
Joshua of San Diego, CA on July 8, 2010
I ordered a 1,800 sq. ft. of Brazilian Teak manufactured by Bellawood for Lumber Liquidators. What a nightmare! Several boxes arrived damaged upon delivery. The delivery person noted on the paperwork that the boxes were ripped open, damaged and discolored from other boxes. After not hearing from the store about the damaged boxes delivered, I called the store directly and spoke with store manager, Mike. I expressed my concerns and he assured me that the boxes would be fine and I should have no worries about the installation of those boxes.
When my installers arrived for the install (after the boxes had acclimated for three weeks), they too pointed out that several boxes looked beat up and odd. I told them that I already called the store and that they would be fine. They opened those three boxes along with seven others and sorted them by color variation, size, and proceeded with the install. After laying many of the boxes, they expressed that they were having constant issues with gaps in the boards. They pointed out that the boards had two separate kinds of milling and it was causing major problems. The problem was the actual width of boards were very different and so were the tongues. They suggested that I contact the store and let them know so I can return them and reorder new boxes all from the same milling. I called the store and spoke to Ricky. He told me to bring in some sample boards.
The next day, I brought in several boards demonstrating the boards' varying width and completely different tongues. I could tell that Mike, the manager, did not want to admit that they were from different mills but it was impossible to deny. He would just make comments like, "a good installer would know how to deal with something like this," and, "they can be altered by your installer to work." I pointed out that it would cause additional labor which I would have to pay for and I should not have to pay more money to deal with milling issues. He then said that he could send out his own installer (Brian). He said that he would be able to make them work just fine. As I had nothing to lose, I agreed.
Later that day, a woman called and said that she spoke to Mike and her company would come by to look at the floors. Several hours later, there was a knock at my door and it was a woman named "Sarah." She said that she was there to look at the floors. I told her I thought a Brian was coming to look at them as he is the installer. She said that she was his wife. I showed her the boards and how they were all different. She just seemed oddly quiet. She obviously knew they were messed up but didn't want to say anything other than, "don't worry, we can fix everything." I pointed out the many rows that would have to get ripped up. She said that the three boxes that were mixed up with the others could be dealt with by "sorting them back out and putting them in the same rows."
That sounded fine but she said that I would have to remove what was already laid down and also order replacement boxes. She also said that they would only glue down the wood. I told her that as long as the price was the same, that would be fine. She said that Mike would probably replace the boxes that caused the issue. I told her that I would speak to Mike and let her know. I showed her my current installer invoice (3 sq. ft.) and told her that as long as she matched that, I would go with them. She said that she would match my installers and email me the estimate.
The next day, the email comes. Guess what? They wanted $2,500 more than my current installers. Not only that, the glue was an additional $1,200 more. So they wanted $3,700 more than my current installer! She had the square footage at 3 but had the stairs priced out separately and also wanted $1,000 more to level the floors for glue down process. Obviously, I was not going to go with them and she never said that the glue material alone would cost so much! I called Mike and said that I am just going to go with my installer and l am going to return the unopened boxes and reorder the same thing. I even agreed to upgrade the wood to 3/4 inch thick from 3/8 inch thick since they had the same teak in a smaller width but for a similar price. He said to bring them in and I would reorder them.
After renting a U-Haul and breaking my back getting the boxes back to the store, the manager said that I had ten boxes missing. I told him that three boxes had milling issues which ** up the other 7 laid down. I told him about how I called when they arrived and was assured that they were okay. I explained yet again that those three boxes installed with the other 7 were mixed and rendered useless and they had to get ripped up. Mike said that he would only credit me for the three boxes that had the wrong milling. He did not want to recognize that those boxes caused the others to be useless.
Trying not to loss my cool, I told him that I wanted to focus on getting the replacement material (2 1/4 teak) that is listed on the website because it's a similar price. Guess what? The replacement material was not available. The only option he said that I had was to pay for an even more expensive (3.25 teak). I told him that I didn't even want that as I have a 1915 craftsman, I was not comfortable going with such a large width, and that the cost was more expensive per sq. ft. ($3,500 more!).
Now, he was telling me that my only option was to pay $3,500 more! It was obvious that I was getting nowhere with him. He had no compassion to the situation and just seemed to generally not get how I was put in a situation not of my choosing. Let's not forget that this entire nightmare was brought about by having different milling mixed in with my order since they no longer had any replacement material at similar cost (2 1/4)--even though the website says they do.
I requested to just have the unopened boxes I just returned credited to my card. I said that I would have to eat the 7 boxes and just order them somewhere else since the only option extended to me was to buy a more expensive teak. This ** had the nerve to tell me that he would "not give me my money back." He said that he "was not convinced it was a milling issue." Are you freaking kidding me? I was just speechless. To think that I would have to take the hit on all of this is like putting a gun to my head. I told him that since I was left with no alternative, I had no choice but to pay an additional $3,500.00 and order the teak in 3.25.
I left the store feeling sick to my stomach--like I had been mugged. It's just sad when you feel so completely taken advantage of and have absolutely no power to make the store take responsibility. All I can do is share my story and let others know of my horrible experience.