First American Home Warranty Reviews
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+3 more
About First American Home Warranty
First American Home Warranty is a home warranty company that’s been in business for over 35 years. Its plans protect homeowners' budgets from unforeseen expenses due to normal wear and tear of a home's major systems and appliances.
- HVAC tuneup
- No age limit on appliances
- Can pick your service call fee
- Not available in all states
First American Home Warranty Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (4,626)
- (1,076)
- (490)
- (322)
- (2,417)
Popular Mentions
- 4,882,006 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Top reviews
- Top reviews
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,882,006 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Reviewed June 29, 2017
When I bought my house in 2013, we negotiated a home warranty in with the purchase and kept it ever since. I submitted my recent claim with First American online off my phone, which was simple and quick, and I've also submitted over the phone. I've had no issues with their claims rep, but I had one hiccup with a technician that came to my house. The AC company that came to my house did not have a service truck and was just working out of a Chevy S10 Blazer and it wasn't very professional. They weren't rude but they looked like somebody who did service on the side. Then they did my outside unit, which says Carrier all over. They just noticed it's Carrier when they got inside and got on the air handler, and they told me they can't work on the unit. Other than that, I've been pleased with the work I have received and I feel the quality is good. First American is a good investment and that people should entertain the idea of getting one.
Reviewed June 29, 2017
We bought a house with First American as a home warranty and filing a claim with them was an easy process. Also, their representative was courteous and helpful.
Reviewed June 28, 2017
Please remember when purchasing this home warranty that if the thing works when the contractor leaves your home, that is considered "fixed" under their terms. I had to place a claim 5 times in a year for the same problem with the gas stove. At $65 that about paid for a new stove. When I confronted First American with this, their response is, “If it works when they leave it is considered fixed”. I actually did end up buying a new stove.
More recently this is the 4th time in a year I have had to call them about a plumbing issue, but this issue has been consistent throughout the 9 years I have owned the home and the warranty. The clean out in front of the home will start spewing out water and food that is supposed to do down the drain connected to the kitchen sink. Then the water and food sits against the house until they come out. They are pretty good about response time so far though. So every time they've come out, the plumber snakes it and calls it good.
This time however, the plumber came out and then with an attitude told my daughter in law he couldn't work in these conditions, that it was a waste hazard and that I needed to call another company to take care of the waste hazard. Then he asked her who the company was that last came out, she said "It was you." And the actual plumber that came out the last time was with this plumber, but would not say one word. This same company has been the one that First American sends out every time and this is the first time anyone has ever mentioned it being a hazard. It is in the same condition every time. Now I'm concerned about secondary damage this has probably caused and hazard to my house, family, pets, etc.
When this plumber called me to tell me he was on his way to the house I told him this was the 4th time and that someone prior had mentioned it needed hydro jetting (?). So I call this other company because of course secondary damage is not covered by the warranty and they told me it would cost $875.00 to remove the soil in front, bag it and dispose of it and treat it with chemicals. WHAT?!!! Why wouldn't any of the other plumbers from the same company mention this? Why wouldn't they fix it long term? I am really concerned because this same problems happens all the time. But their motto is if it worked when they left, it's fixed. Someone needs to do something about this racket!
Reviewed June 28, 2017
First American is excellent. I did some research and they look better than other home warranties and they also have a lower payout. I have been submitting my claim online and the website's easy to navigate. I have called when I made my first claim and it went fine.
Thank you for taking the time to leave your review Terry!
Reviewed June 27, 2017
I submitted a request for repair on my KitchenAid range approximately a month and a half ago. Their only repair technicians for the greater Seattle area Sears have now been out to my house 4 times and an additional two times that they no showed. Sears is only available during working hours so in order to get my oven/range repaired I have had to take off time from work. Sears still has been unable to repair the oven. I have called First American to discuss the issue that I cannot take another day off work to have my range not repaired for them to only offer me $212 to basically go away. I have a slide in KitchenAid range which the value is well over $1,800.
After another failed attempt by Sears to repair my range on this Monday, I have been on the phone this past week with First American to have all of their calls drop as soon as they put me on hold to "research" and not one representative has made any attempt once the call has dropped to call me back. I have phone records that show over 40 calls to First American that have dropped. I have spoken to over 30 Representatives all of which again have not bothered to call me back once they dropped the call on their end, over 40 hours on hold for nothing!
The latest repair attempt occurred on Monday they (Sears) once again, unable to repair it. Sears requested authorization from First American to order another part (same part as they put in before). First American denied the request. Told them that they would discuss it with me and call me that night to get authorization from me and they would order the parts on their end. First American has not contacted me and when I have called First American again today I have had them drop my calls three different times again with no callback. So I still have an inoperative range with no solution and a warranty company that says, "I am sorry we cannot call you back, we have incoming calls that are our priority." Not the customer who has called over 40 times and waited on hold trying to get their oven repaired which is covered under the warranty they sold me.
Reviewed June 27, 2017
2 unfulfilled ill-managed claims: Failed to provide any resolution or even any workman at all on refrigerator claim, so I managed to get it done privately after FAHW said they could not find someone! Months of being under-served and workmen left without proper direction on plumbing leaks, so I finally found and paid for my own plumber who was able to fulfill claim. The fault was in the bizarre, redundant misadministration by FAHW and what is more, the plumbing company administration, NOT its plumbers but the office scheduling and coordination and communication, was so bad that it is not worth the time to detail.
Hello Jess,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Updated review: July 26, 2017
After a claims representative took over my repair order, they did a persistent follow through to be sure my repair was completed correctly.
Original Review: June 27, 2017
Requested HVAC service: Contractor assigned as emergency. I've had an issue with my HVAC unit for 2 weeks. I explained to Contractor what was happening. Of course the unit ran fine with the contractor. Nothing repaired. 2 days later the unit failed. Same issue; I called your offices and they wouldn't upgrade my request as an emergency [I'm a heart patient, having under gone 7 surgeries] and the original Contractor will take 2 days to come back. I explained to your employee but got that's the way it is attitude. Never had a problem with your employees before. I'm not really happy at this point. I may have to change companies when my contract expires. I do have 2 properties with your Company. Thanks!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed June 27, 2017
First, we have their Premiere Service Plan. I placed (2) service requests within 30 days. First was for dishwasher, 4 weeks later it still isn't fix and we have been without it the whole time. It's a dishwasher no big issue but 4 weeks, how hard can it be to fix a dishwasher there are not that many parts. Second request was for the AC unit, 3 weeks later we are still waiting for service and been told several times we have been placed at the top of the list.
Bad part is we communicated to FAHW several times that temps are 90+ outside and one of the family members is disabled with a medical condition. They did offer us $50 to purchase fans. Three weeks and counting without a service tech visit. Sadly, we have several AC repair companies within 10 miles of our homes that we have contacted and they will be out within 2 days if we pay them directly for a standard service fee. Seems the issue FAHW has is that many contractors won't do business with them because of their business practices? Makes one wonder.
Reviewed June 27, 2017
For the last 2 weeks, we've had issues getting First American to fix an A/C problem. First they sent a contractor out that spent less than 5 minutes looking around, misdiagnosed the issue (estimating $3200) and then the claim was denied. We went out ourselves to get an estimate to fix the issue and that's when we found out the first contractor that First American used was crap! They sent another contractor out to verify when we argued with them, who then took a week to send in the report. We had to call every day to check the status of the claim... NOT ONCE did First American contact us!
They finally called almost 2 weeks into the ordeal saying it's not covered because a drain pan in the A/C wasn't installed correctly in the first place and it was denied under some stupid limits of liability. Meanwhile this whole time, fiberglass insulation from around the A/C is coming out all of our house vents! I even had a home inspection done ahead of time and A/C serviced and no issues were found. Irritating because when we bought the warranty, there was no home inspection report needed and no mention of things not being covered like this in the first place. Sounds to me like they'd find any reason not to cover it! I think that First American is a rip off, their customer service is horrible, the contractors they choose are terrible, and we will no longer be using their company in the future. I also don't recommend them to anyone else!
Reviewed June 27, 2017
On 6/22/17, First American Home Warranty (FAHW) contacted L&S cooling and heating to come to my house for a repair because the Air Conditioning motor wasn't blowing. It took 2 days for L&S to show up. With temps over 120 degrees outside, I could not stay in the house so I turned the AC unit off when I left. First thing L&S tech said was, "Have you considered buying a new unit?" This was a home warranty job where I paid him $75 for the repair, so all he needed to do was get my AC going again. Then he said FAHW would not allow him to do work with my coils dirty and it needing service...BUT he could clean them for $250 and service for $120.
When I didn't pay for him to clean the unit he said he would be off until Monday so I should think about it. He did change out a capacitor and said I needed to wait for 4-5 hours before turning the unit on and he left. On the invoice he said the motor had been running and was hot, but I had turned the unit off 2 days prior, so it was only hot because it was 118 degrees outside. When I confronted him about that, he said he "thought" it was running but he didn't change the invoice. On the invoice he said my unit was dirty and badly maintained, but my son-in-law was in the AC business over 15 years, so my unit was maintained and I had a high efficiency filter on the intake.
Of course the unit didn't work when I turned it back on, so I was left in a hot house again. Yelp reviews of this company has numerous complaints that are almost identical to mine. I paid $506 for another company to come out on 6/26/17 and replace the motor. That technician said the coils were not dirty and the unit looked fine, not poorly maintained like L&S wrote on their invoice. He turned the motor with his hand and could tell that the bearings were bad. Unit is working now. It just needed a new motor.
Hello Sonia,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed June 27, 2017
I signed up with First American off the suggestion of a family member. I used them one time and submitted my claim over the phone. It was easy and the rep I spoke with was pleasant. He helped me through the whole process and told me what to expect. The air conditioning gentleman that came out asked a lot of questions. They were really busy so it took him a little while to get it done, but nothing bad happened and it was just standard customer service. Overall, I'm happy. I have a different company for my other house and I'll probably gonna switch it to First American as well.
Reviewed June 26, 2017
It was my realtor's idea to get a home warranty and she recommended First American. She said they've been in the business for over 30 years and they know what they're doing. She also said they were top of the top and one of the best out there and that people are really pleased with First American. And it’s better if I go with them rather than with somebody else. I've submitted a claim and it was a pretty easy process. I did it over the phone and the claims rep was very pleasant. Also, the technician was very knowledgeable, professional and on time. I’m very pleased with their work and my experience overall was very good.
Reviewed June 25, 2017
The Realtor suggested a home warranty and recommended First American Home Buyers Protection when I bought my house. It was a good idea. Submitting a claim was easy and it went very well. The claims representative was very professional and polite and the technicians were all very confident and explained everything. On top of that, their work quality was very good. It was a satisfying experience.
Reviewed June 24, 2017
Every time we need a repair we fight with this company and they do not care how much time it takes the client to have a working appliance. They are great at taking the payments and horrible about doing the work. There is no such thing as a reasonable time frame to have a repair done. They do not respond to supposedly in process work orders until you call and complain that whatever they told you the next step was will get done. How in the world does this company stay in business? I actually hate them and that is saying a lot because I shy away from using the word hate. UGGGHHH!!!
Reviewed June 23, 2017
Absolutely worst customer service I have ever had. Authorized me to have my contractor come out as their contractor was not available for over 7 days. My contractor found multiple leaks in a very old system that cannot be repaired due to age. Recommended replacement. FAHW will not authorize and now making me wait and forcing me to use their contractor... refusing to reimburse me. Have now been without AC for a week. Cannot get anyone to talk to me or call me back. They will not return calls or respond to emails.
Hello,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed June 23, 2017
First American Home Warranty is a Waste of your money! No service nor support. Always on hold for hours. The services support they hire - never show up (wasting your time). They take your money - but refuse to replace broken systems (they continue to try to repair old systems to save a couple dollars... while you need to be home for numerous service calls).
Two months ago, our pool/spa heater started turning off before fully heating the spa. We called FAHW and placed a service request - still today, it is not working. Granted, the analogue heater is 10 years old and it is hard to diagnosis a problem. But, after dozens of call to FAHW, they tried to send 4 different companies... one was booked and would not come out for 7 days to inspects the problem; one service contractor never showed after we waited all day; one suggested to replace with a new digital heater... Each of these calls to FAHW take a week to respond to and numerous service calls which require an adult to be home. As a result, we are now missing 1/2 the Summer without being able to use our pool.
A similar situation occurred with our Home Heating System this Winter! Numerous calls - numerous wasted days waiting for service contractors... We were cold and had to hire our own Heating Specialist (even though it was under warranty) - who indicated the replacement Control Board was installed WRONG and had mixed the wires. For another $300 it was finally fixed - no thanks to FAHW. Do not waste your money on the bad warranty service!
Reviewed June 23, 2017
I have been with First American since 2010 and have been more than satisfied with their service. I currently have a refrigerator that doesn't stay cold and they told me it would be a week before a repair person could arrive. They offered $75.00 to rent a refrigerator. How would I get it to my home and where would I put it. I live just outside a major Southern city, so they can't find a repair person, to service me in less than a week?
I had such good service in the past that I actually recommended First American to my son. In the past month he had a plumbing issue, had a plumber come to his home to free a clogged pipe, which ended up causing a leak that penetrated the first floor ceiling. Called again to have the leak fixed, the original plumber never came back after several repeated calls. Finally a different plumber showed up, to fix the leak, now the ceiling needs to be repaired.
I don't know what has taken place at First American which was a great company to work with in the past. It should be noted this is the first time I have ever taken the time to write about a bad experience. My concern is the quality of vendors they use for repairs since they must have a very short list that will work for what they will pay. I know for a fact that living in a large city I could get a repair person in a day or two max. I have already paid my yearly fee, but will have to consider staying with this firm based on the rest of the year and my future experiences should I have more needs for their services. Certainly if their service continues based on my current experience, I will definitely leave First American. Note: no receipt since still waiting for a repairman!!!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed June 22, 2017
I have been a loyal customer of First American Home Warranty for last 4+ years and wanted to cancel my contract as we are relocating to another country. Their website makes it so difficult for customer to find simple steps for cancellation. Finally I managed to reach call center, and had horrible experience - quoting contracts to say it takes 30 days to cancel (don't think it is right, just ill-informed customer executive), not able to explain why I am unable to delete credit card details in my account (even supervisor cannot say that) and quoting contract for everything. Few Simple question...
2. So called contract does not talk about 30-day notice. Why should they ask for 30 days?
3. Why should a customer not be allowed to delete his credit card details?
4. Last, if this contract is key, why is the contract not sent along with renewal and only after the customer pays renewal charges, they send the booklet which suddenly becomes the binding document on both parties?
Reviewed June 22, 2017
Be careful all consumers who believe that a warranty will fend off future major expenses to a possible failed A/C system. The TRUTH is that First American will only pay their contracted tech up to $200 for labor. Do the math... that's why the contractor will make up "modifications" to the plug and play system to make up for the cost of labor to do the job. In my case, the contractor has come up with a total of $1,100 in bogus modifications. I am an engineer, for the record, and know these "modifications" are bogus and First American know it. Shameful business practices to say the least.
Please provide us a valid address where the contract was in effect, a contract number or claim number so we can look into your allegations.
Reviewed June 22, 2017
you and instead of helping you they argue with you. This the worst home warranty company I have ever seen. $75 charge every time they send a technician and the technician do not even do anything. I rather keep that $600 in my pocket and have that stuff fixed myself. But I never do it again and will not recommend anyone to have the service from them.
Reviewed June 22, 2017
When I purchased my home, I chose First American as my home warranty company and in the short time I've had them, they've been pretty good. They've been very kind and very nice every time we have to file a claim. And the times that we have had to call, they've been pretty cordial on the phone and accurate about getting somebody out there to our house to do any type of repairs. Then the techs did the work that needed to be done and were in and out in a timely manner. I like the fact that they reached out to notify that they're going to be 30 minutes out so we can plan accordingly with our busy schedules. It's very helpful and professional. So far, everything has been done to what they said they were going to be doing and I'm very pleased. Hopefully they continue doing what they're doing and servicing our home if we do need them. That's why we pay insurance.
Reviewed June 22, 2017
My dryer has been broken since last month and I called them 8 times to make the follow up. Of those 8, 2 calls were cut off while they tried calling the technician but they never tried to call me back. If I will not call, they will not do anything or arrange something believable enough and poor me waiting for somebody to call. I have talked to all their agents and nobody can be decent enough to solve the problem. One technician came and just took off my money for he can repair the dryer. This is the second time around. The first time because I did not specify the work so they can't do the work but I paid my $65. What a shame this company is?! I am putting this so people will not fall to their empty promises.
Reviewed June 21, 2017
I got the suggestion that I should have a home warranty. A friend of mine introduced to me First American Home Warranty. Their claims representative was nice. The company helped me with electrical and other issues, but I wasn’t aware that it’s $65 for each claim. That’s not a big deal though. The technicians they sent out were good people as well. There was some leaking on the roof in regards to the air conditioning. When I turned the AC on, the thermostat was also not working properly. They found the problem on their second visit, so when they came back, they fixed the roof and cleaned the thermostat. The thermostat is working right now. I hope it stays fixed for a long time. I would recommend this company to a friend.
Reviewed June 20, 2017
We have had a home warranty with First American for 4 years now and it has hit an all time low this year. I put a claim in on May 8 to have my air conditioning fixed. The contractors are supposed to respond within 48 hours. This contractor did not respond for 4 days! When he finally did respond he was a big jerk to us and treated us badly while he was in our home supposedly fixing our air conditioning. 3 weeks later we began to have the same problem with our air conditioning so I reopened the claim on June 7. I heard nothing from the contractor or First American for days and days. I called, emailed and still heard nothing. Thirteen days later I finally heard back from someone and they lectured me about not contacting them sooner that the contractor had not called me! So now I am stuck with the same jerk contractor because it is the same claim and I have to wait for him to call and come back to my home again. It is all a big joke.
Here is what I've learned after four years of having a warranty. These contractors have figured out that they don't have to do much and they still get the money from us. I have had so many come out and take one glance at my issue and just give me a quote for a bigger job that they know my warranty doesn't cover. They get my $75 and walk away doing absolutely nothing for it. My advise is to save up the $60 a month on your own and pay for repairs that way and do not deal with any contractors that are part of warranties because they have become a crooked breed.
Reviewed June 20, 2017
We purchased the home. The A/C broke the first week under 100+F heat. We called the A/C service immediately to prevent us from getting heat stroke. First American Home Warranty denied the claim and refused to pay. We are filing lawsuit against First American right now. FirstAm is a fraud.
UPDATED ON 07/13/2017: When in 120 degrees heat, First Am wasn't able to send out tech to fix the problem. We had the local AC guy to fix it or my 83 years old mother will simply die in this environment. First Am somehow was able to get ConsumerAffairs to delete my negative comment without addressing the issue, stating it's not the fact. They wrote an email demanding the bill and never respond. Well, this is it. They rely on customer bullying to deny claims and get away with it.
Reviewed June 20, 2017
The reason that one would purchase a home warranty is in the case that something goes wrong with your home after your purchase it. This company has NO concept of customer service and their sole premise is to ensure they spend the least amount of time and money per claim as possible. Unfortunately, we have had two issues with our home since we purchased--which this is exactly why we bought the warranty.
Our first issue is that our dishwasher is not working properly as it barely cleans and the dry cycle is completely gone. The first rep my wife talked to told her that she needed to do something with the children in the background as it was too loud for her. We have four boys under five and my wife was appalled that the rep would even make that suggestion. When confronted the rep said that the issue was a pre-existing condition (which it was not) and said they were not fixing it. We had to have management get involved and apologize and say that we absolutely deserve service. Still 5 weeks later the broken dishwasher remains without resolve. Our second issue is our AC unit. It has gone out in the start of summer and we are sitting here with no AC and they can't seem to get someone to the house to help. We have 4 kids and one is an infant!
Quite frankly we have called over six times today and argued with the reps again with no resolve. My wife has enough stress throughout the day and she shouldn't have to deal with this type of interaction with a company. I have never seen people just not care like I have with this company. I am a mortgage lender and will deflect every client I can from using this company. DO NOT use them. Do your research and go with a reputable company and learn from my mistake!
Hello Jeffrey. We thank you for your feedback and are aware that both of your claims have been resolved at this time. Thanks, Shanee.
Updated review: July 12, 2017
The company contacted me and reimbursed me for most of the cost of the repairs of my air conditioning. Overall the quality of service depends on who answers the phone -- some people are apathetic or downright rude, while others ended up being quite helpful. Not enough to keep my business, but I respect that they made it right in the end.
Original Review: June 20, 2017
I received a one-year First American home warranty when I purchased my home about a year ago. The only time I have needed service is this week, when our AC stopped working in 108-degree temperatures. I submitted the request and then called to follow up the next day. I was hung up on twice while sitting on hold for 10+ minutes. When I finally talked to a person, he told me the contractor had 48 hours to schedule the appointment, that my situation wasn't an emergency, that I should use a fan. He didn't care that I had a baby trying to sleep in the 90-degree house or that I was pregnant. He dismissed me quickly and succinctly.
Next I tried calling the contractor, who "screened" me and sent me to the scheduling department, assuring me I would receive a call in an hour or so. Then two hours later I received a call from the contractor, who "screened" me again and sent my information to the scheduling department, again. Two hours later they called and left a message. I called back immediately only to be told the scheduling department was busy and would call me back. They never did. Not only does First American not care one bit about its customers, but they clearly retain contractors who don't care either. This particular contractor had 70 one-star reviews on Yelp. Real winners. Save yourself some trouble and avoid First American at all costs. I have never been treated so rudely and unfairly by any company. Ironically, I received my renewal notice from them in the mail today. I promptly threw it in the trash.
Hello Chelsea,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed June 20, 2017
We wanted to get a home warranty when we bought our house and our real estate agent recommended First American Home Warranty. We have them since end of September. The first time we filed a claim was within a month after we moved in. We noticed that our AC unit wasn’t blowing cold. Since we have an AC service company that checks our AC periodically, we had them come out. After that company cleaned the unit and serviced it, they said it was low on coolants. They recommended that we replace the unit in the future. I said, “Well, before we do that, let me call the home warranty people because I'm pretty sure that that’s covered. They’ll repair it if they can, and if they can't, they’ll replace it.”
I called First American and they sent a contractor. They filled the coolant up and it was working fine. They also noticed that there was a flexible pipe going into the gas feed for it. They said that’s a fire hazard. I had them replace what was necessary to make that up to code. That was outside of the terms of the home warranty, but the contractor offered to do that as an additional cost. They also said that there may be a leak but they can't tell at that time.
Less than a month ago, we thought that the AC unit was leaking again. So the contractor came out and they found that there was a valve that they replaced as part of the service that was leaking. They got everything up and going, and things are going well. First American Home Warranty is easier to work with than the other home warranty companies that I've had in the past. They don’t give me a big runaround. They’re direct and they take care of things without giving headaches or making me jump through hoops. I've recommended them to friends.
Reviewed June 19, 2017
We've had First American for 17 years now. We’ve used them in California and here, and we've had very good luck with them. We submitted a claim around a month ago for our washer that we thought was too loud. I called them and the process has been easy as always. The technician ran a couple of tests and they showed nothing, but he gave me a couple of good ideas, and I've been doing those. We liked him because he knew what he was doing, which was nice, and we had no problem. First American is one company I don’t dread calling because I can understand the people that I talk to. That makes a big deal with me.
Reviewed June 19, 2017
Received a First American Home Warranty with the purchase of our home in Dec 2016. June 3rd our AC went on the fritz and I called First American, they said I could only use their contractors, opened a claim and said the contractor had 48 hrs to call! My husband was extremely upset we were having a houseful of company as well as overnight guests. He called the company on our heat unit and he was there within 45 minutes, AC fixed within another hour! He had worked with First American before and said just submit the bill, they will cover it.
I called on 6/12 to find out about submitting the bill, and was told I did not have prior approval!! I told them I was never given an option to have someone else repair the AC. I also told him their contractor had just called my husband's phone (4 days later)! He gave me the email address for a Claim review and someone would contact me in 24 hours! 6/12 I called to see if there was any news and there is still no email in my file!! I asked for a fax # to fax my claim in! See what happens next, ready to cancel the warranty.
Reviewed June 19, 2017
We had a water heater claim. The company dispatched some plumber I'd never heard of. The guy came to "fix" the water heater and worsened the leak. All he checked was 1 of 3 fittings on the top of the unit, which made it leak twice as much. Next day, we called him back and then called First American back. They made us wait 2-3 days for the plumber to call, who demanded payment up front "because I'm tired of not getting paid."
We said that we'd be happy to pay 50% now and the balance when the job is done. He refused. First American would not give us another plumber, despite the fact that there are dozens of others in the area. It's a racket. They jew down the contractor rate and only use the one who'll do it for their reduced fee. TOTALLY stay away from First American Home Warranty - RIPOFF if there ever was one.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed June 19, 2017
I switched from another home warranty company to First American Home Warranty based on a referral and from past experiences from one of First American's customers. Dealing with them has been a very good experience. It’s been easy to open a claim and I haven’t had any issues.
Reviewed June 18, 2017
I just started my home warranty about 6 weeks ago with First American and could not be more disappointed. Last night, a Saturday night, the faucet on our bathroom sink broke and we could not turn off the water. Went to shut it off under the sink and the valve started to break so we had to stop and shut water off to the house. I immediately called and explained situation and was told that either the contractor or this company would call me back within 3 hours. After about an hour I saw that a contractor was assigned so I tried to call the contractor directly and could not reach so I called First American back and was then told that they have 8 hours to call me. After 10 hours, it was now 7am, I called again only to now be told they have 24 hours to contact me.
By this afternoon we could just not go without water in the house any longer so I called again for an update - I was told that after 8 hours I was free to contact my own company to get reimbursed since they could not find anyone but it has to go through the escalation department. I was on hold for 39 minutes while they tried to find a contractor then disconnected and had to call back.
I was transferred to Ruben in Central America who refused to transfer me to a supervisor. He was condescending and rude. He told me they close in 1 hour 15 minutes and he would only pre authorize $125 for repairs - minus the standard service call fee - a plumber on a Sunday was obviously going to cost more than that- he said we had to call their office back for authorizations for any higher amount before work was done - and then he sealed the deal - he said the office closed in 15 minutes, not 1 hour 15 minutes and he wasn't perfect for not knowing how long his department would be open for. He also said they did not call any contractors that have emergency numbers - basically they called one contractor and left a message and they never called back so I was now on my own or be without water and have to take off work tomorrow. Which was not a possibility.
$400 later I still have a broken faucet, but water to the rest of the house and I get to deal with this company tomorrow. They better make this right tomorrow - but my expectations are so low after how I was treated by so many employees, my only recourse will be to go public to warn others and possibly court.
Reviewed June 18, 2017
When we bought our house, our realtor made the sellers do a home warranty. My realtor chooses for people when they buy houses and First American is the company she automatically goes with. The sellers bought from First American Home Buyers Protection and we kept it going. I've sent claims online and over the phone before and both have been easy processes. The reps are very courteous and knowledgeable. One time when I submitted a claim, they didn't put in the right information. They didn't charge me when they came out the next time to take care of my problem. They paid the cost of the visit for me.
We've had three claims and each time has been a pleasant experience. I'm always the one that's present whenever the technicians come and they're always friendly. The last one we had was wearing rubber boots and he took them off to come in. I told him he didn't have to, but he said no and didn't wear them to the house. Most of the time, the technicians do extensive work, but last time, all the technician did was unjam something, which was quick. Overall I'm very satisfied with the work that First American does and with their people. I'd recommend them and I've given their number to other people.
Reviewed June 17, 2017
We received this home warranty thru a realtor when we bought the house a year ago. We had 1 claim so far and now our air conditioner has went out over a week ago and First American said they are unable to find a contractor to fix the HVAC. They said all the contractors were busy. It has been over 95 degrees in the house. My wife is seriously ill. But First American did not really care. They gave me the option of getting another contractor and they would reimburse up to a certain amount. Well this could run into a lot of money. I do not feel comfortable with that deal. They have violated their contract with me as far as I'm concerned. I really believe they do not have any contractors or if they do it is just a few. I have gotten nothing but the complete runaround with these people. I asked to speak to higher management they said no.
Reviewed June 17, 2017
I had put in a claim to First American for an air condition unit. Prior to them coming out, I had Acree take a look at it since I have a contract with them. They found a coil that was leaking and they filled it up with Freon. I called First American and they said, "As long as it's working, we can't do anything with it." They said when it stops working to give them a call and they will come back. They charged the $60 fee. And they said if it stopped working within 30 days that they wouldn't charge me the fee. But the 30 days has gone by. The technician was very informative and friendly. We sat and talked for quite a while about air conditioning, his company and other companies he's worked for. And he was very courteous and nice.
Reviewed June 17, 2017
I’ve always got a home warranty when I purchased my home 25 years ago and I switched to First American. My sister referred them to me because she had good experiences with them. Submitting a claim was easy because you can do it over the phone. The claims reps were professional and able to answer my questions. My refrigerator was out and the first company they gave me could not come out for a couple of days. I called back and they found me somebody that could come out that afternoon, but ended up being the next morning. But they took care of the issue, trying to find me somebody that could come out quicker. The techs that came were on time and fixed the problem quickly. They did a very good job.
Reviewed June 16, 2017
I called to place a claim 3 months ago about my furnace not working. They sent one company So Cool Solutions. The man came out, said he could not fix it. He reported back to First American and said I BROKE it. I complained back saying I did not break the Gas valve. After more than 30 phone calls over several weeks 1st American sent another company to recheck the Gas valve. He reported back in fact I did NOT break it. They sent 5h3m out another week later to fix the Gas valve. So the last several months I smelled something but the furnace. Long story short. Gas leaking in my home for the last 3 months. I called BGE. They came out, said it a major Gas leak emergency and shut the Gas down. 1st American won't take responsibility for the faulty work. This could have resulted in a Major explosion with fatalities. Said he could not fix it.
Updated on 08/03/2017: I had a faulty valve on my GAS furnace. First American sent out Ecco Tech. The guy finally arrived after 3 botched scheduled times at 9:30pm to fix the gas valve. He spent 20 minutes fixing, said he was tired, long day and done. The valve leaked gas into the home for almost 3 months. I could not tell what I was smelling. So I would air my hose out regularly. I didn't know I was saving my life as well as my neighbors’. I called BGE Emergency. To come and check the property. Upon arrival to my home they said I was very lucky the home did not explode.
First American Home has been horrible through the whole process. They sent Ecco Tech Home back out and they lied. Said they didn't do it. I've made over 90 phone calls over a two month period to some lady at Jammie ** at First American Home. She has done nothing, no repair nothing for over two months. I finally called BGE and paid to have it fixed myself. BGE Home said the repair was from the faulty valve. We could have died. This is a very negligent company. Please do not use it. Could be your families’ lives on the line.
Reviewed June 16, 2017
It's been 5 weeks since our Refrigerator went out and we still have not been reimbursed by First American for our Out of Pocket expenses totally over $700. Our Fridge was out for 3 weeks before the situation was ever addressed. Our fridge went out. We immediately called First American and were informed that we would hear from someone to fix it within 24 hours. We never heard from anyone. We had to be the ones to keep following up only to find out that they weren't calling anyone to help us nor did they care since their call center was based in the Dominican Republic. No department knew what the other department had told us. We spent countless hours on the phone trying to get resolution. We lost over $600 in food and having a family of 4 live out of coolers for 3 weeks was a terrible experience that wasn't addressed in the slightest by FA. Our contract is up in July and we will not be renewing.
Reviewed June 16, 2017
My income is limited and I was completely unfamiliar with my house. The house is not brand new, the appliances are used and I don’t know how abused they are. So I need a home warranty if I’m going to be living here and everything breaks down. It was easy submitting a claim to First American. I had my air conditioner serviced and the technician did a good job. It was a great experience. Overall, the whole process was satisfactory.
Reviewed June 16, 2017
I submit my claims over the phone, however, I need to learn to do it online because it's hard over the phone. They don’t understand my southern dialect. My recent call was a claim on my air conditioner. The first guy they sent was horrible. He promised to order a part and he'd be back but two weeks later he still hasn't come. I'm in Mississippi and it's hot down here so I called First American back and told them that I don't want the same guy to come. They said they had policies and that guy needs to finish the job but I refused. So, they told me to wait for 30 days. I would die if I had to wait for 30 days so I asked to speak to a supervisor. The guy on the phone was very accommodating and they were able to get me someone new.
The second guy that First American got also ordered a part for the A/C and unfortunately, his workers, and not him, were the ones who came and put the cord in. My A/C is upstairs in the attic and they didn't put some tubing back so when they ran some water, it leaked all onto my ceiling and garage. The guy explained to me about it and he said he would repair and make it right. I'm having him to look at it tomorrow because I'm having the same issue which started today. Other than that, he was very nice and he did everything he said he would do.
Reviewed June 15, 2017
I've had this warranty since 2007. I've never had an issue with them until I had to get my AC fixed. I had 2 bad contractors and they stuck by them! When my AC broke again, it assigned me to one of the bad contractors and they refused to find another one! They said it was impossible to change contractors because the system is automated. They told me to put in repeat request to see if the system would find me another contractor, I did that 4 times and called customer service. After expressing over and over my dissatisfaction with the contractors they finally said they could dispatch a different one. They weren't concerned that I had a poor experience and bad service from that particular contractor! They even put in one of the emails, "We actually have quality contractors"...
Reviewed June 15, 2017
I called First American when I submitted a claim and I didn't have any problems. They seemed like they have handled the claim fast and got the job done. And I'm satisfied with their work.
Reviewed June 15, 2017
With a home warranty, I can pay monthly which is much easier than making a big payment when something goes wrong. My realtor recommended First American Home Warranty and I signed up with them. I call them when submitting a claim and the representative takes the information and then have the company contact me to set up an appointment. But there has been a couple of times when they the claims department was busy and they told me to leave my phone number and they called me back. And that worked well. I have always gotten very prompt service but I am dissatisfied with the plumber they sent a long time ago. I kept telling First American that I don’t want that particular plumber but somehow he's always at the top of the list when I need plumbing. I had this plumber before and I was satisfied but he didn’t back his employer. And he left me in a bigger mess than I was to begin with. After that, I didn’t want to mess with him. First American finally sent somebody else out and he did a great job.
With the exception of the plumber, I’ve had very good experience with their technicians. They cleaned up after themselves and I'm very satisfied with the quality of their work. I had a technician come out in December to fix my range but the check has never come through the bank and I keep getting letters from the collection agency. I need to write a letter to the collection agency because I've got a paid receipt and I'd be more than glad to half the cost of the shipping payment and then pay the rest of it. But I can't get hold of anybody. It's a Sears technician and they keep transferring me to a phone call in some other state and the last time I talked to them, they said I had to deal directly with the collection agency. So I need to get it out because it would make my bank account much happier to have it all cleared up. But overall, I have been very pleased of what First American did.
Reviewed June 14, 2017
If you want to witness the pinnacle of deflection and avoidance exhibited by modern customer service, look no further. I've been attempting to obtain the phone number of a human employee to help me with an issue for two days now. The wait goes on, as they refuse to supply me with one. It's actually quite comical.
Reviewed June 14, 2017
First American Home Warranty has the best coverage. They don't have a cap on their policy regarding air conditioning unlike other warranty companies do. I usually call when submitting claims and their people are pleasant and accommodating. They genuinely try to help and they're apologetic if there's a problem. We had dealt with their claims rep regarding a plumbing issue. We had upgraded faucets and they needed to be replaced. They said that they will replace it but only with a standard low-grade faucet. So, I chose to do a buy-out and it ended up being $69 for the two faucets. The $69 was fine but I didn’t like that they won’t pay for the plumber to install the replacement faucets. The plumbing company had done everything to tell me that it was not covered. I called the warranty company and they said that it is covered. So, I'm in limbo if I have an outstanding problem right now and it has to do with plumbing.
Some of the techs that came were better than the others. We had such a negative experience with the plumbing issue but we got it taken care of. The plumber wanted to cut into my wall and my husband asked, "You don't really have to do that, do you?" They found another way around so it turned out okay. When I get an ongoing issue with the plumbing again, it'll be the third time they come out with the bathtub. But, they said they're going to get it taken care of.
First American Home Warranty is still the top of the line warranty company over others. Through the years, I've had bad experiences with several other companies so overall, First American has the best record as far as getting back to you or having their technicians to get back with you in a timely manner versus not hearing anything for several days. Through the years, we've gone back and forth with First American and were back with them again. They're the best. I would definitely recommend them to my friend and to my client.
Reviewed June 14, 2017
I filed a claim 5/16/17 due to my AC not cooling. They sent someone out who stated I needed a new TXV as well as freon. The tech from Grady's A.C, added the freon and stated he'd be back when the part came in. 2 days later he "replaced" the part, which he charged my Home Warranty for, however never even replaced the part which I discovered a few days later when the ac stopped working again. I contacted First American again and they said they'd send someone out, which they did Mango's Residential Services. My evaporator coil needed replacement due to leaks/holes, First American has agreed to pay for the evaporator coil however stated that I had over 1k worth of non-covered services needed: $120 Haul away, $200 secondary drain, $80 duct insulation, $90 copper, $ 250 2 float switches, $175 transition modification, $120 PVC modifications, $175 Plenum however my contract states these items are covered.
They are no longer answering my calls, I'm being sent to voicemail, and when given the option to push 0 for an operator, I'm told an operator is unavailable! Mind you, I live in Texas where our temperature is already in the 90's. I am amazed that First American Home Warranty Co is still operating in Texas even though they refuse to honor my contract. I will NOT be renewing my contract!!!
Reviewed June 14, 2017
My realtor got me First American when I purchased my house and since I've had it, I have submitted two claims. I did them online and it was a very, very easy process. Dealing with the technician was very positive and everything was done really well. I thought they were a scam at first but my experience with them has been very positive and I anticipate renewing it once my year is up. It's a really good product and it has a great value.
Reviewed June 13, 2017
I understand that service takes some time; service call made, service provider responds and assess, recommendation sent to First American Home Warranty, authorization made, parts purchased and sent, service provider collects parts and completes repairs. My problem is when FAHW tells me parts are ordered and will be here in two days and in two days I find out they haven't been ordered until today; I get a little disappointed. I have to vacate my house until the repairs are complete due to the current 100+ temperatures in the desert. When asked if FAHW can expedite the part order they indicate they cannot. Let's see. One week displacement in a hotel at my cost is getting old. Please make sure you review this company and others before you commit.
Reviewed June 13, 2017
I have had a great experience with another home warranty company so was excited to have a warranty on my new home. First American has been a horrible experience. I have had four claims this year and none have been covered. The poor contractors that they hire are very apologetic and you can hear them on the phone begging them to cover the claim and describing in great detail why it should be covered and you typically hear someone with a foreign accent telling them no. Having this warranty has cost me money. Go elsewhere. BEWARE.
Reviewed June 13, 2017
First American was on this home when we bought it, and the first couple of times we used it, we were extremely satisfied. They've been very prompt, honest, and knowledgeable, and my claims have been taken care of quickly. The technicians who had been here have been very good. I’ve never had to call somebody to come back and redo something or continue doing it because they didn’t do a good job. It’s been good work every time. However, some contractors don’t always call like they’re supposed to but it's not First American's fault. That has been very few though and when that goes on, I tell First American and they've done well trying to correct the problem. I’ve already recommended First American to some other people.
Reviewed June 13, 2017
When I purchased the house, the First American warranty was part of the deal, and I stuck with it once it expired. They’ve been helpful and everything’s been satisfactory. The technicians are responsive and come within 24 hours. They diagnosed the problems and then solved it. I had one issue with the last claim I submitted but there was a computer glitch and the plumbing company never received it. I had to call, but other than that, it’s been good and that wasn’t a big deal. Unfortunately, there’s a negative perception about home warranties. People expect a lot more than what they pay for, but as long as they educate themselves about warranties, they’re gonna have a good overall experience. And, I’ve had that so far.
Reviewed June 12, 2017
We just bought the house about a month ago and the previous owners had First American and so we took over their policy. The sales reps were great and I told them that everything is in order, quick and great, so far. Last week, our air conditioner broke down and the guy from First American came over right away. There was a squeaky sound from the fan and he said that the motor was bad. I left him for five minutes and he was done. He came over all the way to Titusville, Orlando, and then just lubricated the fan. I paid him $75 service charge.
Three days later, the air conditioner completely broke down in this hot weather and I hoped the same guy is coming again. He knew something was not right and the A/C would break down soon but he didn’t fix it. That's the thing that I didn't like because if somebody already knew that something is wrong, I would like them to fix it for me. He said I won't need to pay again since it was a recall but I had to wait for him for three or four days later and it's so hot. Other than that, the service is great.
Reviewed June 12, 2017
We've had First American ever since we were selling a house several years ago. We had one contractor last year that wasn’t the sharpest, but overall the service has been good. The First American reps have done a good job and we're very happy. We'd recommend them.
Reviewed June 11, 2017
I've been having AC problems since last year. After multiple service calls, out of pocket fees that aren't covered by First American, and now hotel fees they still can't seem to fix the issues going on. After contacting First American the answer I get from them is that my claim isn't a priority because I'm not in extreme weather. I live in Arizona and my home is over 90 degrees. I don't know about them but I know at those temperatures I sure am not staying in that home with an 8, 6, and 2 year old. According to them they will only reimburse the hotel if I have an infant or there is a senior living with me. After paying them the yearly fee, the service fees, the out of pocket fees, and the hotel fees I could have just called a contractor and could have fixed my AC unit without First American.
I don't know how they are still in business. It makes me wonder they are quickly to collect money and won't do any service if they aren't paid but they fail to perform their responsibilities. I was already with no air for 2 weeks November of last year but in June, no thank you First American. I'll find someone else to fix the problem because clearly this company and the contractors they hire are incompetent.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed June 11, 2017
We got our First American Home Warranty when we purchased our house. It was the homeowner’s warranty that was offered. When we had an issue with our heater, we got all the paperwork and went online to file a claim. My wife filled out the information needed. A couple of days later, somebody called. We set up an appointment to have someone to come out. They told us that they’ll be here between 8:00 and 9:00 or 1:00 and 5:00. The technicians showed up on time in their window. However, the heating element that has gone out on our furnace was not available. We've had the cold snap remain.
The technicians got the report and put it in. Fortunately, the weather warmed up and we didn’t need the heater anymore. The technicians then replaced the bar and the heater was working fine. Hopefully, when it gets cold again and we turn the heater on, it would work fine. We also had another guy come out for an electrical problem. Both the technicians who came here were punctual and professional, and did their job in a timely manner. The quality of their work has been very good and everything is working like it should.
Reviewed June 11, 2017
I have bought a new home here and whenever I buy one, I always get a home warranty. I went out and picked First American Home Warranty and so far, I've been successful in submitting a claim. Their process has been very easy, the claims representative has been very professional and very helpful and the technicians provided good service. The repairs and quality of work were good but I had an issue with the length of time to get the parts. It took me about six weeks to get the last repair I had because first, the part that was ordered was incorrect and then when the parts have come, they're saying I have to wait to be scheduled with the contractors. Nevertheless, I was satisfied overall.
Reviewed June 10, 2017
A/C Repair. I was generally happy with the service. The contractor was great and very professional but I had to pay for a coil cleaning that was $195.00 that was not included in my policy. I thought I had the most complete policy available. First American said someone would contact me about the mix up but they never did.
Reviewed June 10, 2017
My sister said she had a very good experience with First American. So far, I’ve had a real good experience with them, too. I had a home warranty with some of the other companies before and First American is a lot better because they come right away and they handle stuff a lot quicker than some of the other ones. Submitting a claim was efficient and the reps handled the claims well. They took my information and I told them what appliances are messed up. And it didn’t take the contractors very long to call me. And the claim reps also called me after the guy they sent out did the repair and asked me how did the guys do.
The technicians were really good, as well. However, I did have a bit of a problem with Best Services. I was told that all I had to do was pay $60 for the trip. They came out and when they got through doing the work, they charged me an extra $190 for something. But other than that, I haven’t had a problem with them. And the quality of work has been good, too. We just had a little bit of an issue when they installed the hot water heater. I had a low pressure after they left. But the technician came back out a couple of weeks and got that taken care of for me. I was pleased with First American when they sent him back out to get my pressure back up. My expectation with them has been very good. I wouldn’t go with another one. I would stay with them as long as I can.
Reviewed June 10, 2017
I've had First American for years now. I call them, they put in a claim, the problem gets fixed, and the claim experience is good. The work performed is great so I keep renewing every year. The overall experience has been good and I recommend them.
Reviewed June 10, 2017
First American was part of my package for my home purchase and so far, I'm pretty pleased with them. My thermostat was installed incorrectly and needed to be fixed. I submitted my claim online with First American and within 24 hours, I got a call with my scheduled date and time, and they answered all my questions, too. I was taken care of within five business days. The technician came, explained to me what was going on and even showed me how to fix it then and there. It was a simple and a quick fix and was on his way in a matter of ten minutes. The thermostat is working great now. Overall, I like the quickness and the effectiveness of First American's service.
Reviewed June 9, 2017
We have been customers of First American Home Warranty for six years and their customer service has become a living nightmare. We are a military family, we are working public service professionals, and human. They have left me personally feeling as though our loyalty as customers has meant absolutely nothing and for that I believe they are a terrible business.
We had a problem with our washing machine. I contacted FA through the website and set up a claim to have it repaired. The first contractor came to our residence about 48 hours later. Firstly, the contractor's personal hygiene was totally inappropriate. Secondly, he assessed what the problem was, informed us that a part needed to be ordered to fix the washing machine yet left our laundry room a complete mess. He said once the part is ordered, they would contact us. He noted it should only take a day or two. We paid the deductible. After 7 days passed by I contacted the contractor and after no response I contacted FA about not being notified by the contractor via web and the contractor called us a day later and said they would be at our residence the next day during a certain time frame.
The day of the appointment I took off work and remained at my home. About an hour after the initial appointment time passed, I got a notification saying that I had a voicemail but I did not have a missed called (neither is there a record of a missed call from the contractor on my phone records). His message was for me to call him because he was en route to my residence. When I called him he told me because I did not respond within 30 minutes (I got his message exactly 1 hour later) he had to move on to the next customer.
The first problem is that no one stated that before that point. Secondly, I was confused because they did not need to give a window for their arrival and should have set a definite time. When I called FA, the customer service rep told me that the contractor said they tried to call several times and there was no answer. I asked FA to reassign the case to another contractor because I was not comfortable with that contractor being in my home. They reassigned the claim to Sears. Another 48 hours has to go by before someone can come to our residence. Sears has a policy that someone 18 years or older needs to be at home when a repair shows up. No problem, our oldest daughter was home that day with our two youngest.
When the service man showed up and ring the bell, my 11 year old answered the door. The service man decides that there are no adults home and leaves before my 18 year old gets to the front door (literally within seconds). When my daughter informs me that the service man left, I immediately called FA. When I spoke to FA customer service and they called Sears, they clicked by over to me and said the service man said there wasn't anyone at the residence. By now I am completely frustrated.
I ask them to get someone, anyone who can come fix our washing machine. They reassign it to another company and tell me that the company will be at my residence between 10 am and 12 pm two days later. I take off work and no one shows up again. When I called FA they ask me to hold on so they can talk to the contractor. After waiting several minutes FA informs me that the contractor stated the appt. was set up for a day later. At the same exact time, the contractor called me on the other line and asked if they could come to our home the next day. I was really confused by that, nevertheless I agree on the next day. FA had the times they communicated to me in their notes.
The new contractor is a no show yet again. When I called FA I was told that they reassigned the claim to a 4th contractor because the contractor could not perform the service. I asked why they had not called me to inform me of that and I was told that "FA does not have process to inform customer of these changes. Customers must call in to be informed". Of course I said that does not make any sense. FA customer service asked me to hold on so they can get my appt. scheduled. I told them I would reach out to the contractor directly myself. When I called the contractor the VM message says they are currently closed due to a flood in their area.
This all started on May 24th and today is June 9th. We have paid the deductible and have paid our monthly fee and no work has been performed. To add insult to injury, I received a contract renewal from FA for the next year. I called FA to cancel the renewal and when asked why I explained everything I wrote about and they wanted to help us have a better experience. Unfortunately, that was between contractor 3 and 4. I explicitly said that I am not comfortable renewing a contract with an agency that has provided such shoddy service. I told the representative I spoke with that I would be willing to reconsider if they could deliver on the work needed. The work as of this day has not been completed.
So far: I have paid the expected deductible ($65) and the monthly warranty fee. I or someone over 18 has been at my residence during all of the times that contractors were supposed to show up. My washer is still not fixed. If I simply focused on the payment issue alone, First American is in breach of its contractual duty under the warranty agreement. I am going to try and find another means to get our washer fixed but I may have to sue First American to recover the damages plus attorney fees as well, dependent upon how excessive the cost is. First American customer service processes are horrible and obviously the contractors you all use also fall into the same category as well.
Reviewed June 9, 2017
I got First American Home Warranty when I bought my home. The claims experience was easy. I called their number, they asked me what the problem was and I gave them the problem that I was having. They told me the solutions to the problem that I had and the price and then they sent someone out. The technicians were fine and they told me what the problem was. It was an easy feat. They were here for no more than 20 minutes and got the job done. And their work was efficient and good. First American does the part like they say they'd do. I was very satisfied with the overall experience because the insurance saved me a lot of money and the pain of the going rate for what they came for and did.
Reviewed June 9, 2017
I'm a first time home buyer and I got First American. Their claim process was pretty easy. All I did was call and they set it up with one of their vendors. Their vendor then gave me a call and set up a time to meet. The technician was very good.
Reviewed June 8, 2017
I'm a realtor and the company I work for used another company years ago. I had bad results with that company. I continued to use them just because that's the only thing that was in town at the time. Then I heard about this girl named Maryann. She started doing talks at the Association of Realtors and I met her and she impressed me. She takes care of her realtors, the homeowners, and even the buyers. I tried to talk all the sellers into listing when they list it to put one on the property. In case something happens, they'll have it and it will be covered. And that's why I'm with First American.
When I submitted a claim, I called and told them that I need the water heater fixed. The claims rep was very courteous and gave me the S&S company and number. I called the company and the guy said that he cannot tell when he can get to my house to do the repair, and this was at 8 o’clock in the morning. I asked him if he has a schedule of what he's gonna do that day and the next. He said he can't tell me anything until he gets back to his office and would call back in 15 minutes. I waited an hour and a half, he still didn't give me a phone call. So I called him back and he can never give me his schedule. In my opinion, First American doesn’t need to have somebody like that on their list of providers. I called up First American and canceled that and got who I wanted to come out.
I used the contractor that previously came out on another plumbing issue and the guy's great. He knew exactly what to do, told me when the part would be in and exactly when he'd come back out to repair it. The quality of work was very good. I'm happy with First American and I wouldn't have my warranty with anybody else. Not only did I recommended them to friends but every deal that I do, I try to get that warranty in there.
Reviewed June 8, 2017
It was very easy submitting a claim with First American. It was late when everything happened so I sent it online and it was easy to navigate the website. It was just a circuit switch that was off and the technician clicked it on so the problem was solved. But by doing that, it shows that they went through their procedures correctly. That was my first experience with First American and it was good. They're quick and they show their concern. The cost was very inexpensive too. It was $55, which was very reasonable.
Reviewed June 8, 2017
My home insurance provider has First American Home Warranty and told me really good things about the company. The guys that I dealt with from First American were amazing. They communicated with me every step of the way. It was really easy to submit a claim to them. I was comfortable and knew what I was getting when some of the appliance didn't work. When the air conditioning stopped working, I filed a claim and the claims representatives were a little difficult to understand because they didn’t speak proper English, but I got to figure it out. Then they sent two gentlemen who were very friendly and understanding. They called ahead of time to see if I was home. And they showed up on time. They did everything just right and it was perfect. They didn't leave a mess too. They explained the work that they did and the air conditioning is holding up pretty good.
Reviewed June 7, 2017
I sell real estate. I've sold a few warranties and seen how those work well for our clients and so I got one for myself. I'm very satisfied with what First American Home Warranty has done. They fixed everything that needed fixing. They also used to give real estate agents an incentive, but RESPA decided that we shouldn't get the incentive anymore. Most of the time it's easy to submit a claim. I always do it over the phone. I’ve had mostly positive experiences with First American’s claims representatives and the technicians they sent out. I’m happy with the quality of the technicians’ work as well. However, there's been a couple of experiences I had with them that weren't positive, but I reported them and the issue has been resolved.
Reviewed June 7, 2017
We called for a claim for a plumbing issue, and it went okay. First American called fairly quickly to make an appointment, and the technician that came over did a good job.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
I don't know where to start. I had two opened tickets with them in last three months and both experiences were just horrible. Each took over a month to resolve the issue and I spent the average of 20 min to 40 min to contact with them at least three times a week. Every time I spoke to them, they were giving me different answers. I even brought it with their complaint department, but they weren't acknowledging the issue.
With the last ticket, they were offering me a $20 cash out to fix my AC unit which didn't make any sense because the contractor couldn't provide their license and insurance to gain the access to the roof where AC unit was located. Also, they just didn't want to deal with the situation. At the end she just read me the terms and condition of the cash out even though I kept saying I don't agree to accept the cash-out, she just hung up on me. I am just exhausted from the experience. I spent too much of my time and energy for no reason. Avoid while you can.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you
Reviewed June 6, 2017
Received this warranty with the purchase of my home. I have one AC unit over 21 years old that start having an issue and called the warranty company. They sent technicians which reported that the evaporator coil needs to be replaced. I was totally fine with that until they come back to me with an uncovered fee of $600 for modifications on the system. I got another tech to look at it and estimated the repair for $800 for part and $500 for labor and there was no modifications needed to be done. He also suggested that since the unit is too old and take R-22 refrigerant which will be phased out soon he advised to consider replacing all together.
I sent the paperwork of the estimate to the warranty company but they come up saying either I pay the deductibles and get it done or take a payout of about $450 and call it a day. I don't know what to do now and I am stuck with a dead AC unit. I hope this helps other people make their decision when considering this warranties.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
Memphis Air Care was sent to repair my AC by First American Home Warranty. To start, it has been three weeks since my air went out. Memphis Air Care diagnosed a broken furnace and blower at the initial review (~2 weeks ago). I was told it could be up to $1500 for "modifications" to have the new furnace installed. Sure enough, MAC shows up today with a $1500 bill (not including any damage they do getting the unit into my attic). Keep in mind, this is ONLY the furnace unit - no coils, no condenser. I've had entire AC units replaced for less labor than this. They wanted $650 to re-reroute an exhaust pipe, and that's just the beginning. Steer clear of MAC and First American.
Hello Mike,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
First American Home Warranty has no time table for repairs on your service request. I had a dryer that I called in for service. It took a week to get a repairman out to look at it. I was told I needed a part which he would order and would probably come in the next day. That was over two weeks ago. In that time, I have called the contractor several times and left messages. No return call. I have called First American 8 times. They will not dispatch a new contractor because they do not want to have to cover the $65 service fee. They keep telling me that they have contacted the contractor and will call me back to tell me when he will show. They don't call back and I have to call to get the same BS. I have spent a fortune taking clothes for a family of 6 to the laundromat. This is not an isolated incident. First American uses the cheapest contractors who have proven to be unreliable time and time again.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
I've had no problems submitting claims with First American. Their technicians have been really good but they had to fix my washing machine several times. The first two times, they didn't do the job because they were fixing the wrong point. But the last guy they sent from Sears knew what was going on and ended up fixing it right. Since then, we've had no problems with the washing machine.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
First American Home Buyers Protection is fabulous. I’m very well pleased with it and I intend to keep it if I can. I have had experience with other insurance policies but this so far has far outdone the others. They had to come in and repair the furnace and the dishwasher and do some plumbing work. I’ve had four different people come in. Two of them were from Sears and two were from other companies. Every one of them has functioned greatly. They just did what was necessary and got it done quickly. The companies so far that they’ve sent have been really good. All of them have been professionals. We, at this point, don’t have any more things that we need fixing. Everything’s great.
Reviewed June 6, 2017
I've had First American since 2003 since I bought my home. I continually tell everybody about it. I usually submit claims online and in person. It's more personal to me and they're always really nice, receptive. As far as the process to call them and get that going, it's very easy. I had appliances come out since I got this home like for my washer and dryer and they've been really nice.
The last time they were here it was my washer was leaking and so the guy went in and replaced the water pump. He said it's good but then, I load the laundry and five minutes later, there's water gushing all over my garage. I called him back and he said he'll come right back out and gonna finish it. He said we had another leak in it. It's the hose that's behind the washer which has to be ordered. It's gonna take a few days and I said it was fine. As soon as he got it, he called me. He said he'll be right out. He came out and got it fixed. That was so great. Considering all the washer and dryer takes minor repair, it's good to go again and again.
Another issue was my sink in my kitchen was leaking. On The Spot Plumbing came out and they said it's that little tub that catches everything, I call it a drain, that's leaking. They fixed it, they left and by the end of that afternoon or a couple of days later, I put a washcloth down there, I reached to get and it was soaking wet again. I called them back and they sent a very young and quiet guy. He said he fixed it, that he put some more putty around and it's good to go. But two days go by and it's still leaking. The guy came out and he said it wasn't just leaking from there. It's from underneath the hose that connects it. Around that time I left to Denver, I was gone for about a week, I get back and it's still leaking.
The guy said that he believes that the leak is coming from the actual faucet. He called First American and they said they don't replace the faucet. I told him he's been here four times and now, he's telling me that it's the faucet. I called him back because of the note he left and they said immediately that it wasn't the faucet but they put on it that it was. I don't understand that lingo so I asked to be called back and that they explain that to me.
I already know based on their note that they're not gonna replace the faucet so, I know that’s something I need to get. But I'm thinking I don't want to get a faucet or put anything new and then they come back and tell me that line's broken. This was supposed to be a big repair job and it hasn't been handled properly. The plumbing company has never even called me back to explain that situation. I'm not being disappointed with First American but very disappointed with that particular contractor. My disappointment was that he was a master plumber and he should have been able to catch that as far as the faucet from the very get go.
Each visit was already covered as far as the cost. It's ongoing and I'm still to get a new faucet. I'm sitting here thinking if I'd go to Home Depot and get the faucet. There's gonna be extensive cost now to me and I looked into the cost of a faucet. I don't want them to come out to install it and say there are all these nets underneath here. This guy left it like that and what I was asking from him was to give me the courtesy of calling me back, explaining to me what happened, what didn't happen and what do I need to do but he's never called back. If this was something that was not covered on my plan then obviously he would have been the first one that I would get to do the job. That's an additional job for their company but he didn't so I will not use their company.
But overall, I would rate First American really high. They've done their part in taking care of my home and my appliances and everything that I've needed. Everyone's been really good. They come out, they'll always say it's a $55 or $65 charge and I am totally aware of that. So they calmly do their business and it's good to go. They have replaced air conditioners, broken toilet and things like that. It's just that this one issue has not been resolved and I am troubled with more for the contractor than First American.
Reviewed June 5, 2017
My AC went out on April 22nd 2017 and today is June 5th 2017 and it's still not fixed. They ordered the part twice and both times the part came in damaged. When I call them (almost everyday) they tell me there is nothing they can do about it and they have no timetable as when my AC will be fixed. I'm the homeowner but I'm renting my house out and I had to dish out over 600 bucks due to the fact that the tenants had to be put in a hotel due to the heat wave. Each time they order the part it takes about two weeks to get here and now they're ordering it again for a third time. They obviously don't care about the well being of the family living in the house because they would've had to part sent overnight and had the AC immediately fixed. That's not the case and they're taking their sweet time. I've had a bad experience with them and wouldn't recommend them to anyone.
Hello Furqan, We appreciate your feedback. At this time, we are aware that your air conditioner has been repaired. Thanks, Shanee
Reviewed June 5, 2017
We’ve had warranty every time we purchased a house and someone recommended First American Home Warranty, so I switched. The service fee was less and then they had more coverage. But they’re changing to match everybody else as well. I’ve had it for a couple of years now and I have called for different things. I haven't had any issues submitting a claim. The process is easy and the representatives were nice and helpful. When the air conditioner wasn't cooling, the technician that came out was fine but he didn’t do too much. He just recharged it and we're waiting to see if the problem occurs quickly and if there’s an additional problem. But overall, I don’t have any issues with First American.
Reviewed June 5, 2017
I have a couple of things that are not working in my house but I don’t call First American to fix them because every time I call, it costs me $65. The air conditioning was leaking water from the roof so I called the air conditioning technician. He came and said it's not the air conditioning, it's the gutter. So, I ended up paying $65 and nothing happened. There's still a leak from the roof. Also, I have a problem with the ice maker. The water is not getting to the icemaker and that can be resolved very easily with some technical thing, but I don't know how to do it. So, if I call somebody, it's going to cost me $65. I recommend them and I have them on my other property but there are tiny problems that could be resolved for very little money and every call is $65.
Reviewed June 4, 2017
I had an issue last year with my kitchen. There was a hot water pipe leaking in the outside wall. First American would only pay for the part of the galvanized pipe that was leaking, which was a couple of feet, and the only way they would pay was for me to take out the whole wall and the cabinets, which I had to do and found mold. My homeowner's insurance kicked in and fixed the whole kitchen. The plumber said it would be stupid to tear out the whole wall, fix just the leaking part of the pipe, put the whole wall in the kitchen back together and have it leak again. I needed to replace the whole pipe, but nobody would pay for the rest, so I had to pay $600 out of my pocket. It upset me that they wouldn't fix the whole pipe.
My oven was the latest claim I had with First American and it was a wall over with a microwave on top and an oven on the bottom. The microwave started sparking and got really hot. The repairman told me not to use it and First American said they would replace it, but it was hard to replace because they don't make too many of those anymore. They found and got it though it took a month and a week for the whole process. They were supposed to haul the old oven off and the guys wouldn't take it, so it’s sitting out on my curb in my yard. The woman from First American called me and said she was gonna get those guys back out here because they were supposed to carry it off.
I also had a lot of problems with my ice box and it still isn't fixed. I got tired of having them come out here. Now I'm gonna have to get them out for my dryer. It was overheating last year and it's doing it again. Every time they come out, it's $65. It used to be $35. I can understand that, but still. And before, I had trouble getting through to them and had to hold on the phone forever, but their service has improved in the last year with the phones and the emails. Now, I can at least email and it takes a day to get a response back. If it's not an emergency, it's okay.
I've had First American since 1999, and they're pretty good. They take a long time sometimes but I'm satisfied and will continue to use them. They are better than some of the other ones. Overall, the insurance has paid for itself over the years. They replaced an air conditioner, the garbage disposal, and the trash compactor. They fixed the leaking pipes in my house, they've done some plumbing repairs over the years and they've worked on the ice box a lot. It's better than not having any kind of insurance because it does get expensive.
Reviewed June 4, 2017
I had First American Home Warranty on the house when we bought it and we just continued it. It worked fine. We used the online ordering system and then within two days, they called back. We had a problem with the garage door that needed to be fixed urgently. We couldn't open the door at all. We had to call back and get a different provider because they couldn't come right away and we couldn't wait a couple of days for that. We were able to do that and get it fixed the same day. I've also had problems with the dryer and they had to come back a couple of times because they couldn't find what was wrong. But, they ended up fixing it. It has all turned out well. It has been all favorable. Once we got them fixed, like the dryer that had strange issues, it has been fine since then.
Reviewed June 4, 2017
I bought a house, which included a warranty from First American. I normally submit a claim online and it has been easy. I had good interactions with their customer service representatives and the technicians who came too. The technicians were an hour late each time, though. But as a whole, it was a fine experience with First American.
Reviewed June 3, 2017
If you don't mind pay a little bit more this company is a good choice. They have good service and professional contractor. The only thing I concerned if the service fee will keep going up every year...
Reviewed June 3, 2017
The case manager of First American, the person I dealt with a lot of times, was very engaged, proactive and she did a great job. We have six rental properties and there’s something for our rental property that we had to do. And I like submitting a claim online. It’s very user-friendly. Even if somebody is not tech-savvy, you still can do it and manage your way around the site. Being online, you could all get information or feedback. It’s good and I’m happy with everything.
The technicians that they sent have also been professional. They try to give you a courtesy call 30 minutes prior but sometimes, it doesn’t always work. But they’d get to you when they can. They just don’t want to be tied to something that they can’t perform as well. So I understand that aspect of it. But I wish it was less than a four-hour window because I’m always moving. But I’ve been happy with everybody that came out.
However, there’s a certain AC company that my wife does not like. They haven’t given us the best thing. The job is done but there are some nuances that the wife doesn’t like. If I put a work order in and their name pops up, we cancel it or we call immediately and try to get somebody else. But overall, there are people that do the job very well and with the majority of everything, we’re very pleased. I’ll recommend First American to anybody.
Reviewed June 3, 2017
I've been a member of First American Home Warranty for a few years. I submit claims online so it's pretty easy. The technicians are very responsive and everything has been right on. The quality of their work has been very good too. Everything has been done pretty well.
Reviewed June 2, 2017
We've had good experience with First American. We've always had a home warranty ever since we built our home. We were first with another company and after hearing about First American, we checked the website and studied the difference of what they would provide on their coverage. The cost per coverage was the same but First American gave us a better deal and so we decided to switch to them. First American is a very good company to be with and we appreciate their coverage on the items in our home and outside.
The only bad experience we’ve had with them was when we had problems with the sink area with the disposal. The technician they sent was located an hour and a half out from where we live. It was entirely too far and the number of days between the problem and their schedule to come out and fix it were too many. The disposal and the dishwasher was a one-line type thing. So when they came they didn't fix it, because they said it wasn't their problem. They said that it was a plumbing problem, because it was also leaking under there. But it really wasn't the disposal leaking, it was the line going to the dishwasher from the disposal. All of the rest have been good. As far as refrigerator, pool and the other claims, we are happy with our experience.
Reviewed June 2, 2017
I used to have another home warranty company and I was looking for someone that was a little less expensive. I saw First American's advertisement on the television and I went from there. The thing that's interesting is that I've been getting good service because a lot of the companies that the other outfit use, are the same ones that First American use. Submitting a claim was not a difficult process and I did it over the phone. The interactions with First American were good. They are an exceptional company and they're treating me well.
Reviewed June 2, 2017
I got First American Home Warranty first from the previous owner of the home that we got and have had them for a couple of years. Claim submission was fairly easy. I call it in, make arrangements with the provider then they come by. They fixed a water heater problem the first time. They fixed it and it worked for a few days but after a week or two I called them again as we were having problems with it. The water heater has two heating element, they replaced one the first time and the other one burnt out about a few days later. Evidently they took care of it the second time because it's been working. Their technician was friendly and didn't have any issues in getting to work on the problem.
Reviewed June 2, 2017
First American's price per service call was competitive with others. And typically, I go online to submit a claim and it was an easy process. Their customer service is quite good. I had to call them once because their contacts didn't call us in time. But, they were able to resolve our situation for us. I'm renting out our home and the tenants were happy with the repair work done by the technicians sent by First American.
Reviewed June 1, 2017
When I bought my home 10 years ago, the previous owner had First American. I am still single and I'm not very handy. It helps to know that when something happens in the house, I have a reliable service to call. I like the coverage and the service has been good so I kept it. Also, I looked to get two other companies at some point but I felt that the service that FA offered was still better so, I stayed. Submitting claims has been fast and they are really responsive. One time, I had a problem with my furnace and it was winter and really cold. But even during the late hour, I was able to get someone to come to my home, make sure that the repair was done quickly and my heat was restored. I like that.
Also, the reps have always been understanding, really kind and pleasant. I feel like the service is with the customer in mind and I like that. I've called for several different services and everybody's been able to explain the repair or whatever needs to be done in layman's terms so, that way, I can understand it. They also always seem to do what they can to make sure that the service is covered under my warranty. Everybody and everything has been good and I haven't had any problems.
Last September, my washer went out and Christina, the girl who handled my claim from start to finish, was excellent and her service was phenomenal. From the moment I called and put the claim in, she repeatedly called me to make sure that I sent the documentation and that I could get a new washer without any problem. She called me before the check was sent to me after the check was sent to me and the follow up was good. It was really a pleasant experience and I can't say enough good things about her. They have excellent customer service.
Reviewed June 1, 2017
Our First American Home Warranty came with the house when we bought it. Submitting a claim with them was all okay. I did it over the phone for the water heater and pest control. Their claims representatives and the technicians who came over answered my questions and were professional. The technicians also tidied up after doing their work.
Reviewed May 31, 2017
First American Home Warranty came with the house that I have purchased. I have several properties with them right now. I continued working with them because the policies were already in place and I'm already acquainted with them. Recently, submitting a claim hasn't been too bad unlike years ago, it was worse. It was difficult. I have submitted some so it has gotten great. I do it over the phone. The reps were very helpful. After the questions were answered, I see if there is any way I could fix the problem myself. Whether it was rinsing a drain thing from the dishwasher and rinsing the basket.
The techs in Las Vegas were good but the ones in California, one of them almost killed us. That one was same one that came out several times prior trying to fix the same water heater. It had to do with a gas of the water heater, it kept messing up. She went for a month having it off because he kept coming back every 10 days because it wasn't working. My mom was trying to rib some way to make it work. She showed me what she had to do to turn on the water heater and it was scary. I said, "Mom, that's not right either." She got really upset. She was losing sleep over being annoyed with these people.
They put the wrong kind of valve on it and I smelled gas in the place. This is in Ventura on my Englewood property. Good thing I opened the windows because my mother wasn't there. I was at her house visiting. I said, "Whats that smell?" She thought it was her pet that peed and it smelled. We just couldn't find it. It's a manufacturing home and our lives were at risk because of the water heater company that they sent out. The technicians sucked, almost killed us. My mom had already cried and argued with him over so many times trying to get him out. It was terrible. That was also bad because I had the First American fire protection and they weren't protective. It was obstructive and dangerous. They'll send out whoever, whatever. They don't care if they have an education or what.
The same thing happened with the heater at my brother's property. It took them forever to get the heater fixed when it broke. I had this house for seven years and I had tenants. They had children and they're cold in the winter time. I tried to send them space heaters to keep them warm until the service man can get there. I've had the warranty for several years with First American so they sent out an HVAC guy who claimed that there was a dead cockroach in the wires and claimed that the cockroach chewed the wire. He went and charged me about $1,800 for a new unit. I was so mad at him saying, "How dare you call and try to rip me off like that?" He even tried to charge me $4,000. He wanted to sell me a new unit and had any excuse in the world not to cover it. I never heard of a cockroach eating through a wire.
They don't bet the people that they send out very well. They just say, "Oh they have a license? Check!" They don't realize that these people are trying not to cover because they want to milk us literally. I would tell my friends to get it at their own risk because some things they cover, somethings they don't. It depends. Las Vegas has a better service. They repair a little better but California and Texas are scary. My brother who is a lawyer used to have it on his rental house in McKinney, Texas. He got off of the warranty because he got tired of dealing with them.
Reviewed May 30, 2017
It's been ten years and everything has been good with First American. Filing claims online has been easy and interactions with their reps have been fine, as well. Also, the technicians have been good and the quality of their work has been fine. I haven't had any issues.
Reviewed May 29, 2017
I had two properties and have both of them covered by First American. Claim submission has been wonderful and everything was resolved quickly. Their claims rep has been very good and their technician was very friendly, informative and resolved the problem efficiently. Another home warranty company approached me with prices better than First American where there was a difference of maybe $10 or $8 per month. I had talked and considered them but because of the wonderful service with First American I said, "Well, I'm gonna be going nowhere." They were efficient and easy. I have recommended them to a friend of mine.
Reviewed May 28, 2017
I had another warranty and it was going up on the trade call. I didn't want to pay at the time so I decided to switch. I had information about First American so I switched to them. Submitting a claim through First American has been smooth. Making the call, getting the claim and giving information about the people who would come out to do the repair were easy.
Moreover, their claims representatives were very courteous. Whatever problems I was having, they always seemed to be very empathetic. Their response as far as getting someone to do the job was timely. Also, the technicians who came to our home were very professional. They identified themselves, got right to the job and let me know what my cost would be. They usually complete the job the same day unless a part had to be ordered and they would return.
Reviewed May 27, 2017
Absolutely the WORST warranty company. I have had home warranties for years. This was the first and last year that I will be a customer of First American. To make a very long story short, they will tell you one thing and then perform completely opposite. When told that a contractor would be in touch with me within 8 hours, I expect their contractor to fulfill the duties expected. Found out by doing a little research the company is out of the office until 72 hours later.
When calling FAHW to discuss calling out another contractor and being reimbursed for the services they will provide -same day- I was told that the dispatched contractor has 48 BUSINESS hours to call me. Really!?!?! I could keep going. Customer service reps are very difficult to understand and rather rude. There is absolutely NO compassion for the customer. Think twice before going this route. I never had these problems with American Home Shield, which is where I will most likely go back. Good luck!
Reviewed May 27, 2017
We had a couple claims and we had no problems at all. We had a rental house that needed a shower and some lighting fixed. They fixed the shower valve, and that was no problem at all. We had an issue though with one of the electricians we had. They fixed the lighting and when they were done, I went to turn it on and things started smoking. That was because the chandelier was messed up, not because the wiring to the chandelier which was not covered was messed up. Nevertheless, I was pretty happy with what they did, so we just went and rebuilt the chandelier and the problem went away. They did fine. The guys that came out did what they're supposed to do. So we're happy with them and it was an excellent experience. Everything went the way it was supposed to go.
Reviewed May 27, 2017
First American Home Warranty sent Falls AC to replace AC unit. Falls listed $1430 worth of "uncovered" charges such as permit, removing old unit, drip line, modifications and other items. A NEW AC UNIT COSTS $1300!! First Home Warranty offered $400 to let us choose our own AC repair person but would not say what they would pay Falls AC to repair the unit. This is truly a scam. Not only does the insured have to pay so many uncovered charges that there is not really any benefit to having the coverage. Ultimately the insured has to not only pay a premium but also uncovered charges. Do not get this coverage!
Hello, can you please provide us with your claim number and/or contract number so that we may assist you? Thank you
Reviewed May 26, 2017
I've been a customer with a premium policy for 9 years. The policy includes replacement but when my 25 year old a/c unit went out recently the company decided to charge me $650 to make modifications to fit a new evaporation coil (part cost of $577) because the old part is obsolete. I can see this repeating as parts that are no longer made are replaced by new modified parts (at my cost) until the unit is completely replaced. Extremely frustrated at what feels like a lack of good faith dealing with their replacement policy. The company has found a creative way to pass the replacement cost off to me as the customer. I will not be renewing this policy and I caution anyone considering them based on their replacement policy or premium services.
Reviewed May 26, 2017
We got First American Home Warranty to cover unexpected expenses. They were the best price at that time but they've gone up a little bit. I've heard of a competitor that is cheaper but I haven't checked to see if I'll make the switch. Claim submission is easy, the website is pretty straightforward but could be a little better because the options aren't always clear to describe the problem I'm having so I got to explain it. Once you're able to describe the situation, the reps have always been very helpful. Most of their technicians are very knowledgeable and take care of things right away and we've only had problems with one contractor that they used for air conditioning. They're still trying to send this same contractor out but I refused them because they're rude to us and they're just not getting any more money from me. Other than that, it's been very good overall.
Reviewed May 26, 2017
I've had good and bad experiences with First American. I usually call them up to file a claim but I did it online recently. My oven was broken and we needed it done as soon as possible. The contractor called me the next day. But then, it took a while for somebody to get here. However, that was pretty much a good experience and I have another good experience with my hot water heater, as well. But over the years up 'til two years ago, I was fighting with this company that fixed my air conditioner. By fixed it, I mean all they wanted to do was put Band-Aids on it and that doesn't do me any damn good. They didn't even speak English.
One time four years ago, the air conditioner went out and they waited for some stupid little part that could have been procured locally down the street, 15 minutes away from me. The unit was out for nine days and it was August here in Texas and it was hot. That experience was brutal. Then two years ago when I was down at my mother's funeral, it finally went out and crapped out while my wife was stuck up here by herself. They eventually put a new air conditioner in, but it was after years of beating my head against the wall, begging, pleading, screaming and hollering.
Plus, I've been with First American for a number of years now and I'm tired of their prices going up for the monthly payment. Then I have to pay the contractor and that's continually going up as well. It's the cost of business and I don't mind paying good money if they send good people out here to fix stuff. But the contractors that they send are hit and miss. I might get a good one today on accident but most of the other times, I get people that couldn't find their butt with both hands. Half the number of times that I've had to use them, people ended up having to come back and do something over or put another Band-Aid on it.
Reviewed May 25, 2017
First, I have been with First American since 2004 when we purchased this home. This year I had a pump in my spa go bad and the claim was denied (they have replaced this recirculating pump before but have decided that since it recirculates the spa water and runs the water feature that it is not allowed any longer). Over $500 my cost to repair.
Now I have 2 evaporative coolers that have gone bad (both are 30 years old) and I want to cash out and replace them with air conditioning. Now to install new coolers, which they would authorize is approximately $4,000. But to cash out of the coolers and install something better on my nickel, they will only cash out at $400 per unit. They did the same cheap trick with a refrigerator I needed to have replaced and the new one is the lowest end they could get. I am NOT happy at all with the service I have gotten in the past several years from them. When we first got them, they were responsive and wonderful and now they are like every other insurance company... They just want all the money and they do not want to give any back or provide the service that is paid for.
Hello Patty,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed May 25, 2017
We have been with this company for three years and have had several claims. Garbage Disposal 3 visits over several weeks as "Approved" replacement unit on back order? Stove Repair multiple visits as repair company had difficulty obtaining approval. Outside faucets required $3.00 backflow preventers, 4 visits over many weeks to get repaired. Garage door weeks to get company to come out and they didn't fix anything but took my deductible payment. Last summer 2 A/C Units failed (NO Freon) Tech serviced Freon.
This Spring 1 A/C Unit Failed (NO Freon), FAHW Dispatched Memphis Air Care (901) 654-7047. Visit 1, Found system out of Freon, Serviced with Dye. Returned several days later and determined Evaporator Coil Leak and ordered GrandAire WLNC244AA. This is an R410a Coil being installed in an R22 system and is not a direct fit. And I will be charged $435.00 Installation for plenum modification plus the $75.00 Deductible. I Have the First Class Plan that clearly states this is covered. Spent many hours on the phone with FAHW as to why this is not covered and was given statements that, "Yes that is what your contract states" but really means something else.
Then FAHW provided examples of cases the $435.00 would be covered. "If State or Federal Regulations required a change to the A/C the full install would be covered." Well it is no longer possible to install R22 Equipment and Since they're installing R410a Equipment (Due to Federal Law). It should be covered, this is one example of many. They just switch lanes and state your situation doesn't fit or it would if we replaced the entire unit, which they should since R22 and R410a is not compatible for many reasons and my condenser manufacturer warns against Using R410a. FAHW Refuses to complete repairs Sensibly, Properly or Legally. I am contacting Legal Help, State (Insurance Commission) and Federal Agencies (EPA) to explore options. Stay away from this company!!!
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed May 25, 2017
We have been with this company three years. We've only had to call them three times, all minor problems. The first two they didn't cover, supposedly! The third was a water pipe in the ceiling that had started leaking. The plumber came out, (@ $65), put a $10 boot on it, told my wife (I was away with work for about a year) the pipe about 6' long and had additional areas that were bad and left. The way we noticed the leak initially was wet drywall, which I have a recording from the First American stating they will cover that and they didn't. At any rate, the plumber having noticed the condition of the pipe should have replaced it. His cost materials $10, time 30 minutes. No, he was gone, so we had an additional cost to have another plumber come out and replace the pipe. Then another cost to have the drywall repaired.
I encourage everyone to read all the reviews and realize that these are only a percentage of all the total reviews. The ones posted most generally show positive reviews which I sincerely believe is a lie. Save your money, pay someone you trust and can depend on to makes repairs to your house. First American has all this information in their records.
Reviewed May 25, 2017
I have chosen 1 star only because 0 stars was not an option. I will not attempt to list all the difficulties I have had with your company but simply pick the latest one. Since November 2016 I have attempted to collect a $50 reimbursement fee your company owes me. It is now May of 2017. Dozens and dozens of phone calls to reps and conversations with supervisors have yielded no results. Finally I decided to not pay your $65 fee for work order # ** (Feb 2017) until I received my reimbursement from last November.
I called and discussed this with many First American representatives as I continued to receive threatening letters from your company. I expressed my concern re: the threat of turning this over to a debt collector. I was assured this would not happen. It has. And though you've claimed 2 different checks have been issued and mailed - I have received neither. I am exceedingly frustrated and cannot bear any more telephone calls. I hope that this will work.
Hello Kenneth. We appreciate your feedback and are happy to assist you with your concerns. Thanks, Shanee.
Reviewed May 25, 2017
We've had First American now for ten years. When we bought our house, part of the contract with the previous owners was that there would be a home warranty in the first year. They were with First American and then we just kept it this whole time. However, submitting a claim is usually a nightmare. They have the worst phone tree ever. If I need to tell them something specific, the automatic system won't understand. Then I keep talking until finally it says, "I'm gonna connect you with an operator." And I'm like, "Hell, yes." It could also take a long time before I can talk to a person. But recently, my husband has found that submitting a claim online is his new favorite thing to do because it's so much easier.
But I like to talk to a person over the phone especially because over the years, we've had issues with the pool and the air conditioning. And we have found that sometimes they contract with idiots. They sent somebody who is not knowledgeable with my type of pool system or my air conditioning. Sometimes, I'd have the claim go through two different companies before they get somebody who knows. So when they automatically assign me to a contractor, I can tell them not to use certain people if I've dealt with them in the past and I didn't like them because I would end up having to get another service contract person to come out anyhow. However, when I have an issue, First American always fixes it. They don't give me a hard time.
Reviewed May 24, 2017
I am new to the home warranty service contracts. This has been a BIG, BIG disappointment. Need a repair on a leak on pool, 9 days later still no part. Still haven't heard from Cool Water Pool & Spa who was supposed to fix. He has not submitted report nor ordered the part. In the meantime, my pool will go green. THANKS, First American Home Warranty, for NOTHING. I have been calling for 3 days in a row. I'm receiving the same response, "Sorry we can't do anything because the contractor has not submitted his report".
Reviewed May 24, 2017
I have several homes on the First American Home Warranty program. Things break so I decided to acquire a home warranty. I submitted a claim for plumbing recently and it was a good experience. The claims rep was efficient and the contractors did a good job, too. The quality of work performed is excellent.
Reviewed May 24, 2017
First American Home Warranty only is concerned with taking money. They are not concerned with safe work or reputable contractors to do the work that is needed. We had problems with our AC after having been in our new house 10 months. It was April, it was beginning to get hot, even having days in 85-90 deg range. We called First American because they were the warranty company that was purchased by the sellers when they sold the house. They sent out someone to assess, not fix mind you, the system. “Oh it just needs an evaporator coil,” the tech says. He said he'd send in the request. We waited a week, no word. Called the contractor to see where the part is. She hemmed and hawed and I got the impression it had not even been ordered. By this time it was 3 weeks without AC. We bought portable units just to sleep = $650.
They finally got the part, and it wasn't the same SEER as our system. It was a 14 SEER and our system was 10 SEER. They said, "Oh it’s no biggie." Got the coil on and they left. This cost $1260 ($1200 for the work that First American said was not covered, and $60 service fee). Worked exactly one day. AC started blowing hot air. Power starting blinking out in the house, lights in certain rooms did not work. Bad burning smell inside the house. We called back. Took another week to get someone out. "Oh they didn't charge it correctly." The AC blew cool air for about half a day. Power problems continued in the house, and they got a lot more scary. The appliances started blinking out and sparking, burning smell continued, and the TV would cut off and on by itself.
By this time we had NO faith in the contractor that First American sent, so we called a local company. They listened, were nervous when we told them of the electrical issues and sent out a technician for FREE. He looked at what they did, and said, "I'm surprised your house hasn't burned down." They had put on again, an oversized coil, and it was drawing 120 amps through a system designed to manage 20 amps, plus the breakers were oversized, so they were not tripping as they should, and causing serious overload in the system which could have burned the house down. Also the work they did damaged the furnace and the whole system would now need to be replaced.
We got quotes from other HVAC companies because we did NOT trust First American nor their shoddy contractors any longer, and went with the one that had the best equipment for the best price. It so happened it was the company that sent the tech out for free. We are now out over $10K because of the completely inept, unsafe, shoddy, incompetent work from First American and their contractors. We tried to at least get our $1200 back?? Oh no. First American says they owe us nothing and they actually hung up on my husband.
Run, do not walk, away from this shoddy completely unprofessional and unsafe company. We had the AC go out in a house 8 years ago. We bought in the lower part of the state and our warranty was with American Home Shield. They replaced the whole system for a $60 service call instead of trying to send someone out repeatedly and take our money. We are renewing the home warranty with them. Use American Home Shield if you want competent service.
Reviewed May 24, 2017
We knew people who had other warranty companies, and they would not cover things that did not have an inspection report. When we bought the house, First American would cover anything even if it wasn't working when you bought the house. When our AC went out three weeks after we moved into this house, they covered it. That's important. The fact that we didn't have to prove that it broke down after we bought the house was a big factor. First America poses a problem to other warranty companies because the warranty company couldn't prove the things were in working condition when we purchased the house.
We've been in a rental house before where we had to find our contractors to make repairs. The very idea that I don't have to spend three or four hours on the phone trying to find somebody to come and make the repair or come see what's wrong and try to fix it, that I'm not the one spending time on the phone getting somebody scheduled to come out is worth a lot to me.
We've had really good experience submitting a claim. I've only done it once on the internet and it was easy to use. I find it easier to call to give them more details. Most of the time I just call the number.I don't remember what my account number is. But they are always able to pull it up. I know that sounds bad but I'm probably like most people. I'm able to give whatever details I can when I call it over the phone or as we put it in on the internet. I'll always get to put in all the comments that First America may need such as the model number of the product or anything in particular that I've noticed about noises, smells, what it's doing or what happened before.
The sales rep are always really good. They usually ask for more information and give it to me. Sometimes they're even able to give me the contractor. It's assigned over the phone. Sometimes they email it out. Usually, we get the email of what the contractor assigned is within 30 minutes or an hour. The technicians who came have always been very knowledgeable. I think we've only had one or two that we weren't really happy with, and it seems like they've stopped using those particularly with the AC. The only downside thing to it is that we did have problems with the AC and they had to condemn it and it took forever before they were willing to condemn it. One of the contractors did some fixes to keep it working because they condemned that we're not up to code.
Most of the time the quality of work is good. They're very efficient. We've had everything from AC, plumbing, electrical, garage door, refrigerator, washer and dryer worked on. They usually do send out competent people and it usually isn't a waste of time. It's been very practical and it's been worth the cost because it saves me not having to take off of work. We actually have recommended to First American to friends.
Reviewed May 23, 2017
When I bought my house last June, they already had First American Home Warranty. One time, I had a leak in the roof. A man came out and repaired the leak. He's very nice and the interactions we had was good. He did a pretty good job because I haven't had a leak since. I had a very positive experience with First American Home Warranty.
Reviewed May 22, 2017
I have had First American Home Warranty for about 4 years and have filed claims twice. Both were horrible experiences. They have a very limited number of service providers. I was told on my first claim they had only 2 that could fix my water heater and now was told only 3 that could work on my AC and the one I was assigned to was based 4 hours away in another state. They give the providers 2 business days to contact you but seem to have no limit on how long you are supposed to wait for them to actually come out.
In my case my AC went out on a Friday night and I filed my claim on Saturday. It was already over 80 degrees in my house and they assigned me a company that wasn't open on weekends. I had to plead with customer service to try to find somebody who was at least able to call and set up the appointment even if they could come out because I was afraid this would drag on which it has. I'm being told now that I have to wait 3 more days in the heat before somebody will be able to come out. It is miserable in my house. My son is sick and running a fever and the temperature is making him feel even worse. We can't sleep or get chores done without sweating. And the customer service department, which is based out of Central America (so I guess the company name should actually be First Central American) is horrible.
I've called many times in both my current and past claim trying to get them expedited and each time I've had to speak with different people. Each person tells me something different about how my issue can be handled and they contradict each other. They do not call back as they tell you they will and keep you on hold (over 15 minutes) while they try to contact providers. The weekend supervisor told me I hung up on them when in actuality the call was disconnected twice on their part. I was told by one person that if they couldn't provide actual service by Tuesday that I could use a provider of my choice.
Now I'm being told I have to wait until Wednesday and that what I was told wasn't correct. And despite it being their representative who said it, they aren't willing to stand by it. I went through this same frustrating situation a few years ago when I was without heat and hot water. It's definitely not customer First with First American and I will be canceling my policy and urge others not to use them.
Reviewed May 22, 2017
Horrible experience with First American Home Warranty. My HVAC system was never repaired. Going on 5 months. First American Home Warranty (FAHW) is not what they represent themselves to be. When you open a service request, it takes them 48 hours or longer to schedule an appointment to come to your home. The problem, whatever it is, will not be resolved, and you will be very unsatisfied with the technicians they send to your home. The contractors they use are either new companies that have not built up their own clientele or companies that have done an extremely poor job servicing their own customers and fail to get enough recommendations.
FAHW is a very "hands off" company. They contact the service technicians, and then it's "hands off." There is no follow up to see if the issue was resolved. You, the customer, are expected to contact the technician if they do not contact you within 48 hours. I have had an issue with my HVAC since last November (5 months). A variety of techs have been to my house each finding something different and each passing the buck onto a different group. The HVAC compressor was held together with wire and string put there by one of the techs sent out. We finally paid a reputable company to look at the system and take care of the problem. The contractors used do not want to actually fix the problem, they are there to apply band-aids only. They are only paid pennies on the dollar to fix your problem. FAHW does not allow them to purchase parts or do work other than very minor fixes. Do not waste your money or time using this company.
Reviewed May 22, 2017
I was given a First American Home Buyer Warranty through my mortgage company upon purchasing my home. I have used this warranty 3 times over the course of my first year in my new home. On two occasions I had no issues. However, on my third attempt at using the warranty I ran into a major issue, which has led me to write this review to warn anyone looking into this company. I had an electrical wiring issue which kept tripping a breaker in my circuit box. I immediately called it in to my home warranty company. They assigned a contractor from over 2 hours away from my home.
In the three days between reporting the issue and the contractor coming out I looked into the issue myself. Some of the wires had become overloaded and heated up to the point of burning. The coating of the wiring and the backing of the insulation it was in contact with had both turned burnt and black. Upon the contractor coming out he turned the power back on and said that he found no issues. When I showed him the burnt wiring and insulation he said that it looked like the wiring "had gotten tar or some sort of paint on it." I pleaded my case but the contractor refused to believe the wiring had burnt.
He made his report to First American Home Warranty stating that everything was fine and there were no burnt wires. I pleaded with First American to send out a second contractor for another opinion. I talked to multiple level supervisors and they consistently refused to send out a second contractor, taking the word of the first contractor over my concerns. I eventually had to call in a second contractor on my own dime and that contractor came out, confirmed the burnt wires, and found the overloaded wiring. I sent that information to First American and they refused to compensate me because they hadn't authorized me to call a second contractor without their knowledge.
Hello Roger,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed May 22, 2017
When looking for my own properties, a lot of times they come with a home warranty. So, my option was either First American Home Warranty or a couple of other companies. I tried out other companies before for home warranty and I didn't like the service so I gave First American a try. They've definitely exceeded my expectations. Submitting a claim has been an easy process. The easiest way to reach them for the claims was through the phone and talk to someone live. They have very good and very professional customer service. The techs have been okay. However, it has been a hit or miss because of different technicians at different times for different things. But, if I ever have any issue, I let First American know and they notate it. They take my concerns and factor that into their customer service.
The air conditioning units have issues every three to four months so I brought that up with First American and they said that they have to go by the word of the technician in terms of what the issue was. If the tech feels that they could fix it, they fix it. If it's something that needs to be replaced, they replace it. I tend to see a lot of recurring issues with the air conditioning units but they get the techs out there fast to take a look at them.
Reviewed May 21, 2017
I had First American when I had my condo, the last property I owned. My real estate agent chose them. It was something that was part of the contract that the seller provided when I was buying my condo. I've been happy with their service ever since. I'm now four years with them, three years with my condo and now, with my new house. I definitely referred them to my friends and family when they start asking questions about the home warranty. I always tell them that they need to contact First American Home Warranty or look into you.
Submitting a claim had been easy. I've never had to actually call back the tech for any claim that I've put in. Once they've come out and identified the issue, if they weren't able to fix it there, they already set up to come back out and make an appointment with me. Then by the next time they come out, they'd fix it. My first claim that I put in for my new home is my washing machine. It just took a little bit longer than expected.
But it's not their fault. It was the contractor that came out. He had to order a part and said it would take two weeks to actually get my dryer fixed. However, it took him about a month. I had to call him to see if he was gonna come back or not and check on the status. After I left him a message, I got a call the next day. He did work and did a good job. I believe that the company is just a small company, like one guy running around. It's just the industry he's in. It's kind of broad as far as appliances go. He doesn't have available stocks and I don't know if he has vendors that he's working with to get the equipment faster, probably not. So, that's the only thing. But overall, I'm happy with them all.
Reviewed May 20, 2017
Please after 4 years of service with this company don't use them for your sake. I called on Friday and asked for a A/C repair and told them I am 100% disabled vet with children and dogs and can't afford to not have it fixed. First they assigned me a a/c company with 65 one star rating out of about 70 and then changed it to one that has no rating and one employee that works on Mon-Fri 9-6. Now it will take at least 4 days to hear from the one guy and he may not come for who knows how long, so my family suffers the heat with no help in sight. They just say, "If you want you can go find your own repairman." If this is how they treat the disabled don't you wonder how they will do in day to day operations and with all the 4 and 5 star a/c people around Dallas there only two they can get are one star reviews and people not in business long enough for a review or more than one employee???
Reviewed May 20, 2017
First American Home Warranty is fast to respond and easy to work with. I’ve submitted a claim over the phone and it took a long time. So now, I’ve been logging any claim or service call on the website, which works very fast. I also prefer submitting claims online because I can document the problems. Their reps are always very courteous, friendly, and helpful. Sometimes, there’s a wait when I have to call in, but not abnormal. The claims I had were processed in a timely manner too.
The technicians sent by First American were very helpful. The latest claim I had was my air conditioning. They came out and explained the situation. They said they weren’t sure what was covered. It happened on a Friday and by Monday, they were back and did the repairs. I had no problems, other than one bad experience I had. It was a repeat problem. The first one that did the work didn’t really fix it. But since it was two months between, it wasn’t warrantied and I had to pay for the next visit. Also, I hate that First American raised my prices for this coming year.
Reviewed May 19, 2017
Caution!! If you are buying a home or thinking about a home warranty, beware of 1st American Home Warranty. I have had 2 dealings with them. Both times were a complete mess. Hold times literally over 30 min, (unless you get smart and select "new purchase" option). The contractors do not like working with them because it's so difficult to get things done in a timely manner because of 1st American's process and it takes forever to get paid. Just FYI. I didn't give a bad review the first time, but now it hardly seems like a coincidence.
Reviewed May 19, 2017
When I bought the house at Fortworth, it has been an antique for over a year. It was prudent to look into acquiring home warranty and the real estate agent recommended First American Home Warranty. Submitting a claim is straightforward, easy and painless although when my washing machine and dryer went out, my particular brand of dryer wasn’t in the list so I included it in the body of the note. Fortunately, the service person read it. Otherwise, he would’ve brought the wrong heating element. It’s frustrating though because I had a high-end Samsung washing machine and they replaced it with a refurbished one. However, since my recent claim, the repair has worked perfectly. Plus, the contractor was prompt, got the job done, and cleaned up after himself. I'm very happy with First American.
Reviewed May 19, 2017
We have had 4 or 5 claims, and every single one of them has required babysitting these people to get responses or to get our issue resolved. We have had to resolve the issue ourselves on most of these occasions, and customer service and responsiveness is absolute garbage. I will never work with this company again, which is unfortunate because I am likely to sign up for another home warranty program.
Hello Eric,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Thank you.
Reviewed May 19, 2017
I will just list my cancellation letter. I can not believe how much time they will spend trying to sign you up and how little effort they will give in keeping you as a customer. There were two customer service reps that were incredibly helpful. The only problem is by the time you call back you have to start all over again. I would like to cancel my policy due to the fact I was told my house would be covered even if it was an older home built in the late 50’s.
I placed a work order in November because my power in half my house kept going off and on intermittently. The breakers weren’t popping off but the power was going in and out. The contractor that you sent out which is Woo Brother’s Electronics said my panel was old and would need to be replaced. They told me my panel was overloaded. My panel had been working fine on the same load up until that time. Your claims department said they would not cover the replacement of the box because my home was old. I look into hiring a second opinion or for someone who could do it cheaper. I was advised to call SMUD. SMUD is the utility company I purchase my electricity through. They came out and said it was due to the power lines coming to my home and they replaced the attachment where the power line was coming to my home.
Today they replaced and updated the lines coming to my home. There was no charge because the lines were covered under SMUD since it was due to the lines coming to my home. Since November 17, 2016 my home has not had a power outage or surge of any sort. I have not had to do any work on my electrical panel. I have not updated my panel and it seems to work with no problems. I called and spoke to a woman in April 2017 about how my panel seemed to have no problems since SMUD fixed their problem. I asked if I could have my money back for the service call since the diagnosis was wrong and misleading. She said after talking to her supervisor that I just needed to get a letter from SMUD stating that they did work on my home around that time. There is no work order or invoice or SMUD does not charge for the work they did.
I got the letter and emailed it today to Irvin **. I had a hard time sending the attachment but I finally got it sent. When I called back to talk to Irvin ** I was connected to a new person and then her supervisor. They told me that my letter from SMUD was not detailed enough. I have spent multiple hours dealing with this problem. I am frustrated and disappointed and feel ripped off.
First of all when I purchased this warranty I was not told my electrical panel was exempt from the warranty due to age. That was misleading. Secondly the wait for an electrician to come out was long and the diagnosis was false and misleading almost causing me to spend thousands of dollars that didn’t need to be spent at that time. I have spent hours on the phone trying to explain the situation and getting the proper documentation to no avail. I also have a letter that states the insurance policy is already going up in price.
I am so frustrated and would just like to cancel my policy since my panel is not covered due to age and who knows what else will conveniently be determined to be too old if it breaks down. That is not what the sales person told me when he sold me the policy. I would like my money back on the service call to Woo Brothers Electrical. I expected to be told the real problem with my electrical problem. I would like reimbursement for the policy since I was sold a policy that was supposed to cover my home regardless of age. I would like my policy cancelled so I don’t receive any more charges.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed May 19, 2017
We bought a condo and my realtor gave us a one-year home warranty under First American as a gift. I've renewed it a couple of times already. However, they didn’t do too good with their last choice of plumbers. But other than that, they’ve been very good. I had a pipe break underneath my kitchen sink. The claims rep was very polite and nice. She filed the claim for me and said that the people would be in contact with me in a day and they were, but they just sent out somebody inexperienced. The plumber didn’t fix it totally and so it leaked all night long and caused more damage than what it originally did. I was not too happy with that and I had to have them out twice.
Also, I had a problem with my dryer and the tech fixed it the one time. Then, two months later, something else came up and they immediately told us that we needed a new part. They didn’t even bother to open it. My son opened it up when the tech left and found out that there was a pair of nylons twisted all the way around the motor, stopping it. I don’t wear nylons. Nobody else in my house wears nylons. They’ve had it open prior to that from the first time we called them a few months earlier regarding a different problem and should’ve been able to see that there was a pair of nylon sitting there. It just seemed awful fishy that it was going to be a $300 repair. I wasn’t too happy with that.
Reviewed May 18, 2017
We called the home warranty company because our kitchen sink faucet would not pivot and would not turn off properly. We received a visit from a gentlemen, from a company selected by First American Home Warranty. We took a day off work to meet with the plumber, who came in with a clipboard in hand. He proceeded to look at the issue and said "Yes you need a new faucet", he then proceeded to let us know how much money he makes, cracked a couple jokes, and let us know he would have his "girls" call to schedule for the plumber to come out. If anyone has seen the commercial about the "Security monitor" at the bank, that just lets people know when the bank is being robbed... that was this guy, a "Plumbing Monitor".
We schedule with the plumber, take another day off work. Plumber comes and changes out the faucet. He changed the faucet (definitely not the same quality of what was taken out) and leaves. A couple hours later we turn the dishwasher on, which floods our kitchen, damaging the cabinets. We try to call the plumber, who does not answer, so we call First American Home Warranty to end up talking to a person who spoke broken English, obviously outsourced customer service representatives in another country - difficult to understand. He was unable to help and said he would have the plumber come out the next day to take care of the issue. I asked to speak to a supervisor, so he connected me to another gentleman with broken English in another department that handles such issues.
The new gentleman tells me First American Home Warranty will issue a claim if we send them pictures of the damage, but they cannot get our issue fixed that night, but assured me it would be fixed in the morning. We forward the pictures to the email he gave us that night. After not receiving any communication the next morning, we called First American Home Warranty back to be told that a work order was never initiated and they are not responsible for what their plumber may have done and they do not know why we were told to send pictures. They then initiated a work order for the plumber to return and said the plumber would be contacting us. We finally received a call from a young lady with the plumbing company, who told us she could give us another 4 hour window for a visit on Monday of next week.
We told her that their plumber made the mistake and it needed to be taken care of immediately. She told us that their plumber was never sent. When we told her the plumber's name, she then said "How do you know he made the mistake to cause the damage?" And still rudely insisted that the only available time slot to get the plumbing issue fixed was next Monday, take it or leave it, they are really busy. And the new appointment would be with the first guy whom I call the "Plumbing Monitor". We still do not have use of our kitchen sink and are awaiting the plumbing monitor.
Hello Charlie,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed May 18, 2017
We had a little bit of a glitch in my last claim for the ice maker. The vendor they chose first was not going to be able to come out for two weeks and yet, they’re only 20 miles down the road. I called back and then one of the claim reps reassigned it. This guy was there in three hours and the problem was fixed. He should have been their first assignment as opposed to those other people. We’ve had people out for the ice maker three times before to the point that it had to be replaced and First American also took care of that very nicely. So far, I’m very happy with their response and the program.
Reviewed May 18, 2017
When I bought my place, First American was what I had for the home protection and I kept it because they’ve given me good service. In the last six months, I've had several claims including when my freezer went out and I had to have a whole new air conditioner unit on top of my roof. That worked out wonderful. Then, I had a leak in my faucet in my bathroom that was leaking into the storage room below my condo which took a little while but it eventually got fixed. I also had a shower faucet fixed and everything was done.
Also, the contractors were all very good especially ENA, the one for the air conditioning one. The plumbing people that came to fix the faucets and the shower faucet were good, too. I’m very pleased and I will stick with them. I’ve been in my 13 and a half years and I quit them for a little while but then I thought something’s going to go wrong. So, I started up again and when things started to go wrong, I was very happy and little by little, everything worked out for me. So I was very pleased.
Reviewed May 17, 2017
From Feb 28th to current (17 MAY 2017) I have been dealing with a dripping sound between my floors from the master bathroom toilet. There is also an odor that is very strong that I now sleep in another room. I have had the wax ring replaced and told the jets in the toilet are messed up and the toilet needs replacing. The tech also stated that the smell of sewage was present. Because of this comment alone my claim has been denied. Not because of the other reasons but solely on the smell alone.
I called in to get a second opinion, I was told the company assigned would call me in 24-72 hours. So I waited a full week. (Maybe they meant 72 business hours which equals 9 working days). Nevertheless I find I have a person assigned to my claim. I asked if I could speak with them and was advised they would be calling me. NOT ONCE have I received a call from the first time the contractors came out nor the SECOND time. I had to call in and find out each time what was going on with my claim. This is not a way to run customer service. I'm looking at American Home Shield for coverage. Although 10.00 more expensive it covers my pool and EVERYTHING in my house. If you ever want to email First American's claim service here's the email: claimreview@firstam.com. Just so you know, THEY DO NOT REPLY.
Reviewed May 17, 2017
Placed a service request to repair my air conditioner. After inspecting, the repair contractor stated he will have to return to complete repairs. Paid service request fee for inspection. Contractor called and stated to total service cost will be $1500 to complete repair. My FHW premier plan includes air conditioner option. Contacted FHW and rep couldn't explain why total service cost is $1,500. Repair contractor returns at 9 am PST (this day) to complete repair. Feeling pressured and no resolution forthcoming soon.
Hello Donnie,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed May 17, 2017
I’ve been a customer of First American Home Warranty for 13 years now. Submitting a claim to them was okay. However, I hate their automated system. Their machine does not recognize my keyword. Also, I have very bad experience with them. The claim I filed was really a pain. They messed up and it took forever for them to settle that because they did not file it on time and did not send anybody for several months so I had to get supervisors. It has been a very, very stressful experience. Nevertheless, they were able to fix it but it was three months of yelling and screaming but they've been okay lately. Overall, they’re very good and they know what they’re doing.
Reviewed May 17, 2017
I got First American when I bought the house. I had no problems the first year. When I was thinking of renewing, I called them and talked to one of their representatives. They explained how everything would work and I thought that it was a good thing to keep, so I elected to have it for my house. When the fan on the convection oven of my dual purpose stove was making noise, their claim reps were very helpful and got the repair people out who were really knowledgeable. The first guy came out and figured out what was wrong and what he would have to do. Then they ordered the part. When the part came in, a different repair guy came and repaired it. I'm quite happy with everything that has been done.
Reviewed May 16, 2017
My First American Home Warranty came with my home when I bought it three months ago. They had more options on their policy than the warranty I had with my previous home. Also, I've spoken to their customer service representatives to ask about pool coverage because I'm going to add things like that to the warranty. I'm very pleased with First American so far.
Reviewed May 15, 2017
My realtor has First American and told me about it. He said that having a home warranty would be great because the owner who sold the house to me didn't really want to replace anything, and that if something breaks, at least I'm covered and won't have to spend as much money on replacing or fixing things. I've already done three claims with First American. The first one was for the washing machine. The pump broke on it and a tech came out and fixed it. It was a wham-bam-thank-you-ma’am kind of deal. It was great and I had no issues there. It was the same thing with the plumbing, where a guy came out, fixed the problem, and went about his way.
However, my last experience wasn't so great. It was for the AC unit and there was nothing really done with it. It's still broken and right now, it's probably running on its last breath. The AC unit is kind of working, but I haven’t set it to a lower level for it to freeze up. It’s 13 years old so it is bound to fail soon. When I put in the claim for it, I called that day remembering that on the website, there used to be an emergency module, and I thought an AC being broken in Florida would be an emergency situation. And then, they sent out a company called Comfort Tech and the tech who came out said that it's not failing, but I think it is because it still keeps freezing up. When I called back First American, the rep said that if the technician says that it's not failing, then there's nothing they can do about it. I asked if it would be possible to send a different company or different person the next time that it does not work properly but he didn't say anything. I feel that it’s the same person who I’ve talked to twice and he was kind of not very helpful. But other than that, my experience with First American has been great.
Reviewed May 15, 2017
I've been a First American Home Warranty member for 10 years. Recently, I submitted a claim for my ice maker. I called First American and they put everything up for me. However, I didn't realize that my ice maker was not covered by the warranty until the contractor they sent told me. But First American has been great and I choose to stay with them because they're cheaper.
Reviewed May 14, 2017
The first time that I used First American, the experience was pretty good. The technician was fine. This would be my second time using First American. I had called yesterday and the people said they had set me up with a plumber. But they cancelled because I'm not in the area. I didn't know they weren't coming until I had called. They never called to say that thing has been cancelled. So, I had to call back today and they got me set up for Thursday with somebody else.
Reviewed May 14, 2017
I put a claim 3 weeks ago and they still haven't resolved it. They told me I need to look for a company myself to get an estimate. I called back with the estimate I receive from the company (the company I looked for) and all they've done is transfer me from one department to another. The department haven't been able to help me. Overall, the Service is terrible and I am disappointed with the company after I've had them for 9 years.
Reviewed May 14, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American was really easy and pretty straightforward because I do it over the phone. The reps were helpful and knowledgeable. The technicians were knowledgeable, too. I try to look up the stuff after I talk to them and they know what they're talking about. But I had a guy come out initially on the water heater, flushed it, and said that was the only issue. Then a month later, I was seeing a lot of rust in the line. Another guy came out and replaced the heater. So the first time was not as good because the first guy said it'll clear up after I run it a while. But the second guy came out and recognized the issue right away and it got taken care of. It's nice to have the warranty. I don't want to have to use it, but if I need it, it's there. It's like insurance. I don't want to buy insurance, but if I need it, I'm glad I have it.
Reviewed May 14, 2017
I had a great experience with First American and I’m happy with it. It did not take the representatives very long to process my claim. For the general part of the process, they got on-site the same day. They went up a little bit, though. I used to pay $65. Now, it’s $75. But I like First American. It is a good company, so it's good keeping.
Reviewed May 13, 2017
When we purchased our previous house, it came with a year of First American Home Warranty. We continued it after that. Then when we bought our new house, it came with a different warranty company so after the year was up, we switched to First American. It was much better than the other company. The level of service and the features covered the benefits provided. What’s most difficult is to submit a claim by phone instead of online because you have to wait to talk to someone for ten minutes max but it’s not nearly as bad as the other company where I’d wait over half an hour. I called today and got someone on the phone within two minutes. It was an easy and smooth process. I've never had an issue with that aspect of it. Plus, the claims representatives are right to the point. If I called with a question, they always answered or get it handled and contact me back. It’s usually quick and not much wasted time.
I put a claim in for my air conditioning. When the first technician came out, they noticed that it was low on Freon and he said that it’s typical to need a couple of pounds of Freon every year. Within a few days, it had already leaked out several more pounds of Freon. The owner of the company came out and looked at it and basically apologized for the misinformation of this other employee. He made it all right, did all the inspections and found the leak. We are now in the process of getting the part ordered and shipped in. When the replacement part comes in, the owner himself has assured me of the quality that it will be in and he guarantees his work even outside of the warranty company of First American so I feel confident that it will get taken care of. Nobody is perfect. A mistake did happen but at least up until this point, they are doing everything they can to correct the problem quickly and appropriately. I'm satisfied with First American.
Reviewed May 13, 2017
Our realtor bought First American as a closing gift for me and my wife then we renewed it. Submitting a claim was smooth and easy. My wife called in and she got a good experience talking to their representatives. We got a couple of things that we had to use it on like a water heater and a plumbing issue and it worked fine. Their technicians were great as well. I felt the price is reasonable and it’s a great warranty company.
Reviewed May 13, 2017
When we purchased our home, First American Home Buyers Warranty was already on it for a year. It's comfortable. They follow-through right away and we've had no issues with them. So we just renewed it. Filing claims has been easy. We just call it in and it's not been an issue at all. A lot of times, it's because of air conditioner issues. Occasionally they'll have to research and call me back but usually they have it already assigned to someone before we get off the phone. And the technicians have done very well. They're Johnny-on-the-spot. They always know exactly what to do to fix it and fix it in a very timely manner.
And if we've had to call First American again, it's gonna be a different issue maybe with the same unit. It's not like they do a sorry job so we need another person to come out. The only thing is just that the cost has gone up. It started out at $500 the first year. And now, we're almost to $700. That's just unfortunate. But I've recommended them to our children that are married and just starting out.
Reviewed May 12, 2017
Based upon my own experience, I cannot believe this company is still licensed to do business in California. I have had to police every step of this relationship and have nothing still to show for it. I had a full plumbing failure due to pinhole leaks in the pipes and a leak under my slab, found after taking the outer wall of our house off (ourselves). We turned off our water as First American advises to minimize damage from further leaks.
First Am's contractor was 2 hours away from our residence and didn't even bother to call to say he wasn't coming. We had to find our own contractor and have him call First Am for authorization (tough enough to get a plumber to come out, much less jump through red tape while we are without water). Took 3 weeks after claim was made to get water back on thanks to my efforts, not their claims of saving us hours of finding a contractor. He had to repipe the house and circumvented the slab so we wouldn't have this issue come up again.
They did a great job, but I had to pay directly for the job as required under selecting your own provider option nearly $5,000.00, but considerably less than going through the slab. I submitted proof of payment in a cleared check, paid invoice, and even my bank statement showing it was cleared. Then nothing. Calls and e-mails finally got me a promise of a payment of $500.00 since it was under the slab, and as limited within the contract. I've read the contract, and there was a slab leak, but fixing this would not have fixed the problem. Ambiguity in the contract is on them!! I could even argue that no work was done under the slab so they're responsible without this limitation.
Didn't really matter as nothing came, I had to call many times just to find out it was rejected for payment. Other e-mails said we needed an itemized invoice, and one that I needed to submit proof of payment (uploaded on their site 3 weeks prior — their ticket system is highly ineffective). Things happen, but when is it just obvious that they're going through some sort of checklist of excuses not to pay? I had a specific case manager assigned who would not return calls. First American, this means your first-line customer service folks are getting the brunt of frustration when the specially trained contact won't respond.
So now, supposedly I am again being issued the minimum check amount. (Oh, but they tried to deduct the $65 co-payment from my $500 instead of the thousands already out of pocket. Really??) If this check shows up, I'm writing to this company for their handling of this process and requesting they pay an additional sum towards the rest of my out-of-pocket. I consider this incident an example of unfair, deceptive, and just inappropriate consumer retail business practices. If they do not respond and offer to rectify this in some manner, I will consider my next options. As a banking compliance professional, I would expect regulatory action from this unacceptable lack of caution and amount of effort. Mistakes happen and can be fixed, but this has been compounded and nothing would have happened if I hadn't stayed on it. PS: I have the premium coverage too.
UPDATED ON 05/19/2017: It took my initial post here to get someone at First Am to speak with me beyond the front line. Marciela took the time to contact me and my contractor, whom I had to pay out of pocket since First Am couldn't send anyone that would show up and gave me this option (they treat this as some sort of privilege, but means you find them and pay out of pocket and like me, try for 8 weeks to get a dime back). Our contractor didn't remember anything beyond a slab leak - but we turned the water on for just a minute for his assessment. We had pin holes in other pipes outside of the slab, one was pretty big in that we lost water pressure - no wonder he couldn't see them when we turned on the water. His honest response cost me any further reimbursement, and I accept this from his end without question...
My opinion remains that their practices are not as advertised and they hide behind a contract they do not even know (I showed Marciela the provision and she agreed that my interpretation was obvious as to a specific point First Am was hiding behind). I am in an impossible bind that precludes my getting any additional reimbursement mostly thanks to the way they handled it - would have been easily identified if the contractor they initially assigned actually showed up... during the two weeks it took me to find someone (while without water but for quick instances in which my husband would turn on then off) maybe the leaks above ground would have been easy to see and the larger one that made us lose all pressure and escalate First A to action would not have happened. I didn't ask for anything unreasonable except to protect my resources as anticipated by buying this policy.
As to not burden my own hired contractor, I will pursue other venues to share this experience to dissuade purchasers. I am responsible for fair and accurate advertising and disclosure for my financial institution, and looks like First Am could use a little work of what we call UDAAP. Someday in some way, I'll be able to show them that the pipes have pinholes that would have required replacement if we had gone to the additional expense of re-piping under the slab instead of going around it. Maybe I'll send in the darned pipes themselves - they're still in place just no water goes through them. Even if too far off to gain additional reimbursement, enough to maybe change their thinking on how badly things can go wrong when they set my situation up to FAIL. Find my initial complaint for more information on my specific situation. Shame on First American.
Reviewed May 12, 2017
We have lived in our home for 3 years. We acquired the home warranty when we purchased the house in 2014. Two months after moving in, the A/C unit for the upstairs stopped working. We actually completely forgot about the home warranty until after I posted on Facebook that the initial A/C company quoted that the system needed to be replaced which was roughly $7500. Our realtor, seeing the post, quickly reminded me that we had the home warranty. We called them and they sent out another technician where they ended up replacing the compressor and one of the valves. We paid for the call out fee which was $95.
In 2015 we had a cracked cooling coil in our air handler and it flooded our part of our attic space along with a bad capacitor and again it was recommended to them that our system get replaced. Again we paid for the service call. In Aug 2016 the compressor and valve from 2014 was again replaced (see a pattern here yet??). Now in March 2017, we called again due to the fan running non-stop and no cool air. The first technician they sent out stated that there was no electricity running to the unit. So the electrician comes out 2 weeks later, repairs that piece. We still don't have any A/C and the original A/C repair company, Home Reliance, does not know how to return phone calls after leaving 3 voicemails over a 5 day period. So I call First American to complain and get a new company assigned to us. At first this was denied, but after they couldn't get a hold of them they finally relented.
Finally we get the next A/C company, Belair Heating and Cooling (5th different A/C company at this point in a 3 year time span) who states we need a new system because just replacing the compressor isn't going to fix this repeated issue. But oh by the way, First American does NOT disclose to us that now we are not only responsible for paying just the service call we are also paying for the removal/disposal of the compressor (that was put in 9 months ago) and the charging of the new one which is going to cost us $455. The A/C company tells us this. The A/C company has told First American that they can not ensure that this repair will hold. Their "representatives" Nicole **, Calvin @ ext ** or Louis @ ** can't return phone calls or when told to move my call to their supervisor want to argue with me that they are the 'sole' decision makers on these issues.
I have my elderly mother with medical issues living with us and my special needs son who now both have window A/C units in their rooms. I don't have $7500 lying around to replace an A/C unit nor do I have the time to keep going through this every summer. One would think at some point that after reviewing the past 3 year history of this one and only issue that we have repeatedly called upon them for repairs, someone would realize the amount of waste occurring here. But I guess that's the minimal input from First American. So here is me reaching out yet again 6 weeks into the A/C unit still not working and paying for a service that doesn't provide their promised service.
Hello Erica,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed May 12, 2017
When I got the house, the lady that helped me with it advised that I get a home warranty because I am alone. She recommended First American. At first when I had to submit a claim, I just started panicking. And then I'd call the number, and they usually have a technician call me back. So far, the claim process has been easy. Sometimes I don't even talk to a person because it's automated. The technicians who have come in have all been very nice, as well. They always explain what they're doing to fix the problem. I feel good about their quality of work and the payments have been fair, too. First American is a very helpful service especially if you're not living in a brand new house, you're an older person and living on one single income.
Reviewed May 12, 2017
With First American, I can either file a claim online or call in and they pick up quickly. Their price is a bit higher than Fidelity and we're in the second year so the co-pay goes up from $50 to $75. But I've rehired some of the contractors that they have sent over. These contractors are good people. I love the plumber. He’s been back here twice doing some installations for me which were a separate item like when we took out the Corian and put in granite.
Reviewed May 12, 2017
We have renewed with First American every year. Other places were just as expensive and it seemed easier to stay with First American. The claims reps are okay, but getting a claim over the phone is obnoxious and the website's even worse to try and navigate. But once we get a contractor here, everything seems to go okay. We feel pretty good about the repairs and we're satisfied.
Reviewed May 11, 2017
My air conditioner went out then the vendor came and just collected his money. He said, "We've got let it fall out before I can do anything. I'll be back in a few days," and he never came back. I called First American and told them about that. They apparently called the vendor and the vendor said that it was not true and that's not what happened. First American took the word of the vendor over mine and threatened to send me to collection. I got really irritated and angry. I told them that I did not want that vendor to be sent to my house ever again.
I've only had one bad experience with a vendor. Overall, I am pleased with them. I felt that their $65 deductible is pretty reasonable. My pool pump died and I couldn't fix it. They replaced it which is like $800. Then I kept having problems with the central heating air. It finally reached the point at 37 years old that it could not be repaired and they replaced it as well. All I had to do was to pay $300 for a cord outside to put it on. I was out of air conditioning in Pensacola, Florida in September for two weeks and that's understandable because they had to get it authorized. Then recently, they replaced my pool filter and all I had to pay was $70 for the fan in addition to the $65. So, they're acting in good faith.
I have been told by other companies that First American is the most fair home warranty company that one could go with. And recently I mentioned that I'm planning to most likely move when I retire to another area and I mentioned it to a Realtor. The Realtor said that they had never heard of that home warranty and I'm thinking that I don't want another hassle about it. I've certainly got my money's worth with First American and they are quick to get somebody on it. They mean what they say and they say what they mean.
Reviewed May 11, 2017
I like the price and the things that First American Home Warranty offers. I just call them when I submit my claims or I do it online. The techs that have come have been good except for one that was supposed to return but never did. However, First American was able to resolve it. I would recommend them all the time.
Reviewed May 11, 2017
First American is a reliable company. However, the contract states that their reps work 24 hours a day, seven days a week, but when I call them during the weekends, they are not there. And if I call them after 5:00 PM, nobody picks up the phone. So whenever I have a problem, I have to wait to get services. If they cannot perform during the weekends and if they are open only between 8:00 to 5:00, they should not put on that contract that they are available 24 hours a day and seven days a week. They should be specific and they should not put a clause that they cannot support. I've called and asked them about that and they have no reliable answer. I'd rather remove the clause.
Reviewed May 10, 2017
I had a horrible experience with one of the contractors First American sent out. They had to come 3 different times to fix what should have been a very simple problem. The contractor said they'd be back at a certain time, then never showed up several times. Each visit was "We'll come sometime on a particular day" so we had to sit around waiting for these jokers every time they failed to fix the problem.
I just found out while tromping around up in my attic, they broke the drain line to for the AC. Now I have thousands of dollars of water damage to flooring and walls due to the small leak that occurred over a few months time, but of course the contractor won't own up to it even though they were the only ones in the attic. Managers at the contractor wouldn't return calls and basically ignored the horrible service and multiple mistakes.
But this review is about First American. You know what their response was? Basically nothing. Would they intervene while I was having this problem on my behalf? No. Would they contact their contractor? No. The only thing they'd do is file away my complaint. They have a problem contractor who provides sloppy, substandard repairs and they basically ignore it. First American doesn't care about its customers - evidence is they will do nothing to deal with problem contractors. BTW, First American's customer service takes on average about a week to respond to any complaint - wow!
Reviewed May 10, 2017
Submitting a claim to First American Home Warranty was easy. I called and told them what was going on, they asked questions, sent the claim and then the contractor contacted me. We set a date, he came out and fixed it and it was done. It was simple.
Reviewed May 10, 2017
I've used First American once and it went fine. I felt a little foolish because our disposal wouldn’t work. And then, the guy came in and within five minutes, he had it fixed.
Reviewed May 10, 2017
First American was the one we had when we got our house. When we had a problem, somebody came out and fixed it, and we were happy with that so we renewed with them. I talked to the gentleman who came out to my house and he was friendly, knowledgeable, helpful, and courteous. He changed a whole switch out. He knew what he was doing and didn’t take a long time to get everything up and going. Overall, I'm completely satisfied with their workmanship.
Reviewed May 9, 2017
I purchased a house with an upgraded premium home warranty. Firstly, you can't select your contractor (I don't use the ones they contract with). The electrical box to the pool shorted out and they would not repair it even though the system was connected to the main electrical box. Then I had a leak under the sink. It took days before the contractor could come over to take a look. It was determined that it was the garbage disposal and they replaced it with a new one. However, the plumber said they could not replace the rubber piece in the sink because it would be too complicated. It's only been in for a couple months and it now sounds like an airplane engine ready for takeoff.
Then my dishwasher was leaking. That appliance repairman could not find out where it was leaking and though perhaps there was a small kink in the hose that could have caused the problem. After he left, the trim piece around the dishwasher fell off after he reinstalled it and now the dishwasher is noisy. I called to have the drain stoppers checked because they were stuck and inoperable... not covered. Knocking in the pipes... not covered. Stove was shorting out and I called the manufacturer, but then someone told me if the stove needed to be replaced that First American would not necessarily replace with the same type of high-end stove.
When I got the renewal notice, the service calls went from $65 the first year to $75 for the current year, as well as the warranty purchase price increasing by approximately $100 a year. I got a phone call from First American asking why I didn't renew, so gave them the info. My real estate friends told me that home warranties are not a wise investment... kind of like the warranties that you purchase for your vehicles.
Reviewed May 9, 2017
I used my warranty several times over the course of a year. The contractors they sent were sketchy to say the least and each time they "fixed" the problem - more like put a band aid on it. Several things I had to have re-done by a reputable contractor. Specifically my AC - they sent two different contractors out because the first one didn't fix my issue. Each one basically just added freon and called it good.
However, now that my warranty has lapsed, I'm having the same exact issue as I had last summer and the tech I had inspect it this year explained my system has a freon leak in the evaporator coil - which basically means my unit needs to be replaced. I asked both contractors last year to check for leaks. So even though they didn't fix the problem when I had coverage, now that my policy has lapsed First American will not do anything. Even if I renew my contract, they will not cover the AC because "it is not in working order" - GREAT. Their contractors failed to do their job. Why in hell would I renew with them? I asked to speak to their underwriting dept and was put on hold and then disconnected. What a surprise!
Reviewed May 9, 2017
First American was the home warranty that we had when we purchased the house. Once it was up, we had the option to renew it. And we decided to renew it and we've renewed it ever since. They are reliable. When something needs to be fixed, it's pretty easy to get through and they send out people who are decent. We've had a couple of ones who were not agreeable. So, we had requested to not send them back for reasons as not fixing the problem and not having a really good attitude about it. And First American took care of it. We are happy with them and I've already recommended them. My brother has First American now because I told him about them.
Reviewed May 9, 2017
I was with a different provider before and had some problems. Then I found First American and went with them. Most of the time we do claim submission online because I have an accent and it's hard for me to talk with the computer. I have to talk with the customer service and many times I cannot catch them, but if I do then it's okay. A year ago, I had a problem with the plumbing and air conditioner company. I waited three weeks in the winter to fix the air conditioner and after three weeks they made a mistake and all the units broke in 24 hours. I requested them to send me another company and they did. And half an hour, everything was okay. Most of the time, I don't have a problem and the experience is fine.
Reviewed May 9, 2017
I was with AHS but they were a little bit overpriced. Since First American was a little less expensive and was offering the same service, I swapped. Filing a claim was easy. I called them, they passed all my need to some recommended providers and I was immediately called back. The deductible was a little bit high, though. Other than that, First American was helpful when I needed them and I would recommend them.
Reviewed May 8, 2017
Submitting a claim to First American is easy, you just call. The claims representatives are prompt in getting somebody to take care of the problem if it's covered. The interaction with the technicians is fine. It’s not a gigantic metropolis so we're working people that we're familiar with. They have a good reputation.
Reviewed May 8, 2017
We have an older home so getting a warranty was most important. The first home warranty service I had didn't work and I didn't like it. The warranty offered by First American was a little cheaper compared to other warranty providers. The service of First American is also okay and it's easy submitting a claim over the phone. They get topnotch technicians who come out to our home and fix whatever problems we have. The technicians ask what the problem is and fix it. I'll recommend First American. They're good people and having them is beneficial. They're fixing up stuff in my house and make them operate the way they were.
Reviewed May 8, 2017
I call First American. They give it a claim number. They contact the contractor. The contractor contacts me. They come out and do whatever needs to be done. It goes really smooth. I’m really pleased. I typically pay $65 copay for claims. An example was my gas water heater went out and I paid $65. That’s a $1,700 unit so I'm happy with $65.
Reviewed May 7, 2017
First American sounded reasonable and so we got their warranty. We never had any difficulty filing a claim and they came to the house and fixed whatever we needed. The technicians have been very nice, polite and good. The last claim was for the air conditioning. It's working well once they figured out what was actually wrong with it. First American is one of those things you don't wanna have to call but we're so glad that we can. In fact, I have recommended them to a friend.
Reviewed May 7, 2017
I had First American Home Buyers Protection with my old home. I've researched and most companies don't cover a lot of stuff. But I liked the appliances that First American covered. Submitting a claim was super easy and the customer service is good. They play step by step during the process. The technicians were friendly and their work was good.
Reviewed May 7, 2017
We have insurance with First American for years and I referred them to a lot of customers because I'm pleased with their service. We live in Westlake Village, which is 150 miles from our property, so to accommodate the tenants and provide good service, the best thing is to have somebody close by. Also, we know that First American deals with licensed and experienced contractors and stand behind their work. I can call them anytime and everything that we have any questions on was done. Their claims reps are also polite, patient, and work with their people. Not everything can be done on the same day but I have no problem. I pay my co-payment and I know the issue is gonna be taken care of. The tenants never complained about any of the technicians. And usually, if the people who work for First American cannot attend to an issue, then another one can step in. So, you cannot ask for a better deal. First American gives me a peace of mind.
Reviewed May 6, 2017
My daughter and her family have First American and we also have them as our home warranty provider. Submitting a claim is mostly easy and I contact their representative on the phone. Their customer service is good and the technicians have been really nice and always been real good.
Reviewed May 6, 2017
I'm on my own and sometimes, you can’t get people to come out and you don’t know who to call to fix. I have furnace people because I have my oil company but no one when it comes to plumbing stuff. I looked into home warranties and my neighbor who lived down the street told me I should get First American. Submitting a claim hasn’t been too bad here but I'm very disappointed this last time. I had my faucets replaced in my kitchen and bathroom and I called back again because when you turn the hot water on in my bathroom, the faucet screeches all the time. They sent another guy out and the guy said there’s not much they could do for it because they’re not very good quality faucets.
I called them back and they said that’s all that they pay for and if I wanna upgrade them, I have to pay the difference. I said that it’s all and good but if they're gonna give me a low grade, they should still work right. They asked if they were leaking and I told them they weren't but I asked if they would want to hear screeching every time you go to the bathroom and turn the faucets on. I called back again and asked for a supervisor but they never called me. I understand if that’s what I have to accept but if they’re gonna put a lower grade in there, shouldn’t the lower grade be working right? Why should something be put in there that screeches every time you turn the faucet on? I'm 75 years old, I never had a faucet to do that in my life! It’s annoying and I'm very dissatisfied. I am gonna look into someone else now because I’ve seen things advertised on television.
Hello Helen,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed May 6, 2017
My husband passed away and I'm at home by myself. I'm also handicapped and I needed help. And so, I decided to look into acquiring a home warranty. My neighbor recommended First American so I went with them. While it's nice to submit a claim to them, their phone service is a little slow. They take too long to answer the phone. I had to wait for two minutes before. Nevertheless, their claims representatives helped me and the quality of their service was wonderful. First American is an excellent company. I love them.
Reviewed May 5, 2017
A-1 Plumbing - I was quite happy with the plumber that AHB provided for me. Even though I had to call them to arrange, and they seemed overloaded with repair jobs, they still came by the same day, fix the problem, and got my family water to house again. I am quite pleased.
Reviewed May 5, 2017
First American did a good work for me before. I'm a senior citizen and it was easier for me to just continue with them. I call them if I have a claim to submit and they take my name and the problem. Within 24 hours somebody calls me back. Their representatives were very friendly. The technician that comes to service and overall quality of work were very good. They had to go out and come back because apparently the house had an asbestos mold issue that had to be addressed before they could finish. It was an easy experience although it was traumatic because they had to have the kitchen cabinets knocked out and they weren't even a year old. They replaced it with the same cabinets and then I just called the contractor who remodeled for me. They were lucky enough to be able to prop up the granite.
Reviewed May 5, 2017
We thought that a home warranty was a good service to have. We signed up with First American and so far, we've submitted one claim which was for the air conditioning unit that was leaking. We kept calling the company that we've given the information about. Eventually, a lady answered and told us she had just received the email from First American. It wasn't sent at the time that we were given the information. When we did the claim that night, the email should have went out but it didn't. Therefore, they had no knowledge of the claim that had been filed until we kept calling and calling. Other than that, the service is great. The technicians eventually came in and did what they had to do. The problem was resolved and I would recommend them to come back. Talking with First American on the phone was great, but because they didn't email the company and notify them that there was a claim, it wasn't a great experience. But I renewed and we're gonna keep the business.
Reviewed May 5, 2017
My husband chose First American to be our home warranty provider. Submitting a claim is an easy process and it's easiest for me to call over the phone but my husband does online. Their claims representatives are professional. We've had good experiences with the technicians and a few bad experiences, so it's been positive overall. If the technician hasn't been good, we tell First American that we don't want them. We had some issues with one company and they sent another company. They are very accommodating when we complain. Our things have been repaired pretty good and we are satisfied overall.
Updated review: June 11, 2017
Issue finally resolved.
Original Review: May 4, 2017
I am waiting on a part that the home warranty company is supposed to "locate" air con part to no avail. It is 90 degrees in Vegas and 80 at night. We are suffering every night for 3 weeks now. The first technician they sent didn't even look at unit. Then second company looked and stated we need a part which we've been waiting for over a week now! Our ordeal is total of 20 days now! WTF? I do not recommend you use First American Home Warranty company!
Reviewed May 4, 2017
Last summer I placed a claim for a leaking faucet. When the serviceman came out to fix, he dismantled my faucet completely, and said he had to order a part. I then received notification that faucets were not covered? When I called and asked why someone was sent to do this when it wasn't covered, I was told I would have to upgrade to include faucets, but could not do so until the new year contract. So I waited and did so. I called to schedule, and they said I had to wait 30 days, which I did. Finally, I was so excited to get my faucet back in my guest bathroom. The serviceman came in, said they don't cover preexisting conditions, but would not charge me, since he felt so bad about the whole story.
After wasting a day off work fighting this with First American, a supervisor asked for me to email him a copy of the original claim where it was dismantled. I did so, and no response. Emailed again, no response. A couple of weeks later I saw a letter in the mail rejecting my claim. Now, I receive a bill for the $65 service fee. I call to dispute, and she puts me on hold to call the plumber, and comes back and says they are going to charge me (which the plumber said he would not). I am calling the plumber service as soon as I hang up with her, and their billing service department is unreachable at this time? Ask for a supervisor, am put on hold for twenty minutes and disconnected. No words. I have been a customer for years, and no major claims, and they don't care about me one bit.
Reviewed May 4, 2017
I heard about First American through FHA when I bought the home. The first time I submitted a claim was a great experience. They repaired and everything was good. I've got a dishwasher and something else fixed by them. But the last time that they sent somebody out, they did not fix the garage door which the spring had come off. It's closing on one side. I paid $65 to have that did but it still ain't fixed and the springs were laying on the floor.
Reviewed May 4, 2017
If you had an appliance that was bad and you paid the fees, First American would even go all the way up and replace it if needed. It was easy to submit a claim with them. I have no problems. It was a recording and First American would ask you different questions and you’d tell them what you want. And finally, they’d get down to the place where you need to discuss the particular problem, they would pinpoint the problem, and then they’d tell you who is going to come out and work on it.
Their reps were very pleasant and receptive. When they gave me a worker that came out previously and I didn’t like what they did or they did shoddy work, I would call and talk to a live person, tell them the problem, and they would look it up on their file and say, “That’s true. We won’t send that person anymore.” All of the contractors they sent have been good, except for two. Also, the quality of the contractors’ work were 90% good.
Reviewed May 4, 2017
We've always submitted claims to First American online and we call them to ask questions afterward. Their representatives were great. They were very nice and informative. The process has been super easy. We recently had problems with our hot water heater. The plumbing company that came out, Island Mann Plumbing, was fantastic. They actually got a permit from the city and did everything correct. They did a good job. We're confident with the quality of their work.
Reviewed May 3, 2017
I've always had a home warranty but I wasn't happy with my last company so I switched to First American. Their representatives were very knowledgeable, courteous and respectful. Moreover, submitting a claim with them was quick and easy. Also, the quality of the work was good.
Reviewed May 3, 2017
I wasn't aware that I could put three claims on one until the guy sent out by First American told me. I had a dishwasher that had some bad parts on it, a refrigerator and washing machine leaking and making noise. So, I said, "Well, I need to get my washing machine fixed. I'll call you in a couple of days because my dishwasher is messing up, too." He said, "Hold up. That can be put on the same claim." I said, "Really?" One $75 payment. Then I said, “Well, check this out. I got a refrigerator that's leaking water." He said, "Yeah, we can definitely put that on the same claim." So, in a week and a half, they had everything fixed. The technicians have been great and the last one was wonderful.
The only problem I had was when I submitted a claim last year. I was having trouble with my air conditioning and First American couldn't get a contractor that had a ladder, they said I can call an outside contractor and they would reimburse me. But evidently, something happened. I didn't get my $60 back. It doesn’t matter at this point. But I called somebody else. And then when the guys that fixed it got here, he said, "Well, does First American know that you called somebody else in here?" I said, "Yeah, they told me to. They would reimburse me up to $200." And one of the guys says, "Well, that's $200 just to go to the roof." Long story short, the only thing that was wrong with the air conditioning was the fan blade had come off the motor. And they went up and they put a whole new motor fan blade on for me. It cost me $120 in co-pays. Other than that, the rest of the claims have been fine. I have already recommended them to other people.
Reviewed May 3, 2017
When we bought our current house, the previous homeowners had the First American plan in place, and we chose to continue it. It seemed like a good idea to do so and it has been a good experience for us. Submitting a claim was pretty smooth. During the daytime, from 7:00 AM to 9:00 PM, I can call and talk to a person to file a claim, but otherwise I have to do it online, like if it's in the middle of the night when nobody's working. Usually, when submitting a claim, I just called and talked to the reps, and they've been pleasant. I like the personal experience, and I prefer calling and talking to somebody better than doing it online. In fact, I've only used the website one time, and I try to avoid websites if I can.
I recently filed a claim for an air conditioning problem, and the service contractor that came out to do the work was fine. He was knowledgeable, knew what he was doing, and he fixed the problem. Although the work he performed wasn't the best for me, my AC unit is working, so it was good. Overall, First American has been easy to use, helpful, and I've been glad that they were there.
Reviewed May 2, 2017
We were offered this company when we bought our house. Never, ever use them! They nickle-and-dime everything. Most of their repair companies are below average. We signed up for the first class service and additional refrigeration coverage. I have been dealing with repair/replacement of our wine fridge for over 9 months now. They initially did not have anyone to repair it. We eventually had a company we found repair it but still did not work. Despite over 5 hours on the phone with them, they were unwilling to pay for it to be replaced and offered me $150. You will spend hours on hold waiting to speak to a supervisor and have to repeat the events of the repair over and over as they apparently don't document previous conversations. In my mind, they will do everything they can not to replace, and do not provide a warranty. BEWARE!
Hello Jeffrey,
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you. Thank you.
Reviewed May 2, 2017
Disgusted and enraged are the only words that come to mind when I think of FAHW. I've had contractors in my home 6 times in 3 weeks and still no resolution. I originally contacted them on 4/11/17 regarding my freezer not defrosting. They sent a contractor out. He diagnosed what the problem was and set an appt. He came out and did the work but while doing so, something else died. Had to order more parts. Visit 3. Came back out to replace the next part Visit 4. Now every time the freezer goes into a defrost cycle EVERYTHING THAWS. Water is leaking all over my freezer, all the food is freezer burnt and ruined. Visit 5 he came to "look at the issue". I tried explaining that it only thaws when it goes into defrost. Since it was frozen while he was there he said nothing's wrong. Even though you can clearly see ice crystals and dripping water. I told him I had video and photos which he has no interest in seeing.
Fast forward to today when the "second opinion" company comes out. First I had to contact them to set the appt because no one ever called me. The guys looked around and then handed me a clipboard. I had to ask, "So what's wrong?" He said, "Uh maybe this and maybe something else but I don't want to talk about it until I talk to someone else." "Excuse me? You don't want to talk to ME about what's wrong with MY appliance?" I asked when I should hear something He told me to call them in 3 days. WHY should I call you? Why am I the one setting the appts and doing all the leg work.
Both contractors that they sent to my home have 1 star reviews on Yelp. One has over 60 NEGATIVE reviews. What am I paying your company for yearly First American? I could have taken that yearly premium and applied to the cost of a replacement refrigerator. Why am I now at 3 weeks with no properly working freezer with children in my home? Has anyone in your company ever been without a freezer for 3 weeks? Would your CEO go 3 weeks without one? Why is this okay? Why is this not a priority? I contacted your company today, spoke with a "manager" who then transferred me to his manager. Which was just a random voicemail service that you needed to know the voicemail box. Once again no resolution, no assistance. I can assure you I will not be renewing my policy next year and I will make sure all my friends currently purchasing homes know not to use your company.
We appreciate your feedback and look forward to being able to address your concerns directly with you.
Reviewed May 2, 2017
First American compares really well against the company I had before so far. The one I had before, I didn't care for their services. When filing a claim, I call First American and they give me a number for me to call while the previous one did the arrangement themselves. But it's expensive because I'm living off a pension and when I call, it's a recording that starts talking to me, saying, "If this is what you're calling for, press this," and 90% of the time, it's not what I'm calling for. So, I have to wait until the end when it says, “Otherwise, wait or press 0.” But it's not just First American. It’s all the companies now. Also, when it says, "Go at a computer. Do this and do that", it irritates me because I'm not computer savvy.
Reviewed May 2, 2017
I was a first-time homebuyer and knew I could not afford any big pieces such as furnace and water heaters enough that I would need to have someone in order to help me do these things. The lady I bought the home from paid for a home warranty for me for a year but it got expensive, so I had to let them go. And at the times that I thought I needed them the most, they didn’t cover what I needed. My air conditioner went out and when I felt that they were to help me, they didn’t. So I was really in need of a home warranty then I heard about First American Home Warranty on the TV so I called them and asked a few questions.
First, I filed a claim for the oven coil in my range that went out and I was satisfied. And then, my dryer stopped working this March. The starter/stop switch went out and I called them. The technician who they sent was polite and funny. He looked it over, ordered the piece, and put it in. So far, I'm satisfied with First American. Their claims process was easy. However, they had Sears for everything and they took so long. It took two weeks for the man to come back and fix the parts for my stove. But the one who fixed the dryer only took one week. He was right back like he said and took care of the issue. I would recommend First American and already have.
Reviewed May 2, 2017
Getting a home warranty was a requirement and my realtor told me about First American when I purchased my home. Submitting claims has been fine which I can do either online or over the phone but I typically do over the phone. They have a good customer service and our interactions were fine. The process is easy and the technicians that I have had come to my home were very courteous. They explained some of the processes of what they were doing as they were doing it and their quality of work was fine. It's been a very good experience.
Reviewed May 1, 2017
I called a week ago about my air conditioner. I had a problem with it last year as well, and they "fixed" it. The tech actually disconnected some safety wires. This year a different company came. He said there had been an electrical fire! Probs due to the lack of safety turn-off wiring? The new tech wanted to do the right thing and replace the ac unit. It is 24 years old and well past its life expectancy. They told him they want a second opinion. It has been a week... still no AC. Wondering why we pay for this insurance. It seems they want the cheapest way out and not concerned about doing it right. I am a doctor and I would not do that to my patients.
Reviewed May 1, 2017
I’ve been a realtor for many years, and always used First American for the properties that I have listed. All of the representatives have been very helpful. The technicians are great too. First American has a good technician base, although we have some companies that we’ve blackballed from working with our company and when I’ve asked First American to reassign, they do it right away. And if there’s any recalls, the techs go back out. So everything is good. First American has been professional and easy to work with.
Reviewed May 1, 2017
The claims process of First American was really easy other than writing the checks. I called the number on the contract that we had and they brought to my attention that I can create an account. They sent me an email with the link so I got that setup. It makes it a lot easier to communicate that way. The responses are very prompt and dealing with their people has been fine. They are very cordial and very understanding.
I got the warranty policy from closing upon purchase of the new house from the previous owner and the problem I have with the claim is the person who purchased the warranty because it didn't cover what I wanted it to cover. If I did it myself, I would have spent the money and got a better warranty than the basic. I should have checked but I didn't. So I have to outlay a lot of money to repair our air conditioner right now. It's a little disappointing. And it's taking a little while to work some of the things out on this air conditioner claim that we have going. They came out twice for the diagnostics and found different issues both times. As it turns out, they were both related. The air handler had to be replaced but they didn't know that the first time. But First American has been great all along. I also get prompt follow-up calls from them. Even the air conditioning company that they have associated with have reps who are really responsive and nice.
Reviewed May 1, 2017
When we first bought our house, First American came with it and it was prepaid for a year. We didn’t want to renew the contract afterward but we had a lot of problems with the house during that year so I called them to get a new contract. I researched a couple of other home buyer protection warranties and they all seemed to be within the same price range. But we decided to go with First American because we have five sump pumps on our property that flood quite a bit and First American had the option of covering them which was pretty important.
Filing a claim with them goes really well mainly because it’s online. We’re able to list our problem relatively easily and they’re able to understand what the issue is. However, on the first year that we had the contract, we had an electrician come and look an outlet that wasn't working in our bedroom and he said that he can’t fix it because it was in the walls. I hadn’t researched the contract well enough to know what was and wasn’t covered. It was annoying in that sense.
In the washroom where you’ve got the drain that leads to the main sewer line, we found out that the previous owners drilled holes into that pipe so the outside groundwater got into that pipe and drained out to the city main, which was stupid because when it rained a lot, it backed up into our house. We filed a claim for that and the plumber said that it was underneath the concrete so he can’t fix it. That was another thing that wasn’t in the contract. You have to read the fine print and not assume that it will automatically be fixed. I also know that some people have had issues with the contractors that First American sent them. But other than those, I've had good overall experiences with First American.
Reviewed April 30, 2017
When I purchased my house about ten years ago, there was a First American warranty on the property. I then just renewed it and after 11 years, I'm still with them. It's very easy filing a claim. I make the call and they schedule a contractor to come out to the house. That contractor calls me, schedules the time, and come out to do the repairs. It's pretty much cut and dried and that's why I'm still with them. The deductible is very reasonable although it went up by $5. I was paying $60 when I first started and now, it's $65. Otherwise, the work of their contractors have been very good and I've never had a problem with them.
Reviewed April 30, 2017
I had a compressor that I had to put on the air conditioning about a month ago. The first guy sent by First American didn't do what he was supposed to do. Two days later, the air compressor went out on my a/c. They sent the supervisor over and confirmed it. They came back and fixed everything. I prefer them doing the work correctly once they send somebody that had a little bit more knowledge. But I'm not throwing the first guy they sent out there under the bus. I'm an old gentleman and I understand him. He was just trying not to mess up but he needed more experience. Other than that, from a scale of 1 to 10, I'm extremely satisfied. I filed about four claims since our home is an older model. They come in and I pay my deductibles then they do what they need to do. I'd recommend them to others.
Reviewed April 29, 2017
I was up in my age and live by myself. I couldn't afford stuff and thought First American was a good insurance. I have submitted about three claims and one of them was with my furnace. They send someone at least four days after I call. One of the contractors was nice and let me know when he's coming out. And as long as someone comes, I'm okay. First American is good and their service is worth it. But if something’s wrong, they don't come out right away. And they don't even call. They should have somebody ready to come out in a case of emergency.
Reviewed April 29, 2017
I have had to spend hours upon hours on the phone with this company to have 3 issues repaired. I have yet to have our final issue resolved and have contacted the Dept of Insurance for help. This company does everything it can, including verbally mislead, in order to avoid having to pay for repairs. Their contractors are terrible because they get paid so little by FA. Please avoid this company at all costs!!
Reviewed April 29, 2017
We had a house and I figured that getting a home warranty would be the best thing to do. I did some research online and found out First American was one of the best ones to go with. I also heard about them from my mother-in-law. Submitting a claim with them online was very easy because everything was self-explanatory on how to do everything. Also, everyone was pleasant and nice. The people shopping around to find a home warranty are wasting their time on shopping around. They just need to go with First American. They're awesome.
Reviewed April 29, 2017
We have an app on the phone and we just choose what the problem is, type in what’s wrong, hit send and submit a claim then First American would have a contractor go out to our home. Their quality of work isn’t like the American Home Shield. One of them was great and the other was one not so much. Our air conditioner was not working so the contractor came out and said that it was probably the thermostat.
The contractor had a used thermostat in the truck so he put it then the air conditioner came on, which meant it was the thermostat. He said he usually carries thermostats with him but he just leaves the old one there and it would fix it. I was like, “No. It’s supposed to replace what’s on the wall.” So he took the old thermostat with him and he said he’d order me a new one. And then when he did that, he replaced it with a cheaper and basic thermostat that goes up and down. Whatever we set it, that’s what the air is. I had a seven-day programmable where we could program it different times a day and he didn’t replace it with that. It didn’t make me happy but he was ugly and so that’s what we got. I would never use that contractor. But overall, First American's good.
Reviewed April 28, 2017
I was allowed to choose the home warranty company when I purchased my home July 2016. My realtor recommended First American so chose them. This was the worst decision I could have made. Not only did they initially take 1 month to process the payment for the warranty, they gave me the run around about it. The title agency sent them the check, not me, and the title agency could tell they had cashed the check.
The first claim with them was regarding the a/c about a month after we moved in. The assigned contractor never called so I called over the course of several days trying to reach them. No response. First American finally changed the contractor 8 days after the initial service request. They could not reach the first contractor either. The second contractor fixed the a/c no problem. We had no further claims until April 2017 when the drain tiles needed cleaned out. I filed a claim and tried for two weeks to reach the assigned plumber. Finally I could no longer wait so I cancelled the claim and First American said, "We will note that your oven was fixed" in their reply. This goes to show how horrible their customer service really is. The claim was under the "plumbing" category.
End of April now and the a/c is not working again, so I filed a claim. I was assigned the original a/c contractor who never responded. I demanded that First American change the contractor because I do not want to wait another week until there is no response. They refused saying he is the preferred contractor. WHAT A JOKE! Steer clear of this company. They are designed to keep you renewing your warranty for years and years, they don't hire reputable contractors, they hire random guys that will do the work for the cheapest price. Flaky contractors that cannot even call on an assigned job. Customer service with these people is horrible too. Choose another company. I have colleagues at work that have had no issues with their home warranty company, of course they do not have First American.
Reviewed April 28, 2017
I've had First American for a number of years. They have a good company that quickly fixes our air conditioning. But I have a current claim which is for a dishwasher repair and it's been going on for about two months. We're waiting for the parts to arrive for about a month each and there are two parts. We're living without a dishwasher for two months which is horrible. I called First American and they said the contractor has to wait for the part until it comes in. I told them I can go across the street and get the part for them if they want me to. The parts are readily available but they told me we have to wait. It's the worst experience I've ever had. They don't know how to talk to people. They are very bad. And they’re very short with me. They say, “This is the way we do it. You take this deal or you don’t, you tell me. I offer you Thursday. That's it." It's like they are doing me a favor or they work for free.
I don't want to argue too much because I need my dishwasher to be fixed. Today, the technician came out and he found a new problem. I asked if it's going to be another two months for the part and he said, "No. I don't know how they do it in the office. But they get parts twice a week. I don't know how long it's gonna be." I should ask them to give me a payout for the dishwasher and go buy a new one.
Reviewed April 27, 2017
This is so frustrating. Why would someone pay a premium and buy a home warranty when there is no responsibility and urgency from the service provider. I am waiting on a refrigerator repair service for last 2 days. I didn't get any call from the service provider or the assigned contractor till now. I would rather call some independent contractor with good rating on Yelp and they can come over same day in few hours. Here I am paying a premium plus service fee for each visit. I can just pay one time service fee to those independent contractor and get things done quicker. FAHW also increased the premium and each service fee drastically for the 2nd year. I am not going to renew for 2nd year.
Reviewed April 27, 2017
When we purchased our home, the previous homeowner had the service. When he sold us the house, he bought us one year. He took care of all the appointments and everything. After the year was up, I received the letter from First American Home Warranty and we renewed it from there. It was a good price and we added in appliances too that fit into our budget. We already purchased appliance insurance like the dryer all that other stuff and we added up all of those. It would have cost more than what we were gonna pay for everything, including what they would cover with the plumbing and the electrical. It was a way better value than individually having one for your washing machine, dryer and refrigerator.
The first time I submitted a claim, I called. But I also had gone online at the same time to see which one would go faster. I tracked the whole process and they were helpful about getting somebody out in time and getting it fixed. They had somebody out the next day. It was for our washing machine. My insurance on that washer was only for one year. It came in handy and perfect, and played out good. There was a copay, but so as my other insurance too. The contractor assessed the problem when he came. He had to order an actual part for that and he came back in a couple of days and fixed it. The washing machine is working fine.
Recently, our hot water tank blew up. I did the claim online and then I called them. They have somebody out the very next morning. We are trying to get them out that night, but it was already six or seven o'clock at night by the time I got home. They got here and had it replaced the next day. It was the original heater with the house. It was old but they didn't question the age of the water heater, which was like, "Okay, cool." I didn't have to pay for repairs. My son helped out because he was there, but we had to put a piece of wood down. It was in my garage and it was sitting on a drywall. So, the water was everywhere. They don't cover that, but I was able to fix all that myself. I got a water pan and drip system going out if it ever happens again. I am happy that I bought the insurance, because I saved money in the long run. It's a very excellent job. So far, so good.. My supervisor actually signed up with them.
Reviewed April 26, 2017
I purchased the one year home warranty through First American Home Warranty Company, but that was the worst choice ever. The water heater in my home broke down and I contacted them. It was a Saturday so they gave me the contact information of another scammer "contractor" that is J and S Mechanical. I called the contractor and they never responded. I sent them email, and called them and left multiple voicemails. No one ever called me back.
On Monday, I received a call from the contractor saying that they were going to come to fix the issue, but the soonest they could come was on Tuesday. I told them that I had two small children and I was already out of water for a few days. They were like, "We are too busy, so you either tell me yes now or goodbye." I was like, "Wow!!! Really???"
On Tuesday, the contractor showed up with no call in advance (although I called both the contractor, and the warranty company three times to give me an ETA), and told my wife that they needed to replace the water heater, but they had to "send a report to the warranty company before they can do that." That means they did nothing but just left a $75 invoice that I needed to pay.
Tuesday passed and no one called from the warranty company or the contractor. I called the home warranty company, but I was told that I had to come up $725 out of pocket in addition to the $75 for the contractor trip charge in order for them to replace my water heater. I had to either pay $800 or accept their cash offer. The call dropped multiple times after putting me on hold and I had to call again and again and go through their stinking "verification process." It is Wednesday and I am still having no hot water to at least give shower to my two years old and five years old children.
Finally, I called the home warranty company again and they offered me $420.77 cash for the issue so I can fix it myself. Please note the following ridiculous numbers: First American Home Warranty offered reimbursing me $135 for the Installation Cost when in fact their contractor asked me to pay $725 out of pocket for installing the unit plus the $75 trip charge. And by the way, $800 was only my cost, and that they may bill the home warranty company too.
Also, they offered $345.7 for the water heater. I think that they meant to give me the price of a used or maybe broken water heater. I looked online and I couldn't find any gas water heater of similar model for less than $400. In sum, this company will try to rip customers off in one way or another. It's been almost a week I am out of hot water, and I still stand right in the same place that I was without a warranty, much less to say that I lost hours being on hold on the phone.
Reviewed April 26, 2017
I purchased First American Home Warranty before the start of summer (February) and the salesman for company made me buy extra coverage at premium level to cover for any pre-existing issues. At the beginning of summer (April), I started having HVAC issues. The contractor discovered issues with the HVAC coils that need to be replaced. The company refused to service and denied any claims despite having paid for the extra coverage. I believe this company exists to swindle customers and any claims greater than a minor repair, which are not profitable for the company after the $75 deductible, are denied based on pre-existing conditions. This is a fraud.
Reviewed April 26, 2017
Submitting a claim with First American has usually been easy. They're on top of it and are efficient. The technician who came out to my home was respectful and he explained everything thoroughly. However, we were expecting First American to pay the whole bill, but they only paid half. Also, the last time we used them, they only paid $1000, but the bill was $4000, so I had to take out a loan.
First American Home Warranty Company Information
- Company Name:
- First American Home Warranty
- Year Founded:
- 1984
- City:
- Santa Rosa
- State/Province:
- CA
- Website:
- homewarranty.firstam.com
Media


