Buyer's Choice Award Winner

American Home Shield Reviews

4,887,169reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
+1 more
Author picture
Edited by: Ben Strauss

About American Home Shield

American Home Shield is a home warranty provider that offers service plans throughout the contiguous United States. It offers three home warranty plan options, priced from $29.99 to $89.99 per month, with either a $100 or $125 service fee. In addition to normal wear and tear, plans cover breakdowns from rust, insufficient maintenance and faulty repairs, which are often excluded from home warranty coverage.

Pros
  • Three plan options
  • High coverage limits
  • 30-day workmanship guarantee
  • Covers rust, corrosion and sediment damage
Cons
  • Relatively high service fees
  • Not available in all states

American Home Shield Reviews

Over 100k reviews since 2012

Filter by Rating

  • (67,006)
  • (16,404)
  • (8,667)
  • (4,315)
  • (13,525)

Popular Mentions

    How do I know I can trust these reviews about American Home Shield?
    • 4,887,169 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Top reviews
    • Top reviews
    • Recent
    • Oldest
    • Most helpful

    A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

    3 featured reviews
    How do I know I can trust these reviews about American Home Shield?
    • 4,887,169 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
    • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
    • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
    • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
    Page 516 Reviews 102635 - 102835
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 15, 2015

    I have been a customer for over 10 years with AHS. I have had a lot of bad experiences with the company. Hence, the 1 out of 5 or 20% rating. Most of my issues concern the central AC in my home. Contractors have "fixed" evaporator coil freezing up on a few occasions over the past 10 years. Once the contractor said he had to replace the coil. We waited several days in a hot Florida summer for that to happen. More recently, same problem, contractor said the evaporator coil needs to be replaced and we would have to pay the rest of the Freon charges since AHS only pays ($10/lb?).

    I was given an estimate for around $700 (Freon cost $80/lb) for my out of pocket to replace the coil. After I complained to corporate they sent out a second opinion contractor who looked at the system and, without performing any checks, offered to sell me a whole new AC. We asked him to leave but not before he demanded his $75 co-pay. AHS finally offered us a cash out. All of this in Florida heat! I immediately found a contractor who replaced my coil and put Freon in for less than a couple hundred dollars out of pocket.

    My contractor showed me the coil he replaced. It had information on it that showed the date of manufacture to be the same as the original unit (15 years old). This is the one that was "replaced" by an AHS contractor a few years ago. You figure! Other issues with the AC involved the motor on the outside unit "screeching" so loudly (I have a video of it) all the time that we had to turn off the unit at night so our neighbors could sleep.

    I was told by AHS that they cannot replace anything that had not completely failed. Within a week it failed and it was replaced. I asked the corporate person if her AC was doing this what would she do? She did not reply. On another occasion one of the hot water faucets was giving only a trickle when turned on full. The contractor said it was caused by sediment in the water heater and AHS will not cover it since I did not properly maintain it. I always drain the water heater properly once a year. I paid the contractor to clean the tank. After he tried the faucet again the problem was still there. It turned out that that the actual hot water line to the faucet was blocked. He still insisted that the water heater had caused the problem but I did not persist with AHS about it.

    These are only a few of the problems I had with this company and I gave notice that I do not want my contract renewed when it expires in June. I was transferred to the retention department and spoke with the nicest person I spoke with at the company so far. Of course she was only trying to get me to stay but I did not relent.

    Thanks for your vote!
    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed May 15, 2015

    On the first hot day of this year we turned on the air conditioner and found that it was not cooling the house. I called American Home Shield and they assigned a contractor to come to diagnose the problem. He came here last Friday, May 8, 2015. I needed a new compressor. My air conditioner is an older Freon based unit. I was told that I would need 8 lbs of Freon, for which he charges $70.00 a lb. AHS only pays $10.00 a lb, so it would cost me $480.00 in addition to my service fee of $125.00. I was told that within 24 hours this information would be sent to AHS.

    On Friday night, the owner of the contract company called and said that he recommended an upgraded system, and that he could give me a good price. He wanted to know if I wanted to go along with that. I told him I needed more details, and that I wanted to hear from AHS first. On Monday morning, first thing in the morning he called again with a price and told me that it was a good price. He also told me that it would cost me $720 for Freon.

    I told him that I was told that the unit only needed 8 lbs not 12 lbs. This made me very distrustful. Again I told him that I wanted to hear from the insurance co first. As of Tuesday afternoon he still had not contacted the insurance co. AHS contacted him and he told them that he was waiting on my decision before they contacted AHS. The AHS rep told him that I wanted the information sent to them BEFORE I made a decision.

    Meanwhile it has been hot here and I feel that this contractor is not dealing with me fairly and honestly. I feel that he was trying to get me to circumvent the insurance so I just hire him to do the upgrade. I have called AHS about 4 times and told them this. The people on the phone just listen and "Yes Ma'am" me. They offer me NO feed back.

    I called AHS again on Wednesday. I reached a man who finally actually talked to me. I told him my story and he found out that the contractor finally sent in his diagnosis and was authorized to replace the compressor and fill it with 8 lbs of Freon. I asked how much money was authorized for the job and he told me. I asked if I could get another contractor out since I was uncomfortable and did not trust the first guy. I was told that that would cost AHS money and that I could take a cash out. However I'm afraid that that would only cost me even more money since I have already gotten quotes for the repair at much higher cost that what AHS would probably give me as a cash out.

    I feel that I made a big mistake getting this insurance. I feel that I am not being dealt with fairly and that for it to cost me the least amount of money, I have to use a contractor who I don't trust. Lastly, I have tried to contact the cash out department and can never get through. I was told that they would call ME but they never did.

    Thanks for your vote!
    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 15, 2015

    It has been a good experience with American Home Shield so far. We had a plumbing issue, it was taken care of as soon as we called it in.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 15, 2015

    We recently called for AHS services when we had a power outage in the house. We called on Saturday and it took several attempts but when I eventually spoke to someone, the lady was very sympathetic and helpful in trying to get somebody out here as soon as possible. It took until Tuesday for them to come out and fix it, and we didn't appreciate that. We had to run extension cords from the garage to the side of the house that had power so we wouldn't lose the food that we had in the freezer and the refrigerator. Although, everything's been performing great since the repair.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 15, 2015

    I need to warn others about American Home Shield (AHS) that when you have something that needs to be fixed, they will try to figure a way to deny your claim by interpreting your contract. In my situation, AHS denied the claim to fix the AC saying it was not installed. The AC was installed and working for years. AHS sent out a service provider to check and he came back with a report that there were two wires that were disconnected. This was enough for AHS to deny the claim to fix the AC. After contacting the service provider, he said he could provide the service directly to me without using AHS and would cost 3200 to fix. Doesn't this whole thing seem fishy? I really regret signing up with AHS.

    Updated on 5/20/2015: Warning - Do not trust American Home Shield. I have a very bad experience with AHS. The AC broke down and they have found ways to deny the claim by saying the AC had wires that were disconnected. As an example, if your car engine is under warranty but the warranty complain denies your claim saying that the battery was disconnected. In my situation, AHS first claimed that the AC was not installed. The AC had been installed for years! Then later another rep said that was incorrect and that the AC could not be tested properly because the AC wires were unplugged. These are not legit reasons to deny a claim. If you want to sue AHS they will tell you that in your agreement you agree not to sue them and have to go through a company they selected to arbitrate a dispute. The company they selected will charge you at first $200 to file. AHS scheme is to have many obstacles in hope that the customer will eventually give up.

    1. AHS will not honor their contract by interpreting their contract in ways to deny your claim. 2. AHS is very disorganized where when they deny your claim, different representatives will give you different reasons and will even tell you the previous reason was incorrect. In my case, AHS had changed 4 different reasons. 3. AHS avoids ways to be sued by requiring you to go through arbitration with a company they selected and this company will first charge you $200 to just file the dispute. Thus AHS set up this method to intentionally discourage any disputes.

    My recommendation is to AVOID American Home Shield. When I first signed up they told me other warranty companies would give you the runaround if you make a claim which is exactly what AHS had done to me. They will make their warranty sound very easy and that they will repair whatever breaks. But I have found through direct experience that this is NOT the case. AHS will do everything they can to deny your claim and avoid their responsibility. I believe there were a few class action lawsuits against AHS for bad business practices. If you have a bad experience you can contact ** in hopes to slowly develop a class action lawsuit against AHS bad business practices.

    Thanks for your vote!
    No response received
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    Every time I call AHS (even to make a payment on my account) I get a Customer Service Representative with an attitude problem. As is stated with all company phone calls: "For training and quality purposes, your call may be recorded." Well, I hope that some high ranking official in the company actually listens to the conversations that take place between representatives and customers because this customer service attitude problem for sure is not helping AHS.

    On the other hand, American Home Shield ought to call customers and ask about the experience they've had with vendors/contractors. This one company that they use in my area is doing more harm to them than good!! Can you only imagine calling in AHS on Thursday evening in the winter to report a leaking water heater and then hearing from the vendor on Saturday morning just to say that they will not be in the area till the following Thursday? Like we can be a whole week without hot water!! LOL, Please AHS high execs, be on top of your customer service reps and vendors!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Coverage

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    I recommend and value our warranty. Very positive results with my stove and dryer. The Air Conditioning coverage could be better but the repair service is great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    Contact AHS for service on my AC unit. Vendor determined the unit need a replacement compressor. AHS contacted me to inform me of the terms of replacing the unit / major changes in cost to me versus 3 years prior. I agreed to the terms of replacing the unit. Vendor replaced the unit. Several days later I contacted the vendor and AHS and informed both unit was not cooling correctly. Vendor came out about 11:20 and reported the unit was functioning correctly.

    Over a period of 3 days I repeatedly reported the non-cooling issue to AHS, on the last call the CSR told me a repeat visit was not need because the unit had been repaired. I argued the difference and sternly request a recheck of the non-cooling of my home during higher ambient temperatures. I also called and left a message with the vendor. The vendor made a return visit and corrected the problem with the unit. This repair took 4 trips by the vendor and numerous call to both to get corrected. This was the worst service related experience by far in my 30 plus years as a home owner.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    I have American Home Shield come twice a year and I also pay extra for my annual AC check and everything has always been good. The representatives and the contractors have been very good, they were professional and have always cleaned up after themselves. I have had no issues with repairs and they work as they did before. I recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    Hello - I'm trying to reach someone to help me with a warranty issue. I've had American Home Shield for less than 1 month. The warranty service came with the purchase of my new house. Here's my current situation: Prior to buying the house the home inspector flagged the hot water heater as leaking. The sellers called AHS and a service provider was dispatched to look at it in late March. (Based on the reviews of the service provider, AHS should more carefully evaluate service providers, but that's a separate issue). The service provider said there was nothing wrong with the hot water heater.

    Fast forward to this weekend when the hot water heater started leaking all over our garage. Luckily this happened within the 60-day window of the first service so we did not have to pay a repeat service fee to have the hot water heater looked at again. The service provider confirmed that the hot water heater needed to be replaced this time and AHS only covered a portion of replacing - we had to spend close to $500 out of pocket. While this was going on yesterday, I had to call AHS a few times and consistently had to wait for 30+ minutes to speak to someone live. Additionally, I was told twice that a supervisor would call me back and I'm still waiting on a phone call back. Now I want to cancel my policy and that is proving to be the most difficult! I hate posting in a public forum, however want to find out how I can reach someone at AHS who can actually help me. Please let me know.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    My garage door wasn't opening or closing properly. The repairman made some adjustments and left. The door seemed repaired, but after just a week it is starting to act up again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 14, 2015

    We had a leak in our bathroom and it came through in the dining room ceiling. We called AHS and had it repaired. They sent a guy here and he had me write a check to him for service charge and I bought the stuff for the repair of the ceiling for repainting. He did a job okay. The only problem was it made our floor wet and he didn't do anything about that. We're very pleased with American Home Shield. Most of the time it does very well.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 13, 2015

    Any time I needed the work and I called American Home Shield, they were very nice and helpful. I had peace of mind, they take care of it and they always have send good specialist who knew what to do. I have been very happy with them. They are very quick even I had problem on Sunday, it was taking care of it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 13, 2015

    The worker showed up on time and was very friendly and did a good job. I'm so glad we have American Home Shield!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 13, 2015

    My refrigerator has been freezing since my first call on February 9. A service tech came out after about a week wait and changed a part. Within 30 days it happened again. A recall was made and a tech came out and reprimanded me for defrosting the refrigerator because he had a harder time diagnosing the problem. He worked on the inside and left. Needless to say it has frozen again and another recall was made. This time a new service tech came out and ordered more parts. I waited 2 weeks for the parts and when he came back and opened the back of the refrigerator and started making the replacements, he determined the coil was bad and called the company. He recommended a replacement refrigerator as he could not unclog something inside.

    Today I got a confirmation message stating that another tech call to set up another appointment. I have been without refrigeration since February 9. I have contacted GE Corporate and they offered a discount on a new refrigerator but could not assist with American Home Shield. I have lost loads of food, my electric bill has skyrocketed and have to intrude on my neighbors kindness to store insulin medication. I'm glad so many people have had success with this company but I haven't had much luck. It is very hard to live without refrigeration and I really don't see this ever getting resolved.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 13, 2015

    I was very impressed with the speed with which they called me to schedule the appointment to come out. We've had AHS now for six years and we had several claims filed on our last house. The people that they send out were great. They were courteous, professional and did their job well and quickly. So overall, we've had a lot of very good experiences with AHS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 13, 2015

    It was pretty easy submitting a claim with AHS. My most recent claim with them was for an air conditioner. Their representative was helpful and kind and the contractors that they sent out were really good. And so far, the performance of the AC was good after the repair. So, everything was fine. They always take care of my concern, so I appreciate the service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 12, 2015

    AHS as far as I am concerned is FAR from being a 4 stars company. What I have gotten so far is: plumbing. AHS wanted to give me $750 for the repair BUT the crook they send me wanted another $700!!!! I had it fixed for less than that!!!! Refrigerator: The lame repair man left without saying much and never left a report to let me know what was wrong! I did end up buying a new fridge since my tenant could not wait anymore since their food was spoiled. From my experience: the contractors they send you are not efficient AND if you read the contractors or companies they send you reviews you may be surprised or not to see low rating. I am giving 2 stars by pity!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 12, 2015

    I've only used American Home Shield once and it was okay. But the company they sent out for my AC repair were crooks. What AHS does is send out contractors who they recommend but the contractors try to rip your head off the prices and say that AHS doesn't cover probably anything. They try to charge you and they want you to buy a new AC system. AHS can be rated with a perfect 5 star for contacting the contractor and having them come to your house, quick response of timing and taking your monthly payment on time. But rating them on who they use would get them a 1 star because the company they sent was terrible.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    TechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 12, 2015

    There was recently a leak in one of my pool pumps so I filed a claim with AHS. It went very smoothly. The contractors did a great job. The only thing is that I would like to have a little more write-up of what was repaired. I really have no documentation about what was done and what the cost would have been if I had had to pay for it out of pocket. Otherwise, I am happy with them. I'm very, very supportive and I would recommend AHS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 11, 2015

    The last 2 plumbing problems I had with my home were very dissatisfying. The first time I filed a claim for a leaking kitchen faucet, leaking valve outside of the house and my leaking valves for my washer hookups. My outside valve still leaks and the plumber would not fix my washer valves. I had to hire another plumber to fix the valves for my washer hookups. I paid the service fee of $75 and my AHS premium but did not get full repairs. I should have cancelled then but didn't.

    It's the second problem that I'm going to cancel my contract over.

    I had a stopped up water line, my kitchen sink was back up with water. I filed a claim. After waiting well over 20 hours the plumber still did not call me. He finally called, came by to look in the sink and confirmed with my son that the line was clogged but he refused clear the line. He took my money (another $75 and AHS took my premiums) but would not do any work. I called AHS to complain and asked to speak with a manager, which was last week; I'm still waiting for a call back. I found a friend with a snake and we unclogged the drain ourselves. Do yourself a favor and find another company, one that values their customers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 11, 2015

    AHS help to ensure that any appliances are kept in working order at all time. Their choice of contractors ensures that the right people call at the right time and provide a great service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 11, 2015

    Our contractor was outstanding and did excellent work. While it took longer to get the project started that I would have liked, it was completed to my total satisfaction. Our hot water tank was ultimately replaced which required some replumbing and reventing which did accrue additional costs not covered by the plan, but the tank was fully covered. We chose to upgrade to an even better fast recovery tank and the contractor worked with us to accomplish our goal.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Thank you for sharing this experience William! We appreciate your feedback!

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 11, 2015

    Our recent claim was for the dishwasher. The claims process was fine, though a little confusing about what we could and couldn't order. There was a little confusion when one person would say one thing and then somebody else would tell us something else. It took a little bit but we finally got it figured out.

    The first contractor they sent was horrible. I tried to call the guy and left him three messages and then when he called me back, I was at work and he said he could be at my house that morning. I was like, "Well, I'm already at work and I'm 45 miles away." And then I never heard from him again so we wound up getting somebody else. It took us like three and a half weeks to finally get it replaced. We were kind of mad about the way things were going with the first contractor. But then when we got our new contractor, everything was great. He diagnosed the problem and had everything switched out pretty quick.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 11, 2015

    I'm a single mom and when things break down you know repairs are a fortune so it's a true blessing that I have AHS. Most recently there was a leak in our bathtub. The water just kept running! AHS has courteous and friendly claims reps and their contractors are awesome. I've only had one bad experience and it's not with them, it's with the contractor they sent out to me in which I've told them never to send back to my house. I had a few other incidents and since then they've never sent him back to my house. With all these, I'm always recommending AHS to my friends.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 10, 2015

    My refrigerator became disable 12/2014. After two different contractors came out to repair- each time it did not work. I have purchased a refrigerator, because I had no way of keeping my food from spoiling. I am requesting some compensation for the new refrigerator. It is my desire to hear from you soon. This will determine keeping my contract. You can find other information on your website.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed May 10, 2015

    It was very easy submitting a claim with American Home Shield. Basically, they just took the information, set up the contact and everything went really smooth and the company called shortly after that. The service company and the service technician that came out were very good and have been very helpful. They did some warranty work and were good enough to help us in other things that were not covered under the warranty. Everything's good right now, I would recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 10, 2015

    I had a little bit of trouble getting the last plumber AHS sent out so we had to put in a second call but other than that they've re-dispatched him on an emergency and he was out here the next day. The person on the first and second call was very understanding. On the second call she said "Let me put this in as an emergency and let me know if they don't call you today." They called later that evening and he apologized and made an appointment to come out the next day. I had a busted leak underneath my mobile home so they took care of it. I would recommend American Home Shield definitely also because they've got good prices. Service is good too. This one missed appointment was the only one that I've ever had so it was family issues. His wife got sick and he had to pick up the kids. I got a family too so I understand.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 9, 2015

    Our air conditioner pan was dripping so the coils had to be removed and fixed and then put back in again. We sent our claim and the rest was taken cared of by AHS. The contractors they sent were very responsive and did a great job. Everything's working fine now and we're very satisfied with their service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed May 9, 2015

    HOMEOWNERS BEWARE!!! AHS or American Home Shield is the worst warranty company we ever dealt with. They don't even deserve a star in this review. Customer service is very poor with bunch of liars. A simple claim for dishwasher repair has been ongoing for over 8 months and still nothing happened, every time we call they always say that the parts is in back order and will be coming soon. Then a month ago they said that the parts are no longer available and AHS will just have to replace the dishwasher. Turned out to be another LIE!!! After 8 mos they wanted to send another repair company to check our dishwasher again. So we requested to talk to supervisor, we were promised that their very busy supervisor will return our call w/ in 24-48 hrs, 6 days later we received no calls from them.

    Such a blatant disregard of customer's welfare with intentional neglect. Sorry but we just cancelled our contract with this company and will never return again. Prove me wrong on this: Call their enrollment/purchasing or payment department they will answer right away. Call their claims dept and you will be on hold for more than 30 minutes.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 9, 2015

    Customer service is horrible. I have had nothing but horrible experience in dealing with this company. The representatives are also incompetent. I will not renew my contract with them. Horrible service, if I could have rated them negative star I would.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 9, 2015

    I had electrical and plumbing issues so I called American Home Shield. The electrical company did their job right. As for plumbing, I paid $75 for someone to come and fix it. The person that came was very nice, but if he was a real plumber, he would have known what part was broken. I am in shock that they actually thought they can pull that over. American Home Shield's response was they had to call the plumbing company, so I ended up fixing the problem myself. I also have not gotten my refund, they told me I should call the company. I would not recommend American Home Shield, in fact I'm considering cancelling my service. I pay over $50 a month and I hardly ever use it. Overall, they are a waste of money.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Dorothy, We are sorry to hear about your recent plumbing experience. We sincerely apologize & would like to make it up to you. Our team will contact you privately to begin resolving your issue.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed May 9, 2015

    I got the warranty on Jan 6 and I had a issue with my humidifier due to which I had a turn of my heater in the month of January. And I raised a issue with AHS. And they said someone will call me in ASAP to resolve the issue but as no one called me for 6-8 hrs hours, I decided to call them back. Imagine without heater in month of January in NJ weather. When I contacted them after 6-8 hours they told that someone can come only the next day to fix my issue, so insensitive people. I told them that I don't have a heater and it's tough with small kids but still they said they can't do anything. I then decided that it's not worth having warranty where they can repair my emergency needs for close to 24 hours more.

    That is when the actual problem begin, I canceled my warranty on Feb 7 just one day after the 30 days trial period. They charge me administrative fee prorated cost of warranty and sent me letter saying that I will get my refund in 10 days. It is more than 90 days till date and I did not get my refund yet. Every time I call them they say different reason. One of the call rep told me that they did not have my address to issue my refund. One call rep said that they issued me a refund a month back. And she promised that she will cancel the refund check issued and re-issue a new check. And it's been over 2 months and I did not get my refund yet after they told me that they re-issued me a check. One call rep told me that they are doing a check search and came back to me after 24 hours and told me they can find my refund check. So be away from AHS. If you want to get into trouble then go for AHS. I wish I could give a negative star.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    Very impressed with how fast AHS gets a contractor out to fix the problem. They are always very courteous and genuine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    The ice maker was not working, called to set-up appt. The contractor showed up in a timely manner; needed a new part ordered and when the part came in it was only a few days before he came back to install.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    AHS's dispatch of a/c repair was timely; the contractor's personnel were helpful and kept us informed as the progress and challenges of the repairs to our system.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPriceOnline & App

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    Recently bought a home with an AHS Warranty. After 9 months in the house the washing machine started to go. Contacted AHS and service technician came out. Technician explained the repairs would cost over $1000 to repair and someone would contact me in 3 business days to schedule replacement. 3 days later the office notifies me they could repair it for $720, having never seen the unit before. I explained my concern that a technician hired by AHS, who has seen the unit, does not think it should be repaired, yet someone in the office crunching numbers thinks it is repairable. The office was to call the technician to discuss further and contact me back.

    Fast forward 2 1/2 weeks of back and forth phone calls with AHS (horrible customer service representatives, with nasty attitudes) and still at square one. Sears is to repair a 15 year old washing machine that probably cost $900 new this afternoon (they received a budget of $800 dollars for the repair, yet I would only be given 720 towards a replacement).

    Spoke with the "appliance discount program" department to see about putting it towards a new machine and it is not a discount at all. Their prices are determined by the manufacturer and are not a "discount" (10%, 20%, etc). A Maytag washing machine selling for $900 at all major retailers is $1050 through AHS "Discount Program".

    I would not recommend this product if you haven't bought in already. You are better off saving yourself the headache and the money you would spend on this warranty. I was extremely displeased with the way I was spoken to by all of the AHS representatives during this encounter. No one has a straight answer and the departments that supposedly do have the answers do not speak to customers. And no, I do not want a case manager to contact me. You had close to a month to have management internally handle customers' concerns. Contacting after the fact because it is negatively reflected on a website does not constitute good customer service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    I have three claims with American Home Shield and the one that's done would be the refrigerator and the oven. Submitting claims was no problem - it worked great. Their reps were very professional and everything was taken care of satisfactorily. After the repair, American Home Shield contacted me and said everything was done so I got an invoice from them for $75 yesterday. On my receipts, we had paid it so I called them and told them about it. They checked and erased the $75 so that worked out great. Another highlight was when I had an account that was an automatic deduction for my mortgage which had some problems. My policy got cancelled so I talked with the AHS lady and we renewed and took out a new policy which went really sweet too.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    We've had AHS for nearly 2 years. We recently had a sink plug up so we called to put in a work order. For some stupid reason AHS assigned a contractor that is over 3 hours away! The contractor called to set an appointment which was to be after 3pm. At 8am on the date of the appointment, the plumber call to say he was in town and on his way. We were at work of course and pointed out that they weren't supposed to be there until after 3. That's when they told us that they don't come to our area in the afternoon. Not sure why they scheduled us in the afternoon if they only come in the morning, but they did.

    We ended up having to call a local plumber ourselves because AHS said they had to let the contractor do the job even though they admitted that they couldn't. Worse though, a few weeks later we got a 75 dollar bill from AHS for a service call. We went round and round with a couple different people and finally they told us we didn't owe the bill after all. Now, weeks later, we received another bill. This time past due. Now when we called they say we have to pay the bill because the vendor tried to come to our house. Even though he was 5 hours early without notice and never actually made it to our house. We are cancelling our account. I'm baffled that they actually want us to pay for no service! This company is awful.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jenna, a case manager is available to assist you with this matter if that is ok?

    Factual basis uncertain
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    Contracted company they used for repairs was unprofessional and untrained. Air conditioner broke and they sent a company to fix that specializes in plumbing and appliance repairs from an hour away even though I live in the 4th largest city in the state. Was several days before the company could come out to fix the air conditioner. When they did come they said they replaced the condenser and that it was fixed, my wife told them it is still blowing hot air before they left, serviceman left anyway. I called to get them back out for the repair and they never showed. I called AHS customer service and they told me they would send another company but I would have to pay the 100 deductible again...what a joke...look elsewhere, you can get the same poor service for less money.

    Thanks for your vote!
    No response received
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 8, 2015

    AHS contractors who were here today were very prompt and knowledgeable. We had asked specifically for them to come back today (as we had to had two other previous plumbers out here and I wouldn't have them back for anything). Our hot water had turned rust color so we didn't know if our water heater was going out but it wasn't. It had sediment that had to be drained out and so they flushed it out.

    The guys also were here on Monday as well because one of our toilets was leaking. They came here to fix something that's not a cut-and-dried issue. They had to look around to find out what the problem is. These guys were actually fine to stand there and listen to me - I'm disabled so sometimes my cognitive is way off and I'm not always able to express myself well, but these gentlemen were very courteous. They listened to what I had to say and they got right to it which was great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 7, 2015

    I have had American Home Shield for 5 years. The last year and half, I have contacted them to send a company to fix the appliances and utilities that we agreed that would be covered. They have not responded to 3 service request and my phone calls. I have paid a contractor $75.00 to come assess one of the issues. He said that he would be back in a week to fix them. Over the next couple months and after many phone calls he never came back. The other work orders were never fulfilled. (In the past every time I call, American Home Shield representatives states they see the work order and are sorry.) Then nothing is done about it. I called today and spoke with ** in the retention department, he said there wasn't any work orders. I have been paying as agreed to the agreement, am requesting they fill their part of the agreement or refund my installment fee.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Shane, We apologize for any inconvenience this may have caused, but we do not show any active work orders under your contract. If you're in need to place a new service request, please contact our customer service department. Thank you for sharing your feedback.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 7, 2015

    Reliable - all of my concerns so far have been handled with any difficulties, I will be submitting a new service repair soon for my dishwasher.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed May 7, 2015

    We've been with AHS for six years and we renew every year. We love them. My claim experience with them is always fabulous. I submit it online and get a response right away. The last claim was to repair pool equipment. The technician called and came right away. After the repair everything is working fine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    American Home Shield provides fast and effective responses to issues with our house. After they sent a professional (who was very prompt) to confirm that our dishwasher had died, AHS was very helpful in replacing the dishwasher for us, completely free of charge. Our AHS customer service representative was able to answer questions as we were decided on a replacement and although the installation took longer than usual (given our house's older plumbing set-up), we are very happy with the outcome.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingSales & Marketing

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    Absolutely horrific company to work with. My claim for a/c repair was denied. Reason for denial was that the problem had existed before I started the policy. I had another company come out and look (one that AHS wasn't working with) and they said no way was the problem existing prior to start date. So I have been calling for over 10 days to cancel my policy. I have called every day and am always told, "We will contact you by the end of the day." And they don't! I cancelled before the start of my new month, but was still charged. I am about to dispute charges with my bank. And the more people that I talk to, the more I realize that AHS is basically a scam company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Lindsey, We regret to hear that the coverage decision for your a/c service work order has led you to cancel your home warranty with us. We offer second opinions in cases were the customer does not agree with the original vendors diagnosis. I would like to have a case manager contact you to discuss this matter.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    I had my washing machine and dryer serviced by American Home Shield. I went and made the request online, and got an email acknowledgement with the assignment for the contractor. On the evening of the next day, the contractor called to set up the appointment. This was on a Friday evening and the contractor called to set up the appointment for Monday. On Monday, they called en route, came in and fixed the problem. Everything's been working fine since then. The ease of the online system was nice - I recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    American Home Shield has made my experience in my new home a nightmare. On Saturday, my water heater burst in my basement and resulted in significant water damage and a large clean up project. I submitted a service request on that day and found out that a water heater is not an emergency and that the AHS approved plumber would be in touch with me on Monday. On Monday I did receive a call from the plumber and they stated the soonest they could come a diagnose the issue would be Tuesday.

    The plumber arrived late Tuesday afternoon and noted that the water heater needed to be replaced but he could not do the work until the AHS estimator approved the repair. It's now Wednesday morning, day 5, without any type of hot water in my home and no approval from American Home Shield. I have made numerous calls to AHS and they state that they are following their policies in the warranty contract and there is "nothing they can do." The terrible customer service continues when I have requested to speak to a supervisor. No supervisor has taken my call or returned my request for updates. They took my premium and have provided nothing in return. I would have been better off without the warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    Got an HVAC tune up, as I do every season. He noted a part failure that needs to be replaced immediately or compressor will die. Called AHS to schedule work order and was told that I can't schedule work order if AC still works at this moment. So I had tune up guy just replace at cost of $300. Then I called back to AHS in hopes of getting reimbursement... Hoping I just talked to someone inexperienced. Asked for manager and was on hold for well over one hour! Manager came on and told me I can enter work order at any time regardless if AC was working or not.

    Then I explained that I spent $300 out of pocket for replacement due to first person I spoke to. Manager told me that I need send in the invoice to some physical address and no guarantee for reimbursement and takes several weeks for review. I asked for email so I can scan and email invoice. Manager told me no email available for this. At that point I had had it. Told manager I just want to cancel warranty. Was told someone would be back in touch with me with 48 hours. It has now been 72 hours and no contact from anyone. Find a different company... You will save yourself a LOT of frustration!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Mr. Baldeep, Thank you for making us aware of your experience in attempting to get your a/c unit repaired. We regret to know this has led you to no longer want services with us. I will forward this to our Retention Department to contact you in regards to cancelling your home warranty with us.

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    This water leak (not stoppage) has been an ongoing issue since April 24th. The original company, ** Plumbing, which AHS dispatched, could not come for five days (4/29), when they did show up the technician, made it very clear he was not prepared to find a leak. He told me he had 6 other jobs and did not have the time, or the equipment to find a leak. He cut a hole in the wall, where we thought a screw might have punctured a pipe, left it to be repaired by me and then proceeded to go through every bathroom and run the sink, toilets and bathtubs trying to see if they were clogged.

    He stepped into the attic and looked at the hot water heater. He did not inspect the pipes, nor did he go into the second level attic to see if the pipes were leaking. He told me he did not get paid to go on the roof so he would not inspect the "stack". This is a three story townhouse. He told me I would need leak detection, which his company did not have. The only alternative was to have him come back with another man and spend 8 hours cutting holes in my wall to find the leak. He told me he was going to call AHS and tell them he did not find the leak and we needed someone with leak detection.

    He also told me the area the leak was coming from was not sewage (as he opened the sewer cap and looked inside) and was contained to one wall so I should just have someone drill a hole on the outside of the foundation to let it drain out. This was very unprofessional. He told me someone from AHS would contact me. No one did.

    I called AHS the next day and spoke with another customer service rep. I was told that ** Plumbing would be the next vendor to try. I have requested, several times a vendor that has leak detection. They could have come out earlier that ** plumbing but they were denied because they are not approved vendors. Another company I would like to use is a vendor; they have a vendor number, and have done work for AHS in the past.

    Here is their email they sent me when I inquired about them as they were the only ones listed to do leak detection in our area: "we are already a vendor for American Home Shield. Our vendor number is 1037902, I don't know why they keep saying we are not one." On April 30th my mother that owns the property called AHS and was told that ** would have to be dispatched to repair the leak. The company we want to use was not approved and we could not use them to detect the leak.

    On May 1st ** called me to schedule an appointment to find a "stoppage". I explained it was not a stoppage it was a leak and asked if they had leak detection. They told me their equipment was broken and they could not find the leak. The person I spoke with told me she would call AHS and tell them they could not fix the problem. On May 1st My mother, who owns the property called AHS and again explained that the companies AHS have dispatched cannot fix the problem. They told her once all the vendors were exhausted we could hire our own. It is now going on almost two weeks out and one of the girls in the house has a severe autoimmune deficient disease. The standing water on the slab needs to be fixed immediately. It is not a water leak, it is a drain leak. Turning off the water cannot fix this problem, plus the girls that live in this house are in college and this is extremely disruptive to their final schedule.

    Today, May 5th I spoke with an AHS customer rep, who suddenly told me I was no longer allowed to speak with a supervisor about the issue. My mother had previously added my name as a contact on the account, however now I was not permitted to talk. Again another company, ** Plumbing was going to be dispatched. I called them while I was on hold with AHS. They DO NOT DO LEAK DETECTION!! I am trying to get approval to have our plumbing company, which states they are a vendor, to detect the leak. They have tried calling AHS to be approved, but have been told (even though they have a vendor number) that they are not authorized. Can someone please, please, please authorize them to come repair the leak? They can come tomorrow, May 6th. The issue is becoming an extreme health problem.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed May 6, 2015

    I had plumbers to my home through AHS to repair a leaking faucet of a slop sink in the lower level of our home, along with two other plumbing repairs involving a handle of a faucet in one bathroom and a stuck H/W valve in the shower of the master bathroom. The plumber came and looked at everything and told me he would need to get approval to make the repairs. He never mentioned water pressure while he was here. AHS denied the claim, stating that the home's water pressure was high (95psi) that caused the faucet to leak in the lower level (it's the original 40 year old faucet), and likewise caused the other two problems.

    I called the water facility and was told that they pump at 80-120psi which is the standard for the city, and advised that 95psi was normal, not high. They also told me that 95psi could not cause faucets to leak, H/W valves to stick, or faucet handles to be loose. I then called another plumber to make the repairs. He advised that the slop sink was leaking because the washers needed to be replaced -- done and no more leaking faucet. He went upstairs and repaired the handle with a special tool he had. Next, he repaired the shower's H/W valve so it could now be regulated. He told me that the reason given by AHS, that 95psi pressure was high and caused these issues, is simply untrue, and the claim was wrongfully denied!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Michael, Since we are not physically in the home, we rely on the diagnosis of our licensed vendors. Per the warranty verbiage, if you disagree with the techs diagnosis, you can request a second opinion from a different vendor. We apologize for any inconvenience this has caused. If you would like to discuss this matter further, a case manager can contact you.

    Verified purchase
    CoverageTech

    Reviewed May 5, 2015

    This is a HORRIBLE COMPANY. The vendor they send out are either shady. I requested an air conditioning repair and the guy said that it's not covered because of "pre-existing condition" and rats chewed the wires that caused the unit to short. However, the technician said that I have to replace the whole unit. He can do it for $4K. I got my own air conditioning guy out and he found out that the transformer was broken and the rat chew on the wire did not cause any short, and that the transformer was just old and the fix total was less than $400 for labor and parts. Of course, AHS didn't cover the $400 because my tech -- "it was not their vendor." Of course, my $75 deductible is basically paid for nothing.

    Second incident, I had a leak on a sink and requested service. They send me a plumber that wouldn't be able to give me a time when kids have to be picked up on a regular basis. The plumber would only work 11 AM - 3 PM. I asked if there is a day that they can come before 11 AM, and they said, "NO"...not ever. I asked for a different plumber and AHS won't assign a new one, citing that I have to be "flexible." I've had 3 service requests. 2 turned out bad. Only one incident, to clear a clogged pipe, that was actually done. HORRIBLE COMPANY!!! Don't buy this company or any other company. They won't fix anything but gladly take your money!! They will not fix your covered items just by citing "PRE-EXISTING CONDITIONS" -- total lies.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 5, 2015

    Everyone was very polite and our issues were addressed immediately. I'm happy with AHS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 5, 2015

    I did research on several home warranty policies, before I purchased my home 2 years ago. I chose your company, because it had the best policy. I am very happy with my choice. Your company has taken care of several repairs in my home to great satisfaction. I have referred your company to others in search of a home warranty policy. Thank you.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 4, 2015

    The entire process was seamless and intuitive. The online web interface is user-friendly, informative, accessible and self-directing. The telephone representatives are not customer-centric and results-focused, but also clearly place great importance on professionalism. It is always a pleasure working with the AHS staff to address my needs. They provide excellent value for money.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 4, 2015

    I placed a work order online March 27th with American Home Shield (AHS). An AHS contractor came out but didn't order the part. I found this out via an AHS associate. AHS put me on hold to call the 1st vendor but they never contacted me. Today is May 4th - after several more calls a 2nd contractor came out but went to the wrong address so I missed a day of work for nothing. I called the contractor & AHS to ask why I was not given a courtesy call. I was told by both that a courtesy isn't mandatory and AHS can not make a contractor call me. That's extremely poor customer service. I asked to speak to a supervisor and was told that their information can't be given to the public, more poor customer service. I've paid my AHS fees, my $75 service fee and have received nothing but apologies and excuses.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Wendy, Thank you for making us aware of this. We would like to have a case manager contact you to discuss this issue.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 4, 2015

    I was very pleased with American Home Shield's customer service. We filed a service request for a plumbing issue; but the original contractor never responded. In fact, both AHS and I attempted to contact them repeatedly to schedule service - they did not respond to repeated requests for nearly an entire week. After speaking with American Home Shield customer service, they assigned a different contractor. The new contractor not only responded promptly to schedule the work, they actually called the next day asking permission to come a few days early to get the issue fixed sooner! If it weren't for AHS's network of contractors, we would still be waiting on a plumber that obviously didn't value their customers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Melissa increased rating by 2 stars.
    Claims HandlingCoverageTech
    After a positive interaction with American Home Shield, Melissa increased their star rating on May 24, 2015.

    Updated review: May 24, 2015

    A case manager did contact me quickly and took care of the claim in a quick satisfactory manner. I am happy with this result. Just frustrated that this is the 2nd time I have had to file complaints in order to get them to cover my claim. If can use AHS vendors it works fine, unfortunately we have a covered item that their vendors are unable to work on so we have to use our own contractor then submit for reimbursement.

    Original Review: May 4, 2015

    I have been trying since April 13 to do what AHS wants to complete - a claim for an outside vendor. I have jumped through their hoops, and have decided they want to wear you down so you will not pursue your claim any further. I cannot help that they do not have vendors that can work on my covered item. My experience with this company is less than stellar. Stay away from American Home Shield! ** in claims is horrible. ** has tried to help but unfortunately I am here due to frustration of this run around.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Melissa, we are sorry to hear that you have not had a good experience. I would be happy to have a case manager reach out to you to assist with this issue. Thank you for bringing it to our attention.

    Verified purchase
    Coverage

    Reviewed May 4, 2015

    American Home Shield wouldn't replace the dishwasher outright because the shelves and the racks were not covered. They were willing to give me $200 toward a new one but I have not received that payment yet. I sent a receipt for having purchased the dishwasher and they said I would get a check. Overall, I've had a good experience with them and I do recommend AHS to people I know. The only thing I've run into is sometimes I've needed something repaired and I was told it wouldn't be covered because it wasn't part of the original house which I hadn't understood when I signed up for the plan. When you buy an old house, you're not aware of what is considered part of the original house and what is not, so that's been my only complaint.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 4, 2015

    My freezer was not cooling properly so I called for a service repair on 4/6. It has been a month and my freezer is still not repaired. The first service company came out, took my $75 and said "yes it's broken but I can't fix it." They sent transfer request to Home Shield. Eight days later I call Home Shield and they do not have request, even though it was sent to them. When I call Home Shield and give them my address, they can NEVER pull it up. After I give them contract number, they can find it and the account has the address that I gave them. When I call, the wait time to speak to someone is always at least 10 minutes, a few times over 15 minutes! The second repair company had to order part that should take a few days to arrive, 2 weeks later I am still waiting to hear from them. There has been zero communication from AHS or repair co. unless I contact them. I will never pay for this warranty service again and will NOT recommend it to anyone.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jennifer, Our apologies for the delay in getting your freezer repaired. I would like to have a case manager contact you if you're still in need of assistance with this service work order.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 3, 2015

    I have never had so many issues with a single company in my entire life. Dealing with American Home Shield has been by far more time consuming, difficult to deal with and impossible to get a straight answer from than I ever expected. I had mostly good reviews online prior to purchasing my plan, so maybe my expectations were too high. Here is a summary of my encounters with American Home Shield. It has been 3 weeks since my reported problem. I have spent 7 hours on the phone, 2 hours dealing with contractors, 11 hours waiting on contractors and absolutely nothing has been done to fix my air conditioner. I have to call at least 3 times to get a representative who can actually help me with my problem, and the first two generally give conflicting information.

    Do not get a home warranty through this company. They will waste your time, use any reason necessary not to cover your items (check your “Additional Limitations and Exclusions” section carefully because they will use all of them. Also note, they had to have an “Additional” section because the first “Limitations and Exclusions” section was not big enough) and never attempt to resolve a problem.

    Here are the details of my experience: In early April 2015, I called in a service request that my air conditioner was not cooling properly. They said they would have their top service company come out and repair the issue. I scheduled an appointment two days later from 9-12. They called at 11:55 saying they will be here at 12:20. At 1:45 I called them to ask if they were still coming – they said they would be here at 2:10. They show up at 2:30. I told them the problem and 20 minutes later they said they fixed it and were done. I went upstairs to check, and they did nothing but clutter my attic with trash, the unit still did not work properly. I asked them to fix it and they said they couldn't. They left shortly after.

    I called back 3 times over the course of 2 hours to get another contractor out to my house to fix the problem. The next guy showed up on time, but again left within 30 minutes. He said he would report the problem and have someone else to come out and fix the problem!? I asked about his diagnosis and he said that American Home Shield would tell me, but he would not. I called in the next day to American Home Shield and his diagnosis was completely incorrect. He did not report air leaks, and that was the only thing I knew that was wrong with the system. He also reported numerous extra problems that were not there to make extra money. I took pictures of these issues and had to send them into another contractor to verify this.

    Three days later a 3rd contractor came out and came to a completely different diagnosis than the second contractor. His diagnosis was covered under my contract with American Home Shield, but American Home Shield would not cover it because they claimed it fell under the limitations and exclusions section of my contract. It took me 4 separate calls to get this information, with one of the first 2 saying they would send another contractor out to my house. One of the remaining two wanted to call back the technician and get more information. Read your contract carefully, because if there is any chance they can claim it under “Limitations and Exclusions” they will. It has been 3 weeks since my initial call, I have wasted nearly a day of my life, my air conditioner still does not work and I am trying to figure out what American Home Shield actually covers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Zac, I would like to have a case manager research this matter and contact you. Do you mind a call?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed May 3, 2015

    Signed up with AHS Warranty - paid for contract. Our water heater broke and leaked. We called Monday at 10:30 PM and received a claim# **. I had to contact the contractor at 8:30 a.m. on Tuesday. Contractor said he would not be able to come and look at the water heater until Thursday 4:00. As my basement was flooded we had no hot water in the house. I called American Home Shield to get another contractor and they said, "As long as you had contacted him within 48 hours your service warranty is in effect and we will not contact another contractor". I spoke to several customer service agents and they basically said "You will get another water heater as soon as the contractor contacts us and we get you a new one. You may not get one until Saturday or later." I called the corporate office and ** told me to "boil hot water to bathe with" and that "a water heater is not priority, you can live without it."

    I also had another person at the Memphis corporate office 901-597-8000 tell me, "We are not fixing it, you have been contacted within the policy of the company." I said "I had spoken also to a **." And she said "There is no **... I asked for Mark Berry - the president of the company and she said "Oh he quit and no longer works here". What this company does is they want you to wait until they decide to fix your appliance, heater, etc. so you fix it on your own, so they do not have to pay for a new one or the repair.

    When you call, you are on hold for at least 10 minutes and the customer service people are rude and not helpful. The corporate office states that it is up to "their discretion on what items are priority items". I asked ** if she would wait 5 days to take a hot shower and her response was, "Of course it is not a life or death situation. I would take a cold shower for week". I have read on the internet bad reviews on American Home Shield because they do not honor what they state in their contracts. They take your money and do not provide the warranty service...

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Barry, Thank you for sharing your feedback in regards to your water heater service work order. A case manager is available to assist you with this matter if you'd like.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 2, 2015

    They contracted with one pool repair company in Bakersfield, Cool Pools. This person wouldn't return calls until receiving multiple texts and voicemails. Upon calling back, he tried to sell us something outside of the warranty company. After declining, he wouldn't return our calls. I contacted AHS. They told me to use whoever we want and submit a receipt. I called back and was told that wasn't true. I was put on hold over 10 min. I called back and was told there was no one else. I was reassigned the same company via email. We are under water restrictions due to the drought in California and will likely be forced to drain our pool.

    Updated on 5/13/2015: AHS assigned Cool Pools for warranty of our pool pump. After being difficult to reach and get to our home, a refurbished pump motor was installed and we now have a leak that wasn't previously there. The pump is against minimum requirements for Private Swimming Pools and Spas per Kern County Code of Building Regulations. "Pump sizing and flow rate including system piping shall comply with the requirements of CEC Sec. 150 (P)." California Energy Code states, "Pump motors used for filtration with a capacity of 1 hp or more shall be multispeed." Cool Pools also removed our timer without authorization. Contact by an AHS case manager was offered as a response on this website, however no one ever called.

    When calling AHS direct, I was told I could not speak to a manager. According to the rep at AHS, Cool Pools said the pump is actually variable speed and we need to scratch out the information on the casing that says it is not. I had another company come out and verify that the pump is single speed and against code. I also have a picture and email from the manufacturer stating that the pump is single speed. AHS has been unresponsive and unwilling to resolve. We have spent over $1,000 towards warranty coverage and $125 for a deductible. We still do not have a pump that meets code.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Christina, If you're still in need of assistance with your pool service work order, a case manager can contact you.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed May 2, 2015

    For regular issues (non-emergencies) this insurance may be worth something but for emergencies beware! I have a sewage problem (there is poop and water all over my basement) and I submitted a request over the phone around 11:30 or so. Then I contacted AHS to expedite my request around 12:37 pm as we have 7 people in the house with no access to water and no usable toilets. The person said that they will look for a contractor and if no one contacts me in 1 or 2 hours I can call again and look for one myself. I waited over two hours since the last call and now they are telling me I have to wait 4 in order for me to contact someone on my own. They said they did not have access to the recorded conversation in order for them to listen to the conversation I had with the guy I spoke with first that told me 1 to 2 hours. That was so ridiculous!! I now have to wait even longer. Will definitely not ever do business again with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Vanessa, I would like to have a case manager contact you to discuss the issue you had with your plumbing service work order.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed May 2, 2015

    I have a 3 year old pool heater for a salt water pool that stopped heating. The inside of the unit rusted out. AHS said this was not normal wear and tear and therefore declined coverage. I have always paid a professional company to maintain my pool weekly. They said that the rust inside the pool heater was due to improper pool chemicals. This is subjective. I properly maintained my pool and equipment. If there is a failure though no fault of my own I expect "insurance" to cover it. Failure that is not normal is still failure. IMO it's ridiculous to insure only "normal" failure and it invites subjectivity for the insurance company to claim anything as not "normal" and decline coverage. Really a farce. And oddly, the link to view my contract does not work from both my iPad and my new MAC computer.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jeffrey, We apologize for any inconvenience the coverage decision has caused. If you would like to discuss this matter further, a case manager can contact you.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed May 1, 2015

    Thankful. Plumbing problem was not a serious as I thought it was going to be.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed May 1, 2015

    American Home Shield took care of the problem. They sent a contractor out who did a really good job. These guys are great!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Alejandro increased rating by 4 stars.
    Customer ServiceCoverage
    After a positive interaction with American Home Shield, Alejandro increased their star rating on May 21, 2015.

    Updated review: May 21, 2015

    I am happy that the last manager that contacted me was able to resolve our dilemma. It is greatly appreciated. Thank you!

    Original Review: May 1, 2015

    My dad has the 3x3 combo plan. His garage door spring broke and he called American Home Shield to have it repaired. He was told it was not covered. So on 4/30/15 I called American Home Shield and spoke with a representative after we had submitted the claim for repairs. I asked the representative twice if the Garage BROKEN SPRING was covered and TWICE she assured me it was covered. So since I was told it was covered I called the dispatcher and confirmed the contractor to go to my dad's house on 5/1/15 between 11am -1pm. The dispatcher shows up at my dad's house at 10:30AM. (All time is Central Time). The dispatcher calls American Home Shield to confirm coverage, what is he told? That NO, that the broken spring is not covered. So my dad had to pay his deductible for nothing.

    I called back American Home Shield and spoke with representative ** to complain. I asked them to have a supervisor pull up the conversation between myself and their representative dated 4/30/15 at 1:52pm where I was told TWICE that the garage door broken spring was covered. I was told the supervisor had 24 hours to call me back after they review the conversation. So I am waiting, hoping they honor their word. I will keep you all updated once this situation has been resolved. Thank you!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Alejandro, I would like to have a case manager contact your father in regards to this matter as we truly apologize for this experience. Is it okay to call?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed May 1, 2015

    I've made two service calls during the couple years I've had AHS. The first time was a quick and easy fix and taken care of quickly. The second had multiple appliances most of which were fixed well and quickly overall. But then the final item, a seemingly simple burner fix, has caused my claim to stay open and unfinished for almost 4 months now! The contractor is next to useless for keeping me updated and AHS seems to be just as careless when it comes to fixing the issue.

    The contractor has sent out 3 different technicians a total of 4 times (meaning 4x5 hour block windows I had to set aside) and each time the tech said "no problem, just need to order the part and I'll be back in a few days". Not once have they come back. Not once did they call me to say "oh, guess the part is not available" or anything like that. Not once did they say "hey, it's been 3+ months maybe we should look into why this claim isn't closed", and that goes for AHS as well! To be fair, every single one of the tech were friendly and seemed competent. But whatever inventory and follow up process this contractor is using (or likely NOT using) has been a complete failure.

    After calling to find out what was taking so long for this part... or more importantly the follow up to let me know what was going on, I was told that the estimated date of the part availability was changed automatically by the supplier they go through. So evidently, they would just sit for years and let this automated system just go through and change the estimated date a few days in the future without ever actually having the part and the contractor would not bother to figure out a workaround. And worse, AHS seems to think it's OK that the claim hasn't been closed and has been just as bad as the contractor as far as keep me in the loop on what was going on... or more accurately what they weren't doing still.

    There is no way this should take 3.5 months (so far) and not have any real and definite date on when this will be completely. We have already gone through two major holidays without the use of our burners when we definitely needed them. Not to mention the inconvenience every other regular day that it would be nice to be able to cook with. My stove isn't so old that they would have to find an antique dealer to find the parts. I actually wouldn't be surprised if they weren't on Amazon... though I'm afraid to look as finding them there would likely send me in a terrible rage lol. The service center employees are friendly and try to be helpful. The contractors tech are friendly and seem to know what they are doing, but in the end, if they can't finish a job and then completely drop the ball when it comes time to follow up and do what is needed to actually finish the job then what use is having AHS?

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Ron, Thank you for making us aware of this ongoing issue with your burners. A case manager is available to assist you with this if you'd like?

    Rating has been updatedMay 29, 2015

    Ron updated their star rating from a 2 stars to a 1 stars after speaking with the company outside of the ConsumerAffairs platform.

    My stove burner, the main repair waiting on parts this whole time (4 months and 5 days to be exact) has finally been repaired. Again, it took 4 freaking months to actually complete a seemingly simple burner repair and AHS seems to think that is ok since it took them that long to get on the vendors case to actually get this taken care of. Does AHS feel bad about making me wait 4 months without a burner...through 3 major holidays when I actually needed it?

    The most they would do is "apologize for the delay" as if is was par for the course. After complaining that an apology was not enough they finally said they could offer a $75 service call credit good for one year so if I happen to have another call then the deductible would covered. So, in other words, if I have not other issues/calls within a year, it's phantom money.

    No offer for a bill credit. I am not happy it took 4+ months to get a simple job done and pretty upset about all the incompetence and complete lack of urgency and the lame future service credit is the most they are willing to do. They did complete the job. The burner appears to be working as of now. But it took 4+ months, a total of 5 visits from the contractor (each with a 5 hour window I had to make available) and countless hours on hold having to call both the contractor and AHS to find out why no one was following through or to demand some kind of update. All the while AHS was perfectly able to bill me exactly on time without any issues at all with their billing software. Wonder what kind of service I would have gotten if I was 4+ months late on payments!

    So I guess that is my updated review/warning. I got my appliance fixed but it was a long very frustrating process with a seemingly complete lack of empathy from AHS and a lame restitution. Worth it? Up to you. I'm downgrading my review from 2 star to 1 star because it seems AHS feels it is completely fine to make customers wait 4+ months to get simple repairs done and that is NOT ok with me.

    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 30, 2015

    I have been with AHS for approx. 10 years. We stuck with them mainly for our older AC unit. It dies at least twice a year. This year, it has died again. Called AHS, they sent a contractor. Contractor said repair was needed and that freon had leaked out. AHS would repair the unit but we were stuck with the freon replacement - nearly $700 worth on a 20-year old unit! Not to mention the fact that the unit leaks EVERY year! So I am to pay at least $700 every year until they deem it "unfixable?" I want the unit replaced by them, but of course I am getting the run around.

    I have tried to contact them for a week. No one can get me a supervisor. They all say a supervisor will "contact me in 24-48 hrs." It has been a week of daily phone calls on my end and still no supervisor call. HORRIBLE customer service. They obviously don't care about the customer and apparently no supervisors EVER WORK THERE or maybe they have no phones. I am calling the Better Business Bureau, my local news channel, and my attorney. I am paying for a service they are not providing and have paid for a new unit already in the 10 years I have been with this company. If this is how they treat a loyal customer of 10 years, imagine a new customer. RUN AWAY from this HORRIBLE company!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Michelle, I would like to have a case manager take a closer look at this service work order. Do you mind if we contact you in regards to this matter?

    massimiliana increased rating by 3 stars.
    Customer ServiceTech
    After a positive interaction with American Home Shield, massimiliana increased their star rating on June 25, 2015.

    Updated review: June 25, 2015

    After a "rough start", American Home Shield had me talk to a case manager who addressed my concerns and understood how much of an inconvenience would have been to leave my family and I without an oven for over a month.They decided to replace my broken oven with a functioning one which was delivered in less than a week.I am now a happy customer and I have regained trust in AHS.

    Original Review: April 30, 2015

    Following a power outage on April 22nd my Whirlpool electric oven stopped working. I called American Home Shield immediately and for a $75.00 fee on April 23rd they sent a contractor to look at it. He verified that my oven doesn't start anymore and he said: "This oven is dead." He also informed me that the oven was at least 20 years old - which I didn't know and couldn't tell, since I purchased the house where I live in last July, and the oven was already there. A week later I called the contractor company to ask for a status update and they said that the part needed to fix the oven is no longer in production.

    I then called American Home Shield asking what would happen next and rather than replacing the appliance with a new one, they insisted that they want to try to repair the unit by rebuilding it using I don't know which replacement part at this point and that it will take 4 to 5 WEEKS to get the oven rebuilt!!! The other option they are offering me is to take the money they would spend for the repair ($229.00) and use it as a credit towards the purchase of a new oven. After talking to 3 different American Home Shield representatives, but never to a manager they won't transfer my call to one - I find this situation extremely unfair.

    First of all, I have safety concerns. I need American Home Shield to replace the appliance rather than attempting to rebuild it because, after learning that my oven is at least 20 years old and calling Whirlpool myself, for safety reasons I've been discouraged to attempt to have it repaired without its original part, or to have it repaired period. It's 20 years old, it did its job and now it died. We are talking about a built in oven which is underneath a gas stove so I am nervous that a repair or a quick fix on such an old appliance and without its original part available - could lead to something more serious. I don't want to end up with my kitchen blowing up or catching on fire, because this old patched-up oven could short out under the gas stove.

    Also, it is unacceptable that I will have to wait for over a month to have a working oven back. The oven is an essential appliance of the house. It is used on a daily basis, especially in my case since I am a stay at home mom with 2 kids. I only have one oven and I've already been without it for over a week, so it's unheard of that I will still need to wait 4 to 5 weeks to be able to use it again. It is simply unfair to inconvenience a family in such a way, when in a matter of one day American Home Shield could have a new oven delivered to my house.

    Last but not least, I find American Home Shields offer of accepting a $229.00 credit towards the purchase of a new oven at my own expenses a joke. If I had the money to buy a new oven I would have purchased it already, rather than staying without one for this long. I have American Home Shield for a reason! And that reason is to cover the appliances in my house that are not working anymore, so that I don't have to buy a new one. However, unfortunately, I realized that American Home Shield is not here to help its customers. Instead, it will inconvenience them even more and try to screw them. I will not renew my policy with them and I am filing a claim against them with the Better Business Bureau.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Massimiliana, We apologize for the delay in getting your oven repaired. A case manager is available to assist you if you'd like.

    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 30, 2015

    Service was promptly provided and my garbage disposal problem corrected.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 30, 2015

    My boyfriend and I have a warranty that we got within the last 6 months but have lived in our house together for the last two years. Our AC unit out back stopped working about a day and a half ago. I stayed home from work today so it could be FIXED today instead of next week when it is supposed to be at least 10 degrees warmer. The repairman, **, was very friendly and quick to say the compressor was gone but since our unit was so old that he would recommend its replacement. He told me he was going to call it in and it should be replaced within the next several days, if not tomorrow. At this point I was under the impression that we were done. I paid him $100, (in cash: 4 $10 and the rest in $5).

    He then sat in his van for 45 mins to an hour outside our house before ringing the doorbell saying he would like to check the attic to see if we might want to/should have the whole system replaced. He was up there for maybe 5 minutes and then went back to his van for maybe 10 more minutes and finally left. NOW for whatever reason AHS refuses to replace the unit or fix it. They claim that the unit never worked when we bought the warranty, but we've been using it for the last 2 years and most recently all of March and April as our power bill shows. I understand that they wanna cheap shot it and merely replace the compressor, but to not fix the problem and then make outrageous claims about the unit's past condition is beyond absurd. You won't be taking any more of our money but believe me, everyone I know will know not to do business with this company. If I could, I wouldn't even give you a single star.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Kaitlin, Coverage decisions are based on the vendors assessment of the unit in question and then the contract verbiage. If you do not agree with the technicians diagnosis, there may be an alternative. Do you mind if we have a case manager contact you to discuss this?

    CoverageTech

    Reviewed April 30, 2015

    This will be my last experience with AHS, God willing. I called AHS because I had a leak from the bypass valve that goes to my water softener. After making the service request I spoke with a representative, in the plumbing department, to make absolutely sure it was going to be covered under my contract. I told her exactly what was leaking and where and what it was connected to. She looked at my contract and assured me that it was covered. Grateful, I proceeded with the service request.

    When the plumbers showed up, they didn't even touch anything, they promptly called AHS and it was determined that the repair wasn't going to be covered, but guess what, I'm still out the $75, exactly what I was trying to avoid by checking with a rep before they sent someone out. We have had a similar problem before when they sent out the WRONG type of service provider... Still out the $75 then too, just twice (once for the wrong one and once for the right). I cannot and will not recommend them to anyone and you can bet that I am not renewing my contract when it expires.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Leah, Our apologies for the coverage decision on your water softener. I understand this is frustrating and would like to have a case manager contact you to discuss this matter.

    No response received
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 30, 2015

    We have had American Home Shield coverage since we purchased our home in 1998. We stuck with the company when their reviews were terrible. We used their repair people and requested ones that were better than others and they provided them. In general, we were satisfied with their coverage and service although it took some trial and error. We paid for extra coverage on some items. We received decent service, although it took some trial and error. But then our washing machine of TWENTY YEARS broke down and AHS said it was OUR FAULT. Repair people have typically been prompt in returning request for service… UNTIL THIS WEEK when our WATER HEATER that was here when we moved in in 1998 failed to provide hot water, and the repair company, BEAR PLUMBING, has been horrible in just returning a phone call and setting up service!

    A call to AHS complaining about this lack of response was met with resistance when I asked to make a complaint! I asked to change providers and AHS said I would have to wait longer (longer than four days from my request for service for NO HOT WATER???). I had to call Bear Plumbing TWICE just to get them to commit to a time -- and then they changed without telling us!! I am thoroughly furious with the plumbing company. AHS has gone way DOWN. IT'S A RIP-OFF!!! They are doing whatever they can to get out of covering our broken appliances. Isn't that what we've been paying for? We didn't break our washing machine. We deserve better response and coverage on our water heater. Their repair people do not inspire confidence!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Ellen, I would like to have a case manager contact you to discuss this matter further if that is okay?

    No response received
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    Customer Service for Water Heater- Called American Home Service and had terrible experience with several of the customer service agents. They are so rude and always come up with lies that are not in the service contract. I started calling a 3:00 pm for expedited service and it will be 5pm tomorrow before a vendor will be out to provide service. I have been a loyal customer for 12 years, but will thinking seriously about cancelling my contract after today.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Ellen, We apologize for the delay in service of your water heater. If you're still in need of assistance, I would like to have a case manager contact you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPrice

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    I was with AHS last 5 years and I did not requested any service for them last 12 month but last week I had gas leak and I requested service. They sent plumber and instead of fixing the leak he said that “Oh! I can charge you $270.0 to fix” and he said that “I am not recommend AHS to fix because it look like you did not gently moved your oven so I don't think they will cover”. And I said “I don't understand what you talking about” and he said that “I need $75.0 call service if you don't wanted to fix me”. I called to AHS and tried to discuss and also terminate my contract. Up to now forget about fixing the leak but I can't even have someone who can help me to terminate the contract. When I call they just saying “someone will call you within 48 hours”. After the 48 hours I called back and they said “7 days someone will call you”. I can't believed how they treated to us.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Liban, If you're still in need of assistance with this work order or would like to have a Retention representative contact you to discuss possible cancellation, we would like to help.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    Day 1 of heating system equipment failure response... Called and scheduled inspection. Day 3 - inspection made by local HVAC contractor. Heating system was CONDEMNED by local contractor. Day 4 - Local contractor needs to send someone else out. Scheduled. Day 7 - New tech inspects and comes up with a game plan. Says he will provide estimate within 24-48 hours. Day 9 - no estimate. Day 14 - no estimate.

    I call local company to get info. They say call AHS. AHS says "Why'd they say that?" LIKE I WOULD KNOW!!! I call local and they say they must not understand. (At this point I am believing they may not want to stand behind the "WARRANTY" because the system doesn't work. EXACTLY WHY I WOULD PURCHASE A WARRANTY.) Day 15 - local contractor calls me and tells me they have been authorized to do $1,900 worth of work to "upgrade" my system because the HVAC was old. (A replacement system would go for around $8K - $12K). Local contractor is now telling me I need to call AHS again. TO BE CONTINUED...

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Allen, I would like to have a case manager contact you to assist in moving your heating system repair along. Do you mind if we contact you?

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    I requested service for my gas range oven. The tech that came out said a new thermostat is needed and he didn't think a new one could be found since the range is 31 years old. I was told I would hear back from either AHS or his company. Over a week later, still no phone call. I called AHS, was told they would look into the status of the part and call me back in 30 minutes. No return call ever came.

    I called again today, over 2 weeks since the tech was out. I was told the part is no longer made but it could be rebuilt which would take 6 to 8 weeks. That means the tech would come, take the current thermostat and 6 to 8 weeks later come back with it rebuilt. This also means that I can not use the oven at all for this period of time. AHS did offer me $240 toward buying a new range instead. This is completely unacceptable. I have to be able to use my oven. Dinner is made in the oven at least 4 times a week. We are having 30 people over for Mother's Day and I won't have an oven to use? AHS will not offer me any other resolution. Having this warranty is a complete waste of money. I will be canceling my warranty ASAP.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Mary Kaye, Thank you for making us aware of this issue with your has oven. A case manager is available to assist you with this matter if that is okay?

    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    I contacted American Home Shield about a gas cooktop that two of the burners were not working. I filed my claim online, and was told there a service person would contact me to set up service. After a week they had not so I called them. The service man came, said I needed a part. Called AHS and got the OK but he told them at that time he could not locate the part. Another week goes by I do not hear anything. I call AHS they tell me the technician needs to call them, I told them he already did I heard him make the call. They have no record. Another week goes by, a technician comes to put a part in my oven, he calls AHS to tell them he cannot find the part. AHS tells them I will hear from their options department in 48 hours. No call. Another week goes by, I still have no working cooktop, I call again and they again tell me 48 hours.

    They do not call you back, some of them, not all, are downright unfriendly, and the follow up is horrible. And, they will not put a supervisor on the line, period. You have absolutely no recourse but to keep calling. AHS you should be ashamed!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Margaret, We apologize for the delay in getting your cook top service work order resolved. I would like to have a case manager contact you to assist.

    Verified purchase
    CoverageRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 29, 2015

    We put in a request to have our air conditioning serviced. AHS approved replacing the unit but will only pay $10 per pound for freon which actually costs $70 per pound. Apparently they have changed their contract and no longer cover this across-the-board. So now we have to pay $600 out of pocket on top of our $100 deductible. I pay $51.00 per month premium for this poor coverage. We will be changing companies as soon as we can.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Amber, Thank you for sharing your experience. You are correct, our contracts cover $10 per pound for refrigerant on the initial install. However, if additional refrigerant is needed within the recall time frame of the service work order, AHS will take responsibility for full costs. If you would like to discuss this matter further, we would be happy to have a case manager contact you.

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 28, 2015

    We purchased the home warranty service when we purchased our home. On 4/18/15, we went to turn on our HVAC system and noticed it wasn't cooling the house. We submitted a service request that evening and on 4/19/15 I saw it was assigned to a contractor. On 4/20/15 I contacted the contractor and arranged for them to come out on 4/23/15.

    On 4/23/15 the contractor came out and checked our HVAC system. His diagnosis was that we needed to replace the condenser, but he said given the age of the system he recommended we replace the whole system. He told me he could either tell the warranty company that the condenser needed replacing OR he could tell them I needed to replace the system. If I went with the latter, I would at least get $3,000 from the warranty company to put towards a new system. I asked the contractor for a written quote so I could consider my options.

    On 4/24/15 I followed up with the contractor again requesting a written quote for the two systems we had discussed. The contractor replied with the following, "Upgrade to Trane xr14 complete heat pump system. Customer balance 8400.00 after all credits, rebates, discounts." I asked for a detailed quote including labor, the equipment cost, and anticipated rebates, credits, and/or discounts and was told that their systems were flat rate and the quote was better than most. I was still not provided with anything other than a verbal quote for the second system (7500). Both quotes "included" a $3,000 credit from the warranty company.

    On 4/25/15 I contacted the warranty company and explained that I was having a hard time getting detailed quotes from the contractor and asked if they could put me in touch with someone else within their network as I had some concerns. I was informed that I could not work with anyone else until the contractor provided a diagnosis. I asked if they had an in-network provider list that I could use and I was told that under no circumstances could they share that information with me until the first contractor got back to me. I was beyond shocked that the warranty company would not let me work with anyone else especially when I clearly stated that I had some concerns about the business practices of the first contractor. Nice to know they stand by their contractors, not their customers.

    On 4/27/15 I had a different contractor come out to look at the system. He provided a much clearer diagnosis of the problem and provided a detailed quote for replacing the whole system. His quote came in $800 lower than the quote that included the "$3000 home warranty buyout"! The same day the first contractor asked me how I wanted to proceed. I asked him to provide the warranty company with his diagnosis. He asked if I wanted him to repair the unit, replace the unit through him, or replace the unit through someone else. I explained that we would work with someone else. He said he would take care of it. It's the end of the day 4/28/15 and my service request is still on hold. The warranty company said they have not heard from him and he has 24 hours to respond. If he keeps dragging his feet THEN they'll put me in touch with another in network provider and I would get to start the whole process over again.

    I am extremely disappointed in how difficult it has been to get the warranty company to provide me with a contractor I can trust. Apparently I have only one option - go with their guy or get absolutely nothing from the home warranty. We have an actual problem here and their contractor is not filling out his paperwork and seems to be engaging in some dishonest business with AHS's customers. As a result we will have to address the solution and pay for everything out of pocket.

    I thought the home warranty would provide us with peace of mind during this first year in the home. Instead I now have to continue to deal with a contractor with whom I am not comfortable doing business and I have to make multiple follow up phone calls to get AHS customer service to try to move this along. I now regret purchasing it and would advise others against wasting their money on a policy. I will have the new contractor document everything they find as they work on our heat pump and hopefully that will help as I follow up with the warranty company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Laura, I would like to have a case manager contact you to assist with this matter if that's okay?

    No response received
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 28, 2015

    Pool repair - Everything went as planned. I am pleased.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 27, 2015

    My Dishwasher broke so I called to get it repaired. They send out a contractor to look at it. He spends all of 3 minutes in my house and does not even take the dishwasher apart to find what was wrong with it. 2 weeks later I call to find out my status and was told it was denied due to the electrical fire in my dishwasher- it is not coverable. I asked what fire and was told the contractor wrote up that the dishwasher malfunction was caused by an electric Fire in the motor. I filed an appeal since there was no fire. They were unable to find another contractor and they told me to find one. I did and they came, took it apart and discovered that the motor went and needed to be replaced.

    AHS called and confirmed that there was no electric fire and that the motor was bad. AHS told me that it was a high estimate and that I needed to use their original contractor to do the repair or they are not going to pay for it. Like anyone would have Affordable Appliance come back out to do the repairs after their bogus estimate. So now I am out the repair costs, the original service charge and my monthly charge. Never get AHS, it is not worth the hassle.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Chris, I wold like to have a case manager review this work order and contact you if that's ok?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 27, 2015

    I have a diabetic son who lives in our home and because of American Home Shield's complete lack of response and lack of customer service, after 3 weeks of the run around, we still have no working refrigerator and no acceptable way to keep my son's insulin cold. This company is a joke. Our fridge went out THREE WEEKS AGO. We immediately called American Home Shield and they sent out a local so California company called Accord Appliances, one week later, to fix it. The service guy handed me a WAIVER and tried to FORCE me to sign it! I read the waiver. If I had signed it, this company was basically off the hook for any repairs, issues afterwards, like leaking water, damage they may cause or any replacement. I refused to sign it. He left in a huff after speaking with my Dad on the phone, while slamming down my new cell phone on our kitchen counter.

    We immediately called back American Home Shield to complain. They said they knew nothing about any waiver and had nothing to do it. They apologized. We expressed again, that we NEEDED a working refrigerator ASAP as our son is diabetic and his insulin needs to be kept cold. They set up ANOTHER appointment for 7 DAYS LATER- with another repair company affiliated with Sears appliances. That was two weeks ago! My son's insulin is still sitting in an ice bucket on our back patio. The stress is incredible! The repair guy from Sears finally showed up last Friday. He was nice and seemed to know what he was talking about. He said he could repair our refrigerator, but he did not have the part. The part needed to be special ordered! He said the part would be special ordered and delivered directly to our home and he'd be back this next Friday to fix our refrigerator.

    Today is Monday. No new part and our refrigerator is still broken! And, my son's insulin is still sitting in a ice bucket in our backyard! American Home Shield's answer to our crisis today- is their "NEW generous offer" to reimburse us, if we buy a small $100 beverage type of refrigerator for our garage! They'll pay us up to $100 for a small refrigerator and all we have to do is send them the invoice! (Wow! How generous! NOT!) Fact- For three weeks this rip off insurance company has given us the run around and made us suffer with no working refrigerator! And, their answer today is to replace our standard sized refrigerator with a small beverage sized $100 refrigerator to sit in our garage?!? This is totally unacceptable!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Dana- We regret to hear of the delay in getting your refrigerator repaired and would like to get a case manager involved. Is it okay to contact you in regards to this matter?

    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 27, 2015

    I'm a Realtor and have a policy on a listing. While an inspector and buyers agent were at the home the AC system seemed to quit cooling. I had a repairman from AHS come. He thoroughly inspected the system and all it needed was one pound of Freon. The buyers came back and are satisfied with how the system is working now!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 26, 2015

    I ordered a home protection plan. 11 days later, I called for a normal yet small plumbing repair. They had a plumber come out and he checked out the problem which was low flow in my one shower bathroom. He then called AHS and they outright rejected the claim. They said my home inspector which when I purchased the home 11 months ago should of found the problem. I advised them it was not like this when I purchased the house and things happen over time. Also, what inspector takes apart the fixtures to look behind the walls? Absolutely none do. Nevertheless, I still had to pay the $75.00 deductible. Needless to say, this warranty is completely worthless and cancelled. Do yourself a favor and look elsewhere for a home warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Scott, Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We sincerely apologize for any inconvenience you had with your warranty service that led you to cancel with us. Your feedback is valuable and we will use it to better our services.

    No response received
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 26, 2015

    I have had AHS home warranty for a couple of years and every time we have a service call, there is an issue with the tech companies they send out. They send out repair technicians who have no experience or knowledge on how to fix anything and make the situation worse. AHS will not do anything about complaints about a company, they will send out the same companies to fix problems they caused. I don't know how AHS compiles the list of companies to use but it seems like all the ones they send out have awful reviews.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Susan. We sincerely apologize for the experiences you've had with our vendors. If you currently have an open service work order that needs attention, a case manager is available to contact you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 26, 2015

    I have been a customer of American Home Shield for a long time and suddenly, without explanation, AHS has decided not to accept payments from people who use a bill-pay service. I have used USAA as my bill pay service for many, many years, with never a problem and that includes AHS. Now suddenly we must pay every three months rather than my usual monthly payment. I spoke with a rep on the phone and despite my threat to cancel my account, he was ok with AHS losing my business. So I cancelled my account. Business must be very good when they can lose a customer that had no claims and always paid on time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Darwin, We regret to hear that you have cancelled your home warranty with us due to payment issues. We do offer month to month payments as well. Thank you making us aware of your experience as we will use it to better our services and products.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 25, 2015

    I currently have a home warranty with American Home Shield. Three weeks ago, I put in a service request for a malfunctioning HVAC. I live in Atlanta, GA and the weather is starting warm as it is April and the air conditioning unit is not blowing in cold air. I personally spoke with an American Home Shield representative and informed the representative that I lived in a condo and that the air conditioning unit was not inside my unit. The representative of American Home Shield immediately created a service request with one of its contractors. I scheduled an appointment with this service contractor as is protocol.

    On the scheduled day of service, the contractor informed me that he could not assess my A/C unit as he is not licensed to enter the roof. I thus paid a $75 service fee as required by American Home Shield and contacted American Home Shield for another contractor to come out and assess the issue. American Home Shield called three companies before it found one that was licensed to enter the roof. This company was AirSolutions USA, Inc. based in Woodstock, Georgia. I scheduled an appointment with AirSolutions USA.

    A technician from AirSolutions USA came out to assess the problem on a Thursday. The technician informed me that a part needed to be ordered and they would call once the part was received. I heard nothing on Friday. I called AirSolutions USA all day Monday, leaving messages - no one answered the phone and no one returned my calls. I attempted to contact AirSolutions again on Tuesday morning to no avail. I finally contacted American Home Shield Warranty who was able to get a hold of AirSolutions and scheduled an appointment for Friday, as the part had since been received.

    I took the day off Friday and when the noted time frame had elapsed for when AirSolutions was to arrive, I contacted the company to learn that the company had ordered the wrong part. At this point, I have been without A/C in Atlanta on the 5th floor of a condo complex for two weeks. I contacted American Home Shield Warranty and was informed that no other contractor with American Home Shield was licensed to enter the roof and thus, the representative recommended that I do a cash out option; that is, American Home Shield pays me what it estimates the cost to repair the A/C will be and American Home Shield Warranty will write me a check for that amount so that I may contract with an independent contractor to fix the issue.

    I thought this was great. I was informed I should receive a response on the cash back option within 48 hours. 48 hours elapsed with no word from American Home Shield Warranty. I contacted American Home Shield Warranty inquiring into the status of the cash back option. I was informed that no decision could be made because AirSolutions USA refused to contact American Home Shield Warranty with the exact issue. Now I am over two weeks without A/C and thus asked to have the issue escalated.

    The issue was escalated per American Home Shield Warranty protocol. I was then contacted by the owner of AirSolutions, John, who stated he would come to assess the issue on Wednesday. To no surprise of mine, AirSolutions contacted me Wednesday evening to inform me it would not be out to asses the issue. We rescheduled for Saturday. After initiating contact with AirSolutions USA on Saturday, John informed me that he would not be out to assess the issue, but could reschedule for Monday. I informed John that our working relationship had been terminated due to poor customer service and lack of reliability.

    I immediately contacted American Home Shield Warranty who informed me that another contractor would be contacting me to schedule an appointment. Mind you, I have been without A/C for over three weeks and I was previously informed that AirSolutions USA was the only contractor with American Home Shield who was licensed to enter roofs. Now, I am informed the opposite! After much resistant, I was finally able to speak to a manager; I wanted my repair request expedited. I was informed that I could not expedite the request even though I have been without A/C for 3 weeks in Atlanta. Also, during this time, I incurred an ant infestation because the windows and doors had to be open to cool my home.

    I am highly disappointed in American Shield Home Warranty. I have been over three weeks without A/C and there is still no resolution in site. I have yet to be compensated for any inconvenience I have encountered. American Home Shield Warranty has shown a complete lack of interest in my needs and concerns. I will NEVER purchase a home warranty through American Home Shield because of this incident and I recommend others do not as well. American Home Shield should monitor and censor their contractors. AirSolutions USA has negative reviews on every social media site and all reviews pertain to the same type of situation that I experienced. If American Home Shield Warranty truly cared about its customers, it would terminate the contract with AirSolutions USA and only contract with contractors who were reliable and provide customer service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Kelly, We apologize for the delay in getting your a/c repaired and would like to make this right. A case manager can contact you to help move this work order along if that is okay?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 25, 2015

    Purchased a home in central Kansas in 2014 that was built in 1960s. AHS was purchased at time of sale... contract coming due this mid-May. Sump-pump acting weird and detached garage lights and an electrical outlet went out. Called AHS and THEY CONFIRMED issues are covered under contract. Two separate service calls at $75.00 each... sump-pump tech comes out says pump needs replaced and pump replacement is authorized by AHS BUT.. BIG BUT... AHS will not pay for $980.00 of "required plumbing" for the sump-pump, even though plumbing is covered under contract. HORRIBLE COMPANY. LOOKING FOR CLASS-ACTION ASSOCIATES.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Eric, If you have questions regarding your coverage decision for your plumbing, a case manager is available to assist you.

    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    Notification of requiring a repair effort is very simple and easy. I like to use the website and the simple questions on it make it very brief. Additionally, it gives me a contact point and the name of the company that should be contacting me within 24 hours before I leave the site.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    I used AHS in the past and was delighted with the service and the contractor. This time, I called due to leaking pipes that caused water damage in my basement. I verified if indoor leaking pipes were covered before making my service request and was told yes. A plumber comes out and says it was not covered but they can fix my problem if I pay cash for the repair. Due to the emergency of the situation, I paid to not have further damage to my basement. And I paid my service fee.

    Later, I called AHS because I felt I had been "scammed". I was actually told that I may have been "taken advantage of" because I was a single female. I also found out that the plumber had lied and said my pipes had burst due to freezing weather. It was 56 degrees and the damage was inside not outside. They fixed the problem but nothing was replaced. If I had a pipe burst due to freezing conditions, then there would have been an obvious crack or break in the pipe.

    The representative said she (**) would call me back after researching the problem but never did. I placed 5 calls afterwards but no one has called back. My question is....Is it normal practice to employ a company that takes advantage of extreme situations? I am so disappointed and afraid to have other companies come into my home. What will the next contractor do? Rob me?

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Marla, Thank you for making us aware of this. I would like to have a case manager contact you to further discuss this matter.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPricePunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    Took out warranty with AHS 7-8-2014. Called for service on AC in August. Sent a repairman out right away. When he called AHS, they said warranty did not cover coil cleaning that cost $450.00. Put a repair request again in March 2015 on AC. Repairman came right away and said it needed to be replaced. AHS would only cover $730 of $3,700 bill. Called and cancelled warranty April 5-2015 (had to talk to many different depts before we got it cancelled.) By then they had taken the next month payment out of out account, so had to call back for refund. Said it would take 7-14 days. Have not seen refund. Called AHS again and they said we would not get refund, so we are cancelled and still paying for an extra month that we do not have service. They said that they prorate the amount due on refund and that we do not get refund.

    I very highly recommend not using AHS or any other warranty for that matter. They take your money right away but when you want anything from them it takes forever.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Ej, Our Retention department calculates any refunds that are due to the homeowner at the time of cancellation. The checks are sent out within 7-14 business days. If you have any more questions about your cancellation, our Retention Department can assist you. Thank you for sharing your feedback.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    I purchased my new house last year and purchased my warranty from AHS. I filed two claims after I purchased my house. However, they declined all of my claims because they always can find many excuses. I canceled their warranty service even if they do not refund me because I do not want to waste my time anymore. I will share the experience with all of my friends. Thanks.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Anqi, We regret that the coverage decision led you to cancel your home warranty with us. We appreciate the opportunity to better our products and services,

    No response received
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    I have owned 3 different houses, with 3 different warranty companies. I always did my research so no company was bad, but American Home Shield blows everyone else out of the water and I call them for EVERYTHING. The broad range of items covered, the responsiveness, attentive customer service, no limits on number of service calls, and good contractors. If you have an option, go with American Home Shield. You won't regret it. I love this company.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 24, 2015

    American Home Shield has great timeliness when it comes to getting a contractor scheduled to set up an appointment. The resolution of my problem was done in a timely manner. I have requested a ticket through automation before, but the times I have spoken with a representative, they were very nice and helpful. The contractors cleaned the area, once they were finished.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    Our experience with American Home Shield has less than great. Our 26 year old ac went out April 14 and we called and were told someone could come on the 16th. This company came, we paid $75, for them to declare it "dead". They never turned in their paperwork to AHS. We waited several days and no one on either side called us. We finally got in touch with someone from AHS who sent yet another company out. They said the compressor was gone and AHS would have to authorize ordering one. This was two days ago. Still nobody called and most of their customer service is rude as are these cheap companies they contract.

    Now after 10 days without any air conditioning in Florida and still no call from anyone, we called and AHS had gotten the paperwork and said they would have to order the part (for a almost 30 year old unit) with an approximate time of April 29th at which time we have to call (again) to schedule appointment for them to replace compressor. By that time it will have been three weeks without air! This is not acceptable. We have people in the house with medical issues that need air!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Lindsay, I would like to get a case manager involved to help move your a/c service work order along if that is ok?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    I am very disappointed with American Home Shield. I called for a repair service to adjust the hot water for my tenant. I called my tenant to confirm that AHS will be sending a plumber to fix the problem. My tenant had figured the problem and no longer requires the service. I then called AHS to cancel the service. AHS had charged $100 from bank account since the service fee has to be paid the same day. I informed AHS to refund my money on 4/15/15. The first customer rep. said she would reverse the fund. I called again on the same day to confirm that the refund has completed. The second customer rep. did not find any paperwork from the first customer rep about my refund of $100.00. She then asked for my credit card number so she could process the papers. She mentioned that it would 7 days to get my money.

    Today is the 7th day, 4/23/15 and I did not get my money in my bank account. I called AHS again to find the status of my money. This customer rep now mentions that it would 10 days to get my money since they don't have the control on the processing procedure. I called again at 5 pm about my refund. This 4th customer rep. now does not know how long it's going to take. At this point, I had enough with AHS as I am getting around about my money. AHS still has not delivered any information about their company mail after a month I called them. What is the policy of getting refunds? It seems AHS wants money up front but when it comes to returning money, it feels like pulling teeth from them. They are not very professional at all.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    HI Jocelyn, I would like to have a case manger contact you to assist with any reimbursement that is due to you. Is it okay to call?

    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    Great response, repair, and value.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    We are currently dealing with a company "Appliance Pros" who has given us the run around in reference to repairing a range and range hood. AHS refuses to send us a different company to repair the appliance. I am a Realtor who sends many of my clients to AHS, however, I will not be doing that in the future. They are not working diligently to resolve repair issues at my own residence.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Alisha, We apologize for the delay in getting your range and range hood exhaust fan repaired. A case manager can contact you to assist in this matter.

    Verified purchase
    CoverageTech

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    We recently had a problem with a 20+ year old toilet that would not stop running. When the technicians came, they were amazed at all the problems inside the tank. They said they could probably get it to stop running again, but it would never work properly. However our home warranty would not cover the replacement of the toilet.

    We opted to buy a new toilet because it make no sense to repair something to less than full working order, especially when it would be very likely that we would have more problems very soon. I wish AHS would take that into consideration, since this is not the first time we've had this issue arise with a covered item.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Christina- Thank you for sharing your experience as it is greatly appreciated. If you're ever in need to clarify a coverage decision, we are here to help.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    It took the contractor over a week to go to my condo and provide a diagnosis and quote for my hvac. I spoke with one AHS rep who assured me I could select my own contractor and be reimbursed up to the contract limit ($3000). First time I called AHS I was on hold for over 15 minutes then disconnected. Contractor selected by AHS was very difficult to contact by phone. Please forward a check in the amount of $3000 per contract agreement.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jeffrey- If you would like a case manager to contact you i regards to your a/c service request, one is a available. Thank you for sharing your experience as we will us it to better our products and services.

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    My first claim with American Home Shield was good, I had no complaints. My Jacuzzi wasn’t heating up and the contractor they sent, who was a very nice gentleman, fixed the problem.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 23, 2015

    Woke up to water all over three rooms, water BBB running out of back of refrigerator, called American Shield. They got hold of Sears would be out next day between 8-5 next day. At 11am Sears called could not do job for week or so. Called Home Shield told them, and told them it was not acceptable. They said "we cannot find anyone." They would be back with us in 24 hr. My first ever problem ever, am I happy? Far from it. Will I let other people know? Every chance I get. Very poor service to say the least.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello William, We extend our apologies for the delay in service for your refrigerator service work order. If you're still in need of assistance, a case manager is available to contact you.

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 22, 2015

    I submitted a claim for service on our pool pump last week. A vendor was sent out to do the repair on Friday of that week 4/17. The company was unable to fix the problem and notified your company. Your company then arranged repair with a second vendor who could not come to evaluate the problem until the week of 4/27. Your company offered me authorization for an outside vendor but then reneged on the offer. That was done subsequently by **, then **, then **, and finally ** a floor supervisor. The vendor told me specifically that he told your company on Monday April 20 that he could not come to my home to assess the problem until the following week - 4/27.

    I have been given the runaround, been denied access to a supervisor by your associate **, have repeatedly been told that "yes, this situation is outside your service guideline," but basically oh well. It has taken multiple phone calls, too many minutes on hold and much aggravation to basically be denied the service (according to your own guidelines) that I am paying for. I don't see how I can renew my contract with your company or recommend you to anyone else seeking this type of coverage.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Eve, We apologize for the delay in service and would like to have a case manager contact you.

    No response received
    Coverage

    Reviewed April 22, 2015

    My heating and air conditioning unit just went out. I called for service. American Home Shield sends a repair company out and tells me my unit is missing parts. I told them it just went out, how can it be missing parts? I asked for a second opinion and they sent someone new out. The second opinion tells me my unit has been opened and water has gotten in so it's not covered. If the only people who went up to my unit and opened it was companies sent by American Home Shield, should it not be covered? I am really frustrated. Will not do business with a company like this again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    No response received
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 22, 2015

    I contracted AHS for my elderly parent's home in Sept. 12. It was a $729/yr policy with a $75 service fee. The policy was paid in full and we used it once for the dishwasher. I chose not to renew the policy. I received an email saying they didn't have a current card on file for "reoccurring" charges. I let them know it was a one time contract. Dec. of '13 my parents started getting collection calls and letters from Transworld Systems Inc., a bloody collection company. My 85 year old father was about to pay it. I am disgusted with their tactics. Do not use them for the sake of other who might fall victim.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi EA, if you're having troubles with a bill, we would like to help. Is it ok to contact you?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 22, 2015

    My most recent claim with American Home shield was about my leaking washing machine. I called and requested service and got it. Their initial reply was that it would be a week before service but we're a family of four that needed laundry. They found an alternative and got a local service agent out here instead of the original company, so it was great. The claims representatives and the contractors were very good and very professional. The contractor was also very personable and broke down exactly what he was doing, what time frame we could expect. He had to order a part and gave us a shipment date. Everything was great and we will recommend American Home Shield! We’ve been customers for years and plan to continue.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 22, 2015

    My A/C (Condenser) went out on Wednesday, April 15th. It was late in the evening so I submitted a claim via the web and was assigned a contractor. I called the contractor that evening and left a detailed voice mail explaining what the issue was. Thursday rolls around and I hear nothing, so I emailed and called the contractor again still getting the voice mail. I started to get concerned so I called AHS and informed them of what was going on and requested to be reassigned to a different contractor.

    Friday morning I finally get a call from the original contractor and they said the earliest they could fit me in would be Tuesday of the following week (Today). This was unacceptable in my eyes so I called AHS and the best they said they could do was reassign me to a new contractor. The new contractor they assigned me to had been out to my house before and did great work and they were able to come out a day earlier (Monday). The new contractor came out yesterday and figured out that I had a bad compressor and said they would work with AHS to get it repaired.

    The next day (Today) AHS called me requesting that I pay, get this, $880 for 11 pounds of R-22 (Freon). Question: Why would a 2.5 Ton system need 11 pounds of Freon (My recharge is 4.6lbs)? I requested a second opinion and AHS honored it and will send another contractor out Thursday to diagnose. Question: Why doesn't AHS validate the recommendations of their contractors (Protect your customers)? AHS, Please protect your customers by doing some due diligence. Don't always assume the contractor is doing what's right.

    AHS, your Customer Service department needs work. When you say you'll call someone back, DO IT. If you don't know the answer, just admit to it and find somebody who does. I can go on, but I think you're already aware of the areas that need improvement. Question: Why does it take 24-48 hours to speak to a supervisor or manager? Oh, by the way I still have NO A/C and summer is approaching quickly. Someone Please HELP.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Brandon, Thank you for making us aware of the issues you're having in getting your a/c repaired. If you're still in need of assistance, a case manager can contact you.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    We have been customers of AHS for several years, and although we have had some problems, this time we are looking for a new home warranty company because the treatment we have received has been unacceptable. We first put in a call for a plumber on April 10th, the plumber finally came yesterday after canceling twice -- my husband took off two days of work and the plumber was a no show/no call both days.

    When he (MOORE'S PLUMBING) finally did come yesterday it was hours after promising he would be coming to our house as his first stop, and he came in complaining as soon as he walked in. He was completely unprofessional in every way, and he could tell my husband was annoyed. When he called in the problem to AHS, he didn't report the problem accurately -- which was a leak in the pipe -- he said it was a blockage, which (coincidentally) is the one thing that AHS doesn't cover. It was completely untrue and my husband spoke to the AHS rep and insisted on getting a second opinion, which is our right under our contract.

    He was told that we would have to pay another service change of $100 and he said that was fine; then the AHS rep said he could not get a second opinion because "AHS does not have another plumber who services this area." This is absurd since we live in Monmouth County, NJ, in a very populated area, and there are hundreds of plumbers around here. Therefore it is ridiculous for AHS to say that they didn't have another plumber to send.

    Obviously, the plumber who was here did not want AHS to send anyone else out here double-checking his "diagnosis" because they would see that there wasn't a blockage at all, and his call to AHS claiming there was a blockage and not a leaking pipe wasn't based on anything except a desire to get out of doing anything other than collect the $100 service fee. Now we are stuck with our plumbing problems and took all those days off of work for nothing. Waste of money to pay for AHS every month but when you need it they deny you coverage!! We are canceling and going with another company!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Lynn, I would like to have a case manager contact you to assist with this work order if that is okay?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    A few weeks ago, my laundry tub filled up with water and wouldn't drain properly. I called AHS, and a plumber came out. The plumber came out and said, "Well, we can't fix this without a main cleanout. That needs to be installed." $75 check written, and I still had a problem. I received a call the next day that AHS would not cover the cleanout installation; it wasn't under warranty terms. When I asked to have another plumber come out and get a 2nd opinion, they said over and over again, "A cleanout install isn't under warranty."

    Not what I am asking -- I just would like a 2nd opinion on a possible, different solution. Apparently, this went off their script...and couldn't respond. Now let's think about this reasonably -- if you were told you needed to have brain surgery, insurance denies it, so you ask if you can see a different doc for a 2nd opinion...and they just repeatedly say, "WE WON'T COVER THAT SURGERY!!" Do you think you would lose your temper? Bets are...you would. Listen to understand, people...not to respond. So, I am having a different plumber, on my own dime, come out to assess it. $75 check was worthless.

    Next, my oven stopped working. Called AHS again. I explained, "I have an older oven...not every technician will work on them." Sure enough, they request a technician who said, "Oh goodness! Glad you called and mentioned that. Yeah, we don't work on O'Keefe and Merritt...You need a specialty service." Called AHS again. Let's see how this goes.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Sarah, If you're in need of assistance with your open service work orders, we would like to help. We apologize for your experience and would like to make it right.

    No response received
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    I had a problem with a refrigerator that died. First problem was getting the first service call. They made the appointment but it was a no show. I called back and was told that that company could not service a closed system. They told me they were having trouble finding someone who could. As it was a Sears fridge I called them myself and arranged for the call. Turned out it was a bad compressor. A part was ordered and I waited several days for it to arrive and the tech to return. About 3 weeks has elapsed.

    The same day after the tech replaced the compressor it started making the same noise it did before. I Called in and another call was placed. I waited another week for the tech to return and finally I was told it was a bad compressor. Now 6 weeks have passed and am trying to feed a family of 6 out of a 40 qt ice chest. After several days of calling back and forth I was told there was nothing they could do until it completely broke. So rather than buy food and take the chance of it all going bad again, we are still using the ice chest for anything that might spoil and only keeping drinks in the fridge. The noise is getting worse but still not dead yet. I canceled my contract and am having to buy a small, used fridge for now. Don't trust this company to follow through with their promise of good service or anything else.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Tim, We regret to hear that you cancelled your home warranty with us due to the issue you had with your refrigerator. Thank you for sharing your feedback as we will use it to better our services.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    PricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    Very efficient, timely and inexpensive.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    I paid for the systems warranty on my house for 5 years and my A/C unit needed service this last week. The system is older, which is one reason I have the warranty. They have a clause to not pay for the coolant on older systems which meant they replace the part and I am stuck with a $900 bill. The AHS warranty is therefore pretty much worthless on older systems. Since newer systems are typically still covered under manufacturer’s warranty the warranty is basically worthless. Service calls are $75 through AHS. Going direct to my local A/C company a service call is $65. Most other items covered by AHS like ceiling fans or garbage disposal, the items are less than a service call or very near. If they replace a fan you don't get to choose from whatever you want. They will replace with a similar quality, but whatever style they have, so again, might as well self-insure and not bother giving away your money for no actual benefit.

    I opted for the cash out on my A/C unit as I didn't want to spend almost $1000 on my 15 year old A/C unit. They have not told me how much I am going to be getting for the cash out. They closed my service ticket. I asked for an email stating that they will be contacting me or giving me some sort of cash out and they will not send any written communication. They assured me the call was recorded, which does me absolutely no good. I expect fully that AHS will drag out this process until my contract is up in 36 days and just drop it or send me near nothing if I am lucky enough to actually get a cash out.

    Awful service. Awful product. Too much money wasted for nothing. Expensive lesson learned. Hopefully this post will help some people save some money. Self insure!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jason, Thank you for making us aware of the issue you're having in getting your a/c repaired. I would like to have a case manager contact you in regards to this matter.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 21, 2015

    My experience with AHS is generally very good. Submitting it online is very easy and quick and then I immediately get a response from them and the local person they choose so everything works great, except for one small detail. When you get online to submit a claim, they list a bunch of things that might be wrong with your house and you have to choose one from the list. There are several items that they cover that are on my contract but are not among the choices that they present. So I just have to pick something at random that is as close as I can get.

    Also, it's nearly impossible to tell them what my problem really is. They intend for my submission to them to explain what the problem is but it's really hard to do that. I wish they would make it easy. I realize this is probably a big programming problem, but I wish they would look at my contract and see what's covered and give me the choice of everything that's on my contract, not just the 15 most likely things that everybody calls about, which is what they apparently do now.

    If they were to make the text box such that it didn't include very many spaces like Twitter, then they wouldn't have to get a whole lot to work. I can explain my claim in a few words. The request would have to be reviewed by a human and I'm sure, currently, it's all automatic. I say I have a leak and they send me a plumber, and when the plumber calls, I have to tell him what the problem really is. So I don't know if the text box would be fine, though I bet they will say "No, we just can't do that." The better thing would be to add 10 or 15 new items to that list and maybe they'll hit me more often.

    One time I had a ductwork problem, but that's not an option on their list. So I had to figure out that a duct is in the AC system and the only thing they have to do with air conditioning is 'air conditioning isn't working'. So I just have to choose that. And if they could just expand that to include some of the other common things, then they could still do it automatically. They wouldn't have to have a human, but that would be more likely to hit me and when they do hit me, then it's extremely easy. When they don't, I just have to go through that whole strange step of figuring out which one is going to get me the right service professional and tell him what the real problem is. But other than that, the process is great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    AHS has been great. I had no problem with them. Everybody that they send out so far has been good. They got the work done.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    I had AHS for 2 rental condos that I own. I called January 27, 2015 to cancel both. I noticed that my credit card was charged on February 2, 2015 for both. One charge was reversed on February 12, 2015 but the other one wasn't. I called back and informed the CSR that I was charged but I had cancelled the plan. The CSR said that he didn't see that the plan had been cancelled but would cancelled it. I inquired about the February 2, 2015 charge being reimbursed. He said someone would be calling me back to handle that. I never heard back from anyone.

    Then, March 2, 2015, I was charged again. I waited until March 24, 2015 to call because I thought maybe it was talking some time to process. The first CSR that I talked to said that she could see that I cancelled in February and that the March payment was being refunded but it takes some time to process. The refund was approved on March 12, 2015 (or something like that). She said she couldn't do anything about the February payment because she didn't have a record of the cancellation request. She said I would have to speak to someone in retention.

    I spoke with a CSR from the retention department and gave her the history. I informed her that I requested this to be cancelled at the same time that I cancelled the policy for another unit. She reviewed the notes for the other unit and said that there was nothing in the notes about cancelling for this unit. At the end of the call, she informed me that I would be refunded for the March payment and that it was processing but for the February payment, she would have to have the call rebuild to verify that I made the request. She said it could take up to 2 weeks. I gave it almost 4 weeks.

    I called back today, April 20, 2015 and the CSR told me that according to the notes, I am not due a refund for February and March because I did not cancel before February and March. I informed her of what I was told before and asked for a manager. She took down my contact information and said someone will contact me within 24-48 hours.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Naquisha, Thank you for making us aware of the issues you're having with your cancellation payment reimbursement. I will forward this to the appropriate persons to review this and contact you. Your feedback is appreciated.

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    I have been with AHS for years. Heat pump leaking freon and replacing motor every season, compressor no longer works. I was asked to pay $900 for freon that leaks into the environment, Environmental Protection Agency said "violation".

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    We called AHS for our AC and the service tech came out and said our AC coil has gone bad and that the coil we have is obsolete so they will have to replace the coil with another coil. If they change the coil they have to also change the outside unit in order for it to work and that it would be our responsibility to pay for the unit. I have spoken to several people including a case worker in the complaint department. But what no one can give me a satisfactory answer to is why have I paid insurance for 10 years and our system is now obsolete and they can't replace it without replacing the AC, how is that truly our responsibility? Our contract clearly states that if for any reason the AC unit needs to be replaced, it is covered. It does not say if the parts are obsolete then it is the homeowners responsibility. My next step is the news and a lawyer.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Gary, We apologize for any inconvenience this has caused. Per the contract verbiage section G-7, AHS is not responsible or liable for upgrades, components, parts or equipment required due to: (a) the incompatibility of the existing equipment with the replacement system or appliance or component or any part thereof. We will only cover the equipment that has failed and received authorization to replace. We can not discuss legal matters. Your complaint will be forwarded to your case manager to assist with any additional questions. Thank you for your feedback as it will be used to better our products and services.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    AHS was timely in their response and getting someone to my home to handle the problem.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageTech

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    AHS dispatched a plumbing contractor (F-rating with BBB) to fix our water heater. The plumber has no water heater inventory and doesn't know when they will. Also they claim they are not responsible for any damage to my home when replacing the unit. The contractor wants over $800 to bring the water heater "up to code" which other plumbers have indicated is a scam - this is a 9-year old house. I tried explaining this to the person handling my ticket at AHS, but this fell on deaf ears. AHS will only cover $335 to have an outside vendor replace the unit. You can't purchase the tank for that amount, let alone begin to cover the labor costs. This too fell on deaf ears. We are very disappointed.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Peter, We sincerely apologize about your experience! We appreciate your feedback. When offered the option to take a cash in lieu, AHS bases the amount from the costs we would spend to replace the unit, not retail value per our contract verbiage. If you're still in need of assistance or would like to have a case manager contact you, please let us know.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    We have had several bad experiences with American Home Shield the past year. When we put in a service request for our refrigerator, it took over 2 weeks to get repaired. Even though there was medication in the fridge, they would not expedite service. They would not cover our broken pool heater and claimed it wasn't working due to water exposure from sprinklers. The term of the contract states on our paperwork that it is from 4/18/2014 to 4/18/2015. We assumed this meant we could request service us to the 18th but when we called, they said the contract expired on the 18th and they refused. I tried to talk to a manager, left messages twice. No one returned my calls and the third time I called, the representative just said, "we can't help you".

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 20, 2015

    The contractor AHS sent to fix our refrigerator was very good. We liked him and we give him a ten on everything. Submitting a claim was relatively easy too.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 19, 2015

    I would recommend AHS because I have never had a problem with them. Everything I called them for, I was satisfied with the results.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 19, 2015

    I submitted the claim online to AHS and it was easy as pie. The contractors they sent were very nice people. They had been here before. We had had other electrical issues and the guy that comes bends over backwards to make sure we’re happy. If he can't come, he sends his father who's also a master electrician. In a matter of a few minutes, the problem was taken care of.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 18, 2015

    I've had a couple of claims. This last one I have to reschedule. The other one was regarding my kitchen lighting having issues. I scheduled the repair and it got fixed. They have been excellent. Submitting a claim is fairly easy too.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    In early April 2015, I contacted AHS for service on a microwave. On April 3 a Sears Repairman was dispatched to my home. He was here about 5 minutes (plus $83.00 worth) only to determine that the part my microwave need was no longer available. He left telling me I'd be contacted by AHS shortly. Thirteen days later, I tired of wait. I call and was told Sears had not reported back to AHS and that they would call me back in 24 to 48 hours. I objected to the time period given and they said I should check back at noon on the 14th day if I'd not heard. I call at 2:40 on the 14th day, was placed on hold for 3 or 4 mins while they contacted Sears. Still no report and I am getting my microwave fixed. I asked for a manager and none was available. Today is Friday, I am now told they should have the Sears info by Tuesday. This has dragged on far too long and I am not a happy customer!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Steve, We sincerely apologize for the delay in service and would like an opportunity to assist you with your microwave service work order. Is it ok to call?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    I haven’t had any problems with American Home Shield. I will recommend American Home Shield based on my experiences with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    Woke up this morning and found that my AC unit was not cooling. The inside unit was running but not the outside fan. Called AHS to put in a Service Request. After answering all of the automated system questions it told me the name of the service contractor. My problem: This particular contractor two months ago attempted to service my heating system. After two attempts and submitting a false report to AHS, a different contractor was sent for a second opinion. The second opinion contractor found the problem and has repaired the heating system. After finding out the contractor AHS was sending out to service my AC unit, I called by and went thru the automated system until I was able to SPEAK TO A LIVE PERSON. But this is where my problem started. The woman that I spoke to told me that "I HAD NO CHOICE BUT TO HAVE THIS VENDOR SERVICE MY SYSTEM".

    I explained to the woman the issues I had with this contractor and that I did not want them in my house ever again. She then told me again that "I HAD NOT CHOICE". No matter what I said to her about this contractor and the problems I had, she still told me "I HAD NO CHOICE". She could not change the service contractor because that is whom the SYSTEM SELECTED. If this contractor could not service my issue in the allotted time (Today is Friday and they have until Tuesday) then I could CALL BACK and they would select a different contractor. As long as the contractor stated they could service my AC unit by Tuesday of the following week "I HAD NO CHOICE". I don't understand, I am telling her I do not want the contractor the SYSTEM SELECTED in my house but that did not matter.

    The last words she spoke to me were "They worked on your Heating System last time and this is your AC system. Maybe you will have BETTER LUCK WITH THEM THIS TIME". I waited a few hours and called back hoping to get a different person. I did, but was told the same thing: "I HAD NO CHIOCE". This woman went as far as calling the contractor and had us on a 3-way call to make sure they could service my AC unit on Tuesday as stated. The contractor said that they could but would put me on a cancellation waiting list. I have been with AHS since I purchased my house 17 years ago and have NEVER received service like this. Apparently it does not matter what the customer wants, it's who the SYSTEM SELECTS that matters. My rating for customer service, value and coverage is solely based on the way they use to do business before the SYSTEM SELECTION take over. My rating for the service I received today is -3 STARS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    I called AHS re a stoppage (water slow to drain in tub). Plumber would not work on it because there was no "clean out". AHS said the estimated cost to build a "clean out" between $700-900. After that, the plumber would use a snake to unclog the tub. I gasped at the cost and AHS said I could get a free second opinion but if I did that, I would then be obligated to have the work done if that 2nd opinion agreed with the estimate.

    I've been well treated by AHS in the past (I don't call them if I can help it) and they have been prompt, efficient and well-qualified. I guess "p traps", "waste overflow", drum trap, "clean out" are the pipes and fittings located under the tub. I'll have to research those things and find out what I'm paying for.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    I am an AHS customer since January 2015 and so far I have made 2 claims and both of them have been just a miserable experience. The first claim on a refrigerator, took their vendor about 5 visits over 2 months and seems like they have no clue as to what's wrong with it and so they are doing a trial and error process and the vendor also wanted to charge me a second trade fee. AHS send multiple messages to the vendor to send in a senior technician but it is always the same technician who comes in! The last visit by the vendor was yesterday and hopefully this visit has fixed the issue-will wait and see!

    My second issue was with a duct out of my bathroom exhaust being broken-a bird got into the attic and broke this and when I called AHS, I told this to the representative and he filed the claim and assigned the work to an electrical vendor. When that vendor called me to schedule an appointment, I explained the issue to him and then they said this is a duct work issue and then AHS scheduled a different vendor who came in and saw the broken duct and said this is a plumbing issue! But I had to pay half of the trade fee since he was there! but he said when the plumber comes in I will not have to pay again.

    I called AHS while the vendor was still there and they confirmed it. Next day morning I got a call from the vendor and AHS saying that my claim is denied since it was caused by a bird and that is not covered under the policy! I called back and explained that I had mentioned that it was caused by a bird when I made the claim in the first place and so they put my claim in for a dispute and said a supervisor will look into the claim and call me back in 2 days.

    They did not and I called AHS, they said they are working on it and I'll call back within 24 hours. Today (4/17), it is 8 days since I made the payment and 7 days since I disputed the claim and nobody from AHS called me back even once. So I called them again today morning (my 3rd call this week for this issue) and they want me to wait again for 24 hours and would not let me talk to a supervisor and after a 20 minute call send me to a voicemail and I had to leave a message. I worked all my career in customer service and I just can't believe that this is happening but as of now I am still waiting for that call!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Pradeep, I would like to have a case manager contact you in regards to this matter if that is okay?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    It's easy to submit a claim with AHS and they respond promptly. I've also had no problems with their contractors - they do their job very well.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePrice

    Reviewed April 17, 2015

    Called in February to fix - was not and still broken and now they don't have any workers to fix it so want to give me $200 for a new washer that cost $1200.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Mahdee, Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We apologize for your recent experience with your washer repair. I will have someone from our resolution department follow up with.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    norma increased rating by 2 stars.
    Customer ServiceTech
    After a positive interaction with American Home Shield, norma increased their star rating on April 23, 2015.

    Updated review: April 23, 2015

    AHS contacted me and after reviewing my story and my invoice, have agreed to pay the full cost for the external vendor. The representative I worked with was great...I am thrilled to have this resolution. Still a little sore I had to go through this all to get a toilet fixed but happy they stepped up in the end.

    Original Review: April 17, 2015

    Oh AHS, you let me down. I own a 1 bathroom condo unit with an older model toilet. This toilet started leaking. I called AHS and they assigned Vendor 1. Made arrangements for him to come out the next day. Took the day off of work and waited. He showed up only to tell me he couldn't fix my model toilet. AHS assigns Vendor 2. Vendor 2 gives me an 11-2 window for the next day. Take off work again. Vendor 2 never shows. Remember, ONE toilet in my unit. I call AHS. Because Vendor 2 promises to come out the next morning, there is nothing they can do. Take off work day 3 for Vendor 2's 10-12 window. He shows at 2:30, starts work, and randomly leaves without saying anything to me and doesn't return.

    After an hour, I call Vendor 2's boss who tells me the plumber injured himself and won't be completing the job. They had notified AHS an hour ago and no one called me. The kicker? Vendor 2 had disconnected my toilet so now instead of a leaking toilet, I had nothing. AHS tells me they are attempting to find some else to come out. If they can find anyone in 2.5 hours, I am authorized to get an outside vendor and be reimbursed. I hear nothing and call an emergency plumber who informs me Vendor 2 royally screwed things up and now my job is going to be twice as expensive. During this repair, AHS sends me notice they found a vendor... which turns out to be Vendor 1, the guy that couldn't fix it three days ago. Now, I’m told I can submit for reimbursement and see what they grant me. They damage my toilet, waste 3 work days, and cause countless headaches. I will be cancelling my warranty.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Norma- Thank you for making us aware of your recent issue with your plumbing. I apologize for the delay and the inconvenience, someone from our resolution team will contact you for assistance.

    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    I needed a new fridge for my home and AHS helped me save money by finding the fridge we wanted at a discounted price.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    AHS uses Sears to fix dishwashers in my area. Sears has now visited 6 times and made me wait a total of 24 hours. Today Sears showed up and suddenly (after 5 other visits) asked me to sign a release indemnifying them for any damage they may cause while repairing the dishwasher. AHS claims no responsibility for anything to do with the repair after they contact Sears. In fact they refuse to follow up with Sears for any reason and claim that if Sears is late or a no show or repeatedly fails to fix the problem that they (AHS) has nothing to do with it. In fact when I called AHS and asked to speak to a supervisor they refused to allow me to speak with a supervisor. My call last week to AHS went unreturned as well.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Brian, a case manager is available to assist you with this matter. Do you mind if we contact you?

    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    Submitting the claim was pretty convenient and they responded right away. It was a good thing that AHS gave me the number of the repair company. I talked to them and they made sure they came as soon as possible. That was very nice.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    They came and replaced the gasket in the bathroom upstairs. The process of submitting the claim was very easy. We've used American Home Shield a few times before and each time it's relatively simple and painless.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    Submitting claims with American Home Shield has been really easy. My most recent ones were for the garage door opener. They've been very responsive and have gotten somebody out pretty quickly. The person assigned to it called us pretty quickly so we've been really happy with it.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 16, 2015

    Your "LACK" of customer service is unmatched in the world of customer service. I can not begin to tell you how bad your "LACK" OF Customer service is. You must have the laziest group of supervisors in the world. They will not get on the phone, or return a phone call. I have only been a member for 22+ years. Your service SUCKS MORE EACH YEAR. I spent over one hour on hold today waiting on someone to pick up the damn phone. I would like a phone call from a CEO or vp of your company. If I could rate your service with a negative number I would.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 15, 2015

    When I submitted a claim, everything went fine and the claims process was good. The contractors sent by American Home Shield were wonderful with repairs. I would recommend AHS!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 15, 2015

    The AHS Representatives are very efficient and knowledgeable, and provide quick response time to wonderful contractors.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    CoverageRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 15, 2015

    I'm a little disappointed with American Home Shield that pre-existing conditions that are not correct are not covered because I bought a house and there was a lot of things that I found out were not done properly and I've had to pay out of my own pocket to get them fixed instead of having help from them, which was why I bought the plans if there was anything like that. That's been a drag. That's not necessarily really fair.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Annemarie, we're sorry to hear that you're having problems with your home that is uncovered. If you're in need of assistance or would like a case manager to contact you, please let us know. Thank you

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Bonnie increased rating by 2 stars.
    After a positive interaction with American Home Shield, Bonnie increased their star rating on April 17, 2015.

    Updated review: April 17, 2015

    AHS finally ordered us a new washer. I just wish it hadn't taken 5 weeks to resolve this. Laundromats are not cheap when you have a large family. We had problems with them about our dishwasher but I think that was more the repair people than AHS other than that they have done just fine.

    Original Review: April 15, 2015

    Our washer broke & was reported on March 12. It is now April 14 & still no washer. LG no longer makes the part needed. Today they AHS said they found the part but it is the same part # that has already been shipped to us twice & it does not fit our washer.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 15, 2015

    My experience with American Home Shield has been good so far. Overall, AHS has been efficient and prompt.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverage

    Reviewed April 14, 2015

    Our pool motor needed replaced and were told by two pool repair persons that "this need replaced." Called AHS and they sent one of their trolls who stated AHS pays them to write it up where it would not be covered. This same troll sent an invoice wanting $2940 to replace the same pool pump he stated was fine. AHS is nothing but a rip-off and like a typical insurance company wants to take your money but will find any excuse not to cover anything.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Factual basis uncertain
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 14, 2015

    The folks at American Home Shield are extremely courteous and responsive to arrange the needed repair/maintenance.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Ray, We’re delighted to read your feedback about American Home Shield! Thank you for taking time to share your positive experience. We aim to provide the best service for each customer.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTechPunctuality & SpeedRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 14, 2015

    It was a painful process when I submitted a claim with AHS. What they do is even though you make the payment of the co-pay, their system will continue to bill you even though it is taken care of. The bookkeeping is sloppy between the contractor and Home Shield so I'm not impressed with that. They kept hunting me for almost a year and a half of a co-pay that I had already paid. When once the thing gets hung up in the system, even if you have a new repair issue, they won't even allow you to make a reservation to have the contractor come until you pay that, which was very, very sad for me and I had to literally go through them saying "I have paid. I have paid."

    I even gave them the proof of payment with my VISA card. It just took forever, and meanwhile, the repair that's supposed to have taken place to fix the toilet clogging they never showed up until it was cleared and it was all due to the fault of the contractor and American Home Shield not getting things properly entered into their system, and that caused me a lot of problems. Furthermore, there was also an unpleasant instance that I had with one contractor that despite my repeated request to call me back with when he can go and fix it, he never returned my phone calls and I had to call American Home Shield which is even tougher to get hold of with too many voicemail prompts and voicemail messages. It's very difficult to deal with these people but once they do it, they do it okay but I'm not very happy with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi A.V., Thank you for bringing this to our attention. We sincerely apologize for any inconvenience you had with your warranty service. If you have an open service work order that needs attention, we would like to help.

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 14, 2015

    My experience with American Home Shield has been okay. When submitting claims, they were good, efficient and responded to me quickly. The representative they sent to do our ottoman repair was accurate and did a great job in a minimum amount of time. We were pleased with him. He was prompt and on time and his appearance was wonderful.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 13, 2015

    Very good experience. The company is great and worked with me to get the right appointment date and time. The HVAC technician was very knowledgeable and did a great job, I've had no problems since.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Gregory, We're happy to hear that the HVAC technician did a great repair. Thank you for providing your feedback!

    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 13, 2015

    I have had no problems with AHS since I subscribed in 2010. Each time that I needed service, a professional in his/her field was expeditiously dispatched and fixed my problem in a timely manner. I never needed to make a follow-up request since the problems were fixed right, the first time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Great feedback, George! Thank you, we genuinely appreciate it and we’re happy to hear you’re happy with your home warranty!

    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 13, 2015

    American Home Shield was excellent. The first people chosen to do the service had to come a long distance to get out there but the guy was very professional and he had to go back to actually do another trip in the town to find the proper water heater for us. Everything is working great and it was such a good experience I've been telling my neighbors.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 13, 2015

    I had one claim with American Home Shield and I was treated very well and professionally. I called. I was having problems with my icemaker. It wasn't making ice. Within 10 or 15 minutes of being on the phone, I had an appointment for a service which thrilled me beyond words and this service appointment was for the next day, which was great. I live in a rural area of Pahrump, Nevada. It's 50 miles west of Las Vegas and the service person came from Las Vegas which surprised me because I had assumed that perhaps the service company would be a local company and there is a local company here that I have dealt with in the past and they've been very good. But the service gentleman that I had from Las Vegas was very professional and gave me some clues on how to not spend an extra amount of money per year on a filter on my refrigerator because it really didn't need it. I was very pleased.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 12, 2015

    There was no water pressure in certain sinks in the house, so I submitted a claim with AHS, and I had no problems. The contractors they sent were really good. I was pleased with the professionalism and how quickly they were able to resolve the issue.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingCoverage

    Reviewed April 12, 2015

    I'm very happy I got coverage from American Home Shield because I used it and saved money. I filed a couple of claims. I had a dishwasher that was leaking and the guy came to put in something on it - they have every picture of the problem, and it was fixed. Then I had a plumbing problem and that was fixed. The only thing I have a problem with was my first claim with my refrigerator which took a week to get somebody here. I thought that was much too long. However, the other claims were responded to in a day.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 12, 2015

    I'm completely satisfied with the service that I have received from American Home Shield. Very professional!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Curtis, Thank you for taking the time to share your experience with others. We’re happy that you've had a great experience with us and look forward to assisting you with any future home warranty needs.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 11, 2015

    My experience with AHS has been really good or really bad. We've had two really good experiences after the first really horrible experience. So it's a little bit of mix. First claim, AHS sent a plumber from Plumb Genius who was just horrible. It was the first after we moved in the house. We had three faucets that were leaking. They came in and didn't even look at the faucets. They didn't touch the faucets. They went back out to their truck and sat in their truck for almost an hour.

    They came back in because I had another guy here installing a hot water heater at same time and they said "We've talked to American Home Shield and your request isn't covered because you turned it in too soon. If you had waited a few weeks..." Our policy was in effect. There's no question about that. They would have covered it but they're not really good on plumbing.

    At that point, I was ready to cancel because we had paid about $100 for a couple of months of coverage only to be told that you can't turn something in as soon as your coverage is in effect, because I had turned in the hot water heater as we were moving into this house and it was leaking into the floor and gas was leaking from it. There was no problem with replacing it for $1,100 but I've still got two faucets leaking from that first experience. I don't know whether, since it was turned down originally, that it would be covered if I turned them in again. I don't know what to do about that but until now I’m still blaming the plumbing company, not AHS.

    Second claim was when we needed an electrician. He was wonderful. There was a mistake made with him regarding the bill. We need to pay the $75 for him because he fixed everything. He had an email on his phone that said he wasn't supposed to collect from me. I had a check ready to hand to him but he said no. That's been a while ago and we never got a bill or anything until yesterday and I'm going to pay that. The third claim was a heating problem. Our heater wouldn't stay on. The pilot ignition was bad but the guy who came was wonderful.

    Calling for claims means you have to be on hold for a while but the only problem we ever had with that was the electrician. That was another part of the confusion because I called in and told the person that the hood over the range, the light, and the fan weren't working. The cust service rep and I both couldn't decide whether it was an appliance call or an electric call. First we talked about an appliance and then I said "No. I think it's probably the electricity. There's probably some problem with that." So they sent out the electrician and he fixed it.

    Then I got a call from some appliance people and they were kind of upset because they thought they were supposed to come out and I said "No. That was supposed to be canceled." The rep said she would just cancel that. So then we got a call later saying we owed $75 and I thought it was for the appliance people that never came out. So I disputed that. I just called the electrician and talked to him and he went through his records. We got that straightened out.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 11, 2015

    My Home warranty provides great peace-of-mind, knowing that an appliance breakdown isn't going to break my budget. Our dishwasher recently "bit the dust" and American Home Shield replaced the unit. All we paid was the nominal deductible. We were without a dishwasher for about two weeks, but overall, very happy with service provided.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Mark, We apologize for the delay in getting your dishwasher replaced. We're happy to know that you're satisfied with your home warranty with us!

    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 11, 2015

    I've had American Home Shield for years. I call them when I have a claim and they will go ahead and set it up. I'd pay a charge of $75 now on any call that I would have if they send someone out. When I started, it was $50 originally. Now it's gone up to $75, which I wasn't too happy about, but then that's the sign of the times. But they really have handled everything real well through the years. With my recent claim however, I had a refrigerator problem and they haven't been out to fix it. They did call a company here in town and they also gave me his phone number in case he didn't call me. I did call in this morning and talked to him, and he's supposed to be out tomorrow or the next day. Everything sounds fine so far.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 11, 2015

    I have been, what I thought was reliable customer for over 10 years, filing very few maybe not even 6 claims with AHS, & just days ago when I needed them when my a/c went out, the authorizations dept. denied out claim due to me having pine straw on my outside unit. It sounds to me like they are just trying to deny the claim instead of fixing the problem, like their policy states. The worse part is less than a year ago an awesome company came out to add freon & they stated all was well, so this time around we requested the same familiar company & service and were told that we couldn't use them.

    Now the new company which barely speaks 10 words to me, tells AHS, they think it is on us, due to lack of removing pine straw from around the unit. Now I'm not asking for a new unit, but I just want mine to work. Why can't AHS, just comply with their policies. So folks who are complaining of an appliance like a dryer, remove your lint trap, because if lent is found they would fix or replace due to debris. But maybe if I added up the hundreds we've paid every year since 2000, AHS, would realize they already got paid to buy us a new unit.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Cicily, I would like to have a case manager review your service work order for your a/c system and contact you. Is that okay?

    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 11, 2015

    Our pool motor went out. It was less than a year old and we turned in to AHS because it is a covered part. The contractor they sent fixed it leading us to believe we would be out about $300 but then billed us for over a thousand dollars. AHS has been terrible to deal with. Every time you call you get a different person and have to start all over again. Covered part but we are stuck with the bill. You would be better off choosing your own contractor and using the expense of the warranty to pay for repairs. They do not stand by the wording of their own contract!!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Joye, We apologize for any confusion or inconvenience the coverage decision caused with your pool work order. A case manager is available to assist with any open service work order.Thank you for sharing your experience as we will use it to better our services.

    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    Our clothes dryer has been non-functional for almost a month (3.5 weeks). It is still not working. Placed initial call on March 18. Tech came out within a couple of days, said diagnosis needed parts ordered. Tech was supposed to come back on March 26. Tech never came out (I had taken off work). Tech came out March 27 instead (another day off work). Claimed he fixed the issue, and ran the dryer before he left for a few minutes. I advised the tech that the dryer had a burning smell and he said it was normal.

    Within 30 minutes of the tech leaving, the dryer broke again. I called the company and they sent another tech out on April 8. The new tech stated that the dryer was not properly diagnosed the first time, which caused not only the parts that were replaced to break, but additional parts now had to be replaced. They are now placing an order for the additional parts, which are expected in sometime next week.

    After the parts come in, they will call to schedule an appointment. By then it will be a month without a clothes dryer. Not only are we paying the monthly premium, but we also paid the $100 deductible for this call, and have spent close to $100 at a laundromat over the past month. Each time I have called the reps over this issue, they sound uncaring, rude, and start reading me my contract, stating that there is nothing more they can do for me. I asked to have a different company come fix the dryer and they refused. I asked how long they would let this go on and they said indefinitely.

    AHS, you have lost this customer of 12 years. And I will share my experience with any homeowner I know. Mind you, this is not the first bad experience I have had with you, or I would not be writing this review. You have disappointed us over the past couple of years. We will take our business elsewhere. You are not the only one providing this type of service, although your reps seem to think so, and their behaviour would lead anyone to believe you are doing your work for free. We are paying for this service! As previously stated, we will gladly take our business elsewhere.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Deborah, Thank you for making us aware of the delay in service in getting your dryer repaired. We understand this can be frustrating and would like an opportunity to assist you if you'd like?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    Our water heater ruptured. We called early in the morning but did not see someone to evaluate it until about 9 PM, even though we were told this is a priority issue. The service tech did not exactly push to get the new unit ordered, and in fact, deleted a message telling him to move the project along. In trying to contact Union Plumbing in Las Vegas, their phones are busy, it is not an easy task. The original replacement project was not truly acceptable in that the recirculating pump was put in at an angle, not a professional job. The circulation pump then froze up, another service call. That tech told us he would submit the claim and get back go us. That has been at least 1 week with no reply.

    I then called the AHS office and was told that I would contacted the next day. That was about 3-4 days ago, no reply from that person, **, and as I have spent an entire day trying to talk to someone, nobody other than the automatic recordings answer. It sounds like there is either nobody working, they can see my phone number and will not reply, or they are out of business. This is service that is about as poor as it can get. AHS does not live up to its implied contract of service. I'm going to take matters into my own hands, perhaps that will move someone of their backside.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Jack, Thank you for making us aware of the delay you're receiving in getting your water heater serviced. Do you mind if we contact you in regards to this matter?

    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    A problem-free encounter. The contractor arrived on time and performed well. He fixed the problem the first time.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims Handling

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    The most recent claim I had with AHS was the water heater. It was original and always kept in the garage. The service date they said was much longer than what they expected it to last. It doesn't really take much maintenance. It's just when they burst, they burst and that was it. It was a smooth transaction the whole way through. I really enjoyed having somebody who was knowledgeable with what they're doing that actually came to the house. As far as ease, it is extremely user-friendly. The only thing that I could recommend is that once it is submitted, they call a little quicker. I think most of the service requests that I have made, it’s been at least 24 hours before somebody had contacted us, whether the claim was made in the evening or in the morning. And that typically, for me I would like it to be a little shorter. But I understand that that could be a little out of the ordinary as well.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    I have had to have two repairs in a year. Both times the repair was done no questions asked and within 24 hours. They made it so easy - I filled repair request online, someone contacted me and repair was done. Yes I paid $75.00 copay but that is less than a service call. Thank you AHS 5 stars!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Joe, Great feedback! Thank you, we genuinely appreciate it and we’re happy to hear you’re happy with your home warranty!

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPrice

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    I have used AHS for many years and never had a problem. I recently called because my AC compressor broke. The contractor that they sent out tried to tell me that I had an electrical problem that needed to be addressed first. I called Center Point Energy who came out immediately, determined that there was nothing wrong with my electrical box and that the AC compressor was tripping the breaker.

    The contractor then came back out, admitted that I do NOT have an electrical problem, and attempted to address the problem. They tried to hard sell me on an entire new system for $13,000! Then they tried to tell me that I had a leak and all of my Freon had leaked into the ground and it would cost a minimum of $780 to repair the compressor and charge the unit.

    Without moving one blade of grass? When I tried to report this to the authorization rep, **, he got belligerent and argued with me that the first contractor was correct. I 'm deeply disappointed that the company rep refused to allow me to speak to his supervisor and laughed that he would never tell me how to identify him when I complained about his unprofessional behavior!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    I called American Home Shield this morning around 6:30. They did send the call to the vendor until 8:50. I then talk to the vendor, they tell me it will be Monday before they can get here. The same thing happen in July during the heat of the summer. My 94 years mother had to sit in a house with heat rising above 99. I had to spent money on a window unit so she would be safe. I call back this morning and finally got to talk to someone after waiting on the phone for over 10 minutes. She was very unconcern and just kept quoting the rule book - no help at all. I just wanted some help in getting another company who could come today. They have no problem getting their money but when come to customer, no help at all. I know no one looks at these but just wouldn't to let you guys know. A very disappointed customers.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Katie, If you're still in need of assistance, I would like to have a case manager contact you about your a/c work order. Per our contract guidelines for a normal work order the vendor must schedule you within 24 business hours and service you within 48 business hours. Our expedited guidelines are different. Please let us know if you need help with this service request.

    Customer ServiceTechPriceRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    We had an AHS contractor come to our home to look at our central air and heat. To summarize, he recommended that the interior unit be replaced, then did the installation incorrectly. He flood the evaporator, which ruined our exterior unit on our home. Of course, we didn't realize this and called him back due to the unit malfunctioning. He then recommended that the exterior unit be replaced, which cost us over $500. But the new exterior unit was ruined for the same reason as the first. After getting nowhere with AHS customer service, I posted a negative review. At that point, I was contacted by a case manager who finally began to help us resolve out issues. We requested that another AHS contractor take a look at the work that the first had done. At that point, he explained that the initial installation was botched and caused all of the damage and cost thereafter.

    AHS did pay 100% for all further repairs, and agreed to refund the service fees ($75 x 2) we had paid the first contractor to come back and attempt to repair his botched installation. However, I've only ever received a refund for one of the service fees, and AHS refused to refund the cost of having to replace the exterior unit ruined by their contractor in the first place. The case manager actually recommended that I try to have the contractor who ruined the unit reimburse me! The case manager that had been so helpful has since stopped returning phone calls, and the customer service department, who stated that they would have to get with the case manager and get back with me within 24 hours, has failed to follow through as well. Overall, I would say that customer service is beyond poor.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Abby, Thank you for sharing your feedback about your experience with your a/c repairs. We appreciate the opportunity to better our services. This will be forwarded to your service resolution specialist to check for any additional reimbursements.

    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    Recently, we have replaced the ceiling fan. I didn't know AHS was going to replace it. For the garage door, I got an inspection and the guy said that they have a thing when they try to reverse and they tear them up more so than anything else. So we have to blame the inspector for that. But those are not existing problems and just came up. I know the garage door guy and he was nice and did his best, as well as the electrician. They were excellent. AHS did real well. In fact, I'm seeking another house and when I do I'll put in that I need them as far as to cover for the first year.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceCoverageTechPrice

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    I had paid extra in addition to my contract to get my refrigerator covered when I started my contract. Well I called because my refrigerator stopped working the representative told me it is not covered and there was nothing they could do. So I dug out my contract and called back and talked to someone else who told me "yes it was covered." So they sent someone out to look at it. The contractor said they needed to order some parts.

    To make a long story short I have wasted hours on the phone and got no good answers and have been with out a refrigerator for 10 days now and have no idea when it will get fixed. As soon as it does I am canceling my contract with AHS. I have found that their competitors are much cheaper both annually and on service calls and have better reviews. If you are considering AHS go another direction you will be glad you did.

    Updated on April 14, 2015: I have already written a review so this is a follow up. After the contractor sent the part for refrigerator that needed to be ordered to American Home Shield, American Home Shield did not order it for what ever reason and conveniently have no record of the request for the part, (although I have confirmed with the contractor that American Home Shield had been informed days ago).

    I have contacted American Home Shield almost daily who keeps pointing the finger at the contractor but never followed up with them even though the work order is over 2 weeks old and no progress has been made. Not to mention the part costs $9.95 and I can get it 1 day shipping from Amazon. But on principal I pay American Home Shield over $700 dollars per year for over 7 years now I will not stop until they do their job. One more thing I would like to mention is after my first post on consumer affairs American Hone Shield replied and said a customer service manager would be calling me right away to straighten out the problem. I provided my number but no one ever called "can't say that I'm surprised."

    Thanks for your vote!
    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServicePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 10, 2015

    American Home Shield was fantastic. I appreciate their fast help. They called me right back and set up the appointment. The man who came out was so knowledgeable and helped me on a few things that he saw could be potential dangers and then he didn't say "Oh, well, we're going to fix this." He said, "What you can do is have your friend do this." And he said, "Make sure you keep the doors of your filters closed. It could cause a potential fire..." He checked everything. I highly recommend them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    Our Air Conditioner wasn't cooling, so we called for service on Thursday. They only work with 1 vendor (in a large city), and the service man was not available until Monday. We are told that this is within 48 hours since the weekend doesn't count. Since we were going on vacation on Saturday, we called and asked if there was someone else we could use. The answer was no, and we were told to take it or leave it. During the hour we were on hold, we googled the vendor and found that he had lost his BBB accreditation due to complaints. We asked to speak to a supervisor and got hung up on. Called back and again asked for a supervisor to discuss refunding our entire account and were told that we would be contacted within 72 hours. HORRIBLE company!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    HI Mary, We regret to hear that you're wanting to cancel your home warranty with us. We will have a representative reach out to you to assist in this matter. Thank you for sharing your feedback as we will use it to better our services.

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Customer Service

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    I have a warranty from American Home Shield that guarantees 24/7 service. At 3 am this morning, I woke up in my home, freezing. The temp in my home was 48 degrees F. I called American Shield and spoke with a gentleman, who gave me the phone number of the company that would come to my home. (OAS). When I called this number, I got a voicemail that said to leave a message. I finally got a call from OAS at 7 am and the contractor arrived at 10am. THIS IS NOT WHAT I CALL 24/7 SERVICE! Had it been the dead of winter, my pipes would have frozen and broken long before OAS arrived. I do not blame OAS. I blame American Home Shield for guaranteeing 24/7 service and contracting with a company that does not have 24/7 service. I am very dissatisfied with the response to my emergency!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Claudia, Thank you for sharing your experience with us. However, per your contract section C-1 and C-2a, AHS will accept service accept service requests 24 hours a day and 7 days a week. For expedited service request, AHS is to locate a vendor that can service you within 24 hours. The company dispatched was well within the guidelines of servicing your furnace service work order. We apologize for any inconvenience or confusion this may have caused as we value you as a customer. Your feedback is appreciated and will be used to improve our services.

    Factual basis uncertain
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    4/9/15 12:51 - I am going to do a real time experience with AHS; might be good or it might be bad. Today is 4/9/15 at 12:30 PM. I just called AHS to request service on two units that were repaired last summer. I requested a specific repair technician that I have had good results with in the past. Was informed that someone else had to make the repairs but I told them that I only wanted Climate Makers (JT Business group). The operator quickly arranged it. Climate Makers is on their approved list of contractors.

    I am writing this real time report because of the terrible experience last summer having two HVAC units repaired. It took about 4 months in the heat of the summer to finally repair the units. The first contractor never finished the job. The second put in the wrong size air handler, a 3 ton instead of a 5. The third contractor, Climate Makers, finally installed the system correctly. I must have made 50 or more calls to AHS over this issue before it was resolved. Also, don't hesitate to ask for AHS customer affairs for help (if you are having trouble), because the operators will just keep saying "I am sorry you are having trouble". Even after my horrible experience last year, I still recommend AHS to my customers because I think they are the best of the group of home warranty providers; they just need to work on follow up and customer satisfaction.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    My home is new and I had to get an inspection. I didn't pass it. I had a problem regarding plumbing for propane so I filed a claim with American Home Shield. I was told that there were to issues and that I'd be charged $75 per issue to fix. I thought this was ridiculous since it would take just a few minutes for the contractor to fix both. But my claims have been paid and I haven't been bothered. After this incident though, I had to file another claim and it went fine.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    I called AHS to schedule a service call for my dishwasher. The day of my appointment, AHS called and said service guy called out sick and they had no one else to send. So I scheduled for the following week. The service guy came out and saw what needed to be done to fix dishwasher. He ordered the parts and had them sent to my house. We scheduled an appointment for him to come back to install the new parts a week later. The day of the appointment came and went, he never showed up. I called AHS to find out what the problem was, they said "oh that appointment was cancelled." I said "the appointment cancelled but no one ever called me to let me know?" This is RIDICULOUS!! How can they stay in business with this lack of consideration to the customer? I have already called my realtor and told her to never to refer anyone to AHS again.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Kathy, I apologize for the delay in getting your dishwasher repaired. I would like to get a case manager involved if that's ok?

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 9, 2015

    We've been fine with American Home Shield. There were no problems in submitting a claim and the process is pretty easy. The plumber that came for a house call was really, really nice and really good - very informative, kind, courteous and prompt. No complaints.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Many thanks for the feedback, Kristie! We’re pleased to hear you’re satisfied with our services and your experience with our technician.

    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 8, 2015

    My water heater stopped heating and began to leak, so I called American Home Shield. Someone then came out to look at it, diagnosed the problem, and replaced what needed to be replaced. Fast, positive experience!

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Alan, Thank you for the great feedback for your water heater service work order!

    Verified purchase
    Punctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 8, 2015

    American Home Shield is a great company oriented at addressing their customer needs/issues timely. With the recent problem I had, they worked quickly to resolve the issue and explained the options and gave me an opportunity to make the choice that is right for me and they supported me along the process. Glad that I have the warranty with AHS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Claims Handling

    Reviewed April 8, 2015

    I use American Home Shield because submitting a claim to them is always fantastic. They have made an appointment for my latest claim but haven't come in yet. But for previous claims, they've been great.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Arthur, Thank you for sharing your experience about your service with us!

    Verified purchase
    Claims HandlingTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 8, 2015

    Last night we noticed that the air conditioning system was getting warmer in the house and it never got any cooler and so this morning, we knew there was a problem. We turned the system off. We had this problem before and it was a freon problem, so we're thinking it might be another leak. We submitted a claim to AHS and it was very easy - no problems at all. Everybody has been very helpful. The technicians are always very prompt and schedule us as soon as possible. They seem to be knowledgeable and professional.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    Placed request on a Sunday due to a toilet leak. AHS representative was rude and wrote the problem as water closet instead of toilet leak. Received called from contractor and they said they could not come out that day and it would be 3-5pm the next day. They did not show and I called the contractor and said order was cancelled by me. I told them I NEVER cancelled the service but they would not listen and refuse to explain why my service was cancelled. Had to make numerous complaints to AHS supervisors as the representatives are not trained properly.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoveragePrice

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    We've had AHS for a year this month. We've had a couple of little things we called them for and they have been okay experiences. I have no problems with them but it was just too expensive. This is the reason why we're cancelling our coverage with them.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Barbara, We regret to hear that you're cancelling your home warranty with us due to costs. Please contact our Consumer Sales Dept, to see if they have a contract that better suits your needs. We appreciate the opportunity to better our products and services.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPricePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    Great customer service. Contractor timely responded to initial contact and made the necessary repairs promptly and efficiently. Would recommend American Home Shield for your whole house warranty. Excellent product at affordable prices.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceClaims HandlingTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    I filed a claim for a plumbing issue, American Home Shield sent out some guys who took care of it. There was no problem at all. It was convenient. We do it online, we request a visit. AHS then calls us back, provides us with a contractor and their number. The contractor then calls us to set up an appointment. They show up, do their job, and it's done. Since the repair, I have had no problems whatsoever with my plumbing, no need to call back. I would recommend AHS.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Alex, We're delighted to hear that your plumbing repair went well. Thank you for your positive review!

    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    AHS comes to AC rescue! The service request was handled quickly and the contractor was timely and professional.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceCoverageTech

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    I've been a customer for two years and have had a passable experience in my few other minor service requests up until the last three weeks when my refrigerator broke. Since then it has been a complete run around. Despite knowing the type of refrigerator they sent an unqualified technician out the first time. He said he needed to order parts, but then 3 or 4 days later called to say he wasn't licensed to fix it.

    On to technician number 2. He came out, thought it was likely one problem then finally determined on the third visit that the problem wasn't fixable as it was a leak in the refrigerator wall. Then it turned into a three ring circus of no accountability and miscommunication. They created hoop after hoop that had to be jumped through with reports, requiring the tech to come out for photos and some other seemingly useless confirmation that is was still broken. They've claimed not to get the technicians reports and then claimed the 2nd technician wasn't qualified to do the work and that the service company recommended someone else come out to take a look.

    I immediately followed up with the service company and was told this was not true. After several contentious blood boiling calls they finally relented on sending out another service company, but of course had to send the case back to another department for review. The customer service people you can get on the phone are not empowered to actually solve a problem and the issue at hand is consistently in someone else's court. Countless phone calls, crazy amounts of hold time, no results and worst of all no refrigerator. Easily the worst customer service I've experienced.

    After three weeks it was suggested to me to contact the manufacturer because they might take care of the problem. Really, then what did I pay you for? The refrigerator is out of warranty from the manufacturer and AHS is seemingly attempting to skirt their contractual obligation to replace my appliance. I'm probably having one of those nightmare scenarios, but these situations are what you're trying to cover yourself against and it hasn't been worth the headache.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Jason, we apologize for the ongoing issues you're having with your refrigerator and would like to get a case manager involved. Do you mind if we contact you?

    No response received
    Verified purchase
    CoveragePunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    Read the fine prints please! There are lots of things they don't cover. You have to read their contract carefully to find out all the situations they don't cover. However, you don't see this contract when you sign up. As a matter of fact, I have never received any contract. In my case, I had a stoppage problem. I had to leave work early for the service, but the service guy was two hours late. And after 5 minutes, he told me that this is not going to be covered because he cannot find a cleanout for him to work with, according to a contract that I have never seen.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Zhou, Per the contract verbiage for plumbing stoppages a ground level accessible clean out must be installed for service. We apologize for any confusion this has caused. A case manager can contact you to discuss this matter.

    Verified purchase
    Coverage

    Reviewed April 7, 2015

    Ice maker not covered. It should be.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    I needed to have my clothes washing machine repaired. The first contractor came out and determined that it needed a transmission and clutch and that I would be notified by 10 am the next day. Three days and numerous unanswered calls later I finally found out that AHS was requiring a second opinion and had told the contractor not to contact me again. The second contractor arrived on Saturday am one week after the problem was discovered. He was very professional, had all the necessary parts on his truck and the ability to replace them properly and quickly. The machine works like new.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Tech

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    I had a leak in my kitchen sink and filed a claim with American Home Shield. They found a plumber who called me back and set up an appointment. The contractors were very good and dependable.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hello Alice, Thank your for sharing your feedback about your kitchen sink repair. we're glad to know the vendor was dependable.

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTech

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    I cannot believe the number of favorable reviews for these people. We have a rental unit on Maui, Hawaii. It has been over a month and 1/2 with our air conditioner not working. AHS has yet to provide a solution. The technician from AHS is totally unreliable. This is the third technician in three years. Previous technicians have told us they resigned from AHS because they we unable to work with this AHS. The AHS service is horrible, their online service people are rude, unresponsive and are could care less of a customer's needs. We have nowhere to go. We have no place to go, all we get as a run around. Meanwhile we are losing $600.00 per night because our tenants are moving out with no AC.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Gary, I would like to have a case manager contact you in regards to the matter with your ongoing a/c service request. Do you mind if a case manager reach out to you?

    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    My call for service on my heating system was answered promptly and efficiently. After customer service asked a few questions about my problem I was given the name and telephone number of the HVAC company who would be repairing my heater and told they would be calling me to set an appointment. Within 10 minutes I was called and told someone would be at my house in 1/2 hour. The technician arrived having stopped to pick up the part he imagined would be needed and within 15 minutes my heater was up and running. Great experience as a consumer. Thank you AHS!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    Customer ServiceTechSales & MarketingRefunds & Payouts

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    On 4/2 at 3:52 (MST) I called AHS to enter a service request for a home in IL. I was given a dispatch number as well as the name of the vendor for my plumbing request. That information was also sent to me via e-mail from AHS. As instructed, I tried to place a call to the vendor but was sent to voice mail where I left a message. Fast forward to 4/6, I am still waiting to hear from the vendor after numerous attempts to call them. No one ever answers the phone (even during supposed business hours) at Triple HHH Plumbing in Litchfield, IL. Customer service at AHS also put in a call at my request. No response. My latest call to AHS ended with a customer service representative telling me that there are no other vendors in my area and that there is nothing they can do. WHAT???

    It is unclear to me. Do I wait forever for a call that will never come from this MIA plumbing company? Why won't AHS contact a local plumber or have me contact a local plumber and reimburse me, under AHS warranty conditions, for their services. Seriously, the call ended with a "so sorry, nothing we can do" resolution. What do I do now? I am clearly out for my yearly warranty fee and the "commitment for service within 48 hrs." is not only a "not happening" but a smokescreen for a company that does not fulfill the service language in its contract. I honestly feel I am being scammed. A shame since this was my first contact with the company for a service request. By the way.... After waiting in excess of 10 minutes each call attempt to speak to a AHS representative, it took only one ring for an AHS agent to answer to sell a new policy when I tried that number out of curiosity.

    Thanks for your vote!
    American Home Shield
    Response from American Home Shield

    Hi Kathleen, Our apologies for the delay in service. I would like to have a case manager contact you in regards to this service work order if you don't mind?

    Resolved outside ConsumerAffairs
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    AHS tried to fix the front loader washer. The washer could not be repaired. AHS replaced it for a new one. THANKS AHS!

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase
    TechPunctuality & Speed

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    I received prompt, friendly service both from the American Home Shield representative, as well as the service provider.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    I have been a customer for over 10-years. Can only recommend AHS and will continue my contract with a firm I can trust.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Verified purchase

    Reviewed April 6, 2015

    The seasonal check up service for HVAC System was great, helped a lot a people out. You need to put back into effect, this was a great asset to the warranty. This a great service and that is a couple a bad marks against you for doing away with that great service.

    Thanks for your vote!
    Loading more reviews...

    American Home Shield Company Information

    Social media:
    Company Name:
    American Home Shield
    Company Type:
    Public
    Ticker Symbol:
    FTDR
    Year Founded:
    1971
    Address:
    150 Peabody Place
    City:
    Memphis
    State/Province:
    TN
    Postal Code:
    38103
    Country:
    United States
    Website:
    www.ahs.com

    Media

    VIDEOS & IMAGES