Best Renters Insurance in Milwaukee, WI

More than 40% of Milwaukee residents rent their homes, creating a real need for renters insurance in Wisconsin. Renters insurance replaces personal belongs and provides liability coverage if someone is hurt in your home. To help you choose, check out our list of the best renters insurance companies in Brew City to protect your assets.
Top 12 Milwaukee Renters Insurance Companies | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|
Lemonade Renters Insurance | Read Reviews | Offers basic renters insurance at super-low rates. No-frills insurance means fewer features like live customer support. Zero Everything option for zero deductible. Users can file claims through a mobile app. | ![]() | Visit Website |
Allstate Renters Insurance Milwaukee | Read Expert Review | Offers a variety of discounts, including ones for installing security devices and bundling multiple insurance policies. Free online quote available. Employs Spanish-speaking representatives. | ![]() | |
Brew City Renters Insurance | Read Expert Review | Offers a discount for AAA members. Analyzes 12 different renters insurance providers to deliver the best quote. Provides instant online quotes 24/7. | ![]() | |
DernCo Insurance Superstore | Read Expert Review | Provides renters insurance quotes from 14 different carriers, including Progressive, MetLife and Travelers. Offers free online quotes. Consults with customers to help choose the best plan. | ![]() | |
Frank Medina Renters Insurance | Read Expert Review | Provides free quotes online. Works with 15 different insurance carriers. Offers options to extend coverage for flooding. | ![]() | |
Freeway Renters Insurance Milwaukee | Read Expert Review | Employs English- and Spanish-speaking agents. Offers a wide variety of insurance options and add-ons to bundle with your renters insurance for a discount. | ![]() | |
Friedle Insurance Agency | Read Expert Review | Provides renters insurance quotes from 17 different providers, including Acuity, Erie Insurance and Zurich. Offers free quotes online. | ![]() | |
Procter Insurance Agency, Inc. | Read Expert Review | Offers Milwaukee residents renters insurance quotes from up to 15 different insurance providers. Provides a wide variety of coverage options that can be bundled together for savings. | ![]() | |
Schwade Insurance Agency | Read Expert Review | Works with 25 different insurance companies to provide renters insurance. Specializes in Erie Insurance coverage. Offers free renters insurance quotes to Milwaukee residents. | ![]() | |
State Farm Renters Insurance Milwaukee | Read Expert Review | Offers bundling discounts. Provides savings for Milwaukee residents with home alarm and safety equipment. Delivers free renters insurance quotes online. | ![]() | |
The Insurance Office Renters Insurance | Read Expert Review | Partners with more than 40 insurance carriers. Provides free quotes online. Consults with customers to help them choose between multiple packages. | ![]() | |
Young's Renters Insurance | Read Expert Review | Offers free online quotes. Responds to all inquiries within 24 hours. Delivers discounts for referrals. Provides a customer satisfaction guarantee. | ![]() |