
Plaza Auto Mall Reviews
Brooklyn, NY
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
About Plaza Auto Mall
- Transparent sales experience
- Long wait times for service
Plaza Auto Mall Reviews
Filter by Rating
- (8)
- (3)
- (2)
- (76)
Popular Mentions
- 4,895,222 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
Recent
- Recent
- Oldest
- Most helpful
A link has directed you to this review. Its location on this page may change next time you visit.
- 4,895,222 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.

Reviewed May 24, 2026
I would never recommend this dealership, they tell you that GAP is added to your car with payments in the finance and then trying to tell you something else. The worse rip off dealership. 0 STAR!!!! NEVER BUYING FROM THEM AGAIN.

Reviewed April 14, 2026
Completely unprofessional. Should be zero stars. I was looking for a specific used car that they had on all the websites (CarGurus, Carfax etc.) and needed to buy quickly and would be buying outright. I wrote expressing interest and called - both spoken and written, shared my situation, and was told the car was available and could I come right away. I agreed and said given a concussion from the collision that gave rise to my needing a new car, I wanted to avoid heavy traffic hours, especially as I live over 100 miles away in the Catskills. We agreed upon me arriving mid-morning. I made the trek and was greeted by a salesperson named Amin. He didn't even know what car I was there to drive, despite multiple texts confirming. I thought that was odd, but handed over my license and waited. He returned to tell me the car was not even on the property.
I was aghast. I told him how egregious the situation was, he agreed. I said, "would you want your mother or grandma to drive 120 miles through NJ, Manhattan and half of Brooklyn with a concussion to be so misled?". He concurred not. I asked for the sales manager, and this person, Santiago, approached me and very unapologetically restated the situation, suggesting I come back another time. I commented he had not remotely apologized, and he stared at the ceiling while muttering an apology. I said, " look me in the eye when apologizing". I mean, come on! Human decency! Amin escorted me back to my rental car.
It occurred to me how much I wanted that car, I had even researched where I could drop the rental, how far away a bank branch was so I could get a cashier's check to buy outright, and I had even already ordered a model-specific back seat cover for my dog. I was ready to commit. I walked back into the dealership and asked Santiago (still nonchalant, but borderline hostile given I had insisted on a proper apology) for the name of the GM. I got that and left.
Two or three days later, a female salesperson called me, inviting me back down without acknowledging the situation, which I detailed for her. She said that was why she called me, rather than a male salesperson, because as a female, she would never treat me that way. Ok. I said the only way I would consider coming back is if the GM called me himself to apologize. I heard from her two more times, never heard from him. I guess I have to return the backseat dog cover. Avoid. Arrogant. Irresponsible. Too much ego to lower themselves to apologize - and that's with a motivated buyer. Can you imagine how they treat people once they have your money?
Thanks for subscribing.
You have successfully subscribed to our newsletter! Enjoy reading our tips and recommendations.
Reviewed March 16, 2026
The service department for Hyundai at Plaza Auto Mall are not at all honest. I went to them because of a recall and at the same time I thought it would be a good idea to also change my oil and filter and rotate my tires. Before I dropped my car off I decided to number my tires to insure they would be rotated. Well the first problem is that they charged me for a job they never did. My tires were in the same place as when I brought the car in. Spoke with the manager Anthony about the issue and he said prove it and I did. The he tires had not been changed to which I had photos of my tires prior to dropping it off. I requested a refund which I was told it would be in two days. We are now in the third week and still no refund. At the same my car sounded strange and Sunday I went to check the oil level was down two quarts in which I had to go to Auto Zone and the oil for an additional expense. I would not at all recommend the service department.

Reviewed Jan. 20, 2026
If I could choose less than one star, I would. WILL BE SUING IF I DON'T HEAR BACK! This place is an absolute joke. During buying, they rarely responded in a timely manner. They had my husband sign papers FOR ME without MY CONSENT. They told him it was fine, which he didnt know wasn’t ok. They said he said limited POA for me since I wasn’t there, which was not true.
My husband drove from Virginia to get a Honda CERTIFIED PRE-OWNED vehicle from them. It is 10k miles and less than 3 years old. When he got there, something minor was wrong, so they said they’d fix it. It took 2 hours. They then said they had to detail it. Uhm, excuse me? You knew we were coming to get this vehicle a week ago and decided to wait and detail it when he got there? He got there at 9 am and did not leave until 5-6 PM.
They had multiple issues with their DMV, (which happened before he got there, too- they kept telling us the wrong sales tax rate- even though I showed them the Virginia website and code that states it), and it took many calls for them to finally see I was right and actually charge us the correct sales tax. Anyways, by the time it was ready, it was raining, and almost dark. He wanted to get home as it’s a 5-hour drive, so he signed the papers. He had looked at it earlier in the day but it was raining so he couldn’t see everything clearly. It looked nice until we got it home and took a better look with our local body shop and Honda dealer.
When we got it home, we found SEVERAL ISSUES, including MOLD IN THE BACK CARGO AREA! There was a screwdriver underneath the carpet. We would’ve never found these things had our local body shop not shown us as they were hidden, but anyone with knowledge on how to repair body work can see these things so I’m confident they knew. Shoddy body work, rust spots all in the paint due to not covering the vehicle when sanding/grinding, and we were informed by our local body shop this looks like it was in a larger collision than we were informed. Our local Honda dealer even said if a whole quarter panel was replaced, the damage was way more than we were told.
And you can tell it was replaced because it looks awful when comparing it to the other side. Along with this, one window rolls down slower than the rest, the gas tank was put back on wrong when the work was done on the vehicle leading it to rub and rust the frame, there’s an internal light that is broken, and more. I’ve contacted them a week straight and have gotten the runaround, "We’ll call you back." So freaking shady. The manager is “always in a meeting” when we call conveniently. Theyve taken my number several times as if they don’t already have it. They will need to pay for the repairs or take this back and reimburse us for every penny we have spent on this absolutely ridiculous, grueling process. Legal action will happen if we do not have an answer from you all ASAP. YOU are messing with someone who will take every legal action necessary, so I recommend you do what needs to be done and call us back with a solution immediately.

Reviewed Dec. 31, 2025
I called the dealership and explained the manager (Manny) my requirements from the car. He advised me that he has the car and it's ready for me. I drive all the way from Queens to Brooklyn. I meant Manny and he introduced me to the sales person. I explained her again what my requirements. Manny and pointed to the car that I am going to get. The rook out about 5 cars from the show room. In I had a test drive with the car and the sales person and she explained me about the features of the car. I negotiated the monthly payment for the car and we agreed on the price. They advised that they are going to run a soft credit on me. I asked then again if it's a soft or hard query and Manny and the sales person assured me that it a soft credit.
After this process I went outside to get pictures of the car and the vin number. Manny approached me and ask me why I am taking pictures of the. I told him that I want to make sure that I am getting the correct car upon delivery. Suddenly, he told me that this is not the car I will get. I was confused. He said that that I am getting a car with less features. I was in shock and disbelief. I ask him why he is doing that to me. Why he tricked me with the soft/hard credit query and the model of the car. No specific answer. He kept proving false information and blamed the sales person. I request to get my file and they refused. Then someone came to my help and gave me my file and I left the place. They provide false information and use inappropriate tactics.
Reviewed Oct. 28, 2025
Sneaked in a LoJack charge without actually installing the system they then gave me the runaround. Would not email me the bill of sale or purchase agreement for over a week, once I received the documents I noticed this.
Reviewed July 25, 2025
This dealership operates with an alarming lack of professionalism. Despite having an appointment, we spent over seven hours waiting, being passed from one unhelpful staff member to another. There was no coordination, no respect for our time, and absolutely no basic courtesy not even a simple offer of water during the entire ordeal. The sales staff were poorly trained and couldn’t answer simple questions about the cars. One even claimed that automatic side mirrors were manual and attempted to open them by hand. A stunning level of incompetence. The finance manager was visibly sick, sneezing openly without covering his mouth or wearing a mask, disregarding basic health standards. The car we were supposed to see hadn’t even been taken out of dealer mode. It was clear no preparation had been made before showing us the vehicle.
The facility itself was not clean, and the overall experience felt chaotic and dismissive. No one checked on us, no one cared about how long we waited, and certainly no one respected us as customers. If you’re considering buying a car here don’t. Go to a different Honda dealership where professionalism, customer care, and basic competence are still valued. This location is a complete embarrassment to the brand.
Reviewed July 7, 2025
The tech did not torque the transmission bolt after the transmission service because I noticed a leak in my driveway, so I gave the tech a bad review. Plaza Honda correctly torque the transmission bolt. After a month later, the next visit to Plaza Honda service is when things went south. I dropped my car off in the morning for another service. Later in the day, I called to check up on my car. The Asst. Service Manager (DW) hung up the phone while I was talking to him. I went to pick up my car after the rude behavior. I noticed my car was not serviced. The service manager also showed his displeasure with rude remarks. Just be warned, if you give a bad review, they will treat you like shit even though they screwed up. If I did not notice the transmission leak, they would have never replace the transmission if it failed due to low transmission fluid.
Reviewed June 24, 2025
Classic "Bait & Switch" fraud. They advertised a 2022 Pilot Sports with 16K miles. I drive over from Long Island and the car has over 23K miles. I will be reporting them to FTC and the BBB. AVOID AT ALL COST!!
Reviewed June 5, 2025
If I can give negative stars I would. One is too much. I found car online through a 3rd party website. A certified pre-owned. Hyundai Tucson. I spoke over the phone about the car and was told we don’t negotiate over phone and the only fees are the normal 175 document fee and taxes. So I took a 2-hour ride the next day to see the car. I test drove the car and noticed for a CPO car had lots of scratches all over hood. Door dents. Passenger side plastic trim dented. The interior trunk area has lots of deep scratches like from Tools and interior was dirty. The car said it was fully detailed.
I speak to Manual **, the sales manager also known as Manny the snake. I said, "What can you do for the car" and he says, "You drove all this way so you want the car and that’s the price." I said they told me over the phone the price was negotiable. Then there is 1295.00 LoJack fee that was never discussed. So I decide to buy the car because mileage was low. Call and telll them picking up car Tuesday. I take a 2 hour bus ride and get a call from 3 different salespeople while I’m on bus to get the car. The salesman says "You coming down to get car." I told him on my way and would be down in few hours. Manny ** calls me and says there’s an open recall on car and won’t be ready. Told him on my way down to figure it out. Get a call from service manager and would love to give share his info but I don’t have it. He says there is open recall on the car and can’t sell it at this time and parts are on back order. I’m already annoyed about LoJack fee.
I call Hyundai USA to ask about open recall. Guess what - there are zero open recalls or recalls on vehicle at all. Two days later I get a call from Dallas ** to follow up on car. I told her the whole story and she calls her manager Robert ** and he goes out of his way and takes photos of car and calls me back saying the car is available and when can you pick up. Told him thank you and will be pick up the next day. I get a call again from service manager again and says there’s same story, open recall can’t get car.
I’m like I’m tired of these games. The following day, get a call from Manual ** sales manager. Says "If you want car, it’s ready now." I told him I do not want LoJack and was advised by legal. So no LoJack but after paperwork all done I see Manny doesn’t include my coupon for test drive. He also promised me touch-up paint that he won’t take my phone calls now. It just goes to voicemail when I call and ask for Manny. Ask yourself do you want to deal with this business that for even $20.00 they will screw you. Still have no idea how this is a cpo car besides the mileage. The car was far from clean, but after all this, I understand how it became a cpo. I want to say thank you to Dallas ** and Robert ** again, if it wasn’t for them, I would have not purchased car. The used car salesman bait and switch, misinformation is all in this dealership.
Plaza Auto Mall Company Information
- Company Name:
- Plaza Auto Mall
- Website:
- www.plazaautomall.com




