Hagerty Reviews

I have 1930 Ford Model A. I needed a jump and requested roadside service. I informed them in writing on my request that it's a 1930 Ford model A and it is a 6 volt system with positive ground in capital letters. They are classic and antique car ins. Provider that's why I insured with them. The guy they sent assured me his jump starter does 6 volt up to 12 volts his word. He also showed up in a regular truck with blacked out tint so didn't think that pickup was for me, but it was. So I showed him the negative side for the positive red cable and same with the positive side for neg. cable.

I was denied coverage for lack of high performance car experience. I'm a retired Los Angeles cop of 27 years with mandatory high speed drivers training every two years of my 27 years. I have owned a corvette, two Porsche Macans, Mini Cooper John Cooper Works, several Mr2 sports cars. The underwriter sounded and acted like a day one 18 year old. I'm exactly what any insurance company in the world would want to have as a client. Very poor experience from Hagerty.

Car was totaled loss in a hit run accident and towed to co part. Was told a investigation was happening on a car in pieces from to back a week later. Then start asking me for pictures of prior the wreck. I was never asked for when I started my policy? Bullshit and will not provide rental or none motorists no deductible. Better Business Bureau call getting made.

To the Super car owners do no I repeat do not insure with this company. My car engine I own a McLaren caught on fire in wild driving there own tow truck came and saw it on fire. All the smoke and they lie to me not to denied my claim. The the name of the property damage Adjuster is Brittany ** and she lie about talking to my mechanic about what he said to able to denied the claim. I was there when they spoke and he told her that there was a fire and clearly there evidence on a the engine about the fire melted and burns. I’m in the process of filing a lawsuit against them. They have a lot bad reviews cause they don’t like to paid but love to collect is that wrong.

Hagerty SUCKS and denies claims no matter how much documentation I provide and they are even asking for documentation that can't be provided and by their own admission they wouldn't have the documentation they are asking for. And giving them 1 star is to more than they deserve. Bad Faith Policy wrote all over it.

I have had Hagerty on and off for ten years. During which time I had one or two small claims. They always paid out as needed. Thank God, right now, I have FOUR cars insured with them. The total AGREED value of the policy is $104,000. I hope what I am reading is NOT true. I have been paying Classic car insurance for 55 years! I am a die hard collector. Without taking sides with the insurance company, there are those that use insurance for their own purposes. I'll leave it at that. They Never consider how lucky they are to drive MULTIPLE cars cheaply.

I just cancelled my new insurance policy. Hagerty billed me $409 more for my policy than the quote they sent me. They claimed my broker had verbally approved the increase, which my broker denies. I believe my broker. Since this made the Hagerty policy 25% more expensive than my prior insurer, I cancelled and returned to my prior insurer. What a waste of time and money, not to mention the frustration. Terrible customer service over the phone, to boot.

I shopped for insurance in late July of 2025 for my 1949 Ford F-3 which was expiring in September. I received the Hagerty's quote for $223. I spoke to Charlie on 8/9/25 to sign up. Charlie told me to call back after the 16th because it was more than 30 days before my previous insurance was expiring on September 16. In the meantime, I sent two requested photos of my stake bed to Hagerty. I called today and spoke to Miranda and the price was now $273. No explanation other than the effective date was in September. BEWARE!

They will insure your vehicle but you cannot drive it. It can only be inside a garage 100% of the time. If you ever file a claim they will drop your coverage immediately. They love being paid but filing a claim is a death sentence.