Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath: Which is better?
Re-Bath and Bath Fitter both provide innovative solutions for people who are looking for a bathroom remodeling contractor.
Bath Fitter focuses on quick, affordable bathroom updates, often installing acrylic bathtub liners and shower surrounds in as little as one day. On top of a fresh new look, you can add safety features like shower seats and grab bars.
Re-Bath offers more extensive remodeling services, including full bathroom renovations, walk-in tubs and upgrades to fixtures, cabinets and countertops. Re-Bath is perfect if you’re looking to overhaul your entire bathroom, especially if you need greater accessibility options to address limited mobility.
 |  | |
|---|---|---|
| Products available | Tub and shower surrounds, safety additions, accessories, wall and ceiling enhancements | Tubs and showers, wall surrounds, cabinets, countertops, toilets, faucets, lighting, hardware |
| Services | Bathroom updates and tub/shower installation | Bathroom renovation and redesign |
| Demolition required | No | May be required |
| Material options | Acrylic only | Acrylic and stone |
| Design consultant | Yes | Yes |
| Level of customization | Limited | Extensive |
| Timeline | 1-day installation | Multiple days |
| Products available | Services | Demolition required | Material options | Design consultant | Level of customization | Timeline | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tub and shower surrounds, safety additions, accessories, wall and ceiling enhancements | Bathroom updates and tub/shower installation | No | Acrylic only | Yes | Limited | 1-day installation |
 | Tubs and showers, wall surrounds, cabinets, countertops, toilets, faucets, lighting, hardware | Bathroom renovation and redesign | May be required | Acrylic and stone | Yes | Extensive | Multiple days |
Bath Fitter
Bath Fitter is primarily known for bathtub liners and tub-to-shower conversions. The company installs prefabricated liners over existing tubs, offering a quicker and more budget-friendly remodeling option. There’s no demolition or risk of damage that can leave your bathroom out of commission for multiple days.
However, this approach does not address issues with surrounding bathroom fixtures. Bath Fitter does offer additional solutions for walls, wainscoting and accessory renovations, but these aren’t the main thrust of their operation.
If you’re looking to make safety updates such as grab bars, shower seats or hand-held shower heads, Bath Fitter provides plenty of options. They also provide services for those looking to turn an existing shower/tub combo into a shower only.
Bath Fitter pricing
Bath Fitter’s costs vary based on the project type, bathroom size, upgrades and location. Bath Fitter doesn't publish standard pricing on its website but offers free consultations for personalized estimates.
Tub liners typically cost between $5,000 and $10,000, while tub-to-shower conversions range from $5,000 to $7,500. Based on customer reviews, many homeowners receive quotes around $10,000.
Financing options are also available, including low monthly payments and promotional 0% interest offers.
Bath Fitter warranty
Bath Fitter offers a lifetime warranty on all of its acrylic products. The warranty applies to the original purchaser, as well as any subsequent homeowners.
Maintaining Bath Fitter’s warranty requires that you only use cleaning products on an approved list, which can be referenced on the company’s website. You must also be prepared to show proof of purchase to simplify your warranty claims that may arise.
Bath Fitter installation
Bath Fitter installations can be completed in as little as one day. The process begins with an in-home consultation, where a representative measures your existing bathtub or shower and helps you choose a replacement liner, wall surrounds and accessories.
Bath Fitter then custom-manufactures an acrylic liner to fit over your existing bathtub or shower. During installation, technicians prepare the existing surface, address any necessary repairs and install the new liner.
Projects involving tub-to-shower conversions, plumbing modifications or underlying damage may require additional installation time.
Re-Bath
Re-Bath offers more comprehensive bathroom renovations. The company can replace your existing bathtub or shower, including walk-in tubs, tub-to-shower conversions and accessibility upgrades. These solutions typically come with a higher price tag, but also do more to remodel your entire bathroom.
Re-Bath also provides consumers with a five-year guarantee on their products. If you are looking for a complete remodel, Re-Bath gives you options for everything from cabinets and countertops to bathroom lighting, bath wall surrounds and all aspects of your new bathroom design down to the hardware.
Re-Bath contractors assist you with deciding the best choice — a full remodel or simple upgrades — and help you move forward with the best option for your space.
Re-Bath pricing
Re-Bath remodeling costs vary depending on the size of your bathroom, the extent of the renovation and the materials you choose. A tub liner typically costs between $5,000 and $10,000, while a bathtub or shower replacement or conversion ranges from $10,000 to $18,000. For a full bathroom remodel, expect to pay between $25,000 and $30,000.
Re-Bath offers free in-home consultations to help homeowners explore their options and receive a personalized quote. Because Re-Bath locations are independently owned and operated, pricing and available services may vary by location.
Re-Bath warranty
Re-Bath offers warranties on all its products and services. DuraBath acrylic products, including liners, wall surrounds and accessories, come with a lifetime warranty. This covers labor costs for repairs or replacements due to manufacturing defects.
DuraBath natural stone products come with a 10-year limited warranty. Walk-in tubs’ frames, shells and door gaskets come with a lifetime warranty, while components like faucets and trim kits have a 5-year warranty.
Re-Bath also offers a one-year warranty on the workmanship and installation of your entire bathroom remodel project.
Re-Bath installation
Re-Bath handles the entire installation process, from the initial consultation to the final walkthrough. During the in-home consultation, a design consultant looks at your existing bathroom, takes measurements and helps you select materials, fixtures and finishes.
Then, professional installers remove existing fixtures and prepare the space for renovations. Depending on the project, installation may include plumbing updates, bathtub or shower replacement, flooring and other bathroom upgrades.
Re-Bath can complete most full bathroom remodels in just a few days, although larger projects or those requiring extensive plumbing and structural changes may take longer. Installation timelines vary based on the scope of work.
Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath cost
Here's a side-by-side comparison of Bath Fitter and Re-Bath's costs. Your cost depends on the size of the project, the condition of your existing bathroom and the materials or products you choose. It's best to reach out to Bath Fitter and Re-Bath to get an accurate quote.
| Bath Fitter | Re-Bath | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost range | $5,000 to $10,000+ | $5,000 to $30,000+ |
Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath warranty
Both companies offer lifetime warranties on acrylic products, but Re-Bath also provides coverage for natural stone products and installation workmanship. Here’s a comparison of Bath Fitter and Re-Bath’s warranties side by side.
| Bath Fitter warranty | Re-Bath warranty | |
|---|---|---|
| Acrylic products | Lifetime | Lifetime |
| Natural stone products | Not applicable | 10 years |
| Installation workmanship | Varies by installer | 1 year |
| Transferability | Yes | Varies by product |
Bath Fitter vs. Re-Bath: What customers say
Both Bath Fitter and Re-Bath are well-rated by ConsumerAffairs reviewers. Here's what customers have to say.
Bath Fitter reviews
Praise for Bath Fitter repeatedly singles out installers who arrived on time, worked quickly and left the space cleaner than they found it. One reviewer in Nebraska described workers who "covered my wood floors for protection, installed a beautiful walk-in shower, cleaned up and were done in 1 day." Others emphasize communication from the first consultation through the final install, and a number are repeat buyers. A reviewer in Tennessee called it "our second Bath Fitter installation," and a customer in California said the company did "a fantastic job both times."
Negative reviews for Bath Fitter mention issues with scheduling, order accuracy and responsiveness once the job is done.
Re-Bath reviews
Re-Bath’s positive reviews cluster around skilled individual installers and crews who get the job done efficiently and respectfully. A customer in South Carolina praised an installer whose "professionalism is outstanding... making sure each panel fits before applying the sealant," with plumbing "properly sealed" and doors that "operate smoothly.”
The negative end of the spectrum, however, surfaces recurring and serious complaints: botched installations, leaking showers, pooling water and warranties that turn out to be far less comprehensive than advertised. In Massachusetts, a reviewer learned the hard way that the "lifetime warranty" excluded workmanship issues, noting bitterly that "cracks are the only thing covered.”
FAQ
How much does a bathroom remodel cost with Re-Bath vs. Bath Fitter?
Re-Bath remodels typically cost between $10,000 and $30,000 depending on the extent of the renovation. Full remodels are on the higher end of that range. Bath Fitter offers a more affordable option, with prices ranging from $5,000 to $7,500 for tub-to-shower conversions and around $5,000 to $10,000 for tub liners.
How long does it take to remodel a bathroom with Re-Bath or Bath Fitter?
Bath Fitter specializes in quick renovations, often completing projects in as little as one day. Re-Bath projects take longer, typically requiring multiple days for a complete remodel due to the extensive work involved.
Which company offers better warranties on bathroom remodels?
Both companies offer strong warranties. Bath Fitter provides a lifetime warranty on all its acrylic products, which are transferable to subsequent homeowners. Re-Bath offers a lifetime warranty on DuraBath acrylic products, a 10-year warranty on natural stone products and a one-year workmanship warranty on installation.
What is the difference between a tub liner and a full bathroom remodel?
A tub liner is a prefabricated acrylic shell installed directly over your existing bathtub, requiring no demolition — this is Bath Fitter's primary service. A full bathroom remodel, like those offered by Re-Bath, involves removing existing fixtures and replacing them entirely, which allows for greater customization but takes longer and costs more.
Does Bath Fitter or Re-Bath offer accessibility upgrades for seniors or people with limited mobility?
Both companies offer accessibility upgrades, but Re-Bath provides more comprehensive options. Re-Bath installs walk-in tubs, roll-in showers and full accessibility-focused remodels. Bath Fitter can install an accessible model if your existing setup allows for it. Bath Fitter also offers grab bars, shower seats and handheld showerheads as add-ons to its liner and conversion services.
Is Bath Fitter or Re-Bath available in my area?
Availability depends on your location, as both Bath Fitter and Re-Bath operate through local franchise networks. Bath Fitter has hundreds of locations across North America, while Re-Bath operates in most U.S. states.
