Home Warranty vs. Appliance Warranty

How home and appliance warranties compare

A home warranty works as a service contract that covers multiple home systems and appliances — for example, HVAC, plumbing, refrigerators and dishwashers. An appliance warranty provides narrower protection for a single product, such as a dishwasher or dryer.

Home warranty coverage may pay to repair or replace covered appliances and systems that break down through normal use, often after their manufacturer’s warranties expire. For example, it might cover an aging dishwasher that stops working, although you’ll pay a service fee and coverage limits may apply.

A manufacturer’s appliance warranty generally covers defects in materials or workmanship on a new appliance for a limited period. It usually doesn’t cover breakdowns caused by ordinary use or aging.

Home warranty vs. appliance warranty at a glance

Here are the basic features of home and appliance warranties side by side:

» FIND OUT: What home warranty statistics reveal

Home warranty vs. appliance warranty costs

Generally, an appliance warranty is cheaper than a home warranty — understandably, since it offers less comprehensive coverage.

Home warranty costs

Home warranties typically cost between $400 and $800 per year, with service fees ranging from $75 to $150 per visit. Total costs reflect your home size and type, selected coverage level, location and qualifying discounts.

Adding optional coverage for items such as septic systems, pools and water softeners can increase your home warranty premium.

Appliance warranty costs

Appliance warranties are commonly available from manufacturers, with the option to purchase additional coverage via third-party providers. A factory-backed warranty typically covers defects in materials and workmanship for a limited period. Most manufacturers incorporate warranty costs into the price of their appliances, so coverage is automatic.

Extended warranties offer optional coverage that goes beyond the manufacturer’s warranty terms. Costs range from $50 to $300, although additional fees may apply. An extended appliance warranty may offer more value for an appliance that is prone to breakdowns or expensive to repair or replace.

Home warranty vs. appliance warranty exclusions

Broader coverage doesn’t always mean fewer exclusions. A home warranty may list an appliance as covered but exclude the failed component or cause, while a manufacturer’s warranty generally hinges on whether the problem qualifies as a defect.

Common home warranty exclusions

Home warranty plans don’t cover every repair or replacement. Depending on your contract, common gaps in home warranty coverage may include:

• Cosmetic defects
• Certain types of preexisting conditions
• Poor maintenance
• Mold
• Improper installation
• Solar panels
• Fireplace
• Windows
• Items covered by the manufacturer’s warranty

Exclusions under a home warranty also encompass scenarios that homeowners insurance would otherwise cover, such as theft or fire. Some home warranty companies may also cover unknown preexisting conditions (with or without an inspection requirement), but exact terms vary.

Common appliance warranty exclusions

Most appliance warranties share several exclusions with home warranties, including:

• Normal wear and tear
• Cosmetic damage
• Improper installation
• Lack of maintenance
• Unauthorized repairs

How to choose between a home warranty and an appliance warranty

There’s really no one-size-fits-all approach to choosing between a home warranty and an appliance warranty. A home warranty may be the better choice if you have several aging appliances or systems that are no longer under manufacturer warranties. An appliance warranty may make more sense if you want to protect one newer, expensive appliance.

Before you make your choice, consider:

• Home age: Older homes benefit more from comprehensive coverage.
• Appliance age: Newer appliances benefit from individual coverage if expensive to replace, while home warranties often cover out-of-warranty appliances.
• Number of items: A home warranty can cover multiple systems and appliances under one plan, while an appliance warranty protects one product.
• Repair history: Neither option generally covers existing problems, and repeated repairs may indicate that replacement is more practical.
• Budget: Compare premiums, service fees, coverage limits and likely repair costs — not just the upfront price.
• Claim convenience: A single point of contact simplifies the claims process compared to managing multiple warranty providers for several appliances or systems.
• Local contractor availability: Home warranty companies often assign technicians, while manufacturer warranties may require authorized service providers.
• Risk tolerance: Broad coverage spreads protection across several items, while individual coverage concentrates it on one appliance.

Before buying either type, check for overlapping coverage and read the contract’s exclusions, limits and service-fee requirements.

FAQ