
Clare of chicago, IL on Feb. 4, 2012
Satisfaction Rating: 1/5
I terminated my account several months ago. Today, I was browsing my recent credit card statements and saw that eHarmony was still auto-renewing my account and billing me.
I called and the help guy said that I had never even attempted to close my account, much less succeeded in doing so. The help guy said that if I had even attempted to cancel my subscription by clicking to the first page of cancellation, for example, a record would have been generated that he would be able to see. He claimed there were no such records. I specifically recalled cancelling my account. Account cancellation through the website is easy and fast, so once I did it I didn't count on it not working. I figured if they made it so easy, they must be an honest company. But apparently it didn't work, for some unknown reason, although I have a very strong suspicious of why it didn't work.
Next, the help guy made a claim I knew with 100% certainty was false. Although he may have been telling the truth, as he knew it, since eHarmony likely manipulates their records to mislead their help desk people. He claimed that, according to his records, I logged into my account and closed matches less than a week ago. Once he said that I knew eHarmony was screwing with my account.
The help guy seemed like an honest guy (although I have my doubts even about that), and he refunded the full $22 monthly charge I had been charged. It was somewhat humorous that he did that because at first when I called he was quoting the contract and telling me he couldn't refund any of it. But after arguing for ten minutes he went up to an $11 refund, then after 20 minutes he went up to a $22 refund. Unfortunately for him, I could not care less about $22, and I kept arguing. I never once asked him for a refund, he was basically just doing it to get me to go away.
I wanted him to explain to me how it is my account didn't close and how it is he had records of me logging in when I was sure I hadn't been. I demanded an explanation but he had none, he basically just intimated I was crazy and refused to even admit the possibility of the eHarmony system being faulty or erroneous. It is one thing to say he had a given set of information in front of him, but it is entirely implausible and insulting for him to refuse to even admit that he might be wrong. He claimed that in the entire history of eHarmony they have never gotten a complaint like this. I find that extremely hard to believe.
I suspected someone might have illicit access to my account and was secretly using it to meet girls. However, the account only showed activity in the form of matches being closed, which apparently only I can do, and only after I login with my email address and password. He was extremely emphatic that only I could close matches, and he went on and on about it. I could tell he was not a particularly intelligent individual because much of the information he was giving me was irrelevant to the core issue, and he wouldn't even stop spouting off irrelevant information once I explained to him why it was clearly irrelevant. I don't have a problem with stupid help desk people. They have horrible jobs and don't get paid much so I don't expect them to be highly intelligent or effective.
Anyway, no messages were sent from my account to any ladies. So obviously no one was using it for their illicit gain, because no one gains anything from just closing matches. Closing matches is a highly tedious process, especially given the number of matches eHarmony emails you every day.
Why should you believe this story? I am highly educated, highly intelligent, financially well-off individual. I have no criminal background, reputation of being a liar, or any history of getting in trouble. I certainly didn't argue on the phone for a half hour or write this review because I care about the money. My memory is at least good enough for me to remember what I did in the last week. I am 100% certain I did not login to eHarmony, and I have clear memories of cancelling my subscription a few months ago. Additionally, I have had a girlfriend for over a year, and certainly have no reason to be using eHarmony at all.
Basically, I argued with the guy for a long time trying to get an explanation for all his clearly erroneous records. But, unfortunately, it is impossible to argue with someone when I have no hard evidence of my allegations. The help guy claimed that I should have gotten an email confirming my cancellation, but, when I cancelled just now, I got no such email. Ultimately, the only person who controls the eHarmony records is eHarmony, and they obviously manipulate the records to extend subscriptions. If someone gets pissed off enough, eHarmony has set up a misinformed staff of help desk people to get all flustered, refund the money, and protest endlessly about how supposedly wrong their customers memories are.
I suppose the ultimate takeaway is that eHarmony is as greedy as every other subscriber-based business out there. If you want to cancel your account, don't count on it being easy. I am sure they make some cancellations easy so that they have plausible deniability, but likely they have some kind of system for identifying people that don't pay close attention to their bills, and they target those people as special revenue generators.
Don't join eHarmony. Meet a girl in the real world. Just to make it clear this review isn't posted by a competitor: I am sure match.com and all other dating websites engage in similar shenanigans.