Allstate Homeowners Insurance

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Get a Quote on SmartFinancial
3.5(998)
Get a Quote on SmartFinancial

Our promise. We provide a buying advantage with verified reviews and unbiased editorial research.

Overall Rating3.5 out of 5
See all 998 reviews & ratings

About Allstate Homeowners Insurance Reviews

Allstate is the second-largest homeowners insurance company in the U.S. When you request a quote, Allstate suggests three different levels of coverage to choose from. You can further customize a policy to fit your needs. Although Allstate’s prices can be higher than some other companies', it has multiple discounts available and a high financial strength rating.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Several coverage options
  • High financial strength rating
  • Plentiful discounts

Cons

  • Slightly high costs

Bottom Line

Allstate provides good homeowners insurance with several levels of coverage. The prices are a bit higher than average, but Allstate might still be a good choice for those looking to protect their home.

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Reviews

ConsumerAffairs has collected 998 reviews and 3,093 ratings.

Recent
  • Recent
  • Oldest
  • Most helpful
Any
  • Any

A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Allstate Homeowners Insurance?
  • 4,314,214 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
  • We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
  • We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
  • Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Page 2 Reviews 10 - 40
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingStaff

Reviewed May 8, 2023

March 3, 2023 a storm caused damages to my home, garage, and pool. I contacted my agent and was told by two different people on several occasions I had to have estimates to file my claim. It took me 4 weeks to get the estimates. Almost $8,000.00 in damage. I sent the information to my agent and filed the claim. An adjuster was to come to my house in two weeks, needless to say he was a no show-no call. They tried to put it off for another two weeks and I refused. One week later he appears. Estimate done and the insurance company wants me to accept a little over $4,000.00. My policy is 100% replacement with a $1000.00 deductible. I plan on contacting the better business agency and the Kentucky State insurance board if this is not rectified. Buyer beware. Allstate is not as good as their word.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims HandlingCoverage

Reviewed May 4, 2023

They will find ways and excuses not to cover your claim. I had a roofer tell me I had hail damage that came by. Guess what, Allstate claims there was no damage whatsoever. Find another insurer. Don’t throw your money away to them. They suck money from their customers and don't pay them out when you need them.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceCoverageStaff

Reviewed May 2, 2023

I was trying to work with Thomas Vanidestine Agency, Venice Florida, to assist my 89 year old friend who I have power of attorney for. I requested numerous times over a few mo this for his homeowner's insurance policy to be reviewed without any satisfaction until two weeks ago. Once I felt coverage was adequate I tried to pay his premium in full over the phone and I was disconnected and then recommended to pay online. I attempted this but due to policy renewal of 3/31/23 this system did not work. I tried to explain to numerous representatives within this agency but they did not understand and transferred me to Southern Oaks who transferred me back. Before I could resolve and pay I received a threatening email from the agency manager. With one call to State Farm I received a very helpful and polite agent who immediately understood my need and provided coverage within a day of my call.

Thanks for your vote! Report
profile pic of the author

Reviewed March 23, 2023

Low price provider but absolutely the worst customer service at the local and corporate level. Extremely hard to get anyone to help you with anything so buyer beware if you want to make simple changes to your account, need something or ever file a claim.

Thanks for your vote! Report
profile pic of the author
Verified purchase

Reviewed March 9, 2023

In The Marion County Court In And For Marion County Florida, Shawanda ** v Castle Key Insurance Company (Allstate) Case#**...I am forced to represent myself in court while diagnosed with Bipolar, and on **. A prick test revealed that my then 12-year-old daughter was allergic to mold. Mold was found in the AC unit due to a drip pan overflow, in 10/15/15. The claim was denied. While fighting in court, the mold has spread throughout the house. Allstate has won, without me being present in court due to extreme chest pains, and a mental breakdown. Allstate is requesting Taxes, fees, and cost, with the threat of placing a lien on my house. After serving 7 years in the Navy, I built my house through the Veterans program in 1997, and I have been a loyal Allstate customer since then. I am forced to live with this mold. My family is getting sicker. I am not in good hands.

Thanks for your vote! Report

Reviewed Jan. 13, 2023

My home flooded. I called Allstate. I've had to do all of the work. My adjustor never really communicated. It was my first time experiencing a loss through a flood. My original adjustor told me the day of that he was retiring right before 6pm. He didn't document well at all about my claim. The young new adjustors that were placed on the claim were terrible to say the least. I was told that he had 40 other claims and that he didn't know when he would get to mine. His supervisor began calling after I had to constantly inquire about the status. I was spoken to as if I caused the flood and they constantly questioned everything that my contractor did although he undercharged me.

The mitigation company also did a terrible job because they were only interested in putting fans throughout my home trying to dry the sheet rock and cabinets. After the mitigation guy left and contractors began working, they found mold and mildew. Allstate's adjustor said that he needed proof that the mold and mildew were part of the claim! I was wading in water in my home and because the mitigation team didn't catch everything they are refusing to pay! On top of that, I never got reimbursed for my meals and they closed my claim! Run for the hills because everyone that I have spoken to in my area has had the worst experiences with Allstate. Now I'm forced to find legal help! Do yourself a favor and switch to a better homeowners insurance!

Thanks for your vote! Report

Reviewed Dec. 21, 2022

We had Allstate insurance on our home and cars for more than 22 years. We had never filed a claim, ever. They told us we had to trim a tree and replace 4 tiles on our roof or they were going to cancel our policy. We trimmed the tree and replaced one part of our roof. We hadn't made it to fix the tiles yet and they canceled our policy. They canceled us after 22 years, never having filed a claim, for 4 tiles. Now we have State Farm, the same coverage, lower cost. Use your imagination on what we think about Allstate now. - F. *8. Northern Kentucky.

Thanks for your vote! Report

Reviewed Oct. 28, 2022

My first house claim, a leak caused damages about $ 15,000 dollars worth in a bedroom and a bathroom in my house. Very unfortunate and unexpected event for anyone to suffer but the most ironic deplorable thing is not to get the economic support of ALLSTATE, my claim was denied as soon as I filed in. They did not care not either took the time to evaluate or consider it, even though I have been AN ALLSTATE LOYAL CUSTOMER FOR MORE THAN 20 YEARS. ALLSTATE has more than one face, ONE OF GOOD HANDS TO COLLECT OUR PREMIUMS THE OTHER, DEVILS HANDS TO DISMISSED AND DENY YOUR CLAIMS. That is the job of their well trained claim department to deny any valid claim by using one or two of their infinite list of options to AVOID HONORING OUR CLAIMS.

They sort of playing lottery with our claims to see which is to be the lucky one to be consider to respond positively for it. THE MAJORITY OF OUR VALID AND LEGITIMATE CLAIMS ARE THEN DENIED. I am writing this review based on my recent experience OCTOBER 2022. For those looking for an honest, supporting, genuine and sincere insurance company read very carefully my review before you decide. DO NOT WAIT TO LIVE IT TO BELIEVE IT!!!!

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims HandlingStaff

Reviewed Oct. 11, 2022

I could have given 5 stars to Allstate if not because of these three reasons: First, premiums keep going up. Second, it takes time to get approved on your claim. I have to refile a claim before they approved it. 3rd, the damages on my first filing were not included in the payments that I received because they're saying that it was approved on the first one. It's just that it did not meet the deductible. Tricky! But the good thing about them is they are all nice people. Especially the group of people who were assigned to my case on the second time filing. They made sure to do a good job of reviewing my complaint. Shout out to Mr. John ** who took care of everything!

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims HandlingCoverageStaff

Reviewed Oct. 10, 2022

Rated 1 out of 5 stars In Good Hands with Allstate: NOT!!! We had Allstate coverage for our home, vacation home and autos. Premiums are high and go up substantially every year without any claims or violations. Then we had a rock hit our car windshield and had to pay completely out of pocket. Not covered. Next a hailstorm ravaged our neighborhood and all of our neighbors got new roofs. The roofer said "If you had any company but Allstate, you would get a roof. They are more interested in protecting their shareholders than their policyholders." So we cancelled all our policies and were hit with a surcharge on the auto policy which we had already paid in full. 3 strikes and you are out, Allstate. Agents are lovely as long as they are soliciting/collecting your money, but if you should ever need to file a claim, you will be sorely disappointed.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims Handling

Reviewed Oct. 3, 2022

I as consumer have not had a very good experience with Allstate. I was with Statefarm for about 5 years I switched due to my rates going up every year. So far Allstate has shown very bad Customer service. My whole policy was done wrong they had denied my claim for repairs due to them wanting me to keep spending thousands of dollars for me to repair over and over my roof. I don't know what I need to do so I can get some help.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageStaff

Reviewed Sept. 28, 2022

I have had a very negative experience dealing with Allstate from their customer service, communication, and the fact that they denied a claim based off a standard that was impossible for me to satisfy. They literally had me send them a weather report to prove that there was a natural disaster. They never sent an inspector yet denied my claim based off an employee's conjecture about the state of the building that I live in. I'm not sure how some random guy was able to tell me about the state of caulking around my window and the building façade over the phone without making any effort to visit or inspect. Their employees are clearly trained to find any made-up loophole and make broad assumptions about the cause of damage without actually doing any work to make an inspection. Very disappointing experience, they essentially cover NOTHING because they will make assumptions that make it possible for them to deny your claim.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServicePunctuality & SpeedStaff

Reviewed Sept. 20, 2022

My home burned down the last day in July. Leaving my family of 7 displaced. My insurance is trying to withhold the money in my policy to replace possessions. They offered an insulting amount and if I want what’s in my policy I basically have to earn it. So on top of the stress of losing my home and most of our things. I now have to find time to sit at a computer and itemize everything we owned. Which is difficult when both of us work full time and have 3 littles to care for and my elderly mother also lives with us. Long answer but it is my life right now. By the way my insurance is Allstate and it isn’t my local branch handling it. It is 3rd party assessor they hire.

Shame on them for making an already devastating and stressful time more stressful. Not to mention if you don’t have a computer due to the fire you're out of luck. You can’t use your phone to do the itemization because the spread sheet requires you to use a computer and Microsoft Office. Which I don’t have at the moment. They count on people being too overwhelmed to fight for what their policy says they have. I could go on and on. Took them 5 weeks to tell me they were giving me the insulting amount. I was not not to touch anything so what could have been salvaged was ruined sitting in the open house in soot and water molding conditions. Not to mentions all the animals that made themselves at home. Then the assessor that came took things out and left them in the elements that could’ve been possibly salvaged. Altogether very bad experience. A nightmare on top of a nightmare.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims HandlingCoveragePriceStaff

Reviewed Sept. 6, 2022

Let me start by saying Allstate is popular but not necessarily good. I filed a claim about hail storm damage to my roof last year. Allstate denied my claim. Allstate claims that the damage was not hail stone damage. And so I left it at that. This year 2022 I put my house in the market and the buyer’s inspection agent also reported hailstone damage to the roof. I refiled my claim again and Allstate once again denied my claim. I uploaded pictures of the hail damage as approve of hail damage and Allstate still denied my claim. They give me no justifiable reason to deny my claim because there was none. This denial was based on greed on the part of Allstate.

My advice for all those thinking about purchasing a home or auto insurance with Allstate is just stay clear away. For me to be able to sell my house, I had to cut my price by $15,000. What is the point of having insurance coverage when you can’t use it when is needed?? In Allstate commercial they say “Allstate you are in safe hands” but I say Allstate you are in dangerous hands.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceCoverage

Reviewed Sept. 1, 2022

I have been insured with Allstate since 1994, this will be my first claim. Due to a major wind and Hail storm. I have quite a bit of damage, roof, siding, broken windows, damage to gutters, spouting, etc... The amount they want to settle for doesn't even cover the cost of the roof, which they told me would be completely covered. They do not want to replace all of my siding, they want to "blend" and "Patch". It takes several days to get a return phone call. I do have a really good contractor helping me. Allstate is ignoring Ohio codes that apply to my situation, which I believe is not legal.

Thanks for your vote! Report

Reviewed Aug. 23, 2022

I had hail damage to one side of my house. The color of my siding is discontinued and there is no reasonable match. They have repeatedly refused to side the whole house. I have filed a complaint with the department of insurance in Ohio.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims HandlingCoverage

Reviewed July 24, 2022

Recently, July 2022, I had a pipe burst (spigot). I turned the water on to water the grass and the pipe burst. I found out Allstate do not, repeat, do not cover this mishaps. Allstate will only cover pipes seasonally. What that means is if your pipe freeze & burst during the winter, they might, perhaps, possibly cover the all the damages. By the way, when claims are submitted, they will low ball you and advise you to go with another company for less. Make one of the biggest decisions of your life. Select another company. If my review don't sway you, read all the unethical things Allstate has been guilty of (even the CEO admitted wrongdoing).

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverage

Reviewed June 28, 2022

My roof was damaged and caused water to leak in my bedroom. I began a claim on December 1, 2021. Allstate initially would only pay for like 6 shingles. After months and months of my contractor sending in the details, Allstate denying it and saying they need to send their contractor in which led to their contractor stating it was unrepairable. Allstate then said we have to submit a video. My contractor submitted a video and they said it was too long and wouldn't accept it. Then he submitted a shorter one but they couldn't find it. Again, he submitted it and they said they couldn't find it again.

Finally, I had to email over and over and they finally received it. It was now that 60% of my roof is damaged but because they don't cover "wear and tear" they will only fix 60%. This means that the new shingles will be completely black and the rest of my roof since it is over 16 years is completely faded and grey - it will remain with the old shingles so I will have two different colors throughout my roof. I wanted to possibly sell my house which this is going to be a huge detractor to anyone wanting to buy it. Allstate tried to use every tactic in the world to deny my claim and also handled this so poorly with everything they did.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims Handling

Reviewed June 25, 2022

UPDATED 09/05/2022: On April 26, 2022, we had a hail storm at night that damaged the property and a vehicle, the next day the claim was filed with Allstate and this company sent its inspectors to assess the damage on four occasions, and on both occasions, Allstate argued that They would not cover the expenses incurred in the entire argument that there was no evidence of hail damage both on the roof and on one of the windows that was broken by the impact of the hail, all this after four months, so we made the decision to hire an appraiser to pursue an appraisal claim in which Allstate ultimately had to cover all expenses. It is not fair that this company promotes itself by announcing that you are in good hands when the only thing that happens is that you are in the worst hands and have to resort to unexpected expenses and have to continue paying an insurance policy to receive a lousy service from Allstate managers.

ORIGINAL REVIEW: I had a hail storm in my area and Allstate, after sending three inspectors to check and take photos, considered that there was no hail damage and they do not want to be held responsible for the damage caused, the decision was made to proceed legally against Allstate, I not recommend this insurance, the report was made on April 26 and they were only taking time to say that the claim did not proceed after two months of waiting.

Thanks for your vote! Report

Reviewed June 4, 2022

We had two hail storms pass through our area in two weeks leaving homes. Cars and property damaged. Allstate sent a third party paid by them to take photos while other insurance co sent adjusters to survey the damages in our neighborhood. Allstate deemed the photos inconclusive and refused any payment on my behalf. This is a third-rate insurance company. Stay away!!!! Their ratings are dropping every year for this reason.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceStaff

Reviewed April 13, 2022

Would never recommend anyone to use Allstate. My experience has involved multiple phone calls, absurdly long wait times, and I have consistently been told one thing while the company representatives did another. Please tell your family and friends to go elsewhere.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Claims Handling

Reviewed March 11, 2022

I would give Allstate zero stars if I could. I have had Allstate Insurance since 2008. Home and Auto. Several years ago a storm damaged my roof and water leaked in and damaged the ceiling. Allstate Claims Adjuster stated there was nothing wrong with my roof. Had to pay out of pocket. In 2022 an ice storm that damaged my roof. I did some research and found out Allstate pays Hancock as a third party to do inspections to deny claims. Hancock has less than a 2 star rating with BBB. I requested an alternative to Hancock and was denied. Hancock stated there was no damage to my roof and my claim was denied. I would advise you to find a better insurance company if there is such a thing. You are NOT in good hands with Allstate.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverageStaff

Reviewed Feb. 22, 2022

My wife and I decide a change of scenery and moving to great state of Washington. We buy a nice house with 8 acres outside of Arlington in late July. The house was built and lived in by a nice couple for the last 20 years, the house is fully ready to move in, turn key. Fast forward 4 months, my company is releasing a new product and it's all hands on deck so we have not moved in yet. We have gone down to the house twice and our cousin is checking up on the property but in the week before Thanksgiving, thieves hit our place. They were likely construction savvy, because they cut out and stole materials like our furnace, water heater, kitchen cabinets and sinks, doors, garage doors, leaving our place gutted. The electrical, plumbing, water tanks, furnace were all cut and needed professionals to reconnect it, they didn't just disconnect these services, they cut it.

We make a claim and I begged the advisor to make this an emergency because our place is now open to the weather. They assured me that they would send assessor and advisor would call me asap and discuss emergency remediation like boarding up the doors and allowance for me to stay in hotel and address these issues locally (I am in a different state). 7 days after opening a claim, advisor leaves 1 vm identifying adjuster, multiple calls and VMs later, 16 days later the adjuster informs me he is no longer the adjuster for the case and the new adjuster would call me asap.

20 days later after even more calls, Nicole ** - my new adjuster calls and tells me in her 10+ years of realtor experience, there is no malicious intent and no theft has occurred and that it looks like it was professionally demo'd. She follows up with they won't be paying for anything and a day later tells me to prepare for EUO (examination under oath) stating they want some clarification on what happened, that it was theft and not someone I hired. We actually hired a company to install cameras and board up the property, actually filming the thieves stealing more stuff..

They delayed all their responses, rarely called back to return my phone calls and/or had lot of days off and passed our claim back and forth different people for weeks. They promised to take care of us in this situation and really in the end - total of 78 days later, stuck us in front of lawyers and then promptly dismissed our claim, stating we didn't occupy the property 30 days prior to the loss. Which I stated to their agent, when we bought the property, 2 months into ownership, and when we started the claim. How many Washington people leave their properties unoccupied for more than 30 days, I hope you don't have Allstate insurance.

BTW our lawyer says this is 100% within their rights to treat a homeowner this way, leave you paying the mortgage for months so you're broke while they delay/stall tactics, hire lawyers and stick it to you. Check out Allstate's reviews, they might look alright on paper, but they have the worst reputation once a customer goes through a claim with this company.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Coverage

Reviewed Jan. 12, 2022

We had issues with Allstate not paying to have my son's car fixed after a car accident and terminated that policy but we kept the homeowners policy on the rental units only. Terminated the resistance insurance when we terminated the auto insurance. Now to my point We had a storm and blew away but 100 shingles from the roof. Now they don't want to pay to have that repaired properly. They want to replace the shingles with a different colors which I'm not agreeing to. Most likely I'll end up getting a lawyer to go after them.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Coverage

Reviewed Dec. 18, 2021

All-State canceled our policy without our knowledge. They added over $700 to our policy without advising us. They didn't let us know our proof of prior insurance wasn't accepted. They are sneaky and dishonest.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoverage

Reviewed Oct. 29, 2021

I have had my homeowner insurance with Allstate for over 10 years. During hurricane IDA, my apartment had some water damage which affected the wall paint and wood floor. I filed a claims with Allstate and without even visiting the property to inspect the damage, I got a call from one of their representative that my claims was rejected as the policy doesn't cover water damage. My insurance premium have been increasing every year over the past 10 years, and now when I file a claim to cover the damages in my home, they can reject my claims. What is the purpose of having a homeowner insurance if it doesn't cover any this type of damage. I am cancelling all my insurance Allstate. I strongly recommend anyone reading this review to find another insurance company.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingStaff

Reviewed Oct. 7, 2021

I think Allstate has some illegal practices. We had a tornado hit our property, FEMA was brought in and paid the insurance companies for the people's claims. Allstate made us pay a double deductible claiming they had to break the damage into two parts, wind then lightning. Two very large trees were twisted, split wide open all the way to the ground and hanging over the house. Shingles were ripped off the roof and siding, soffit, etc. were torn from the house and the garage. Allstate paid a fraction, ($500), of what it cost to remove the trees and repair all of the damage. I attempted to contact Allstate but they didn't wish to hear anything we had to say. The woman kept calling me "sweetie", very disrespectful.

Their damage assessor called before he came, I told him NOT to come to the house unless I was home, he chose to come while I was at work and my wife was home alone. We made many attempts to contact him on what he claimed was his cell phone but he never answered and refused to return our calls no matter how many voicemails we left. It took Allstate months to pay the little bit they paid, I kept leaving Allstate voicemails explaining the damaged trees are hanging dangerously over the house and were about to come crashing through the roof, they would have taken out the back half of the house. The only reply I received was, "then we will pay for that damage" even if there is a loss of life. It seems Allstate may have taken the FEMA monies and only disbursed a fraction of what they received to the homeowners.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Verified purchase
Customer ServiceClaims Handling

Reviewed Aug. 27, 2021

My Dishwasher leaked underneath causing a water damage to my Floors. Allstate denied the claim. They have stopped responding and completely shut me off. I was paying $2200 per year and was thinking I had the best insurance But surprisingly this company has grown so big and has so many clauses that you will get stuck. Be super careful and go somewhere else.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingPrice

Reviewed June 26, 2021

Hope we never have to put a claim in. Tho, we pay the extra fee to have total replacement. I can see if something happens, it would be very costly to replace today your home. Due to price of lumber and will we see rate hike coming? This would apply to all insurance companies.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Customer ServiceClaims HandlingCoveragePricePunctuality & SpeedStaff

Reviewed June 19, 2021

I have had Allstate for my Homeowners Insurance for years and stayed with them because they have always keep my premium at a reasonable cost with the best coverage. When I have needed to submit a claim Allstate agents were there and things were settled very fast and I was reimbursed for property lost or damaged in situations that had happened. Allstate is great and keeps up with the times, and they DO pay out claims fairly and promptly with no big hassle or paperwork to deal with. Allstate also gives many different discounts on your premiums if you qualify. You just need to check it out. I highly recommend Allstate for any Homeowner.

Thanks for your vote! Report
Loading more reviews...

Allstate Homeowners Insurance Company Information

Company Name:
Allstate Homeowners Insurance
Website:
www.allstate.com