First American Home Warranty Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+2 more
About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 40 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.
Visit homewarranty.firstam.com- HVAC tuneup coverage available
- No age limit on appliances
- Discounts on related products and services
- Not available in all states
- Does not publish detailed pricing
First American Home Warranty Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (4,666)
- (1,105)
- (500)
- (326)
- (2,440)
Popular Mentions
- 4,946,193 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,946,193 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed Sept. 22, 2017
My cousin had First American Home warranty and I got a good recommendation from her. But the first time I wasn’t too impressed because I think I might have had a new person and they didn’t know what to do. I had to call a couple times to get it straightened out. But the second time they were really on top of it. The claims representatives were courteous and the technician was awesome. He wasn’t here that long since he fixed things right away. He also was a very nice person. It was a good experience and I was really happy with it.
Reviewed Sept. 22, 2017
I bought a home where the previous owner already used First American Home Warranty. On the phone, I looked at a couple of other warranty companies and the prices all seemed the same. I stuck with First American since I already came through with them. When I submit a claim, they’re very fast and I like them. I call them up and let them know what's going on and they look at my warranty to see if it's covered. Then they’d let me know if there is a charge and they’d give me the number of the person that they're sending out as well as contact that person themselves. Once they do all that, the company calls me and schedules the appointment.
The claims reps were always very professional and so far, the technicians that they sent out to me have all been great. But I had one that’s bad and he was on his cellphone and busy having personal calls while working on my stuff. The next time I had an issue, I asked First American to send somebody else out and that’s what they did. Nevertheless, the quality of the work was very good. We're very happy with First American Home Warranty and I plan on keeping them.
Reviewed Sept. 21, 2017
First American was part of the contract that came with our house. I've had another home warranty in the past and I like First American better because they use small businesses instead of big ones that do everything. Small businesses are easier to get out and seem more receptive to what I had to say. We've had them for three months now and we've already submitted a claim. I did it online and it was easy. The overall experience has been wonderful.
Reviewed Sept. 21, 2017
I've had First American Home Warranty since I bought my house and it was part of the deal. I go online to submit a claim and I go on the website and request service. I’ve interacted with the claims reps a couple of times and they were nice, which only goes so far. Their contractor came out and I already knew what the problem was. It's a warranty water heater and they contacted the manufacturer and said that they’d be giving hold of me within 24 hours. I still haven’t heard anything from them and it's been three days that I don’t have any hot water. I thought that I'd at least get a phone call by yesterday. Now I would have to get my colleague in and see what's going on. I hate to make three phone calls for one situation but I have to. I don’t like bugging people and I pay good money for this service from First American every month. The overall experience with them was pretty good except I still haven’t gotten any satisfaction on my call.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
We've always had a home warranty whenever we owned a house. It’s like life insurance or auto insurance. You have to buy insurance if you own a house or a car, or if you get married. We might have had a warranty with First American for our previous house and they were good then. Anyway, we took our friend’s word about First American and got insurance for our current house from them. Submitting a claim with First American wasn’t too difficult. I just called and told them what was going on and they relayed this to the contractor that they picked. The technicians were very good, helpful and friendly. They introduced themselves, looked at things, and explained what they were going to do. Everything has been great with the work done.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
Well I have a 2 year old fridge. I have had First American the whole time I have had it. In July it broke. I called First American and they sent Sears out. Sears said it needed a new compressor. Then the next time they came out they said, "No you need a whole new fridge." First American then said they need a second opinion. The second opinion told them the fridge needed replaced but the parts are under a manufacturer's warranty. First American tells me now that since the parts are under warranty I need to go through Kenmore.
Kenmore me no and that I have to go through First American. I called First American again and they said that they will not replace the fridge because of the manufacture warranty. But I asked, "Well you are supposed to cover labor and the warranty only covers parts." They said that's not their problem. If this is true why would First American allow me to pay for them to come out and why do I have coverage on a fridge that they won't cover. I feel totally taken advantage of by my home warranty.
Hello Maegan,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
I am blown away by all the positive reviews... They MUST be paid reviews by First American. My experience so far has been absolutely horrible. From what they're willing to repair to the terrible attitude of the claims person and her supervisor telling me that she is the highest level I could speak to within the entire company. I have a 20 year old refrigerator that is on the verge of dying - nothing works (from the refrigerator stuck on freezing temperature, ice maker, ice and water dispenser not working, and the incredible noise it makes). They refuse to fix anything except the temperature sensor. They sent 2 incompetent contractors who fix appliances on the side (they have full time jobs). It's been over a month since the problem was reported and nothing has been fixed. Other insurance companies would have replaced the refrigerator.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
When we first bought our complex years ago, I heard about First American. When submitting a claim to them, I do it over the phone and usually, I don’t have any problem. It’s been okay dealing with their claims rep and the technician’s quality of work was fine. The last claim was for the air conditioning for the back unit.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
We’re happy with our experience with First American Home. Their contractor, Blueline, came right away when we called, did our air conditioner, cleaned up their mess, and left. They’re excellent and performed great. Since then, our air conditioner has been working fine. We're happy with First American and it's been fantastic.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
The realtor that I went through suggested that I get a home warranty from First American, so I went ahead and got it. Submitting a claim was good and easy. The claims reps were very polite. It was awesome when the technician came to do the repairs and the quality of the work done was good. First American has been very easy to deal with and I've had a good experience with them.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
The previous homeowners purchased the First American plan for us when we bought our home. This was our first home purchase so we didn't have a whole lot of experience. I asked some members of a local moms group and a few of them have good things to say about First American, so we went with them. We submitted a claim. It was a quick process and the tech that came out was positive and helpful. He had to come a few times but the problem was taken care of. We've been satisfied with First American.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
My appliances are not new and I want to be secure and also to have a peace of mind that I got something in case I needed it. I had a home warranty before but I didn't like the company they hired. I put a claim and they took a long time and didn’t respond as quickly as First American. I submitted a claim to First American for my spa. Submitting the claim was easy and the customer representatives were very helpful. When I call for any reason, they respond fast. I've been taken care of the way it should be. The people they sent worked fast. They repaired the spa and it's working good. I will recommend First American to my friends and neighbors.
Reviewed Sept. 20, 2017
First American was added when we bought our house and we wanted to keep it. They were also recommended by the real estate agent. Submitting a claim has been good so far. We had Central Appliances fix several items and they were good, fast and they called us. But Sears has been extremely bad. We just put a claim for our washing machine two months ago and it still hasn't been fixed. The guy from Sears who came out changed the pump in the washing machine but it's broken again and the guy can't come back until a month later to repair it. He was also chosen to report to First American but he hasn't so First American hasn't done anything about it. We don't want to have anyone from Sears coming to see my appliances anymore.
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2017
In the spring 2016, I called First American (FA) Home Warranty three times for my HVAC system. The FA assigned the job to an incompetent heating and AC service company. The contractor failed to show, failed to call and ignored my numerous messages. I suffered in the cold home until a replacement company responded. If FA was slow to respond, therefore, I will not renew with First American after multiple years with them.
Hello John,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2017
Every time I call I get someone who barely speaks English and goes out of their way to make the claim difficult. With almost every claim I have submitted, the first contractor that is assigned to my claim has not been capable/willing to perform the work needed. With one exception every claim has required at least 2 separate appointments and 2 different contractors to come out and get my claim resolved. The only way anything gets resolved is when an adjuster in the United States is assigned the claim, even getting that done is like pulling teeth. Most recently I had "Karla at ext. **" assigned to my claim. I left her a message on 9-12-17 and without a return phone call she closed out my claim. I have attempted to contact her 2 more times, and have still not received a phone call back. I am currently waiting for a phone call back from her supervisor.
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2017
My air conditioner went out, so I submitted a claim with First American over the phone. My interactions with the rep and technicians were very professional and the techs got the AC fixed in less than 30 minutes. All in all, First American is a good company.
Reviewed Sept. 19, 2017
I was with Sears and had their homeowner plan, but I wasn’t satisfied with what they charged, so I switched to First American Home Warranty. The plan for the overall home of First American's was much cheaper compared to that of Sears which costs about $75 or $80. Submitting a claim with First American was great and everything was smooth with the claims rep. I had wonderful interactions with the technicians who knew what they were doing and took care of business.
Reviewed Sept. 18, 2017
I had a dryer stop heating. I called the company and requested service. First they attempt to send a repairman 20 days later. I explained that was unacceptable. They found another. He would be here in a week, they would contact me for an appointment. After several days I finally hear from the servicing company and the user setting the appointment sound like she is talking into a poor speakerphone. Finally an appointment, The day arrives for my appointment, between 11 and 2. I receive a call around 2:30 explaining the technician had a flat tire and he will be "a little late" he arrives at 7 pm. After 45 minutes he determines it is a Thermal fuse for the dryer. He explains my machine is a "crappy Korean made machine" and he does not carry the part. He will need to order the part. While he is describing the part I find it online and could of had the part in hand by Monday, it was less than $15.
The technician scribbles what he has done and explained I need to sign and give him a check for $75. The technician leaves and I never hear from him again. Finally a week later I call the fine people at First American expecting some assistance, RECEIVED NONE! I was informed the part was scheduled to arrive on Friday. Now it is Monday. The issue has been on going for 17 days. I have called the service company and never receive a call back. I have contacted the Warranty company and the claim was escalated to a "Specialist". The "specialist" called and left a message, that they contacted the Servicer and has not had a response.
I have called and talk with several people and am unable to get any assistance. Save your money DO not pay these clowns anything. So after I finally get someone to answer me they say "Well, we can wait on this technician or we can have a new company contact you!" You have got to be kidding me, Are these idiots really that incompetent?
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Sept. 18, 2017
When I bought my house, I was given First American for a year. I've had no problems with the claims except for the last time when I called and told them that the drain for my AC was stopped up and water was going inside the house. I asked if the warranty covers it and the lady told me there was no problem. But when the technicians came, they told me the warranty doesn't cover the issue. They didn't tell me that and then they were supposed to give me my $75 back. Otherwise, filing a claim with them is easy. All the other times were fine too. The technicians came in, did the work and got it down.
Reviewed Sept. 17, 2017
Hurricane Harvey came throughout the Corpus Christi area and we lost power for a week. When the power came back up, the blast freezer wasn't acting the same so I contacted First American. I gave them the model number but I couldn’t understand the guy. I don’t think his first language is English although I have to get used to that at this day and age where you’re talking to people in India for stuff that’s going on here in the States. He said something about the 28th of September and I said, “What?” Then he said he would give me the information and then once the contractor has contacted me in two or three days, I could go ahead and let them know what my concerns were. I agreed to do that and wait.
It had been a couple of days and no one contacted me so I contacted the people who we supposedly had the contract with to say they should get here sooner rather than later. However, the lady I talked to didn't know anything about First American's contract. I gave her my contract number but she asked for my phone number and then said I was not in the system. So I called my home insurance.
They told me with Hurricane Harvey, there was a lot going on and I can accept that but I'm sure there are a lot more technicians and other resources available that are probably not getting reached out. I understand 24, 48 and 72 hours, holidays, workdays and weekends but not a couple of weeks for services that I've paid for to have in case of an emergency like this happens. I've had coolers sitting here with ice in them trying to keep what food I salvaged. I’m totally upset and disappointed. I was thinking of other avenues to take but it got to the point where the lady asked me to give her 24 hours. She was going to try and find someone but my fridge has been sitting in limbo in my home. I ain’t expecting a 5-star service but at the same time, some type of service. Right now I'm not happy with First American.
I've had claims before though. One with the air conditioning, which was fine, and one with the garage, which was great. The garage door had two double springs and the left spring was broken initially. They sent a guy out to do the repairs and I asked if he was gonna replace both of them. He said they would only fix one but I was pretty sure within the next couple of weeks, we were gonna have issues with that other one. Sure enough, the right spring broke a couple of months later. All in all, I've had good and bad experiences with First American and it depends on who you talk to. But I would like more follow-ups and better customer service from them.
Reviewed Sept. 17, 2017
I had a major claim with First American for replacing a heat pump. They accepted the claim, sent a contractor to review the claim, found that I was correct and what the problem was and replaced the unit. All I paid was the deductible. I was happy with the technician's work. He was good, knowledgeable, and customer oriented. I had a second claim when my other air conditioner quit working. The same technician came to investigate that claim and found that it was only a capacitor, which was within the deductible. He replaced it and the air conditioner started working. I have referred friends to them since then.
Reviewed Sept. 16, 2017
I've had First American warranty for 17 years and I always had good service. I file my claims by phone. I don't like to do it online because there are too many steps. Their claims reps were always courteous, I get service as fast as I can and they tell me who's gonna come out. That gives me a chance to check out the company if it's a local company, even before they come to see how far they're coming and if I'd see any complaints. I even called one of the plumbers again who came out because he was in the neighborhood and I had another problem that wasn't covered and he did a good job.
There was a time when the first guy couldn't fix it, and First American sent a second guy and they didn't charge me twice. They only charged me once. Everything has always worked out well. I get fairly quick service. Sometimes you have to wait, but if it's an emergency, they could send somebody out immediately. That happened one time when my shower wouldn't stop running and the shower pan was filling up. They also fixed my washer a couple of weeks ago. It's an old washer and they had the part on the truck. It was a quick fix. I'm very satisfied with First American and I really rely on it. I have recommended it to my friends.
Reviewed Sept. 16, 2017
My realtor used First American in the past and when I bought my house 10 years ago, he gifted me my first year of protection and I decided to stay with it because I was satisfied. Submitting a claim has been pretty easy because I tell them what’s going on and they tell me who the service provider is going to be. The reps were courteous, cooperative and helpful and the technicians who came were professional too. They did great quality work. My only suggestion is if they could look at being able to cover a bit more appliances than what they can. They could really corner the market if they cover a bit more than what other home warranty companies are covering.
Reviewed Sept. 15, 2017
A neighbor gave us information about First American. We've been having things fall apart regularly for the last five years since our house was built. Our builder turned out to be a scam artist who did a lot of crappy work and First American has come in handy. Submitting claims has been easy, they're helpful and courteous and I'm happy with everything that has been done. I would personally recommend that homeowners have First American.
Reviewed Sept. 15, 2017
My real estate agent recommended First American. Submitting a claim was an easy process, but it was difficult the first time I did it because for some reason my payment at closing didn't go through. First American was not yet showing me as a client. I had to call my real estate agent and he had to pay it. That was taken care of and I now can submit claims online. The guy that came out for plumbing was professional and courteous. I had the same company come out for electrical and they had to come back because the issue they came out for was not fixed.
Reviewed Sept. 14, 2017
I purchased this Home Warranty on April 10, 2017 at which time I was charged $62. I was told that if we canceled the policy within 30 days that would be refunded to my credit card. In July 2017 I noticed they had been charging my card every month and called them to get this resolved. They said it would be resolved and somebody would contact me by days end which never happened. In August I called again because another charge for $62 was added to my credit card. When I called this time I was told I needed to be transferred to a Supervisor and was hung up on.
After a 3 hour phone event trying to get this resolved, I was told again that I would receive a call within an hour and they would refund me the 5 months of fraudulent charges. They never called back. At that point I got the Credit Card company involved and they had to close the card and file a claim. Then, on 9/10/17 they tried to charge my card again. Since the card was closed they called me to tell me that I was in danger of losing the warranty coverage. I went through the whole event again for a couple of hours and was now told that the claim was being processed. I called again on 9/14/17 and they stated that they did not have any of this on file and they were still trying to charge my card. BUYER BEWARE!!!
Reviewed Sept. 14, 2017
I received my First American warranty when I purchased the house. I had used another home warranty company before and First American was definitely much better. Submitting a claim was fairly simple and straightforward. One drawback, though, was that their online system isn't very user-friendly. The call-in system and the operators got things done a lot quicker. The techs have been very professional and flexible, and my interactions with them have always been very good. If I had to cancel appointments and reschedule, they said, "No problem. We'll work around your schedule."
Another issue was when we had an HVAC problem, the contractor they sent out wanted to replace the entire system. However, my brother-in-law is an HVAC tech and he had put the system in, and he said that the system didn't have to be replaced and we were just low on refrigerant. The contractor was a little shady and my brother-in-law suggested that we ask the warranty company to get this contractor off their list. On the other hand, the quality of First American's service for the other claims that we've had has been outstanding. They were very fast and reliable, and quick to react even when we had a major problem here, and their service was very different from that of the other warranty company that I had previously.
Reviewed Sept. 14, 2017
Submitting a claim was easy and straightforward. The technician was knowledgeable and he did his job very well. Overall, my experience with First American has been easy and simple. I like it.
Reviewed Sept. 13, 2017
First American Home Warranty is in the contract when I got the house and I renew the contract every year. Whenever I have to claim a warranty item, First American gets somebody out here for the job. Submitting a claim is easy. I call in and tell them what's going on and within the next hour, they’ll send a text message of who’s coming out and I’ll get in touch with the person and schedule when he’ll come. All the technicians do their job diligently and get things fixed. Everybody is cool and everything is holding up. I've recommended First American Home Warranty to a lot of my friends.
Reviewed Sept. 13, 2017
We have been without a water heater for 3 weeks and still they haven't contacted us as to when they are replacing it. Now we have mold issues which they don't cover but due to the fact it's taking a long time they should be held liable. I have been contacting them daily twice a day and all they can say is "sorry". I have contacted the contractor and they have told us they provided all the information to First American but seems that there is no urgency on their end. I would definitely will not be using their service again nor will renew my contract or refer them to friends and family. FYI their contract says if they can't get anyone to fix it we can go and find a contractor ourselves but they have to approve the charges.
Reviewed Sept. 13, 2017
I'd call in to submit a claim to First American Home Warranty and the process was very efficient and pretty easy. I've had really good experiences with the techs and they were all pleasant. They described to me what my problem was and the methods that they were going to do to fix them.
Reviewed Sept. 12, 2017
I had a warranty provider before that didn't keep up to what they were saying and First American Home Warranty seemed better, so I thought I'd try them. They have sent me contractors that were great and did the job well. With the latest claim I had, the rep said that she had selected a contractor but it was going to be two or three days before they could come out, and I told her that she had to have someone here that day. She said that was hard but she got someone out anyway. I had to call the contractor back and they had to order a part, but that's no problem. The only thing is that when the reps call the contractors, they put the customer on hold until they find someone, instead of finding someone then calling the customer back, and the waiting on hold could take up to 30 minutes, which is a little long.
Reviewed Sept. 12, 2017
I acquired First American Home Warranty so I am covered in case something breaks in the house. I have filed claims two times. I called and they sent out a company who did a very good job. But I’m unhappy because they are charging me too much money. First American Home Warranty is charging me $72 but on the TV it was $44.
Reviewed Sept. 11, 2017
A realtor initially purchased the First American warranty for me. Since then, I've had them in the last three homes I've owned and I love them. Submitting claims has been easy. I would go online or call then they would take my information and the next thing I know, somebody is giving me a call. They were always good, very professional and Johnny-on-the-spot. Some of the vendors can be goofy but that's not First American. I had my wits about me with regard to plumbing and when a guy came in and told me all the extra work I needed on my plumbing in order for him to put in a water heater that is needing to be replaced, I knew the guy was trying to up his fees. But I would imagine he gets away with it with some people. I called and told First American about that guy and they made me feel like I did them a favor, so I still like them.
They do a great job and I've been happy with the quality of work done so far. Most of the stuff I've ever had to have done, like a water heater or a dishwasher, can wait one or two days so it's been no big deal. Maybe someday I'm going to be in some sort of quasi real emergency. But so far, their service has been satisfactory and I would be happy to buy and use them again.
Reviewed Sept. 11, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American is easy. However, getting the claims is not. The first time I got a claim, the guy had to come back out and do the work. The second time I submitted a claim, the guy patched up my garbage disposal and he never came back out yet. I’ve reached out to both First American and the contractor about it. First American tries their best to fix the situation but they need to do better or take another company that they deal with. Things work well in other situations. One of them was the dryer and it’s still pretty good. The guy had to come back out and do what should have been done the first time. It's supposed to be replaced but it’s not being replaced, it was just patched up.
Reviewed Sept. 10, 2017
Getting things repaired all at one time costs a lot of money. So I decided on getting a home warranty because, with it, repairs would be more manageable. And among the providers, I chose First American because they seemed to be more customer-friendly. Their customers would just call them or go online to submit claims and the reps would call back promptly to set up an appointment. Their site is also very user-friendly, I’m 64 and I can do it. My experience with the reps has always been pleasant as well. The technicians they’ve sent been have also been really good. It was just a little frustrating in the beginning because sometimes the technicians would come out and they’ve never done a certain job. But now, First American changed the company that comes out and they do their work really good. We’re having an awesome experience with First American, it’s refreshing that we have a company that does what they said they’re going to do.
Reviewed Sept. 10, 2017
I've been with First American Home Warranty for a few years now and I renew with them every year. I’m satisfied with them. They've always taken care of my needs and they've been very prompt when I've called to file claims. The rep would take my information and then First American would have the company that's going to take care of the situation call me. I usually hear from the contractors within 24 hours and we set up a time that they're going to come out. The technicians sent by First American have been very good, professional and usually take care of the situation. I've had an electrician, an air condition tech and three sets of plumbers, and their quality of work was excellent.
Reviewed Sept. 9, 2017
Kitchen faucet started leaking up at the counter from the faucet stalk. Plumber came, took 2 minutes to look at it and said it needed to be replaced but warranty would only cover builder’s standard. I called First American and was told the same thing. I asked if I bought my own faucet, wouldn't they cover the labor. They said no, that if I bought the more expensive faucet, I would be responsible for the labor as well. I canceled the home warranty immediately. What good is it? What kind of racket is it that they will not even cover the labor as they would have had I given the OK for builder's standard.
I had this company for years until 2016 when we sold our last home. On a year and a half, they added the words "builder's standard" and refused labor, even if I purchased a better unit. Then, there is no one to talk to who does not give the standard, trained, robotic response. They’re great at collecting your funds, but what used to be good has become horrible in both the service they provide, as well as poor in customer service.
Reviewed Sept. 9, 2017
Arrived at my home to find that the hot water heater was blowing water out of the top of water heater. I contacted the warranty company and was told someone would service water heater within 2 to 3 days. Explained to call center office I needed it repaired sooner as I had no water. A representative from Ideal services arrived 5 hours later and stated I needed a new water heater. He did bypass the water heater and would need authorization from warranty company.
Next day contacted Ideal services to find out when they could replace water heater, I had received work order # from warranty company. They explained that warranty company had to send them authorization. I called the warranty company call center which is located in El Salvador. Informed that I would have to pay $685.00 to have water heater installed. Apparently the warranty covers the water heater but not the installation. Bait and switch price gouging. Warranty company sent me a check for minimal amount. Did not cover price of water heater. Very dissatisfied with service.
Reviewed Sept. 9, 2017
We purchased our house in April and the warranty from First American came with the packing. I have been extremely happy with their warranty. The claims process has been wonderful. I call up and I explain to them what I need, and I get someone out here immediately. The people they pick to work with us have been really good, and the work quality has been top-notch. The service has been prompt and I love it. I'm going to renew it and add my air conditioner when it's up next year.
Thank you for your comments and congratulations on your new home!
Reviewed Sept. 9, 2017
I've had positive experiences with all my claims with First American Home Warranty, even though the contractors are a little slow to call us to schedule so sometimes I would do it myself. Ordering parts is a slow process as well, but that is out of First American's control. For the most part, the contractors have all been great though. They did a great job, especially for the last ones that I've had. The same company kept coming out for my washer and dryer, microwave and icemaker. I enjoy having the comfort of having the warranty and knowing that if anything breaks, I can make the phone call to have it fixed. I've had a great partnership with First American and I've recommended them to quite a few people.
Reviewed Sept. 9, 2017
So far, things have been good with First American. They were a recommendation of our realtor, who we enjoyed working with. Filing a claim through the phone has been a very smooth process and this is the third claim that we filed. However, it has taken a few days for them to get back to us and haven't heard back from anyone yet. The problem has already resolved itself so I need to cancel the claim. But everything they’ve addressed up until now has been done in a very timely manner and on the first visit. Once we get a contractor assigned, it happens pretty quickly. Each time, the contractors have been very professional. I’ve had no complaints at all. I like the efficiency of using their phone system. I would like to learn more about doing claim on their website if that's possible. I may not have been paying attention when we first signed up. That’s the only thing that I would want to pursue in the future.
Reviewed Sept. 8, 2017
My wife & I have a home warranty through this company, and the warranty itself isn't worth the paper it's printed on. We bought a home 1/2017 from a major manufactured home company. It was a repo they purchased and allegedly refurbished. Regardless, the seller gave us a home warranty through this company. We've filed three claims, and not one of them have been paid, but rather, denied. The most recent claim was earlier this week for an electrical panel that blew up. Our plan says it's covered, however, they denied the claim because the panel isn't in the home or attached to the structure; it's the master panel on the pole below the meter.
At the same time, we filed a claim for a problem with our septic system. They denied it as they said we don't have septic coverage. When I asked why it was included in our coverage book, they wouldn't directly answer, but rather, continued to say it would be added if we wanted, but it wouldn't cover this issue. Lastly, we filed a claim in June as our A/C wasn't cooling. They sent out a technician and then promptly refused the claim because they called the issue a "maintenance" problem.
We bought the home in January 2017 and it hadn't been used for years beforehand. I explained we recently bought the home and asked how could we be responsible for maintenance, etc.? Regardless, they denied it. Mind you, I not suggesting you not purchase a home warranty from this organization, but rather, read what's happened to us and make your own, informed, decision. Lastly, I've attempted to supply a copy of the email I was sent at the time this claim was filed, but it will not allow me to upload it here.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Sept. 8, 2017
I bought a home a couple of years ago and the home warranty that I went through with the insurance company didn't want to renew me. So, I had to research for a new home warranty. I liked that First American has a comprehensive plan that would cover most of the main things that I know I can't do by myself so I went with them. I've been with them for over a year now and submitting a claim was easy. I just go online and put in my request then the claim is taken care of within three or four days. Also, the technicians have all been professional and nice. If they didn't resolve the problem or they had issues, they were right on top of it. And they would come back and say, "We've got it fixed. Here's your problem." They explain the problem thoroughly so that I would understand it and if it happens again, I’d call them and they'll come and resolve it. First American is a company that’s very professional, polite and easy to work with.
Reviewed Sept. 8, 2017
I'm a homeowner and I needed home warranty protection. I did some research by word of mouth and First American Home Warranty was the one I determined to use as the best. Submitting a claim online was fine. My interactions with both the customer service and the claims representative were fine as well. The contractor that came out was a good company. The technicians were able to do what they needed to do and got everything taken care of. The work done was very much to my liking and it was just as I wanted it. They brought the appliance back to its original state, like it was in the beginning. My experience with First American was great and I'm glad I have them.
Reviewed Sept. 7, 2017
I switched to First American Home Warranty because their warranty was cheaper than that of American Home Shield. It was very easy to submit claims with First American. Their technicians came out here two or three times and it was good each time.
Reviewed Sept. 7, 2017
First American Home Warranty is a customer service oriented company. I had them on my last property and I had a decent service with them so I've kept them when I purchased my home over 12 years ago. Their claims process was simple and streamlined. I've had positive interactions with their reps and technicians and I've been satisfied with the quality of work they've performed.
Reviewed Sept. 7, 2017
We bought a house and our real estate agent got First American Home Warranty for us. Submitting a claim has been great. The contractors called back when they were supposed to and then they came when they were supposed to. The quality of work is good and I’m satisfied.
Reviewed Sept. 6, 2017
My live-in partner, Loni, had First American in his home. Stuff started happening and we were calling little contractors and I asked him why didn't he go back and get his home warranty. So, I looked at First American’s details and it seems like it will be a whole lot cheaper to have it than be dealing with the little people around the corner because they charge a lot. And if something major happens, it would be a fortune. I set it back up for him so we wound up getting it and we're thankful for it because if we're going to have a microwave, refrigerator and the hot water heater fixed.
The hot water heater was a little bit of a drama because the policy went out on the 4th of July and it was a month by the time we got it fixed. I have to make an appointment and then that person didn't come out for a minute. And then, when they came out and checked it, a part has to be ordered. They forgot what the serial model number was. So, they called me to get it again to give it to First American. We didn't know that we had to call First American to order the part. But I happened to call because we called about it on Tuesday, and it's Thursday and I haven't heard from anybody, and the girl said that they were waiting for us to call them. The part was ordered that Friday didn't get there 'till a week later. And then, we had to wait another half of a week for them to come back and put it in. It was a long process.
Nonetheless, the company did a good job putting it in but it seemed like we were without hot water for a whole month and we were lucky that the part they ordered worked the first time. But nobody seemed to know what was going on. Their claims rep put me on hold to find out what's happening. I felt when the part was ordered, somebody should have called me back. The person said the part would be there that Monday so when the company that was doing it didn't call me, I called them and they were saying that they have to go through their emails and they set me up for an appointment that Friday. They usually call to say they're on their way so when I didn't hear from them, I called them and they said they can't find any appointment for me. They realized the part wasn't there and canceled the appointment, but they didn't tell me they were canceling. And the part didn't show up Monday like the claims person said it would.
It was one miscommunication but we've always had good service before that. Everything was done on time and we knew what was going on. And this time, things were falling through the crack. When I did talk to somebody, they were going to have a manager call me but no manager ever called me and it's how all that went down. Nevertheless, the technician did well with taking care of the issue. First American is a good company and I'm glad that we went ahead and applied because it really worked out. Considering all the things we've had wrong, it was the first time we had a bad experience. But we got hot water and I'm good.
Reviewed Sept. 6, 2017
First American Home Warranty has been prompt about getting contractors out here so I renewed with them year after year. Submitting a claim is easy when I do it online. Everything in their website is clearly labeled and easy to find. The representatives are very friendly but sometimes I have to wait a long time to speak to one. The technicians have always been friendly and their quality of work is good. But I understand that in some cases I have to hire someone that I'll pay for myself and not within First American.
Reviewed Sept. 5, 2017
This company (FAH) doesn't have 24/7 back up contractor for emergency situations, so company or management team should not claim that you can resolve the problem in 24 hrs in the case of emergency. And I think it's not fair to any customer to wait this long (in my case more than 24 hrs.), anyway I asked for the service I paid you for, not that you were providing service for free. Very bad experience with this company, hope management could see these conversations and I would urge other customer who are thinking to go with this company for their home warranty. Please think more than twice before you proceed with them as they don't have any 24/7 emergency back up team, neither they have any integrity in what they promise to you at the time, you filed the claim for the services.
I called several times and begging for service as we have 2 year old kid at home and we were worried as inside house temperature was more than 90. So, I found and called a company on the weekend and guys came, evaluated the problem, recommended what's need to be replaced and fixed it. I then went ahead and cancel my request with this company. It was all waste of time and effort with mental agony. So, please think more twice before you proceed. And, here is the kicker--- when you call them and ask, why the claim hasn't been resolved yet? They will reply as follows- (emergency service contractor is assigned, contractor will contact the consumer in 8 hrs from the time you created the claim and problem would be taken care off/resolve within 24 hrs.)
1) We are trying to contact another contractor and will resolve it soon (Note: Even you filed claim as an emergency. In my case - I have 2 year old at home and inside house temperature was more than 90 degree F, those 24 hrs was a nightmare for our family). 2) You don't know how home warranty works. --- Really??? 3) If they have no proper answer to your question, they will reply you as "do you want cancel your warranty". And so on. 4) When you ask for their extension in order to reach directly to them because you don't want to go through all the explanations of the situation or problem, they will give you wrong extension number (as they did in my case. When I called back and asked to transfer the call to mentioned extension, guess what the guy other side told me. This was not their "extension in their calling system".) 5) It was long holiday weekend that is why it wasn't taken care. "If you want we can reopen your claim and someone will go and look at it". 6) We will not reimburse you for the service you had from other contractor as we didn't approve you for 2nd option.
Not a professional at all, company doesn't know what they are claiming for their service as service provider. Had there been negative stars I would have given that. Unfortunately, there is no any option available for that. Question comes to my mind - when we have the warranty we have to pay on time before the midnight of the expiration date, otherwise services are not covered. On the other hand, when it comes to providing the service then it is going to be according to their availability not according to our urgency. Why??? In the terms of Steps of Service this company (FAH) can't "connect genuinely, compassionate customer care, own the experience, excellence and stewardship".
Hello Chandra,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed Sept. 5, 2017
The home warranty company never resolved the electrical issue we had in our home that impacted not having air conditioning for two weeks. Finally, the company authorized me to fix it on my own to a limit of $150. The cost to repair was $575 and the warranty company refused to pay the cost even after speaking with the electrician. I am canceling all the contracts we have in the other homes we own and further will not encourage anyone in our real estate business to use the company. Very disappointed.
Reviewed Sept. 5, 2017
Every experience should have to be a good one but we've had bad and good experiences with First American. When we submitted a claim for the dryer, it was a terrible experience as far as who they chose to work with us. The quality of the dryer was poor and it took them over a month. We finally ended up having to get a new dryer anyway, so that was not a pleasant experience. But then the next claim we had on the electricity and air thing went very well.
Reviewed Sept. 5, 2017
I've been very pleased with First American for a number of years. Their rates are more than reasonable. They are quick to respond and a pleasure to work with. They always have good service personnel that they contract with. They’ve all been very professional and very courteous. And in general, we've had no problems at all. The claims process has changed over the years from calling them for a claim to being more web-centric like most of the companies have gone. The online procedure that they have is very straightforward and very clean. And I can still call them for the claim verbally. The claims reps are very courteous, professional, and caring. They're very interested in what my problem was and very true to help. In some cases, they made suggestions as to how to proceed. It's been very good with them.
Reviewed Sept. 4, 2017
My experience with FAHW has been less than acceptable to say the least. My rental had a water heater leaking and I submitted a service request online. I requested emergency service as water was leaking into the drywall and all over the floor. FAHW had the contractor Worco Plumbing call me to arrange a tech to go to the house, which he did. Unfortunately, the tech didn't send the report to Worco office, so Worco office didn't send info to FAHW. After 3 days, mind you water is still leaking all over, I finally called Worco and was told that the water heater needed to be replaced.
I am a Journeyman Plumber and so is my renter and told the Worco office this and we were both fully aware of what was needed. I was then told that I would be responsible for the cost of the modifications. I asked "What modifications, there are none needed". I was told that the gas supply line, venting and T & P drain line all needed to be modified, for a cost $350. This is absolutely false! I was also told that if I didn't agree to pay it, they would not replace the water heater. I told Worco that this is a complete rip-off and they will never work in my home. I called FAHW and told them what was said and they weren't the least bit concerned that Worco was trying to rip me off. They did tell me that I could take a cash out and have the repairs done myself. I accepted this option. I purchased a water heater and had it installed. I took before and after pictures to prove to FAHW that no modifications were needed.
I didn't have to modify anything. I did change the supply lines for the water ($14) and gas line, ($19) which would be part of replacing any old water heater. I didn't have to modify the venting or gas line. I also had to cut the T & P drain line and then solder it back together with a coupling ($1.10) which is also a standard repair when changing a water heater. All together it took me one hour and 15 minutes to complete the change out, which included going to Home Depot for the supply lines. All parts are covered under the home warranty, however, because I didn't allow Worco the rip me off, FAHW charged me an additional $55 for the so-called service call from Worco. This is a complete and total rip off from Worco and FAHW is completely aware that they are doing it. That makes FAHW just as guilty for this blatant rip off.
There are so many complaints against FAHW and Worco on Yelp that I stopped reading them after 35 stories of exactly the same treatment. I challenge ConsumerAffairs.com to post this review instead of only posting the positive reviews. I guarantee there are way more negative than positive reviews for Worco Plumbing. I am fortunate to be a plumber and was able to replace the heater without using Worco, most others were not so fortunate and had to pay the extra money to get their plumbing fixed. First American Home Warranty and Worco Plumbing should be ashamed of themselves, but I guarantee they aren't.
Reviewed Sept. 4, 2017
When we bought our home 15 years ago, my sister who is also our real estate agent, recommended First American. She told us all about it and had it for her own home and I took her work. We've always called First American, told them what we had a problem with and within a certain amount of time, they had someone call us to come look and take care of it. Their representatives have been very knowledgeable and they’ve given us the name of the company that would be coming out. They told us to let them know if we didn’t hear from the company within a certain period of time, and they'll take care of it. Also, we never had any problems with the work that the technicians have done. They were always here when they said they were going to be here. They took care of the problems and they were professional in every way.
Reviewed Sept. 4, 2017
First American Home Warranty was offered to me when I bought my house and I’ve had it for about 16 years now. The claim process is prompt and not difficult at all, and the reps are very understanding. They explain everything, and I'd talk to them about the problems that I have and right away, they'd take care of me. I'd call them and they'd call the service people, and then the service people would call and come to do what they've got to do here. Some of the techs have been really good but there were some that just came in and looked and never came back to do the work. I have complained about them so they’ve never come back anymore. But I haven’t had any complaints against First American and I've had excellent experience with them.
Reviewed Sept. 3, 2017
Let me start by saying I've lived through the joys of slab leaks - both the catastrophic and the "caught it just in time" kind. My husband and I bought a home in Southern OC, in California seven months ago. The sellers purchased a home warranty policy for us through First American Home Warranty. Friday afternoon I suddenly could hear running water UNDER my kitchen sink cabinets and through my walls, but no water faucets, spigots, showers or toilets were running.
Definitely looks and sounds like a quacking, waddling duck to me.
Late yesterday, I finally found my warranty paperwork. This morning I called First American Home Warranty and suffered through the computerized attendant that took forever to schedule a local service technician to call me. I tried to redirect the call to a live person, but the computer said "Goodbye" and hung up. Joy. I called the service technician's number I was given to see when I can expect someone - even more joy! They're not open today and their hours are limited to a standard 8am to 5pm M-Th; Fridays even fewer hours, with no weekend or after hours service. Unacceptable.
So, I called First American Home Warranty again. Suffered through the computerized attendant until I got placed on hold for a live person. "Ruben" got on the line. He had a heavy accent and spoke quickly. I explained a few times I was having difficulty understanding him. He asked me if there was secondary damage. I told him I could not see any water on the floor or in the walls, but clearly told him there is obviously running water when no water should be running, so it's going somewhere underneath my house and the situation cannot wait until Tuesday. Long story short... The conversation escalated. "Ruben" began to repeatedly read from a script and flowchart telling me that if there's no (obvious - implied) secondary damage it's not an emergency, that tomorrow is a national holiday so someone will probably call me back Tuesday, that I need to read my warranty and that's what I signed for on my contract.
No matter what I said "Ruben" spoke over me, literally, and told me to "listen." I repeatedly asked to speak to his supervisor or manager and told him that his responses and customer service skills were unacceptable and that just because there is no obvious water damage at the moment doesn't mean the situation isn't an emergency. I asked him to clarify that he was telling me to "shut up", that my call wasn't important, someone would call me on Tuesday and that his intention was to simply end the call. He said he didn't tell me to "shut up" but "yes" he intended to end the call.
I felt so belittled and frustrated. All I could do was ask for his supervisor or manager. "Ruben" continued to ignore my requests and loudly read First American Home Warranty's scripted guidelines over everything I tried to say. I was shouting at that point. So was he. This went on for about 3 - 4 minutes. I continued to demand his supervisor or manager. He then said, "I am escalating your claim. Why do you want to speak to my supervisor?" Duhhh!!!
"Ruben" put me on hold for at least another 5 minutes. I began to wonder if he had simply placed my call in suspense hoping I would just hang up and go away. Then "Carla" got on the line, explaining she's the supervisor. I BRIEFLY explained the issue with "Ruben" but told "Carla" I would simply communicate with First American about the experience. I told "Carla" I needed her to help me with the situation with the running water under my cabinets and in the walls and said it cannot wait until Tuesday. "Carla" started reciting the flippin' protocols to me and explained that without secondary damaged to my house it's not an emergency.
What is wrong with this company? Does my house have to fall into a giant sink-hole for them to send someone out to assess the situation. According to their protocol, I have to get a service technician through them. I can't just call someone of my own choosing. This is Southern Orange County, California... Slab leaks are more common than fast food restaurants.
So... The icing on the cake..."Carla" isn't rude, but makes it clear - because my kitchen isn't flooded or showing signs of "secondary damage" at this moment, it isn't an emergency. She's "escalating" the claim to see if someone can call me sooner than Tuesday. (Apparently - until Tuesday, all service technicians (aka plumbers) have broken fingers and hands). It occurred to me there must be an obvious disconnect somewhere... How can a home warranty company not understand the significance of a broken water pipe underneath the slab of a house in Southern Orange County in Southern California. So I asked Carla where she is located. Central America.
Reviewed Sept. 3, 2017
I’m old style and I don’t want to move from one company to another, so I stayed with First American Home Warranty, even if I would have spent a couple of dollars less by switching. But some of the contractors that First American chose were not good. Some companies were okay, but I didn't like some of them. The plumbing company they got was not good.
I had the plumber check the leaking water in my master bathroom and he said, “You have to change all your bathroom cabinets.” He wanted to remodel the shower and that would have cost $10,000, including all the countertop changes, because the countertop is between the tiles under the sink. But my brother-in-law is a plumber and he laughed at what the plumber told me, so I didn’t like it. I could see that the plumber didn't want to do the job. If I had to have the repair done myself, I would've had to pay $600, but I didn't do that. Insurance is something you need to have as you never know what's going to happen.
On the other hand, a technician came out last year to repair the smoke detector and at the end of the year there was another problem with the smoke detector in the bathroom and the office, and he fixed it for me. The technicians were nice and could do the job, except for that plumber who bothered me. Overall I'd recommend First American.
Reviewed Sept. 3, 2017
We’ve had a great experience with First American. I like that they don't require customers to have routine maintenance on the appliances that are getting insured and their online system is great. Submitting claims is very simple which only takes a minute. I now have them for multiple properties and we’re in our fourth year with them. We had multiple interactions with their reps and they have been fine.
Reviewed Sept. 2, 2017
Our fridge is freezing and can't get to the right temperature. We have requested service since July 28 and now it's September 2. They sent out two companies to cost compare the repair and they have struggled to find the parts for our Kenmore Fridge. SO NOW they have ordered parts off EBAY instead of buying a new fridge. We have lost food… oh they said we could rent a fridge but I have NOWHERE to put my old fridge while they sit around looking for parts on eBay. And now this part off EBAY is coming in another week and then I get to schedule with the repairmen to fix it. We have had this contract for FOUR years and this is the FIRST warranty repair. RIDICULOUS service. I've filed a complaint with the BBB and they don't care. DON'T GO WITH FIRST AMERICAN HOME WARRANTY. THEY DO NOT CARE.
Reviewed Sept. 2, 2017
I've been very happy and satisfied with First American Home Warranty. I did some research online. First American had a good price and a lot of options of what they covered. They had good reviews too. I signed up online and then they followed up. When I put in a claim, they sent someone who was very professional. This was the problem I've had with my old warranty company.
I called First American on Monday and told them about my dishwasher. They scheduled an appointment for me within 24 hours. The repair person came on time. He was very presentable too. He fixed the problem and I just had to pay him the standard $75. I also had a related problem with my well and there was clay in the filter in the dishwasher. He removed and replaced that. The quality of service was good and the dishwasher's still running.
Reviewed Sept. 2, 2017
When we bought the house, we also purchased First American Home Warranty. We're in San Diego and we bought the house in San Jose. We came out and look at it. Since I'm across the country, I didn't know the home inspector, who we just guessed, so I wanted a little more insurance. First American was our only option. Submitting a claim wasn't too difficult. We did that when the toilet wasn't working. The toilet in the master bedroom flushes half of what it should and the one downstairs works best out of the three but it still double flushes at times. We had a problem with the plumber that First American used because the toilet still doesn't work. They're better but they're still not right. The plumber has been out here three times.
We also submitted a claim when the air conditioner was out. It took almost a week for them to get here, so since my nephew, who's in Arizona, was in heating and air conditioning, he told me what to do. I was getting water all over the place and First American didn't put any rush on getting someone out here. I had the air conditioner fixed before someone even got here. There were two techs who came for the air conditioning. One did the paperwork and the other guy checked the condenser and all that stuff. However, I was calling about the water that was leaking inside. After checking, I asked them if they're going to open it up and clean it, but they said no because it's part of my maintenance. They still charged me $75.
In both cases, the plumbers and the air conditioner tech guys were super nice. But I got to know somebody out here to get something done right. I'm not part of the network yet. I haven't been here long enough and I need to get different people in to handle our claims. Nevertheless, I would recommend First American and I'm glad we have them. I'm happy with it, but just not with the results.
Reviewed Sept. 1, 2017
I'd recommend First American. I submitted a claim with them when I had some issues with our kitchen appliances and dealing with their claims rep went very swiftly. But I had an issue with the tech who came out. They were working on my wine cooler in the kitchen and I was sitting here watching the whole thing. He had a kid helping him out and he scratched my hardwood floor, which is a Brazilian cherry, but he didn’t say anything. They tried to cover it up but I didn’t need my fridge fixed. Their work was great but I wouldn't use that company again.
Reviewed Sept. 1, 2017
We did some research and First American had good reviews so we went with them. Our realtor also told us about them. I've submitted claims and the process has been really simple. You can call or do it online and whatever’s wrong, they'd use somebody to fix it. The technicians that have come to our house have been really courteous and respectful. They do the job and leave just like they're supposed to do. There have been a few times where they had to come back out because something is still wrong but they don't have any problem coming back out. Overall, First American is a good company.
Reviewed Sept. 1, 2017
We've been with First American for 11 years now. We call when we submit a claim and the experience has been positive. My interactions with their reps and technicians have been good. Their technicians have been capable and they resolved the problems.
Reviewed Aug. 31, 2017
We filed a claim in our new home at the beginning of August when our AC unit broke. First contractor came out and added 3lbs of Freon. Later I found out from an AC contractor that Freon does not need to be replaced unless there is a leak. After a huge ordeal FAHW agreed to send another contractor to check for a leak. I insisted that the contractor not be the person that came before and that the contractor have his own HVAC contractor's license. The same guy showed up. He had no license and refused to tell me what he was there to do. I told him I wanted to know what work he was planning. He refused to tell me and then got smart assey with me. He left. I called back the warranty company. They agreed to send a new company to check for leak. The new company showed up but did not check for leak. He checked for pressure that's it. His report claimed he checked for leak but found no leak.
We were supposed to get a call back but nothing has been done. It has been 2 weeks trying to get the warranty company to even answer our calls. Our account shows that only one person in the entire company is allowed to speak with us. Carletta. She has never answers our phone calls. She has never returned our phone messages. We have called her 8 times, at different times of the day. We have left her 5 messages. I filed a claim with the BBB hoping this will encourage them to fulfill their obligation on our claim.
Hello Joyce,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 31, 2017
One of the repairmen that I used recommended First American. I have been with Choice for a while but every time I call them there was something that they didn't pay for and it was frustrating for me, so I decided I would try First American. I submitted a claim for a plumbing issue on our shower in the bathroom which was easy to do, and my renters and I were pleased with their claims reps. Also, the technician did the job quickly and didn't leave a mess.
Reviewed Aug. 31, 2017
First American Home Warranty was a recommendation. I’ve had several claims with them. When I file a claim, I always sit on the line 20 minutes to talk to anybody there. All claims were satisfactory until the last one. My dishwasher quit working. First American sent a tech who said the dishwasher had to be replaced. First American said they’re going to replace it. And then a tech showed up asking about the dishwasher because he’s supposed to install it, but I have never seen it. He called First American and then told them that he came out to give a second opinion. This happened mid-July. First American set us an order, but they didn't order the dishwasher until the 30th of July.
A guy brought the dishwasher from Phoenix. He drove four and a half hours to install it. I live in a modular home and all the utilities rendered in a pit and the water comes up from the floor. He got here, looked, and said, "The water lines have to come through the wall." I said, "Well, this one don't. It comes from underneath." He told me that he couldn’t install it and he left. It wasn’t too long when another tech came. We made sure he would come and install the dishwasher right. He’s a very nice guy and I like him a lot. But I was frustrated with the whole process. Every time we called, they told us a different story. All the people I had to talk to were in Central America or South America and they don't have a sense of urgency about it.
I was upset because we were misled several times. But First American always has a fix first mentality. We had a washing machine that went out and they wanted to fix it. Parts wouldn't come for six weeks, so they replaced it. They just stepped up and said, "You don't need to go that long." And they took care of it right away. So I've been pleased with them until the last episode.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
One of the worst home warranty companies I have ever dealt with. Half the time customer service doesn't know what's going on, I get disconnected on the recording constantly. This afternoon alone I've spent 2 hrs alone talking to customer service and the contractor. Paperwork wasn't filed correctly so contractor couldn't schedule... then when we finally get it scheduled the service request gets canceled.
I've had 3 HVAC issues all within 30 days of each other and they just want to keep replacing different pieces instead of replacing the unit which the contractor keeps telling them, "That's what it needs". It seems Ike they want to keep replacing parts until my warranty is up so they don't have to replace it. Contractor even said that they told him to fix it the best I can temporarily. During one of these calls I wanted it flagged as emergency because it was 99 degrees in my home and my wife is pregnant... their response was if it was 100 we could flag it. Are you freaking kidding me?!?
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
After 2 hours on the phone and having to repeat myself to each rep after being transferred many times, it's like no one listens to what you're telling them. I explained the situation and the response has almost nothing to do with the problem that needs to be addressed. When asking to speak to a manager I was told to call back during business hours (it was 1pm). When I asked, "Isn't it business hours right now," all they would tell me is that I needed to call back.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
We are currently trying to have our AC fixed for the 2nd time in 2 months. Yesterday they dispatched a contractor who told me they need to send someone else because he could not fix the AC. They keep telling me they can't dispatch another company until they receive the report from the first contractor. However we are currently in another heat wave with excessive heat warning and temperatures of 110-111 degrees. I have pets and a 9 month old baby I watch and my house is getting over 95 degrees inside. They continue to stall when they should be treating this as an emergency. The AC should have been fixed properly the first time but instead they just keep collecting $75 every time claiming it is now a new claim. I have been calling over and over again but no one seems to want to help get this issue resolved.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
I asked the seller for a warranty when I bought the house and they put in First American. I filed a claim with them and I had a pretty shoddy experience with the company that they sent. The first guy that they sent was an idiot. He was late by two hours and he didn't call me. He didn’t do anything at all. Then he charged me $95 and I paid it. But he didn’t turn in that I had paid it. I also called the company to told them that the problem wasn’t fixed. So for the second time, they sent the same person out. But he was late again, so I called the company. The rep said he was about to try to reschedule it for tomorrow but I told him I’ve already taken off work so he can’t reschedule. He then said the guy will come that night. But at 11 that night I called to cancel it. He was supposed to be there at noon but he never showed up.
The guy from the same company asked me how I wanted to remedy the situation and I said I wouldn't be using them anymore. He said he’ll call First American so they can send another company out but he didn’t do that. I had to call First American about two weeks later and told them myself that the issue hasn’t been fixed. Then they sent somebody else out. The guy looked at it, and he told First American of what he thought the issue was but they said they didn’t cover that. So I still have the same issue I had from the get-go, and I have a completely nonfunctional bathroom since the 1st of July.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
When I first bought my home, I had different options. The homeowners that I bought the house from had First American. I figured if they liked it, I would like it, too. I have been with First American for 11 years and I like the program. The claims process has been simple. I always like to talk to a person so I always call in and let them know what's going on. They will then ask me basic things. Sometimes, whoever is on the phone points it out for me. They tell me that they have a contractor and that they'll send me an email and the contractor will call within 48 hours. They always call me normally the next day and they always give me their information just in case I want to call them or they don't call me.
I had an incident where I was having an electrical issue within my walls. Like certain plugs, you plug up your fan and this plug might work and this plug may not. The gentleman who came in, he fixed one area. I assumed it was done, but is wasn't when I went to the other area a couple of days later. I really didn't feel comfortable calling. I didn't want them to think that I was falsifying a claim even though it probably wouldn't even go like that. I was really upset and then just let it go. That was the only issue that I had. Recently, I had the same issue happen to me again and the gentleman came and fixed everything with no problems. Over the years, every time I've called them, they send out great people. I've only had a few issues. If I have issues, I tell them to not send one company back and they'll send me somebody else. I'm always satisfied with First American and I love working with them.
Reviewed Aug. 30, 2017
I've had several homes and acquiring a home warranty was the best thing to do. On July 2nd, I submitted a claim on the refrigerator with First American Home Warranty and it was difficult at first because the guy the first guy they gave me did not fix it, did not return my calls and did not show up at all. It was a mess and a nightmare. Our back and forth took two weeks and I was ready to throw him out in the street. I would not recommend my experience with that company to anybody. Then First American gave me a guy from a different company who's work was outstanding and everything was repaired.
Reviewed Aug. 29, 2017
The first issue I had on June 29th 2017 was resolved on Aug 4th 2017. It took 5 weeks to resolve the issue with A/C and I was left without any A/C for the peak summer and living with a baby at home. The problem reoccurred on Aug 19th 2017 and is yet to be resolved. Pretty much the whole summer I was without A/C and living with an infant at home. After paying all the premiums, 95$ per visit and 200$ for the contractor on some fees for the first visit, which lasted only few days, I am being asked to pay another 200$ to the contractor for the same A/C issue. I was stripped of A/C for the whole summer and paying a lot of money for no reason. Is this how the company works. Does everybody face the same issue. Is there anybody who can take action on this company.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 29, 2017
First American replaced our A/C Unit with one that is not cooling our house. It can maintain a temperature, but it does not cool. Just last night, we lowered temp 2 degrees, and 5 hours later, the temp was the same. The customer service is polite, but they are only scripted to send out a contractor that has been rude and dishonest. After spending an additional $1,090 out of pocket, we're still having a problem. We've complained of the problem a couple times now, but still no solution. They wear you down mentally by fixing the problem. They've only patched the problem by saying the A/C unit meets specs... Those specs don't matter if it's not cooling the house like the old unit. NEVER AGAIN.
Hello Paul,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed Aug. 29, 2017
My realtor got me on First American Home Warranty and I've already submitted several claims. There's a little wait when calling them up but it's smooth sailing as soon as I get on the phone with them. I like the fact that the people who I get in touch with on the phone speak really good English, so it really helps to have call centers being stateside. Then it takes 48 hours to have a tech out. I had a broken pipe a month ago so they paid the coverage. The tech who came out was very punctual and really professional. I have a curious mind and the techs let me stick around and watch them work and it's nice of them. My HVAC system was also leaking so they sent over a contractor who got it fixed in no time. There was a claim I had before that couldn’t be fixed the first visit because the techs needed extra equipment and they came back and resolved the problem in a couple of days so it worked out for me. Also, I had a garbage disposal replaced a year ago.
Also, I have their app and I like the fact that I can access my account on. I like First American and it’s really beneficial for me especially with the fact that I’m not a handy person. For anybody who’s not DIY inclined, it’s a really nice thing to have because the repair costs are a lot more expensive than the claims or the co-pay that we have to pay for every visit.
Reviewed Aug. 29, 2017
I had a home protection for years which I was never happy with. My daughter has coverage with First American and she said that I should go with their service. I looked into it and I got them. I have submitted claims online over the years and it's easy to do. I had a plumber and an electrician come out and I was satisfied with both of them. They were both gentlemen and did a more than adequate job. They took care of the issues I had and even though they were able to do that in a very short period of time, I still had to pay them the $65. But I was glad they were able to fix the problems.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2017
NO U.S. customer service. It's all in Central American and Pacific Islands. They are robots. They all use the same verbiage and struggle to think outside the charts they are given to answer questions. I had a broken water heater. An electric one. They sent out Ideal Services, which sent a tech that didn't know how to test electrical wires. He told me (and First American) that he is a plumber, not an electrician, and that he would need to have a shut off switch installed right next to the water unit to make sure it was turned off… PER CODE!!! The circuit breaker for the heater was 20 feet away, well within code. Conveniently, Ideal Services also has an electrical division that could take care of this "code violation" for around $650. I had to fight and argue with First American about how this guy was just trying to scam some more business for his company.
It took me 4 hours on the phone and numerous agents before I finally reached someone that said it didn't make sense and ordered a 2nd opinion. Then next company that came out said they had to do $850 in code upgrades, which involved raising the water heater platform to 18", thus also increasing the water supply lines. Conveniently, this company also had someone that could come out and perform the BS code upgrades. When I informed First American that my height was already to code, and provided them with the website to the County's water heater code page to confirm, First American told me that I would have to hire a licensed plumber on my own to file a statement to confirm... AND it would take 7-10 business days for them to review and approve a 3rd opinion to come out. It took me to having to deal with the contractor on my own and threaten with a formal complaint to the County before they came out.
The contractors were bad enough. What made this awful was how First American sided with them and even when given the code information, still wanted to side with them. They offer a "Cash Out" where they will pay the customer to do the job themselves. They offered me $293 to cover expenses of labor and cost of a new 50 gallon water heater! You can't find one for under $400, anywhere. They were willing to buy the water heater for the contractor, plus pay them for their labor. When I asked if I could pick up the water heater, THAT THEY ALREADY PAID FOR FROM AN APPLIANCE VENDOR, and then I would install it myself and they wouldn't have to pay me anything, they said no. This company is awful. Their customer service people are rude and unintelligent.
Hello Steven. We appreciate your feedback and apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced. Furthermore, we aware that you water heater has been replaced. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2017
When we bought the house, the realtor suggested First American. We use the phone when making a claim and they’ve responded quickly every time. It’s been a great experience. The representatives have always been very pleasant and they answered questions. We had a couple of issues with some of the technicians but nothing major and First American has always taken care of it. When they come out, they’ll look at the problem and usually, they can fix it. They’ve been up to our standards but there was a miscommunication when the plumbers cut a hole in the wall and they fixed the pipe but didn’t replace the drywall. The plumber said they don't do drywalls and we’ll have to call First American. Somebody else would have to come out and do it. But I've never had too much of an issue with it. When the technicians repair something, it stays repaired.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2017
Some of my equipment were getting a little older and I felt more comfortable with a protection plan. I've been dealing with Dominion Products for limited things like plumbing. It worked so good but I figured I would branch out and get a more extensive plan. And First American got an extensive plan. I submitted my first claim with my refrigerator and it was excellent. When I called them, they jumped right on the case for me. They sent the man the next day who diagnosed the problem, but he didn’t have a particular fan to go in the back of my freezer. So, he ordered it and had it come to my house. He gave me his number and told me to call him when it comes in. He came directly after I got it and put it in. It was a wonderful experience and I had no more trouble with my refrigerator.
I called them again when my air conditioning unit went on a blink. They did the same thing then. They jumped on it right away, and they had a number that would get in touch with the people who would take care of me. First American told me their name and they got in touch with me. Then I set up an appointment. It was extremely a hot day that day. So, I assumed that they were going to take a little longer to get here. I know they were busy that day and I had a friend that works on air conditioning. He was right on hand. He diagnosed the problem right on-site for me and fixed it. So I called the people that was referred to me and had the order cancelled. I also called First American to cancel it and to let them know that I had the problem resolved.
Overall, I like the way First American do their business. When I called my claim in, they asked me about the particular brand of equipment I had, and they sent someone that specialized in the brand. I really liked that. They do a professional job and I will recommend First American to anybody.
Reviewed Aug. 28, 2017
My realtor recommended First American to me and I bought their warranty. When I called for support to figure out how to submit the claim I had, their reps were informative and helpful. They called me back pretty quickly and took a little while to schedule an appointment. Then the technicians came and they were great. They needed to change the light switches and brought the stuff. They fixed everything and the repair was quick and simple. It was also effective and it was only $75. I wish I could say the same about some other issues I have going on that I haven't made a claim about because I wanted to call somebody else.
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2017
I needed a home warranty and went with First American Home Buyers Protection due to their price and coverage. Once I get a chance to speak to a human being, submitting a claim is good. But I don't like and I don't trust their telephone tree and I have trouble believing that the telephone trees are going to get all the information that I needed to get to know about a claim. Still, the claims representatives are fine and the technicians who came have all been very good. Also, the quality of work that's been performed has been excellent. It's been all that I expected with First American.
Reviewed Aug. 27, 2017
I'm a realtor in Chester County and I have access to home warranties. I was with American Home Shield before but my friend, Debbie, left AHS and went to First American, so I moved along with her for my own personal house insurance. But they were always slow. If you have an emergency, you're screwed because nothing is going to happen for the first two or three days and you'll probably wind up calling the contractor. The contractors are very slow in contacting you. I don't know whether they don't have enough contractors or they don't pay their bills and nobody wants to work for them. Most of the contractors are good tradesmen and they're very good at what they do if you can get them.
My last experience with a contractor was a total, freaking nightmare. Nearly two weeks ago, I called First American because my swamp cooler broke. It was 110 degrees outside and my swamp cooler didn't work. You seem to get help faster from First American if you submit a claim online than if you call them up. So, I called First American and submitted the claim online on Thursday morning at 4:00 in the morning because it was so freaking hot that I couldn't sleep. I waited most of the day on Thursday, then I called to verify that they got the claim and they were acting on it. They said, "Yes. We have the claim but we can't find a contractor to come work on your swamp cooler." I called and checked on Friday and Saturday... nothing, and I was so put out that I didn't call on Sunday.
On Monday I got an email saying that I can hire my own contractor and they will reimburse to a point. In the meantime, I got up on the damn roof and fixed the cooler myself, and I'm really pissed off and angry about it. A 71-year old woman has to get on the roof and take care of her own problem when she's paying them. I paid the high price of $56 a month for my home protection plan and that's over $600 a year, for them to come and take care of my problem, and I couldn't get anybody out here.
Before this, I had a broken pipe and First American kept telling me that they weren't going to fix it. I said, "Could you just send a contractor out and let him evaluate it?" They sent a contractor out and he said it wasn't covered, and that's all fine and good, but it took four days to get a contractor out and I was turning the water off and on into the house because it was running so much, and I couldn't spend money for that.
I also had a leaking faucet and I had to turn off the water outside. We went on water restrictions where I live and I needed the faucet fixed. I'm covered for that, so I called them up and they gave me the name of the contractor, AIM Plumbing. But the contractor didn't call me, so I called the contractor and they weren't going to come out until the following Tuesday, and this was on a Friday. But the contractor's wife was very nice and she went ahead and scheduled me in for service that day. Then the technician came out and fixed the faucet like it was no big deal and I was very happy with him.
My other issue is, whenever I called in to talk to someone there, the people that answered barely spoke English. I'm glad these people can get jobs but they could not understand what I was saying. They tried to talk to me, but I couldn't understand what they were saying because of their accent. It's like they were calling from India or overseas. It's no wonder that First American wants customers to transact their business online. But it's very incomprehensible to me that a professional company doesn't do better than what they're doing to facilitate doing business with customers.
Despite all that, I had a good experience in submitting a claim for my washing machine. Way back, when I first got my policy, my washing machine broke. The repairman came out a week later and said that it would cost more to repair it than to just get a new one. To give First American the credit, they gave me a new washing machine and they let me pick it out of different choices. But then, they had to order it and there was the shipping and coordinating with the contractor. They got the shipping all screwed up and shipped it to the wrong place. I got a new washing machine, but it took a month to get this done. All that time, I was running back and forth to the laundromat downtown. I live about 60 miles round-trip outside of Redding and that burned a lot of gas and caused a lot of heartache and issues.
Overall, the First American people have been slow and unresponsive. They're not going to get good press from me. I'd write them a letter. In fact, I have a call-in to my friend that works for them and I told her that I'm going to be sending an email and making a couple of blogs about First American. In addition, being a realtor, I sell a lot of homes but I won't be selling any of their policies. They have wonderful coverage, but the problem is, what's good with coverage if you can't get anything fixed?
Reviewed Aug. 26, 2017
We've had a good response from First American. Submitting a claim has been very good. And their claims rep and technicians have been very good as well.
Reviewed Aug. 26, 2017
I have home warranties in all my properties and I've used First American Home Warranty on and off for years. Then I wanted to test them out again. Submitting a claim with them is good and the process was easy whether I do it over the phone or through online. But they should make signing on to their web page easier. Still, interacting with their claims representatives and technicians, was good, too.
Reviewed Aug. 25, 2017
First American home warranty came with my house. Submitting a claim to them has been easy and I can do it all online. The technicians have been fine and the only people that I've had a problem with is Sears scheduling department. They're terrible but that has nothing to to do with First American. Their quality of work has been great and my experience with them has been very convenient.
Reviewed Aug. 25, 2017
I needed a home warranty and I heard about First American being the best so I went with them. Their claims process was real easy and their reps were proficient and on time. They also understood what my issue was and processed my claims without any problems. Also, the technicians have been good mannered and they provided very good quality work.
Reviewed Aug. 24, 2017
When I purchased a home five years ago, First American Home Buyers Protection was included in the first year and I’ve renewed it every year since then. I compared their plan with the other warranty companies, what they have to offer and it seems like it’s a better choice. Normally, I submit a claim online and it’s very quick and easy. It takes five minutes or less. Usually, I get an e-mail almost immediately confirming it with the contractor that’s assigned to whatever task it is and the contractor will contact me by the next business day. I have called in a couple of times and their reps were very courteous. They’ve taken care of everything very well for me. I’m very happy with the quality of their work. Overall, I’m very satisfied with First American and I’ve recommended it to friends as well, and I will continue to do business with them at least for the foreseeable future.
Reviewed Aug. 24, 2017
I had a different home warranty provider but they went up too high on the price ladder. We didn’t want that and I couldn't pay for that so I went with First American. They helped me with submitting claims. They listened to me and I explained what was wrong and they came out. The only thing wrong there is they don't pay for the machine. Like when my ice maker was not working right and it's freezing up the technician they sent explained everything that was wrong there and how much it's going to cost me. It turns out that they don't take care of that part. They have to send it away and get it back and it would cost too much money. I just told him if I decide to let him do it I'll call him back. So I just had to just fool around with it and see if I could fix it myself. But still First American don't give you the runaround and are really straightforward and I would recommend that insurance.
Reviewed Aug. 24, 2017
We never know when something's going to go wrong so we looked into acquiring a home warranty to get our things covered. Our realtor suggested First American Home Warranty and I was sure she knew the good ones. She's a very good realtor and took care of us. First American has been fabulous. As far as we're concerned, it's a great company.
A plug wasn't working and I called First American to submit a claim. The claims reps were very knowledgeable and helpful. They called back and had the electrician, John, call us. He called us and, the same day, an appointment for a service call was set up. John was going to come out on a Monday and we told him we're home all the time. He came on a Sunday, a day or so after we had called in, which was great. He knocked and asked if that was okay with us and we said, "Sure, come in." There was a loose wire in the circuit breaker box and he found it. The quality of the work done was great and we're very pleased with it so far. Overall, First American provided us with fantastic service. They were very fast and expedient and, if need be, we'll call them again.
Reviewed Aug. 23, 2017
These guys just don't care about their customers AT ALL! I have had my A/C break twice since I bought my home almost 3 months ago. First American Home Warranty insists on using the worst A/C repair in the Dallas Fort Worth area North Star Mechanical and has sent them out both times. The first time I was still leasing the home back to the sellers and the repair guy came to do an evaluation and never came back. I'm dead serious when I say NEVER. The sellers moved out of the house because they had no A/C and when I moved in 2 weeks after there still was no A/C. Both First American Home Warranty and North Star Mechanical did zero follow up to ensure the job was being done!
When I brought this to both companies' attention they just told me we needed to start the process over and I held no precedence over other repairs. This was just my first issue and it took almost a week and a half to get my A/C back up. My A/C broke again last week and they sent out the same terrible company North Star Mechanical. They were able to come out to evaluate the very next day but said they couldn't do any work because everything was frozen so I had to turn off the unit and he left. In this Texas heat it took less than a half hour for everything to thaw, but I guess he was too busy to wait around or come back. The repair man comes back the next day to fix the leak and does not bring any freon with him to recharge the unit. That's right my certified HVAC repair man forgot freon. So I am sitting here 3 days later and I can't get them to come back out but tell me every day that I have someone coming out.
When I called First American Home Warranty I was hung up on by their claims resolution department and when I called back they said that there wasn't a way to tell who I was talking to. The only thing they would do for me is tell me that I was on a priority list for the next day, pretty much the same story I was getting from Northstar Mechanical 3 days in a row. Let me add that I have a pregnant wife at home and hits triple digits on a regular basis Texas, but there still was no haste to repair anything. Don't waste your time with these guys, once they have your money they don't care.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 23, 2017
A friend of mine recommended First American. It made sense to get a home warranty and so I got one from them.
Updated review: Sept. 5, 2017
First American reopened the claim for possible reimbursement for the work I had to pay with our own HVAC company to correct the mistakes the other contractor made. I was notified today that they are reimbursing us for the parts and labor for an overlooked drain stoppage, coils being cleaned, and a correct thermostat being installed. Our total bill was a little over $239. We are being reimbursed roughly $226. So we ended up having to eat the sales tax. I can deal with that. My faith in this company has been restored. Had the original contractor done what they should've done, this all could've been avoided. A lot of needless stress and wasted time.
Original Review: Aug. 23, 2017
I've had First American Home Warranty for 14 months now. The first 12 being part of a real estate purchase, and we currently renewed for another year. During this time, I've only made 2 claims. The first time being plumbing in nature. The second, and most recent being HVAC. The first time included work on 3 toilets, a laundry room sink drain, a drain in the master bedroom sink, and checking a kitchen faucet due to air in the lines in spite of no leak. That repair order came to around $1200. We paid our $85 fee, and everything else was taken care of. The tech did a reasonably good job; however, I didn't care for the contractor at all.
They were constantly moving times and dates around and there was an overall lack of communication. When I did say something, they acted like I was the problem. I was nothing but respectful to them and patient. I had made some comments to First American Home Warranty about the situation, but they didn't seem to care. I did not do a favorable review of the contractor in the end, so they got all bent out of shape. At least they got a competent tech in to do the work.
The HVAC company was another story. I went through several appointment changes, no calls/no shows, and the tech finally showing up to only do the work incorrectly. He did a partial job at best. When confronted about the tech install mistake, I was told that the correct thermostat was installed. Sorry, but wrong answer. I gave them the part number and what the manual said. Neither the HVAC company nor the warranty cared. I paid the $95.
It has gone up the 2nd year. I ended up having to have my own HVAC person come out to verify the work. It took our tech that we personally hired out with money out of our own pockets 2 seconds to determine it was indeed the wrong one. He ended up replacing it with a correct one and found that an overflow tube was still clogged by the drain. He fixed that as well. He did do an overall check of the system to make sure it was ready for winter and the A/C was operating at optimum levels. We paid out another $239.76 to fix the warranties contractors mistakes. Once again, I mentioned the issues with this and problems we had with their new contractor in the area. Nothing.
Customer service is lacking with this company. They care less. Unfortunately I still have 10 months left with them. They will not be renewed. Lesson learned. The main problem here in WV is the contractors. It seems the competent ones don't want to fool with a warranty company like this. The ones trying to hit it big are not competent or lacking. You would think First American would care.
Reviewed Aug. 23, 2017
For one year, we had a different home warranty company that the previous home owners paid for but we did not like this company, so we got First American Home Warranty. It's easy submitting a claim with them and it was good with the claims representatives. They're helpful too. I call them then they’ll tell me what thing to fix. It has been positive for the most part with the technicians as well. But the technician we had last time wasn't very nice. I was trying to explain and he was talking to me as if I didn't know what I was talking about. But I let him do his job and he fixed the problem so it didn't matter. Other than that, we never had a bad experience with First American and we’re happy with them.
Reviewed Aug. 22, 2017
I have tried to use my warranty contract twice (once for plumbing services, once for a broken AC unit) and could not be more displeased with the service and ethics displayed by this company. The representatives you speak to are difficult to understand and they sound like they're falling asleep whenever they talk. The "service" was absolutely terrible. I had to submit a claim for plumbing expenses that I incurred because a representative at First American incorrectly marked my issue as standard as opposed to an emergency due to flooding in my basement, and it was denied.
During the second occurrence, my AC unit, which is 50 years old, was not cooling my house. After about six calls to First American, the tech finally showed up, "cleaned" the unit and left, which the AC still broken. I called back, he came back out and "tested" the AC and said it was fine, even though the thermostat was set at 68 and my home never dropped below 80 degrees before 10:00 PM, which I can tell you is a real treat with a 20 month old baby that can't sleep because of it. I will never do business with First American again and I will actively tell people about their unethical and dishonest practices. Easily one of the worst companies I've ever done business with.
Reviewed Aug. 22, 2017
My experience with First American has been outstanding. I got it when I bought my home. It was negotiated by the people I was buying the house from and everything has been pretty good from the submission of the claim to the technician and the quality of work done. I just hope that when I refer someone I get something because I've been referring a lot of people.
Reviewed Aug. 22, 2017
I'm an old widow and I didn't want to bother my family members, so I thought of having a home warranty for my home and when I bought my house, it came with a First American Home Warranty. First American has been wonderful and I wouldn't give them up for anything. Their representatives have been very knowledgeable and always cheerful. When submitting a claim, they schedule the service visit then the technicians will come. I will pay the technicians a little bit of money and First American will take care of the rest. The only thing was that when they tried to fix the microwave, the technician had to come back twice and the microwave couldn't get fixed. We then had to buy a new microwave and my check for the new microwave came in three days.
But overall, it was a perfect experience with First American. I've had them for nine years and I’ve been very pleased with them. I also have their extended coverage because I have a pool and spa and they've fixed that with hardly any problem. I've as well recommended them to everybody who just had to put in a new thing or afraid something's going to break.
Reviewed Aug. 21, 2017
The A/C was not cooling my house. It felt we had it on fan mode. We called First American Home Warranty and they took the order. The contractor was contacted by them. The contractor called me to take care of the situation.
Reviewed Aug. 21, 2017
We cancelled back in June due to years of bad service. Then in August we discovered they were still taking money out of our account for 2 months. I called on Aug 7th and told I was correct that we had cancelled properly but they didn't stop the payments. So they said within 10 days we'd have our money in our bank. In 10 days nothing. I called and they kept trying to say they paid on the 7th. I called and talked with our bank. Nope. No money. I called First American again in 18th. The next guy says nope, not approved on 7th but approved that day. Hmmm. Suspicious. Said would be in our account in 5 days. 2 days later on a Saturday I lost my debit card and had to cancel and get new number.
Called first American this morning. After 45 minutes of hell, I'm first told it went in on the 7th. Then I made him talk to a supervisor. Nope. They said it went in on the 18. I said nope because I checked on 20th when I cancelled my card and not in. Because the robot young man couldn't understand what I was telling him we went in circles. I begged and pleaded to talk with a supervisor. There is absolutely no way to speak to anyone in authority. Customer service is horrible.
They have stolen my money. I will complain everywhere about them to BBB and whoever and all over Facebook until we get our money. I called to tell them I have a new card number but because they keep saying they sent the money, they won't help. And don't tell me what happens to my money when bank rejects that account number. I hate First American. They are evil and don't care about customers.
Reviewed Aug. 21, 2017
We got a home warranty from First American when we purchased our home. They were recommended through the agent that we got our house from. When I called in to submit a claim with them, it went smoothly and I had no problems whatsoever. My interaction with the claims representative was perfect. He was very knowledgeable, took his time to speak with me when I asked questions, and explained things to me so I can understand them. So far, so good — My air conditioner is now working great.
Reviewed Aug. 21, 2017
Someone I know uses First American and think it's a great idea and suggested I also sign up for a home warranty so I did last July. I called in a claim when I had a problem with my washing machine and I had a call back within 24 hours. Then the tech came out within a short period of time and diagnosed it. They had to order a part, came back and solved the problem. The washing machine was perfect and good to go after the repair. I was very satisfied and I'm glad that the warranty was available when I needed it.
Reviewed Aug. 20, 2017
First American came with the house when we bought it and claim submission has been easy, however the representatives weren’t very accommodating and we actually had to talk to a supervisor. In the initial process of putting in the claim, they told us which company we're using and we told them we preferred to go down on the list. I really did not want that one contractor because of the way he had talked to us before and he was totally non-responsive. When they sent the claim in and the guy didn’t even call us back. So we didn’t want that guy because if we take time off work for him to come, we needed a reliable source.
When I explained this to the representative, I wasn't belligerent and I asked if he could understand it and he said he didn't care. The guy told us we couldn't just do that but I told him we're paying them so he could give us what we wanted or we would go. We were actually thinking about changing home warranties as well. But he was rude and then he hung up on me because I asked to speak to a manager and he acted like we had to take whatever he gave us. I wish First American made that part of the process easier but it was a pain in the butt to not get that same contractor again. Then the guy called and we told him we're not using him.
Our renewal may be coming up and I don’t want a company that’s very good at taking my money but not at listening to me. Once I asked the rep if he could see the notes from the other person that I talked to and whether they made good notes, and he said he was reading them right then. When I talked to another representative, she got a little attitude too. When I see people whose demeanor or voice isn't very nice, I would say, “Hey! I know you might have had a bad day and I’m sorry." After I said that, she took it down a notch and she said she wasn't mad.
So maybe some customer service training is needed or First American can look into their initial process so that before they can assign me a contractor, they would tell me who it is and I can have the option of going to the next one. But the guys who actually came to the house were great. The contractor was prompt and did a good job.
Reviewed Aug. 20, 2017
A neighbor referred First American to us. He said that they were a good company to deal with and that they had a good reputation, and that they had the job done. And then I did some looking around online and at some of the reviews just to validate that before choosing them. Their claims process has been very good and doing it online or over the phone is pretty simple.
Their representatives are professional and courteous and they get back to me in a good time frame. First American is reasonable with what they cover and what they don't. I've had some other warranty companies that you pay for the warranty service but you have to arm wrestle everything that should be covered. First American seems to be very honest and willing to do what they need to and take care of what they need to take care of. The most recent claim that I had done was for a garage door opener. They were excellent, fast, and did everything very well. We just bought another house in Texas and we're moving so we are getting our warranty through them for it.
Thank you for your business John!
Reviewed Aug. 19, 2017
Toilet was leaking at the base. The repairman replaced the wax ring. He said the Flange was too high and needed to be replaced. He set the toilet and it continued to leak. I called again. A second plumber looked at the toilet, did not touch it and wait. It would cost 325.00 to repair it. When I called First American Home warranty about the issue they said plumbing and sewer is covered but repairing the flange was a modification.
I was already charged 75.00 when I tried to talk to the First American Home Warranty telephone operator. He said he was looking at The SAP work order and that I would be responsible for the 325.00. I called SAP and asked them to get with the Warranty Company and they would call me back. Neither the Warranty Company or SAP returned my call. I got another repairman to reset the wax ring correctly and the toilet stopped leaking. SAP is the only contractor First American Home Warranty Uses for plumbing work. Claim **.
Reviewed Aug. 19, 2017
I just purchased a house. We had 2 inspections on the AC unit. But inspection passed. They said the units are fine. 1 month later the units stop cooling. FAHW send out tech. FAHW said someone had damaged the fins is why it's not cooling. And they will not replace. Maybe the former owner damaged the fins. But they aren't covered under the home warranty. I'm the owner now. So the AC doesn't work and they won't replace it.
Reviewed Aug. 19, 2017
I work for realtors and they use the services of First American Home Warranty. I was buying a new house and got a warranty from First American. Submitting a claim with them was good, except if I do it over the phone. It was hard to figure out how to submit the claim if I wanted to file claims for the washer and the dryer at the same time, but I figured this out. The claims representative was really good to work with. The technician was super nice and knew what he was doing, and I had positive interactions with him. Once he figured out what the issue was, he was able to fix it, and the quality of work that he did was good. All in all, I had a super smooth and easy experience with First American.
Reviewed Aug. 19, 2017
I was a previous customer of First American and because of that, when I called them, the gal said I could get service right away and I didn't need have to wait 30 days. I'm widowed so getting a home warranty makes more sense. My sons were constantly working and it was easier that way. The reps were very nice when I called in my claims and they took care of everything right away. The technicians who came out were also great and fast. My first claim was for my oven and I had good service from the guy who repaired it. Then I had a problem with the spa where it took a week for the tech to come out and three weeks to find the part they needed. A contractor also came out to work on the ice maker of my refrigerator and I was satisfied with their work. They brought with them a part but it wasn't the right one and I waited a week for them to get it. It would've been nice if they could've fixed it the same day.
For my last project, I wanted the heater fixed but I told them why I could tell it's leaking. I have some water faucet dripping but it's self fixed and I didn't file a claim for that. The first guy who came out was looking for a small part to fix the leak then he said he could check the heater. The next one came out twice but still couldn't find the piece. Here's the odd thing, they still have the parts that they took and that doesn't make sense.
The third time, a different guy came out and said he would've ordered the whole thing because the part comes with a unit and the heater's out anyway. That way, they wouldn't be searching all over for one little piece, though it was cheaper to do just that. So when I called First American back, I told them that and until now I haven't heard from them. They sent something in the mail but I haven't really seen that. I also waited too long for them to fix it and I need to call them about it. But I don't want to talk to the same guy I got last time because he wasn't very nice.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
I filed a claim because I had 3 inches of raw sewage backed up in my bath tub's total blockage of main sewer line. House was uninhabitable. According to my warranty they were to respond within 3 hours and schedule within 24 hours. I did receive a phone call but he was working on getting something scheduled because he had service set up for 5 days later. I contacted AHW later and was informed they had 8 hours to contact me. I received a call from a plumbing company 3 days later. Needless to say I had to pay out of pocket.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
I have 3 policies with First American home warranty. Unfortunately 2 of my AC in different property broke in 112 degree summer time in Arizona. One happened on Wednesday. According to their policy they won't respond for 2 days then it was weekend so it was 4 days before they even send somebody there. I was getting sick because of heat. They offered to buy portable AC about $150. Went to Home Depot. The cheapest one was about $400-700 so I end up buying a fan only which did not help at all. I called my AC guy. He came and fix it at no time. They won't reimburse me for repair ($185) because their reimbursement is not guaranteed.
My other AC also broke at the same time. It has been almost 3 weeks and still is not fixed. First they said the coil is dirty and I have to pay $800 before they do anything. I cleaned the coil but the problem was not the coil. Then they charged me another $125 for something that was not covered then they needed to order the compressor in order to be fixed. My Ac is covered under my contract and I pay about $780/year to have a coverage. If my AC breaks I should not be liable for this part or that part. First American always come with some excuses not to cover and customer service is so bad they put you on very long wait and will not get the any result. This is not the first experience I had with them. This is happening every time. Nothing goes smooth with this company. They should not treat their customers like I was treated.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
We have used First American 3 times now. We bought the premium package and have never missed a payment. The first experience was OK. The next two are what I would call nightmares. It took 3 months for them to finally replace a microwave that 3 techs could not fix after ordered part, new appointment, didn't work, new ordered part, new appointment, still did not work. When they offered a replacement ($1400) microwave we assumed the 3 techs that had been to our house to repair, provided dimensions and type. NOPE - they are not responsible for that. So, the microwave showed up, didn't fit and their contracted installers recommended I reject it. So, I did and then was charged a restocking fee.
The very next week my dryer stopped producing heat. It took 10 days for a replacement part and installer to arrive. He called to say he was running 1 hour early and asked if he could come. I was in a meeting at work and said I would not be home until the scheduled time. The tone in his voice indicated he was clearly irritated. He showed up, "fixed" the dryer and said that I might have a problem with my vent. I pointed out that when he moved the dryer to install the heating element, that he pulled it from the vent. He acted completely put out that he had to move the dryer and work on it. Once he was back there, he said, "It's broken. I recommend you go and buy a new one and have your husband put it on". So, we did just that.
After almost 3 weeks of not having a dryer, I started the laundry and quickly noticed that the lint filter no longer fits in the space. The top of my dryer is bent in, the face is now moveable and could be easily pulled off and there is a screw missing on the front load portion. FAHW - I suggest you hire reliable contractors that provide the service that you claim to provide YOUR customers.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
It is not fair that I live in an area where temperatures can get dangerously high and I have to wait for a service man to come out sometimes for days to fix an a/c. I do not get compensated for the money I have to fork out for gas and a hotel room because I have 3 children and no a/c. How is it fair that I have to leave my own house because the warranty has no 24/7 contractors? Then I get terrible customer service over the phone because they do not care. They get some at work and go home to a nice cool house. I am so fed up and if the seller would not have purchased it I would be with another company. My sister in law has another company that sends out services promptly. I may just have to pay my own warranty and let this one run out. Sorry First American Home Warranty, but you need better customer services and to treat a/c and leaks as emergencies!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
My best friend seemed pleased with First American so I never looked to anyone else. I've had several claims before which I mostly submitted over the phone. It's very easy and their reps have been good. They respond quickly and update me either through phone or email.
Reviewed Aug. 18, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American has been really good. I appreciate their quickness and promptness and it's easy to use the website to do a repair. Their reps have been really professional and courteous. The technicians that have come out to our house have also been really good. They repaired different things over the years and everything has held up really well. The only one I had any problems with was the guy that put in the new garage motor springs and hinges. He was saying a lot of things that I needed that wasn't covered under the warranty and I ended up paying quite a bit for that.
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2017
The worst customer service I've experienced. It has been 2 months since we make the claim and the problem is still far to be solved. The washer is broken, the contractor that First American assigned didn't fix the problem, so First American Home Warranty agreed to replace the Washer. But the purchase department can't find a washer that is similar like our current one LG model, and the similar size that can fit the space, so First American Home Warranty agreed to cash out which is $1300 including labor and accessories. We agreed.
We've waiting for the cash out approval for 1 week, nobody called us back, and we are trying to contact the case manager, but she never called us back as promised. After a week, I call the customer service supervisor who said that they can only offer $633. or you should accept the huge washer they found from GE which can't fit in our space. I said that I can't find a similar washer with $633. You know what they say? "Not our problem, this is the cash out amount, either accept this amount or accept the huge washer." First American don't match your machine's capacity, color or anything. Sucks. I hope the management team of this company see this review and train your staff how to value your customers. Let's see when the company will go out of the business.
Hello Tao,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2017
I purchased this home warranty for one complete year and pay for it upfront. Now that my air conditioning needs to be replaced they sent somebody out here and found out the compressor is no good but yet instead of them paying for it because I pay for my home warranty they want me to come out of my pocket for an additional $424 to help get my air conditioner repair. This company sucks and if this is type of business that they going to do as soon as my year is up. I will be cancelling and would not prescribed to them anymore because you don't state that you may be out of pocket least 400 some dollars when you sent someone out to my house to find out what's going on with my air conditioning and then you try to use some type of law about California that everyone should be energy-efficient and we should all be using the same amount of energy because we live in California to meet us a bunch of **.
So yes I'm not giving them a good rate at all because I want my air conditioning fixed but yet you're willing to reimburse me if I go buy a portable air conditioning up to $150 so that I can stay cool at night me and my wife but yet you don't want to pay the additional $424 to satisfy customer and keep them as a customer because you want to be cheap.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2017
FAHBPC's website is not user friendly and they don't appear to cover preventive maintenance. It seems easy enough to create an account but then I have been unable to login and they don't have a help desk for the site. Phone reps are good.
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2017
We've always had home warranty just in case things break. A friend told us about First American, and we liked their rates and coverage. We called to submit our claim and the experience was easy. The technicians were very helpful and professional. They had to come back twice, but it was because we had lost the AC running before they came the first time, and they knew that they were gonna have to come back.
Reviewed Aug. 17, 2017
I love First American Home Warranty. They're great and they’ve helped me out so many times. We’ve had many rental properties wherein at one time, we had 14 of them. I had many of them on another home warranty until about 10 years ago, somebody told me that First American is very reliable. And so, we've always used them.
It’s very easy to submit claims. You just key in on the computer. If we have a problem on one of the addresses, they’d let you know who they're assigning to come out and fix it. This way I can call the contractor directly if I have a question because most of our properties were in Tennessee and we moved to Florida. The contractors always came out too. And if First American couldn’t get somebody, they’d let you use a local person that you know and they’d reimburse you up to a certain amount. I've had three repairs recently on some properties and First American took care of it all.
First American also pays everything. I had an experience about two years ago on a refrigerator that was purchased new three years prior. It was a nice refrigerator but I had a repair on it. First American said it was unrepairable and told me that they would replace it. The rep sent me the model numbers and made sure this is what I was happy with. It was a $1,500 refrigerator and they replaced it. That’s almost like two years of premium. And that wasn’t the only repair I had at that house. When you have renters, you expect repair. But that was the best experience I had.
Most repairs I had was for plumbing, electrical, and garage doors. It's one thing after another. One issue I had was the garage door openers had to be both replaced, which was expensive. Also, the service calls are only $65 and they might be going up an extra $10 plus the premium. I know some people don’t want to pay for a warranty, but then when they're hit with a $2,000 bill, they'd wish they had done it. I have recommended First American to a dozen of people. I told them, “You should have a home warranty and you don’t have to worry about it. It's a wild card you don’t have to deal with."
Thank you for being a loyal customer for over 10 years Shirley!
Reviewed Aug. 16, 2017
We used First American Home Warranty from our last house. The real estate agent had already set it up as a warranty and it was part of a deal. Submitting a claim was smooth and easy. I did a claim on my first house and then as soon as we moved in to this house, we had an incident with the water heater. The contractors who came were fine. They cleaned up everything and were respectful. Everything is still working so the quality of their work is good.
Reviewed Aug. 16, 2017
I purchased a home in Nov 2016 and it came with a warranty from First American Home Warranty. The first time I used the warranty, it was for a problem with my pool pump heater display. I paid the $65 for the "service call" and the provider came out an entire week later. The digital display was inoperable so instead of just replacing it with a new display ($75 online), they replaced it with a used display along with a used heater cover in worse shape than my cover. The technician said they are not required to use new replacement parts and had a lot of used ones lying around.
The next time I had to use the warranty, my garage door spring snapped causing the door to get stuck half open and half closed. The tension on the other spring as well as the entire garage door assembly was dangerously high but First American didn't consider it an "emergency" so the repair company wouldn't come out for a week! I ended up having another company come out that same day for $650.00 out of pocket to make the repairs. A couple of months later, the garage door broke again, this time ripping one of the tracks right out of the wall. The First American contractor showed up and told me the repair wasn't covered because the door closer was the only thing covered. In addition, my other garage door didn't work as the closer is 30 years old. He messed around with it for about 20 minutes and said it was fine. I showed him that it wasn't fixed and only opened 50% of the time at best. He said it was fine and that was that.
He then quoted me $200 to repair the main door for repairs not covered but said it had to be in cash, no credit cards or checks and he was in a hurry so if I didn't pay right then, he would leave. After having a brief conversation with his boss, they finally accepted a check. He made those repairs and left with the other garage door opener still not working.
I have since refused to pay First American the $65 service fee since the technician never replaced or properly repaired the 2nd garage door opener. I have repeatedly told them this but all they want is their $65.00. The contractors used by this company are a joke as is customer service. Average wait times when you call them are 30-45 minutes every time you call and the CS reps are like robots reading a script.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 15, 2017
I called on Aug 10 to open a claim on the day my dryer stopped working. They assigned a contractor that never called & would not respond to my phone messages. Today, August 15, First American finally agreed to assign a new contractor. They supposedly are coming on Thursday. If they show up, my guess is they will have to order parts which will take another week. Terrible customer service!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 15, 2017
I've had a couple of different claims with First American and they were able to send someone out and get the problems fixed pretty quick. I had a claim on a garbage disposal and they replaced it. Then when I had a clogged drain issue, I told First American to send the same company that they sent before and that I like working with but they sent a guy from Sail. I was wondering why they would send somebody from Sail that’s over an hour away when they got a company in Raleigh that's right around the corner. That doesn't make sense to me. I also had the line drain clogged with my HVAC. The lines needed to be cleaned but First American sent a plumber to clean the line out. When the plumber got here, he said he can’t do the job, so it took three other phone calls to get the problem straightened.
I had First American work on my stove, too, for three different times. The guy who came to work on it during those times said First American wouldn't do anything about replacing the stove when I've had four claims on it which was crazy. Then I had a claim with the air conditioning which was 27 years old and the reason I got the warranty. It took about three or four months of going round and round to get it replaced and I wasn't crazy about the company that First American used to work on it. I live in a town house so the air handler sits in a closet under the stairs and they had to do a custom built air handler for the new system because they didn't make them to fit the closet. It was a big rigamaroo to try and deal with the owner. Half the time he'd answer the phone and half the time he wouldn't. I also passed for all the warranty paperwork that came with the new system but I never got it.
Then they told me that part of the new installation would include the hydro heat system and that the water heater should be under a drip pan in case it leaked and that was part of code when they put in the system, but they never installed that. They told tell me they were going to come back and do that but they never have and that's been three years ago. It's a headache. But I renewed with First American for year four despite the issues. I figured that I paid $50 and got a $10,000 air conditioning unit installed and they're doing what they're supposed to do. Having the warranty is a good value for the money but it's hard to work with some of the contractors they're sending out. I've also learned that I'd rather do the claim online than speak with them because sometimes the representatives don't speak English very well. If they do, they don't understand the issue.
Reviewed Aug. 14, 2017
The claims process was easy. My husband calls the claim in and their representatives have been friendly, helpful and knowledgeable. Also, the technicians who came to our home have always been polite. They also seemed to be friendlier and more knowledgeable than some of the other technicians we had out in the past before we took out the insurance. For instance, the first comment of the people who came out to service our heat pumps every six months was that our heat pump was getting old and that we might want to consider a new one. Conversely, the technicians from First American who come out never make any comments. They do the job and know what they're talking about. And so far, we've had good results. We've made a point to recommend First American every time somebody brings something up because they may want to try it.
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review Ernestine!
Reviewed Aug. 14, 2017
Waiting now 4 weeks for the AC repair. An almost 10 year customer of First American Home Warranty and about to switch. I took time to review every report about them on this site in detail and realize now that the problem with FAHW is their customer service processes and service levels. Agents are mostly courteous and well informed. So it is NOT the agents in general. What they lack is an effective follow up system for ensuring work orders get immediate follow up and customers are not inconvenienced. Instead they document status of work orders and only follow up re-actively when the customer (like me) is angry that no one called them back. In short, customer service is not accountable for making sure customers are getting what they NEED but rather they let things go at whatever pace it takes.
Of course, that means that when a contractor sends a report telling FAHW that they need parts, etc. It takes them 2-3 days to read it, then another day to respond, and 4 days for the part to come in. THEN another 3 days to verify the part came in, another day to schedule it, and hopefully the contractor is available because, if they are not, it will take another week for them to come out and finish the job. Absolutely screwed up process. When it comes to out-of-warranty repairs... I too have had contractors charge me for additional modifications to the AC not covered under warranty. It is happening to me as I write this. I decided to push back on the modifications this time and magically FAHW tells me they will look for a part that fits the unit so they can avoid the modification.
ARE YOU KIDDING ME? They couldn't have done that to avoid me the unnecessary expense? I have had some good service for small repairs like toilets and clogged food compactors. And for the most part the technicians themselves have been great. But the process is horrendous and extremely inconvenience for me, the customer. I plan to change warranty companies as soon as this work order is closed.
Reviewed Aug. 13, 2017
I had American Home Shield for a long time. I was put through this program when I purchased the house and had it since then. Overall, I’m okay with how the AHS reps respond to claims I submit and the quality of work the contractors do. But depending on how busy the reps are or contractor’s experience and different people’s attitude, experience is different. As long as everything works, that's fine with me.
The last time, two guys came here for my air conditioning. The first one was good. The second one got the job done but not in a professional way. And then I had somebody look at it and said, "Oh, this is a dangerous job they did with the wiring," and that they shouldn't do that way. But it was late to call back to complain for that. Then if they try to change or fix something, they bring lots of excuses to put the lowest price, cheapest quality they can. My garage, for example, I had a hard time last year talking with management. After three technicians came in and gave us a quote they said, "Oh, too expensive to do that." And finally they approved to put something.
At that point, I decided to cancel my services. It’s the same thing with the tap. Instead of changing the $26 faucet, they tried to look for parts. It took one week for them to come back here to do the cost. I'm thinking of not continuing for the next year. AHS advertises good but when it comes to work, they try to do lousy job and cheapest way.
Reviewed Aug. 13, 2017
I had a very good experience with First American. It was the hot season then and there has been an issue with our air conditioner unit upstairs. They sent someone out after our claim. They analyzed it and it was a heating problem and they got it working just fine. It went exactly as it should be although there was a little bit of a delay because of the person that they recommend it to. They were just busy and it took them about a week to get here. We're not upstairs that much, so it was okay. I have waited for them instead of getting another contractor.
Reviewed Aug. 12, 2017
I have read similar reviews. First American used to be a good company but something has changed. I made a call to them for my broken dryer. I was appointed Sears to come out 4 days later. I waited all day for them but they never showed or called. I called First American the next day and they didn't know why Sears didn't come out or call but they rescheduled me for 3 weeks later claiming that is the soonest they could have someone out to "my area". When I talked to the Sears rep in the Philippines she told me the same thing... first appointment would be in 3 weeks.
When I said my area is just 12 miles outside of the capital of Maryland and 20 minutes from the capital of the United States and I wasn't in some remote area she kept saying "exactly" but would not understand that I needed the repair done sooner. She did assign another contractor and I waited for the first contact email but it never came. FAHW then told me to call them. I did twice. The second time the guy said he was over an hour away from me and told First American that they did not service my area. When I asked the woman on the phone where she was located she told me Central America.
After 4 more phone calls to FAHW and pleading with them to allow me to use a local contractor who could give same day service they told me I would receive a call back in two hours with authorization but of course that call never came. I called again and insisted on speaking to a manager but she could not or would not put one on the phone. She promised me dispatch would call me back that day. It's two days later. I called my own company to come out. I will be buying a new contract with a different company. First American puts Americans last... do not use them. I have been a customer since 2008.
Reviewed Aug. 12, 2017
As a woman owning a house where people come in and tell me I need repairs that don't need to be done, having a home warranty is my way of protecting myself. I've had a couple of other providers that I didn't like. I didn’t find their warranty to be very good. But with First American, my overall experience has been effective and efficient. I submitted a claim with them online and I received a call within a couple of hours. And the repair was done the following day. The heating and air person fixed the problem right away. It was very simple and no parts were required. The quality of work has been excellent.
Reviewed Aug. 12, 2017
Right now I'm very disappointed with First American Home Warranty because I've been waiting for this man to come to my house to fix the plumbing problem we've had. He had me sitting at home from 3:00 to 5:00 and he still hasn't shown up or responded to my emails or text. Before this issue happened the technicians who come out here were okay. Submitting a claim with them was fine and I do it through emails. But currently at this time I am very dissatisfied.
Reviewed Aug. 11, 2017
I had a hot water heater not supplying sufficient hot water, sent repairman who said since he could not see into the heater I would need a licensed plumber to come flush the tank for $200 before they would look at replacing; so no work was done. The recent complaint is about my washing machine, it would not start or finish cycle. 2 months ago this was initiated; they sent appliance repairman, another $65.00 service call, they did not have the parts so had to be ordered. 2 weeks they arrive, that part did not fix the problem so need new part, 2 weeks again wrong part and this time the machine flooded my basement. Called First American, they do not cover damage from faulty equipment, but they do understand my frustration. Every time they were called I was promised a call the next day which never occurred.
Forward to Monday Aug. 7th, receive call from appliance repairman wanting to know if I have heard from First American, he calls them to be told they did not order any other parts because they thought it was already fixed, even though the repairman asked for more parts. That repairman said that First American was to call me the next day to let me know it was their fault for the parts but he said I should call them because they never call back. I called First American Aug 9th (they never called me again as promised) to be told that the hold up was that They were doing a price comparison of whether to fix the machine with other parts or buy a new machine, and I would have an answer in the morning.
This time since I had been sent to so many people and departments I would be assigned a claim representative to just deal with my claim, and she would call in the morning with the decision of which way to go. Well, no call, when I left a message I did not receive a return call after 2 tries so I started the process over with the customer unresolved claims, 3 - 4 more transfers. One person was even going to place me on hold for 40 min, which I was willing to do at this point, only to come back and say that since the parts were already ordered I would have to wait for the parts’ price, another 1-3 business days.
2 months later I still have no washing machine, children in the house, and school starting next week. I am not an evil person, I am a professional in public service but I am losing my cool and have demanded a full refund of the 10 months that I have spent on this 12 month warranty, but no, they cannot do that but I can sent an e-mail or letter asking to be let out of the 2 remaining months. I have had good warranty companies so I know what to expect.
This company is total garbage, will do anything to get out of a claim, lie every time you talk to them, resolve an issue by wearing you down. I will not stand for this treatment, 2 months to have my washer repaired, another several days or weeks still for a decision. My only remedy is a full refund and I demanded it only to be met with a "I understand your anger and frustration", really, I dont think so. Please put this out there for any other unsuspecting consumer, this company has not heard the end of me. Any assistance you might be able to give would be so much appreciated, I am out of patience. Thank you.
Hello Mary,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed Aug. 11, 2017
One of my neighbors told me he had First American he thought it was worth having. So, I checked into it and got it too. Having claims, I prefer to talk to people rather than machines. So, sometimes, that is a little process you have to work through. Their reps are always helpful and make it as easy as they can. But with the technicians, sometimes that's questionable, one in particular. Well, I don't know the whole process, but they just kind of talked you into things that you don't need. Instead of just taking care of the problem, they want to add some costs so they can make more money.
Also some of the companies that First American use are not the top of the line. The garage door once had a problem but it wasn’t real obvious so it took another trip to eliminate the problem. Other than one, I haven't had any problems with any of them. They've always been able to normally take care of whatever it is. I'd definitely recommend First American. There are numerous people here that have it.
Reviewed Aug. 11, 2017
When we purchased this home nine years ago, it came as a packaged deal. The inconvenience of changing to something else was our reason for keeping First American. We’ve had both good and absolutely horrific service. One particular experience happened two months ago. We had a nine year old microwave that has been repaired three times before and literally the boards were worn out. They wanted to replace it with identical boards but it is impossible because they don’t make identical anymore. It took six weeks to get a replacement. That is a bunch of BS. I could go down to Sears, Home Depot and shell out 200 bucks and have one handed to me. Although they keep sending the wrong people to install it, we love the new microwave. It’s the same as the old, also from Maytag, with interchangeable parts. You get used to the convenience of having a microwave, and the advancements are fantastic.
Another experience is the plumbing. The plumber was great and did everything we wanted but it developed a leak that went from our upstairs bathroom down to the bottom bathroom directly below it, then out to a supporting wall. Now, I got a little mold issue taking place which I got a fan running on it. He came back and put new valves in. He thought he had it tight but it was leaking. He ended up tearing a hole in the ceiling which we gave him permission to do before he realized that it wasn’t loose. He did not check the valves before tearing the house but It was a matter of tightening it up and that took care of the problem. There’s a big hole in the ceiling which has been patched. The guys did a crappy job.
I just got out of the hospital so I can’t do anything at the moment but I can do the fixing and painting. It’s frustrating. They are conscientiously billing me every month. That is why the hassle of changing is not worth it because I talk to your subcontractors and other people, it’s like all these insurance companies have the same set of issues, a problem is a problem. I know companies want to shop the best price. I don't object to that but clients shouldn't be put on the back burner because companies are trying to save 50 cents. Subcontractors cover multiple companies. I got to know these because of the business I was in, and chances are, the company has some problem and the same runaround.
I'm not satisfied with the phone interactions with them quite often but they are polite, courteous and they’re doing the best they can. These last few times everything has been handled very smoothly over the phone. However, there’s been times where the call keeps bouncing back and forth, asking questions, re-enter numbers until you reach a human being. There’s also when I want to talk to someone but in various languages. But overall, I'm satisfied with First American. The end result is what I want. I'm not happy about the situation in the downstairs bathroom but we'll muddle through it somehow. There’s a point of frustration that some battles aren't worth fighting.
We apologize for the inconvenience you experienced during the handling of your claim. Our records indicate that you have confirmed that the repair to your shower valve has been completed and consider this claim closed.
Thank you
Reviewed Aug. 11, 2017
Submitting a claim to First American Home Warranty is relatively easy. I call them up because it's easier when I remember or have information before me. But twice, I had to follow up and even when I did a follow up on the same item, I still had to pay co-pay. The claims representatives were friendly and helpful and I had outstanding interactions with the technicians. So far it has been the same company and the same technicians a lot of times. A few times, I knew who the technicians were because of the area I’m in. The work is always good but what I’d like is to know their recommendations or advice if the item they are fixing is getting close to having taken out because I don’t want it to sit down and break altogether when I’ve already put all the lights back in that I possibly can.
Reviewed Aug. 10, 2017
I took First American home warranty when I bought my house and there's been no problem when submitting claims. I submit the claim usually by calling and the reps are really good. They get back to me in a timely fashion then they have a technician in one or two days. The technicians are very knowledgeable and friendly. They do their work and go, and their work is always good. The furnace went out in January and the washer went out a couple of months ago. I was worried about the problem and First American took care of them. It's been a pleasant experience and I have recommended First American.
Thank you for your review Geraldine!
Reviewed Aug. 10, 2017
I compared prices, coverage and co-pays of different home warranty companies and First American's price was a little bit better so I went with them. Submitting a claim with them has been easy and my experience has been good. Also, their techs have been very professional, polite and the quality of their work has been excellent. I plan to sign up again next year.
Reviewed Aug. 9, 2017
Still ongoing, my AC was approved for replacement on 01 Aug 2017 according to the e-mail and the entry on my FAHW login page. I called contractor on the 04 Aug twice to setup install time and got no answer. Called FAHW on the 4th for an update if any and was told there was none. Called FAHW at 1434 7 August 2017. Transferred twice. They attempted to contact the contractor 3 times with no results. They will assign someone to follow up with me tomorrow (never happened). Contacted FAHW 1408 on 8 Aug 2017 due to no response or call from the warranty company and after a transfer to claims and being on hold for 14 minutes was told “Samantha” with claims resolution was assigned my claim and should have a response to me by the end of the day. I asked if there is a special extension number and the service rep stated the 800 number and use option 2.
Contacted FAHW around 1900 on 8 Aug 2017 due to no response or call from “Samantha”, I spoke with Alex. He told me that Samantha was the person assigned to my case and quickly connected me to her extension, of course no answer so I left message. Called 800 number back and got Alex again, kid was super polite and apologized for Samantha not answering and he gave me her extension (**) so I don't have to go through all the explaining with each rep. Contacted First American Home Warranty 1240 on 9 Aug 2017 due to no response or call from Samantha. She answered, we spoke for 3 minutes and she put me on hold. After 10 minutes she came back and said she is talking with the contractor, I told her as I have told the other 2 reps I don't want him, she again put me on hold for another 9 minutes.
She said the contractor had been calling to fix the claim (which is crap since the other 2 calls stated they had no response from the contractor). I then asked why it has taken since the 1st of Aug to now to install a compressor, Samantha responded "I never sent you any authorization for the work to be conducted." This did nothing but infuriate me to no extent, she did everything short of calling me a liar. This contractor has given me the runaround and here I sit on week 3 with no AC and Samantha is telling me she just authorized the replacement!
WHAT ABOUT THE 1 Aug 2017 AUTHORIZATION??? She said she doesn't see on her screen what I was referencing and for us to start fresh. Are you kidding me, here we go again when this should have been fixed already. WHY ARE WE REINVENTING THE WHEEL? I made my claim the 19th of July 2017 and here we are 9 Aug 2017 and we get to "start over" due to the companies negligence. Woohoo. Another 3 weeks with no AC.
Reviewed Aug. 9, 2017
4 outlets in my kitchen went out. FAHW sent same technician twice, didn't fix it. No show on third time. Later they called me, saying the issue is not covered because of lack of power capacity. I requested for second opinion. They told me to hire my own second opinion. I hired one from Amazon Home Services. And the new technician fixed the issue within half an hour. FAHW refused to reimburse me. And I still need to pay FAHW the service fee $65.
Reviewed Aug. 9, 2017
I've been here for 10 years. I've submitted a lot of claims and I've never had any problems. Whoever I’m speaking with on the phone, they talk to me well and take their time with me. I have called at 3:00 o'clock in the morning and no matter what time I call, they're always polite. They're good at their jobs. If I call on a Thursday, the technicians will come out on Monday or Tuesday. When I ask questions, they try to explain it to me as well as I can understand and they're always good answering.
I have been calling mostly about my washer, dryer and my plumbing with the faucet or the bathroom. I liked Sears above all when they come out to do my appliances. My washer has been broken about six times and I've been getting other people coming in. But when Sears comes out, they last a longer time. The technicians do what they're supposed to do and although the other companies do also, Sears seems like the better company. They really know what they're talking about. I've also had guys come out for my plumbing three times over the years and on the most recent visit, they put new pipes in which cleared the problem up good. It’s been a great experience and I'll recommend First American to my family members and friends.
Reviewed Aug. 9, 2017
A neighbor told me that First American's one of the best ones so I signed up with them. Submitting claims with them has been excellent. I either call them or do it online. I recently filed a claim for my pool heater and within 24 hours, somebody called me to come out and take a look at it. The first company that First American sent out said that they needed to replace the heater. Then they came back and said they needed to take pictures of it. So they went out, took pictures of it and said that the thing has been on fire. But it's a 400,000 BTU heater and it catches on fire inside because it heats the water. First American had to get a second opinion from another company who said that it's normal wear and tear. So they got rid of the first tech and went with the second one.
They put a new branded heater in because they couldn’t resolve the problem so I'm 100% happy. First American ordered the heater and sent it to the techs. They had to wait for it to come in which took about a week or so. But once it came in, they were right out within three days to put it in. Everything is up and running now. I go out there and hit the button and the heater fires right up. I'm 100% satisfied with First American and I'll keep them forever unless they fire me. They're easy to deal with and they take care of the problem. I love them. I tell everybody to look for a home warranty and I refer First American.
Thank you for your referrals Glenn!
Reviewed Aug. 8, 2017
The warranty sounds good but they will not be your advocate when the service provider service is poor. I hadn't had a service request all year. Finally needed my AC fixed and went 12 days without AC because First American believed the lie the service provider kept telling them that my part was not available. I had my AC fixed on my own and was told I could not be reimbursed. First Warranty hung up on me three times. One rep didn't even want to deal with me so she said nothing. Just transferred me to someone else. I was told that if my AC wasn't fixed they would transfer it to another provider but they never would transfer the request. I never had this problem with American Home Shield.
Reviewed Aug. 8, 2017
We had a slab leak at my home last December. According to all contractors and home owner insurance, the best way to fix the leak was to reroute the pipe. First American, however, refused that and will only stick to a fictitious quote of drilling the slab at a price that no one could have done it. Furthermore, when I asked them for the quote, they were unwilling to provide the quote. Even based on the word of the plumber they sent, they could not fix the leak for the price that First American quoted me over the phone. In the end I had to cover most of the repair myself. I was their customer for 6 years, and when I needed them they cheated me instead. I will never use them nor recommend them to anyone I know again.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed Aug. 8, 2017
When I bought my home, the warranty with First American came with the house and I kept it because it takes care of things and saves me money. One time, I had an air conditioning system went out upstairs and they replaced everything. It was about $8,000 but I paid $65. I've also had hot water tanks and washer that went out, attic fans that have gone out and the downstairs furnace worked on several times. But they bent the blade on the attic fan that went out and it vibrated really bad so I wasn’t real happy with it. Eventually, they had to replace the whole piece that sticks out through the roof. But the repairs of the hot water heater and washer turned out great.
For the last claim I submitted, I talked to somebody in the United States instead of being shipped overseas talking to somebody I didn’t know or understand. It was easy to get a hold of them but they wanted to send somebody else out who I've had in and didn’t really care for. I requested for a different company to do the work and that's the company they sent. The techs came out after a couple of days, were really quick and took care of the problem. First American's price can't be beaten. The warranty paid for itself for several years over the price of the air conditioner alone. The deductible fee and the cost of the policy have gone up several times and a new person coming in gets it a whole lot cheaper but I understand that's to get them in. The value is there and First American is a great thing to have as a homeowner. I tell everybody about them.
Reviewed Aug. 7, 2017
IF you get them to answer the phone, be prepared to be on hold for at least a half hour, then they gave sub par contractor who won't answer their phone!! It has been 3 days without AC in 100+ weather and still haven't been out!!' They are the worst!!! And then I promise they will have to "order" a part!! Had them for my dishwasher and the terrible company they sent out took 3 weeks to fix and still isn't fixed. I called back and they said they've closed that claim and I would have to start a new one and pay the co pay again!!! They are terrible. I'm going to cancel the policy and go with a better company. This one stinks!!!
Reviewed Aug. 7, 2017
When I bought my house, the seller had First American on it for us. I kept it to cut down on the expenses. It was easy to get a hold of their claims reps. I needed service for the roll up door 2 months ago and they were able to send out a technician as soon as possible. The technicians were good, got the job done quickly, willing to talk and very friendly. It was a good experience and I’d recommend First American to others.
Reviewed Aug. 7, 2017
I just bought a home and my realtor signed me up with First American. I started with them last March. The first guy I talked to about a claim did not write down the order correctly. We also couldn’t understand each other. He wouldn't shut up long enough for me to tell him what I'm calling about. Talking to him was not a pleasant experience. He should have a little respect for the people he's talking to. I got the order through and the service guy came out here. However, he had only one item on the list, instead of the few items that I requested to see. But, everything else is fine. He was very prompt and didn’t make a mess as well. He made some phone calls and First American approved it. Overall, they helped me out a lot and I had a pretty good experience with them.
Reviewed Aug. 6, 2017
We purchased our current home and the seller gave us a year's warranty with First American and we just continued. There's a lot of things that break every year, especially for the used house so it was beneficial for me. And I'm not so handy, so it works to pay for the service fee than if I do it myself. Submitting a claim is easy and I'm pretty busy during the weekdays so I appreciate that they take claims even on weekends. I usually call the claims in and the claims representatives schedule a contractor right away. There was one time that the contractor didn't show up on the schedule and their representative was able to find another one.
Most of the time, the technicians are okay but generally, Sears is not good. They do a half-done job and they don't confirm the functionality after the service completion. It looks like they're too busy with handling too many services and rushing from one to another. It'd be nice if First American has a sort of a rating for the contractors and they can find the higher rating contractors are the first try for the schedule. But other than that, having First American Home Warranty has been pretty simple and easy for house maintenance. And I'm pretty much comfortable with their services.
Reviewed Aug. 5, 2017
When I bought the house, the people that I bought the house from had put the First American warranty on it for six months for me, then I kept it on there. I usually call First American and talk with somebody on the phone to submit a claim, and all the reps have been very good and helpful. When I first moved into the house, I was having issues with everything. I called First American and told them that something was wrong with my breaker box, but the technicians would just take a leg out and stick it in a different hole each time. I told them that they'll burn and blow the house up in doing that and I needed a new breaker box. There are no more legs there and they must come out and replace the whole switch breaker box if the breaker has an issue again.
Another issue was I kept telling one company that I had a leak in my air conditioner. They'd come out two or three times every year to put Freon in my AC and that would take me through the summer. Then when the next summertime was around again, they'd turn on and check my AC, and the Freon would be down 30 lbs. I knew that ACs are sealed units and there was a leak somewhere, and I told them to find the leak and fix it, but they said that they don’t do that. They'd rather come out and just put Freon in my AC, and that pissed me off. Once, the technician claimed that he put 2 lbs of Freon in my AC, but it hadn’t been a while when First American sent another company out and the other company ended up putting in three more pounds of Freon in my AC, so I didn’t think that the previous company even put any Freon in it and I told them to stop doing that.
Then I had to call these people out here many times just over a fitting. I had a smaller air conditioner of the same type as my other AC and these were both in my home. They split the smaller AC in the middle and kept saying that the problem was because of the way it was. They never figured the damn thing out and it was horrible. One of my son's friends went over and said his dad does commercial air conditioning, and he knew all kinds of stuff about the line. When I told the technicians where the line was, they kept telling me that wasn't the line, so I asked them to show me where the line was. But it was just that one air conditioning company that gave me a real hard time. I told First American about my problems with this company and they've been sending a different company out every time now, and we ended up with Sensible Air. When I had my AC done, the technicians discovered some issue with the inside unit, but Home Warranty told me that I had to come up with $800 for the repair work.
Reviewed Aug. 5, 2017
We returned home after a week away, in the end of July, in the South, to find our entire 2nd floor was over 90 degrees and the AC unit was making a loud noise. We immediately filed a claim on 7/29. FAHW failed to get a contractor to us until 8/1. They were able to diagnose the problem and very promptly filed the paperwork and request to repair on 8/1. On 8/2, we spoke with FAHW multiple times over the phone and were assured the work order was in place and the new compressor had been ordered. As of 8/4, we still have NO working AC, with 3 young children (one is an infant) and 2 adults and 2 dogs in the house.
After repeated phone calls yet again, one lasting 3 hours, FAHW finally placed an order for a new compressor for our HVAC. Because it came late Friday afternoon/early evening, we STILL will have no working AC until at least next week. Temperatures and humidity levels expected to rise over the weekend. No apology. No offer to compensate us - either paying for portable AC units or putting us in a hotel have been made by FAHW.
Hello Megan,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
First American Home Warranty Company Information
- Company Name:
- First American Home Warranty
- Year Founded:
- 1984
- City:
- Santa Rosa
- State/Province:
- CA
- Website:
- homewarranty.firstam.com
Media


