
Nicole of Wake Forest, NC on Dec. 29, 2009
I received two sets of pots and pans as gifts last Christmas. The one I decided to return cost $299.99 and came from Target. Since I didn't have a receipt, I knew I would probably get store credit, but I didn't mind since I knew I'd eventually spend $300 in Target with no problem. I took the set, brand new and never opened, to customer service, and the girl at the counter said they would happily give me store credit, but I have to spend it TODAY. In other words, she would do an exchange instead of giving me a credit to use later, so I had to go shopping right that second and spend $300. At first I was perturbed, but then I figured I could stock up on things I needed anyway. Fine.
So I left the pots and pans at customer service and spent half an hour trying to spend $300. I came back with a cart full of diapers, baby formula, groceries, a few DVDs, toiletries, clothes for my son, et cetera. When I got to the counter the girl said, "Oh, sorry, you have to spend that money in the same department where the item you're exchanging came from." I said she must be kidding. She said no. I tried to argue but another customer service rep confirmed the ruling, even when I said they should make an exception just for wasting my time. So I left the cart there (no way I was putting all that stuff back) and went back to the housewares section to start shopping again.
I came back after another 30-45 mintues with a bunch of stuff I didn't really need... picture frames, a new set of sheets, some plastic storage bins, a new coffeemaker, a new stick blender - you know, stuff from the SAME department as the pots and pans. The girl said, "Oh, oops, I should have told you it has to come from the same (something)" with (something) being a some term that I don't remember. I said, "What does that mean?" and she said something else I didn't understand. I said, "I'm sorry, I don't know what that means." She said, "Go back to where the pots and pans are and ask somebody, and they can show you what I'm talking about."
So I went back to the housewares department and after a few minutes was able to flag down an associate. I repeated what the customer service rep had said, and asked what the heck that meant. He said, "Oh, she means these two aisles right here." I looked and realized that "these two aisles" were the aisle with the pots and pans, and the aisle with the bakeware. I said, "You mean to tell me I have to exchange those pots and pans for MORE pots and pans??" He shrugged and said, "I guess so."
Now working on my second hour of this nonsense, I walked down the aisles looking for something - anything - that I could possibly use that would add up to $299.99. There was nothing, so I stormed back up to customer service prepared to make a really big scene.
This time the girl I had talked to before wasn't there. Her replacement asked me how she could help, and I explained to her angrily what I'd just been through. Before I could even finish my story, she quickly said it would be no problem to exchange the pots and pans for anything in the store, so I checked out with the stuff from my first cart, which was still sitting next to the second one.
Unfortunately, it turns out the first person was right about the return policy, and the second person either didn't know any better or was doing me a favor. For that reason alone I refuse to do gift-shopping at Target, because if someone wants to return an item, I don't want them to get hassled like I did.