I cannot honestly give them a rating at this time. If and when that time comes I will be more than happy to give my opinion on their service.
Reviewed March 22, 2021
I called into customer service about my problem that just arose and was told the process to take it to repair shop that accepted CARSHIELD WARRANTY. The repair shop called claims to start working on my car and was told my problem not covered under warranty. But customer service told me it was covered when I called in. I still have car problem. I asked for something to show me what's covered. Haven't received it yet. Please cancel my service. Refund me my money. This is a JOKE, SHAM, FRAUD, I will be reporting CAR SHIELD TO THE BBB.
Reviewed March 21, 2021
Customer service reps were all very nice! Made it easy to obtain and even got a discount for 3 vehicles! Made it a pleasant transaction for me. Staff was very knowledgeable about your services and your different levels of coverage!
Reviewed March 20, 2021
I inquire what are covered on my contract and she explained well. The agent is polite. Answer all my question about what is covered on my contract. Well done. I hope I will not encounter major problems with my vehicle for a long time. The agent is very nice. She knows well about my coverage or what am I entitled. Thank You Teddy **
Reviewed March 20, 2021
I called prior to scheduling service and was told problem would be covered, then when dealer called Car Shield, they were told it was NOT covered. I do not care for Customer Service that does NOT know what is really supposed to be covered and what is not. Seriously Considering Cancelling.
Reviewed March 20, 2021
You need to stop making commercials. You are over selling a product you can’t support. Nobody wants to sit on the phone for hours with you for a claim just to be turned down. Your agents even comment they can’t keep up with what you are selling. There are much better extended warranties available.
Reviewed March 19, 2021
Received a mailing from CarShield discussing available service plans for my 2015 Mercury. Needless to say, I do not own a 2015 Mercury since that brand ceased to exist years earlier. Have to wonder how a company whose sole mission involves service plans for vehicles could be that out of touch with reality or show that level of inattention to detail. Don’t see how I could trust them.
Reviewed March 19, 2021
Talk to the agent to receive a copy of my CarShield contract. It is to be sent out by mail. When I clicked on the my email, the contract never came up. So I called in. The customer service rep was very nice and indicated a booklet would be sent out to me.
Reviewed March 19, 2021
I called the day before taking our Ford Fusion to the dealership to make sure our problem was covered by our warranty. I was told the purge valve was covered under the engine warranty. Took the car to the Ford dealership and got it fixed and then Carshield told Jordan Ford the problem wasn't covered. I only took it there because I was told it was covered. $640 is what it cost. Terrible.
Reviewed March 19, 2021
Called in concerning a car rental because my car is in the shop being repaired. They inform me that I can only have two days which I will have to have it back Sunday not enough hours. The shop has been waiting on you all for the part. Not satisfied.
Reviewed March 18, 2021
Car was rough shifting so I took it to AAMCO Transmission and had them do the work on the car. It took a little bit like five six days for them to fix it but CarShield took good care of it and make sure it was paid. I appreciate it very much.
Reviewed March 18, 2021
The contact I had was positive and the service being covered is complete, based on discussions with the transmission shop. The problem came as a total surprise, and I am happy that the coverage is as good as advertised. I appreciate it very much.

Reviewed March 17, 2021
On 2 Feb 2021, I agreed to take a CarShield Warranty but changed my mind and cancelled on 3 Feb 2021. I was charged for the initial payment and then again on 2 March I was charged for another payment. I called a few days ago and the customer service man said it was a mistake and the amounts would be refunded. I received a credit back for one amount but not the other. I phoned 17 March and Kaycee said the 2nd one was coming in a check. Thank you.
Hi Stephen,
Thanks for the review and sorry to hear it didn't work out. Be on the lookout for the refund check and let us know if you ever want to start coverage back up again.
Reviewed March 17, 2021
I took my car in to the service shop for A/C service and Fuel system needing repaired. Suspension repairs were identified that are not included in the warranty coverage. Overall, very satisfied with the cost and coverage and ease of use.
Hi Danielle,
We're happy to see we saved you $1812 on your recent repair!
Reviewed March 17, 2021
Phone reference person very knowledgeable and helped with setting up the best account for me. I was lucky enough not to have to use their service but have friends who have and stated the service was good. I would certainly recommend this company.
Hey Jacqueline,
Thank you for the review and when your vehicle does encounter a repair, don't hesitate to give us a call! In the meantime, if you have any questions about your policy or what is covered and what is not, please let us know.
Reviewed March 16, 2021
After viewing the television advertisement daily about the coverage CarShield had to offer it was the initial representative who I spoke with regarding my account returning a call was my deciding factor to select Carshield. I look forward to being a customer for the life of my vehicle and I will be recommending Carshield to all of my family and friends.
Hello Cecelia,
Thanks for the review and welcome to CarShield! Thank you for choosing us! We want to make sure you're completely satisfied with your policy, so please contact us with any questions or concerns you may have regarding your coverage.
Reviewed March 16, 2021
So far my experience with you all have been good. I will know more about you all after I have used some of your services===Thank you for the experience I have had with you....from Willie **. Thank you for the opportunity to use you all for all of my automobile needs.
Hey Willie,
Thank you for your time and review. If you have any questions give us a call!
Reviewed March 16, 2021
Battery/Alternator. The battery would not charged. There seemed to be a problem with the alternator. Firestone fixed it. First time we used it and did not get authorization to take it to Firestone. We were happy to be reimbursed regardless.
Hi Judith,
Glad to see we could help you save on the alternator repair!
Reviewed March 16, 2021
Thank you for the affordable price that covers both of my vehicles. It was so nice and easy to speak with your representative, I was also able to get a better price on my previous car. Thank you so much!!
Hey Denise,
We appreciate your time and we are glad you took the opportunity to protect your vehicles. If you have any questions give us a call!
Reviewed March 16, 2021
I E-mailed a receipt from Enterprise to your department that handles that and have not heard, or seen any reimbursement check yet. It has been a while since my car was repaired. Please let me know ASAP.
Paul
Hi Paul,
Thanks for the review. However, it looks like the repair you had included 1.8 hours of labor. In your contract, you will see rental reimbursement is only for repairs of over 4 hours of labor time. We are sorry if there was any confusion about this. We are glad we could save you $222 on the actual repair though!
Reviewed March 16, 2021
I enjoyed talking to the lady about the coverage, I just purchased my vehicle and worried about making sure my vehicle would be under a warranty but she put my mind at ease. After 20 days I will be secure. Thank you, I wish I remembered her name.
Hi Michelle,
Thanks for the review! It looks like you most recently spoke Joseph. Prior to that to you spoke with Corey. Either way, we're happy to see our reps could help you out!
Reviewed March 16, 2021
I was very happy with my service. I haven't had to use the insurance yet, but feel much more comfortable knowing that I'll be covered for major repairs on my truck if and when it is needed. Our truck is our only car and it needs to be in good running condition for us.
Hey Olivia,
Thank you for the review and when your vehicle does encounter a repair, don't hesitate to give us a call! In the meantime, if you have any questions about your policy or what is covered and what is not, please let us know.
Reviewed March 15, 2021
I called CarShield to see if my car was covered. I explained what was going on, and I was told that it was covered by CarShield, but when I took it in to Firestone and after the diagnostic test a representative from CarShield called me telling me that what I needed done was not covered by CarShield, and the past that was covered could be fixed until I got something else fixed first that wasn't covered.
Hi Sharon,
Thanks for the review and sorry for any confusion regarding you claim. It looks like multiple parts needed to be fixed. One part was not covered under your coverage, however, the compressor might be covered. For the compressor, we just need a diagnostic test done to determine this. Your claim is marked as inactive as we have not heard back from the repair facility regarding this. We'd like to help you so if there is anything we can do, please contact us.
Reviewed March 15, 2021
I received Great service. Although I have not had to use the service as of yet. I called to inform them of my change of vehicles. Personnel is knowledgeable and friendly and helpful. I would recommend this service to friends and family.
Hi Nola,
We're happy to hear this. Let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed March 15, 2021
My payments are being drafted from the WRONG account and I have tried to get this straightened out TWICE now and it is NOT being changed to the correct account YET. I had, I thought, this set up to draft from a specific checking account and NOT from the debit card that I used to make the first payment when I purchased the policy. I am NOT satisfied about this and still do not know if my repeated request is going to show my payments being made by ACH Draft from my designated bank account.
Hi Charles,
If you have questions about your payment method, please call Payment Processing at 1-800-587-4162 and they will be happy to help you out with that.
Reviewed March 14, 2021
The people are very nice. I'm hoping to hear something about my car tomorrow. The adjuster was out to look at it on Thursday or Friday. I would probably recommend them. Will keep their coverage and will definitely acquire for my next vehicle.
Hi Laurie,
Thank you for your time and review. If you have any questions regarding your claim, please reach out to the claims administrator, American Auto Shield.
Reviewed March 14, 2021
Updated on 05/05/2021: Car was brought in for service and was initially misdiagnosis. After repair and upon next unfortunate incident. Carshield was there to help me get back on the road promptly. Thank you carshield. Thank you for your nice customer service. Quality second to none.
Original Review: Melissa helped clarify. Issues I was having with my service. Was being denied because I'm ** man With nice car. Hopefully American Autoshield does what they're contractually obliged to do. Thank you for servicing a Veteran. At first I was skeptical. I was reassured that my vehicle will be fixed and contract honored. Thank you Carshield for making America great again.
Reviewed March 13, 2021
I never had the opportunity to use Car Shield. I now have a new car, so I had to cancel it for now. When I first signed up, it was too soon to use and later I had no reason to need it. It was too expensive to just keep for no reason since my new car is covered for 7 years.
Reviewed March 13, 2021
Your company is not good. Broken promises of coverage. Rude workers. Overall bad. I am recommending to anyone I know to not use your company. Already got it moving on social media with now over 109,000 many likes and agreement of how bad your company is. More to come too. Good luck.
Reviewed March 13, 2021
Efficient and customer driven. Great coverage and easy reading of contract wording. Peace of mind driving long highways by myself monthly. I am not worried anymore. I feel I can extend my investment in my car, drive it till the wheels fall off!
Reviewed March 12, 2021
This story is about a Chrysler 300, that overheats. We replaced the radiator and the thermostat (our pocket). This didn't fix the problem. Called Car Shield, to see if there was a mechanic in our area that accepts Car Shield as no mechanic we know does. They recommended a AAMCO. Steve the owner, nice guy. So we drove the 300 there, and that same day, Car Shield DENIED the claim citing causation of a cracked block was a non covered oil pump. The next day we went up to AAMCO, and the owner Steve told us that's not true. The block isn't cracked, nor is there a malfunction of the oil pump. Steve told us that the head gasket was blown, thus warping the head, allowing water into the oil. Knowing this as fact, per recording played to Car Shield, they still denied us.
Opened a Better Business Burough case (BTW they have an "F" rating), and they repeated the lie of causation as a matter of public record, and closed the case, while still taking money out of the bank account, to pay for??? Looking at the reviews here, "This review is featured by CarShield" yeah, that one... They are taking claim that they approve claims. This is also not true according to their statement in the BBB case. I'm going to say it... Car Shield is a fraud. Change My Mind.
Reviewed March 11, 2021
I have not had to use my coverage as of yet but I am happy to have it so that I don't have to stress over any breakdowns...whenever I have had questions or communications with Carshield, I have been very satisfied with the response and resolution of my inquiry.
Hi Marie,
Thank you for the review and when your vehicle does encounter a repair, don't hesitate to give us a call! In the meantime, if you have any questions about your policy or what is covered and what is not, please let us know.
Reviewed March 11, 2021
I drive from Arizona to California to visit family often. I feel safer on the road with CarShield! It covers the expensive repairs that come with these newer vehicles. A lot of my friends are signing up for Carshield because I say good things about the coverage.
Hi Joan,
We appreciate your support and review. If you have any questions about your policy don't hesitate to give us a call!
Reviewed March 10, 2021
Obtain warranty for a used SUV purchase. Gave history (or lack of) that I had of the vehicle prior to purchasing warranty, was told not a problem. Time to use the warranty I would have to first put up approx. $2000 before they are able to make a decision. Never mind that an experienced mechanic explained exactly what needed to be done, the engine needed to be replaced, (let me put this into perspective, it actually showed the timing chain failed, in which the mechanic told me he had to ultimately replace the engine on about four of the same vehicles in the last couple of years), they wanted me to pay for tear-down (approx. $2000) before they make a decision.
The initial diagnosis was made at the dealership and I in-turn took the car to my certified mechanic because he is less expensive. If approved the $2000 would be reimbursed, my point is I had placed two other small claims, heard nothing from that, I paid. Therefore, I have no confidence in them approving a larger claim, I would just be out of $2000 plus the cost of the repairs. There is no communication with them, you always have to call to ask for the status. I have had a representative get nasty with me and hang up. This has been such a trying experience, I can not tell you anything good about CARSHIELD, other than they were very timely in taking their money out of my bank account every month.
For the money that I wasted with them, I could have almost paid for the car repairs. You live and you learn, and I am writing this review to help others, STAY AWAY! Two different repair shops told me that CarShield was not going to pay, they had never experienced payment from them, but I held out hope, but no, not a dime. I can not discredit anyone's positive review, BUT...I can't see all of the greatness happening.
Charlene,
In regard to your most recent claim yes, the admin needs to know the cause of failure which a teardown would show. This is outlined as a possibility in your contract. Please know, not all repairs require a teardown to be performed. If the mechanic was so sure its the timing chain then we would cover the cost of that and the teardown. However, we never heard back that a teardown was performed so we did not get the chance to help you out on this repair. For a previous repair, we were told you moved your car to a different repair facility and again, we did not hear back from you or the repair shop in regard to that repair so we could not move forward. We have helped millions of people save over $1 billion in repairs and we wish we had the opportunity to help you on yours.
Reviewed March 10, 2021
Thank you for your feedback and attention, when I call I always get someone on the line that is patient with me and gives me info I need. I thank you for all your help with my car and it's great to have help when you need it.
Hi Jonathan,
We're happy to hear this. Let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed March 10, 2021
Supposedly this company prides themselves on being one of the top auto warranty companies. I had one of the worse experiences with them. The lack of unprofessionalism and customer care was just disgusting. There are various loopholes and shady dealings in their contracts and policies. In the end all I got was the round around and no support or resolve in regards to my car issues. They fight really hard to do everything they can to not have to fix your car and then take no accountability or provide any actual assistance. I will never be doing business with this company again and I would never recommend them to anyone.
Reviewed March 9, 2021
We have cancelled our contract with CarShield and are awaiting a refund that was promised. During the time we had the contract, we did not have to use your services. When dealing with customer service, for the most part, we had an adequate experience. Thank you.
Hi James,
We're sorry to see go! If anything changes, feel free to contact us.
Reviewed March 9, 2021
I have been paying $109.99 monthly for a year and when the check engine light came on I put the car in the shop. Problem was Code P0128 for ECT below thread hold. Also found blown fuse to OBD connector and thermostat was replaced. Car Shield told mechanic this was not covered. A claim was not filed. I had to pay $504.06.
Marlene,
Yes, a claim must be filed in order for us to have a chance at helping you out with repairs. Give us a call and we can explain how to submit a claim so we get a chance to help you on your next repair.
Reviewed March 9, 2021
I received outstanding customer service from Johnathan **. He took the time to explain the plan in detail. I was very happy with my experience with Johnathan to make my decision on getting a Protection Plan for my vehicle.
Hi Quentin,
We are pleased to hear you found our customer service team helpful! If you have any other questions, don't hesitate to contact us.
Reviewed March 9, 2021
Jessica was very helpful, we lost signal and she called back, she got me a step closer than I was yesterday. Hopefully the inspector comes out sooner from all the great work she put forth helping me out.
Hi Adrian,
We do hope to get you back on the road as soon as possible. Thank you for your patience and please let us know if you have any questions.
Reviewed March 9, 2021
I call them this morning and made my claim and by the next hour a tow truck pulled up and drove it to the repair shop. The customer service was good and provided all the information that I needed. Car Shield did good.
Hi Akeem,
We’re happy to help. Let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed March 8, 2021
I experienced great customer service and loved the value and coverage. However, I told the Rep that I was unable to download and print my contract and still haven't send me a copy. That is very negligent. Service after sale very important; I am in sales too: I know!
Reviewed March 8, 2021
My experience with Car Shield is okay. I just signed up and the customer service rep was great. She explained the different plans that they offer. I chose that plan that we figured out would be best for me. Now I am signed up with Car Shield.
Reviewed March 8, 2021
Thank. Much help. Everything for labor service. CarMax they called. Told me for warranty multiple everything. To my car was in service then make sure test obey. They told me back normal too. They fixed labor and a new part ordered. Finished and I got happy. My car work normal fOr. Thank much help me.
Hi Connie,
Glad to see we could save you $325 on your alternator.
Reviewed March 8, 2021
Due to personal financial hardship, I was going to cancel. However, Ashley was very friendly, empathetic, sympathetic, courteous, and knowledgeable. She discussed with me the pros and cons of maintaining the plan. Of course, the pros outweighed the cons. She willingly changed my due date and helpfully lowered my monthly premium.
Reviewed March 7, 2021
I called about text messages I was receiving to purchase Car Shield. Since I was getting these texts I called Carshield to see if I was a member. An agent was very helpful and ensured me I was a member and would make sure the texts would stop. She was very helpful and I had a stroke. She was very patient and understanding.
Reviewed March 6, 2021
I had a great, easy experience. I took my car to the shop. They did a diagnostic, handled everything and all I had to do is pay my hundred dollars. I would recommend to anyone. It was easy and hassle free.
Reviewed March 6, 2021
I thought the people on the phone were friendly and honest. They didn't pressure me into buying anything and it was one of the more pleasant conversations I have had with a salesperson. Everything seemed straightforward and I was able to purchase it over the phone.
Reviewed March 6, 2021
I called to see if a repair was covered by my policy and was told that it was. It was the clutch and leavers for an automatic transmission. So, I had the car towed to a local shop who took CarShield. After paying for the tow and an additional diagnostic, CarShield denied the claim because although it's an automatic transmission, the car shifts like a manual transmission. I paid for coverage, I paid for a tow, and paid for a 2nd diagnostic all based on a phone call with a live representative... and got denied by lawyer wording technicalities. Bottom line, after all the money spent on coverage, tows, and diagnostics... I ended up paying double for a repair.
Reviewed March 6, 2021
Brought car to repair shop as directed on 4/5/21. Shop called several times between 9-12 noon on 3/5/21, was put in a queue and never heard from Car Shield. No call to shop to me at home. Cancel my contract!
Reviewed March 6, 2021
So far I haven’t had any problems with my car. I just hope that when the time come Car Shield be there for me and my family. I seen the ad on TV and see how much people save on their car. Am planning to put my there car two
Reviewed March 5, 2021
Jeneane was very helpful during my application process... She was helpful when I was concerned about approvals of claims, and she assured me it is a smooth process, and that she and her husband both have Car Shield. I hope this is not a scam in refusing to pay for repairs due to fancy wording in the contract. If this policy works as it advertises, I will recommend to all my friends and post on Facebook, but if it doesn’t? I will also tell all my friends and post on Facebook.... I hope it goes well? Honestly, I hope I never need to use it.... Thank you.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
Our repair shop applied for payment and it was refused. It would have been nice if Car Shield had communicated with me about the reason for nonpayment. I was not satisfied with the handling of this claim. In the future Car Shield could at least send information stating reason for refusing coverage.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
I have 2 vehicles covered by Car Shield. The first one had a service bill of 925.00 and car shield only paid 256.00. The second vehicle had service in the amount of 724.00 and car shield only covered 225.00 of this repair. My policy had a 100.00 deductible. Car shield does not live up to the advertisements. Very disappointed. Cancelled my coverage and I have nothing nice to say about car shield.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
Electrical Information for my car when I have my maintenance man to check it out next week when I have my car checked out. The operator answered my questions to have him to call if I need support from Car Shield.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
Great customer service. I was very pleased with the service that I received. The staff was professional, helpful and courteous. They were very knowledgeable about their product that they were selling. I was very satisfied. I will be returning to conduct business with you in the near future.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
Online car sale that help also help in a time like this. I will tell my friends about CarShield and let him know that they need get it before it's too late. They do need it. It's a good thing to have and I thank CarShield for being there when people need them.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
For 03 Mercedes Benz. After difficult time finding a repair facility it finally worked out well with cooperation with all parties, including your company Small mt. town has limited service centers for this vehicle!
Hi Bruce!
We have now partnered with RepairPal.com to help you find a repair shop! We've listened to customers like you and found a solution to make the process easier for you! And glad to see we could save you $292 on that repair!
Reviewed March 5, 2021
My 2013 Toyota Tundra has at the dealer, Auto National, Fort Myers, Fl since 2/27/21. Has not been repaired, due to CarShield not responding back. I have been in contact with several people from CarShield, have not responded back to me. I have the Diamond Plan. Had to get a rental car. The first week.
Hey Raymond,
Glad to see after the wait, we saved you $2711 on your air injection pump repair. We do apologize for the delay and happy to see we could help you out.
Reviewed March 5, 2021
I haven't had to use any of my coverage but I'm in love with the monthly price and deductible. I have told all my friends and they say they're going to purchase Carshield. They don't know what they're missing out on.
Reviewed March 4, 2021
I’m a new customer and they called me for exact mileage on my car. Agent was very pleasant and documented the information promptly. It was a pleasure speaking with the agent. Thanks again for the follow up. Please feel free to call again if you need anything else.
Reviewed March 4, 2021
My wife and I are very satisfied with your customer service. They're very polite and considerate and have all the information of any question that we have to ask and we have no problem with telling our friends and family about this program with CarShield. Thank you for everything. Mark
Reviewed March 4, 2021
My chat with the agent was pleasant and informative, but it turns out I am unsatisfied with my policy and the conversation I had with the sales person it was misleading as is the TV commercials. You don't cover repairs like regular maintenance, and brake jobs. When I purchased policy, I believed that was covered.
Reviewed March 4, 2021
I was told my VISA denied your charge and I provided another card number. Your representative was very helpful answering all my questions and explaining everything I needed to do. He was courteous and timely in securing any information I needed.
Reviewed March 4, 2021
Very happy. Did not disappoint. Just wish the period from vehicle goes in to repair when finished was a bit more quick. Customer service kept told me the same thing over and over. Adjuster took a couple days to call but honestly was very happy with the service. Quick I have to say and everybody on the phone was very helpful. Thank you guys.
Reviewed March 3, 2021
Dealt with customer service at least eight times to resolve this issue. Took too many tries to get odometer reading adjusted. Many of customer service representatives gave mi guided information. Finally this is resolved and I am hopeful there will be no need for further issues.
Reviewed March 3, 2021
My previous request which was two months ago was never entered, and this customer service representative took care of everything as it should have been initially. Great job! I would recommend Car Shield without any reservations. Car Shield has the best coverage for the money.
Reviewed March 3, 2021
We are new with Car Shield going on 3 months now. The customer service people are so nice, kind & very knowledgeable! Like I said we haven't had you very long but my husband & I are very happy that we got accepted. Thanks Car Shield!
Reviewed March 2, 2021
The guy I spoke with originally who was Lewis was very patient and polite with me compared to Megan I just spoke to after I got an email from Car Shield about my actual mileage on my car. I think they should be compared to each other.
Reviewed March 2, 2021
CarShield was great. Sent a tow to us in a timely manner and at very low cost to me. The tow truck driver was friendly, courteous and professional. Got my car to its intended destination safely and quickly. I love CarShield.
Reviewed March 2, 2021
I was to get discounted on a service and Car Shield was nice enough to lower my monthly payment. I was grateful for the for time of my policy. Courtesy of customer relations overall was great and their understanding!!
Reviewed March 1, 2021
Made a claim over a week ago and I can’t get any answers about my car that is covered under the warranty! I’m losing money every day. Don’t know if you’re trying to get out of fixing my car but the parts that need repair is under the warranty that I have with you. Could someone call me back at **?
Reviewed March 1, 2021
I looked up CarShield on Google and called a the number that was not CarShield. The person at the other end of the phone had nothing good to say about CarShield and scared the heck out of me!! I hung up and found the right number. The CarShield rep. put my mind at ease and I proceeded with my claim, which was easy and painless!
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2021
When I signed up didn't have cash on hand so I set payment up for payday and it went through just as planned have not needed yet but its there when I need it after grace period so I thank the person answering the phone was very helpful.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2021
I no longer have this contract. I replaced it with another contract that better suits my needs. My time horizon is 5-6 years, so the long term continuous coverage in Car Shield is less important than the five-year cost. During the sales process, I was a bit annoyed that it took three offers from the sales associate to get to the best price for my vehicle.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2021
I asked for my payment to be taken out of my bank account on 2-26-2021 and there was no problem with that and the representative set it up and it was done on 2-26-2-21. I hope I never have to use it but I know if I do that everything will be took care of.
Reviewed Feb. 28, 2021
I havent had any problems, I believe I need to update my billing info. I keep forgetting. I'll find out more how good they are whenever. I need service done on my vehicle. I'll be in touch so I can update info to them.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2021
It’s been six weeks now and nothing done to update my mileage for my account. They suck!!!! I’ve called and talk to 15 different people. I’ve sent numerous emails and nothings done yet after six weeks. This is a big joke this company.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2021
I've dealt with Carshield among many other aftermarket car warranties. They are not worth the hassle, being a service technician and advisor they will find any possible way to get out of paying for claims. The worst I have seen was an engine claim denial due to sludge build up. The customer recently purchased the vehicle and had done an oil change per their contract but the claim was denied due to sludge build up, I can understand that, however the history of the car from the previous owners has nothing to do with the new owner and the new owner should not be punished or ripped off due to the previous owners neglect.
Furthermore, how can sludge been seen without a complete engine tear down? Are customers expected to not only have a certified inspection and an engine tear down before purchasing? I mean come on, that is unforeseen and it is not the new owner's fault. These companies are garbage, save your money and put it towards a repair fund!
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2021
I recently purchased coverage from CarShield. My vehicle's cluster module went out after 20 days and over 500 miles. My speedometer, gas gauge, odometer and rpm stopped working. This is a safety issue. If I have no idea how fast I am driving or how much fuel I have then this should be fixed and covered right? I called to see what steps did I need to do and if my coverage covered. Because if not, I wanted to cancel my account. They had already drafted my account on the 30th day. They counted the day I called and got service which was late at night and I was not going to be driving. I read over my contract and seen that electrical was not covered. I called to cancel. They then lowered my rate because they could not reimburse me. I agreed. But then called back to cancel the service because it was pointless..
They told me to get a diagnostic and then they'll know if I would be reimbursed or not. I went ahead and spent the money I didn't have and submitted it to American Car Shield. The next day I received a call telling me that it is not covered. I called again to cancel my coverage and wanted to get a reimbursement. I knew that I had to "eat" the diagnostic but hopefully make it up with getting my refund for canceling. They were very nice and tried to help until I went to the supervisor who just said that they couldn't do anything and that they were the highest that a customer could go.
I told them that it is not cool that I could have had my reimbursement the day prior but instead I had to wait until my refund period was past the 30 days. They told me that the day prior was 31 days. That means they counted a day that didn't really count. All in all I lost out almost $250 which I did not even have just to not have any results or help. This company, not the customer service representatives, but this company rather take your money than help you out.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2021
I lost two days pay waiting on your adjusters to okay my claim to have my car repaired. I feel like it shouldn't take 2 days to approve a claim. If somehow CarShield can improve on that aspect of your coverage it would be wonderful to me. Thank you.
Reviewed Feb. 27, 2021
Everyone was polite and helpful. I will recommend this to family and friends. I'm happy with all they would take care if my car will be in default. My payment will only be $100.00 out of pocket. Happy how all agents were knowledgeable.
Reviewed Feb. 26, 2021
Kept requesting documents that already Been submitted or I would call just to be put on hold for thirty min then hang up. Not only did CarShield waste my time... waste my money paying for something that didn’t follow through with what they were advertising.
Hi Dewayne,
On 2/12 we spoke with the repair facility and spoke with Hector to ask you about continuing with the diagnosis on the engine problem. Since then, we have not heard back from the repair facility about whether this diagnosis occurred and if it did, what did they find. We want to help you with this claim, but the repair facility needs to provide us with more information.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2021
My experience with CarShield has been good so far, but it's really too soon to say. I was pleased with my interaction with your representative named Tanesha. Once I receive your booklet and have a chance to read it over, I'll be in a better position to talk about my experience.
Hey Stephen,
Welcome to CarShield! We have emailed over your contract on the day you signed up which was 2/19 as well as when you called back in on 2/22. I see you requested that we mail you a copy as well and that is on its way. Please look over your policy and contact us with any questions you may have.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2021
Took you 3 weeks, 25 phone calls for you people to see if you could fix it, LAZY, SLOW, not doing his job. FIRE HIM!!! You people are testing my patience. All I got was the run around and a ** story. You failed the service, and timely repair.
Clarence,
We're sorry for the delay but do see we paid almost $3,000 for your repair in December. I also see you called us on 2/17 to start a new claim. However, the repair facility call was disconnected it appears and they never called us back from what I can tell. If your car is still at the shop, please have them contact American Auto Shield.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2021
No one inform me about anything via email or by phone. Of course if I call Car Shield or the car repair place (AAA-Auto Care Plus). My car is still in the shop and it has been there for three weeks. Still not repaired.
Hey Robert,
We were made aware on 2/16 that the repair shop is unable to perform a teardown to determine the cause of failure. We spoke with you on the same day and recommended you to move to a different repair shop. Then as of 2/23, the repair shop says they will do the teardown. That was a delay of 7 days as we thought you were taking the vehicle elsewhere.
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2021
Purchased a contract with Car Shield based on your promise announced in your commercials. BUT reality was unclear. Didn't realize you would ONLY pay for repairs, and I would have to pay unforeseeable out-of-pocket labor costs, PLUS find a qualified car repair shop that accepts Car Shield first. My husband and I are very busy, but this method doubles our workload. (We live in an area with limited qualified car shops.)
Because of COVID19, I am currently unemployed and can no longer afford your monthly deductions from my account. Your customer service reps tried to save my account, and I appreciate their efforts. But I don't have the time nor money to continue to find a qualified car repair shop AND to pay you and the car repair shop for labor, too.
Therefore, I have no other choice but to CANCEL my account with Car Shield. Please inform MEPCO to stop deductions from my account. I really hope you re-engineer your business model to protect your reputation and ensure long-term sustainability. Since I have more than 11 years of B2C and B2B marketing experience, let me know if I can help you in anyway. Thank you.
Hey Norma,
Please note: We cannot accept cancellations here. You must contact us for this to process.
In terms of your claim, I see we are paying $568 on your window motor. We pay parts and labor. We use a nationally recognized labor guide to determine hours needed to repair parts and some repair facilities choose to overcharge for labor. In those cases, we recommend going with a different repair facility because they are overcharging and it will leave you paying more out of pocket than necessary.
Reviewed Feb. 24, 2021
I had Car warranty from one other companies On one of my other cars. They refused to pay a claim because it was fair wear and tear. You know normal driving. So I would recommend Car Shield to everybody. With car shield there is no contract If you want to cancel. The other companies want a contract. If you want to cancel it takes an act of Congress to do it.
Hi Michael,
We appreciate your support. If you have any questions don't hesitate to give us a call!
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2021
I have the Diamond W Elite warranty. I have a booklet that explains all the parts that are covered. I have a repair on a covered part that has not bee negated by any of the listed exclusions. The repair facility has been waiting for literally WEEKS for CarShield to approve the repair. They are forcing me and the shop to jump through hoops in the hopes that we will give up and they will not have to do what they are contractually obligated to do. I had really high hopes when the sign up process was so easy, but now cannot imagine how I could be more disappointed in their service. Having my car in pieces for weeks while they play games is completely unacceptable. Would NOT recommend.
Hi Kelvin,
First, we here at CarShield, do not approve or deny claims. That is completely up to the administrator of your account. We do see an approved claim for $820 from June as well as your current one. For your current claim, we have waited from 2/3 to 2/22 for the repair facility to determine the cause of failure. We could not move forward without this information.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2021
During the sales call, I was lead to believe that the entire drivetrain including the clutch was covered. A year or so later, my clutch starts slipping and I call and I'm told it's covered. Then I take it to my mechanic and he is told it is not covered. I am refunded one month's fee. I would NEVER do this again. I feel completely ripped off. I was told that extended warranties were a rip off. My fault for not listening.
Hi Ted,
We're sorry there was confusion about your coverage. We ask that you review the policy and let us know if you have any questions about it before needing a repair done. We've helped millions of customers save over $1 Billion in repairs and we wish we could've helped you, too.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2021
In short, I called to make a payment. I talked to 2 different people. I made my payment over the phone. This was Thursday the 18th. I was told I would get my receipt via email. It never came. I called the next day and was told they would mail it via the USPS. It never came. I called MEPCO. They referred me back to the Car Shield customer service. I didn't call them but the bottom line is I never received my receipt. Very poor customer service.
Hi Richard,
We reached out to MEPCO and asked them to send you a receipt. Not sure why they transferred you back to us. Also, if it was sent via USPS it may still be on the way. We will make sure you get this one way or the other! Please let us know if you do not have the receipt by 3/1.
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2021
Just more contact would be nice. My car has been in the shop for a couple of weeks and then inspector just came out today. I just would like to have my vehicle back because I'm at this point in my 3rd week of renting a vehicle to get back and forth.
Hi Steven,
We appreciate your patience. I see we are waiting on the adjuster to review the recent inspection that was done. Typically, they reach out to the repair facility but each case is different. We do hope we can get you back on the road soon!
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2021
Very good experience dealing with Alexis regarding the cost of my program and other key points. She was very prompt and courteous when we were chatting. She sounded very professional and was courteous to me an ole buzzard who has retired.
Hi Bill,
Happy to see Alexis was able to help you out! She's pretty great!
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2021
I'm a new customer as of February 19th however, I had not received my contract information via email. Carlos was very helpful in resending my contract to a new email address as well as requested a paper copy be sent to my home address. Additionally, he confirmed my contact information was correct and the email address updated. Thanks for your assistance.
Hi Kalynn,
Glad to see Carlos was able to help you out and welcome to CarShield! You have a 30 day money back guarantee and we recommend reviewing your policy during this time and contact us with any questions you may have. Our happiest customers understand what is covered and what is not. Let us know if we can help clarify anything.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2021
I had my coverage for just over a month and of course my engine light came on. No big deal I thought, probably just a loose gas cap. Was I wrong!! It turned out to be my transmission, and the cost was thousands. CarShield came through and my cost was 100 deductible and part of my car rental as they did have a "cap" on the amount they would pay. I would definitely recommend these guys should you need after market coverage.
Hi Thomas,
Thanks for the review and looks like you got coverage at the right time! Happy to see we saved you $3318 on your transmission!
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2021
Wasn't quite what we expected as far as coverage, car rental etc. We have nothing else to write, it was just a back and forth, back and forth conversation in getting our car fixed. What did you pay on the car rental? It took three days.
Hi Marlene,
Glad to see we could save you $885 on your repair! In terms of your rental, if the repair took over 4 hours of labor you would be eligible for up to $40/day for a max reimbursement of up to $280. Please contact American Auto Shield with the rental car receipt for reimbursement.
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2021
We had a great experience and we thank you for being there for all of us. We will give all friends a fine recommendation. Please teach other business how to act. We would have a better world to live in. Thank you again. Donald.
Hello Donald,
Thank you for the kind words. We are pleased to hear you found our service helpful! If you have any other questions, don't hesitate to contact us.
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2021
I paid $79.99 a month for 10 months. I brought my car in for repairs and CarShield covered nothing. It is a worthless warranty. I never received the policy and finally got it in the mail after I cancelled and it covers nothing. Very disappointed. I barely am surviving financially so losing $800 really hurts. I had to get a loan to pay the $4500 auto repair bill.
Hi Robert,
We can only help out on repairs for parts listed on your contract. Your policy covers many, many other parts. Also, an oil leak should not cost $4500. We recommend contacting a different repair facility for your future repairs.
Reviewed Feb. 20, 2021
Great customer service. Great price and gave me peace of mind when at home or traveling. The person I talked to answered all my questions and gave me information I didn't think of. I will definitely be telling others about your company and great customer service. Thanks.
Hi Charles,
We appreciate your time and we are glad you took the opportunity to protect your vehicle. If you have any questions give us a call!
Reviewed Feb. 19, 2021
Lisa in your Customer Service was very helpful and polite. I was not pleased at all with the first person I spoke with. It was upsetting to see all the bad reviews and then to speak with someone that made me feel I was being interrogated and treated so rude.
Hi Mary,
We're sorry to see you go and apologize if the first rep did not meet your standards. If anything changes and you'd like to get coverage again, just give us a call.
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2021
I began having engine problems and I took my vehicle to Audi for diagnostics. Audi has a TSP method that is used to discover mechanical issues. Carshield isn’t accepting the TSP test results presented by Audi El Paso. This TSP method is well known throughout the industry and is very effective. We live in an age of technology and the methods used by these technologies are very accurate and are designed to save time and money. Carshield wants to have the entire engine removed just to get a visual of the results already proven by a more advanced TSP method. And all this to be done at the cost of the customer, wow such great customer service this is. With this being said. I’m a disabled veteran with a spouse on Active duty. I would expect better service and cooperation at least for those who have and really do provide a “SHIELD".
Hi Terrence,
Looking over your account notes, I do see you spoke with a claims rep the other day. A technical service bulletin assists technicians in finding what the issue could be but does not definitively give a diagnosis. In order for this claim to continue, we need the true cause of failure and this teardown is covered if it turns out to be a part that is listed for coverage on your policy.
Original Review: Feb. 18, 2021
It was smooth but I would’ve liked it more if I didn’t have to pay $300 of my own money to fix my car. Seems like I should have paid 100 and been done. Since I’ve have the cover for so long and paid so much into it and this is my first claim. If I saved 150 a month and insured myself that way it would be cheaper.
Hi Dante,
We do see we saved you $520 on your starter. In most cases, you would just need to pay the deductible, however, the shop you went to did not allow us to send in the parts we recommended which left you paying the difference of their part minus the one we recommended. In the future to help with your out of pocket expenses, make sure the repair shop allows parts to be shipped in.
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2021
I had to change my auto pay card # due to fraudulent activity in my bank account. Young lady was very helpful and knowledgeable. Took my information in a matter of a few minutes. Representative was very nice and pleasant to talk to.
Hi Kathryn,
We're happy to help you with this! It's never fun when you have fraudulent activity going on. Please let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed Feb. 17, 2021
Any time I took my vehicle to get fix nothing cover. I’m getting tire of this situation. I call they said to please send in my papers work. If you guys can reimburse here I sending in the Paper work.
Hi Betzaida,
I am showing we paid $219 for your window motor on 2/21/21. Please contact us if you have questions about this claim.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2021
Updated on 04/09/2021: Car Shield is a scam. You buy your warranty from Car Shield but when you need your car fixed you deal with American Auto Shield. They are hard to get in touch. They give you little information. My truck was in the repair shop for 3 1/2 weeks. The shop had to call American 10 times half the time leaving messages. I personally had to call American Shield 20 times. I have a record of the calls to American Shield. American Shield called me once.
The warranty I bought was for engine transmission, differentials, transfer case but when I needed to have them fix my engine they would only pay labor, no engine, no gaskets, no head that they say they covered. I canceled my contract. I wish I had spent time checking them out more. If you check out Car Shield there are so many reviews that are so negative. The list goes on. Don’t waste your money. There are so many other companies to deal with. They have great commercials. All lies. Do not trust them.
Updated on 02/18/2021: The truck has been in the repair shop since 2/11/2021. The repair shop has called American Auto Shield 8 times. Still waiting for a answer. I have called 13 times to American Auto Shield. I have sent all the service records so has the repair shop. If I haven’t been calling so much I don’t think I would get a answer. Today is 2/18/2021. It’s been a week. The plan I have said it covered heads. The car repair shop said that’s what it is. I am not happy. I’ll have to see what happens from here ???
Original Review: My truck has been in the repair shop for a week waiting for the adjuster to approve. I keep calling them. Have sent service records. The repair shop keeps calling them. This is becoming a joke. I don’t know what to do. I paid for the warranty. They sure move slow. I hope tomorrow they will approve. 2/16/2021.
Hi Dave,
Thank you for your patience. The adjuster is not a CarShield employee and is dispatched based on your location. Unfortunately, we cannot control how quickly they get to and review your claim. We are doing everything we can on our end to expedite this as quickly as possible and get you back on the road soon. Please let us know if you have any questions.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2021
My car is having issues with transmission which is cover in my contract. It’s been nearly two weeks in shop and no accountability on CarShield addressing the issues. Instead I’m getting the run around. I feel as though CarShield is a scam and I’m about ready to report this because they’re not honoring the contract. Nobody communicating but myself and getting the same story/lies..
Hi Mary,
Thank you for your patience. It appears there was a delay because the repair facility is not able to perform a teardown to determine the cause of failure. We see now that you have moved your vehicle to a new facility which is great! Once we can determine the cause of failure, we can move forward with this claim.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2021
I was told that you guys would cover my serpentine belt as well as the tensioner.... It was all lies. Please make sure that customer service, knows what they are talking about before giving you false information....I was left to pay for my or car services. Thanks. Got nothing!!!
Hi Janice,
We do not see a claim was placed for those parts so it does not look like we had a chance to help you on those repairs. Please contact us if you have questions about claims.
Reviewed Feb. 16, 2021
Overall experience was positive. A little slow approving my motorcycle repair, but I attributed that to the person not fully understanding motorcycle repairs. But he did eventually approved my claim. At this point in my dealings with Carshield, I would recommend the service to family and friends.
Hey Willie,
Glad to see we could save you $2300 on your recent repair! We appreciate your patience with this as well.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2021
I’ve been with CarShield since May 2020, my car broke down on Nov 9th and till this day my car is still sitting at Aamco waiting for Car Shield to do their job. The Manager of Aamco as well as myself have been attempting numerous of times and left numerous of voicemails. Haven’t heard from him since. I received a call from Car Shield saying my part (engine) was four days out but guess what, that was two weeks ago. So I’m seeking for an attorney for this matter because it’s ridiculous how this is going on. It’s been over 3 months of walking to and from work. I don’t blame Aamco for not wanting to work with them in this region. I wouldn’t advise anyone to go through what I’m going through.
Marcus,
We apologize for the delay. As we have discussed on a few phone calls, the biggest delay was with the repair facility not determining the cause of failure. They also tried sending in videos but it was audio only and that slowed the claims process down about 2-3 weeks. Please contact us with any questions you may have. We are working to get your claim processed as quickly as we can on our end.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2021
Wanted to use non factory parts - had to go around and around with them - the car dealership even had to get involved and had trouble with them. Finally after much negotiating the car dealership was able to use the factory part but we had to pay for the difference. I would not recommend CarShield to anyone as they never disclosed that they provide refurbished parts. It is simply not full disclosure and I repeat it's not what we were told when we signed up. Not worth the time and trouble.
Frank,
We do see we saved you $688 on the new radio! Your contract states the information regarding parts that we ship in to the repair shop on page 11 and 13. It is disclosed there and we apologize if that is something you were confused about.
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2021
Your customer service reps were very good. Maybe I need a better explanation of what you cover or you all give the clients a list of these vendors who honor the prices and what's set forth in your policies. I was told $165 by you but wasn't told the things that weren't covered. The shop that has my car is telling me $915. Granted the dealership can be higher but it needs to be a better setup. I'm not sure if I'll keep CarShield.
Hi LaTisha,
I do see we approved your repair for $1386! If you had your spark plugs replaced during this repair, that is a part not listed for coverage. Also, the repair facility overcharged on labor according to our nationwide labor guide causing you to pay an extra $65 out of pocket. We want to help clear any confusion up about your coverage and this claim that you may have. Please contact us and we'll happily answer any questions you have.
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2021
I joined Car Shield thru my friends to say what a great company you are. I become a member and when my car broke down Car Shield denied my claim. The claim adjuster Josh never returned my calls. Poor customer service. I liked Car Shield but not now. Now my friends are questioning your company.
Hi John,
We do apolgoize we could not help out on this repair. It was determined the repair you needed was due to a lack of maintenance which is not covered under your policy. If you can send in previous service records to prove otherwise, then we can move forward with this claim. In terms of the adjuster, they do not work here at CarShield and are a 3rd party company and we cannot control when they return calls. Please contact us if you have any questions about this.
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2021
Latter part of January I had to change bank account and found you had my auto listed as 2012 as you had wrong EIN number by one letter and you had the wrong mileage. I sent all I was asked for at that time to correct this problem then on 2/5 our car had a problem and we took it to the shop. On 2/8 we took our paperwork to the shop for them to call for repair. Well they called me and said we were still listed as 2012. It took almost all day to get this corrected and when the inspector finally looked at the car on 2/11 here it is 2/14 and we still have not heard any word on the outcome. Now the longer you take to cover the problem the more I feel maybe I picked the wrong car warranty company. Please address this issue as soon as possible. I will be calling again (4th time) Monday 2/15 to get an update.
Hi Mary,
We apologize about the incorrect year and mileage we initially had. That has since been corrected. In terms of the claim, it is approved. We did have to wait for the inspection from the adjuster then wait on their report. We appreciate your patience and please let us know if you have any questions.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2021
I am at the beginning phase of the repair. The claim representative has not yet evaluated the vehicle yet in the shop. The mechanic mentioned about a "deposit" but after speaking with a customer service representative I will not comply.
Hey Winston,
Thanks for the review. In terms of the claim, it looks like a teardown is needed in order to determine the cause of failure. If the teardown shows that a covered part failed, we will pay for that part and the teardown. If its not a covered part, you will have to pay the teardown. Just want to make sure you understand this. Let us know if you have any questions.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2021
The driver side controls for windows, locks & doors stopped working. My mechanic put in a request regarding the work and it was completely covered by CarShield. I am very satisfied with all aspects with my experience. Highly recommended by me to family and friends.
Hi Theresa,
Happy to help you save on repairs! Let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed Feb. 13, 2021
CarShield is great and l will tell my friends and family about them. And also l will be with CarShield for a long time. My wife love them very much too, And also my daughter do too, And my uncle in Brown Summit. Have car's coverage with CarShield too. Love them. Thanks very much!!!
Hi Donnie,
Thanks for the review and your support! We look forward to helping you save on future repairs!
Reviewed Feb. 12, 2021
When we called the Agent was very respectful and very helpful. We believe this is the best insurance we could buy. He went through everything involved in this policy. He was very informative. We received our plan right away so we could make a copy and be able to see exactly what we bought. Very impressed. Thank you, Sandra and Garry **
Hi Sandra,
Happy to hear this! Let us know if you need anything else.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2021
We are very impressed with the CarShield; however our Dealership doesn’t accept third party, so we have extended our warranty with our dealership. Other than being accidentally misled that all dealerships accepted CarShield, it would have been nice. Everyone we have spoken with since we discovered that it isn’t for our Car, has been very nice. When I receive my refunded payment and down payment, I will definitely give CarShield 5 stars.
Reviewed Feb. 11, 2021
My warranty on my car ran out and I was nervous about something happening so I looked into extended warranties. I was pretty skeptical but CarShield has been absolutely amazing. I have only been a customer for 6 months and 3 months ago they paid $1308.20 to replace the transfer case in my 2013 Cadillac SRX with no fight or hassle, it was so easy. I also used the included roadside assistance a couple of months ago when I slid off the road and had to be winched out. They paid 100% of the fee for the fee immediately, I didn't have to pay first and wait for reimbursement. I honestly don't know what I would have done without this coverage. If you are on the fence or feeling skeptical take the leap, you will not regret it!
Hi Jade,
Thanks for the review and happy to see we could save you $1308 on your recent repair!
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
Even though engine won’t operate with this, they said it wasn’t covered and I had to pay. Scammers. Don’t waste your money on these crooks, 880 dollars to get engine repaired and I thought I had a warranty.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
No complains whatsoever! I am completely satisfied customer! And don’t have Any problem recommending Car Shield! Car Shield is one of the best decisions I’ve ever made concerning future problems that could arise with My car! Every representative that has helped me throughout my experience were polite and efficient!
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
I haven't used the service yet. But any questions have been answered politely. If anything goes wrong with one of my vehicles, I will be able to let you know how good the coverage is. But as far as being friendly, they've been great.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
We purchased CarShield for two of our vehicles in the past 8 months, and had one claim on one of the vehicles prior to selling the car. The claim was paid quickly and the "team" at Car Shield were responsive and professional. We were able to use a trusted neighborhood repair shop, which was a bonus, as well!
Hi Mona,
Happy to help you save on your recent repairs!
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
Placed an order for Car Shield. The associate was knowledgeable, professional, and people friendly. What Questions I had were explained. I felt very reassuring that I had made the right choice to purchase Car Shield. I am positive when something happens to my vehicle, that I can be reassured that Services will be rendered.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
Everything went great. No problem. Work was excellent and I appreciate Car Shield. Take care of my repairs that was need on my car. Excellent service. No complaints. Very satisfied. All repaired car run great. Very happy with service.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
I researched car warranty programs and went with CarShield after reviewing coverage, deductibles and other reviews. Watch out. My turbo went out and they only covered 1/2 of the $4,500 costs. Their coverage for the engine and drivetrain doesn't cover everything despite what is in writing.
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2021
Breanna and Kelsi at American Auto Shield helped me get info to process my claim. Kianna and CarShield got me a new claims adjuster after being ignored. I want to Thank All these ladies for helping me and explaining so much. An email has been sent w all records needed. Thank you so much.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2021
My car broke down. It cost me $780 for coil packs on 6 cylinders. Not covered by CarShield. My car broke down. Short on the wiring $465. Not covered by carshield. I paid $150 a month for full coverage. $1800 each year for coverage and nothing was paid for by car shield. Transmission went out at 180000 miles. Not covered by car shield.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2021
I should be able to do add on and I thought that you guys over covers everything well. I just needed a 02 censor and Honda called Carshield and they were told that what my car coverage doesn't pay for that.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2021
I called to see steps needed to get my transmission replaced. The customer service representative was very helpful. Now I hope the Claims administrator is as helpful. I will be calling them at this time and hope to get the same excellent service.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2021
Was initially thinking about this program for some time. Was thinking my car may be too old and mileage just over 100k. Was I surprised to find out I could get coverage with the gold plan that would cover all major items and labor. And I was given a deductible of only $100. Now I really have peace of mind when I have to go out for food errands.
Reviewed Feb. 8, 2021
Some confusion with exactly what I have covered as when I set it up, some things not explained; I do not have a packet of info from Car Shield nor a card to keep in my wallet for reference. In a panic I did not know I had to call for authorization prior to getting car towed.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2021
I have not had any experience with Car Shield outside of my enrollment in the latter part of January, 2021. The Service Rep did a good job explaining things once I let him know I needed him to do for me. I am having a contract sent to my door for reference and to carry in vehicle. There are too many different telephone numbers to call for different matters. The company should give a card to customers, instead of relying solely on the phone.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2021
I needed instructions on how to file my very first claim. It was difficult finding the correct department to talk to. Customer service at my mechanics shop says CarShield is difficult to reach on the telephone to file claim.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2021
Very pleasant young lady helped me and provided me the information and resolution I needed. I would recommend to anyone needing a car warranty. It did not help me since the vehicle already had a warranty when I purchased it,. It was under the manufacturer's warranty yet. I would recommend Carshield to most people. If only they would get rid of the Ice T dude who is a Trump supporter.
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2021
I am very satisfied with the Car Shield team, in how they work with the dealers, I didn't have to do a thing, everything was taken care of. Thank You so much for all your help. I appreciate the quality of the work that was done. And the fact that they gave me a courtesy car to use to continue to work.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2021
I did not have a hard time with CarShield! I am sure CarShield will work out fine. I trust the name. I have heard about how well this company is. I do not have to say or type more. Try it for yourself!
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2021
Awesome. Kudos to Sierra. Her Customer Service skills were exemplary!!! She literally made my day. All my questions were answered with friendly and knowledgeable responses. This is my first claim, and I'm hoping that when it's time to pick my car up, it will be as pleasant as my call.
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2021
Car Shield was quick in taking care of getting my van repaired. It is very comforting to know I don't have to panic when something goes wrong. The cost of getting Car Shield is reasonable and I can afford it.
Hi Katherine,
Glad to see we saved you $527 on your ball joint repair!
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2021
I am trying to get to look at my policy... I once again haven't been able to even see my policy yet! When I spoke with the agents they were very professional and very helpful! I have absolutely nothing against them. DON'T LIKE THIS POLICY!
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2021
The dealership took care of everything. I was not involved in the initiation of service but was thankful I had such good coverage. I would recommend Carshield to anyone. The repairs were done well and I have no complaints.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2021
Achieved a COVID-19 extension and reduction in rate. Reduced my rate from $99 to $69 and extended my February 5th payment to March 1st. Another payment will be due March 5th to catch up. I thought I would have to cancel my policy, but this allowed me to keep my policy.
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2021
The customer service person that I had contact with very helpful, and knowledgeable as to what I needed to do for my accounts, and it was very pleasant to work with her. If this lady ever needs a recommendation for anything call me.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
I had a pleasant experience. Everyone was pleasant and helpful. I appreciated everyone making sure I understood everything. If I had a question I was sent to someone who could help me. I am glad I was able to get this coverage. We are on a fixed income so major repairs are very hard to cover.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
I'm writing to you to let you know about the superb experience I had with you all. Please, keep up with this great work you all display and continue to excel with this exceptional service...This is a excellent example of a leader in the field in service to the American people.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
Kimberly was extremely helpful following my call about canceling my service. She was able to provide a major discount on service. So far, Car Shield appears to be a great value and I am glad to retain coverage at least for the time being.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
Internal failure. The door lock was making noise and had to be replaced. I did not know if this was covered so I contacted the office and was told that it was covered. I went to the garage in Opelousas and was told that I could get the work done within 48 hours. I took the vehicle in and work was completed within 60 minutes. I was told that I was going to save money doing this so I did it. I must admit that I am very satisfied.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
Lincoln dealer opened claim on Jan 22, 2021. So far today, Feb 3, 2021, I have had only one call from CarShield to which I responded with the documents they requested on Jan 28.2021. On Feb 2, 2021 I called to determine the status of my claim, spoke with two people and ultimately was told a third person was to review the "part replaced" and I would hear from that person yesterday, which I did not. This vehicle is my only one, I paid the dealer on Jan 27, 2021 for the car repair to get my vehicle back operational and to me.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
I’ll give J my representative who help me today a high 10. He’s an exceptional young man, very honest, very knowledgeable, very professional and very patient with me. He (Jay) answered every question I had for hi, thanks J. Please be and stay safe. Have a blessed day.
Reviewed Feb. 3, 2021
They always aim to get customers the greatest affordable rates. They are committed to making sure customers are satisfied with their coverage and policies. I will be staying with this company for a very long time..and hope that others will choose CarShield.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
The conversation and description of products was well explained and easy to follow. I wish that the products provided were a little less expensive but the cost is understandable. Overall, I was extremely satisfied with the experience and it moved along with ease.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
Your Representative was very Friendly and helpful. Thank you so much. I am very happy and I don’t have anything Else. I am very happy with CarShield and I will recommend to my family and friends and that’s all.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
Stephanie **
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
First time calling. The promptness and great customer servicing and the ease of understanding was fantastic. Looking forward to seeing how well my Silver Coverage Plan comes into play when needed. Can not comment on how well the coverage works. I signed on in January.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
I call for my car to be tow to a shop today. I talked with a young lady. Sorry I don't remember her name but she was really nice and helpful to me. She found me a tow within a hour of my call. Thank you CarShield.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
Still waiting for your decision on a salvage title too much Chevy 2004 Silverado. I'm just still waiting. I'm hopeful that things will work out and we don't have to cancel this policy. I would love to continue my policy so that I can be able to take my vehicle in. Call me and let me know. Thank you.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
I'm a college student and I have 2 jobs I need transportation to, but here I am 3 weeks later and they are taking forever to service my car. NOT SATISFIED! I pay just like everyone else. I expect it to be done in a timely fashion. My axle falls right under the gold package which I pay for. I don’t see why it takes 3 weeks to review. And I’ve yet be accepted for my rental I was promised. I’ve in total missed 6 classes and called out of work 3 days. Thanks.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
My Transmission was fixed and I'm satisfied with the way CarSheild handled everything. They made sure my 2015 Yukon was handled well and fixed in a timely manner. Thank you guys for jumping right to work and doing a great job.
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
Great customer Service!! Have already Referred 6 friends and family members and they all have your insurance now! The representative I Had was the best and and very understanding knowing I have a fixed income. Thank you. Mitchell
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2021
Paid off my contract on 1/24/2021. Called to make sure that there would be no other automatic payments charged to my VISA card as it's easier to stop them ahead of time than it is to get the money back after the fact.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
Making sure to follow up with me. Checking to see my service receipts have arrived. He listened to me and treated with in a professional matter. When I called before calling Gage I was getting the runaround. Gage listened to what I had to say. I was so frustrated when all the other people reached out to me asking for me to fax or email all my service receipts. The service man Bobby ** at Tommy Vaughn Ford has always taken care of me. Everyone else I spoke to just didn't listen that I have only had the SUV repaired at this one place.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
Calling to find out when my January payment was going to be taken out of my account. Thought maybe it had been overlooked and I didn't want two payments coming out at the same time. I have been very satisfied with the service I have received with Car Shield and would recommend them to any of my friends.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
I had questions about the contract which were all answered satisfactory. I called several times and always received a helpful response to my question. I will put my car in the repair shop tomorrow and see how the contract works, Thanks for asking.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
The representative was very professional and helpful. She answered all of my questions. I would recommend your company and this rep to all of my friends. I hope to never need to use your services, but if needed, it is good to know you all are there for me.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
My husband had bought an older vehicle and we didn't know if it could be covered. Nancy was kind enough to run the miles and year to see if the truck could be added. Also changing payment, canceling one card and replacing with another..
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
Just as I said I'm glad to have CarShield. I didn't have to use it but I have it in case something goes wrong with my car. I would and recommend CarShield to my family and friends and suggest that everyone needs to have CarShield 'cause you never know what will happen with your car and you want to be protected when it comes down to your car.
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
For what I pay a month for Carshield, they paid less for my repair work than I did. Didn't cover the hoses or taxes. I had to sit at the garage for 2 hours waiting for Carshield to send payment to the garage for the work they did on my car. Was very disappointed!
Reviewed Feb. 1, 2021
I needed a new date for payment. Is there is a payment due? Can you still take auto payment withdrawal. The girl was very helpful with my requests. I am on a fixed income. That comes on the 3rd. So she was happy to give me an extension.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2021
Agent was very informative and helpful. Sent him the information that I requested. Came in a very timely manner. Thank you very much period. I am glad I had chosen your company to work with. They are always quite helpful. Thank you in advance for all your help.
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2021
You've got a terrific team there with CarShield and I appreciate it every time they call me as I'm caring for two seniors, my parents and it's hard to find time to be timely with my payments to CarShield. So thank you for your reminder calls from your collections dept. They're all very courteous and helpful. All your Sales, Marketing, Telemarketing and CSR's or Collections Depts Teams all deserve BIG raises or and more commissions. Excellent Team - Excellent company! Thanks again CarShield! Best wishes, Eve ** South Philly PA :)
Reviewed Jan. 31, 2021
Professional and patient. The salesman explained the benefits of the warranty. It was a pleasure to have him as my sales consultant. I would highly recommend him. I transferred the Diamond package to another car after selling the other car which had CarShield.


