HealthgradesConsumerAffairs Unaccredited Brand
I actually had a practitioner post a fake 5 star review of herself posing as me & using my name. I can only imagine that the rest of her positive reviews are fake as well. This is someone that I would never rate as “5 stars” (quite the opposite) and the fact that she actually went and created a faux profile (using my name) totally creeps me out. It’s nice to have a healthcare review forum for clients/patients but I very much question the validity of what gets posted. As for “my” review, I’ve requested that it be removed. We shall see...
I have had 30-5 star reviews on Healthgrades, and as result have received additional patients, which I appreciate. Approximately a month ago, one of my patients gave me a 5-star review with comments. There was a typo in his comments concerning me, he used the word "experience"; it came out in my review as "sexperience". He has tried numerous times to have Healthgrades correct the error. No response or correction. I have tried several times to do the same. No response or correction. Both of us followed the Healthgrades protocol. It appears that Healthgrades has a major customer relations problem. Now, I am concerned, if I should receive a negative review, would I have a chance to report my side.
They allow people who may or may not be patients to leave reviews. They do not respond to emails asking slanderous false statements to be removed. If a patient or reviewer states the truth although hurtful this OK. However, why must lies, untruths and slander be tolerated?
This site posts fraudulent reviews. All the reviews they posted about my business were inaccurate, and half were from people who were never seen by me. They never check and make sure info is accurate. I tried to contacted them numerous times, without result. After 2 years, they send me an email stating it is my fault I get the bad reviews. I know multiple other physicians who have exactly same issue like me, and never posted a review here due to lack of time. They should be hold accountable for ruining so many doctors reputations. Can an investigation be open about the way they conduct this website?
Healthgrades will make it seem like you are calling the doctor's office, but really you are calling Healthgrades and they will take down a lot of information about you before transferring you to the doctor's office. I did this and they took down my address and age and insurance and when I was transferred to the doctor's office I was told they don't have any availability. Avoid.
- 1,047,660 reviews on ConsumerAffairs are verified.
- We require contact information to ensure our reviewers are real.
- We use intelligent software that helps us maintain the integrity of reviews.
- Our moderators read all reviews to verify quality and helpfulness.
For more information about reviews on ConsumerAffairs.com please visit our FAQ.
A review about me was malicious but also could have easily been identified as bogus as I am an adult psychiatrist. The review claimed to be about a child. There was no way to immediately contact anyone. Also, studies indicate there is not a positive correlation between patient care and health grade scores. My sister, an attorney, (see review by Elizabeth in Venice) has also had such a hard time getting a positive review of her doctor (who had also been the victim of a bogus and libelous review) posted despite multiple attempts to submit the review and contacting Healthgrades. I was unaware of her experience and had the pleasant surprise of seeing her comments without any prior bias from her. In short, the site is Inaccurate and thus misleading. Although I was unhappy that I was misrepresented, I am far more concerned about patients being recklessly misled. First do no harm.
I have now reviewed a VERY bad physician three times on Healthgrades without receiving an email to confirm. I in fact wrote the review and it has never been posted. Now my friend had the same experience with the same physician and apparently Healthgrades is withholding these bad reviews for some reason. You cannot trust a website that picks and chooses the reviews they print and give horrible doctors decent grades.
When I questioned the validity of the one negative comment I got, and showed Healthgrades the background of it not being true, Healthgrades stuck to their policy and refused to take down the negative review. I asked to be removed from Healthgrades altogether, and they refused to do that also, saying that unless my NPI is canceled, they cannot do that. They are not easy to reach, not friendly and very unresponsive to dispute negative ratings.
When I looked into the matter, it was a case where the patient's father misbehaved with me (along the lines of what's happening in the news now!), and I dismissed the patient. Though I didn't tell the mother about it, she must have found out and decided to punish me for her husband's misbehavior. I explained to them that the excellent reputation I cultivated over many years is stained by this one negative comment, and asked them repeatedly to remove it. But, they did not, and stopped answering emails after the first one, where they refused. I would never recommend Healthgrades to anyone. I wish I saw THEIR 1.5 star rating before I signed up with them.
All Brite Dentistry - Most people do not look forward to going to the DENTIST!!! Dr ** is friendly competent a wonderful person who puts the patient at ease. I have heard her working with children, while I was in another of her waiting rooms, I was so impressed I will be bringing my grandchildren to her. She cares, is very careful in learning all information. I trust her and would highly recommend her to anyone. I am honestly glad to have met her and have her in my family's life.
I tried to submit a review on three separate occasions to no avail. There was NO email sent to verify and no phone number or contact information for an inquiry. Is this website a scam - I would expect more professionalism regarding clinician content/recommendation!
Three times tried to write a review about a merchant and three times was told that I would receive email verification for its posting and three times I did not. I assume that this means that the reviews on this site are fabricated as I, a real customer of a medical provider, could not post a legitimate review.
I have been in practice as a psychologist for 25 years. (Ann **, Ph.D. in McKinney, TX). I have never had a negative review posted on any site until your anonymous posting about me dated June of 2017. The reviewer mentions Manassas, Virginia. I have never seen or known anyone from Virginia. I have been experiencing a legal issue with an unstable individual (not a patient) who is being investigated for harassment and threats on my life. I suspect this 'review' is connected to that individual.
This is a personal legal issue of which Health Grades has now become involved. I seriously doubt that doing more damage to an individual already being targeted by an unstable individual is the intent of Health Grades. However that is now the situation. My attorney will be investigating Health Grades. How this organization can post unfounded and unproven degrading comments about a professional is unbelievable. Professional reputations are built over a lifetime and some unethical website with no standards or business ethics destroys everything they have worked years to build.
Heathgrades on this site I don't know how many times nothing was accomplished. All they do is give you a list of doctors you already know about so I don't know why they're in business. They have no business ethics at all. You post something and all of a sudden you go back in and it's changed. Most likely on doctors and their facilities. I don't know who is behind this site or business. The people post and because to complain. Shouldn't it be investigated? That's the reason for sites like this. I think people need to be heard and not looked over so I will not use this site again. It does absolutely nothing.
I currently have a 3.9 star rating. So, you might say, why am I complaining? That's because I have two very negative reviews, one of which was recently mentioned to me by an attorney as the reason he was reluctant to refer a client to me. This leads me the following: I have no idea who these so called reviews come from. Healthgrades also has no idea where these reviews come from. Any person in the world can claim they are a patient of mine and say anything they want. There is no verification process! Due to HIPAA regulations, I couldn't even actually respond if I did know who these people who wrote the negative reviews are. I have only been able to make a broad generic response, but the damage is already done with the negative review.
I do a lot of FORENSIC work. Therefore, many people I evaluate may not even want to come but they are court ordered, referred by employers, worker's comp cases, on forced leave from work for behavioral issues, etc. Believe me, not everyone is going to be happy with my conclusions. For example, if I do a clinically excellent report that recommends a person is not suitable for probation, that person can write a negative review on Healthgrades, even if my report was sound and defensible!!! Healthgrades has a question on the survey asking consumers if the provider is accessible for emergencies. I'm NOT accessible for emergencies, it's not part of the services I provide so that question isn't applicable but I can be downgraded for it.
Clinical work is complex, and despite educating our patients as best we can, they don't always fully understand what we've told them. Or, they may not like the truth that the diagnostic evidence indicates. This could be because of many reasons, especially if mental health is a factor. But hey, they can go on Healthgrades, hide behind a wall and take shots at my reputation!
As clinicians, we're not celebrities or politicians who by the nature of our work are in the public domain. We have a right to privacy being infringed by Healthgrades. We should ban together and hire lawyers to restrict these anonymous attacks on our professional reputations. We've spend a lot of time and money investing in our careers to make a living and serve the public and then these people come along and just allow unsubstantiated comments/complaints about our services. Let's lawyer up !!!!!
This is the worst website ever, they do allow people to place reviews online without verifying the information if accurate or not. I called them to dispute an inaccurate review placed by an unhappy patient, which was discharged from our practice for non payment and bad behavior, they would not even talk to me, could not verify the patient review, nor they had a proof it is accurate. Same happened to my other colleagues and is hard to understand how this company is still in business. They should be taken to court for destroying physicians' businesses and posting lies on their website, without verifying the information, or having a proof is accurate.
How is this website even legal? Promoting defamation and one of the most unethical and biased ways in reviewing a physician. Patients I haven't seen making a complaint. How is this website allowed to gather personal information such as listing a physician's age. A class action lawsuit needs to be started to put an end to such illegal activity.
I am an Occupational Therapist who doesn't own a practice anywhere. Somehow this awful place got ahold of an NPI that was given to me by a contract company over 10 yrs ago (2005). Since then I don't have an NPI anymore. Now, my name comes to the top of Google search with bad reviews for people I have never seen (probably a disgruntled boyfriend). Healthgrades refuses to remove my name, address, ph no. What a terrible rotten service. Follow the money, this organization is probably run by George Soros or some other evil philanthropist.
Healthgrades is a completely unethical and biased website. I don't understand what they get from it but for some reason they only published a horrible comment about my physician and when I read the comment, I added my own complimentary comment which was NOT published. I wrote to them and a person by the name of Armando wrote back to say that they WERE properly recorded! I kept checking and they were NEVER published! That was October 2016 and to this day, my comment has not appeared.
An investigation needs to be conducted into the practices of Healthgrades! Something stinks to high heaven here!
I have been going to Dr. ** for a few years now. I believe he shows much concern for his patients. He will explain fully and shows compassion for his patients. I will continue with his service and believe he will strive to find the solution to my and any other patients problems.
Healthgrades' Board justifies their data capture policy by stating that providers' information is openly populated on the net. That part is true. Evidently, in their view, this gives them free license to vacuum up providers' names and create a site that makes money from our intellectual property from a variety of revenue streams. Great business strategy, horrible ethics. What their policy can never justify is their strategy of coupling a data sweep with unvetted customer reviews.
As far as I know, Healthgrades is the only healthcare site that 1) amalgamates providers' data without offering an opt in or opt out; AND, this is the key point, allows anyone - even non-patients - to write a review with no filter! Their excuses not to be able to vet reviews ring false. Amazon, for example, has a system for unhappy customers to seek mediation with the seller until the complaint is resolved. The negative review then can be expunged. So, there are ways to manage negative reviews to everyone's satisfaction. The only justification must be their bottom line -- the cost for staff to manage these instances.
The unintended consequences for providers are numerous. Two examples: 1) If a patient has not paid a bill in a timely fashion and then the provider informs the patient his account may go to collections, the patient can then post a scurrilous review to justify non-payment; as a result, the provider risks further retaliatory negative reviews from the patient's friends if he/she does go to collections or small claims court. This is terribly frustrating and unfair, especially if one is a sole practitioner. Healthgrades platform not only affects providers' reputations but also their income! 2) While Healthgrades site now offers providers a response option for negative reviews, there is a double-edged sword to be considered. Personally, I am not comfortable with this option as, first, it could come across as defensive, and secondly, a response could also result in retaliation. It's better just to ignore the review. Easier said than done.
I've being mulling writing this review for months. Being human, an unfair hit on your integrity is hard to swallow. Healthgrades clearly doesn't understand -- or perhaps, care -- about this impact on providers. Our hands are effectively tied. Healthgrades Board: Speaking on behalf of all healthcare providers, we care deeply about a dedicated quality of care for our patients. The code we daily do our best to live by is "do no harm." We are not restaurants or movies that can be rated 1 - 5 stars. Your open platform diminishes our work and harms us professionally and personally. Please reconsider your policies.
I left a positive review for my original doctor who has retired and I left a negative review for the doctor that replaced him. My positive review was never uploaded and my negative review was changed to a 3 star review.
Healthgrades is dishonest and unfair. We never signed up and now receive negative reviews from people who are NOT our patients and we have no way of responding. We called the customer service line and they said they could not take these bogus reviews done. Also, this website allows disgruntled patients to write whatever they want, even if it's untrue without being challenged, which reflects negatively to my practice. I pay for my own service, Demand Force which allows us to always address any negative thoughts or comments. I don't want my practice listed on this website, it's unfair and dishonest. The reviews are bogus and many are not true. Please address this issue. I am not the only doctor that feels this way.
Will not let you leave a positive review or make corrections on reviews, even after exhausted attempts to do so. I am aware that most internet reviews are negative, because most people only post reviews when things don't work out for them.
My business never got reviewed before this individual began to leave slanderous and blatantly false comments that could negatively affect my business. The reviews from healthgrades.com also managed to show up on the top whenever a google search is done for my business. It all started when I sent a delinquent payment case to collection and had to go to court twice to resolve the issue. All the bad reviews (with 1 star) I got since seem to be posted by the same person even though different names were used and vicious and baseless in the nature. All the reviews have grammatical errors, which also indicates they could be posted by a same individual.
Contacted Healthgrades multiple times about the issues since Oct 6 and they said they would look into it but I never heard from them until I called only to find out they didn't do anything yet as of today (Dec 1). If they really go through proper verification process as they claim, they should have known the reviews left on my business are abusive and absurd. Healthgrades should allow either that any review (positive or negative) be not posted for the business or that the business name be removed completely from the site so that dedicated professionals like me do not suffer frustrating and unnecessary nuisances. Google did remove a false and defamatory review presumably posted by the same individual right away just by flagging it. Why can't Healthgrades do the same?
They are using the bad reviews to get doctors to try and offset them by getting more people to sign up, then they apparently sell the email addresses to marketers. The positive reviews are often left out, which many of my patients have told me and others have complained about this here. They don't care what people say on this site, but they apparently do resolve complaints through the Better Business Bureau: www.bbb.org. I suggest that all of the providers who have complained here post their views on the BBB website and file a complaint there. The patients can likewise file complaints for false advertising because they are relying on these websites to find providers and they are getting skewed results that may be leading away from perfectly good health care professionals just so Healthgrades can make a quick buck from their email addresses.
I am not long out of residency and I am trying to build a practice. I do not have the time or the resources to sue a company like Healthgrades, but many others here have posted that they have tried to get blatantly false information removed and they were fed up and ready for class action. I really hope this happens. The people with "resolved" complaints with the BBB simply had the survey function removed, or had their names removed from the site. Healthgrades pays Google to get their results at the top, and if you advertise your practice with Google, they will link your Google Plus with your address and hours etc. right next to your rating from Healthgrades. Having them tell you then that you can choose between having misleading, libelous or possibly even vindictive reviews from your competitors (with nothing vetted), or you can have nothing at all (which is almost as bad if you are trying to attract new patients), is unfair.
I could easily start up dozens of email addresses and put in glowing reviews for myself, and possibly a few other mildly negative ones with responses to them that make me seem human and forgivable, but I have enough integrity that the thought of that makes me feel physically ill. I would rather just have ALL the reviews, with a chance to contest the ridiculous ones, and then let the chips fall where they may. I am not perfect, but I am dedicated and hard working, and I genuinely care about doing what is right for my patients. If doing that makes some of them angry because I refuse to give them narcotics for "depression" then they should not be able to say whatever they want about me on Healthgrades and have Healthgrades leave it up on their site no matter how absurd the review is, or if it was not even from a patient that I actually saw.
Horrible site. My patients told me they have tried to post excellent reviews, but only one negative review shows up, which is slanderous and a personal attack. I have contacted Healthgrades multiple times, and they do not respond. Any class action lawsuit would be welcome, please include me. This site should be taken down because it destroys the reputation of good practitioners.
I am a physician who received a review from a patient that threatened me physically. I had him escorted out from my office but now the patient has written one review citing me as unprofessional. There is also one other review using the same language on the same day that I saw the patient in the office later on. I think this is unfair and never signed up for a Healthgrades account. I have decided to change the location of my practice over this and want my profile taken down so that it doesn't affect me at my new practice but have received no response from Healthgrades with regard to my inquiries to do so. Please help!
I am finding out what they cannot be trusted. Tried to put up a review on a Dr. ** that butchered me on a amputation revision. He botched it big time. The reason he gave for doing it? He "Didn't like the way the last surgeon left it" and they would not allow a negative review.
I have been trying for six months to have Healthgrades remove a review that was on the WRONG doctor. I had never seen the individual and was clear that she saw another physician with a similar name in the same town. Not only will they not remove it - they have been unwilling to allow my comment below the erroneous review. This is a sleazy company. Unreliable reviews. If ever there was a case for a class action suit against a company, HEALTHGRADES fits the bill.
While multiple patients have reported that their positive reviews of our practice never showed up on the site, Healthgrades permits false/slanderous comments from unverified reviewers! Our practice has received two 1-star reviews that included false accusations. In both cases the reviews accused of actions that, if true, would be tantamount to malpractice. In both cases we knew who the accusers were because of the dates of their statements & certain comments made in their reviews.
After the initial incident we filed a complaint with Healthgrades. They stated that they would review the case, but weeks later they had not responded. When we contacted them for follow-up, they stated that they had essentially done their job by "verifying that the reviewer used a legitimate email address"! As has been mentioned by others whom have had problems with Healthgrades, their "solution" was for our practice to solicit positive reviews to offset the negative. (Our practice will NOT ask patients to write positive reviews to attempt to fluff up our rating.)
Healthgrades Company Information
- Company Name: