Allstate Homeowners Insurance

Compare Homeowners Insurance Companies

Research top Homeowners Insurance Companies recommendations on ConsumerAffairs

Compare Companies

Consumer Complaints and Reviews

on
Satisfaction Rating

After suffering a robbery of our home, Allstate all but slapped us in the face and basically we felt completely robbed again. 10K of items stolen, including a safe which held a diamond ring with an official appraisal which we had photos of. Not only did Allstate take 3 months to respond to the claim, they came back with a $354.00 check. It was literally surreal. They claimed we needed to list all our items with them or they are not covered. Also if someone is living there for 5 years with proof, but is not on the actual deed, then nothing they owned is covered at all!!! It was the most horrific experience to be violated and then to get completely violated again by the people you pay to protect you. The worst company ever, total scam. This whole ordeal has left me sick to my stomach.

on
Satisfaction Rating

RUN!!! I was a 14 yr. policyholder. My Advice --- do not do business with them. Research "which companies have highest re-enrollment rates" --- it's not Allstate. These hands are filthy lining their pockets with your money. Payout is almost impossible. July 13,2016 a faucet busted after I left for work. $280,000 home. By 1:15 pm an inch of water had covered first floor -- ~ 1300 sq ft. Allstate wanted to settle by giving me $15,158 to REPLACE kitchen cabinets, all wood floors, baseboards, paint, necessary electrical and plumbing costs. ARE YOU KIDDING ME???

Vendor Estimates were over $40,000!! They delay, delay, and lowball settlement offers. I could not even start the job as I did not have the $25,000 difference. 3 Months passed. MOLD GREW due to delays. Costs escalated. They want to wait you out. They take NO responsibility. They refused additional living expenses so I could not even obtain equal living quarters during this time. I had to contact the STATE BOARD OF INSURANCE TO REPORT THEM.

They refused to pay fair market value for wood flooring -- they assign the lowest possible value to your home at payout but highest value to set monthly rates they charge. Same problem with electrical. These were not upgrades -- they are replacements. This is November and the nightmare continues... INSANE and unethical. PLEASE REPORT YOUR ISSUES WITH THIS COMPANY TO YOUR STATE BOARD OF INSURANCE.

on
Satisfaction Rating

My rental home was damaged during a storm in November of 2015. I filed a claim with Allstate Insurance Homeowners Policy and was denied. The Insurance adjuster stated in his findings that Allstate does not insure homes with torch-down roofs. I provided proof that when the home was initially insured in 2005. It was stated that the home had a torch-down roof, and the policy was written with that understanding. I then filed a complaints with the Insurance Commission of Oregon, who did nothing to help me with my claim. Beware of Allstate. You're in "Good Hands" if they are taking your money and don't file any claim. What a Rip Off company.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I had renter insurance with Allstate for over 8 years without any claim. In May 2015 my wife and I were moving out our apartment and the neighbor created a hostile atmosphere which forced us to leave some household and personal belonging behind. I made a claim to Allstate of the loss ($2414) which the adjuster claimed was not in the contract... My understanding has been that a renter insurance is supposed to cover all contents for loss when the event occurs. If my situation was not covered as a legitimate claim what was the policy covering??? I would high urge consumers to boycott Allstate when they fail to cover a legitimate loss.

on
Satisfaction Rating

Being a homeowner for over 20 years, downsizing to an apartment has had its adjustments. Since I've never had a Renter's Policy before, I wanted to stick with a highly reputable and well-known company - which is why I chose Allstate. I filed a claim after my neighbor upstairs had a leak that came down through my apartment with nasty brown-colored water that soaked and ruined clothing inside a closet. I sent the adjuster at Allstate pictures and video of the incident. Immediately... and let me repeat this, IMMEDIATELY. The adjuster began running down a list of excuses why they wouldn't pay. He even accused me of trying to scam them. When I called him out on it, his excuse was that they have a high incidence of fraud with renter's policies. I was shocked.

While I understand adjusters have a job to do, not once was I reassured that Allstate was in my corner. Quite the opposite was true... you can tell a very STRONG emphasis is placed on them to get OUT of paying claims, and ZERO emphasis placed on quality customer service. I did not appreciate being called a liar - especially when I gave them all the proof they needed for the claim.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Allstate?

  • 633,951 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

For more information about reviews on ConsumerAffairs.com please visit our FAQ.

on
Satisfaction Rating

Very bad experience. I been their customer since 1996, sadly I had a theft claim last June and it's my first claim ever. I been through a lot with the whole situation and with ALLSTATE that I have to keep repeating myself over and over and asking me again and again for the list of the stolen items which they have it since 06/24/2016 because they want me to get fed-up and give up, and they are not even covering my whole loss, because my insurance policy is only $15000.00 and my loss is over double from that, almost all my jewelry is gone in gold and silver, my black watches bands, $1638.00 cash, gift cards, my home spare keys, some antiques and crystals, couple small brand name bags and wallets, coach key chains, perfumes etc...

The thief has a long history of stealing and drugs, she is in jail, but I don't know where to find my stuff or some of it at least. I been suffering a lot from this situation even with my health with no help at all. And I used to think that AlllState is a good company, and they will be there for us BUT with this experience it came out to be it is a very bad. It seems that I have to get the media attention on the whole situation through Internet, newspaper's or whatever, and hire an attorney to file a lawsuit even if he will take all of the money from this claim. Their renters insurance claims department is horrible, they make me suffer more on the top of what I have from my loss and damage.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I've been with AllState for a long time, and I have never file a claim. Two months ago, I got robbed, after living at the house for 16 years, needless to say I felt scare and violated. They took my two laptops where I had backup of photos and receipts. The agent, Steve **, or I think he's an adjuster, more like a clown have call me a liar for not be able to give him exact receipts from the merchants for the items stolen. Even though I have give him all receipts and paperwork he has asked for. He writes back letters telling me that those receipts are not acceptable. I'm in despair and looking for a lawyer at this point. I know he has a personal vendetta against me, or at least it feels that way.

on
Satisfaction Rating

One of their agents was very rude. About two weeks ago, I requested Allstate to investigate liability of my home damage. One of the agents called me to tell me that they cannot cover the damage because it wasn't under their policy. That's totally fine. All I wanted was to check back in with them and see whether it can be covered or not.

The part that really offended me was that this guy's manner. He treated me as if I was the one who kept asking for money or arguing with him about the policy. He was defensive in the beginning of the call and kept going on with his argument. Then I asked for clarity on some damage coverage statements. He cut my question and repeated the same argument quickly as if I couldn't understand his statements. At that point I already got angry on his tone of the voice and manner. This unpleasantness ruined my morning. I don't know what type of call he made right before mine, but it was really unfair and offensive that I was treated as such since my claim was about investigating the situation with them and understand it not getting money from them.

If they could simply explain how they investigated the case and answer my question in polite way, I would've been ok with this situation. I don't want to worry about talking with rude people in the future, especially when I am worried about the accident happened in my house. I appreciate companies with polite, right mannered agents and apparently Allstate is not one of them.

on
Satisfaction Rating

My home is less than 2 years old and we have owned it for less than a year. An inspection of the home was completed by a home inspector and by Allstate prior to insuring the home in Aug. 2015. A hail storm occurred the first week of July 2016. Allstate did cover all damages related to hail damage EXCEPT the most expensive part, the roof. The adjuster told me and showed pictures of an estimated 50 chipped concrete roof tiles that he claimed not one single chip was due to the hail. I don't know how anyone can make that assumption knowing that the roof was inspected less than a year ago with no damage reported.

Allstate claims that all of the chipped tiles are due to a manufacturer defect. So in their view, they are saying that at least 50 concrete tiles all chipped, on their own, in less than a year with no weather related damage. Other homes on my street with different insurance companies but the same type of roof ARE covering the damages to their roofs. I will not continue to insure my home with Allstate in the future.

on
Satisfaction Rating

We live in rented apartment community in Tampa, FL. We were out on vacation and when we came back our daughter bedroom roof came. Luckily, no one was hurt. When we called our apartment leasing office they told us while we were out there was a tropical storm and that caused the damage and we should file our claim with our Renters Insurance for all the personal property damage. When we filed our claim with Allstate and Castle Key insurance they said everything will be taken care of and we need to submit the picture of the damages. We did all that.

After 3 months they came back stating the claim is denied. When we asked why they said the property manager said on the phone that the damages are not due to rain or wind. When I asked the insurance company whether the property manager gave anything in writing they said no, stating verbal communication is enough to deny the claims. I submitted all the email communication which I received from the same person to insurance stating it's the storm but the insurance company without any written communication or letter from the property manager denied the claim.

on
Satisfaction Rating

We filed a claim for a hail damage back in April 2016. The insurance company issued a check but we had to return it as they had the mortgage company's name wrong. Fast forward to August 23, 2016 and we still haven't received the replacement check. We have called numerous times but we got no response from them, our agent is always "busy" or in a meeting. I am starting to lose hope that we will ever get our money back as we had to pay out of pocket for all the repairs. To everyone thinking of going with Allstate, please reconsider and save yourself all the headache of dealing with this company.

on
Satisfaction Rating

Got a quote online for a renter's policy. Was affordable and a few bucks cheaper than our policy with Geico. We signed up and paid the premium. A few days later, the local agent called and asked for appraisals for the 3 pieces of jewelry we listed in the online application. 2 weeks later we get a bill for $2500. I called to ask what this was since the policy we were quoted was $723 (and we paid it in full). The person insisted I made changes to the limits and this was why the policy went up.

After arguing for over a week, someone called and admitted the policy was being jacked up to cover the jewelry (even though I listed them in the online quote to the penny) and insisted we were called and this was discussed and we agreed to pay this. They actually increased the premium 500% and didn't call - just expected us to pay. Laughingly, I asked her if she was being serious in asking us to pay $3500 per year for a renter's policy. She was dead serious. Asked to cancel it immediately, kept trying to talk me out of it and insisted I needed to send her an email to confirm the cancellation. That's more money than my parents paid for homeowner's insurance. Lol. Avoid.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I am now disabled and unemployed so I was shopping for better homeowners insurance so I went online for quotes for homeowner insurance. Allstate called to give me a quote for homeowner's insurance. The agents name was Diane. I was receiving a lot of calls from different insurance. Some called while I was talking to her and I did not like the way she was trying to get me to decide on the phone. I received a call and placed her on hold. It was Travelers. They had better coverage and better rates that I could afford. I agreed to sign with Travelers instead of Allstate. I switched back to the call with Allstate and she was gone but I received a call from another agent. Told her I had got a call from Diane but I went with another insurance. Diane was talking to my mortgage company unbeknown to me. I signed with Travelers, called my mortgage company three way, got everything set up and started.

Next day I received a call from Diane's manager asking me why I did not choose Allstate. I explained and he ended the called saying that he was sorry about not getting me to sign. I then received a call from my mortgage company and that is when I found out Diane had called them and told them she was going to be my insurance agent. I said "no way." I had already signed with Traveler and spoke to another MORTGAGE REP. WHO CONFIRMED, SO THAT agent who spoke to Allstate called them and they had to resolve that between them.

Now I just received a letter from a CC. A debt collection agency stated I have a past due debt with Allstate for the full amount of a policy I never signed nor agreed to. They kept sending me paperwork to sign and I never did. I repeatedly told them I did not want their homeowner's insurance. That I had insurance with another agency. I feel like I am not in America anymore. This is a terroristic move by ALLSTATE to take my civil liberties away. I HAVE A RIGHT TO CHOOSE WHO I WANT AS A INSURANCE COMPANY!

on
Satisfaction Rating

My wife and I recently purchased a home that was built in 1955. Allstate Homeowners Insurance was recommended to us. We purchased a homeowners policy and while doing so we were ask if we wanted to purchase a life insurance policy as well. Not knowing what the future holds we did decide to do this as long as our payments for the life policy would be deducted from our escrow account just as our homeowners policy and yearly taxes would be. The agent assured me that would be no problem to have it set up that way. Keep in mind that the Allstate Agent Bonny ** was told ahead of time that if this was not a possibility, that we did not want the life insurance policy.

Everything was moving along smoothly until we were in our house for 3 days, then we received a cancellation notice for our homeowners policy due to the fact the "5" shingles on our roof were worn a bit. So then we moved on to another home owners policy, not that much headache involved. At that point we start getting notices from our bank about being overdrafted in our account...which by the way our account has never been overdrafted in the 3 years it has been open. Allstate was debiting money out of our account for the life insurance policy. We contacted Bonny ** for 3-4 straight days by email and telephone leaving several voice mails as to why Allstate was debiting the money out of our account when it was supposed to be taken out of the escrow account.

Finally on the 4th day we received an email stating that she worked 5 separate offices and did not have time to keep up with every finite detail of her customers' lives and that we should have contacted her before closing on our home so she could have it set up that way. Also in her response was a statement that we purchased a policy and now we had to pay for it, the policy was not free of charge. We conceded thinking our mistake was not notifying Bonny ** about our closing. Ms. ** said now that the closing had taken place we could not set up the payments to come directly from the escrow account. We apologized and corresponded with Ms. ** about the payment and requested that all future payments come out of our bank account on the 21st of the month, not the 5th of the month due to our pay schedule. Ms. ** assured us that this would be no problem and we thought all was settled once again. It was not!!

We continued to get cancellation notices from Allstate due to lack of payments. Again keep in mind we started the policy April 14th 2016 and paid her $90. May 1st Allstate direct drafted $91 from our account. I contacted Ms. ** about the cancellation policy notices and she stated that it was a billing issue and it was out of her hands and we would have to contact them to get any issue resolved. When we contacted billing and spoke with Christy she stated that it was set up on quarterly billing and that would be easy to resolve. However due to the fact that we wanted the payment date changed from the 5th of the month to the 21st of the month, we would have to send in another $91 and also on the 21st of July another payment of $91 would be direct drafted from our bank account. In doing this everything would be resolved and we would be caught up on all payments and everything would be resolved. It was not resolved.

On July 22 I called the bank to make sure the direct draft came through - it had not. I called Allstate Customer Service Line and was told that the policy was in cancellation due to non payment. Summing up all this mess we have paid out $$270 and have gotten nothing in return except headache, stress, grief, and horrendous customer service. Now in order to cancel the policy we have to fill out a cancellation form and after Allstate approves it should they deem any refund due they will cut a check at that time.

I will not recommend anyone purchase any policy with Allstate. We were not in good hands. As far as we are concerned Allstate Insurance is nothing like they advertise. Buying life insurance and home owners insurance should never be this stressful and hard. We have never had such a horrid experience anywhere like the one we encountered with Allstate Insurance and its agents. Please please please take our advice and run when you hear the words Allstate insurance. Trust us you will not be in good hands!!!

on
Satisfaction Rating

Just received a non-renewal notification from Allstate Homeowners Insurance Company. I have paid insurance through Allstate for the length of my home ownership, 15 years, starting at a premium of $899 which is now over $2200 per year. In those 15 years I have had a total of 2 claims, the first a little over $3000, which occurred in May of 2012. The second most recent was filed February of 2016, of which the entire payment was recovered from the other claimants insurance company.

In other words Allstate recovered all of the monies that was paid to us for the damages incurred, an SUV struck our garden area destroying our brickwork. The non-renewal statement clearly shows both claims with the latter indicating $0.0 paid. It is beyond my belief how an insurance company whose slogan is "You're in good hands with Allstate" can be so heartless and drop a customer who has paid insurance for 15 years, but because of two claims which totaled less than $4000 can drop a customer with two months left on our policy.

My recommendation to anyone considering going to Allstate for homeowners insurance is to not even consider them in the first place, and for current policyholders I would seriously consider looking into another company for insurance. Allstate should change its slogan to "You're in good hands with Allstate, until you file a claim". Apparently Allstate only cares about those customers who never file a claim. I thought the purpose of insurance is to cover your home for damages, but in Allstate's case its only purpose seems like to collect your money and hope you don't file a claim or two. This company turns out to be probably the worst insurance scam I have ever heard of.

Apparently Allstate never heard of the power of social media. This letter to ConsumerAffairs is only the beginning, I intend to put this company on blast until it reaches the media, enough is enough with this company. I had no idea Allstate was this bad, and to find out how bad this way, makes it even worst. This is not the way to treat loyal customers, Allstate should be ashamed of itself. The claims filed were NOT of negligence, and was through no fault of our own. With the notice Allstate has the gall to state "Feel free to contact your Allstate representative to see if there are any ways Allstate can continue to work with you to meet your insurance needs". Really, why would I want to be a customer after this. Never again, not homeowners, not car, not rental, no insurance products ever again from Allstate for this household. I intend to pass this on to as many people as possible.

on
Satisfaction Rating

Which is why I'm writing this. So my fiance has Allstate & after reviewing his policy I contact his agent. Now this agent tells me that Allstate will cover a rental property or 2nd home so I go through the lengthy process of trying to determine the right coverage. He and another person at the office are very responsive to my emails. He calls me when I prefer not to be called, seems like a genuine guy. I pay one month's premium, but when I get the policy it say I live there & had another misprint on it. When I ask him if it's okay, because I don't live there, I get no response. I tell them I won't sign the papers & fax them back until I get an answer. This was 2 weeks ago & several messages later to him & the other person not a blip from either. No response whatsoever.

So yesterday I finally call the 800# to clarify some things & just to verify I even have a policy, which they confirm I do. But I still feel leery. I mean who hounds you & then ignores you but makes you think a company is reputable? And I found out that most things can be handled by the 800# so why are there field agent offices? My car company, Wawanesa, doesn't have field agencies. It's a company & I never had an issue with a claim so this is weird to me someone courting you then "dumping" you once they get your money.

Plus, I'm worried if something does happen, because the policy written isn't correct, that they'll deny any claim if they realize I don't live there even though they said it wasn't an issue. Why lie? Apparently my fiance's policy is written the same way, but he hasn't dealt with the guy in over 10 years (no claims). I think I will look into Liberty Mutual. I know a couple of people who have them & rate them very high.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I would never, ever recommended Allstate to cover ANYTHING! After 25 years of paying them they refused to cover a water leak in my home, before that my roof! Everyone around me had hail damage from a storm & had no problem getting a replacement, oh, but not me, I had ALLSTATE! My children & I went on vacation. During the time we were gone we had a pipe burst in our garage wall with backed up to kitchen/dining area. All dining room was ruined, things stored in garage was ruined. We filed a claim, that's why we pay right?? Wrong, we were denied, time after time! Switching today & will tell EVERYONE I know/see NEVER think you're in good hands with Allstate!

on
Satisfaction Rating

I would not trust this company because I had insurance with them for renter insurance. Then I transfer to Homeowners after I bought my house. The first hurricane I received a letter saying they were no longer providing insurance in FL. They bailed on the people leaving us to find another company. They have engaged in the worst form of gamesmanship to achieve their own goals. Run away don't walk!

on
Satisfaction Rating

We recently switched from American Family for our homeowners to Allstate... What a huge mistake! The agency botched the switch over and we had to send in all the paperwork to our bank. A few weeks after we with Allstate, we received notice that we were missing 5 individual shingles on our roof due to a "windstorm" a few weeks earlier. We were much luckier than others in our neighborhood. 3 days later we had the 5 missing pieces replaced and we notified our agency the problem was corrected. Today we received a refund and cancellation notice for roof problems. We contacted our agency and received info that it was because their inspector could not make it out within the 20 days. I was upset and wanted to make sure this was just a "wires crossed" situation and they could not confirm.

I called the agency when I got home, still upset, and demanded to get answer as to whether or not they were going to reinstall the policy or if I needed new insurance. The agency was unable to give me an answer. Fed up I left a negative review on their Facebook page. The agency owner reached out and asked to speak with me Monday to fix the problem, which I agreed to.

One of the girls at the agency wrote a reply to my post telling me to go elsewhere and made an outright lie about a conversation with my wife. I contacted the agency owner and told him that since his people wanted me to go elsewhere and called us liars, we would not be looking to contact him. 15 minutes later the Facebook posts were deleted. What a mistake we made to save some money. Mayhem? Allstate and its agencies are the real mayhem. Hopefully someone will learn from this and not make the same mistake we did. Never been treated so rudely and unprofessionally in all my life.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I made a BIG MISTAKE. I called Sughrue for a quote. I decided against switching. I verbally told them I would not be buying insurance from them. They charged my mortgage servicer for a year of homeowner's insurance. They were paid. In addition, my real Insurance company was paid. How did they get my mortgage info. I was told to get a quote I had to prove that I had insurance the past 12 months. I faxed the declaration page from my insurance company to them. When I called Sughrue I was told the person that had handled this was no longer employed. Conveniently her last day was just the day before. I asked to speak with Sughrue, before I could explain the problem he yelled at me "you have insurance with us" and he hung up on me. BTW I have written proof that I did not agree to the policy.

My mortgage servicer called them. My mortgage servicer said what they did was ILLEGAL. ILLEGAL to have 2 insurance policies. It was agreed to refund what my mortgage servicer had paid them. Weeks later I receive a Cancellation Notice with a partial refund! Finally months later I did receive the full amount. Maybe it was an honest mistake, (who knows maybe that is why the person that initiated the quote was no longer there). If I had been treated courteously and if they had admitted I never had a policy and was sent the full refund I would feel differently. But this has gone on for months with several hours on the phone. I am filing a complaint with the Insurance Commission.

on
Satisfaction Rating

My area had bad storms last year that damaged home siding and roofs. Everyone on my block was affected. I was the only one insured with Allstate. Most had State Farm. I filed two claims for roof damage. Allstate refused. Their premiums are very high, they do not insure their customers, they rape them. We had a wind storm this year. I have sheets of shingles that flew off the roof. Allstate refuses coverage. Have had them for 16 years. Find another company. If enough people pull away maybe they will get the message. Oh, and contacting the Department of Insurance is useless. Allstate bought them.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I was ok, until I talked to the man that works there. He was rude, and treated me like I was not important. My husband try to call but he was rude to him too. I will never be insured with them again.

on
Satisfaction Rating

Submitted claim to Allstate Homeowners Insurance in March of 2015. We had storm water damage that was caused storms. Water came in through windows from rain/windstorms. Dry wall and kitchen cabinets were damaged along with mold damage. Water damage was behind drywall, walls and kitchen cabinets, hence damage from mold incurred due to damage being unseen, not visible until over time.

Allstate claims adjusters stated damage was "long term" and or maintenance related and therefore not covered. Their assessment incorrect as I have requested numerous times for Allstate to provide proof when damage started. They cannot provide that information or proof of damage starting. Therefore, they have not proven that it is long term damage. Over $6,500.00 damage, of which Allstate should have paid out $4000.00 to cover cost of damages. I have both Allstate Homeowners and Allstate Flood insurance and with all this coverage, Allstate refuses to stand behind its product and service. If you think you are in good hands with Allstate, you are sadly mistaking.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I was with American Family for 15 years. The rates were a little high so I I decided to shop around. I choose Allstate. HUGE mistake. I see a lot of reviews regarding claims, I haven't even submitted a claim. I have only had them as my insurance company for three months. I have wasted so much time with them "straightening" things out.

First off my homeowners insurance was a little higher with them but I was getting a significant savings on my car insurance. The first issue was they told me they would take care of cancelling my current insurance policy but they did not then they acted like they didn't know what I was talking about. Luckily American family refunded me for the extra six weeks I paid them. Second, they kept sending me a partial bill for my homeowners insurance. I called numerous times to straighten this out. This bill was to go to my mortgage company. I had to provide them with the contact information numerous times. They are A big company. They should know how this works.

Third, they sent an inspector who decided we needed a new roof. Our roof was not horrible but did need to be replaced in the near future. They decided this a month after the policy started. They gave us little time to do this and who puts on a roof in March in the Midwest? They said they were cancelling the policy but would reinstate it when the roof was complete without a lapse. We got a new roof in their timeframe but because they took too long to send out an inspector the insurance lapsed. They reinstated the insurance about three weeks later. In the meantime my mortgage company tacked on some insanely high priced insurance because we didn't have any. So that was all done with and I was like "ok everything's good now."

Haha I was so wrong. Today I'm balancing my checkbook and see Allstate took out $544. I was signed up for monthly automatic payments for my auto insurance, which should only be $100 or so. Naturally I'm fuming. I call my local agent thinking it has something to do with my homeowners insurance again but she tells me it's my auto insurance and she doesn't know what the deal is but will call back later.

She calls back and tells me they made changes to my auto policy. Changes I have no idea about or authorized. She goes on to tell me that because I don't have proof of continuous auto coverage I lost that discount. So my insurance went up $1200 for a six month period. Mind you my insurance was $600 for six months. I was like "that's not true. I've had American Family for the last 15 years." My policy with Allstate started 2-19 and my coverage with American Family ended 2-23. There was no lapse. I've had Allstate for three months and they're just coming up with this now. No one contacted me about this.

The lady at my local agency tells me they will charge me $544 next month too. I argue with her for a while that I did not authorize this charge and would never pay $1800 for six months of auto insurance. I didn't get anywhere. She tells me to call American Family and have them fax her the information stating when my insurance ended with them. They do so quickly. I get a call back from Allstate saying they received the information but it's not good enough for them. They need a special form that comes from corporate headquarters but she talked to American Family herself and they were going to get that for her. Once they get the form she will have the underwriters review it but that could take 7 days.

Next American Family calls me and says Allstate is being difficult. He says this form will take 7 days or so to process but he will get it to Allstate ASAP. So now I'm looking at two weeks at least to possibly see my money again. Another interesting thing is that there seems to be this magical database for all insurance companies that has all this information from all insurance companies. Both Allstate and American family mentioned it but somehow American family could see that I had insurance through 2-23 but when Allstate looked at it my insurance ended in December. Weird? Why did it take Allstate three months to come up with this. Obviously when they gave me the quote three months ago they knew I had insurance when they gave me this discount for having insurance. Three months later there's an issue? They never called and said there's an issue. If they had I would have taken care of it.

I regret setting up automatic payments but I did this with American Family for 15 years and never had an issue. I was always notified when there was a change in the amount they were taking out of my account even if it was a few cents. It's complete fraud. It's stealing in my opinion. I work hard for my money and feel ripped off. I filed a complaint with the Allstate corporate office but have not heard anything back yet. This is a major insurance company. They know what they're doing but they sure play stupid when you question them. They pass the blame or make up ridiculous excuses. Not professional at all.

I'd love to get a lawyer because surely this has to be illegal but that would cost more than I lost. I am hopeful that I'll get this "straightened" out and get my money back. I'm sure there will be something else that comes up. I plan on looking for another insurance company after I get my money back. My advice is to stay as far away from Allstate as possible. Do not give them your business unless you like spending all your time dealing with them and having your money stolen.

on
Satisfaction Rating

My insurance company is planning to cancel me if I don't have the shingles on my roof fixed. I am indigent. I worked for 35 years with the State of South Carolina and now I am going to end up on the street. I am trying to go through the Lexington County Grant program but nothing can be done until the first of July. They are closing out their end of the year papers and my renewal for homeowners is July 1. I was told that if they send contract to Allstate I might get to go until July 20th. I would just like to say that I think Allstate should change their trademark "You are in good hands with Allstate". The last part should be "until something happens".

I am very disappointed in Allstate. I have had the Auto 35 years and homeowners almost 12. If I could find another company that would take me I would leave Allstate in a skinny minute. I can't sleep. I stay keyed up all day knowing that I am going to lose my home. I just want to thank you so much for your non-help in this matter.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I am complain for stolen car from body shop. Contains in car. Allstate won't help you any way with paper work. They want you to make mistakes so they do not have to pay. They will take the extra mile not to pay. Do not buy vip policy thinking you are treated vip. Waste of money. Please do not think you pay extra you are treated better. NO. My case will be in court. When you have claim one day you will learn a good lesson. Please do not take a chance.

on
Satisfaction Rating

The continued increase in auto and home insurance is leaving me speechless. I contacted my insurance agent for a policy review. The meeting was excellent. I gained a much better understanding of why the increase in insurance. The increase comes from so many reasons but here are a few... if you're in an accident and you have injuries, or a person you hit has injuries your auto insurance pays yours and their medical bills however, if the cost of health care goes up, the cost of the insurance has to go up to keep up with the cost of the health care increase.

And auto repair... when auto repair goes up, auto paint, labor, parts, etc. the cost of insurance has to go up to keep up with the cost of repairs. If you have a widget you're selling... and you have to get the parts from 4 different companies and those 4 companies raise their price, the widget price has to go up because cost of goods has gone up. Once it was explained to me I understood better. No one likes to pay more but at least I understand now.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I am very disappointed in my agent, Bill **. The company slogan is "You're in good hands," - maybe not with this agent. I would expect any agent to work for the company, but with me as well and not seemingly against me. I am a 26-year customer of Allstate who has never complained, paid premiums on time, and never once filed a claim. When I had a recent issue with a rental property, I became painfully aware I was dealing with an agent who didn't have my best interest at heart. I would recommend anyone dissatisfied with their agent to take action. Contact corporate, change agents, or even companies if need be. If still not happy, file a complaint with the Dept. of Insurance. After many years with Bill **, I am no longer recommending this agent.

on
Satisfaction Rating

I recently switched insurance companies for Allstate as they offered a cheaper rate, but the local agent called after I canceled my insurance with Liberty, and said I needed to add more to my insurance, which would be a higher rate. Then he called me again and said, "A inspector went to your property and we want you to paint the trim around the windows and replace a piece of vinyl siding, etc." I said, "My previous insurance co. never asked to do all this." He said, "We are a different company." If I knew they would be like that I would have picked a different co.

on
Satisfaction Rating

On 7/13/15 an area in Woodridge Illinois experienced a hail damage event, as documented by the national weather service. Many homes in the area had damaged roofs, and in the area that I live 85 roof replacement permits have been issued between 8/1/15 and 3/31/16. Many homes were visited by roofing companies that knew our area had damage. I had a roofer come out and stated that he did see roof damage and he showed me pictures. We did file a claim, and Allstate sent out a team of two to review the roof. Allstate found NO hail damage on our roof. Coincidentally our neighbor was also having their home inspected (State Farm) and they were granted a new roof. We are left to conclude that Allstate treats policyholders differently than other insurance companies.

Expert Review

Matthew BrodskyInsurance Contributing Editor

Matthew Brodsky is an established expert on insurance, having written hundreds of articles and other pieces of content on the subject, interviewed countless practitioners, and attended dozens of conferences and events. He served as an editor at industry magazine Risk & Insurance for six years.    More about Matthew→

Allstate is one of America’s largest and most popular insurance companies. The company provides many types of insurance, including auto insurance, life insurance, homeowners insurance and more.

  • Accessible: Allstate offers insurance across America, making it a convenient choice for a homeowners insurance policy no matter where a person lives.
  • Reward programs: This company offers helpful programs for people who pay for protection but don’t need to use it, such as the claims-free rewards program,. Even if discount programs aren’t advertised, consumers should call or email their insurance representatives to ask about discounts, since many companies award them without publicizing them.
  • Convenience: Allstate has an excellent Web presence and convenient online tools. Potential customers can request custom quotes via tools on the company’s website.
  • Customer service: Allstate is a huge company, but it operates with thousands of local agents around the country.
  • Best for Traditional homeowners, condo owners, mobile home owners

Compare Homeowners Insurance

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Company Profile

Company Name:
Allstate
Website:
https://www.allstate.com/