How ConsumerAffairs uses cookies

This website utilizes technologies such as cookies to enable essential site functionality, as well as for analytics, personalization, and targeted advertising. To learn more, view the following link:

First American Home Warranty Reviews

4,946,193reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+2 more
Author picture
Fact-checked by: Jon Bortin

About First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 40 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.

Visit homewarranty.firstam.com
Pros
  • HVAC tuneup coverage available
  • No age limit on appliances
  • Discounts on related products and services
Cons
  • Not available in all states
  • Does not publish detailed pricing

First American Home Warranty Reviews

Filter by Rating

  • (4,666)
  • (1,105)
  • (500)
  • (326)
  • (2,440)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about First American Home Warranty?
    • 4,946,193 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Top reviews
    • Top reviews
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    2 featured reviews
    How do I know I can trust these reviews about First American Home Warranty?
    • 4,946,193 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 35 Reviews 4875 - 5025
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 2, 2018

    Five years ago, we had another warranty company but they didn't cover anything at all so I cancelled it. Then my friend recommended us to First American Home Warranty. We are retired persons and we may be needing it someday. We'll be able to recommend some of our friends too to make time so they don’t have to struggle with some minor problem. Filing a claim was not difficult at all. We called First American up and the representative was nice and very friendly. We paid the co-payment which is $75 and they sent somebody. The technician came in on time and fixed the refrigerator. Now, the fridge is working.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 2, 2018

    Our realtor suggested that we use First American and it came with the house when we bought it since the previous owners purchased a year. It’s pretty easy to submit a claim although some of the contractors that they have on record may not fully be able to work on issues like a hot tub or a whirlpool bath which I have. And pretty much contractor that they have can’t work on the issue itself or what’s going on with it. But it’s a great company and the contractors are very professional and usually get here in about a day.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 1, 2018

    My wife Carol had a condo and she was very happy with First American Home Warranty. So, when we got married, she moved in with me and then we put First American on as a warranty with the house. I haven’t had many issues with them, but when I've had, they’ve been very prompt in taking care of it for me. In my most recent claim, I called First American and they set me up with a plumber. Then an appointment was made. The guy came out, did the work on time and was done very timely. He was excellent and very professional. But the guy who does the billing said he messed up and overbilled it. It was supposed to be $75 for the service call. I gave my debit card and they took $105, overbilling me by $30. I got a receipt yesterday and they apologized for it. Hopefully, the $30 will show up in my account tomorrow.

    Other than that, I’m very happy with First American and I’ve had good luck. They’re one of the better warranty companies. I worked in the swimming pool business for nine years, so I know having someone where I couldn’t get them to fix anything. All they did was put a band-aid on stuff. But with First American, they'd come up with new parts or whatever is needed. I would recommend this company and tell other people what my experience was.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 1, 2018

    After talking to several different home warranties, I liked the package that First American offered and the rate was good. The claim process was simple. I called in and the representative was wonderful. I told them what my situation was and a couple of hours later, they texted me a contractor. They gave me his number and said I could also call them if I wanted to. I called him and got everything set up real fast.

    I had a technician out here but he was not what I expected. I wasn’t happy with the work done at all. That guy was in and out of here in two minutes. I asked him what he did but he didn’t speak in English. He wanted me to communicate with him through Siri on the cellphone and I've never heard of anything like that. That was awkward and I was disappointed because we couldn't really communicate. This guy didn’t do anything but collect the $75 basically. But as far as what First American did for me, I'm good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechOnline & App

    Reviewed April 30, 2018

    My landlord uses First American, so I only use them. When I have a claim, I do everything online and it's fairly easy. I'm savvy when it comes to their website's interface and I've never had any issues with it. When I submit my service request, I get an email saying it has been attached to the contractor. Then First American usually sends out a technician within 24 to 48 hours but I'm typically more proactive in reaching out to the contractor myself before a contractor calls me to schedule.

    Sometimes the companies that First American uses are nice and respectful. But in the past, I've had some frustrations with some of them. One time, I had to call in and request a different technician to come out from a different company because the customer service end of things wasn't the best. Still, I would tell others to check First American out. That issue was not a reflection on them but more of a reflection on the contractor that they assigned the ticket to.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 30, 2018

    I’ve had First American Home Buyer’s Protection for 15 years and we've had four contracts with my daughters and granddaughters. We have to call in to submit a claim and though we might not get somebody to come out for 5 days, we’ve had a good experience with them so far.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 29, 2018

    I pulled First American HB Protection up using a search engine and when I called them, I liked their price compared to other companies so I decided to work with them. I specifically said I wanted a sump pump covered. We have lived in the house for seven years and made it a rental so we didn't want to have any sump pump issues just as we moved out. So I asked about sump pumps and the person said that sump pumps are covered. It turned out that even though we call it a sump pump, the actual name is sewage extractor, but I didn't know the terminology. What they cover is something a cabin would have in a well and it pumps up the water.

    When the sump pump did go out, I submitted a claim and put in the note, "Sump pump is running non-stop". They didn't interrogate me if it was a water sump pump or a sewage extractor. The tech that came there charged me $75 for his time, called it in and said that it was not covered. He could have just said to cancel because the sump pump thing is in the waste in a tub.

    I called First American HB Protection to confirm. It just happened to be on my 30-day review so I was gonna cancel. But I couldn't because there was another call in there for the refrigerator's compressor. The company that the home warranty had recommended ordered the part but didn't pay attention to something. So they needed another part and that second part took another week. They brought the part back and were due to do the installation on the day I called First American HB. First American HB said that if I closed my account, then they're not gonna pay for the refrigerator's repair because that hasn't been included. I'm like, "Make a note. Do not renew with this warranty." Now that the refrigerator is fixed, I'm going to be looking into what my refund thing is. Maybe I'll just use it full. It’s a 12-month thing and just prepare myself for the next 12 months.

    They know the customers don't know all terminologies, so when somebody says sump pump or some other vague or dual-meaning repair, they should educate their vendor to double check. One other claim that I put in a call for was a pool water feature pump. I told the vendor that it wasn't working and I don't know if it was part of the pool equipment completely. They said, "If it's designated for the fountain, then we don't cover it. If it's designated for the filter, then we cover it." That helped me avoid paying $75 for that vendor.

    I have two other home warranties with First American HB Protection but I'm just gonna take my time and look for a warranty that covers sump pump extractors. That's gonna be one of my questions to future warranty people. I upgraded my policy just to be sure everything was covered. Now, I'm like, "Do not upgrade and just take the minimum warranty." I'd tell friends to forget First American HB Protection.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2018

    Getting a home warranty would be a good deal for the things that we had going on in our home and so we got First American. The experience was really good when submitting a claim and I had claims for the refrigerator, microwave and washer/dryer. Then, I also had a very good interaction with the technician who came to fix my washer and the quality of work performed is very good as well. We're very pleased with First American and they're the value for the money.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Thank you for taking the time to leave your review Suzy.

    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 28, 2018

    A bad outlet caused a power surge. Power surge fried my stove. They covered the outlet being repaired but won't cover the stove because they don't cover "consequential damage." Complete rip off. DON'T GO WITH THIS COMPANY!! Then I called to have it explained to me, and was told by Roland that they won't do anything about the stove. I asked for a supervisor and he said he was the highest rep in the company, and they don't give out call reference numbers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 28, 2018

    I was spending too much money taking out warranties per appliance at Sears and my daughter recommended First American home warranty to me. She thought it was something that we could probably benefit from and wouldn’t cost as much. I usually call First American when submitting a claim and they tell me they’ll get back with me in about 24 hours, and we’ve never had a problem. The most recent claim was my refrigerator and it has been fantastic since the repair. First American performs, and they call back and they get right on it which really pleases me. They’re dependable, truthful, and they do excellent work.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Thank you for your business June.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 28, 2018

    Our friends said that they had bad experience with another insurances. So, we decided to try out First American Home Warranty. So far, I've only done one claim and I went online to file it. Their online process was easy and straightforward. Also, our technician was fast. He came, he fixed the issue and he left.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 27, 2018

    The sellers of the home had to buy a warranty for me when I bought my home. First American was the one I chose just from looking online and they're the recommendation of my realtor. I submit my claims online and it's been fast and easy. I’ve had a few claims with them including the most recent one for two ceiling fans that were out. A couple of claims took a few phone calls as they were more complicated issues. And the quality of the work done by the contractors who have been sent out is good. My experience with First American has been good and the warranty has more than paid for itself.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 27, 2018

    I have home insurance and when I call them, First American is the one I would have to call to get a work order completed. I had a fine experience with them and submitting a claim is simple and easy. My home insurance told me that I could either call First American directly or they could contact First American to let them know and First American would then reach out to schedule an appointment. I ended up calling First American directly, left them a voice message, and they called me back within less than an hour, which was really quick. The guy I spoke to was one of the plumbers who came to my home and he told me that they were on the road and that they can make it the next half an hour, which was convenient and worked out perfectly.

    The guy who did the toilet flushed the toilet then he told me to test it a couple of times. I only tested it once and I told him that the water was still going down slowly. He told me that that was fine and that's the way it should be. I told him that the other toilets in my house don't work like this. They're faster. He didn't leave any room for negotiation and said the toilet is fine and maybe the toilet is just older. He even put his hands in there to show me that it is working. I didn't have problems with the unit after but I was just concerned because I didn't wanna have to call them back again later.

    Also, the guy's demeanor put me off. But it wasn't that big of a deal because the guy with him who I spoke to was friendly. His customer service skills were great. He told me that if I still have issues with the toilet in the next couple of days, I can claim a warranty, they'll contact me, and that they'll take a look it. It put me at ease that they'll still come back for free in the next couple of days to fix it if there's an issue. Another thing is that they should have change on them if someone's paying in cash. They should also have cash in order to reimburse appropriately. But again, that's not a big deal.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed April 26, 2018

    I'm a new buyer of a home that has a pool and spa so I asked for the pool and spa equipment to be covered. The policy with First American Home Warranty states that the circuit board is covered under the pool and spa. And then when you start reading what is not covered, it says any computerized, pneumatic or manual management systems. Management system tells the pool pump when to go on and off, and run the filters. So, when the circuit board went bad, First American automatically resisted, "No, we don't cover it." And I said, "Well, I don't understand why because if we have a computer and the circuit board isn't working, the computer doesn't work once I put a new fuse in the system." The circuit board booted up and when it was plugged in to the non-manual circuit board, or the manual circuit board because evidently there's two, it blew the circuit board again.

    I asked them, "Then what circuit board do you cover?" They couldn't answer me that question. And I said, "Well I need to know because the policy said you cover a circuit board. How am I supposed to know what circuit board you cover." So after being on the phone for two hours and 15 minutes, with multiple representatives, it was an absolute fiasco. They came back and said, "The only circuit board we cover is for a variable speed pool pump." I said, "Then your manual or your policy needs to be specific." Nonetheless, the rep of company that they used to come out seem to be very nice but I would never recommend this company, ever. There's absolutely no way as a consumer, regardless of who paid for the policy, that the company should not specify exactly what circuit board they are covering. And they wouldn't even give me a second opinion.

    Now I am very concerned because we have a recirculating heat pump in our house. And it says it covers the recirculating heat pump. What happens if it goes out and I get the same runaround. Underneath all the items that they cover, it specifically says circuit board. When in fact, a circuit board runs a computerized system. Now, I'm manually going out there flipping a breaker because it's gonna cost me over three grand. They don't allow even manual management system. It's nonsense and it's stupid.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Pamela,

    We apologize for the inconveniences you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. Please note, per your contract electronic, computerized, pneumatic and manual system management and zone controllers are not covered. The failure was with the control board within the management system and therefore not covered. We recognize that your last experience fell far short of your expectation, and we want to let you know that we are truly apologetic.

    Please note, your claim remains denied.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 26, 2018

    I had a leak in my sink and I couldn’t find it underneath. I called First American and the guy who came out here was a real good guy. He told me what it was and because we have hard water in Nevada, the leak was inside the actual faucet. But it was internal on that and it had eaten up the stuff inside, almost some of the metal. Mine was a Moen and he said he could take care of it in 15 minutes. So I paid the $75, which I always had to pay upfront. That was also the first thing they'd asked for. Then he couldn’t do anything because for whatever reason, First American didn't cover a faucet and he was not allowed to work on it. So I ended up having to call another plumber. Then, I went to Home Depot and bought a new thing because the water had set down on the bottom. I had to firstly do the demolition, which hurt my right leg, then I went back to Home Depot to get the new boards because the ones I had had been soaking in water.

    So, my suggestion to First American is that it’s stupid not to cover the faucet. My son has another warranty company and they cover faucets. The whole thing ended up costing me $400 and some for a new faucet. That’s an expensive thing if you have to call a plumber to come out on a Saturday. And the plumber took 20 minutes tops to replace the thing because he knew how to do that stuff. First American's rep told me the other day that they're gonna refund $75, which I appreciated, but it was kinda frustrating because it was such a minor thing.

    Recently, I had a thing in the garage with Ideal Services. They replaced my water heater and were supposed to put a drip pan in but they never came back to do it. So I called them and they told me that they were no longer working with First American Home Warranty. I paid extra money to them and I didn’t get a drip pan. And in order to get another drip pan without making a claim because Ideal wouldn’t do it, I had to call a whole new plumber because First American wouldn’t do it. But it was not the warranty company's fault because the people that put in the water heater forgot to put the drip pan. Other than that, everything else has been fine. I have First American for nine years now and 90% of the time, my experience with them has been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 25, 2018

    I have had my warranty on my main house for over 6 years and this house for 2 years. I got my 2 brothers and my parents with this company including friends and neighbors! I've been sent to claims resolutions but we always worked it out. Minor stuff! But now I have a major problem with the outside a/c condenser. Around July 2016 we had a service (Air-it-Cool) call and they fixed a leak by spot welding the coil. I thought that was substandard practice but it was blowing cold so I was satisfied. Then in Oct. 2017, another service call (Air-it-Cool). This time a faulty start-up capacitor. Worked until April 2018. Started blowing warm again! We called for another service call (our third) and they sent out their tech (Total Air). This time he said the the coil on the condenser which sits out in the backyard had a pin hole leak due to pet urine. The claim was denied. Damage by pet urine is not covered.

    We said to FAWC that our 2 dogs which are 13 years old are both female and don't lift their legs! So they sent out another company (their choice) who came out for a second opinion and stated that he felt the corrosion was due to water sprinklers and not pet urine. They once again denied the claim because water from sprinklers are not allowed to spray water on the condenser!!! Ridiculous!! Call Resolution dept and left a message for Maria or Mary, could make it out but her extension is **. I left a voice mail asking her to return my call. Gave her the claim number # ** and left a detailed message and asked her to return my call because once again the claim was denied! I also found on the internet that Lennox had recalls with their coils from 2005-2007. I submitted this article to the claim resolution dept. So before I had called Maria ext ** the gentleman Brandon told me now they denied the claim because they don't cover recalled items!!

    So it was denied for pet urine, then water sprinklers, then they don't warranty recalled equipment! I called Lennox to find out what it was about. The recall was on evaporator coils NOT CONDENSER COILS and starting in the year 2005. Our condenser was built in 2003 so we are not under the recall!! The bottom line is that our system is approx 12 years old and the coils are corroding due to the elements of the Florida climate! In my other houses all the condensers are hidden by bushes with sprinklers in them. Also why would they fix the unit the first two times if it shouldn't have been under warranty due to corrosion! This is absurd! It's ok to warranty for a quick zip fix with the welder and a start up capacitor but no to do the job correctly by replacing the broken part from the get go!! Now to top it all off Maria Ext ** never returned my call and is hoping I will just disappear!!

    I am a businessman and I know how to treat customers right! I am not going away!! If I don't get this fixed I will FedEx this letter to the President and CEO of FAWC. When they tell me that it's not covered then I will stop but also I will cancel on both my homes and my brothers will also. And my new home which they just sent me the letter to start up. I'll hold off on that right now! Seems to me they'll take care of the little minor stuff but when it comes to a major claim they look for anything to deny it! This is not the way they advertise their business and I'm not going to accept this answer until the CEO or President deny it!! I'm going to the top. I want the service that I paid for and was promised.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    G increased rating by 3 stars.
    Customer ServiceTech
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, G increased their star rating.

    Reviewed April 25, 2018

    My water heater broke 2 days ago, this company is full of liars! They said in the contract if an emergency happens they will respond within 24 hours, it was almost 48 before anyone came to the house to even look at it! Called after the first day and they cancelled an appointment saying they wanted to find another vendor so they could get water back to my home, they didn't find anyone else but since they had already cancelled the appointment I had to wait longer for someone to come. I called AGAIN and the guy on the phone said bluntly that they didn't honor the contract terms and would be there when they got there. I don't know if these positive reviews are employees, bots, or just liars but this company is terrible and I wouldn't recommend them to fix my dog house!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 25, 2018

    I just recently purchased a home, and the homeowners purchased supposedly the best warranty that was offered through this company. I have experienced nothing but dishonesty and frustration. I had a major plumbing issue where my shower wouldn't turn off. The water was constantly running. It took them two days to send a plumber, who was incompetent and not a license plumber removed the shower handle, and then told the warranty company that the handle was broken. The warranty company then refused to fix my shower handle or replace it stating the item was broken. I had to send pictures and practically prove to the warranty company that I didn't break the shower handle. The plumber took it off to "see what was wrong with it". Then the company had to send another plumber to confirm the shower handle wasn't broken. That item was proven and the shower handle was fixed.

    The second plumber came in my house complaining about the first plumber calling them incompetent, and stating they were not plumbers, and had to be the second opinion on their work at least 3 times a week. Everything the first plumber fixed either broke or wasn't fixed from the beginning. I had to argue with the warranty company extensively take extra days off from work meeting different contractors to prove to them the legitimacy of every claim. I then sent the issues regarding the leak in the kitchen into arbitration with the company because they said the sink was preexisting.

    Well I just bought this home a month ago, had an inspector thoroughly inspect items, and a signed due diligence from the seller, as well as a walk-through prior to closing on my home. The company is saying things that were fixed were not fixed properly therefore the warranty that was purchased for me to cover the home after I became the owner was not covered. The representative requested that I get receipts from the sellers of the contractors they had in the home. This company tries to prevent from repairing anything at all cost including being dishonest. I was told to get a second opinion to confirm the problem was not due a preexisting issues and I was told to pay for the contractor, and they will then replace the sink faucet.

    When I sent the second opinion diagnosis in the representative stated, "I don't know why you were told that" and refused to fix my sink and it was some other problem, and even they had documentation a representative told me to pay for a second opinion. They did not even offer my money back for the second opinion. The company is only good with the least expensive cost, and attempts at all cost to weasel their way out of paying for anything costly including contracting dishonest contractors and standing behind dishonest employees. Additionally, as I was attempting to complete an arbitration dispute with a representative, who hung up on me three times. This is absolutely ridiculous. I closed on my home March 6, and this has been a nightmare working with this warranty company. I am going to have to seek legal assistance to get the funds returned so I can obtain another company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 25, 2018

    My wife told me about First American and the warranty came when we bought the house. They're very reliable, admirable, and I didn’t have any problems with them. They’re very good in their work. I had two techs out in two days for two different claims. Both of them were for plumbing though and they fixed what they were told to fix. The work they did was quick, very good, and amazing.

    It seems that the hardest part of all was making sure that I had the right people and the right connections. One time I called the wrong phone number, but I didn’t know why. First American's contractors come from different places and they're not local. Their phone was connected with the inner-city plumbing and I thought that was in Palm Desert. But they came from Palm Springs which was about ten miles away. I was leery about that, but that was necessary. When we bought the house, they could have sent us a little information out about how to use them and a good phone number. But now, we manage all right, so it’s not the end of the world. I talked to the people in their company when I called them up but it would have been easier if I had all the information ahead of time where I knew I was calling up the right people and a little bit more about First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 25, 2018

    I was searching for an affordable home warranty because I had one which was paid for a year when I bought my house and when I went to renew that one, it was really costly. So, I shopped around and I found First American Home Warranty myself. However, I was very disappointed with the claim I just submitted and I’m not sure if I’m going to stay with them.

    There was a leak in my washing machine drain where it goes into the drain pipe that was eroded. The plumber came and he said that he could see it but there was another pipe in the way. That pipe had to be removed because he couldn't sweep through and so he couldn't do it. They wouldn't cover it unless I provide clear access. I asked the plumber what would be required and he said that he would have to make a call and see my deal and that they had to reschedule. And it was a Saturday, so I have a feeling he didn’t really want to be there.

    Even though I’m paying them every month, I have to go hire a plumber and pay it myself. Right now, I’m not very happy and I can’t use my washer. Except, I’m very ingenious and I made sure that I double check with everyone. It’s not leaking from anywhere except that point and they said that that is the first point of the drainage system. So, I skewed in my washer out because it’s right next to my kitchen and around a little half wall. I lifted and attached everything, put the drain pipe in the kitchen sink and wash my clothes anyway until I could pay the full price if someone would come and fix it. The plumber said that there’s about 12 inches of clearance and I can’t squeeze my body through there so I need them to send a plumber who is 11 inches thick.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2018

    As a new homeowner, one looks for this type of warranty to give some assurance against unforeseen failures in the first year. But #FirstAmerican has demonstrated bad faith, obfuscation, and unresponsiveness in my current experience. The technician they sent to look at my dishwasher told us the machine was not repairable, that they should replace it. The warranty company told us that it required maintenance, and maintenance was not covered. I tried to discuss this with the company, but they refuse to share more details of the technician's report, instead focusing on the technician's observations that there was sediment build-up in the dishwasher. In fact, the small amount of sediment in the dishwasher is NOT the cause of its poor operation - the water distributors need to be replaced (at minimum) - and maybe a few other parts. The technician concluded too much needed to be replaced, so he didn't recommend this.

    I explained this to First American, but they have closed my claim and not responded to my request for further review. When I requested a copy of the technician's written report, they told me they did not receive a written report. But that is not really true, because two of the people I spoke with on the phone told me they were looking at the technician's report. Perhaps they mean they do not have a handwritten report - which is ridiculous and deceptive. They have not shared with me the whole report, despite my request. We also had the bad luck of a failed air conditioning unit. First American did agree that this was a covered failure, but their contractor also proposed to make $1300 in uncovered "modifications" as a requirement for the repair.

    I tried to get an explanation from the contractor, but the salesperson I spoke to told me she would need to get someone who could better explain to call me. I've been waiting for 3 weeks. In the meantime, I also asked First American if I could use my own contractor. They seemed pleased to offer a settlement - and I understand why... The amount they offer to settle is a paltry amount compared to what it actually costs to have a contractor come in and replace a condenser coil, $281. No negotiated contract can explain away this type of discount. I asked for an explanation, whether this includes both labor, parts, and installation supplies - but I'm still waiting for an answer. In the end, I would suggest that most people are much better off pocketing the money they would have spent on a First American Warranty, placing it in a saving account each year, then paying for their own repairs.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2018

    The coverage is good for a first-time homebuyer. We continued it from the previous homeowner and once we had some pricey charges that were paid for by First American, we decided that it was a good deal for us as a homeowner. Previously, I had put in a very detailed negative review online about one of the previous technicians. They tried to get me to pay some extra money at the end of the repair and I never heard back from First American so I was disappointed. But the technician who came out most recently was very nice and efficient. The online portion of submitting a claim is also very easy. The representatives have been a little difficult at times but once I talked to a supervisor, they were understanding.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2018

    First American Home Warranty is a good company and they stand by their work. We have been with them for four years. One time, we had problems with our washer and it took them three months to get it fixed. But before we renewed it, my husband spoke with the person and told them about the problem with getting the washer repaired. She assured us it would never happen again, and it’s true. We had good experiences since then. Also, the claims process has been easy, their representatives have been fine, the technicians who came to the house have been excellent, and the quality of the work done has been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed April 23, 2018

    The marketing material is very deceptive. It gives the impression that your home is covered. The reality is, if anything major goes wrong, there is some tiny print excluding that item. And if you miss the exclusion in tiny print... they will charge you for the service call to point out you’re not covered. Every phone call is miserable. The reality has set in that the only thing actually covered are things that are cheaper to fix than the actual service fee. It has cost me more money using this “service” than it would have if I had figured it out on my own and called a handyman. It’s frustrating that my realtor suggested this company and I’m more frustrated having this warranty than if I didn’t have any.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 23, 2018

    I may have signed up for First American Home Warranty back when I bought my house in 1988. Many years later, I got a special offer to come back. It was also recommended by the home seller. I came back and have continued since then for the idea that things are protected by today and it works. In submitting a claim, I use the website but sometimes I seriously can't quite get a hold of the contractor and schedule an appointment. It varies by contractor though. My most recent claim was fast and smooth. I filed the claim and talked to the contractor within two hours. I got an appointment for the next morning. The contractor came on time and fixed the thing right away.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 23, 2018

    When we bought a house, I found out my ex son-in-law works for First American when he told me about it. It’s worth it to me and I don’t have to buy all the different warranties from all the different companies. Submitting a claim to them is okay but it works better when they have the more local people. I initiated the claim online and then I called up the contractor. The first time, the contractor was quick in getting here and it was good. Then he noticed another problem and it got to be a big deal this last time.

    I had a guy come out and work on my hot water tank. And he noticed the pipes around the hot water tank were leaking. The plumber and I sent pictures and nobody got them and they didn’t call back. I called and they sent a whole new plumber out. Then they sent this whole other company out and they fixed it quickly. The work is good once they send the guys out but it’s hard to get stuff approved and it took too long. Still, I’m satisfied with it all and I told some of my neighbors that it’s a good thing. I live in an upscale mobile home park. They’re really nice places with a lot of older people and they’re always calling a handyman to fix things and I’d rather a professional do it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 22, 2018

    I have a simple leak with my shower and First American has been in my place four times but it's still leaking. They spent a few hours on it yesterday and left a mess in the shower. My wife cleaned it up and five minutes after they left, the shower started leaking even more. It looks like they are looking for some cheap solution and they tried to untie and changed something. I told them I was not going to pay $75 every time they came out. Also, they showed up when they wanted to and called me about 15 minutes before they did. But I told them we were not at home because my wife and I were working. Then we had to stay from 1:00 to 5:00 and wait for them.

    Right now, I'm at the point where I want to call an independent plumber, replace the faucet, and charge them for that because it's so annoying. Somebody called me and left a voicemail after I gave them a bad review and that was it. It's the worst service. Their guy even asked me on the way out if I was considering remodeling our shower and told me I better do something. But I told him it was not his business. I'll give First American one more trip, then I will take care of everything by myself and charge them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 22, 2018

    I bought an older home and I looked at getting a home warranty for a safety concern. My real estate agent mentioned First American HB Protection and it was what was recommended to me. Submitting a claim had been really slow in the past, but most recently, the service has gotten better as far as response time and the claims process has been fairly easy. I’ve had a dryer repair and it was a simple belt that was fixed and the technicians couldn’t do anything for me. They wanted me to wait another seven days. I still had to pay for their service and I got nothing out of it so, that one was not so great. On the other hand, I had a well issue recently and filed the claim about 5:00 in the afternoon, and the service company was at my house by six. That one was fantastic. Some of the companies that First American uses have been really good and some of them have been not so good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2018

    We got First American HB Protection for my daughter's place and we were very pleased with them. The realtor told us about it and recommended a home maintenance package for single women. We had one claim for a plumbing leak after we bought the place and our interaction with the claims rep went fine. We called them and they sent out a very good plumber in two days, and the quality of work was excellent. I paid the guy $75 and he went about his business.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2018

    Getting the insurance from First American Home Buyers Protection was part of the deal when I bought the house. I’ve had the coverage for two months now and submitting a claim with them has been a terrible experience. The amount of time that I had to go through on the voice recognition over the phone took forever. Then the technician they sent out didn’t fix the problem properly and I had to call First American again to have somebody else come out. And this issue has been going on for a week now.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Todd,

    We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during your plumbing claim. Our records indicate your plumbing issues have been resolved. At this time, your claim is considered closed.

    Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoveragePrice

    Reviewed April 20, 2018

    I paid $160/year extra to have pool equipment covered. Oh no they didn’t. 2 examples: 1.Filter pump. Couldn’t get anyone to show up... so I had to pay my own guy to do the repair. 2. Heater. First American EXCLUDES the heat pump repair - which I discovered is the typical repair to fix a pool heater. What a SURPRISE!? Pretty clever. Great way to get out of paying claims. EXCLUDE the most likely repairs. CHOICE Home Warranty now has my business. Costs less. Better coverage. Good luck all!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 20, 2018

    I've had First American HB Protection when I first got into my house and I hadn’t had problems since. They made submission of claims convenient where you can do it online and that's what I always do, and it’s much better that way. They give a claims number and they let you know who you’re going to be dealing with and who’s gonna come out. Those people usually call within 24 hours. If I have a claim today, I’d go online and pay my fee. I don’t have to worry about giving it to the service people anymore. Most of the people that they have sent out had been very good and I was grateful about that. So, I pay so much and then they pay so much and they were very kind people. So far, their performance had been really good. If the work is not done correctly, they get you someone else. You just have to let them know. Overall, I’m satisfied.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 19, 2018

    Sent Ridge Electric out who assessed that I needed a heater/vent/fan in my master bathroom. Ordered replacement and came and installed. BUT the vent/fan/heater was smaller than the one they replaced. Ridge Electric told me First American would send out sheetrock contractor to fix the 2 inch gap where the fan was the wrong size. First American sent sheetrock guy who said the fan is too small - just need the right size installed. After numerous emails and phone calls (of which you get cut off 3 times after going through all the options to get to talk to someone) the supervisor indicated that my warranty said they DID NOT HAVE to match the size - only the capacity and function.

    So I'm left with a hole in my ceiling (see picture). I sent a picture and that was still their answer. The sad thing is that they called Ridge Electric who confirmed they put a NEW vent/fan/heater in my ceiling. So Ridge Electric flat out didn't order the right size but I'm stuck with a hole in my ceiling and my warranty doesn't cover it. So the warranty is truly a rip off. So watch out if you have to have a microwave replaced and they can install a smaller one that still performs to capacity and function then you will be stuck with a be opening around it also. This is totally not a quality of work with their contractors and even worse that First American will not do anything about it. I will not buy another home warranty from First American again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Mary,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 19, 2018

    A co-worker has First American Home Buyers Protection. And then when I bought my townhouse about 14 years ago, she told me about them. I got them after that. Submitting a claim has been very easy. When I first got the warranty, I would call in. But then when I got familiar using the website, I usually submit an issue through the website. It takes about a day or two until a contractor contacts me. And there were some contractors who have called me more quickly than others. But they have always been very professional and polite. And I've had no problems with the quality of work they performed. It's all been done to my satisfaction.

    The technician had to come out a couple of times for my washer. My washer would spin and drain but the clothes would still be completely wet. Once, they thought it was the motor, and then they thought it was the transmission. They had to order some parts in between. So that took a long time but after the second time the technician came out, he submitted it back to First American and they decided to replace the washer instead of continuing to repair it. They sent me a check within a week. And I bought one on my own. Then I had to go upload documentation that I had purchased a new washer so it could be covered as well. The only trouble I had was that it took me a while to figure out how to upload my documentation that I purchased a new washer. And I didn't want to buy the one that they recommended. But overall, I'm glad to have the coverage.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 19, 2018

    Jokes in the subject line aside... Two quick things to note: 1) I haven't worked with any other home warranty company before - so FAHW could be the best within a terrible industry and 2) I probably got my $795 value in repairs. However, the customer service process was so unbearable that I ended up paying $1,200 out of pocket for a repair that was clearly covered - and that was never refunded. The long story short is that it is abundantly clear that FAHW's system relies on a tier of virtual assistants who do not have the authority to make decisions - only to relay the information on the pamphlets that are in front of them. Simple repairs like fixing a faucet would take 2-3 hours of my time to coordinate. My property manager would call me and say FAHW wouldn't talk to them. I would then have to call FAHW to get the repair authorized, call the contractor (because FAHW gave them wrong information every time), then call my property manager back.

    Each time on hold for 15-30 minutes for FAHW. Basic communication was so atrocious I literally think that FAHW has a deliberate disinformation campaign set up amongst the VA's to delay the repair process to entice owners to just pay for the repairs themselves. I'm talking worse than federal employees. Worse than going to the DMV (O no!). I own a business and have managed a few others, so I understand the value of virtual assistants and how to incorporate them into a customer service funnel. FAHW's process is terrible. Never once was I forwarded to a decision-maker or someone who was able to make rational decisions. Only people who talked in "contract code."

    The last thing I will leave is a quick story that put the nail in the coffin for me. I have a duplex rental property. One of my units sprung a sewage leak. There were also some issues with the bathroom sink and kitchen sink. The first contractor went down and fixed the kitchen sink with no receipts, no report, nothing (contact to completion time approximately 6 days). I contact FAHW and asked why the bathroom sink and sewage leak wasn't fixed - they said the contractor said it was unsanitary, but didn't file a report. I had them send out a second contractor. The second contractor came out and said he "didn't have the right equipment to fix the sewage leak. He left. No report, no notification, nothing (contact to completion time approximately 5 days). I called FAHW and get a repeat response. At this point, I'm done messing around.

    Two weeks into an emergency repair, I decide to PAY ANOTHER PLUMBER TO DRAIN THE POOL OF WATER [now standing water because FAHW took so long] AND SUPERVISE THE CONTRACTOR THAT FAHW SENDS. The Third contractor comes out and says that he can't access the leak and that I have to uproot all of my floorboards. At this point I have had a sewage leak for 20 days that has accumulated a cesspool under my unit and created an unsanitary condition for my tenants. I paid out of pocket $1,000 to get it fixed outside of my warranty company. The guy did it in two hours. The floorboards didn't need uprooted. The "equipment" was a basic plumbing line bore. And he cleared the pool of water (for the second time) for $100.

    My 'Educated Opinion' on why it went down like this... FAHW has worked out deals with contractors for a discounted rate. The contractors get jobs and FAHW gets a deal. However, the underpaid workers who are actually doing the job aren't held accountable. They show up, say "I don't want to do this," make an excuse, never file a report, then leave. I can't blame the contractor - that makes perfect sense if you are operating in a system where YOU AREN'T HELD ACCOUNTABLE. It's easy for FAHW too... They can just fire off excuses for why the work can't be done. The only person who doesn't benefit from this system is the homeowner.

    Throughout this entire process, FAHW REFUSED to pay for my contractor and refused to pay me out for the work. No reports were ever filed from the FAHW contractors and when I called, emailed, messaged about the pay-out, I got more disinformation tactics. I gave up and wrote this report. Horrible service. Bottom-of-the-barrel contractors. I definitely did not renew my contract. I can't think of a situation where FAHW would be a good fit. It is definitely NOT a good fit if you have a rental property and cannot allocate 4-5 hours a day fixing what FAHW screws up.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 19, 2018

    It's easy to submit a claim with First American Home Buyers Protection unless I want to request the certain contractor in our town. Sometimes I have to call them to do that and I can't log-in. That's a little irritating but other than that, if I fight for it, I can make it happen. I live in a small town here and I know the contractors, so I usually end up calling them myself and ask if they got the claim yet, then they'll come out. If I get a good technician, I request them again. And so far, so good. Their customer service was good for the last couple of calls I had, but the overall quality of their work has not been okay. Nonetheless, I would recommend First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 18, 2018

    We have been with this company for a while now. I don't understand why is this company continue to hire these non-professional technicians. I have to continually call this particular technician to schedule for him to fix my refrigerator. I should have known he was a non-professional with a Gmail account. He did not have a receipt book for my 75 dollars I gave him. This is not the only bad encounter I had with First American technicians. It's pretty much constant.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 18, 2018

    Purchased the home with this First American Home Warranty at the end of June 2017. Around August we started to experience problems with the AC running non-stop and not cooling the home sufficiently. The home was recently re-insulated with foam in the walls and attic insulation. But on hot days the AC would run all day and never get down to 76 F where we had it set. First American sent out a technician 2 weeks later due to two cancellations and on a cool day which cost me $75.00. He inspected the unit and said the AC was old (28 yrs) and although not cooling as well as it could was operating normally so there was no warranty issue. My electric bills argued differently.

    I called the company back and explained the non-stop running, the fact the AC tech came on a cold day, and the tech’s negative attitude that suggested I was trying to scam the company. First American said that they do not warrant age and if it isn't broken it is not covered. I asked if I could get an independent second opinion from another company of my choosing. They said that they, First American, would need to send another technician out and if they found no issues they would charge me another $75.00. Another $75.00? At that point I felt that this was their way of keeping me from a warranty issue.

    So fast forward to March of 2018, still under warranty. I called two different companies for a free analysis of my unit. Both indicated that the compressor was worn out and it would not last another season. As of the age the unit, it would need total replacement, particularly because of the old Freon and the changes needed for the new Freon.

    In the meantime, I received a "renew your warranty postcard" in the mail from First American. I decided to try one more time to see if they would honor their warranty. I talked to a salesman who said the same thing. "If it isn't broken then we won't fix it". I explained the hot days, the constant running, the high electric bills and I said to him "put yourself in my shoes! So, I have to wait until it breaks before you will honor your warranty? What about running all the time and not getting down to temperature? What about two independent AC contractors opinions?" I also said I would be willing to renew this insurance if they would honor their warranty. He then said he may have misspoken about it breaking, was sympathetic, agreed with what I had said, thought I had a valid point and transferred me to claims.

    I again started to explain everything to the claims department and in the middle of me talking they hung up on me. I waited for a callback thinking the hang-up was accidental and if it was, they had my record and phone number on their computer. No callback came! You can imagine I was not happy! So, I will not continue to waste my time with this company. I am having my AC replaced independently and suggest you avoid First American Home Warranty!

    Updated on 05/19/2018: I recently wrote a review on April 18, 2018 about my experience with this company. I gave them every opportunity to make this wrong right. But they insisted I did not follow proper procedure and therefore I invalidated my claim. This involves a failing AC unit that ran all summer day and night in 2017 and never getting to the temperature setting of 76 degrees, which I feel is not an unreasonable temperature setting. They did call me back two days later after I wrote my first review. I explained that after the warranty department became conveniently disconnected with my last phone call to them and never called me back I decided to write the one star review dated April 18.

    We decided to get the unit replaced independently as First American Home Warranty refused to honor the claim and it has been running great and cooling the house as a normal unit should. This proves that the 28 year old AC unit which was warrantied by them was failing and not cooling the house as it should have. They called 2 days after the new unit was installed and said they would waive the second $75.00 fee to inspect the unit again. A day late and a dollar short! I would have loved to have seen their second opinion! I asked them to just pay half the cost of the new unit I had installed and I would change my review, but no go!

    Eight people read my first review and said this helped them make a decision about this company! I would think eight people who decided not to go with them. Imagine the money lost to them because of my review. Imagine had they just paid half my new unit cost the money they would not have lost. I don't understand a company that does not get customer service and customer satisfaction. But I do know this, the power of free speech goes a long way. This company is a ripoff and AVOID FIRST AMERICAN HOME WARRANTY AT ALL COSTS!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 18, 2018

    I've been in the banking industry for over 40 years so I knew about First American Home Warranty. I've been using them for six years for this house and eight years in my house in California. They've always done right with me and if it's necessary for me to file a claim, they make it easy. I submit my claims over the phone and they're quick to respond. The reps have been very knowledgeable and they know what department I should go to or they put in my claim the way I requested. And if it's wrong, they'd clarify it and put it in correctly because maybe I didn't know the terminology of certain things. My interaction with them has been very good. The technicians who have come out have been very good too and I haven't had any problems with the quality of their work.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 18, 2018

    We knew some people that were on the First American HB Protection plan and we got them by their recommendation. I typically file my claims online and it’s pretty easy. The technicians that they send are very professional and do their job. My experience with First American is so far, so good and I hope it stays that way. It's a quality company and they stand behind their work.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 17, 2018

    After plumber repaired water leak in pipe and left a 5 foot by 5 foot hole in my ceiling 03/16/2018, I contacted First American Home Warranty to send someone out to repair the hole at least 4 times. It's 04/17/2018 and still looking at this same hole in my ceiling, not good at all. Thanks a lot First American Home Warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 17, 2018

    I believe in home warranty and we've always had one. We are with First American and whenever our issue is covered, they handle it. We call them for claims since it's sometimes easier than submitting them online and because I want to talk to a real person. Our most recent claim was for a pool pump and it was straightforward. The pump was leaking and they fixed it. However, there has been a few times where we've had things that we thought were covered but then when we go back and look at the contract, they weren't covered. And so homeowners need to make sure that they completely understand what's covered and what's not and that what they're covering meets their requirements.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 17, 2018

    I needed something to protect my home from anything that could damage it. A friend of mine then referred me to First American Home Buyers Protection. Submitting a claim is very simple. I call them and they help me fill it out. I can also do it online. However, I do it on the phone and make sure I complete it right than being online. And it doesn't take long to get hold of a person. They come in a couple of minutes. The technicians usually make a call within a day and it depends on what direction before they get to my home. One came from Maryland and he was there in the nick of time. Other than that, they are excellent people and I feel very confident in the quality of work they do. Overall, First American has been outstanding to me and they were very helpful.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed April 16, 2018

    First American Home Buyers Protection is still working on my claim, but they are back out and they are wonderful. I like that I don't have to worry and I always have a repairman. Sometimes, I get a great agent, sometimes, however, I get a bad one. But, overall, they are good. They did not charge as much and it seems like sometimes, every year the contract goes up a little bit, but I continue to pay it because I do not want to not be without them. I have had them for 18 years and I will probably have them for another 18.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 16, 2018

    I've been using First American for about three or four years now and my latest experience with them was great. I'm a realtor and I know that systems break down. I use First American all the time. I usually submit a claim over the phone and it takes a lot of time. I recently filed a claim for a garage door spring and I had a great interaction with the technician that came out. Also, his work was excellent.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 15, 2018

    My last experience with First American went very well and things were taken care of without any issues. Their rep did an outstanding job and did it quickly. He was very good and we've had no issues in the last couple of years. I will be renewing with First American in the coming weeks.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 15, 2018

    I've been with First American for two years now. They were given to me as an option for insurance when I purchased my house. I usually file my claims online and then a day or so later, someone would contact me and tell me that they’ve appointed a contractor. The contractors come by, do the work and have been nice. Then usually, First American would call back and make sure everything was done correctly and that there’s nothing outstanding that needs to be taken care of.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPriceOnline & App

    Reviewed April 14, 2018

    First American was the home warranty company I had originally when I bought the house and have been with them for about five years now. Submitting a claim is easy as I just go online and submit it. It’s a lot better than what it used to be. Navigating their website is very simple too. The people that they use are great and they pretty much knock it out on the first go, but we’ve had a lot of stuff done and for some of the bigger jobs, they’ve had to come out a couple of times. Like when our washing machine was out, it took almost two weeks for somebody to come out from Sears, and it would have been nice to have a little more flexibility with getting someone else that can do the same job out sooner.

    From five years ago to now, however, they changed a lot of their customer service in terms of attitude, response time and follow through. Originally, it was horrible. But over the last three and a half years, they’ve done a lot better. There’s room for improvement, but overall, they do a great job. They offer good quality pricing for the services rendered and are a pretty good home warranty company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechOnline & App

    Reviewed April 14, 2018

    When we bought our house in 2008, First American was included as a home warranty for the first year that we purchased it and then we renewed every single year since then. It is an old home and we need to have some protection. We stuck with what we knew pretty much and we like First American. Also, we are satisfied with their service so we continued with them. When we've had to replace things or get things worked on, they were fair. I would recommend them if people were asking me about getting a home warranty or asking specifically about what I think of the company.

    When we were first involved with the warranty company, we submitted claims only over the phone. But now, I submit online. I'm very familiar with the computer and online and I love that part of it. It makes it a lot easier. Navigating thru their website is intuitive and easy. I've filed claims online three times and getting a tech out was fairly quick. Usually, it's within two days. But this last time was a bit longer than usual and it had to do with when the claim was filed. It was on a Thursday and so they didn’t have anybody available until the following Monday. It was the longest we've had to go, but it wasn't totally inconvenient. Moreover, I've always felt the technicians and the people that First American use were very informative and professional and they let us know what's going on. They provided various suggestions on running things more efficiently. I've always been happy with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 13, 2018

    I’m so glad our real estate agent recommended First American Home Warranty to me. We automatically signed up as soon as we bought the house. We've had them for five years now and submitting a claim has always been great. I just give them a call and they start the ball rolling. Then we communicate through email as the work progresses. They're easy to get a hold of and I wish everybody was more like them.

    The techs they've sent have all been great too. We had a problem with our washing machine last year and the guy who came was nice, friendly and very knowledgeable. The techs were also fine with the oven and knew what they were doing. Everything has been fixed and done reasonably quick--within a few days or less than a week. We had to wait the last time but that was because we went on vacation in the middle of the progress and they were going to come out the day we were leaving to go out of town, so we had to delay them. We called them up to ask if they could wait for another week, so that was on us. Overall, we've had excellent service from First American and I'd definitely recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 13, 2018

    First American has better coverage and I first heard about them through a friend. My wife takes care of submitting a claim and it's mostly done by talking with someone from First American. Their contractors usually come out quickly and the quality of their work is usually good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    teresa increased rating by 2 stars.
    Claims HandlingCoverage
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, teresa increased their star rating.

    Original Review: April 12, 2018

    Horrible experience with trying to get information on a plumbing coverage. I've spoke with a claims resolution manager who gave me unsatisfactory information. Upon investigating further more and speaking with somebody who supposedly holds a position above the mentioned supervisor, I received different information which was acceptable, however promises were made to me and were not kept. I hope the conversation was recorded for the purpose of reviewing it. I am very dissatisfied with the way this company is conducting its business.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Teresa,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed April 12, 2018

    We just bought the house and we already had First American Home Buyers Protection through the people who had the house before us. We have the coverage for six weeks now and it was easy to submit a claim to them. They were also very easy to get in touch with. We've called three times and it took one to three days for someone to come out to address the issue. The people that have come out has been very professional and we've had nothing but great experience with them. When we had an issue with the leak again, I called and the same guys came out and they were nice. They explained exactly what they did and we have not had any problems since. They have fulfilled our expectations and the quality of the work was great. We were very pleased and we were talking about continuing to use them even after it expires.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 12, 2018

    We purchased a home in Arizona and the warranty with First American was offered as part of the purchase. And after my husband died, I felt that having the warranty was awesome because I was moving to a new area where I didn't know any workman. It was a good way to be sure that I got good quality workmen and that they were safe in my home. And so I kept it up when I moved here. Also, I was forced to use the house in Arizona as a rental for a while and I kept it up on that house also, and it worked perfectly for me.

    I submit my claims by phone and I have always had excellent results. They give me a name of a company that will call me and they ask whether if it's an emergency. And most of the time, it hasn't been an emergency. But the one time that I did have an emergency because my roof was leaking, they had a person out within 24 hours. They always have someone respond to me within 24 hours. And I've always explained the problem to the technicians and it was silly sometimes and very easy to fix, but they were always very courteous. My most recent claim was for my garage door opener and the technician's work was excellent. First American is an all-around good company and I have recommended them to friends.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 11, 2018

    I like First American's price. It was better than the others and I've had them for two years now. We've only put in one or two claims, but the experience was good. We filed it online and they were prompt in getting back with us. The contractors who came told me what they were going to do and what the price would be. Everything was copacetic.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 11, 2018

    I've had problems with First American Home Warranty in the past, but this time it was fine. They did a good job. The contractor was good. They were professional and they were on time. They also cleaned up after themselves.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechOnline & App

    Reviewed April 10, 2018

    I have several rental properties and a home warranty will help me with the repairs. I looked at other home warranty providers but First American was better. I usually submit a claim online and their website is very easy to navigate. Their claim process is good and it takes 24 to 48 hours for a technician to come out. However, I get a lot of excuses from the technicians in getting them to submit their findings and the time it takes to get the parts to do the repairs. Sometimes they don’t tell First American what the problem is and what parts they need to order. Then they'd say it was a big backlog of getting parts but I’m not sure if that was true or not because sometimes it’s not that way with certain items. Other than that, I have no problem with First American. The quality and service are good and they respond back to me in a timely manner.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTechOnline & App

    Reviewed April 10, 2018

    First American was convenient and I've been covered with them for two years now. I submit claims online and it's easy to navigate their website. Usually it takes 24 to 48 hours before a contractor contacts me. They're good service people and they've all been fine. I had a couple of claims recently, one for a water leak and one was for a washer repair. It took about a week for each of them to get fixed. First American is a good solid company and my experience with them has been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 9, 2018

    I asked the seller of my home to purchase a home warranty. My inspector noted a small leak at downstairs bathroom. Once we had lived in our home for over a month, the drain slipped in the upstairs bathroom. They are using the small leak, in a different bathroom, in a different part of the house, to call this a "pre-existing condition." I even had my inspector contact them to correct them, and it didn't matter. It is all a con! They won't even let me talk to a supervisor. They put me on hold three different times for over a half hour each time and no supervisor ever came on the line! DO NOT PURCHASE A WARRANTY FROM THIS COMPANY!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Sales & MarketingRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 9, 2018

    This company has no problem collecting your premium every month, but when it comes to doing the right thing, they don’t. They have contracts with horrible unqualified companies that work with them to lowball repairs or replacement to force homeowner to pay out of pocket. It is a scam at highest level.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & SpeedOnline & App

    Reviewed April 9, 2018

    First American Home Buyers Protection was already part of my contract when I moved into the house and I've been very happy with them. In fact, I just renewed my contract with them. I’ve been pleased with their timely action to my issues and I’ve had no reason to seek out other companies. When we submit a claim, we either call or go to their website and tell them what’s wrong. And then they'd get in contact with a contractor which takes no longer than 24 hours. They’re a liaison between us and the contractor. And then we pay the contractor the $75 fee and that’s done. So far, everybody has been very helpful and knowledgeable. I had quite a few problems when I moved in and anybody that they have sent has been professional. As a homeowner, it's an important thing to have First American Home Buyers Protection. I’m lucky I have them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 9, 2018

    There were big Ziplock bags in our refrigerator's freezer and the door did not shut well because of them so everything thawed out. First American got somebody out to the house in a couple of days. The guys came over and they knew what they were doing. But the fridge actually fixed itself because I just unplugged it and it reset itself. Still, I was really pleased with the service and I'd recommend First American Home Buyers Protection.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 8, 2018

    I looked into a home warranty for the coverages that they were covering and for the positive things I saw. I did some research online and found First American. I’ve had to use them quite a few times and when I submit claims, my experience has been excellent. I file the claim online and then, they call within 24 hours, set up an appointment, come out, and evaluate it. The last time I spoke to a claims agent, they were very good and followed through very well. And the technicians have all been good. They tell you what’s wrong, give a certain amount of time they’re going to repair it, fix it, and move on. My wife handles it if it’s an appliance and she usually requests the same company to come out each time and the same thing with the pool because we had good luck with them. First American always allow us to do that, so it worked out fine and they've always taken care of me.

    I recommend First American to my clients. When people ask, I always tell them to use them. They’ve always done what they said they would do and there’s a lot of benefits to having the program. It’s like an insurance policy continually. So, I’ve continued to maintain my coverage all the way through. Also, it’s an easy process. I don’t have to go and look for a technician or a repair company for whatever I’m looking for. First American already got people that they’ve done research on and they’re quality people and not out there trying to screw somebody. That’s already taken care of so, it is worth it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 8, 2018

    My daughter said that I should have a home warranty and based on her recommendation, I went with First American. I filed a claim over the phone for a microwave that was messing up and the process wasn’t difficult at all. The reps on the phone and the technicians who came out to fix the appliance were nice. Everything was just perfect. I did recommend someone to First American. I told her about the experience I had and that she should try them because they are really nice. So, she took me at my word.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 8, 2018

    I looked into acquiring a home warranty due to the age of the house and also for protection. I file claims by phone and submitting a claim to First American Home Buyers Protection was very easy and I was very much satisfied. My interactions with their reps were fine and they were excellent. I had a recent claim for the water heater and the contractor who came over was very polite. They did their job and we had the water heater replaced. If I know somebody buying a house, I'd tell them to get First American. We would definitely recommend it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2018

    The house that I bought was and would continue to be covered by First American Home Buyers Protection. It was the seller’s choice to have the coverage. I have submitted claims and those have gone well. I generally call them and I personally prefer to talk to somebody. Also, the interactions I had with the technicians were very good. I would suggest to anyone who is inquiring that First American is beneficial because whenever we purchase products, they are warrantied for a certain time. First American will pick up the coverage once the manufacturer warranty is already expired.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2018

    I'm a real estate agent so all of my clients and I have had First American for forever. Every home that I sell or buy, I recommend First American versus others. But, I'm not satisfied. Their office is not on top of their job, and it’s not the vendors. First American doesn't take good information down. They bill you when you shouldn't be billed. They also have poor record keeping. They did this to me three times wherein they charged me. I paid the contractor and it took two months to get that straight. Also, I called about three items and the vendor only gave me one. When I told them that two of my AC's weren't working, the vendor that came told us that they could only service one because they were only told one.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2018

    First American was already with the home when I moved in about 10 years ago so I just kept it. I stayed with them because I have had great service. When I submit my claims, I used to do it on the phone but it was extremely frustrating because I like to talk to a live person and it prompts on what my issue was. Then, I say it but they go, "I'm sorry. I didn’t get that." So, that drove me crazy. The last claim I recently put in was done online and I'm seeing the contractors on Thursday. And First American's online process is good.

    The contractors who have come out have been good, very friendly, fast and efficient. But six years ago, there was a plumber that was not good. He had to go under my house and he didn't want to, but he had to, and he accidentally cut a wrong pipe. Instead of saying, "I'm sorry. I messed up," he said my pipes were breaking in his hands, and told my insurance company. So, I ended up in tears and I found out that he messed up because I had somebody else come out. I spent my own money on it. It was horrible and I already complained to the company so I haven't seen the plumber since. And It’s been a great experience with First American. One of my guests came in the other day and was going through some issues and I recommended First American and told him that I never had an issue and denial. They fixed my claim and it was easy-peasy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2018

    I wanted a warranty so that in case something went wrong, it would be convenient for me and the cost would be good. I knew someone that used First American and I liked their coverage and cost. This is the third year that I've had them and I like the convenience of having their warranty. When I submitted a claim with them, their process was very simple. The technician who came was very professional and polite. I described the problem in advance so, he was prepared with the part that I needed. He did it really quick and everything worked great. The quality of the work was excellent and I was very happy when he left.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 6, 2018

    First American Home Buyers Protection was sold by our realtor when we bought our home. We’ve had the service for eight or nine months now and we’ve filed claims before. They've been done over the phone and it takes a minute or two to get through to somebody. The first technician that was sent out to my home was okay but he never returned. Then the guy that took over the job from the first guy was very good and knowledgeable and he fixed our problem. And then the last guy we had out fixed our problem and he was great. We’re looking forward to being covered with First American for another year at least and I would recommend my friends to pick up the policy.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Luis increased rating by 2 stars.
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, Luis increased their star rating on June 20, 2018.

    Updated review: June 20, 2018

    After getting contact to new employee from First American, Ms **, things changed and while the plumbing company remained rude for the most part, Ms ** from First American did everything on her power to get repairs completed with a reason, we agreed to charge a sum of money to me for repairs and we finally had it completed and seems to work according to needs. Wile plumbing company I still have no sympathy for them I would like to change my rating for First American to 3 stars, and keep in mind that Ms ** earned them for the company, if I was rating her would give five stars. They must be proud of having an employee like her fixing other people mistakes and rudeness.

    Original Review: April 5, 2018

    Inherited First American when purchased the property, faucet in shower drips, called First American on January. They sent technician, he said need it to get a part. Never heard from him. About month and half latter contacted insurance. They said they will send a second opinion, new plumber came in. Said same. Never came back. We are in April now 4 months since claim was made of a drip in a shower faucet. Ms ** is not returning calls nor is the plumbing company and I don't know if they have an intention of ever come back to make the repairs. They not only rude but when talking to her she disconnect the call if she feel like it and when you call back she won't answer. I just left another message to her and also to the plumbing company. I don't believe they will answer, if they only give me back the money paid for the year insurance so that I could go to a honest company. Unfortunate the site does not let you give minus stars to do a fair review.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 5, 2018

    I had two repairs done with First American on the same day. The gentleman who came out to repair the springs in my garage door was very nice and very thorough. He was in and out and my garage door opens really great since then. My other claim was for my garbage disposal that just stopped working. There was no noise, and I dissected it. I know how to set the toilet and do all those kind of repairs, but I could not get my garbage disposal to work. I filed the claim and I had been out of town for a month working on business, and I came home to a very rude letter from First American telling me that because there was kind of a metal stuck inside the garbage disposal that they are not going to cover it. It was a tiny little piece of metal that looks like the backing of earrings but smaller.

    The contractor did something underneath my sink and I know it wasn't the reset button because I did that. He turned my garbage disposal on and he had this little molecule piece of metal in his hand. My garbage disposal worked fine after that but I told him, "I don't believe that you got that under my garbage disposal. I think you planted that. I think that you pushed the reset button in a certain way that I didn't know how to do it." And so he went, “Well, give me the metal or I’m gonna make up a piece of metal.” He told that to the home warranty company. I will never allow that contractor company to come into my home again. The tech was rude and arrogant.

    Now, what First American's got to have me do is have somebody come out. I have to pay the money and they'll have somebody come out and write a report on that garbage disposal. But it is working and I'm not doing that. I have had this home warranty company for 15 years since I bought my house. And the letter that they've written was very offensive enough that one of my job today and tomorrow is to see how I can switch my home warranty to a different company. They did not even call and tell me that they have excluded the garbage disposal. I'm a real estate agent and I worked at a Security Pacific Real Estate for 28 years. And I'm going to make sure every single person at my office knows not to work with First American. I will badmouth them. They don't know who they're messing with.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 5, 2018

    I have had First American for over two years now. Generally, I am happy with the company. Everything is satisfactory except when I initiate the claim. I had to speak to the recording, not to a real person, and that’s very inconvenient. I had a claim for refrigerator stuff and the technician had to come back a few times for the same problem but he was very helpful.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 4, 2018

    Submitting a claim has been quite easy. I just go online, and the interactions with First American claims reps were easy as well. It's been simple and quick too. The technicians have always been professional and got the job done within a day. And I feel very good with the quality of their work.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 4, 2018

    My experience with First American has never been a good one. Their people take forever and even if it’s a 24-hour emergency, it still takes four days. You get put on the disclaimer note that they’re only gonna get paid $75. So, they take their sweet time and don’t come out. So I don’t even want it anymore. I’ve been thinking about cancelling it because I’d rather just pay a plumber to come right away instead of waiting for four days. First American will put you on the back burner.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 3, 2018

    My microwave needs to be replaced. First American Home Warranty contracted with Sears to replace the microwave. Without my knowing, Sears had the microwave delivered to my house but I was not home as I was not aware of the delivery and I am unable to be there during the week. They made arrangements for the technician who would be installing it to pick up the microwave at the warehouse and bring it with him when he was to do the install. When the tech got to the warehouse they didn't have the microwave so his time and mine were wasted.

    FAHW has now asked Sears to re-deliver the microwave...even though I have made it clear I cannot be there to receive it and they need to have the technician pick it up. After numerous phone calls to FAHW and going over the SAME story with them they still don't seem to get it. They still say Sears is going to attempt to deliver the microwave to my house (when I am not there and cannot sign for it). The customer service at FAHW and in particular, Melanie at ext **, is horrible. This is a microwave folks...a microwave. It shouldn't take an act of God to get it installed.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Rebecca,

    We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your microwave claim. Please be advised, our records indicate your microwave was replaced and installed on April 14, 2018. We consider your claim closed.

    Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 3, 2018

    My experience with First American Home Buyers Protection has been great. I heard about them from the homeowners I was buying the house from. They gave me that year’s protection plan and when the year was about to be up, I checked into it. I didn't know about home warranties at first though. It was explained to me how it worked and I figured it would be great to have because it covers all my appliances. All I have to do is pay a service fee for a technician to come out. I googled First American and saw the rates people were giving them. First American was the best out of all the reviews so I decided to pick it up and keep it.

    I filed my claim online one time, but the other couple of times, I called them and they responded pretty quickly. I've always had a positive interaction with their reps too. Once I submit the claim, someone would call me within a day or two. Then they'll send out their techs who have been very professional. First American uses the same ones for a particular claim. For the air or heat, they use the same company then for kitchen appliances, they typically use the same company as well.

    I would recommend First American because they're very honest. Sometimes, you get something that's too good to be true but it’s not like that with First American. What they offer is what you're going to get and there's no hassle about it. I really love that about them. I don’t have to keep calling and bugging them to do something. With a lot of the other ones that I've checked into, there were a lot of complaints that they wouldn't cover things and they weren't paying in. But First American is a legit company. If a unit has gone out and it couldn't be fixed, they would replace it so it has all been positive so far with me.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 3, 2018

    Another home warranty company in the area was having some financial problems and were not taking care of the people in the way we felt they should be taken care of. I discontinued that policy and went with First American. People I knew who were satisfied with them recommended them and I’ve been with them since. Also, I'm a realtor and I do my escrows through First American. Some of my clients had them as well and were satisfied with them.

    I submit my claims over the phone and the reps are very courteous and helpful. The last claim I had, the gentleman who came explained some other features about my oven that I was not even aware of and I thought it was very helpful. And one of the most important things to me is that if something can’t be repaired, then it will be replaced. Moreover, if it isn’t the brand that I like, I have been given the choice of taking a settlement amount and purchasing my own appliance so they match the rest within my house. I'd tell friends that I've been with First American for 15 years and for the most part, I’ve been very satisfied with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 2, 2018

    When I purchased my first home, I knew that a home warranty was something that I needed to protect myself. I’ve been with First American for so long now and I’ve been submitting claims online lately, which has been okay. However, the vendors haven't been getting back to me right away, and a couple of times it’s been several days before they’d call and schedule an appointment. And I’ve had to call First American back to let them know that no one has called. Nevertheless, the technicians who have come out have been professional and helpful and have, for the most part, provided solutions to whatever issue has been going on.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 2, 2018

    When we purchased the house, First American came with it and then we renewed with them. We were first time homebuyers and we wanted to protect ourselves as much as we could. Submitting a claim with them can get a little tricky, but there's no easy way to get through. You've got to go to a switchboard and talk to an automated machine that doesn’t work well. And then by the time you get to a person, you're so frustrated. The wait times can be significant. Sometimes, there can be a language barrier in submitting a claim or information, and there's just lack of knowledge based on what's needed at the home.

    The call center could make the process of submitting a claim a little easier. In certain instances where we live, heat becomes a major issue starting about three or four weeks from now until November and it's not an easy problem. It's something that needs to be addressed quickly. I went about it a couple of times where I needed it addressed and sometimes, it was tough to get to people. But we've had pretty good successful interactions with the techs who come out here. There has been a couple of instances where we felt that the technician came out and just put a band-aid on a bigger problem just to get paid. But at the end of the day, we got what was wrong fixed. For the most part, they've been okay. But overall, our experience has been good and I appreciate their service. We've saved a lot of money using First American Home Warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 1, 2018

    When we bought our house, First American Home Warranty was included in the purchase. We had had a different program at our previous house and we were fine with it, but First American seem to cover the same thing with a little bit less deductible so we thought of keeping First American. We usually submit a claim online and it's easy navigating their site. All the technicians we've had did an excellent job. They were professional and did their job quickly. But one time, First American had some other issues in a particular week and it took them quite awhile to get the claims resolved. Other than that, they usually get to us within two business days. They also seem to have reasonable prices and we used them all the time so we've got our money's worth.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 1, 2018

    Our experience with First American has been a hit or miss. We have a pool and there's a lot of limitations on what is or is not covered, then half of the stuff that goes on with it is never covered. Also, we had some items which we had them repair repeatedly because the repair doesn’t really stick. For example, I had an oven door that kept falling off. The first two times, they sent the same person out and he wasn’t sure what the replacement part was going to be. It wasn’t until the third time that I finally required they send a different vendor, and that vendor was more proactive in trying to find a more permanent solution as well as the replacement part that was needed and then replace it.

    The reps have been very helpful, though. When I brought up this situation with our oven door, they understood and tried to reorder our calls so that we had a couple of tickets and that was most beneficial for us from a cost perspective. They looked for solutions and it didn’t just go through the motion. I would recommend First American. However, I have friends that ask who we have and I tell them. I also say the same things about how it's hit or miss on what's covered for our pool. That's one area where we will start looking at other home warranties for. The pool is the one reason we're buying a home warranty, and with so much of it not covered, I'm starting to question the value.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed March 31, 2018

    I've had a warranty with Fidelity before so I always had a warranty on my properties. My wife knows one of the escrow officers at First American and we decided to switch because she recommended it. This is my second year with them and right now, I have a garage door claim. They came, fixed it, and charged me a ton of money. Then the garage door had problems again last week and I still can't get anybody to come out to fix it. It has been a pretty poor experience. My experience with Fidelity was much better and I've considered moving back because of the service I get with the contractor and how long it takes for them to come out.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 31, 2018

    Whenever I submit a claim to First American, I do it over the phone and they take care of it. Their claims reps are very professional. They put me in touch with someone who would take care of the issue and they gave me a telephone number to call the contractor if I wasn't called within 24 hours. But generally, the technicians come out the next day and I've had no problems at all. They were very professional too. They did what they were supposed to do and were out in no time. I’ve been very satisfied with First American and they've served us well.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 31, 2018

    I like First American Home Buyers Protection. I have had them for a number of years now. When I had some problem with my electricity, I went right there and paid. Without the contract, I could not afford it. With this right here, I know what I’m paying, and I know what they are going to do for me. In submitting a claim, in two or three days, either they will call me and say, “We can get you on this day.” If they cannot give it, they will call back and say, “Well, we can’t get you now. Something came up.” So, that’s fine. The techs they sent out were nice and polite, too.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 30, 2018

    This warranty came with our house so we had no choice but to use it, our heater broke and they sent a technician out. The technician diagnosed the problem and everything seemed fine, until he started complaining that he was too busy to order the part and didn't have anyone in the office, I thought that was strange but no worries, a week went by and he did nothing... Then when he finally did order the part we find out it was back ordered. Two weeks later I call just to get an update in and tell me the parts in. Meanwhile the technician tells me they didn't approve the order for the part and he would have to put a band-aid, never came.

    So I finally get them to communicate and they figure out the part is approved and it's on its way... it's actually not here yet so couple more weeks go by. The part finally gets here, and guess what.. The technician is too busy to install it and claims he has other jobs to do, that's fine for a couple days but for weeks now, and now that our heater has been broken two months you think they would make a special circumstances. It's kind of important when you live in the Sierra ** mountains.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 30, 2018

    I decided to get a home warranty for protection and First American was recommended by friends. Whenever I submit a claim to them, the process is easy and they are generally very responsive and good. I've submitted claims to them both online and over the phone, and their reps were courteous and professional. The technicians who have come out to our home were generally very qualified people. We talk to them and they provide good professional advice. First American is a good company and a good service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechOnline & App

    Reviewed March 29, 2018

    My unknowingness of the new home I was buying led me to get a home warranty with First American HB Protection. Their website was easy to use and submitting claims online had been seamless. Then I would get a call from a contractor the next day, so it was very effective. But, there had been times where the contractors didn’t fix the original problem because they got feedback from First American that they would not cover it even though it was associated with the initial problem that was covered.

    Our pool pump system is all-inclusive. In the contract, the pool controller was covered but it was also clearly stated that a board component in the control system was not covered. But since my pool controller is integrated with that component into one piece, then everything was not covered and I couldn’t get anything fixed. I still have some issues now that I've given up after them coming back five times for the small leak in my pool pump. There was a point in time where I felt that First American was not worth it with what I paid for a year and the amount of hassle that I had to go through to get something fixed. But for the most part, I'm happy and I keep up and redoing my home warranty with them every year.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed March 29, 2018

    When I bought my house, the warranty company that I had wanted $300 a month for 15 months. I asked my mom through a friend that goes through First American Home Warranty and she said that they are really good. They're also way affordable, and the people are very professional and get the job done right the first time. Submitting a claim was super easy. I did it online and I got it done within 10 minutes. The techs normally get out here in about two days and they are professional and courteous. First American is a great value.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Profile pic of the author.
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 28, 2018

    I've have had a policy with First American for 4.5 yrs, the first couple of times I was satisfied with the outcome of my issues. 2 weeks ago my water heater had a major meltdown, it took 2 days for anyone to get back to me. They only have one plumber that will service my area, an elderly man over an hr away. It took a week to get a new water heater only to find out the vents don't match up, he was told they would cover the part but it had to be ordered.

    Days later I get a call that upon review the vent is not covered and that will be a $400+ out of pocket on my end, when I call customer service I was put on hold with the call center in Costa Rica for a half an hr only to be answered with a person I could barely understand trying to read me the contract where it says they don't cover that. So here I am 2 weeks later still waiting for hot water. If you are looking to do business with a company with integrity that will do the right thing, these are not your guys. The last 3 times I have called them they have found some small print to get out of completing a claim. That's it for me.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 28, 2018

    If something breaks, the home warranty company would fix it. I got a policy with First American and I paid for it a few times for a year, but they're not that good. My contract with them says that they would fix my stove, my refrigerator, and my dishwasher. But when I called them to come and fix my refrigerator, they said they wouldn't do it. The ice button at the bottom of the front panel was broken and when the contractor came over, he wanted to take the $75 from me even if he didn’t do anything. He only offered to see if they would work on that then later, he called me and said they wouldn't work on it. So I don't know what's the use of having First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Conrad,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Ryan increased rating by 1 star.
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts
    After a positive interaction with First American Home Warranty, Ryan increased their star rating on April 2, 2018.

    Updated review: April 2, 2018

    AFTER our review the company offered a replacement or cash payment. Of course it won't cover 1/2 the cost of an actual decent model fridge... but its better than nothing. Its unfortunate that we have to get nasty online in order to have issues resolved.

    I will say thank you for actually following through, but I still wouldn't recommend anyone paying for a home warranty. We learned our lesson.

    Original Review: March 27, 2018

    We have paid for 2 years of home warranty after purchasing our home in 2016. Our total amount paid is right around $1000. We have submitted 3 claims because of our refrigerator and the process has been a nightmare. I understand it's the business model of these insurance providers to NOT pay out and to string people along so we just get tired, and annoyed and frustrated. I get that you send people who can barely speak English, who are constantly late, or just don't show up. I understand that your business hours are 9-5 even though everyone in the real world lives and operates their homes outside business hours. I get it... I'm in business too and if I treated my clients the way you and your 'preferred' vendors treated us, I'd be out of business.

    We were out a working refrigerator for 6 weeks. The latest guy they sent out was late, rude and couldn't communicate. He supposedly fixed the problem in about 15 minutes. He told me not to turn on the ice maker for about an hour (long enough for him to get out of there) and didn't leave us any paperwork, just the trash on the counter and none of the fridge items put back. The Ice maker makes ice, but doesn't dispense it. The next day water was pouring out our fridge because he loosened the water supply line and didn't fix it. Calling AHW yields absolutely nothing. They pretend to be interested but don't do anything. I can't get all the time back that my wife and I wasted, but I should get my money back. This company is not worth the money. Don't by a warranty, fix it yourself or pay a reputable appliance repair shop and skip the nonsense with AHW.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedOnline & App

    Reviewed March 27, 2018

    First American Home Warranty was suggested by my real estate agent when I bought my house. I fill out a form on their website when submitting a claim and it is fairly easy. I would get a confirmation within 24 hours from them but it varies with the repair technicians. I have submitted about three claims and in one case, I heard from the tech in less than 24 hours. It was about a couple of days with another one and the other one was a week and I had to do a follow up.

    We had an appliance technician do the repair on the stove that took a follow-up because there were parts. However, they were very professional, they came in generally on time and got the job completed. The pool one ended up not being an issue. They were able to go when I wasn't there and they were quick about it. The electrical one was a little bit disappointing because I specifically put in the notes what the problem was. But when they got there, the electrician said that it was not covered by the warranty. I was a little disappointed that First American Home Warranty didn't stop that on the front end so I wasted 75 bucks there.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 27, 2018

    We went with this other company when we bought the house four years ago. But they totally sucked and it was like we didn't have any coverage, so I wasn't sure what we were paying a yearly fee for, being that everything we did seemed to cost money and they didn’t cover anything. When it came time to renew, we started shopping around. I worked in the mortgage industry and I knew First American was a big thing and seemed to be a trusted name. We switched to them and we've been utilizing them for three years now. I usually submit a claim online which is easy to do. Then, the contractor calls within a day or two and makes an appointment, which is always within a reasonable timeframe. So far, the techs who came out have been courteous, polite and professional. They got the approval needed, did whatever was needed to be done in a timely manner, and the quality of their work has been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 26, 2018

    Absolutely terrible experience, had a claim that wasn't covered, paid for it out of pocket. I asked for just a little common courtesy on the claim. The plumber said he isn't certified to diagnose the problem being that it was a septic system, but tells them his diagnosis is that the septic system needs to be pumped. I have a seller disclosure documenting the system being pumped last year. All I asked is that they send the septic guy and if it's not covered at that point then I would pay, I then try to add said missing coverage and was told that I couldn't add coverage while there is an outstanding issue. I now call back and said I am now outside the 60 day time period by 8 days. I felt disrespected and taken advantage of in the nicest way possible of telling them no we will not help you. I always have home warranties and I will gladly be paying American Home Shield for coverage next year.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Steve,

    We dispatched two independent contractor's, K and G Services and Vintage Plumbing Services LLC who reported your septic tank needed to be pumped. Upon review, you did not purchase the optional coverage for septic tank pumping/system. Subsequently, septic tank pumping is not covered under your home warranty contract. First American considers this claim closed.

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 26, 2018

    On my first experience with First American, they were very reliable and they provided the services that I needed. But my most recent interaction with their technician was not as good. The process with that particular contractor was a little bit frustrating. They booked three appointments and it created a lot of confusion and difficulty on my schedule. That mistake could have been avoided if they were a little bit more professional in gathering the right information on the part that needed to be repaired. But overall I'm satisfied and I'm relieved that I was able to get the part repaired. First American is a great service for your basic unpredictable needs and I would certainly recommend it. Their pricing is reasonable and it's also convenient online when you can interact and open a claim electronically if needed.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 25, 2018

    I'm a homeowner and I figured that at some point if certain appliances would break down, I would need some extra protection. I first had American Home Shield and when I put in a claim with them, it seemed like they didn't want to cooperate or live up to what they promised to do on the claim. So, when my renewal came up, I decided to go and stay with another company. My interaction with the reps at First American is pretty good other than the fact that when I call, somebody's foreign and I can't understand what they're saying. I usually submit claims over the phone and at times the process is a little redundant and hectic. Overall, it's okay, but it could be better. A technician normally takes a day or so to get out to me and does a good job coming in and making a friendly, easy conversation.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed March 25, 2018

    First American Home Warranty was the company that the realtor suggested we get a homeowners warranty with. We've had two different people then - one was an electrician and then we had a heating and air person come out. They were very nice and professional. They called and notified me when they'd be here so I'd give them a time frame. The quality of their work seemed to be fine and I was very pleased.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 24, 2018

    We had had two appliances that we tried to get fixed at the same time so we had two claims back-to-back with First American and one of them went much easier than the other. I've submitted claims a few different ways and doing it online works out better because I've done it verbally and it was a little slower. With the online way, I got my log-in and everything set up so when I put in the claim, the tech came right out the next day. Everything was completely fine and that was wonderful.

    However, we had a horrible experience on our first claim. I have two boys and we use the microwave all the time, but the claim for it dragged on for about three weeks before we got a resolution. First American told me that there were no techs in the area. I live 10 miles south of Houston and I find it very hard to believe that they can't find someone to work on my microwave in a whole greater area of Houston. They told me that I needed to find a technician to come to my house. I told them it was not my problem to find a tech and they needed to figure it out. It was what I was paying them to do. I also told them that I would give them a few days then I'd call back in.

    First American told me that they were going to note the problem and they'll have a manager call me back, but they didn't call me back. So when I called them the sixth time, I told them I've been waiting for three days for a manager to call me back and that I wasn’t hanging up until they get someone on the phone. Within five minutes, a manager got on the phone and the very next day, I had someone at my house. It was ridiculous that it took three weeks and six calls for that. After the third week of being without a microwave, I could've probably made a phone call and found someone.

    The vendors have been fine and the technicians have been wonderful. The quality of their work was great. The technician who came for the microwave had fixed the issue within a few minutes. There was some little catch on the inside of the door but it was a minor fix. The problem that we had was with the First American side. I had one experience where everything was awful and then the last experience was fine, so it depends. I'm sure that all businesses are that way, having successes and some things that are not so successful. So, I would still recommend First American HB Protection. And we're going to keep the warranty but we don't like being treated poorly.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 23, 2018

    I was a customer for almost 10 years. In that time the service technicians went from bad to worse. I have been accidentally paying for 2 warranties since 11/17. They refused to refund my payments and seemed happy that I was getting taken advantage of by them. I will be filing a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance and disputing the charges on my card. I had 3 technicians for 1 heater problem in one month. The same problem had been happening every year for 4 years but finally seems resolved. The customer service is awful and they send no name “companies” to “fix” your issue. It’s my own fault for not finding a new company years ago. Don’t be fooled by a Realtor who recommends this company. Buyer beware. There are other and much better options for the same price with no runaround. Good riddance First American.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 23, 2018

    I have had First American Home Buyers Protection for years. My husband had it when he was with real estate and we just kept it after he retired. Recently, I had trouble with my water heater and my sink faucet was leaking. And then, I wanted them to check my commode. So they sent this plumbing company that I've never heard of, and their plumber fixed the sink but it has a little hole that comes up from it. As a result, I can't use it since it leaks around it. What I needed is a new faucet because ours is 26 years old and it's been there ever since we built this house. Then my commode is only five years old. When it fills back up with water, it makes this horrible squeaking sound.

    The plumber said he fixed it. It flushed twice okay, and then he's gone. But it still wasn't right. And then someone went into my garage and checked my water heater. He came back and told me that the pilot light is on and that is all. As far as I know, they didn't do one thing to the water heater. I feel there's not enough hot water. All in all, they didn't fix the water heater, they didn’t fix the commode, and they didn’t fix the sink. I have just been so aggravated, I didn't want to get into it with First American.

    Additionally, I had trouble last summer when my air conditioner acted up and they sent this guy who had to come back three times. Sometimes, my air conditioner would be off for a day or two and then all of a sudden, it might come back on. I kept telling the technician but whenever he gets here, it would be on. He told me he can't do anything since he can't see what's wrong with it when it comes back on. The last time he was here, he said he changed some of the wirings to it. It was okay the rest of the summer.

    Lastly, I had trouble with my heating system. It went out on the coldest day of the year, on New Year's Eve. I called Sunday, but they couldn't get anybody to call back and make an appointment until Tuesday because Monday was a holiday. That aggravated me so I just called the local people and I ended up having to pay $800 myself. I swore up and down that I was going to discontinue but I don’t feel I can because I might need them. Still, I would recommend First American Home Buyers even when the people they send maybe two hours away and that there aren't local contractors that work for them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed March 22, 2018

    We’ve subscribed to First American for over three years now and we haven't had any issues with them coming out and handling our claims in an efficient time. I could call them or file a claim online and they're handled it fast and easy. Their customer service reps have all been helpful, happy and easy to talk to. The technician who came most recently was a friendly guy, knowledgeable, and explained to me what he was going fix and how he’s going to fix it. All of the technicians who came have been efficient, clean and left the house clean in the same way they came in the house. The quality of the work they performed has been good overall and I haven't had anybody back to fix any issues that have been fixed.

    However, last year I had a guy come and fix my microwave for me. And the microwave cosmetically was chipping on the inside and some other stuff so he recommended that we get a new microwave or have somebody come out and send it down to repaint and fix it. He mentioned that although it would be a separate claim, it was definitely fixable. And so, I waited and called back. I told them what the issue was and they sent somebody out to fix it. But when the guy came out, he said that he it’s cosmetic and he can’t fix it. It cost me $65 to have somebody tell me that they couldn’t fix it when the person that made the claim for me, the claims analyst, could’ve told me that themselves.

    That time, I wasn’t happy with their answer that it clearly states about claims if I look at the contract. I looked at the contract and told them, “Well, you’re 100% right. And I didn’t read the contract all the way through and nobody does. It’s not my responsibility. But on the flipside of it, your claims analyst should know the contract inside and out better than myself. When I clearly stated it’s cosmetic, why would they set up the appointment? ‘Cause that should’ve been told at that point.” And they were like, “Yeah. You’re probably right. But still, at the end of the day we don’t cover it.” I wasn’t trying to get a freebie, but they could’ve handled it a little differently. That was the only issue I ever had with them the whole time. Overall, First American Home Warranty has been good and I’d recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPrice

    Reviewed March 21, 2018

    The guy whom I bought my home from included First American Home Warranty with the purchase and he paid for the first year. The first year was really good but when I renewed the contract the second year, the price went up and the service dropped. I have two refrigerators wherein one is not freezing and the other one is making a noise. I got two calls in now on those two and it has been a month but no one has still called or assigned the repair to anyone. I reached out to First American and I found out who the contractor was and called him. He said that he's going to call me back but I haven't heard back from him at all. Also, one of the refrigerators have been fixed before and during that time, it took them about five months to get it fixed. I called back since it's broken again, but because it's past 90 days long since the repair and the guarantee only works for 90 days, they told me I have to pay the service agreement again.

    But, mostly their contractors would come out. When I submit a claim, I'd usually go online and First American would file it to a contractor. They'd shoot me an email and let me know if they've assigned it to a contractor to do the work. First American prefers that you submit the claims online. If you call them, they will ask you to come online. It was rare that I spoke with their reps but when I get to talk to them, the interactions have been good. The contractors would then do the job and I'd pay them and I'd pay the co-pay. But I'm not going to renew my warranty with First American and I wouldn't recommend them to anybody.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPrice

    Reviewed March 20, 2018

    I opened my refrigerator and the interior was warm. I checked the freezer and food was thawed. Called First American Home Warranty and they scheduled an appt w/ SEARS. To make a long story short there were 4 visits - 1st visit (6 Feb 18). SEARS changed the thermostat. 2nd visit SEARS came out and changed the starter. I requested another company (which will be the 3rd visit) because SEARS first available appt was a week later. 3rd visit - A contractor came out and stated I needed a seal/compressor. Contacted First American and they made an appt with SEARS for seal/compressor. 4th visit - the SEARS contractor could not guarantee that the seal/compressor will do the trick.

    It was at this time the contractor called First American to let them know that this may not be fixed with the compressor. First American is not factoring in the amount of time the customer is without a refrigerator, food spoilage (2x) and the runaround with customer service and claims dept. First American said I did not have enough in receipts/invoices to include compressor amount that warrants a replacement offer. Come to find out First American does not follow up with the contractors they send out and it's a good thing I had receipts and a photo snapshot of an invoice to include in my email to them. The day after I sent the email w/ attachments I received two phone messages stating that the item was fixed and that the order will be closed out.

    Needless to say they were many more follow-up calls to no avail. Then I receive an email offering a replacement. They are offering a refrigerator that is not comparable to what I have now. They are offering a standard fridge. I have a 3 drawers (deli, humidity control crisper, and temperature control meats) and shelves that slide out to name a few... And let's not discuss cubic feet. I had to do my own research and provided First American with the information to include the manual that has the specs. I went to SEARS to pick out a model that is comparable with mine (the item I chose is being discontinued and is on sale) and it's still not enough for First American because of the receipts which is how they do their cost comparison.

    The refrigerator I am requesting is not an upgrade but is the closest to what I have now when it was in working condition. I do not have a basic First American contract. I pay additional money to have the upgrade package in my contract. First American wants your money and is not concerned about work ethic, nor are they concerned about the runaround and numerous calls made. I am still waiting for First American to review documents I sent to them. It is now going on 42 days...

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 20, 2018

    Since I can't do a lot of things around the house, getting a home warranty was the best way to go. First American has been okay compared to a lot of other providers. I'd usually call in when I have to submit a claim because I hate being on the computer. I'd get the claim going, then I'd also get the number of the people that they were contracting with to do the work and call them. The reps I've spoken with were very courteous and professional. The technicians they've sent out have been fine too. You get a different company or person every time when somebody has to come out. With that, it's a hit or miss. Last year, a person came out for a leak in my kitchen sink. He replaced one of the piping underneath the sink but he cut it too short and it was leaking. The piping had a wiggle room. So about three weeks ago, I had to call somebody to come out and that's what I was told--it was a smidge too short.

    Also, you have to read the fine print in your contract because even though it's your house and they say this is covered, it's such a nitpicky thing as to what they cover and what they don’t cover. For instance, I had an issue with the icemaker on my refrigerator door. I called this number and they told me, "Oh, we don’t have anybody that was contracted for, so call out First American." But what I did was I took things apart and got things working, so I didn't even have to call them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & SpeedOnline & AppRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 19, 2018

    I've had First American Home Warranty for 3 years. They were great for responding quickly to failed plumbing and appliance problems in this previous rental property. This year, however, my gas wall furnace quit working and the repairman condemned it as unsafe. Rather than get the bottom of the line wall heater offered by the home warranty, I decided to take a reimbursement check and upgrade. I cannot afford to replace the heater right away and I am saving for a gas heater, but in the meantime, I was told that the warranty would be suspended until I replace the heater. During this time, they have continued to withdraw my monthly payment from my bank account even though they are covering nothing.

    I just tried to call them to get reimbursed for the payments during the months I have not been covered. I got transferred four times to four different departments. Nobody could answer my request and the fourth transfer, they just cut off my call. Now, I'm going to request that they simply cancel my contract and hope they will do this. The only way to cancel the contract is to email them. There is nothing on their website to cancel the contract and nobody will do this on the phone. I think they may have 3-4 people sitting on the phone just transferring calls between each other and when it comes full circle, they hang up on you. Overall, I have to say, they did a good job covering problems, but good luck trying to get out of your contract or get money back from them!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 19, 2018

    I've been pleased with First American. I've heard a lot of nightmare stories about home warranty companies and so far, First American has been a good company. I've been with them for a little over a year. Submitting a claim has been very smooth and really easy. I've done most of it on their online portal and I'd normally get a call from the company within a couple of hours, then the contractor who would be coming would be in touch within 24 hours.

    Every contractor they've sent has been great, has treated us well and hasn't taken advantage of us. Also, I've been pleased with their work. Almost every time, the contractor has resolved what was going on except for one instance when I didn't understand the issue I was having and we needed a different type of contractor from the one they sent. First American has saved me money especially during the first year we had the warranty when it was part of our house purchase and we didn't pay for it. Now, since we've renewed it, it won't save me as much money, but it's been a worthwhile thing for us.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 18, 2018

    When I bought my condo about eight years ago, a friend of mine recommended First American so I proceeded with them for the value of peace of mind. I'd call them personally to submit a claim then they'd take my information, and it has been a very easy, seamless and hassle-free process. The reps have been also very attentive and they've listened to what I was saying. They've been very accommodating too. If the time works for the contractor, then I'd schedule the work. Also, the technicians that they sent have always been good. They've always fixed the problem and I've never had to have them come back and fix anything else so I'm very pleased with the work they've done.

    The only thing with First American is they'd give a window of time when they're going to come out and sometimes it could be as much as four hours. I wish they had a lesser timeframe like a two-hour window because that would help me better plan my day. Other than that, I'm very satisfied with how good this company is.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechSales & MarketingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 16, 2018

    I am a realtor and wanted to give this company a chance on my personal home. My heating/ac quit working 3/11/18. Called to file claim... Hung up on after inputting all the info. Went to online site to enter info. Completed this 3/11. Worried, I called 3/12...they have "no record, perhaps there is a glitch in the system (their words)". It is now FIVE days later. They haven't ordered parts yet in spite of almost daily calls from me. 85 degrees. Last comment was that they will TRY to ship parts to the contractor in about ANOTHER FIVE DAYS!! One more phone call trying to get a cash out to get it repaired myself...response, "We don't know how much the parts are because we can't find them so we can't give you a cash out price to repair it yourself either." Funny, my repair contractor knows EXACTLY how much the parts are and can get them for me immediately. WHAT A SCAM THIS COMPANY IS!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 16, 2018

    I was with American Home Shield but I was very unhappy with them because getting them to do the right thing was like pulling teeth. When First American contacted me at a good time so I gave it a shot and made the switch. When I submit a claim to them, it seems to be a smooth transaction. I make a phone call, get a claim number and the contractor that they assigned calls me. The claims reps that I dealt with were fine and professional. I'm pretty in tune with the procedures because I've been with them for a while and I know what to expect when I call. The contractors that they sent were good and very friendly. However, I got a problem with one right now and apparently, they don’t back up their work.

    I had a plumber come out four months ago to fix a leak under my sink. A few weeks later, it started leaking again at the very same spot. I called First American. The fellow that I talked to told me that I needed to talk to the contractor because it was a workmanship warranty issue. But when I called them and told them that their repair didn't work, they said, “Sorry. We only guarantee our work for three months” and I was not happy with them so I’m going to have to file a new claim and specifically request that they don’t send those clowns out again. Other than that, I’ve been recommending First American. I bought and live in an old, two-story farmhouse. It’s 95 years old and a beautiful old home. But some of the appliances and some of the things that came with it are old too, and it was a perfect candidate for this type of a service. $70 a month for the warranty is a lot. However, it was a great deal and they seem to be doing their job.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Price

    Reviewed March 16, 2018

    Only downfall so far is we needed our dishwasher repaired. Bad seal, gasket, floater, broken silverware holder etc. The option we pay for, in the book says all parts covered. Well what do you know they wanted to charge $44 to get a new one. If it says “all parts covered” then cover it, that’s what we pay for every month on top of the $95 service call fee now.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 15, 2018

    March 6, we unplugged our fridge, filed an online claim for our fridge, it was freezing everything in the fresh food compartment. Mar. 7, claim was processed by First American, technician was contacted and date scheduled to come out. Mar. 9, we plugged in fridge so it would be on and cold when the tech showed up. Tech arrived on time, wanted service fee payment before starting work, we paid by check. Discussed details with Tech, showed him the temp gauge in fridge, 4-5 degrees below control panel temp. Tech said he needed to order parts and re-schedule a time to come back out with parts to fix problem. Stated on his invoice fridge worked fine and left the fridge plugged in.

    Mar. 12, we opened up fridge to check on it, it was below 20 degrees, frozen and had now fractured the water filter tank. We unplugged the fridge and had to install a water shut off valve to the water supply line. Mar. 12, we called the Tech Co., no one answered, we left a detailed message, what had happened, new damage and asked for a callback, No call, no follow up, nothing. Mar. 13, we called the Tech Co. again, talked with them, they had no parts listed as on order, no noted they were to reschedule a follow up visit to finish the repair work. I discussed details in person with them and noted that our water filter tank was now damaged due to the Tech leaving the fridge plugged in. They committed to call us back with an update, no call, no follow up, nothing.

    Mar. 13, we called First American. Told them what was happening, the problems with fridge, damaged water filter tank and that we called the Tech Co. Also told them the Tech Co. had no parts, no plan to come back out and no plan to call us back, No call, No follow up, Nothing. First American put us on hold while they would call the Tech Co, no one there so First American said they would follow up and have a supervisor call me back as requested, No call, No follow up, Nothing from First American.

    Mar. 14, we called First American again. Talked with another Rep, he said there was no record of our discussion with them the day prior. Told this Rep everything, more helpful, tried calling Tech Co., no one there again. This Rep said he would follow up, reschedule a visit from the Tech Co., validate they had parts on order and have this claim assigned to a claims Rep. We were offered a $75 credit to rent or purchase another fridge to use. Rep said that a claims Rep would follow up within 24 hrs., No call, No follow up, Nothing.

    Mar. 15, we received two (2) emails today. First email stated they had three (3) parts on order as of this day. Second email stated that First American would review our claim and get back with us in 1-3 business days. REALLY? I called First American again, talked with another Rep and asked to speak with a Supervisor. The Supervisor reviewed our claim, I informed him of the significant amount of time that had transpired since we filed our claim. We again discussed details with the Supervisor, problem with fridge, new damage to our fridge. We were told that NO claims Rep was assigned to our claim, as such, no one would be calling up back as committed.

    The supervisor said he would assign our claim to a claims Rep and stated again they would call us back. Said he could not take our word the water filter tanks was now damaged and needed the Tech Co. to come back out, verify the damage and order parts. We were again offered $75 dollars to rent or buy another fridge, really, the delivery and pick up charge for a rental would cost close to $75, not including the minimum lease of 30 days they wanted. Parts should be on order, however, no eta for parts, no eta for when the Tech Co. will come back out to verify the newly damaged part, no working fridge (using our neighbor's garage fridge for now). No call backs, No follow up from anyone, Nothing unless we call, NO END IN SIGHT! We may have overlooked some details, however, this represents the issue, ongoing frustration and total inability to resolve this issue within any reasonable amount of time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 15, 2018

    I’ve had a warranty with this company since I bought my home in 08. They have been a great company until a couple of years ago. Over the last few years I’ve had a few claims and each claim it takes a couple of days for the vendor to call and then a few days to get my problem fixed. Every claim in the past few years I’ve had to pay significant out of pocket expenses. Furnace was $700 out of pocket not including the service fee. This week water heater went out and I have to pay $690 out of pocket not including the service fee. The point of having a home warranty is to avoid large amounts of expenses and I will not use this company anymore.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 15, 2018

    We have had this for one year. The refrigerator started to freeze the food. They sent out a repair guy and he said the fridge was a poor design and that it did that if things were too close to a wall near the freezer. It had worked fine up until then. They closed the case. We called back and they sent out another company. The tech told us that a damper door was not functioning and would order a part. When we called to find out about the repair they said it had been denied and that everything was working properly, but that it was set too low. He reset it, but it kept freezing things. They closed the case again. I called and they said they would send someone out to rediagnose it. It is frustrating that everything is handled from Guatemala or the Dominican Republic. I actually called the renewal line and got someone from Arizona. I told her my frustrations and she forwarded me to the Dominican Republic.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 13, 2018

    I switched over to First American from the warranty company that came with the house. I always submit my claims with First American online and it is a very simple and easy process. And I usually get technicians quickly. I’ve had very good experience with them and always been satisfied. They do a good job. First American tends to send the same technicians that they sent before, which I like a lot. Having First American is worth it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback Gilmer!

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 13, 2018

    I was told that First American HB Protection had great service and so far, I’ve been satisfied with them. It’s been a couple of years now since we got them and our experience in submitting our claim was very good. We did it over the phone and the rep was good. The last technician was from Sears and he was here within two days. He told me what he was doing but the job that he did was not the correct function. They’re currently backed up so they couldn't repair the issue. Nevertheless, First American is a very good company and I have recommended them. Having a warranty is very important because things would just come up and the warranty will cover that.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    We appreciate your continued business Gary!

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 12, 2018

    When we bought our house, our agent gave us a stack of different warranty companies. We went through that and it appeared that First American HB Protection had the best consumer report type reviews and their price was good. So we went with them and we just renewed in July. We live in Alaska and we are not there at the house all the time. So for us, the warranty is very important because we don’t know the vendors too much and we could count on whoever First American called to repair something.

    So far, we did two claims last year and one claim this year, and when we called to submit our claims, their reps were very professional and perfect. All of the techs who came out were very good as well. They made appointments, came when they said they would come out, and introduced themselves when they arrived. They identified the problem, fixed what they could, and I’ve been pleased with all of it. As for the price, First American did what other companies do. After they got us in, we kept on paying the same rate and they gave the best price for the warranty only to the new people. I would like them to appreciate my business more since I've been hanging in there with them but they're not unique.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Thank you for your review Ruth!

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed March 12, 2018

    When I file for claims with First American Home Warranty I do it over the phone and the claims reps I was able to talk to were adequate. And the technicians have been professional and timely mostly. They have done what they're supposed to do. However, the overall claim process is terrible. First American has a lot of fine prints to try to not cover anything. It's an awful and horrible business. It's not worth the money and I feel completely misled. I dislike them strongly.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Jessica,

    We would like to apologize for your negative experience with our company. We have a high standard for customer service and your experience should never have been an exception. We will utilize the information you provided as learning opportunities and growth as a company. If you have any questions regarding coverage please feel free to contact us as we would greatly appreciate the opportunity to discuss this further with you.

    Verified purchase
    TechPrice

    Reviewed March 11, 2018

    First American Home Warranty does not stand behind the service providers and contractors they send out to their customers. After 30 days they want to charge another $70 fee even if it is for the same issue that was not fixed on the first service request. I would not recommend nor would I ever use them again!!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Brenda,

    We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.

    Thank you.

    Insufficient response received
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 11, 2018

    We had this company purchased when we bought our house, they were recommended by the realtor, so we asked the sellers to purchase it as part of the contract. They were really good up until we wanted to renew our contract with them. They stated that it could not be renewed but couldn’t give us a reason why. They have something in their contract that states It’s up their sole discretion if they choose to renew your contract? We always paid our contractors on time and never had any issues with the company but they couldn’t give us a reason why they wouldn’t renew our contract?

    They also state that you are suppose to receive new information with new pricing for a contract renewal. We never received this as well. We really wanted to keep this company but they didn’t want to renew our contract. I would highly recommend that no one go with First American Home Warranty. I would also recommend that you do your research before going with a Warranty company. My husband hurt his back overseas and he can’t do anything with the way his back is. That’s part of the reason why we wanted to keep them but they didn’t want to renew our contract. This is not First American Home Warranty more like Not American Home Warranty. Don’t use this company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 11, 2018

    I've been First American's customer for seven years. It was something that came when I bought the house. I just renew the warranty and it has worked okay, in general. But sometimes, the contractors that they dispatch are not high quality. There have been times where I have not accepted the job and I have to call again and they send another person. It takes a long time for them to recognize that the contractor is not knowledgeable. I have higher end appliances and most of them are new. Not all the contractors are versed in repairing or doing things the way I expect.

    There is one claim for my dryer that I have not been able to finalize with them yet. It is one of those high-end dryers from LG. Two technicians came and they didn’t really know how to fix it. They ended up calling the 800 number for LG and they went by the instruction manual. However, the issue was still happening even though they did everything that the manual said. When someone is experienced with those machines, they usually know what's going on. I ended up speaking with someone in First American. They wanted to send the first technician to my house again but I told them that I don’t want that technician because he couldn't fix it the first time. They should find a technician that is versed in my machine instead of sending the first technician.

    The lady told me to find the contractor that I want and then they'll reimburse me. That was a bummer because I was expecting for First American to take care of that instead of me having to do the all leg work. I'm a busy person so I cannot do it. It seems that they have a process. Once they send Company A, if the thing doesn’t get resolved, they have to send Company A again and again until it gets fixed. However, that didn’t work for me. I don’t love First American. It's not necessarily the best experience ever, but I'm not looking to cancel.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 11, 2018

    I had a good experience submitting a claim to First American. I either do it online or I call the 800 number. For the most part, the technicians they sent are okay. Though, I had a bad experience a few years ago with the guy who redid our hot water heater. He hooked it up wrong and then we had a gas leak. Other than that, the quality of work performed by the technicians is generally good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 10, 2018

    Every time we've ever had anything, First American has always been there. I bought the warranty 20 years ago when we bought our house. Our realtor recommended them and we thought it was a good idea. I call when I submit my claims. The only problem I had was calling down to Costa Rica or El Salvador. It’s hard to understand them. The people didn't speak good English. Then I got a phone number for guys here in the United States. Since then, we’ve been getting better service.

    I’ve had good service from First American over the 20 years. They did my microwave, put in a new dishwasher, and had the furnace worked on six times over the last 10 years. They put two motors in it. Then, they had the motor on and the fan that goes around that brings the air around from outside. That thing went out and within two weeks, it went out again. They had to come and replace the whole motor. And it was the fault of the manufacturer.

    They also did a great job on our garbage disposal. The guy that came out did a fantastic job on it. He told us some things that we never knew. He told my wife how to grind it. He said not to put lemon down there because it gets under the blades and it causes more smell. He also said that we run hot water when we put ice in there because when we turn it on and it got ice in there and use cold water, it just makes it more hard. So, it’s been good. I've recommended First American to several people. I’ve been telling all my friends about it. I went to my marine colleague and I told my experience to about 30 guys.

    But once, I had one guy and he didn't bring a ladder to go up into my attic. I said to this guy, “You came out here without a ladder?” And he said, “Well, I just didn’t think I needed one.” I had to get him a ladder, and then he got up there. However he was so fat he couldn’t get in there. So I called First American and they sent a nice guy, about 5’5” and really skinny, so I got no problem. He crawled back there and put in the new motor.

    So everything has been good except for our most recent claim. We have more problems with this heater and now we’re having problems with it again. They’re coming Wednesday because they think there’s a leak now. The company they sent put a new a compressor in December and it hasn't worked well since then. I don’t think the guy who put it was very good because I’ve had problems ever since he did his job. When he scattered compressor pipes in, he didn’t get them done well and now it’s leaking Freon. They've also sent people from Rockland but they didn't come out. The guy never showed up the whole day. I called them and they told me that they have no one to send me.

    So I called First American and they sent AquaPro out. Five people came out and they’re on to it. They're Hispanic. They’re all nice, professional and top-notch. They brought their own ladder. I’ve had the same guy out now three times and he put his motor around up in my attic and then down here. So he seems to know more about what’s happening.

    Then, they came out and put the heater on it to keep it from defrosting. But this last week it defrosted it up and I called and they came out Saturday and they said, “Well, it’s low on Freon. We think there’s a leak in it.” So, AquaPro is coming out Wednesday to do a leak check on it. We had to order the compressor and it was Christmas and New Year's and a guy had to put it in. It also rained a couple of times and they didn’t want to be working out here since it's electrical, which I understand. I don’t want anybody gets in shock, be killed or hurt badly.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 10, 2018

    When I bought an older house, I knew there was going to be something wrong with it so I figured I'd get some help on getting it fixed. I trusted my realtor who was so good to me and I went with First American. The first time I tried to file a claim, I went through their phone system and it took quite a bit for them to get a contractor out. I've gone and done the service request online as well and it also took a bit of time for the contractor to call me and set up a time.

    It's an issue for me that I always have to call them. Last week, I had to call the contractor to get an appointment then I had to call them again after the appointment window closed to tell them that they were running late. I tried talking to somebody about the issue but I haven't gotten any results. So I'm giving them my service fee and be done with what they’re actually going to cover.

    One time, they sent a contractor who just came in, leaned up against my table, looked at my A/C and told me it needed to be replaced. He had also locked his keys in his car so he had to sit at my house for 20 minutes to wait for a locksmith. He left with my service fee but didn't put any claim in until weeks later. It was the middle of summer with no AC. But other than that contractor, all of the others that have come out have been all fine. But I would tell others never to call in an emergency because it would be a couple of days before they call back. Nonetheless, a warranty is still a warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 9, 2018

    Stay away if you want to save yourselves the hassle and money. My Refrigerator started having issues around 12/15/17. Once I started the claim process, the service contractor came by next week to fix the issue. The issue started again within a couple of days and that’s when my nightmare started. I had to make several calls to the contractor and First American to get a 2nd appointment scheduled. The service contractor eventually came 2nd week of February 2018 and said that several parts including the compressor needs to be replaced and they will make the necessary arrangements with First American. After this the contractor went completely off the radar and would not respond to my calls. I had to escalate this to First American multiple times and they finally assigned a claim specialist for me last week of February.

    I had to stay in hold on several times, and go through their ridiculous prompts each time I called wasting several minutes of my day. The representatives had no clue what my issue was and I had to repeat the same information every time I called. They would also say that the issue has been escalated and they’ll take action within a day but nothing had happened the next time I called.

    Once they assigned a claim specialist at least I started getting updates in late Feb and she said that the issue should be resolved within a week. But the daily updates for the next severally days were that we are still waiting for the purchasing department to make the final decision on whether they will replace or repair. On 03/09/18 they called to say that they will to repair again and I now have an appointment for end of March. Months without a refrigerator: 4! They only pay $75 for a mini fridge as temp relief and have no regard or urgency to fix customer issues. Poor service, too many delays and a complete waste of time. I will add an update on what happens next but they have already lost my trust. Stay away.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Abhishek,

    We apologize for any inconvenience you may have experienced during the handling of your claim. Our records indicate your kitchen refrigerator was repaired on April 16, 2018. Your claim is considered closed.

    Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 9, 2018

    I've been with First American for six years now. When I got them, I was having different issues with the house and I thought it might be good to get a warranty. I usually go online to submit claims, which is convenient but it is also a little confusing and difficult to go through. The website doesn’t say on the front page that I got to go to the top and hit the little unknown emblem to make a claim. There should be a place on the site where it says the claim on the very page that you get. Also, they should have a place for instructions on how to cancel the services. I had a problem when I had complaints about First American not covering some of the items that I thought they should.

    As for the technicians that they sent, some of them are sharp while some aren't. I got to know the prior plumber well because they've been here for numerous times and they were good. And although the last tech I had fixed the water heater and did a good job, he didn't seem as knowledgeable and as professional as the ones who came prior to him. Also, I wasn’t as comfortable with him as I was with the people who came before. He seemed like he was a contractor for the person or the company that has a contract with First American. Other than that, the overall quality of work performed was good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 9, 2018

    When I bought the house, First American was there and I continued it. I had problems a couple of times and they came and fixed them. The first time was a bad experience. My cooler was not working. I switched the AC and it would not come on. It took almost a week for it to be fixed. Three different agents came and kept going back and they were not able to fix it. The first person who came could not figure it out. I told him it was the wire but he didn’t pay attention to that and said that it was a different problem. And then the second guy came and was not able to fix it too. The third one came and figured it out. I told him the wire is the problem so he checked the connection here and he went to check the connection in the attic. He said there was no continuity. We were with no cooler for almost a week.

    I also had a problem with the garage door and it could not go up and down. The door cost only $11 and I knew how to fix it. I called First American HB Protection and they fixed it and they charged me $75 for a five to ten-minute job. It went very good and the garage door guy, before coming, called me before 8:00. I missed the call and then I called back. He asked me what time he can come.

    The recent one was for the water heater and we didn't know where the water was leaking. I told them to come the fast way because the weather was very cold. I called them Sunday and requested that somebody come on Monday. They said they can come only on Tuesday so we had to heat the water on the stove and put it in the tub. Then they came, checked the heater and changed the plastic pot. They did it promptly and sent me some refund. But if they had done the work on the first day, it would be much better and we didn't have to undergo all that stress.

    When there is a small problem, they can fix it. The First American claims reps have been very nice and prompt and quick, and the technicians have been very good and knowledgeable. They fixed the job in a time limit that they've done. They were very fast and prompt. They knew what they’re doing. One guy didn’t charge me. I told him to take the payment but he said that First American will send me a bill and that I don’t have to worry. I will definitely recommend them to my friends and anybody else.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 8, 2018

    When I bought the house, the former owner had First American. When I have to submit a claim, first, I would look a little bit quick to make sure I'm covered on that particular thing. Then I would call and tell them I'm having a problem. They would usually let me know who they're going to call and give me the phone number so that I can call them if they don't call me right away. The service has been good. It's $75 when the contractors come to do the service and it usually gets resolved. While there have been a few contractors who don't try real hard, most of them have been very good.

    My last experience was with bath plumbing. I had a leak under my kitchen sink and I thought the faucet was leaking because it's loose. The contractor determined that it was the disposal that was leaking and he put a new one in. I asked if I needed a new faucet and he said he doesn’t do that. There must be another guy who does faucets so he didn’t fix my faucet. But it was called plumbing and that's plumbing. I would think they would be glad to sell me a new faucet and that's really the only question that I've ever had. Still, everything has been satisfactory.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 8, 2018

    I've had First American for over two years. A friend of mine that used to come and worked on my computer told me about them. Somebody told me they were good. I figured that if something breaks down, I could call them. Years back, my ice maker wasn't working and a guy came out and got it working. It's not hard submitting a claim too. I just call and they just send someone.

    So far, except for my refrigerator, I haven't had any big problems. I thought the person who came was going to fix it but instead, he told me that that part wasn’t covered. And I gave him $75, which First American said they’re going to send a check back. I haven’t received the refund yet. I talked to one of the managers and he had me on the line for a long time. I told them that it was fair even though it was my fault for paying the person who came to my home. After all, he told me I had to pay him to come over. I have told my son about First American and he’s been on it since.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 7, 2018

    When I purchased the home, this was the company that was recommended for the home warranty. After 2 months, I filed a claim for problems with the pool plumbing. They declined the claim with the explanation that this is a pre-existing issue. The explanation of the problem from their technician was calcium buildup inside the pipes and it was causing leaks.

    Since this problem started before the policy was in force, then this is not covered. Their technician, in the notes provided to the company indicated, that there was no service done, and no fee should be charged. The company still charged me with the fee and claimed that if I do not pay this fee, they will not do any other services on this contract. This company is a total SCAM. Most problems done occur overnight. They often take time to develop. Their excuse for denying the claims seems like it will always be a pre-existing issue. DO NOT DO BUSINESS WITH THEM. STAY AWAY!!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 7, 2018

    We have a good experience with First American and we’re happy that we renewed with them. When we bought our house, the homeowners included that as part of our sales. So they had purchased it and then we bought the extension after the year had run out. Submitting a claim is easy and takes only a few minutes. We usually get a response within a day or two; two days is the longest I’ve had to wait. Everything has been hassle-free when having to deal with a claim or request someone to come out. The process is user-friendly and painless, which I appreciated. Most of the techs that have come out have also been easy to work with and helpful. The last guy we had out was really nice. He was a plumber. And last year, we had a guy who I don’t know if he fully knew what he was doing, but the situation ended up getting resolved, so that was fine. And overall the work they’ve done has been good. Aside from very good service response time, all our interactions with First American so far have been positive. Plus, the deductible is reasonable.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 7, 2018

    When I first bought my home, the last homeowners used First American and I stayed with them out of laziness. The service is mediocre. The claiming process is not that bad and the reps have been fine. Every time I submit my claim, I have to call them before they call me. It usually takes at least 24 to 48 hours until somebody responds. The techs were satisfactory. Some of the contractors are not great with appliances. I would tell a friend to research to see if they can get a better deal somewhere else.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 6, 2018

    I have many years of Customer Service under my belt, and I have NEVER experienced such poor customer service. When we bought our home, First American was grandfathered into the home – so we have continued to renew with them. Within the first year of owning the home (Jan 2016), the coils in our HVAC burned up. We called and explained that we had a 2 weeks old newborn at home, please send someone promptly. We went round-and-round with their agents about who had the ball in their court - warranty company? Or contractor? It took 3 weeks and 3 visits to fix the issue. 3 weeks of freezing cold temps and spending the coldest of nights at my parents’ house to keep my son from getting sick.

    Fast forward to December 2017 - another piece of the HVAC blew up. We called First American; they opened a new claim, sent another lousy contractor out... And another. And another. I have 5 canary colored invoices sitting on my kitchen counter, 3 of which suggest replacing the unit. FA refuses! They keep sending out new parts to repair on an old unit, which continues to burn up anything and everything they replace. It's getting ridiculous. First American cares about one thing only - their money. They don't care about the loyal customer. They don’t care that the customer is spending money every month for virtually nothing. They must not even value their outsourced contractor’s opinions, because they overrule every suggestion given to them. This is the first stop. Next complaint will be filed under BBB.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed March 6, 2018

    I wasn't happy with the groups that I had when I had the water heater replaced. They had so many add-ons that were so unnecessary and they lied to me. I paid my handyman to install it and it saved me over $100. Then on Christmas Day, my thermostat went out. Our turkey wasn’t any good because of it. Their guy took four days to come out. But I understood–there was a holiday. But then they said they had to order the parts and so it was another week and a half till they came. And that was crazy. But then, it happened again and it went down a week ago. And that experience was awesome. I called on a Sunday and the guy came out on Monday.

    He found out that the previous guy put in the wrong charge. So I just said I should get back that money I gave the first time they came. I was told by the home warranty that they can’t do that and that I should call the place directly. I thought that is not right. I think the home warranty should guarantee if the work isn’t done right. It’s obvious they did it wrong because it didn’t work that long. I wasn’t happy with that. The gentleman I talked to is very nice, and he said that he would talk to his supervisor and see what they could do. But of course, I know I'm not going to get it back.

    When we bought our house, our realtor gave us one year of First American warranty. We then renewed it after that. Submitting a claim with them has been very easy. It was very good with the claims representatives and I love being able to have somebody available on Sundays. But when I'm up for renewal, I'm looking into another place.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 6, 2018

    First American was what was offered to us but we stayed because it's a decent coverage. I've only had one experience that pushed the issue but out of all the different claims that we had over the years, the claiming process was relatively very smooth as well as our interactions with their claims reps and technicians. However, it would be better if during the communication between the contractor and the home warranty they get the right information transferred so that you don’t have any issues. Other than that everything was good.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed March 5, 2018

    We have had First American since 2003, I believe. I have recommended First American Home Warranty multiple times in the past because of the service we received on various claims. However, I will no longer recommend them. I have had seven claims on my refrigerator, all for the same problem, each service call $65.00. The leak has ruined my wood floors (which they will not cover). First American continues to send out a technician and will not replace the refrigerator. Three parts have been replaced: the heating element twice, the seal around the freezer once, and the main panel four times.

    They are now sending out yet another technician for the same problem. The back panel was replaced 12/29, 2/8 and 2/22. I'm so tired of this runaround! This next visit will be the 8th time a technician has come out for the same problem. Each time I am taking off work, having to empty my entire fridge and of course put everything back. I can tell you right now that they will come out, fix one of the above parts (again), and we will have the same issue. I am so very frustrated.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed March 5, 2018

    I gave 1st American Home Warranty two stars because we had them for one year based on our realtor's recommendation; however, they did not renew our contract and would not tell us why. This was our first home warranty and found them useful for the most part and always there and top notch on paying and fixing the issues we had wrong with our home. Being an older home with some issues when we first moved here it was nice to have the coverage and we planned on keeping 1st American Home Warranty in the future. Again, we never had a problem with the company...seemed always on top of the game and we were impressed so much that we began telling others about how great this company was.

    When it came time to renew our contract, we got a letter stating that our contract would NOT be renewed. Believing it was an error, based on the fact that the sellers had purchased the contract for us on closing we questioned 1st American Home Warranty reps twice and they concurred that it was not an error and that we could not renew our contract for another year. They would not tell us why or give us any other information. Overall, was happy with the service while we had it. Question the rationale as to why our service was not renewed. Still have not been given an answer whatsoever.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello Alan,

    We appreciate your business. Unfortunately, it is First American’s discretion to offer future coverage. You may refer to your home warranty contract per Coverage Time and Renewal, Number Three,

    “Offer for future coverage is at Company’s sole discretion. You will be notified of rates and terms for continuation of coverage.”

    Thank you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed March 5, 2018

    Our First American coverage came with our house and the company has been good in taking care of things for the most part so we kept them. Submitting a claim is a little difficult however because their automated system doesn’t understand voice command sometimes, like when we try to describe the problem we're having. Otherwise, it's easy. We’ve spoken with reps lots of times too and most of our experience has been very satisfactory. Our interactions with the techs that have come out, as well as the quality of their work, have been really good too.

    I'm satisfied with First American and things could be better if there’s not much hold time on the phone and easier response when we have a problem with an existing claim. I’ve checked into American Home Shield before and it was a little bit cheaper but I didn’t really want to change. They almost have the same price but First American doesn’t offer water softener or anything like that, which AHS does, so the only reason, if I’d change, would be the additional appliances AHS offers. First American goes up every year quite a bit but for the most part, if we have problems, it's actually very worth our while.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 5, 2018

    I decided to look into warranty as I was buying a house at that time and my real estate agent recommended First American. She had other clients that had used them before so I decided to use them as well. I usually fill out the claims online and they've been good on some claims and not so good on others. I have a first class upgrade and I find that oftentimes, the contractors that they send are not very good and are not used to working on high-end products. They rarely send people out that are certified and not everybody has the knowledge or the skillset to work on products like a Thermador or a Sub-Zero refrigerator. They send people out that tend to do more damage which cost me more money since I have to pay out of pocket to have a certified person come in and do the work. When I paid extra for the first class upgrade, I should be able to get people that are qualified to work on the type of appliances that are having issues.

    For the Sub-zero, which is an A1 Appliance, the guy First American sent out was the absolute worst. He did not speak English and translation was very difficult. By the time I called Sub-Zero, he had done so much damage and it cost me $1,500. Sub-Zero only wanted to take a portion of that because I said I could only have $2,500 worth of work on the refrigerator and the work that the technician had done previously had already eaten up part of that money. He was not successful in fixing anything but we still had to pay him and it was not an enjoyable interaction. I would never use First American to fix anything on my refrigerator again.

    When I get in touch with customer service, they are great. It is easy when I first open up a claim but afterward, when I need any follow-up and when I have questions, it is extremely difficult to get in touch with the people and that has been my displeasure. I have to wait 20 minutes, they don't call me back and I would have to call somebody and explain it all over again. It's inconvenient. Also, when I have a replacement, they don’t always replace the products with the same brand and maybe not even the same quality and that's a concern. I'm satisfied with some things and dissatisfied with others. I would tell other people to do some research before going with First American and to not just go to them. I would recommend that people compare notes and find someone that they think is suitable for their needs.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingOnline & App

    Reviewed March 4, 2018

    When I bought my house, First American was the insurance that was part of the deal that I worked out. I submit my claims online and the website is easy to maneuver through. There was one tech that I had issues with getting back in touch with me. But when I called First American, they jumped on it right then and there. They called him on my behalf and he was better after that. I would definitely recommend them to another friend and family member.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed March 4, 2018

    We have been in this house since 2006 and the realtor and the person who sold the house made sure that we have acquired First American Home Buyers Protection and was paid for. We live in the Columbus area and when submitting a claim, we call First American and they contact the agent that they have in the area. Then the agent contacts us to make an appointment to come and see what they can do to take care of the problem.

    We’ve seen the representative, many times in the last 11 years and whatever is needed or whatever we have expressed the problems to be, he or his people have always verified that “Yes indeed. That is the problem.” And they fix it. There’s a solution. There’s always the same payment and we see the same person over and over. They always explain to us what's going on and talk with us about how did we get to this point or what happened beforehand so that if there's something we're doing that is causing the problem, we can look into it and make sure that it doesn't continue to be a problem.

    They're always very well-educated, well-prepared and polite, and courteous. The quality of work is always good. Sometimes, it depends on what you give someone to work with and then they do the best job they can. One time we had a leak and we thought we had just a leak. It was serious, and we didn't know how serious it was. Sometimes, it is just a really easy fix and sometimes it's not easy for us. We’re not DIY people. We have other things that we have to take care of. So we depend on American Home Buyers to come in and tell us what needs to happen and do the right thing and they do. We're satisfied. It's a premium.

    And if someone would ask about First American, the first thing they have to realize is their level of understanding of what needs to be taken care in their home. Diagnosing the problem is important and they should learn the basic. But if they want to rely on First American Home Buyers, they have to let First American diagnose the problem and they'll give a recommendation on what they need to do to fix whatever is wrong. And if they can't fix it, they can pass it on to the next agent so people don't pay two fees for one problem that hasn't been taken care of.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 3, 2018

    We got First American eight or nine years ago. We bought the house and somebody recommended them so we went with them. About two years ago, we had some problems with somebody they sent to repair an air conditioning. It took two or three months to get their own parts and that went on for a couple of times. But the last two times I filed a claim, it worked well. The claiming process was easy. It's just that the contractor that we were dealing with was extremely bad and I let them know about it at the time. The guys weren’t very professional at all.

    The claims reps were excellent. They listened to what problem I had, followed up on it, gave me a claim number and a contractor. I called the contractor and he was just here like it's supposed to be. He was extremely professional. He fixed it and he did the job really well. Same thing with the one we had before that. First American is good. I got friends who have First American too.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed March 3, 2018

    The people that were in the house previously used First American and my escrow company has a title company that I closed with First American. I never had a home warranty before and I just went with them. When I submit my claims, I do it over the phone. The people that they sent out weren’t great vendors and I would’ve never used those people on my own. One issue was a plumber. I’ve had air-conditioning units and a pool. They either couldn’t fix the problem or they’ve had to come out several times and it wasn’t a smooth operation to me. One vendor never called me back and never even had to fix what was needed to be fixed.

    I couldn’t even get a hold of them, and even First American tried to call them back five times. In terms of my interaction with their reps, it was 50-50. When I was moving, I emailed to cancel my automatic withdrawals from my bank account and I never heard anything back. I called in the other day and they didn’t even have it in the system. They pulled the money out of the bank account and charged me for mid-February to mid-March. The guy that I ended up speaking with to resolve that was excellent and he was the first person I’ve ever spoken to that really was on it and knew what to do. I would tell a friend of mine to shop around a little bit.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 2, 2018

    I've been a real estate broker for 41 years and I push home warranty all the time because it's the greatest thing. Our First American representative, Roberta, has been amazing. Over the years, I've had different claims for different things and they've been fine. But, one of the contractors that First American sent was horrible. I was shocked that they would even consider having him as a vendor. He shouldn’t even be working for them.

    When he came in, my refrigerator had been so hot to touch. It was like a burning iron on the outside. He took off the top and he said it needed to be cleaned. I told him it gets cleaned. And he said there was nothing wrong with it. It just needed to be cleaned. But I told him there was something wrong with it. He told me he could clean it up for me and he could give me a deal that day, but it was going to be $175 in cash. I thought that was odd and I've never experienced anything like that. I asked how long was it going to take to clean it and he said about 20 minutes. So I thanked him but I told him I'd keep my $175 and clean it myself. And then I let First American know and so I've got a new guy coming out on Monday. Other than that, I still push their company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechOnline & App

    Reviewed March 2, 2018

    My real estate agent recommended First American to me. Navigating their website was easy. I sent my request online, the contractor called me to set up the appointment and they sent a technician within one or two days. I showed them the problem, they figured them out by themselves and then they told me what it was. They repaired everything and their work was good. I will tell a friend that it is not bad coming here.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed March 1, 2018

    They told me something by phone when I first start with them, then when I have problems they said is not covered, they told me, "We sent you our policy". But you know what they send it after I called them after three months of signing contract, everything is not covered even they don’t offer anything to keep businesses, so please stay away from them and find another company. Bad bad customer service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed March 1, 2018

    Asking me to put $500 from my pocket to replace gas furnace as it is covered 100% as per insurance clause. Looks like they have good tie with contractor so they can make case such a way that we have pay from pocket. I asked for cashback option. They offered me only $1000 which includes gas furnace and labor. No way. I can find someone who can install it in $1000. Current average replacement cost is $3000. Total fraud.

    Updated on 03/05/2018: It's been 3 weeks after I filed claim. Tried to reach out many time to the (claim handling department) officer who handles my claim (Sandra **). She stopped responding me after I asked her to provide me estimation details to replace furnace. I sent emails and left messages on phone many time. No response at all. I called customer service line. They says that they cannot answer or help me as my claim is handled by claim settlement department.

    I called their contracting company which is replacing the furnace (Furnace Doctor, phone 2066225018). They also not providing me any technical details like what is my current furnace, BTU, Model and what will be new furnace. Very frustrating. I am completely exhausted at this point. Don't know what to do. Thinking to go to consumer court.

    Thanks for your vote!
    First American Home Warranty
    Response from First American Home Warranty

    Hello SanjayKumar,

    Our records indicate your furnace was replaced on March 9, 2018. At this time, we consider your claim closed.

    Thank you.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed March 1, 2018

    I was persuaded to buy a home warranty with this company. Biggest mistake that I ever made. I submitted three claims; one for an air conditioner, one for a stove handle that fell off and one for the handle on a microwave that came loose. All claims were denied within a day. The stove and the microwave are over 20 years old. So the handle on the stove fell off and I put it in the laundry room. The handle on the microwave came loose because it is so old. First American sent two "technicians" to look at the problem. The "technicians" were two Russian high school kids in shorts and t-shirts who look as if they got back from the gym.

    They asked me no questions. They just looked at the stove, then microwave and left. Later I got a call from the representative at First American, they denied the stove claim because they said the part was missing. But it wasn't missing; it was in the laundry room. If the "technicians" would have asked me for it I would have showed it to them. They denied the claim on the microwave because they said I used excessive force. But the thing was over 20 years old!. And anyone knows that a microwave door handle only opens outward. How can you use excessive force on that? I asked the representative if there could be a second opinion and she laughed at me. Then flatly told me no.

    Then I received two letters from First American telling me that the claims had been denied. So I bought a new microwave and oven. Then I received a phone call from another appliance contractor with First American telling me that they had been scheduled to come out for a second opinion. But I had already received a decline form First American and had bought new appliances. After that I received another letter from First American telling me that my claims had been declined because I had replaced the appliances without their permission. Seriously?

    I also filed a claim for a broken air conditioner. That was back in October of 2017. It is now March of 2018 and nothing has happened except that I have had to argue with their contractors from Platinum Repair who are all Russian and who are the most obnoxious and rude people in the world. Don't waste your money on First American. Also, in case you do not know, they have over 700 complaints against them with the BBB!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed March 1, 2018

    When I bought my house, the seller had bought me the first year warranty of First American and I always continued with it after. If I ever have any problems, I just call First American and it's cheaper to have to pay the service fee than having to pay out of pocket. When submitting a claim, I call them and the experience is fast and easy. Their reps are always good and friendly. Last Saturday, we had to call because of a plumbing problem. And then, it happened again last night so I don't know if they're just flushing it and then not really finding the real problem. We called the plumbing company and left them a message but they haven't called us back. I don’t know if I needed to file another claim and pay another service fee because it was for the same thing. Other than that, I'm recommending First American to people that have houses.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed March 1, 2018

    When we bought our house, First American had the best rate going as far as home warranties. The warranty has been working well so we figured we'd stick with it. Submitting a claim has not been difficult. I call and tell them what's going on but then there's a little disconnect between the time I make the call to put a claim in and somebody getting back with me to fix an appliance. It takes a couple of days for someone to get back to us.

    When we called to get our dishwasher serviced, the service guy just showed up at my house and I didn’t even know and I was at work, too. I never got a phone call for an appointment. And so, I had to reschedule with the guy for later on in the afternoon. But then when I got home, my daughter got the flu and I had to take her to the emergency room and the guy came back to the house. The claim just went null and void. I need to call them again and resubmit that claim because I never got my dishwasher serviced. But, we usually have different service guys and they call and give us a heads up and ask us when is a good time for them to come. And generally, the work they've done has been great. I'd recommend First American's service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    First American Home Warranty Company Information

    Company Name:
    First American Home Warranty
    Year Founded:
    1984
    City:
    Santa Rosa
    State/Province:
    CA
    Website:
    homewarranty.firstam.com

    Media

    VIDEOS & IMAGES